Reviews (page 8 of 15)
Great. Classic Sinatra, good lyrics.
It literally says what it is on the tin.
These are 15 songs sung by Frank Sinatra.
Ok, this was much better than the last Sinatra album I got. Out with the melancholy, in with the joy. I'm sure plenty of 50s lovers were swingin' 'round the dance floor to this one, as it was fun and lively. The shorter song lengths also made it a peppier listening experience since most of the tracks just breezed by. The album's 15 songs lasted less than 45 minutes, which felt like the right amount of time for it to play. There was the distinctly classic sound that you get with brass instruments and Sinatra's voice, which made is a pleasant listening experience. It feels like you're in an earlier version of New York when it plays. I had only heard a few of the songs on the album before, but they all felt familiar as a result. On the other hand, those details meant there wasn't much diversity here. Sometimes it was hard to tell whether I was listening to a different song, or if the previous one was still going. At one point I was on the third song since I'd last looked without realizing the first one had ended. That worked for the feel of the album, but did make it all kind of a general blend. I think the album ending when it did was smart, because any longer and it would've started to get old. It also sounded dated given the stuff mentioned above. Which was great for the vibe, but isn't something that would necessarily mesh with a broader playlist. In short, it was fun and lively with entertaining music, but it didn't really do anything special for me to say it was great. Vibes are important, just not quite enough on their own. It's something I enjoyed listening to, though I question how often I would want to come back to it. I think if Sinatra had combined some of the songs from Wee Small Hours and this one into one album, it would've been a much more interesting work that I could rate higher. Overall: 3.3/5
Good background music, a couple standouts.
While definitely a product of its time, it’s aged remarkably well in spite of this. Sinatra’s vocals still sound amazing, especially when coupled with the band. It’s just a shame that this album merely functions as a collection of songs and not a more cohesive experience. I still thoroughly enjoyed this though, in spite of the repetitive song structure.
Natal em maio?
Classic!
The lyrics are interesting because in this era they almost sound clunky but they must reflect the speech and writing patterns of the time. Also, there is such an emphasis on rhyme - pretty much every verse in every song follows a simple rhyme scheme that you only hear in pop or rap nowadays. It's very homogenous but I don't really desire anything else from Sinatra, and in fact it means the album perfectly achieves its purpose as "mood music" - where every song sounds similar enough that you could play the whole thing through and never kill the mood.
Those sure were songs for swingin' lovers, which is something I am not.
Fine background easy listening. At work.
I get it, it’s classy. But if charm were a sleeping pill, this would be prescription-strength.
Frank Sinitra's voice is always comforting as the songs is singing. It's always comforting to listen to his voice, so this album was definitely an easy and chill one to listen to. Pretty fun and happy vibes, liked this one but I won't listen to this everyday, not really my style even if it's cute ahah
Good stuff, makes me want to dance while I’m cooking dinner.
(A6/V7)
Classic smooth listening Sinatra
Too much of a samey thing don’t get the fondness for this.
ehĥhhh
Classic for the right mood
Sinatra's voice is velvety smooth and sensual and beautiful. I'm not the biggest fan of this type of music so it did fall a bit flat to me, and I hate the fact that the word "whoopee" was not only in the song's title but in the chorus and repeated. It was a decent album, but middle of the road for me all things considered
Chad 4.5
Oldie but not bad. Classic Frank Sinatra
Great album. I've listened to a lot of the older singers thanks to inheriting records from my great aunt, but Sinatra always stands out at the top. Listening to this album this morning really helped, as I've been dealing with a lot of various things this week, and needed something on this level to help calm my brain down.
Classic
No....fuck this crooning horseshit. Broadway/NY in the 50's must have sucked ass. Cole Porter's original version of Anything Goes is miles better than Sinatra's version. Favorite songs: Anything Goes, You Make Me Feel So Young, Too Marvelous for Words Least favorite songs: Swingin' Down the Lane, Makin' Whoopee 2/5
8 out of 10. Maria Man sang good love song
Un clásico. Punto y final. Mejor que leer, escuchar o bailar
Better than Coldplay.
Ahh old blue eyes! I love me some Sinatra! Actually the whole rat pack, dino, Sammy! All of them! But this was a good album a very focused album of live songs that he gives his own spin on obviously! But I've only ever listened to his like greatest hits but this was a good one!
There are many good Sinatra songs but this album is lacking any of them for me. 3 stars or C-.
Well well well. If it isn't some wife beating music. Im joking but only kinda. This is music that I would see tony soprano rough up one of his girlfriends. Maybe that Russian one with the peg leg mom. But all jokes aside it's Sinatra. That's all. From the get go it's exactly what you would expect. And it's good. All around. Not really my favorite thing but i enjoyed my time pretty thoroughly.
По большей части приятно. Лучшая песня - I've Got You Under My Skin.
Much more enjoyable and relevant than I thought.
Frank Sinatra definitely one of the greats. Solid album but it's older then my parents and so again - great songs to use as a backdrop for different media (movies etc) and I'm not going to balk at this if they play this in some establishment I am at, but I'm not going to be listening to this album on my own. He's got a magical voice that came to define an era. But also he didn't write any of his songs so I guess he was a great performer, but in my opinon maybe not a great artist? I don't think he ever experimented with new sounds or pushed artistic boundaries or explored different styles. Found a formula that worked, and just did that with different collaborators. Can't knock the hustle, but 3/5 for me.
You know what Ol' Blue Eyes, I get it. Keep on swingin'.
Croon away Frankie boy.
There's something just so happy about the way Sinatra sings, and I've always enjoyed it. My first college roomate sang and played a lot of Sinatra and so I've got a soft spot for this music. A lot of great songs, including a great cover of I've Got You Under My Skin. Excellent album and totally worth a listen.
the same song 15 times but its frank sinatra so it okay i guess. great singer but man this was boring ngl
What a good time. That is all.
