Reviews (page 5 of 14)
I enjoyed this one!
Not bad at all
Only got partial tracks.
The reason I signed up for this in the first place was to broaden my horizons and discover gems I didn't know existed. I've heard so much about Supertramp over the years so thought I was in for a real treat. Sadly this album fell WELL short of my expectations. Just boring, bad singing, nothing going on. Not a fan.
proc je vetsina unavailable?? hudbou pripominajici bowieho (asylum) a queeny, not bad, neco jsem uz slysela, ale do playlistu to nejde..
A Proggasm. Progtacular. Progtrocity. Operatic Prog, Rock Prog, Jazzy Prog. Prog. Decent mind.
A case where the principle of the sound I seem too quite like. They just seem deft at ruining it from time to time. "Bloody Well Right" is not good and its up and down from there. Their USP is generating some engaging melody that gives it some real depth, and I really really like that. Maybe it's the complex layers, but I can imagine this would be good building a scene up in a film. "Hide in Your Shell" was a glimpse at getting the vocals to match the drama and even went Elton John like in the middle with some interesting piano moodiness. Ultimately not bad at all and I listened to this loads as background (it was short). Ironically the songs I knew are the sole reason why I only gave this a 3 and I also liked it way more than expected and included some excellent songs.
Great name, great album cover and I can see how this album would have sold well when it was released because it would have piqued my interest in a record shop. Unfortunately, I would have got it home and spun it up to ultimately be underwhelmed. It's prog-rock, but with a heavy emphasis on the prog. The opening track was pretty good, if a little soft. There was evidence of a little more bite here and there, for example the heavier bridge of 'Bloody Well Right', which got me momentarily excited before it dropped back into a Elton-Johnesque prog-pop blend. Generally far too soft for me. I'd like more rock with my prog, please.
I've decided to rate everything subjectively rather than objectively as these all have plenty of critic ratings out there. This is of course a super solid classic rock album, excellent mastering and dynamics, big impact. Down a star simply because for me it's a bit of a slog style wise outside Bloody Well Right, Asylum and the title track. Was a good listen though and it had been a long time since I'd heard it.
6.5/10
Gostei.
This was ok, but I didn't love it. (3)
It was okay
Good but not something I'd add to my rotation and I'm not super keen to listen to more from this artist.
Feels like if I ran a Merry-Go-Round and wanted to use 70’s themed music, I’d pick this. Can’t imagine coming back to this much but it isn’t the worst.
All of the songs blended and felt like one unit to me, which enjoyed. The one that jumped out was Dreamer. It sounded louder and a tad different- it was also the one song I knew before listening to the album. I enjoyed the sound, and I like Supertramp.
I liked the album. It sounded amazing but it felt like it was missing something. Like it was really close and then it just didn’t find it.
A lot of fun! not great, but good Best Song: Crime of the Century Rating: 7.5/10 Stars: 4
Just a bit too proggy for me, but I did smile at the thought of an American trying to make it all the way through ‘Bloody Well Right’.
This was very very good. It sucks youtube music only has part of the album available, but someone else just uploaded the entire album as a video and I just listened to that. Very cool album. Really into it.
i’ve gotta be real sports fans: idk if i’m a big fan of prog rock. this is not bad, but it’s not for me.
3/3. Heard this album many times growing up, still love it today. Hodgson and Davies voices contrast so well, the keyboards are top-tier, as are the arrangements. Some really groovy songs and thoughtful lyrics as well. A classic for sure.
If the ratings were more granular this is probably between a 3 and 4 I didn't like it as much as I thought I would, but it was stilly a really fun art rock/rock and/or roll record. I preferred the straight up rock moments more than the more artsy moments, which I wouldn't have expected. I found some of the longer songs dragged as the arrangements weren't interesting enough to justify the length. Still a bunch of really good stuff on here.
Supertramp is criminally forgotten by most people. They had a number of forgettable albums but this one is just fantastic
Eh, boring mostly.
Supertramp is so engrained in me from my years of working a terrible retail job where Supertramp played so much. Bloody Well Right and Dreamer take me right back to the days of restocking adult diapers in a drug store. Glory days. Liked Tracks: Dreamer
Raspberry ripple. Veins of great taste running through mostly bland and homogeneous vanilla stuff. It became background music after 3 songs. Dreamer came and went and I was gone again before the end.
Love Dreamer, though hasn't realised it was Supertramp! Was not so familiar with the other tracks, but I loved listening to this most 70s of albums...
Between this and Breakfast in America it's hard to escape Supertramp at hifi shows. That said, it's for good reason that these albums are used to show off audio equipment. Superb musicianship and songwriting and these album just seems to flow.
Has the popular screaming song that was trending on TikTok for a while and sounds haunting. Quite groovy album
Loved Dreamer
I never confuse supertramp with supergrass. Bloody well right. Dreamer is under appreciated
Good, but prog rock isn't my thing
Fine, but kind of boring (adequate but slow)
Too slow to warrant a band name like Supertramp. It’s fine, but not what I was expecting. Kinda boring
070126 11:06 3.5
Somewhat contemplative, classic pop-rock
I was at a party that turned out to be a Sith party. I don't remember much now but Cobra was there and the Jedi were fighting both. Idk where G.I. Joe was
superrrr underrated again another album i havent heard any songs from before! i love this genre/ type of music its so unique in my opinion
I absolutely loved this. The themes of alienation and loneliness and the exploration of fear of differences is so interesting and is explored through instrumentals and lyrics that perfectly match the theme. While listening to the title track I genuinely had a moment where I audibly said “this may be the best song I have ever heard”. The only album so far that I have immediately started again after first listen. Definitely one of, if not my favourite album on this journey yet. Wow
four in the morning and im zoning
School y el title track fueron mis favoritos, de nuevo algo que no se si escucharía pero me gusto mucho la verdad.
Lwk I’d listen to a few songs again
This album was actually excellent; yt men serving a lot of cunt for the sake or art.
Nothing grabbing me but fun
Trippy
Cool funky album, recognised dreamer but didn't realise how many tunes this band had (logical sign etc)
It was just okay… the first half just… existed… Dreamer reeled me in a bit for the latter half but it just wasn’t my jam. Some really neat music and sound at times but overall didn’t keep my attention / focus.
