Reviews (page 7 of 14)
I’m not sure that this is a good album but it’s a perfect trap album for me. Hints of prog rock but not an onslaught to the ears and kind of silly. Not every album needs to be Pulitzer worthy. This was good fun and a perfect album to mow the lawn to, which I was doing.
The Crime of the Century is including this album on the 1001 list. Presumably Breakfast in America is coming later so I guess we're doing two Supertramp albums. I came to this primed to enjoy this album because the song Goodbye Stranger is a banger so I was rather disappointed for what was mostly an unforgivingly boring album full of songs that are escalators to nowhere. I'll start with a two because it's not gratingly terrible like Tommy but I reserve the right to revise this down to a one at a later date.
Sorry, I just find this super cheesy.
Really liked this, sound a lot like Elton John to my ears
I enjoyed it, but I wouldn't seek it out again.
This album has so much nostalgia for me. I grew up in a prog household. My first gig was Barclay James Harvest, I've seen ELO Part 2 multiple times, Floyd and Roger Hodgson amongst many others. I remember listening to this album on vinyl through my dad's over ear headphones and in the car on long drives. I think that School is a fantastic opener to an album, the launch into Bloody Well Right is just brilliant. This is the first album where Supertramp feel like they have their own sound. You sometimes hear people refer to them as a poor mans Floyd and I think that's unfair. Yes, it has a lot of the winding elements that we hear on Dark Side of the Moon that came out a year before but it's still its own album and sound, but it has shades of The Wall years before its release. The way Davies voice has us spiralling down in Asylum and then you flip the record over to side B. That second side opener with Dreamer just hits hard and then we come back down with Rudy which is a musical whirlwind. Things I particularly love, the alternating between Hodgson and Davies on each track, every instrument is perfectly balanced, Siebenberg's drums are perfect and his skill as a percussionist really does bring this album together IMO. Every track feels like a conversation between the two vocalists and I think that the differences between Hodgson and Davies and the way they lean into this are really are what make Supertramp special. Some people hate this album and I think they probably mostly hate prog and concept albums and that's fine. For me, this album tells a story, it flows together beautifully and thematically and takes you on a musical tour. I can lose myself in this album. That long winding end to Crime of the Century that finished with the harmonica echoing from the opening to School is a master stroke and so easily missed. This is a 5/5 for me. If I was alive in 1974 and listened to this for the first time, I would flip the album and play it straight back from the beginning.
good
I feel like I *almost* really like this. A lot to love but then something just doesn’t quite gel. Asylum and Crime of the Century were my favorite tracks. Knocked from four to three because it was also annoying to listen to - the quiet parts were too quiet and the loud sections were so loud. I was constantly fiddling with the volume the whole way through.
Oh sweet mamma jamma that was delicious! This is the exact reason you participate in a project like this, to expose yourself to incredible music that so clearly should have been taught to you from a young age but society failed you haha. So good!!
I enjoyed this album. Good soundscapes and catchy chorus.
Decent rock
this was ok I suppose. Nothing at all stuck out but I didn’t hate it. It’s music.
Now i’m all for a bit of harmonica but the introduction to this album is taking it too far. Aside from from that the tune (eventually) is jolly enough but the singer’s vocal grate on me. Bloody well right continues the pointless intro issue. Already being to get tedious. When the tune (again eventually) arrives i dont think there’s any doubt, if there ever was, what decade this album is from. This is just slow boring drivel.
This is the first of Supertramp’s albums that moves away from its art school wankery and into a poppier vibe. Songs like “Bloody Well Right” and the classic “Dreamer” are clearly the standouts, but really this album starts to move the direction of traffic into something that will culminate in the masterpiece that is “Breakfast in America” a few years later.
I feared the worst, given my track record with 70s prog rock (and prog rock adjacent stuff) has been patchy at best. But I was already really liking this at least partially due to it being pretty keyboard/piano heavy. Then Dreamer started. I have rambled on a lot about my Dad during many of the 70s albums on this list, and this is another opportunity. He loved this song. The absolute wave of nostalgia hearing this for the first time in probably 25 years made me a bit misty-eyed on my walk to work. When I started this thing, I wasn't expecting to have days where the album just really, really made me miss my Dad. He would have enjoyed the idea of this project, because he genuinely loved music, though I'm sure would have despaired at some of my ratings (Pink Floyd always worth 5 stars to him). It made me feel feelings (and listen to Breakfast In America later in the day). 4/5
The only song I knew on this album was Dreamer. And the only other Supertramp song I can think of is Breakfast in America. I don’t think of this group much but I actually liked this listen. Dramatic 70s rock but fun and showcased some musical variety. Much better than yesterdays ambient stuff
Supertramp never really was a group that did much for me. The standouts if you want to call it that were "Bloody Well Right" and "Dreamer".
Al eens geluisterd, snap de hype echt niet. Niet slecht, niet goed.
Hmmm. Dreamer is good. Bloody well right is good—some interesting stuff, and some really dull stuff. I don't love it, I wouldn't buy it. I wouldn't turn it off or change the station. So a 3 it is.
Prog is best when infused with other genres, and Supertramp is a great example
Going into this album knowing only "The Logical Song", I had my reserves. However... Never did I expect to listen to an actually really good prog rock album with a lot of symphonic elements. Great songs, great listen. I have to learn more about early Supertramp. 4/5
It's non-offensive and non-interesting
One of my favorite records, and one of the first "adult" records I owned. In 1974 I was 9. I don't think I heard this until I was 12 or so, but "Dreamer" was a constant in our house.
