Reviews (page 2 of 8)
What I am about to say is bad criticism. It is lazy; it lacks any explanation beyond immediate opinion; it places those who do not agree in a out group where the presumption immediately is that if you are in that out group, you are of a lower intelligence. And while this may all be true, that this is spurred on by my own idiocy, due to a lack of intellectual verve, this is the only way I know to truly give my opinion on this album. You either get Randy Newman or you don't. There is nothing more to say about a man who is hated for his music's sound so much that his lyrics, sarcasm filled and biting, and pushed off to the side. After all, what can you say to someone who says that the Tom Jones version of You Can Leave Your Hat On is better, other than "have you listened to the song?" Seriously, the song is about a man asking a woman he just picked up to keep her hat on during sex, and then starts spouting conspiracy theories about how only he knows what love truly means. Thinking that is a serious song is like thinking Hallelujah is about God; you're woefully missing the point. So, what am I to say to people who don't get the biting sarcasm at play? What do I say to the people who don't see how the classic Americana instrumentation is there to be in direct opposition to the point of the songs, and that the languid sounds are needed to get his point across? Never mind that Newman is a brilliant piano player and that beside his lyrics the songs sound straight out of the Great American Songbook. What do you say to someone who, seeing the sarcasm of the lyrics mixed with the smooth Southern chops of an ace producer, does not understand what is happening and calls him boring? No amount of convincing I could try would get people to appreciate Newman's genius if they firmly do not or cannot get it. Sail Away is of its time in terms of it's social commentary, existing in a medium whose materials success is based on emotional connection far more than intellectual connection. As a result, no one I have ever talked to about Newman has understood why I like him so much, even after I show them his most overtly winking song Political Science (a song that only gets better with age). Hence my previous statement; you either get Randy Newman or you don't. For me, it makes complete sense, and Sail Away is maybe the best example of Newman's specific voice. If you get it, welcome aboard, I'm happy to have you on board. And if you don't? Well, I guess I'll jusy Sail Away then.
A bit funny sounding, nothing bad, just not to my liking. I can appreciate that it's a tiny bit different.
achei bem legal algumas músicas, mas eu sempre dava um risinho quando eu lembrava que era o cara do toy story, me perdoem.
2.7/5
Quite enjoyable.
🎩⛵️⚓️☀️🙏🏻
Smart songs, quirky delivery—that’s always a combination that works for me.
Awesome. Love Randy Newman. Song writing genius.
First listen
Hat gestern irgendwie garnicht gepasst , aber eigentlich ist gut
mooi album met goeie teksten...
America in 60s is pretty cool
With any album by Randy Newman, you have sit down and listen to catch the meaning behind the songs. Behind the arrangements is some bitter truth and snarky humor. It may take a few listens to pick up on everything that he’s trying to convey to the audience.
Randy Newman is good, until you ask him what he thinks of the vertically-challenged. There's an unmistakable feeling that the whole thing feels like a Disney soundtrack due to the man's association with the movies and company in general, so it loses a few points because of that. "Political Science" is a great song though
Newman has a strange voice. It's either really good for a bad singer or maybe really bad for a good singer. Regardless I like listening to him and his voice gives the album a milquetoast personality that somehow resonates with this dead heart. The songs themselves are pretty consistently good without ever blowing me away. It's basically an album full of 3-star songs maybe one 4 and one 2, but almost everything else lands right there. Nothing groundbreaking but an enjoyable listen throughout.
Есть несколько интересных песен, но по большой части исполнение кажется очень незамысловатым. Оно не плохое, но довольно ординарное
I went into this album knowing Randy Newman’s voice, but not recognizing anything from the track listing. By the end, I was surprised by just how much variety he packed into such a short album. Newman has one of the most distinctive voices in music, but this album proves that having a distinctive voice doesn’t mean every song has to sound the same. There’s vaudeville, blues, rock, beautiful piano ballads, humor, sadness, and some biting satire. The title track immediately grabbed me. “Sail Away” sounds beautiful until you realize the narrator is selling Africans on how wonderful America will be while we know the horrific reality awaiting them. “Political Science” uses the same kind of cheerful sarcasm while talking about dropping the big one on the rest of the world. On the other end of the emotional spectrum, “Old Man” is genuinely sad, while “He Gives Us All His Love” has a bittersweet spiritual quality. I also loved hearing Newman rock a little on “Last Night I Had a Dream,” and “You Can Leave Your Hat On” brings in a great bluesy sound. “Lonely at the Top” and “Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear” have a fun vaudeville feel that fits his voice perfectly. “Burn On” was probably the only song that didn't do much for me, but there really wasn’t anything here I disliked. A great discovery. Randy Newman manages to sound unmistakably like Randy Newman throughout while making almost every song feel different. Vinyl Verdict: BUY
I just can’t get into Randy Newman as much as this list tries.
Randy Newman songs sound like Randy Newman songs. The musical variety is almost nonexistent so it’s all about the lyrics. This album has some interesting things to offer in that respect. You need to pay attention to get the value of this one.
Newman's distinctive voice makes most of the songs sound like I Love LA/You've Got a Friend in Me but a) those are good songs and b) God's Song stands out as beautifully melancholy.
Realistically this might be a 3, but it's just not quite for me and I'm trying to be more critical. There are some good songs on here for sure, and I won't deny that he can write a tune. But there are some stinkers, and this just isn't an album I'm going to want to return to often, if ever. Fave tracks: - Lonely at the Top - Last Night I Had A Dream - Old Man - Political Science - Memo to My Son - You Can Leave Your Hat On
Just a perfect collection of songs. Can always put this on. It was nice to have another excuse.
I just love the way Randy writes here. One of the best and most underappreciated American lyricists. Quintessentially American, too. It's dark, but always a bit tongue in cheek. Sour topics cut with a classic sound. It's more of a whiskey album than anything that isn't Tom Waits.
Think he’s a good composer and writer, saw some real value in the album, but it’s much too America and god focused for my liking - and romanticising 1903 Ohio (“when folks were nice to you”). I love how his voice reminds me of toy story
One needs to pay attention to the lyrics. Sail Away is good and even better if you know what it is about (but that makes it sad). Political Science is hilarious and even more appropriate in the current political climate (2026) with the US being a big bully. Not really something I would listen to on my own but definitely there is something to be appreciated here.
Never heard him before. Weirdly feels like a singing cat in a Disney movie??? Feels very old fashioned for 1972. Lonely at the top was intended for Sinatra and sounds like it. I like other things in this genre but somehow not a fan of this, bit dull and hokey.
This was decent. His voice was cool.
I didn't realize that the song had changed until I was already halfway through the album. Everything he plays sounds exactly the same.
Some of these songs sound one step away from a Fiona Apple or Amy Mann song….that step being a giant leap that is Newman’s voice. Pretty fairly annoying stuff though mostly. I don’t need the dancing bear song or saying “the good times don’t last”, lackluster gospel & god takedown tracks…but Randy being randy? I’ll take that. Telling an old man everybody dies, that’s good.
