Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme by Simon & Garfunkel

Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme

Simon & Garfunkel

3.61
Rating
30539
Votes
1
2%
2
10%
3
32%
4
38%
5
19%
Distribution

Reviews (page 6 of 15)

If internet did not exist I don't think people would have preserved this shit to this day

Scarborough Fair was a 10/5 but the rest was okay at best

This site is trying to convince me that I actually like folk rock. Yesterday Nick Drake, now here's this album... Oh well...

It’s a beautiful album. Accomplishes a lot in only 28 minutes, some other artists could learn from that ability to keep it brief.

Glad I listened to it. Like Shakespeare and Citizen Kain, good context for where we are today and how we got there. But probably won't ever listen to it again.

This is the first of what I'm sure will be at least a few Simon and Garfunkel albums on this list. They are a great group and this is a solid album. Its very calming and beautiful. Its weakest on "A Simple Desultory Phillippic" where they try to channel Bob Dylan for some reason. They're best when sticking to their core sound, folksy, melodic, calm. The back half is a worse than the first, but its overall a very good album.

ну тяжело слушать щас

A gorgeous classic. Loved every song.

Oh FFS. I just had to endure Paul Simon's cultural appropriation solo album, now I have to listen to this turd again. I'm actually somewhat ok with Garfunkle, but Paul Simon just seems to rub me the wrong way. The whole thing with them breaking up seems to be because Paul Simon didn't want to be, or couldn't be the song writer by himself. We know from Graceland, he's incapable of coming up with ideas on his own and has to take them from others, so it's not surprising he couldn't function without someone giving him the ideas for songs. Credit where it's due, once he's stolen a concept, he's a great writer but he's completely flaccid without his pills. Maybe that's harsh and maybe i'm wrong, but that's my impression of Simon at this point. That said, S&G together produced some iconic music together. Simon doesn't exist without Garfunkle and Garfunkle doesn't exist without Simon, and they were better musically together than apart. Of course i've heard their hits, and it was nice to listen to this album in it's entirety. .......and ranting again, it's unbelievable how short the songs are. average of what, 2min 20 seconds? The "legendary writer" couldn't come up with one more verse? Scarborough Fair is the longest song at 3:14 and it's the longest by a good 45 seconds. That's crazy. Silent Night / 7 O'Clock News is such an impactful song. The peaceful harmony of Silent Night juxtaposed over news bulletins which are just......tragic and depressing. When you step back though, these specific bulletins were resolved, they were just depressing at that moment in time. MLK's open house march WAS successful in helping pass the 1968 Fair Housing Act, which the previous bulletin said had no chance in passing. Richard Speck was found guilty and died in prison from murdering those student nurses. Nixon's war in Vietnam was ultimately a failure and we know that he lied to the American people about the war and the war and Nixon are viewed pretty unfavorably in history now. So there is hope on the horizon even if it seems bleak in this moment. Yeah I wrote too much, but I write these things for myself anyway. Good album, songs too short, Paul Simon sucks.

Fun and groovy

Actually really enjoyed this, loved the instruments and harmonising

Ihan kelpo levy. Muutama kovempi hitti joukossa, mutta aika takuuvarmaa Simon & Garfunkkelia tää on. Ei kyllä omassa arviossa neloseen yllä mutta ei tää huono oo

Tässä oli ihan lempee meno, toisin kuin Paulin soolopainajaisessa. Levyn pituuskin oli juuri sopiva, eikä ehtinyt juuri kyllästyä. Rieskan päätösraita oli hämmentävä paketti, mutta näillähän taisi edellisellä arvosteltavalla levylläkin olla jotain todellisia psyykkisiä romahtamisia. Paiskataan kolmosella

Ihan jeppis Gaarfunkkelia 👍

Alkometri taas vauhissa kun kaks Simoo putkeen. Sit tässä on viel kuunneltu sitä toista tän huokailijakaksikon levyä aiemmin. Ei tää tästä varmaan monella kuuntelulla parane, semmonen hyvä lauleskelu ilman särmää. Sillai, että jos ei oo pakko niin ei tuu kuunneltuu, mutta ei kuitenkaan ärsytäkään ihan kauheesti ja paikoin tuntuu, että käsijarru saahaan pois päältä. Äkkiä siin kuitenkin sit taas lähetään paineleen sit jarrua ihan jalalla tai sitten tässä on niinkin moderni kun automaattinen käsjarru käytössä. No mut näkemyksestä, yristä, Bob Dylan -imitoinnista ja joululaulun+seiskan uutisten erikoisbiisistä voi antaa ihan posia. Mut ei saateri sentään tätä kyl voi korkeemmalle nostaa kun siihen mitä nyt lätkitään näköjään joka rievälle. Eli keskari pystyyn. Joulupukilta kuitenkin semmottiis toive, että pistetään vaikka sata älbyymiä ennen seuraavaa johon nää tai toinen näistä on sotkeutunut.

Jes, lisää Simonia ja Garfunkkelia! Sehän passaa itselleni. Tätäkin on tullut todella paljon kuunneltua vuosien saatossa, mutta miksei tänäänkin. Keskenään kivan erilaisia biisejä. A-puolellakin oikeastaan melkein virsimäinen Scarborough Fair/Canticle, kivaa Americanaa Homeward Boundin muodossa, ja kunnon rokahtavaa menoa The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machinessa. Sitten vielä Greatest Hitsiä Feeling Groovyn muodossa. B-puoli ei ihan yllä samalle tasolle, mutta on sielläkin hienoja hetkiä muunmuassa Dangling Conversationsin ja A Poem on The Underground Wallin parissa. Lisäksi itse ihan pidän tuosta levyn viimeisestä raidasta, vaikka se varmaan ehkä vähän kitschiä onkin. Itse vaan rakastan sitä miten Simonin ja Garfunkelin äänet soivat yhteen. Ihan mieletöntä korvakarkkia. Tykkään myös noista folkin päälle tulevista instrumenteista. Kellopeliä ja patarumpua ja ties mitä. Aikaisemmin arvioitavana ollut Bookends sisälsi ehkä parempia yksittäisiä biisejä American johdolla, mutta kokonaisuutena tämä on kyllä mielestäni parempi. Bookends sai neljä tähteä, niin lämätään tälle rohkeasti viisi! Kuunneltu vinyyliltä.

