Reviews (page 3 of 8)
just a bunch of noise
I don't think I like Sonic Youth
Strange music. Not impressed.
me encantan las guitarras, bastante oscuro, no es mi estilo but good
I’m at a point in my generator journey where I am having trouble articulating my thoughts, and that’s doubly true when it comes to these iconic bands like Sonic Youth. I’m just in awe of their achievement, reveling in their influence on everyone, a little drunk on their sound, and don’t feel able to objectively rank anything. Maybe once I’ve heard all their albums on the list I’ll feel differently about this one, but for now it’s another five.
I've been meaning to listen to Sonic Youth some more. I really liked this one.
I’m torn between a 3 and 4. I enjoyed it.
Schizophrenia 4 (I Got A) Catholic Block 3.8 Beauty Lies in the Eye 3.4 Stereo Sanctity 3.7 Pipeline/Kill Time 3.7 Tuff Gnarl 3.3 Pacific Coast Highway 3.8 Hot Wire My Heart 3.5 Kotton Krown 3.5 White Kross 3.2 Score: 3.59
I guess you had to be there
Pretty rough but ok for early in their career and the state of music in the 80s. Not nearly as good as Goo imo, which I saw 5 days ago!
Superior to EVOL, more focused than Daydream Nation, but less accomplished than Goo
More sonic youth?! I tolerated more than other albums of theirs, but still did not enjoy it. 2*
Non-stop brilliant. As if from an adjacent planet--you think you recognize the life-forms: all the same parts are there, but they're a little tweaked.
It’s fine as noise goes.
God, these guys were so good. When they're at their best (as they are here), they're using a totally different musical language than every other artist. It's not easy making noise sound this good. I've tried. The guitar interplay is mind-boggling. I think this might be their best album.
When I first hit play I thought “oh maybe I have misjudged Sonic Youth all these years.” No Noise
I’ve listened to two prior albums that were just hard tunisian to and rated poorly but this album mane was more polished later n their career …
Not the best SY album but still no bad
I'm a big fan of later Sonic Youth records but I'd never listened to this before today. It's not great. Mostly it sounds like typical late 70s / early 80s rock with a sprinkling of extra distortion and atonal weirdness. Sonic Youth have done much, much better work in my opinion.
not for me
Jamais écouté avant. Un album en avance sur son temps, où Sonic Youth trouve le subtil équilibre entre expérimentations bruitistes et structures mélodiques alternatives. Même la production un peu crado colle parfaitement au projet. Top : Stereo Sanctity Flop : Cotton Crown
I can appreciate where this stands in the history of music and the intent. But it doesn't make for an enjoyable listen.
Yeah, no. I tried. It's not offensive, but I do not understand what all the fuss was about. I don't hear this as early grunge; I hear it as that last ingredient that gave grunge its je ne sais quoi. The very long list of artists that cite this as a pivotal influence cannot be ignored, and you really should listen to one Sonic Youth album before you die, but the correct answer is Daydream Nation. Influence 4. Quality 3. Hits 1. Intangibles 3. Not my bag, baby 2.
This just didn’t really catch on with me, and wasn’t my jam. It had some interesting sounds, but for the most part it was a little bit too artsy or experimental-feeling for me to fully enjoy.
More Sonic Youth. All I can do is shake my head. It just sounds bad to me. Awful unmusical instrumentation, terrible singing, stupid lyrics
This band is not bad but they do not deserve 5 albums on this list..
I think I listened to this at the wrong time because I was trying to study and this didn't help. Still, it wasn't too bad. I'm never really sure what to think of Sonic Youth because on the one hand I like the noise and the chaos but other times, like today, it starts to annoy me. I think this album, and more of Sonic Youth as well, deserves a relisten when I do not have other things on my mind.
Their fourth album. Indie Rock / Alt Rock. Thankfully it wasn't all Hair Metal and slow motion high kicks in spandex during the 80s. There was a more ominous flip side under the veneer of all that 80s gloss and this album is part of that. The album broods along oppressively in it's tone and tackles some darker themes. I thought it was good without being blown away.
medio medio no me gusto demasiado 6 de 10
A friend made me borrow this in my 20s. I listened to it two or three times to make sure I gave it a fair shot. I am dreading the third or fourth, and probably final, listen today. I once saw Sonic Youth open for Pearl Jam and they were sincerely a top 5 worst band I've ever seen. A lot of this is Kim Gordon's fault. I hate her voice and her delivery and her lyrics, though i guess part of the latter could be Thurston's fault. He certainly isn't blameless. Catholic Block isn't "better" than Beauty Lies in the Eye, just differently bad. Some of this could be OK. Like, I like lots of the music this directly influenced. I'm not angry at the dischord of the music, though certainly there are moments that are just noise to me. It's not even dumb song names like Tuff Gnarl and Master-Dik, either of which could have been a Pavement or Pixies title. It's that Pacific Coast Highway is indelible in my head from those first listens as sounding like the definition of drug addiction, with Gordon moaning less angry than bored, atonal at best, tranqed animal at worst. Thurston tends to just bark meaningless words over his squonking. Kim is intentional in her unlistenability. If I had to hear one of these songs again, and I'd prefer not to, i'd probably go for Pipeline/Kill Time. 2*, but make no mistake, we are rounding up to get to 2.
When I think of Sonic Youth I think musical exploration over hooks and melody. This album is definitely in that vein. Well performed and conceptually cool, though not something I would go out of my way to listen to.
Left a really positive first impression. The noise and punk elements created a dark intensity that I’ll be excited to return to. 1 listen Favorite Track: Schizophrenia
Expectation: -> 1987 and a recognizable name has me optimistic. After listening: -> This isn't my jam. No track stood out for me so I didn't make a track ranking. Looking forward to tomorrow.
I really liked this one. I have been meaning to listen to more Sonic Youth, I'm glad I did. This was close to a 5 for me.
I’ve liked other albums like Goo wayyyyy more. This one was kinda discordant and freaky more than it was fun and interesting
Given what I’ve heard (on alternative/modern rock radio over the years) and know (Kim Gordon is a rock icon) about Sonic Youth, I really thought I would like this album more. (This is the first Sonic Youth album I’ve listened to in its entirety.) Perhaps those songs I like are on later albums. Didn’t dislike it too much, but I doubt I’ll ever come back to this one again. 2.49 stars
An album I can respect for its influence and intent, even if its wiry noise-rock edge isn’t something I’d reach for often.
I just don’t like this
This was not good.
Haven't listened to this one start to finish in a minute. Full frontal Sonic Youth!
Yet another solid entry in Sonic Youths catelog. Scuzzy with some great guitar hooks. Schizophrenia is a stellar opener but I really enjoyed the direction that Pacific Coast Highway goes as it slows midway thru into a druggy haze. I really like what Sonic Youth does and they do what they do well on Sister and therefore I enjoyed this. 4 stars
Admittedly I don't love this, it's lacking something, but I am taken back by how contemporary it sounds. There are enormous bands playing feckin arenas right now that sound just like this
I like alternative music and noise in general, but I'm just not into Sonic Youth. I tried.
Sonic Youth have never really done much for me tbh
My second Sonic Youth album so far and they’re becoming a bit of a welcome treat. I can’t yet pin down what it is I like, but there’s a thrilling energy and imagination to their music that resonates with me. Favourite track: Pacific Coast Highway
It is definitely influential but to my ear it is just fine. Love Catholic Block tho!
