Reviews (page 4 of 14)
Didn't get them when I was young and I still don't . Awful . Listened to the remastered version and it was terrible so dread to think what it was like first time round . First track was dreadful and it got progressively worse . I just knew from the title that A Day in the Life of a Tree was going to be dire . Can I give it a zero ?
Absolute garbage. Could not wait for it end.
Did not expect it to be so upbeat cause of the album cover. Album was a nice surprise and honestly didn't think I would like it that much but I did.
This albus shows almost everything I hate about the music of the seventies. Nice album cover artwork by the way.
I appreciated this more experimental album sound and culturally relevant songs but it just wasn't what I wanted to listen to right now. The track Surf's Up is absolutely angelic, however!
OMG LOVE THAT MOVIE FAVS (top 3): long promised road, disney girls, 'till i die mençoes honrosas: student demonstration time, lookin' at tomorrow curti cara, o começo n é mt chamativo mas o meio fica legal e quando passa do meio vc ta meio hypado entao o fim tambem fica legal :D nota final: 3.5/5
Enjoyed this, perfect for a Sunday morning
Enjoyed this, different to other beach boy albums
A treat, thank you RGP…Right up there towards the top of the three stars. Tom.
"LoOk GuYs WeRe ExPeRiMeNtAl"
Beautiful album great work. Favorite song was Disney girl.
This was fascinating, at multiple points I forgot I was listening to The Beach Boys because it just feels like such a departure from what they’re known for. I saw the title and thought, this must be the album stuff like Surfin USA come from but boy was I wrong. Fascinating listen and an incredible album!
Would’ve a fine example of this era if it was not an album from “The Beach Boys”. Made me think the only reasons this is on this list is the fire album cover and to make you further appreciate the impact of Brian Wilson. Looking forward to being assigned better, more sonically rich albums from their catalogue
Not loving this album and wondering how it made the list. And I am a fan of the Beach Boys. 2 stars. Fave track - Surfs up (an absolute standout from a mediocre album)
Didn't get it. Not your typical beach boys. Give us at least one song with a beat.
This was a beach boys revelation for me, havibg obly been familiar with greatest hits i kinda thought they were a one trick pony. But this album had depth, musicality & a touch of thr Eagles at times
Am I being pranked? That album art is rad af and they deliver this?
A difficulty with the Beachy Boys, as a drunken friend got a festival crowd in Serbia to chant, is their built-in anachronism, their syrupy harmonies made for crooning dreamy, slightly deranged ballads being applied to baroque, sentimental arrangements can come across as kitsch, insincere or creepy. This one’s interesting because it leans into the latter. “Feel Flows” is the best song here. An uneven record, better for it, better than I expected.
Appalling, but in a different way to your usual Beach Boys rubbish. Here they try to meld psychedelic whimsy and social commentary (god help us) with their usual puerile drivel and end up coming a close second to William Shatner's "The Transformed Man" for the lamest incongruous effort of the hippy era (at least Bill is funny, deliberately?). Pleased to see Brian confirming his genius here from the back seat, with a great "beep beep" sound effect at the obvious point in the shocking "Take A Load Off Your Feet", almost as masterly as the concluding train sample in Pet Sounds. Don't Worry Baby, I think we're now done with this cabal of morons.
A few ham fisted songs with a message but there are some real gems in there
Much different than the Beach Boy sound that I am used to. A heavier album talking about protest and politics. I checked twice to make sure I was still on the album.
A more darker side of The Beach Boys that I really appreciated! Loved this one!
So much better that I expected
I think it’s cool how this is so different from the Beach Boys stuff I was familiar with previously. It just didn’t really catch me personally but hey, different strokes for different folks.
I did not realize the Beach Boys were like this. A rabbit hole to explore later
Everything on this album was new to me, and I had to listen to it twice after seeing some low reviews to make sure I wasn't missing something. This is so good, experimental pop in peak form with definitely some stuff that falls on the wrong side of the fine line between clever and stupid, ie Student Demonstration Time. But otherwise really great stuff, standouts were Feel Flows and Disney Girls. Rounding down for Student Demonstration Time.
The lyrics on this album are so terrible and heavy handed, it’s like they decided they needed to do a socially conscious album but had absolutely nothing to say. I also felt like the gorgeous layered harmonies that the Beach Boys are known for are missing, all in all quite disappointing.
It is pretty music, I just can never get into the beach boys. Feel like I just don’t get it (and never have)
It’s not bad just found it a bit boring, I sort of understand some of the messages in the songs but just didn’t really connect with it. I guess it’s quite bluesy and different from their big hits but found all the songs to sound quite samey apart from the student one. A high 2-Star from me.
Good
Kinda feels like the passion was gone by this point
This certainly ain't Surfin' in the USA. This Beach Boys album comes off as more serious and experimental VS what one thinks a Beach Boys album should sound like. Frankly I need to spoend more time with this but it might be my new favorite Beach Boys album.
I like that there was anti war sentiment in some lyrics. One thing I noticed was how multi-layered most of the songs were. 3 outta 5
Interesting record, the cover is awesome. There’s just not quite anything super memorable on here
grata sorpresa
interesting - some blues, some downtempo. still some falsetto too
niceeee
Not my cup of tea but there are a few standout tracks.
Super nice. I like.
Most difficult to rate
Inget som riktigt fastnade hos mig. Andra halvan bättre. Feel flows var skön. Förväntade mig mer från Beach Boys faktiskt
Okay, this was a different Beach Boys sound (kinda) than I grew up with, the cover said as much. It's not something I want to listen to again, but I'm glad I heard this.
Much better than I expected. Pretty relaxing. I listen to it in the background, so I would recommend it.
Langweiliges Werk der 70er. Wenig Spirit wenig Spaß .. dunkel wie das Cover irgendwie ein Album gemacht um Kohle zu scheffeln..
