Sail Away by Randy Newman

Sail Away

Randy Newman

2.96
Rating
23584
Votes
1
7%
2
24%
3
41%
4
21%
5
7%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 8)

all of them sounded the same

I liked this a lot more than I initially thought I would. Randy's voice is not the greatest, but it's familiar and he's got a way with words. I really do think I will come back to this, if I can remember it.

Great songwriting, ok voice- now associated w famous movie soundtracks.

Think I like this one a bit more than the last Randy Newman album I got, but not by much. Still a solid record though. Certainly has a style, sounds exactly like the Toy Story stuff. You Can Leave Your Hat On is a great bar somg though. Also, fun that I was driving through Dayton, Ohio when that song came on.

God is cruel he’s so right he’s just like me

Lowk didnt listen but sounds good

The guys lyrics are incredible, his voice is good, maybe an acquired taste. The music is okay, it's kind of schmaltzy in some places, and like jazzy clown music in others. One of those albums where I can appreciate the talent and artistry without feeling the need to listen to it ever again.

I do really like his voice but there’s something about his writing that makes me zone out

I just cannot stand Randy Newman's voice .....

Liked some of them (Sail Away, Simon Smith and You Can Leave Your Hat On) but otherwise let’s just focus on Toy Story.

Found this depressing, not for me.

Boring music

Nice album

Randy Newman is a brilliant and witty composer/writer. He's a perfect example of someone that knows how to write to their strengths. His voice isn't spectacular but it's perfectly suited for his music. And let's not pretend that "Political Science" isn't super relevant today

Lively songs and easy to listen to. Liked it a lot and you can tell the influence it had later on. Very good.

An odd one but I didn’t mind it

Randy Newman is great! Love this album!

3⭐️/5 04.04.2026

Can’t move past his voice

Good tunes, good songwriting, I just can't get past wanting to laugh at his vocals. Hard to imagine myself getting deep into Randy but I respect him

It’s difficult to hear Randy Newman’s voice without thinking of Toy Story. ‘Sail Away’ has very much the same vibe to it as ‘You’ve Got A Friend In Me’ and makes for an enjoyable intro. Unfortunately from there, whilst Randy has a wonderfully rich vocal the songs just dont do much. Political Science is good, but hardly thrilling. The last track is a bit of a dirge and a poor way to end the album. Just needed more energy in places to lift this from just being a good vocalist with hit and miss material

This was perfectly pleasant to have on in the background. Randy Newman is lovely to listen to, in whatever incarnation you get to listen to him.

The whiplash change of emotions that happened to me within the first minute: "Oh, Randy Newman! This should be really interes... What the fuck! Did he just say a slur?!". Look, I know this is from 1971... and I know it's far from pro-slave trade... but ooooh gosh it made me uncomfortable. At least partially because I really liked the song despite it. When Lonely At The Top followed I breathed a sigh of relief - I also *loved* that AND it was mercifully slur-free. Also Will Wood clearly listened to that song before he wrote Front Street. The album continued at pace, nothing outstaying it's welcome, and then Simon Smith and His Amazing Dancing Bear came on. Oh the massive fucking wave of nostalgia! Story time: When I was a kid, whenever we went on holiday a long drive from our house, my Dad would drive overnight, and on the way down (usually to Cornwall or Devon) we'd stop for breakfast in a Little Chef. If anyone reading this a) isn't middle-aged and b) British, Little Chef was a chain of restaurants that acted as service stations on motorways and A-roads in the UK. You could get food, but they also had a little shop that had sun cream and sweets and stuff. One holiday, I suspect in the late 1980s, we picked up a compilation cassette tape from a Little Chef little shop. I have a weird, possibly false memory, that we got it free with stamps or points or something. The only song I remember from it: the Alan Price version of Simon Smith and His Amazing Dancing Bear! I loved it, absolutely adored it. I listened to it thousands of times. Finally hearing the Randy Newman original was fabulous and made me a little misty eyed. I can't think of any artist with a voice that is as untraditionally, but in actuality, fabulous. It's just perfect for the tales he tells. And those tales are perfectly constructed 3(ish) minute pop songs. Seriously, all those artists who spend 7 minutes a song saying virtually nothing, could learn a lot from Randy Newman's ability to construct a story and a song. I loved this Randy Newman album. It's a combination of things I have such a soft spot for: honky-tonk piano, brass instruments, songs that have a narrative, a guy with an interesting voice. This, for me, is clearly a 5/5

I've been dreading another Randy Newman album. It's partly because I can't listen to him without thinking of Toy Story. Partly because I find his nasaly voice a little grating. But I'm trying to give it a chance and appreciate the artistry. The songwriting is pretty good, enough that many of these songs were performed (sometimes famously) by other artists of the era, most notably Harry Nilsson. And thankfully this album doesn't have any obvious racial slurs, unlike the other one on this list. But wait, is there a song encouraging nuclear war? I mean, maybe it's meant to be satire but I think I'm kind of glad to be finished listening to Randy Newman albums now.

Good tunes and melodramatic feelings, but boring as hell

I did, to an island in Florida back in the 1950s. It was incredible!

Listenable.

Campy show tunes, marginal lyrics and two songs about doom this to the bottom 10% of listens so far.

This was a pretty chill vibe. I enjoyed it!

Good album. I'm not sure what I think of his voice, but the instrumentation was great and the lyrics as well, some of which are still relevant today, sadly. The album had a really bittersweet and melancholic feel. I can see myself returning to this in the future, and maybe his voice will grow on me in those later listens.

This was my first time listening to Randy Newman outside of movie soundtracks. It was interesting to listen through, but I did find that alot of the songs sounded the same.

I liked this, for my sins

Charming songwriting, but a bit one-note Not nearly as cool as the album cover suggests

Very peculiar voice and intelligent satirical songwriting. I don't think that I will listen to this whole album again, or that I will casually listen to it for pleasure, but I will return to some of the songs. Favourite song: "Political Science". 3.5 / 5

Eh... Didn't really resonate with me much. Alright piece of music

He's great but I can't listen to him for more than 3 minutes

Really good album with a lot of statements about America that still feel relevant today. No song is too long or feels drawn out. Nice succinct album with a lot to say

There's something deep within me that wants to dislike this, but honestly it was pretty fire. I thought there was a lot of fun writing on it, and he's a pretty great vocalist. I don't know what it is, but something just feels off about him. I can't describe it, but regardless this was a pretty good album. Favorites: Sail Away, Lonely at the Top, God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)

He’s such a good songster but as a whole the album is nothing incredibly exceptional

Solid Pop country music I find but I can't say it was very memorable.

It's always a pleasure to hear something from Randy Newman. One of the best find-outs I made thanks to this site. 5 stars.

In America, we get food to eat, Won’t have to run through the jungle and stuff up your feet. This man is national treasure, his music is so catchy and endearing. It always has such a whimsical nature to it. Like his music just feels like he really loves what he does and he loves telling fascist prices of shit to eat dirt. And one of his greatest qualities is his ability to see what makes America such a special and magical place (or at least it was at one point) and write songs capturing those wholesome, hard working qualities. Like listening to his music makes me feel way more patriotic than a song about “shoving a boot up their ass, it’s the amaerican way” ever will. Seriously, I think the greatest singer songwriter of all time IS Randy Newman, and this album contains most of his biggest and best songs.

It should be the "you got a friend in me" album...