"Scarborough Fair / Canticle" makes me want to die an honorable death trying to save the princess. Paul Simon and Gart Funkelbunklekadunkle or was it Fart Garkunkle or Bart Gartuncles or Bart Lartbrukel or maybe klart startwartmartfunker. None of that was funny and I know it, but the man deserves a medal for surviving childhood with that name. Jokes aside these two are legends. The harmonization they hit on "Scarborough Fair / Canticle" is straight up magic. They had stretches where they were way ahead of their time while still sounding very sixties. The album isn’t perfect though. Some tracks are dated and some are just boring. "The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine" feels like a cookie cutter sixties track that never wakes up. Solid 8 out of 10.

Gran disco de oro para un clásico del folk rock

I've always been a fan of Simon and Garfunkel so it comes as no surprise that I would like this. It's not a perfect album, far from it actually. Songs like Cloudy and the closer really did nothing for me. However, there are a lot of good tunes on this, including Scarborough Fair (though I am very used to listening to the Queensryche version), Patterns, Homeward Bound, and The 59th Street Bridge Song. A better than solid album.

Great songs, sounds very dated, but that also gives it certain charm

Great songs

3.92/5 Stars Top Songs: A Simple Desultory Philippic, Homeward Bound and Patterns

Some timeless stuff on here for sure. One or two that haven’t aged so well but it packs a hell of a lot in to 34 minutes.

Some good songs on this album but also some not so good songs, often is the case with Simon & Garfunkel.

Solid album with great pop tunes, traditional folk songs and even an Bob Dylan parody song (or at least to me 'A Simple Desultory Philippic' sounds like a Dylan parody). Possibly my favorite from all Simon and Garfunkel albums.

Better than expected.

As much as I dislike most folk, I was kind of interested in this one, mainly due to Scarborough Fair and it's pretty harmonies. Aside from few tracks that has a bit of an edge to them, the whole album was a bit of an miss. And boring. I just do not like folk.

some really enjoyable calm tracks but a few with too whispery of a voice. Some fun folksy tracks as well.

Good but a not all songs I enjoyed

take me to church S & G

those herbs could use a lil lemon and salt but I don't really mind bland

Lovely album. Loved listening to it and also didn’t mind breaking the no Christmas songs before December!

7/10 I liked a lot of them honestly. I feel like I need to go back and work through the meaning behind 7 o’clock news/Silent night. Audio balancing was interesting between left and right sides.

Some good songs, a great song (7 o clock news) and quite a lot of filler. The Bob Dylan pastiche is kind of terrible. Generally I thought this was good but a bit too twee in places.

I really fancy some lamb.....

Nothing outstanding outside of songs I already knew

Strong 3

Christ, how I hate Simon & Garfunkel, this was why I became a punk (in my teens) in the first place. Luckily, it didn't last more than 28 minutes. Plain, dull pretentious and sugar coated folk, yuk! 1/5

wonderful as expected

Great fn record

Ugh. I anticipate this will suck. OK, it didn't suck. It's actually pretty decent for a 60s hippie album. 3 stars, did not hate.

A very nice folk album with soft and cozy tracks. I love the atmosphere, it's somehow warm and reassuring even on the more energic parts of the album.

Nothing special but bumped half star to get to 4.

I've always thought Simon & Garfunkel worked well together. None of their music is super exciting but I don't think that's what they were going for. Overall, this was an enjoyable album.

Loved the lyricism. Favorite songs- Scarborough Fair/ Canticle , The Dangling Conversation, and Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall. Least favorite was the 59th Street Bridge Song. A Simple Desultory Philippic could’ve fooled me as a Bob Dylan song.

It's pretty good for the folksy type of music I generally don't like. This is my second S&G album on this list and I was fairly surprised by both. Out side of the Dylan thing, "A Simple Desultory Philippic" and "Silent Night" which are quite horrible, everything else just works. "The 59th Street Bridge Song" had me Feeling Groovy, "Homeward Bound" is good because of nostalgia, I think. And every one knows "Scarborough Fair " is a great song, covered by hundreds of people. (Check out Queensryche's version!) I can see why people love it/them. I just don't imagine I'd pull it up to listen to in it's entirety again. I'll give it a 4 for it's historical significance (which almost got tanked by that Dylan thing!) I

Feels like a gentle kiss on the forehead before tucking you in. 4/5

I'm not listening to Simon and Barfunkle.

Bit biased as I know and enjoy a lot of the songs already.

Great album

until the rat dies

There's no way to impugn the guitar playing, the signing ability, the music craft quality. It's impeccable. I just don't feel groovy. I like folk music, but not this rainfall and thyme bullshit. i think that says more about me than S&G. still id like to see GWAR punch them.

This wasn't quite as painful as I thought it was going to be. There are some hooks here that I don't mind. But no way am I revisiting this. I can't really deal with how the vocals sound on this album. And that cover. No. 2.49 stars.

Picture the most insufferable characters in a Woody Allen movie from the '70s. This was their favorite album. Listen, I try to be open-minded. I don't want to judge albums by their covers, or even by the songs I've heard before and disliked. I'm open to the possibility that I'll be surprised. Hey, I didn't even hate Bookends! But this album is proof that you can do all that and still have your presumptions reinforced. It starts with the cover, easily one of the wussiest in the history of pop music, and continues to the songs, which also earn that title. I'm not anti-folk. There's just something so acutely annoying about "The 59th Street Bridge Song," for instance, that turns me into John Belushi smashing the guitar in Animal House. The lyrics frequently come across as annoyingly self-satisfied (the nadir being "A Simple Desultory Philippic"), but are annoying in general. Ugh, and the ham-handed social commentary of "Silent Night" with news reports to close? The worst.

Switched to Best Of…

Pretty good, I would say as Simon and Garfunkel go, this is very classic for them.

a true love of mine

idk what recommendation will ever top this album. this was stunning.

Haven't heard and it was great. Probably favorite one so far.

I wish it were a longer album!

This album is SO GOOD!!! With me NOT being a huge fan of 60’s folk rock, this album moves me on so many levels. None of the songs are overly long; but despite their briskness they fully evoke strong emotions and a sense of familiarity. Many of these songs I haven’t heard before BUT I feel like I have heard them before….if that makes sense. I couldn’t stop listening to this album over and over again. And it only got better after each listen.

A classic and a beautiful way to spend some time. The ethereal harmonies on the classic folk songs are unmatched and then the songwriting of Paul Simon coming through on the original compositions shows he is one of the greats. Maybe one point down for the weird Dylan piss take but an absolute must listen.

