Sail Away by Randy Newman

Sail Away

Randy Newman

2.96
Rating
23584
Votes
1
7%
2
24%
3
41%
4
21%
5
7%
Distribution

Reviews (page 4 of 8)

- Instant Toy Story nostalgia - Last Night I Had A Dream a lively vibe change - You Can Leave Your Hat On the first I recognised, though more familiar with the covers (Tom Jones) - Overall: nice easy listening, iconic voice

Honestly, it seems a little odd that there would be a Randy Newman album on this list. Not that he's bad, but I don't think he's particularly remarkable, other than for his work on Disney/Pixar soundtracks. It's not that it's bad. It's a pretty enjoyable album. If you're familiar with Newman, it's exactly what you think it would be. Piano heavy, but lots of other instrumentation. His unique voice carrying the melody of every song. Occasional great lyrics with a little bit of whimsy. It's not a great album, but it's definitely good. All of the songs do end up blending together quite a bit though. Favorite Song(s): Sail Away, Old Man

Started strong ended in nap time music

It started off with a really strong four songs, then went completely off the rails. Is this the score to a musical? 1.3 outta 5

Nope. His voice is irritating, I can't hear anything but Toy Story, and the Jesus stuff is not my thing.

To be honest, it is boring. 1

Sail Away from me Randy Newman. Your mealy-mouthed character studies do nothing for me. Tinkle forth on your piano to someone that will enjoy it more than me.. Oh hey, it's the song from Major League. That one is okay.

Never really new Randy Newman other than his songs featured in soundtracks or I love LA which is played when the Dodgers win. This album was good and reminded me of listening to the Toy Story soundtrack, but in a good way.

Actually enjoyed this for what it was, the better Randy Newman album from this list

Billy Joel lite delivers a montage of vaudeville-esque piano stylings. This album would be 2 stars if the orchestration wasn't so exquisite, and 4 stars if he knew how to properly end a song.

There are a few amusing or decent tunes here & there, but the whimsical musings of Randy Newman have never connected with me.

Meh..a bit schmaltzy and full of po faced observations

Pretty high 2 to pretty low 3. Feel like I could get into it, but wasn't feeling it on first listen

One of the most baffling figures in music history. The musical equivalent of Lenny Bruce - held up as a legend but truly sucks to listen to. Good at the one trick of pairing banal sentimentality with cutting sarcasm for sickly sweet cyncism that, I guess, passes as world weary wisdom. I guess you can see that working for songwriter, but when you have that voice, to release a solo album? I suppose the sheer audacity to step into a recording booth to lay down the vocal tracks is admirable.

He certainly has a sound. I liked a few of the songs here... they are evocative. Liked this more than the other album I've heard that was on this list. The music is a little cloying for the subjects of some of the songs but perhaps that was an intentional dissonance.

Boring. Not interesting from musical perspective. Maybe it has more value i one listens more carefully to lyrics

All I can hear is him about to sing “you’ve got a friend in me” but he never does. Boring folk otherwise.

4/10 - the guy who made you’ve got a friend in me did not make a very good album

This was nice but I’m gonna forget about it in 3 days

This was an absolute slog to get through.

He is so annoying. Good lord

He's a sly one, that Randy Newman.

With how blah this album was, I'm floored Disney even gave this guy a chance to do songs for their movies. His work for Disney was great, whatever this is.... not so much.

Middle of the road. Doesn't grab me.

23/10/2025 It was what i expected, nothing stood out for me. Spotify listeners: 4 million

Whoo boy. Maybe it's the result 40 years of soundtracking generic rom-coms and Toy Stories, but I Do Not Need This. These songs do not tickle anything in my spirit.

Not a fan of Randy to be honest

This is amazing, but I wish Nilsson would have covered every single one of Newman's songs.

There are only two decent songs from Randy Newman and neither are on this album.

Felt like an Old Man after this one.

It has nice messages followed with a good amount of satire and humor, loved how it sounded. Like lullabies for ansious grown ass man like me.

It's scary how much the song Political Science was ahead of it's time. Pretty sure it's being used as an instruction manual in 2025. Awesome album!

TIL "You can leave your hat on" is from this guy and not Joe Cocker. This version does sound way softer and I don't like it as much. Some songs on the album are a bit boring.

I could listen to it again. Weird. Something about it was good....

It’s fine but it’s a really limited sound

I didn’t dislike it like many others seem to, but I’m still not sure why Randy Newman has *two* albums on this list. This one is classic Randy Newman—if you enjoy his usual style, you’ll probably like it. I was pleasantly surprised to recognize a few of the songs. The real standout moment, though, came when I realized some of these tracks reminded me of the movie Major League. It all clicked when I reached track 8, “Burn On,” which plays during the film’s opening credits. “You Can Leave Your Hat On” is another familiar song, though I’ve always known it better through Joe Cocker’s cover.

Fuck. I hate this with every fiber of my being. I feel bad for the other musicians who are playing the otherwise decent music underneath. I hope they tracked the music separately so they didn't have to hear repeated takes of the vocals. I can't understand how Randy Newman is remotely appealing to anyone with a modicum of taste. At least the songs were short so it was over with quickly.

Randy Newman is a god.

You know what, for as fun as it is to make fun of Randy Newman, he's not too bad at this

Well, musically it’s not a bad album when it comes to theatrical baroque pop, but I just don’t like Randy Newman or everything he represents.

Sail Away is a pretty good album that does go by a bit too quickly. I mainly only knew Randy Newman for making a lot of songs from Pixar movies, namely songs like Friend Like Me from the original Toy Story and the Monsters Inc. main theme. So it wasn't really a shock to me that the songs here sound like songs you would hear from any of those movies. The songs sound good and definitely do have some pretty good lyrics. My main problem, like i mentioned, is the songs go by so fast and really don't give all that much time for them to sink in. I still thought this album definitely had it's good points though. Best Song: Burn On Worst Song: Dayton, Ohio - 1903

GOBBLESS AMERICA At first I couldn't tell if some of this album was satirical or if Randy Newman was just delusional. Political Science made me laugh out loud, and wasn't just because of Newman's voice. Definitely getting gospel and jazz vibes from this album, but some tracks also have an orchestral or cinematic feel to them as well. Hidden gem of the album for me is Maybe I'm Doing It Wrong.

“Sounds like Toy Story” -me

The whole time listening to this all I can think of is Toy Story.

This sounds like the guy who sang in Toy Story (you've got a friend in me). Wait a second... could it be?? No... *googles it* No fuckinggg wayyyytt, IT ISSSSS Felt like an expansion of that song, an album version of that song with different lyrics. Loved it, hes got such a great voice. 7/10

Great songwriter, especiallyfor other people. And I actually dig his voice. But he's mean & resentful & cruel in so many of his songs.

