Reviews (page 6 of 14)
I like me some Big Band, but this didn't really hit. I think it's just a bit too shmultzy? Also pretty much every Sinatra song sounds the same, which isn't a problem when it's one in a playlist, but it's a bit much for a whole album. Neat that it's the first ever UK #1 album though, that's a cool fact
It's amazing what kinda lyrics you can get away with as long as you have an excellent singing voice and a great orchestra backing you up. Fun songs that make me wanna get up and dance around.
Ol' two eyes himself!
I'm not sure what there really is to say about this album. We all know Sinatra and what his music was all about. Smooth baritone, swinging tunes, and just generally pleasant to listen to. It probably "deserves" a higher rating than a 3 because obviously Sinatra was so good at what he did, it's just that what he did was a style of music that I and most of the rest of society largely got over years and years ago. These days it's music to fall asleep to. So, I can't really justify giving a higher rating to something I know I'm never going to actively listen to again. Favourite tracks: Anything Goes, Makin' Whoopee, Old Devil Moon
I've heard several of these songs before, and obviously Frank Sinatra's voice is smooth and iconic. However, as a critic, he has a pretty limited range, and only one sound. In the time period, that was fine, but looking back, it all sounds the same and runs together. 5/10
A bunch of hits. The lyrics are great, I can see why he was a heartthrob. I think it's undercut by the genre somewhat; I'm predisposed to just not take crooning seriously. Biggest critic as I attempt to actively listen is that the album is a bit of a blur. Each song seems to have the same music behind different words.
Rarely in the mood for Sinatra
Sinatra is such a classic! Not my favorite collection of his but pretty great.
Sehr vibey und vor allem weihnachtlich. Vielleicht etwas für ein Weihnachtsessen.
Ok but boring
vibe fixe
Pronto né I've heard this before Bom saber.. que almost every frank sinatra song.. sounds the same 👍👍👍
As músicas kinda parecem todas iguais ngl, mas tipo gostei de ouvir na mesma
Top notch
Smooth songs and Sinatra has an incredible voice, but it's always going to be a chore for me to fully appreciate a record like this that isn't my cup of tea and runs for 40+ minutes.
Just enjoyable
I almost got through this. Luck be a lady is amazing
A bit one note, but that note is very good
I never think of Frank Sinatra as having albums, but as an album this one is great. Lots of familiar songs but also the ones I was not familiar with were also good Biggest Hit I’ve Got You Under My Skin Biggest Miss Makin Whoopie Biggest Surprise You’re Getting To Be A Habit With Me
So. Always loved Frank Sinatra mainstream songs. However. Listening to this was definitely an experience. With tracks like You Make Me Feel So Young alongside Pennies From Heaven and I've Got You Under My Skin, it's hard to fully dislike this album. With that being said, songs like Makin' Whoopee and Swingin' Down The Line were pretty boring and wasn't a huge fan. Overall, strong start with some okay songs in between a few other bangers.
easy listening
More of a background music while working for me.
Very good album - made me swing
Je sais pas si c’est parce que je l’ai écouté en faisant de la thermodynamique ou si c’est parce que les sons se ressemblent tous mais ça m’a semblé long mais looooooong… Après c’est pas grave c’est bien mais ça fait plus comme un long son qu’un album en fait c’est assez plat.
This Frank Sinatra kid is definitely one to watch - he can really carry a tune.
Quite cheerful but definitely not my thing.
I’ve always liked Sinatra’s voice, so this was very enjoyable to listen to! The songs, however, don’t sound all that different from each other and all kind of blend together. So not the most exciting, but pleasant nonetheless.
3.5
For me the Capitol years is peak Sinatra and this particular album is a fine example of why. He's well past the greasy kids stuff that he was in the 40s, and definitely not the Vegas schmaltz that he started becoming in the 60s, he sounds elegant refined and though his voice always sounds big and commanding it's not overbearing. Of the of the two Sinatra albums we've had so far, i think *In The Wee Small Hours* is a more finely curated selections of tunes, where this one relies heavily on standards at the time. But man, does he ever do it so cool and suave. But this is also got some of my favorite Sinatra recordings "Old Devil Moon" is probably in my top 10 Sinatra tracks ever, and "You Make Me Feel So Young" is probably not far behind that. And this also might be my favorite version of "Got You Under My Skin". All around a fantastic sounding project him with Nelson riddle is pretty much gold in this era. I honestly want to do a dive on just his Capitol albums at least and maybe then back up to the Columbia albums... then go as far in the reprise albums as I can stand. I'm actually kind of surprised that Frank Sinatra Sings Only The Lonely it's not on the list considering it's the first album to win the Grammys album of the year, but I think with the two albums selected for this list I think it shows the two sides of Sinatra really well during that period. There is one more Sinatra album on the list. It's a '60s jazz leaning album, which will be an interesting listen for me because I have really only heard his pop schmaltz from the era. 9.8 ★★★★½
Cool swing arrangements, but I prefer Sinatra more ballad-heavy. 4 stars
Probably my favorite Sinatra album I've heard. This style of Rat Packian vocal jazz standards has always felt really cool and comforting to me. Some great tunes here, including "I've Got You Under My Skin", "You Make Me Feel So Young", and "Anything Goes". 4 stars.
3.5
Hard to beat a bit of Frank. In The Wee Small Hours is even more superb but this is still a smashing collection full of sterling, sophistomicated highs such as You Make Me Feel So Young, You’re Getting Into A Bad Habit With Me, I Got You Under My Skin plus other jollities such as Makin’ Whoopee. Another swing and a hit from the king of the swingers, the gangsta vip. 4.5 stars.
When this was released, there was no vaccine for measles. 70 years later, measles is fashionable again. Anyway let's talk about Frank. Amazing voice. Great performance by the band. All around good stuff and I can imagine my parents generation prancing around to it as they unwittingly filled the world with lead and asbestos, nuked Pacific islands in the name of science, etc. Nice but I probably won't listen again.