Scarborough Fair/Canticle 4 Patterns 4.1 Cloudy 3.4 Homeward Bound 3.6 The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine 3.2 The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy) 3 The Dangling Conversation 3.3 Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall 3.1 A Simple Desultory Philippic (or How I Was Robert McNamara'd into Submission) 4 For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her 3.7 A Poem on the Underground Wall 3 7 O 'Clock News/Silent Night 2.8 Score: 3.433333333

love the first song, lowk gives very xmas mass reverence + awe inspiration if that makes sense? the rest of the album didn't really stand out too much to me...

Talented songwriting and harmonies are well done. A little too slow and melodic for me. 3/5 Might listen again

Nice easy listening 2.5 stars

Frankly a bit disappointed in this album. I thought this was definitely going to be 5 star and admittedly I have not listened to a complete S&G album for a long time, There are some great tracks: Homeward Bound The 59th Street Bridge Song A Poem on an Underground Wall However the rendition of Scarborough fair is very mediocre and Silent Night with news in the background does not stand the test of time. Still going to give 4 stars.

Music to pick herbs to, which is in the name I guess.

Snoozefest folk.

I was prepared to rate this album 3 stars, but the back half of this album really changed my mind. I'm sure it wasn't the first diss track ever, but a roast of Bob Dylan (who I would similarly roast, were I clever enough) kicked off what I think are some really fantastic songs. This isn't my favorite S&G album, but it's an S&G album, so it's pretty damned good ⭐⭐⭐⭐

A blend of beach boys, Beatles, the cure, and

Great song writing, harmonies, and vocals. But this is definitely not my style of music

Hieno albumi!

Too early for prime Simon and G

Love lots of the songs on this album

Short and sweet. Little bit folky and samey but a fantastic album.

kindheitserinnerung. naja.

Lieblich und dann Silent Nicht als Protestsong.

Truly delightful. Full of whimsy and silliness. Fav song - 59th Street Bridge Song

Simon & Garfunkel at their best. Most of their greats are found here.

I can with this type of stuff. In my head I just see pretentious white dudes in the corner of a coffee shop singing this with the air that they’ve tapped into some really deep meaning. But no.

very chill and calming, very much a like,, driving album? its soothing and sweet and soft and good!

Great harmonies

Short and sweet with some classic tracks

Waaaaay better than I thought it would be. And some dark af songs in there too

Fantastiskt album med stark höstkänsla

4.5 I know just a couple days ago I was talking about not liking folk but actuallllllly I’m suuuuper basic and LOVE Simon & Garfunkel! What can I say? This isn’t my favorite album of theirs but it’s great!! A couple songs I’m not super fond of but also some stone cold classics, plus the whole thing is less than 30 minutes long! A beautiful whisper of an album!

A good begining

Great singer songwriter lyrics and music. Classic.

This is an album of my childhood. Always playing.

Not much stood out to me personally but I could hear the craftsmanship. Lyrically and musically well done.

it's pleasant in a somewhat cheesy way.

Such a lovely album. I can see inspirations for Elliott Smith, and I can hear Bob Dylan's influence (honestly though, a simple desultory philippic is so good)

Not to be obnoxious, but this was really good on vinyl. I've listened like 4 times since this came up on 1001; didn't realize I hadn't actually reviewed it. It's perfect. I can't remember what the review I'm sure I wrote and didn't publish would have said, but I am moved by practically every track on this album. It's very earnest, which with less gifted musicians would have hurt the performance, but not this time.

Beautiful, smooth harmonies do not make for an exciting album. It makes for a beautiful one that is great at fading into the background and make you forget you're listening to one. Artistically this should be a 4, but because of how soporific it is, I'm docking a star. Plus, "The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine" is a sex thing, right?

Just kinda meh. Maybe I’m just not a Simon and Garfunkel fan but this nearly put me to sleep. Kinda same-y. I recognize some of it was probably very politically counter, but that just doesn’t change the face that it’s boring.

Definitionen av Singer-songwriting. Folk och pop samtidigt. Och vilka röster, vilken stämsång! Femma, solklart!

I liked it, it was very calm and it was short.

dont like it lol

- jaha toinen simon n garfunkkeli lets go - tää on tämmöstä, tulee mieleen että tää on ollut aikansa hipsteri/älykkö musaa - 59th street bridge song kuulosti iha hyvältä - a simple desultory philippic kuulosti bob dylan kopiolta - ei muuttanut mun käsitystä s&gstä, ihan alright mutta not my cup of tea

More upbeat than I anticipated.

Enchanting, wondrous harmonies coupled with some beautiful lyrics. First time listening to a S&G album and I look forward to the next entry.

Grew up listening to Simon and Garfunkel - but I had never listened to this full album before. The news broadcast outro was a fascinating inclusion for someone who was born a few decades later.

For as much lore as Simon & Garfunkel have the lexicon of American music they didn’t actually make that much music together. So any album of theirs is going to be enjoyable. “Homeward Bound” is the standout.

It is a great folk album, a lot of familiar hits.

Jel ovo jedan od najlipiših albuma ikad? JE

I don’t like folk too much but there were some standout tracks! Def a 3 1/2 star album for me.

Great album. Silent night drags it down from a 5.

Also liked this one, another 3. I liked their final album more though

Had to go listen more Simon & Garfunkel to decide if I wanted to rate this a 4 or a 5, so I guess I spoiled their next albums on this list. I really liked this but they've made even better music in my opinion. Edit: after a couple more listens I changed it to a 5.

What to say about Simon and Garfunkel? And this album specifically? I have been a huge fan of theirs since I was a small child. This is music that was playing in my house and in my friend's houses. My music teacher in elementary school taught us to sing Scarborough Fair and The 59th Street Bridge Song, among many others. Whey they toured together in the early 80's I got to see them live. With all of that, I actually haven't listened to this album in many many years. I was a bit nervous jumping in, as I worried that maybe I wouldn't love it as much as I used to. Thankfully that wasn't the case. Their vocals touched me as they always had, and the musical accompaniment is perfect for each song. I had mid 60's Dylan yesterday and this record today, reminding me that I don't dislike folk/folk rock when it's done so very well.

I preferred bridge over trouble water I think. Still a nice listen, but realistically I’m just not going to be putting this back on in a hurry, if ever.

this song was hauntingly beautiful when it was sung by my ancestor art this warmed my heart as i listened, love the bob dylan diss track

Nice! A high three

More of the same. What else am I gonna say except some of it is super corny and Garfunkel was carried by Paul Simon. I question if they were gay lovers, just curious nothing wrong with that.

great, very fun to listen to

Mid-sixties time capsule. Meh.

Beautiful album. You’d think the culture references wouldn’t age well but still felt relevant today.

Beautiful harmonies and some classic tunes, but I don't know what was going on with that Bob Dylan-esque song and Silent Night/7 o'clock News was a failed experiment. I get what they were trying to do, but no.