I appreciate how Sinatra became a legend, the innocenct innocuous undertones and usic style just isnt me. Making woopie though.
What a voice. Enjoyed but a lot of the same
Thought I was going to hate this but actually didn’t dislike it at all! Happy, easy listening songs that made me think of the old 50’s films I love. Nice voice and that cheeky smile on the album cover made it a winner for me 😉
I mean, what a voice. No one has done it better since and many have tried.
Sinatra is always an easy listen, the horns and the plungered trumpet with the silky smooth vocals is vintage. Nevertheless, even though Sinatra does what he does really well, the ceiling for his brand of music is pretty low. There isn't anything daring or dazzling about perfecting generic mid-century tunes. Not sure Sinatra can crack above 3.5 for me, so he's rounded down 3
lol at this title. Language truly is malleable and ever-evolving. My prior that Frank Sinatra is fine but generally boring remains. Such dulcet singing for such limited payoff. The lyrics are pretty shallow, the vocals are as conventional as they can be. This album feels really long because all of the songs are roughly the same. 2.5 rounding down. Every time I was listening to this I'd be like "okay that was fine", then I'd check and it was only half over. How can a 45 minute album feel so long?!?
I don't understand Frank Sinatra's reputation as a charismatic singer when "Makin' Whoopee" has so much negative rizz.
Bring back songwriters honestly. Not that they don't exist anymore, but hearing Frank Sinatra croon like this reminds me how important it is to have someone to ACTUALLY SING THE NOTES CORRECTLY.
Stemmen til Frank Sinatra er som balsam for ørene, men det svinger ikke helt som mine preferanser tilsier.
Good for the time period, but I ain't a swingin' fella.
Good orchestra sound coupled to a timeless voice. It is inoffensive mood-setting music in my mind. The sort that takes you back to an optimistic perception of a period in history only few got to actually experience. I wasn't there for it. So as a mood, interesting. As active listening, dated and naive.
Not for me
I really do love Frank Sinatra, but this album just sucked. I did not really care for most of these songs. Frank's always got a great delivery but when most of this just goes in one ear and out the other it doesn't matter. And this is not because I just got dumped a few months ago because even before that I didn't like this album. Couple good tunes kept this from a 1
Noen absolutte klassikera, og ellers alt som gjør Sinatra til Sinatra. Akkurat sånn det skal være.
Now this is the good stuff! It would be easy to mistake this album for a best of compilation but it isn't. It's just an amazing album made by one of the masters of the genre at the height of his career. A major tonal shift from his previous album "In the wee small hours of the morning". While that album is probably his best artistically, it had a dark, melancholy introspective feel to it. This album almost seems like a return to the light for Frank. Upbeat, hopeful, even the slower tunes have a certain sense of light, ironic wistfulness. You could loop this in my home all day and I don't think I'd get tired of it.
full of classics honestly.
I’ve kind of struggled to get into Frank Sinatra. I can absolutely tell that he is one of the great singers, but his music doesn’t usually appeal to me, for the same reason that most other pop music doesn’t appeal to me: it just sorta sounds shallow and simple. It’s also hard to fully appreciate the complexity of the jazz ensemble when the center is around the simple lyrics and melodies that Sinatra sings. Favorite Track: We’ll Be Together Again
I mean… it’s Frank baby 🎶 a pleasant listen
Klassisk Sinatra da. Herlig. Helt nydelig kvalitet på alt. Tenk for en produksjon
A true classic. I kept thinking of the Elf movie with Will Ferrell because some of the soundtrack from it uses songs from this album. Good stuff.
4.5/5 Martini-Slick Melancholy Because nobody loses gracefully like Frank. He’ll sing about love like he’s holding a rose, but you know he’s already bleeding from the thorns.
It's exactly what it says it is. All the songs are utterly charming and completely interchangeable. Zero surprises, zero disappointments
Fav: It Happened in Monterey; You Brought A New Kind Of Love To Me;
Although no standouts for me, I actually really enjoyed this album. Its hard to not feel good whilst listening to it. That being said, 'Makin Whoopee' was not a pleasant listen.
So confident! Sinatra of fashion nowadays but he was great at what he did. 4.1
Let me be Frank
just so very classic. effortless and his voice is so clean docked because the songs sound very similar
No one's loved and lost like Frank.
Didn’t really listen closely but had it in the background of the cafe while I worked which was nice
Third time's the charm. The other two Sinatra albums on here left me cold, while admiring their craftmanship. This is just spot-on and advances son's theory on why jazz from the forties and fifties sounds so good: playing an instrument was a route out of poverty as well as a vast industry. So we're hearing the tip of a very large pyramid. Rather like watching Premier League footballers. Because the musicianship on this album is frightening. An all-uptempo album takes out at a single pass most of what I dislike about Sinatra and swing, leaving the fabulous playing under his cool cat phrasing. Only track that outstays its welcome: We'll Be Together Again. These are all miracles of concision and thus have to be under four minutes.
smooth af
You Make Me Feel So Young is a classic, if only because it was used in Elf. Sinatra didn’t compose it though, just sang a great version. This album flows so smoothly that the songs blend together, for better or for worse.
Love some good Sinatra, his music is almost always amazing to me. I don’t know if this is the definitive album that I would use as an example, but it is very good. I’ll say four out of five for this one.
Sinatra osaa... mutta ei lemppari genre,, ei huutele 5 star genre syö tähden,.,, mutta ultimate respec silti
Great stuff from him but not really my thing. The songs are very samey and the lyrics are (obviously) dated. I can see myself listening to a good Christmas album from ol' Frank. Difficult to find another time i would listen.
If we should have nostalgia for anything we didn't experience from the 1950s, it should be singers whose voices sound like velvet and cigars. Not enough seduction these days.