This album is so weird? Not rly Beach Boys vibes, but also maybe this is just Brian Wilson’s weird dark underbelly that he needed to throw out there? Student demonstration time was a flop, but everything else at least had me intrigued…
The artwork for "Surf's Up" has always been a favourite of mine - striking enough to make you curious about what lies inside. However, the music is a bit of a mixed bag. While it’s a pleasant three-star experience, it falls short of being an 'essential' listen. The highlights are saved for the very end with '’Til I Die' and 'Surf’s Up', but these are undermined by two tracks - 'Take a Load Off Your Feet' and 'Student Demonstration Time' - that simply don't fit the mood. It’s a schizophrenic record that lacks a cohesive identity. To my ears, it feels like a 'me too' project, chasing the trends of the time rather than leaning into the unique spirit that defined the band's best work. Side one 1 "Don't Go Near the Water" (4/5) 2 "Long Promised Road" (4/5) 3 "Take a Load Off Your Feet" (2/5) 4 "Disney Girls (1957)" (3/5) 5 "Student Demonstration Time" (2/5) Side two 1 "Feel Flows" (3/5) 2 "Lookin' at Tomorrow (A Welfare Song)" (3/5) 3 "A Day in the Life of a Tree" (3/5) 4 "'Til I Die" (5/5) 5 "Surf's Up" (5/5) Total - 34 Average - 3.4 256/1001 139/256 albums reviewed were new to me
they have a talent of putting the most gorgeous song you’ve ever heard right next to the most embarrassing thing you’ve ever heard 😭 obligatory: what the fuck student demonstration time
Aburrido
Really solid album with resistance and climate change activity at the forefront of it's ideals. Don't go near the water and Day in the life of a tree are really good and solid examples of this. Student demonstration time is a good song about the resistance in colleges and schools which i think resounds especially well at the moment.
This was kind of a weird album. About half of the songs I really loved, but the other half I hated. I think the track that stood out to me the most was Long Promised Road and I can see why it was released as the first single from the album.
Gar nicht bemerkt das dies BEach Boys isrt, fand die Musik gut und die Säner auch
Not for me. Started crap, picked up here and there but was largely uninteresting.
Mu bueno Mu bueno Mu bueno Mu bueno
Never appreciated the skills and craftsman’s ship of this band. Now I do
The "underrated Beatles." 10/10
This really just wasn’t anything interesting. The songwriting was nowhere near as good as what I recall from pet sounds (haven’t run into it on the list yet) and the whole thing just felt a little flat.
I can’t believe an album from The Beach Boys, a band I loathe, was the best offering all weekend. Way more heavy blues and tuned down guitars than I was expecting on this album, but vocally I still greatly dislike them. They still sound too much like a barbershop quartet a lot of the time. Best I can do is a 3/5 for some of the interesting instrumental work
как-то смазанно мне не зашло хотя у бич бойс есть хорошие релизы, но в целом пойдет
The Beach Boys – Surf’s Up Es un disco complicado de valorar con una sola escucha. Con Pet Sounds recuerdo que casi todas las canciones me parecieron himnos desde el primer momento; aquí no me ha pasado eso. En la primera escucha solo me entraron claramente Don’t Go Near the Water y Long Promised Road. En la segunda ya empiezo a apreciar más detalles y melodías bonitas —por ejemplo Disney Girls (1957) tiene un aire muy nostálgico y elegante—, pero sin llegar a parecerme canciones increíbles o memorables al instante. Me da la sensación de que es un álbum más sutil y menos inmediato, quizá algo irregular, aunque con ambición y momentos muy cuidados. Es posible que crezca con más escuchas, pero de momento no me ha impactado como otros discos del grupo. Nota: 3/5 (con margen de crecer).
tiene gracia que los Beach Boys sean mejores cuanto más triste están
4,5/5
Nunca afondei na discografía dos Beach Boys. Nunca entrei nela máis alá do aclamado Pet Sounds e nin sequera me lembro da última vez que o escoitei completo. Non porque non me gusten, senón porque o tempo é finito e non hai sempre capacidade para abarcar todo o que un quere. Ten a parte mala de que vivín estes trinta e un anos (e oito meses) alleo a discos coma este Surf's up. Ten a parte boa de que aínda hai marxe para que un álbum que leva publicado cincuenta e cinco anos me voase a cabeza nunha primeira escoita nada máis comezou a soar 'Don't Go Near the Water'. Pareceume unha marabilla. Psicodelia, clasicismo, pop, unha banda irrepetible adentrándose no inexplorado. Confeso tamén que se me apagou o cerebro a medio disco (despois de 'Disney Girls') porque estou desfeito de embalar, cargar e descargar caixar cidade arriba e cidade abaixo, pero volvín conectar no tramo final cun trío fantástico de cancións de peche. Foi a miña primeira visita, mais seguro que non a última (é máis, a segunda xa está a ser mentres redacto isto) (#22 dos 1.001 discos que escoitar antes de morrer: 4/5)
desalentadorb
Weird literal lyrics. Mediocre songs. 4/10
Oddly enough, I just can't get into The Beach Boys. I know Pet Sounds is widely considered a masterpiece. Even Paul McCartney has claimed that "God Only Knows" is the greatest song ever written. But the sound of The Beach Boys, while very pretty, just doesn't appeal to me as a listener beyond a few of the early singles. My first casual listen to Surf's Up left me ambivalent. I just didn't care. My close listen through headphones was much more interesting. The arrangements, production, and performances are just stellar. No one should ever deny that The Beach Boys' harmonies are top-notch. In rock and roll, only Crosby, Stills, and Nash have better male harmonies if you ask me. And this record has a much more mature feel. It sounds like the Dark Beach Boys from an alternate universe. I came closer to liking this record than even Pet Sounds, but something about it still felt contrived to me. I wasn't surprised when I read up on the album's history and learned that it was deliberately created to shift the group back into the early '70s mainstream "counterculture" zeitgeist. The result is a gorgeous album with a lot to love. But something just feels off to me, inauthentic. To me, this album has a five-star sound with a three-star execution. Let's split the difference and give it four stars.
really enjoyed this. nice to have a summery feel like this
very short and very forgettable. though it was nice to hear a totally different vibe and sound than the one on 'pet sounds', this one is a little more dark and wistful.
cool
Не стал углубляться.