Ugh. Why is this here? Two songs that matter and the rest is awful

Lovely. Just lovely.

One of their better ones

Meh, some short songs with nice vocals and not much substance. 3 stars

Just great without being preachy or too high brow.

Really great work. Snapshot in time.

Paul Simon has his way with words, but 'Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme' is still clearly a novice work.

I was fully prepared to hate this album, recognize its musical brilliance and insane influence, and stumble through a bs 3* rating. But damn if I didn't dig it. Twenty-eight minutes helps immensely. I was peacefully grooving along, and then A Simple Desultory Philippic hit. I thought Spotify slipped into a Dylan record. I'm a fan, who knew? Influence 5. Hits 4. Quality 4. I'm here for it, man 4.

masterpiece.

Big S&G fan, but in this case, I'll stick to the greatest hits.

this was a task. no thanks.

60’s soft rock sound

Classic folk

Some good songs

Enjoyable, will admit nothing truly stands out, but I think I could listen on repeat without real complaints. Homeward bound has stood out It’s unfortunate that I’ve decided to do this project while at work. It means albums like this can easily blend into the background and come up a little short. I enjoyed my time listening but probably missed the thesis of the album. Enjoyable enough that I may go back with a second listen on my own time 3/5

Great, loved it

More of a 3.5 but rounded up.

Parte stile skyrim, e non dispiace, poi a fine album si riprende un attimo con l'armonica... Ora perché chiudere con silent night+notiziario? Immagino sia stata una scelta rivoluzionaria ma non la capisco.

This is a sweet record, with several classics. The style of music isn't my cup of tea, and I don't consider the record life changing, hence the four stars.

High 3, some nice sensibilities and interesting choices

75/100. Good folk pop record. Not as groundbreaking as some of their later work, it’s still a well-crafted and consistently strong album.

Love them, heard this a million times. 4/5

discão bonito, dois hits dos mais bonitos, poesia e melodia, wrecking crew...4 ou 5

29 minutes long with 12 tracks - this is going to be a banging punk album, right? Well, maybe not. I haven’t listened to this album before, but a couple of the tracks are familiar from hearing them on the radio, ranging from nicely harmonised folk to bouncy pop and a Bob Dylan style rant about the government and numerous drug references. One odd surprise was a cover of the carol Silent Night overlaid with a grim news bulletin. Not as good as Bridge Over Troubled Waters.

Good melodies, good execution, good harmonies especially in their own style, with both voices and guitars melding into each other. Short enough to avoid to be too repetitive, and actually it's pretty diverse with "high energy" tracks I wasn't expecting from them.

Good album. Reminded me a bit of Beatles. I like the calm vibe of the Album.

Best Track - "Homeward Bound"

Not bad. Completely inoffensive, middle of the road listening. Short album at 28 mins.

a new favourite i think! gentle, sharp and quietly radical. just encapsulates everything i love about folk. 5/5

day 15: very nice! bardy singing on folky tunes.

I love Simon and Garfunkel, but this is definitely on the softest side. Good songs, but not my favorite.

Bra folk. Til tider jævlig bra. Og et par duds (Dylan-parodi og julelåt).

Albumet beviser at Paul & Art er mer enn bare to karer med kassegitarer og flotte stemmer. De er det også, altså, men måten de leker med instrumentering på særlig første delen av plata løfter plata langt over mange samtidige. Så er de også gode på varemerket sitt. «Dangling Conversation» er en av tidenes flotteste låter og både «For Emily…» og «A Poem on the Underground Wall» kunne gjort enhver melankolsk indiefilm noen knepp bedre. De skal ikke få noe trekk for fjolleri, men fra 1. januar til 30. november kan man sikkert droppe sistesporet. Selv om kombinasjonen med nyhetssendingen sikkert sier noe viktig og aktuelt om datiden.

Slik skal 60-tallsmusikk være! Denne skiva har også en utrolig kul og ukonvensjonell produksjon, noe som folk generelt kanskje ikke forbinder Simon and Garfunkel med. Denne gangen hørte jeg på både mono og stereo versjonen, og mono versjonen er selvfølgelig best.

Decent album - the hits stand out, but all good

A perennial favorite.

Bridge Over Troubled Water is their biggest album but this is definitely my favourite of theirs. Lovely, beautiful, delicate, pastoral stuff. Great songwriting. Have acoustic guitars and voices ever sounded prettier? And then there's the Bob Dylan ripoff, and the final track is surprising, but really well done.

Pleasant harmonising and folky vibes. Definitely easy on the ears. “Homeward Bound” was my favourite track here, however it did leave me grumpy as I’m currently on the train to work…

Excellent folk album. Love the rendition of Scarborough Fair (besides the American mispronunciation of ‘Scarborough’) and the Silent Night closing track with the gradually rising news was quite powerful. Some really excellent tracks throughout the album too - Cloudy, Homeward Bound, Feelin’ Groovy. Love that the album didn’t overstay its welcome - short and sweet. I’m a fan of Simon & Garfunkel thanks to this generator. Will revisit.

It's ok. I liked a few tunes like "Homeward Bound". But It's not really the kind of music I listen to. I can appreciate it in small doses. Thinking it deserves a solid middle of the road 3 stars.

This record is all rainbows and butterflies, but seen through meloncholy-tinted glasses. It plays like a Beatles record, but not as catchy. The Bob Dylan spoof was totally unnecessary - who in their right mind would want to sing like Bob Dylan?

Irgendwas an den Harmonien hat mir sehr gefallen. Wieso nicht?

It’s interesting how these guys flit between slow heartfelt ballads like Scarborough Fair and For Emily, whilst following up with seriously intense and upbeat rock numbers like The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine and a fantastic Dylan (Bob, not Thomas) satire in A Simple Desultory Philippic. Through my grandfather and by extension my mother Simon & Garfunkel are well-known to me, well, at least their Greatest Hits are. There’s one or two on here, but the half-hour album experience will of course always trump a ‘greatest hits’ record. There’s a few pleasant surprises with the songs that I wasn’t familiar with, but all in all it’s as expected, a Simon & Garfunkel album. It’s all jolly well good, but it’s nothing that you’d deem anywhere past that, just ‘good’.