Love me some swing Its pretty milquetoast jazz but simple doesnt mean bad
Can't be mad about Frank Sinatra. Listening to this puts me in a good mood. I like the big band and all the brass instruments. The whole album is lighthearted and fun, just some feel good listening. I never realized before but Frank Sinatra is a master at talking on pitch - he generally doesn't sustain notes much. I think it's a style choice, it seems like it serves the genre and I don't mind it cause he does it so well. And then there were parts where he really belted it and I was reminded that he is a great singer too. The band is awesome. I like the occasional flute moment. Makin Whoopee was the only song that I wasn't into, mostly because the phrase sounds weird to me lol. The songs do get rather same-y after a while, if I'm going to listen to a whole album I like it to have an arch or a through story. Overall, nice sound, great musicians, solid style choices, it's a top notch example of the genre.
Hell yeah I fucking love this. So warm, that trumpet tone chefs kiss. Feels like Christmas music too. Vocals, of course, fucking on point. Jazz band on point. Music composition on point. We don’t write music like this anymore… Sooooo many incredible songs on this album. Not even just like, good songs but songs that have become household songs that I feel like everyone in at least North America knows or has heard. Definitely some very traditional gender role lyrics in here. Sucky, but unfortunately that was the time… “You’re only a maid, and I am only a man”, what.
I remember someone told me Frank Sinatra was a bad singer with a good orchestra behind him and I agreed. I was wrong. 4/5 would chainsmoke to this album
Never really listened to Sinatra before and swing isn't my thing either but I actually enjoyed this album and I could imagine listening to it again
Not my cup of tea
How did this one get onto the list? It is older than me! Nelson Riddle provides the orchestration and all the big band sounds of the 1940s and 1950s. Sinatra does his usual top notch singing, although after several tracks they all seemed to blend together.
Some of my best friends are Swingin' Lovers! I assume there are no musical soundtracks on this list, so maybe this is the closest we'll get (based solely on the album cover). Not enough popular songs have a full orchestral accompaniment. Plus, such clear vocals! The songs themselves are whatever, but the performance is great. (Yes, I do have Michael Bublé albums, what about it?) I could not believe there was a song on here called 'Makin' Whoopee', but it turns out the Newlywed Game meaning actually came *after* this song, not before, and it used to just mean "to enjoy oneself in a boisterous manner". Highlight: 'Anything Goes'
Song For Swingin' Lovers! was an album i enjoyed quite a fair bit. I already have had experience with Frank Sinatra due to the prior two albums on this project that i did that were by him and i was expecting this one to be the best of the three, and i was completely right. This album did have all the Frank Sinatra staples i would expect from him, like the vocals and the Disney movie/Christmas violins and i feel like they are all at their best here. Granted the songs here do sound kinda samey as is expected of Frank Sinatra but i thought that the songs here were all good enough for me not to care all that much. This album gets a 3.5. Best Song: Pennies From Heaven Worst Song: Makin' Whoopee Side note: Since this is gonna be my last Frank Sinatra album, I'll rank them here; 1. Songs For Swingin' Lovers 2. In The Wee Small Hours 3. Francis Albert Sinatra & Antonio Carlos Jobim
I enjoyed this more than I expected, flows very nicely and its got good rhythm. A little repetitive but overall enjoyable. Standout Songs: You Make Me Feel So Young You’re Getting To Be A Habit With Me Old Devil Moon I’ve Got You Under My Skin Makin’ Whoopee
I tried, just not my thing
Even though his songs and albums are so similar, I can't not like them. Always have a good time listening to Sinatra.
He really was so big for good reason, one of the classics. I'm not going to pretend that pretty much every song on this wasn't impressive with each arrangement. Frank would rizz me easily.
Mostly pleasant, very samey. It's alright.
Two albums of love songs in a row. You’d think I’d be done with them after listening to all 69 on the so-titled Magnetic Fields album. But the love songs on this album are all classics, delivered in the best possible way by an excellent vocalist. The arrangements are stellar and timeless, all brass and strings — but tgey’ve aged well. This album can play on repeat at a cocktail party or serve as an enjoyable concentrated listening session on a desert island. A five.
I’m glad to see a Sinatra album on this list. I’ve listened to Sinatra my entire life, but never just sat down with one of his albums or collections. And this one does not disappoint! His smooth vocals and charm are timeless. The music resonates as much today as it ever did and should be in everyone’s list.
Some of my favourite tunes and some of sinatra’s best vocal work.
Fabulous voice, can see why he was so popular
Great songs, nice mood
Still don't really care for Sinatra in full album form like this. One or two songs at once is cool, but it gets so samey
Classic
All such classics by the one and only Sinatra. The instrumentation, the arrangements, his delivery all perfection
Many classics. Examined as a whole, perhaps a bit samey.
Absolute classic, and great on the sunday morning!
I’ve loved this album for a very long time and was so happy to see it on this platform! 1000% recommend. It’s Frank and it’s classic!
It’s really good. Just very samey.
I just can't get into this.
Ahhh - the Original and the best when it comes to Swing. One of my Dad's favourites. Pretty timeless now thanks to modern crooners and they're all just pale imitations compared to this. Songs are perfect, the arrangements so smooth and it's Sinatra in his prime. This is his perfect album. Almost 70 years old, but still sounds sublime.
A really fun and swinging album.
Was wondering when Ol' Blue Eyes would show up for me. 50's swing & jazz are always an easy listen, made even more prominent by one of the greatest and most iconic vocalists in Sinatra. It's easy to forget that every track here is already an existing pop standard too. The way these were recorded and arranged by Nelson Riddle to become jazzier and hipper, molded right into Sinatra's wheelhouse, make these tracks feel almost brand new. Sure, almost every track here kind of operates on the same wavelength, but I do prefer an album of upbeat, swingin' tracks over an album of slow, crooning ballads when it comes to this era.