School isch en maximale Start für sones Album vode Supertrampers wo scho hoffnig uf es Album Maximum Punctico gmacht het! Die restliche Lieder sind denn au ganz losbar gsi aber ned nöch ah dere Messlatte wos doch sich selber gsetzt hend mit School. Da hends im Dramaturgie-1-Mal-1 leider s Spannigsboge-Seminar verpasst. Trotzdem gnosse und git defür en solide Vierehalber (aka es solids 3 bide 1-5 bewertig)
Biz 1970er masseware. Eich easy aber würki null speziell. Aber ja, 3 crimes for the 20th century Befor super trump
supertramp isch wiedermal herzensahglegeheit <3 «school», «dreamer» & «crime of the century» (s'lied) sind fantastisch, de rest isch guet – wobi «school» speziell hervorghobe werde muess (was 1 song!!) de richter hertzog bewertet das kriminaldelikt mit 4 hammerschläg und haut es «ruhe im gerichtssaal» use
I don't like supertramp
Hated the first song, far too Pink Floyd like, felt a bit more charitable towards song 3 Hide in your Shell. Asylum is very Elton John. Given up by Rudy, really not enjoying this album, just not for me.
Very fun album, sounds like something that would play in a 70s discotheque
167/1089 - Bloody Well Right was cool. Some parts kinda feel almost like Boston or Chicago which I'm not a huge fan of, the bands not the cities. I enjoyed my visits in Boston and Chicago. Overall, this was above average. I'll listen to "Breakfast in America" sometime in the future. I listened to "Breakfast in America" too. Damn, 1979 was a great year for music. The Police, The Clash, Toto, Michael Jackson, Music for Airports, etc. I wish this one was on the list too, I'd give it 5 stars.
Great album by a great band! Loved it then, love it now!
Far more sweeping and theatrical than I expected. I’ve always thought Supertramp’s radio hits to sound kinda lazy… not the case on this album! I’ll have to give it another listen when I can pay closer attention. For now, they get the benefit of one more star than I was thinking to give.
I've never had the pleasure of listening to a complete Supertramp album before, but as someone that grew up through the 70's and 80's I've obviously heard many of their more well known tracks. This album was excellent. I enjoyed every single track and had to listen again straight afterwards, as it was that good.
Good, just didn’t vibe with it as much
This was great. Fantastic use of stereo too.
A obra prima do Supertramp. Faixas com melodias ricas e diversificadas entre si e que ao mesmo tempo soam como uma unidade, funcionando tão bem no conjunto, como um álbum conceitual. Arranjos elaboradíssimos que valorizam a participação de cada músico, com destaque para as abordagens de Rick Davies, ao piano. Diálogos vocais impressionantes (Davies e Hodgson), uso preciso de cordas, efeitos de percussão e partes de instrumentos de sopro. Maravilhoso!
very epic sounding, but I was too hungover to fully grasp it
Okayish ig. Instruments are good, vocals are meh. It's just not for me. A forgettable expirence, except for the last song 6.5/10
School is a trip, second track is fairly solid too. A lot of their songs end really well. Those two minutes of Rudy starting around the halfway point hit. Way too much piano, that’s just a me thing tho. The slower, less intense parts aren’t interesting, but the highs on the album are great and unique. Like they crescendo really well. Works well as an album.
Soft-core Prog-Rock, but like, not in a bad way? By today's standards, this is classic Yacht Rock(TM), for sure. I know "Dreamer" was the single, but wikipedia claims that "School" and "Bloody Well Right" are the more enduring hits. It's hard to argue with that as I find Dreamer pretty cloying after about 30seconds. I can’t see School as a hit but as an album opener, you could do far worse. Portions of Bloody Well Right feel like they had direct influence on Pink Floyd's Animals (1977), which surprised me at first. I am much more familiar with the latter, so hearing similar sounds caught me off guard here. At ~45min, this is a very manageable prog-rock album that never feels like it goes off on a big space voyage for too long despite the slightly ominous album cover or the threatening “will he take a sailboat ride?" in the chorus of “Asylum”. We get harmonicas, saxophones, talkbox guitars, Wurlitzers, all the things I wish we still heard more often. I don't know if I need to revisit this whole album, but I'll spend some more time with Supertramp.
I wonder if Dan Bejar digs Supertramp. Probably.
Not my usual type of music, but a pleasant surprise.
Good
Some good tracks there, but wouldn't put in my playlist, but won't mind listening if starts playing
Reminds me of Dark Side of the Moon. Asylum was my favorite.
Vanille
OK, not a huge fan but not a hater either. More musicality than I would have guessed for what I otherwise recall as a pop band.
Never been very drawn to Supertramp, and nothing in this album led me to regret that sentiment.
The older I get the more I lean in to how much I appreciate Supertramp. There is a lot of levity, super proficient musicianship, theatrical energy and delightful melodies. I wont praise this album too too much because I'm sure there is other albums that better represent the band as a whole. I'll keep at it.
Some brilliant songs and an original sound that no other band has ever really recreated. Some songs are forgettable though.
had some Strange British moments but i liked it sure
Started out so good....then faded into just fine.
Whatever they call this - prog rock, or art rock, or anything else - it's good and it takes me to a happy place. Oh, to be 18 again...
Love the weighty synth sounds. Blends with the guitars. Drums sound nice and tight. Stereo field is super tasteful. Everything sounds pretty up front but not super loud which is crazy. Love it.
Super tight, satisfying and very clear mastering. Prog elements, but also very structured and melodic. Very depressing lyrics and tone. Keyboard solos are my favourite part, sax parts. Drums are so clear and tie it all together. Only downside is that it could've been a little more experimental; a little more risky.
great
Definitely feels like a classic
I've never gone out of my way to listen to Supertramp before, and I regret it! This album is fantastic. I would give it 4.5 stars if I could. Lots of great tracks on this album, especially the closing track with an epic instrumental lush with saxophone, piano, and drums. I'll listen to this many more times to come.
adri: 10, los compositores clásicos serían fanses de supertramp. Claro candidato al mejor CD de la historia. Cada canción es un viaje y el conjunto una experiencia increíble. Wow mar: 10, esta debe ser la vez 289 que escucho este album al completo. Es mi album favorito de la historia. He llorado.
Supertramp! Heck yeah! I haven't given many "this was already in my music library" five star ratings yet, so this is a special occasion! 🥳 (Supertramp are in my top 50 all time artists on last.fm, at #39, so this was a foregone conclusion. Just wait until the one album from my number one most listened artist turns up!)
