Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness by The Smashing Pumpkins

Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness

The Smashing Pumpkins

3.68
Rating
30822
Votes
1
3%
2
10%
3
27%
4
35%
5
25%
Distribution

Reviews (page 2 of 16)

Good tunes

Recognized a few songs. Not my type of album though.

Meh, don’t like the lead’s voice

I actually thought this was way better than Siamese Dream but the fact that it's 2 fucking hours long kinda ruins it a bit.

Far too long.

too long

This guitar tone has my face doing weird things. Side one is almost perfect. Great mixture of beautiful tracks and absolute rockers, every song is so unique but works really well together. Really liked 'Take Me Down' on this listen. SP works well with and without Billy Corgan. 'Here is No Why' reaches one of the most orgasmic crescendos in music imo. The rest of the song is also pretty good, but man does that last chorus hit like a truck. The world is a vampire... that will haunt me for the rest of my days (pocket bar quiz). Tonight, Tonight is another incredible song. I could rave for hours about this. Second half is definitely weaker, but still some interesting stuff on here. 1979 might be the greatest B-side (?) of all time. By Starlight is also pretty good. Think first half is a 10/10, but second half is like 7/10. will give it 9/10 as compromise. It would feel wrong not to rate it a 5, despite all the filler that I'm not too keen on. The rest of the songs are that good Edit: don't think I can give it a 9/10 based on side B. 8.5/10 it is.

It was actually quite a lot of fun to listen to this one. Smashing pumpkins is such a fun band to listen to. I am dreadfully poor at describing the technical components of a rock album. Still +1 for the star, +2 for the album art, +1 for the music. 4 Stars.

Hmm, I think I would have told you I liked this album before listening to it again today. I’m more conflicted now. It’s sooo long, with lots of not great stuff. Saved by a few great highlights.

I liked this more than I thought. I never really considered Smashing Pumpkins for me, something was lacking. But a bit of focused listening has revealed something interesting. It's made me curious but maybe not enough. I can see why it's there and simultaneously maybe it's not quite up my alley.

A two hour album is way too long. This isn’t up to the quality of Siamese Dream for me but would have come closer but for the never ending nature of it. A slightly more sophisticated sound but I just couldn’t get away from the time it took to finish it.

Perhaps one of the most personal impactful albums that I have been given the ability to listen to. A beautiful mix, especially the Deluxe version. Such frustrations and teen angst within the album, making my younger self fall into loving it deeply. I wish I could go back in time to listen to it for the first time. But I can only close my eyes and dissect the lyrics more than I have every time it plays. First set is an incredible set of tracks, nostalgic and classic. Second half isn’t as put out there apart from 1979, but the assortment and closer still stand out beautifully.

Richtig tolle Balladen, sehr vibey und comfy. Tolle Melodien. Peppered with higher energy songs. Hat mir sehr gut gefallen :)

This is a very special album. I new a few of the songs going in and I expected to like this, but I came out loving it. It captures a moment in time and a feeling that very few albums can do. It feels like being a teenager in the 90s and for me, encapsulates the decade in a very unique way. It's very hard for an album this long to justify it's length, but for me this did. It kept surprising me and changing sounds at just the right moment. Just so beautifully written, produced, and so exciting to listen to. Is it cheesy to think 1979 is one of the best songs of all time? Top Songs: Tonight Tonight, Bullet With Butterfly Wings, Love, Galapagos, Take Me Down, Thirty-Three, 1979, Lily (My One and Only)

Meanders like a pompous, never-ending dream.

Første plata var bråkete, de to siste var bedre. Med den spisse nasale stemmen blir det mye med spiss nasal gitar og. Andre plata var best. Mer av de gode sangene jeg har hørt før, fortsatt litt blanda men mindre skriking. Beste sang: through the eyes of ruby In the arms of sleep 1979 Through the eyes of ruby var sykt nice Stumbleine Lily

Eg elske The Smashing Pumpkins<3 Og takle de ikkje. Någe e absolutt nydelig, andre ting e hodeverk. Bullets with butterflywings, Porcelina of the vast oceans og 1979 e nydelige. Beste sang: 1979

I had my Spotify on shuffle when I hit play on this one. I was a few songs in before I noticed so, I let it roll but, as I was scrolling through song titles I accidentally hit Tonight, Tonight and it started playing and I clicked off shuffle. Now I can’t tell if which songs I’ve already heard. This album is not that bad, in fact I like it more than I thought I would. Of course, I know the hits, a few others and I’ve heard most of it in passing but, I’ve never listened to it start to finish. I have a complicated relationship with Smashing Pumpkins. I really like Gish, my roommate had it, my girlfriend had Siamese Dream and I went to see them on April Fools day, 1994 with both of those people. There were 3 opening bands and I didn’t like any of them. I was bored, and by the time the Pumpkins went on, I was in a bad mood. That experience informed my attitude from that point forward. So, how does Billy respond? With a double album (triple on vinyl). I’m out. I would just barely tolerate this transgression! Ok. I didn’t turn off 1979 if it came on the local alternative rock radio station, but a double CD? No way, Jose. “Despite all my rage I’m still a rat in a cage!” Yawn… I get that artists can be complicated and annoying at times, and if it someone I really like, I’ll forgive a lot, but Billy… just rubbed me the wrong way. I’m older now and so is Billy. I’ve softened my perspective. I’m not as cantankerous and judgmental as I was (maybe a little) and so is Billy… I guess. It seems so. I enjoyed this. I’m never going to listen to it again from start to finish, but I actually enjoyed it. There were a lot of surprisingly great songs that I either never heard or, don’t remember. Billy’s whiny voice and manufactured fury doesn’t bother me as much. I’ve forgiven him for having three opening bands that I don’t care about on that warm spring night. I miss the people I knew back then… but don’t we all? 4.6

Stone-cold motherfucking masterpiece, never mind that Corgan is a difficult character.

great and iconic album i think tomorrow tomorrow is such an incredible song. unfortunately i found it didnt have the kick to it as much as when i was younger

I have tried so many times with The Smashing Pumpkins. I think I just can't do Billy Corgan's voice. I like the hits. Tonight, Tonight, Bullet with Butterfly Wings, 1979 are all great here. 28 songs is WAY too long for me. I think I generally liked it more than Siamese Dream, but Siamese Dream scores more points for being over faster...

A one-of-a-kind mixture of heavy, gritty rock songs and softer, dreamy tunes, blending into an album with a very unique feel Altogether it sounds, looks, and feels like a universe born from the sporadic imagination of a mind that thinks ten thoughts before I can think one... and that's a pretty cool kind of album

I’m sure it’s great if you’re really into it but I’m not and I don’t like his voice And why is it so long

I love smashing pumpkins and this could have been 2 amazing albums but for some reason they did a double album ! Too long, needed trimming. Shame as would have been a lot better as 2 albums

The hits off this album are outstanding and the rest is mostly self indulgent nonsense I don’t want to spend 2 hours listening to. I thought about two stars just for that but I’ll give it a 3 because the good ones really are that good.

I’ve never been a huge fan of Smashing Pumpkins but I do like their music. 2 hours on a single album might be a bit much, but it is good music nonetheless. A number of very recognizable songs and a talented group of musicians. Worth a listen and I would do it again.

This is a magnum opus for Billy Corgan and the Pumpkins. Too bad they didn’t have the decency to end it all after recording it. They haven’t put out a good album since and Corgan’s bloated, self-aggrandizing douche-baggery is a huge reason why. This album has a lot of great songs but they are held down by all the ‘experimental’ shit around them that all sounds the same. The hits are strong and carry the ranking here.

Epic album. Smashing pumpkins in peak form hitting on all cylinders. Dynamic track list ranging from hard rock to tender ballets tied together beautifuly by the Smashing Pumkins unique sound and orchestrations. The hits on here are 90s classics, most of the deeper tracks are just as incredible. Huge fan of this album, an absolute treat to sit down and listen to all two hours of it.

L.I.S. = let Iha sing!

album is good but GOD it is long

sry i don't like this band -_-

Généreux album. Oui oui, sa longueur est sûrement un défaut, mais on peut quand même apprécier les bons moments et admirer le côté prolifique.