The list creator is a coward, Randy Newman’s best and most prolific work has always been his movie soundtracks. The only Sail Away I’ll care about it Enya
Randy Newman is great at writing soundtrack music. His non-soundtrack work. . . I don't get its appeal. So much orchestration. So many attempts at quirky humor? And then there's "Political Science". I remember hearing this one years ago and being mildly amused, as a child, by it. Hearing it today, it's just fucking scary.
The gospel of Randy Newman ... not buying it.
Good album. Easy listening.
It's a lot better than his other album on here. Dancing Bear is always a crowd pleaser. I think Old Man was really brutal. Lots to like.
Closer to a four than a two. Comforting voice that I was happy to hear in a new context. Could probably do to listen closer to the lyrics on a second listen.
This album feels very much of its era. I can't help but hear how Randy Newman is something of a progenitor for someone like Tom Waits. But instead of circus music it's kind of more of a smoky piano bar. Strange amount of God and Jesus on this album... not really into that. The songs have legs and there's a ton of talent oozing out of them, but I don't find the music very compelling.
Once again, I like the social commentary and satire, but I hate Randy's vocals. Favorite track: Political Science
This was so hard for me to get through Playlist add: “Sail Away”
Pretty much a whole album that sounds like " You Got A Friend In Me." Very ragtime and harks back to an old fashioned style of music, but not my cup of tea.
It was fine but all sounded a bit same same after a while.
Sounds like the SNL skit of Fred Arminsen impersonating Randy Newman but for a full hour.
*1972. *Can't listen to Randy Newman without immediately thinking Toy Story, so from the opening notes, you're already in a warm, happy, nostalgic place. *Sail Away is a really nice opening song. *A small handful of cheesy tracks that very much sound like they're made for Pixar... (looking at you, Lonely at the Top). *Otherwise, mostly slow, sweet songs, which are the stars here. Really comforting and pleasant. *Other than Sail Away, nothing else really stood out here, but it was a nice experience. Probably a 3.5*, so I'll round up out of respect for Buzz and Woody. RATING - 6.5/10
I see no reason to listen to this before I die.
(Light 8/10) Damn, Randy's writing and arrangements really shine bright on here. The album's overall mood is pretty somber and pretty dark, but it's kind of the right thing for an album like this. This thing is full of satirical takes on politics, religion, and a few snarky views on life in America. I found this to be very charming, and a good introduction to the world of Randy Newman.
All his music sounds the same
Bluesy with a raspy, lounge vibe
oh
This was OK. He has a nice voice and there is some whimsy and commentary there. But this didn’t really catch me.
Didn't do anything for me.
Pop, Soul, 1972 -> 2
Monkey tree. I liked political science
Angenehm zu hören. Ein paar Coverversionen bekannter Songs. Ansonsten keine großen Highlights. 3/5
You really can't truly appreciate Will Sasso's impression of Randy Newman until you hear a full Newman album. Chef's kiss to you, Will. Randy Newman is a good songwriter & satirist. Political Science is a great example of this. Newman's voice is interesting to say to least. In trying to figure out whom he sounds like. Kermitt the Frog from the Deep South? No, he sounds like Ray Charles if he was white. It's weird but it I think Randy Newman is White Ray Charles. I can't unheard it, now. That You Can Keep Your Hat On is a sexy song, it's a damn shame it's sung by Randy Newman <shudders> Hey, Randy, maybe let some other people make movie music. 2
Absolutely insane track about nuking the World yet keeping Australia because he don't wanna hurt no kangaroos. Fave track: Sail Away
It’s quite hard to separate Newman’s iconic voice and sounds (from soundtrack albums like the one for Toy Story) and listen to his solo work standing alone. And it's kind of boring to be honest. 2.5/5
Not particularly enjoyed the vibe nor his voice. I understand his impact on movie songs but I was not thrilled by this album
Got quite into a few songs. Liked it more than I expected, though I did have low expectations.
He is different and interesting. I love the song from Major League. It is also really appropriate he is the Toy Story guy. As I listened to it there was something deep yet juvenile. It really made me think about Jack Johnson and the Curious George soundtrack. Something is so right in the difference but then at times there are moments that I am not really sure what is going on. I don't dislike it at all, I just don't think I could go to a concert for him because this was almost too much.
Aww, I recognize Burn On from Major League. I don't really know much of Randy Newman outside of Toy Story music and this was a fun listen. He has such a distinctive voice and style and he almost feels like your friend while listening. He's a great songwriter, and this was a nice blend of simple and soulful.
Enjoyable! high 3
You've got a middels rating in me. Helt grei vel.
just not in a randy newman mood sorry to say
Two stars: Sail Away feels like Randy Newman accidentally scored a seagull’s midlife crisis.
Me gusta su voz y el piano. Muy familiar suena, claramente gracias a las bandas sonoras, pero también a que es súper cálido. Me suena a Elton por momentos. Me gustó, no me mató, un poco aburrido por momentos, pero ha de ser el disco no el artista.
The third chapter of "Mister-Smarter-Than-Everybody-Else Stoops To Your Level To Show You How Much Of An Idiot You Are" has Newman setting his sights on slavery (wow, daring), industrial pollution (courageous!) and God-fearing folks (his takedown of apple pie must not have made the cut), all served with a thick topping of his patented sonic syrup. Newman loves them ol' traditional American musical forms, perhaps in an attempt make his semi-ironic critiques of America seem more so pointed. Clever idea *in theory* but the final product is pure hokum.
This album is gorgeous. Such a great take on taking string arrangements into a very classic way of making pop-rock. It sounds classy, but still delicious. And, maybe his voice is a bit difficult to adapt at first, but it matches so well the songs, having a kind of melancholic and raw feeling added to it too. There is also a very beautiful addition of a more jazzy, bluesy style, most at the end of the album, which takes it to a different stage without losing cohesion nor that dreamy aspect the songs transmit. So, I've loved it. It is not excellent, but everything is great in here, and it is also a very easy album to enjoy. It is wonderful.
Not really anything here that I latched on to and wanted to hear more of. His voice is an acquired taste and that's fine, but the songs themselves did not make me want to invest the required time to come around to Randy Newman
Some decent songs. It's very Randy Newman.
Randy Newman is close enough to being a novelty artist to make more than one of his albums unnecessary to this list. That said, this is the album that everyone should listen to. There is some excellent songwriting here. Too bad many of the songs sounded much better when performed by other artists. I'll deliver an extra half-star for "Burn On", an ode to my home town.
Absolute Randy. He's "edgy". This record contains some of the most problematic material that discusses interesting stuff but strays into bad taste at the least. That said, I love the record. He is such an engaging songwriter. This feels like a greatest hits almost, with a lot of his most famous and high quality writing. Then the production choices and delivery are absolutely to my tastes - very direct and low key, with just a sprinkle of nice studio elements to bring it to life.
i dont really have the nerves to listen to the whole album, but i see the point
Yeah, great. Smart, and very lovely, with two or three all-timers. Not quite as consistent as Good Old Boys maybe.
house divided: one of us thinks Newman is a supremely gifted composer and the other thinks he has basically been writing the same tune for 50 years. maybe we’re both right?