Loud, clangy, but that appears to be what I like as of late.
I still maintain to this day that Sonic Youth was the loudest show that I have ever been too. My ears rang for 2 or 3 days after this show. Noise rock at its finest. This feels like so much music that came later, its kind of in the source code of all contemporary indie music. The shoegaze / noisey / fuzzy impressionistic style of this record is fantastic. Its not an easy listen, but its also not a hard listen. Maybe my ears are just adjusted. I enjoyed this!
There’s nothing wrong with Sonic youth or this album. It’s just kind of bland.
Not a fan of anything on the album really
Once again, just not a fan of the sound of these guys. On the bright side, there was less of the woman’s vocals.
it was FINE and it was better than the last sonic youth album i listened to but ughhhh i am really never going to be excited for this sludgy staticy glop.
having this album after some cuban jazz/mambo was like walking into a much darker room and having to wait a few seconds for your eyes to adjust. but once they do, there's a lot going on here. i enjoyed this album a lot more than i thought i would. cool proto-grunge sound, good samples, and each track had more going on it than it seemed at first blush. nothing mind-blowing or revolutionary but pretty good for this list. favorites: schizophrenia, i got a catholic block, beauty lies in the eye, stereo sanctity, master-dik
This is my group's last Sonic Youth album, and it sure is more of that sound they have. Solid 4 Stars.
I’m at a 4.5 that I’ll bump up to a 5. This is the 5th & final time we’ll get Sonic Youth, and out of all the albums we’ve gotten from them, this one feels like the most traditionally shoegaze-y of the bunch. It’s a natural step right between the eerie tones of “E.V.O.L.” & the slight heavy metal / grunge influence present on “Daydream Nation” – that applies to everything from the lyrics to the soundscape itself. I think the lyricism here doesn’t matter as much as it did on “E.V.O.L.”, but they still have enough purpose behind them to help really set a tone on each track, unlike “Daydream Nation” & its more sonically-driven approach. That’s not to say “Daydream Nation” doesn’t have good lyrics, but I don’t think they matter as much to the enjoyment of the album. This album’s soundscape leans far more into the overdriven guitars as a backing ambience / wall of sound, sort of like a much softer version of what The Jesus & Mary Chain did with “Psychocandy”, without absolutely burying the rest of the mix underneath it. It also does the “Daydream Nation” thing where the soundscape drives a lot of the tracks, but in the traditional shoegaze-y way where the overwhelming nature of the wall is meant to open up the imagination. It’s still loud enough to feel, but not loud enough to distract, and that’s where this album succeeds in a way that “Psychocandy” didn’t. “Psychocandy” also had pretty drab delivery in its vocals, and while Thurston Moore & Kim Gordon aren’t exactly lifting themselves up that much higher, they at least have a more natural charisma in their vocals where their dry delivery fits for the songs. They also know how to lift up in a way that plays around the chaos of each track (or come in directly after the chaos to provide a good contrast), so their vocals have a really defined presence in each track that helps tie the songs together. Honestly, I can’t say there’s a bad track here, at least for someone who’s listened to enough shoegaze-adjacent stuff now over the past 809 albums. So, why a 4.5 & not a flat 5? There’s just a few moments where the structures of some tracks feel a little repetitive, a few times where the soundscape doesn’t feel as interesting as intended, a moment or two where the tension just never released in the right way, and at least for me, I think the last two tracks could’ve been flipped around. “Cotton Crown” just feels like it would be a way stronger track to end on. That said, I still think it’s worth bumping up to a 5. It’s a really tight 37 minutes, and honestly, if you want a quicker hit of Sonic Youth than “Daydream Nation” nearly doubling this album’s length, this might be the one to go to. I enjoyed it. So, out of the 5 Sonic Youth albums, it’s a 3.5 (Dirty), a 4.5 (Goo), a 5 (Daydream Nation), a 4.5 (E.V.O.L.), and a 4.5 (Sister). Lots of rounding up, if you couldn’t tell. That averages out to a 4.4 per album, and honestly, that feels about right. They’re consistently strong, but only Daydream Nation managed to get a flat 5 out of me. Perhaps I owe “Dirty” another listen just to see if that’s first-time jitters or if that score still holds up. Regardless, I’m glad to have been introduced to them, I think they’re definitely worth checking out, and I hear all the acclaim.
Ok but like how many Sonic Youth albums does one really need to listen to before they die? I think 3 is really pushing it! (I did enjoy this one more than I’ve enjoyed others!)
I'm really struggling to rate this one. I've listened to it twice and both times thought I had left and come back when the album was done playing. I guess that means nothing was remarkable for or against. So that screams solid 3 to me.
Странное, не моё
Meh. I didn't notice that album started playing 2nd time.
Sain kuunneltua 6 biisiin asti, ei toimi kitaran vingutus.
Liked more than Dreamland Nation.
Nice noisy one.
Scho okay.
Schwierig. Es gab einzelne Lichtblicke im Vergleich zu manch anderem Album.
Experimentelle Musik bleibt ein zweiseitiges Schwert: Kann richtig cool und erfrischend sein, geht es allerdings an rhythmische Experimente wehrt sich schnell mein Autismus. Sehr schade, weil es immer mal ganz nice zwischendrin klingt. Insgesamt aber nicht schön zu hören
Finalmente ascolto qualcosa dei Sonic Youth, ma non mi lascia granché
Thrilling fuzz-rocker rambling in a mad haze, consistent Sonic Youth album with a healthy amount of ferocious enjoyment
music is love
Just not my thing.
Fun and punk.
Wel ke
I can appreciate this as being a really great blend of experimental music and alternative rock, there's a lot of things about it I thought were interesting and even a few moments I enjoyed, but this didn't really click with me.
Pretty cool and I enjoyed most of it, but probably not for me long-term overall. Favourite tracks were Catholic Block and Hot Wire My Heart (which almost made me think of Jeffrey Lewis kind of vibes).
I endured this because it was only 40 minutes. But what amateur sounding, painful dross.
This album sits in a unique place in the 80s when punk rock has been obscured by new emerging hair bands and alternative rock. The band really does an impressive job of threading the needle, because though it comes out in 87, it shares none of the negative production value of most big rock bands. At the same time it doesn't retreat to the anarchy of punk. I don't know much about Sonic Youth, but this album is a breath of fresh air from where most of the 80s turned.
I liked the first song, didn't really enjoy the rest. Too noisy.
Album 75 Top 3 favorites off the album: Stereo Sanctity, Tuff Gnarl, Cotton Crown So, the opening track was more enjoyable right away than the last Sonic Youth album I listened to on here. I was really ready to say that the whole album was better than the last one I listened to by them, but then I listened to the whole thing and remembered I don't like Sonic Youth that much. I liked Stereo Sanctity for both the lyrical and instrumental content; "I can't get laid cause everyone is dead" was just a little funny. I like how it drives forward without being one big wall of sound the whole time; there's that slight pause in lower percussion for a few bars at a time after verse 2, then the loss of all of it for a few bars after that. It had enough going on to stay interesting the whole time. Tuff Gnarl was also an engaging listen, though not for the entirety. It got a bit noisy there towards the end in a way that I stopped rocking with about 20 seconds before the song ended. I don't care for Kim Gordon's voice. I don't care for her singing style. Not my thing. So much so, in fact, that I almost skipped Pacific Coast Highway halfway through. I'm also not a fan of the spoken word approach here. Track 2, that portion of Pipeline/Kill Time, regardless of whose turn it is to plunge me into a highly distorted, sometimes shrill, often overly dissonant hellscape, I'm not rocking with it. I sound like such a whiny, boring bitch. "Rah rah rah dissonance, meh meh shrill, blah blah blah too much distortion, back in my day---" okay grandma, let's get you to bed. I think my track record is proving that I do have an appreciation for these things in some contexts, though (I hope it is). Sonic Youth just isn't my flavor of them.