J'ai toujours trouvé ça épuisant écouter cet album. Tout le monde le dit, c'est trop long. En mesure standard de vinyle, c'est un album triple. J'aurais quand même de la misère à éliminer assez de tounes pour que ça fit sur deux; j'aime presque tout. 4.49 étoiles

I’m ready to get a lot of hate for this. Did not care for the album at all. Every song felt and sounded the same why was this 2 hours. I really wanted to like it so bad but I really did not at all. Might’ve just not been in the mood but this might be the album I feel most differently about than the rest of yous

I love it. There’s so much emotion in this album - Billy corgan’s voice is timeless. I forgot how chilling “Tonight Tonight” is. The volume of high quality music on this album is insane, but due to the 2hour timestamp, that also means it has its low moments. The whole album is great at capturing anger, confusion, love, and everything in between. I would listen to this album front to back a lot in the summer, and I always felt like it accurately painted what was going on in my head throughout life. Idk, just hits.

Too long and sounds flat and compressed. But other than that love

A masterpiece of alternative rock that pushes every edge of the genre. There is never a dull moment here, just hit after hit. I love how it switches from heavy emotional stress to dreamy ballads and back like it’s nothing. At times it feels like this album loses itself in its own grandiosity

They tried out a lot of stuff and lots of it was beautiful.

Their big classic songs are on here. Great stuff but the whole album isn’t great outside those.

just one of those albums that speak to me somehow. i can see how this could be a grating, bloated, arrogant mess for some people, but somehow none of that ended up being a problem for me just two straight hours of great riffs, mental solos, and softer songs that have no right to have the emotional weight they do considering they're being sung by billy fucking corgan lmao. i can definitely say i didn't expect to get through a 28-song triple album without getting bored, but it was honestly fantastic from front to back favourite songs: 1979, bodies, to forgive least favourite songs: none

I like it

Such a good album. Really defined their sound

Amazing album. But good lord is it long. At least it's all great music, beginning to end

This should have split up into two days.

For an album this long, I found myself engaged throughout the entire thing. This is an enjoyable listen if you're in the right frame of mind to listen, but I will say that it does require a certain frame of mind to fully appreciate. Lyrically, the Pumpkins tended heavily towards the melodramatic, and things got quite cheesy at times with the woe-is-me teenage angst. While a few songs are duds, there's actually a decent amount of good ones! I partially question the necessity of a two hour album (and this is the short version; the deluxe is nearly six!), but even still, the album flows incredibly well thanks to the ordering and pacing of the songs. There are still some tracks that should have stayed on the cutting room floor, but for an album that should come off as bloated, I didn't hear as much filler as I was expecting from a 2-hour double album. I appreciate the sheer amount of styles and genres that they touch, and how fresh the Pumpkins managed to keep things. I enjoyed the more tender ballads and soft rock than the pure metal tracks, even if I had a lot of fun with songs like Bullet with Butterfly Wings (even if the lyric "despite all my rage I am still just a rat in a cage" is eye roll inducing). 1979 is probably their most well-known track, and soaked in nostalgia for me personally, but it's a standout for a reason. I really enjoyed Galapogos and Stumbleine as well. Corgan’s voice is definitely an acquired taste. He's like an even tone deaf-er Mick Jagger. It unfortunately cuts into my enjoyment of the album somewhat, but not as much as I initially expected it to! It's only really bad on a couple of songs. I expected myself to be harsher on this album than I ended up being, but I couldn't help but enjoy it despite the length. 7.5/10 Favorites: - Tonight, Tonight - Jellybelly - Bullet With Butterfly Wings - Galapogos - Muzzle - Porcelina - Bodies - In The Arms of Sleep - 1979 - Stumbleine - XYU - Lily

This album was so long it took me a week to give it a proper listen and review. As long as it was I enjoyed this album from front to back. Billy Corgans voice at times sounds like nails on a chalkboard but it does the job similar to Mick Jagger. This album loves to switch up between soft touching ballads and heavy metal tracks. I was a fan of this pacing because some of the metal tracks are tough listens but you are immediately rewarded for toughing it out with soft healing songs like Bullet With Butterfly Wings, Galapagos or Thru The Eyes Of A Ruby. My favorite of the heavy metal tracks was Love only because the gritty, reverberating bass line reminds me of Elephant by Tame Impala. Shoutout to James Iha for writing the two lovely and perfect outro tracks to each disc. This was definitely an album I definitely needed to hear before I died and was deserving of inclusion on this list. Favorites Disc 1: - Zero - Bullet With Butterfly Wings - Galapogos - Porcelina Of Vast Oceans - Take Me Down Disc 2: - In The Arms Of Sleep - 1979 - Thru The Eyes Of Ruby - Lily (My One And Only) - By Starlight - Farewell And Goodnight

Wow. Just had this last week. Can’t say I am sad. Certainly not infinitely sad. But this IS a f*ing long album. See how I feel about that today. Yeah. I actually really love this album. I would definitely love it more if it were two albums. It’s just too long, dang it! 4 Boolean: True

I bought this album as a teenager after seeing the video for Tonight, Tonight. I loved many of the songs, and it works great as a double album. Already had Tonight, Tonight, Bullet with Butterfly Wings, Tales of a Scorched Earth, and We Only Come Out at Night on my liked list. Added Zero this time.

Are there just some bands that you can’t stand for no real reason? This is one for me. The Smashing Pumpkins get right on my tits. Blerg.

Right up there with "Use Your Illusion," the White Album, and "Sandinista!" in the all-time "this would be absolutely incredible if it was just one LP instead of a double/triple" rankings. Stevie Wonder scoffs at their paltry efforts.

A two hour album - on a Monday?! It’s a lot of album to handle, but it’s pretty decent. Favourite track: Tonight, Tonight

Excellent mix of heavy and soft, such a shame that Billy Corgan's voice is so poorly suited to the softer tracks because they're the highlights of the album for me

Familiar with the singles. First time listening to them as an album. Really well orchestrated. Talented musicians at work here.

Some good, some bad. Not too shabby

Some really good songs - overall kind of long though

The Pumpkins' third record is a massive double album clocking in at around two hours, featuring a blend of both louder, angst-filled, raucous rock and quieter, atmospheric moments. The quality of the songs ranges from mediocre to good (except for Tales of a Scorched Earth - I hate that song), and the musicianship is stellar. While the music is otherwise pretty good, Corgan's nasal vocal style takes some getting used to after a long break. I would enjoy this album more if someone else were singing. The lyrics are at times quite cryptic (or just random whiny nonsense, depending on how you look at it), though not as abstract as in Corgan's later work.

I enjoy it, its my type to music so that helped

Such a dynamic range of sounds and styles on display here, and certainly one of the longest albums I've listened to, but it didn't all blend together nearly as much as I expected. Overall there's a lot to love and I will definitely be listening to more pumpkins going forward.

Inside of the 2 hours of this album lives a great album. I wish someone had found it for them.

Really nice

I do not like long albums. I’m not a fan of the Smashing Pumpkins either, so this was a drag. These should be split in my opinion.

Day995 - one of the few albums that i looked forward to the release. it’s still great and it’s time to put the pumpkins in the rock and roll hall of fame

Hard pass

How is it so consistently good yet varied? I don’t think there can be any 2h+ album better than this

sounded like a compilation album with how varied it is. Very cool

Billy Corgan might just be my least favourite '90s vocalist, which is a shame, because he's obviously a top-tier songwriter. It's almost impressive how much he sucks the life out of the often brilliant music the moment he opens his mouth. Put anyone else on these tracks and I could easily imagine enjoying them, even loving them. I still really enjoy a decent amount, regardless. I usually don't mind when a singer has a more bratty vocal delivery, but Corgan somehow sounds both obnoxious and timid at the same time, without any charisma to back it up, and he's way too prominent in the mix to ignore. Anyhow, well-written tracks, but I just can't get over that particular factor. This is my second listen of the album and my opinion didn't change over the years. Hopefully, I will enjoy Siamese Dream more. Favourite track: 1979

My opinion can't be objective because I really really like them

I am so surprised by Smashing Pumpkin's versatility. It's impressive to hear them go from rock to heavier metal to soft ballads. I enjoyed this one a lot. Unfortunately, I am not one to separate the art from the artist and I am not sure I like their presentation of apolitical-ness.