Breaking with personal convention a bit here. I generally ignore the lyrics for most of these albums--I'm mostly playing these while I'm working, and for most artists I can't make out all the lyrics even when giving the song my full attention anyway. I'll check out the lyrics on Spotify sometimes, though, and it was worth it for this album. I can't say I love the sound of his voice, but I appreciate the satire. The songs aren't good enough to get this past a 3 for me (I like piano rock, but there's nothing exceptional here), but the lyrics are good enough to keep it from dipping down to a 2 on account of the vocals. 3.2
This album has a super fun vibe Everybody in the reviews are right that this sounds like Disney music but I think that works in this albums favor Songs are good to start but get old after a few listens Favorites: Dayton Ohio, old man, political science 3.5 or 4/5
Didn't enjoy this one. Wholesome album, but so meh. I'm sorry
Considered giving this one a 5. The songwriting is really strong, and the times have maybe put me in the mood for this brand of bite. There are definitely more than a couple of 5-star tracks here (among them "Sail Away" and "Political Science"). My impressions of Randy Newman before this were "rambling man who's hijacked the piano and won't leave" and "well if it isn't Mr. Toy Story." Just wasn't familiar with his game; now I look forward to getting the follow-up album.
Od ovog čovjeka sam znala samo špicu za Monka i evo veseliju Cockerovu verziju Hat On. Od ovog mi se prispalo. Skoro sam i odspavala.
Eh. This was an album. The title track was weirdly patriotic to the states in a way that felt… iffy. Going into lonely at the top, it was solidly alright, I enjoyed He Gives Us all His Love more music wise. I didn’t love how overtly religious it was, but that’s just what I have to deal with occasionally. Last night I had a dream was really cool. I actually quite liked the way it came together. Old man was quite interesting. Political science was aight. Dayton Ohio had some moments I enjoyed. Let it shine had some nice music going for it. 3/5 ⭐️ 225/1089
let's stick to toy story love xx
A champion on the people.
I was utterly bored listening to this. Don't understand why it's on the list.
Simple yet sweet
Meh. It was alright. Not a big fan of his voice. I didn't hate it, but probably won't be returning.
All his songs sound the same
I did leave my hat on and I did love this album.
The writing was great. The music was superb. Not a big fan of his singing. 3.5 stars
The music itself is nice but the vocals ruined it for me!
Lite som filmmusik. Och You Can Leave Your Hat On. En bra skiva som får 3,5.
I can’t get past the voice.
No likey
I was not expecting Mr. "You've Got a Friend In Me" to be so dark. Well done to you good sir; you've won me over. This is some fantastic satire.
I can't help but think that doing the Toy Story soundtrack has ruined his music for a new audience. Maybe not his bank account, but I can't see anyone becoming a new fan without thinking this is a Disney soundtrack.
Not very notable but has some good tunes
Randy Newman is a great songwriter. And his voice has always been strangely comforting to me. I hadn’t heard this album before, although I knew some songs. Solid listen. 3.5/5
This is a record that I have owned for a number of years. I'm a bit fan of the earlier records by Newman and this is probably my favorite of these texts. Newman's satire is fairly entertaining and he can write a pretty good song as well. These are frequently satirical songs, but not really 'joke' songs. I also really enjoy the instrumental arrangements. Overall, there's a strong New Orleans influence throughout, drawing from both jazz and R&B. You can definitely hear a bit of a Louis Armstrong influence on the vocals as well.
Ok
Like if a fedora was made into an album
Randy Newman’s voice annoys me
no gracias
Wow this is dull. I listened two days ago and can’t remember a thing about it
Political Science is such a good song. Never a bad time with Randy. He just sounds like comfort. Maybe it's a Toy Story thing.
Randy Newman. 4
Randy Newman is a vaguely familiar name, though I can't say I'm all that familiar with him. When going off of the album cover I think it's relatively obvious that I've got another 70s rock album on my hands, which is a huge, massive bummer. For the first quarter of this list I couldn't stop bitching about all of the 60s pop rock albums that were clogging up the list. I'm now more than half of my way through the list and I'm still fucking pulling 70s rock albums (whereas the 60s rock nominations have mostly lulled). Honestly, I think the 70s might just be my least favourite music decade. Most of the frontrunner acts have a limited appeal with me and a lot of the music is just boring, rehashed singer-songwriter boolshite from the preceding decades. In any case, I shall enter this album with an open mind. Here goes. Eh, It's alright. Certainly very quaint, which is a style of music that I'm generally able to appreciate. I just don't think this style of music is able to go the distance - even across 30 minutes. Still, I didn't mind lumbering along with this album. The ragtime pianos are fun and complement the lightweight quality of Newman's voice. I generally favoured Newman's vocal performances on this album, though his strained delivery can be a little much at points. A lot of the songs pass by very quickly and the album falls into a bit of a long, vacuous slump by the time it reaches the end - both of which are things that annoy me. All in all, I was content to listen to this album passively, though there wasn't much in here that really grabbed my attention. Book time. Newman had penned a few hit songs for other bands before taking the center stage himself. This was Newman's breakthrough release after his previous albums were commercial failures. Quite politically charged. "Sail Away" is about the transatlantic slave trade whereas "Political Science" is about American foreign policy. Newman comes from a family of famous Hollywood film composers - a mantle he would later adopt himself. His most notable contributions to the film industry are the scores he wrote for the Toy Story films. Go figure - I thought his vocals were familiar. Wikipedia says this album features covers of some of the songs he had written for other artists. The handful of critic reviews for this album have been glowing, though it only charted in two countries, peaking at No. 163 in America and No. 42 in Australia. Hmm. One list album seems about right for Newman, though I can't help but notice that he has two in here. His other inclusion - "Good Old Boys" - appears to be the more celebrated and successful album, so I propose that we rip this shit outta heyah. In place of this album, I humbly submit "Ram" by Paul McCartney for inclusion on the list.
It wasn't bad, but I was honestly bored the whole time. I know he's an icon, but I couldn't keep my attention on this.
Meh...
I'm not a fan of Randy Newman's voice. I do think a lot of his songs are clever and that he is a good lyricist. I had heard the song You Can Leave Your Hat On before, but I didn't know any other songs on this album.
It's tough to hate on. He's not the best vocalist for sure, but I found myself enjoying alot of this. I'll have to go back and listen to his other entry on this list again.
Love the politics of Newman for the most part. The music ain’t half bad either.
Day933 - listening to this i thought it would make a great stand-up bit or a david sedaris type of satire book. the lyrics are so good and then he has the classic “you can leave your hat on” that joe cocker made famous
Great songwriter but average delivery.
It's a little batter than Don McLean - American Pie but still quite boring
I know people are having a go for saying it's a Toy Story album, but it is extremely hard to get rid of the feeling for the first few songs. Tune in though and this is a nice album. Nothing spectacular, decent.
