Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme by Simon & Garfunkel

Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme

Simon & Garfunkel

3.61
Rating
30539
Votes
1
2%
2
10%
3
32%
4
38%
5
19%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 15)

Folky, very folky.

Honestly not an album I super love. It's a bit too all-over-the-place for me. I like Simon & Garfunkel but I only ever like maybe 60%-70% of each album. I do think 7 O'Clock News/Silent Night is interesting as piece of art (both for the obvious juxtaposition of the peaceful imagery of Silent Night with the horrors of war and also the fact that neither of them sing the melody, inviting the listener to do so), but it's not an album I will listen to whole.

very interesting

Very nice album and quite eclectic. Enjoyed all the tracks. The Bob Dylan parody was hilarious!

This record reminds me of my mom. I have fond memories of helping her cook in the kitchen as a young child, and whenever a recipe called for any of the herbs named in the record's title, she would sing the line from "Scarborough Fair". I do the same thing in my head to this day.

The only good songs on here are the ones that end up on the Greatest Hits albums. As for the album as a whole, remember what Rufus said in Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure - they get better.

Album #30 of my 1,001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die List Simon and Garfunkel - Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme I’ve dabbled in Simon & Garfunkel before, though not this album. It’s loaded with songs that filled me with melancholy, as in, the songs kind of depressed me. It’s not just this album, but a lot of folk music kind of depresses me. No idea why. There are some upbeat moments like A Simple Desultory Phillipic, in which Paul Simon does pretty good impression of Bob Dylan. But otherwise, it's a lot of acoustic guitar & heartbreak. The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine is a hoot. The album is a masterpiece & I find myself listening to it over & over. Many of the songs or their arrangements make them feel like they were sung in the woods by knights who are drinking grog in a tavern in the forest on their way to slay a dragon. The fancy way of saying that is baroque. The album is really short, which is commendable. All the songs are great, & you are likely to have heard Homeward Bound. If you want a taste of why S&G were such a huge influence on folk and music in general, this is a great album to listen to.

I really enjoyed this album. I was quite familiar with some of the songs as my parents had some of these songs on what must have been a compilation album that I listened to growing up. It is quite beautiful. Bonus points, for a project like this where I find it quite difficult to keep up with the album per day pace, was that it clocked in at only 28 minutes. More bonus points for the song Silent Night which is a top tier Christmas song. I can't wait to add it to the rotation in December.

This album made me want to curl up next to a window to watch the rain, sip on tea and work in a puzzle. A delightful soundtrack to a quiet moment alone. Will remember this famous duo when the occasional arises soon

Would buy

Brilliant album

Really was not a fan. Just wasn't for me. I found the whole thing pretty boring. There were a few tracks that didn't make me feel like I was falling asleep and that's the only reason I'm giving it 2 stars instead of one. There was just nothing exciting about it, nothing that stood out or grabbed my attention. Maybe I'll explore it again in the future but for now it's a no for me.

Like a warm hug....that occasionally scolds you about the Vietnam War

Lovely songwriting, loved every minute of it.

Great album, solid tunes throughout and no lulls

They were very good. It's a shame they banged each other and ruined the duo. The downside was my mum kept trying to sing along

Art Garfunkel was absolutely carried by Paul Simon throughout his career, Paul outshining him at every single opportunity. No wonder he went solo tbh. Not my favourite S&G album but definitely some bops on there

This was wonderful. Every track was enjoyable, no skips. Simon & Garf really knew what they were doing and it shows. Five stars.

More emotional than good

Pretty chill album, nothing exciting but I think that it's a bit outdated nowadays, although it's still pretty alright. It's just a bunch of talking while music is playing in the background but yes.

I love Simon and Garfunkel their music feels like a calm rainy autumn morning. This album is poetry masterpiece.

Not my taste, still good music

just came home from a party night. too lazy to write more than this

I often wonder if Paul really needed Art... Couple of bangers, some more folky bits that I'm never really sold on. Gets four purely for 59th street bridge song. Was a favourite of mine growing up.

Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme? More like Poetic, Delicate, Timeless and Harmonies.

This was very comforting - good length because it would have dragged if was longer. Esp liked the last song with it’s theming

For a lot more mellow and less developed Simon & Garfunkel, it doesn't reach the same high of some of their other albums. Feels more soulless and like they aren't using their potential. Homeward Bound is a great song, but it isn't as developed as their later hits.

Folk poético, melódico y tranquilo

It would probably be a 2 or possibly a 3 depending on what the singles were as there are definitely some flops (the awful Silent night for example). There are definitely moments which are worth listening to again, and the album overall works well, it's just not to my taste. I would probably enjoy it more if they were playing in a pub, but I can't see myself listening to it at home again. Interesting hearing as an album as there are some interesting things like similar riffs and motives coming back in different songs.

If you judged this by its cover and went in hoping for some great quality, soppy floral stuff, then it delivers.

Couple of bangers but rest of the album is meh

Surprisingly good, likely something I won't listen to again. Maybe pick out certain songs.

Inoffensive, but ultimately forgettable

CLASSIC! Loved the album before, will continue to love it forever. I can't believe we got scarborough fair and homeward bound on the same album.

This is what country/folk music really is.

Beautiful, relaxing, melodious and stunning!

Some good, catchy songs. Trivial lyrics. Pop music from before I was born.

Another older album. Nothing really special that I noticed in this one. I did really like the silent night song though. Not exactly something I want to listen to all the time, but artistic and impactful.

So excited to see this album pop up - I love Simon and Garfunkel's music! I really like the variety in this album.