Ugh, don't like Randy Newman. His voice just drives me up the wall, this is not going to be fun. Damn, this album sucks. I hate Randy Newman so much, listening to this album should be considered cruel and unusual punishment. I ejected on the 8th song which is far longer than I should have lasted, I deserve an award for that.

fine; makes me think of monk; won't be revisting

You‘ve got a friend in me. Not.

Ist eindeutig besser, wenn man visuell einer Cowboy-Puppe folgt, die diese Songs singt. Rein auditiv, sind es 30 langweilige Minuten, die so lähmend sind, dass man auch nichts anderes machen kann außer an die Wand zu starren und zu denken "warum zur Hölle hör ich das ganze Album?"

A master at work, one of the greatest to live. Any album by Randy is a classic, this one is at the top of the list and a must own for anyone.

Excellent lyrics, his voice s kinda annoying, but I like it

chanson préférée : Lonely at the Top

It’s hard to get away from the Pixar soundtrack sound that he has become. But this is ok and some enjoyable covers.

I will not include the CD bonus tracks in this review. For people like me who grew up in the 2000s, you're probably more familiar with Randy Newman as a film composer. I grew up watching a lot of Disney films like Toy Story, Monsters, Inc., and A Bug's Life, and Randy was there along the way, scoring these films. But, for an older crowd, Randy established himself as a credible songwriter for other acts before pursuing a successful solo career. In fact, several of the songs collected for Sail Away were recorded by other artists, like Alan Price and Harry Nilsson. With that in mind, how does Randy handle his own material? Let me address the one aspect of Randy Newman that is likely a barrier for people getting into his music: his voice. He has a particular Southern-accented enunciation that paints his songs in a cartoonish manner, even if it's unintentional. Now, this vocal styling can work in a satirical sense, which Randy was able to work with, such as his portrayal of an American slave trader on the title track, the disillusion of perceived success on "Lonely at the Top", the lampooing of U.S. foreign policy on "Political Science", and even a tongue-in-cheek reference to the Cuyahoga River catching on fire in "Burn On". Plus, there are a few moments where Randy can dial back his singing to a softer croon for a more serious tone, usually when addressing his atheist background on the likes of "He Gives Us All His Love" and "Old Man". But I'll admit that his vocal cadence over these schmaltzy piano-driven showtunes can get repetitive and tiring after a while, even if there isn't an outright bad song on here. I still overall enjoyed Sail Away and recognize how successful a singer-songwriter Randy Newman became. Even if it was a tad fatiguing towards the end, I can recognize the genuine hit-maker he would turn out to be.

Classic Randy Newman; fun to hear his stuff before Toy Story, etc.

I like Randy’s voice, but the tracks didn’t do much for me.

Showtime style and his singular voice and charm make for standout Randy. Otherwise I felt eh about it

every time i listen to randy newman i can't not think of the rock opera he made where he said the N word a bunch of times. all of these songs *wish* they were the toy story song.

ugh, i already had the other randy newman album two months ago and now this? i went into this one thinking “well, it couldn’t possibly be more boring and racist than good old boys was” but noooooo, mr. newman had to squeeze a racial slur into track one. and it just gets more boring from there. i can’t for the life of me understand why i need to listen to these songs he wrote 20-30 years before he got good at it. this one gets a 2 as well. favorites: dayton ohio 1903, you can leave your hat on

As good as these songs may be lyrically I can’t stand Randy Newman’s voice

No...Tosh! Fuck this process; so many weak albums Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ Some Revisit ❌️ Crap ★☆☆☆☆ (2/10) Total reviewed : 256 Already owned : 59 Purchased : 14 To buy list : 2 Nope : 181

This was good. I stopped listening for a bit and this was the perfect album to start back up with

Really didn't like this one. Just found it boring

I tried to be open-minded about this, but really couldn't stand it at all. Not for me. Sorry Randy!

Every song quite similar sounding. Lyrically strong but musically repetitive.

Not bad.

Such a lovely voice and the lyrics are always wonderful. The songs, I can take em or leave em.

Political science You can leave your hat on

it was fine i think

I liked this, but I have a soft spot for showtunes so someone being best known for writing for movies was never going to put me off. (Also, Political Science - that barely feels like satire right now.)

I can't listen to Randy Newman without thinking of that Family Guy bit where he's just singing about things that he sees. The album wasn't enjoyable. It was an artist from the 70s trying to sound like music from the 30s. The songs didn't even seem to go together. It felt like a bunch of songs from a while bunch of musicals or together.

Think about these first three tracks and how effortlessly he moves from devastating satire in “Sail Away” to the tongue-in-cheek self-effacing “Lonely at the Top” right into the completely earnest and beautiful “He Gives Us All His Love”. Who else can do that?! Also, it’s simply incredible how many people sign up for this project and seem to absolutely hate listening to and thinking about music in any truly open-minded way. Your lazily dismissive, knee-jerk, sophomoric, incurious one-star takes on half these albums are an embarrassment, you philistine babies!

Sail Away is a breathtaking song, and the rest of this album is a mixed bag

chill but good. no bangers

I owned this album when I was a much younger man after reading Greil Marcus' Mystery Train book. Didn't get it then, not sure if I get it now, but I appreciate it much more. Had no idea he wrote You Can Leave Your Hat On.

Where the hell did Family Guy get the idea that Randy Newman just sings about what he sees?

Too many ballads, but Newman’s voice, piano playing, and lyricism are undeniable. Would love to hear another one of his albums with more variety.

Fine listen.

I couldn't get behind this album. Maybe it's a case of the Mondays, maybe it's his voice/songwriting.

America and god themed lyrics over a Disney soundtrack... What a waste of lifetime

Decent record (even if I was expecting Toy Story vibes)

I only like Randy Newman when he’s singing about bugs, toys, or LA.

A strong ⭐️⭐️⭐️. I liked this!

nomol randy newman?? sail away kenni glaub, er cha scho songs schribe, recht schön. er singt SO weird. guuet arrangiert. lonely at the top chunt mer au sehr bekannt vor. d blöser sind echt huuere cool. uh fuck ry cooder slide uf last night i had a dream. cooole song ouyeah. aso echt s het uuhuere gwicht und d drums und d lyrics sind so creepy? huuuere geil. ähm das stüürt direkt uf es füfi zue what the hell? memo to my son isch huuere herzig und funny. political science vorher isch uuuuultra funny satire? omg you can leave your hat on isch vo ihm im original und ry cooder gitarre und er isch chli grusig uf dem song? so chli sleazy? uuuuultra geil fuuuuck. holy moly god's song ishc au de hammer. es zieht eim so ine. finds super. FÖFI.

WIEDER NEWMAN sail away isch hueere schön! lonely at the top ischmer chli zu amerikanisch falls das sinn macht james bond bassline e isch reecht es sanfts album bis jz und iwie bini au gad ide stimmig defür memo to my son isch iwie no cool und herzig und hört denn eifach uuf hahaha iwie komisch so churz joo mengisch chli sehr ballade/klavier lastig nach mim gschmack aber trz au es megaa schöns album

Ever watched Toy Story, enjoyed the music, and thought "what if I could listen to a whole album of this?". No? Ne neither. It's fine but mostly saccharine but also a bit odd

Amazing, classic american singer songwriter, just great songs one after another. Political Science is worth the price of admission alone. It's so fun seeing the strains of what would become some of the most famous movie songs of all time in the future.