Super moody. I was in pure awe of the strength of sound across every single song. That kind of impact can’t be understated. The thunderous distortion is something you can feel in your very bones. I got the same type of feeling I get when I see a local live hardcore show. When a sound weighs this much, it stays with you. And it’s not a sluggish feeling because of the diversity throughout the crested soundscape. It’s a testament to the strength of the composition that the guitar is this thick, this dark, without it ever feeling draining. With each incoming song I found myself waiting for the lull, but it never came. It just flowed together so naturally and never felt like there needed to be a break in any of the aggressiveness. Faves: Catholic Block, Pipeline/Kill Time, Tuff Gnarl, Stereo Sanctity, Pacific Coast Highway, Schizophrenia, Master-Dik, Cotton Crown
To be listened to
Eh. Not sure what I'm supposed to feel with this one. It's ok. Nothing is like a big standout I can't even really tell what type of music they're trying to make here if I'm being perfectly honest. "Sister was not successful at the time of its release"... hmmm.... I tend to agree. Granted the issue here could be on me, maybe if I started from the beginning of Sonic Youths records this one would make more sense, but jumping right into this journey, it's not landing.
++: Schizophrenia, (I Got A) Catholic Block, Stereo Sanctity, Pipeline/Kill Time, Tuff Gnarl, Cotton Crown +: Pacific Coast Highway, Hot Wire My Heart, White Cross, Master-Dik +-: Beauty Lies in the Eye 7,7/10
A few decent songs regularly broken up with pointless, atonal noise. It might be "art" but it's not music I want to revisit. Also, I think this is my fourth Sonic Youth album - they are over represented on the list. I would say Daydream Nation is the only one that’s worth being included. 2⭐️
This one’s weird, even by Sonic Youth standards, at least compared to the stuff I’m more used to from them. It’s got plenty of that jagged, off kilter energy, but it didn’t feel as locked in or immediately memorable for me as their later records. It’s not bad at all though. I just didn’t connect with it the way I do with Goo. So yeah, not as good as Goo, but not terrible
One thing I’ve learnt is that Sonic Yourh are pretty crap and not worth investing 45 minutes in
My big problem with this album is that most of the songs start out fine, but then it just turns into incomprehensible noise. It makes it so unenjoyable.
My favourite SY album, maybe my favourite album. Beautiful noise
Early discordant sonic youth lighter on Melodie’s heavier on grunge. Probably one of the missing links but I won’t be returning too frequently.
so awesome
Sister stands out as a bold experiment, pushing boundaries and helping to shape the sound that was emerging in the underground scene of the late ’80s. I appreciate its willingness to embrace noise, dissonance, and unconventional song structures—it feels like a blueprint for what was to come. That said, while I admire its role in defining that era’s aesthetic, it doesn’t resonate with me on a visceral level as much as some other records from the same period. It’s more of a fascinating document of transition than a personal favorite
I just...cant stand this. Unlistenable.
Sonic Youth #2 for this guy. Never heard any of these tracks. So much noise but there's some great musicianship buried under there, as expected. I definitely prefer Kim's vocals, and the songs where she leads, to Thurston's in almost all cases, across this and Teenage Daydream.
Muito ruim, muito barulho. O rock merece mais respeito.
I understand why it was popular as it was a completely new sound for the time it came out. However, it is not something I would voluntarily listen to again. No real top songs. 4.5/10
very scuzzy and off kilter. need to relisten paying more more close attention i think.
Not really my thing, but I could see Sonic Youth growing on me as it had similarities to other music I like. I at least found Cotton Crown to be an enjoyable song and could see myself revisting it Favorite Track - Cotton Crown Least Favorite Track - Master-Dik ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Sonic Youth! This is why I'm doing this challenge. Sonic Youth is one of those bands that I've known about for years, but literally no one I've ever met has been a fan. So it seemed like music I'd get around to eventually, and I never did. Until now! I was leary of this, because I know they're considered very avant-garde and noisy and dissonant. But I was pleasantly surprised by the first track - yes, it's noisy and dissonant, but it's incredibly musical. And I think that holds for the rest of the songs on Sister as well. They can be tough to listen to - but they have their own beauty that I find compelling. I liked this a LOT more than I thought I would. FOUR STARS
meh
I really just don't understand why anyone would sit down and willfully listen to this band.
These guys have a great and interesting sound probably because of all the unique tunings they use. It really makes the songs sound different and out of this world within the format of conventional riffs and song structures. The problem I’ve always found though is that it takes a long time for any of these songs to stick in my head without any strong melodic or harmonic hooks but it’s definitely worth putting the work in as I really appreciate how these songs sound with all their experimental touches. I haven’t really dug into their discography much (other than Dirty) due to the difficulties of getting inside the material but I’m definitely looking forward to getting around to the other albums on this list.
Average SY album
Wenn Grunge übertrieben wird und es auch nicht nach Rock klingt, kommt dieses Album heraus.
heavier rock
This was a very difficult listen. I hate saying an album just sounds like a lot of noise, but unfortunately I feel like this was the case here.
Really liked this. Great sound, good tracks.
2.5 - Meh
Ah, Sonic Youth. What a distinct sound. Groundbreaking then, still interesting and fantastic now. I don't think there's another band who's made noise and dissonance sound so beautiful and intentional. - Heard before? Not sure about this album. - Will I listen again? Yes. - Does it inspire me to listen to more of this artist? Yes. I haven't heard them in a while, and it was a good match for my angsty, chaotic mood today.
There's something about this band that grabs me despite myself - I tend to enjoy the more melodic and hooky, poppy music than anything else, and while Sonic Youth do have melody and hooks, they are genetically intertwined with noise and punk, and not in a Green Day way. Renaldo, Moore, and Gordon all have distinctive voices and the music sounds like no one else - dissonant and droning guitars, compelling rhythms and drums, hypnotic patterns within the melodies and noise. I love Goo and the rest of their 90s records, and this is right up there with those.
dang this sounded like something good incredible
3.4 2x solid but nothing too amazing here
5 out of 5. This is probably the band I should have listened to by now more than any other on this list and what a strong start.