Koselig
IF you have to choose a 'best' Sinatra album, this one would serve you well. He's in perfect voice and Nelson Riddle is arranging. It gets no better than this, in any genre.
Pretty much a faultless album throughout. The album serves as a definitive mood listen, which removes some versatility. This would receive a 3.5 usually, but with the current scale will be rounded down to 3.
Big band, 1950s sheen, very enjoyable and easy listen. Probably not his best album of all time but I can't imagine rating any Sinatra album less than 4. 4/5.
Just wonderful.
Ol’ blue eyes, classic, great music for making breakfast and dancing around with Quinn in the kitchen
Nelson Riddle's arrangements on this album are utterly hyperactive, with horns and strings cartoonishly jumping out in every direction, *seemingly* trying their hardest to steal the spotlight from Ol' Blue Eyes. Two things prevent this: one, Sinatra's voice is squarely up front in the mix, and two, he sings with absolute confidence and control. Lesser voices might have been overwhelmed by the barrage of instruments, but Sinatra is completely in charge. Even though most of the songs on this album are from the 30's and 40's, Sinatra's delivery is thoroughly timeless. What detracts from the whole enterprise though, is the ridiculous, gimmicky (and horribly dated) big band accompaniment which renders this album both tedious and exhausting to listen to.
Some charming ditties Perfect for a glitzy night Of romantic fun
here's a secret: i'm a sucker for sinatra
Love
I like some Sinatra albums; yes, he's a great singer. no, these upbeat orchestral pop tunes nothing for me. his more melancholy stuff hits harder. this is OK.
I love Frank Sinatra. Biggest entertainer of the last century by far. He did so much. This was one of his two best albums. The other being In the Wee Small Hours. Just perfection.
Fantastisch
Not a big Sinatra fan. The songs on this album for the most part were pretty ordinary, with simple lyrics, and uninteresting music that didn’t bring out the greatness Frank is capable of and lauded for. If I never hear this album again, I will not care one bit.
Good laid back cooking dinner music.
The problem for me is all the songs start to sound monotonous. But giving it 3/5 stars for the nostalgia.
Gillar inte riktigt swing. Inte min grej
Absolute classic
swing at its best
The old boy could sing. I shouldn't like this but I have just been entertained for over 40 minutes.
pleasant listen, all of his music sounds the same tbh
It's good, very Sinatra.
Sometimes these '50s albums feel like the soundtrack to a brunch where the pancakes are stacked too neat and everyone’s wearing suspenders for irony. Frank's voice is undeniably smooth, and the musical arrangements are lush in that clean, glossy way only the '50s could pull off. But man, it’s like biting into a plastic fruit - pretty, but not juicy. There’s no grit, no weight. It’s hard to find any emotional fingerprints on it. Everything’s just so tidy. It floats, but never dives. Honestly, it’s like a vintage filter on your ears. Spins: 2 Playlist Additions: - You Make Me Feel So Young - Love Is Here To Stay - I've Got You Under My Skin
Sinatra on taitava ja yksittäisinä biiseinä kivoja, mut ehkä albumi vähän liikaa. Silti 3/5. Kiinnostavasti huomasin et koska sinatraa on käytetty niin paljon kauhumediassa, on vaikeaa olla kuulematta täysin kuvitteellista synkkää pohjavirettä tässä siirapissa.
Pretty standard Sinatra. Most songs sound the same.
While I don't expect any of this album to be part of my daily listening rotation, Frank Sinatra's crooning and the jazzy stylings of this album made for an enjoyable listen. Listening to this album felt like I could envision the set pieces of a romantic movie from the 60's. I value music that can give you an experience that can fully envelope you, even if it's not something I will go back to regularly
Classic originals and covers by Sinatra
I have loved this stunning album for years. The songs, mainly whimsical love songs, are classics. Sinatra's voice, languid yet agile, has never been better, some of his phrasing is mind-blowing. But, at least, equal billing should go to Nelson Riddle - the arrangements complement and augment Frank's singing. Vote and music are in perfect balance, the whole soundscape incredibly rewarding. There are so many great moments and no lows - the way Sinatra will take a repeated verse in a completely different way the second go-round; the way a muted trumpet solo will grow out of the horn section. Songs for Swingin' Lovers makes me smile every time I listen to it.
Classic Sinatra when he was at peak.
2.5
Great album to throw on while just doing things, such easy listening. His voice sounds so effortless over these tracks. I think swing really complements his voice and makes it stand out. He’s got some huge songs on this album and by no means are they the only good ones. Stand outs: You Make Me Feel So Young, It Happened in Monterey, Old Devil Moon, Makin’ Whoopee, Anything Goes. I had to check and our modern definition of the word “swingin” came to prominence 8 years after this album. So looking back now, this album title is just so funny
I loved this. If at any moment someone says, "Hey, let me put on an album," and this is what they play - I'd enjoy it. It's pleasant, it's easy listening, it feels casual, but also makes me want a cigarette and martini.
It’s very much your typical Sinatra work that’s not In the Wee Small Hours.
His voice is iconic. Can’t help but enjoy it. The instrumentals is what kept me engaged though. Don’t get the back and forth between singer and band like this much anymore.
Amazing voice. Easy listening, like something you'd hear in a cafe. Not my thing, however. A lot of it all blended in together, with nothing really standing out.
Correcto
Pretty good.
classy. great. can't believe I hadn't listened before.
Niet helemaal mijn ding, maar snap wat mensen hieraan waarderen. Hij heeft een iconische en zeer herkenbare stem. Maar ik vind het wat te veel van hetzelfde.
Great
Feels like xmas songs, slow and comfy. Moody dependant
Sinatra is in great form here with a spectacular selection of standards. Some of his best work.