Great opening, album felt like a proper musical journey from epic to more relaxed songs like Crime of The Century. Not every song was for me but appreciated the whole album nonetheless
I love Supertramp, their happy/theatrical sound & some of their most important songs are on this record.
Beste album van Supertramp. 4.2
Mate... this is what I needed, a banging album
Absolutely fantastic in so many ways. So many classics it's insane. Maybe even better than Breakfast in America. About 15 years ago I had the idea of using the second half of the "Crime of the Century" song as a movie score (from about 2:07) - it's unlikely I'll ever get to do it, but hopefully someone does!
Bridging the gap between prog and pop. School, Bloody Well Right and Dreamer are the hits but If Everyone Was Listening and Crime of the Century close off the album beautifully and make you turn the volume right up. Easy five stars
For those of my generation, Supertramp is like Electric Light Orchestra and The Alan Parsons Project. You think each group had just a few hits but when presented with a greatest hits album you’re pleasantly surprised to realize they each had quite a few. This group wasn’t on my high school group’s radar, since they didn’t have hits until 1974 (post high school) on this, their third album — in fact their first two albums are not streaming. Breakfast in America is a better album of theirs (sadly, today’s is the only one of theirs in the 1,001), but this is pretty good. Two FM radio staples and a number of other tasty tracks. Makes me want to listen to more of them.
As luck would have it, just two or three weeks ago I decided I needed to listen to the whole of Supertramp’s classic album “Breakfast in America,” because I never had. If that’s on the list, that’ll be a 4/5 debate when it comes up. But bad luck for this album, I think, because I was expecting another collection of non-stop bangers and this ain’t it. Just okay.
Un disco que mi yo de 18 años le habría gustado mucho.
Downcast. Theatrical. Sincere. Prog is the lowest genre, it smothers music in musicianship. This is near the top of prog, for what it's worth. "The nicest of the damned", in the words of a band not on this list. The songs with the good melodies are also from the ridiculous singer.
Unremarkable
Listened in the truck via Amazon music. Soundscape was awesome but songs were not. Highlights were the guitar and key sounds.
Supertramp has never been one of my favorites. Their songs are full of amazing moments but never come together for me. I felt the same for this project. Rudy was my favorite song. Asylum was almost good but it just didnt do it.
Wrong (wrong), you're bloody well wrong, you got a bloody right to say this was a PASS
Not a big fan of yacht prog.
Lightweight and dated, but still good smooth jams.
There’s nothing that tries so hard and yet does so little as 70s prog
Looking through the track list on Wikipedia, I think I preferred the songs with 'Davies' on vocals over the 'Hodgson' songs. I liked the piano bit on the first track, some of the heavier riffs, and the long drawn-out ominous jam at the end of the album. The lyrics were weak and the whole thing had a West End musical kinda vibe.
There are too many albums of this genre and decade on this list. But I'm glad this album is one of em. What a neat discovery for me! Each of the tracks stood out, and I liked them all. By the second listen I was singing along.
85% Best: School; Bloody Well Right; Rudy; Crime of the Century Must-Hear? Sure
The album that saved Supertramp...a couple of strong singles but the album is a bit boring. It may have been seen as great in the early 1970s, but by 2025 it's just nostalgia. An annoying example of prog-light pop.
Classic 70s! Fun and good cohesive energy as an album, but not many standouts.
Nice 1970's pop/rock, good musicianship. Not overly exciting but I'll happily listen to this. Almost a 4.
I thought I liked this album a lot more than I did, the second half was great, Rudy onwards. But a few of the earlier songs started to irritate me.
Bom álbum. Algumas músicas são excelentes. Moondrop May.
Everything that sucks about 70s music distilled into one album
Fine, but it can be dangerous to write classics when most of your songs are only fine
Totally uninteresting, but not actively bad
Quite liked this, kinda like a proggy 10cc. Will definitely be coming back to this!
No note. Just classic tunes
It was pretty good. Kinda let it play in the background because it has some great instrument solos
Brought back wonderful memories of my teenage years
I always confuse Supertramp with Supergrass. That’s on my though because sometimes one of me few brain cells goes to sleep. This was a fun album though, and it enjoyable from front to back. Supertramp have a style that seems hard to find in any other bands, toeing into prog just enough to be wacky, but never far enough to get real weird with it. This is a pleasant, fun album, and Dreamer is sand very frequently in our home.
Good musicianship but a bit too cheesy for my taste
A really good record… for forty seconds.
Prog rock lite. It's okay I suppose but it lacks the inventiveness and theatricality of better prog rock bands. Hard to believe this and Pink Floyd's Animals are considered to be in the same genre.
idk super tramp just doesn't do it for me. I appreciate them but don't find myself going back.
PRE-LISTENING: I am very vaguely familiar with the music of Supertramp but cannot imagine that this truly is an album I need to listen to before I die. I don't recognize any of the song titles but we shall see if any of it sounds familiar... LISTENING: The opening track ("School") does not sound even remotely familiar. Wikipedia says it was released as a single and was kind of a hit, which is wild to me. Wikipedia calls Track 2 ("Bloody Well Right") their "breakthrough hit" and again it doesn't sound remotely familiar. I have MAYBE heard "Dreamer" before? (Or more likely, it just sounds like generic Supertramp to me.) POST-LISTEN: Absolutely not an album anyone NEEDS to listen to.
Witty
Enjoyed it.
While the album is undeniably Supertramp, it is a a certain showing of their progression toward Breakfast in America. It sounds more like a refinement, a demo album, than a noteworthy album.
Innocent!
great album!
Fine
It took an age for me to find Breakfast In America on CD. One reason why I was, once upon a time, a big endorser of streaming. Halcyon days… Oh, yeah, this. So so.
Probably one of the most important albums of my life. I've been listening to it since I was 13 or 14, and I still love it. Supertramp is one of the most important bands I've taken with me from the '70s anyway. Full marks, because nostalgia also plays a huge role with Supertramp.
