Reviews (page 5 of 8)
Mediocrity Minus. Boring songs, vocal and music. Not on par woth some average albums on this list, it stands out with its universe of dullness. Soon to be forgotten (at least by me).
I'm not MAD about the amount of punk I'm listening to but this is getting silly. So far I can see why Another Girl Another Planet is the song I know. Everything else sort of blending together. Good voice tho, def one of the instruments. Becoming a pattern that I say all the songs sound the same and then immediately one stands out: I'm enjoying creature of doom. Language Problem also. Enough standout tracks here to enjoy but mostly background noise. Look ultimately I just don't think punk was really meant to come in albums. It was made for spitting at each other in shit clubs and for shuffling in your car while you crash into the palace of westminster. The LP format is just an unfortunate necessity.
I can't tell if this is really good or really boring, but Americans did it better. I'll enjoy the source material: Television and Blondie.
I didn’t have time to listen to the whole thing, but the songs I listened to were alright. I particularly liked Another Girl, Another planet
Pass
Mediocre at best
Surpsingly good. Who said punk rock allowed non-musician to make music?
That is nice
At first I thought this album was a total miss. That wannabe Lou Reed / Bowie voice really threw me off, especially on the slower tracks where it just sounds awkward. But as the album went on, it really won me over. It’s sharp, well put together, and often delivers some proper post-punk energy while keeping a raw, punk edge. A really solid find in the end … but with an unpleasant voice.
Those vocals brought this down to 2/5
Nothing Special.
Прикольно вроде
I don't care what anyone says, this album is lovely. I saw quite a few people complaining about the main vocalist's voice, but I guess they've never listened to something like Pavement (or, if I'm being bold, even The Smiths and maybe The B-52's). Actually, the most off-putting thing about the album is its cover, but that's beside the point. I liked the first two tracks the most, I think they're really solid. The rest of the album wasn't too memorable, but I still really liked the overall style of the music and some of the lyrics (like in No Peace For The Wicked) were really relatable. All in all, nice a record.
soft Pop, alter. Rock, 1978 -> 2
I imagine this landed much better at the time. It's not bad, but it's also largely unremarkable to these ears in 2025. Grading on a curve a bit for the release year, so this one sneaks into a 3. 2.5
Really not into the vocals but the rest of it kind of hits.
The instrumentals are rad but the flat singing is bothering me I’d probably really like this as a sync in a movie
God, shitty singer in a 70s punk band. I have heard enough of these. The music at least was a little better than most punk
Absolutely thrilled this album made it onto the list. Another Girl, Another Planet is easily my favourite rock song and the album holds up terrifically. 5+
Definitely a typical late 70's album. Nothing overly complex, but the bass really cuts through the mix on a lot of these songs. City of Fun is the coolest riff Somehow it gives me a Lynrd Skynrd mixed with Beatles vibe
I liked the album for the most part but his voice was taking me out of it
Decent punk rock, especially considering it's from 1978. Never heard of the band though. 3/5
I always get excited when my album of the day is from a band I’ve never heard of; a true mystery. Will it be a hidden gem that slipped my radar? More often than not, however, there are one or two good songs that were super popular in their day but are now forgotten. Today’s is not even that - a fairly talented group of musicians that are let down by very off-putting vocals. Unfortunate. 2⭐️
Another Girl, Another Planet - knew the song but never heard of the band :D But not so fussed about the rest of the album
Oooo his voice gahhh. I didn't hate the music, I actually liked some of it but during 'language problem' I just needed it to stop. I only knew 'another girl, another planet' and I did like that song but a whole album was a bit much. I feel like this list is compiled by people who liked a hit and then felt the need to include a whole album rather than considering including worthwhile and diverse albums.
When a lead vocalist is that bad, the music really has to be top tier. A few songs did deliver, but not one I'll rush back to.
His voice grated on me a tad too much. Music was pretty good though.
No, didn’t ignite anything in my world
One day fly Oh why oh why Are you on this list Standing betwixt All the greats And their mates Maybe I can't relate To a simple twist of fate A mediocre find But I can leave it behind
Exactly what you will expect. Not terrible and the sound grew on me a bit the longer I listened. Still, not for me.
Post punk / rock, very brit
I’ve never heard or heard of this band. First song starts with some good sax - I’m hopeful! Then the vocals start and don’t line up with expectations at all. I’m sad! Then the next song is not bad- vocals match the mood. Suddenly we are in Violent Femmes territory. Not sure who came first but they are very similar. Overall a slightly punkish pop sound. Definitely grew on me. The Immortal Story, which was the final track of the original album (there a reissue with bonus tracks) was the highlight for me.
Instrumentals were great, but I didn’t like the vocal style
I was not hopeful - based solely on the cover. But to my surprise this sounded like a Post-Punk Faces record. Will put on my rotation!
I don’t like handing out ones but I just couldn’t stand this one
Das war seltsam und irgendwie hat es mich genervt, aber nicht so schlimm dass es nur einen Stern kriegen würde.
Really very good. Feels ahead of its time. A band I've never heard of before too. This is why I'm doing this!
Fnope
Give me an instrumental version and it’s a 5.
Miles said, "it takes a long time to figure out what you sound like." And generally that's true. So it's amazing to find acts that, while steeped in the conventions of their time, sounded unique right out of the gate. Beautifully recorded; cohesive band; unique sound; great songs. Yes, please!
Meh
Another girl, another planet is a banger, the rest is fairly forgettable
What a great new-to-me band! 4.5 stars
Not really my type...