My favorite Randy Newman album

Randy Newman is always a surprise because it's like "the Toy Story guy?" Damn

Amazing album, so many bangers and hits I never knew ALL came frok this single album?! Amazing. So much soul, so much passion. Such raw grooves. Love it.

I don't often watch Disney movies by choice, and I won't listen to this album by choice. Hard to pinpoint why, because there is good songwriting here. I suppose it's too samey and "not my thing". I think it's the sort of predictable instrumentation I don't like (and what makes it all sound Disney). Oh and the cabaret-esque songs I really don't like. In fact, only Tom Waits does cabaret well in my book :-). I learned that You Can Leave Your Hat on is a Newman song, and not a Joe Cocker Song. Kudos to Newman and Cocker sinks deeper. I'll say, it's a three. Could be a 4 if I just liked it better.

I wasn't pulled in immediately, but by the end I felt I understood what he was trying to do. I like his approach to songwriting and the way the quality of his voice suits the songs. I think Old Man is really the gem, but some of the other tracks could grow on me with further listening.

No randy no

not my vibe but can see why people might like it

I weirdly mostly liked this? "Lonely at the Top" and "Political Science" were my faves on here.

Faves: Political Science

Is this a musical or an album. First track is decent but the rest is pretty schmaltzy.

What a great satirist! I had to replay a few of the songs because I didn’t want to miss a single lyric. Really enjoyed this one!

Балдёж 100/100 Ещё и саунд к диснеевским мультикам

I liked the song about nuking everyone \m/

Hard to take it seriously. Kinda feels like a neo-noir Pixar film...

I was excited when I thought this was going to be Gary Numan.

Lovely story telling with with backing to match. Unfortunately non stick out particularly

Randy is a true American treasure.

I really prefer him in Pixar movies, but this album wasn't bad at all. Just a little too generic for my taste.

I don't really have an opinion about Randy Newman. You know, the guy writes songs, with chords and words and sing it them. What else can I say?

As a frequenter of the subreddit for this project, about a week ago someone posted about getting two Randy Newman albums back to back. My response was “wow I’m 70 percent through this project and have gotten ZERO Randy, guess my final stretch will be Randy heavy!” And lo and behold, about a week later…. I’m a Randy Newman fan. I think important to understanding him is that “Randy Newman” is kind of a character. He writes through a thick layer of irony and satire, and while these aren’t particularly “comedy” songs, he very often is trying to convey a double meaning in his work. He often comments on “traditional” American life, ie, the hypocrisy of White Christians, by writing songs that sound like they’re celebrating him, but he’ll just have one or two little turns of phrase that give way to his real feelings. I think his voice is great, idiosyncratic and unmatched, and the musicianship is second to none. If I had one nitpick for an album I really love, it’d be that I wish some of the songs were longer, but that’s simply not his style. He gets in, hits his point, and gets out. They’re brief impressions. Newman is one of the greatest American songwriters of our age, and it was a delight to listen to this.

Listening to one of his albums has actually been a thing that has fascinated me in the back of my mind for years now, the fact that the guy behind ‘you’ve got a friend in me’ had an earlier career of writing notoriously controversial music sadly it’s just okay

Songwriting is ok but I do not like his voice.

'I saw a vampire / I saw a ghost / Everybody scared me / But you scared me the most.' Newman writes baroque & ironic pop standards, vocally as far from Scott Walker or Tom Waits as you can be but likewise addicted to the potential of show tunes in blues-soaked America. Lyrically, treasures really do abound, cleverly, socially, & politically: 'Oh, who would think a boy and bear / Could be well accepted everywhere'; 'They don't respect us, so let's surprise them / We'll drop the big one and pulverize them.' But none of this would remotely work if the man didn't have soul. Yet, he does have soul, & not only a respectful reserve but a bluesy, all-too-human supply ('Old Man,' 'You Can Leave Your Hat On,' 'God's Song'). This is salubrious; it's honest.

I don't got a friend in him.

Well, here we are, my final album. And like Randy Newman, I too will be sailing away. When I told my wife that this was my final album, she started singing the Enya song of the same name, and I attempted to sing that same song in Randy Newman's voice. It went poorly. I just reviewed Randy Newman's Good Old Boys a few days ago, and I enjoyed it, so I'm assuming that I'll enjoy this album too. I didn’t enjoy Sail Away as much as I enjoyed Good Old Boys, but I thought it was a pretty good album. Just like Good Old Boys, this album had some really great arrangements; the piano playing and strings were particularly good. The best thing about this album though was the biting satire and sarcasm of the lyrics. Despite this album not being the type of thing that’s really up my alley, I can’t deny that Randy Newman is incredibly talented as both an arranger and a lyricist. If you would have made me listen to this album right after I watched Toy Story in 1995, I would have probably descended into a dissociative state. When it comes to this albums shortcomings, I wished there had been a throughline connecting all of the songs, like there had been on Good Old Boys. The songs were good, but the thematic shifts from song to song didn’t work for me that well. On top of that, some of the songs were just okay musically, while others were really great. Lyrically, “Sail Away,” “He Gives Us All His Love,” “Political Science,” and “God’s Song” were the best of the bunch. “Political Science” was probably my favorite of those songs, because as we watch the shitty Trump administration stab our allies in the back, this song still feels incredibly relevant. Musically, though, the title track stood out the most to me. I really loved how beautiful the piano and strings were. Even though Sail Away was pretty middle of the road to me, I thought it was a fun and apt way to wrap up this project. What an absolute blast these last few years have been!

It was a pleasant album. I did not realize all the sound tracks Randy Newman had done.

кул😎

This was alright, just hearing his voice gives you Toy Story vibes.

Talvez eu tenha que ouvir de novo com mais atenção, paciência e interesse. You can leave your hat on!

It is hard to get past the success of Toy Story. This album sounds like a collection of sad Toy Story songs and happy Toy Story songs.

I don't have patience for this guy right now.

This is the kind of thing you expect from Randy Newman, and to the extent I like that kind of thing I liked this. He likes to describe little vignettes of American cities in a nostalgic way like Springsteen can do that's not sugar-coating. His real strength is in creating an intimacy with the listener thru his spare instrumentation and a feeling like he's working out the lyrics and melody in front of you.

I think I'm just grumpy this week.

I'll be the first to say I'm not really a Randy Newman fan. Sure we love the Toy Story stuff and Short People, but never really gave much thought to him otherwise. This album does offer more tender-hearted offerings; sad at points. What I love about this album is that it does not overstay its welcome. There are twelve songs? I think (depending on the version) and they all stop when they need to. They are like Randy just sat and sang out journal or creative writing entries he was going to write for the day. It worked surprisingly well. Biggest Hit - Sail Away Biggest Miss (if I had to choose) - Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear Underrated Gem - He Gives Us All His Love

You gotta give it to Randy, he is distinctive and he does what he does aimed a specific type of listener. That listener group does not include me. His piano centered music lies somewhere on the spectrum between Billy Joel and Elton John but with a bigger debt to the 40s and 50s than either of those dudes. Much of this record I would expect to hear in a theater as songs from a play. Show tunes for a generation of individuals who would still go to live theater. See a performance. For me, Last Night I Had A Dream centers the record. Catchy orchestral pop that is catchy with just enough of an edge to not grow tiresome. It is certainly a notch up from Billy Joel but only because the lyrics capture the music and every song has a distinct direction sung by Randy. It’s not an album Randy is known for because I’m pretty positive I Love LA and Short People are the only songs anyone recalls in this century. So, it boils down to this - would my life be different not hearing this? Not a fucking chance. 3/5

There might be a day when I listen to this album and I get that light bulb moment of why it is so highly regarded, but I doubt it. There's a bit of charm I suppose, but so much of this is so awkward. I liked the opening song, but I quickly tired of the soundtrack style. Songs like Simon Smith... and Old Man just abruptly stop, while Memo To My Son and Let It Shine seem to fade out half way through. You Can Leave Your Hat on is a great song, but not with Randy's nasal style - he sounds bored! It's just so massively unsatisfying and a trawl to get through, even though it's barely 3 quarters of an hour long. 1 star. Next.

