Reviews (page 2 of 9)
Hard pass, on the title alone. Listened to first half minute of 2 tracks, and done. Why is this on this list??? DNF.
Definitely doesn't sound like something that would have been recorded in '77, which is why it made the list I reckon. Every track feels like a build up that gets about a third of the way to a great song, and then just stays right there. I appreciate the art here, just leaves me wanting to hear something more substantial.
Not what's traditionally seen as music, but could've been worse.
beautiful, timeless, and visceral Listen to "Cheree" from this album released in 1977, then listen to "Desire" by Dehd from 2020.
Fuck that.
idk man
I almost want to give this a 4, but I am going 3.5. It was okay...almost good.
Just shows how subjective music is. With the low score and one star reviews wasn’t expecting much. But I really liked the listen, 1977 that’s surprising. The rockabilly influence combined with the minimalist electronic sounds, yeah. Frankie Teardrop takes things to an extreme and not the easiest listen, and drops a star for me, but can see its influence. 3 Star
malísimo, porque canta así
If I somehow die before I can write a longer review, let me just say, this is the fucking bomb.
se mi si disconnette il bluetooth è un bordello è troppo sensuale per il lavoro ahahah girl è crazy
Creepy. Intense. And really weird. I love it.
interesting sound although sometimes so intense i had to skip
so bad girl is the single worst song ive ever heard this album sucks
( °-°)
First song: okay, most likely not the best. Second song: ok is that a patern? Third song: did they really need to make a remaster? Please never again
Creepy, mean and kind of miserable
Huge letdown for a band named suicide
I will leave this one up to the experts to dissect. I like Bill Laswell - something with a bit more tonal depth, variety, melody, less droning. I am just not qualified to have an opinion on this other than I'm not the right customer for what this is selling.
I was surprised by how much I overall enjoyed this one. I don't know if I'll be revisiting anytime soon, but I was happy to hear it. A nice variety to the songs and you can hear how influential they were on other later groups; it's hard to believe this album came out in 1977.
Heavily inspired by Silver Apples, but missing the groove that made it enjoyable.
Well, I definitely listened to this before I died. Will I listen to it again anytime soon? Hell no! Just a bit rubbish!
I hated this.
I'm rating this a few days after the Ed Sheeran controversy so the idea of what the role of a musician is may be colouring my thinking. Unlike Ed, Suicide understand that the role of an artist is not just to sell concert tickets and offend no-one. They actively seem to want to alienate and disturb listeners and that's good, otherwise we get safe music that refuses to take a stand on anything. I know Dream Baby Dream and I'd heard Rocket USA and Cheree before, but Suicide were one of those bands I know of their influence but haven't really got round to listening go. I'd not listened to Frankie Teardrop before other than in part in the Springsteen biopic, and it was genuinely even more unsettling than I could have imagined. Perhaps Ed should consider covering it to prove he has a backbone.
I am over 500 albums into this. There is way too much bad stuff. This might be at the very bottom of the barrel. I'm too invested to quit, but this list is one disappointment after another. The only list this should be on is the list to destroy every copy ever made
I mean I guess this is ahead of it's time for 1977 but my god that does not mean it's a good album. It's experimental and slightly abrasive but the tracks go absolutely nowhere. It just sounds like white noise with dogshit vocals to accompany it; and don't get me started on the vocals, especially on 'Girls.' The less said about that the better. 2/10
Terrible
The minimal electronic sound is interesting. The vocals make it pretty uncomfortable though.
Markan 1 Sara 1
I'll keep this short, something album would've done if it didnt just have an absolutely bloated 10 minute borefest at the end. If this book is literally 1001 albums to listen to before you die..... what is gained by listening to this? I know that by the time I die that i hate it? if so mission accomplished. This did nothing for me. I understand that classics and pioneering albums for all genres should be included, and to some people this is under that umbrella. But i'll be damned, did this one just slip the cracks in terms of quality? If this book ever gets revised... i nominate this for removal. 1/5
Awful
The songs are basically spoken-word poetry on top of synthesizers. At times the album is wonderfully minimalist and hypnotic, but ultimately unsatisfying.
I liked this one a lot more than I thought I would. I didn't think I would care for the rudimentary synths and stream-of-conscious vocals. The Elvis (and The Doors?) influence was interesting. Frankie messed me up tbh, damn...
Have to say, the first time I was unprepared for what this actually was. This is another album that definitely benefits from multiple listens. Freaky as it is, with Frankie Teardrop being a standout as one of the most disturbing things I’ve ever listened to, and as a participant in this project I don’t need to say how much I have heard over the years, there really IS a development and world created by the album overall, so much so that this is moving into the 5 category for me. Alan Vega isn’t just shocking for the sake of being shocking. He’s telling a story. He builds up to Frankie Teardrop in a systematic way. Martin Rev is creating a world. It’s affecting and effective. So… yeah. That’s a 5. 5 Boolean: True - Glad I’m in for listening more than once
Punk before punk was punk. Seriously.
How did this band go from synth-punk to doo-wop in the span of 11 years? I can't reconcile how "Frankie Teardrop" and "Surrender" are from the same artist. I did not like this. I only remember the screaming in that one song.
Liked the first song but didn’t really vibe with the rest
úff, ég reyndi en náði eiginlega ekkert að fíla þetta.
Fyrri parturinn var þannig séð allt í lagi, svo dalaði þetta fljótt.
Shit
Did they not notice the cicadas in the studio when they recorded this? :) It is awesome that an album like this exists and that it influenced Bruce Springsteen of all people and among many others. Full marks for committing to a unique and challenging artistic vision. But a tough one to listen to on repeat.
I know why this is on the list, I understand its importance, I also understand why most people (myself included) don’t enjoy it. However, you can’t ignore how influential this album is. Try to tell me that the beginning of Girl doesn’t sound exactly like an LCD Soundsystem song.
The first few tracks of the album were like an entirely separate album from the rest of it. they were good rockin' tracks and then it becomes this ambient experimental sounding thing.
★★½
I had to sit through how many hours of Donald Fagen on this list? 3 hours of Christina Aguilera? U2? Korn? I'm really glad that this list includes Suicide self-titled at approximately a half-hour of runtime. A band that caused a literal riot after 23 minutes of playing. Inspired to exist by The Stooges and I would argue almost more of a condition of the time and place they were created. I do 100% think people should hear this before they die.
The repetition made me feel uneasy. But I like feeling uneasy sometimes. Fucking hell Frankie!
The screaming during Frank I didn't need. The rest was interesting
not for me at all, turned it off during 'girl' the sex noises whilst saying 'turn me on' werre a little rich for my blood
Nah not for me
Great idea, awful execution.
I don't get it & have no desire to try & get it either
For me a great punk album. The price of synths dropped and anyone could start making music with them. The influence on the early Some Bizarre & Mute acts is plain to hear. An electronic equivalent of the first VU album maybe? (Commercially unsuccessfully but hugely influencial). However Frankie Teardrop brings the album down so maybe 3.5 stars.
Was ok. Mix of kraftwerk and screaming
сука это так круто + супер тупо
Uh some of these made me want to have hallucinations, like why are we screaming?? why is on song just a recording of someone having sex??
Not sure about this band
To save a bit of time, can we all just agree this is dreadful in every respect and move on.
Nil pwa to this horrible album.