If 70s brown was a sound, It would be this.
I actually liked this album, along with the song ‘Dreamer’
Really, really awesome. It’s great to listen to this album start to finish, as most songs are quite long.
def relisten so good
Great album
I feel like I should like this album, but I just didn't.
absolutely incredible!! loved so many songs on this album
A uniquely 70s prog rock sound with a couple big hits. Not bad.
good
One of the songs Hide in your shell really reminded me of the song Fairy of Shampoo covered by TxT. I do not quite know if I like this album it is quite boring and it reminds me of queens music like the ensemble chorus in the background. Actually maybe that might me the first few songs Hide in your shell is a bop. It reminds of Space Odessey.
A surprisingly great album
me han gustado mucho las melodías aunque no haya entendido ninguna letra
I hear the prog rock. It’s okay. There are so many different things I hear as I listen to I hear some Bowie as I listen some Elton John and it all kind of works. I knew the name Supertramp more than I knew the music. Is it my favorite? No. Is it good? yes. I’m not going to add it to my playlist though. I’m glad I heard it.
Listened to this while reading substack and didn’t even realise the album replayed itself three times, 8/10 would recommend as background music for any creative endeavours.
quietLOUDquietLOUD for the love of god just set your volume in a certain range and let me actually listen to a song without being unable to hear or having my ears blown out by the sudden volume shift. Dreamer is obviously an absolutely killer song but also not that especially different to anything else on the album. This left me somehow both bored while craving more?
Intelligent music
More piano-centric Pink Floyd meet Bee Gees vibes. Enjoyed a few songs
188/1001 :: Supertramp - Crime of the Century Heard before? ❌ Would I revisit? ❌ Rating: 6 Listen before you die: No I’m pretty sure that if you looked up “70’s Rock” in the dictionary there’d be a picture of this album cover starring back at you. I didn’t love it but didn’t hate it. Some of it was pretty cool but also felt like it ran long. My guess is if I was in a rock band this would be good reference material…
Like if Elton John wrote musical about the Beatles
Favorite tracks: School, Hide in Your Shell This started out decently enough, but got old very quickly. Not unpleasant, but this was maybe the most dad rock/generic 70's soft rock band I've heard
A very nice easy listening progressive rock album. The keyboard is a main stand out in a lot of the songs, setting the tone for most the album as uplifting, but with heavy guitar riffs from time to time keeping it engaging & interesting. I also love the way the bass builds slowly in ‘Dreamer’, it’s a perfect display of prog rock. I think the production value of this album is what makes it stand out so much to me. Whether this album is for you or not, you could not argue that it doesn’t sound absolutely spot on. It’s laughable how British they sound in ‘Bloody Well Right’. Favourite tracks are: ‘School’, ‘Bloody Well Right’, & ‘Dreamer’.
At first, I was like ehhh this is so randomly orchestrated I don’t think I’m going to like this but it’s definitely not bad. But then I don’t know what happened but it became so beautifully done instrumentally. I genuinely can’t believe how much better the second half of this album is and how much it made my opinion change. Will be listening in the future.
I loved the drama of this album. It felt grandiose in its compositions. I loved the symphonic elements combined with the builds!
High production value and catchy songs that are fun
I always forget how much I like Supertramp. This was a good listen and a good reminder to play more of their music.
This is standard 1970s Supertramp, Including the hits “Bloody Well Right” and “Dreamer”. Those are good tracks which we all heard on the radio, while the remainder of the album was decent but not memorable. Let’s give it a solid three stars.
Space rock? :D? I know this is a famous band, but I've only ever heard 'Goodbye Stranger' before (not on this album). They're OK. Kind of a Pink Floyd/Queen/Don McLean hybrid. A little bit guitar-heavy for my preference. Highlight: 'Hide in Your Shell' (nice horns)
ここでいま初めて知ったバンド。このアルバムはプログレをポップに格調高くしたような感じかな。 悪くはないけど、涸れたようなボーカルがあまり好みではなかった。また、音色や展開に対して、悪く言うと古臭い時代性を感じた。 今のところ好みではないけど、聞きやすくはあったので、再訪して好きになる余地はあるかもしれない。
Wonderful
Meh2
The Good: We are going to witness a crime! Of the century no less! The Bad: We’ve been duped, as there is no crime to be found… The Ugly: My supertramp outfit… I mean, it’s bad… Back in my college days I befriended someone who, I found out later, had this knack for creating mixed tapes for friends. The opening track of this album was the first track on Side 2 of the mixed tape made for me. Somewhere in my disasterous belongings, there is a cassette case that should include this mixed tape… my only worry is that I will find it, because that will mean I must go shopping for a cassette player so that I can listen to this tape and reminisce about those good old days… The fact that this album is on this list makes me more than happy, though I was confused when I saw it as my immediate thought was “where’s Breakfast In America”?… which, to my horror, is NOT included on the 1001 list of albums I need to listen to. Needless to say I continue to question the rational for an album to be included in the list… Oddly enough, getting the album presented on my list meant it was the first time for me to listen to it… and what a joyful listen it has been. So joyful that I’ve listened to it daily for the past week, twice a day if the presented album turns out to be a turd… Hurray Supertramp, you get 5*
Kinda Elton Jenesis
Enjoyed this, very 70s. Not familiar with much Supertramp but could see myself investigating their back catalogue.
3.5 if I could. Really liked the start, lost me a bit near the end
First time I’ve given supertramp a proper listen and I’ve been missing out
Original 70’s edm/rock
The songs are overlong and it's a bit schlocky, but boy did I enjoy myself. Love the instrumentation in particular. Considered going up to 4 stars with this, but couldn't get all the way there.
No, I'm sorry, but you can't make prog rock that actually sounds pleasant and considers the audience's entertainment. And if you are a boomer rock band and the first lyric on your album is "I can see you in the morning when you go to school", it needs to either be some creepy perv thing, or Pink Floyd's po-faced Wall. Jokes aside, I'm really enjoying this mix of prog and pop-rock. This album has the ambitious scope of 7-minute developmental tracks. But it also has absolute ear worms and grooves. It has little fragments of jazz rock. The singing and songwriting are solid. The whole record is as clear and crisp and rich and detailed. All 8 songs are solid, and the sequencing of the album is solid, with the A-side and B-side equally strong in different ways. Big surprise album for me, having only listened to one of their later albums a couple of times. 5*
Almost great but not quite
Enjoyed but one or two of the songs a bit long.