The context and baggage with this one made it hard to give this a pure, nonjudgmental listen. Randy Newman is another instance of a white guy intentionally sounding a little too much like a black guy to just ignore it. He’s also impossible to extrapolate from his role as the Toy Story guy now. Like, “Lonely at the Top” is a solid song, but it seems like something that was lifted from Tom Waits, then rinsed until there’s no sign of grit or character. There is one huge praise I can give this album: it’s method for examining American culture! “Political Science” is the obvious one, riding that line where it can be read as a third-person criticism as much as a red-blooded patriot could lovingly take it at face value - especially when it’s followed up by the even more sweet-sounding “Burn On”. Lastly, “Dayton Ohio” has a little melody that got lifted by John Mayer many years later on his “You’re Gonna Live Forever In Me” song. Both very Disney-friendly. This would be a true 5/10 in a better scoring system. It does some things really well and falls short in other categories.
Interesting concept with decent songs
Not for me thanks
Álbum de um jazz cinematográfico com cara de trilhas sonoras. Muito agradável. Vocal cativante. GK Kunten.
This is so goofy. No wonder he ended up doing music for children's movies.
Sail away - 4 Lonely at the top - 4 He gives us all his love - 3 Last night i had a dream - 4 Simon smith and the amazing dancing bear - 3 Old man - 3 Political science - 4 Burn on - 4 Memo to my son - 4 Dayton, ohio - 1903 - 3 You can leave your hat on - 3 God's song (that's why i love mankind) - 3
Bonne découverte
Sympatoche cute quoi
Randy Newman and his lovely lilting melodies remains an underrated songwriter.
I dug it.
1. "Sail Away" 2. "Lonely at the Top" 3. "God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)" and of course "Political Science"
6/10
I enjoyed how earnest his tracks all felt. Not my favorite but still a good listen
The guy from Toy Story. And it all sounds similar. What's the genre? Blue-eyed soul (Last Night I Had a Dream)? Bit of blues too? Rag/ragtime influence too (Simon Smith) God's Song is a hard hitter lyrically. Not pulling any punches It's all just fine. Nothing blows me away Best track - Sail Away 3 stars
Some of the songs are good, but I don’t like his voice or the overall instrumentation of the album - sounds more like show tunes than rock or folk or jazz.
Listens: 2 Standout Tracks: None This album felt like a single 41 minute long song. The album was devoid of basically anything that could be considered "variation". The same lilting piano every track, the same pitch and tone in Randy's voice. The only shred of anything even remotely different came in the last 20 seconds of Sail Away - some sort of random drum beat and cowbell jingle. Why? Who knows. Probably not randy.
So yeah I’m familiar with Randy. I know Short People and I Love LA and, of course, Toy Story. But never heard more than that that I’m aware of. So here we go… Three songs in and very strong thumbs up so far. Love the music and love the lyrics even more.
The same cartoony voice, recording boring covers on a piano. 2/5
Feel-good på ett rätt irriterande sätt
Nja alltså, kändes genomgående osympatiskt.
Halvtrist tyvärr.
Orchestral pop.
This is the first time I've listened to a full Randy Newman album. Having grown up in LA, "I Love LA" is inescapable. I knew he did music before Disney as well, and I do not immediately think of Disney when I hear him. He's definitely an American Songbook singer-songwriter; kind of like Harry Nilsson (I love). There were some clever lyrics and good musicianship on this album; overall he's a strong songwriter (which is why Disney hired him). I don't imagine I'd revisit this album, as it's not really my jam, but it's not bad and has decent variety and thought-provoking lyrics. I'd listen to it over some of the other stuff I have been barely able to tolerate (or outright hate) on this questionable list. I kind of want to give it a 2; it's really between a 2 and a 3 for me.
Never listened to Randy before initially I was like damn this sounds like something from a Pixar movie then I read more about him and it seems he did become the sound of Disney and it's pretty obvious once you know even though this album came out before his pivot to Disney he had that sound before that I didn't mind the album it was quite a enjoyable listen even if it's not my type of music
It was good!
zaglupljeni dylan
Eh, love the guy but this did nothing for me. Bummer
Couple of good songs. Overall mid
Good enough not great.
Newman has a particular sort of charm that 5 year old me loved, both in his work on Toy Story and his sillier songs. That being said. I can't fathom wanting to sit down and listen to an hour of Randy Newman deep cuts 2/5
Cabaret Costello sings New Yorker cartoons
Randy Newman is a songwriter above anything else. He's one of those artists that can write amazing songs for anybody, but probably isn't the best person to perform them himself. This album is no exception. Several songs on it that I knew, but from the versions other artists did of them and not Newman himself. Definitely some classic songs here and fun to listen to on a Saturday morning.
Goofy ahh voice.
I can't hear him without hearing "You've got a friend in me" and it's pretty distracting. I'm not a huge fan of his voice and this album just isn't for me.
Not my favorite RN album on here, but still good!
Brilliant and Funny. Ohio and leave your hat on were perfect
Some good song but Randy Newman just not really my type of song.
Nee sorry. Disney muziek
4+
I mean this guy's voice is inseparable from Toy Story. This is just ok though.
He is so goofy but the songwriting is great
Very stripped back compared to the other RN we had and didn't find it worked very well for his voice, he needs a jaunty tune. This didn't really hold my interest, though it was largely inoffensive.
I wanted to like it a lot more than I did. Fantastic songwriter, my favourite level of maudlin, but his voice gets old after a while and I found the structure and musicianship very pedestrian.
Was initially thinking this might not be so bad, but I'd had enough surprisingly quickly. His voice is so suffocating and tiring and the subject matter is so twee. Nah, 1
I just can't get away from toy story with Randy Newman.
Unexpectedly shocked by this one. I've been getting a lot of albums I've note heard lately and, while being a fan of Randy Newman, I had never heard this one. It feels like a perfect distillation of his singer/songwriter chops. Aspects of new orleans jazz, classic american ballads, blues, rock, old ragtime inspired/circus sounding music (looking at you simon smith and the dancing bear). Just a great listen.
5/10
It was like the soundtrack to a boring movie I never wanted to see. 2/5
Randy Newman is hard to review. Parts seem profound, parts seem like a simpleton. I feel like if he was a minstrel at the end of the world recounting everything that would probably make sense.
Randy Newman plays a style of music with deep American roots He cooks a lot with the same couple of ingredients. An example like this belongs on this list, he just doesn't do much for me.