Uh, kinda weird, but not bad. I see this more of audible art than I do music. Music is art, of course, but this is art that's in music form? Something like that. When I go to modern art exhibits, this sound is often what the artwork looks like. I'm rambling and incoherent, searching for the right words and just cannot get close. Anyway, ⭐⭐⭐, glad I listened, won't listen again
Pretty terrible. None of the songs ever get going. The are all just one note. The last couple of songs are just awful. 1.5* rounded up to 2*
Hated this.
This album was another word that I can think of beginning with "s".
Nope, not for me. It just wasn't an enjoyable experience
Scream-mumbling over half-assed, repetitive synths = you’re gonna have a bad time. "Girl" might be the worst song I've ever heard. Why is this on the list?? 1⭐️
Had a sound that seemed ahead of it's time
7/10 – Good
If I have to listen to anymore of Frankie's plight, I'M going to commit suicide
Never heard of this "patient zero" - 4 points for doing this in 1977 (or whatever the year was), but it didn't age well
Pioneers of the yelping man genre.
I know I have heard a couple of songs here and there from Suicide's self-titled debut. The duo of vocalist Alan Vega and instrumentalist Martin Rev would be considered pioneers of synth-punk, combining the intensity of punk rock with synthesizers and primitive drum machines. Yet they would also have a much wider impact on several artists and genres, across synth-pop, electronic, alternative rock, industrial, and even Bruce Springsteen himself. So the historical significance of Suicide's debut is well established. The question at hand is: does it still hold up decades later? Well, if there is one song to take away from this album, to encapsulate the essence of what is profound about this record, it's "Frankie Teardrop". The track is ten and a half minutes long, with a simple two-note keyboard riff and an even simpler drum machine pattern, where Alan talk-sang about a young man named Frankie. Frankie struggles to make ends meet with his factory job, as he's about to be evicted from his place. Driven to insanity from his desperation, he proceeds to shoot his wife and six-month-old kid before taking his own life. Frankie then makes his descent into hell, with one of the last statements in the song that "we're all Frankies/we're all lyin' in hell", implying that any one of us can be driven to insanity with the right conditioning. This track, complete with Alan's blood-curdling screams during the fatal deaths and the descent into hell, is pretty bleak. I'm not surprised this song would affect guys like Bruce Springsteen and Henry Rollins; it is that disturbing and dark, with such an enveloping atmosphere conjured from such a simple instrumental arrangement. In fact, "Frankie Teardrop" is so profound that the rest of the album pales in comparison. Don't get me wrong; it's not like I hated any of the other songs. From an instrumental standpoint, I can vibe with the simple yet catchy synthesizer riffs and drum machine patterns. But lyrically, none of the other tracks quite flesh out their character moments to the same visceral degree as "Frankie Teardrop". Whether it was the 1950s rock & roll pastiche of "Johnny", the doomed couple's car crash of "Rocket USA", the ode to Marvel comics superhero Ghost Rider on the opening track, the fluffy romantic ballad "Cheree", the sexual prowess on "Girl", or the light critique of Cuban Revolution leader Che Guevara on the closing track, there isn't enough detail to develop these stories in the same way "Frankie Teardrop" managed to accomplish. If anything, it seemed that Alan was largely going off "vibes" for these songs, which I didn't find as gripping. It's especially egregious with the attempt at a political bent on "Che"; I get that Che Guevara wasn't a "saint", but it would have been nice to at least touch upon why. Overall, I get how important Suicide's self-titled is to many artists and genres, and I recognize those formative elements here. I can certainly respect the album, even if my only takeaways are "Frankie Teardrop" and maybe the singles.
Some unique ideas and production choices for the time. But this was just boring and was a drag to get through for a 30 minute record.
Interesting album, it sounds plays like a sound track a late 70's early 80's movie.
Music for people who think that they’re “misunderstood” but they actually just don’t wear deodorant. I didn’t wear deodorant until I was 13 and I would have loved this album if I listened to it then. But good hygiene comes with good music taste I guess.
Ask me about the Frankie Teardrop challenge
They say suicide is painless but it sounds like John Darnielle trying to make a Kraftwerk record with Bruce Springsteen lyrics. 1 keeper in 7 (14%). 1 klunker (14%). 1 star.
An interesting listen with some cathartic moments. Also an interesting sensitive n taboo subject to make a music album around.
Suspect I enjoyed this more than most. It’s like listening to early rock n roll music through a primitive synth with a lunatic on vocals. Frankie Teardrop rightly gets mentioned a lot but I love the run at the start of the record. Don’t be scared, it’s just Suicide.
401/1001 Suicide - s/t Heard before? ❎ Revisit? ❎ I can absolutely see how this can work for some people and after the safety of Taylor Swift as my last album, being pushed by this worked its favour for me. The number of elements at play here did work well and very experimental for its time. Thing is, I'll probably not really reach for this again...
it's the type of album that you hear and think it's good, albeit it sounds like other stuff. and then, when checking the dates, you realize they were so ahead of their time, that even today, it sounds fresh and influential. brooding, weird, sinthy, strange
I've heard this a handful of times and each time I think Ghost Rider is an interesting start, that persistent one-note buzz saw riff, that throb below the surface, that evocative, haunted line, “America America is killing its youth”. I'm on board tentatively. And then Rocket USA does the same trick, and it's less impressive but it's longer with more grunts and gasps. And then Cheree invents every soft focus, huskybreath, goth adjacent yearn of the 80s. There's something to be said for being first I guess. But i'd rather just hear J&MC. By the time we get to Frankie Teardrop, the formula is dead and buried: repetitive, hypnotic, minimal difference from track to track, minimal lyrics from a minimal vocal talent. But Frankie brings the big guns. You kind of get hints of it in the annoying orgasm-coded moans throughout “Girl”, but this prototype for the much better Bela Lugosi's Dead, after much banal nothingness about Frankie Frankie, about the oh so tortured Frankie, devolves into squeals and screams and gasps and the whole mess of unlistenableness. It's a Jumpscare in song form… by now I know it's coming, but that unrelenting non-riff, that terrible, washed out echo of production, makes it so tense, so unpleasant, that you can't settle enough to steel yourself for it. It's already the sort of story an edgy but uncreative and socially inept goth kid would tell around a campfire without the cheapest tactic in the book. Frankie's lying in hell, alright, and his sin is inspiring this song, which takes up, for all intents and purposes, a full third of this pointless album. If I never hear Suicide again it will be too soon. ⭐️.
En dan heb je zo een albums...
There’s plenty of examples in art and on this list of works being inspired by greatness that do not end up being good. Think of some of the average soul and RnB on this list inspired by the ‘60s and ‘70s greats. Here’s a rare example of the opposite. A bad album (this) that helped to inspire a very good one (Springsteen’s Nebraska). But while The Boss made powerful emotion out of a sparse sound, this is pretty dull stuff. Not offensive enough for 1, but it’s pretty unremarkable stuff, there’s really not much to comment on here.
This album influenced a lot of music I enjoy listening to, particularly post-punk and electronic music, and on that basis was well worth a listen. The oppressive sparseness of the album, just Martin Rev’s malfunctioning organ and Alan Vega’s shuddering vocals, provides a soundtrack to what they saw as the breakdown of American society, especially the crime-ridden and almost bankrupt New York of the 70s from where the band originated. ‘Cheree’ provides something of a respite but is still fairly menacing in its own way. Overall, it’s not something I’d listen to regularly, and therefore I can only give it a high 3, but it is an album everyone should listen to once.