Have heard of this band, but hadn't heard any of these songs before.
A fun 70s prog rock album that’s a fairly easy listen. Similar to the album I had yesterday from “Yes”.
I had this record and didn't really listen to it, felt like something you needed in your collection but didn't really need to listen to. I think their other one is bigger and better but this is fine, a couple of bangers and some filler, nothing special
Narrative elements felt a little clunky, but the songs within them grow to a nice climax. More familiar with prog bands like ELO and Genesis from this era. El Dorado from the same year is one of my favorite albums and has a much smoother flow. That said, some of the driving rock and funk from the second half of this album is undeniable. Had me moving without thinking.
Put this off because I enjoyed Breakfast in America. Enjoyed Bloody Well Right, Rudy and some others but a 3.5 on the lower half seems fair.
This was better than I expected, but I’ve never liked Supertramp. Good for what it is, but not really for me.
I have to admit that I have a soft spot for Pink Floyd-inspired dollar-bin prog rock. The first half of the album delivered for me, with some powerful riffing and the frenetic medleys you’d expect from a band with too much studio time. “Bloody Well Right” has everything I could want from this record. However, things started to fall apart in the second half, which offers much less charm or inspiration. Maybe it felt like they were reaching too much for FM glory, or maybe that’s just how long it takes for me to get tired of hearing a Wurlitzer.
Sometimes Brit Pop sounds like a parade of silliness. This is one of those times. I tried to find merit...there are some good parts that felt "out of this world" but mainly it sounded like a trite cacophony of arrangements that have been done before 74 and were over-done after 74.
dictionary definition of MOR
Couldnt finish as some songs were unavailable on soundcloud, youtube, tbh i couldnt be bothered to search more 5/10, dead in the middle
++: Bloody Well Right, Asylum, Rudy, If Everyone Was Listening +: Hide in Your Shell, Dreamer +-: School, Crime of the Century 7,0/10
SUPERTRAMP JA JA JA. es git glaub lüt wo nöd gern mundharmonika (cringe). ich lieb sooo fest d chords und wies langsam afangt und denn iiiirgendwenn chömed d drums ine. es tönt soooo fucking guet. die chline 16tel uf de gitarre? ischs e hihat? het de song en refrain (school)? wies uufbaut mit de gitarre ohyes. es isch vo afang ah afoch en build. mit xylophooon. ooooh de huagadugu uf de gitarre ooohyesss. ich lieb bloody well right sooooo fest. vlt min lieblings supertramp song. d hits am aafang ohgoooott. QUITE RIGHT. lieb s saloon piano und de gitarre bend und denn de pinch harmonic fuuuck yes. und denn ischs so groovy mit de claps und smooth sax?? hide in your shell isch soooo guet, dynamik masterclass. d drums töned soo fucking geil. d response vocals au soo cool. asylum sehr en albumtrack aber seehr geili melodie. gitarrestab bi 1:30 seeehr cool. ah syke ich kennen au seeehr guet, wies ufegoht wenn die ganz band inechunt ohshityes. ooooh de ivm turnaround. shityes. es isch es HERTS füfi. dreamer hani immer gfunde isch mer chli zu chindlich well de refrain so simpel und meeega aggressiv dur isch. aber denn OOOOOOH. sie sind z guet. ah stimmt und denn mega breakdown. mit soo coole bgvs. trotzdem de schwächst ufem album. obviously e single well dumm catchy aber de schwächst. ihren bossa quasi. rudy. super chords. isch rudy mega gsamplet worde de mega klavier teil? s album wird darker mit de ziit. if everyone was listening isch sehr dunkel irgendwie. crime of the century findi etz au nöd de best ufem album. d pianohook isch seeehr cool, aber naja. nöd so guet wie die andere sehr dramatisch. halt so fest en andere mood. immerno super. FÖFI
omg sit ewigkeite nümme glost bin READY in school passiert SO VILL JAAA hmm ah bloody well right hanimi nümme möge erinnere und hans au so naja gfunde hide in your shell isch denn wieder ener mi gusto DREAAAAAMER vergesse wie goofy das lied isch hahaha omg crime of the century BANGER UND S KLAVIER würkli riese song zum schluss muss sege s album isch teilwiis chli seicht worde für mich? aber ellei su nostalgie via
Supertramp is criminally underrated. Musicianship is top notch and unique style with the different keyboard parts
Honestly this was very good BUT nothing more really. Just a good standard 70s pop album sooo 3/5
Okayyyy I like it
Bangers
I already know I love this yo
Super surprised at how much I enjoyed this!
I can hear what they’re trying to achieve, but I’m sure there were better examples of this genre of music in the 70’s. “If everyone was listening” and “crime of the century” hold their own though
Nisam nikad cula nijednu pjesmu s ovog albuma, bio mi je dobar, al generalno nije nesto sto mi se bas istice i sto bi slusala mimo ovog svog “projektica”. Mozda treban dat drugu priliku nekim pismama, dobre su al nisu me na prvu osvojile.
As much as I wish Prog Rock hit harder for me, it seems that none of it is really able to quench my thirst I have for the genre, even with a staple like Supertramp's Crime of the Century. This album is very grand and bold as are many Prog Rock albums, but Crime of the Century feels different as it also have some very theatrical elements I feel aren't as prominent in the genre around this time as many would have you believe. Crime of the Century feels a bit cheesy if you ask me but has some really cool elements all over this project that definitely jived with my likings but as a general album I struggled to full connect to the music at hand. I believe Hide in Your Shell was by far my favorite track here and then again I felt like I could barely get by with liking it. I enjoy some of Supertramp's other work but I really don't get what didn't work here. Oh well life goes on a guess....
Some interesting soundscapes to be had here, with hints of Prog. Very British overall, but very distinctively Supertramp. Dreamer is probably the most famous song here, also the most memorable. Definitely somewhat interesting.