Lovely old school
It’s Frank. It’s good, but so were the last two Frank Sinatra albums on this list. Not certain of the significance of this one.
Even though this album is much older than I am it reminds me of being young and having hope. Therefore I hate it very much, but it's still good for what it is.
Was really fun to listen to!
He is so down bad and me fr fr
i tried my best to go into this with an open mind, and not let my bias affect my rating, but i was unable to. i love this guy, i don't care anymore, this is so fire
Felt ready for a change of album by the end. 2.5 really
Some of his absolute best. So effortless.
It started off nice enough, and then it just kept on going on and on. It does turn out that I only like Sinatra's voice in small doses.
I prefer a sadder Sinatra myself-more September of My Years than Swinging Lovers. That said, the plug for safer sex in Making Whoopie is pretty hilarious. Man’s got some chops, that’s for sure. Properly 3.5.
My jam. I dig this one.
I mean Frank Sinatra had one of the best voices of all time, so this is great just for that reason alone. His music isn't really something that I'd listen to very often but every time I hear Sinatra, I'm glad to be listening. This album is good, but I think this is one of the rare occasions where there should have been just one Sinatra album on this list, and it should have been a double length best-of. The problem with this album is that, even though the songs are great, none of them really stand out from the rest. They do all kind of blend together as others have said. But to his credit, I listened to Sinatra for a while after this album was over so he gets points for that. 3.5/5 and will round up to a 4.
It's okay every song sounds similar but throughly enjoyed it enough, his voice sounds angelic but just not the biggest fan of jazz i guess
All the songs are the same. I didn't know any song on this record. But the iconic voice makes it better to listen.
None of these songs stuck out to me
I have already listened to a lot of Frank Sinatra, including this album. However, that doesn't stop Sinatra from being the jazz goat.
Frank Sinatra is always a good choice, but he’s got better albums than this one.
what a douche
Classic.
Enjoyed it
Tiktok låtar, mid
A legend.
Absolute snoozefest. Not denying sinatras vocal ability, but every song is the exact same and the chord progressions are painfully predictable. I guess you have to be a swing lover who also knows what it feels like to be loved in order to enjoy this. I guess I wouldn’t mind it as background music at a party/date, but that’s about it
not for me
This put me in a fantastic mood to start my day
I don’t mind Sinatra generally but this album didn’t do anything for me.
I will agree with a lot of people on these reviews and say that the music is good, the singing is good, however when its 15 songs that sound almost the same they start to get tiring.
Classic
Man is great and his sound is great, but album isn't. After fifth song it felt absolut repeat of itself.
blah
I like showtunes, or american schlager and I like to call IT. I especially prefer the lounge stuff, but big band versions are cool too. Sinatra is not my favourite, but he has a pretty cool style and bravado to his singing, that cannot be dismissed. I'll take Richard Cheese over Sinatra any day tho.
8/10. Love frank
Smooth, great vocals but not super interesting. It was a nice mellow album to listen to while working. 7/10
I wish you could have all seen Angelina's face when she walked into our office and saw me snuggling with our cat and listening to Frank Sinatra.
Perhaps it's too old for my taste. Nothing here stands out. All the tracks feel and sound the same
Just not that into it
тоже обычный альбом синатры в его стиле, 50-е, без хитов, ровненько со вкусом
I really don’t understand how people like this
Swingin' Sinatra is the best Sinatra.
It's like really good vanilla ice cream
It's pretty good.
finally a 50s record!! i mean, Frank Sinatra's music is a classic for a reason, and this album is no exception. his voice is smooth as butter and the production sounds incredible. though i have to say i'm not really a fan of his more downtempo renditions of songs like "Pennies from Heaven" or "Anything Goes", but maybe that's just because i'm more familiar with uptempo versions. it all kind of blends together in an easy-listening sort of way, but honestly this type of music from this era was designed to do just that, so i can't really complain. sounds like the soundtrack to a 90s rom com lol
This was pretty cool, great singing, great songs incl. the lyrics, and most of all a great orchestra performance.
This one felt like It Happened In Monterey. Was almost Too Marvelous for Words.
Its exactly what it says on the tin
Old Francis is undeniable but I’m not sure I’m the type of swingin lover that Frank meant this for
Frank is never bad, cuz he’s so consistent. Perhaps TOO consistent. 45 minutes of this is far too much. It’s just Frank Sinatra doing Frank Sinatra. It’s fun, it’s swinging, and easy breezy. But the buck stops there. And that’s just not enough for me. Making Whoopee was horrendous but worth a chuckle, but his cover of Anything Goes was probably my favorite.
Fuck this Olive Garden ass garbage
Goddamn it we get Frank. This fine lady has stolen your poor old heart, yadda yadda. Any of those songs in isolation is a pleasant, wholesome listen. All of them together are a repetitive monotonous croonfest. This is a collection of songs more than a cohesive album. 7/10 Fave: I've got you under my skin
Not my stuff
downloaded 2&9 only. trumpets man. could listen again and again though would need to be dancing or doing something else besides listening to every song with headphones . dare i say his album is background music 😔
Kids these days don't realize The Chairman released like 12 albums that were four to five stars in the span of 6 years. This was the 5th one.
fedora's and whisky, big bands and misogny. las vegas and blah blah blah
3/10
Nothing to hate about this at all. The musicians on this record sound great, Frank's voice is the definition of smooth and the songs just flow very well all-round. I'm not a fan of the opener, but that might be because it's been played to death. I knew a few of the songs already before listening to the album as a whole (for the first time) and was afraid it might just sound old to me and I won't be able to get into it much, but I gotta say I really enjoyed it!
Definitely not my style, sounds quite nice though. Probably won't be coming back, first thought 6.5/10.