I went into this album with some trepidation, but overall it wasn’t as bad as I’d feared. That’s not to say it was particularly good either, but it had some interesting qualities, and sounds very unique for 1977. A sparse electronic album with reverb-drenched vocals, swirling organ parts, and repetitive drum machine rhythms, it successfully creates a menacing atmosphere. However, although it’s largely not unpleasant to listen to (as I had feared), it isn’t very engaging either. It’s so sparse and minimalistic, including lyrically, that it left me feeling like there’s something missing. An intriguing but largely failed experiment, perhaps?
the same rhythm to which your leg bounces when you can't relax, the buzzing synthetic every compulsion and suicidal thought dental-drilling their way out of your head to the tangible world. not always essential but frequently pretty staggering!
HAHA WAT IS DIT in het begin vibede ik en teon werd t gwn slechter en slechter en toen kwam frankie teardrop ik kreeg gwn jumpscare van het geschreeuw. lowkey savo zou dit leuk vinden
ik word bang van zijn geschreeuw op frankie teardrop
Me encantó, bastante oscuro, ideal para una noche de velas !
why would you scream like that for an entire song
Turns out there’s a whole album that sounds just like “Dream Baby Dream,” but without “Dream Baby Dream” on it. And it’s great. 4.5 stars.
I do not agree with Rolling Stone. This is not one of the 500 greatest albums of all time. I understand how it could be influential to many and I agree that it has its enjoyable moments. If an album is going to have a 10 minute story track I will always compare it to Cortez the Killer. If it doesn’t measure up even closely to that, I consider it a waste of my time. 2.5 rounded down. I did mildly enjoy perhaps 30% of this album
Wtf was that?
What a dark brooding vibe that definitely was ahead of its time.
Requires more listening, but good. 3.5/5.
SHIT!
Probably on here caus it was different for the time. Doesnt hold up though. Nwver got going. Then got annoying. Thankfully it was short.
Not an easy listen, but really interesting and ahead of its time. I didn't hate this and quite enjoyed it at points.
Kind of interesting, not what I expected.
Never heard them or heard of them before, but I thought I was listening to Gun club, but really liked the electro beats here, great little album, packed a punch for me
Eh..... I can see it influencing the industrial and noisy stuff to follow, but not for me.
I mean interesting. P good music. Weird. Very out there even now which I do like in an album. Fun. Suicide. And it's short which is always a plus. Not anything groundbreaking for me but I can see how it wouldve been pretty insane in the 70s. It has a pretty unique sound even for an album today so I like that. Can definitely hear what influenced Springsteen. What is no wave. Ok this is kinda bad. Second act kinda dropping the ball. Giving me Talking Heads, also definitely Springsteen. I love when you can tell how much an album or artist influenced their successors. It's so cool to hear the connections. Favourite: Johnny Least favourite: Girl/Frankie Teardrop.
Found this quite bland. The drum/beat was pretty similar in all tracks, which contributed. Would I listen again? No!
Very good record. 3,5
The name fits, just a little too grim at times for me. Musically, I
When it comes to electronic punk music, this is probably one of the earliest examples of that style. These guys were so one of a kind that it's really hard to label them because they were doing things that predated styles of music that would eventually evolve from this sound, and that they probably helped influence. For example, I would ultimately call this a post punk album, but they were already leaning heavily toward what would eventually become industrial music. You can hear the foundations of synth pop and other forms of electronic music in there as well. At the same time, you can really hear how influenced they were by 1950s rock and rockabilly, especially through Alan Vega's vocals and his Elvis influence. So if anything, what Suicide did was draw from music that came 20 years before them and use it to create something that sounded like it came 10 years into the future.
JL : 2, Che (wasn't that bad, just feels like I should listen to Bauhaus instead)
Quite impressed by the modernism of this project, it definetly as vision, impact and point of view. I just think Frankie is just a slog that drags the records, and without it, its only very loosely an album.
It didn't feel like music. It felt like a parody of what hip culture was doing back in the 70s. Maybe this is very culturally important but I've only experienced the satire of it. Either way, did not like it.
I liked the first two songs and then there was a wannabe "The End" track without the musicality ("Frankie Teardrops"). Top tracks: "Rocket," "Ghost Rider"
--Ghost Rider...is this what the Penance Stare feels like? --Rocket U.S.A....cool, heavy, driving synth rhythm. not much beyond that --Cheree...ooooh, I like the bells. still not really a song. could I get a middle eight or at least a chorus? --Johnny...not a good sign when your album feels long after 15 minutes --Girl...the synths are at least trying to lay down some movement. vocals feel detached and improvised --Frankie Teardrop...this is just in bad taste --Che...I do like the "cello" quality of the synths here. I'm trying my best to find compliments for this LP
Wild chaotic pinkish fun.
Sparse and hard-hitting. Synth like sandpaper (complimentary). The minimalism combined with the instrumentation makes this feel like it was beamed in from another world, or like I’m tuning in to a haunted radio station with a signal I can only just find. I went into this knowing that this was a huge influence on Bruce Springsteen in his ‘Nebraska’ era, and I’m surprised to say that I can totally hear it, especially on “Johnny” and “Frankie Teardrop”. The rockabilly structures combined with the lo-fi, grimy synths makes for a striking and almost bleak sound.
Yikes
This might be one of the longer 32-minute long records I’ve had to endure. Synth performance art, ugh. You know, I expected metal, and got this…my rating might reflect the fact that I feel like I got duped. It’s not the worst thing I’ve heard here, not by a long shot, but it still does kinda suck. 5/10
Painful
This made me cry how bad it was
A huge album
정말 듣는 내내 귀가 고통스러운 노래였다. 이걸 노래라고 할 수 있을지 의문이다. 앨범 제목과 참 잘 어울리는 것 같다. 0점을 줄 수 있었으면 줬을 것 같다. Listening to this song was truly painful for my ears. I question whether it can even be called a song. It seems to fit the album title perfectly. If I could have given it a zero, I would have.
I’ve heard this before and I own it. You might think it silly to say the best synthesizer album ever was released almost 50 years ago, but this is a correct statement and I’m referring to this album. If you were to say I’m wrong and the best synthesizer album ever was released 46 years ago and is called Suicide: Alan Vega and Martin Rev, I will allow it. The keyboards and drum machine are both sparse and dense and the vocals add to that feeling like an echo in a crowded room. Frankie Teardrop is a phenomenal song although my favorite on here is Ghost Rider, probably because of the Henry Rollins covers I heard when I was a teenager and had never heard of Suicide or no wave. His slow version from the crow soundtrack can stand up to the original. But we’re not talking about Henry Rollins here. This gave me an excuse to listen to the album three times in a row, which I’m doing right now while writing this review.
I was BORRRRRRN FREE— Except it's not M.I.A., but the original sample. I love finding those gems, understanding where more modern artists got their inspiration. That first track was euphoria similar to the nostalgia of seeing a childhood friend pass you by on a bike. It's sounds I know, because they were inspired here, and not just M.I.A., but a lot of harder electronic projects like Prodigy. That means this is a little rough around the edges, and I think that's part of the appeal... But I like it better reinterpreted, personally. It feels maybe like another form of Lou Reed on some electronic acid. It's a vibe, and I'll flip shit if I find myself a copy, but I can also live without this. 3.2/5
*1977. American rock/punk, I guess? *The entire album sounds like a build up for an 80s horror movie, except we never actually build up to anything. *Lots of synth, and kind of desperate whispery, pretentious vocals. You can skip to any point in a track, and it'll still sound the same as any other point in that track. *Only 32 minutes but a bit of a slog. RATING - 5/10
What a truly weird but interesting album. I can't say I enjoyed the experience roundly but it got my attention at several points and I'd love to time travel just to see what a show would've been like.
didn't compel me
Apparently these guys were the first synth pop duo...it's good to know who to blame for crappy 80s music. They repetitive droning backbeat is sleep inducing. This is better than the bands Spotify wants you to believe came after it. There's clearly more of a punk/Velvet Underground edge to this than to Soft Cell or Erasure. Having Throbbing Gristle as a band you influenced is not a feather in your cap. I bet the Dust Brothers had this on repeat when they did the Fight Club soundtrack. Frankie Teardrop, between the screaming and the length, is pushing this album lower.