One of my all time favorite albums
Supertramp has been a favorite since my dad played them when I was younger, though it was always their greatest hits. Now, at this stage in life, diving into their actual albums gives me a whole new perspective. Supertramp has a great balanced blend of instrumentation, particularly making the saxophone, harmonica, and piano stand out. The dual vocals of Roger Hodgson and Rick Davies are another highlight that really elevates their sound. Technically, one thing I really give Supertramp credit for is their seamless way of switching the direction of their songs. They manage smooth transitions between different sections while keeping a cohesive core theme and unified whole, avoiding abrupt musical shifts or disjointed pieces. I love how they incorporate complex prog rock characteristics, yet keep it all within a pop rock sensibility, making it easy for just about anyone to enjoy.
I like Supertramp. Songs like "The Logical Song", "Give A Little Bit" and "Breakfast In America" are exemplary tracks that inspired a new generation. This album however, is just not for me. Listenable, but a bit dull. Sorry folks.
not my vibe, the album itself was pretty good
Just learned that Super Tramp had a dutch millionaire support them and that's cool.
I was happy to see this today. Been meaning to give it a full listen. I used to kind of scoff at Supertramp when I was a kid. Sometimes when me and my friends would drop acid I'd randomly ask "What's up with Supertramp?" to make them all laugh. But these days I think Breakfast In America is a masterpiece and this one is up there. Their songs are cinematic but not in an overblown way, the music just evokes images that illustrate the themes of the lyrics. I think "School" is good example of this. I've heard "Bloody Well Right" so many times that it's actually wrapped around from being "that song again" to a fresh listen.
Long songs(8 songs, 45 minutes), I didn’t really enjoy the execution of the lyrics. I think this album would have been just as good if it were solely instrumental. Bloody Well Right made me feel like Tom Cruise in Risky Business dancing in his underwear, so +1 for that. Overall, definitely not Supertramp’s best work, but I would listen again while walking down the street alone at 2:30 in the morning (asylum would eat). Sidenote: Background vocals genuinely scared me multiple times. 2.4 stars.
Good, but pretty uninspiring, that title track rocks. Will return but not soon.
Przykro mi, ale wolę inne płyty tego zespołu. Ta jest wyjątkowo nudna. Długie utwory, bez polotu i porządnego hooka. Nie wiem, chyba tak brzmi przeciętność. 5/10
Not what I remember Supertramp to sound like. I liked the sound of a few of the songs: Rudy was an interesting and kind of funk-y song, and Crime of the Century was pretty good too, I really liked the piano. School and If Everyone was Listening also weren't bad. Listening to Bloody Well Right was just weird, because their music sounds incredibly American and now I know that they're not. sooo weird. 3/5 stars.
Not for me
Classic progressive rock album, wonderful from start to finish.
i’m not super impressed by this album. not incredibly interesting, no songs that i feel compelled to listen to again really. maybe just not my thing. i want to find it interesting because of the prog vibes, but it’s just kind of a bland album to me.
Dreamer is my favorite Supertramp song. There’s a bunch of other good ones on here. Not every one was amazing but a solid album.
7.5/10 pretty good
Supertramp generally made so much diverse and different music. Awesome band.
I don’t quite understand why this album is so revered. It did nothing for me, sadly.
Never heard of album or band. Had started a review but didn’t save so quick recap: like school but the sound engineering is very off. Way to quiet at random points. I like bloody well a lot end to end. Hide in your shell is fine but not great. Asylum is awesome, good lyrics set to great orchestration. 100% have heard dreamer. Absolute classic. No notes. Rudy is very well written, guitar solo at 2 mins is great. Middle is kind of uneccesary, seems like a time filler. But then 430 on is great, love the build up but sounds like a completely different song. Not necvasarily a bad thing. I like the piano and flute a lot on “listening” beyond that just an average song. Title track is a great ender, feels like a culmination of the whole album. Some elements similar to the rest of the songs but Also feels like the last song. Pleasantly surprised as a whole, I think I need to give this another listen in the future. 3.2 stars.
Great album!
Yes, cool! Will have to revisit sometime.
Heard Breakfast in America before. This album is way better, not really "wow" but better than their more famous one 3/5
Enjoyable but not all that memorable.
This is the first album I got on here that i own on vinyl, I absolutely adore this album. A prog rock masterpiece, so so beautiful. There is not a track I would skip. Long epic instrumentals, incredible vocals, everything blends together so perfectly. I could listen to this album a hundred more times. Standout Songs: All of them
did not like it too much, did not finish listening.
How have I got this far in my life and not listened to much Supertramp. Absolutely blew me away. Great album with absolutely no skips.
This was my first listen to an album by this group, although I had heard the one song, not on this album, which was played constantly on the radio. I liked this album, but I would not have called this album. rock and roll, maybe alternative rock, but not really rock and roll. Still, it was an enjoyable listen, and I would listen to it again. Best song: "Hide In Your Shell" and I didn't really have a song that I didn't like, but my least favorite was, "Crime Of The Century".
Really liked the keys on this one. Definitely got groggy and rock opera-y but that's alright because kept it in the groove allot
This album is epic. I had no idea Supertramp could rock so hard. I love the the way the piano drives the tracks forward. I love the cinematic, orchestral moments and the brassy interludes. Vocals are all spot on. Chord changes are always interesting and intelligent. The tunes are almost a more accessible version of prog rock. The Kinks meet Yes. You know an album is good when the tracks are all on the long side and yet you dont ever feel like they are dragging on. 100% an album that is getting a second spin. Favourite track - hard to say, i loved them all for different reasons. Maybe School or Crime of the Century. 9/10
I get why people like this and the album is made really well but it’s just not for me
It was alright, not as good as some other stuff of theirs I've heard though.
I always think of Supertramp as the band I described to my mom when I couldn’t think of the name as, “you know that band that’s like ELO, but it’s not?” and she knew immediately what I meant. This is a fantastic prog album and deserves to be on the list, but if we’re operating under the assumption, as this list is, that Supertramp deserves only one album here, then how in the hell did this make it over Breakfast In America??? That is far and away the superior album, and the fact it isn’t on this list is a travesty! With all that being said, this is still a 5 star album. Great songs and some of the best prog rock you’ll hear. Not a weak moment.
The greatest!