First Sonic Youth album selected after 133 albums, which is kind of crazy when they have 5 albums on the list. For the record, still no Rolling Stones popped up either, in case anyone cares. Sister isn't my favorite Sonic Youth record but it's still a damn good album. I prefer their stuff from Daydream Nation through Washing Machine. I don't feel like writing more sentences
despite my proclivity for noisy, experimental guitar music, I'm still more or less a newcomer when it comes to Sonic Youth, one of the most significant bands in the entire lineage of that kind of rock 'n' roll. I've given Daydream Nation and a couple of their early-80s LPs a cursory listen or two; but I'm considering this listen of Sister, their fifth album, my first proper, full-attention experience with this New York quartet's work. what I remember from the band's first couple albums was a sound pretty akin to New York's "no wave" scene of the late 70s and early 80s, as well as the work of totalist composer Glenn Branca (check out the insane barrages of noise they serve up on this album's closer, "White Cross"). as it turns out, Branca was a huge influence on Sonic Youth, as well as other bands that formed in reaction to no wave like Swans. members of both bands were actually involved in some of Branca's electric guitar symphonies, so that makes total sense! Sister takes that foundation of noisy, off-kilter guitar work and imbues it with a keen sense of tonality and melody. the opening one-two punch of "Schizophrenia" and "(I Got A) Catholic Block" demonstrates the band's ability to embrace both ends of the spectrum, the abrasive and the pretty, and synthesize them into something novel. "Catholic Block" in particular has that sense of forward drive you always want out of a punk song, but that riff matching the title lyric is just such an earworm. the final 30 seconds are a beautiful comedown after three minutes of such ferocity. the harmonic language of these songs is mostly based on an ambiguous mixture of open and closed intervals; crunchy major and minor seconds, but also wide fourths and fifths. the likelihood of hearing a standard major or minor triad (thirds) at any point is pretty low, which makes the melodies the band writes sound almost like they're floating. when you do hear those more typical chord sounds, like when they dial it back and rock between the V and the IV in the middle of "Pacific Coast Highway", they feel so earned! also approaching (but not reaching) typicality is the cover of "Hot Wire My Heart" by Crime, a pretty straightforward garage punk song which turns into a ball of hot fire in Sonic Youth's hands. the vocals of Thurston Moore and Kim Gordon have made this band into one of the most famous in the category of "rock bands with multiple lead singers" over the years. given that this is punk rock, the vocals aren't the most important thing, but I certainly can't imagine anything other than their voices (together and apart) being here. unlike with Black Francis and Kim Deal of the Pixies, whose voices oddly pair well together because of how different they are, Moore and Gordon's vocals feel more like they're combining to make one instrument at many points, like on the slow-burning "Cotton Crown", where they sing a simple melody in octaves together following the main guitar riff. I'm very excited to return to Daydream Nation and experience the rest of this band's seemingly legendary five-album run from '86 to '92, which 1001 Albums... should serve up for me within the next, I dunno, couple years. light 9/10.
Really good album. I liked this a lot. Worthy addition to this list for sure.
A couple of songs were ok, but genrally just a wall of noise for me.
Incredible vibe on the opener. Guitars are crazy good. What a song. Second one goes very hard as well. 3 is mysterious and dark. 4 5 6 take you to a beautiful and loud journey. 7 starts loud and later transforms into something else. The journey of this tracks is amazing. The guitar work is very original. 8 is a lighter moment on the project, and not my favorite. Love the vocals on 9. A great track overall. White cross is the closing track. It has great energy and vibe. This is how you make noise. Lush, interesting, dynamic. It's loud ,it should be. That's the point. It's a well deserved 4
Wow some stuff I really loved and some stuff I really hated. Spoke to my punk rooted tastes but then throws some weird in that made me want to turn it off.
Like BCNR forgot how to be melodic.
Love Sonic Youth but there are some better albums of theirs out there.
My favorite park was when it ended. :,)
Songs I saved: Stereo Sanctity
I should be Sonic Youth’s number one fan. I love crazy psychotic guitars, New York City, and rebellious energy. I even know someone who used to tour with them. But, whenever I play a Sonic Youth album, I always end up shaking my head. I always end up feeling the bad kind of dirty. This was almost the exception. I was into the first four tracks or so. Then, after a while, I just had to hold my hands in the air in exhaustion. I don’t know these people at all, but I feel like I know people like these people, and they’re awful people. So, Sonic Youth albums just give me bad vibes.
Grungey af so it’s right up my street, but the end of the album dragged a LOT.
Still not my favorite Sonic Youth album, but outside of a discography runthrough this rocks. SK should cover Catholic Block.
Sonic Youth's final hour. Or 45 minutes or whatever.
I love dissonance
every track has a moment that i can just disappear into. this was never my favorite SY album but it is part of a dazzling run of albums (much of which it looks like we'll be able to visit). where they just are always inches away from disappearing into something amazing, like the end of "Catholic Block" (a song that somehow I previously dismissed but on this listen very much stood out). I still think it's not in my upper echelon of rock albums like the best of Sonic Youth, but my oh my is this such an experience.
Sonic youth a real “not for me but I respect it” type band
I don’t think I like noise rock? Better than einsturzende neubautwn though
Музыка Sonic Youth требует некоторого переключения и адаптации.
A perfect mix of classic sonic youth sound and normal song structure.
They weren't nearly as cool as they thought they were.
started off really strong, then got weird
Was this popular because it had the new alternative sound and there just wasn't much else to turn to at the time? I honestly can't remember, and I'm not remembering why people thought this was so great at the time because it's just dull now.
Strong four I like these guys
I don’t like hearing effort
Cacophonic more than sonic… but interesting! Made me feel like I was listening to a live band in a garage. Loved the church bells at the end.
I liked this because it’s in a lane I tend to enjoy, but not enough to push it past a 3 for me. I can hear where a lot of Boston DIY bands get their inspiration
Schizophrenia - 4/5 (I Got A) Catholic Block - 3.5/5 Beauty Lies In The Eye - 3/5 Stereo Sanctity - 4.5/5 Pipeline/ Kill Time - 3/5 Tuff Gnarl - 2.5/5 Pacific Coast Highway - 3/5 Hot Wire My Heart - 3/5 Kotton Krown - 3/5 White Cross - 2.5/5 Master-Dik - 2.5/5
Surprisingly good
I know I’m supposed to like Sonic Youth. But I just don’t.
Mächtige Band. Einflussreich auf so viele Bands, die ich mag. Tolles Album.
Mmkay. 2.4.
Personal enjoyment: 4/5 Relevance to this list: 5/5
Scruffy and urgent
love it honestly giving alt band from the 80s
ok
Super moody, still experimental. It doesn’t quite have the “wow” of side A from EVOL or Goo, but hey, more prime Sonic Youth is something I will never complain about.
Schizophrenia builds and builds, never quite reaching catharsis. Everything is muted somehow, rounded off corners. The musings of an emotionally unavailable person. I love the tremolo picked riffs though, it's very post-rock. If that existed in 1987. Catholic Block is a bit more punk, a bit noisier, mixed with acoustic guitar. Lovely outro. Speak-singing on Beauty Lies in the Eye, but I don't mind, it just adds another layer of ambience to the waves of sound. The music almost sounds like Agalloch. There's enough melody to balance the weirder stuff that comes - sometimes in the same track - Tuff Gnarly is poppy before a dissonant breakdown totally transforms the song. Hot Wire My Heart is basically a glam rocker with a filter of grime and noise applied to it. Cotton Crown returns to the mid paced, heavy melodic stuff. This is all a bit epic, but exhausting. I do like it a lot.
Listening session: february 5th, while commuting to internship Listened to before: no Thoughts: I can imagine listening to this when you’re an angsty and wannabe edgy teen in the 80s and 90s Favourite track: White Cross & Stereo Sanctity
Hm. Maybe I’m just not a fan of noise rock. Was just a very messy record that sometimes engaged me and did something interesting, and other times left me scratching my head. Some decent tracks to walk away from this from, however.