How perfect of a coincidence i get this album the day i see Al Jardine make a quick guest appearance on one of my favorite podcasts and he talks a TINY bit about this! This is as Tim Heidecker calls it “the reccord all the hipsters like” and i’d be right with them i guess.
I’m glad the boys had it in them to make an album this weird even if I didn’t enjoy it all that much in the end. I think you have to be able to willing to try stuff like this if you are also going to be a band good enough to make Pet Sounds.
Really good stuff
Second best Beach Boys album. Enjoyed it a lot
There was an unexpected blues banger in this. Not the cheesey pop i was expecting. Song about a tree was weird but good. Student demo my fave song. Harmonies were banging tbf - 'til i die especially.
beach boys!
AKA the Beach Boys get weird and sad. This has an odd sound but a couple good ones. Top tracks: "Feel Flows," "Don't Go Near the Water," "Student Demonstration Time"
--Don't Go Near the Water...an environmentalist ditty --Long Promised Road...solid rocker --Take a Load Off Your Feet...yeah, Pete! --Disney Girls (1957)...sweet, maybe too sweet --Student Demonstration Time...love that guitar intro. nice distortion. pretty straight forward blues but it works. Mike Love still sucks --Feel Flows...always appreciate a flute but this wanders aimlessly --Lookin' at Tomorrow (A Welfare Song)...interesting production choice, not sure if it enhances the song but it adds spice to the album --A Day in the Life of a Tree...Treebeard? --'Til I Die...bonus points for using "'til" instead of "till". this track is nice 'n' lush --Surf's Up...Van Dyke Parks making presence known. wonderful harmonies
A strange but strangely beautiful later career album from The Beach Boys. Gone are the days of fun loving surf rock. This is building on the precedent.set by the experimental "Pet Sounds". But it's not simply Brian Wilson at the helm, although his work is clearly present. All of the members have their stake in trying to stay relevant after the late 60s. It may not be their best work and certainly not their best known. But this is more evidence that The Beach Boys were one of the most significant bands of their era.
I think you can separate the Beach Boys into pre- and post-Charles Manson. Tonally this is definitely post-Manson, and you get that just from the cover art alone.
A little better than the earlier stuff
I like the classic Beach Boys sound. I don’t know what this is - it is not Beach Boys.
Okay, not my style
I had only listened to their very early works and Pet Sounds, so this was my first time hearing this album. It's also been a while since I last listened to The Beach Boys themselves, but their vocals and harmonies are as pleasing as ever, with a beautiful timbre that sounds great. However, it's far from perfect.
I have never heard of this album or any of the tracks on it. This is not the Beach Boys I knew. This is a reinvention and it works. This album is filled with social messages and it works.
Liked it more than pet sounds
I really liked it, especially the first half of the album. It's a great time capsule for the times when it was released, but the second half was a bit too slow compared with the first one, would've probably preferred it switched the other way around more, but still had a good time.
I do not get the hype behind Beach Boys. Never did. This feels like the soundtrack to a bad fever dream I'd have after dunking a 4-pack of the strongest beer near me. Even the 2009 mix makes me feel like I'm listening to a detoriated tape on my uncle's broken Walkman. I still don't know whether it's my ears or the recording itself.
Loved Feel Flows(listened to several times) and Surfs Up, most everything else was a bit druggy in a bad way and preachy, however I agreed with the sentiments.
I don't really get the Beach Boys. Like Pet Sounds I do get, but the rest of the Wilson's output is kinda whatever. Must be a me thing. I guess I like when they get all barbershop a capella-y? Like the song Surf's Up is magnificent at least - very melancholic, like the feeling of a faded summer polaroid from memories half-remembered and evenings coming to their inevitable end. Fav tracks: Surf's Up, A Day In The Life Of A Tree
- 0 nummers toegevoegd aan MMMM - 0 nummers al toegevoegd aan MMMM
the album art really screams "SURF'S UP!" and beyond that the music is fine, and other than the weird nonsense lyrics about ecology and garage wine, there's nothing here that really perks my ears up. I'm longing for the falsetto harmonies of the 60s.
Loved
Don’t love this anywhere near as much as pet sounds for a punchy album I got bored?
Pretty good pretty gooood
Definitely not for me!
Candidly I need to listen to more of the beach boys. I really haven’t dove in as I haven’t been compelled by the small sample I’ve heard and purely rely on their historical significance and popularity as my reason to listen to more. This album broke the mold of what I thought they were and I liked that. It’s definitely not my favorite album in the world but I can see myself returning to this and liking it the more I listen to it.
honestly… boring
I haven’t listened to much of the Beach Boys, but this is more dense and “Beatles-esque” than I expected. The album art is a bit dark and somewhat captures the vibe. Great song writing. I enjoyed this! 3.5/5.0
I bet a lot of people saw the title of this album and thought it was going to be a collection of happy, cheesy surf-rock songs, but instead, this album is something else entirely. This may possibly be my favourite Beach Boys album, even though it is not as perfect as Pet Sounds. I mean, Pet Sounds doesn't have Mike Love attempting to rewrite Riot In Cell Block 9 in the middle of it. But there are many beautiful moments to be found on the record and I love nearly every minute of it (even Student Demonstration Time kinda slaps, even though it is very out of place). Also, it has the only great song sung from the perspective of a fucking tree.
Not super memorable but generally good
Pretty cool, surprisingly rocky, and bluesy.
A somber psychedelic pop/folk album. Lots of songs here focus on environmental and political concerns. A gripping, beautiful listen. One of the most fitting album covers I've seen to capture the mood of a record. 4/5.