“Songs For Swingin' Lovers” was undoubtedly a milestone for both Frank Sinatra and music history, as it was with this album that he began singing and recording standards - for which, to my knowledge, he is still best known today. While his unique voice immediately makes every song his own, I'm not entirely sure that the arrangements and orchestrations, which of course no longer sound contemporary today, live up to this claim. Although I like swing and standards, I feel that this record is at the historical limit of what can still be fairly reviewed today – accordingly, it is also one of the oldest albums on this list. “Songs for Swingin' Lovers” is certainly a very good album, but it doesn't contain any of Sinatra's really big hits, and to me it just sounds too "standard" to give it five stars.
Its a Sinatra album. Don't know what else to say.
Not a fan of frank
Really swings - each marginally too corny to want to relisten. Saved a song: N RYM: N
Great collection of songs from one of the best known crooners.
Loved it!!!
This was a great Sinatra Album. Fun, jazzy, and swinin!
It's my first time listening to all of Frank Sinatra's album, and I realize now there is a good reason why he has been loved for decades.
Did not disappoint. Very easy album to listen to.
Absolutely perfect!
Classic Sinatra. Some of the songs haven't aged well, but I can't deny that most of these songs are just good. It's not music I would have on repeat unless I'm in a very specific mood. But I do enjoy me some Sinatra. 5/10.
I definitely prefer Sinatra when he’s in his love songs bag, but I can’t possibly give an album with “Makin’ Whoopee” anything higher than a 3.
If I were to point to an album of standards, it would probably be...an Ella Fitzgerald album, but Frankie could get a mention too.
This album title seems to have aged... not poorly, but interestingly. It seems a usual release for Sinatra, a collection of covers of popular songs, mostly from musicals. He's a great singer, and the arrangements make for fun jazz-pop. I think it's pretty good, but not a style I love.
All the songs sound very similar but not of them are bad. Makes me feel like I'm in a smoky club in the 50's.
It's... fine.
Kind of same-y but I have a real soft spot for old school crooners so I'm not complaining
This is #day463 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… who doesn't like some Frank Sinatra? This record, which also happens to be my last album from 1956, represented on the list, is all-out '50s: big band, swinging jazz, and the unmistakable crooning of the Chairman of the Board. It can be hard to tell the songs apart, aside from a handful of all-timers like "I've Got You Under My Skin" and "How About You?"; it all kind of blends into one song/story, but I'm fine with that. We'll see what his other two albums have in store. This is a 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day464.
Banger
Just put a smile on your face
I'm swingin'
Not for me
++: You Make Me Feel So Young, It Happened in Monterey, You're Getting to Be a Habit with Me, You Brought a New Kind of Love to Me, Too Marvelous for Words, Old Devil Moon, Pennies from Heaven, Love Is Here to Stay, I've Got You Under My Skin, I Thought About You, Makin' Whoopee, Swingin' Down the Lane, Anything Goes, How About You? +: We'll Be Together Again 9,9/10
One of his best!
3ish it’s samey and I don’t know how much id revisit but I like it
Most of these songs sound the same
Swing! Big band! Frank!
Im not swingin nor a lover
Ah, Frank. What can you say about Ol' Blue Eyes? It is Frankie's world and we get to live in it and enjoy his music. This album is a great example of why he earned the nicknames "King of Swing" and "The Sultan of Swing". Put it on your rotation, you won't regret it.
I’m sliding over the dance floor with my gal and this Sinatra classic is playing
I'm sure it was popular back in the day. More or less wallpaper music for me personally though.
Solid classic
Sinatra was the epitome of cool in the 50's and this album could be the soundtrack to that ethos of the time. The arrangements by Nelson Riddle were impeccable and the perfect foundation for Sinatra's great voice and phrasing. A classic!
OK, but not my taste in music
How can anyone be THIS in love. It was a good album, but like most Sinatra, it's going to sound about the same every song. 3/5
Very classic feel, timeless stuff. Not something that absolutely floors me but this will always be around and is a great listen
Great songs not entirely my thing. Bit samey
All songs pretty good. No real stand outs for me though. Nice music, but I doubt I'll ever queue it up intentionally.
The exacting precision of the instruments and voice make the slightest nuance amazing.
Hard to think that the voice of Peter Griffin has this guy as basically his idol. Frank is still the GOAT, but I think ol' Seth can give him a run for his money
Oh, to be an ol' fashioned swinger.
You can tell by some of these reviews that some of yall did not live through the lounge revival in the 90s :). Frank is a top tier interpreter of the classic American Songbook. The arrangements are top notch. What's not to love? This is a fun album.
As others have said - 45 minutes of the same song. Not offensive, just not extraordinary.
This album reminds me of my grandparents I love it
Easy listening
Virkelig dejligt swing-humørboost! Får mig til at tænke og føle gennem et lidt naivt og sødt “julet” filter
5/10
People used to be so horny
good album, knew most of the songs already without realising they were all on here.
Gotta be one of the easiest listens ever.
This one expired a few years ago, no longer fresh, just a bit stale. They banged this album out in one day, all the horns & orchestration are identical and vocal delivery is blueprint Sinatra. I don't hear any reason this is on the T1001 list. I just can't imagine that being the hip new album everyone is talking about, it seems like 200 years ago and people were wearing powdered wigs & triangle hats. I threw in the towel after Track 9, I simply couldn't take any more. One or two songs over an evening but 15 in a row? That's what they do at Guantanamo. 2 Stars.
Didn’t think I’d enjoy this one as much as I did.
This is a good Frank Sinatra Album. I think I prefer Live at The Sands myself. Frank is a bit tainted for me because of how much boomers love him due to their overdeveloped sense of nostalgia.
Streit
Gir meg julestemning, og litt fallout vibes. Hadde ingenting imot å høre på albumet på vei til jobb, men tror ikke jeg ville satt den på igjen.
I really loved it. Really classic and nice to dance to. I don’t usually listen to this kind of music but when I do I typically enjoy it. No surprises here.
Exactly what I expected from Sinatra
Une grande voix, mais bon toujours un peu pareil, pas de gros coup de coeur, et pas une grande fan de cette décennie en musique donc bon.