Having enjoyed Good Old Boys more than I expected, I thought I’d probably found Randy Newman. Instead, Sail Away showed me something different. Rather than one sustained moral landscape, this is a gallery of self-contained dramas. Every song introduces a new speaker, a new world and a new way of persuading you to believe something. That word, persuasion, became my way into the album. Almost every song features someone trying to sell a version of reality. The slave trader in the title track sells America as freedom while quietly omitting the chains. The celebrity in Lonely at the Top turns isolation into proof of superiority. The politician in Political Science mistakes grievance for foreign policy. The nostalgic in Dayton, Ohio - 1903 quietly edits the ugliness out of the past so the present has something to complain about. Even the lover in You Can Leave Your Hat On repeatedly insists that he knows what love is, which I found surprisingly unsettling once I stripped away the Joe Cocker baggage. The biggest revelation, though, was Newman the arranger. I’d always thought of him as a brilliant lyricist who happened to write good tunes. This album made me realise the arrangements are carrying half the dramatic weight. The repeated piano ostinato in Sail Away fascinated me. Newman could easily have written a conventional accompaniment. Instead, beneath “In America every man is free”, he places an insistent repeated figure that never quite lets the listener settle. It isn’t harmonically disruptive. It simply nags. He even leaves it repeating after the vocal has faded. Burn On opens with another ostinato, joined by a brass note that’s only gently discordant, allowing unease to develop without ever announcing itself. The arrangements don’t simply support the songs. They quietly argue with them. What gradually emerged was an album about the stories people tell themselves in order to live with the world. A burning river becomes civic folklore. Simon Smith’s companionship with his dancing bear becomes much harder to accept once you remember the bear isn’t there willingly. Memo to My Son is almost comically empty. The title promises distilled wisdom. The song offers little beyond, “I love you. Now along you go.” It ends up saying something unexpectedly profound: none of us really have a clue. Old Man strips away almost all of Newman’s theatrical machinery. I found myself hearing it simply as an acceptance that death comes when we eventually lose the energy to say “not yet”. No grand metaphysics. Just quiet recognition. Then Newman finishes by pulling the rug away entirely. God’s Song doesn’t read to me as a simple attack on religion. Instead it imagines a God looking at humanity almost with bemusement: look at all this suffering, and you still love me. “That’s why I love mankind” becomes less an expression of compassion than an acknowledgement that humanity continues to need God regardless of the evidence. It is a profoundly unequal relationship. What impressed me most was Newman’s economy. He wastes almost nothing. He sketches characters in a handful of lines, trusts the arrangements to carry much of the argument, and almost never explains himself. These songs don’t feel like essays with melodies attached. They feel like tiny pieces of musical theatre, each one presenting a different way in which human beings persuade themselves that the world makes sense.
Simple piano melodies with Randy's iconic voice. Very similar to Good Old Boys, which I had 3 months ago. Maybe that's not long enough because I didn't enjoy this as much. I've previously heard covers of You Can Leave Your Hat On, so it's interesting to see how everyone else turned it into a sexy song when the original sounds really goofy and tongue in cheek. Sail Away isn't too bad either.
Initially I wasn't quite sure if these texts were serious or satire. I've tipped over to believing that they have to be satire. Randy sings well and the lyrics are interesting enough to make you think a bit, but probably not enough for me to return to them in the future Standouts Sail Away Political Science You Can Leave Your Hat On 3/5
Randy Newman is always intelligent and enjoyable
This is my first 5 star album rated not on how good it sounds but on the message and theme of the album. The speaker sings about societal issues such as aggressive nationalism, racism, and in my opinion, religion. He paints the picture in such a satirical tone that I mistook it for praise of these issues rather than the opposite, critique. If I didn't seek to understand what he truly meant I would've missed the entire message and that goes to show how skilled he is at his art. I'm not rating this a 5 for how good it sounded to me or the melodies, but for the overall message and how well it was passed. Fantastic.
An all timer.
Не знаю хто це. Не виглядає цікаво. Коротше він відомий своїми сатиричними текстами, що для мене, не англомовної людини представляє невелику цінність. В загальному не моє. Навіть не дослухав.
he's a good man
Before starting this album, I was not a fan of Randy Newman. He has a couple songs I like, but overall I was not a fan. After listening to this album, my stance has not changed. He sucks. His lyrics are laughably stupid. The musical accompaniment is competent but simplistic. And did he seriously have a song basically calling for the US to destroy the rest of the world? Family Guy didn’t lampoon him nearly hard enough.
Annoying voice, mediocre piano playing, and shit lyrics. Terrible album that doesn't belong on a list like this. His best work is actually his soundtrack work, particularly from "The Natural", where he doesn't sing and doesn't sound like himself.
Loved this, close to a 5
Actually, I should be a huge Randy Newman fan. I like talented singer-songwriters who write powerful lyrics exploring the darker sides of life. I appreciate self-deprecation and sarcasm as forms of criticism. Yet there's something about Randy Newman's music that just doesn't resonate with me. It could be his brittle singing style, even though I have no problem with so-called 'ugly' voices. It could be his deeply American perspective on the world — bitter and critical, certainly, but thoroughly American — or it could be something else entirely. Even though I find most of the songs brilliant, the album just washes over me. Sorry, Randy.
It took me a while to realize all the religious songs and references were not in adoration, but in criticism. And when that clicked, and I learned Randy Newman was an atheist, this pleasant album revealed itself to be way ahead of its time. The title-track that opens the record is bitter and depressing, and the closer is probably the boldest criticism of religiosity that I ever witnessed (definitely check out Etta James' cover if you like this). But my favorite song of them all might be 'Old Man', a sobering, morbid tune that closes out the first side of the LP.
Instantly realised that Randy Newman sings you’ve got a friend in me from Toy Story. Not my favourite songs would give it like a 2.5 if I could.
An amazing album. Randy Newman deserved more recognition for his wit and how well he fits it over blues forms.
God damn have I been sleeping on Randy Newman??? This is really great. Randy really hits on everything in this album - love, ennui, both the light and dark sides of faith, and serious political malaise. All with his iconic voice and piano playing. This is already a solid 8/10 for me, and I feel like it could rise more on repeated listens.
Randy Newman - good for Toy Story soundtrack, bad for full length album. I did not need to hear this before I die. I was also baffled to learn he has not one but TWO albums on this list.
He definitely has an unique singing voice, for those who are into that. Honestly this didn't do anything for me. Supremely indifferent.
I think Randy Newman is at his best when he's doing biting social commentary. There were a few songs on here that felt like throwaways to me, but I really enjoyed the tracks like Sail Away and Political Science.
No real opinions here.
Harmless and vaguely listenable but it feels like there's some actual rock and roll in there somewhere dying to be let out.
Contains You Can Leave Your Hat On, which is one of the worst songs ever written (and turns out the original is even worse than the Tom Jones cover). The rest was bland but inoffensive.
Now forever linked with Pixar. Nice enough though
Quite pleasant to listen to, though the expanded edition contains two versions of You Can Leave Your Hat On, which is frankly unnecessary
Fantastic, a great LP, thanks for sharing RGP. Four stars❤️❤️❤️❤️ Tom.
expected more thats on me
This is probably my favorite of the Randy Newman’s. Back in ‘006(?) we saw Randy with the CSO and many of these songs were played that night. The thing I appreciate and annoys me about him is you really have to listen to the lyrics. You never know what is going to come out. You Can Leave You Hat On is a classic song. I love how the Joe Cocker version is major cords and upbeat, but Newman’s original is minor cords and musically dirty. It’s like Cocker’s was talking to a hot girlfriend (definitely not a married man, in which case the lyric would be “I will leave the sweatpants and hoodie on”), whereas Newman’s is to a prostitute. Political Science seems rather relevant today. Matter of fact, I think it might be the USA’s current foreign policy directive. My favorite track this time was He Give Us All His Love. I don’t know if I would say this religious as much as spiritual, but there was a certain sense of hope and grace portrayed in the song that resonated today. Final thought: Randy Newman is an oddity insofar as his music is elegant, yet raw; focused yet random; expected yet shocking. I think he and Alice Cooper may have been the precursors to Eminem.