Synth Punk/Minimal Synth Favorite Song: Ghost Rider (although, I’m probably not gonna put this in my personal music library) Least Favorite Track: Frankie Teardrop So, I see that this album is very divided amongst those from this site in comparison to Rate Your Music. At the time of writing this review, this site has a 2.46/5 in comparison to a 3.72/5 on Rate Your Music. Decided to also look at Album of the Year, and it has an 87/100 critic score and a 74/100 for user ratings. And with me…I feel like I can see both sides of the argument here, but I’m more than likely in the middle of the camp. The album is considered to be very influential due to how it incorporates electronic elements with the rock elements, and while the sound is minimalistic, on the surface, the album’s sounds definitely feels revolutionary in how new this sound is back in the day. However, while it might be due to its technical limitations, I did find the songs instrumentally to be very repetitive for my tastes (and I’m usually the guy who likes repetitive stuff within electronic music like house or trance). But it’s where the lyrics tells the full story, and there’s certain elements in these lyrics that are also very minimalistic, but with a few exceptions, they aren’t too repetitive. They’re also very progressive in the sense that you would understand the messaging. Take Rocket USA for example where it talks about driving in a car, being described as a very dangerous vehicle that can kill someone, and the driver’s carelessness of safety on the highway speeding at around 100 mph. The messaging seems clear enough about trying to teach the listener about the country’s car culture. But then we also have stuff such as Girl, where it sounded like the singer in bed with a girl, and I think it might be about a critique about men’s obsession of sex, but frankly, I feel like this song’s too dirty for my tastes (and I listened to Satisfaction by Benny Benassi, a really dirty song). And we have my least favorite song Frankie Teardrop, where at the start of the song, it describes the main character, Frankie, dealing with a lot of stress of his job and not being paid enough money for his wife and kid. And his solution is to…kill both the child and wife…and then himself. And this is where the track lost me. Now, people complain about the shouting in the track, and while I did find it off putting, I can understand why he did it, because it’s to show off the characters’ shocked, pain, and tortured state within the song. Probably would have done without it, but it’s whatever. For me, the song doesn’t have a clear messaging, and I think it went too minimalistic that the message got lost in the weeds. Is the message that work sucks, or that we need to have a strong union force, or that people are so desperate to leave the kind of struggle they have to the point where they’ll be in hell (something that I should note that I’m an atheist, and that I don’t believe in hell to begin with)? I’m just…so lost and confused by the track in itself. Overall, while I can very much understand what the album is in its lyrics, or that the album’s revolutionary by incorporating electronic elements, I don’t think I can get behind the record personally due to how minimalistic and repetitive the whole thing sounds. 5/10, but I’m giving this a 2/5 stars.
What a pleasant surprise of a punk album.
Songs that will make your friends ask if you are ok and need somebody to talk to.
Music for art students who may have smoked a little too much herby business and spend their lives getting off with each other and being soooo cool.
If you like electronica/ synth acts like Depeche Mode or Jean Michelle Jarre, then this will not be for you. I tested this theory out on a work colleague who loves everything alalogue electronic. He didn’t like it or get it as it was too far from Ultravox etc to appreciate it. That said, if you like punk and low-fi with attitude, atmosphere and experimentalism, then you should love it. This album is another influential, groundbreaking recording featuring minimalist, monotonous growling synths and a drum machine with an amphetamine problem. You can tell when it is on a come down, it defaults to the bossanova. 'The highlights are Ghostrider', 'Che', 'Cheree', Rocket USA has been covered by a couple of my favourite bands over the years. I cannot fail to mention the angst ridden seven minutes 'Frankie Teardrop', its a jolly old story with an equally happy ending. I do not tend to concentrate on lyrics, but when I first listened to this nearly forty years ago, when I wanted to discover exactly who this strange legendary duo were snd what they sounded like, I was blown away. Dud dud dud dud shish shish shish as their drum machine goes!
Listened previously. Expectations: Mid - Verdict: Good - Ghost Rider is a very cool opener. The sound is almost krautrock meets new wave which works as a really good combo. The songs exist in a constant state of hazy stasis and it is incredibly unique. The glacial progress of the tracks is belied by a propulsive quality reminiscent of Autobahn and on Cheree the twinkling keys and vocals are quite beautiful. Frankie Teardrop is the centrepiece and it unfolds with spooky, dark grace before the screams shatter the night. A really interesting listening experience.
Initially, after reading the band’s name (and the album, respectively), I thought it was some kind of punk rock or hardcore punk, but definitely not something like this. The album can be described as some kind of abstract rock or something along those lines. It sounds unusual, but this unusualness doesn’t become the album’s huge advantage; rather, it makes it strange.
Strange album. Quite uncomfortable at the end! 2.4/5.0
this album aint perfect but its essential, and some of you boomers here cant appreciate anything that isnt inoffensive clean country
I didn't really mind this until I got up to Girl. I just ran a half marathon and it was easier on my body and mind than listening to 10 minutes of Frankie Teardrop. On the plus side, this is a great album to give as an example if someone asks me what a one star album sounds like.
This is #day723 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… hell yeah, imagine hearing this at the time. This is what you get when you marry '50s rock 'n' roll with '70s electronics and punk. It's crazy to think this thing is turning 50 next year. "Frankie Teardrop" is, of course, a fun piece to put on a record. This is a 5 out of 5. Looking forward to #day724.
8/10
no tengo ganas de escuchar a un loco gimiendo
Cool album. Very timeless sound.
Ok
What? Why is this album even on this list?
Nyt oli harvinaisen huono! En pystynyt kuuntelemaan kokonaan. ⭐️
Was expecting punk or something less weird, would like this more if I was in the mood for weird
I felt that went nowhere and Frankie Teardrop was the final nail in the coffin. That screaming is annoying as hell.
Interesting. I can see how it could be so influential at the time. The mellow drone punctuated with manic screams leaves you in a tense meditative trance. Love the last song, Che. Very powerful and somber dirge to close the record.
ooooooooohhh turn it AWFFFFFFFFFFFFF
You only have one chance so take it before it is too late
2.5/10
bleh
Velvet Underground wannabes
They tried to make it performance art but it was just awful. Groaning noises and jumpscare lyrics
Yeah. No.
Innovative, ahead of it's time, and basically unlistenable. The single star on the sleve is apt.
Rate: 8/10.