Je connaissais un peu, première fois que j’écoutais un album entier. J’ai adoré, très comédia del Arte donc j’avais l’impression d’être dans un film tout le long
Moi j'aime bien Frank Sinatra. Par contre peu importe l'album j'ai l'impression d'écouter de la musique de Noël ahah 4/5
*1956. 10th studio album. *A couple notable songs. *This is just quintessential Frank. RATING - 7/10
This is more my speed with Frank. Kinda goofy bravado, selling bad lines, doing his best with his kinda limited range/affect (breathing a problem? on Marvelous for Words at the end - a modern recording would surely punch in rather than leave that performance intact).
Standard. The definition of standards. People of multiple generations were singing along before the end of the fist verse. Hard to evaluate when it's such ubiquitous wallpaper.
I don’t always listen to old school crooner jazz… but when I do, chances are it’s going to be ol’ blue eyes.
Genre: Standards Frank’s got a nice voice, and lovely full bands behind him at all times. And I know this stuff really hits for some people, but not for me. Easy to listen to, but I personally don’t need to again. Also, to all the pearl clutching happening in the 60s with rock and roll, Frank was literally singing a song called Makin’ Whoopee. Doesn’t get any less innuendo than that. 3/5
The entire album sounds like one old good love song. Legendary voice of Frank Sinatra cannot be mistaken. Unfortunately, this kind of music is outdated for me and I can’t really enjoy it.
Really great stuff
Its probably not Sinatra's fault that by this point his songs have been in a million shitty movies but they sound so bland and commercial to me. And he's an a-hole.
While Frank Sinatra was a Grade-A piece of shit, it's not the reason that I hate him and his music. There's a smarm to his voice that I find cloying and insipid, and which belies what a garbage person he was in the same way that P-Diddy's weird drippy flow made him sound like a massive, leering creep. Maybe they both rot in hell.
I liked this more than other Sinatra albums. 3.5 rounded down.
I kinda understand the popularity of Sinatra, but it still seems weird. He was making albums like this when no one else was. Still, I don’t love his voice, phrasing, etc. Some good songs here, but still, only a 2. This came out when I was 9 months old…
Honestly this felt like banger after banger for this genre. I knew most of these just from cultural osmosis. It is also the case that while I was thinking “oh another incredible jazz standard delivered with impeccable skill by the best guy ever at this,” I was also thinking “3…3…3.” So I think we’ve determined what the highest possible rating is, for me, for this type of music: 3/5.
It’s fun and classic.
Easy to listen to. Nice. Classic crooner voice, great backing band, makes you want to tap your toes. I liked it more than I thought I would. 4.
Fuck it. I own a bar and host karaoke and I should be sick to death of this man...but...damn it he's so smooth.
I'd drive with this driving crooner, baby. Nice songs for ethical non-monogamists. Also very funny there's a song about how having sex makes babies that was a chart-topper in 1956. Not much variety between tunes, but I'm not a jazz/swinghead so I'm probably missing something. The album lacks the dizzying heights of Sinatra's prior Wee Small Hours but this one's still great listening. As is often the case going through earlier albums it's refreshing with the shorter, more punchy track lengths here and the rich smoothness of the sound makes this feel like warm liquor on a cold evening. fav tracks: You Make Me Feel So Young, Anything Goes
Þægileg að hlusta á og skemmtileg orðnotkun hjá honum
Sveiflandi swing. Bara gaman.
Quaint
Kadett, Pegnitz - Hof, Deutschland. Wenige Banger.
I really went back and forth between 3 and 4 stars on this one. It's so cozy and lovely and full of optimistic and romantic love that it's hard to find flaw here. In fact, the only real issue I have is that there's only one sound and one theme throughout. But when you do one thing and do it well? 4 stars. Not 5 stars because, while immediately recognizable, I don't seek this out often and get tired of it easily.
The sound got a little monotonous, but it's Frank!
In 1955, Frank Sinatra poured his heartbreak over Ava Gardner into In the Wee Small Hours — an album so cohesive it’s often cited as the first true “concept album.” It’s a masterpiece, but a monochrome one: an extended sigh in blue, all midnight gloom and lonely cigarettes. A year later, he re-emerged — libido restored, swagger back — with Songs for Swingin’ Lovers!, and it’s like someone threw open the curtains. The joy in this record is infectious. Nelson Riddle’s arrangements shimmer with effortless grace, and Sinatra sounds untouchable, completely at home in this universe of winks, charm, and brass. Sinatra may not have had the prettiest voice in the technical sense — Stuart Staples of Tindersticks, say, has a richer baritone — but no one has ever phrased like Frank. His performance on “Old Devil Moon” is jaw-dropping: the way he bends and dances around the melody is as free and daring as Charlie Parker on sax. He doesn’t so much sing the songs as play them, using language the way a jazz soloist uses notes. Cole Porter’s sly wit is tailor-made for him — “Anything Goes” practically purrs — and even the ancient chestnut “Makin’ Whoopee” becomes deliciously risqué in his hands. (Ava Gardner, after all, once quipped that of Sinatra’s 119 pounds, nineteen were... well, censored.) It’s an album that radiates pleasure — sophisticated, a little naughty, endlessly listenable. Maybe it’s a touch too smooth to be perfect, but honestly, who cares? Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! is pure joy on vinyl — a tonic for melancholy, a reminder that charm, when done right, is its own kind of genius.
Jazz? Sure. Tell me you don't know how to categorize a legend without saying you don't know. And Frank is a legend, and this is a really great Sinatra album. No notes. Influence 5. Hits 5. Quality 5. Love it.
6/10
I can’t remember if this is the second Sinatra album or if we’ve had more, but I think this should be enough. It’s not bad! Sinatra was 1 of 1, his vocal presence is unmatched, etc etc. But you get the point after the first 10 songs. Silky smooth lyrical delivery, quintessential romantic backing tracks that are tightly performed. I’ll take “Too Marvelous For Words” from the pack of songs on this album. It’s a very happy, simple, fun take on a romantic song. Strong 3/5, if I was of an impressionable age when this album came out I’m sure it would be 5/5
Classic! His voice is like butter! His music always reminds me of my grandparents.