Voegt niet zoveel toe. Beetje nietszeggend, en er staan betere bands in deze stijl in de lijst. Af en toe leuk.
8/10 Favorite Tracks:*The Beast*, Creature of Doom, The Whole of the Law, Another Girl Another Planet, Breaking Down Least Favorite: Language Problem, No Peace for the Wicked, As My Wife Says
Don’t know how some of these albums are cracking the all timers list, but it’s getting pretty disappointing.
Kind of bland and samey
Very good sound and energy and intention from the artist. This album just did not mesh with me personally, it was dreadfully middling to get through. I am definitely an outsider to the genre, but I do listen to enough music to recognize there is quality present, and a fair amount of diversity in tone of some of the tracks. Middling score from me, this is not bad, but does not perk up my ears besides the skill heard from the musicians playing the instruments.
interesting lil gem.
Musically it is quite good, but the singer can’t sing in the worst possible way. He just sounds constipated
Pretty boring and drab, saved maybe one song, sounded like generic orange juice or prefab sprout.
Completely fine.
Didn’t like the first track, was dreading the next 40 minutes. Then Another Girl, Another Planet came on and it is an absolute BANGER. The rest of the album while good doesn’t hit that same high but still a really good listen overall.
Probably one of the worst voices.
nah 2/5
Correcto
1.8
I enjoyed this! It felt remarkably current given how old it is. Vibes.
This was weird and I really liked it. I ended up listening to it a couple times. Nasally punk vocals with some more intricate, full-band instrumentals. Catchy, fun. The type of interesting album I’m looking for while doing this project!
2.9 Bit of a strange addition to the list. One hit wonder, and the one hit is barely a hit. Not sure what the list has gained from their appearance. They aren't bad, but they aren't good. Distinctly average.
Fun music but vocals by someone who can at least sing would be highly welcome.
Seems like an early violent femmes
I liked it, light rock but it did sound a little Beatle-ish if you like that but slightly more whiny.
Some good moments, but mostly boring.
The guys voice on the first track made me think he was originally a bad singer, then he suffered a stroke, making him worse. Later tracks were uphill from there, perhaps with me getting used to it, sounding much like the Violent Femmes singer at times. The music behind him I enjoyed universally.
Pretty cool album. Has some classics!
I didn’t hate it. Listened through it without skipping any songs. Vocals are a bit tough at times. 2.5 stars.
pretty good
This is a very obvious one-hit wonder. "Another girl,Another World" is a nice track but the rest is meh. not bad but nothing that sticks.
nice 70s rock, no complaints
Kann weg.
Not what I expected - but no worse for it. Just the sort of ramshackle I like.
- Rather surprised that this is considered punk, but I can see how it led to quite a few pop-punk groups in the 90s and 00s. Has a flavor of Arctic Monkeys to it, too. - Considering how very British Perrett's voice is, I was surprised at how often I grooved along with it. But it did lose me occasionally with its whiny drawl. (Also having Kakoulli on backing vocals made an odd tension considering how much more melodic her voice is.) - Not surprised that "Another Girl, Another Planet" is the only track with longevity. It is the clear standout.
Pretty good, but i already don't remember much about it. A light version of British punk. A bit softer but easier to listen to. Vocals take some getting used to
As Punk goes, it’s not a bad album, but nothing that’ll set my hair ablaze. A nice blend of grit and whine.
Had some horns every now and then but no track or anything really grabbed my attention. 2.5 but gotta go one way or the other.
This was a real pleasant surprise, despite the shaky start. Will definitely be returning to this one.
Enjoyable listen, sometimes almost punk
Fine
Loved it, what a delightful find. Reminds me of so many things I like, I don't know how I could have never heard of them.
50 seconds into the first track I started laughing. Which isn't a good sign. The vocal performance takes a bit of getting used to - a cross between the Buzzcocks and They Might Be Giants. But then the second track. hey I know that!? 'Another Girl, Another Planet`. Great song. Never knew it was them. Album grows on you. Excellent for a first album. Shame they never pushed on.
According to my lastfm stats I've heard one song from this album before but I genuinely don't remember it and was dead sure I don't know them. Well, after listening to the album I can say I didn't miss out on much. Not awful but also there was nothing truly interesting on the album either. 2/5
Not a huge fan
Enjoyable.
This was a huge influence on me. Tough to listen to now. But perfect
I'm getting sick of British rock.
Here is another British band I never heard of. This album starts smooth and mellow then transitions to rock. The singer has a sort of droopy voice (reminds me of Lou Reed). Overall this was better than I expected, but nothing memorable. Three stars.
What a voice! Very British. If this is "power pop" I'll eat my hat. (Update: The wiki list of power pop artists is making me have to eat a lot of hats...) At first I thought I might like this, but it turns out I really don't. Too muddled. Highlights: 'Creature of Doom', the absurd line "I love my mother but I wouldn't want to have sex with her", 'No Peace for the Wicked', rhyming "calm" with "harm"
normal demais
vocal esquisito é o charme, tem jeito não. esse aqui é 100% pro meu bico. curti pra carai, bom misto de pop, punk e psicodelia. até um pouco a frente do tempo, né, lembra algumas bandas de indie britânico do inicio dos anos 2000.
It's okay. Some decent songs but not my thing.
I'm in love with extreme mental torture.