If you take away the synths and drum machines and just look at the lyrics, this could easily be a Bruce Springsteen album (and we know he was a fan of Suicide). This band and their sound has been described to me as "music for musicians." Well, I'm not a musician but I can still dig how weird and intentionally repulsive some of it is. The world is a better place because of these two NYC freaks. And Frankie Teardrop is an all-time karaoke song
Two anecdotes; First anecdote; one time I was listening to this album on the bus after a fairly long day. Didn't feel well but no big deal, I'll be home soon enough. Bus was packed, standing room only. I was lucky enough to get a seat. I'm really focused on the album. I get to Frankie Teardrop & it makes me so viciously anxious that I had to get up and leave the bus and walk home the rest of the way. Second anecdote; I was at this bar in south philly that had an old jukebox near the front entrance. The vibe in this bar, on most nights, is your average Cool Kid bar, but on this night for whatever reason they had the rape revenge film The Last House on the Left (2009) playing on the television. It set an odd mood, I think the bartender just was not paying attention to Tubi's autoplay because after two assault scenes, I noticed something else was one. As my friend and I are leaving, we start flipping through the jukebox while we wait for another friend to get out of the bathroom. The album line-up in this jukebox is incredible. The owner really knew what they were doing. And they, inexplicably, have this album in there. The next step was obvious. We put in the quarters for Frankie Teardrop and left.
Tämä oli tuttu ja levy on tullut muutamaan kertaan kuunneltua. Hämmentävä äänimaisema.
Suicide by Suicide is one of the few albums on this challenge that I can say I didn't enjoy at all. I tried to approach it with an open mind, especially considering how influential it was and how experimental it must have sounded when it was released in the late 1970s. For me, the album is relentlessly repetitive, abrasive and difficult to connect with. The sparse electronic backing and Alan Vega's vocal style never clicked, and I spent most of the album waiting for something to happen that never really did. Rather than sounding hypnotic or unsettling in an interesting way, I just found it exhausting. The biggest challenge was "Frankie Teardrop". In over 900 days of working through this challenge, it's the first song I've actually skipped. The relentless screaming was simply too much for me, and I couldn't make it to the end. I know it's often praised for its intensity, but it just wasn't an experience I wanted to continue. I completely understand why this album has such a devoted following and why critics regard it as groundbreaking, but it's a reminder that influential doesn't always mean enjoyable. This one definitely wasn't for me. Favourite tracks: I genuinely couldn't pick one. Nothing on the album stood out in a positive way for me. Least favourite tracks: "Frankie Teardrop". The first track I've skipped in more than 900 days of this challenge because I simply couldn't take any more of the screaming. Album artwork: The album cover is better than any of the music inside.
If you like the sound of someone whispering (sensually?) and/or shrieking over cicada noises this is the album for you! Experimental? sure Successful? nah One star for the synthesized cello sound
A tough one to rate! I knew "Ghost Rider" going in, but nothing else, and I mostly dug the vibes of the first half, especially the drone-y repetitiveness of the music, even if the vocals weren't always my thing. I didn't really care for the back half as much, especially "Frankie Teardrop" with the random screaming. Just made me think of the *1 HOUR OF SILENCE BROKEN UP BY [Insert noise here]* youtube videos
Was enjoying this album until I got to "Frankie Teardrop." That's definitely a song that will stop me from returning to this record.
There’s a lot of hate regarding the lyrics, rhythm, and depictions of “street life”. But this is not only an iconic album, but dare I say a great one. The monotony in this album is intentional. That’s what makes the screams and terror more chilling. The lyrics are a counter culture to the lovey dovey feely good free love era after Vietnam. In an era where beer drinking rock and roll was king, this album actually took music in a different direction. But I get some of you all hate the fine wine of life. I personally think it helped give life to modern rap music and the alt 80s scene. “Frankie Teardrop” is an awesomely intense song. “Rocket USA” come to life when you watch Alex Garland’s Civil War. All of Bruce Springsteen’s catalog owes its moody landscapes to Suicide. This album is independent rock that gets hate from mainstream labels. Not liking this album is falling victim to Big Music. Not liking this album is akin to asking for ketchup with your steak when you go to Jeff Ruby’s No, I’m not kidding. I’d give this thing 6 dammit.
1 point for the cover, the design looks more modern than 1977. Everything else.... not a fan. Add this one to the Gooner Jams playlist.
Erik and I had the supreme misfortune of listening to this album together on the way to The Strokes, and I feel the editors of this book owe us each $50 for making it through all ten minutes of “Frankie’s Tears” because what the fuck
i was digging this until Girl and it soured the whole experience so much the rest was unbearable
Thought several of the songs were interesting, but I found the whole album difficult to get into. Would give it a 2 +1 star for inspiring the GOAT Peaches
I first heard Suicide through Frank Ocean’s Apple Music radio show, blondedRADIO, in 2017. He played “Frankie Teardrop” and all the other Frank fans lost their fucking minds at this song. Until 2020 when the fandom died down tremendously, these people constantly brought up “Frankie Teardrop” like it was a Vietnam flashback. I didn’t hate it and immediately grabbed onto those drums. You can hear their influence on Frank in the back of “White Ferrari” — at the very end, there’s a backing track with some similar vibes. Very haunting stuff. This album is good and different, but not one that has me super psyched to listen to it ever.
This album came out at the very tail end of 1977 so, much like Talking Heads 77 before it, I don’t understand how Wikipedia can call it proto punk and not actual punk. I’m having a weird internal conflict right now because I’m pretty sure if I went into this album today blind I would hate it but I got into it at the peak of my CBGB obsessive phase and so I really have a lot of appreciation for it. As to what sets this apart from Spacemen 3, I would say that Suicide is trying to sound like Suicide and Spacemen 3 is trying to sound like Suicide. Super super super important and influential but not super super enjoyable. Pretty neat little artifact though and it's interesting to hear this right after Nebraska, knowing Bruce cited it as a major influence on that specific album
What, was the studio charging $1,000 per chord used? This went from "huh, this is kinda cool" to "I never want to hear a droning synth bass again in my life"
Interesting for sure, but I kept waiting for something more. Eventually I got used to it, but It still never really sounded like more than demos of songs to me.
"You're not alone. If you or someone you know is having a hard time, talk to somebody today." Thank you, YouTube. May I please listen to the album now? On second thought, what was that number? Honestly, it's not THAT bad. The A-side is definitely more accessible than the B-side. 'Ghost Rider' is actually pretty decent. However, 'Frankie Teardrop' is sorta a knockoff of 'The End', and I didn't like it when The Doors did it, so I'm certainly not all that warm to a perceived tribute to it, either. I'd like to give this a passing 3 for its pioneering efforts, obvious influence on other artists I enjoy, and the overall atmospheric synth - despite it truly feeling like a 50-year-old relic that doesn't hold up quite as well as its less minimalist peers.
This was weird. Cant say I enjoyed it all. There was a lot of lows on this album. But i still kinda liked its weirdness all the same.
какой долбоёб это записал я не знаю. Я бы ему ебало набил. весь альбом один и тот же рок н ролльный троп под однообразную дрочку драм машины и стонущий хуесос которого ты прямо представляешь в голове как он перед микрофоном стоит с закрытыми глазами и кривляется
Viendo las reseñas me esperaba lo peor, y honestamente me gustó mucho el álbum. Ya conocía la canción de Dream Baby Dream, pero no recordaba el nombre del grupo, así que lo primero que pensé cuando escuché el álbum fue lo mucho que se parecía a la canción (pues ya con eso tiene todo el sentido) y a unos de mis grupos favoritos, LCD Soundsystem. Es cierto que las últimas dos canciones, en especial la de los gritos, sí se la volaron, pero podría escuchar en loop el rato del disco.
