Reviews (page 6 of 15)
4.6/10
Nice album, only really heard "Changes" before. Obviously, Bowie is an icon but other than the first song, nothing really stood out.
A classic
I've always thought I hated David Bowie. I was right.
Virkelig godt! Mangler liiidt ekstra kreativitet, som Bowies senere, for at vi ryger helt op på 5, men han er jo bare fantastisk i alle aspekter ligeneget hvad 😍
Ch-ch-ch-changes….great start to the album. 3.5 stars
I was pretty disappointed by this album. The last album I heard from him (The Next Day) was a really impressive and exciting album for me, and this just kinda wasn't. I wasn't impressed by anything except Changes, which I already knew was good. I think it's probably a little overrated, but it is a showcase of potential, if nothing else. Favorites: Changes, Song for Bob Dylan
Fav was kooks
Classic, love Quicksand
Bowie, moja wielka miłość. Pierwsza połowa płyty to mocno 9/10, ale później gdzieś wytraca na impecie, staje się rozmyta, nie do końca potrafi dociągnąć to co zaczęła. Gubi moją uwagę. W efekcie kończy na mocnym 8/10
10/10, innit
Classic
I actually listened to Hunky Dory right before I started my 1001 Albums Generator project and quite liked it. I've yet to listen to everything by Bowie, but from all of the albums that I've listened to, I think Hunky Dory might actually be my favourite one. Not sure if I would say that everything on it is great, but rather everything is good with individual standouts like Changes or Life on Mars.
Wow
I mean, I know it's a classic but David Bowie is not my favorite.
Probably not the best David Bowie album, but I enjoy listening to this so much. Just so fun. It has some of his best work (Life on Mars, Changes), although some songs are a bit more weak. And Quicksand is a seriously underrated track.
2.5 out of 5 stars I'm not a big Bowie fan, Changes is the obvious standout on this album. I did enjoy Andy Warhol a bit. I'm glad I listened, but I won't listen again.
An interesting listen. Definitely not my preferred genre, but I see why Bowie is held in such high regard.
Timeless
Tracks 1 -4: Damn David Bowie had the sauce Track 5: 60s pop slop :(
This is such a good album!!! Probably one of Bowie's best!
Approachable Bowie, while still being quirky. The music is dynamic and BIG. Catchy hooks.
Eh, not what I was expecting from my limited exposure to Bowie. I’ll have to give it another listen or two.
Andy Warhol :)
Ten album zasługuje na 4.5 ale nie da się wstawić takiej oceny
One of the best albums by one of the best artists. Quicksand is such an underheard song and has such depth. Life on Mars? has such a unique sound. Changes is such an easily popular song in how easy it is to listen to while not being simple. This review is much worse than the album; give it a listen.
There are too many albums on this list. Many of them don't live up to what an album should really be. This is an Album, not just a playlist of songs. Each song is an event, with time and care invested in the outcome. They are distinct from one another, yet sonically form a united whole in the final product. Quicksand was the stand out track for me that may get overlooked.
Amazing album. Intimate yet powerful, the production is so good it feels like you're in the same room. All the songs are beautifully written and performed with no weak tracks. Absolute banger.
I did enjoy this a fair bit - some really strong highlights and it is genuinely expansive and tries a bunch of styles. I found that this made it a bit less cohesive and I didn't enjoy it as much but I understand that others could argue that this is the greatest strength of the record. I can imagine listening to this in 1971 (?) and being very excited for what Bowie will do next
Best Bowie so far, I LOVE Life on Mars
Fav song: Life on Mars? I love David Bowie. This one's got some BANGERS but it's also just a biiiiit too polite sounding. Crazy that just one year later we got the spiders from mars!!!
This is where David Bowie truly started to come into his own as a songwriter.
Some songs are great, but not all of them are my cup of coffee.
was a good listen but got distracted
I was gonna say this feels like a space themed Bob Dylan album, but then i heard Andy Warhol and that kinda broke that immersion. Anyways this is another bunch of songs form David, they're really hopeful and gleeful. 8/10
Potentially my favorite of Bowie's albums. Not quite as "dancy" as Young Americans, but more of a rock vibe. I proffer again that Bowie is not a great singer (in that I don't think he has a great voice), but he is a phenomenal artist and musician. Has great instincts for when and where to be different.
Start was good and then it went meh
What a genuine pleasure when an album has three mega hits AND the rest of the album could have been hits too. Bowie is probably the genius that everyone has always said he is. Everything on here is a banger, he even faked me out with Andy Warhol, weird start into one of if not the coolest riff on the album. Obsessed with this album, easy 5.
This dude fucks so hard. First time listen, loved it. I want to own a copy of this record, it's so good and plays so well. Changes alone warrants an entry in Dimery's list but that's just the starting point. Holy shit is Mr Brightside pre-chorus ripping Queen Bitch? Truly a singular artist, no one has had the creative career of David Bowie. I can't wait for the next one 5/5
It’s Bowie!
OK, starts good but slopes off
Actually enjoyed it. Changes is a little too cliche from its overuse in movies and stuff, but the album is fun, musical, and cohesive. Would listen again.
Big enjoy
Creative, original, wild, captivating. Bowie.
..
This album is the perfect example of David Bowie, some of it is great, some not so much.
Not my favourite Bowie album, I must admit. It was mostly a bit too weird and "out there". "Life on Mars" and "Changes" are the only two tracks that I really quite enjoyed... Oh! and the song for Bob Dylan is pretty good too.
Although Life on Mars is my favorite song on the album, I prefer my Bowie with guitar rather than piano. Give me the main acoustic riff from Andy Warhol or the electrics on Queen Bitch any day
Look out, you rock'n'rollers
It's kind of amazing how much of Bowie's sound emerges on this album. Furthermore, how much of his future work is hinted at here. Hunky Dory may be the first truly good Bowie album. Then again, there are songs like "Kooks" and "Fill Your Heart" that feel like a hangover from past album cycles. A great effort, I'm just not that into the 70's sounds the songwriting tends to fall into. Listened to while stoned and chilling in bed between the hours of 9:30-10:30 on a Sunday in May
I'm in general not a Bowie fan. This album didn't do it for me
70'ler rock sıkıcı geliyor moruk
Obvs a good ‘un
Brilliant album. Packed with classics. Original, influential, class.