I like it
Interesting - never listened to them before
I find it so hard not to enjoy Supertramp. I didn't start this project a fan, but I may very well become one by the time I'm through. While this isn't Supertramp's best record, it still has great vocal harmonies and fun songs. "Dreamer" is the clear high point here.
88/100. A great art rock album with jazzy undertones. The atmosphere and overall vibe are captivating, unique yet oddly familiar. It's a distinctive record that really leaves an impression.
אלבום די משעמם השירים לא מיוחדים במיוחד והם די חוזרים שיר מועדף - Crime of the century
Prog for people who don't like to be challenged. I still thought it was alright. Not everything has to push you. 7.5 out of 10. So I'll have to round it up to 4.
This was actually quite good. I’ve listened to very little supertramp but I quite enjoyed this. Very Pink Floyd which wasn’t what I was expecting
Really liked the opening track and the piano solo but the rest of the tracks not something id revist maybe bloody well right. However not a bad album just felt the other tracks were flat & I see the effort put into this album with the different melodies and drum patterns just it didnt do it for me.
classic good rock. Supertramp gets the panties!
Heck yeah Sonic Voyagers. You're bloody well right this album kicks ass. Years ago I had a friend gift me a nice collection of albums. They had 5 or 6 Supertramp albums in there and I really enjoyed them all. I would add this to any discussion of 'perfect' albums. Thoroughly enjoyed listening to this again.
missing a bit of punch at the end. is a solid listen. 3/5
É incrível como eles forçaram esse piano em todas as músicas e ele não se encaixa em nenhuma.
Kinda weird, kinda silly, kinda liked it.
I love to see that some people hate this record because it sounds like a mix of Queen, Pink floyd, Elton John and Steely Dan, and that's exactly the reason why I like it! First time listening to it, I found it incredible, from start to end. And it sounds amazing, top notch production
never heard of them before but enjoyed the music. quiet eclectic with dramatic arrangements. will revisit. close to giving it a 4.
Prog rock sucks. A better project for this album would be deciding who is worse, Supertramp or Rush. The only good Supertramp song is Goodbye Stranger. This is awful music, Hide In Your Shell could be titled Representative Awful Supertramp Song and it would be more accurate. Listening to an entire album of this is making me like Goodbye Stranger less because it sounds too much like the rest of this. How can some of these albums keep getting worse when they start out so terribly. Dreamer is the hit and it is awful. I guess the lesson this album teaches is that things can always get worse. Crime of the Century is like the worst Pink Floyd cover band you can imagine. 70s dad rock Floyd...no one is filling a planetarium to see a laser light show for that. Even the album cover looks like a Pink Floyd ripoff.
Banger album. Only heard Dreamer before, decent song, but the entire album as a whole was great. Intro kicked it into space, felt like Pink Floyd inspired? Not sure about the timeline. Use of all the different instruments was amazing to listen to.
Some good vocal parts. Some nice instrumentals at times. Periods where not a lot seemed to happen, and songs on the longer side. Not a huge fan overall.
The first track was promising but the rest was boring
Supertramp can be a hit or a miss for me. This one is a definite hit. Great from start to finish and well recorded.
Of it's time not sure if they wanted to be a prog band or more pop. Some good songs on it even the ones that reminded me of genesis
Never listened to Supertramp (knowingly, at least) in my life until now. This was actually pretty cool. Like yeah, it's corny, but I don't know. It's perfectly enjoyable. I'm not sure when I'll come back to it but I enjoyed the ride. I felt like I was at a white dad's barbecue, but in a good way. He can grill.
Fantastic. 4.5
1. zchool - 1.5 2. bloody - 1.5 3. zhell - 0 4. azylum - 1 5. dreamer- 1.5 6. rudy - 1 7. liztening - 1.5 8. crime - 1
superfun!
2.5 stars
Me ha gustado mas que el de ayer, tiene melodías y junta instrumental de una forma muy guay. Según lo que he leído es rock sinfónico, me gusta este tipo de rock, mezcla diferentes estilos musicales. 7/10
Not my type of music
Not memorable but fine. 2 stars
Frequently rocked and was often strange. Excellent beginning to end
Really good stuff. Rips all the way through.
bom album. mas não é meu gosto
Decent listen. Couple great tunes.
I couldn't get too excited about this album, but I can't really put my finger on why that is. It was just OK.
It’s no “breakfast in America” but it’s still solid
Absolutely a banger 5/5
Amazing as just a straight up vibes album. Could listen to this on repeat for hours.
I should likely own this. Likely will pick it. Not my thing normally, but its cultural impact is unmistakable.
Enjoyable throughout. Cool soundscapes. None of the songs particularly jumped out, mind.
Perfectly cromulent radio psych rock but nothing stands out enough for me to be ranked any higher.
The sax fill in Hide in Your Shell kinda sounds like who can it be now by Men at Work Hearing the piano breaks always brings a smile to my face, wish we could get Breakfast in America soon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jspCAfZeDqc
ruined by classic rock radio
Godt album lyttede sammen med Frede. Det er åbenbart et band som tog inspiration fra en masse af de store i 70’erne og lavede det meget cleanly produced og derfor er det heller ikke så populært blandt kritikere fordi det ikke rigtig som sådan gør noget unikt, men det gør det stadig godt non the less. Til gengæld banede det vej for at normalisere konceptuel albums.
This was a tedious listen. I have no idea how it made the list.
Not bad
I didnt know they did all those hits, only one on here imo
Love it. Great song.
Enjoyed the album and many of the songs.
pretty cool
Surprisingly like this.
I had never heard of this group or album, so far as I can remember, but I’ve heard the song “Dreamer” in commercials. It’s not a bad song, but it’s not even one of the best here. There is a Pink Floyd influence without imitation, but also more of a grinding, melodious element. Pleasant surprise here.
Han marcado una época, con pocas piezas muy bien logradas, con seguridad están entre los músicos del siglo. Dos, tres o cuatro temas, trascienden los años fácilmente.
Lord what an album. How odd and spacey and fun. Technically high-level without being a dick about it. Supertramp in the morning is a rad way to kick off a week.