The vocal harmonies and production stuff (like the vocal reverb) just evoke an indescribable feeling and its just so wholesome and wintery. I feel like the more I listen the more that I can hear how much of the vocals Paul Simon does, I always thought it was more 50/50, but I'm pretty sure he does the majority of songs on here, plus I think he played/wrote the guitar on most as well. I think I definitely like the more folk melancholy ones more than the slightly bombastic bluesy ones, but there are some of those where there's some 4th wall breaking cheekiness, which is great. I guess the only thing wrong with it is its so short, not even the album length, it just feels like some of the songs end too early. But songs like Scarborough Fair just paint such a vivid picture of a place from the past, especially nostalgic because I think I read Paul Simon came to the UK and was inspired to write some of these. Favourite songs: Scarborough Fair, cloudy, homeward bound, the 59th street bridge song, the dangling conversation, flowers neve bend with the rainfall, for Emily, whenever I may find her, a poem on the underground wall. Overall around 8/10 (if longer could totally be higher)

Like McCartney, another musical genius of our time, this Paul can get a bit cheesy, but that is the folk style. Dated folkiness aside there are beautiful songs and harmonies. I don’t know what the Bob Dylan pastiche is about, it sticks out badly. Maybe you had to be there.

A strangely tentative album with a degree of recycled material. Think I prefer Bookends.

Probably disrespectful but it was a mostly uninteresting album. But Homeward Bound was a 5star song on its own

I liked this more than I was expecting to! "Scarborough Fair/Canticle" and "Flowers Never Bend With the Rainfall" were my favorites on here.

Not really feeling it

Super chill & nostalgic One song I used to sing in elementary school

folky. classic. ear worm.

I thought the Dylan parody was funny, but otherwise it was an boring album

unfortunately kind of boring. all the singles I've already heard a million times from radio play.

intersting worth another listen

Day639 - they sound so good together i hope they never break up

Very soothing. Exactly what youd expect, both in good ways and kinda flat uninteresting ways, but overall a solid enough listen.

A genuinely great album. It's impact is a little diminished by everything that has come since, but it is easy to hear how they have influenced future artists. Favorite Song: Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall

What a beautiful album! When I listened to it, I discovered there were more familiar songs on it than I'd thought when I looked at the titles.

classic right here

Fun. Neat. Easy listening. But just kinda “good” to me.

Wow, does this album scream, "Hey, boomer!" Lots of wonderful tunes here that have held up well and some that really haven't. I found it surprising how uneven the album was, starting with the second track, "Patterns." This was a complete miss for me, with turgid lyrics and bongos, worthy of Maynard G. Krebs [look him up]. Paul Simon did grow into a songwriter capable of creating truly great albums. "Bridge over Troubled Waters" and "Graceland" are two that come to mind. The plusses on this album are incandescent and resoundingly overshadow the misses.

Some of Simon and Garfunkel's best ever songs, but also a decent amount of filler. For Emily and Scarborough Fair are the highlights. 7/10

Not my cup of tea. In fact, this has convinced me to quit tea outright. ★★ for the first track.

Don’t like

Short and sweet. Nice to see best friends never part...

27 minute long album is amazing. But it was it was 27 minutes at a snails pace

Great album, some really good songs on it.

Tremendously beautiful and gentle in every way. Normally I take every opportunity to make fun of Paul Simon, but it must be said that he has always been an important blueprint to emotionally driven teeny boppers... from the stomp clap hey-ers to midwest emo to whatever Billie Eilish is doing (I assume). I would love to see a highly fictionalized Simon + Garfunkel biopic directed by Kelly Reichardt in which during the production of this album there is a montage of Art Garfunkel looking longingly at Simon.

Already had the two best songs downloaded

Delicate and tuneful.

As someone who only knows Paul Simon & Art Garfunkel through other artists’ covers of "The Sound of Silence" and "Bridge over Troubled Water," I was pretty excited to (for lack of a better phrase) finally get my S&G cherry popped with Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme! It’s also the duo’s first album on this list chronologically, so that made it doubly exciting. From the moment this album starts, it’s obvious that there’s enormous musical talent behind it. "Scarborough Fair / Canticle" really sets the tone for a project loaded with a wide array of instruments, engaging storytelling and occasionally dark themes. I can’t overstate just how instantaneously the first moments of the project hooked me. While I don’t think I thoroughly enjoyed any of PSRAT’s other tracks quite as much as the intro, the quality certainly doesn’t fall off! It’s hard for me to believe some of these songs came out in 1966 because they just feel so timeless. I literally listened to the album twice in a row because I felt like there was still so much more enjoyment to get out of it. Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme isn’t QUITE a five star album for me, but it probably would have been in constant rotation if I were born 40 years earlier and electronic music didn’t exist. Looking forward to discovering more gems from Simon & Garfunkel before this challenge is finished! Highlights: Scarborough Fair / Canticle, Patterns, Homeward Bound, The Dangling Conversation, A Simple Desultory Philippic, A Poem on the Underground Wall, 7 O’Clock News / Silent Night

well... it's Simon and Garfunkel. not their most iconic work but it does its job fairly well. one of these songs does a Dylan parody which is kinda fun but definitely is out of my cultural frame deserves to be one of the 1001? you could make a case for it i think

I mean, it’s Simon & Garfunkel. I love Simon & Garfunkel. “Scarborough Fair” is lovely, you get so used to it but it’s an outstanding rendition. “Homeward Bound,” is a windows down on an autumn morning vibe. Loved the time capsule of “Silent Night” hearing Nixon echo the sentiment of Ben Shapiro.

This album, which came before Bookends, is seen as Simon & Garfunkel’s real breakthrough. The music is often stunningly beautiful. It opens with Scarborough Fair / Canticle, a gorgeous arrangement where their combined vocals have never sounded better. My favorite moment is Homeward Bound. The beginning is unbelievably beautiful—one of Simon’s finest songwriting moments, with its simple vocal line, plucked guitar, added harmony, and bass foundation. Unfortunately, the chorus is a bit too poppy and cheesy for my taste. Other highlights include the lovely The Dangling Conversation and the sharper A Simple Desultory Philippic, which adds some welcome bite to an otherwise gentle album. Overall, it’s a very good record with no real misses—except perhaps the closer, 7 O’Clock News / Silent Night. The concept is clever, but the execution feels overdone.

It was alright. At least Simon and Garfunkel sound different than the rest of the albums on here. It also was not too long either. I think it is a decent albulm.

pleasant

This album is special to me because I think Scarborough Fair was literally one of the first songs I knew. For some reason, when I was a little kid, my parents put me on that song. Otherwise, this album is just really great. I think Simon & Garfunkel do a great job of storytelling and presenting such a compelling tune with their voices and instruments. 7 O'Clock News / Silent Night is probably one of the most chilling songs I've ever listened to

BEAUTIFUL

Decent slice of folk rock, even though it isn't my favourite genre. Their version of Silent Night is eerie and is comparable to events today. Might not listen to it all the time but I do think this belongs in the book.