I'm old enough to remember "Another Girl, Another Planet" when it came out, and remember it as a better than average bit of Power Pop. So, seeing the debut album here in the pantheon of greats was a bit of a surprise. here goes.... OK. So "Another Girl, Another Planet" is the standout track of the album, but the rest... distinctly average. I can't understand why this LP is here in the 1001, but superior albums like "Can't Stand The Rezillos" isn't. Ah, sweet mystery of life.
another girl another planet innit
Overall a decent 70s album, but most of the songs were a little too slow, and the vocals on a couple songs were really annoying. My favorite song was The Whole of the Law because of the sax parts.
How frustrating, there's snippets of some really good stuff in here but overall the record just doesn't really do much. There's so many fun instrumental elements which don't match with the singing or the general vibe of the music. What exactly were they trying to achieve?
Apart from their hit single "Another Girl, Another Planet", I wasn't really familiar with this band. Musically the album is all over the place: Power Pop, New Wave, and Punk Rock. The depressing whining nasal vocals, particularly on "The Beast", make me want to shake the lead singer and tell him that life's not that bad.
I'm not familiar with this album or artist, but I'm definitely getting Cheap Trick vibes from the album cover. I haven't been wowed by any of the power pop albums I've reviewed so far on this list, so I'm heading into this with pretty muted expectations. Here's hoping that The Only Ones will be the first ones of their genre to blow my socks off! When “The Whole of the Law” first started, I was not impressed. I thought it was really boring, and I was dreading listening to the rest of the album. However, my fortunes quickly changed when “Another Girl, Another Planet” started. I’m familiar with Blink 182’s version of this song, and I had no idea that it was a cover. The lyrics were fun, and I really enjoyed the unique guitar playing. The vocals really fit the tone of the song as well, and this was easily the best song on the album. I wasn’t blown away by the rest of the first side of the album, but I did like “City of Fun.” Its guitar riff was great, and I liked the energy of the music. I found the second side of the album to be a little better than the first side. The keyboards on “The Immortal Story” were really great, and the guitar playing and percussion blended with them nicely. Overall, I thought this album was okay. The song structures were interesting, and the band sounded like they’re pretty proficient musicians, but I just didn’t enjoy the overall sound. However, I can see how this album influenced other artists into the early eighties. In the grand scheme of late seventies power pop though, The Only Ones just kind of fade into the pool of other similar artists like The Saints, The Stranglers, and The Undertones.
Never heard of these guys or this album, kind of enjoyed it after a hiatus from this project due to vacation. 3*
Didn’t really care for this and would not listen again - city of fun was kind of ok? Rounding up from a 1.5 here.
pretty cool
Mancantao! Super divertido, variadisimo en estilo y vibes sin llegar a marcarse del todo como full rock ni pop
good
I don't understand how this might be labeled Punk. Musically, it was mediocre British (Power?) Pop, but the voice was the showstopper.
Whiny English drek
5.5/10 Could have been good if they had a better singer. Highlights: Another Girl, Another Planet Creature of Doom Peter and the Pets
This has got to be one of the most uninteresting albums I've ever listened to. It is yet another late 70s British rock album. HOW MANY OF THESE FUCKING THINGS ARE THERE ON THIS LIST?? I genuinely don't know what to say here because nothing about it is special to me, yet it also doesn't really piss me off. The sound is decent. The singing is kind of annoying for some songs but not that bad for others. The writing exists. Even this album's one decently popular song "Another Girl, Another Planet" doesn't really interest me that much. Despite the band name, these guys are certainly not the only ones to make an album with this style. This album doesn't need to be here. Objectively speaking, I know that this album isn't bad. I just couldn't give a crap about it myself. High 2/5.
Pleasantly surprised by this one, then again, when an album is described as power pop, there’s a 90% chance I’m gonna like it, great stuff.
Like a mix of Velvet Underground and Boston. With jazz and punk. Despite that, dig it a lot??
It sounds like if David Bowie wrote and recorded an album while drunk.
Fun jammy stuff, love the organ. This list is so British
## In-Depth Review of *The Only Ones* by The Only Ones The Only Ones' self-titled debut album, released in 1978, is often hailed as a landmark in the punk and power pop genres. This review will explore the album's lyrics, music, production, themes, and influence, while also weighing its pros and cons. ****Lyrics Analysis The lyrical content of *The Only Ones* is characterized by a blend of dark themes and introspective storytelling. Lead vocalist Peter Perrett's writing often reflects personal struggles, existential musings, and societal observations. - **"Another Girl, Another Planet"** stands out as a quintessential track, encapsulating a sense of romantic escapism intertwined with a flirtation with mortality. The opening line, "I always flirt with death," sets a tone that resonates throughout the album, showcasing Perrett's ability to juxtapose light-heartedness with darker undertones. - **"No Peace for the Wicked"** explores themes of loneliness and alienation. The repetitive chorus serves as a haunting reminder that inner turmoil can persist despite outward appearances of cheerfulness. - Other tracks like **"The Beast"** delve into the dangers of addiction, using vivid imagery to convey a sense of urgency and warning. Perrett's lyrics often reflect his own tumultuous relationship with drugs, making them relatable yet unsettling. Overall, the lyrics combine poetic depth with raw emotion, inviting listeners to reflect on their own experiences while navigating the complexities of life. ****Musical Composition Musically, *The Only Ones* is a rich tapestry that blends elements of punk rock with pop sensibilities and hints of psychedelia. - The guitar work by John Perry is particularly noteworthy; his riffs are both catchy and intricate. Tracks like **"Another Girl, Another Planet"** feature razor-sharp guitar lines that propel the song forward while maintaining an infectious energy. - The rhythm section, consisting of Alan Mair on bass and Mike Kellie on