Sail Away Lonely at the Top Political Science God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind(

Never listened to this before but know a few of the tracks as covered by others and Randy’s versions. This is a great album. It would be easy to be cynical about the whitest of white boys who grea ip in LA playing and singing like a creole New Orleans jazz player but Randy’s songs are great, the lyrics are thoughtful but nover stateed or heavyhanded, the compositions simple but emotive, the backing band super (not just the trad jazz bomp bomp and horns but also some beautiful percussion on Last night I Had a Dream, slide guitar on the same and you can leave your hat on). I bet Randy writes somgs like a chicken lays eggs, they just drop out of him naturally. Thats what it sounds like anyway. This album caused me to go look to his later stuff and he has albums apart from film scores (and there are plenty of those). great album that can make someone want more.

Emotional, thoughtful, and ever so slightly humorous. A really easy listen with no real weak spots. Lacking a true standout song in my opinion, but a very well-rounded album that is a joy to listen to. Top tracks: Sail Away, Lonely at the Top, God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)

Just sounds like Toy Story

Same artist as you’ve got a friend in me, but that’s not on this album.

Wenn er seine Songs nicht selber singen würde, wäre das ne schöne Platte geworden :-D

I remember reading about this album at length in the book Mystery Train which I read when I was 22 thinking I might be a music critic someday. I also bought the album on vinyl around at that time and don't think I made it all the way through. Which is why I am not now a music critic, other than this. I feel like I need to listen more closely (i.e. not while doing stressful, brain-intensive work) but I really like it. I also had no idea he wrote "You Can Leave Your Hat On" which I have to come to learn is apparently a huge, timeless hit in Ukraine via Joe Cocker's version of it for the movie 9 1/2 Weeks. Now you know.

Old timey film music with bad vocals, quite charming actually

Cheesy and repetitive- just as I expected from randy newman.

Langweilig!

It's fine as a genre album, but not something I care to listen to

Tämähän on positiivista kuunneltavaa.

Ihan jees chillailua.välillä veisut vähän omintakeisia.

The first thing that strikes me is that this isn't an album, it is a collection of songs. There is no structure. It's a selection of tracks best described as 'show tunes'. Most sound as though they would be more at home in musical theatre than on a pop/rock album. The final nail in the coffin is that I really don't like Randy Newman's voice. A generous 2/5.

Great songwriting, with witty and fun sounding melody he hits with deep irony and social consciousness as satire when you actually listen. What at face value may appear simple and straight forward tend to have hidden depths. I mean the title song is the American dream right, except it so isn't, pure genius or how Randy sings Leave hat on, is totally different to the cock sure seduction covers, which kind of totally rewrite the same words and miss the point. I got into Randy because of Pixar so don't see that as a negative, disney songs?! of all the brilliant things pixar did at the start asking Mr Newman was up there as he added such depth, melancholy and bite with his songs. Which is what he does. Not a great vocalist but a great singer songwriter. 4 Star, bordering on 5

Pixar tom waits

Good music. Reminds me of Al Tuck. Didn't realize how dark "Sail Away" is.

Randy Newman sounds like he's writing songs for a musical that doesn't exist.

I was not paying attention to the lyrics. It was enjoyable. They can be disguised as satire I’m not too fussed about that.

a good mixture of fun, funny, and pretty sentimental songs. not sure if i will ever think of Randy Newman and not immediately think of Toy Story and the other countless childhood movies he did the scores for, but pretty cool to see another side of him.

Was not expecting him to be on here. Also was not expecting him to sound the exact same 20 years later as he does in Toy Story which just makes it a little bit hard to take him seriously. Also what was up with some of those lyrics. I was kinda half listening at one point and then I was like, wait, what did he say?? Interesting.

I'm pretty sure Randy Newman is the most soothing voice to listen to for just about every 90s kid. If there was a movie I watched hundreds of times as a child, odds are high that Randy Newman composed and performed the soundtrack. Obviously, its a lot different to listen to some of his other original works, but was still enjoyable. Probably gonna watch Toy Story here soon.

This is an album by Randy Newman.

great for coding. very relaxing and soothing too.

Good but not as good as some other Newman albums

I like the Randy Newman songs that Pixar used for some of their movies, but unfortunately none of those feature on this album. I remember Alan price doing "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear", but I never knew that it was written by Randy Newman. The album is OK, but not great.

Randy Newman is his own thing and I can get down with it.

Same person who scored for Toy Story :) Favorite track: last night i had a dream other picks: sail away, lonely at the top, god's song

Such classic ditties.

When listening this one, I could hear how so many of my favorite songwriters who came after took influence, and you gotta respect the OG.

So much of this album is just “You Got A Friend In Me” at slightly different tempos.

A bit boring

With this, I’m a Martian scrutinising an exquisite vase: what is this, how does it work, is it used for procreation? But the title song’s bite is unmistakeable, and puts one of edge for the rest. Still confused, though intrigued.

just boring, really poor effort and awful vocals

Such a cool style.

Why does he sing like that? Did the poor man suffer a stroke or something? This album did not have a friend in me.

Sappy, sad, funny and extremely serious and poignant. I can understand complaints about Newman that he is formulaic and writes jingles, but this is a wonderful album. Sail Away, God's Song, Son of Mine and Old Man are really hard to listen to and come away not appreciating Newman's skill.

I couldn't care less for this music. It sounds like absolutely nothing in the background. I barely even noticed it was on.

Maybe the Toy Story films have ruined Randy Newman for me, because these kind of sound like variations on "You've Got a Friend in Me." I know they aren't really, but they aren't grabbier or more interesting than that, either.

Many weeks ago, we reviewed Randy’s album Good Old Boys. There was a lot of jarring content on that one, but I tried very hard to engage with the album on its own terms, which was an interesting and thought-provoking exercise. This time around, I’ve run out of patience for his schtick. Sail Away opens with the title track, a pitch-black satire that just doesn’t land right in 2025. I was surprised to find he did this on more than one album. I kind of thought Good Old Boys was a contained project. But listening to his song Political Science, I’m like, was this his whole thing? Is all his pre-Toy Story material like this? I don’t need to find out. It’s exhausting.

I really didn't need anymore Randy Newman. There's something so American about this album. In this moment, I really want to think less about that damn country. I find myself constantly consumed by their current political situation. The last thing I need is for the state of America to seep into the music I'm listening to. And this album dragged me kicking and screaming into America's shit. There are songs about American history, American exceptionalism, American Imperialism and the most American thing of all, God. I just can't engage with this album right now. It brought me down. I guess the warm piano ballad vibe was solid? I guess the track about bombing everyone was cute in a the world is fucked and America will never change because this song was writtten in 1972 and they're still bombing people in the year of our lord 2025 kind of way. Maybe someday i'll be able to appreciate this thing, but not now, not today. This is album is a generous 2.

Okay, so there's the album that cements Randy Newman in the pantheon of the greatest song writers. Stunning stuff.

This was a pleasant surprise. I really like Newman’s quirky lyrics and cadence. I was amused by the phrase as happy as a monkey in a monkey tree. I like the sparseness of most of the arrangements. There’s something so satisfying about listening to the chords on the piano.