all nostalgia

Ist natürlich wieder schwierig, an ein Album, welches man schon dutzende Male gehört hat, dieselben Maßstäbe anzulegen wie an irgendwelche first listens. Zur Wahrheit gehört, dass ich bis heute kein Doppelalbum (außer Live-Alben) kenne, das wirklich seine gesamte Laufzeit rechtfertigt. Irgendwo schleichen sich immer Längen oder Skip-Kandidaten ein. So ist es auch bei diesem Album. Während die erste Hälfte hier nahe an der Perfektion agiert ("Cupid De Locke" ist nur ein okayes Interlude und "Take Me Down" als Outro rauscht auch so vorbei), hat die zweite Hälfte gerade gegen Ende mit "Beautiful" und "Lily" schon einige Schnarcher zu verzeichnen. Generell finde ich hier das Pacing mit einigen Balladen oder Midtempo-Songs hintereinander sehr merkwürdig, die den Flow der Platte unnötig ausbremsen, zumal hier auch am deutlichsten wird, dass Billy Corgan wirklich nicht der allerbeste Sänger ist. Zu guter Letzt gefällt mir auch die Produktion dieser Platte nicht. Während "Siamese Dream" einen recht klaren Sound hat, klingt hier einiges etwas muddy, was im Kontrast zur krassen musikalischen Ambition steht, die hier an den Tag gelegt wird. Das ist für mich auch die größte Stärke dieser Platte: Hier werden so viele verschiedene Genres zu einem kohärenten Ganzen vermischt, während der Songwriting durchgehend ein sehr hohes Niveau hält. Hier sind einige Songs für die Ewigkeit vorhanden. Trotzdem werden hier keine Kompromisse gemacht und mit der gewachsenen Ambition die Ecken und Kanten im Sound abgeschliffen. Teilweise klingt es sogar mal ganz schön rough. Alleine für diese Entscheidung muss man wirklich den Hut ziehen. Auch wenn die erste Hälfte weiterhin mein Favorit bleiben wird, sind auf der zweiten Seite mit "Bodies", "Thru the Eyes of Ruby" und "X.Y.U." (den ich irgendwie immer mit "Zero" verwechsle) auch einige bockstarke Songs vorhanden, die sich nicht verstecken müssen. Also kann ich mich irgendwie doch noch zu einer knappen 5 durchringen, auch wenn am Ende wahrscheinlich 20 Songs gereicht hätten.

An sich ziemlich gut, aber auf diese Länge verliert es mich dann doch teilweise.

Wegen solchen Alben mache ich das hier. Witzigerweise habe ich vorgestern erst eine Anzeige zur Remastered Vinyl reingespüot bekommen :D Für mich ein sehr schön abwechslungsreiches Album. Die Gesamtlänge hätte am Ende ruhig 30 min weniger sein können, aber es war nicht zu kurzweilig.

Ich liebe dieses Album wirklich ganz ganz doll, jeder Song hier drauf ist mindestens gut, wenn nicht sogar ein Meisterwerk. Aber auch ich muss zugeben, dass dieses Album vermutlich mit 30 Minuten weniger Material besser flowen würde.

Not my jam. Two stars.

Some great songs, but just too long.

Before listening to this album, my mindset was "The Smashing Pumpkins is a prerty overrated band" After listening to this album tho, I still believe that they are. But at least I know which is overrated in their music. If they strip away the symphonic, dream, chamber, and some parts of their grunge sounds. They'd be a pretty good alternative rock band. That's not the case here so this album was only decent in my opinion. 3.5/5

People complain about Corgan's voice as if rock singers were always trained singers with actual technique. This could have been a great album but to make it double was just relasing some of the greatest songs 90's rock gave with many fillers.

There are some enjoyable songs on this album. The only problem is, I was bored after 15 songs (1 hour through) only to find I was at the half way mark

This may be my favorite Pumpkins. I actually LOVE this… album. But that’s the thing. It’s not. AN Album. Like Prince’s Sign O’ the Times and Stevie’s Songs in the Key. And like those other two, I fully believe it would be better as TWO AWESOME albums. Edited, organized, and put together thoughtfully for a SINGLE listening experience. If it were two albums I would probably give them both 5s. But this 2 hour madness is bloated. I get fatigued. Even if a large percentage of the songs stand out and can standalone. 4 Boolean: True

One of the best 90s album of all time. Has a little bit of everything. Great songwriting

Heard it many times before. It holds up pretty well, though some of the quieter and quirkier songs seem a bit dated.

Hits aside, the album flows sonically and spans different genres while creating memorable moments. I appreciated the dreamier cuts as well as the heavier riffs. 8.9/10

Double albums are always too indulgent. Highs/singles are great 6.5/10

Eu conheço essa banda já há alguns anos, já tinha ouvido algumas músicas e nunca achei grande coisa. Eu dei play no álbum pensando que seria uma tortura, 2 horas de uma banda que não gosto? Torturante. Mas foi surpreendentemente muito bom, provavelmente vou ouvir mais coisas do Smashing Pumpkins. Deveria ter dado uma chance antes.

This is a long album...but there are so many good songs on here. Add to that a hefty dollop of nostalgia and this is a 5 star record for me easy.

I recognize the impact, but this album sprawls too much and makes me sick of listening to them.

I don't mind the length, it's great front to back. But if they had split discs 1 & 2 apart to seperate the grunge tracks from the more melodic tracks it'd be perfect.

I am told Billy Corgan is a big fan of this album

I owned this cassette and album. Bullet with butterfly wings forever altered my musical tastes. I appreciate this album now after listening with my old ears. Still not a huge fan of the ballads

Infinite? Sadness? Better say infinite maniac

Great guitars and some really nice quieter parts. It's a loooong album though.

a solid album despite Billy Corgan's best attempts to ruin it, both prior to and post release

Реально крутий альбом, не то чтобы гранд, особенно первая часть альбома. И первая часть для меня альбом на 8/10 и вытянула

Liked the first one. Didnt really vibe with the rest.

Have I listened to this album before No How familiar am I with this album I know a few songs How do I feel about this artist? I kinda like this Smashing Pumpkins but I only know the hits Pre-Listen Thoughts: This is one of those albums that some people absolutely love and others hate. I’ll probably be in the middle somewhere. Favorite track(s): 1979, Tonight Tonight, Stumbleine Post-Listen Thoughts: Parts of this were too intense for me, others were very pretty. I appreciate that it had so much variation because it’s a double album, it definitely wasn’t boring even if I didn’t love every song.

Whew ... That was about an hour and a half too long! I guess if they didn't have all of these songs, we couldn't have found the good ones. But still, too much.

why did bro say "balegdeh" i caaaannttt!! Ok why we doing metal now Hi. this guys voice is insufferable. To Forgive is actually really good, me likey!

Classic and perfect

The thing about The Smashing Pumpkins is that if you don't love Billy Corgan's singing voice, you're going to have a rough time. There's some good songs here, and I ended up enjoying more of the non-singles than the singles (maybe because I'm burned out on them), but I still can't really fall for Billy's singing style.

An absolute monster of a record that I love so much, even though it can be a bit of a chore to get through all at once. So many fantastic songs though. I find that they are best experienced shuffled within a playlist rather than for two straight hours, but that doesn't at all take away from the quality of what the band created here. It's ridiculously ambitious, it ranges from heavy to heavenly, and has held up tremendously over the last thirty years.

It's 3.5

Some great songs on this album, definitely their best work

uhh yeah we’re back with a banger. Absolutely floored that 1979 wasn’t my favorite of the album Highlights: Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness Tonight, Tonight Bullet with Butterfly Wings To Forgive Cupid De Locke Thirty Three (favorite) 1979

oh i liked it! a little thrown off by the voice at first but then i got over myself and found it complemented the music very well. and the music! the music is my favorite part. that intro track is just gorgeous, and getting to hear the instrumentals peak through the whole album was pretty cool. and i really liked how much diversity in the songs there were, not everything sounded the same FIVE plus probs my favorite album art

I wanted to like this album a lot more than I did… it was really long which would have been fine if a lot of it didn’t feel that same? The stuff that was good was really good it just got lost in a lot of mid

It’s an album full of bangers (Zero, bullets with butterfly wings, 1979, etc) and is overall a very thematically consistent album. I just have to acknowledge—oh hello, elephant—that it’s a tad long with some songs that easily could’ve been cut to make a more concise listening experience. Could be a 5 on a couple relistens though

Me, listening politely I've said it once, I'll say it 1001 times, there's good material on here, but need to cut out the rubbish and get themselves down to a normal album length. Once again, cost themselves a point in doing so

This would be 5 if they made some cuts. No need for it to be 2h long. But hey, at least their gloomy music stops me dreaming of a future I can't possibly provide for myself

I smashed a pumpkin

There are a wide variety of sounds here and some strong moments, but unfortunately I can't take Billy Corgan's voice for two hours straight.

classic, but doesnt need to be 2 hours.