I honestly feel so little about this album. I liked it, I can't remember not liking it, but honestly it was just kinda nothing. I feel like there were so many other albums I could've been listening to this morning that would've been a better use of my time. Favorites: Schizophrenia, Pipeline/Kill Time, Kotton Krown
cool album cover but no for me
Al grupo de Thurston Moore hay que tenerle ganas, y normalmente no es de lis que tienes ganas de escuchar una vez finalizado. No porque sea una mala experiencia, sino porque la experimentación a veces puede indigestar. Y te tiene que gustar o, al menos, tienes que apreciar el noise pop. “Schizophrenia” debe ser lo más comercial del disco, y se agradece, lo malo es que encabeza el álbum, no es el respiro que se merece a la mitad. Se queda en álbum interesante, pero no de culto.
I just dont get Sonic Youth. Somebody explain the appeal.
This album has a vibe that would definitely resonate with me at a different age. I was going to give it a 4, but the last song was irritating, bumping it down to a 3.
Album 1039 of 1089 Sister - Sonic Youth (1987) Rating : 2.5 / 5 This was a fair album for me. It held my attention well enough while it was on, and I can appreciate what they were doing, but it never quite crossed into territory that made me want to circle back and revisit it later. There’s a solid atmosphere throughout, and the band’s identity is clear - noisy, angular, and intentionally rough around the edges. That said, nothing here really jumped out and demanded my focus. It’s one of those albums that works fine in the moment, especially if you’re already inclined toward their sound, but it didn’t leave much of a lasting impression for me once it ended. I enjoyed the listen, just not enough to elevate it beyond “that was decent.” A respectable entry from a band that clearly helped shape a lot of what came after them, even if this particular album lands more in the middle of the road for my tastes.
Deciding what score to give to this album was challenging. For the past 6 days, I've being listening to it, even hearing it several times per day, in order to develop a proper opinion. The only reason I gave it so many tries is because Sonic Youth albums can be very challenging, so I needed the time to slowly digest it. Also, if it wasn't because I love "EVOL" and "Daydream Nation", I probably would have given up the first day and rate it 2 or 3 stars. "Sister" was released between the two already mentioned albums. It shows a clearly progression towards a more cohesive and accessible sound with a lo-fi production while keeping a lot of the noise and chaos of the previous album, even though it is not as bold or punishing. And landing in the middle is what really made it difficult for me, since it doesn't reach the incredibly high points of "Daydream Nation" and it is not as macabre and daunting as "EVOL". The album starts with "Schizophrenia", a very powerful song which is very reminiscent of "Teen Age Riot" with the very powerful guitar riffs. Instead of sounding bright and cheerful, they have a little touch of sentimentalism and melancholia to it. It also features a very post-rockish build-up in the second half which is very beautiful. Next is "Catholic Block", which changes the album tone to a more energetic side and features some incredibly noisy and catchy guitar works. Then, "Beauty Lies in the Eye" slows things down again, bringing a quite relaxing and calm with a very meditative vocals and guitars with a lot of detail in the background. "Stereo Sanctity" follows up and returns the energy of the second song and turns it up. The main riff sounds to me like it was extracted from a surf rock track, but with a more gloomy sound. I also loved the slow down to the second half and the very sinister sound of if that keeps building back up. Afterwards, there is "Pipeline / Kill Time", a more serious song which has an incredible and melodic guitar in the second verse that I absolutely loved. Then it gets super dense and slow in the latter half. Up next is "Tuff Gnarl", sounding quite uplifting with some of the most catchy vocal melodies and great sounding guitar lines that slowly descends to a very chaotic ending. "Pacific Coast Highway" has a nice industrial touch with the impending sounds in the background and Kim Gordon sounding very menacing. There is a very calm section in the middle, but in the end, the song comes back to the starting motives. Then comes "Hot Wire My Heart", which is very unique. It doesn't have any super noisy section like all the other songs, and it could be qualified as their more standard track if it wasn't for the super dissonant guitars and forced voice. It might feel a bit like an outlier, but it is very fun with the most anthemic chorus of the whole project. Coming up is "Cotton Crown", which might sound very slow and relaxing at the start, but does feature some very noisy and dissonant guitars that begin to make a build up once the second half starts. Finally, the album ends with "White Cross", one of the most frenetic pieces of the album with some of the fastest drums and guitars. Actually, there is one more song, "Master-Dik", that is included as bonus track. It has a lot of attitude and very sticking sampling which makes it fun to listen to. So there it is, the whole album described. It was difficult to get to this point, but I'm glad I dedicated enough time for it to grow on me and appreciate all the interesting things it does.
I think Sonic Youth are one of those bands someone like me is meant to like. Frankly I spent most of this album wondering whether to put 2 or 3. It's not something I ever care to listen to. I'm all for discordant sounds and singers who can't sing. But... Nothing here is memorable. Too much jars wrong places but not in any particularly interesting way, and whoever decided the running order had no idea what they were doing. Ok the final track Master-Dik just started and I think I can say this is a high 2. Sorry, James.
i really wanted to like this more but the instrumentals just really put me off today
I really enjoyed the instrumentation on this. The guitar textures were brilliant and kept going to places I didn't necessarily expect. But it was let down by the overall songs. Nothing really captured. I wasn't left with any of them in my head, they just came and went, meaning even the cool guitar parts can't easily be separated across the album. There are other sonic youth albums which don't suffer this fate, so that knocks it down a bit. It's either a low 4 or a high 3... I'm still not sure what I'll press, let's find out.
Very good
I’m hyped for the noise and distortion at the start, but then I’ve lost the plot in the middle of this album. Master-Dik saves it, this song is great, ballsy, strutting, cool.
Just more sonic garbage. 1 star or F-.
Noise
It’s a fun album even if it’s not cool to say it’s fun.
Doesn't do anything for me
Sonic Youth for me is a band that could do no wrong. The sound, angular and menacing and noisy yet melodic and rhythmic is just something that gets into me. Admittedly, lyrically and conceptually, I don't pay attention to a lot of it. This is supposedly a concept album about Philip K. Dick and his stillborn sister, something that affected him his entire life, but it could be about practically anything as far as I'm concerned. The music is what makes this album for me, and while I appreciate Moore and Gordon's vocals, they run secondary to the awesome sounds backing them up.
Heard it before. Surprised to find out how many Sonic Youth albums are on the list. Too many honestly. This is one of those that could've been left out. Still, an interesting piece of music 2/5
its fine
very very rocky, maybe too rocky...
Non male alla fine
The dissonance works for me. Most noise rock annoys me, but I can listen to and enjoy Sonic Youth.
Glistening, angular, noisy, a rawer version of what was going to come with Daydream Nation I guess. If I could send one message back to myself when I was a teenager, it would be to get into Sonic Youth. I played this through four times: - first listen, not much stuck - but it went fast, so I figured I had enjoyed it - second listen, similar experience - third listen, the first half of the album started to click, along with a couple of tracks near the end - fourth listen, the second half also clicked this time round Five stars.
More Sonic Youth? This is the third SY album thus far. Not mad about it, but I’m sure there are more bands deserving of a place. Anyway! A great album overall. Feeling charitable- full marks.
They had me early on but lost me when songs descended into noise. 2.5/5
I thought a few songs were okay, but as a whole this wasn't for me.
Bon album qui réveille
Maybe a 4
май кап оф ті☕
Wow this was terrible. Like hard to listen to but not in a good way
*sigh* Spotify was playing silly buggers so i was in quite a bad mood by the time I got round to listening. Nothing stuck to the sides at all. No sentiment or sound or groove. Just.. dunno.