Perfect. Really high quality, the ones I knew and the ones I didn't (for some reason I'd only ever really thought I'd listened to side 1, but side 2 had quality to spare. Turns out I've had Queen Bitch in my head for years without knowing it!
This is the third Bowie album I’ve listened to so far, and I’m really loving his stuff. This album’s a near 5, but I just wish it wasn’t so front heavy and it kept the momentum going all the way through. Otherwise, it’s still a very solid album, and I’m excited to listen to more from him.
Brilliant. Under rated album of Bowie’s, especially by myself. Greatly enjoyed. 9/10
#7 Please no more 60s and 70s...
Start of the soundtrack to the 70s!
This is among Bowie's best, in my opinion. Or at least this is the Bowie I like best. This and his Berlin phase.
Forgot that Metallica used the riff of 'Warhol' in 'Master of Puppets' bc Cliff loved Bowie. And I don't know if I'd ever heard the actual version of 'Life on Mars' just the Portuguese cover from The Life Aquatic. Bowie was definitely reading his Nietzsche when he made this. 'Song for Dylan' nails Dylan to a T.
a classic
enjoyed
What can you say about David Bowie. The man can bend time and space with his voice. Every song on here is a banger. Standouts are Changes, Life on Mars and the Bellway Brothers.
The album is good, but it may be time for me to admit to myself that I'm just not a huge Bowie fan. Most of his music doesn't do a lot for me.
Better than the first Bowie one I listened to. Still not crazy about it but there are some good vibes. Very different in a good way.
Is there a Bowie album *not* on this list? This one was pretty decent, anyway. Just didn't enjoy the B-side all that much.
Bowie’s gets one step closer to making a masterpiece. Favs: Changes Oh! You Pretty Things Life On Mars Queen Bitch Least Favs: Kooks
This sounds like if they let the King George character from Hamilton have an entire album.
It's really good. I'm tired and it is really good. Maybe "Andy Warhol" doesn't hit for me completely, but the more I hear the rest, the more groundbreaking it sounds. I hear a true artist coming out of the shadows on this record. I mean, "Changes" and "Life On Mars?" on the same record is crazy. By far, this is Bowie's most artistic statement I've heard from him on this challenge. I've heard three different albums from him (Station To Station, The Next Day, Hunky Dory) and they all sound drastically different. If there was a man who could pull off musical dress-up while still sounding identifiable the entire time, it's David Bowie. It's true art-pop/rock. It's art, in general. It's a pretty thing (9/10, 5/5 on this scale)
It’s OK, but Bowie doesn’t get great until later.
On HYVÄ
Hieno levy 👌🏼
Fanitin pienenä Hectoria ja kuuntelin Sudenkorentoa tietämättä että sehän olikin käännösiskelmä. Kiva kuulla myös idolin idolilta 20v myöhemmin se alkuperäinen. Melko maaginen biisinikkari.
Fun glam rock/pop album that sees Bowie coming into his own. The first half is stellar with arguably his best song ever "Life on Mars". The 2nd half falls off a bit but there are still good tracks like "Queen Bitch". It really shows where he is headed after this album, like he's in labor with Ziggy Stardust.
A lot of this is new to me, even being a modest Bowie fan. Really good stuff, and a 4 star album for sure but then the remaining tracks at the end brought this to a 5 for me.
Vibes: 3/5 Instruments: 4/5 Production: 3/5 Emotional Value: 4/5 Storytelling: 3/5 Stand Outs: Oh! You Pretty Things, Life on Mars? Overall Rating: 3.4
No one asks me what my favorite song is any more, but when they did, it was always a Bowie song. The Bowie song changed periodically, but it was always a Bowie song. For a long time, it was Changes. I love that song. If you put a gun to my head and told me to sing a song with no mistakes, this one would probably be in the running. This album also has a few other runners up: Oh You Pretty Things, Life on Mars?, and Queen Bitch. According to Spotify in this moment, I have 20 Bowie songs on my "Liked Songs" playlist, but only 2 or 3 from each album. Despite my unending love for Bowie, I don't often listen to full albums of his work. I've never listened to Hunky Dory all of the way through, but now that I am, I can say that it's all delightfully Bowie, but I'll stick with my 4 aforementioned standouts for now.
I was never a fan of Bowie to begin with, but this is the most forgettable album I’ve heard from him so far. I don’t know what to say. It’s just a nothing burger. It’s not bad by any means, but it didn’t stuck with me at all and left no impression. It’s fine, I guess, but not something I’d want to return to in the future.
I’m definitely more of a Bowie greatest hits kinda guy
I'm more into his weird Berlin era but this one's solid as well
Close to a 4, couple of big hitters on this one ★★★½☆
Not my favourite Bowie album but very consistent and a classic. Andy Warhol is one of my favs
not my favourite Bowie album but it's got my favourite singles. non-single tracks are a bit boring
Dad- NA Mom- 9.5 Mike- NA Lori- 9.5 Michael- 9.5 Miles- NA Cole- NA Avg- 9.5
He conocido mas canciones de las que pensaba, pero me ha acabado sonando un poco lo mismo todo y me ha dado pereza al final. Nunca he terminado de pillar a este tie
What is the most powerful song to you? I was asked this question before and it’s a very tough one but eventually I realised the answer… ‘life on mars’ I could literally go mad on linking every line to something personal in my life right down to the ‘norfolk broads’ and the ‘my mother my dog and clowns’ lines. It’s one where I can just make uncanny personal references, all I will say is that verse 1 feels like 1 part of my life then verse 2 is another. I get it’s a bit ‘sad’ but this song just shows the power of music for me. The other songs are great, Changes brings me back to the horrible histories parody. Kooks really isn’t as bad as the reputation it’s given and I find it really fun. Quicksand is a masterpiece. Andy warhol is brilliant I especially love the weird intro. Queen bitch is one of the best rockers bowie ever did. Then the Bewlay brothers is one of those perfect closers. 5/5
I started to enjoy 70s+ David Bowie much later in my life - after I'd seen him live on the Sound+Vision tour. This album harks back to his 60s stuff with the famous songs thrown in too. It gets added to the albums I need on vinyl. 5/5
4.5 - Good Stuff. Plenty I knew. Some Vaudeville piano songs.