Nice and chill

As a Dodgers fan I love Randy Newman for what might be his biggest song, I Love LA! Obviously that song isn't on this record though. His lyrics often feature comical and biting social observations which I find interesting. That being said, it's not necessarily the kind of music I would seek out typically. But that's why I took on this challenge, to expand my horizons. 3.5/5 #187

Dylanesque sounds carried by straightforward but soulful lyrics. Not something I'd typically seek out but I appreciated it while it was on

Randy Newman on a movie soundtrack: ok, this makes sense for a CGI film where toys come to life. Randy Newman on a full-length: Fuck no

Reminds me of that one friend everyone has who NEVER shuts up. Only Randy sings and noodles on a piano. Just a stream of conciseness no one asked for. This sucks.

This would be your favourite album if you were 75.

YOU CAN LEAVE YOUR HAT ON

For those still with whimsy in their heart...

Randy Newman is Bob Dylan for squares

I need to listen to more Randy Newman. This is exactly my type of shit. The album feels the slightest bit sleepy, so not all the way to 5 stars. But I am a huge fan of this.

Some good tunes and pretty chill, something I'd happily put in the background but hasn't rocked my world

Très agréable mais un poil ressemblant

This was nice, familiar, relatable.

As a Brit, it’s very strange to hear You Can Leave Your Hat On when it isn’t in the context of male strippers

No not woody again. All jokes aside, I enjoyed this a lot more than Good old boys as it had a lot more variety in the songs. It had like a mix of Circus music (for some reason), American casino style cabaret and piano led ballads. I also felt this didn’t sound as much like Pixar music as the last did, due to the change up in styles unlike the other one which was very repetitive, this one was still a little repetitive but not nearly as much, although, musically it didn’t exactly hook me all the time. This guy is definitely a good lyricist, especially with his political commentary on songs like political science and sail away, however his vocals and instrumentation (the latter being less of an issue) leaves a bit to be desired for me personally. Also, with the album being remastered in 2002 it made it seem like the song Dayton Ohio-1903 was suggesting in the title that the place somehow died in 2002 which was pretty funny. Favourites: Last night I had a dream and political science. Overall, 6/10. (Also, I had to rewrite this review as the site randomly died for some reason).

Cool take on singer-songwritter music. Sounds like something from a spy movie. Great vibes. I like the piano parts especially. Some songs are a bit more forgettable but nothing bad.

He jumps between serious and silly from song to song. It's an interesting ride, but not something I want very often.

Solide Stücke im Geist der Improvisation. „Leave your hat on“.

This was easy listening for a Friday morning. I liked it, but I'm not sure I'd revisit the album very much.

extremely unique and singular and Striking in a number of ways...extreme musical economy from the song structures to arrangements, newman's distinctive somewhat old-timey voice, but more than anything how the surface-level sappiness of both contrast with the content of the songs being buried in so many layers of tonal and dramatic irony. inevitably, this is what keeps me at a bit of a distance...despite occasionally prodding at some things from reality i wish he wouldnt reduce to a self-congratulatory abstractions, i suppose there is some inarguable cleverness to Just How Much newman commits to the bit in every song. but the fact that i rly cant reliably tell if Anything is supposed to be sincere here is just Not The Experience For Me...even an early track that seems like unadorned simplehearted religious faith is later upended by the pitch-dark anti-religious closing track, it makes the whole album feel Unreliable in a way that i guess is cool but is not terribly fulfilling for me personally. i am far too sentimental and sappy of a person myself to get much out of the uncanny skewering of these styles that newman does here. the universe does not revolve around me and my taste, and im happy that it doesnt. but yk, its all i can speak for

I don't think I've been more disappointed in this list than when listening to Sail Away. Not at all because Randy Newman is a bad singer or songwriter, but rather, it's because this feels like such an OK album. I usually give each album a fair shot by listening to it twice, once for first impressions and another to really analyze the lyrics, but this is genuinely the first time I've tried putting off my relisten before finally biting the bullet on it. Half of the instrumentals on this album feels either somewhat dated or doesn't have enough of a hook to keep me invested for the whole runtime, which is baffling to say to an Orchestral Pop album. The lyrics on the otherhand can be so damn impactful and are by far the best part of the 30 minute runtime. Political Science is possibly the best song on the tracklist as a result, being tongue-in-cheek about how much of an ego the USA has, while also being pretty damn catchy. The best I can say is that this album sounds nostalgic, even on its first listen. However, that feeling can only get you so far, and it results in an album that was practically made for me to not think too fondly of.

The Toy Story guy far out man

Sail Away 3.4 Lonely at the Top 3.2 He Gives Us All His Love 3 Last Night I Had a Dream 3.5 Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear 3.3 Old Man 2.7 Political Science 2.9 Burn On 2.8 Memo to My Son 2.8 Dayton, Ohio - 1903 3 You Can Leave Your Hat On 3.5 God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind) 2.6 Score: 3.058333333

чел написал кучу саундтреков к пиксаровским мультикам и оно и слышно. но в рамках альбома как-то неинтересно совсем, скучно. не дослушала

Enjoyed this. Never listened to a full Randy Newman album before, discovered a few tunes and it was a good listen for a morning's commute

There's really only so much of this I can take.

An album that blew me away, I love it and it impressed me, it's really cool.

First song hit me hard best one on here so far at least as surprises go loved it

Mostly listenable. Like the satire but afraid too many Trumpists don't get the sarcasm and follow the sentiment of Political Science with brains on non-active. Good variety of styles but not a fan of musical like tunes.

Fucking ass lol, sorry, I don't like anything on this

Not bad, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that I was listening to a Disney Pixar soundtrack the whole time. Plus, that nasal voice of his is a bit hard to get used to.

Randy Newman, of “Short People” infamy. He’s Elton John without the talent. Ok, that might be a bit harsh—his piano and voice are competent. His songs bug though. I like “You Can Leave Your Hat On” for the kink element. That’s about it.

cute! 75/100

This album is brilliant. To those with the cheap takes who only know his more recent movie songs: get your head out of your sanctimonious ass and listen to the album, you fucking nerds.

simplemente no es lo mio, mucho disney

Haha toy story guy

Cabaret pop?

Depressing, sardonic, and occasionally sentimental. As far as songwriting goes, it's not bad. Wouldn't mind hearing again

I think watching The Full Monty last night summoned the album generator to give me 'You Can Leave Your Hat On'

Better than the other one I got from him (at least he didn’t say the n word this time) just some decent country stuff I guess. 3 stars

Pretty good

Relatively enjoyable, but very little variation between tracks. All a variation on a theme.