Sail Away makes for a solid, emotional album premiere. Very pretty strings. And Lonely at the Top, a clarinet- and brass-heavy tune reminiscent of old-fashioned detective mystery, is a good follow-up. The songs get slightly weaker from that point onward. I think Newman would agree with me that his music doesn't exactly push any musical boundaries – which is perhaps sinful for any 70s inclusion on this list. And 1972 is one of the most competitive years of the lot. You're telling me Sail Away is up there with Ziggy Stardust, Exile On Main Street, Close To The Edge, Talking Book, Honky Chateau? Sure, it's fine – nice pretty arrangements, decent musicianship, very inoffensive to the ear – but it's not "top 1001 albums of all time", you hear? Newman's vocal has always come across as a bit derivative of older blues singers. (He's not the only white guy to do this. Robert Plant and Billy Joel (circa New York State Of Mind) are two others that come to mind.) Contrary to the top-voted review, he does not sound like an inflatable bear with a slow leak or like Satan talking after inhaling helium. If he did, he'd be be a heck of a lot more notable and controversial. But he's nothing revolutionary either. Every song showcases a nice bluesy, soulful, countryish flavour of vocal, better than any drunken factory worker at karaoke night (but not *much* better). And for that reason, nearly every song is pretty dang enjoyable. Memo to My Son is the only track that doesn't pass, and that's because of boring songwriting, not Newman's strange timbre. Others are well-written and catchy: You Can Leave Your Hat On and Political Science are way more upbeat and memorable than they have any business being. Not influential enough to warrant 5 stars, even if it did pave the way for some excellent movie soundtracks in the 90s. 3/5 Key tracks: Sail Away, Lonely at the Top, Political Science

i mean it was fine, felt quite nostalgic in a way? doesn’t really mean it was good though.

I was hoping I'd love this but for the most part I just liked it. OH WELL!! I don't know if this is sacrilegious but I kinda wish the arrangements had more variation. I liked the songs where there was more going on. Maybe this'll grow on me.

Newman is a too often forgotten American songwriting treasure! I'm very happy to see him on this list, which has for some reason completely ignored a similarly talented and playful contemporary of his: Warren Zevon.

Great Songs: Good Songs: Last Night I Had a Dream, Old Man, Mid Songs: Lonely at the Top, He Gives Us All His Love, Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear, Political Science, Burn On, Memo to My Son, Dayton, Ohio - 1903, You Can Leave Your Hat On, God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind) Bad Songs:

Good shit 👍🏼

I'll be honest, I'm not sure if I actually like Randy Newman or if I'm just being ironic?

I know he’s a legend, considering the Toy story soundtracks, but this album is such a fucking snooze fest

Great writing, but the minimal bluesy sound gets old pretty quick.

respectfully not listening to this

sail away--oh hmm ok. this is slow. a 2:53 song has never felt so long. lonely at the top--this is a polka vibe, love that. still slow. pokey lafarge has definitely heard this song. he gives us all his love--still slow. jesus song. last night i had a dream--ope there's a single fast beat, back to slow. i need to actually listen to this album for its musicality simon smith and his dancing bear--ahh sad boi circus music? old man--i'm starting to get a temp on randy newman: sad slow emotional music, where the lyrics express a range of emotions across songs but musically, vocally, rhythmically, etc. they all sound the same. political science--ok maybe that's not right; this song is the most upbeat so far. but what in the world is this song??? "boom goes london, boom goes paris..." ah love some good old fashioned cultural american imperialism singing about... nuking everyone???? wait what?!?! burn on--cleveland, ohio, that perennial subject of song and verse. memo to my son-- dayton, ohio--dayton, ohio, that perennial subject of song and verse. you can leave your hat on-- G-d's song (that's why i love mankind)--is this a prayer for G-d to leave people alone? idk 1/5. this album is painfully slow.

Great songwriting and arranging.

One is enough and it’s neither of the two we’ve seen this week.

Short People got no friends, short people got no friends in need...sail away, sail away, sail away..Hoagy Carmichael's got a friend in need..

It's only a few days since I reviewed Randy Newman's Good Old Boys, and it is pretty clear that Randy really only writes one song. It's a pretty good song and Sail Away, the title track, is a pretty good an example of his oeuvre. Deceptively tuneful, seemingly beautiful, with a heart of darkness lurking beneath the surface. Some observations: - Sail Away is a pretty sharp recognition of the cognitive dissonance between the idealised dream of America and the reality of white supremacy, horribly manifested as chattel slavery. Newman is unafraid to call out the racist nightmare behind American history (see also: Good old Boys) - Political Science sounds a whole lot like Trump's current foreign policy. The satire doesn't really feel that funny anymore. It feels true. A victim of Poe's Law? - I really like his string/orchestral arrangements. They are sophisticated and subtle, tasty without drawing too much attention to themselves. You can tell that the family trade was soundtrack composition. At the end of the day, however, you don't need more than one Randy Newman record. You can pick this one or Good old Boys, it doesn't make much difference.

Un album vraiment sympa, j'ai seulement pas compris pourquoi est ce qu'on appelait ça du rock mais sinon c'était vraiment agréable à écouter et la personnalité de Randy Newman embellit vralment l'album

Good when you're in the mood. Funny, insightful lyrics abound. But it is a bit same-y sounding throughout. And that voice! Too nasal, too thin. He sounds like a Muppet on helium sometimes. It's hard to rate because the music is fine enough, nothing crazy. The songwriting and lyrics are great and often hook-y. Just hard to listen to too much because his voice can be irritating. Guess I'll put this squarely in the 3-zone and move on.

Wasn't so bothered about it.

Who knew I would be enjoying a Randy Newman album as much as I did here. When I saw it next I rolled my eyes, considering how eagerly he dropped a racial slur in the last one we got. Could he really have TWO albums that belonged on this list? Short answer, yes. Man, what a good songwriter Randy is. He really paints a picture with every song and really plays in the space he has. His manner of singing would usually shut me right off (much like Bob Dylan) but damn he makes it work for him here. This makes me want to give Cop Rock a chance again. I'm sure I'll regret it but dammit Randy you got me wanting more.

I really dig this Randy Newman album and he doesn’t even say the N word on it

I wish these songs had more of a chorus.

Randy has such a unique voice, definitely picture Toy Story as soon as you hear him! The first side of this album is sooo good, one song that is meh. The second song has a couple great ones and a few that weren't as good. Overall a good piano rock album by a witty songwriter with a warm singing style most are familiar with.

3.5 - pretty good

This feels harsh, because I like Randy Newman, but I didn't really enjoy this. I like listening to a Randy Newman song, but a full album is too much

Vrij saai. Niet zo'n fijne stem

This album sounds like it's going to tell me to "cheer up, love, it might never happen".