drums, provides a solid foundation that complements the melodic elements without overshadowing them. The interplay between instruments creates a dynamic soundscape that feels both cohesive and diverse. - Production-wise, the album has a raw yet polished quality typical of late '70s recordings. The mixing allows each instrument to shine through while maintaining an overall gritty aesthetic that aligns with the punk ethos. ****Themes Thematically, *The Only Ones* tackles issues such as love, addiction, alienation, and existential dread. - **Love and Relationships:** Many songs explore the complexities of love—its joys and its pains. Perrett's lyrics often reflect on lost love or unattainable desires. - **Addiction:** The specter of drug use looms large over several tracks. Songs like **"The Beast"** serve as cautionary tales about the perils of addiction. - **Existential Reflection:** The overarching theme of searching for meaning in a chaotic world permeates the album. Perrett's introspective lyrics invite listeners to ponder their own existence amid societal pressures. ****Influence *The Only Ones* has left an indelible mark on both punk and power pop music. Its blend of catchy melodies with thought-provoking lyrics paved the way for future artists who sought to merge pop sensibilities with deeper themes. - Bands such as *Oasis* and *The Libertines* have cited The Only Ones as an influence on their sound and lyrical approach. The band's ability to balance catchy hooks with serious subject matter set a precedent for subsequent generations of musicians. - Additionally, the album's exploration of personal struggles resonates with listeners across genres, making it a timeless piece that continues to inspire artists today. ## Pros and Cons ### Pros - **Lyrical Depth:** The album features introspective lyrics that resonate with listeners on multiple levels. - **Musical Diversity:** A blend of punk rock energy with pop melodies creates a unique sound that stands out in its era. - **Cohesive Production:** Despite its rawness, the production quality enhances the listening experience without compromising authenticity. ### Cons - **Dark Themes:** The pervasive darkness in some tracks may not appeal to all listeners seeking lighter fare. - **Pacing Issues:** Some songs may feel slower or less engaging compared to more upbeat tracks like "Another Girl, Another Planet." - **Niche Appeal:** While influential, the band's style may not resonate universally due to its specific blend of genres. In conclusion, *The Only Ones* by The Only Ones is a remarkable debut that skillfully combines poignant lyrics with captivating music. Its exploration of complex themes through an engaging sound has solidified its place in music history as both an influential work and an enduring classic.
Songs with such varying topics (like City of Fun, The Beast, Language Problems) shouldn't sound exactly the same.
Could barely get through the album
Fav: Another Girl, Another Planet Least Fav: Creature Of Doom Think it drags a little in the second half but that first half is back to back perfect songs. This is the sorta stuff I like to see. Also shout out to having a song unironically called Creature Of Doom, that’s what I like to see from song names
I have never heard of this group before today. Some of the songs sound very contemporary, while others are very much of their time. I can also hear how this music showed up in the decade following its release. This album was a nice surprise!
3-
Had not heard of this band before! Total surprise. Really fun from the get go. Peter Perret's voice reminds me of Neil Cicierega'a.
More British punk from the 70s… it’s fine
I've heard better music come out of my asshole
Seems like Diet Britpunk. Bit monotonous, and didn't really pull me in, but certainly well-executed.
I am torn on this album. I liked the songs, the style the vocals everything. That said there were no songs that stood out in such a way that I thought I would seek them out again, but should they come up again I would not be unhappy. Maybe I will come back around to them again but I cannot see why that would be.
Enjoyable and very British take on New Wave/punk.
Almost turned this off during the first song due to the dreadful vocals. Can't really say it got better, but it was less cumbersome. Some of the songs would have really shined with better vocals. Also seemed like the recording and sound drifted vastly apart on different songs.
The band is great but the singer sounds like an extremely inebriated Bob Dylan. It’s too bad they didn’t kick ol’ slurry voice to the curb, this album could have been good.
Decent album. Sound often like The Violent Femmes on downers. All of the tracks with heavier guitar and faster tempo are my favs.
Reveal reaction: I've never heard of this band. I started listening to this a couple days ago, and just wasn't in the mood. Then I got sick and kind of forgot about it for a couple days. Coming back to it, it's actually quite a bit better than the first little bit of listening I did. I don't really know how to categorize it. There's definitely a punk twinge to it, down to the singers somewhat nasally delivery, but it's got some four-on-the-floor straight ahead rock chops as well. There's a few songs in here that have some shades of what would eventually become grunge. I gotta be honest - for a guy that is PROPER sick of 70s rock, this kinda slaps. I'm not going to listen to it every day, but it actually sounds fresh for what it is. I know that's weird, because if I didn't know the year it was released, I'd definitely peg it as a 70s album, but at the same time it doesn't really sound like other 70s albums.
Hasnt aged that well
Fing gut an und hat dann stark nachgelassen :-/ Werde mit diesem Brit-Pop/Punk nicht grün
nicht schlecht, aber auch nicht gut. kein lied besonders herausgestochen.
Komische Stimme
I really liked the first half, but towards the end it all felt like variations of the same. Were these guys even influential?
not a fan of the vocals
Sounded like a mix of the Violent Femmes vocals and Television and The Gun Club musically.
No es la gran cosa, pero suenan lindo. Son un rock básico, arregladito que va.
The only song I knew from this band before listening to this album was Another Girl, Another Planet. I love that song, but I was not expecting much from the rest of the album. There are hundreds of band that I only like one song from and if this band was worth exploring I probably would have done that already... right? I was wrong. While Another Girl is still by far my favorite track, the rest of the album continued to surprise me. I added several songs to my library. I think of like to check out more from this band.