Like the feel of the opening song (smth canticle) that reminds me of sound of silence? Would be interesting to pin down. The multiple threads going in each song was interesting (esp closing song) but would be tough for me to appreciate without the lyrics. Very cohesive album/consistent, was a fan.

Everyday's an endless stream/Of cigarettes and magazines

Listened to 2 consecutive full Simon and Garfunkel albums because of this site. This obviously doesn't sound as clean as their last album from 1970, but it's still good. The very last song on this album is the most important and relevant right now in 2025

Low-key, well-written.

Maybe I'm in a more amenable mood than usual, but I didn't hate this. Sure it's acoustic. Sure it's folk or at least folk-adjacent. But there's something "dark" for lack of a better term that seems to exist just below the surface of the harmonies, and that makes me at least a little interested in it. In all honesty, I'm starting to think that's Art's influence since Paul's solo work feels so different.

I'm just happy for the chap who was able to reminisce about their late father

Simon and Garfunkel are fine but I roll my eyes every time they appear on this list, they’re just such a bore to listen to

Moody, sonically beautiful, and lyrically outstanding. Maybe not S&G’s greatest, but still an excellent record. Hear the Dylan influence overtly on A Simply Desultory Phillic. Almost too overt. For Emily… is such a gem.

Listened to this on a walk with the dog after a heavy storm passed through and the sun just starting to go down and it definitely nailed the vibe. Very solid

Sounds like floating down a river in a drug haze

Clean S n G. Philipic indicates that maybe Bobby D not so easy as it looks. Come at the king best not miss, and this is a miss. Otherwise stellar harmonies and tight songwriting/production.

Oof we'll see about this. Good song writing and performances. Patterns was kind of a cool track. I like the sense of space in the production, but I wish everything wasn't panned so hard left or right. A Simple Desultory Philipic kinda kicks ass. Love the fuzztone bass. The final track was pretty haunting. Disturbing but also reassuring in the juxtaposition of finding beauty in difficult times. The social and political commentary is an interesting snapshot of the 60s, but at times it feels very relevant to today. Idk if I'll ever revisit this one, but I'm glad I gave it a chance

This is the 185th album I’m rating. Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme that is a Lana Del Rey rhyme. Adding to my Playlist - Cloudy, Homeward Bound, The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine, The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy), Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall, and A Simple Desultory Philippic (or How I Was Robert McNamara'd into Submission). Not Adding to my Playlist - Scarborough Fair/Canticle, Patterns, The Dangling Conversation, For Emily, Whenever I may Find Her, A Poem on the Underground Wall, and 7 O'Clock News/Silent Night. 7 O'Clock News/Silent Night - I prefer the version with Fiona Apple. All in all I liked 6/12 songs. Not as bad as I thought it would be based off of how much I disliked Graceland.

Short and sweet! It doesn't quite compare to the albums that came after it but its still a absolute delight! The harmonization on "Scarborough Fair" makes me melt. Favorite track: Scarborough Fair/Canticle

Nuit du 5 au 6 août. The dangling conversation 💓

Whatever man, silent night.

Solid, laid back. Definitely got the 60's Summer of Love vibes

big tavern silencing the haters

I'm not really one to give this a proper review really because this sort of music loses my interest at some point, but their voices are gorgeous and it wasn't anywhere near as monotonous as other folk albums, meaning I did enjoy a fair few songs, like the opening one. A high 3. Oh and their Bob Dylan pisstake did make me giggle too

Wasnt enjoying it too much but then Dylans voice came on and tanked the whole damn thing

Good, but not quite a 4

so adorable and cute

A little Garfunkel with my Simon.

It’s impact in the times is bigger than how the music has held up, especially compared to their other albums.

Wasn’t for me

Even though I’ve never listened to a lot of Simon and Garfunkel their brilliant lyrics and song writing are hard to ignore. I really liked this album.

i love simon & garfunkel ! the title track is iconic but i forgot about a lot of the other songs. they are quite good even if not up to the singles standard. also i really like the silent night version

short and sweet folk album. i enjoy the more downtempo songs here. the more upbeat ones not so much. not something i would put on myself but i won't be mad if someone put it on

Can’t playlist it because it’s a specific vibe

was trully expecting rock/pop but nevertheless was pleasantly surprised. It won't be my favourite album that's for sure but it was a nice alternative for previous albums

I don't usually like folk music all that much, but this was a pleasant experience.

Esses dois anões (Garfunkel não é tão baixo na realidade), numa voz fanha, quiseram satirizar Kerouac e Dylan. Quanta pretensão. Achei meio bosta o nome do álbum ser um monte de tempero também. "Qual o seu álbum favorito?" "Salsinha, sálvia, alecrim e tomilho".

Simon & Garfunkel were the high brow counter culture of the 60s. Even as they engage the folk rock vibe with songs like “Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine,” they exhibit their discomfort with it as they satirize Bob Dylan (then in his prime) in “A Simple Desultory Philippic.” Most of the album, however, is classic Simon & Garfunkel: gentle, poetic, telling stories and developing characters. Always worthwhile, even if not always stunning.

Simon & Garfunkel are great, but I just don't consider them an album duo. They have great singles and great greatest hits collections. Their albums don't stay with me like other great albums from other bands... That said, I enjoyed this album, though it feels more like a nostalgic enjoyment. I can't really figure out where to place them in my own catalog of greatness - though they are there somewhere.

genre: folk rock vibe: driving through farmland or lowkey traveling merchant sometimes 😍 fav songs: - scarborough fair / canticle - patterns - flowers never bend with the rainfall - a poem on the underground wall

I was really impressed with this album. I’ve seen it for sale at garage sales for dirt cheap and I never picked it up cause I thought it was a less successful album for whatever reason, but this album is great. It is definitely a slower album like a lot of their work, but there’s a good amount of variety on it as well. While I don’t think it’s either of their best album, I do think this album might be under appreciated by people who have a similar first impression as I did when I saw the cover. That’s also my only major complaint is I don’t love the cover. I know portraits are kinda their thing when it comes to album covers, but I just find it boring. Either way this album is definitely a “don’t judge it by its cover” type of album.