It's a nice detour into prog-rock. However, "Crime of the Century" is nowhere near as good as the likes of Pink Floyd and Porcupine Tree. I suppose some people really love it. The outro of the title track makes a classic conclusion to the album. Other than that, there's nothing to say about it. 3 stars for "Crime of the Century".
Excellent concept album.
Pretty good album, it took several songs to get used to it but overall a memorable prog rock entry I hadn't listened to before. Notable tracks that stood out to me were Asylum for the stage show feeling presentation, Rudy had elements that felt ahead of its time, and the title track felt like something I should hear on the radio more but don't. I enjoyed it, but I don't know if it will be in my constant rotation.
Their 3rd album. Rock / Prog. Struggled with this one. I'm just not into this type of prig stuff. They're a tight band and it's well produced but meh.
Pretty solid prog-pop. A classic in Bloody Well Right, but the rest didn't really hit me. Couple songs that I didn't like (Hide In Your Shell and Dreamer). They got a kinda silly, childish sound that I feel like a lot of 70's prog bands would dip into and I'm not a fan. Overall though, baffles me this album was picked over Breakfast in America, which has way more hits on it. Not that this record doesn't deserve it, but BiA should have been put in before Crime of the Century was even considered.
Christgau in Village Voice memorably described Supertramp as ’Queen without the preen’, which is cute but not quite right. Supertramp have much more respect for the values of a good straightforward pop rock song, and are only proggy in that they can actually play their instruments. There’s not too much of the baroque or excessive on this album, it’s mostly just classic early seventies pop rock. It was the decision to turn their back decidedly on prog in favour of pop for this very album which saved the band from obscurity. Good pop song writing, musical ability and some decent originality in arrangements combine to make this album more than just a throwaway pop release but an album which combines commercial appeal with genuine creativity.
I listened to this while I was running and I don’t remember feeling anything (positive or negative) about it.
Some parts were pretty enjoyable, more parts felt a little derivative / forgettable. Nothing was actively unpleasant
Trumpet goes hard same with piano. Limited vocals
Great stuff. Surprised by the Pink Floyd vibes
Hugely popular in my first year at uni, played it loads and tried hard to love it. A fine album clearly but maybe a little too close to prog rock for me...
Nice, but nothing that really grabbed me and made me want to listen.
Tricky. I kinda enjoyed it but I have already forgotten it.
I enjoy supertramp, breakfast in america has bee in my playlist for some time. Crime of the century is not quite as catchy but it has very similar strength, beautiful piano, philosophical lyrics and nice progressions . It lacks enough catchy and top tier songs for me to rate it in top albums but very enjoyable
It’s okay. Kind of hokey 70’s dad band. Not totally my jam
Enjoyed this, it felt creative although similar to other prog rock. A few overindulgent aspects but overall enjoyed.
Supertramp have a lot of songs I know and enjoy, though they seem to be spread among albums. The intro to School is pretty great. Dreamer is a classic. Bloody Well Right is fun! Good to hear some Sax. The electronic vibes throughout add a different dimension to their music, too. Album is very good.
Yea i mean, I can see the complexity and difficulty and originality of what's here. But I think its also very forgettable for the most part
Good album, really liked the first 3 songs. Fun use of dynamics in Asylum, like someone in the booth is turning down the volume knob. Dreamer is kind of annoying to listen to. Rest of the album is ok, title track is a little boring but I like the reprise of the harmonica from the first track school.
A vibe but not much variation
Enjoyable 70s prog rock time capsule, has aged well
This album is very Pink Floyd, not even just the music, they went for a space cover a year after DSOTM 🤨 if you're gonna have an influence might as well make it a good one I guess I did enjoy this, some of these tracks have a nice build and the brass is cool when they appear. The typical prog lack of structure puts me off slightly. Also as I go to do the rating the next day, I realise I didn't find a lot of it memorable. So 3 seems fair
I genuinely liked this album more than I thought I would. Closer to ELO than ELP.
Meh. Not for me.Bloody Well Right is the best song. Asylum is an interesting song. Musically they great musicians its just not my bag.
Good production and instruments, but boring songs.
Geweldig album
I'm a fan of prog rock, some of my favourite bands are prog rock bands. However, I found this album slow and boring.
I didn't think it was too bad. Listened all the way through with no complaints really. The only song I knew was "Dreamer" because of some commercial that it's on. Although I've heard of Supertramp, I've never been exposed to their music.
I wasnt in the mood for this but it won my respect for being a big grand sound
no redeeming qualities
Good album all the way through. Classic 70s rock.
Pretty good. Very 70s in a dramatic movie soundtrack sort of way that reminded me of, like, Xanadu or the Beegees Sgt Pepper movie. So maybe not good? But I liked it. Crime of the Century was good.