Random thoughts: * Randy Newman exists in a weird space for me. He’s kind of always been there but I also can’t really fathom a time that his music was popular and played on radio. Maybe because he was never on MTV. Maybe because his music really doesn’t exist in a time period of production and sound. He’s timeless is the most literal way. * Also, his songs are full of irony. So they don’t play out in any traditional patterns of pop music. * All that being said, I’m glad to be exposed to Randy Newman beyond Toy Story (Friend in Me) and I Love LA. * the first song (Sail Away) is big time irony, maybe too much. Damn son. * What?!! He’s the OG leave your hat on?!? I was today years old when I found this out. * Nice listen! I won’t mind coming back to some more Randy Newman. I’ll probably have to read the lyrics and then Google to understand all the points he’s making. But when I’m in a curious mood, this is intellectually stimulating.
This man is one helluva songwriter. Wild seeing some of the reviews, but this made me enjoy his music even more. Good stuff!
I dunno, it just seems like with these old albums people liked such boring music. It wasn't offensive, but so meh.
This is a pretty chill album and also pretty much what a Randy Newman album would normally sound like. Nothing too exciting, but I know that the chill audience out there enjoys it.
I loved the atheistic and activist tones of this album. All packaged under a folksy guise meant to lull you in.
I love this album and it is perfect
Didn’t love. Randy is a pretty good pianist and a decent songwriter- the lyrics are at times funny and sad, and tongue in cheek like a song about the burning cuyahoga river in Cleveland lol. It’s a bit of a slog though, just not really interesting. Sounds like atmospheric BG music from a movie. Something you’d hear on a radio in a movie in a scene with dialogue. ⭐️.5
- 5 for "You Can Leave Your Hat On" ........ -
2/3
Rv
Never listnened to the chap before. Super distinctive voice which I personally like. Album is good but nothing outstanding, You Can Leave Your Hat On is the only song that really makes an impression. 6/10
A good album, I liked Lonely At The Top, Simon Smith and The Amazing Dancing Bear and Political Science the most.
Everything this guy does sounds like Toy Story now. This is the album that saved Brian Wilson's life, so it can't be all bad. I can't get away from the goofiness of his lyrics, I guess that kind of hit you over the head storytelling works for some people as a break from all the symbolism and "does it really mean anything" lyrics from someone like Dylan, but it just comes across as a joke to me. It is actually amazing that Disney never had him do a soundtrack until Toy Story. And then he did half of them for the next two decades. Burn On is a funny song about Cleveland, those poor water burning bastards. Dayton, Ohio - 1903 feels like an admission. His version of You Can Leave Your Hat On isn't the best, I like Joe Cocker's and Tom Jones' better, but he wrote and and it is a great song.
neat
good! every song sounded like “you got a friend in me” but wasn’t that. a peaceful listen
Unlike Colton, I did not listen to the lyrics intently. His voice does really remind me of Toy Story as well. I just can't see him popping off in 2026. No doubt he's talented and a different kind of voice and vibe. Which I think is a little sad that now there are formulas and algorithms to get the most out of musicians and thus people try not to be experimental or go off on weird voices like this. But with all that. I still rate this a 2.
I love me some Randy Newman… but in small doses 😂. I feel like if I listened to a song a day it would be higher… but going 3.0
I did a spit-take listening to “Political Science.” Just drop the big one! 😅🫠🙈 But the one that really left me thinking was “God’s Song.” Is he writing against organized religion, or all religion? But then there’s “He Gives Us All His Love” as a counterpoint. I don’t know what to think. (And yes, I know it’s unfair that I actually listened to the lyrics on this one and keep giving Dylan shit ratings. I’m a shitty music critic.) Randy Newman is so inextricably linked with Toy Story in my mind that I had a hard time listening to this objectively. I don’t think I’ve ever heard any of his other songs! But this was short, punchy, satirical, and relatively interesting. The writing really shines. A couple of the songs genuinely rocked, too (“Last Night I Had a Dream” was a surprise). Musically, it’s not my favorite. “Political Science” and “God’s Song” carry it to 4 stars for me. 8/10 Most Excellent
Shoot boring my god.
Superb writing and lovely instrumentals, really a great listen. Unfortunately though, his voice just reminds me of that bit from Family Guy where Randy is singing about what's happening after a nuclear apocalypse, and that kept playing in my head when I was trying to listen. "And she picks an apple from the tree. Chews once. Twice. Three times... Left foot, right foot, left foot, right foot..."
No standouts
Pretty horrible to be honest. I was very disappointed to see this cuz i hate this guy's voice and mannerisms. But I was willing to listen. People citing the satire and lyrics, but im sorry thats not enough. The instrumentation is weak and delivery is lackluster
sorry nej.. som ett långt skämt
Tom Waits on librium
Another one from Mr. Newman. Not my favorite thing to listen to, but he’s definitely got something there. Kind of like Tom Waits for normies.
Hokey AF
Music-hall tunes, several of which actually were performed by Muppets. Not really my jam.
A Randy Newman album is a surprise, although it shouldn’t be since he’s been in the music business a long time. I haven’t heard from him in a while; seems like he’s more into making movie music recently. The music here feels like a Broadway show or something from vaudeville. The lyrics are classic Randy Newman though.
Pretty sure I've never listened to a non-Toy Story Randy Newman song. (Until now.) This had the effect of making the album feel like a Toy Story soundtrack. Was not expecting a paean to Cleveland ('Burn On') in this Toy Story movie. Why are there multiple songs about Ohio? Randy's from LA. This is like CCR's bayou stuff all over again. I fear it is not for me. Highlight: 'Memo to My Son'
I can't imagine a time where I'd be in the mood for this
Another Randy Newman album? Maybe this one is less racist. I see the Disney resemblance. Singer songwriter albums rarely get more than 3* from me. This is ok, but not something I'd revisit. 2* The cover of "you can leave your hat on" gave me the creeps, it's like your creepy drunk uncle doing a karaoke rendition.
Did not listen. Could not bear his voice for more than 35 seconds. Shudder.
Favorite track(s): Sail Away, Old Man, Political Science, Burn On, God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)
He doesn't have a great voice, and there are probably too many songs with too many strings in them, but I enjoyed this a lot more than I expected to thanks to some great lyrics and Newman's distinctive and sad gravel. My favorites were the title track (although I had to re-listen to it after reading about the album--I didn't get the slave trade connection the first time around (and apparently a number of people who did covers of this tune never understood that this is *not* a patriotic song about how great it is to be an American, sort of like Reagan (purposefully?) misunderstanding "Born in the USA")), "He gives us all his love", "Old man", and the OG version of "You can leave your hat on". Best of all, there's no tragic story of how Newman died soon after, or was never able to make a living writing songs that other people made famous (especially since he was a prolific movie composer).
I really don't like Newman's vocal style but his songwriting skills are amazing.
I liked it. Not my go to choice of music but thoughtful written songs, good arrangements, and enjoyable.
17 songs Can't say there is any song I'd choose to listen to again, but it wasn't a bad listening experience honestly. I'd say that the lyrics are the highlight overall, Randy seems to have one of those voices that can be very polarizing, but fortunately it didn't bother me.