Came in with a flourish with THE WHOLE OF THE LAW and ANOTHER GIRL, ANOTHER PLANET. Kind of fizzled a bit, but enough to make me want to investigate more of their catalog.
Middling at best. Seemingly uncertain whether they are punk, pop, rock or emo (which hadn’t been invented yet), the sum of their uncertainty is blandness.
I agree with Mike- firmly in the not a fan camp. His voice grates on me.
Yea this is a pretty slick little album. though it falls off for me in the back half.
Very enjoyable. Hope to listen to it again. Mid 3s
Yup
fun album that switches from jazz to classic rock - pretty good.
Good blend of punk, new wave and indie sounds. Simplistic song structures allow this album to be digested easily. This album for sure help late 80's alt rock and punk music get some more notariety. The vocals lose me a bit, but all else is really good. I enjoyed it.
Some good songs with strong playing. As an album it does feel incomplete missing more often than hitting. Fine for a debut I suppose. Might check out the followup.
Whole of the Law is such a sweet opener. Another Girl is a classic and easily my second favorite song about heroin. After that one-two punch, the album definitely settles down into more generic Brit pop-punk. They do better when they slow down a bit like with No Peace for the Wicked. The rest is serviceable but the first 2 tracks get this to an easy 4.
Never heard of this band. Not sure they made it across the Atlantic. Too bad because this is a good power pop album that has a touch of punk in it. Really good guitar parts. In one song, the organ part reminded me of Kitty's Back a little bit.
I'd never heard of this band before but this was good stuff! Punk energy but with melodies that would make me want to listen again. Reminds me of Television. The harmonic double guitar solo in "No Peace for the Wicked" really spoke to me.
Imperfect but often fun
it was fine
Not gonna lie, this is pretty bad. Nothing really redeemable about this album. Worse than a high school talent show band.
These guys sound like a mediocre high school band where no member is able to sing.
I thought it was interesting in parts, but a totally mixed bag. Feels a bit in-between genres and got tedious.
2.5
The drop off from Another Girl, Another Planet to everything else is massive. Such a great track
I should come back
Awful
Another album, another random inconsequential British inclusion. Unsure why this album is here and who it's for. Another gloomy British vocalist mumbling through each song. 3.5/10 (1.75/5)
I liked this! Never heard of this band, but enjoyed the mix of sounds and lyrics
cool album cover let's be fr here nice opening good ol' late 70s british rock, what's not to like tbh
Very fun album, somehow the singer’s voice worked with the beach guitar and funky bass lines. Glad it’s on this list.
No... I don't get this ones inclusion in the list. Makes no sense to me.
Ehhhh
Hmm this ain't for me.
This is like a combo of generic 60s rock and 70s punk. Interesting but not amazing
It's an alright new wave punk album that has a few standout tracks. C
Pretty good but once again not much else to say. Reminds me of a sort of mix between Coma Cinema vocals/lyricism and Hoodoo Gurus instrumental.
I listened to today's album and yesterday's album back to back and didn't even notice when one ended and the other began. Too generic
Overall: 3/10 So uninteresting that it's already left my brain. I enjoyed only one song and it seems to be the band's biggest hit. Big pass on this one. Fav Song: Another Girl, Another Planet Least Fav Song: The Whole of the Law
3.75
Not for me
Wasn't my jam
Bold name for such modest results.
Great proto punk album.
Quite a fascinating album, alternating between slower and up tempo tracks, with decent left field songwriting and a band that plays really well together (the musicianship is superb). You could argue the singing is the weak link, but I think his voice has charm and personality, sounding a bit like a combination of Lou Reed and Al Stewart. It's not an out and out 5 star record but it is different. And like say the Stranglers or Velvet Underground, it's the sort of oddball music that appeals to me.
No, no their not!
Interesting in places but ultimately felt unfulfilling, everything seemed overshadowed by the (admittedly great) single
Wow. Scraping the bottom of the barrel for essential albums again? Someone clearly likes, "Another Girl, Another Planet" enough to nominate the whole album Nothing offensively bad here, but really only that one track to revisit.
Another Girl, Another Planet... the "only one" we care about.
The album The Only Ones, by the band of the same name, is an intriguing musical experience that, despite the vocal limitations of the vocalist, manages to captivate the listener. The voice may be considered peculiar and far from traditional standards of beauty, but this does not prevent the engaging melodies and deep lyrics from standing out, creating a unique atmosphere. The energetic guitars and well-crafted production support the album, allowing even voice critics to find pleasure in the nuances and emotional honesty present in the tracks. Thus, The Only Ones establishes itself as a work that deserves to be appreciated, regardless of its vocal imperfections.
One hit wonder
This was pretty good. Obvious single excluded this was new to me. Like a poppier velvet underground maybe. Nothing earth shattering but not offensive
What's wrong with some people-this was made in 1978 at the cusp between Punk and New Wave. It has that fresh vibe and energy and knocks the spots off other bands that came after.
2.5
3/5
Not bad. Certainly a template for any number of other bands years later. I figure Paul Westerberg was WAY into these guys. An interesting side diversion into punk. Unexpected bangers: No Peace for the Wicked, City of Fun
I think I like these guys
pretty inoffensive, I get the vibe of royalty free music from this album. its not bad or anything, in fact I liked Another Girl, Another Planet, but overall its just a pretty average album.
The definition of a 3 star album. Pretty bland and right up the middle. Nothing to write home about but not bad
RFK Jr? Is that you? When did you get into 90s British pop rock? Really cool instrumentation, doesn't sound like anything too ground breaking but it sounds good. Oh but the vocals, yeah those are dogshit.