Nothing about this justifies the length.

Poslusala teke, bio oke

I don't recall any bigger news in all the world the day this album was released. I think me and everyone else I know had a passionate 3-year marriage to the Pumpkins, followed by a bitter divorce (in other words: it wasn't mutual, and Corgan blamed us). The breakup drama was followed by several decades of general indifferent forgetfulness. Revisiting this certainly reminds me of that love affair. Hilariously overlong and overblown and overwrought, but still full of some truly wonderful moments. In the end, this is an album made by people who did not believe there could ever be consequences for their actions. But they were wrong.

This reminded me of a few things: This was the first album I ever bought. It was purchased at the same time as Everclear’s So Much for the Afterglow, which I suspect and hope is not on this list. Fast forward 30 years, a period of minimal Smashing Pumpkins listening, and even less Everclear listening, to 2026 where we have a little family tradition of watching music videos after dinner. The five-year-old and the two-year-old were both delighted and a little scared of Tonight, Tonight. It really is a triumph of a video - a beautiful homage to Méliès. I saw the Smashing Pumpkins and QOTSA in Wellington a long time ago. Billy Corgan was wearing this sequined dress thing. He came back out, alone for an encore. This consisted of him announcing it was his birthday, getting the crowd to sing him happy birthday, then walking off stage and never coming back. So what do I think of the album? Well, much like my darling daughter: when it was good, it was very, very good, but when it was bad, it was horrid. And perhaps there is no finer example of the golden rule: bloated it be, one must give it a three.

Featuring the song “Zero” from the season 7 Simpsons episode “Homerpalooza”.

I'll never forget the first time I listened to this in high school. I bought it on a whim after seeing the video for 1979 on MTV2, and was utterly blown away. Incredibly diverse album with banger after banger. Love it!

Album : 17/1089 songs known going in : 4/28 favourite song : X.Y.U Cover art : stunning remind me of a christmas tree ornament I had as a kid Rating : 4/5 notes : really enjoyed the album just thought there was some filler all are good but some dont stand out too much I'd definitely listen to the whole album again when cleaning cooking etc. I really want to say this is a 5 star album because there are songs that I love but there are a few too many I wouldnt actively put on.

Muy bueno

la verdad es que no disfruto el heavy metal. Si hay un par de temas mas tranquilones que son un poco más piolas, pero después no lo disfruto tanto. 5/10

Decent album tbf, not convinced it all goes together in places and obviously very long. 1979 can see why it's a big track but doesn't make sense in it's location, would fit better in disc 1. Think as a 12 track disc 1 album with 1979 in it would be rated higher imo. Other than that a few really enjoyable tracks especially the butterfly one and enjoyed "here is no why" probably due to it's punk influences. 3/5

muito grande.

Ah, I played this album all the time! And saw them live @Roskilde from the front row (it was heavy, and amazing). A superb album, varied too.

this is where i jumped off the train. Gish meant so much to me. this is a different band. and it only got worse from here.

9.28.26 Really long but good Favorite Song: Jellybelly Rating: 4/5

Unas buenas otras no tantos, unas increíbles y unas para el olvido.

I mean it's the smashing pumpkins, what can you have against them?

Gemoedelijk begin album, rustige piano. Verder heel wisselend. Soms wel wat te veel geschreeuw.

Non il mio genere

I’ve kind of avoided listening to this for years. I thought this was actually quite good. I think my issue is I just get tired of Corgan’s vocals. They work on some songs but 2 hours worth just gets on my nerves. Still enjoyed this though.

Crazy good songs and some duds

Favorite Track: Bullet With Butterfly Wings

I used to say that I couldn't listen to more than 4-5 pumpkins songs in a row before I got tired of Billy Corgan but here I am, two discs later, unapologetically rating it a five. Perhaps a little nostalgia is at play but that's ok.

Some of my favorite songs, but overall album 4/5

Good stuff is so good. But a lot of it is kind of mid for me.

Favourite tracks: Where Boys Fear to Tread, Love, Cupid de Locke

There are some great songs in here, which on their own would be a 4/5, but when I got tired of the album I went to look and I wasn't halfway through, maybe the second part has some bangers that I didn't appreciate because I was already bored of the mediocre songs in between and the shitty vocals.

Good album. Could be a 4.

Beautiful atmosphere established in the intro Tonight tonight is one of the greatest songs ever made Wow abrupt switch into the next track, fw the energetic drums and guitar Zero is so damn grimy i love it, that hook(?) is so infectious and always feels so cool to sing I like billys whinyness in this song, not much else to say lol. Ooo solo rips DESPITE ALL MY RAGE I AM STILL JUST A RAT IN A CAGEEEE. Had to turn my headphones up. The beating march of the drums leading up to the chorus is an underrated part of this song Slowing it back down again. He really can do the soft and heavy vocals both so naturally. Not as much of a fan of this one tho, feels a bit filler Ok right back to it. Fastest song so far i think. Another energetic banger. Nasty ass solo Interesting use of distortion on the vocals on this song, unsure how i feel abt it. Does help change up the sound a little This is a better example of a softer song imo. The harp is so peaceful Love this sm. Even better feeling than the last one. The guitar tone and synths combined with the beat on the ride create such a soothing atmosphere. Great climax too Again, whiny corgan is hard to beat. Great mix of energy and softness. I get lost in tge guitar 9+ minute song this should be good. Slow buildup doing its job rn. Wow i was not expecting that drop but i am pleased. Ok potential to be one of my favorites. Already 5 minutes in and I’m far from exhausted. I love how layered this sounds. Man the switch between this more somber ballad sound and heavy rock sections keep this song such an interesting listen. Not once in this almost 10 minute song did I feel bored or like i needed to go to the next song Ok this is definitely the most subdued song I’ve heard from them. Not that I don’t like it, i do, but this feels more like a transition from disk 1 to 2 Alright onto disk 2. The guitars at the start of this song feel like they’re talking from my left ear to my right and my brain is in the middle just absorbing their conversation Felt like i just changed the channel onto an old show that I forgot about but loved. Love is suicide. What is this caressing my ears rn🥹. Might be the best singing I’ve heard on this album. The piano compliments his voice really well. What a beautiful and motivational song Cool little acoustic song. I like it, but probably the weakest on this side so far Classic. Youll be hard pressed to find someone who doesn’t like this song. Can’t even a Say too much, just that it never gets old no matter how many times I’ve heard it Wow another big vibe switch. Back to the distorted vocals, although this time a lot more grating. The first song on the album id really say i didn’t like Another longer song. Liking this a lot more than the last track. Nothing too specific on this, just that it sounds great. Didn’t take me on the same journey as the other long song but it didn’t have to The fillerest of filler Ok great energy pick up. Banger but I am starting to get a little worn on this sound. Hope they’re able to find a way to keep it fresh in the final stretch of the album. Damn i didn’t even realize how long this song was. Right when I thought it was about to end there was another 2 minutes left, so it does kinda overstay its welcome a little bit Went from wtf is this to huh ok ill give it a chance. Ok back to wtf. I feel like there was a little bit of potential but they just did nothing with the song. At least it’s a different sound Oh fuck another weird one. Already not feeling it. It feels like their rendition of a children’s love song. Ok it’s kinda pulling me in a little halfway through but it may be too little too late Nope this one isn’t for me either. Feels like they heard my complaint about the sameyness and pivoted way too hard away from the sound that made the rest of the album so great. Im hoping these last 2 tracks end the album stronger than this stretch has been Ok another slower love song but this one feels a lot more natural in their style. I really like the bass on this song. Really sweet song and helps get this album back on track right at the end Decent closer. I mean i get the vibe they were going for with the emotional ballad to wrap up the album but i think the last song would’ve been a much better outro while still holding onto that same emotion they were going for Overall even though it kinda fell off towards the end, the majority of the album was able to keep me engaged to the point where the extended runtime was almost warranted. If they had cut it down to like 1hr 15min to 1hr 30min i think it would’ve been perfect. Solid 8.5 tho still

Very good, maybe a bit too many soft tracks

Gostei das músicas mais cantantes mas das outras n

The problem with most double albums is that there simply isn’t enough amazing music to allow for a fully enjoyable listening experience. Those that are consistently good all the way through (White Album, Keys of Life, Sign o’ the Times etc) are incredible feats of musicianship as well as great albums to listen to on their own for this reason. Most double albums begin to drag without a compelling concept or simply brilliant music for an hour plus. Now w this album, I understand why the Pumpkins wanted to get grander and more expansive after their brilliant album Siamese Dream. But two hours is simply unnecessary; that’s 3 entire sides of an LP - almost no album could be great all the way through. And indeed, this isn’t. Had this album been condensed into a Siamese Dream-length album it could be a brilliant effort, but a lot of the heavier tracks just do not hit for me and they drag this album down.