3.5. Political Science and Leave Your Hat On bump it up.

Enjoyed the lyrics especially. Very sardonic, often funny. Still relevant in many ways.

2+ Stars (6/15)

Randy Newman is most famous for people from my generation (either the youngest millennials or the oldest zoomers) for his work in film scores, particularly for Pixar; I'll readily admit this is the first time I've taken a serious dive into any of his early work that actually put him on the map; this is definitely no lightweight, "You've Got a Friend in Me" type of romp! Newman's early work is famous for its use of dark, sarcastic humor to prove points that are often the opposite of what the songs appear to be about on the surface. for instance, the cuts that seem to be odes to a higher power ("He Gives Us All His Love" and "God's Song") are actually bitter condemnations of the idea of religious faith itself; and the political numbers ("Sail Away", "Political Science" etc.) appear to promote American patriotism, but quickly reveal themselves to be takedowns of jingoism, xenophobia and imperialist violence. many of these tracks are only around two minutes (or even less!), but they feel so complete as statements on the world at large. the orchestral arrangements on these 12 tracks are also to die for! there's a real Tin Pan Alley/early Broadway quality to this record that I find very alluring, from Newman's piano playing all the way to the strings and brass. i especially like the dissonant notes thrown into the texture on "Old Man", an especially dark number that sees an atheist son saying a final goodbye to his dying atheist father, whom nobody else came to see in his final days alive. light 8/10.

He writes good stuff, but not fan of his singing.

My billion dollar product pitch: a Randy Newman tear-off calendar, with a new musical vignette to go with your morning coffee, the whole year round. It will give those gloomy headlines you'll be scrolling through on your phone a certain almost cinematic sense of irony, making them that much easier to swallow.

I had no idea the guy from the Toy Story theme wrote Simon Smith And The Amazing Dancing Bear, or You Can Leave Your Hat On. There no song on here over 3½ minutes and some are under 2 minutes. He doesn't muck about with bloat does he! Bravo. The voice isn't technically the best but it delivers a great collection of songs.

Randy Newman is a respected and historically important songwriter, I just don’t find myself that compelled by the material. There are some good songs on this album, and they are recorded well, but nothing really grabbed me.

So very American but I like this one. Yes his voice isn’t the best but it works for his style. Some of the songs get me a bit emotional and the lyrics are clever. 4 stars

As good as people think Bob Dylan is. Simple, interesting, lyrically colorful. Nostalgic Americana without being campy.

oh that guy, yes but no

I came to this album with the idea that I like Randy Newman, but all his songs sound the same. This album blew that assumption out of the water. While he certainly has a style that is instantly recognizable, there’s a lot of musical range on this record. In previously knew “Political Science” (which feels a bit too real in 2026) but on this listen I loved tracks like “Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear” or “Dayton, Ohio” that seemed like they could’ve been at home in a 1920s jazzy saloon.

I like Zevon better

Where's all the stuff about Buzz Lightyear and Lightning McQueen? And when did Pixar start making movies about the children of Israel?

A mix of show tunes, pop and light rock from the singing voice of Toy Story. Not heard before but very Randy Newman and its easy to see how he got to do some many soundtracks.

I'm only familiar with Randy Newman's hits, like "You've Got a Friend In ME," "I Love LA," and "Short People." None of which I dislike, they're just out there in the world not doing too much. Then I hear this and it kind of blew my mind. Surprisingly eclectic, fun, philosophical, and funny. It's not rock, so maybe that's why Randy Newman was never on my radar. What a great collection of songs though. I'll listen to this again.

Randy Newman oli minulle tuttu vain Toy Storysta. Sail Away on aika hyvä levy, mutta jos haluan kuulla pianovetoista pop rockia 70-luvulta, niin valitsen mieluummin Billy Joelin tai Elton Johnin.

YOu'vE Got A fiREnd In mE

Randy Newman seems to catch a lot of hate, but this really wasn’t a terrible album. His songwriting is sharp, and the humor comes through pretty clearly if you’re paying attention. His voice can just be hard to get past. The title track was the highlight for me. The tongue in cheek delivery is really well done, and it’s one of those songs where the sarcasm sneaks up on you. It didn’t totally win me over, but it was better than I expected.

Not a big fan of his singing voice. It's all good musically, but an acquired taste I guess. Joe Cocker's version of You can leave your hat on is so much better.

Solid album all the way through.

Now this was a good listen. Better songwriting for me than the Cat Stephens album. Don’t mind the orchestration/ ragtime pop as the lyrics cut through

Hard to get into as it's generally quite one paced and difficult to listen to his voice. Interesting lyrically though and also didn't know he did the original of Leave Your Hat On. Suspect it could get up to a 3 if i listened more

Didnt get into this one as much as the earlier Randy. There are a couple of songs on here that I think Nilsson crooned better, so I cannae really go above a 3 here.

Some nice tunes, some fun tunes, some plodding mediocrity amongst some nice storytelling. The final track, God’s song was the standout. This one didn’t really float my boat.

Thoughts before listening: Randy Newman is fun. Catchy little piano led songs with the lyrics often being the star of the show. Funny, poignant, witty songs with often biting social commentary. He's a joy to listen to. Review: Yeah...this is great. I described it well in my intro, just an interesting listen all around. There is a little more rock here than I was expecting, which was a welcome sound, but ultimately this is the typical jazzy, piano led ditties that are Randy's claim to fame. This is probably something I wouldn't have really appreciated when I was younger, but the older I get the more I can enjoy just a simple, well written song...which Randy had plenty of on this album. I'm glad to hear this today. 4-stars

was fun at times but why are we singing about the us bombing the world

i did listen but don’t really remember

This was okay. Not anything astonishing for me. The story telling was good and I enjoyed the mainly piano music. But don’t think I would listen again.

Didn't really enjoy this. Found it plodding and dull. Sub-Bob Dylan easy listening mass market fodder.

Before Toy Story and all the other work on other films later in Randy Newman's career, he was actually seen as quite a respectable Piano Rock musician that knew how to write a good comedic song with the perfect amount of parody sprinkled all over. I wouldn't call Sail Away a remarkable album by any means, but it is a very interesting insight into one of the most wordy musicians of his time and how he works. Personally I didn't mind anything on this album but it feels like it forgets it has 12 songs because some of them are under 2 minutes in total length and just get swallowed by all the bigger tracks around them. This album is pretty forgettable once you finish it up and I really wish there could have been a better Randy Newman album picked that showcases a more memorable tracklist from one of the most unsung heros of the world of music.

I have never listened to Randy Newman beyond his songs appearing in films and on TV. In particular, I love the theme tune to Monk, 'It’s a Jungle Out There'. Having never heard "Sail Away" or any other Newman album, my interest was thoroughly piqued. Before diving in, I spent ten minutes researching the record, so I was aware that each song is performed from the perspective of a different character or an 'unreliable narrator'. Sonically, the album is a pleasant and fascinating experience. The arrangements of strings, wind instruments, and piano, combined with Newman’s distinctive voice, hit the ear beautifully. I am not normally one for lyrics, but knowing the subject matter beforehand felt essential. Unless you are paying close attention, the music could easily carry you off without you realising the weight of the lyrics. This track-by-track depth is incredibly interesting, and in some cases, such as 'Political Science', it feels more relevant than ever. The title track is a perfect example too: a soaring 'sales pitch' from a 19th-century slave trader trying to lure Africans onto his ship. Then there is the well-known and much-covered 'You Can Leave Your Hat On', which, in this original form, feels far more predatory and sleazy than the cover versions we are used to. I listened to this album from start to finish three times and genuinely enjoyed it. In terms of a rating, my first listen was a clear four-star experience. However, on subsequent listens, my appreciation deepened as I picked up on the nuances of specific tracks. For now four stars but I'm sure that with repeated listens it will become a firm five star favourite. Side one 1 "Sail Away" (5/5) 2 "Lonely at the Top" (4/5) 3 "He Gives Us All His Love" (4/5) 4 "Last Night I Had a Dream" (4/5) 5 "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear" (4/5) 6 "Old Man" (5/5) Side two 1 "Political Science" (5/5) 2 "Burn On" (4/5) 3 "Memo to My Son" (4/5) 4 "Dayton, Ohio – 1903" (5/5) 5 "You Can Leave Your Hat On" (5/5) 6 "God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)" (4/5) Total - 53 Average - 4.42 214/1001 120/214 albums reviewed were new to me.