Alright
What's to say, it's Sinatra. Classic big band with crooning. Not really my cup of tea, most tracks sound the same to me.. Best track - Anything Goes
I can’t not enjoy this in the background, in fact I hadn’t realized that Spotify had moved on to other albums until an Oscar’s Peterson track came on. So great background stuff for sure, even a few that I sang along to in my head, over all no complaints listening to this.
Very frank sinatra.
Couple bottles of wine. Homemade chicken parm. Watch something classic like Casablanca. Possibly finish a with a tobacco pipe on the porch.
Feel like this has to be played on vinyl while drinking champagne with a 10/10
heeft de tand des tijds niet goed doorstaan... the ole blue eyes are closed!
I love frank
i like some old people music but this isn’t rlly the type of old people music i’m really into lol
twas ok
It's albums like these that make you realize some people really just have the one trick repackaged over and over
The man with perfect pitch - they didn't call him Chairman of the Board for nothing..a solid 5 for me, I'd give him a 6 if I could.
Golden voice in his prime. This is a book of standards. Captures the zeitgeist.
He has such an easy way about him. Floating through, enjoying life, and performing for the crowd. It’s feels much more about the listener enjoying the song than about him oddly enough.
I prefer the previous outing (in the wee small hours) but frank and Nelson Riddle knock it out of the park yet again. Standards perfectly suited to Sinatra. Totally enjoyable - even the songs they have been heard too many times to count.
All these songs sound the same to me. Great voice, simple music.
fínasti swing-söngur. hlusta samt varla á aftur.
Love sinatra
Of course he sounds unbelievable, he was basically the voice of a generation but I’d be lying if I rated it any higher than a 3. It was just a nice listen.
Ain’t too bad
All-time great voice, classic sound, tight band, savvy songwriting... and weird cover art. Five stars in my book.
This is a brilliant album.
Franktastic
Pure class
This is an absolute belter, a master class in crooning!! This is the album that finally made me understand why people love Sinatra. No duff ones just a perfect selection of classic songs all sang to perfection. Don’t think he ever bettered this one.
When younger Franks very controlled style would have made me say yeah it’s ok, how wrong I was, this is timeless, this is a classic. actually just put this on randomly the other week and was blown away of how good this is. Nearly 70 yrs old, someone will always be listening to it, which has got to be a criteria for this list. 5 Star
82% Best: You Brought A New Kind Of Love To Me; Pennies From Heaven; We’ll Be Together Again; Makin’ Whoopee; How About You? Must-Hear? Sure
I’ve listened to this a few times and loved it every time, but when I saw it was my album today I couldn’t help but scoff in some disappointment. How could an almost 70 year old album compare to some of the great rock albums I’ve had lately? Well, I forgot how good it is. What a tremendous record. Frank sounds incredible, several of the songs are timeless, and the backing music is so varied and textured and well performed. A triumph.
You know what to do Frank, keep doin' it to me
3. I enjoyed this more than his earlier album (on the list), but not quite a 4 for me.
I could listen to Frank for days. The crooning and easy way that Frank glides over these delightful accompaniments is calming. It's a 5 for me for nostalgia and the feeling it evokes, but I wouldn't argue that it's diverse or pushing the envelope so I expect others will have it lower. Not everything needs to be groundbreaking though, and having a vocal giant like Sinatra sing a bevy of love songs is a match made in heaven. It's timeless and effortless. The greats are the greats for a reason.
What lead paint does to an mf
Not for me. These songs have been ruined by all the x factor hopefuls thinking they are as good as Sinatra
Classic Sinatra. I am not a fan of him as a person, but he sure had pipes.
3.5! Good fun. Can't get my head past it sounding like Christmas music though.
For as old as this is, it hold up pretty well. You could play it at a wedding and nobody would complain. Many of the well known Sinatra songs
I found this to be a little underwhelming. I guess I'm neither swingin’ nor a lover. It’s all very nice, his voice is smooth, and the band is great, but nothing really captures me and the melodies are so meandering. standout track is: “Love Is Here to Stay”
It was fine - big band just doesn’t do much for me to rate it any higher than a 3 star.
Frank Sinatra was such a charmer! Finding another artist that had the same amount of charisma is almost impossible. The personality he brought to swing and jazz music... there was nobody like him. His voice is so unique and captivating. That being said, as my group member accurately pointed out, this album is rather one note. But to Sinatra's credit, the songs are beautiful and so easy to listen to. I wasn't bored one iota. I enjoyed this so much that my 3.5 is rounded up.
It's kind of wild to be this far into this project and only just now be getting a Frank Sinatra album. Frank definitely had a "formula"; so many of these songs sound pretty similar -- similar pacing, similar arrangements, and ultimately similar subjects. But look, his voice is so buttery and backed by great sound (even if it is kind of repetitive), so it's hard to care too much. His music just undeniably evokes a mood of class. I'm definitely nowhere near the biggest Sinatra fan, but even I'm not immune to his charm.
Very smooth and relaxing music. I listened to it while being on the train and it was quite an awesome experience.