Swell stuff
My childhood soundtrack was my dad’s car cassettes: either James Bond scores or Frank Sinatra. So this one hits pure nostalgia. Nobody from the crooner era touches Sinatra’s effortless tone. Hard to believe Columbia dropped him, only for him to return and conjure something this smooth with Nelson Riddle. Every line is silk, every phrase perfectly timed.
Fun fact: this album cover is to scale. Frank Sinatra was 16 feet tall. And he likes to watch. He really likes to watch. It’s kind of a problem. Frank, just because you can easily peep in a second story window doesn’t mean you should.
Sinatra is fine, don’t really have a strong opinion on him. This is about as good as he gets for what that’s worth.
I’ve always preferred Dean Martin, but Frank is also good.
Fun catchy songs.
Wow, the hits on this album! I don't think I've ever listened to a Frank Sinatra album in it's entirety, but if there was just one, this is it, no skips here. I think he really does well with the swing/big band genre. I loved the Bossa Nova stuff from the previous album I heard, but swing is definitely his wheelhouse. I didn't realize this album had so many great songs, but it is on my playlists now.
this album is literally Crooner triple platinum. Imagine getting the GOAT to remake the last 20 years of music. That’s what this must’ve felt like to its contemporaries. Insane. Old Devil Moon is the big time tho. I’m going to give it 3.5 stars and round down, bc it’s a cultural landmark and the encapsulation of an era at the end of its cycle of innovation, but doesn’t do anything new or exploratory. It’s old hat, but it’s a certified cultural artifact
Culturally impactful and unmistakeable vocals by Sinatra
Pretty good. Very Sinatra.
Made walking around a train station so much fun. Felt like I was in Lego movie.
Don’t get me wrong I love you Frank but this album felt like a Christmas album without any of the Christmas. Every song was sort of the same. Favorite Track: Old Devil Moon
Pretty boring for me, a great singer for sure but I'm going to go with a 2
Objectively, every element of this album is fantastic. The big band accompaniment, Sinatra's voice, the arrangements. Subjectively, I'm almost never in the mood for Sinatra, though. Small doses in movie soundtracks? Sure. That's where I've heard half the tracks on this album. I'm almost never going to sit down and listen to a whole album of it. Objectively: 5 stars for the quality of arrangements and performance Subjectively: 2 stars for the overall enjoyment. Will average the two to get 3.5 stars, but I'm rounding down to 3.
Just finished this album up at work, it's classic Sinatra.. Only problem is I need suppress the urge to pour a glass rye, light up a Lucky Strike and call my female coworkers "Doll" or "Broad".
Such a great voice! Such dumb songs.
Better then the other 2 Sinatra albums we've listened to. Still don't like Sinatra.
This is a pretty good album of Frank Sinatra classics and standards. It's good, just shy of great. I enjoyed it, would probably be a 3.5 if I could do that, but since I can't and I probably wouldn't choose to put this on, I'll round down.
Muito bom, que voz, me sinto em paz escutando essas músicas
I liked it well enough, It's just that ai think it sounds like he didnt give it a lot of thoughts, it has some good songs but most if them are mediocore
I liked this album bcs it truly evokes the passionate love that anyone feels at the start of a relationship. It's full of hope, it's tender and pure like a warm hug from a beloved. And pure love penetrates to your skin and becomes a part of u, like u can feel it under your skin. I love the album ends with a question, leaving us wondering.
Pleasant but kinda samey.
This is better as a relic than an actual listening experience. The music…. is fine, its samey, overly sentimental and Frank’s crooning gets boring after a while. However, if you treat this album as a piece of history on taste of people in the 1950s I think this album becomes more interesting, however it still doesn’t make it special. I could have chosen any Frank album for that same experience. It also doesn’t function as a wholistic history like Ella’s songbook series which is infinitely more interesting. Tl;dr you can skip this one 2/5
I can enjoy some frank Sinatra every now and again. But a full album of it just blends together and drags
I like Anything Goes for nostalgia reasons, so it gets 3 stars instead of 2, because the rest of this is patently uninteresting to me. I like Sinatra's voice, but it feels like background music exclusively.
some famous songs but just not something i get into
- Light, superficial love songs; not much variation. - Includes "I've got you under my skin" (the other songs are consistent with each other, but can't compare). - Can't see myself listening to this very often... I definitely prefer a best of album to this one. I get tired of it really quickly - there are 15 songs, for me, it would be more enjoyable as, like, 5 or 6.
It is genuinely impossible not to enjoy this. The music makes just draws you in and makes you tap your feet, his voice is perfect for this, the lyrics are full of romance and wonder and its just a fabulous way to spend an hour. Deducting a star for making whopee because ewwwww
Classic Sinatra. Great album.
Sinatra and his swoon-worthy, sexy voice is superb. So many great classics on this album.
Classic big band music with lyrical word play. Standard Frankie
Easy 4, not quite a 5. Pleasant album, fun and bouncy but the love songs get repetitive. Not really an album in the modern sense but a collection of love song singles - Frank! - So suave. This is dancing music indeed - Very fun, at least a 4. May need many listens to fully appreciate. - On a 2nd listen, the whole ‘I love you so much’ gets a bit tired. Fun at times, but how many ways can that be said. Easy 4, not quite a 5
One of a kind voice
I constantly felt like it's Christmas and that was not the vibe. Didn't finish it.
It's hard to find anything to complain about for any one song on this album. Sinatra's voice is of course very good, and the perfect fit for these swinging songs. He's loose and able to make the songs feel effortless and airy. The music is jazzy and light. The lyrics are quite good, with the opening lines of tracks 4 and 5 especially standing out. A couple tracks near the end feel a bit quaint 70 years later, but the music otherwise doesn't sound dated outside of inspiring a subconscious association with old movies. So the songs are good, but as an album? A little variety would certainly help, as by the end it feels like you've already heard these songs before. This would be great to listen to in an elegant ballroom at a party. But just sitting down to listen to on its own? It doesn't work quite as well.