This was a really solid album. There was a lot of really fun instrumentation, and there's just something that feels very of its time about it. It's vintage in a way that makes it very enjoyable for a modern listener. Favorites: Don't Go Near the Water, Student Demonstration Time, Surf's Up
this band is so mid man
So very different, to ally and thematically, from other Beach Boys albums. I’m not their biggest fan, I do think this album is better than the others I’ve heard, but still not sold. Between a 2 and a 3, I’ll upgrade to 3 for the surprise.
I enjoyed the album, but it was not what I was expecting from the Beach Boys. The songs were not typical of the Beach Boys, but I liked the various styles and different themes: social, health, and environmental which were addressed by the songs.
très agréable à écouter et le cover art waw
Only familiar with Pet Sounds and Smile, so this was a treat and a banger. A rather raw edge for the Beach Boys.
I wasn't familiar with this record prior to this listening. But I liked it a lot. It is a different style of beach boys, made evident by the first track telling us Don't Go Near the Water.
The Beach Boys – Surf's Up (1971) On Day 52, Surf's Up felt like a bit of a mixed bag. I really enjoyed Pet Sounds, but this one didn't quite hit the same heights. There’s something missing from the sweet production and the vocal blend that I usually associate with them. It gets quite political and heavy with its environmental themes, which takes away from the overall musical enjoyment for me. It’s a decent listen and the musicianship is obviously there, but it’s not something I’ll be rushing back to. A solid 3/5.
First of all love the cover given it's something never expected from the California Girls guys. The album is all over the place and contrasts with a Pet Sounds which is such a cohesive album. Either way I'll give it a five given it has some of my all time favorite songs.
I liked this album. I didn’t like every single thing about it, but it is definitely more mature than the early sixties songs of theirs. I was never a big fan of the Beach Boys, but I have to admit this is definitely worth listening to. Solid 4 for me.
After plenty of attempts at listening to the Beach Boys, perhaps I wasn't looking at the right albums. I'm used to Pet Sounds and their 60s stuff that I've had people point me to the direction of Surf's Up as the Beach Boys that I would probably like the most. And while they're kind of right, I'm coming to the conclusion that the Beach Boys are simply Not For Me. I'm not that big fan of their classic harmonies and the fiendishly whimsical music really just makes me feel more indifferent about it. I don't hate or dislike it, it just doesn't gravitate my attention That attitude keeps going through Surf's Up, instead of annoying harmonies it's just slower and kind of more acceptable to listen to. The songwriting is absolutely a step above here and is probably some of their best stuff (save for that one song I'll get to in a second). I think Pet Sounds is still better with my own meaningless personal criticism aside. I know how important this album is, but I can't really care that much more about this band. I'm not a pop guy. Also the Mike Love student song was really cringe. Could have been an acceptable 4 but that definitely had to stop it from being thought about in that rank. If you like the Beach Boys and that sort of pop music deconstructed from its "safe" 60s sound to the then modestly ominous period of the early 70s, this is the album. I can't care for it. Worth a "must hear or die" listen? Certainly.
Not my vibe, but I get it
65. ok
Kind of socially conscious but in kind of stilted ways? And a lot of it is lacking that strong beach boys harmony. Still, it’s good chill listening.
Well that was a pleasant surprise; I haven't listened to much past the big hits.
I haven’t really listened to the beach boys much, apart from the popular one. But I was pleasantly surprised by this. It was so dense and not the poppy album I was expecting. I would listen again. I really enjoyed how sad this can sound despite how upbeat Brian Wilson’s voice is. But the more I listened to it the more haunting I found the harmonies.
This was fun, all weird and dotty. I enjoyed it, but probably not enough substance to get me to listen again. Just a few strange tunes.
Only rating this a 3, but I did find it an interesting and worthwhile listen. I consider myself a casual Beach Boys enjoyer but I don't think I've ever heard anything off of this album before. Maybe that shouldn't be surprising for a band with 29 studio albums, but - with this being one of just a few Beach Boys albums picked for the 1,001 list - I would think I'd recognize something. Some hits, some misses. "Long Promised Road" is my favorite track. "Hit hard at the battle that's confronting me, yeah." It doesn't sound much like the Beach Boys to me - except for some very Beach Boys "baa baa baa baa"s in the background. "Don't Go Near the Water" and "A Day in the Life of a Tree" are both good. I don't like "Take a Load Off Your Feet" or the Kent State song.
O fost normal
More matured than the early albums.
Surprisingly good, especially for a Besch Boys album I’d never heard of before. Several songs took on political themes, as far as I know a new development for them, even if the lyrics were a little more simplistic than their norm.
Not my thing
Surprisingly poignant
Fast 5 aber knapp noch eine 4/5
better than i expected and there was a song about feet.
Sure
"Brian will always be my hero and Mike, well Mike is a villain for sure."
What an album. It’s starts with the odd Don’t Go Near the Water. I’m sure it was an honest plea to fight water pollution but they chose toothpaste and soap to attack. Take a load off your feet was another odd song. Just odd lyrics. The reworking of a blues song to create the protest song Student Protest Time. When I started listening I thought okay this is a pro-protest song but then by the end I was left unsure. Also some of the do-dos were a bit too happy for such heavy subject matter. But I liked Til I Die and Surf’s Up. There was something about both those song that grabbed me. The lyrics were good too. I also liked Disney Girls.
I'm not the biggest Beach Boy's fan in the world. They're fine, and I wouldn't say I dislike them or anything; I actually do enjoy the harmonizing. But I don't really gravitate toward their very "beach-forward" aesthetic at all...and honestly, how many songs really need to be written about the beach, or the sun, or surfing? Surf's Up is kind of intriguing though. The cover art vibe here seems to exist in stark contrast to literally everything I know about the Beach Boys. The record even seems like a bit of a downer, which counterintuitively actually makes me really happy. I still don't think the lyrics are that deep, but at least they're headed more in a direction I can actually jibe with. This feels like their effort toward something a little more authentic and existential than everything else I've heard from them. It's still not gonna be the thing that I rush to listen to, but it does get points for its attempt at depth. And like always, the production is really good. 7/10
good album, some good songs on it, felt more intimate than other albums
AHHHHHHHHHH
Disney Girl(1959)
Nostalgic even though I’ve never heard it before
Standout tracks: Long promised road Disney girls (1957) A day in the life of a tree 'Til I die Surf's up This album isnt at all what i was expecting and was way better than what i thought i was getting in to. A really great listen with some memorable moments.