A great sample of classic rock, but a bit out there conceptually
An excellent, enjoyable album.
Changes is an all-time great. God, I love Bowie.
"So I turned myself to face me But I've never caught a glimpse..." Love how piano-forward this album is. *Eight-line poem
While the singles here are masterpieces, I don't think they quite make up for some of the filler tracks here which really break up the flow of the entire thing.
Bowie's first great album. Changes and Life on Mars are two of his greatest tracks.
I may regret only giving this four stars. My mum's favourite Bowie album, and it is of course brilliant. No weak tracks - just on the whole it doesn't carry the same weight as The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars, Station to Station, or some of his later stuff. This album is a little lighter and more whimsical in the lyrics, which I do like a lot. I enjoy every song, but at no point did I really go WOW, like I do with a lot of his other work. I think part of it may be due to the fact that most songs are sort of ballads. Who knows. Very good, but not his best.
I am not sure how overall these years I’ve criminally underrated David Bowie. This is an outstanding album. Definitely worth your time.
Bowie zum dritten, "life on mars"/"Queen Bitch" wieder das cover so gut, Dorian grey reminiscence? die Musik? c
Hands down, all-timer. Influential on so many levels.
Absolutely amazing album
Not my favorite Bowie album but still beast.
Nice sort of old-school country rock
Quite the experimental album but I guess that is what Bowie was all about.
His first or second greatest record
So good I listened to it twice. It's "vintage Bowie" but it's got some super familiar classic tracks interspersed with some decent less known material that holds it all together rather well.
i have struggled with bowie my whole life, and i guess i always will
So excited to have a David Bowie album! The only song I knew beforehand was Changes. It’s the first song and it’s also the song I listened to on the way to my new job! :) It wasn’t my favorite David Bowie album, but I still liked it. It was a little slow and I needed faster tunes for the morning. Best Songs: Changes (duh) Oh! You Pretty Things Life on Mars? (Have you ever noticed David Bowie’s best songs are about space?) Worst Songs: Andy Warhol
Solid stuff
Second half a bit weak, but first half oh so strong. Maybe a four.
I still don't care for David Bowie but this earlier album was better than his later ones, IMO.
Very interesting and ahead of it's time I would say. Better than I expected fs.
Need to relisten once. Wasn't blown away.
Who knew Post Pop began in '71? With Ronson more background and Wakeman's piano to the fore this is a real mix of styles but as an album it still works, surprisingly. Life On Mars and Changes still sound fresh today.
Fantastic album. Lyrical mastery mixed with interesting and catchy music
Probably not my favourite Bowie album but it’s a pretty high bar considering all his work. The first half of this album is particularly strong.
I LOVE David Bowie. That doesn't mean I'm not honest with myself when it comes to his albums. Just like most of his catalogue there are 1 or 2 GREAT songs on here and a couple of fantastic sections in other songs that are otherwise good to poor. Very uneven throughout. The great vastly outweighs the bad though because when Bowie is on he's genius.
Such great songwriting, not a lot to say here. Production is so sweet as well
Let me start by saying that I have a tremendous bias for David Bowie. This was the music of my "I feel miserable and I need to not feel miserable" music. The day he died, I went in to work early and put on my Bowie playlist and when the first notes of "Life On Mars" dropped, I started sobbing uncontrollably. I've never shed tears for a celebrity before or since. But this was my guy. A more rational opinion would acknowledge that "Eight Line Poem" and "Fill Your Heart" ain't that great, "Andy Warhol" isn't much aside from a cool guitar riff, and impending fatherhood made Bowie maudlin on "Kooks" (although this a song I sing to my dogs, so I obviously don't hate it) and I don't know what he's on about in "Quicksand" (but the music's great, so I don't really care). I rarely focus on lyrics and Bowie could often be inscrutable, but "Changes" is not that. Unpretentious, pointed prose that comes together melodically and resolves in a great chorus. Life On Mars is a seminal piece of music and never fails to make my heart swell. "Queen Bitch" has one of the all-time great riffs. "The Bewlay Brothers" is a devastating song about Bowie's schizophrenic brother. "Oh! You Pretty Things" is joyous and "Song For Bob Dylan" that serves as both send-up and tribute is a lot of fun. Any album with "Changes," "Life On Mars" and "Queen Bitch" is getting an automatic five stars, but even without those three giants, I think this album might still earn it. One of the best from one of the greatest English-language artists of all-time.
Some of this is the best music Bowie ever made (Changes, Life On Mars), some of it is a teensy bit forgettable. Still a brilliant album, just not his absolute best.
I have to be in the right mood for Bowie. Some days I love him, others he just sounds irritating. That being said, this is one of my favorite albums of his.
I've always appreciated Bowie but never got into him, guess there's no time like the present. I like this album but not something that I'm super into. I guess I can appreciate David Bowie as an icon without actually loving his music; some of my favorite artists were heavily influenced by him. I would never turn off a Bowie song but not sure I would ever put one on. Great for what it is and I will have to try another album to see if it "sticks"
Upbeat, does what it says on the tin.
Not my vibe
Life on Mars is one of the greatest songs of all time. Also, Rick Wakeman is a beast
I can see how this is considered the first great album of Bowie's career, with songs like Changes and Life on Mara front-loading the track list. Everything else her works too, even if to a significantly less degree. It's a pleasant listen but certainly nothing that would come to characterize Bowie's groundbreaking career. But this is just the beginning.