My teacher in 7th grade used to play this record for class to calm all of us sugar overdosed kids to get us to calm TF down. I learned to truly appreciate it. Now it gives me fond memories every time I hear just one song off it.

Short but nice. It scratches a very specific itch in my brain that I love listening to.

too mellow for me

Very short album. Didn’t love it but I get why it’s important. Sounds like Northampton liberal elite stuff. Weird sound collage about Vietnam war. Very earnest sounding bordering on pretentious.

Sorry, but I don’t find this band good. It is the second album that I have to rate and for me it’s like bad church songs with very cheesy lyrics. I do not enjoy the voice of him and it’s too repetitive.

Love the harmonies. Beautiful voices that just mesh well

Didn't like most of this album. Just very soft and not what I prefer. I did like the song A Simple Desultory Phillipic a lot. 2.5/5.

my first Simon & Garfunkel album! They know how to create an atmosphere in a song, I noticed it initially with the song Patterns. The guitar work was incredible, although a few songs were lackluster for me.

On A Tour Of One Night Stands 1001 Albums Generator 83 (07/28/2025) Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme is the third studio album by contemporary folk legends Simon And Garfunkel. Despite featuring two of their biggest songs in Scarborough Fair and Homeward Bound, PSR&T is often not held in the same regard as the duo's later albums, Bookends and Bridge Over Troubled Water. Personally, I had actually never even heard of this album, but man I have really been missing out. This is a wonderful collection of 2-3 minute folk songs with the harmonies that Simon And Garfunkel are known for. As I previously alluded to, the two big hits on this album are Scarborough Fair and Homeward Bound. Scarborough Fair is actually a traditional English folk tune that Simon And Garfunkel rearranged and added anti-war lyrics to. The duo actually only listed themselves as songwriters, choosing to not include the traditional source, which got the group into some trouble. The way the duo interweave lyrics from the two songs is genius and the tale of a lost love juxtaposes nicely with the lyrics of the horrors of war. Homeward Bound, on the other hand, is relatively simpler, but it is my favorite. The lyrics detail Paul Simon's homesickness while he was on tour and the chorus is probably the catchiest bit on the album. Folk pop perfection. For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her is a beautiful love song that Paul Simon managed to write in a single night. I started trying to learn this one and was surprised how difficult it is to perform. Patterns was originally featured on Paul Simon's debut album (as many S&G songs were) and has the weirdest guitar work on the album, alongside some crazy bongos. It's great. The album ends on a strange note with 7 O'Clock News / Silent Night, which is a collage of a piano-led rendition of the Christmas classic Silent Night alongside a slowly crescendo'ing broadcast of the nightly news. It's really weird, but honestly beautiful. The more rockish songs are in general not as high quality. The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine, which has a great title, is perhaps the weakest song here. A Simple Desultory Philippic is an obvious Bob Dylan pisstake, with shitty harmonica and all. As a parody, it's honestly quite funny, but on an album full of such beautiful songs, I'm not sure that it really works. Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme is a beautiful album from one of the greatest folk duos of all time. It features an eclectic mix of soft folk with folk rock that flies by in its short runtime. Some weaker moments hold it back from perfection, but it's a 4/5. Favs: Scarborough Fair / Canticle Homeward Bound For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her Least Fav: The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine

It's not as strong as other albums by them but it's a nice easy listen. Some tracks are actual songs others are poetry set to music. I prefer the actual songs, but the others are nice. It's a solid album, a bit dated now but that's going to happen.

Listened

Great folk

Kocham folk. A to jest piękny folk. Z cudownymi tekstami. Tylko ta cicha noc na koniec psuje wrażenie. Inaczej byłby album prawie idealny, a tak to obniżam ocenę na 8.5/10 i równam w dół. Po co wam to było?!

Very ethereal sounding folk music. Angelic harmonizations. Somewhat odd song topics. This is also probably the duo's least accessible record, but that's not to say it doesn't mean there aren't memorable songs on here. Key tracks: Scarborough Fair/Canticle Homeward Bound 7 O'Clock News/Silent Night

it was boring to listen to but had songs that were interesting. sounded really good but didn't grasp my attention

So soft.

Short and sweet and simple. Maybe not super for me but pleasant enough to listen to. My favourite part was realising that The Simpsons cribbed some of the lyrics on this album and now I get the reference.

Man, that album cover is terrible. Don’t judge the album by that though. Paul Simon pens some great songs here.

While not their best (admittedly not saying much considering their best), this is excellent collection of folk tunes. A continual refinement of their sound that they would come to perfect on later albums.

I love all things Simon & Garfunkel and rated their previous album on this list a 3. I'm going with the same for this album, mainly because while it has some bangers, the second half of the album is really annoying and short songs with rambling poetry just can't hang. I really appreciated Paul Simon's solo work and I can see how these 2 would have never made it far if they didn't split up. 3.21/5 stars.

Kult album.

Silent night is a classic with the news overlay? I love it

Soothing and enjoyable but nothing special, but it didn't need to be either.

This was sooooo great, one point a song sounded just like Babe Rainbow

Nice, quick, and fine listen. 6/10

It’s ok

This is excellent. Way better than Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme. The Boxer is just a perfect track. The model tracks glide along without much consequence.