Music hall and musical theatre are an obvious influence here, but I think I prefer artists such as Harry Nilsson, Freddy Mercury and Paul McCartney, who also wrote songs in a similar style, better.

Tried the second album just to make sure I didn't like him. I don't get the hype. Is he related to someone in Pixar? How did he get that gig?

Its my fault. All I can hear is Toy Story. I find his voice nasally and his quaint and fuzzy style unpleasant, and then getting hit with 'You can leave your hat on' felt like a hug that goes on inappropriately long with a creepy aunt or uncle.

Not my kind of thing

His voice is so unique. I feel like as this album progressed, I liked more of the sounds. Way better than my expectations for the "you got a friend in me" artist.

I was expecting worse.

Len Houmous once famously said on Jools Holland….’Randy Newman? I wish he would sail away’. His timing was terrible. He was meant to say it to Ken Chutney quietly during Jamie Cullem’s set. Jamie went quiet, Len was heard around the world! That’s the problem with Jazz, very unpredictable! 1.7 13/17 Let It Shine

Anede ikke at leave your hat on ikke var Joe Cockers nummer. Han var ikke langt fra kilden. Fin oplevelse.

Der er noget Tom Waits over Randys vokal. Lidt mindre hæs, men leveringen ligner. Instrumentalt er der mere pop over det end Waits’ jazzede lyd. Alt i alt et interessant og hyggeligt bekendtskab

cheesy as hell

Warm, soothing, and quite charmingly low-key. I found a couple of these songs, including 'he gives us all his love', provoked quite a string emotional reaction. Lovely indeed.

This is a reluctant "3". I found this album distasteful. The songs are subversive but without benefit. Burn On alludes to the Cuyahoga river burning but doesn't actually have much to say.

Such a talent.

Great instrumentation and vocals. Lyrics were okay for me

Very 80's, overall good if you're 55 yo 3/5

good album for a long road trip

i cant take it

Well este é uma vibe bem mais depre amo Sail Away, musica bem biba a america i guess Já estou a gostar da intro da lonely at the top Simon smith and the dancing bear - senti l desepero de atingir as ultimas notas… A old man matou me 🥺🥺 Memo to my son é bem fofa da me vibes disney Dayton ohio, que date fofo ir beber um chazinho CALMA A YOU CAN LEAVE YOUR HAT ON É DELE? este album parece um pouco uma mixórdia… É bem chill vibes Fun fact: o randy newman escreveu bué musicas da disney tipo a icónica youve got a friend in me

You just sing about jesus and drink wine all day, its great to be an american akakakak certo Bue vibes musiquinhas de filmes da disney mesmo o album nao tendo nd a ver c filmes ahahs Oh who woukd think a boy and a bear couls be well accepted everywhere, its just amazing how fair people can be - ok amigo ok Old man: que musica depressiva do caralho ai Political science: ele quer que os americanos dominem o mundo? Akakaksks certo Dayton, Ohio - 1903: esta música deixou me triste pq vivemos num mundo de tecnologia, ganda merda, imagina a paz de viver em ohio em 1903 e ir beber chá num domingo à tarde 😔 gostei desta Vibe fixe no geral mas nd de mais, 3*

Sigh... Can someone tell me why anyone likes Randy Newman? His voice is harsh and gravelly, he constantly reaches out of his register, songs are childish (think "Short People") and clearly fit into a British tradition that was old when he started recording in the 1960s. I mean, just listen to the opening bars of "Lonely at the Top" on this album. It's right out of a 1910s London dance hall, and not even the better part of town. Let's talk about his lyrics. They are best when they are simple, such as in the Toy Story song "You've Got a Friend in Me". Otherwise, they are range from the silly to the hopelessly obscure. Newman seems like one of those "artists" that can fool critics and aficionados into thinking that bad music is somehow "art". This album just highlights this.

Even with a Dayton song, I'm not listening to this on purpose.

Some great songs on here--"Sail Away," "Political Science," "God's Song". The political ones are more relevant than ever. And his theological takes run the full gamut from the hopefol, optimistic "He Gives Us All His Love" to the distant, cold God of "God's Song." Really interesting and thought-provoking lyrics. And then you have "You Can Leave Your Hat On" which is just goofy and fun. An outstanding album from a true American original.

This one is not getting the flowers it deserves, on here at least, so I'm gonna rave about it. Ive loved this record since I first stumbled across it five or six years ago. It's a pretty bizarre one, with no unifying feel or theme, but it showcases Newman's brilliance as a lyricist and composer. Songs run the emotional gamut, from sad (Old Man) to touching (Memo to my Son) to just fucking funny (Political Science, Leave Your Hat On). He also explores deeper themes, like America's filthy slavery origins, and the outlandishness of an omnipotent loving God. He always walks a razor thin line between irony and sincerity, which takes a lot of skill. Whether he's doing serious or pure goofy vaudeville, Randy Newman always does what he wants. He's a consistently unique creator and Sail Away is a gem, one of my favorites

Not terribly exciting but still a good listen

Great voice but boring music

Left foot, right foot. Left foot, right foot.

Very, very good, perfect but not my style.

soothing even if repetitive, but nothing standout for me

Great songwriter but Disney has ruined his voice for me. Felt like a Disney soundtrack but I did like a few songs. Wouldn't mind other artists covering these songs 👀

Poignant lyrics. Old Man was a good one.

Very easy listening, enjoyed from beginning to end. The album had a light tone that felt upbeat no matter what the song. I quite enjoyed it.

Randy wants to bomb the rest of the world lol (Political Science). Expect Australia. Dude, what the hell. The piano was strong in this one.

Kinda corny, but nothing offensive here. Its aight

Pleasant jams

Never was a huge fan of his...good social commentary but can't listen for long stretches!!

What a great writer.

Respect. A wordsmith. A lot of Disney-esque music but always happy and loving.

Just wish he wrote more songs about short people.

Randy Newman is a really good songwriter with unique vocals and a pop/folksy style. I will not, however, forgive him for writing Short People. Minus a star for that.

It was alright but not great.

I don't know why, I just really like Randy Newman.

A Randy le conocemos por tres cosas: las bandas sonoras de Disney (Tiana y el sapo, es sin duda mi favorita), I Think It's Going to Rain Today y You can leave your hat on (incluida en este álbum). Solo por una de ellas ya merece estar en la lista. Este disco suena muy bien, su voz entre Ray Charles y Cocker (mejora su versión de You can leave your hat on) se maneja de maravilla en su cancionario. Destacan Sail away, He Gives Us All His Love, el ritmo de jazz cabaretero de Political Science y Lonely at the Top (escrita para un Sinatra que nunca la llegó a grabar).