I don't know how Sonic Youth got 5 albums on this list, and I can't say I am a fan of their noise rock sound after listening to those 5 albums. I truly do not like noise rock: I didn't before, and I don't now. But when you move past the noise rock, Sonic Youth has an early alternative, post-punk sound in their Sister album. Some of the album is bland with little direction, but some of it is catchy and engaging. Kim Gordon's vocals are superior, as mentioned in my previous reviews, and their lyrics are once again strong. I wish there wasn't so much noise rock.
One thing I've learned from 1001 is that I really don't like Sonic Youth as much as I thought I did. I hinged my liking of them around a few of their songs that have a more alt, less noise lean. But in reality, they probably ultimately lean a bit too noise rock for my liking, ultimately just leaving me feeling "okay" about them. And with a total of five of their albums on this project, all more or less doing the same thing, I feel like we could have made room for something else. This was my last album of theirs, and looking back, I've just been consistently whelmed.
A nice one from Sonic Youth.
Kind of felt this would be another 5 stars, to match EVOL and Daydream Nation. And it's a great album, sonically brilliant, but there's something about it I don't love as much. I think the problem is me, here. 9/10
started so good but fell off
Pretty funny because in the past week, I sat down and basically marathonned Sonic Youth's highest rated albums (Already got Daydream Nation for the generator previously, but in the past week I listened to Goo, Sister, Dirty, EVOL, and Washing Machine). All fantastic records, and I'm usually against bands having this many records on the list, but honestly with Dimery leaving off Washing Machine, they might actually be *underrepresented* on the list. But yeah, I don't think any of those records are quite as good as Daydream Nation (gave that a 5), but they're all at minimum a 4. Of the non-Daydream albums, Sister is probably not my favorite (right now I think its EVOL, but its really hard to evaluate 5 records when you shotgunned them in a week), but its still a fantastic record. More noise rock than on Daydream Nation which is why I think it's holding me back from enjoying it quite as much (other than Goo, Sister might be my "least" favorite right now, Goo is definitely the "weakest" of the albums right now for me, but it'd still get a 4). But still some standouts like Schizophrenia and Catholic Block. Wasn't expecting the Beastie Boys-esque "rapping" in Master-Dik. Overall, great record, and overall Sonic Youth really are that great a band that I have no qualms saying they deserve 5 albums (honestly 6 with Washing Machine) on the list. Incredibly influential to 90's alt rock.
4.1 Finally found one! Just over a decade I got heavily into Daydream Nation, and quickly flicked through their catalogue in search of anything which hit me the same way but never found it. Everything before it seemed too raw, unpolished, everything after too bland, filtered. This might be the fourth (or fifth) appearance of SY on this list which is surprising in itself, and my opinion of non-DN albums hadn't changed until now. This is some good shit. Ignoring the cover (not the first album that seems to include an unnecessary cover that I've lambasted on here), the only weak track imo is the last one. The rest of the album, particularly the first half, is pretty stellar. Different to Daydream Nation, but not necessarily in a bad way. Looking forward to exploring more.
Not a big fan of the vocals. But the guitar sounds were something special. How they get the guitar to sound like it’s screaming is something else. Great punk record but need more listens
Not bad, actually. But the noise gets old after a while. I've had two of their albums and kind of liked them, but it's starting to get old. And five albums on this list are way too much. I get that they're Important, but so many other classics are missing...
Meh
Holy peak
Not for me!
2.5 3
I loved it and listened to it like a thousand times 21/1/26
album de welcome to the jungle, buena entrada, también está paradise city y sweet child o'mine
On the surface I should've loved this: somewhat experimental with a ton of fuzz and effects that still sits in the "an album of songs" space rather than the region of soundscapes and noise. Started off pretty promising, then slowly went down, and down, and the last stretch was just awful. It sounded like a high school battle of the bands except rather than get music lessons or singing lessons to learn more than 3 chords they spent all that money on guitar pedals.
I would have loved this in high school
Too much noise.
A little bit too noisy for my taste.
7/10 Like with the previous Sonic Youth album an overall enjoyable experience but the songs dont really stand out Highlights: Schizophrenia Stereo Sanctity Cotton Crown
duhhh duhhhh duhhhhhhh errrrrrr duhhhhhhrrrrrrrr
I love Sonic Youth's sound, noisy and dissonant, fairly similar to the Pixies, but theres more space, quieter and less hooks. Very influencial band and album to everything alt-rock and indie.
First song was alright, then it went downhill
Meh
Good.
4/5. Not my personal favorite Sonic Youth album, but still a great burst of noisy rock/punk music. Not too much to say really, this album slaps.
Heard the chord progression on the first song and thought I was going to love this. The rest disappointed me.
In one ear and out the other.
There were some parts of the album that really captured me, but for the most part I was bored and wished I was listening to something else. I do think a lot of artistry was put into this album and it’s more than just random chords and screams but I don’t have any interest to look deeper. Light 2/5
This is when SY found the perfect balance between noise and quiet somberness. This and Daydream Nation are just nearly flawless albums.
Schizophrenia - 4.5/5 Catholic Block - 5/5 Beauty Lies in the Eye - 3/5 Stereo Sanity - 4/5 Pipeline/Kill Time - 3/5 Tuff Gnarl - 4/5 Pacific Coast Highway - 3/5 Hot Wire My Heart - 3.5/5 Cotton Crown - 4/5 White Cross - 4/5 An interesting blend of punk and post-punk and noise rock that comes together quite nicely. I wouldn't say I was a fan of noisy rock before this, the rawness of the whole thing made me appreciate it a bit more. It does sound a bit compressed at times but otherwise it is quite a fine album. Overall: 4/5 Favorites: Schizophrenia, Catholic Block, Tuff Gnarl, Cotton Crown
put a bunch of notes down for this while listening but i lost it. I thought it was cool - one of the interesting things ive found since starting this project - hearing definitive inspiration for modern musicians that I have on heavy rotation. tracks like catholic block gave off bloc party, beaty lies in the eye gave me rolling blackouts coastal fever, and i got plenty of the vaccines in there throughout the album. obviously a super influential band and album. Despite this, I enjoyed it, but not heaps. 6.7/10
Art
I dig this but it still leans a bit too heavy on noise making over music making for my taste.
Suspect this is probably another track-by-track album for me, based on Daydream Nation, so going to take the same approach here. Schizophrenia - Mostly just get vibes of that group of edgy kids in school who go off and form a band and just play in their parent's garage and shout at their younger siblings when they try to join in. Overall fairly tuneful but also just not that interesting. Vocals are a bit shit. 3/5. Catholic Block - Awful vocals. Main riff is sort of OK if a bit repetitive. Couple of crappy noise sections that don't do anything for me. 2/5. Beauty Lies in the Eye - Someone accidentally turned the volume right down so I don't know if it's any good. I'm going to assume not. 1/5. Stereo Sanctity - Oh that's an unpleasant start. Oh god the vocals are dire too. Second half got better, end was shit again. 2/5. Pipeline/Kill Time - Started off OK but my god why would anyone listen to the rest of it by choice. 1/5. Tuff Gnarl - Did the same thing. Started off fine. Descended into shitness. 1/5. Pacific Coast Highway - Oh no Kim is back with her out of tune singing. Kind of nearly got to the point of being OK in the middle and then went right back to being crap. Genuinely awful. 1/5. Hot Wire My Heart - Just kind sounds like a not very good rock song. Nothing special but listenable. 3/5. Cotton Crown - Plodding dreary guitars, and now 2 shitty vocalists at the same time. Listenable but I'm not sure why anyone would want to. 2/5. White Cross - Not a lot to say about this one, it was OK. Vocals are still bad. 2.5/5. Master-Dik - This is the only track where I looked at the lyrics and ... wow it's just utter tripe. Music is too. 1/5. Averages out to ~1.8, but the last song was so dire I don't feel like rounding up.