cute
Interesting but feels outdated
could see this as a 5
Pre-listening thoughts: okay Frankie let’s see if you can sing standards better than Ella Fitzgerald (unlikely) Post/during listening thoughts: while I personally don’t think Frank Sinatra’s voice had the emotional depth Ella Fitzgerald’s did, he’s got that silky crooner quality ala Bing Crosby that is impossible for me to dislike. Every song just rolls off his tongue with such ease. The big band arrangements are fun, and complement his voice well. I think I really enjoy pop/vocal jazz from this era. Even though they all sang the same damn songs. I really liked this but shoot I just prefer other people’s versions of some of these songs. 8/10 DID I NEED TO HEAR THIS BEFORE I DIE: ya know I think everyone should hear at least one Frank Sinatra song but maybe not the entire album Fav tracks: You Make Me Feel So Young, Too Marvelous For Words, Love Is Here To Stay, I’ve Got You Under My Skin, Swingin Down the Lane, How About You? Least fav tracks: Pennies From Heaven (they could never touch you Louis Prima), Anything Goes (they could never touch you Patti Lupone)
This is the 63rd album I’m rating. I’ve always liked swing and electro swing. Frank Sinatra has some great songs too. Adding to my Playlist - You Make Me Feel So Young, It Happened in Monterey, You’re Going to be a Habit With Me, You Brought a New Kind of Love to Me, Too Marvelous for Words, Old Devil Moon, Love is Here to Stay, I’ve Got You Under My Skin, I Thought About You, We’ll Be Together Again, Makin’ Whoopee, Swingin’ Down the Lane, Anything Goes, and How About You?. Not Adding to my Playlist - Pennies from Heaven Pennies from Heaven - This is good but I like the Louis Prima version more. All in all I liked 14/15 songs. This was just a really nice chill romantic album. It wasn’t the most interesting but it was very pleasant.
this is frank zappas grandfather
Can't go wrong with Sinatra
it's sinatra, neither good nor bad, doesn't get in the way and is easy in the background while cooking or baking christmas cookies. it's just darn toothless
Nice enough. Can't picture a time where I'd want to listen to anything but a best of though
Love the way Frank sings a song.
Sinatra at his finest. Nailed on Cafe Kelvinos material
It all sounded like the same song tbh. Not a huge fan
Синатра хорош конечно
frankly a very lovely album.
Swingin' from the gallows, maybe... OK, it's not THAT bad, but I can only take so much big band and ol' blue eyes... Furthermore, this can't possibly be the best Frank has to offer, so I don't know what this album is doing on this list... make room for something better...
I don’t really know how to rate this. Didn’t hate it. Didn’t love it. I can respect it. I do feel like it loses its charm as it ages. It’s an album you’d listen to for nostalgia. But you’d be hard pressed to have another emotion while listening to this album.
I have to be in a particular place to appreciate Sinatra, and since I don't drink anymore, I'm never in that place. But I actually enjoyed this. Even more than the Rundgren. 5
Classic crooner.
joa, Franky swingin
I've had this in my queue a long time, but for some reason I couldn't stomach inhabiting the headspace of the legendary old Twinkle Tonsils. Then it came to mind I used to be a big fan of Harry Connick, Jr., whose voice and style tended to bear an uncanny resemblance to Sinatra's. At some point the luster wore away from Mr. Jr., and probably took down any residual enthusiasm I might hold for the Las Vegas Larynx.
This makes me nostalgic for a time I wasn’t alive for
Bello
It was okay, but not my cup of tea. I don't really like that style of music, and it grew old for me.
Sinatra's voice is simply unrivalled. This album gives you exactly what it promises - it's elegant, it's beautiful, it's heartwarming and it makes you swing.
honestly he botched pennies from heaven
<3
I like the happy go lucky I'm having fun and trying to get laid Sinatra allot more then the sad "In the wee hours" Sinatra.
Classic Sinatra
Already got this album
- ich wiederhole mich wahrscheinlich: tolle, entspannte Musik -- vor allem für den Hintergrund - wie Sunny beim letzten Sinatra Album schon schrieb: moody und man fühlt sich direkt wie im Wintermärchen in einem Loft in NY mit Whisky in der Hand (.. etc), kann man gut mal hören, aber eben auch nicht immer 2,75/5
Today, the sound of big band swing and suave jazz vocals is practically synonymous with Frank Sinatra, but when Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! first dropped, this style was more closely associated with Black artists like Nat King Cole, Ella Fitzgerald, and Louis Prima. Sinatra didn’t invent this sound — he borrowed it, polished it, and sold it back to America with a grin and a raised glass. It’s impossible to ignore the racial dynamics at play: the swaggering, urbane style Sinatra rode to career-defining success was built on foundations laid by Black musicians who rarely received the same accolades — or paychecks. Sinatra needed a reinvention after a shaky run at Columbia — and this album gave him one. Partnering with arranger Nelson Riddle, Sinatra didn’t just record a set of standards but also built a whole persona. The Sinatra you picture in your head — tailored suit, cigarette dangling, half a smirk — that’s this Sinatra. Sophisticated but never stuffy, romantic but never sappy, confident with just enough vulnerability to keep it interesting. What’s striking is how easy this album is to love. Every track glows with charm and confidence, epitomizing the “Swingin’ Sinatra” sound — brassy, bold arrangements that walk the line between elegance and swagger. Riddle’s orchestrations are a masterclass in dynamics: playful horn stabs, gentle string swells, and a rhythmic bounce that propels each song forward. Sinatra, in peak vocal form, moves effortlessly between flirtation and heartfelt romance, phrasing every line like it’s a conversation whispered across a candlelit table. His mastery of close-mic technique — a relatively new approach at the time — gives these recordings an unusual warmth and intimacy, even with a full orchestra at his back. The album’s biggest moment — and maybe Sinatra’s career peak — is “I’ve Got You Under My Skin.” That slow-burn arrangement, the building tension, the sharp brass accents, and Sinatra’s immaculate phrasing turn a simple love song into pure cinematic drama. But the brilliance doesn’t stop there. “You Make Me Feel So Young” captures the giddy rush of new love with irresistible bounce, while “Too Marvelous for Words” is charm distilled into three minutes of effortless swing. Even slower moments like “We’ll Be Together Again” show Sinatra’s gift for understatement — he doesn’t oversell the emotion, he just lets it simmer. Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! wasn’t just a personal triumph — it helped redefine what an album could be. Instead of a loose collection of singles, this was a cohesive statement: a fully-formed mood, a curated experience from start to finish. Arriving just as rock ‘n’ roll was rewriting the rules of youth culture, this album became both a pinnacle of sophisticated pop and, in some ways, its farewell. And yet, its influence echoes far beyond mid-century cocktail bars. From the orchestral pop grandeur of Scott Walker to the crooning confidence of contemporary artists like Michael Bublé — who made an entire career out of imitating this schtick — the template Sinatra set here still shapes how we think about the “male vocalist” persona. Even artists outside the genre — from Nick Cave to Arctic Monkeys — have tapped into Sinatra’s blend of bravado and vulnerability. Even if ‘50s pop isn’t your usual thing, this album’s sheer charisma and melodic brilliance make it impossible to resist. Before rock made rebellion the default, Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! proved that charm, swagger, and a perfectly timed wink could be just as dangerous.