On *MC&TIS* Billy Corgan's pinched, sensitive boi singing sits squarely in middle of piles of guitar bombast and orchestral glop laid on thick enough to give The Moody Blues a run for their money. Some of this excess could be excused if there some actual *songs* underneath all of the aural muck, but even if you look past the surface there's nothing there except go-nowhere riffing and randomly strung-together chords.

Very nice Standout tracks: tonight, tonight and 1979

First thoughts no album needs to be this long. If you have this material you think is so good release two separate albums. I can see why live albums would be doubles but this takes the mick. Now can I listen to it all in a day. It's soooo long. I liked a good number of songs but the length is a killer

The SP album with the highest highs but Jesus christ is this the textbook definition of bloated or what. Even its lows are pretty decent but in no universe can this be a 5 with a 2 hour run time without a tight core narrative. The intro track going into tonight tonight is a magical start to an album. Standouts are Tonight Tonight (fave), Bullet with Butterfly Wings, Cupid De Locke, Galapogos, In The Arms Of Sleep, 1979, Beautiful, Lily and By Starlight.

Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too long

I've loved this album since it came out. 10/10. No notes.

I know the Smashing Pumpkins for one song, "1979", which I like, but I'm also not a big grunge fan, including Nirvana. To me, it all sounds very "teenagery", immature, garage-rock-sounding, like a lot of 90s music. Probably the point, but still. However, the music here doesn't annoy me like other bands do. There's a weird bland of hard-hitting distorted grunge erupting with energy, and softer ballads that are at times beautiful, and other times schmaltzy. This would all be fine if the album had the decency to shut the fuck up after an hour. Instead, it's this bloated, over-long double (triple??) LP. And look, there are incredibly good double albums out there. London Calling and Songs in the Key of Life come to mind. But this is not it. There are some great songs, but they're drowning in an ocean of fine songs. Overall, this was boring, not gonna lie.

5: I will happily play this album anytime 4: I may occasionally play this album of my own free will 3: I will happily listen to this if someone plays it in the background 2: I will tolerate this if it is playing in the background 1: I will leave the room if someone plays this in the background I was about to rate this a 4 w/o listening as this album was on constant repeat in my house back when it was released. If I'm going to play a Smashing Pumpkins album it will almost always be Siamese Dream. However, I did listen to it on the way to work this morning and was reminded that despite the sprawling and harsher (production relative to Butch Vig) tone of this album there are a lot of great songs here. Porcelina and Ruby have always been favorites of mine.

Some great songs, but a bit long

another 90s classic. pure grunge. every album has been a pure banger

I mean it’s in my top 100 for sure ! Siamese dream is in my top 10

Individual songs are great, but in full it's a glorious, hot mess. Plus it drags on forever.

Such a good listen really good range and fkow,

I like some of the punky elements, but the length is gratuitous and the voice grating after a while.

Drags on after a while but this does have some of their best songs

I fucking love this album. What a throwback to my childhood this listen was. Can’t wait to enjoy it again. I added a few tracks to my playlist

Would rock out again

Genuinely one of my favorite albums of all time. The immense scope of this is everything that I love about "alternative" music, there is something for every mood and emotion. But wait, theres more! In an era where most groups were trying to sound polishedly unpolished here is a guy that actually wanted to make something that sounds great. Sure you could make the argument that because of the big swings that there are a couple of misses (for me the misses most people reference aren't misses at all) and we could go on and on about his voice though it suits his compositions here. The real gems in this album aren't the singles. This is record that rewards actually sitting down and actively listening. The more you really listen the more you seem to find as time goes on. 5 stars all day every day and twice on Sundays.

An album in need of an editor. Billy Corgan says they were making the "White Album" of 90s alt which, ok sure- but whereas the White Album already was arguably a bit too long at 90 minutes, this one is a ridiculous 2 hours. A frustrating 2 hours too, as it pinballs from some absolute bangers to useless filler.

A lot of ups and downs. Some songs were really good, some I didn't like at all. But all in all a good album

If you boil this down to the top ten songs on the album then you have probably the best album from the 90s. However, everytime I listen to it I pick another song I like. 8.25/10 Top song... 1979

So much going on here. A grunge White Album. Some great tracks but far to long.

Never ends.

I found this to be overindulgent and a slog to get through. If you only know the singles, you're not missing much.

Uu, najprej sm bla vesela, ker s kle mi je en kup komadov všeč & nikol se nism lotila albuma, potem pa vidim, da je album dolg dve uri... DVE URI. Ugh. Ok. Mam dve uri. Gremo. "Jellybelly" slišim prvič - ful fajn! Ok, mogoč bom tokrat (dve uri!) bl izpostavila meni nove komade (obviously the famous ones poznam & so mi bli zmer kul) & všečne at first listen: "An Ode To No One" (bobni! Energija na splošno!), "Cupid De Locke" (whimsical! Ful mi evoka naslovnico albuma.),"Galapogos" "Muzzle" (mislim, da vidim v kero smer gre moje poslušanje...). Na disc 2 je prvi neznani komad, ki mi je izstopajoč šele "Tales of a Scorched Earth". I guess preferiram prvi disc. Sledeči mi je isto fajn ("Thru the Eyes of Ruby"). (Mogoč pa rabim sam mal pavze & frišna ušesa? I'll do that.) Ok, druga polovica dics 2 mi je bolj pri srcu ("X.Y.U."). Ampak, predolgo je tole. Ha, "We Only Come Out at Night", kok random. Mja, prvi disc je ful boljš. Uu, najprej sm bla vesela, ker s kle mi je en kup komadov všeč & nikol se nism lotila albuma, potem pa vidim, da je album dolg dve uri... DVE URI. Ugh. Ok. Mam dve uri. Gremo. "Jellybelly" slišim prvič - ful fajn! Ok, mogoč bom tokrat (dve uri!) bl izpostavila meni nove komade (obviously the famous ones poznam & so mi bli zmer kul) & všečne at first listen: "An Ode To No One" (bobni! Energija na splošno!), "Cupid De Locke" (whimsical! Ful mi evoka naslovnico albuma.),"Galapogos" "Muzzle" (mislim, da vidim v kero smer gre moje poslušanje...). Na disc 2 je prvi neznani komad, ki mi je izstopajoč šele "Tales of a Scorched Earth". I guess preferiram prvi disc. Sledeči mi je isto fajn ("Thru the Eyes of Ruby"). (Mogoč pa rabim sam mal pavze & frišna ušesa? I'll do that.) Ok, druga polovica disc 2 mi je bolj pri srcu ("X.Y.U."). Ampak, predolgo je tole. Ha, "We Only Come Out at Night", kok random. Mja, prvi disc je ful boljš. Brez drugega bi blo 5 zvezdic.

not really my type of genre but not bad music

What a classic rock album! Favorite songs are Galapagos, Tonight Tonight, 1979 and Cupid de Locke.

The hits are hits, the rest...Billy Corgan's voice can grate on my ears.

Sounds good I’m just not listening to over two hours of anything not gonna lie.

It was really ok, too long though. Some good drumming and some flashes of brilliant guitar. Vocals irritating. Not as bad as I was expecting for such a long album.

Well, damn. Never bothered with Smashing Pumpkins before. My mistake. This was really, really good. I didn't even find it too long when some albums feel long at an hour. Impressive.

There is some excellent stuff on here and it's as good as I remember it being when I last heard it years ago. There's a good mix of songs as well. That being said, it could do with cutting a few tracks. Although maybe not quite enough to make it a single album. 1979, bullet with butterfly wings, tonight tonight, today we all know but throw in Galapagos and to forgive plus a load of others and you've got a great double album.

Surprising range of styles. Instrumental opening, then alternative classic in Tonight Tonight followed by metal drums and baseline...drums on this album stand out. Tonight Tonight, Bullet with Butterfly Wings, 1979 all bring heavy mid 90's MTV nostalgia, great songs. Not a huge fan of Bill Corgan's vocals, though his voice in these songs is iconic. Besides the old hits nothing really stood out as amazing.