A few great jams on this album (feelin' groovy I have had as an ear worm for the last 20 years) but also some kind of strange stuff that feels a bit out of place. Still undeniably brilliant songwriting but as a whole I wouldn't say this album is their best.

A masterclass in songwriting in a surprisingly short album. Scarborough Fair / Canticle is an obvious classic, but I really enjoyed Patterns and the Bright Green Pleasure Machine. Also as a major fan of Bob Dylan, I loved A Simple Desultory Philippic (or How I Was Robert McNamara’d Into Submission). My only complaint is that some of softer, dreamier songs are just a bit too soft and sweet for me and they somehow start sounding like parodies of Simon & Garfunkel.

Lots of classics packed into a 28-minute album

It was a five star album until the Bob Dylan parody, and fuck that pretentious silent night shit at the end. But otherwise it is a genuinely stunning record with the most incredible harmonies and beautiful songs.

I feel schizophrenic getting this after Lightning Bolt. These guys piss me off so much: they make the wimpiest, most self-satisfied music around and they're extremely talented. Fuckers!

Feeling Goofy! The folks at 4Ex had this album (I would say shortly after it dropped) as I remember it getting played through the late 60s and knew all the lyrics back then. Haven’t heard it in over 50 years, but still familiar with all the songs. L= (1.5*s) Scarborough Fair and Homeward Bound are good, the rest of the album is whimpy ballads. J = (3.3*s) Flowers Never Bend leads the way, and I like the ballads.

I think I prefer the herbs over the album. This is a bit limp-wristed. Best song was the Dylan pastiche "A Simple Desultory Phillippic" (whatever that means). I'm just not an S&G guy. Unfortunately we are bound to see more from the duo on the list and I hope they are better records. These 2 herbivores get 1.48 stars for this one.

Simon & Garfunkel certainly have a signature sound but I'm not sure it holds up over the length of an album. I really enjoy the soft vocals and delicate instrumentals on Scarborough Fair/Canticle, but after that it's pretty easy to tune out the rest of the album. It's hard to knock the album as it contains some fine work, it's just nothing I would sit an listen to unless I'm trying to meditate, fall asleep or take a relaxing bath or something. There must have been some sort of wider allure when this was contemporary in 1966, but I don't know. I'm glad I heard it before I died I guess but I don't think I'll ever listen to it again. 2.02 stars

Not my favorite Simon and Garfunkel album, but has some excellent tunes

Scarborough fair is decent. Lyrics are good, and S&G have always been good at using stereo sound to create atmosphere in their music. 3/5

A classic!

Very much not a folk person so couldn’t really appreciate this that much. Very melodic and tight overall, but just not really my bag.

Cloudy and Homeward Bound go hard, I'm suprised by how good this is honestly, all bangers and soothing lullabies, most just as good as the songs they are known for.

My least favorite of the S&G albums I’ve gotten so far. Just didn’t really click with me, and ending on “Silent Night” kind of sealed my thoughts on it. 2.5 /5

Nobody could harmonize like Simon and Garfunkel. This album is a truly transcendent experience. The “Silent Night” ending hits pretty close to home these days. Unfortunately timeless.

Sublime. Great Harmonies and guitar work. Timeless.

Man, taking me back to my childhood and loooong drives.

A slightly generous 4 The general vibe was good, classic tracks such as homeward bound still hold the test of time

This is a masterclass in harmonizing. I also loved hearing the Afro-Cuban influence on Patterns that Paul Simon would take into his solo career on things like Graceland.

4 for the album. 5 for, For Emily. One of the greatest love songs.

Two shoulder two chips lift the ego tension to sublime levels

Better than I thought it would be but I still had to listen to it in shifts. The memory of the songs of theirs that I really like... Hazy Shade of Winter, Cecilia, Sound of Silence, 56th St Bridge Song... propelled me through, and I do like their vocal harmonies, but I think this is one band where I can honestly say I like their greatest hits, and not much else. Respect them? yes.

Atemporal

Day 3 First listen- Lovely to see this album here! I have been meaning to listen to it fully. I have only listened to Scarborough Fair / Canticle and For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her before. (4/5) Now that I have fully listened to it, loveee the album. For Emily, whenever I may find her is DEFFO my fav.

another 3.5 that i’m not quite willing to give a 4. i really want to give an album a higher or different rating but nothing has really blown me away about any of the albums so far. i rlly liked some of these songs but it just doesnt have enough substance to really hold me or engage me beyond just simple enjoyment.

Kinda nice

This album has some hits I recognize, but the album is all over the place. The short songs and varied styles demanded constant attention in a way that seemed to fight with the individual songs. Better than the other albums I've given a 3 so far. Maybe this is the bottom of 4.

A few good songs but I find it funny that I really enjoyed the Bob Dylan spoof “A Simple Desultory Philippic” as it sounded a bit different. I think I’d listen to “Homeward Bound” again but prefer Paul Simon’s solo stuff personally.

Heard it before. Not a single bad song on this album, the right mix of serious and a bit more fun 4/5

There’s a few good tracks on here

Wie auf einem Mittelalterfest und sehr nostalgisch klingend, sehr schön

Maybe not my fav S&G album but brilliant nonetheless the less

I like the brevity of the album. 28 minutes was a good amount of time for the simple tunes to sustain my interest. Best part of the album was definitely the lyrics. Very poetic, and pleasing to the ear. My fave song was The Dangling Conversation, the singing was great on that one. Fave lyric was from A Simple Desultory Philippic, "Been Phil Spectored, resurrected" crazy Hollywood lore pull in a S&G song. Sometimes I'll think where is this going, only to be surprised in the end of the song with something really good. This is not typically my kind of music, but I can see why it's so revered.