Very Tommy-esque (derogatory). Last song was a banger tho
4/10
It's really late as I'm listening to this so I'm honestly not expecting much. Gonna try to be as objective as possible despite the non ideal hour. Supertramp is a band I know of from their "Breakfast in America" album which came out a few years after this. Expecting something very 1970's. Hoping for some catchy tunes and an accessible experience. School Cinematic opening. Promises something dramatic. Seems to be building up to something in the first verse. Kinda proggy. A dynamic track with some complexity to it, has a lot of really distinct parts and passages that are characterized by entirely different compositions. None of the verses repeat a single melody and the tempo changes a lot throughout the track. Love the extended piano passage. Interesting track, though perhaps a bit too ambitious, feels a bit unfocused. Decent. 3.5/5 Bloody Well Right Jazzy opening. The keys create a groove all on their own. Has some edge to it with the heavy distortion on the guitars. The at times yachty vocals don't really do much for me. Theres a certain underlying blues feeling to the track, it seems to hide under layers of instrumentation. Feels like it's missing something, though I can't quite place what it is. Fine. 3/5 Hide In Your Shell Sleepy vibe from the keys. I don't love the vocals, they a bit underdeveloped. The instrumental is a bit too loud, especially the bass. Extremely 1970's. Comes across as cheesy and dated, and not in a charming way. A bit lame. Does not have enough going for it to justify being almost seven minutes long. The climax of the song just comes of as wailing and desperate with unconvincing backing vocals to go with it. Did not like. 2/5 Asylum The first verse reminds me of a melodramatic B-list musical. Terrible mixing. Very jarring drop in volume. The sound is very empty and hollow, the variations in volume does not help with this, genuinely just makes the song distracting. I don't like the vocals at all, feels like a raving madman on an especially bad bender trying to start a fight with the instrumental. Strongly dislike. 1.5/5 Dreamer Wow that's annoying. Sounds like a children's song at times. The keys in the background add nothing positive to the track. I can't see the intention behind this song, is it supposed to be inspiring? I feel like I'm being mocked by some irritating toddler. Strongly dislike. 1.5/5 Rudy The piano intro is pleasant. It's not entirely terrible. There are some pretty cool guitar riffs, and at points the vocals come through a few memorable melodic lines. The bassline is also pretty consistently good. Though the first half of the song meanders a lot, dragging you along through a boring journey. It starts picking up later on bringing a pretty dynamic conclusion to the whole ordeal with a more energetic climax before wrapping up with a decent enough conclusion. Suffers from the first half being stretched too thin. Average. 2.5/5 If Everyone Was Listening Fairly dramatic with a hint of theatricality in the performance. Suits the lyrics well. Love the flute. The violin also adds a nice dramatic effect. Decent. 3.5/5 Crime of the Century I don't buy it. Attempys to be dramatic, but it feels a bit manifactured. The guitar solo however is quite good. I enjoy the atmosphere set up by the dueling piano notes and the bass. Has the potential to grow on me. Is a pretty okay closer. Decent. 3.5/5 That was a bit mediocre if I'm being honest. Some songs sorta worked, but there was also plenty of unflattering melodramatic slop, which while not being directly out of ideas came off as goofy and lame. Some songs were overly long, slow and grating. Possessing unpleasant vocals and strange production choices that made them difficult to listen to. It's not entirely hopeless however, as many of the ideas present in the instrumentation were well executed. There's some good guitars, well paced piano passages and strongly implemented moments of flute and violin. The drums were also mostly fine, providing power and intensity to some tracks, but I feel like they sometimes were victims of some not great mixing where they sounded a bit hollow. The proggier more experimental tracks were probably the highlight on here, with a dynamic sound and some fresh ideas. Otherwise a lot of this album strays into yacht rock territory where the slow, calculated songs offer little of value. 2/5 Fave track. School Least fave track. Dreamer
So nice, I listened twice 🤘
It's good old-head stuff, but I've been overexposed to this type of music due to many years of riding around in a crew van with the radio tuned to the classic rock station.
I am admittedly ignorant to the intricacies of music production. But man, why don't more albums sound this good? The mixing is fantastic.
Solid album with some hits. Going to be a little tough and put it on the three side of a 3.5.
The hits were a nostalgic and enjoyable listen, and the rest of the album held up? Not too shabby, Supertramp!
There's not a ton of progressive rock on this list, so I was happy to see this one come up. This is a nice album, very atmospheric in sound. I was already familiar with some tracks, but I enjoyed all of them. I would listen again.
I enjoyed this. The songs were a little samey and it sounds a little dated but a lot of these songs had a great vibe to them and there’s no bad songs.
Supertramp have a sound —springy organ synth, choral harmonies, loopy 58-pound weakling lead singer— that I don’t hate. But even though each song is internally creative, they all sound similar — that Supertramp sound is pervasive. This whole album, while somewhat entertaining, sounds derivative of itself. It’s like every song could be in a sonic sequel to Tommy.
Crime of the Century sounds like your standard issue 70s rock album — well-produced, decent musicianship, but nothing that really jumps out or sticks with you. It’s not bad by any means, just kind of... there. If you’re a big Supertramp fan, I’m sure it hits differently, but for me, it just blended in with a lot of other albums from the era.
eig ganz geiles Album chillig und unique fav track -Hide in your shell
Solide Top: Scool
I mean, fine. Another one that just didn’t really hit for me, but there’s nothing wrong with it. Some cool moments that made me think of Elton John or something, but probably not a band I’ll revisit. Asylum was my favourite track.
"well it's not as though he's fat, no there's more to it than that" lol what
muzycznie świetnie, vibe mi nie do końca odpowiada. trudno określić czemu
Top
Started off excellently, wore me down the more the album went on. Dreamer was a song that was completely lost on me.
Valeur sûre
Just my kinda thing. I can see it being annoying for some people, but this is what I hope from a prog album.
25/04/2025 This isn't their best work, I'm just hoping more of their albums pop up.
I think there's been a mistake. I believe this one is from that other list - 1,001 Albums No One Should Ever Have to Hear Again.
Nope. Never liked them.
I'd never heard any pre-Breakfast in America (not on this list, shockingly) Supertramp, and you can see the roots of the irritating earworms in among the noodly prog. But all in all, no thanks.
2 excellent songs amid a lot of forgettable material.
Maybe this was amazing in it's time, but listening now it's like a mix of Elton John Piano and David Bowie. The only song that really stuck out was Dreamer, but that might be because it was in a movie?
Oooh, I’m having fun so far! It’s impressive! The style is so cool, and not something I’ve really listened all that much to before. I feel like I can hear a mesh of different styles and influences; I can pick out some Beatles influence, but it also sounds very modern for 1974. Almost akin to The Police, perhaps. I wasn’t even aware people were making music like this in the early 70s!! Really easy to listen to. I’m having a ton of fun with it so far. Almost soothing to my ears, as my head has been hurting so much for the past little while before putting this record on. Excited to see where the rest of it goes, on Asylum now. :)) A bit of the way through Rudy now, and I can definitely see myself going back to listen through this entire album again in the future!! I think I understand what prog rock is now lol. Ooh okay, I’m REALLY, really liking this album, which is not surprising, per se, but is a pleasant and exciting treat. Okay! All right! Very, very enjoyable album!! A solid 4 stars for me! :) Also sort of introduced me to a new subgenre that I wasn’t necessarily all that aware of/familiar with.