Loved this. Sick guitar and sad and overall sound.
Pretty good.
I've listened to "Another Girl Another Planet" a bunch before this but never checked them out (a song that sounds like if 'Already Gone' by the Eagles flew to Manchester in 1975 and did heroin for 5 years). Uneven song quality but I like their sound...a mix of Lou Reed, The Knack, Peter Frampton. Tight band and I like the production.
Albumi #105, 10.11.2024 The Only Onesin samanniminen esikoisalbumi julkaistiin vuonna 1978.
Started off very slow and mediocre, but closer to the end it really picked up and saved the album for me. Highlights: Another Girl, Another Planet Creature Of Doom
Long forgotten proto-punk band from England. This album felt like an early attempt at Violent Femmes style music.
Solidly a 3 for me. Some moments where it felt like they were teasing taking it to another level. A definite willingness to stretch boundaries. Will come back for Immortal Story.
Went in with no expectations (or context) but this album put me in a great mood. I think I’ve heard Another Girl Another Planet before but this was otherwise completely new to me. This album is really tight and fun, with a playful energy, though maybe lacking in real stand out hits. I am generally a fan of the sort of louche, jagger-esque singing style on display here, and I think it works here. I usually think punk is a little too artless for me, but these guys can really play. This feels like an early influence on definitely the replacements and maybe the strokes (a top ten band for me)? Anyway this is probably a 4 but I feel a little guilty calling the beastie boys inane pedophile music yesterday so I’m gonna be more generous than usual.
Nothing overly bad, just not for me
Enjoyed this - mix of psychedelic and grungy sound that I enjoyed. Not likely to spin the whole thing again but was glad I listened
This was bad. A couple of redeeming things I can say about this: they seemed ahead of their time - really sound like a generic 90s band in the 70s. And Lilywhite is one of the first producers I ever knew by name, cool to hear his early work, before he went on to make more listenable music. Some nice moments in the instrumentals. I have a very high tolerance for bad/unconventional vocals, if the melodies are there and the lyrics seem worthwhile - this misses the mark.
A bit whiny for me. It sounds much more modern than 1978, so the date was surprising. Some decent songs but it's not really doing it for me.
Solid less than spectacular background rock.
British people who can’t sing shouldn’t sing
Not bad. I think it will grow on me with repeated listenings.
Never heard of this group, so I had no expectations. Wasn't bad, I'll check out more of their stuff.
I wanted to shut this off after the first horrible track, but I always listen all the way through. It got better, pretty good even. Fun rock with a bit of punk to it. Shame about the vocals, though - they never got any better, and ruin any chance at greatness here. They sound like George Harrison if he was intentionally trying to sabotage a recording by half-assing the singing. This is one album that I'm on the fence about listening to it again, but leaning towards no. Best track: Creature of Doom.
I really like it!! His voice is a little toooo languid but I still really liked it
Underrated album from an underapprecited band of the late 70s pop-punk movement in UK. Reminds of bands like The Undertones and The Buzzcocks. More than a pop-punk band as they incorporate doowoop and jazz influences. All the songs are little melodic gems, that stay with you. Another Girl Another Planet is the "hit" but the deeper cuts are just as satisfying and well written. It does bog down a little towards the end but remains a satisfying listen. 4.5 stars
very interesting 70's sound. Would like to listen some more!
I like this one! At least the alvum contains songs that make sense. Vocalist is so so; his voice is ok for some tracks but others would benefit from a change, he is not the most solid and has limited range of expression. Like the guitar riffs and general sound. All in all a pretty good album.
This was a really up and down album for me. I very much enjoyed the overall tempo and energy of the songs and I feel like the instrumentals could have fit in very well in modern Indie Rock. When the vocals kicked in on the first track, I groaned right away. Another whiny 80s new wave voice, great. Luckily my view changed over time, in some tracks his voice worked very well and I found myself getting over that initial reaction though there were a couple moments later in the album i found his voice grating to me. Lyrics were ok, a bit downer for me but when it's high tempo and fun guitar riffs I don't mind as much, and they played around with rhyming structures a fair bit. Overall a pleasant surprise, I feel like this is a band that gets better the more you listen, and was way ahead of their time.
The Only Ones was definitely a mixed bag album for me. All of the songs seem to follow similar formulas to each other but the results would often vary. On one hand, there were some songs with some pretty decent energy and the singer's voice did seem to fit well with them. On the other hand, the other songs were kinda slow and boring and just ruined by the singer's voice in some instances. The album did seem to move at a fairly fast pace and there were more good songs than bad songs so those two facts helped this album but not enough for me to give it more than 3 stars. Best Song: Language Problem Worst Song: Breaking Down
I'd never heard of The Only Ones before. Really enjoyed this. Feels a bit like the Violent Femmes, although it predates them. Will listen again.
3 decent
Yeah, this was good. Better than expected. A good listen, but could get a bit repetitive. It’s original and unique and I enjoyed it. 4/5
not bad. i quite enjoyed this one.
Didn’t really care for his vocals but this was pretty cool. Kind of like Squeeze.
Was fine - nothing really stood out
This album was a strange listening experience. I'd never heard any of the songs before but have definitely heard their influence across dozens of others. Especially Another Girl, Another Planet -- I kept thinking I knew the song only to be completely wrong! Breaking Down had great instrumentals. Veered towards punk near the end of the album, starting with Language Problem. Had me thinking about how all of the albums on this list are good, even if I don't like them.