Beautiful

An epic, a magnum opus, a legend. This stands alone due to its incredible breadth and consistency. To execute the spectrum of the opening track's delicacy to Bullet with Butterfly wing's agression, to write pop tunes like 1979 and Tonight, Tonight, to generate the wall of guitar for Zero and to keep it all together is a work of genius. Too many albums here do not merit their run time, but this does and is a spectacular album from start to finish.

There most ambitious. Some of if not most of their best songs. Say what you want about the dude (reminds me of the Elon of 90 grunge/alt rock) but this is a definite classic.

Their instrumentals are so good but Corgan’s vocals have always been atrocious. If he weren’t singing, I would have given it like a 4/5. Really, even a 3 is pushing it with both his terrible vocals in addition to the TWO HOUR length.

another one of my faves of all time… got me through highschool and i’m planning on getting a tattoo inspired by the linear notes!

The Smashing Pumpkins were one of the most memorable bands of the 1990's for me as I had limited exposure to 90's alt rock and they were on heavy rotation at the radio station I listened to when I was visiting my sister. They are quite distinctive, with Corgan's vocals and distorted guitars. I only owned their debut album, and probably should have had this one in my collection as well. But a double disc of the Pumpkins is a LOT of Pumpkins in one sitting. I like them better in small doses.

This would be a five-star single album. Maybe even two five-star single albums. As a whole package, it's just too much. When this album first came out, I called it "bloated". It still applies. Billy Corgan is not Brian Wilson. "Siamese Dream" is the must-listen. This spot could have gone to Hum, The Pursuit of Happiness, Sloan, Material Issue, or any other Mid-90's Alt band that deserved a bigger audience. Not for nuthin', but....Pearl Jam got only one album on this list.

Obviously a lot of filler here, but the good songs are too good to give this anything less than a 5.

Honestly better than I remembered

Classic SP album, love it

Opening number is quite lovely piano playing. I like the album more than I remember liking it. Possibly it was overplayed at the time. Title of “Bullet with Butterfly Wings” really should be retitled - I think of it as “Rat in a Cage.” Quite a long album - you need to be a fan to listen to this much Smashing Pumpkins in one go.

- A bit too loud and screechy for my taste

Not impressed, the first track is iconic but the rest is so so

Spoko, do uwaznego przesłuchania

I’m not sure you can write the story of music in the 90’s and not include the Smashing Pumpkins, they were that great of a force. This album is really the crux of that statement. It’s a true testament to have an album this long and with a great amount of genre-mashing and still have it be coherent and not feel like a drag.

5 sterren omwille van de "pareltjes" en heb het niet over de hits.

Hitjes zijn top. Duurt gewoon te lang. En voor eens heb ik het lastig met zijn stem

Blown away. de hitjes heb ik ondertussen wel gehoord, maar zoveel op dit album is enorm goed. wel weer een zeer lang album

Favorite songs: Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, Tonight, Tonight, Here Is No Why, Bullet with Butterfly Wings, Muzzle, Porcelina of the Vast Oceans, Thirty-Three, 1979, Stumbleine, We Only Come Out at Night, Lily (My One and Only), By Starlight, Farewell and Goodnight

Another album I came into with super high expectations (for some reason), but this time I'd say they were basically met. This is a mammoth. Somehow, it really does work though. I won't sit here and say that Billy Corgan's voice is actually decent - it's not, although I suppose it does do the job - however I think it'd be ridiculous not to recognize his prowess as a songwriter. How the fuck do you write all of this. Just how. So eclectic, so strong, so deeply emotional. Definitely want to listen to and think about this one a whole lot more. Shoutout Chicago. Oh hey, I guess this is my 420th album. Shoutout marijuana.

Känns väldigt lång. Ett flertal riktigt bra låtar. Samtidigt en del som man kan vara utan. Väldigt varierande. 3,5 av 5. Bullet with Butterfly Wings, Thirty- Three och 1979 bäst.

What a classic album. I loved listening to the whole album after so many years.

Perfection. Maintenant je sais que le rock alternatif est mon genre de musique préféré

I tried but fail to like it. Voice is too whiny.

Some timeless but weird bangers. A lot of fluff. Still this album deserves its flowers

Iconic and 2 hours long

The first track lowkey is misleading to what the rest of the album sounds like. This one was a banger for sure tho.

Bought this CD on the day it came out. Classic.

Siamese Dream is my favorite Pumpkins album, but this one is pretty great as well. Suffers a bit from double album syndrome, but not too many lulls in the tracklist. 3.75/5.

5/10 Best songs: Tonight Tonight, Jellybelly, Thru the Eyes of Ruby I tried for years to get into Smashing Pumpkins but they never quite clicked for me, despite being a huge fan of musicians and bands said in the same breath. Upon this listen, I think I've figured out why their music never worked for me: Billy Corgan's voice is godawful. The music is terrific, but the man just can't sing. On occasion I can overlook his singing when a song particularly stands out (Jellybelly is outstanding, for example). In addition, this double album is unnecessarily bloated. Either it should have been released as two separate projects or there should have been judicious editing to cut it down to a single disc, because man, this album is a drag.

A very involved effort on this triple LP. The longest so gs are the worst. Billy covering several genres of music. Several really good songs. Probably should of been condensed into 2 separate albums.

A bloated, self-indulgent corpse of an album convinced of its own profundity. I bought this when it came out because I had loved Siamese Dream and Gish, yet this one never struck a chord with me. It always felt too long with lyrics inspired by magnetic poetry kits.

I want to give this a 5 so bad, but I always felt the back half of this double album dragged. The 2 most known double albums of famous 90s artists might be this and NIN's The Fragile. The latter is all gas no breaks, this hits it hard. Nothing wrong with that, cause the quality is there, I just can't give it a 5. 4.

Good memories but still prefer the softer songs. Don’t listen all the way through.

good 90s rock album. it has a lot of new influences and I could hear it at a teen party in 2005

Another from back in the day 1979, Bullet For Butterfly wings, Tonight Tonight all smashing songs. Really nice work here from Billy's vocals to the riffs and switch from ballad to rock anthems. I just think it was too long I get one day album one night but I struggle to listen to this in on ego it's just a top much. It's quite heavy and in bits brilliant in other areas hard. However it's a classic album that more than deserving to be here.

i really enjoyed all the instrumentals, but i simply just cant enjoy the vocals. i dont know why but every song i just get irritated because of the voice. would be a 10/10 if it was just the instrumentals because they really carry every song. also holy FUCK this album is long. if it were good i wouldnt mind it, but it just isnt.

Some really good songs in here but it went on forever

the miracle of Siamese Dream is that the Pumpkins were always both floating and pummeling, a jetstream roaring and ascending at their heaviest, their softest moments their most deliberate. on the followup, they've decided they can only do one or the other, and must do each one a whole bunch of times. did you forget to stick the songs together, guys? is that why there's so many?

It’s good but not 2 hours good

Este ya lo había oído anteriormente La voz de Billy Corgan me parece horrenda, en especial sus screams, fuera de eso la música está bien aunque con la duración es fácil olvidarse de tantas canciones

muy largo

could be a 5 but really gotta trim this down Will I listen to again: 96%

It was ok liked it still Album cover was so good

To the user who's 1-star review is currently at the top of the pile, I see you and I hear you. You're not wrong in your assessment, though, I don't know if you were alive or old enough to be aware of this album when it came out. It was a massive record in it's heyday. Anyway, yeah, this album suffers same as a lot of double albums in the sense that had they left maybe half on the cutting room floor, it would have been better for it. Billy Corgan was honestly a great song writer (I say "was" since none of the stuff he released this century was all that good), but a great frontman he is not. His voice is nails on a chalkboard at best. Despite that shortcoming, there's some all time bangers on this record, but there's also a lot of fluff they could have scrapped and this would have been all the better for it.

Reminds me of childhood

I see the talent, but it’s just not for me. Also this many songs shows a lack of prioritization

I've listened to some of Smashing Pumpkins' bangers, yet I hadn't listened to the entire album song by song. Yesterday, I was extremely lucky that I finally did. It was a spiritual session. The album is a very rare example of versatility, musical wholesomeness, and uniqueness. Right after the very first song, my jaw dropped and never got back up. The masterpiece itself is hardly described by words. Everybody can find something of their own while listening to this album.