This album cover could be a gay couple’s wedding announcement. Do you think Simon and Garfunkel ever explored each other’s bodies?

J’ai écouté les cinq albums de Simon & Garfunkel cet après-midi (le vendredi 10 octobre 2025). Je ne les connaissais que pour un best-of avant ça. Beaucoup de bonnes chansons sur ces albums (qui sont, pour la plupart, assez courts) ! Les deux premiers sont assez classiques : le duo qui chante et s’accompagne à la guitare. Le troisième (Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme) est très intéressant, plein de belles mélodies et une plus grande panoplie d’instruments est impliquée. Le quatrième est probablement le plus expérimental, mais je ne suis pas certain que ça convient à leur son. Le cinquième est leur plus fort, je dirais. On sent que Paul Simon a énormément évolué comme compositeur et qu’ensemble ils ont grandi comme interprètes. Aussi, plus d’instruments et de belles instrumentations. Un groupe à réécouter. Cinq albums à réécouter.

This is the type of music I typically like, but something about Simon & Garfunkel rubs me the wrong way. They just feel overly Americanized somehow I think?

Maybe too chill for Monday morning, but we’ll put it on. Oh, this is delightful.

Sublime and tender

I am really enjoying this album. The opener is just a joyful and classic folk tune. These songs remind me of learning to play classical guitar. The string arrangements and orchestral elements are super 60's in the best way. I may have to do a deeper dive into Simon & Garfunkel, I have heard the hits but not the real folk-y acoustic songwriting they seem to excel at. Also - Carol Kaye plays bass on some songs! Hal Blaine on the drums. The Wrecking Crew is all over this album as was the fashion at the time. Very neat. "A Simple Desultory Philippic" blasts straight into Dylan-esque fuzzy rock. I think this is maybe a diss track? It's very on the nose and also sort of comes across as a proto-"We Didn't Start the Fire". In any case, it really jumps out of the album with the harmonica and distorted guitar. I think this is going to be an easy 5, I really enjoyed it. Just beautiful melodies and songwriting. I feel that in a lot of ways this type of music isn't ever going to be exciting enough to be mainstream again and I can't imagine a new artist "making it" playing songs like this. This makes me a little sad as I feel there is a real magic to these "simple" and beautiful songs - they are short, to the point and contain multitudes in their lyrics like the best poetry.

Was familiar with Sound of Silence but not anything else. Ended up liking most of the other songs more than that. Surprised with their sound as it was not all that similar to SoS, in a good way. Short album but wouldn't have minded another couple songs.

Wonderful. Some classics and some lesser-known but still special songs. The songwriting, the harmonies, it’s just that good.

Real wholesome folk music. I can see why this band is referenced all over pop culture

I’m not a huge fan of folk music but this isn’t so bad. Not something I’d give a second listen to though. It’s light and airy, easy to listen to. And that last track is almost spooky but melancholic, I like it. I want to give it three stars but... fuck it I’ll give ‘em three.

So 4 or 5? Brilliant stuff classic songs. Holds together. Of its time and a massive marker in the road. Never tire of this. 5 I spose.

Iconic album. Some incredible songs here, some kind of forgettable.

The way these pretty folk songs are kinda fucked up by distortion and moments of sloppiness brings an edge to the softness

Far more varied than I thought, some good easy listening with a few tracks really catching me off guard for who I thought they were (I didn't know anything)

Väldigt hög högsta-nivå! Höjdpunkter som Homeward Bound, the 59th street bridge song, scarborough fair och rolig text på a simple desultory philippic. Sen så det en hel del tråkigare låtar som drar ned albumet som helhet

Short but sweet.

I think any greatest hits compilations make it harder to enjoy a s&g album from start to finish. Interesting as an early effort, but would not be going back to relisten.

I sang a version of Scarborough Fair in a high school quartet. That being said, the songs here are what you expect but are not something I would listen to regularly.

One of the best albums I've listened to so far. Straight to the favourites folder.

Ok, so this is the first time I am listening to full Simon & Garfunkel album. Really cool how you can instantly from the first song tell it's these 2 fellas. Scarborough Fair is a beautiful opener. Album is very short so already had a go this morning and I have to say I appreciate the reverberated atmosphere and haunting harmonies which are done so well. Already few tracks are standing out and closing Silent Night with 7 o' clock news dubbed over it felt like a fever dream.

My dad is a big Paul Simon fan , so I'm familiar with some of this already, even though I've never listened to it in its entirety. I must admit that I prefer the bouncier pop-infused version of them on _Bridge Over Troubled Waters_. This has some of those moments and at just 29 mins this is pretty listenable and benefits from headphones. But I'm not sure that I'd return to this, I'm much more likely to return to the aforementioned _BOTW_.

I haven't listened to this for so long (maybe 50 years) but remembered each song well. It's truly a classic, but beyond the nostalgia value I don't an urge to listen again.

This is a good album, based on the genre, but it's a bit "hippie" vibes for me. Clearly there's good song writing here, with catchy melody, great playing, and I really do quite like the harmonies. Favorite track was surprisingly "Silent Night," which I had a pretty negative reaction to at first. "Why is this happening?" But juxtaposed with the news, it's a really fucked up snapshot of what was happening in the world at the time, and I appreciate how that all came together. Not something I'd listen to actively, but appreciate the artistry on display here.

It's fine. Not my jam, but there's some solid music there.

- Ik had verwachtingen en ze zijn niet voldaan. - 0 nummers toegevoegd aan MMMM

This album wasn’t as much for me

A great example of the fact an album doesn’t need to be long to be great

I have no real connection to England, yet I can sing Scarborough Fair only because my mother often played this album when I was a kid. For me it’s a mix of nostalgia and boredom. Paul Simon’s guitar sounds great, so I’d feel differently if I heard these songs live. I kind of like A Simple Desultory Philippic.

Overall: 9/10 I've always enjoyed Simon and Garfunkel's music but never thought I'd ever love one of their albums until now. This is a treat, honestly. The songs range from slow, beautiful ballads to straight up rockers in a way that I hadn't known them to pull off. Their harmonies are perfect and both members get their moments to shine. I might have found my next vinyl purchase with this one. Fav Song: Flowers Never Bend With the Rainfall

Sweet folk sounds, but lots of filler too.