Today I learned that Randy Newman wrote the song Mama Told Me Not to Come, which was a number one hit for Three Dog Night in 1970. However, the first recording of Mama Told Me Not to Come was on an Eric Burdon and the Animals release in 1967 called Eric Is Here. Besides Newman, Eric Is Here included songs written by Gerry Goffin and Carole King as well as Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil. They would all later have songs on Dusty Springfield's Dusty In Memphis. It appears that when Sail Away was remastered and re-released in 2002, that someone decided to rotate the cover image 90 degrees to the right--so that Newman is looking left--and tint the entire thing red. Prior to that, the cover was tinted normally and Randy Newman was looking down. The change, to me at least, made the album look like Bob Dylan's Blood on the Tracks. Blood on the Tracks, this is not. But it is a brisk, jaunty disk worth a listen. I know this is a well regarded album and appears on many best of lists. However, it was not a hit record. It looks to me like Randy Newman never had a hit album despite having hit songs. That, to me, is why he now has to slave away on Pixar soundtracks for Disney into his 80's. Poor guy.

i'm afraid i'm a bit toy story-pilled having first encountered randy newman through pixar, and i must admit that every song sounded like "you've got a friend in me" until i really got into the album. he's obviously a great songwriter, but the music itself sounds a little hokey, like a cowboy doll is going to crawl out from my bed at any moment. still - great album!! highlights - last night i had an amazing dream, simon smith and the amazing dancing bear, dayton ohio

Love me some Randy, don't love me under 2 min songs... Fun lyrics and delivery, unique instrumentals but a lot of them end when theyre starting up.

Great songwriting! The first song blew me away. Musically, I prefer the songs with a band.

424/1001

Randy Newman is definitely an artist where you have to listen to the lyrics to get it. And he is solid on this one.

This seemed like the musical version of Shel Silverstein’s Where the Sidewalk Ends. Lots of clever rhymes. Did not enjoy any of it.

Some musicians you can spot from hearing the tone of their instruments, Randy Newman you can tell by reading the premise of his songs: 1. The pitch of an American slave trader to Africans in Bonny, off the west coast of Nigeria. The slaver sings a song about the wonderful life to be had in Charleston. 2. The final farewell of an atheist father to his atheist son. 3. American politicians gleeful discussing "dropping the big one" and remaking all countries in America's image.  4. The beauty of Cleveland - especially when the Cuyahoga River catches fire from pollution. 5. A disappointed dad who doesnt understand why his dumb son doesnt listen to his advice...only to reveal that all of his advice are just cliche'd platitudes.  6. A song where God tells humanity that they are suckers for putting their faith in him.  You don't have to know much, but if I tell you those premises, you have a good shot at guessing those are Randy Newman tunes. I think the guy is retroactively getting some love these days, but I think this album remains underrated. 

I love his voice. His music is like more-refined and softer Tom Waits. Movie magic in it all of course. AND the social commentary on American egotism is great.

Randy's voice just make me chuckle. Its hard to take serious but yet you stay till the end.

I liked this more than I expected. I'm not a fan of his voice, but this album showed a lot of melody and skill that I'd previously disregarded. This might warrant another listen.

Again an example I have had in my closet for fifteen years or so and never liked a lot. I was wrong. It's full of gems, the songwriting is incredible and the performances sometimes beautiful. I love the obvious jewish influences, most of all on 'It's lonely at the top'. But the absolute highlight for me is the wonderful 'Memo to my son' - what an astonishingly beautiful melody, however simple (it's an E-chord). I can understand why I never really liked it. Newman is obviously a better songwriter that a singer, and 'You can leave your hat on' for me has been totally f**cked up by the horrible Joe Cocker. But this is first class songwriting.

Kind of a fun listen. Unfortunately for Randy when I hear his voice all I can think about is Pixar soundtracks haha it's hard to take this as seriously as it was intended. Still he has a great voice and a fun bouncy songwriting style. There's a lot to like here.

OK, so the good think about 1001Album is it gets me to listen to albums I wouldn't normally listen to...and that's led me to some refreshing new artists. And it made me listen to Randy Newman for the time (knowingly.) Very quickly, I saw the usual formula in his compositions....and it just bores me. It was struggle to get to the end. Bland and trite.

Interssante Stimme.

me quedé indiferente

I didn't care for the other Randy Newman album on this list but I really liked this! I didn't know he wrote "You Can Leave Your Hat On." So many of these songs sounded familiar and other than the aforementioned name song, I don't think I'd actually heard them before. Would rate 4.5.

The music is fine and has a jazzy sound to it. Vocals are decent as well. A nice album that doesn't stand out too much. 3/5

Too old timey for me

absolutely grated on my nerves i can’t even

I appreciate the satire of the album but the style gives me unshakable weird uncle energy

I liked Sail Away and Old Man. I like his voice - it matches the songs well

It's kinda nice but kinda boring. I can appreciate that the songwriting and melodies are vastly different than what I am used to listening to. I don't typically hear music that conveys these moods and feelings.

Randy Newman is not Paul Newman who is not Newman from Seinfeld. Personal enjoyment: 3/5 Relevance to this list: 2/5

He never drags a song on too long, so that’s good. They’re all kind of like mini stories. It was ok.

Utter crap. Didn’t enjoy a single track. Sounded like it was a cartoon character or someone putting on silly voices.

Kind of eh, better than the previous one I listened to but think he should probably stick to pixar sound tracks

I usually defend the picks on this list, but WTF? Based on the music alone, I cannot see how this album is important or interesting. At least it isn't for me. If a musician sells out to Hollywood and millions, it doesn't mean that we should lick their shoes. In fact, I feel oppositely. Yes there are some interesting lyrics, but that really isn't enough to carry this album for me. Everything was okay, nothing made me pause and think that I needed to just listen. I call BS on people saying that this was influential to later music. I just don't see it

I enjoy Randy's biting satire set to music. While this style of music isn't everyday listening type stuff for me it's obvious how talented he is. Lots of really great tunes on this one.

Very recognizable voice. Can mostly just think of Family guy. I still think it's good but hard to get it out of my head Will I listen to again: 10%

I’ve been a big fan of this album for years. As a nascent cynic, this one spoke to me when I first found a used copy. Memo to My Son is probably my favorite Randy Newman song.

This is good, but musically it's very samey after a while, and I don't usually pay enough attention to the lyrics to get the full benefit of Newman's smarts

4/5 - I needed to hear this so I could hear Randy Newman beyond animated soundtracks and "I Love LA," as well as pay attention to his smart, biting lyrics. You can just see the sideways grin he's giving with songs like "Political Science" and "Burn On.” I don't love his voice, but I'm jealous of his songwriting talent.

A career best album. Political science is still an appropriate song now. Sail away is a beautiful lilting song. Simon smith and the dancing bear is funny and melodic. God's song is interesting especially in these heightened times when the regard for human life is so miniscule. Nearly all of newmans best songs on this album.

Por fin pude escucharlo completo. Algo pasaba con este disco, que intenté escucharlo tres veces, en días distintos, y algo hacía que tuviera que interrumpirlo. Cosas de trabajo, familiares, etc., pero siempre tenía que quitarlo ya pasando la mitad. Y como soy muy riguroso pues me gusta esuchar los discos de inicio a fin, no unas canciones hoy y a ver cuándo las otras. Y ayer fue el día, en el cuarto intento, que el disco de Randy Newman fue escuchado en su totalida. Y pues equis jajaja, las repeticiones no ayudaron a que lo apreciara más. Como muchas personas de mi generación, a Randy Newman lo ubicamos por You´ve got a friend in me, genial canción de Toy Story, pero ya escucharlo en otro mood más romántico, pero con la misma voz bonachona, como que hizo corto circuito en mi cabeza. Ya no se diga con su versión de You can leave your hat on. Así que fan de Newman componiendo canciones para Disney, no tan fan en sus discos como solista.