Not my favorite Beach Boys album, I guess they left their best work on the 16 records prior to this one
This album is such a 70s vibe! Definitely more of an atmosphere than something I feel compelled to listen to super critically. But everything is varied enough that I can listen and enjoy and tune in and out and not feel like I've missed something. Love Disney Girls Looking at the track list, I'm not sure that I've heard any of these songs before, which is super fun. I feel like The Beach Boys are one of those groups that I know who they are and I can name a few songs, but I haven't listened to a very large chunk of their discography. A Day in the Life of a Tree is a weird song. Till I Die is also pretty weird. Overall thoughts: I think I liked the sound of this album, but didn't actually enjoy listening to it all that much. I like the front half much better than the second half. Once again, I'm not familiar enough with The Beach Boys to know if this is typical or if this album is more the exception.
This was nice, but truthfully I had no idea when the album ended and other “similar songs” started playing. This was nice to make dinner to, but nothing really snagged me like “gotta hear that banger again!” And then all of a sudden I look and it’s old Simon and Garfunkel again instead of the boys who beach. Three stars.
Some good songs here, but also some real doozies. Maybe I don’t get it but A Day in the Life of a Tree and Student Demonstration Time came off as jokey. A song about Kent State that sounded like Bad to the Bone? Also, does anybody think that the end of These Things I’ll Be Til the Day I Die is kind of like “I Got Soul But I’m Not a Soldier”?
Overall a really fun album but oh my god what a stinker “student demonstration time” is
Shoulda stopped after Pet Sounds
This is certainly a strange album. Anyone going into this expecting cheery songs about surfing and girls is going to be very confused. I became obsessed with this album after Brian Wilson passed. I was lured in by the dark cover that you wouldn't expect from the Beach Boys. With the top-notch production and gorgeous harmonies, this still sounds like the band, but there is something darker lurking under the surface. The songs are mostly about pollution. 'A Day In The Life Of A Tree' is sung from the perspective of a dying tree. Although that may sound corny, there's something about the combination of the pained vocals and the organ that makes me feel so incredibly sad. 'Disney Girls (1957)' and 'Student Demonstration Time' are by far the worst tracks here, with the former song being a tacky Disney endorsement and the latter being a dated take on the civil unrest of the time. Post-Pet Sounds Beach Boys are such an interesting band. They continued to experiment and got varying results, but this album is a winner despite the weak cuts.
This was... interesting. Definitely not the Beach Boys I'm used to. Enjoyed the first bit then sort of lost interest. Would be a good one to relisten to.
It’s definitely a very different sound for The Beach Boys, not one that I can say I got overly excited about
Solid start but lost me at the end A bit to dreamy
I'm not really into this type of music, but this was an interesting listen (I even felt compelled to listen twice). It has public service messages (take care of your teeth because no one else will), social justice announcements (student demonstrations and the environment), and dark tones mixed in. I had heard of the Beach Boys, and I knew they were known for surf music, but this was better than I expected.
El que más me ha gustado de los Playus hasta ahora
Lo-fi Beach Boys, I dig this. Wasn’t aware of this record before but this one is a nice twist to what I’m used to with this group. Still the nice vocal harmonies and pleasant instrumentation, but just lower production quality, which I actually like a lot. This is a good one.
I didn't realize how prolific The Beach Boys were. This album is phenominal.
This was kind of sold to me as The Beach Boys' sad album, but I think that aspect made have been a little oversold. That being said, at its best, Surfs Up *does* capture some of the strung out darkness underscoring the psychedelic movement. Don't Go Near The Water, 'Til I Die, and Surfs Up feel less like marmalade skies and more like sinking helplessly. But, at the same time, there are a lot of songs here I don't find nearly as memorable. Feel Flows, Lookin' At Tomorrow, and A Day In The Life Of A Tree did not leave nearly as strong an impression on me, even though they are similarly well crafted. Also, I liked Student Demonstration Time, but it does kind of come out of nowhere. On the other hand, a somg that doesn't quite fit the vibe that I liked a lot is Take A Load Off Your Feet, which has some really cool soundscape work. Overall, I enjoyed Surfs Up as a whole, but it kind of feels like it's being carried by a few extremely strong songs, but the other ones aren't necessarily taking a ton away from the whole. I'm feeling middle of the road overall.
pretty whatever.
Such a cool album! Very different from the usual Beach Boys pop. More melancholy feel overall. A lot of great songs here. "Student Demonstration Time" and "Lookin' At Tomorrow (A Welfare Song)" were my favorites. Still hold up today!
Mediocre
This is #day539 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and... here's to my second Beach Boys album on this list. Revisiting this one after getting The Beach Boys Today! on my #day814, well, today. Probably one of those oldies bands I'll never fully wrap my head around. Compared to "Today," I find this record more interesting, though. I'm not sure if I'd describe it as pensive and somber, but that's what crossed my mind while listening to it. Let it be a 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day540.
Spacy groovy beach boys.
Obviously not the go to Beach Boys album but a great find. All the trademark harmonies but a bit weirder. Nearly gave this a high 4 but by the time it hits the incredible 1-2 of Til I Die and Surf’s Up I had to give it a 5.
Bändi on tuttu alku aikoijensa hiteistään ja jokunen levy löytyy hyllystä. Tämä ei kyllä kolahtanut millään tasolla. Aika väsynyt tekele.
i'm feeling like a hater today so i'm going to give it a 2. listen, there are nice songs on here. keyword nice. i personally found myself bored for a good portion of it
Took me a little while to get on the wavelength as it feels very different from the Beach Boys I know. Some very interesting and solid songwriting. Feels like a Weezer influence.