Without doubt have of the great duos, despite their issues their vocals complement each other perfectly. Homeward bound is a beautifully crafted song, but that along with 59th street highlight that some of the other songs (Big bright green pleasure machine) dont quite live up to that exceptional standard. It also feels odd to include a Christmas song on a normal album, no matter how good that song is

This album ultimately sums up my thoughts on Simon & Garfunkel: inoffensive, but does nothing for me.

This left me with Homeward Bound stuck in my head all day because I'm a certain age and so it's inextricably tied to Michael J Fox voicing a Bulldog. I think their voices are lovely and the songs are pleasant but that this particular S&G album didn't really do it for me. I have always liked "The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)" and "A Simple Desultory Philippic (or How I Was Robert McNamara'd into Submission)" though. Bemoaning the lack of a half star again, I'm going for: 3/5

9/10 Turns out I love S&G, 2 five star albums so far. This one was pure folk rock, a lovely collection of little gems. I had heard way more of these than I thought I had. You’ve got to respect an album that gets its job done in 30 minutes and is more or less perfect. Best: Homeward Bound

Great harmonies and great tunes. I’d be curious to learn more about that Bob Dylan homage/parody, what’s the story behind that?

BEST SONGS: - Homeward Bound - The Dangling Conversation - For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her

mais ou menos

Didn't love every song but definitely one I'll listen through again

I was beyond excited to have the chance to listen to this Simon & Garfunkel album in full, as I adore Scarborough Fair & Homeward Bound. The band's sound is unique, being primarily folk with a bit of rock influence. It's the kind of music that ages exceptionally well. Through the generations of my family, from my grandfather to my dad to myself, we can all enjoy a good Simon & Garfunkel album. This album was relatively short, but it's varied with a good mix of soothing, uplifting, and solemn tracks. I hope to have the chance to listen to another in this generator.

Reet lovely that

I liked the album, really had a unique feel and instrumentation for 1966. Not your standard folk album. However ending with "Silent Night" is a let down. 3.5/5

most of the songs in the album made me feel like i was frolicking in a meadow

Makes a virtue of simple, meandering melodies. The lyrics are tough to judge because to a modern sensibility they seem a tad pretentious, but if taken at their word, they were incredibly in tune with the times they lived in. I choose to take them at their word.

“My life is made of patterns, that can scarcely be controlled” 77/100 Favorite: Patterns

Me ha parecido monísimo y me ha dejado con ganas de escuchar más canciones suyas, lo cual es un logro. The Dangling Conversation es buenísima y no sé cómo no la había escuchado antes.

Back to form with Simon & Garfunkel. Grew on me more and more as it went on. A solid 4 for me, Clive.

Close to a 4, but the last song and the Dylan pisstake mark it down. 3.5.

Gash bar about three songs. Mercifully short though

First listen

I enjoyed the melodies and harmonies, which is what Simon & Garfunkel are known for. Its interesting to consider this in context to the time period in which it was written. At the time, many folk artists were considered counter-culturists, even though the music is sweet and pleasant. The lyrics are strong, and I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. I was familiar with the famous songs, and I never liked them enough to listen to an entire album. I'm glad I did, but I don't know how often I would listen to stuff like this.

My mother used to listen to music like this when I was a small child. Hated it then, hate it now.

Really beautiful music. I think they’ve done the best medieval folk sound out of the albums I’ve heard so far. The last song gave me chills.

When I was a kid, about 11 years old, or so, I wanted a cassette player/recorder for my birthday. My folks came close, and gave me a cassette player that did not record. For a portable unit, it actually had pretty decent sound. Anyway, this is one of two cassettes that they gave me along with the player. I don’t remember what the other cassette was. I think that they gave me this one based on the advice of the record store guy, and also because they could actually stomach hearing this one. Suffice to say, I’ve been very familiar with this album for over 55 years now. I will also say that I like this album a lot better now than I did as a kid. Other than a couple of tracks, for the most part I think it’s aged pretty well; and I love their simple arrangement of silent night. Although the newscast in the background makes a powerful statement, I wish I had a version of it in its simplicity isolated from the news commentary. Another thing I like is that both the songs and the album is short…you don’t get a chance to get bored or tired of it. I was able to pick up a cheap vinyl copy in the last few years that is in excellent condition, as the cassette that I had is long gone, having met the fate of being “eaten” as happens to most cassettes eventually. In any event, this would be a five star album for me if not for a couple of the songs. As it is, I’ll give it a very strong four stars.

Classic album.

"Sine wave" album, there is some great songs and some really shit songs. Overall, this is something I listen to while staring into the horizon or in the great plains or smth. Favourite Song: Homeward Bound

Folksy Some political

Great Album. A lot of classic S&G songs. Music and vocals top notch.

Good album- made me revisit Bridge over troubled water too as I think I was too harsh on it. Need a 3.5 star rating really

Для фона и приятного прослушивания - потрясающий альбом и довольно необычный в моей коллекции. 8 из 10.

A delightful folk album. Short and sweet, yet remarkably mature and well-arranged. Beautiful vocal harmonies. Favourite moments have to be the more acoustic songs (e.g. "For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her") and the more baroque leanings of "Scarborough Fair/Canticle." Kind of speaks for itself, really. Either way, highly recommended.

bright and gentle, short and sweet

Beautiful music I didn't know from Simon & Garfunkel.

Was leaning towards a 3 but had to bump to a 4 after the Bob Dylan diss track. Feels like a soundtrack for a cartoon mouse prince who lives amongst woodland creatures. Can see the influence in Woodlands by Paper Kites, Mystery of Love by Sufjan Stevens, all over the place really.