Coming in between the bluesy rock of The Man who Sold the World and the magnificently overblown rock opera of Ziggy, Hunky Dory is a much more conventional pop album with a much tighter focus on songwriting rather than the showmanship that became a staple of Bowie's later music. Not for nothing did many of the songs on Hunky Dory become staple songs of Bowie's live concerts all the way till the end of his career, there's a raw emotion that radiates from every song and the short nature of the tracks (only three of the eleven on the album go past the four minute mark) means nothing ever lingers long enough to bore the listener. It's probably the most straightforward album Bowie ever wrote and the one that firmly established him as pop rock's vanguard for the rest of the 1970's.
First time hearing. Great album.
Oh! You Pretty Things might be one of his best tracks. Changes is a classic, as is Life on Mars
I like Bowie. I appreciate Bowie's genius. I wish I loved Bowie. I don't love Bowie.
A lot of great songs. Not as consistently great as some of Bowie’s albums.
Absolute Classic. Bowie was formative for me and this is one of the albums that did it. Love how weird it gets towards the end, but the the first half is the winner for me.
Changes was good
The first part up until Life on Mars is amazing, but the rest of the album is very good too
Good sounds like a good David Bowie music
Bowie at his best ❤️
Bowie’s first masterpiece. Certainly not his last.
Snored through it.
Hunky Dory isn't among my favorite Bowie albums, but is an important album for Bowie as much as it is for the Art Pop genre. No historical ranting this time, Hunky Dory is what David Bowie gathered the good aspects of pop music of his time into a better than average pop album for its time. Still probably his worst album that appears on this list. Yay.
7/10 - Classic David Bowie
Me gusta
What a banger of an album. Life on mars has to be one of my all time fav Bowie tracks. This one is very close to being a 5 star but not quite there 4.3
a few songs I knew, never did an in depht of bowie
Great album start to finish
Album 40/1001 With Hot Fuss still fresh in my head, I've just noticed how much of a rip-off Mr Brightside is of Queen Bitch. They call themselves The Killers? The Thieves, more like. 👨🎤 Favourite lyrics: THE BEWLAY BROTHERS "Lay me place and bake me pie I'm starving for me gravy" Favourite song: Life on Mars? 🔭🌌 Honourable mention: Changes 🔄🔁 Queen Bitch 👑🐩 Quicksand ⏳️⌛️ Oh! You Pretty Things 🙀😻 The Bewlay Brothers 👨🎤🙇♂️
Welp.. turns out I really like this version of Bowie A LOT. I did not come across a mid song until Fill Your Heart. Beyond personal taste these are well constructed, driving songs that stay with you. YMMV on the songwriting but they are up my alley.
Highlights: Mars, Kooks, Chamges, Pretty Things, Queen Bitch. Just too many strong songs not to be a 5. I like this folky singer/songwriter era Bowie!
Edit: Nah, y'all are right, this is a 5. Original review: This is a strong 4.5/5 for me, but will keep it at 4. Man, what a great selection of tracks. I haven't loved the other Bowie we've had on the list so far and it was starting to stress me out. Glad there's an era a Bowie I do, in fact, love! Also Kooks is beautiful and made me cry. 🙃
one of my favorites 😍
This is my Always-Sunny-Frank-Reynolds moment for Bowie. I get it now.
one of his better ones.
Bowie had to make this album in order to shake off his singer-songwriter pretensions and start changing music the way the gods intended him to do. THat being said, what a great album. It flows from Introspective meanderings, to a cluster of tributes (Warhol, Dylan, The V.U.) to whatever the hell "The Bewlay Brothers" is. An album I've heard countless times that evokes something different every time I hear it. It grows with the listener. Very cogent and straightforward, for Bowie, which is in itself interesting. "Quicksand" and "Life On Mars?" bowl me over emotionally every time. Beautiful delivery and poetry, and even though Bowie hasn't QUITE found his voice, this is his launchpad.
When this came out I was a sophomore in college, and Bowie was not on my radar much. I did like the song Changes, probably from radio airplay, but I was fairly ignorant (and high) in those days. With today's ears, I think this is a very cohesive and well executed album. Time to dig out the Ziggy stuff, I guess....
Just had a Bowie album recently and loved it. Here's another.... love it as well. Maybe even more than the last. 4.5/5
Awesome album!
this album is all hunky dory
Every song on this record is pretty epic. David Bowie’s a magician who transforms music into emotional sorcery that cuts straight to the soul.
What a fantastic album, seeing Bowie shift to a more piano/rock style is a fun listen. This album has multiple incredible piano sections. And some other songs people don't like(Andy Warhol, which is a solid track) What is there to be said about Life on Mars that already hasn't been said?? Some amazing storytelling, perfectly completed by the music in a non didactic way, building into climax which is the best chorus on the album where the lyrics are working in the opposite direction of the verse. *Chefs kiss* Then you have Changes, Then Pretty Things, Quicksand, Andy Warhol and The Bewlay Brothers. Favorite track, Queen Bitch, straight punk rock in vein of The Modern Lovers Solid 4/5 stars those 41 minutes just roll by
Best: Life on Mars? Worst: Fill your heart Liked songs: 11/11, 100% Mid 4 After listening to Blackstar a few times this week, its really interesting to juxtapose it with the album Bowie became Bowie. Of course his sound and lyricism developed quite a bit in the 4 and a half decades separating the album, but it's clear that Bowie has always been an artist unafraid to blaze his own trail and remain fearlessly unique. It's just a fun album all around, with pretty solid lyrics and a really unique but infectious sound. Its one of those albums where I actually think the B-sides carry, and really make me appreciate the album, though of course the two singles everyone knows are amazing. A very fitting album to essentially start perhaps the greatest artist to ever have lived's career.
10/10
I really enjoyed this album. At the time, the artist was unusual, different, and exciting and producing music with a unique sound. I really liked the song, "Kooks". The song, "Life On Mars?" was the most familiar as that was the song most played on the radio. My least favorite song, "The Bewlay Brothers" as the song went on a little too long.