I liked this a lot more than I thought I would
Album #988 Sort of theatrical, piano driven rock. No super big hits on this one. I've heard Bloody Well Right before. It sounds Pink Floyd-ish, and maybe Dreamer. Interesting, but still not really that engaging to me. Favorite track: Bloody Well Right
On the one hand, they're good at making music. On the other, the music they make kind of sucks. On a third, mysterious hand that came out of nowhere, a lot of later bands CLEARLY stole riffs and sounds from here (and made songs I like more). Unfortunately, the first band that came to mind was The Eagles, who are also talented musicians who make music that sucks. The second was Madness. And then... the Rocky Horror Picture Show. So you lose some, you win some, and on this album I think I'm losing a lot more than I'm winning. Talk about wearing out its welcome, I actually skipped Asylum once it hit minute 5. The long and short of it is that you should probably have heard this album but also probably not more than once if you were born in the '80s or later.
Great piano, great horns, great voices, great vibes.
Bloody well right!! 4
What a day, a year, a life this is
trampalicious
Not amazing but also interesting enough. I’m not sure it truly warrants its place as an essential listen but I did enjoy the last track.
This veered from some of the worst excesses of prog (eg. ‘Yes’) to what were actually some decent moments. I liked the start (is that a Morricone sample?) and ends of the album but it descended into prog wankery about halfway through which soured it a little for me.
This album represents the perfect combination of the most annoying aspects of prog rock and 70s pop
Sort of dreadful irritants, but equally hard to truly dislike. They're like if Roxy Music had a tiny ounce of charm. The highlight, for me, is Dreamer, which was on a mixtape we used to have in the car when I was a kid, called Goodies To Order, made by my uncle. It is a lifelong goal of mine to recreate that tape as a playlist, but I reckon I can only remember around 45% of the songs. Anyway, Dreamer was one I couldn't quite place until today, so thank you Project for that.
Listened before 03/05/2020 & 09/09/2023 Solid enough record
first track nice rest is not. 3.25
One of my all-time favorite albums! I bought other Supertramp albums after this one, but none of them rocked my world like this one did. Like it as much at 66 as I did at 17!
Now here is a band I’m not familiar with. I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. Really nice musicianship and melodies.
Supertramp has always puzzled me. While they make some really good songs, I’ve always had them pegged as a not-as-serious band. Their big hits, while thoroughly enjoyable, are a bit gimmicky. Sort of tongue-in-cheek. That being said, this is a decent album but I prefer their album Breakfast in America.
Enjoyable album. Nice listen. Nothing crazy or revolutionary for me but still a decent album nonetheless. Standouts for me were School and Dreamer. Overall decent album.
I actually liked this more than most 70s AOR. It’s melodic, clever, and mostly avoids the indulgent prog nonsense I usually dread. It does get a little dramatic here and there but it is a solid, art-rocky listen that feels like the older, moodier cousin of Breakfast in America.
Forgot about this band!
Of course it would come from early '70s. Pulled out Bloody Well Right from the start at the top song. Goes through three very interesting sound changes, and groove in the whole time. Dreamer reminded me of Styx.
Some great bops, but a bit inconsistent
Not a bad album, but Breakfast in America is much more consistent and has a wider range of styles. It should have made this list instead.
Wow. Better than I remembered!
Fantastic. One of my all time favorites.
i kinda want to give this album a 0 for making me mildly like soft rock. but it was decent! i didn't hate it or turn it off and for that it gets 3 stars.
I've always found Supertramp to be a bit goofy. They straddle a line somewhere between art pop and prog with mostly successful results. But are not shy about introducing weird instruments, carnival sounds, and otherwise goofy elements. The contents of this album are no different, though I will say I'm surprised to see this one instead of Breakfast in America, from which most of their regular radio hits were generated. All in all this album was just fine to my ear. I enjoyed Bloody Well Right and Dreamer as individual tracks. Asylum felt a little bit like something that could have made it onto Pink Floyd's The Wall (albeit "brighter" in tone). Not an album I plan to go back to... Soft 3 for me.
I thought Breakfast in America would have been the album to be on this list. Forgot that this album is the one with all of the bangers though. Dreamer and Bloody Well Right are great tunes. Thumbs up Supertramp
Always love a good prog rock album, especially a band that i have never really listened to other than a handful of songs. This scratched all of the itches that I was looking for in this album. Wasn't overly fantastic but still very good. Dreamers is the only song I knew going into this and it was probably the 4th or 5th best song after listening which is a good sign.
Surprised we got this over Breakfast in America but it still has jams. Might be able to hit a golf ball to where I saw Roger Hodgson play School, Hide in Your Shell, and Dreamer. Got pretty into Supertramp around then and for good reason. This band is just a pleasure. Not gonna blow anyone away but a sonically fun trip.
ugh... just awful twaddle
idk pretty average, some progy stuff and also some more glam rock stuff. Not too much else to say, some interesting and funny lyrics. I feel like it’s definitely of a time, but seven. Favourite songs: idk Overall around 5/10
Too cheesy for my tastes. The sort of thing that gave prog-rock a bad name.
Smooth record all throughout. It was a pleasure to listen to this one. Favourite Track(s): Bloody Well Right, Rudy Least Favourite Track(s): Asylum
Cheery thoughtful synthy
Not my thing, although I'll avoid the temptation to say it's a musical crime
Pleasant
Musical ketamine. And not in a good way.
Interesting! Pretty entertaining storytelling, and interesting music to go along with it. Listened while running.
Genre: Progressive Rock One of rock and roll's most underrated gem makers, Supertramp, absolutely kicks ass all over this thing. The opener, "School", the prog pop classic "Bloody Well Right", the prog rock title track and closer, ending the album on one of the highest notes that mid-70s prog had to order. Wonderful vocals, as well as some really tremendous piano playing, paired with an impressively tight backing band, Supertramp's sound is clean, polished, and undeniably awesome. This isn't my all time fav of theirs, but it's pretty damn good. Don't arrange to have me sent to no asylum... 4/5
Amazing sound of the seventies
taip sau
This was fantastic. Beautiful guitar sounds, drummer was superb. Really reminded of king crimson, a bit of yes, even some Zappa esq moments. Long musical interludes and some great lyrics
I just didn’t vibe with a lot of the sounds on here. Like there’s some good moments but for me it just didn’t connect. The dreamer part triggered some memory however can’t say I loved it.