Silky, swinging, smooth jazz with Ol Blue Eyes smooth as silk voice is still very much a product of its time but that doesn't make it bad. Most of his hits are here & they sure are swell. The others are swell as well but still suffers from sounding all the same. I've said it before: If you don't like the ONE song they play DIFFERENTLY, you're in for a bad time. If you do, you'll love it. I enjoyed the album much better than the Frank's Sad album that is on the list but it's still a 3.
Enjoyed listening to this. Lots of classics. Some have aged better than others.
You can totally see why he was special
I absolutely recognize these songs are good, but growing up Italian-American you hear A Lot Of Frank Sinatra. It's hard to separate the music from so much personal context.
A hell of a voice, but it’s really hard for me to separate it from the deeply unpleasant guy attached to it. And another one where a little goes a long way for me.
By the mid-1950s, Frank Sinatra was back on top of both his game and the charts, bringing the lie to F, Scott Fitzgerald’s credo that “There are no second acts in American lives.” Regrouping with Nelson Riddle late in 1955, Sinatra mapped out a record with avery different flavor. What emerged from these sessions, held a month after Sinatra’s 40th birthday, was day following night. Next to In The Wee Small Hours’ scotch-soaked, 2 a.m. atmospherics, the euphoric Songs For Swingin’ Lovers! is a sunny summer afternoon walk in the park, positively skipping with joie de vivre. Sinatra never sounded more at ease, breezing giddily around “You Make Me Feel So Young,” delivering “How About You?” as though it is one long marriage proposal, and practically winking his way through “Makin’ Whoopee.” But it would all be wasted without Riddle’s glorious scoring. Legend has it that his unsurpassable arrangement for “I’ve Got You Under My Skin,” hurriedly completed the night before the session, was greeted with spontaneous applause by the musicians who played it on January 12, 1956. The resulting album is the closest any artist has come to defining the Great American Songbook. However, keen-eyed students of pop music may also notice the symmetry in the 15-cut, 45-minute track listing. Truly, the art of the three-minute pop song begins and ends here.
אין שום דבר מיוחד באלבומים האלו של פרנק סינטרה פרט לכריזמה ולאנרגיה ולקול שלו אבל לפחןת זה ממש נוסטלגי
Okay
Classic after classic
One of the earliest albums on the list, it feels very out of place with most of the other albums. There's nothing wrong with Sinatra, his voice is good, but this doesn't feel exceptional. It's hard to believe, but the lyrics of popular music in the 50s were even cornier than the lyrics of today's pop. I don't hate this, but it's not really interesting to me either. The cool, swinging, jazzy good times just wear smooth after a few songs. I always liked the song Anything Goes...probably has to do with Kate Capshaw's rendition at the beginning of Indiana Jones and The Temple of Doom.
For all del
Man what a vibe. These are all bangers.
5 stahs
eww happy couples eww
Franks got a fab voice. Songs tend to blend together but anything goes is extremely memorable.
One of the rare occurrences where I can rate an album high without listening to it first. Sinatra is a guarantee for really good and sophisticated music. Songs for Swingin' Lovers takes you back into the late 50s like few other pieces of media can.
Another Frank Sinatra album! I can appreciate his importance and his wonderful voice, but I still struggle to really enjoy listening to him. Still, I gave Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! a go. The whole album just reminds me of Christmas, somehow. I’m not a swing fan, but I do love a good love song—so I should love Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! I just don’t. On the plus side, Frank sounds at his very best here. What a voice—though I’m hardly saying anything new. The problem is that I simply don’t enjoy swing, and after a while all the songs start to sound the same. It becomes a bit repetitive and, honestly, a little boring. Favourite track: “I’ve Got You Under My Skin” is a lovely song, although I actually prefer the Frankie Valli version. “You Make Me Feel So Young” is also great. Least favourite track: The rest of the album feels too samey. You can’t deny the songs are beautiful and sung perfectly, but after three or four tracks, it all starts to blend together. This album isn’t really for me, although I can appreciate its quality. Album artwork: A standard album cover for the time—simple and classic.
A little bit one note but overall I enjoyed this. Frank's vocals (obviously) sound great and his backing band give all of these songs a really infectious energy. Probably not something I'd return to but maybe take a couple of tracks from this for a playlist
Swing verging on pop with some great melodies and arrangements and of course Frank's voice. Great tone and made a change from the more ballad heavy albums of that era. Not the best album title ever but worth a listen
Hmm depends on the mood I’m in. Today found gross & cringe. Another day maybe cute & nostalgic 🤷🏼♀️
I know he’s kind of a novelty and as common in NY as rats, but on a sunny fall day this hit. Ridiculous album title lol
Extremely one note but extremely good at that one note. My north jersey heritage feels bad giving this a 3 but 🤷🏼♀️
The most Gentleman's 3 to ever 3. 2.5 Editing window update: This is a 2. I got to bored to finish it.
SO fun and Jazzy with a bunch of new songs I never heard by Frank
It's fine, I guess. Not much place for this stuff in my life.
That was a beautiful listen. The instrumental is gorgeous and the voice and delivery of Frank are iconic. I obviously knew already "I've Got You Under My Skin" but the whole album is such a joy to listen to. Another artist that I will listen more often. Also such a joy to have Frank Sinatra playing while cooking and eating breakfast!
whoop-tee-doo. pleasant enough but it felt like it dragged because there’s so little variation in sound. i bet this sounded fire in 1956 though and i can appreciate that.
fine...i'm never THAT excited for frank sinatra but there's also never anything objectionable about it. to me his music is the lowest common denominator in that it's generically pleasant enough that no one's going to be mad if it's on. it's hard to appreciate this for anything other than background music you'd hear at an italian restaurant which is not his fault necessarily...but it's also not particularly thrilling to me in 2025.
Its good but gets a bit same-ey after a few tracks.