Solidifies that I don’t like Bowie.
Every David Bowie album that shows up here further solidifies my opinion that I’m just not a fan. I wish I liked his voice more!
Solid Bowie album, happy with this one
Going well.
Life on mars was great
Bowie at times can feel complex, but this is one of those albums that helps define him, in my opinion. Layered, unique, confusing, but ultimately very entertaining! If one were to be introduced to Bowie, LIFE ON MARS? would be an apt selection. While side 1 obviously is much more acclaimed, for obvious reasons, I've grown to really appreciate how impressive side 2 is, especially THE BEWLAY BROTHERS
An album that makes you feel like the title suggests. One of the better Bowie albums imo and a great one to sing along to that gets stuck in your head in a good way
My preferable Bowie. I had gotten very bored by many of them but I liked this one
I've already listened to his album (24). Not Bowie's best, but Rick Wakeman steals the show. Changes + Life on Mars
4.5/10 Top track: Changes / Life On Mars
Really loved it!!
A really good album. Life on Mars is the highlight.
there are some classics on this one. i thought Life on Mars was before this. it does have that sound that he would eventually be known for. i can't argue that earlier Bowie is better, but i like it more. Space Oddity, Unwashed..., Memory of a Free Festival, these are where my heart are. but this is where he started to be more out there to see where the limit was, hence the song Changes. there are for sure some good tracks here. the references to Dylan and Warhol are cringe, but it was the time. i am not very familiar with this record, but it does have a great variation of songs. Kooks is fun. 3/5.
I've been a fan of Bowie's for some time now, and this album stands as one of his finest. It was released at a fascinating point in Bowie's life, as he had recently gained mainstream popularity and was experimenting radically with his public personality as well as his sound. Much as he would toy with different personas throughout his career, this album sees him "trying on" the musical styles of his influences at the time with tributes to Andy Warhol, Bob Dylan, Lou Reed, and Neil Young. The lyrics throughout blend the personal and universal, with references to change and transition (Changes, Oh! You Pretty Things) and greater existential questions (Life on Mars?, Quicksand). Kooks is a wonderfully vulnerable song written to his newborn son that, in today's context, could easily speak to the insecurities of those raising kids in nontraditional family structures. The true highlight of the album for me is Life on Mars? - cinematic in lyrics and production, it takes the record from a strong showing to a true classic.
The first half of this album is so amazing that it makes up for a few duds later on. Quicksand is one of Bowie's best songs
So good
Sets the tone with the first one and stays right there for the entire album. Wall to wall Bowie, baybeee!!!!
Quirky without losing depth.
Pretty solid
The only hot take I have about this album is that the lesser-known acoustic "demo" version of "Quicksand", made available on CD reissues since 1990, is better than the studio version. Shame it's not as readily available on streaming services. That's why you buy physical, baby!
My music archive informs me I listened to every then-existent Bowie album back in 2009 and the only songs from this album that made it onto my infinite playlist were "Life on Mars?", "Song for Dylan," and "Queen Bitch" and I stand by those choices—"Changes" is overrated, fight me! Flashes of the greatness still to come, but overall too disjointed and derivative with an occasional stopover in annoyingly twee. Best: "Life on Mars?" Worst: "Kooks"
I would call myself a Bowie fan but many on this album I hadn’t heard. Changes was the only one I had heard. I don’t think I’m gonna make myself many fans with this review. There are some really good songs on this album but many of them feel very much “not Bowie.” Now let me explain. Some of the simpler songs remind me of Elton John or the Beatles songs like Quicksand which I think might be my least favorite song on the album sounds so much like an Elton John song. Whereas songs like Andy Warhol, which despite the subject of the song being a shitbag is my favorite song on the album. It is so because it starts so strange and continues to be so unabashedly. As someone who knows David Bowie mostly from after this album, to me David Bowie has always sat in an area where his music both instrumentally and lyrically is dense. There is a lot to dissect and enjoy. In my head his voice shines the most with a full sound behind him. He celebrates oddities and weirdos (or at least he always has in my head) and I love him for that. This album by contrast feels like a man that is sitting on a dock before a voyage into the unknown. We gets some glimpses to the future adventures (Andy Warhol, Life on Mars, Changes) but a lot of the songs are quieter or at least simpler reflections on his past and the people that shaped him. (Quicksand, Song for Bob Dylan). At the time I can’t imagine what might have been going through his head but now here in 2025 I want to shout and tell the man that “Keep going! Unmoor yourself from the present and the past.” I would be surprised if this is the last we see of David Bowie on this listen through and I do appreciate the importance of this album for him to become what he became. I just felt myself longing for later Bowie. That’s not this album’s fault but it’s a feeling I can’t shake.
A banger pianist and soulful instrumentation were not enough to rescue the inscrutable lyrics, disjointed experiments, and aloof vocals of an album unwilling to explore its own thoughts on any of its topics from changes to freedom, love and film. I can tell there is a story here. I wish I knew what it was.
This album was not my jam. The lyrics continuously were creative, powerful, and captivated my attention. But the singing + instruments just sounded discordant to me frequently. The slower songs tended to be the ones I enjoyed the most which was more like listening to David Bowie recite poetry with a guitar. Highlight: Life on Mars. I wasn't a big fan of sound, but the lyrics were a superb story process: "Take a look at the lawman Beating up the wrong guy. Oh man!".
I never thought I would listen to a Bowie album that I would enjoy. I may actually even come back to this one
not my favorite bowie overall but life on mars is a classic ofc
Has some of my favorite tracks, and honestly some forgettable ones
Já tinha escutado um trabalho solo dele (Ziggy Stardust), mas não de outra era dele Gostei da experiência, apesar de já conhecer Life On Mars? e talvez já ter escutado Changes, mas a sua participação em Under Pressure ainda é superior
Not impressed
Another classic, don’t know if this is even better than ziggy stardust
It's more Bowie, the couple of hits are good, especially Changes but overall I just don't get on with him.