A fine album. Nothing too catchy.

Hit and miss. The tunes are good, lyrics cynically clever, his voice like a turtle with a cold.

Some songs that feel like they could be great. But can't past that hurdy gurdy, dumb dumb voice

Sorry Randy this isn’t for me

Another 3 star experience for me. Some nice songs. But a bit samey. Interesting to put this against all the other stuff that was happening all the time though and it does seem quite progressive

Such a throwback compositionally--was and is anyone (outside of musical theatre writers)--writing songs like this anymore? It's wild how his style remained unchanged from here to Toy Story, etc. Not bad, but I wouldn't pop it on--the Dayton song is a high point for me.

Kósý Randy. Skiptar skoðanir á þessu en ég get alveg fílað þetta. Samt ekkert meira en það.

Allt í lagi. Disneylögin eru skemmtilegri.

I can’t get past Newman’s voice. Good lyrics though. 3/5

01) Sail Away - 7,0 02) Lonely at the Top - 6,5 03) He Gives Us All His Love - 6,0 04) Last Night I Had a Dream - 7,0 05) Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear - 5,5 06) Old Man - 6,0 07) Political Science - 5,5 08) Burn On - 5,5 09) Memo to My Son - 5,5 10) Dayton, Ohio – 1903 - 5,5 11) You Can Leave Your Hat On - 7,5 12) God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind) - 5,5 TOTAL: 6,08 (61/100) Current ranking: 585/759

I didn't dislike it, I rather enjoyed the album. Randy has some other off-the-wall songs (not on this album), but it's so hard to separate his distinctive voice from the hokey Toy Story song!

Helt ok. Æ antar æ burde mene mer og sterkere, men det va liksom stort sett det æ tenkte mens det spilte. Helt ok.

Are we not critical enough to listen beyond the Disney references? Gimme a break. This is a high caliber singer, songwriter and piano album. With the occasional full band accompaniment. Certified white boy contemporary sure, mundane sure, a bit slow sure. But holy moly Randy Newman sure can paint a picture and write a tune to really send it home. I like this album alot. If there is more Newman on the list it should be enjoyable.

Even more enjoyable when I was imagining the lyrics being applied to the lives of toys.

Album 982 of 1089 Sail Away - Randy Newman (1972) Rating : 3.5 / 5 For a lot of people, Newman is “the Toy Story guy,” but long before that era he was already carving out a lane that only he could occupy - a blend of sharp social commentary, dry humor, and melodies that sneak up on you in the best way. What stands out to me on this album is how effortlessly he balances lighthearted delivery with heavier subject matter. Newman has always had a knack for saying something meaningful without ever sounding preachy, and Sail Away is full of those little moments where you realize he’s slipped a message into what sounds, at first, like a simple tune. His writing walks that line between playful and profound, and it’s a big part of what makes him such a unique artist. Add in the warm production, the easygoing arrangements, and his trademark vocal charm, and you get an album that’s both enjoyable on the surface and rewarding if you decide to dig deeper. Newman’s catalog is full of gems, and this one is no exception.

The original You can leave your head in.

I enjoyed this way more than I thought I would as my exposure prior was Pixar work and "I Love LA", he's not the best singer, but has a distinctive tone, but his songwriting is top tier.

Not as bad as the auricular torture found in his endless soundtracks for Disney/Pixar (I hope I die before I hear 'You Got a Friend in Me' again) movies but still a ways away from being anything but sometimes cutesy novelty songs that sound very similar to each other. I'm giving 'Sail Away' two stars (out of five) because when I saw that it was today's album I felt slightly nauseated at the thought of a full album of 'You Got a Friend in Me' stuff and was really happy that it wasn't. Also, I enjoyed Ry Cooder's slide guitar on a couple of numbers and the song 'It's Lonely at the Top' a song originally written for Frank Sinatra but never recorded by the chairman of the board was not without its Hoagy Carmichael-esq charms.

Newman has a unique voice that is almost comical in a way good songwriter

I listened it to it once and it was enjoyable enough, but nothing outstanding. Only one song really stood out (political science). I felt it was pretty bland and generic but that it needed another listen. Second listen, I kind of felt the same. It almost grabbed my attention, but did not quite. Notable songs were Political Science and last night I had a dream. 3 stars

Rubbish Toy Story man

I've listened to multiple of them, but I really don't care for Randy Newman albums. The songwriting is obviously there and he's had some good successes, but his own performances of songs feel way too lifeless for me. His singing sounds very dull to me and is accompanied by little more than just his Piano. It's hard to really enjoy, there's a lot of songs but all of them just blend into one forgettable soup because of how similar the sound is on all of them. I tend to prefer beat over lyrics and this just has no punch.

He can write a mean lyric. Can't sing them though.

I grew up with Toy Story, so until today, the Disney stuff was the only thing I had listened to by him. This is not bad. I wouldn't listen to it again, but it was enjoyable. However, it's funny to hear the same guy who sang "You've Got a Friend in Me" sing about dropping nukes on Europe.

Oh I know this guy. Was unaware of his original stuff. I mean I guess "you've got a friend in me" is still an original. I am going to guess just about anything that he puts it out is good.

Felt like listening to a Pixar movie soundtrack, which is no bad thing

### **In-Depth Review: *Sail Away* by Randy Newman** **Released:** 1972 **Genre:** Orchestral pop, satirical singer-songwriter **Producer:** Lenny Waronker, Russ Titelman --- ## 🎼 **Music & Production** Randy Newman’s *Sail Away* is a masterclass in understated elegance. The album blends lush orchestration with New Orleans-tinged piano and ragtime rhythms, creating a sound that feels both timeless and cinematic. The production is clean and uncluttered, centering Newman’s piano and distinctive voice, with tasteful contributions from musicians like Ry Cooder on slide guitar . The arrangements are deceptively simple, often sounding like Broadway tunes for people who don’t like Broadway. Yet beneath the surface lies a sophisticated orchestral pop sensibility that complements the lyrical content perfectly . --- ## 🖋️ **Lyrics & Themes** Newman’s songwriting on *Sail Away* is biting, ironic, and often devastating. The album is a satirical takedown of American exceptionalism, nationalism, religion, and human folly. His characters are unreliable narrators—salesmen, politicians, fathers, and God himself—each revealing more about their flaws than they intend. - **“Sail Away”**: A hauntingly beautiful song that lures listeners in with a gentle melody, only to reveal itself as a slave trader’s pitch to Africans, promising a better life in America. It’s one of the most chillingly effective anti-American songs ever written . - **“Political Science”**: A darkly comic critique of U.S. foreign policy, where the narrator suggests bombing the rest of the world because “no one likes us.” It’s absurd, sharp, and eerily prescient . - **“God’s Song (That’s Why I Love Mankind)”**: A devastating satire where God mocks humanity for continuing to believe in him despite all evidence to the contrary. It’s both hilarious and horrifying . - **“Memo to My Son”**: A tender, funny, and relatable song about fatherhood, filled with clichés and love. It shows Newman’s softer, more personal side . --- ## 🌟 **Influence & Legacy** Though not a commercial blockbuster, *Sail Away* is widely regarded as one of Newman’s finest works and a cornerstone of 1970s singer-songwriter artistry. Its influence can be felt in the work of artists like Tom Waits, Elvis Costello, and even modern satirists like Father John Misty. The album helped cement Newman’s reputation as a songwriter’s songwriter—clever, cynical, and emotionally resonant. --- ## ✅ **Pros** - **Brilliant lyrical satire**: Newman’s ability to write from the perspective of flawed characters is unmatched. - **Melodic beauty**: The melodies are lush, catchy, and emotionally rich. - **Timeless themes**: The album’s critique of nationalism, religion, and human nature still feels relevant. - **Cinematic production**: The orchestral arrangements enhance the storytelling without overwhelming it. - **Emotional range**: From biting satire to touching sincerity, the album covers a wide emotional spectrum. --- ## ❌ **Cons** - **Vocal delivery**: Newman’s voice is polarizing—nasal, slurred, and often described as sounding like “a drunk guy singing to himself at a urinal” . For some, it’s charming; for others, it’s a dealbreaker. - **Repetitive style**: The musical palette is relatively narrow, and some listeners may find the songs too similar in tone and structure. - **Satire fatigue**: The constant irony and cynicism can feel emotionally distant or even smug to some listeners. - **Not immediately accessible**: The layered meanings and subtle arrangements may take multiple listens to fully appreciate. --- ## 🎯 **Final Thoughts** *Sail Away* is a landmark album in American songwriting. It’s a work of genius that rewards close listening and intellectual engagement. While Newman’s voice and style may not be for everyone, the album’s lyrical brilliance, melodic craftsmanship, and thematic depth make it essential listening for fans of smart, subversive pop music. **Rating:** *9/10* – A satirical masterpiece wrapped in beautiful melodies.