Boring as hell
Prog-rock that is great with headphones. I was familiar with “Bloody Well Right” and “Dreamer” from the radio, but giving these songs (and the album) full attention made me like them even more. I like how the two singers alternate tracks. The Wurlitzer is featured heavily and I love how these songs always take a different, interesting direction.
Not a fan of prog rock in general, but find it especially torturous when it gets theatrical and this album went there. It wasn't even that long of an album and I kept checking how much time was left only to learn I was on the 3rd song.
i was impressed at the beginning - first track fucks, second track fucks... then crash. has some other highlights throughout though.
It's nice, will listen to it more, but it's not like insanely good to get 5 stars
Honestly, it feels like if someone tried to redo 60s Who songs in a 70s prog style.
Bloody Well Right -- ok it's a classic Asylum -- sounds like it wants to be in a musical. Bleh Dreamer - don't hate it but I wouldn't add it to a playlist Rudy - technically good but boring Crime of the Century - another one out of a musical Didn't finish. I never loved the group that much. Now it seems over-produced and looking to be a rock opera but without the passion and story of something like Tommy
Not my thing
Ymmärrän, miksi levy on päässyt listalle. Monipuolista soitinten käyttöä, ja kyllä tätä mielellään kuunteli koko levyn läpi. Sellaista positiivista perus settiä, en vaihtaisi radiokanavaa. Ei ehkä tule kuitenkaan omaan levyhyllyyn ostettua.
Oikein hyvä!
Ok
Tämähän oli mukavan positiivinen yllätys. Biiseissä käytettiin monipuolisesti eri instrumentteja esille.
Ihan tämmöstä perus rockia, menevämmät biisit oikein jees. Voi soida taustalla tai olla soimatta mutten kuuntelisi aktiivisesti. Vähän Beatles-viboja. Joitakin outoja kohtia siellä täällä ja kehnonpuoleinen laulaja.
Used to listen a lot to Supertramp and I still like some of the tracks on this album (e.g. School and Dreamer) but I wasn‘t in the mood to listen to it all the way through.
This really grew on me. I wouldn't consider myself a fan of easy listening or however else this could be defined as, but this album has a nice groove and the horn playing holds it all together. 3.25/5.
VERY of its time. Feels like it’s trying too hard to be epic. At least it dials back (some of) prog’s worst indulgences.
Quirky weird 70s
I'm not a supertramp fan in general... I don't enjoy the singles at all. Dreamer specifically is a stain upon this earth that i hope is someday scrubbed away. Turns out I also don't like the deep cuts. This album felt like a mix of shitty The Wall-era Pink Floyd and shitty Elton John. The nicest thing I have to say about it is that occasionally there's a cool instrumental passage like the piano bit in the middle of School. I swear I've heard it in a movie and it's just an awesome little piano interlude rammed in the middle of a shitty song. I wish it was it's own song. I swear this is probably the album that upset angry teens in the 70s so much that they decided to invent punk to try and kill it. Why won't it die?
I really don’t care much for this record, but I do think ‘School’ is a cool way to kick it off.
i found this kind of charming (if deeply unserious) and mostly tolerable in the same vein as ELO and certain songs by queen, but it pushed the limits of my good graces for going on for far too long. it’s like a 2.75 really.
did not like this. theater kid ass music. i didn’t have high expectations but i do like “goodbye stranger” so i went in hoping there would be at least something enjoyable on here but everything was too shmaltzy (especially the saxophone-heavy songs) and just not that interesting.
Good progressive album. Not wow but ok
I didn't think I'd save any tracks from this album but I saved "Dreamer". Classic rock isn't really my jam.
Dad Rock at tit's finest
=The Beatles
Ok, but nothing outstanding or that memorable beside a couple of the hits. 5/10
Good hot tub music
Big jamming
It would probably grow on me. I will listen to it more in future
Overall kinda meh. Had some good parts but it kept tricking me before switching it up. Not bad compared to most other albums so far though.
I REALLY enjoyed the start of this album. Periodically really cool. Easy listen but nothing that breaks into my playlists. Instrumentally this album is AWESOME
If EVERY song was like School (the first one) this would get a 4, but they progressively got a little stranger. That's 70s rock for you, I guess.
5/5. Favorite album so far overwhelmingly
Kind of forgettable again, but Bloody Well Right and Dreamer are real good.
The best
There must be a reason I didn’t have Supertramp in my music collection. Two songs are okayish - the rest didn’t age well.
I thought this album artwork said 'Supertrump' at first. 😆 Pretty fun album!
I sometimes wonder why they didn’t do better in America. W mean we were fine with other British bands, the Beatles, the Stones etc. I think it’s because the others didn’t use phrases like “Bloody well right” which brings out our inherent xenophobia. I give it a four. Three for the music and one for the nostalgia
Another 'okay' album. I'm not a huge fan but it doesn't hurt me when it's in the background. I recognized 'Dreamer'. 'School' was a pleasant discovery. Unfortunately, it was the first track. After that, I found it a bit plain.
I always like a piano-centric record, and this album stands out in that regard. If Everyone Was Listening sounds straight out of an Elton John compilation. The title/final track introduces the heartbreaker combo of high piano, high strings, high sax, and slow 6/8 time. It's a great way to end the album on a grand "impending-doom" note, though it would be significantly better with an actual ending rather than a fade-out. There are also a few mildly suspect tracks that could reasonably be described as filler - most notably Dreamer, which is more of a silly novelty track. One of the singers' voices is pretty goofy. It's most noticeable in Dreamer during the solo vocals. Sounds a bit like the higher range of early-career David Bowie. The backing vocals give an extremely retro feel (almost like something you'd hear from the Four Seasons) that really creates an odd feel, because the instruments heavily imply a mid-70s sound. That being said, the music itself is excellent. A solid combination of multi-part prog, 60s rock, and groovy modern blues. One of the best examples of the latter genre is Bloody Well Right, which is instantly likeable. The keys are the highlight. I love the gritty, positive classic rock feel in that track. 4/5 Key tracks: School, Bloody Well Right, Crime Of The Century
Varied, catchy, layered, fantastic.