Such an interesting, abrasive, groundbreaking record. Very cool stuff, but I feel it's not as fleshed out to reach a masterpiece for me and something I would listen constantly, but it's very cool nonetheless. Few tracks from this one are already in my post punk playlist. Definitely at least 3 stars here and 3.5 on RYM, we'll see I guess.
i dont think i've ever felt my disappointment with an album grow song after song like I did with this. opening track had be excited but it all existed to make me fall that much further 2/5
This was hard work. High 1s.
A complete 'nope' for me. Hypercompressed fuzzed out guitars and excessive reverb is interesting for perhaps one verse, not an entire album.
crazy album, very original ideas. I liked it a lot but its not for everybody.
Experimental, creative, the first half of it worths a listen. But not more.
Yeah, suicide.
Likely important for electronic music. I could not care less though.
Fun little album. A little over the top at times with the glam, but generally I liked it.
I was going to disregard this as "Nebraska" if Springsteen bought a synth drum machine and didn't bother writing lyrics until I saw it predated it by about a decade. 2 stars for being ahead of it's time and having some obvious roots for indoor rock in the 00s. Girl and the random screaming in Frankie Teardrop in my headphones were asking for 1 star
Omg shut the fuck upppp
Right... I love most of this album, I love the unique feeling it has, how influential it is etc. I'd give it 4, but I need to round up to balance out the average score
It's so gnarled and twisted and crooked and toothy and punky and the sort of thing that crawls out the swamp at night
Not that weird, I found a interesting concept, I imagine myself listening to this and be very entertained.
I can see how it was innovative but definitely not my thing. Pretty hard to get electronica.
Intense saker. Repetitiv og stemningsfull.
Som å bli runket av en slapp hånd i 32 minutter. Ganske digg, men ekstremt uforløsende.
De ligg å snuse på femmeren her. Crazy plate. Fy faen som æ skvatt på Frankie Teardrop.
Har hørt litt på dette før, og dette var et gledelig gjenhør. Har noe unikt ved seg som sitter som et skudd. Frankie Teardrop surrer seg for langt inn i lydeksperimenteringen, men ellers er det nedstrippet og tight.
This is so forward thinking for the time, that is a fact. That does not make it in any way listenable. Maybe with the absolute perfect vocalist there's a version of this album that works but brother you are not the guy, what the fuck is this. No thank you not one bit
The song girl has moaning in it The song frankie teardrop isn't that wow The rest is quite nice, I enjoyed it. A little glan rock but with the end of punk/beginning of post punk nuances. Whispery.
Barulho
That certainly was different. But was it good? No! Couldn’t have guessed the year this was released in if I tried, so I guess that is a compliment? The songs were extremely slow paced, meandering, and overall dragged on forever without any interesting pacing or structure. Sure, not all music has to be formulaic 3:30 songs, but come on. Mostly felt like a waste of time and not an album that belongs on this list at all.
Reminded me of a worse version of Silver Apples. It's simply not as good, and Silver Apples was more experimental despite being released nearly a decade earlier. I have no idea why anyone would want to listen to this. The experimentation just doesn't work, nor does it feel particularly avant-garde for 1977. Weak 2.
Not as cool, exciting or fascinating as I expected, but still quite purposeful.
Objectively cool album but not my taste
A bunch of songs with annoying breathy vocals that go absolutely nowhere. Then you get to "Frankie Teardrop" which is wihtout question the most bizarre song I have ever heard. It's like if the ghoulish voiceover on Thriller was just the whole song. Just didn't really get this album at all.
Tiene su gracia. Claramente no soy fana 100% pero tampoco es tan malo como lo venden en otras reviews. Es un 2.5
holy moly this stinks
I found this to be a very one trick pony, taking elements of bands like The Doors and The Velvet Underground but then lacking anything like the range that made those bands great. Some say challenging, I thought it was meandering and a bit boring!
Makes a cool entrance, but left me waiting 30min for a sick beat to drop. Ultimately a disappointment. Don't waste your time, it amounts to a schizophrenic Lou Reed record.
Cheree, bloody awful track. The rest was mostly annoying repetitive and headache inducing crap. Not surprised it didnt chart.
Lyrics are laughable. The music is hilariously bad. The vocal is ridiculous. I think these guys might have been on some seriously strong shit. This is absolutely dreadful and I'm struggling to find any redeeming feature - even the shortness wasn't short enough. I fully expected it to be on the worst rated list, but somehow it isn't.
I enjoyed the instrumentation of Cheree, Girl was very interesting, but I actually liked it. The middle of Frankie Teardrop made me chuckle, which I don’t think was the intended effect??? I don’t think I’ve ever had a song make me laugh before, so in that way, this album IS very unique and groundbreaking. Overall, not unenjoyable. Favorite tracks: Cheree, Girl.
Urgh never been a fan, and extremely poor silver apples !
It's fun to listen to a guy have an orgasm over scary synth music
I see the value in it. Melodically fascinating and I enjoyed the dynamic structuring of the tunes.
Cool and interesting album. This is one of the best “finds” I have discovered doing this 1001+ album journey! Standouts: Cheree, Johnny, Frankie Teardrop, Che…. 4/5
I really liked this and was planning on 5 stars but then I got to the twisted part of Frankie Teardrop and skipped to the next song.
Nope, nope, nope.
total nonsense
suicide's reputation precedes them, and even if it didnt, it's a band called suicide lmao. and it would be impossible to call a record with the infamous masterpiece frankie teardrop on it "light." still, maybe my brain is all broken, but while their approach is undeniably uncanny and macabre i find a lot of playfulness to it on this record, similar to the ramones, or maybe the velvet underground. maybe its just cuz i find this kind of hypnotic minimalist composition and this type of synth-focused arrangement really comfy, or the way the minimalism feels like its stripping down the intricate and poetic embellishments of pop songs down to some kind of primordial ooze. cheree might be kind of cold and strange in another context, but on the same album as frankie teardrop, it sounds downright warm and sweet in a relatively uncomplicated way. some fun little keyboard flourishes and solo parts throughout. its rly not a one trick pony, i appreciate it a lot as raw creativity!
After the first track, I thought this industrial album had a chance of being not terrible. Silly me. Once he started moaning into the microphone, it all but locked in the 1 star. And then it somehow got infinitely worse with Frankie Teardrop. The blood-curdling screams, the rambling, the fast-tempo bassline. If night terrors and schizophrenia were a song, it'd be this one. Definitely in the Duck Stab/Kollaps conversation for worst album on this list.
Between 1 and 5 we have 3.
Mwah kan weinig mee
Don’t know… could be fun… could be…. Yeah. I am definitely here for the weird. Would definitely rather listen to this than Highway 61 Revisited and Blonde on Blonde back to back. Almost want to give it a 4 for not being Bob Dylan. I can get behind experimentation. Actually like the disruptive mechanical “beat” on Frankie Teardrop- it’s used throughout the album, actually. But on that… offering… it really…. Disrupts. The thing is… that whole track needed to be shorter. There just aren’t enough actual ideas here. 3 Boolean: true, definitely here for the left fielders
This had chill lcd vibes
A genre defining album. Pre Soft Cell and all things electronica. Canned off stage regularly, but stuck to their guns.