An iconic album from the 90’s that has one of the very best songs produced that decade (1979 - IMO the best Pumpkins song by a mile). It’s cover art has always particularly stood out to me, like you can’t have album art like that on a record that isn’t super important. Like many have pointed out, it’s a chore to work through this album, as it is for any 2 hour album or any quality. I’ve long been of the opinion that Corgan and the Pumpkins were at their when they stripped things back, à la 1979, though that’s too few and far between. Tonight, Tonight is brilliant, as is Bullet With Butterfly wings, and there’s a ton of good songs throughout the record. As a cohesive project, I think it would vault quickly into masterpiece territory if it was ~50% shorter. Perfect double albums are hard to pull off, especially with CDs allowing more data and enabling a 2 hour album length. I listen to a lot of records and 2 hours is tough to digest no matter how many listens. Still, it’s a fantastic record, even if it feels like the length feels forced at times.

Wonder if I still have this on tape in a box at my parents house.

cam alterneaza genurile, dar overall e f ok

I like these guys but this album was too long to take in properly - and maybe a bit too long for its own good too, from what I was able to take in.

We have had smashing pumpkins before and I remember being really pleasantly surprised and in fact I think I did deem it "smashing" pumpkins. This one was more like squashing potatoes. Har Har har

I actually really like The Smashing Pumpkins. And I like a lot of these songs… I just feel like this album was all over the place as a whole.

I listened to it in depth. While it has some great songs, there is a lot to be desired on a few of the tracks. Overall, very good but not great,

Ambitious as hell. At times, perfect. Other times, it can be frustrating because (for instance) there feel like 3 or 4 album closers that the Pumpkins just couldn't pick between. But it's never poorly produced. For me, it doesn't quite stick its landing across both volumes. But there are enough moments of literal genius (especially for the time in which it was produced) to outweigh the more exhausting experimental songs. The variety is wild, from symphony to grunge to raw to polished. I'm not sure I'll ever have the patience to try to figure out the narrative across all of these songs, but it's an experience I'm grateful for.

I’ve owned "Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness" for years, yet rarely pull it off the shelf - and I’ve often wondered why. It isn’t a bad album by any stretch; I can appreciate the quality and craft behind it. But, to me, none of the tracks trigger that visceral reaction that facilitates repeated listens, a deep affection for the material or a five-star rating. It’s a solid collection of good-to-very-good songs, but nothing here truly grabs hold of me. Three stars. Disc one – Dawn to Dusk 1 "Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness" (Instrumental) (3/5) 2 "Tonight, Tonight" (3/5) 3 "Jellybelly" (3/5) 4 "Zero" (4/5) 5 "Here Is No Why" (3/5) 6 "Bullet with Butterfly Wings" (3/5) 7 "To Forgive" (3/5) 8 "Fuck You (An Ode to No One)" (4/5) 9 "Love" (4/5) 10 "Cupid de Locke" (4/5) 11 "Galapogos" (4/5) 12 "Muzzle" (3/5) 13 "Porcelina of the Vast Oceans" (4/5) 14 "Take Me Down" (3/5) Disc one total - 48 Disc one average - 3.4 Disc two – Twilight to Starlight 1 "Where Boys Fear to Tread" (4/5) 2 "Bodies" (3/5) 3 "Thirty-Three" (3/5) 4 "In the Arms of Sleep" (3/5) 5 "1979" (4/5) 6 "Tales of a Scorched Earth" (3/5) 7 "Thru the Eyes of Ruby" (3/5) 8 "Stumbleine" (3/5) 9 "X.Y.U." (4/5) 10 "We Only Come Out at Night" (3/5) 11 "Beautiful" (3/5) 12 "Lily (My One and Only)" (3/5) 13 "By Starlight" (3/5) 14 "Farewell and Goodnight" (3/5) Disc two total - 45 Disc two average - 3.2 Total - 93 Average - 3.3 395/1001 206/395 albums reviewed were new to me.

Sone great tracks

Massive respect for the ambition and the era it defined, but the theatricality and sonic whiplash make it a tough listen for me.

Only listened to half but I wanna go back and finish it. Liked this one better than the last Pumpkins album we had, and it grew on me song by song.

Unless you were a grunge fan outside of Nirvana in the 90s, this album probably should be bypassed. For me, nostalgia makes me give it 4 *.

Side One is an easy 4 close to a 5, great driving riffs and crunching songs. I'm already a bit fatigued by side 2 which is nice but a bit sleepy in comparison. A shame because taking maybe 5/6 of the best songs from each and you could have a 5 star album TBH

The problem with most double albums is that there simply isn’t enough amazing music to allow for a fully enjoyable listening experience. Those that are consistently good all the way through (White Album, Keys of Life, Sign o’ the Times etc) are incredible feats of musicianship as well as great albums to listen to on their own for this reason. Most double albums begin to drag without a compelling concept or simply brilliant music for an hour plus. Now w this album, I understand why the Pumpkins wanted to get grander and more expansive after their brilliant album Siamese Dream. But two hours is simply unnecessary; that’s 3 entire sides of an LP - almost no album could be great all the way through. And indeed, this isn’t. Had this album been condensed into a Siamese Dream-length album it could be a brilliant effort, but a lot of the heavier tracks just do not hit for me and they drag this album down.

I can listen to and enjoy the smashing pumpkins in extremely short bursts. The bloated sounding excess of 90s alt-rock is... It's a lot at the best of times. The "unique" singing style and the melodrama come together to make this an absolutely dismal 2 hour experience, but a lot of the songs on their own aren't that bad. Rating this as an album, its quite low, but as a set of songs to listen to individually? It's a bit better. Especially the first half.

[4/5] alt rock grunge. wish it was one disc or a bit less than two hours, as i enjoyed the first disc a lot more. disc two feels like whiplash and promises to wind down before doing so. i luckily got used to the nasal voice. my favourite song was bullet with butterfly wings. 3.5 // rounded up for disc 1. track notes: [1] 1. minimal intro with melody tasting of what is to come 2. scratches my brain a lot, but struggling to think what it reminds me of. disarm, age of innocence, blink 182, ocean avenue. the strings are outstanding 3. driving the monster truck in simpsons hit and run 4. gallagher pronunciation of “she’s” 5. guitar so good i wanna learn 6. so this is where neil cicierega got that song from! biblical test with rats 7. working through it 8. raging voice destroyer 9. when he says “love” it’s like the “hello” in smells like teen spirit 10. harp! 11. nice gentle build-up, slowing things down 12. acquired the forbidden knowledge. his knowledge of meaning is the greatest counter to sartre 13. starts out like i’m waking up on a nice beach 14. suitable for a soppy bedtime [2] 15. tongue punching with bombs 16. grunge 17. a bit of a meander 18. yearning and deceit 19. we are so back, but annoyingly overplayed 20. dutty sound but he is just screaming. really jarring considering the surrounding songs 21. this song is longer than youth 22. slow and tender now 23. nursery rhyme but make it angry and gritty 24. squelchy sound with certified owl moments 25. thought i was listening to halo by beyoncé for a second 26. pov ur snape 27. shared emotional damage 28. wind down into sleepytime

A very long (arguably bloated) experience that was still nonetheless very enjoyable. Favourite track: Tonight, tonight

Ugh this one is so close to being higher on this list, potentially even a 5, but there are so many things holding this album back. First off, when I discovered this band in highschool, a big reason I fell in love was because I was the perfect age for this dramatic amount of angst. But also because a lot of their song so liked the most from them came from this album. This is definitely Smashing Pumpkins magnum opus. The biggest problem though, is it’s WAY too fucking long. 2 hours is just too much time with this limited amount of variety. There is variety but that’s just going back and forth between loud angsty music and soft angsty music. And it’s not as simple as, too much soft or too much heavy music. It’s just a lot of what they are trying to say and do is accomplished on the first half of the album which is more than long enough to be its own album. And while I do love 1979, a lot of their song second half feels like they were starting to run out of original ideas and started just adding more of the same. The other massive problem with this band is Billy Corrigan. I used to really like him and I though the fact why he was a big professional wrestling guy made him more endearing and grounded. But then he completely undermines that by being impossible to work with, firing a lot of the musicians that made his music memorable and special, as well as being a massive douche bag now. Like he has become everything he hated, and he’s completely oblivious to that because his head is lodged so securely up his own ass. It’s sad to see talented artist lose everything that made them special. For what it’s worth, “zero” is easily one of the greatest alt rock songs of all time! Thanks The Simpsons hulabalooza episode for turning me onto them as well as Peter frampton, sonic youth, and cypress hill.

U can really tell that the Smashing Pumpkins knew what they were doing when creating this album. This album literally embraced everything that happened in music before its release, making it extremely diverse and interesting.