This album was a must in my youth. I often listened to the LP at friends' houses until I finally saved up the money for it. Then the album was often on the turntable. And listening to it again now after a long time, I realize that yes, the album is really good. 5/5
Great piano based bangers
Never heard it before, but this was great. Essential prog rock. Like a funky and poppier Dark Side of the Moon.
PRE LISTEN: Not entirely sure what to expect. I know very few Supertramp songs. LISTEN: Kinda hard to pinpoint what’s going on, but I like it alright. The vocalist has more interesting a voice than I had remembered.
This is a fun one
4/7/25. Interesting but just okay. Doesn't stack up to the other progressive records of the era for me, but still a good listen.
This is such nerd music - almost as bad as Steely Dan.
Not something I normally listen to but I enjoyed it.
vendez les actions
C'est quand même très bon. Mais il y a une différence marquées dans les chansons des deux compositeurs. Les chansons de Hogdson sont de loin mes préférées tandis que ceux de Davies, je les trouve longues et trop dramatique pour leur bien. Somme toute, ça reste une un album qui contient des chansons que l'on doit avoir entendu dans sa vie.
Cet album est comme une tour Jenga où il n'y a plus de move possible. Changer un seul bloc de place entraînerait un écroulement total.
3.3.
This felt like the 70s. Personal enjoyment: 3/5 Relevance to this list: 3/5
This is great. Going in the rotation
formulewerk
This will be good to listen to. Considering "Breakfast in America" was a great album to listen to with Dad growing up, I am looking forward to this. Opens with school: Classic harmonica from this band. Really love how the bass drops after that slow intro. Bloody well right: I thought that this was on "Breakfast in America" but it's a great song nonetheless. Distorted guitar work is solid. There's also a lil hard rock vibe thrown in there (similar to bad company). Dreamer: Absolute classic banger. There's even a little Pink Floyd in Crime of the Century. Was this revolutionary when it came out? What an album! - 5 stars.
Meh. It's ok. Not really something I'd reach for again.
school- 5 bloody well right- 5 hide in your shell- 5 asylum- 5 dreamer- 5 rudy- 5. im not listening to all that if everyone was listening- 5 crime of the century- 5 most boring shit ever
Like it. Has some banging surprises!
I very much so enjoyed this, the opening track was awesome and even gave me a fright because my headphones were so loud haha. “asylum” and “if everyone was listening” are other highlights for me
Surprisingly great. Proggy, punky in places, with a great range of tones and timbers, and only occasionally lapsing into parody (the theremin on track 3 was a bit much). Possibly lacking in memorable tunes, but a fun listen. A high 3/low 4, pushed into 4 because "Bloody well right" was too fun.
Dope bass lines.
I wasn’t familiar with this group, and I actually liked their sound a lot. Very groovy, blues-y when they wanted to be, and even quite dramatic at times. This album had relatively few tracks for its listening time, and they definitely make you work for it as you listen, since there are lots of lulls and random rises back to volume. It felt very mysterious, and even after two and a half full listens I still felt like some songs were beyond my comprehension.
Great sound but the songs didn't really do anything to me. They could have used more work.
Feel like this had potential to be awesome all the way through. Let down.
Had high expectations, was let down. A couple great songs but the rest was very meh
Not my kinda jam
Great classic rock album for a drive or relaxing.
Did not enjoy.
Music was good. I like some of their songs off other records. Nothing really stuck out to me here.
Good sound. One hit.
OH MY GOSH “Asylum”???? CAN WE TALK ABOUT THAT BRIDGE?!?! genuinely AMAZING instrumentals, their music is so passionate and emotional and loud and impactful and perfect. not a lot else to say other than i really liked this album. one goofy ahh song TOTAL. 4/5.
Very surprising! Liked this one quite a bit.
Quite a mix of genres on this one, the whole 70s are contained on a single album apparently. There are pop, prog, rock and art elements on here. Not sure I if listened to something like this before. Despite the interesting and changing song structures, this album can't be categorized as pure prog rock, at least in my opinion. There are way more elements of pop on here. Maybe progressive pop? Nevertheless, this is a really fun album to listen to, you never know what's coming next. There are great melodies throughtout, on piano, guitar, but also on winds for example. The album features two different singers, which makes the songs even more unexpected and different. This is a quality album, it's really well done, the production is good, nothing is overly aggressive. Everything is polished, from the music itself, to the mix. I just have to mention that harmonica into, it's one of the best album intros I've heard. A pretty cool album. Wasn't sure if I wanted to give it a 3 or 4. This could be one of the best pop albums I ever heard, just for the sheer musicianship and craftsmanship. Giving it a 4 for that.
This album was always our go-to for demonstrating or testing our studio and sound reinforcement system. Absolutely stellar production and dynamic range.
Well. This is certainly an album. With musical instruments such as guitar, piano and drums. And with lyrics. Which are sung. With a human voice. It glided right past me. Granted, my eyes glaze over as soon as I read the word "prog", but there's really nothing here that I found particularly interesting or memorable or noteworthy.
Hit and mostly miss yacht rock
Queen's bombacity meets Pink Floyd's prog, Supertramp is awesome. This album is musicially great and exploratory. It's corny at times, but that just adds to charm in my opinion. I love how funky it can be between It's pop choruses, and the solos throughout a re a ton of fun. Hide In Your Shell is my favorite here, such a dynamic song.
I guess I have a soft spot for early-70s British prog rock. I really enjoyed the album, there are moments on "School" that immediately grabbed me, and I loved "Hide in your shell". The whole album is great, and will probably enter frequent rotation.
Mér hefur alltaf fundist eitthvað sjarmerandi við Supertramp. Gaman að hlusta á lögin þeirra en ég sækist samt ekkert í það. Það sama á við núna. Þetta er hin fínasta plata en ég býst ekki við að ég hlusti á hana aftur.