I thought this was OK, but after having read a bit about the lyrics, I think I need to make another pass through this. Reasonably enjoyable at face value, but I think it's maybe more than that. ⭐⭐⭐ for now

Pleasant Randy session today, very laid back. It's a little too "sing-songy", I would never revisit the full album, but I'll get some mileage out of a couple songs here.

1. Sail Away - 5 Lyrically it's very strong at times. "We will cross the might ocean in the Charleston Bay" is a great line. The rest of the lines about America are a bit dull. Instrumentally the piano and strings are a fantastic sound. 2. Lonely At The Top - 5 It's a good concept for a song but it's lyrical execution is very poor. You don't really understand why it's "lonely at the top". Very simple song but just too simple at times. 3. He Gives Us All His Love - 3 Slow Jesus music. The strings are nice but it's just so over-simplistic and unnecessary. 4 - Last Night I Had A Dream - 6 Musically and instrumentally this song is fantastic. Such an amazing sound. Lyrically it's incredibly weak, especially in the chorus. Outro's guitar sounds excellent. 5. Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear - 7 Solid track. Very upbeat with decent lyrics and piano play that makes this a very light hearted, happy, and enjoyable track. 6. Old Man - 11 Beautiful song. It will move you to tears. 7. Political Science - 7 Solid song with a good meaning wrote very well to make it's point perfectly. As a satire, it's a solid track. 8. Burn On - 3 It's not a bad song I just don't understand the point of it. Instrumentally it's fine and lyrically it's okay. It's just very random. 9. Memo To My Son - 7 Solid track. Very upbeat and enjoyable. 10. Dayton, Ohio - 1903 - 5 Vocals sound good and the piano is solid. Very simple song however that passes by very very quickly. 11. You Can Leave Your Hat On - 2 Another completely random song in its lyrical composition. The instruments are extremely monotonous on the track and as such it just doesn't go anywhere. 12. God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind) - 3 The intention of the song is very good but the track itself is just all over the place. At times brilliant, at other times lost, and at other times a struggle to listen to much like the lyrics try to paint the world as. The album would be better off if this was dropped off the end of it. Average Rating: 5.33 Adjusted to a 5-Point Scale: 2.66 Rounded Up: 3 Stars

Toy Story man can only ever sound like Toy Story to me.

His voice is a little annoying, but the songs are absolute genius. You can't have everything. Political Science - prescient. It is a 5.

Not my vibe but it was ok.

meh. It didn't do anything for me; no song really moved me or caught my attention. There are some nice arrangements and cool piano parts in some songs. 2/5

I was surprised. Good album.

A great and unique lyricist and singer.

Love his voice. And some of these songs were great!

This guy is like if Weird Al Yankovic decided he hates the US. He's a really good songwriter with an almost painfully witty since of humor that rides the line between being too corny for its own good and being too real for its own good. I love the really Vaudeville or Cabaret-ish tracks like Lonely at the Top or Political Science. The best part is how well the album aged despite being from 1972. Much like all punk, funk, or anything else anti-establishment, a 53-year-old message is still just as real and relevant as it was 53 years ago.

This is a nicely made album but nothing was memorable for me and it kinda bored me from start to finish.

Not the worst not the best. A high 2 rounded up.

I might enjoy Mr Newman’s music during a panel discussion at the 92nd st Y, but I don’t ever need to listen to an album of his again.

I don't know...I guess this was kind of enjoyable? But nothing that stuck with me and no songs I wanted to revisit.

i want so badly to like randy newman but i think the best i can say is that this is less annoying than billy joel.

Having a little chuckle while the orchestra swells

This was really enjoyable. Singer songwriter, casual very easy listen, yet songs have more meaning than the simple structure it presents. Burn on really hits home as a PA born person where pollution has ruined so much of the natural beauty.

I've always associated Randy Newman with wholesomeness, joy, and hope - probably because of all those Pixar songs that soundtracked my childhood. But the guy is much more keen than he may initially let on - underneath those sweeping string sections, playful piano leads, and welcoming raspy vocals are lyrics that are parts poignant, evocative, funny, and quite dark at times. There's a sarcasm underlying many of the songs here, starting from the very first song but more hilariously on 'Political Science', maybe my favorite song here. But I was familiar with his political side having already listened to 'Good Old Boys' - it's really the existentially morbid topics of 'God's Song' and 'Old Man' that stuck with my this time around. And there are a couple just really tongue-in-cheek songs here too - specifically 'You Can Leave Your Hat On' and 'Memo To My Son' which has a ridiculously fun and playful instrumental. More than anything though, this album's just super easy to listen to, all the instruments just pop, are ever-evolving, and Randy's vocals are a pleasure to behold on every song. Great stuff.

I like Zevon better

Not my thing... I liked the title track Sail Away best

Great songs, great songwriting, trade mark delivery.

This probably isn't any better than Good Old Boys but I enjoyed it a lot more on the day I listened. This process really brings home how unreliable critical thought is.

This feels like the album that made Family Guy make fun of him.

It’s easy to forget just how influential Randy Newman’s work is. The true modern American Songbook, he manages to say so much in such a concise way, rivalling Dylan and Springsteen for sheer storytelling heft. His voice is very Marmite, but I love it. I’m sure many people have written him off at the Toy Story guy, but Newman has the ability to play a humorous little number that at any moment can wrench your heart straight out of your chest. He’s a singular talent and I’m glad more people will get to hear him from his inclusion on this list.

objectively it’s good but it didn’t stick out to me. most of the songs just kinda phased by for me

Some good tracks but awful voice

Did not resonate with me at all......why is it on the list

No strong feelings on this one - it's not unpleasant and at times feels emotional, sentimental about his own life and history in a way that I quite like. But no songs massively stand out to me - would happily give it a 5/10 so will give it a 2(.5)

24/1001 Randy Newman - Sail Away Heard before? ❎ Listen again? ❎ At first I thought yeah this is ok, bluesy kinda voice and some decent arrangements. Then it turned more and more into an amalgamation of the aforementioned bluesy stuff with show tunes bent and I was out.

Not sure how to feel about this album. Randy’s a superb songwriter. This has been proven over and over again. Unfortunately, his voice is just subpar and listening to a whole album of him is clearly not for me. There’s some decent songs on here: Last Night I Had a Dream for one. Political Science is very cheeky, as is You Can Leave Your Hat On. Memo To My Son was cute and well constructed. But his voice!!!! Ugh, I don’t need to listen to 40 minutes of songs that sound like the bears from Splash Mountain. Just not my thing.

I respect it more than I enjoyed it. The songwriting’s sharp, and it’s packed with great session work, but the whole thing floats by a little too politely. Maybe I just wanted more bite. Spins: 2 Playlist Additions: - Sail Away - Lonely at the Top - Political Science

I’d never heard of Randy Newman. Not my usual style of music but some really good songs here. Especially liked Last Night I Had A Dream, and of course You Can Keep Your Hat On.