This band is pretty good
I used to listen to Sonic Youth quite a bit. But I forgot about them. After a long time, I listened to one of their albums again. It was okay, but I wasn't thrilled by it. 3/5
Really liked the opener - Schizophrenia - but it tails off from there and lost me along the way. I'm trying to work whilst listening and its not going that well - which is probably colouring my view.
Sister And with this album we say goodbye to Sonic Youth. I could say this sounds more accessible and immediate than their other albums, but apart from Goo I can’t really remember much about any of them. It's interesting looking back at my previous SY reviews to note that in most of them I mention looking back at my previous SY reviews to see what I thought on my previous SY, and that I gave them all 3s. I think this is the same, I like it but I don’t love it, and it ultimately cements my feeling that they are a band I like the idea of and the spirit of more that I actually like listening to. Noise, abrasion, droning, female-male vocals, surf pop haze and a deliberate outsider obtuseness are all things I like about them, but I’m much more neutral about the actual music that produces. I did like Schizophrenia, Tuff Gnarl, Hot Wire My Heart and Cotton Crown on here though. So, yeah, a 3. 🔊🔊🔊 Playlist submission: Schizophrenia
The insanely overrepresented Sonic Youth back for the final time. The Sonics always fill me with some trepidation, perhaps a tad of ennui, but they've also invariably win me round to a large extent - even if I've found all their efforts middling. The exception, and the one I understand being on this list was 'Daydream Nation'. "I wonder how this will fare", I thought to myself. I am now able to reveal my findings. I thought this was similar to previous albums we've heard, except 'Daydream Nation'. Where it falls down is the likes of 'Beauty Lies in the Eye', which is more teenage whimpering from Kim Gordon; there's little here we haven't heard several times before. I don't dislike it, but nor does it excite. The album is certainly a progression, however minor, from the washed out 'EVOL', and a clear stepping-stone to the ambient excellence of 'Daydream Nation'. Why we have to follow this unremarkable journey step by step remains a mystery.
Solid Album. Sonic Youth never really grabbed me. They're not bad and on paper they're a band I'd be all in on. Just something about them never clicked for me. Still, solid music, love the noisy quality and I'm not mad about it.
Love Bonnie Raitt. I kinda prefer older Bonnie, but this will do.
Fantastic album. My first Sonic Youth outing
Sonic Youth is a perfect example of what Alternative Music was, before the genre became a contradiction of it's namesake (which, bands like Sonic Youth helped to bring to fruition). Anywho... This is a really good album and I am loving being forced back into Sonic Youth's discography.
Wow, I did not expect to like this as much as I did.
I haven't understood the appeal of Sonic Youth. I've listened to a bunch of their records from different eras, but, to date, they still hadn't clicked for me. Sister might change that. I love the direction SY is taking. They're being influenced by post-punk, their no-wave background, and noise rock, combining these sounds while predating post-hardcore bands like Unwound and Slint by a few years. I also hear the beginnings of slowcore bands like Codiene here. The point being, this is a refreshing and bombastic album that I completely slept on. There's just so much to enjoy here!! What a delightful surprise! Highlights: "Schizophrenia" , "Tuff Gnarl", most of the album, honestly. Lowlights: fucking NONE. this album is gooood.
The drumbeat of Schizophrenia goes down into my soul
Sonic Youth never really hit the right notes for me. I appreciate the rhythmic patterns and the guitar work here, but it's not high on my list. If I saw them live while they were together and were younger, I'd likely feel more.
I wanted to like this
Too many screeching guitars but still good.
Unique sound which has to be appreciated.
I can't say "I'd listen to that song again" for a single song. There are always some parts that sound quite good, mostly in combination with the guy singing then, but mostly i did not enjoy it. And these "singing" parts of the girl? yeah no i guess you needed to have been there. i mean i was there but not THERE. anyway
Great
I don't think noise rock is for me
Not my taste but I appreciate that this is on the list
Fine but didn’t grab me.
fun, wouldn’t listen to again
This sucked. I couldn't wait til this ended. The vocals are not good at all. There are some redeeming instrumental parts here so I will give it 1 instead of .5 lol. Liked Songs: "Schizophrenia" , "Tuff Gnarl" , "Hot Wire My Heart" (I guess????)
Noisy 2
Started interesting, but didn’t like it in the end
Very good!
Had Goo just a few days back now got another Sonic Youth effort. This was very highly rated in 1987 but I'm not convinced it holds up particularly well. The first few songs are quite slow going and the album is a little bit of a dirge but there are exceptions, as 'Stereo Sanctity' packs a punch before the punky 'Hot Wire My Heart' and the slower 'Kotton Krown' provides some much-needed diversity as the album progresses. But nah, overrated. They would find their feet somewhat with Daydream Nation.
I like it Clo I like it!! Love all the different styles of guitar they're using, and whatever they're doing always fits with what the song feels like its going for Didn't really like the vocal melodies they tried on Tuff Gnarl and Pacific Coast Highway but the instrumental sections brought me back around on them. Highlights: Schizophrenia Catholic Block Stereo Sanctity Pretty high 4
We're finally here! Standouts Catholic Block Stereo Sanctity Pipeline/Kill Tuff Gnarl ⭐ Pacific Coast Highway Cotton Crown Master-Dik This is the album that usually gets credited with the first album to achieve the sound I adore. You know how cool live music sounds in a small venue? Yeh let's do that on a studio album! This album has it all, crunchy guitars, noisy guitars, guitars grinding against your ears, fuzzy guitars, feedback... Fun fact they couldn't get this album published because of the album cover for ages. Some noise highlights: Pipeline/Kill Time is a starts of simply but leads into this chaotic orchestra of guitar noises with a simple melody in the background to grab onto and guide you through. Incredible mixing so that melody is always there for you. Tuff Gnarl has this one riff playing throughout it and then they start building up the noise and let the original riff free at the climax which explodes the section into perfection. Master-Dik is a feedback ridden song which is the perfect way to end the album. The constant layered guitars in the back is a forest of sound to lose yourself in. Incredible album easy 5 Unfortunately the later sonic youth albums are less harsh but at least they have the same vibe and goal.
I imagine if I had fulfilled my lost dream of music the results would have sounded a lot like this ~ not musical. This is awful to listen to.
Like, Sonic Youth just has to be an elaborate prank, right? There's no way that a bunch of music critics didn't get together to convince everyone that this crap is actually good over a few drinks late one night as joke.
riffs in this one are amazing. also o think it’s really chill music very good chill music
Ehhh.
Argh..I knew it was in the late 80s.. but simply tuning all tracks to the right notes will make the album much more pleasant. All tracks are slightly off tune.. whether it’s intentional (plus I doubt it), it was very unpleasant. And they love semitones as well. I just don’t like it sorry.