Fav track: 7 O'Clock News / Silent Night

Phenomenal. Every song is fantastic. Patterns, homeward bound, and flowers never bend were new to me and they were sooo oooo good

Een heel warm, zach album met naar mijn mening 2 fantastische stemmen e mooie instrumentale begeleiding. Voor mij was dat 5 reten, ik kan er niet meer aan vuil maken. Absoluut een album om te luisteren.

Atmospheric, beautifully sang from moment 1 to the last note. Homeward bound sings of longing, dangling conversation sneers at smalltalk effortlessly, feeling groovy has a guitar riff unequalled. Bits of the album veer into tweeness. However the album as a whole is amazing and one of the distinctive sounds of the mid 60s.

At the time of its release, I can see how this album was popular. I don’t feel it’s aged well as this style of folk music isn’t in the popular zeitgeist anymore.

BIt of a snoozefest (put me to sleep when I should have been doing work) but only 28 minutes so at least I was able to get through it. Also knew some of the songs already (Homeward Bound, 59th Street...). The Dangling Conversation sounds nice on the surface but the lyrics are sooooo extemely lame and pretentious. Final track is quite cool considering it came out in 1966. But it's another grandma and grandpa record - give me something more exciting!!

I don't like Paul Simon. I don't really like him with Garfunkel. This wasn't as bad as I thought it would be, but it still was a painful slog. The highlight for me was when there was the line from The Simpsons about the lamppost (Who Shot Mr Burns Part 1). Otherwise, snorefest. 2 stars.

So you’ve been living alone for a while now, and your elderly neighbour has asked you to come over to her house because she’s got a couple of odd jobs around the house she needs help with. She always greets you with a smile when you see each other over the fence, so you are happy to help. You head over and help her lift a couple of things out of the top shelf of her cupboard, and move an armchair for her. She then offers you a cup of tea. This album is the 27 minutes of you drinking tea with your elderly neighbour. You offer to help her with the tea, and can’t help notice a fair amount of dust in the mugs she has taken out. You can’t find a way to sneakily rinse them though, so you just accept this tea won’t be nice. This feeling is compounded by her adding water and barely stirring once before removing the bag. She doesn’t throw the used teabag out straight away, and you wonder if she might re-use it later. She adds a couple of drops of trim milk and you sit down. To accompany your tea, the lady offers you some shortbread that she baked “the other day”. It looks about three weeks old, and tastes as such, too. She makes polite conversation, however it is somber, as she makes several mentions of being quite lonely now that her beloved husband has passed. You do feel sad for her, and try to offer words of support and condolences. She assures you she is fine though, because she has found a lot of strength through religion and knitting. In fact she makes a couple of mentions of religion. She doesn’t outright ask you if you are a Christian, but she certainly asks a lot of questions trying to surreptitiously ascertain whether or not you have found Christ. Not looking to go down that path, you try and steer the conversation elsewhere, however the only cues around the room are several pictures of her husband and a tv guide from last month.

Great lyrics and stroy telling. Didn't start strong but built up and finished well. A good album

Incredible chill folk

Personalmente no me gusta ese género.

6/10 awh i love these two but i’ve never listened to this album, how do they know about scarborough, it was a good album to listen to and the lyrics had a story instead of stupid stuff which i love, but it hasn’t changed my opinion on folk music or my outlook on certain things, paul simon was the true genius behind everything and garfunkel was just kinda there, i listened to this doing my homework so that explains itself, i did thoroughly enjoy one song tho. fav song: a simple desultory phillipic, maybe coz garfunkel isn’t in it. it was no mrs robinson

Theres a goofy song here and there but overall great

I really like Simon and Garfunkel although I haven't listen to them a lot. From this album I had heard one song before. While none of these songs are my favorites of them they still have the sound and feel of the Simon and Garfunkel songs I am more familiar with.

Mellow sleepy vibes with gentle acoustic guitar picking and beautiful close harmonies. They're really good at what they do, but what they do is so insanely boring. Good to put on to counteract the stress of an intense 30 minute email inbox sprint I guess. Seems like they have a lot of albums on the list beacuse they had a few 'can't leave this song out!' songs spread out over like 4 albums - a good candidate for a greatest hits/best of band, but even that would be a boring 45 minutes.

I was pretty happy when this one popped up. I’ve always liked their hits but haven’t ever really given them a proper listen. I really enjoy some of Paul’s solo output so I knew I wouldn’t hate this. Homeward Bound is a track I’ve always really enjoyed, just a pretty, catchy tune. Anyway, pretty cool album that covers a wide range of styles that I don’t normally seek out. Some really chill acoustic tracks, bongos, beautiful orchestral arrangements, and great harmonies, sometimes all within the same song. The closing track kind of threw me for a loop-a Silent Night cover with 7 o’clock news audio layered over? Didn’t really work for me but I guess I get the sentiment they were going for.

Short and very sweet but, to my ears at least, it’s lacking the punchier, more robust production of records like Bookends and Bridge Over Troubled Water. It has a very, thin, whimsical quality to it. A nice listen nonetheless.

Off the cuff remark: I'm sure there's a dirty rock n roll story in the background but Simon and Garfunkel always seem so .... wholesome. That with just a hint of hippy hangs on this album. Which makes for a pleasant enough, but somehow lacklustre listen. Call it prejudice but the pronounciation of "Scarborough" really irks too. Standout track: 59th Bridge.. even though it has an annoying whimsy about it. Revisit?: if the mood takes me, maybe, just maybe

Based on the hits on this album, expected it to be an easy 4 star album. Unfortunately, there were plenty of other songs that left me cold. Wish I could give it 3.5 stars.

Its good, but I just cant say its the best album ever to exist.

Some nice songs on the album. Making fun of Bob Dylan seems like a very snobby thing to do which makes me like this less. A little too self-satisfying and safe for me.

I didn't really get into S&G until I watched "The Graduate" in my film lit class in high school. Great art reaches across generations, and that film, and its soundtrack, spoke to me. Or maybe it was just Katharine Ross, the greatest love interest in cinema.

this album opened my eyes on the profound impact of phenomenal songwriting. paul simon and art garfunkel created magic every time they touched the microphone.

Z fav song: The Dangling Concersation H fav song: The 59th Street Bridge Song Z: harmony driven sound scapes with introspective lyricism. 7/10 H: A vary harmonious album very indicative of the 60’s. 4/10

Borderline 5. I love the way their voices sound together, so I enjoyed listening to it. Owned it in a box set, but not sure I ever listened to it all before. Some classics (Scarborough Fair, Homeward Bound, 59th bridge street) a terrific run of For Emily, A Poem on the Underground and Silent Night to finish. But a few less interesting songs, and I really didn't like A Simple Desultory Philippic.