Decent album, not resonating with me on a deeper level so far, may have to come back to it later. Maybe need to give the lyrics more attention. Have certainly connected more with other albums from this time period off the bat though. Likely will not be coming back more than once or twice. Overall all the songs are solid - nothing offensively bad or that I dont like, and is an enjoyable listen overall. Well arranged and produced (may be because I listened to the remaster) for its time, and I can see why it is on the list. Probably a solid 7/10 album, cant really find anything substantial to criticize but isn't quite captivating enough to warrant a higher score.

I loved the nostalgic feel, the lyrics had meaning and the vocals where wonderful. I loved every song for many different reasons.

I quite liked the lyrics, and the music was well written, but overall "Sail Away" was an average album.

Perhaps one of the most nostalgic sounding voices on an album with some of the greatest range of messaging. You'll go from a religious God smiles song to a political statement of modern American imperialism while your heart dreams of the days of Toy Story.

Nope. I mean it's not without merit (like some nice piano playing) but it's very much not my sort of thing. Just uninspiring to me, musically. Apparently, he's quite satirical, but as I was failing to engage with the music or his voice, I was disinclined to consider the lyrics properly. Sorry Randy.

Well, musically it’s not a bad album when it comes to theatrical baroque pop, but I just don’t like Randy Newman or everything he represents.

Surprisingly great. Some masterfully witty, satiric and at times downright bleak songwriting, contrasted against the nice orchestration. I just can't imagine being so close-minded to dismiss it because of some Pixar appearances over two decades later.

I was not familiar with Randy Newman's game

Reminded me of a drunk guy singing to himself at a urinal. The instrumentals were decent but could not carry it; lyrics were funny at times. 3/10

Almost all of my exposure to Randy Newman has been the song "You've got a friend in me" from Toy Story. I love that song. I've listened to it hundreds of times. I'm not sure any musician has ever had a more unique voice. It's so pleasant to listen to, maybe because I associate it with loving Toy Story. "It's Lonely at the Top" is so good. Was anyone else making music quite like this? I love everything about it. "Political Science" is the next song I really liked. It's a funny satire roasting american foreign policy. "Dayton, Ohio" is great. "You Can Leave Your Hat On" is a jam. I liked this album. Not every song is amazing, but I at least liked them all. The runtime was short, so I never had the time to get bored of his sound. I like Randy Newman. 8/10

Poor Randy Newman, because all I can hear is parodies of him singing. This will be my first full album from him I believe. Pleasant and well made. Does Randy Newman picks state per album? From what I know about him he sings about Ohio and California.

Points for being the Tin Pan Alley political satire department, but I can't say I enjoyed this album. Newman's whiny voice grates on me and while I think he is a decent lyricist, I would rather he let someone else sing. This album isn't for me, but its competent enough.

Admire the way he gets Jesus and America into the first few lines but for me this entire album sucks harder than woody and buzz on poppers

Bloody awful. Can't seperate his voice from show tunes.

Meh. It’s fine, nothing remarkable, but I didn’t hate myself for listening to it. I kind of like Newman’s voice, but I found the songs themselves to be pretty boring.

Have and love this album

Фон для разнообразия изредка. Немного однообразная спокойная музыка. 6 из 10.

Everyone loves the sound of Toy Story right!?

this was really boring

Premier album de cete virée dans les 1001 albums à écouter dans sa vie. Je me rends compte qu'écrire une critique est d'une difficulté inouïe.

"Sail Away" is the third studio album by American singer, songwriter, arranger, pianist, composer, conductor and orchestrator Randy Newman. Orchestral pop and rock are the Wiki-listed genres. Yeah, it's somewhere near those two. Newman wrote all the songs and several of them had already been recorded by other artists and himself. The album was produced by Lenny Waronker and Russ Titelman. Newman was lead vocalist and pianist and had a host of other musicians contribute. Commercially, the album reached #163 in the US and, critically, it was very well received. Strings and Newman's nasally vocals open "Sail Away." Piano and a melancholy vibe. A satirical take on presenting the American dream of a promised land to Black Africa in the slave running days. Newman originally wrote "Lonely at the Top" for Frank Sinatra but it actually applies to him as well. This time it's a variety of horns and circus-type music as the narrator repeats it's lonely at the top as he looks down on everybody else. Newman delivers a heartfelt song in "Old Man." The music is lavish with the strings. A sad tale of a son, his dying father and their inability to successfully say goodbye due to their lack of compassion. In "Political Science," Newman takes the point of view (POV) of America where he imagines that no one likes him and pokes fun at foreign countries and cities. So, let's just drop the big one. Unfortunately, there appears to be a number of current politicians who are taking this song at face value. It's hard to hear "You Can Leave Your Hat On" and not hear the Joe Cocker version. Well, this version is the most rocking song on the album with a traditional guitar, bass and drum band. And, of course, that repeating piano note. One of the few lyrically straightforward songs about desire/love/sex. The album closes with "God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)." Stark with a piano and Newman's whispering voice. It's told from the POV of God as he hits mankind with plagues, squalor and misery and, yet, they continue their devotion and faith toward him; That's why he love mankind. This is a fantastic album. It has brilliant and mostly satirical lyrics told from a variety of points of view: Funny, sad, serious, heartfelt and, strangely enough, sometimes optimistic. The production and musical arrangements are excellent with the music matching the lyrical tones: strings, horns, piano and standard rock band instruments. The songs are short with the lyrics grabbing your attention from start to finish. The lyrics are some of the best that I've come across; Leonard Cohen, Bob Dylan and Elvis Costello also come to mind. And with that, yes, a very high recommendation for a listen.

Horrible vocals which ruin any potential enjoyment I’d otherwise have from the songs. Not that I think I’d like the cabaret-sounding songs with a better singer. Don’t see the greatness in this at all. No favourite songs

I can only listen to someone sing about Ohio for so long.

¡Hostia! El de Toy Story...

His voice idk bout it

Rating: 5/10 Meh.

I was not super looking forward to this one. The only Randy Newman songs I’ve ever heard were the sorta cheesy ones from the Major League soundtrack and Toy Story soundtrack (actually, in searching his catalogue, it looks like he’s put in a ton of work on a ton of different soundtracks, which I was not aware of). If I would have been pressed to describe his sound, I might have said something to the effect of, “the drunk sounding guy that plays ragtime piano.” I still kind of feel that way. Randy Newman has a really unique voice that can be a little much (don’t know if I’d qualify it as “drunk sounding” at this point thought…yet it’s still not totally inaccurate…I dunno), and some of the music does have a sort of ragtime vibe. But I’m actually digging this record. The arrangements with the strings and horns is really great, and I like his songs when he’s not singing about how “you’ve got a friend in me”. I guess that’s to say, this record is way less cheesy than I predicted. Some of the songs would fit right in with some of Tom Waits’ early drunk jazz bar records, but with more orchestration. I still prefer Tom Waits - though, to be fair, I prefer Tom Waits to just about anyone - but I will listen to this again. I could actually see sinking into this record. The lyrics are sometimes darker than I would have expected, the music is interesting and sometimes sad, and I think there’s enough to chew on for repeat listens. This record is a happy surprise. 4.0/5

I don't dislike this album at all, but I can't help but feel like I'm listening to the soundtrack to an early 2000's Pixar movie about a mouse living in New York in the early 1900's.