It was definitely different. I’m not sure how much I actually enjoyed it or if it was more meaningful than I can discern. Not horrible just not the usual.
achei que fosse ser um death metal maluco, mas está longe disso. muito bom
Rubbish. Frankie Teardrop may be the worst collection of sounds ever recorded
wtf is going on in 'girl' and 'frankie' 😭
About as weird and ominous as you'd expect, given the band name. It sort of runs through a downward spiral (not to be confused the The Downward Spiral -- it's not that good). For '77, this is pretty innovative. Very electronic, heavily reverb-y vocals but, because the arrangement is so very sparse, it's really not so bad. The first half is pretty rockin' but it becomes quite ambient. 'Frankie Teardrop' is a tragic story and an interesting experiment but sort of a downer and a real tough listen. Needs more music and less theatre. The closer, 'Che', is a two-chord dirge with limited vocals. Fortunately, it's also really quick: 32 minutes. Appropriately, 'Dirt' by The Stooges (who Alan Vega of Suicide listed as a profound influence) came on Spotify immediately after. It really highlighted for me how you can conduct an artistic experiment with music but also involve both musicality and charisma. Suicide aren't nearly as good at doing that as Iggy and the rest of the Stooges were (though, in fairness, they were masters of it and Iggy has a confusing, magnetic charisma). This album has influenced numerous famous musicians and bands and, once you've heard it, it's clear how. On the other hand, I'm happy for them to digest this and produce something else for me. I'm calling it 3/5 but if it were an hour long and kept getting drearier, I'd be giving it an angry 2. On the other hand, more musicianship could really have pushed this (I suspect the minimalism was the point, but I'm not giving a raw plank of wood extra points in a carving contest). Normally, I'd write something about the delicate balance of minimalism (it can't be *nothing*, even if that's the minimum of minimalism) but it's the end of my workday and I'm going home.
Suicide Notable Textzeile: It's doomsday, doomsday Ah, c'mon Speeding down the skyway 100 miles per hour Gonna crash Was ein Quatsch. Sehe auch ein paar musikalische Ansätze, aber darüber hinaus nix. Beispiel „Girl“: Was ich wirklich nicht verstehe ist vertonter Sextalk. Wer will das hören? Das „Girl“ bestimmt nicht, wie absurd das wäre deiner Freundin das vorzuspielen und zu sagen - hier Song für dich. Oder wenn man beim Vorspiel einfach mal nix sagen will? Aber auch man selbst will das doch nicht von Platte hören oder spielen? Das lässt mich wirklich völlig perplex zurück. Und ich will es auch nicht upgiven für Frankie.
Album gewordene Handbremse. Jeder Song klingt wie das Intro zu einem besseren Song, der dann aber nicht kommt. Es könnte doch einmal richtig laut werden, richtig schnell, richtig melodisch, chaotisch, irgendwas. So bleibt der Eindruck, dass sie nach dem einen Synth einfach aufgehört haben.
Meh...ich weiß nicht. Ist Musik für Leute die ihre eigenen Songs hören und "geiler song, ne?" sagen. 1 Extrapunkt weil das für 1977 tatsächlich bemerkenswert ist.
Pioneering electronic music band Provocative band name: Suicide Vocals: not good Songs sound the same; not interesting at all No like. One star
No es para mi
I think if I had never heard Nebraska or REM's cover of Ghost Rider this would get some shade. But I have! And it's probably a 3.5 for me.
Strong/divisive 1 trick pony
A cool and interesting album that I'm glad was on here, but is it good?... Ehhhhh, it's alright.
2/10 - I try to see past genres and styles I don't usually like to at least appreciate the music but this completely eluded me. Vocals and instrumentals did not give me any joy; it felt uninspired and similar throughout instrumentally.
This was a weird listen, I read about their influence on other electronica artists but there was nothing in this that really resonated
i dont love it, nor do i hate it...kinda meh
Repetitive and boring. May have been influential for its use of synths, but the songs wouldn't be better even with guitars instead.
Surely this is the minimal viable product to even be considered music.
well tht was different , def not an album to work to
Some whiny noises, what the heck is this?
Thoughts before listening: For years I've assumed that despite routinely making best punk album lists, this album was too weird for me, and I never gave it a chance. However I heard a song on a playlist the other day, and it was great. Glad it popped up today. Review: Well okay. My assumption was right. This is too weird for me. The music is basically just droney synths and drum machines with heavily distorted speak sing vocals playing music that sounds like 1950s rock melodies. There's definitely a big Velvet Underground/Lou Reed influence here, but its the VU music that turns me off. Maybe these guys were hanging around the punk scene, but this isn't really punk music. Is this whats called no wave, or at least a major influence on those bands? I can hear where a band like LCD Soundsystem stole from these guys a bit, but they cranked up the beats and turned it into actually palatable party music. This isn't for me. 2-stars
It was a 2/5 already, but frankie’s teardrop made me skip the rest 1/5
Mhm, Nick Cave could never.
3 out of 5. A short but bleak album that I enjoyed more than I thought I would.
Dear Suicide, Thanks for the listen, but we're gonna have to break up. Your constant noise is giving me a headache, and quite frankly, Vega's vocals sound like he's being waterboarded with Tabasco. Pass the earplugs, please. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions - Johnny
Pretty interesting actually
You know that unpredictable alchemy that happens when creative people find each other and push each other to create groundbreaking works of art that would not be possible if it relied on just the output of one person? This album is not that. You know those stories that you hear of genius being thwarted by gatekeepers? This album is not that either. Somehow, no one involved in its creation tried to stop it, tighten the songs, or just begin again. This album proves the theme song from M*A*S*H wrong...Suicide is not painless.
I can tell that this album was ahead of its time when it was released. It's still holds up pretty well, with tons of weird and interesting sounds. I don't think it's the most enjoyable album on the list, but I find myself wanting to take it apart and play with the pieces. Favorite track: "Cheree," probably
Album 216. Suicide (https://open.spotify.com/album/0wKU4153oTf5Ne3Wbbcykd?si=Svsr0GrnSXORohp1boXmwg) — Suicide (1977) It's quite a conceptual and peculiar album. It's an atmosphere: dark, intense, impending dread. Distorted industrial electronica with a punk rock and new wave influence. "Frankie put the gun to his head And he went "Mm, ah" Frankie's dead" It's a shit, but a dope schizophrenic shit. "We're all Frankies We're all lying in hell" Yeah, I can highlight only one song from the album, but what a song! 10 minutes of appalling thrill. Bruce Springsteen even wrote a State Trooper on the Nebraska album (waiting very much) based on Frankie Teardrop. 3/5 Liked: — Frankie Teardrop
Elektronista rokkia tai punkkia lähempänä. Syna pärinää ja pörinää. Mitähän tästäkin ajattelis, enimmäkseen aika tylsää ja toistavaa. Mutta Frankie Teardrop on jotain tosi häiritsevää ja sen huudot sai mut nauramaan ääneen. Ja sen sanat on hyvin häiritsevät. Ei se hyvä kappale ole, mutta se saa aikaan erikoisia tuntemuksia. Siis en tiiä, hyvin outoa kamaa taas. Parhaat: Frankie Teardrop, Che
What a treat to get this album right after Coldplay. I own this album and while I think the drum machines can be a bit repetitive and Frankie Teardrop can run a bit long this album is a classic 5 stars.
6/10
Starts off with a really nice bop in "Ghost Rider," but slowly deteriorates from there. There's definitely a Doors vibe here, though Alan Vega was clearly no Jim Morrison. I want to find more to like here, and if I had heard this when I was in my late teens (like I should have), I'd probably have nice feelings of nostalgia listening to this. Still, I'm definitely okay with finally hearing it before I died.