Forgettable
One of Princess Diana’s favorite bands 💔
just some dudes trying to make prog rock i guess? Would I listen again: eh Deserves to be on this list: no 3.1
I think that I used to believe that 'Supertramp' weren't a real band but were a pisstake? I just thought with a name like that, they didn't seem real. This album was great, although my streaming provider made it difficult to listen to the album in full and in order. I did get all of the tracks and I enjoyed it all, just good fun 70s-style rock music.
I like some of Supertramp hit songs but I'd never listened to this album before. While listeting, I got Pink Floyd vibes, yacht or soft rock vibes and so on. I feel like I'm listeting to a bad blend of my favorite musics by Steely Dan or Pink Floyed or Led Zeppelin or some other 70s bands. They took all of this great music and put it in a blender and you get this very strange, inconsistent mix with unpredictable quality. I can't find it interesting and exciting because of this strange mix. If I want to listen yacht rock, I'll play yacht rock. If I want Pink Floyd, I'll play Pink Floyd. But not this. It has little of everything, but nothing special and outstanding. And songs are fucking too long. 2/5 —————————————— Liked: — Hide In Your Shell
Like a more animated Pink Floyd. I can picture the band in my mind's eye as I listen and I don't like what I see but I like what I hear (mostly). Proggy, psychy, poppy but not tedious.
This is fine.
Blech. How the hell did this end up on here? I mean, it's aptly named, so perhaps it was a lark by the 1001 author?
I don’t totally hate Supertramp and their prog pop sensibility. They have some singles that I like, but I’m not revisiting this album. Meh.
Okay, not great. Supertramp has one song I love: Goodbye Stranger. It's not on this album. I like a lot of individual passages and parts of songs, but most of the songs have flaws (e.g. the chorus of bloody well right) that undermine them.
3/5 - I guess I'd describe this as prog-lite, which I'm OK with. I like the keyboard sounds and general pop sensibilities of the songs. I'm not going to have a Supertramp ephiphany, but I'll take some "Bloody Well Right" now and again. This choice for the 1,001 betrays the heavy British bias of the list.
A struggle to get through. Like a mix of pink floyd, king crimson, and ass-suckage.
Remember in The Office when Andy writes that song from the perspective of the little girl? That’s what “School” reminded me of. This was a cool album. I’m not sure I’ve ever listened to Supertramp before. More rock bands should have full bands; the keyboard and horns add a lot I think.
Loved the instrument variety in this in. The sax section on bloody well right was great. Title song seemed like quite the grand composition
Closed with its best three minutes, title track was top. Not sure why this didn’t really work for me overall though. Liked it when it toned back but felt a little derivative of Queen when they ramped up intensity
Surprisingly proggy, but not to a degree that would scare off most casual listeners. Tightly packaged and very well performed. Very very 70s.
Supertramp har man ju hört talas om men när jag går in på spotify och kollar in låtarna så inser jag att jag nog inte har så stor koll som jag först trodde. Albumet överraskar mig dock och jag glider mig igenom det. Njöt så mycket av introt till Bloody well right att jag fick starta om låten ett par gånger för att bara sjunka in i groovet, älskar älskar älskar sån här orgel.
Jag gillade denna. Gott om variation. Gött sound och härligt old school sound. Inget jag kände igen på plattan men helt klart något jag kan sätta på igen. Supertramp ska in i min vinylsamling. En solid 4 från mig.
7/10… symphonic rock / *1974
Decent musicians but boring British rock rock to me
Fun weird prog rock. Breakfast in America is the better album from Supertramp but I appreciate the excuse to listen to one I haven't heard as much. Dreamer isn't their best work.
I want to rate this five for Hide In Your Shell alone, Supertramp’s best song and one of my favorite songs in general. already in collection
#6 British slang, identifiable intonation of the 60s and 70s, folksy, jaunty piano, sounded all over the place. Does this album know what it wants to be?
Good album, 1 or 2 very good songs
I like their hits the most, but I can leave the rest of the album.
I dont like that every track is made up of 17 tiny songlets. I have no idea what track Im listening to or how far in it I am. Also exceptionally 70s
In the mid 70’s these guys and their girlfriends moved into a house directly above my cousins’ vacation cabin. They would cut through the property to swim on the Yuba river. My cousins said they were super chill. Five for being nice to my family. One for the music.
PROOOOOG
I hadn't heard anything from this album before, but I was familiar with Supertramp's other work. There are a couple of songs that have that "waka-chicka" sound that we all associate with disco and the 70's. Good album all the way through, but not really notable. There's a reason this one didn't get a lot of radio play. My Rating: 3/5 jail cells
I already know that I adore this album.
Yesss
Legalzinha a vibe do início já, um Pink Floydzinho mais animado. Divertidinho mesmo, gostei da Dreamer. Bom álbum, gostosinho, é bem essa vibe mesmo, um Pink Floyd mais feliz, nada surpreendente, mas gostei. 3*
Cara, pareceu um primo do Pink Floyd. E teve uma música no meio, acho que Dreamer, que me passou um pouco de The Who também. Músicas com vibes bem diferenciadas, são boas mas não é tanto meu estilo. Eu acabei me distraindo diversas vezes enquanto tava ouvindo o álbum, não conseguiu prender muito minha atenção, mas é bom pra ouvir de fundo kkkkkk
While generally appreciated, could've done with more BLOODY WELL RIGHT and DREAMER styled songs to break apart from the Atlantic City background music. Style of music a Divorced Boomer listens to while drinking Chivas and soda.
Didn’t do much to grasp my attention
Fine but boring, wouldn’t revisit
Unremarkable but listenable
Very 70s but a good listen
The songs I knew about really stood out. But the rest of the album is still solid and fun. 3.5/5
My parents had this CD when I was growing up, so I've heard it before. It's been about 20 years since the last time I checked it out, so I thought I might appreciate it more. Nah, still the same weird avant-garde yacht rock I remembered. Not terrible, but I don't like it.
A light four, the start of the 5 year run that would culminate in Breakfast in America. I can't help but have a soft spot for Supertramp. A fun pop band that knew how to write hits.
I hadn’t ever listened to supertramp. But this was fun!