Il me semble que peu de voix se sont aussi bien mariées que celles de Paul Simon et Paul Garfunkel. Les harmonies et arrangements sont exquis. Il est intéressant que l'album s'ouvre et se ferme sur des cantiques/chants traditionnels, avec en finale un contrepoint plutôt dramatique dénonçant la banalisation de la violence médiatisée. Une belle manière d'inscrire l'album dans une tradition folk tout en le plantant dans son époque.

This album is like pressing a dried flower between the pages of your existential crisis journal while staring wistfully out the window at autumn. Every track smells faintly of vintage bookstores and unresolved tension at Thanksgiving. Simon & Garfunkel were in full poetic monk mode here—armed with harpsichords, harmonies, and enough melancholy to drown a small town. It’s delicate, yes, but underneath all that beauty is a quiet rage at modernity… delivered via madrigal. Rating: 4.6/5 Short Review: Like getting slapped with a silk glove embroidered with anti-war lyrics. Favorite Track: “Scarborough Fair/Canticle” – a haunting Renaissance fair fever dream with political subtext whispering from inside a lace doily.

Yep, it's pretty good - manages to be folk but with an extra level of texture that surrounds and suffuses everything, but never overwhelming. Melody and arrangement worht returning to, and doesn't outstay its welcome. Hello lampost!

Overall it just didn't do much for me.

Pretty solid loved the old folk sound captured by their early work you don't heat that sort of thing anymore

One of the great mid 1960's albums. Really good.

Acoustic guitars, harmonies and weed. Potent combo. Timeless music.

Love this album. Full of great songs

What a haunting last song.

Homeward Bound is a great song; the rest is excellent for background music.

Some pretty moments but it wasn't all sunshine and rainbows for the record.

•first song is so majestic, a great opening of an album. •The second song is very awakening i’d say. Not my cup of tea tho. •The third song just started and I already can tell that it’s one of my favourites. Just such a pretty song. •4th song is something that I think everyone can relate to. Home sweet home •Next song is so wholesome. Like you just wanna dance and feel contentement. •5th song is pretty funky but calm in the same time. Their voices are just so beautiful. •I love the guitar in the 6th track. They are so amazing lyricaly. •I don’t know why but the 7th song made me really emotional. •8th track is so so so folk rock and I’m here for it. Harmonica is really cool in this one. •Of course we need a typical love song. 9th song is making me want to be in a relationship. •I like only the beginning and the ending in the 10th song. •No comment on the last one because I don’t know what to say. Overall this album is such a piece of art, I’ll be coming back to it from time to time:)

Haunting vocals give this an ethereal feel hauntingly beautiful album. Have always been a fan of Scarborough fair and Homeward Bound.

Sounds like Dylan, not the biggest folk rock guy. This was a difficult list for me as I am a huge solo Simon fan. Not horrible, but wouldn't listen to again.

Lovely sound and lyrics throughout, albeit very short. Bonus points for having a song where they just make fun of bob dylan the entire time lol

Opens with their brilliant version of the traditional English folk song "Scarborough Fair", and the English influence continues with the pensive "Homeward Bound" (allegedly written while waiting for a train at Widnes station). Other highlights on the album include happy "The 59th Street Bridge Song" (aka "Feelin' Groovy"), and the beautiful "For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her". The album closes with the moving "7 O'Clock News/Silent Night". Part of your soundtrack if you grew up in the 60's and 70s.

One of Simon and Garfunkels' best! I feel like David Byrne would characterize the production on this record as "tight", while each of the tracks are quite short, they're all excellently arranged and the harmonies of Simon and Garfunkel here are truly wonderful, just an overall pleasant and great listen!

Aika kaunista.

Lightweight and dated, mostly folksy

Earnest and sincere. Precocious in a middle class sorta way. I think I’m too edgy and jaded and insecure for this. Or to put it another way, the last song (Silent Night) made me laugh, but not as much as ‘Eve of Destruction’.

A very high 4 for me. Short and sweet, great lyrics, great instrumentation. I've always loved Feelin' Groovy - just pure blissed-out happiness. But I really loved the other tracks, too. Honestly the only thing keeping me from a 5 is knowing Paul Simon's solo stuff is on this list, and how much more I like that overall.

It was nice but I don't think I'll be very likely to listen to this ever again.

5/10 - Not my music, Slow.

Good, short, organic, melancholic, folky album. Instruments played live, simple as it can be. Vocal harmonies, pure talent. No quantization, metronome, autotune. Just music, with its inherent and beautiful imperfections. Definitely an album to listen to on headphones or good speakers. That being said, it's a very safe album, with little to none curve balls being thrown. A Simple Desultory Philippic is fun and interesting, and the duality of the last track is noteworthy, but I can't see the reason to this album make into the list. I'm feeling something like a low 6 to a flat 7 on this one. 6,6/10 maybe.

I own this record. Its great. Homeward bound is a sensational song that everyone should listen to at some point in their life. The album is varied, and the vocals are just magnificent coupled with a great songwriting duo. Lots of notable songs.4 stars

not bad, fun

Cultural impact cannot be overstated

Very quiet record, lovely for a quick listen and easy to get to. One of their best albums no doubt.

I'll be honest. Could have been better. Ye old cottagecore folk tho, if youre into that.

i was excited when this album showed up as the daily pick, i'd (obviously) heard of it and i love a good, weird, folksy sound. i'm sure this was amazing for the time, but... some of these songs were genuinely annoying. i think i just don't like the vocals. i see what they were going for but it's like oil and water. the components are not mixing.

When I was a freshman in university, I once went to a mixer for incoming English majors early into the semester. One of the professors decided to bring their mandolin and play Scarborough Fair for the assembled students (truly the most English Lit professor action I’ve ever seen). Up to that point, I knew the name Scarborough Fair but had never heard the song—to hear it now brings me back to that night, and actually makes me a little misty. The mixing, the dual and layered verses...it’s wonderful again. That professor, with his quiet voice and beautiful mandolin, passed away unexpectedly last year. To hear this album, with its warmth and gentleness, brings me back to that night again when we all stood and listened to him play, and the joy we felt at our new camaraderie. And for this one moment, the professor lives again. “So I’ll continue to continue to pretend My life will never end And flowers never bend with the rainfall”

great 10/10

I like "Bookends" by Simon and Garfunkel. But this project doesn't have that same energy or more all complexity. Not bad at all, but pretty. 3.5/5 ⭐⭐⭐1/2

It's a fine Simon & Garfunkel album. Not one of my favorites, its pretty short, has two of their hits.