I didn't "get" Bowie for a long time. Sure, I knew the radio hits ("Changes" obviously included in that) but I never really got into his albums until the indie aughts movement where I learned just how big of an influence he is. I was on some message board and someone brought up this album as one of the greatest of all time. It has since become a personal favorite, and although it might not be Bowie's best (I'd probably give that to Ziggy Stardust), Hunky Dory is probably the best to me. I always chuckle when I get an album that's on my personal list of greatest of all time. It's an easy 5-star for me. But will I listen to it again? Of course, why wouldn't I?
My favorite record of his. Exceptional from beginning to end.
Outside of this challenge I've been running my own challenges for a number of years. One of those was finishing the Bowie discography. I came to the conclusion that I'm a fan of the idea of Bowie rather than the reality. His supposed ability to shift like a chameleon didn't ring true, and many of his albums felt indistinct. I couldn't love his vocals. I didn't like the glam stuff. He seemed like he had only two types of song. But, it's Bowie, I get his importance. Nothing against him, but the music does little for me. Having said that, this one includes my favourite Bowie song, one I'd loved before I ever heard the album (Quicksand). My personal take is three stars, but the Bowie importance bumps it to 4.
I just can't connect with Bowie's singing style. I wonder if I'd enjoy it if the backing band had a vocalist whose voice I enjoyed.
Historically my favourite Bowie album, and I imagine that will hold up as I get like seven more of them in my final 300-ish albums here. Queen Bitch probably rocks more than any of his other songs.
Just always a great idea to give this another listen. One of Bowie’s best! How funny are the lyrics to Andy Warhol, though? Andy walking, Andy tired Andy take a little snooze
I liked it a lot
Never really got Bowie in his prime was t until last 20 years that I really listened to him.
muy lindo sonido y voz, canciones divertidas y diferentes a todo el resto, da placer escucharlas. quiero escuchar mas Bowie
I just can't get into Bowie no matter how much I try. I liked Changes and that was about it. Definitely not his worst though
So damn musical. Love this album, no matter how many spins it's spun in my life. Still interesting, with certified bangers throughout.
Life on Mars are all timer Bowie songs, a good chunk of the album doesn’t quite live up but it finishes strong.
David Bowie still is amazing. Cover 5/5 love the art
Man, I love Bowie in general, but this album didn't really do anything for me.
Not my favorite Bowie, but it’s still good.
While it has a lot of eccentricities, most of the album didn't make much of a memorable impression on me. Life on Mars is a certified banger, and the back half of the album is better than the first, but most of it passed over me as a pastiche of British, psychedelic rock. It's well made and there are some nice surprises here and there, but certainly not my favorite of Bowie's. The cover however, is a strong 4/5, just iconic Bowie stuff and very stylish.
An all-timer within the discography of an all-timer, though not completely consistent in its quality (the best tracks are a cut above the rest, and Eight Line Poem basically just takes up space) it's still a rather wild joy from start to finish, it just took a little extra time for this wildness and inspiration to be honed and assembled into a more coherent masterpiece in Ziggy Stardust But there's no sense in skipping this one either, obviously
Life on Mars I knew and like. The rest is also nice but I’ll have to listen to it again. Second listen is also very cool and funky I like it
79% Best: Changes; Life on Mars?; Queen Bitch Must-Hear? Almost. If I were to eliminate a Bowie album for the 1001 (which needs to happen), it would be this. This is only my third Bowie record, but that's the way it stands as of now.
God I love this album
My favorite early Bowie.
David Bowie is one of those artists that people say you're "supposed" to like. And, I do like some of his songs, but Hunky Dory is take it or leave it for me. It feels like a weird in-between from his early stuff before he started getting into his more main sequence glam rock. And if I'm being really honest, this album is pretty sleepy other than Changes.
Yeah Bowie. Didn't know this album actually except for ch...ch...changes. Seeing that spraypainted on walls in the inner Auckland suburbs in the late 70s makes me want to rate this highly regardless of the rest. Some quirky, others rocky, but all quintessential Bowie. Cream on top? His ode to Bob. A Dylanesque masterpiece that brings Bowie on that level.
Life on Mars is one of the greatest songs of all time. Oh you pretty things similar. The rest is good too but doesn’t connect as much with me
Wouldn't put this on my top five Bowie albums, and I honestly think Changes is a terrible song
7.8
Probably my favorite Bowie album so far, I liked it for the most part. Enough melody and hooks, a little bit experimental, but not too far, it was pretty palatable. The hits are amazing as always.
Hunky Dory will always have a special place in how I think of Bowie's discography — it was the first record of his I bought. I've nearly worn it out listening over the years and finding something new in the music and lyrics. It's a mirror — there's a song for nearly every mood and moment. Don't you have one in mind for yourself already? Most people reach for Changes. But Life on Mars, while being about disillusionment and escapism, also names the current geopolitical moment for me even though it was written so long ago. Or I could pick Quicksand because it speaks something into being about being caught between things, liminal and living in what some might already consider some kind of twilight — seeking and paralyzed — intellectually and spiritually stuck while searching for solid ground. But isn't Andy Warhol the best pick? It's about someone known for making himself a surface and yet it's about so much more — the universal experience of performing an identity and the masks we all wear. Listening to an icon writing about another icon, reflecting on what's surface versus substance, feels right today. And tomorrow? Maybe it's a Queen Bitch day.
It’s not my thing Liked Andy Warhol song And last song 5/10
I know Bowie has better than this.
One of my fav albums of all time, nice to listen to it again
I just really don't get the Bowie hype. I think this album was fine. It seemed very normal to me for something from 1971; some hits, some duds, and a slightly-grating, high British tenor voice. Maybe the magic is in his later work, but I don't really see it here. Fave songs: - Changes - Life on Mars? - Quicksand - Fill Your Heart - Andy Warhol
Whimsical, in a way. I can’t get over the (rampant) child rape. I don’t care if everyone was doing it. I do hear some stuff that has been repeated often since. He’s been an influence for sure. I do agree with the Andy Warhol hate (?). Still not a great song though. Nevermind, it was supposed to be a tribute. Apparently Andy hated it.