Finally, I got a Sinatra album today. The songs of his I've heard before listening to this album were all good. Who doesn't love Sinatra's singing? The main problem with "Songs for Swingin' Lovers" is that the songs have no variety. It would make this album much better. 3 stars for "Songs for Swingin' Lovers".
Streit
Great songs throughout. Great voice. Very relaxing. Stand out song - You make me feel so young
I am not ashamed that I have near more appreciation for jazz. Classical it may be, but not for me.
Beautiful voice and is interesting to hear a full album of his. Certainly, an era I've not listened to much of. Not my modern listening taste but it was a nice change of pace.
Pretty disappointed with this one. Didn’t do much for me at all.
ah, the smooth vocals of ol’ blue eyes. so good.
good. I like Frank Sinatra, but this album is not my cup of tea
C’mon it’s Sinatra. There’s no downside to it, although I’m pretty sure “swingin’”meant something else then.
Anything Goes
classic Frank, baby!
It's Sinatra — how bad can it be? Not the most mindblowing stuff in the world, but a beautiful relic from a time when craftmanship was a central part of pop musiz.
If nothing else, I'm glad this album is on the list so I could experience the song "Makin' Whoopee" in the year 2025. Simply delightful. Sometimes unintentional comedy is the best comedy. I'm also glad that I was forced to listen to at least one Sinatra album in my lifetime. I'll never listen to this again, but I'm glad I did; I enjoyed it more than expected. 3.3
I have listened before and it is fine Sinatra music and I will rarely turn to it.
Cant stand it
I can't imagine a scenario that wouldn't be improved by having this on in the background. Cooking? Check. Palm Springs Pool Party? Check. The end credits of a rom-com? check. Swingin'? DOUBLE CHECK. Speaking of, would you just look at this album cover? An apparition of 'ol blue eyes creepily looking at a couple that's clearly seconds away from get'n it on. I wonder if Diarrhea Planet wrote the song Ghost With a Boner about this album cover.
I remember kissing Frank right on the lips on the vegas part of Houmous & Chutneys world tour. It was like kissing a wet ash tray. Horrible. Len grimaced and said ‘good to see you’re still a bit too samey Frank’ 2.1
It's really just the exact same song 15 times in a row, but it's all endearing enough to get a pass.
great- lasts for a lifetime
Great album! I think the Nelson Riddle arranged albums are his best.
I really like Frank Sinatra. I think one of the key things about him to me is not necessarily his voice, but how well he uses it. He always floats notes in the perfect slot around the musicians. I know he was known for redoing a lot of takes, and I think it pays off. You can almost see how he is dancing around the instruments with his voice. That being said, although there were a lot of great songs on this album, it is unlikely I'd ever throw it on. Even in the most romantic of settings. Let's be honest, I'd only need 1.5 tracks worth of time anyway. 3.5-4/5 I'll go with 4/5.
Great voice, can't hate it.
Sinatra is not my thing. It's me, not Frank. I appreciate his songs when they pop up but I don't own any Sinatra albums.
Absolutely stellar
Good background music, but it’s all the same. Gets a bit doom loopy about half way through when you realise you’ve been listening to effectively the same track 6 times already and there’s more to go.
p30. 1956. 4 stars. The great American songbook, with Frank and Nelson on top form. Absolutely timeless. Point deducted for a lack of any real variety though.
On the late ‘90s/ early 00’s I went through a Rat Pack phase where I was nonstop vocal jazz extending from Dean Martin to Nora Jones. Prominent among them was Frank. The song that drug me into this era was “Under My Skin”, which I still love today. A coworker once told me that Frank wasn’t that great of vocalist and was far overrated. Over the years I realized I don’t disagree about the first part. He wasn’t the best singer. However, he emotes a certain swagger in his music that lent to its authenticity. Sure some of music is campy, (eg, You Make Me Feel So Young), but it was also 1956! Most things were campy. I enjoyed listening to this for a variety of reasons including the music. Most of all, I enjoyed the memories of that curious time in my life dancing to these songs in my own living room with whomever was the date of the day or prepping to head to the martini bar. I can only imagine the feeling this evoked for the generations who listened to this new.
Random thoughts: * Frank Sinatra is easy on the ears. There is a reason he's an all-American classic. * Never listened to an album by Frank before but this one was nice and mellow, I could see having a nice romantic dinner and playing this one again. * I hope my grandparents listened and danced to this music. I could almost see some of those old pictures of them come to life imagining this being played. * Makin' Whoopee is hilarious. I know it's probably not supposed to be funny but I found it quite humorous. * Anything Goes is also so good lyrically as Frank is complaining about all the vulgar words in use now and how ladies can show a bit of their stockings now. Shock! * This album captures a whole vibe of America that is long gone. But damn, what a good listen and way to have a time capsule.
Urgh. Awks. I don’t really see the point in rating this because this was a completely anonymous album for me, but it is blindingly clear why so many people still keel over for it (and for him)
He was one of the best voices ever. If I give this less than 5 stars my dad will come back from the grave and whoop me.
If you want some jazzy crooning, Sinatra's your guy.