Classic, elegant and lovely. The voice of Frank is timeless.
a voz masculina mais bela do planeta. meu paizinho.
reminds me of fallout. i love this kind of music.
not to my taste, felt very outdated and songs sounded the same for the most part but respect him as an artist
What can you say, it’s great.
It's so nice to listen to a great singer with a great big band playing great arrangements singing about love.
Yeah it's a run on album but I'll be damned if it wasn't a foot tappin', finger snappin' great 45 minutes. Incredible for almost 70 years old.
Frank is the GOAT! Enough said!
Not finished listening but it is so fucking old and so fucking white it's embarasssing
Chilled easy listening, and when one of Frank’s songs comes on, you can’t help but get drawn into it. BUT, a whole album of songs all starting to sound the same, is a bit too much. Giving this three stars is about fair in my view
Too outdated for me, alas.
Frank is just cool
Fantastic and heartfelt throughout. A wonderful expression of love in so many fun and iconic songs, absolutely something for anyone to enjoy. Some of Sinatra's best work, with great performances from him and his backing band
Listened to this while unpacking boxes in my new flat. Perfect accompaniment.
The work of Ol’ Blue Eyes is about as American as apple pie, baseball, hot dogs, and voting for fascists.
Heartstrings invariably tether with another’s in proximity to this classic crooner’s most classic croons.
Really good music
6.5/10
It’s Frank, Chairman of the Board at his best
Reading about Frank Sinatra’s life is more interesting than listening to his music. I found the whole album to be dull.
One of the greatest singers of all time.
Hearing Frank always puts a smile on my face.
How can you not feel good after listening to such a tight package as this?
Perhaps the most classic of all voices from his era. Every song is great, if not a bit formulaic. Perhaps a touch of weak lyric writing, but always pleasant
Meh
- Macht sehr gute Laune - Würde ich wahrscheinlich nochmal hören aber eher für den Hintergrund und nicht aktiv - Ist schwierig einen Topsong zu finden, da alles gut klingt und einfach gute Laune macht - Klingt alles leicht ähnlich Topsong: Pennies from Heaven
Frank Sinatra's music is timeless. Something I love about old recordings, specifically Sinatra's, is that they feel so close. Listening to this album felt like I was in the room with the musicians. Recorded music tends to be so produced now, which isn't always a bad thing, but this album definitely made me wish there were more efforts to simplify the process sometimes. Of course, as is the case with most older music, this wasn't the most exciting listen, and the songs did seem to mimic each other at times. Even then, Sinatra's silky vocals and intentional lyrical delivery made me return to this album a few times after my first listen. I especially enjoyed his rendition of Anything Goes. He took a classic song and completely made it his own with only minor changes. Sinatra was a master at singing like he was conversing. He really communicated with his listeners, and there's a joyful lightness to the way he interpreted the words of songs. At a time when most songs were written by writers instead of the artists themselves, he took great care of other people's work and did his due diligence as a vocalist. Despite the fact that this isn't my exact type of album, Sinatra ensured that I, along with all of his listeners, spent the 45 minutes listening to this album fully immersed in the stories he was telling.
I love standards and I have performed many of these songs before. There are many misogynistic undertones but that maybe adds to its charm. this was certainly a moment in time.
Velvet smooth vocals, and definitely one of his best collections. Ideal Sunday morning music
Frank Sinatra's voice wasn't as good as people praise it. There, I said it. The songs are catchy, and remind me of New York City on a Summer night, but they're not distinguished enough. My rating is actually generous. Favorite Track: "Makin' Whoopee".
The only way I knew a new song started is because they all started the same way
Was pleasantly surprised I enjoyed the whole album. Frank does have a beautiful voice.
yess
What a classic, and what a voice. You don't hear them like that anymore.
Good for this type of music but just not for me
Fun album. Maybe I’m sentimental because I got it on my anniversary, but I liked it a lot.
I love a bit of swing music and Sinatra is just that guy. He sounds so good even if all the songs start to sound the same. I’ve Got You Under My Skin is phenomenal and a major highlight of the album! Great stuff!
Idk these songs sound pretty monogamous to me
this was quite chill and vibey
Ok def some bangers on here I feel like a lot of annoying people I know love Frank Sinatra though. What's that about
fun!
Pure perfection! Sinatra's velvet voice coupled with these American songbook classics are an unbeatable combination. Put this on the next time you're chilling with some wine or hosting friends for dinner.
Sounds like another Sinatra album. My friend Kurt loved him when we were teenagers, oddly.
Loved it and the big band sound
Reluctant to give another album of this era such a high rating as I do it every time... but they are all so substantial. This case of course is no exception. Incredibly well crafted arrangements and lyrics, with one of the greatest voices of all time on top.
Growing up, my grandmother loved Frank Sinatra and this is one of the albums she plays on her couch-sized phonograph. I rejected Frankie, because he was so "old" by which I meant, pre-rock. Now I love his voice, but much of the overbearing big band backups I never cared for. This is just right, the horns accompanying, not overpowering Frankie's voice. It's a keeper. 4/5
You know what this was pretty good
Worth a listen and it has a certain feel to it which is quite nice. Not something I need, but I enjoyed listening to it. 2/5 stars.
This album is a well done steak and all you have is a butter knife, but then again given the title I'm not sure if I should even be listening to this. 2.5
Excellent album!! Classic Sinatra. Smooth, clean and fresh. Could listen to this music for hours.
"Five Stars... songs from the great American songbook... done by Francis Albert... in 1956... "I've Got You Under My Skin", "You Make Me Feel So Young, and one of my all time faves, Jimmy Van Hueusen and Johnny Mercer's "I Thought About You"... you get the idea... the thing that amazes me, a singer myself, is the effortless way ol' blue eyes has an underlying vibrato all throughout his singing... high and low... and yet, it's so subtle, that you hardly notice it's going on... making him sound simultaneously like a trained artist, and an every man... amazing... like a bridge between Caruso and Dylan... not to mention his flawless phrasing... and the impact of the Nelson Riddle Orchestra... did i say Five stars already? yep..."