Whenever I hear Randy Newman, I can't help but picture a montage of Woody and Buzz being friends. Doesn't matter what track I'm listening to. The music is not quite schmaltzy as a Hallmark Store, but it's in that direction. Kind of a low 3 for me.
I feel like the German language should have a word that translates to "that activity that is probably fine, because others seem to enjoy it, but leaves me wishing I was doing pretty much anything else" ...so then I could apply it to listening to Randy Newman.
Apparently one of these songs got recycled for a Nutrasweet commercial and that pretty much nails it - this mostly sounds like jingles for cutesy ads about insaurance or AARP...or Cleveland, I guess. It's fine, but nothing you go out of your way to listen to.
paso esta lista es una putisima mierda
Didn't expect Randy Newman on this list. I always thought of him as a gimmick. Honestly this isn't very good. His voice is below average, and others do his songs better. So I guess he can write, he just can't sing that well. 2.
Randy Newman is sweet but niche
Snooze fest!
A peor cada canción
It was ok at best. It just sounded like a Toy Story soundtrack. There's nothing jarring or awful about any of the tracks. They're just boring.
lovely
Not for me. 1/5
Whatabanger!
great! just crazy when you have such a songwriting machine like this
Album #108, Sail Away — Randy Newman ⭐⭐⭐ I’ve never really listened to Randy Newman. He always struck me as an artist that I would really like, but having listened to this, I’m not 100% sure anymore. The main reason is that I just don’t really care for this kind of piano-led, cabaret, drunken late-night-at-the-jazz-club style of music. It’s more the music than anything else. I think he’s a really unique vocalist and I think his lyrics are great. There’s a tone to unpack with them. But I just don’t care for some this style. It’s There is also some movie soundtrack-type songs, which I don’t like either. The more straightforward songs like the title track and Burn On are great. I also never knew that he wrote You Can Leave Your Hat On until today, and I was really pleasantly surprised when that came on. It’s also a much more sinister song than I realised. My favourite track was probably the painfully relevant Political Science, which I thought was brilliant. So yeah, it’s more the music than anything else holding me back here. I’m not a fan of Billy Joel, and while this has way more substance than Billy Joel to me, the sound of it sometimes veers a little too close in that direction. That’s probably a massive insult to Randy Newman, but it’s just the comparison my brain keeps making. So overall, I think it’s a great album, but it’s not really an album for me. A strong three stars.
Nothing stood out to me until I got to "last night I had a dream". It was a cool bluesy rock song but no idea what it was about.
c'était cool mais il faudrait que je réécoute parce que j'en ai pas assez profité
5/28/26. Decent record, sounded like piano bar tunes with some added orchestral elements. I do enjoy Newman’s voice and wit.
An iconic voice and an amazing songwriter. There's a reason Randy's catalog has been mined by the film industry, it has a nostalgic warmth to it that, if your heart isn't completely iced over, will draw you in and put a smile on your face.
I have had an affinity for Randy Newman for some time, but don’t listen to him very often…one dose will last me a while. I knew a few of these songs, but hadn’t listened to the whole album before. Well, I loved it! I love the melodies, the instrumentations, and his sharp witty lyrics. Even his voice, which is odd to say the least, works with these songs. I swear, when I listen to Political Science (which was written during the Nixon era), it’s like he predicted Trump’s rise to power all those years ago…Incredibly relevant today. I can see that I’m in the minority here, but I am giving it five stars.
Sail Away by Randy Newman left me a little conflicted. I still can’t quite work out whether I really like Randy Newman or find him slightly irritating, but overall I did enjoy listening to this album. Musically and lyrically, the album is very strong. The songwriting is clever, the arrangements are excellent and there’s a lot of personality throughout. Newman clearly has a unique style and way of telling stories that stands out from most singer-songwriters. My biggest issue is that I can’t separate his voice and style from Disney soundtracks. Every song feels like it could appear in a Pixar or Disney film somewhere, which occasionally makes it difficult for me to fully take the album seriously. That said, there’s still plenty here to appreciate and the quality of the songwriting carries it through. Favourite track: “Sail Away” is a brilliant song Least favourite track: Everything here was worth listening to Album artwork: Wonderful hair
Well written well sung 70s tunes. His voice was immediately recognizable as a GenXer.
the you got a friend in me guy :0 het is prima.. beetje saai..
goofy man
Descontraído, de certo modo reconfortante. As letras são interessantes, mas a sonoridade é morna demais pro meu gosto. Achei tudo muito monótono, e dessa forma o disco acaba ficando entediante. Mas não é ruim, achei ele legal pelo que é. 3/5
https://youtu.be/bPagzl4EQ4Q?si=xQt6XdVn7DFnsIO4
Svårt att ta på allvar då hans röst är synonym med Pixar. Men detta är väl ganska bra.
Ganska bra, svag fyra
Vacklade mellan mysighet och gubbtråkdöden. Landar nog i en svag trea.
Som en varm kram.
Lyssnade en del på Randy under tiden då jag var som mest känslig. Lyckades ändå sätta på fel album och lyssna nästan halvvägs innan jag insåg mitt misstag. Det var ändå fett lugnt efter som Randy är KUNG och hans domän är sorglig satir.
musik som låter bra men som jag inte nås av
Roligt och härligt
Such satire. Perfection. If you're not really listening and hearing, it sounds like a Disney soundtrack. Old Man made me tear up ..thanks for that. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Fat man with and his kids and dog Drove in through the morning fog. Hey there, Rover. Come on over. Red headed lady reaching for an apple. Gonna take a bite -- nope, nope. She gonna breathe on it first, wipe it on her blouse. She takes a bite. Chews it once, twice, three times, four times. Stops! Saliva workin', takes a hard long look at Randy... Five times. Fat old husband walking over. Yeah, They're walking down the road Left foot, right foot Left foot, right foot Left foot -- Family Guy jokes aside, there's some good instrumentation here. I didn't realize Joe Cocker's You Can Leave Your Hat On was a cover.
I've never really understood the lionization of Randy Newman. It probably doesn't help that my introduction to him and all I knew about him for several years as a child/adolescent was the "I Love L.A." video, which I still find cheesy and corny. And then I mainly encountered him in the scores and soundtracks of animated films, which is what I still associate him with. So perhaps if I had been around when the generation before me got acquainted with him, I would view him completely differently. I have no problem with him. His lyrics are definitely clever. I just never saw what the big deal was. This album didn't change my opinion much. "Political Science" was probably funny in its day but now it's just depressing. Hearing the opening credits song from Major League ("Burn On") was nice.
Eh, it was fine. I didn't dislike it. But tbh I don't really see what the big deal is about Randy Newman. It was fine unobjectionable background music. If the album was much longer, or if the individual songs were much longer, I might give it a lower rating.