Amazing. 4.5/5
Not a single miss on the whole album
4.5
Fantastic album that I'm a bit ashamed to say I had never heard cover to cover until this. David Bowie was a true musical genius and it's evident here.
Great album. I can see a lot of his influence in modern music. Really like Andy Warhol and Fill Your Heart. This album is added to a list of repeats now.
Some good, some bad. Not my favorite Bowie tracks, but a listenable album overall.
Stellar. Hunky Dory is the beginning of a 12-13 year period for Bowie that is as good as any artist’s pinnacle. Listen straight through, every song is good. There are obvious huge hits on this album, but don’t sleep on the non-singles - everything here is worth your time. Changes, Oh! You Pretty Things, Eight Line Poem, Life on Mars?, Quicksand, Queen Bitch, The Bewlay Brothers are my favorites.
Schon David Bowie. Hat was zum anhören, aber schon grade eher Theater mäßig. Queen ist glaube auch so eine Richtung.
I've been meaning to listen to this one for a while. I enjoyed it but need another listen.
good
One of Bowie's better albums. Probably the first really, really good one with lots of classics: Life on Mars and Oh! You Pretty Things are standout tracks.
Just pure classics, soul fullfilling
"Time may change me. But I can't trace time." My second favorite Bowie Album, although I'm reasonably sure "Life on Mars?" is my favorite pre-1990 rock song. The first side of this album is especially stacked, with that one plus "Changes" and "Oh! You Pretty Things." The album cover is a dud though.
Changes is a great song! The whole album is a vibe.
Cover 5 Really haven't done a deep dive of Bowie. Growing up, my initial impression of any artist was mostly from the radio. Dancing in the Streets (1985 - I was ten) with Mick Jagger was a horrible introduction to Bowie's music. So I never looked further. I don't think this album helped. I do intend to look further, because it's David Bowie and people are like "he's a genius" or whatever. But this was only ok. Nothing particularly awful, but nothing stood out to me either.
Legalzinho
Another great album from Bowie. The classics which were heard on the radio Changes Oh You Pretty Things Life on Mars Plus some lesser known but worth the listen. Ones which caught my attention were: Andy Warhol Song for Bob Dylan The Bewlay Brothers I liked some of the quieter acoustic based tracks
I really try but Bowie clicks differently to me, and this one didn't make it so far up my list
It was fine, I like others better
One of the best albums ever.
I think this my favourite Bowie album so far. I'm not a fan though but hearing Changes and Life on Mars was good.
Love it. Own it.
My second favourite after Ziggy! This is just too good to be real. Can you imagine an album coming out today with this many massive tracks on it? No you can’t!
By most standards, this is a masterpiece. By Bowie standards, it's mid.
Some hits but a bit inconsistent
This young Bowie guy’s showing lots of potential
I had never listened to this album before. I have now listened to it twice, back to back. It filled me with a desire to dance and to be my true self. Exactly what an album should do!
All time favorite Bowie album.
One of Bowie’s best albums in my opinion. I like how it feels like a musical.
Finally a Bowie album I'm not going to give a 5 to. People see this as the beginning of Bowie's hot streak, and based on the high points on this album, I can sort of see why, but there's too many tracks here that I don't really feel anything about, which I can't say for the album that follows it. Sure, Life On Mars is one of the greatest songs of all time, but I feel people we just impressed that Bowie was finally putting 4-5 amazing tracks on an album, as opposed to just 1, maybe 2 at best. I am giving 4 Stars though. Changes, Oh You Pretty Things, Queen Bitch and the Belway Brothers all deserve the praise they receive.
Not unexpectedly, this is very good Bowie with Life on Mars leading the line for me. Go buy it.
One of my all time favourites
Bowie is the greatest
In theory I should love David Bowie's music. I am a fan of artists reinventing themselves and trying new things. I'm a fan of critic's darlings. I love "weirdness." I have always "tried" to love his music. Unfortunately, I've never really been able to get into it. I can't put my finger on it, other than there is a coldness and detachment I feel when I listen to his songs. There are a few here and there that I really like, but I've never been able to listen to an album of his and truly enjoy it. I am aware that there are quite of a few of his records on this list, and my hope was that I'd have a different experience listening more critically. There are others on the list that I have completely come around on, so I thought it would be the case with Bowie. This is my first album of his that I've been given, so this morning I was both excited and apprehensive. What I came away with after listening is that my original thoughts haven't changed at all. There is talent for sure. There are songs I enjoy more than others, but in the end, I guess I just don't really like his music overall and that's the way it's going to be. I think I have six more to go...
Cool album. Got me familiar with the term art pop. Kind of more ballsy and brave decisions arrangement and composition wise. Interesting chord progressions and production. Not sure if I want to relisten anything from it, song Changes stocked a bit. It could become really dear music to me if I d relisten a lot. Reminded late arctic monkeys, I guess that’s where the inspiration is from. Piano driven tracks but without constant loops spamming the chords progression.
Quite Fringe. Hard for me to personally get through.
Second or third Bowie y
oh god this album is so good!
Changes always makes me think of Shrek 2
3.8
This album is pretty lame. I’m giving it three stars on the the strength of Changes, Pretty Things and Life On Mars. Otherwise it’s folky and it doesn’t rock
A fine album. Changes holds up. There are some interesting songs in there, but overall it's kinda dull
This was great! I have a soft spot for life on mars in particular, but the album as a whole holds up well. It's catchy, varied, well written... You can tell he was writing from the piano for most of it, which I tend to like as a pianist. Songs just sound different when you write them from different instruments, even if those instruments aren't in the final recording at all. This wasn't quite masterpiece level for me, but a good time was had listening, and I'd definitely listen again.
It's tender and understated but also powerful. Bowie's undeniable talent comes through with a strength and softness like a velvet hammer.