Punky Sound. Like the drive. Diverse Songs, I like Galapogos. Surround Sound. Like the second half of the Album even better. My type of music.

Admittedly, this album had some really good moments, especially in the first half. Unfortunately I can't get past the grating vocals, the mix that makes me feel like I'm not hearing it right due to some non-existent hearing loss (especially with the vocals), and most of all, I can't get past being made to listen to two hours of this, even if the songs are not bad by themselves.

I don't love every song on here and I'd be lying if I said I was fully engaged for the full 2 hours, but man, at its best, this is some of the best rock music of the 90s. 'Tonight, Tonight' and '1979' are generational songs.

un album con un rango muy dinamico, el sonido esta lleno de detalles y es muy definido. un tanto muy largo para mi gusto

Tonight is amazing song

smashing!

nice beats

Paar mooie nummers, teveel gekrijs en te vaak irritante gitaaruithalen

If there’s an album that truly captures the spirit of the mid 90s, this one is definitely at the top of the list. So much of the music from that era has worn out its welcome for me I’d happily keep most of it buried. But The Smashing Pumpkins are the exception. Though they’re a quintessential 90s alternative band, they pulled in elements from nearly every facet of the culture back then. They had the grunge edge, hints of shoegaze and dream pop, a dark style that wasn’t quite goth, and even experimented with electronic music that was just beginning to make waves. This album is likely their most diverse, blending all of those elements into a single, cohesive work.

Couple of good songs like tonight tonight and 1979 but there is way too much melodrama and not enough melody to put up with that voice

My first DNF. I liked the first few songs but there’s just not much here. Megalomaniacal to make a record this long when you have so little to say. Lost me at “Bodies.”

Interesante.

despite being a pretty big Siamese dream fan, I don’t know this album super well. I think it’s always daunted me a bit with its length and reputation. I’m very happy to have really given it the time here though, because it’s pretty spectacular. Both halves are chock full of bangers and there are really no low points but some very high points.

Really enjoyed this. Not a band I've ever listened to before, not sure why.

Quite hard rocking but didn’t leave much of an impression

Nice vibes but did not leave a lasting impression on me.

The singles off this album are incredible. The album is quite a bit longer than necessary. Interesting end to the album where the tone and sound are completely different.

It was pretty good. It wasn't my usual style of music but it definitely wasn't bad!

Tremendo álbum. De lo mejor que el rock alternativo logró en los 90s. Quizas la poca variedad de temas y lo largo que es (más de 2 hs.) te hace perder un poco en el medio, pero es un discazo. 9/10

Pompous, overwrought, and bloated. Billy Corgan in full ego mode. Not a good listen.

Alternative rock built from towering guitar walls, delicate piano ballads, layered production, and emotionally charged vocals feels like trying to walk through a forest where every branch is covered in thick syrup—everything sticks together into one dense mass that becomes increasingly difficult to move through. While Others might say the album is ambitious, for me its oversized, saturated soundscape which feels exhausting rather than immersive. Despite the stylistic variety, I rarely felt the music had enough space to breathe.

THIS ALBUM SAVED MY MOTHERFUCKING LIFE AT ONE POINT WHEN I WAS A LOST TEEN STUCK ON FAMILY VACATION HAVING A HELL OF A TIME (BAD) Seth - 5/5 Logan - 5/5

I can't shake the idea that this album is mostly the byproduct of Billy Corgan's long standing belief that he's very smart and very interesting. As true / false / complicated as that opinion may be, you should usually wait for other people to tell it to you first before you make a 2 hour long shoegaze pedal board album about the joys and sorrows of sleeping with Courtney Love. Siamese Dream is great and all, but this album only has (generously) 6 truly great songs. Christ, it may have more than that, but it all becomes wallpaper by disc two. What differentiates the 2nd song about religion and sex and rage from the 5th song about religion and sex and rage? Only the very smart and very interesting know for sure.

I listened to this a lot as a teenager. I probably realized even back then that there are quite a few filler tracks among the classics, and the album doesn't justify its two-hour runtime. Nowadays, if I listen to anything related to The Smashing Pumpkins, it's James Iha's solo album Let It Come Down.

Excellent album. 5 stars. It's my favourite album by The Smashing Pumpkins. It is excessive, but really good. Of course, it is very long but, in this case, that is ok. I like each and every track in this album. To name a few favourites: "Tonight, Tonight", "Zero", "Bullet With Butterfly Wings", "To Forgive", "Cupid de Locke", "Galapogos" (probably my favourite), "Porcelina Of The Vast Oceans", "Bodies", "Thirty-Three", "1979" (a classic), "Tales of a Scorched Earth" (nice aggressive contrast with the previous "1979"), "X.Y.U.", or "By Starlight". And probably a couple of songs I don't like that much: "An Ode To No One", "We Only Come Out At Night",

So much better than I originally thought

I prefer the songs that weren't hits. And improved outlook on the band noow that I've listened to the full album.

Nice melodies

I was really excited to see this one pop up, its been on my list for a hot minute and I was not disappointed. The start to this album is really nice, slowly building in energy, with both emotional quieter tracks and some angsty punkish rock tracks. As annoying as Billy Corgan's voice is, despite all my rage i am still just a rat in a cage is a great lyric for that chorus. I was really surprised by some of the tracks on side one, notably love, Galapogos and take me down, really beautiful and sensitive instrumentals. I've heard some complaints about the overly dramatised lyrics but tbh I dont really focus on lyrics when I listen, more of an instrumental person so I didn't hate this album. Gonna give this one 7.2/10 and 4 stars, subtracting points for the length, (side 1 was great but 2 was a bit of a drag), and because Billy Corgan is a bit of a stuck up wanker. Update, im halfway through the second disk and im getting sick of it, this is lucky to get away with 4 stars.

Hah. There's probably no album I have more nostalgia for than this one. It made such an impression on my childhood, and for a time, Smashing Pumpkins was my favorite band (despite my access to this album being a ripped version on cassette that didn't have all the songs). With time, I can say that Siamese Dream is their better complete album. But still, this album goes all over the place in the best way. And while it does have a lot of the typical album bloat that I feel most double albums have, there is a TON of their best moments here. But the second disk in particular is not quite as strong, and some of the latter tracks feel more like B-sides that were kept on to make it a double album... which is, again, how I feel about most double albums. But still, I'll always love this album.

i mean it's just the smashing pumpkins

Large and ambitious with some really great songs and not a lot of filler. This is one of the first albums I bought with my own money. I enjoyed it then and I still do now.

Went to read the 1 star reviews of this for a laugh

Amazing production and musicianship! Proper rock that borders metal while maintaining a nice diverse style balance. One moment it sounds like some progressive balad, other moment Mudvayne-like madness. Voice is sometimes a little annoying

Great album overall, so many great songs that are on my favorites list like 1979, tonight, tonight, and dizzle. I definitely like they're more chill stuff but the harder rock songs are good as well.

Possibly my favorite album cover art. I thought this album would be a just fine way to spend two hours and enjoy the handful of songs I knew. I was wrong. This was a beautifully executed work with a surprising variety of moods and melodies. I found myself moved at times, head banging in others. From start to finish I loved it, and even after two whole hours, I wondered when I could listen to it again.

A masterpiece of songwriting and musicianship featuring two of the greatest songs ever in "Tonight, Tonight" and "Bullet with Butterfly Wings", as well as several more excellent tracks that would be the crown jewel of any other album including "Zero" "Galapogos" and "1979". Furthermore, these standout moments are woven together by songs like the title track and "Jellybelly", that may not be earworm singles themselves, but are still well crafted songs that perfectly match the tenor of the album giving it the feel of a cohesive work. The guitarwork in this album is masterful and manages to stand out while still serving the song. The other instrumentals consistent enough in style to stay on theme, but creative enough to keep the listener engaged. I know that the biggest criticism of this album is that it is bloated, and while I think it could have been cut down a little, I rarely felt like I was listening to filler. With the exception of a one or two of the songs near the end of the album, each track is unique, but still feels like it belongs. Yes, Corgan is a pretentious weirdo now, but if I wrote the riff from "Zero" I would be the most insufferable asshole on planet earth. Yes, the lyrics are super corny, but they earn the corniness with the instrumentals. Nitpick all you want, it is still a 5/5.

Wide range of styles of songs - didn’t know the Smashing Pumpkins could also do soft. Generally enjoyed.

hell a good a bit of me only 4 cuz I don't like all the songs