A Simple Desultory Philippic is both a hit track and apt impression of Bob Dylan? Lol. Either way, it's completely out of place on a bunch of nice songs that go together well by two musicians clearly at their artistic prime.

Gentle, calm, and poetic album with beautiful harmonies and melancholic mood.

Faborote: Flowers Never Bend Just 2 dudes on guitar. Stellar.

Bob Dylan found nuked from orbit at Scarborough Fair

This is my third Simon and Garfunkel album on this list, and it is probably my least favorite. It isn't bad by any means, just feels a little redundant. The songwriting just doesn't feel as strong on this album. I still enjoyed the album as much as a guy who doesn't like folk can. High 3.

I like this one. Reminds me of simpler times

Really liked this one! Calm mellow vibes. Best song: Patterns Notable(s): The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine, For Emily, Wherever I May Find Her, 7 O'Clock News/Silent Night (this one is just a really neat concept)

Honestly never heard some of these songs ever before. The acclaim they received back then was well deserved. These were amazing compositions and recordings... Why can't music like this be imagined anymore?

I don't really understand the haters on this. Is it mind-blowing? Not really, but it's certainly fun, easy listening. I'd listen to more Simon & Garfunkel after this - 4/5

It's good, but not quite my genre of music

Not a fan, maybe I need to do some mushrooms

Starts off on a high note with Scarborough Fair, but the rest of the album doesn't quite compare even if there are some smooth harmonies.

'My life is made of patterns / That can scarcely be controlled.' This record is defined by control, particularly the impossibly gorgeous arrangement of 'Parsley, Sage, Rosemary, and Thyme,' a traditional English ballad the duo makes very much their own. In many ways, this album feels like a draft of their subsequent masterpieces, tho I don't know if Simon was ever funnier than he is on the Dylan parody 'A Simple Desultory Philippic' or if Art ever sang more beautifully than he does on 'For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her.' Simon's lyrics are evocative and probing: 'Are you looking for a way to chuck it all?'; 'Can analysis be worthwhile? / Is the theater really dead?' Somewhat mushy at times, but it's still an impressively elegant release.

I feel like I've always had it ingrained in my mind that Simon & Garfunkel were all time best songwriters and I mean yeah they're good but I don't think I could name more than 3 songs off the top of my mind at any given time I definitely enjoyed this listen but at the same time I don't think it's an all-timer. A few of the last.fm shouts are saying it's their best and I just refuse to believe that I took a costume design elective my senior fall of college and we did a project where we had to pick a famous duo and find their outfits for under $500 and I recreated their Central Park Concert look. My professor loved it but I did drop the class

Honestly, I believe that Simon and Garfunkel's catalogue is seamless in its perfection. While listening to this one, I realised that I wasn't as familiar with this record as I thought I was. There a true moments of songwriting brilliance as well as some humour and Dylan pastiche thrown in to lighten up the mood. Right from the start, the harmonies will overwhelm you with their beauty.

It's fine but it's not even the best Simon & Garfunkel album from 1966 so I'm not sure how important it was to hear this before I die.

Wonderful songwriting and vocals. Like if a fall walk through an apple orchard became an album.

omg i always thought simon and garfunkel were disney characters, like crunk or lumiere. so that was gaggy i didnt know they were real 😭😭😭. i feel like a hobbit trekking through mountains singing listening to the first 2 songs, very lord of the rings, very folky!! a little psychedelic but not in a tame impala way, it’s more calm. like a light dosage instead of a bag of lsd. then the vibe kinda shifts from Cloudy and Homeward Bound, it gets kinda beach boys like sitting in that volkswagen van on a coastal road with a guitar and a dream. the vibe shifts again with songs like The Dangling Conversation, it’s like that one scene in a 90’s romance film where they are giggling and strolling in a park!! “Communist cause i’m left handed” in A Simple Desultory Philippic is crazyyy they hate to see left handed people win; but i like this song its very camp, like they didn’t really take this one to seriously. the random silent night cover had me gagged LMFAO i was like whattttt, but the layering of the news headlines kinda ateee, they kinda did their big one. very atmospheric it literally felt like christmas night just chilling, and i love the juxtaposition of the very violent harsh headlines with such a calm song. standout to me is Patterns, it gets kinda africany with the bongo sound (i honestly don’t know what instrument they used for that) and it’s a interesting blend.

Great slowly album. Love it.

Classic. Recognizable. Harmony. Folk.

A pleasant listen. Not entirely my thing but some great pieces of music on here. Probably an album that would grow on me with repeated lidtens

Very good album, if a bit short. Excellent preamble to “Bridge” 4/5

SUper chill, cargado de simbolismos e historias. Lástima lo jugo en inglés

HATE. 1/5

Simon is a great lyricist & poet, but apart from a few songs in their catalog, their folky music has never really grabbed me. Best track: Homeward Bound

Incredible, start to finish. Ethereal sound. Knew a lot of them but For Emily, Wherever I May Find her was a gorgeous find.

Very pleasant all the way throughout. Not crazy good or anything… just pleasant and enjoyable. Of course I knew Scarborough Fair and Homeward Bound, but the other songs were also pretty good, perhaps excluding “A Simple Desultory Philippic (or How I Was Robert McNamara'd into Submission)”

4/5 good good

It was chill, nice melody. Not my cup of tea.