Not what I expected, and waaay better for it - a wide range of themes, styles, moods and sounds
Fine. Sounds dated. 3/5
This is the last Beach Boys album on the list for me, thank god. And they saved worst for last. While I understood the inclusion of the other two albums (even if I didn't enjoy them) this one is just? Bad. Sounds like studio outtakes they forgot to do any work on and just released them. The music is bad, the vocals are bad, the album cover would work more for some metal band instead 1/5
I can’t imagine there are many bands that can create something great for their 17th studio album. They are obviously trying something new to reinvigorate their sound, but it’s just odd and unpleasant to listen to, outside of one or two decent tunes. I’m sure we’ll get plenty more Beach Boys to see how we feel about them overall.
There is no denying the influence the Beach Boys had on the music industry, but I don’t think this was the album to do it. This is a far cry from the beach music with catchy beats that they are known for. This album felt more like a collection of hymnals and i wasn’t impressed. Not knocking the band, but this wasn’t their best work at all.
It’s important to push your boundaries and try new things … and sometimes the experiment doesn’t work.
I'm not a big fan of the Beach Boys. I think it's because my first exposure was in the 80s when they were already old and doing goofy surf music nostalgia for the boomers who were into them in the 60's. I've softened on them over the years and appreciate their music a bit more, but still not much of a fan. I say all that to say I didn't expect to like the album, and I was right. I didn't like it. My surprise was the reason I disliked it. This wasn't goofy surf rock, this was just odd and strange. Apart from a few decent songs I was scratching my head wondering what the heck was happening. The exception being Feel Flows, legit good song with a blazing flute solo (not being ironic, genuinely enjoyed it). Granted with the Beach Boys my bar is very low, but that may be my new favorite Beach Boy song.
achei maneiro, coeso, salvei duas músicas, na conhecia a banda nem o álbum
This album was definitely not what I was expecting. Not having the full context, I’m sure I missed some of what lead others to find this album special. I get that the band was trying to give themselves an edge and address current issues. However for me this was not successful. The lyrics really missed the mark on most tracks and paired with the preppy boy band sound I couldn’t help but feel these were crafted for various public service announcements. 2/5
1970’s Beach Boys LPs are pretty much the definition of hit and miss. In truth Surf’s Up’s no different, until, that is, we come to the final three Brian Wilson penned tracks: “A Day In The Life Of A Tree” – a strangely moving lament seen from the perspective of a tree in crisis, dying slowly from the pollution in the air and soil - quite brilliant. “Til I Die” a lovely, melancholy study on existential irrelevance and man’s meaningless journey to the grave, and the title track, originally conceived during the Smile sessions, is a lyrically obstruse sheard of luscious, harmonious psychedelic pop, simultaneously both tenuous and beautifully considered. It’s peak Brian Wilson, post Pet Sounds. As for the rest, “Student Demonstration Time” is Mike Love being Mike Love, Bruce Johnston’s “Disney Girls (1957)” is both humorous and touching, and a highlight. Opener “Don't Go Near The Water” is desperately worthy and “Take A Load Off Your Feet” is Al Jardine’s tribute to his plates. Smashing. 7/10
Not the Beach Boys I'm used to. Definitely a more political take and protest rock than their other album. Not great, but not horrible. 3/10
Makes sense why I've never heard any of these songs, despite liking the Beach Boys. A weird one from them, like a whole album of B-sides.
Better than I expected as I’m not a big fan of their music.
Can I just say that that album cover is terrifying? This is a Beach Boys record, it shouldn't be haunting me??? Anyways this album is actually really good! Usually when i think of the Beach Boys its just old timey surfing and beaches and all that innocence, but this is a very rich album with dreamy or invigorating songs and it was just the right length for you to feel good about it. 9/10
That was nice but not great... i think i'm not gonna particulary enjoy any of the albums here. I'll try to stick around for my my musical culture...
Pretty solid 4 stars. Great songs with a melancholy vibe. Student Demonstration is stupidly out of place in the album but I quite like the song by itself.
Solid album from a great band. Really shocked I had never heard student demonstration time.
I didnt know what to expect from the Beach Boys but I was surprised by the content in this album. Very progressive song lyrics and the guitar and the vocals are nice. I think I liek Student Demonstration Time and A Day in the Life of a Tree the best. Some tracks are very energetic while some are more slow and ethereal. 7.2/10 Also, just realized I've been messing up by out of 10 ratings with the five star system lol.
The first Beach Boys album I actually liked
I liked day in the life of a tree and feel flows. Was this before beach boys found their sounds? Didn’t recognize any of the hits but maybe surfs up the title track?
Sad beach boys.
240626 23:46 4
Simplesmente amo esse álbum. Conheci muitos anos atrás quando ouvi "Feels Flows" na trilha de "Quase Famosos". É um álbum refinado dos Beach Boys, mas tem um tom mais melancólico, o que não é muito comum deles. "Disney Girls" me emociona demais e acho uma das melhores da banda. Arranjos complexos e bonitos, vozes macias e letras reflexivas, não tem música ruim aqui. Além das citadas, ainda destaco "Surfs Up", "Long Promised Road", "Lookin at tomorrow" e "Till I Die". É quase um Greatest Hits de uma fase muito específica da banda.
The Beach Boys always had something good to say. But not the best for their style, and not best of the time.
fav track: student demonstration time
Tom a while to tune into this. Surf’s up sounds like the Beach Boys I’d expect to hear. Great doubling of bass in the Piano bass in the outro. Getting under the skin of that made the second listen through more enjoyable. ‘life of a tree’ stood out in ith listens through. The organ maybe? Probably won’t revist this album. 3. Total no. Tracks 10 Fave track 8(A day in the life of a tree)
Not even remotely in my top Beach Boys albums. Shocked this one was chosen for the list instead of nearly any other
It radiates a certain emancipation and brokenness, but the lack of energy gives the music too little emphasis to really make me feel it.