I liked this one! In general I really liked the guitars and backing music, with their upbeat musical jams. Lots of tracks on here are a total bop. I'd never heard of these guys before (outside of one track), so it was a nice surprise.
first listen kinda a mixed bag
Meh didn’t really like this.
really enjoyed this completely eclectic mix
Started out like a dodgy Doors tribute band, then Another Girl Another Planet drops and it’s great fun all the way through after. Really enjoyed that.
Oh boy! More mid-quality UK music on this list! :|
Considering the line up of the band, this should be so much better.
The vocals are grating, but the instrumentals kept me enamored throughout this.
The great thing about punk rock was that it was meant to be something that anyone can do. The bad thing about it was that many people did. That's not to say that The Only Ones are bad. Not at all. It's just that how many variations of the basically the same thing do you need? This album has some decent punk songs and they're a little poppier than most of the other bands at the time, which is something. They also were influential to the likes of Nirvana, Blur and others, which is also worth noting. It's a good album, but it just kind of fades into the general background of every other punk band out there. There are a handful that stand out above the crowd, but The Only Ones aren't quite at that level, to me.
Definitely will have to listen again. Seems that a lot of bands that came later, and in some cases much later, where influenced by them. I hear early Violent Femmes. Some early Strokes. Some vocals sound like early Brendan Benson. The song “Immortal” reminds of something from Weezer’s Maladroit. Understood this album came out decades earlier, but never listened to any of the band’s material before this listen. Might give it 4 stars based on listening to it more.
Good album
Yea, really nice
Some interesting sounds but only a little bit interesting. After the first song I had some hopes bvut it didnt materialize into anything too interesting.
Ok. Ikke noespes. 3
Had difficulty focusing at work today. Mind kept going back to thinking about how deranged the cover of The Only Ones by The Only Ones is.
This just isn't for me.
Never heard of this before. Eh.
Rockified 70s-80s British pop often slaps, especially this one.
Favourite tracks: another girl another plant; the beast
Couldn’t get through it. The lead just hits bad. The “hit,” Another Girl, Another Planet has great music, but even that is wrecked by the lead.
1.5/5
I thought this was alright. None of the songs really stood out except another girl another planet, but I still enjoyed the overall sound. I got a bit bored at times. I kind of wish I liked this more than I do! 3
It's not bad but not particularly memorable to me.
MIt einem richtigen Sänger hätte es für ** gereicht. Aber so...
This was surprisingly enjoyable, a band I'd never heard of who had an "interesting" singer, and a nice mix of garage rock/ pop. I was reminded of several other bands, most of which came later, like The Libertines. I was also reminded of several other bands who came earlier, like Hawkwind, but on their mid-80s lineup, so still later technically. I was very tempted to give this four stars, but it's a strong 3.
Interesting! I played this through twice, and really enjoyed it more in the background as opposed to listening to it closely, some of the vocals can be a little grating.
I liked this album, probably more than I should have.
Only Ones I liked all the intros but the vocals ruin it for me. The songs are better than most of the other 70’s English punk bands. I think I’d like with another singer.
Kind of fun sleazy rock vibe but not super memorable and lost interest halfway through
I didn’t absolutely hate this. It was kinda weird and unpredictable in a good way.
The music is okay, lead singer is below average, so 2 stars or D+ seems fair.
Yeah okay. Whatever. Hey, new rule! Every time one of these 1001 supposedly world's greatest albums turns out to be just another minute variation on USUK '65-'80s rock the generator has served me many dozens of times before, I will give you a different album you could be listening to today. For instance: ~~~~ \"Djine Bora\" by BKO (2022) ~~~~ To tie it into this project: music as if Ali Farka Touré had ditched that Ry Cooder bore in 1994 and time travelled to hang out with Hendrix and CAN instead and *then* made "Talking Timbuktu". Go listen.
Hahaha, one song has 9.5M plays on YouTube music, the rest have about 150k combined. Another Girl, Another Planet is a great song. I don't mind the rest either, but I'm a tragic for 80s saxophone and unusual vocal stylings. This might be a four. Let's give it a couple more tracks... Maybe just a three. Yeah, three.
Another Girl, Another Planet stands out by miles, the rest underwhelmed. 2.5.
I wondered why they didn't open the album with Another girl, another planet. It's because there's nothing else of note on here.
The lyrics on this thing feel like a run on sentence.
2 -just felt bland
One of those that wavers between kind of annoying and kind of good. I’ll give it the benefit of the doubt and round up. I’m not likely to listen to it again, but it wasn’t bad.
3.8
Crap
The Only Ones’ self-titled album, presents a mixed bag of musical highs and lows. While the record features some compelling tracks, including the standout Another Girl, Another Planet, it ultimately struggles to maintain consistency throughout its duration. The band’s signature blend of punk and pop is evident, but many songs fail to match the energy and charm of their best work. The album’s overall cohesion suffers, as it feels uneven, with some tracks falling flat and lacking the impact of the standout hits. Although the standout song demonstrates the band’s talent and potential, it’s clear that one strong track alone doesn’t sustain the album’s momentum. The Only Ones has moments of brilliance but ultimately serves as a reminder that even great songs need a solid supporting cast to make a lasting impression. NUMBER OF BANGERS - 1 STAND OUT TRACK - Another Girl, Another Planet
could have been a nice forgettable 3 star album but the singer's voice is bad - it would fit better if they leaned more on the punkier sound
Interesante pero sin merecer realmente la pena. Buen grupo.
Punkig, poppig.