Again, heard the band but not familiar with the album… …nice alt sound after a few predictable albums. Nice atmosphere and phases. Can sound a touch empty. Missing a bit of depth and bass, but nice progressions. A kind of watered down Jethro Tull? And nothing quite as English as “you’re bloody well right” Alternative enough but still lacking something that wows or is particularly inspiring. Had high hopes, but kinda didn’t deliver or go anywhere, really. Feels like “nice idea, shame about the finish.” But still prefer it to predictable structure and lack of originality.
Maybe the first ever prog rock album that I've actually enjoyed. Breaking news, making it catchy and memorable rather than noodly nonsense makes it much better.
Haters in shambles, they stay pickin' the corn outta my shit Will I listen to again: 100%
Had a blast listening to this album, great prog rock. Favorite songs: Hide in Your Shell, Rudy and Crime of the Century 4/5 stars
Lindo!
Corny and fun, my favorite moments made me want to listen to Pink Floyd instead
This might be more impressive, but Breakfast in America has all the bops. I should get into prog maybe.
Proggy and poppy
Some solid tunes. Including moments that were silly and bombastic and full of 70s flair that elicited some eye rolls, but I’d still revisit it.
Was not what I expected from Supertramp. Very much enjoyed their more bombastic rock side compared to their more well known late seventies superstar side. 4/ 5
Pop-Prog-Rock? Egal. Ich weiß noch genau wie ich bei meinem besten Schulfreund zu Hause abhing und er sagte: DEN Song muss ich dir vorspielen. Er meinte School. Und dann dieser Schrei, das werde ich nie vergessen. Und das grandiose letzte Stück. Erinnert mich irgendwie an Der Exorzist bzw. den Anfang von Tubolar Bells. Daher (zuviele) Nostalgiepunkte.
c;assic. Excelent. Still relevant today!
The actual crime of the century is not having more Supertramp on this list.
One of my favorite English groups from the 70s. My younger brother got me into this album. Had never heard of Supertramp before. At least five of the eight songs are bangers. My favorites are Bloody Well Right and Dreamer
Supertramp's third album finds the band hitting their stride, delivering a confidently-executed rock record that contains exceptional songs which incorporate progressive elements while keeping the pop hooks ever-present. Rick Davies and Roger Hodgson's songs are sophisticated and smartly-constructed - even when there are long instrumental passages, they serve the songs well. Their lyrics are vivid, relatable and pack an emotional punch. In addition, the crisp production on this record is a perfect match for the songs and sounds fresh even today.
Nothing really stands out as amazing on this album, but all in all it's a pleasant listening experience, good music, good vocals, great production. I enjoyed it.
Awesome prog rock. Loved it when it came out, still enjoy it in this day.
I was 16 when this album came out and the annoying Bloody Well Right played incessantly on the radio. I’m not a big fan of most progressive rock, but this album did make it more accessible. I mostly appreciate this album for the hooky song Hide in Your Shell if I ignore the incredibly pessimistic and negative lyrics which were not representative of anybody I knew at that time.
En esto vas y a punto de tirar la toalla dices, venga, un último intento, y lo das todo. Es esas estaban Supertramp cuando acabaron editando este álbum. Lo siguiente ya esas historia del rock. Este es uno de esos discos perfectos de principio a fin. Una apertura mítica con armónica (cosa nunca vista antes) con “School” y un cierre épico con “Crime Of The Century”. Y por el medio, enormes joyas. Es que este disco es una puta barbaridad.
School, Bloody well right, Dreamer und Crime of the century extrem gut. Schlechte Lieder nicht vorhanden. Prog Elemente, aber dennoch eingängig. Album ist ja ein Klassiker.
very long songs but the drama level (usually) keeps it interesting "i'm just as sane as anyone" highlights: school dreamer hide in your shell if everyone was listening (clarinet bit)
I kinda admire Supertramp for being really hard to pin down. Like, what genre are they? Power pop? Soft boy glam? Post-Beatles? This album did not have many standout tracks, but it's so uniquely characterful I'm giving it a three. Something tells me that three stars might be Supertramp's glass ceiling - perhaps we'll find out in the next two and half years.
Mid 2
Starts off fun, peaks at track 2 and then just becomes quite annoying.
that was a fun musical journey - these guys were the sh. when we were kids, it was nice to be reminded
Love their sound. The vocals, the arrangements, electric piano, guitar. It’s all working for me.
It's fine. Very theatrical. This genre doesn't resonate with me.
I was originally going to compare this to a 70s musical meatloaf (lower case "m"). It's got elements of Pink Floyd, Genesis, Zeppelin, Bowie, even Bread - not so much as influence but straight up sections in a song before switching modes. It's certainly sound nice. But in the end it'snot very satisfying. So less meatloaf - which consists of throwing a bunch of stuff in a bowl of grond beef and baking it. In the end it make be overcooked but you know you've eaten something. This i was just left feeling like I wasn't sure what I was supposed to feel. Songs start to go somewhere and then don't. Some songs even sound nice - in the moment. So it's more KFC Famous Bowl then meatloaf.
Decent album, not my favorite Supertramp.
It was fine, pretty standard 70s rock. Nothing that really stood out to me, nothing I’ve ever really revisit.
Love Supertramp
I’d only heard about half of these songs before. I’ve missed out! This is great all the way through and may become one of my favorite prog rock albums.
Bland. Uninteresting music. Not for me.
A really good album. It’s not breakfast in America which is my favorite by them. It has some great songs on it and feels very supertramp. This album came out when I was 7 years old. I’d never heard the whole album, just some highlights. They were a great piano driven rock group.
Was excited but ultimately a tad let down. I love breakfast in America but this just felt very dated to me. I love the dude w the high voice and he like barely sang where was he
This was absolutely tootly lit. But the mix was kinda awful… not sure how to feel about that. But the songs are awesome I think this is the first supertramp album I’ve listened through all the way and it rocked big time.
Album No. 0057 on my list. I’ve never listened to any of the tracks on this album before, possibly because it doesn’t contain any of Supertramp’s big hits. I was surprised how much of a prog-rock album this is. The tracks are mostly quite long, the sounds very much like the decade this was released in, and the lyrics are more complex than I expected. That being said, none of the tracks got in my head too much. “Bloody Well Right” and “Dreamer” were my favorites. 3/5 stars.
At times this record has been derided as lightweight Floyd, or in some other way derivative. I would only say, just listen to it.