Sinatra is a legend. Will say that a lot of the stuff on here had the same sound/vibe, but I don't hate it!
So good. 4.5
Ol’ Blue Eyes. Crazy how charismatic this man was. As big as Elvis. As big as The Beatles. The archetype of the 1950’s class and style. The music was easy to digest and 40 minutes flew by. The style of music relies heavily on the same tricks of start, stop crescendos but each song sounds distinctive of the next. I’ve heard the hits and never bothered looking into his discography but this album is nearly perfect and will definitely seek out a physical copy as it is a must-have. Consider me a fan.
The backing band had some good tunes. I never understood Frank Sinatra and still I don't think I understand his appeal. The only thing I can think of is he sounds like a guy trying to sing, there was a mass brainwashing to popularize his songs so regular guys could sing them to their girls and sound just like Sinatra. I really don't understand it.
Allt låter samma
same ol' Sinatra things
Never was a fan of the Big Band era. And I never thought Frank's voice was anything but average to mundane. Probably good after sipping several martinis though!
I’m glad people in the 50s liked this, but I in 2025 just do not have that gene
Perhaps not as ambitious as most other albums on the list, but while primitive it is still a very pleasant listen. There’s a certain innocence in a lot of the music of the 1950s and early 60s, which I honestly adore
His tenth album. Jazz. Peak Frank as he seems to effortlessly belt out songs in his style. A very relaxed, whiskey sippin' album to chill out to. Great arrangement on the album too. What more can you say ? It's Frank.
This is pretty good. I would need to be in the mood for it.
Felt as if I was inside a Disney classic
8/10… big band / swing
Yes, this guy is trying to get into your grandmother’s pants. But the band sounds great, and every single one was tracked live with vocals. THE Crooner. Pretty cheesy material, but that was the style at the time.
This album begs for the crack, hiss, and pop of vinyl. It's very much of its time while also feeling comfortably familiar and timeless. You Make Me Feel So Young, Old Devil Moon, and I've Got You Under My Skin all added to Liked Songs.
Not my favorite collection of Sinatra songs, but it was okay.
ma divota!
It is an iconic voice and sound, but I am just not fully on board with the crooning genre.
I don’t care for Sinatra, would be open to non-Sinatra swing from this list. Riddle the real MVP
Certainly nothing to complain about here. I love having an excuse to end up on the Cole Porter Wikipedia page. Good stuff
Brilliant songs—and definitive versions of them. Adult and sexy. Swoon.
Makes me feel like a proper civilised adult. I want to go to a bar and order Jack Daniel’s
Call me a swingin’ lover the way I enjoy this album!!! Super high quality swing music from the king of the voice frank Sinatra himself, not a single miss and from the 50’s too is just yumm
There’s a reason why people glorify the 50s, and Sinatra is apart of that. Such a dynamic voice that is backed by a sweet swinging jazz band. No misses, just a great well rounded album.
THE voice. It’s all said! 👍
I can see how this is a great album. It felt so classy and yet so warm. So happy and yet so far. It was a peculiar feeling, but a pleasant one. I liked it a lot. Not exactly my cup of tea, but it's a good one. For me, it's an 8.5 mini0n, 11/09/2025
Commuting to this soundtrack makes life a movie
#115/1001. There is only one Frank Sinatra. Which is great, since if there was more, there would be way too much crooning and swinging. I was wondering what will be the oldest LP on this list (I think it is another Sinatra record) and meanwhile searched for a bit of LP format history. Turns out a Sinatra album was among the first LPs released as a batch in 1948 - although that album had been issued as a set of four 78 rpm discs earlier. This one at the table here is as far as I understood a collection of existing popular songs handpicked for Sinatra, who in turn made the definite standard classic and eternal versions out of so many. Individually they all shine, but something about rhe instrumentation, the delivery and the general swinging mood just repeats itself. Which I guess is a blessing more than a curse.
This was a wonderful album. Filled with jazz favourites sung by one of the greatest jazz artists. I listened to it twice.
Throughout my album journey, I have noticed an inevitability that certain artists whose legacies have withstood the test of time will receive at least one or two inclusions in the books. Case in point, Frank Sinatra, often regarded as one of the greatest singers of the 20th century, got two albums included. To be fair, Songs for Swingin' Lovers is a pleasant little record. Sinatra's sultry voice and Nelson Riddle's bombastic orchestral arrangements made for a potent combination of ripe textures to these traditional pop standards. Renditions of the likes of Cole Porter's "Anything Goes" and "I've Got You Under My Skin", as well as other cuts such as Josef Myrow's "You Make Me Feel Young" and Burton Lane's "Old Devil Moon" come off as smooth and delectable as butter. That said, it made for an album experience where Sinatra and Riddle stuck to a formula that certainly worked, but didn't push the envelope any further. Also not helping matters were a few instances of the cover selections having language that aged weirdly, such as Walter Donaldson's "Makin' Whoopee". Still, Songs for Swingin' Lovers proved to be a mostly classy good time. I am certainly curious about the other Frank Sinatra album included.
As a full record, this is not really a cohesive piece. The reason I give it this rating however is because I feel relaxed while listening to it. Every song passes me with a slight warm impression and that's enough. Sinatra sails through the night and gets the job done. That is enough for an honorable man (7/10, 4/5 on this scale)
A lovely listen while sorting through holiday photos of the one you love most.
That's repulsive.
La voz de Frank Sinatra se siente como un abrazo, te envuelve junto con la melodía perfectamente ejecutada por las trompetas, violines, piano y demás instrumentos. Me gusta que las canciones sea corta porque a pesar de ser bastante parecidas entre ellas no se hacen pesadas o como si estuvieras escuchando todo el rato lo mismo, y las letras son muy bonitas. Me ha gustado mucho el álbum, me ha recordado a la navidad y algunas canciones parecen una banda sonora de alguna película. En general muy alegre y buen rollo. Canciones favs: you make me feel so young, too marvelous for words, pennies from heaven, I've got you under my skin, I thought about you, anything goes