I love playing in simon and Garfunkel world

Simon and Garfunkel are just a bit boring for me

Very cool folk album. I couldn't listen to it as well as I wanted to, but I feel like it could easily go up to five stars. 9/10

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Y'a de supers morceaux mais j'aurais kiffé entendre ce qu'ils auraient produit après avoir pris 3 RedBull et un peu de coke 😴😴

Un peu plan plan mais c'était attendu

Amazing album. From start to finish.

Beautiful

Very enjoyable.

Too bad for the terrible christmas song x radio news at the end??????

oh sweet music that is simon and garfunkel (any album really). Peaceful listening

Two of the best singer/songwriters of a generation. A lovely listen.

love them

Ok, so lyrically this is pretty brilliant and of such significance to the singer/songwriters of this era of music. Great lyrics, strong vocal arrangements. However, the music itself is dull and often uninspired, but I get what they're doing by not letting the music get in the way of what they are trying to say. There are some absolutely classic songs on here.

A nice listen, I'm only familiar with their hits and Paul's solo career. A little whispery

This is all a bit lovely aye. Every time I start thinking hm is it a bit staid and boring they up the tempo. Nice. Adding half of it to my sunshine driving playlist.

Okay. Just okay.

My problem with this album is that I have heard versions of these songs that are much more energetic than these.

Esta bien el album, pero no es para mi. Hay dos o tres canciones que me gustaron y tal y el ritmo en si es tranquilo y bonito pero no me termina de enganchar

The Cigarettes After Sex of their time. When people describe getting wild and crazy back in the day and its them doing the jitterbug? Teres a song that is just that on here, to really turn up the rec center. That being said it is really pretty.

so calming and the instrumentation/background parts are what bring everything together i feel like :) also reminds me of my childhood fs

It’s fine. First song put me in a coma. The rest were a nice mix of styles, showcasing so much talent.

Paul Simon is a genius! Love the harmony with their voices, great song writing

Album had its moments. Showed the talents of S&G though as always, like them in small bites.

• 5/5 • beautiful, eclectic, and packed with great tracks • timeless

Sleepy boomer music. I'm sure it was groundbreaking at the time.

Great album from my youth.

Homeward Bound alone is worth a four, nice album

This was just an ok album. Not a big Simon & Garfunkel fan and I can see why. Of course it was strong song writing but musically kind of borning.

An all time great

This album is like a spring breeze. It’s gentle and it smells like nice grass. But there’s not enough oomph to shake the branches. A Simple Desultory Philippic just makes me think about how much I would rather listen to Dylan. Favorite songs were Scarborough Fair / Canticle, Homeward Bound, Flowers Never Bend With The Rainfall, and A Simple Desultory Philippic.

In awe of their lyrics & thinking about what they experimented with, like the Middle Eastern influences. In love with their harmonies always. Really want to give this a 4.5 lol Last track had me a bit doomerpilled thinking "nothing really changes" though

I know these guys have some pretty serious and dark lyrical content to some their tunes but from a strictly melodic and sound standpoint, these guys make me smile!

Favourite songs: Scarborough fair, the dangling conversation. I’ve obviously heard much of this album before but not all of it. I see 1966 as the last year before the explosion of rock music and by virtue music as a whole and this is demonstrated with this album. At times you can feel the new sound emerging in songs like ‘The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine’ which almost has a British Invasion tint to it. In others like ‘cloudy’ we hear the classic Simon and Garfunkel sound that they replicated across their discography. ‘The Dangling Conversion’ which is a song I had not heard before reminds of the sort of social revolution of academia I think of the in the early 1960s. The nod to Dylan was cool in ‘The 59th Street Bridge Song’. All in all, I liked this album but prefer some of their later work, especially Bookends. 7.8/10

Short and sweet, nothing influential but enjoyable

Let me start off by saying that my parents small collection of albums in the 60s contained A LOT of S&G, so they’re heavily imprinted on my child mind…. (So is Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass, but that’s a topic for my therapist). The good stuff here is amazing. The Dylan Spoof and the Silent Night thing less so. I applaud both their ambition and their brevity.

Probably one of my favorite Simon & Garfunkle albums

This was okay. I definitly liked the other Simon & Garfunkle album we listened to earlier better than this one.

# 499 : Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme : 10/06/2025 They've done a pretty decent job, it’s a good album, it’s enjoyable and fun overall. Some good hits and bangers, but drags out a bit. It's ok, but not 5 star material. Homeward Bound was my favourite on here.

I know that this album and this duo are an USA legend but it's so boring that i honestly couldn'tconnect with this album. The only song i could feel anything was the last, with the villansicos with that call.

short and very sweet- homeward bound is a great track. felt very groovy and whimsical. What I've noticed with this older music is the interwoven political and social issues with the music- with an apparent message behind the music like a protest that you don't find as common in music these days. The music and art was the vessel for the movement and I think it brings so much more to the songs especially in retrospect.

10/10, banger after banger. No notes.

Honestly the vibes are up in these songs but they just don't vibe with me

My mom loved S & G.

Nice album 7/10

Was close to 4 for me. About half the songs feel timeless, while the other half didn't age well in my opnion.

Love the classic Simon and Garfunkel sound, that Bob Dylan knock off was terrible. 7 o’clock news is a banger.

It's a rainy day today. This album perfectly complements the mood. I typically do not enjoy folk music but this had enough to keep me interested.

So many favorite songs on here. I think I'm a little spoiled by having listened mostly to S&G best-of comps in the past, so I was pretty pleased by how much I liked the tracks on this album that weren't included on them. 4.5

they need to make up their mind about whether they want to go home or go to new york

Yeah sure! Opening track and final track are both absolutely top-tier, some of the middle is too classic-folksy for me but it's all still really well put together.