I can comfortably say I was not a fan of this
I had high hopes for this one, unfortunately it was a bit of a letdown. There was nothing that stood out from the other tracks or that grabbed and held my attention. I feel like a poser for this score but it just wasn’t for me.
I feel like I should like Sonic youth but I don't.
Might be the first Sonic Youth album I enjoy. An eclectic blend of raw energy and jangly guitar. So the question is, is this their most accessible album, or have my tastes changed?
I’ve listened to Daydream Nation a bunch but never came back to this one. I can see lot of the greatness that would come next but this one is just a tiny bit lesser.
Wow a Sonic Youth album that sounds like the other Sonic Youth album. I do like their sound, but nothing was a standout to me
Very nice album. Good rock/punk from the 80s
The words that immediately spring to mind are skronky and clangy. Which might not be actual words but describe this very accurately. It’s what actual psychedelia sounds like slightly confused and distressed as opposed to songs about magic ocelots
Me likey.
Sonic Youth rocks. In other news, water is wet. Favorite track: Stereo Sanctity
Jesus fuck, how many Sonic Youth albums will I get? 5/5
Too cool for school
NOISE
Oh brother
A struggle. Really don't understand Moore and Gordon's God-like status at all. I clearly have to try harder.
I should like Sonic Youth - I like punk, I like rock, I like lo-fi stuff … but they just don’t click. It’s ok, but it’s not very interesting.
A pivotal album by a great band.
Average indie pop
Borderline unlistenable.
This is the third damn Sonic Youth album that's come up. I get it. Sonic Youth is noisy and obnoxious and terrible. No, I don't need to hear any more of it.
Must be their blueprint for the next 5-6 records lol It’s good.
4.5 So great. If you know evol and bad moon rising you know this is the bridge from there to Daydream Nation.
I was lucky enough to be in college when Nirvana hit the world and the 90s alternative scene erupted. Sonic Youth was an intimidating presence for me - the band that people ahead of the curve already knew and loved. The band whose music played in the record store and you were afraid to ask who it was. It was only Much later that I started to listen to Sonic Youth - benefitting from the access to music provided by streaming services, this was mostly in the form of random songs. This is the first time I’ve listened to them in album format and I wasn’t disappointed. Just enough melodic pop elements to help me feel anchored through the experimental aspects.
I so want to love Sonic Youth. Somehow I just can’t.
This one sounds indie as all get out. Noisy and totally grungified. This band clearly influenced an entire genre of music that was to come. For what it is, this is a 4. I have to be in the mood, but it's good.
noise
Respect their creativity, but it looks likes there's not too much things for me personally. The whole album is 3, Kotton Krown is 5, average still remains 3, unfortunately.
It’s ok. A little too raw and grungy for my tastes though.
I expected nebulous feedback and noise. There was some of that but also it rocks pretty good.
I have not been able to really enjoy the chaos in sonic youth's music despite liking a lot of similar, adjacent recommended artists. It must just be a personal taste thing...
3.5. I've listened to this one a couple of times, and I like it, but something just isn't clicking to make me want to round up instead of down. Who knows, maybe that will change.
Not enjoyable in the slightest. Started out ok but got worse with every song. Just a random bunch of sounds with some terrible singing over the top. Not for me at all. 1.5/5
Before I start talking about Sister we need to get a few things out of the way. Kim Gordon is a fucking national treasure she is an artist who makes music! Two fuck Thurston Moore for what he did to Kim Gordon, he is still a great artist and musician as well but Kim Gordon is the national treasure not Thurston Moore. Ok, let's get into it shall we. Wait, before we do I should also say that Lee Ranaldo is an amazing guitar player. I don't think that Sonic Youth would sound like they sound if it was not for him, and Steve Shelley does a fantastic job on drums as well. Sister is right at that cross over period from when Sonic Youth was turning from art/noise artists into indie/noise/art rock. For those that think this is a hard listen to go get "Confusion is Sex" or "Death Valley 69". Anyway, My favorite song on this album is Stereo Sanctity but there really is not a bad track on here. And I know that I'm being biased with my love for this band by giving them a 5 star review on *EVERY* album but Sonic Youth is just that good.
A couple good songs, but otherwise forgettable
There is music that I feel I am supposed to like because it influenced bands I like. This is such music.
Sonic Youth are one of the few bands that make me think, “Maybe I had to be there.” We’ve had a lot of their albums on this list, and I’ve liked a few. But I mostly find myself listening passively. I guess I see why people love them, but I wonder if I had to have listened to their music when it came out, or at a younger age. Or maybe there’s a live energy that’s not translating to the recording. There are some heavy, distorted sections that feel tinny when they should be rocking me at a gut level. The music is mixed in a way I find off-putting. The vocals are grating too. Seems like a few different members sing on various tracks, but I don’t like any of them, at least on this album. Having said that, I do get the sense that the band was thoughtful about all these choices. And there are moments of rock and punk power that almost do it for me.
Sometimes Sonic Youth come across as a little too "serious" for me. I have to be in the right mood, like I can't be just going about my day bopping around and come across a song like "Beauty Lies In The Eye" and hearing: "There's something in the air there It makes you go insane Brings you back to me It's been so long All's I have to do is live along It's coming, coming down over me Do you want to see the explosions in my eye?" in a spoken word style performance with ominous post-rock music behind the voice. Don't get me wrong though, I love serious music and I love music that comes across as "too cool" or "apathetic artsy", but I just don't love being surprised by it I guess. This album has a few times when spoken word comes in and gives that "poetry jam" feel, but I don't hate it. They have some songs that I really enjoy, but none of them were on this album. It just leans a little too much into that "we're seriously mysterious" vibe that is a little off putting for me.
Seems like It's rambling and muffled. Not my thing
I enjoyed it!!
First listen
I listened through all of Sonic Youth's albums just a couple months ago, and I think they have maybe 3 "eras," but I don't think that justifies more than maybe 2 albums on this list, and I think they have at least 3. In any case, "Sister" is really the beginning of what Sonic Youth became. I think it is important, so maybe I'd put this on the list, but it's definitely not my favorite or what I think is the best example of what they finessed starting with this album/sound.
Four, I think, but just barely.
I'm pretty shoegazed out. What sets these guys apart from others in their genre? It just drones on and on.
Meh
I liked the first song but the rest was a bit abrasive and noisy. It's not bad and clearly that's the point, but not my favorite
Solid album. No bites taken of the commercial apple on this album. The guitar is outta sight. I'm not sure why this band wasn't bigger.
Very meh
I didn't really like this. It had some okay moments, but most of it was just like annoying noise. There were several moments when I was reaching for the skip button, forgetting that I was listening to a supposedly-great album and wanted to treat it like some crap that was accidentally playing. Two stars, and I think that's being generous.
Sister was an enjoyable listen. The only other Sonic Youth record that I'm familiar with was Daydream Nation and even then, it's been a minute since I last listened to it. I remember listening to "Kool Thing" and "Superstar" as separate singles as well. I didn't really pay too much attention to the lyrics or the vocal melodies honestly, as the guitars were at the front of the mix, often being very suspended, dissonant, noisy and in-your-face. They reminded me of the noisier Midwest emo bands like Mineral, the Gloria Record, Pop Unknown, etc. that I used to listen to. Something I can incorporate into my songwriting is that fuzzy guitar sound, as well as alternate tunings that the band is known for. It can really make my songs standout.
I think I liked it