Very much a 70s album, proggy and poppy in equal measures. I would have though Breakfast in America would have been a better Supertramp album for the 1001. I'd give this two stars, but the keyboards on this are next level (esp Bloody Well Right) so raising it.
Reminds me of queen - had it on in the background. Morning bops
A well-crafted and thoughtful album that blends art rock with pop sensibility, 𝘊𝘳𝘪𝘮𝘦 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘊𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘶𝘳𝘺 showcases Supertramp’s knack for melody and studio precision. The production is spotless, the arrangements clever, and songs like 𝘚𝘤𝘩𝘰𝘰𝘭, 𝘉𝘭𝘰𝘰𝘥𝘺 𝘞𝘦𝘭𝘭 𝘙𝘪𝘨𝘩𝘵, and 𝘋𝘳𝘦𝘢𝘮𝘦𝘳 still stand out. Yet, despite its polish, the record sometimes feels emotionally distant and overly calculated. Technically impressive, but not always moving — a fine album, just not the masterpiece many claim it to be.
Pretty fun, solid, and enjoyable. Was already familiar with "bloody well right" and "dreamer", but the rest was new to me. Not otherworldly but decent.
How is School the most played song on this album? I’ve never heard it before, and I thought I knew Supertramp pretty decently. Bloody Well Right and Dreamer are absolute bangers which bring me back to my teenage years listening to them on breakfast radio, but the rest is filler.
Bloody alright I like to imagine an adult Gene Belcher rocking out on the keyboard for most of these songs.
Great album
Trying too hard to be epic.
Bloody well right and Dreamers are bangers. The rest is very forgettable innit it
Always thought the were a pop band. An intelligent pop band, but pop. I now understand they are actually progressive. Well I never.
Really enjoyed the energy, grooves and instrumentals on this album - the build & crescendos to some of the songs are very impactful, creating some mega high points. Dreamer & Rudy are absolutely faves from the album, both of which epitomise elements of why I love 70s rock / pop. There are some sections that don't leave as much of an impression though.
Really took me by surprise. I’ve heard of Supertramp but never listened to an album, and this was a great one to start with. In some ways, it’s about as quintessential 70’s psych / prog rock as it gets — almost to the point of satire at times. Alongside that, the vocals left me wanting a touch more when it’s just the male lead… HOWEVER, it was a fun listen and enjoyable through the end. I loved how it started off and ended with the harmonica as well to give a sense of cohesion.
Great grooves, intricate and studied songcraft, good and varied instrumentation. Overall really good cohesive album!
Great seventies rock.there are a few classics on this album (Bloody Well Right and Dreamer), but the rest is pretty solid with little filler.
My dad was a big fan back in the day but I don't see the appeal.
I was tapping my foot - some good songs for my having music on playlist
Very dynamic remaster. I love the production quality as it sounds and feels like microphones in a room capturing real humans on real instruments.
really enjoyed instrumentals all the way through school, hide in your shell, dreamer, rudy and crime of the century were my favourites
Suoertramp are the forgotten huge band of the 1970s. Banger after banger in singles. Roger Hodgson has a stupendous voice and Rick Davies was a stupendous musician. Davies death this year reminded me just how much I enjoyed supertramp. I prefer breakfast in America but this is a worthy addition. The title track and closing number is great. And the singles were spectacular. 3.5
I just had a strange thought: that's the first time I've listened to this album and not been stoned. Maybe I needed to go back to old 70's habits and light up a Camberwell Carrot to properly appreciate this again. I have a nod of acknowledgement to Rick Davies, but I loathe Roger Hodgson's stuff, and to be honest back in the day 13 year old me did too. I cut my hair in 1978 and went looking for straight legged pants. I then frisbeed my Supertramp records into the Hills Hoist and never looked back.
Supertramp is a shiny amalgam of Floyd, Steely Dan, ELO and bunch of other slightly pretentious middle-of-the-road 70s bands blended into a bland slurry and garnished with saxophone. 1.5 stars, rounding down because I am so fucking bored.
A couple bangers rest too instrumental
Fabulous album.
Cool prog rock album, much different than the Breakfast album that I knew. They have a handful of great tunes and a couple meh ones.
I am surprised by how much I am enjoying this. For now I am giving it a solid 4 stars, but will reconsider whether to award 5 after listening to the whole album start to finish with no interruptions or distractions. Thought it would be another Pink Floyd wannabe but I actually think they are less precocious and more listenable than PF - the album is a succinct and crisp delight. No skips whatsoever.
3.7/5 first time lsiten alright stuff not as good as there next album
There's some okay stuff on side one here... maybe "Bloody Well Right," and I like when the piano hits midway through "School."
The highs of this album are amazing. I mean the intro to Bloody Well Right? Come on, that's brilliant. But the lows leave something wanting.
What a delightful album! All the layers on this record add a very impressive atmosphere, so interesting and deep. It is mostly like a cinematographic experience. This album is so immersive, perfectly developed, with so much care and subtlety. I've loved listening to it, it is such an extraordinary, immersive, fragile, deep and pleasurable experience. I have no words for how great this album is. I mean, it is fantastic, a ten out of ten, there is nothing bad here, everything feels so cohesive and magnificent. I love this album. It is one of the best albums I have ever listened to. And it is such a pleasure to have discovered it today.
Wasn’t terrible but don’t think I’d listen to it again
Musically and lyrically powerful. Has the melancholy and energy of Pink Floyd, but in a more orchestral arrangement.
I didn't know that Supertramp has two main songwriters/lead singers. The guy who sings on all of their big hits has a VERY strange voice to me, just below Geddy Lee in terms of ridiculousness. Which is why I've tended to avoid Supertramp. The other lead singer, Davies, has a totally normal rock voice and is fine. Hodgson's distinctive voice is what sets this band apart from most; I just don't like it. It's interesting - this is part yacht rock, part prog.... so is Supertramp just a poor man's Steely Dan? "Hide in your Shell" is an ambitious track that survives not being terribly interesting, as do "Asylum" and "Dreamer." You have to appreciate the fact that the band takes a musical idea and tries to get as much mileage out of it as they can, throwing as many ideas at it as make sense. I like that. THREE STARS
Masterpiece
Very 70s which is not at all a bad thing