This album blew my socks off back in 1972. Still does. Such brilliant and unique songwriting and arrangements. Newman’s wicked and biting sense of humor floors me. The best.

Just couldn't get into this one. I think his voice is way too ingrained into my brain as the "disney song guy".

Don't hate it, don't love it either. Kind meh. His voice is unique but I don't really need a full album of it.

That voice is bonkers and he kind of reeks of "I have a Black friend"

Normally, I enjoy Randy Newman, but this album is just a drag. It has one of the most uninspired, lifeless renditions of "You Can Leave Your Hat On" that I've ever heard.

Let's see what we what here... Sounds like Toy Story music. lol. Can't do this this is a god album. lol 1 star.

I vibed with the instrumentals but I found Newman's voice soooooo annoying that I just couldn't get into it. Also, very disconcerting to hear You Can Leave Your Hat On in this context, what do you MEAN the Tom Jones version is a cover??

Can’t help but think about Disney. Sounds like another Disney soundtrack. I like the soulful/blues elements.

Flaming heck, this is diabolical. The highlight is an absolutely dreadful song that immediately makes you think of male strippers. There you go. Boring, offensively lazy and drab.

It’s good, my brain just has a hard time not visualizing Toy Story when I hear him.

It was fine

Late evening stuff. Solid tracks, but nothing special.

Hard to get over his voice being so synonymous with Toy Story in the first song. After that their are some interesting songs in topics, however I suspect I would find more to connect with in later albums.

Not for me, occational moments I liked. But also... there was a tuba and I couldn't get over it being Randy Newman's voice.

Soft 2/5. Occasional satire without interesting opinions. Schmultzy laid back style.

I like this guy in small doses. Clearly a talented songwriter, with songs covered by other artists.

Political Science could be satirising Trump’s actions this week. It’s funny, a cheery song about bombing the world. The title track is more chilling, soon to be slaves sailing towards America, towards “the land of the free”, written as a patriotic anthem. It’s clever, world weary satire. Risky lyrics delivered in a gentle way. Musically it’s somewhat interesting, lyrically it’s very interesting. I like that you could have this on at a party and pay no attention to the subject matter of the songs.

Doesn’t do much for me at all, though I can see the appeal.

68/100. This album offers an easy listening experience. The highlights are memorable, but overall, it lacks the consistency to fully captivate.

I think I knew only a few of these songs, but his voice and musical style is so familiar that it felt like I'd heard this before. Enjoyed it a lot.

Jarringly beautiful storytelling accompanied by deeply American satire

Good stuff with thoughtful lyrics. God’s song is quite special!! 3.8

the first song and title of the album........................................oof Drop the big one is darkly funny

норм, есть парочка бэнгеров, но сильно я не впечатлен.

I couldn't listen to this without thinking of him as being the Disney guy

# 506 : Sail Away Good background music, if you're writing a kids movie… Favourite Track: None Listened: 19/06/2025

Nice album good vocals

Sail Away sounds like church music by Tom Waits. The only redeeming performance on this album is the song from The Muppet Show.

I like when we get two albums from the same artist in quick succession, gives you more perspective on their career and some more time to think about them. Randy Newman is interesting in how he can make such dark songs sound like show tunes (political science in particular). I found this album a little hit or miss but enjoyed it overall

2.8 Kinda like the other Randy Newman album we did, no? Maybe some more instrumentals. It was fine

2.1 super boring

I love his biting tongue in cheek commentary. The way he puts down the American establishment's illusions of grandeur is both humorous and astute. There are also several very touching moments like the songs he dedicated to his father and a newborn son. Randy is a treasure.

I really liked this album..it's awesome ! I mostly knew randy newman because of movie music but this is a great album of singer/songwriter with some awesome orchestral passages. I also really love his voice. Has some.tom waits vibes to it very good !

Solo rescato "puedes dejarte el sombrero ", no sabia que era una canción de Randy , el disco No es malo , es perfectamente escuchable como música de fondo , es tranquilo y relajado . Entiendo el por que Randy no es un artista famoso a nivel mundial , ya que al ver a los artistas y bandas que comparten su periodo musical (1970-1975) Randy es absolutamente eclipsado por las grandes banda de los 60 y 70.

Was better than I thought. Half of the songs are too cheesy though Fav tracks: Last Night I Had A Dream, You Can Leave Your Hat On, God's Song

Okay for background music, but not something I'll listen to again.

70s. Sound of my childhood and memories form the USA - Toy Story, motels, west coast... His rusty voice is like an old cello. The mix of classical music and a touch of country mixed well with ballads - fire.

I can't do it. He sounds like Spongebob drunk off ice cream at Goofy Goober's. 2 stars though because of Toy Story.

I’ve always thought that Randy Newman must have an incredible amount of hubris to sing his own songs. His voice sounds like he’s singing through a wad of cotton and marbles. Curious about who actually … like genuinely … likes this artist? Are you out there?