Noteworthy songs - 808080808 Magical Dream - Kinda catchy synth, but the rest is bland. Ancodia - Good background noise. Cobra Bora - Actually kind of cool, reminds me of Bomberman Hero. Pacific 202 - N64 vibes, but melody isn't great. Donkey Doctor - Nothing too special, weird ending. 808080808 - Really cool beginning. A little slow in the middle but stays interesting enough. Sunrise - Nothing remarkable. The Fat Shadow - Eerie. Very short.
Rock/Pop, einfach zu hören, nicht besonders spannend 3/5
Good - similar sound to violent femmes
The lead singer of this group sounds like a British version of Lou Reed while he's backed by Springsteen's E Street Band. The further into this album I listen, the less it sounds like the E Street Band, but this was just OK.
The music was just fine. The vocals were hot garbage. I don't know where they found this Lou Reed wannabe, but they should have just left them there
Not too shoddy, a bit Meh in my opinion apart from Another Planet... which stands out as by far the best track
competent pop rock from a band I've never heard of, and am fairly certain I've never heard. Will ahve to revisit to form a final opinion, but this is a solid one for the list to reveal.
Meh. The music was fine. Couldn’t really get on board with the lead singer’s voice. It was unique. But not a good unique. Like an “I’m surprised this guy got a record deal unique”
Why another album that sounds exactly like 20 other ones I've listened to on this list. Boring music that doesn't sound good shouldn't be on a list of 1,001 albums to listen to. Would not listen again, yuck.
Some fun upbeat pop. The only track that really stuck out to me was The Beast, but even that kind of faded into the background as the song went on. I might give this one another listen in the future.
I have never heard this before. It was a fun listen. I see these guys have influenced many bands that I like. I will listen to this again.
I bought and listened to this album many years ago and bounced off it. It's better than I remember, but it's a case of there being a few highlights and a lot that's forgettable.
Album 502 of 1001 The Only Ones - The Only Ones Rating : 3.75 / 5 UK Power Pop. Some catchy tunes with some pretty skillful musicians. Don't think they ever really caught on here in the states but the UK thinks pretty highly of them. The Encyclopedia of Popular Music named The Only Ones one of the 50 best punk albums of all-time. The compilers claimed that the Only Ones were "the closest thing the UK had to Johnny Thunders' Heartbreakers, a laconic, shamble of a band who were, at moments, touched by a creative greatness that made you get out of the glare" - Wikipedia
I recognised that one track. The vocals kinda suck but I admire this for constantly trying to break out of just one sound.
I can see how this fits in alongside other 70s punk like Sex Pistols, but the more elaborate instrumentation and lyrics focused more on love than anger are very interesting and set it apart. Really cool stuff.
Deadpan delivery Melodic approaching wild Uniquely punk rock
I enjoyed this more than I expected I would, just given the general era and the fact I had never heard of them, and they are from the UK... the 1001 has such a big UK bias that many of the UK entries, particularly in the 1990s, are just not very good. That said, this reminds me of The Soft Boys and Robyn Hitchcock and I love those guys so that probably explains why I'm enjoying it.
The instruments were fine in this album, but this guy’s voice was rough. Another one of those albums of why is this on the list.
After two songs, it just became random noise that I just blocked out which was probably for the better
As soon as this fool started yodelling I knew it was gonna be a long 42 minutes. His voice is 🤮🤮🤮. I mean it’s not quite Bob Dylan bad but boy is it close. Everything else was great. The guitar, the bass, the drums, even the occasional horns were okay. But his voice was just awful. The lyrics were meh. The instruments saved this from being a 1 for me.
they're trying to play like the Clash, or Violent Femmes.....but the vocals are so out of tune. at least most of the tracks are pretty short so that is a positive.
Thoroughly ok
eh
I really liked the punk edge to this in the music, but I found the vocals lacking. Not bad though! 3.3
I liked this one a lot!
The songs were well written but it gets knocked down by the out of tune singing
One good song really. Didn’t like it at release, don’t like it now
Not good. Especially do not like the vocals.
Opinión totally biased. I loved this album. It’s the feel, its mystique, and what it represents. The production, the voice and guitars… all is perfect. 4.5/5
"Another Girl, Another World" is the top track. The Only Ones remind me of Violent Femmes, the right mix of melancholy but rocking, punk but also sad indie rock. They manage tight songs that sound more melodic and introspective than punk bands but louder than an indie outfit. I enjoyed the entire first seven tracks are great; the rest is worth a listen.
Track 1 is perfect, want die klinkt zo kut dat de rest van het album daarna best wel meevalt. Een beetje punk-achtig, tegelijk af en toe ook best wel muzikaal. De zanger is het zwakste punt. Hij klinkt als Craig van Southpark met een vleugje Downsyndroom. Zingen kan hij eigenlijk niet echt. Best een aardig album, maar de zanger trekt het naar beneden. Het is geen lang album, maar Peter Perrett begint er toch in te hakken na een paar nummers. Ik moet het op 2 sterren houden vanwege irritatie, maar de muziek is echt wel leuk.
Wow, this album is all over the place. First impression of the first few seconds: Beach Boys? Wait, saxaphone? Billy Joel?! Then it moved into glam/punk territory à la T. Rex and Television, then straight-up rock & roll, complete with soaring guitar solos. Not the hugest fan of the vocals, but this is great stuff.
I rather like some of the music on here and the instrumentation is good, but the vocals are mostly awful.
tiene bangers pero nada que me explote aquí la cabeza so it's a 5/10
4.1. Very listenable.