Fine album. Frank Sinatra has a beautiful voice and the big band orchestra wonderfully accentuate his songs. A full album is probably a bit more of what I can stomach from a big band vocal artist though. Gotta give it some leeway since it's one of the very oldest albums on the list still.
Sinatra is the definition of mediocrity.
Smoooth
I found myself tapping my feet and singing along but after about 5 tracks it began to sound the same. On it's release in 1956 swing had been around for a while so it's hardly ground breaking and was about to be blown away by rock n roll. Pleasant enough but I won't listen again
Before starting this journey, I did not know I would enjoy Frank Sinatra but I do :) Brings you to another dimension and time and that's what you want from music
yawn
Enjoyable on the whole but did get a bit samey after the first couple of tracks. Enjoyed when the big band was unleashed more than anything else. Favourite tracks: You Make Me Feel So Young Probably not one to revisit. 2/5
Very likable. Frank doesn’t oversell or schmaltz it up too terribly much. His voice is strong and clear and more fluid than elsewhere – perhaps the effect of enjoying himself, which he seems to be doing. So many excellent songs – ”Under My Skin,” “Getting to Be a Habit,” “I Thought About You,” “Makin’ Whoopee,” and “Anything Goes.” One's not a Sinatra fan generally (preferring Tony Bennet), but this is his best in one's view.
L'americano bianco
Niente di particolare da Franco “Non ho alcun legame con le elezioni presidenziali” Sinatra
I've never listened to a full Sinatra album but have heard some of this. I think this album shows his voice off to great effect and also what a showcase for his song interpretation. And hats off to Nelson Riddle as the arrangements are wonderful. I really enjoyed this. Favorites: You Make Me Feel So Young, Too Marvelous for Words, I've Got You Under My Skin, I Thought About You Would I listen to it again: Yes
Good stuff, bunch of songs that I enjoyed
Good, but a little too nostalgic sometimes.
esti sétához a dunaparton ez mármár ijesztően tökéletes. és értem hogy mért lehet utálni Sinatrát, mert más hangulatban/szituációban engem is idegesítene, de omg olyan atmoszférája van ennek, meg olyan ereje, hogy ez majdnem ötös
Nice album. It was a good neutral listen. I can see how this would be banging back in the day.
Perfect!
👍
When I started this I thought "oh, this isn't as boring as I expected", but then it went on, and on, and on with the same shit, feeling much longer than its 44 minute runtime. Most songs were just okay, but the mediocre cover of Pennies From Heaven was disappointing, and I really didn't like Makin' Whoopee.
It's crazy how technology has changed the ways music was recorded, back in the 50's it was set up so the live performance was recorded in studio without overdubs just like the band would do so in a concert hall, if someone made a mistake a take just wouldn't be good enough to be released. In just over 10 years Beach Boys and Beatles would go on to record some incredible albums compared to what was before. Crazy that an album like this(with so many studio session musicians) could only be made nowadays by a major label artist, maybe for the better(?) I've got you under my skin had 22 takes(not all of them were of the full song) before Sinatra was satisfied with his performance, what a bad luck for the trombone player. 6/10
this shit works on me. it's the kind of music that makes me do a little dance in the kitchen while I'm making breakfast. maybe give my partner a lil kiss. I guess I'm a swingin lover! with that said I don't think sinatra works in an album format.
I’ve always had a soft spot for Frank Sinatra, not least because I grew up with his voice as the backdrop to my childhood. My mother would play Sinatra in the kitchen while she cooked, filling our home with his smooth, swinging melodies. That nostalgic connection has forever linked me to his music, yet when I listen to Songs For Swingin’ Lovers! now, I find that while it brings back fond memories, it doesn’t fully meet my expectations as an adult listener. Despite these positives, there are notable drawbacks. The overall sound of the album feels very dated to me. Listening to it now, it seems like a relic from another era, and the style hasn’t aged as gracefully as I would have hoped. The songs, while technically sound, can come across as monotonous. There isn’t much dynamic variation in Sinatra’s delivery—often, his performance feels subdued, lacking the spark or excitement that might have been more engaging at the time. Moreover, the arrangements, although rich in detail, sometimes overwhelm the vocals rather than complementing them, leaving little room for the emotional nuances that I once connected with. The overall pacing of the album can feel sluggish, making it hard to stay fully engaged throughout its entirety. Songs For Swingin' Lovers! holds a special place in my heart because of the fond memories associated with it. My mother’s love for Sinatra introduced me to a world of smooth melodies and elegant swing, which I still admire from a distance. However, in my current listening experience, the album feels a bit like a time capsule. nice to reminisce over, but not something I would actively seek out. For me, it’s a solid 3.1/5 a nostalgic gem that unfortunately hasn’t quite kept up with the test of time.
White Nah just like... this is bgm that only white people liked in the 40s/50s. Saying this as a white dude. Great performances I'd say, but so forgettable. I can't remember anything about it other than how similar it was to everything else on it. Historically significant tho. I guess I'm not a swingin' lover. Damn.
Sinatra's greatest sin remains the largely indistinguishable number of auditions of America's Got Talent for which his legacy is responsible.
6/10 It’s a Frank Sinatra album, it’s nice while it’s on, there’s hundreds of people working to make every song sound nice, hundreds of songwriters ensuring Frank has something to talk about, and Frank does his job. It’s sweet, it’s got some fuzzy parts, but ultimately it’s from 1956, we have yet to have an important Pop music structure, a good album structure, and songs that want to make sure you’re going out of your way to listen to them. Frank is important, and he was trying to be ahead of the curb, but unless you’re really into Traditional Pop music, he really is held back by his era. Did you know Frank Sinatra’s last words were "I'm losing it"? Isn’t that fucked up or what? Anyways, here’s Wonderwa