This goofy soulful man was singing Disney songs before singing Disney songs. 6/10

Never really enjoyed this guy. I kinda feel like he has a learning disability, producing music and lyrics that are childish and theatrical. He’s found success there, probably with a ton of help. Can’t help being reminded of my kids’ second grade music recitals, ie a bunch of retards blowing on recorders for adoring parents. Good times.

Ja jako volim ramdya newma a iako ga ne slušam dovoljno

Randy Newman has the voice of a disaffected Muppet and, based on this album of 2-3min songs, the attention span of one as well. Some of the songs barely even get going before they’re over, and that makes this feel more like an album of demos… even though many of these songs had already been recorded by Randy and/or other musicians before this record. Some of the songs would feel a little depressing if it wasn’t for (1) that muppet voice, (2) the fact that the song ends before the despair sets in, and (3) the next track starts with a circus rhythm. It’s so unintentionally whimsical (and sarcastic) that it’s hard to hate. Randy Newman and Tom Waits exist on opposite ends of the same spectrum, and I’m a fan of that spectrum. I’m “as happy as a monkey in a monkey tree”.

It was good, but dull

Awesome Newman!

A little cheesy for my tastes but great arrangements and storytelling

Man what the hell was this

3.8/5 Contrary to many people, I actually like this album. Randy Newman is so much more than just his "You Can Leave Your Head On". He brings a sarcasm and cynicism to his songs with some heavy criticism towards the US which is always cool to see if done right. It kinda makes his music predestined to be featured in a Fallout game (which is a good thing). Apart from that, the whole "Sail Away"-album is not bad at all. Given that I've also placed it in my personal Top albums playlist about the 1001 challenge, I'm happy to rate it accordingly.

The super slow songs (especially the ones about God and/or America) are just annoying, but the other songs are undeniably great. Textbook songwriting, fantastic melodies, lots of variety, and Randy's great voice. 3.5/5.0: Very Good

mostly enjoyed this one. i quite enjoy the satirical songs but the more seemingly earnest songs didnt land as well

Smooth sounding, and somewhat enjoyable to listen.

Although I admire Randy Newman...he isn't my thing and I found this album hard going...

Just associate him with TV

Singer-songwriter without the singer and the songwriter. At least it kept me entertained I guess.

Ce gars là me fait vraiment penser à un pianiste qui rêvait d'une grande carrière internationale mais qui n'a jamais eu assez de talent ni d'audace pour jouer ailleurs que les mercredis soirs au bar L'Étalon sur Dagenais Ouest. J'en pleure de pitié.

Dude sounded like he got shit faced drunk and decided it was a good time to sing. No thanks!

Sail away hits haaaarrrrdddddd.

I found this album to be pretty good. The songwriting is clever. Sharp political comedy disguised by it's easy listening style. You do have to listen closely to appreciate the wit. Otherwise it's kind of just solid easy listening. So while it's pleasant, nothing really jumped out at me. Still, this was a pleasant, enjoyable listen.

Somehow... these songs did not age well.. and I hate the honky-tonk music!

He is just one of those unique artists that has a sound of their own. The album is a great example of his style and is so playful. It’s good, but I can see why some people don’t like it. 3.5/5 Probably will listen again

Offensive and exploitative. This album was worse than boring; it was irritating. Randy Newman does not actually sound like that. He changed his vocal style to sound more like black American jazz artists who actually had talent. A shameless rip off which has no place on this list. I know it’s not the 1001 best albums; it’s a list of albums which influenced and inspired. The presence of this album on the list is a travesty and an insult to the music he is copying. A disgrace.

Yeah it was alright

wow .. could listen to Randy Newman all day

Its hard to objectively review the You Got a Friend In Me guy but I tried Its no bad

his voice is good but each song just reminds me of toy story because his voice is so distinct, i enjoyed the tracks tho

Good stuff here, the family guy skit ruined me though

Fun album. Sail Away is a banger.

Good listen. Didn’t know a few of those songs were originally his since they were covered so well.

Preciso sempre ler as letras porque não entendo o sotaque do malandro. Boas músicas em um álbum curtinho.

Enjoyable. Some fun and cool songs.

Some good, classic Randy Newman. I always forget he's the original writer of Leave Your Hat On. Others have done it sexier, but there's something very humorous about his version. 3.5/5

I liked this. I don't care too much about how Randy Newman sings but the rest is pretty great. The lyrics are good and some of the songs surprised me because I was expecting just like piano ballad type things and there was more diversity than that. 3.49/5

sympa, j'ai bien travaille en l'ecoutant 3

Never listened to much Randy Newman outside of his soundtrack work. Whilst I think Newman is a pretty talented songwriter - and there are some great arrangements here as well - his delivery doesn't always work for me. That said it starts pretty strong, with Last Night I Had A Dream being a highlight.

I like some of the songs a lot, but as an album it's not got anything that stands out. I liked it, I could be convinced to give it a 4. 3.4

His campy delivery has never made me want to listen to him. There's music here, I just don't really care for it.

Toy story guy sings other songs. Admittedly some good ones.

Good album. Randy has a soulful sound that is calming.

Randy Newman’s 𝘚𝘢𝘪𝘭 𝘈𝘸𝘢𝘺 is clever, biting, and beautifully arranged, but it’s also an album that’s easier to admire than to love. Newman’s cynical wit and theatrical delivery shine in tracks like the deceptively sweet title song and the sardonic 𝘗𝘰𝘭𝘪𝘵𝘪𝘤𝘢𝘭 𝘚𝘤𝘪𝘦𝘯𝘤𝘦. The lush orchestrations give the record a timeless sophistication, yet the detached irony can make it feel emotionally distant. It’s smart, sharp, and uniquely Newman — but not always engaging beyond the craft.

Nice songs but too much all in one go

Very relaxed listen, but gets anoyning after a 2nd or 3rd listen.