Some great songs, some cheese, pretty unremarkable

One of the best albums of the 60s

Buenas guitarras y armonias

Scarborough Fair, Homeward Bound, The 59th St. Bridge Song... were the big hits on the record... the other cuts, Patterns, For Emily Whenever, Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine, A Poem on and Underground Wall, Cloudy, A Simple Desultory Philippic, Flowers Never Bend, and 7 O'Clock News... are all killer cuts... The Dangling Conversation is a cool piece of art... Three Grand Slam Homeruns... a few on the warning track... and a few that didn't quite get there... for those i have to deduct a star... four stars...

It was not bad to listen to, mainly because I recognized some of the songs.

What an absolute delight to get this album today! I've been waiting for this one for so long. This was the first Simon and Garfunkel album I heard, and the first CD I ever bought, and quite possibly my favorite album of all time. I even just finished up arranging the title track for a chamber ensemble just the other day! In addition, it was how I came across this challenge in the first place! I had searched the title of the album in Google and found the 1001albumsgenerator page for it. I listen to this album every couple of days, and for good reason! Each track is so good! Even the weaker ones like For Emily are still absolutely beautiful songs in their own right. The perfect blend of sincerity and satire, melodrama and exuberance, timelessness and timeliness. Each track seems to contrast the next: Patterns is dark and dramatic, while Cloudy is simple and content. Homeward Bound sincere in it's message while The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine is ironic. The 59th St Bridge Song is a reminder to appreciate the simpler things in life, while the Dangling Conversation grapples with our relationship with large scale of culture and history. Flowers Never Bend is sincere and expresses a profound message, while "A Simple Desultory Phillipic" is satirical and seems to be mainly about poking fun at Bob Dylan. For Emily is about love transcending space, whereas A Poem on the Underground Wall is about expressing thoughts and ideas in the material world. And to cap it off, the first and last tracks both hold this contrast inside themselves. Scarborough / Canticle and Silent Night / 7 O'Clock News both set old folk tunes against timely critiques of the present day. In doing so, these two tracks end up being the ones that best encompass the themes and totality of the album, and thus one of them will be the one I choose as my favorite track. While I really like Silent Night and it was part of what first sealed this album for me as one of my favorites, there is simply no way of matching the sheer beauty and contrapuntal harmony of the opening track. Favorite Track: Scarborough Fair / Canticle

Any Simon & Garfunkel album is automatically 5 stars.

"Homeward bound" +1, safe and dull, gentle mid 60s baby music

This is one of the best albums from the 60's so far. On my initial listen I was ready to give this a 3, but on my second way through I noticed more intricacies and changed my mind. Particularly the layered vocals caught my attention a lot more. Standouts Scarborough Fair / Canticle Patterns Homeward Bound 4/5

I get it, but not for me. It probably says a lot that my favorite song was the one that sounded like a Bob Dylan parody.

A nice calm breath of fresh air. Just relaxing to listen to.

Sounds familiar but does not stick as well as I thought it would. Arrangements, lyrics and vocals are pretty but I O had forgotten most of it.

Mit gekipptem Fenster beim Regen im Zimmer sitzen und das Geburtstagsgeschenk für morgen nähen. Ganz viele Gedanken im Hinzerkopf; Uni Uni Uni, aber jetzt bin ich erstmal hier mit mir, scheiß auf den Rest.

my dad had s&g's greatest hits playing on an endless loop at home when i was a kid. i could no sooner rate the sound of our old dishwasher.

Bao demais

soft and mellow, great harmonies, probably will listen again 3.5/5

If there ever existed a timeless product of its time, it’s this. Anchored in it’s contemporary world of 1966 it still transcends time thanks to its earnestness and beauty.

So beautiful and of its time. The synths on the weed song are crazy.

First? 3/5 Again? 2/5

Good album

Perfect for evening light reading.

Got nothing against S&G, I actually like some of their songs, but this was too boring. Maybe in other time, on a different mood. Still giving it 3 stars.

Enjoyable. Might put on if I needed something early on a Sunday morning. Enjoyed the dig/parody of Bob Dylan's style in a Simple Desultory Philippic, and a few other tracks

Good good good

not my thing tbh

nie moj typ muzyki

Are you going to give this a four?

Solid effort. Not in my top three S&G albums, but some standout tracks, and Homeward Bound is an absolute American classic. Solid 8 of 10 for me.

I was somewhat disappointed by this album, since I am a fan of Simon and Garfunkel generally. I love their harmonies. I assume that a big reason that I prefer the other albums is because I didn't listen to this one growing up. I really like a few of the songs like Homeward Bound and The 59th Street Bridge Song, and a new one for me is Dangling Conversation. A lot of the other songs didn't do much for me.

Definitely some all time great on this album, but as a whole not something I would listen to again in it's entirety

Decent but not as memorable as some of their other stuff. 3.5 stars

A lot of pleasant songs

Interesting to hear some of the (in my opinion) lesser known Simon & Garfunkel music. Found it pretty decent, especially 'Homeward Bound' and 'Flowers Never Bend with the Rain' stood out as better tunes. Overall I missed some more prominent harmonies which Simon & Garfunkel are known for. In the end, this was an OK album but no smash hit.

Love me some Simon & Garfunkle! There are some true classics on here like "Scarborough Fair", "Patterns", "Homeward Bound" and "A Poem on the Underground Wall". Other than the classics I was a little bit bored towards the end. This is quite surprising given the short runtime of the album and how much I enjoy S&G in general. It just ended up feeling slightly samey and "7 O'clock News/ silent night" just comes off as pretentious. This is just me nitpicking why I'm not giving it a 5 star. It's still a very good album.

Booooooring