Not sail away sail away sail away but it's the you got a friend in me guy three stars
Before he did every Pixar soundtrack that's ever been concepted, Randy Newman was the token singer-songwriter "funny voice guy" of the late 60s/70s, pre Weird Al. Not all of his songs were necessarily funny nor had some Tom Waits voice strangeness to it, it's in the Steely Dan way of irony and unreliable narrator storytelling. It's nice and clever stuff, but it's not beating out Warren Zevon to me. Unfortunately my ears are, for the most part, very bad at picking up following along with words in music. Not saying anything on this album is bad, because it is my kind of songwriting, but I like it when Zappa does this kind of stuff because there's a lot of interesting stuff going on in his albums with regard to instrument virtuosity and wild rhythms. Nothing against Newman's musicality or anything, it's just what perks up my ears more. It's got that 1970s styled pre punk production kind of staleness to it like a reused 60 year old high school science textbook. This is a real gem for those that like to follow along and enjoy those classic 1970s singer-songwriters that seem to have been pumping out of record labels like rabbits. This is one of Newman's classic albums, but not exactly my favorite. The second side is much much better than the first side.
This is a solid, well-crafted album. No bad songs at all, but also not overflowing with those “wow” moments either. It’s just a consistently decent and respectable piece of work. What I really liked about Sail Away is that every single song feels like its own little short story. Randy Newman is such a sharp storyteller — each track has its own world, character, and point of view. Some are funny, some are sad, some are sarcastic, and some are surprisingly tender. You can tell he put real thought into the narratives, and it makes the album interesting to explore from beginning to end. His piano playing and distinctive voice carry the whole thing, and the arrangements are tasteful without being flashy. Standouts for me were the title track “Sail Away,” “Lonely at the Top,” “He Gives Us All His Love,” and “Political Science.” It’s not his flashiest or most beloved record, but it’s a very good Randy Newman album. If you enjoy smart, storytelling-driven songwriting with a cynical but sometimes warm heart, this one delivers nicely.
Eu precisaria me encontrar em um momento frágil para deixar essas canções penetrarem meu peito. Felizmente, ando pra cima e portanto incapaz de apreciar esse álbum do jeito certo. Algumas coisas são assim e não dá pra ser de outro jeito.
2.4 2x nothing wrong but not my thing
After about six songs, I was done. Felt like I was listening to the soundtrack for a kids' show or Disney movie. (Not exactly the "get up and go" tunes I prefer in the morning.)
Ah yes. Randy Newman. I fall firmly in the camp of this guy is great, I wish he wasn't the one singing. A song like You Can Leave Your Hat On is totally undermined by hearing it from a muppet. I think the Family Guy send up of Randy Newman S02E03 is about as accurate a portrayal as there is and it lives rent free in my head.
I'm sorry, Randy. You write great lyrics - they sound deceptively simple, but they've frequently got a lot going on underneath (see "Sail Away"). But I can't hear your voice, with its sort of mopey, understated delivery, without thinking of a decade or more of Disney/Pixar soundtracks (not to mention a great series of parodies of them by Paul and Storm). You write some great songs, but I'd rather hear Joe Cocker or Harry Nilsson, or frankly just about anyone else, sing them.
This left very little impact on me, not to say it it was bad though. I liked the sting parts and other arrangements, but overall, I already forgot this album after only listening to it 4 hours ago. Mid 3.
I didn't realize it until I read the Wikipedia, but he also sang You've Got a Friend in Me from Toy Story. So that's pretty cool. As far as this album goes, it didn't make me feel one way or the other.
Enjoyable. Was looking for reasons to rate it higher, and "Maybe I'm Doing It Wrong" got close, but not enough.
Every song is mercifully short, but really has Randy Newman‘s style. It all kind of sounds like whimsical or philosophical Toy story songs. And not all of them are catchy but again they’re short, which is nice.
Mér finnst hann notalegur, skemmtilegur og beittur. En Simon Smith and his amazing dancing bear er þó betra í flutningi Prúðuleikaranna.
Reminds me of the Toy Story soundtrack, considering he's also the one who made "You've Got A Friend In Me". It's also giving early Elton John.
Randy has a great voice, but I can't listen to these songs for very long.
Some fun sounding piano ditty’s that all sound very Randy Newman, some nice songs but nothing that stood out
Funny how I went from. 'This guy sings like Donald Trump speaks', to 'Hey wait, this voice is familiar...' to 'It's the Toy Story guy!' His voice might be grating to some but I really dig his solo work now, respect.
It's highly regarded, and I don't know why. Even the hit, Leave your hat on, doesn't hit - Cocker's version is much better. Sold many years ago.
I liked the overall vibes of this album
Yeah, they're walkin' down the road Left foot, right foot, left foot, right foot, left... [Apple hits Randy in the head]
pretty nice
Decent rock for a guy who is best known for his Disney soundtrack additions. Not groundbreaking, but certainly enjoyable to listen to. 3.
I love Randy Newman what can I say
Toy Story guy sings songs about America, Jesus, and his son. If he sang about other topics this would be a higher score but these days I’m not very fond of America or religion
Would it be inaccurate to call this Kidz Bop Tom Waits?
Yuck. I'm just not a Randy Newman guy I guess
Today's album is from Randy Newman, who is most famous for his Pixar soundtracks for the likes of Toy Story and Monsters inc. And right the way through this album you can hear the same bright, shimmering piano and melodies. I couldn't quite disassociate from the Pixar connection, and for me it did feel like listening to a whole movie soundtrack. It's fine - if a little sickly sweet at points. Favourites: Last Night I Had A Dream You Can Leave Your Hat On
Low 3 high 2. It's randy Newman. Got exactly what I expected
Not sure how he got a second album on here. This was fine, but nothing that felt special about it.
Randy Newman is a great songwriter, but his performance is limited in scope. The Ragtime soundtrack is perfect for his talents. But I don't care for him in casual listening. Still, his influence can't be denied.
A bit too MOR for me.
I mean it's not bad but it's not outstanding either, I'm not sure how this is in this ranking. And yes I agree it feels like Disney songs (because he made them) so not the best pieces of music ever. I was working while listening and compeletely forgot the music was on, which I feel is telling. Cover : Kind of boring, nice color
He's got a nice voice. My thing is, how am I supposed to listen to this and not immediately think I'm in a Toy Story movie? Favorite track: Last Night I Had A Dream
Listen. I love the song "I Love LA" and all its absurdity, but that being said, Randy Newman songs sound like the music and lyrics are being written off the top of his head and recorded in 1 take. And that is not a compliment.
Very sardonic and sarcastic (and political) album. I do like the slightly jazzy affectation on some of these songs. I'd say this is Randy Newman's best, at least from the ones I've heard. Probably sacrilegious of me to say, but I prefer Father John Misty's more modern and less political take on this type of sardonic singer-songwriter character. Also Joe Cocker's version of "You Can Leave Your Hat On" from the 80's may not have the satirical charm of this original, but more than makes up for in terms of how ridiculous it is (and those horns, too). Key tracks: Sail Away Lonely at the Top Old Man You Can Leave Your Hat On
Randy Newman is a talented singer songwriter whose composition and performance style is entirely suited to providing the sound track for films like Toy Story. It's not music to sit and listen to really. He uses a narrative approach for most of these tracks and it's an approach more suited to a stage musical or movie soundtrack.
Some other folks might be a little bit better at songwriting than he is. Bigger and stronger too, maybe. But none of them will ever write a theme to Toy Story the way he does. Just him and his piano, boy.