It was fun.
Glad I listened to this! Not sure it’s my favorite but interesting to see this version of The Beach Boys. More politically focused. Cool.
This is just not the Beach Boys I know and love. Favorite Song(s): surfs up
Some good songs and I am impressed with their environmental messaging in 1971.
Changed my mind after 100 listens, amazing album with the smoothest of transitions
Who doesn’t love the beach boys???
Feels more rangy and less controlled, more absurd and less Beach Boys. Nothing particularly memorable.
That cover gives a different vibe to what it actually sounds like.
Forgettable
This must have been their political phase. Too much focus on preachy messages rather than good music.
this was very different from what i expected from the beach boys. kind of good though
Still can't really see through this. Beautiful melodies and pop songs mixed up with strange parts and ideas that feel they don't go anywhere…
The first half of the album is upbeat and the latter half is sad and slow.
hat mich gar nich begeistert, nicht schlimm, aber hab auch keinen song toll gefunden
Save:0
A bit sad sounding. Didn't relate or resonate with me unfortunately. 2.3/10
The Beach Chads
Some ok things on here, 'Feel Flows' is a pretty nice and psychedelic which I did enjoy, but the rest of this was a strange mess. 2 stars
What a bizarre album. There is some real dark beauty on this album. So much of this sounds like the darkest, weirdest late-Beatles material filtered through Beach Boys vocal harmonies. At first, I was pretty low on this album, but it's growing on me. I started off between 2-3 and now I'm thinking between 3-4. Going to go with 3 for now.
Love beach boys
The grown-up, more mature, Beach Boys - still some amazing harmony and brilliant instrumentation and playing, but now instead of just singing wistfully about a cute surfer girl or catching the perfect wave, they've got real things to say. They were socially conscious, and this album was one way to express those thoughts. I thoroughly enjoyed this album!
This album made it click why the Beach Boys and Beatles were always pitted against each other (I obviously prefer the Beatles). This isn't my favorite but definitely isn't bad. It was fine. 2.75 or a 3? Liked Songs: "Long Promised Road" , "Take A Load Off Your Feet" , "Disney Girls" , "Lookin' At Tomorrow (A Welfare Song)" , "Surf's Up"
The perfect album for todays walk home. 4 degrees, the ice is melting away, cold and clear skies. The sun is slowly setting. I really liked this.
Fletno za enkrat poslusat ... mal mi je mlačen in brez osebnosti
Honestly this was a great album with a lot of great musical ideas happening. First of all the dreamy vocals which initially I didn't like but they work so well with the dreamy, alternative vibe of the music that I can't imagine the album without them. The vast range in melodies and feels of this album are also a great part of it. 8/10, Favorite Song: Feel Flows
I was all ready to kick of my review with "Look, it was never going to be as good as Pet Sounds" but boy was I wrong! This album certainly isn't Pet Sounds, but I think it's as good - just wildly different. This album is more experimental and weird in ways that fascinate me, and I'm so glad I got to listen to it today. This whole album feels like it's trying not to be beach or boy, but rather darker and deeper like the ocean itself. Unusually for me, I've already put this one on a second time, and will undoubtedly listen to it again shortly. To quote a young white man: "I am not a beach. I am not a boy. I am an elderly black woman, hear me roar." I never really understood that quote - until today.
An album with a wide range of different moods. Their vocals were always phenomenal as well I must say. All in all though this album is very consistent and I don't think there's a dull moment on it. The title-track is phenomenal, however I prefer the version from the Smile sessions. Not much else to say but they were brilliant and so's this.
nije mi se bas nesto svidio, previse stvari se odjednom prebrzo desava i samo je nekako all over the place
Don’t Go Near The Water: 6.5/10 MBPW Long Promised Road: 6.5/10 MBPW Take A Load Of Your Feet: 6/10 Disney Girls: 2/10 Student Demonstration Time: 6.5/10 Feel Flows: 6/10 Lookin’ At Tomorrow (A Welfare Song): 7/10 MBPW A Day In The Life Of A Tree: 7/10 beautiful ‘Til I Die: 6.8/10 Surf’s Up: 7.3 MBPW
Often you hear how this album is departure for Beach Boys and out of character - if this is it, I really don't want to hear their *main* stuff.
Heard of The Beach Boys, don’t know if I could name a song. Don’t think they make the type of music I like. Don’t go near the water is a fun song, very well written. Really good production on long promised Road. The solo in the back half is really cool. Take a load is goofy and dated. But with that being said it is musically impressive. So far, not what I was expecting when I saw the Beach boys. Disney girls was more what I was expecting. Not my style, but not horrible. Good lyrics and harmonies. Student demonstration time is awesome. So many cool sounds going on. Again not what I was expecting from The Beach Boys. A classic rock song. Not a complicated song, but sometimes simple is better. Fuel flows is saved by the guitar/flute solo. Other than that pretty average song. Looking at tomorrow was pretty average as well. Nothing really stood out about it. Life of a tree is really cool. Good use of the flute again. Great song writing. Really emotional. Not a fan of til I die. Just too much going on. Not very catchy. Surfs up is really well written. First 2 mins is what I would expect felt beach boys, very poppy. Cool switch up in the middle. Good piano. Good closer to the album. Very fun overall. 3.5 stars
i liked this album! i wouldn’t call it a fan favorite, but i was not at all mad about it. my top three songs were: - don’t go near the water - student demonstration time - surf’s up with an honorable mention of: - disney girls
The cover VS the band LMAO
3+
Kind of boring but not unlistenable.
I did not expect a Beach Boys album entitled Surf's Up to sound like this. Interesting but not a got to repeat listen.