Yikes, not my thing. Girl and Frankie Teardrop were hard to get through. Feels like something I’d listen to after watching Taxi Driver. Rating: 2/10 Favorite song: Che
Holy fuck this is shit, definitely not my type of music
Not so good
Why is this a thing
(55/100)
I've heard my fair share of messed up and disturbing music and I didn't find this all that unsettling. Aided by Alan Vega's sudden screams, "Frankie Teardrop" is only a dash more peturbing than your standard Nick Cave murder ballad. Banishing the traditional instruments you would find in a punk band, the sound of Suicide is achieved by mixing Vega's poetry with Martin Rev's minimalist synth. They have a decent sound and I found some of the electronic instrumentation to be hypnotic at times. I could see myself adding "Ghost Rider" to my goth playlist as it fits the mood and isn't too inaccessible. I certainly admire the influence this had on so many people, even if I may not return to this record all that much.
Make it stop... I want my sounds and time back from that experience.
At first it sounds like the lead guitar (metal style) is played on an old printer, brrr brrr brrr, chreeerrrr. Fun. Like a zeppelin album we didn't get, fun and funky and not too serious.
Enjoying these grungey, scratchy 70s sounds!! Now here's something a little interesting! I haven't googled the band so hopefully they haven't done something bad.
Fuck yeah all time experimental early electro goth classic I love this shit big time wooooo! Harrowing! Raunchy! Spooky! Yeahhh!! The band Soft Cell should have been!
Maybe possibly a 1.5. Imagine a whole band constructed from “State Trooper” from Springsteen’s “Nebraska,” except five years earlier with way more synth and screaming. Now I love “State Trooper” and I am grateful for whatever this band had to do with it. But its power is in its subtlety and unresolved tension. Contrast that with “Frankie Teardrop,” a ten minute screed about a factory worker killing his kid and then going to hell. Not subtle. Anyway I’m glad this existed because it seems like it influenced some great music, but I’d be happy to never think about it again.
No thanks
This is not listenable music. I mean that literally. Like there is no way to listen to this. If I'm at home, in the car, at a party, in the bath, at a bar, committing suicide, there is no situation in which this would work. It actually just sucks.
Interesting experimental music. Not easy to listen to but “Ghost Rider” is rather a bop!
Frankie cannot make music 2/10
I understand why it's called Suicide, that's exactly how I feel about listening to it again. Which means it should have been called Murder. "Suicide - Murder".
Spent a long time not listening to this feeling absolutely sure that I would hate it but it's actually great.
Huh, well, looking at the reviews they seem to range from absolute garbage to unrecognised genius. I sit in the middle. It was OK. I recognised one song from the album as it was used in a TV advert I think. I can hear that this was influenced by the like of The Doors, and I can tell that this influenced other future bands. Does that make this one of the top 1001 albums? Nah, not really. Everyone's heard of The Doors, I don't know many people who have heard of Suicide (well, not in this context, anyway).
no he sido capaz de escucharlo, estoy 0 en el mood. la gente que hace lo qie le da la gana y se la pela me encanta pero lo siento no es para mi
I understand the low ratings, but I completely disagree. This album carries such an unique atmosphere and it does really well to make itself stand out at such a short runtime. Favourite track: Ghost Rider
2.1 2x good start but weird end
I had no idea what to expect out of this, but given the name, and the time, I thought punk? Death was punk after all, so why not Suicide? Well, no, it ain't that. I don't know what this was, really. There's a sort of fuzzy throughline, a bunch of spoke-sung words, and very little going on. Proto-ambient music perhaps. Which, whatever, fine, I can hang, but it didn't do much for me. Then when it gets to the screaming in "Frankie Teardrop" I start feeling a bit annoyed.
That was the most disturbing album I ever heard. I never want to hear his again.
Feels like it’s in here for being groundbreaking not because it’s goid
I read about this band in music mag last month and this was not what I was expecting! I thought it was going to be unlistenable screamy noise. It was a bit more subtle than that but still not an album I’d put on for pleasure, more to clear a room!
This is either going to be an album I absolutely love or hate to pieces. I can't decide which. First song - so far so good, I dig it. I can tell that a lot of synth pop bands from the 80s owe a lot to this record already. Honestly I don't get the hate for this one. Yeah Frankie Teardrop is weird but that's sort of to be expected I think. And I feel like it's weird in a good way. For something that came out in 1977, this is amazingly ahead of its time. I don't know why this has such low reviews here. I wouldn't really make a point to sit and listen to this one again but I think it is a great album and I am very glad to have heard it this morning. 4/5
Whole album in general just isn’t my thing but "Girl" is an absolute crime against humanity.
Seemed specifically calculated to be as offensive in as many ways as possible. More importantly, it was hard to listen to - almost headache inducing.
Very boring stuff here.
A bit pretentious.
Not really a pleasure to listen to, but still an important and good album
What the fuck was that.
If your name is suicide and your album is bloody you better bring it… but they did not. Ugh. Did I listen to an snl skit of someone trying to be cool but it was just unpretentious schtick? 1.1
I didn’t start skipping until halfway through Frankie Teardrop. Alternated between boring and unsettling. I found nothing to enjoy here. 1/10 Sucko Barfo
Leading off with 'Ghost Rider' had me wondering how the hell I'd missed this my entire life. The rest wasn't as good. Reminded me of Sigue Sigue Sputnik. Still - as a big fan of early 80s British SynthPop, this album isn't too bad for me. Actually quite enjoyable in the right moment.
I had never heard of this group or this album prior to it popping up for me today. And after reading about how many artists it inspired (including Bruce Springsteen), I'm a little surprised. The music really wasn't at all what I was expecting. To say that some of it is intense would be an understatement. While the music itself isn't necessarily anything spectacular or unusual, the lyrics are quite intense on a few of the songs. Not something you would just play if you were looking to casually listen to some music to enjoy. It was fine to listen to. Nothing that I didn't like. But I don't know that I'd want to listen to it again.
No, vähemmän perseestä tämä on kuin vaikkapa Kate Bush. Pisteet lähinnä meiningistä, tämä ei kuitenkaan yritä ola jotain taiteellista kummallisuutta vaan on rehellisesti sitä mitä on. Toki toivon, että nämä veijarit eivät ole ainakaan tämän yhtyeensä tiimoilta identifoineet itseään vakavissaan muusikoiksi. 2/5
I like the sound of- simple and a bit odd. The album has a timeless quality. My one quibble is that “Frankie Teardrop” was far too long. Still, “Cheree” and “Ghost Rider” make up for it.
Was apprehensive when I saw the band name, but pleasantly surprised. Can see the influence on Joy Division, Swans, even some of the darker Interpol stuff
A little slow for me
Creepy and kinda good. They obviously influenced The Boss, because "State Trooper" could have been a Suicide song. Not my normal cup of tea -- but I truly don't understand all the one-stars on here. This ain't without merit. Frankie Teardrop goes on about four minutes too long, but as a whole, it's pretty damned punk rock.
Pretty uninspired. Nothing that bad just bit dull and repetitive.
Different not bad
Something really bugged me about this album…
Zero stars. This has taken the award for the worst album so far. Christ.
Suicide sounds simple but incredibly powerful, using electronic beats and emotional vocals to create something completely different. The album stays exciting from beginning to end, showing how unusual ideas can become unforgettable music when performed with confidence, imagination, honesty, and fearless creativity that still feels fresh today.