Really good

Here's a line that won't surprise you: for most of my life, I knew Randy Newman exclusively as the guy who wrote songs and score for early Pixar movies. If you were to try to talk to me at all about Randy Newman and sailing, I'd immediately think of Buzz Lightyear. That's not an uncommon association for someone of my generation and beyond to have. (There's also the more embarrassing fact that I also knew Randy Newman from the Nostalgia Critic's jokes about him, which, from what I later heard, were stolen from FAMILY GUY: "Foxes / They like lookin' at bags / Then they walk away / So their tails are gonna wag / YoupayRandynow.") But of course, there's way more to Randy Newman than writing music for movies about toys. At some point in my life, I'd learned that if you knew Randy Newman at all, you'd know his **real work** was **nothing** like what he did for Pixar. Musically, no; but lyrically? Oh, no. No, no, no. Randy's pen was **way** sharper and satirical than "You've Got A Friend In Me" would give him credit for. I mean, gawd, "Political Science" from this album is about American politicians wanting to nuke every other country on the planet (besides Australia) because none of them like America. "Sail Away", I'm pretty sure, is about the lie white people tried to sell black people in the slave trading days, and I didn't even realize that until the closing seconds. And those are the most extreme examples, sure, but even on a subtler level, on a song like "He Gives Us All His Love" — that's a song about how awful things happen on Earth, and how people pray to God to try to get Him to do something about it, but all He offers is "His love." (It's on such a subtle level, even, that there's people've covered it sincerely and unironically — though if they'd heard "God's Song" at the end...) And this is a lot about the lyrics already, far more than I normally write. I've expressed many times before that, thanks to being AuDHD, I am not a lyrics person. Most lyric-driven albums bounce right off me, leaving more often than not to just kinda shrug about how the backing instrumentation is fine — or, worse case, it's a singer-songwriter folk album and the backing is just a single guitar doodling along in a loop. So, what is it about this album, exactly, then, that got me to pay so close attention? Let's compare this stuff to the average Bob Dylan recording — specifically, the generic idea of a Bob Dylan recording. On a Dylan song, the lyrics are usually dense as hell. Often, they seem to require a literary degree to even come close to understanding them. These aren't lyrics for doing; they're lyrics for sitting down and pondering, and that's why I've always struggled with them. Meanwhile, Randy Newman's lyrics aren't complex. They're poetic, yes, but they never go so deep with the metaphor that they burrow right under me. It's **understandable**. And again: they are **sharp** lyrics, and **very** witty. Well, OK, maybe not **all** the time; "You Can Leave Your Hat On" didn't do much for me. But the songs I mentioned earlier, and something like "Old Man"... Now **those** are lyrics that'll leave an impact on me, way more than any gobblegook Dylan's thrown at me. Seriously, "Old Man" is a kinda track where you gotta take a pause afterwards like "DAMN..." Then there's the other side of things, the one I normally focus on: the music and instrumentation. It's another area where your typical Dylan song has done me wrong: more often than not, it's a single acoustic guitar with **maybe** a harmonica coming in to squank between verses as a break. **Very** not interesting if you respond better to melody. Like, even Dylan's electric stuff, though imbued with more energy and melody than his strictly acoustic stuff, doesn't really hit as well as I'd want it to; it's still just meant as backing for the lyrics. And that's not to say that the stuff on Newman's album isn't just meant to be backing, either; it can be just as sparse as a Dylan song generically is. But I'll say it: I like the piano better. The piano is a more melodic instrument, and Newman plays it beautifully. Plus: the orchestration. Oh, lordy me, the orchestration. I am such a sucker for orchestral music in pop (or whatever you'd call what Newman does), and this hits all the right spots for me. **This shit** elevates the lyrics and then some. Jus'... Ah, if a lot of it just don't leave me in a quiet state of ponderation. Goodness. I suppose I shouldn't be as surprised as I am that I liked this album so much: I think I kind of always figured that I'd find his music as good as this whenever I did check it out. But to the extent that I did like it? Damn. I still wanna say so much more about this album, but I think I've pretty much run out of words... Just dang. In fact, y'know what? I've only given it one listen so far, but honestly: I'd go so far as to say that I love this album. It's just... B'woof, man. If it ain't some of the finest satirical writing I've ever heard, and anything that can get me paying attention enough to the lyric writing to compliment it like that... That deserves so much credit, you don't even know. So, yeah, Newman. Without a doubt, unless I'm forgetting something, this is the best singer-songwriter album from this list. For sure, you've got a friend in me, Newman.

Good tracks on this record, but I just can't get the thought of "Toy Story guy" out of my head. 3.5 bumped up to 4.

I’m at a 4. I didn’t know Randy Newman was on this list at all, because like many people, he’s just kind of been the Disney song guy to me. Color me decently impressed – he’s got some good witty tracks on this album, a lot of which is baked with Twain-esque sarcasm, delivered in a very intentionally dry way, to make it bite that much more. This is a pretty lyrically driven album, as the instrumentals themselves stay pretty soft & out of the way, so as to let his vocals & lyrics stand out more. It’s an approach that works & it’s an approach that I really like. It’s also an approach that just sort of has a ceiling, but thankfully, this album hits that ceiling right as it finishes up – a track like “God’s Song” feels like a natural conclusion, and as a structured album, this has a pretty good start & a pretty good finish. If someone felt inclined to give this a 5, I wouldn’t blame them. Why am I at a 4 then? I dunno, I think it’s just a little too lo-fi for my tastes. I hesitate to use the Bob Dylan card here, but he at least knew that audiences need a little something to hook onto past just his words, and Randy Newman only really offers that hook around… oh, 60 to 70% of the time, at least to my ears. Hence, the 4. Realistically, probably more of a 3.5 bumped up to a 4. It is definitely an album where you have to really hone in on the lyrics to get the extent of it, so I can understand why someone might give it a 2 or 3 if it’s not their cup of tea. It just clicked for me, what can I say?

Newman is a brilliant writer and a great vocalist. I like someof his stuff better than what's on here, but this is really good, especially SAIL AWAY and KEEP YOUR HAT ON.

If you said "have you ever heard of Randy Newman" I'd say "no", but as soon as this came on I knew this voice (distinctive, not anxiety inducing like Antony and the Johnsons (lol), and heard in apparently every Disney/Pixar movie on the planet). Respect to the songwriting; don't absolutely love this, though.

It definitely sounded like your drunk uncle performing on open-mic night with a bunch of songs he's "workshopping" as well as some tunes he seems to make up as he goes. Also, your uncle is finding his spirituality right now, so he's got faith and god in his heart and he just needs to share it with you. Sorry Unc. Didn't love it.

Kinda sounds like a drunk guy at an open-mic night. But I also can't stop thinking about the Family Guy skit about him signing about everything he sees... and honestly it just makes listening to his music so much harder, haha.

Top Three Songs: 1) Political Science 2) Burn On 3) Last Night I Had A Dream Bottom Three Songs: 1) You Can Leave Your Hat On 2) Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear 3) He Gives Us All His Love

Hard to separate this guy’s serious music from him being the Disney/Pixar guy. This album does a good job of it though - some pretty serious songs on here alongside the usual more whimsical numbers. I enjoyed the R&B/bluesy feel of Last Night I Had a Dream, and I read that Ry Cooder (who I love) provides the slide guitar on this as well as on You Can Leave Your Hat On which was the only track I had prior knowledge of. Decent middle of the road stuff 3/5

This is the 122nd album I’m rating. I only know him from Toy Story and Short People. Adding to my Playlist - Sail Away, Lonely at the Top, He Gives us all his Love, Last Night I had a Dream, Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear, Old Man, Political Science, Burn On, Memo to my Son, Dayton, Ohio - 1903, You Can Leave Your Hat On, and God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind). Not Adding to my Playlist - Nothing. All in all I liked 12/12 songs. I can see why Pixar picked him this album is great.

Chill slow piano rock from the early 70s. Nice background music even though it’s not very interesting.

This one didn't hit for me as hard as "Good Old Boys" but I like the way Randy Newman approaches song writing and, as always, he brings killer musicians to play on the album

I put this off for so long and I regret nothing. 1.5

this sucks! randy newman sucks! why were we inflicted with randy newman for so long! everyone's reaction to randy newman is always "oh yeah... randy newman.. huh" like he's just there by default. he doesn't have to be!

2.5 rounded up because I like this guy's voice but aside from the Cleveland and bad dream songs it felt samey and a bit bleh

My first Randy Newman album and quite a treat. Simple short songs with sarcastic deeper meaning in the lyrics. Enjoyed every song.

Favorite Track: Lonely At The Top

Was it great? No. Did I need to hear it? No, but it was alright.

Randy Newman is another of of those songwriters who occupies a space all his own. The humor of his lyrics doesn’t make them any less biting or even, at times, vicious. Every song on this album is a classic.

A few classic songs, and some interesting delivery.

i don’t like songs about american patriotism, and i don’t like songs about god. fortunately for me, this album had both!