This was a fun listen, particularly with "Life on Mars".
2 out of 5 Star Man was out there lol. Not all of these are hits!
Two great songs on here. Not really loving everything else.
7/10
A classic, albeit with a couple of weak ones which stop it being a 5
If Aladdin Sane was Bowie building on Ziggy by turning everything up to 11, this was him carefully exploring the ideas that would become it. Of his classic albums, it's the most playful, having an almost twee sound at times. But it's also one of the sparsest, being dominated by piano and acoustic guitar with some string flourishes. This formula usually succeeds; "Life On Mars" is a top five Bowie song, "Changes" and "Quicksand" are highlights, and his Dylan and Velvet Underground impersonations near the end hint at the range he'd display later in his career.. But a few tracks, like "Kooks" and "Fill Your Heart," feel a bit too light and airy. It all comes together into a transitional album that exhibits his best qualities without the variety or excitement he'd showcase later on.
We’re gonna run out of Bowie and we aren’t even done with the first year!
This is probably what a lot people think of when they think of “David Bowie.” Go figure the two songs I don’t like on here are named after two people I don’t like.
Better than the other Bowie slop we’ve gotten but I think I’m firmly not a Bowie guy
I wasn’t raised with David Bowie so I hadn’t listened through any of his albums in entirety. I’m not unaware of the massive cultural impact he made and how devastating his death was for many. You Pretty Things was my fave on the album
Bowie obviously one of the goats but theres a few skips on this album. Maybe i’m just not cool enough. 4.7/5.0 Best Song: Life On Mars - jesus christ, this song is just unbelievably good, can only dream of ever writing something like this.
Class album, so many highlights. Changes, Oh! You Pretty Thing, Kooks and Queen Bitch are phenomenal songs. You could argue Life on Mars is one of the defining songs of the 70s. Crazy that this isnt even in my top 5 Bowie albums. Saying that, the bad songs on this album are pretty bad, Andy Warhol, Quicksand and the Bewlay Brothers are just not good songs, which knocks a bit off shine off the album. 4.2/5
David Bowie heeft me nooit echt goed gepakt. Changes is wel een banger, en ik vond Queen Bitch ook erg vermakelijk. Maar de rest was medium.
Cool
This is great. Along with the obvious timeless classics “Changes” and “Life on Mars?”, I also liked “Andy Warhol”. It was really innovative and diverse all the way through in terms of songwriting and instrumentation. Close to a full 5 for so rounding up considering all the random weak stuff we’ve had recently. 4.5/5
Man…the more you sit with this, the more you realize just how brilliant Bowie was. Hard to believe it took four albums for most people to even know who he was. And while this album is a bit more soft and subtle compared to Ziggy, it fits right in with it. A definite mood setter and announcement to the world that he had arrived, which carries right on into the next album. At first listen an obvious 4* would be the way to go. But as you dig deeper, it would be a major misstep to not put it up there with Ziggy. Timeless. Completely unique. Nothing like it then. Nothing like it since.
Man, turns out I might be a bigger Bowie fan than I thought I was. Great song writing that’s still accessible but still very creative and unique with some of the switches, instruments, etc. Also some epic moments and builds. Seems like one of Bowies biggest talents. When do we get the labrynth soundtrack? 4.25
Glad we got Ziggy S-Dust before this one which, while out of chronological order, is pretty much how the world experienced them. Ziggy comes out of the gate and smacks you with alien-rock goodness. You kinda gotta sit with Hunky Dory...let it wash over you. At first I was like, yea this is pretty good. Second listen: Bowie, you MFer! Playing sax and shit. Writing songs about Warhol and Dylan for some reason (side note: couldn't you hear Jack Black singing the lyrics, "Andy walking, Andy tired, Andy take a little snooze"). Absolute classics in Changes and Life on Mars? are here, but Oh! You Pretty Things, Quicksand, and of course Queen Bitch are also very amazing. Not going as high as Ziggy, but still think this deserves top marks. 4.5/5
As per usual, another great Bowie record. Never had listened to the whole album, which is a shame since this is great through and through.
Amazing
I’m not a giant Bowie fan - I do really enjoy much of his work but I’m no obsessive and my patience has its limits. Yet, every track here is seemingly engrained into my psyche - each song is so ridiculously familiar it’s like they’ve always been there. And the really odd thing about it, is I can listen to them again and again without (much) complaint. It was a pleasure listening to this - I didn’t skip a second and when it finished, I could have listened again. I didn’t though.
Off the cuff remark: by far my favourite Bowie album, but with references to Goebbels and making "way for the homo superior" I am uncomfortable with the Nazism dabbling he has had and seem evident here. Standout track: there are several but "Changes" is fabulous Revisit?: my most frequently listened to Bowie album.
My first favorite Bowie album, and it held that title for many years. Still remember where I was the first time “Oh! You Pretty Things” absolutely annihilated me… perfect album, no notes.
One of my absolute favs front to back. Not as familiar with back half
I just like little weird boy music
Bowie always interesting. Some of these songs a bit too out there for me.
Know what. I have, as a result of this challenge, come to dislike David Bowie and borderline hate Bob Dylan. And yet, despite both names coming up on this album (even as a tribute for one), I'd say it was a pretty enjoyable experience overall. It truly is hard to listen to this album and not recognize there's something great about it. It's still not quite my cup of tea and there wasn't anything I'd save to listen to later, but it's definitely still worth a listen.
Yes siree
Great album. I only knew Bowie from the labyrinth and a few key songs. This is a totally different side of Bowie I’m hearing. I enjoyed the whole album
First half: Good Second half: annoying
Ch Ch Changes! Bowie is heavy with the piano. It has that classic Bowie energy, fast paced and energetic. The rest of the band also shines next to the main paino tune. Solid album!
Much more playful than alot of other Bowie entries. A trait I enjoy from him. And yet, I still find myself rather bored towards the second half of this album. I am really close to giving this a 3, but I really cant.