Quite different from The Beach Boys I know otherwise. Makes sense since this is a later album, but still a really enjoyable atmosphere in this. I wish the vocals Overall decent songs, but nothing totally up my alley here.
Son date et qui ne me donne pas encore de réécouter
Pas très fan - cela s’écoute bien by the way
Первая половина альбома мне понравилась, на второй заскучал.
358/1089 - "Surf's Up" the song has one of the most beautiful phrases in all of music, and is my favorite Beach Boys song. I'm excited to see what the rest of the album has to offer. After listening: Normally I deduct stars for emergency vehicle noises as it's confusing for me when listening while driving. I think it's obviously fake sounding in Student Demonstration Time, so I'm not gonna deduct stars for that. I like the cleaner voices of the Wilson brothers over Love and Jardine and thought the album was too safe overall.
fantastic beach boys record - an expansion on already fantastic works. disney girls remains a classic
The vocals irritate me
It is hard to rate. It has it's good moments and it has it's boring moments. It is barely 4.
Manufactured socially-conscious tunes. It's very hard to buy the Beach Boys as counter-cultural, so something like Long Promised Road comes across as really disingenuous. When were these chumps ever oppressed or put down? Even Don't Go Near The Water sounds like it was put out to sell records to environmentalists. Student Demonstration Time is frankly embarassing. The songs with less of a right-on message are better, but not enough to rescue this album for me. I do like the title contrasted with the contents and cover art. It's no 20 Jazz Funk Greats, but it's something.
it was alright, not what I expected when I think of the Beach Boys
When I normally think of The Beach Boys, the kind of music I think of is not contained on this album. I am used to upbeat pleasant sounding songs about surfing and having fun. This album is not that. It has a much more serious tone and each song has a message or a deeper topic. While the deeper meaning to the songs is appreciated some of the insight is very surface level and lacks some nuance. Sonically, you have some beautiful singing and brilliant instrumentation. However, there were some songs I thought captivating, but a majority of the album left me wishing that the lyrics went a little deeper.
Don't Go Near The Water - 5/10 Long Promised Road - 7/10 Probably would listen again. Take A Load Off Your Feet - 5/10 funny Disney Girls - 8/10 Student Demonstration Time - 8/10 Great rhythm. Powerful story. Feel Flows - 6/10 Lookin' At Tomorrow - 6/10 A Day In The Life Of A Tree - 6/10 Melancholic 'Till I Die - 6/10 Surf's Up - 6/10 Good ending to the album. Good music overall paired with good lyrics. Probably will listen again.
vibed
I am blown away. I get it now, The Beach Boys. I get it. They're amazing !
8.7/10. Surf’s up sounds haunting, fragile & everything I didn’t expect The Beach Boys to sound like-in the best way possible. I wasn’t familiar with this record before, and this is the first Beach Boys album I’ve listened to, though of course I’m familiar with most of their popular songs. I’m glad this was the first one of their records to pop up because honestly before this, I wasn’t particularly the biggest fan of their Surf-Style Pop Rock-it just didn’t draw me in before. Now I can say I’m a fan & I’m looking forward to hearing their other material to compare the different styles & eras. Favorite song: Surf’s Up Least favorite: Take a load off your feet
Even with Mike Love's horrible Student Demonstration Time, this is a four-star album. It has some of the most beautiful Beach Boys songs on it
Nice album
Not a Beach Boys album I’m familiar. Love the arrangements. A real focus on environmental issues it seems
It's fine bit unmemorable
There are good moments, for me their day had passed and the reinvention seems superficial
This is nothing like I expected and surprisingly good
It's a bit too inconsistent to be among the best Beach Boys albums, as there are some songs that I just don't care for. Don't Go Near the Water is a bit annoying vocally and too disjointed to be catchy, Take a Load of your Feet is a bit too goofy to be taken seriously and Student Demonstration Time or Lookin at Tomorrow read more as failed experiments that well fleshed out songs. On the other hands, the highlights are really awesome. Long Promised Road, Disney Girls and the last 2 songs all feature amazing songwriting, super strong melodies and really stellar compositions that rank it among the group's best. The other songs are kinda in between, making this a messy but interesting listen.
Despite its name, I think this is a very gloomy and mediocre record.
boring and predictable lyricism. weird, but not for the sake of communicating anything of substance, just for the sake of being weird. idk man, not great, but i wouldn't say it's unlistenable or anything. just kinda dull.
different
8.5/10
Heat
Vocals were so amazing! I am definitely keen to listen to more Beach Boys music. My faves: - Disney Girls - A Day In The Life Of A Tree - Feel Flows I probably need to sit down another time and listen properly to come up with more solid conclusions. Overall strong and want to listen to more Beach Boys.
Hadn’t heard this beach boys record before. Not surprised it’s really good.
There’s nothing wrong with it but I just don’t want to hear it ever again
I liked this a lot more than i thought I would. Good album.
Vibed w this heavy. There were layers on layers and I loved the mix of a bit of folk and psychedelic
Wtf beach boys gone emo?? Actually kinda fire fr??? Student demonstration was actually a dope song about current events and not how awesome California is?? Not a big fan but it gets a point for being cool and unique
This album makes me feel like I'm on holiday relaxing by a lake, but with some other tracks in this album it calms me down (Disney Girls) and (Lookin' at tomorrow).
Fairly competent album, I feel as if many of the songs are quite boring and I believe that many of the songs haven't aged too well, leading to me feeling that this album feels very generic and repetitive. 2/5
My first 4. Unexpected. This was just really chilled and I liked it.
For me this is by far the best album that the beach boys ever released and for its time this album still holds up well even to today’s pop/pop rock standards. One of the biggest criticisms this album gets is on one specific song “student demonstration time”. However I think the criticism is somewhat misplaced as yes I agree that the actual lyrics are not as good as some of the others and the message seems to not have been portrayed very well, the actual musical aspect of the song I think is the best on the whole album. It has a really true 70s sound and the distortion on the guitar paired with the sirens that play every so often really tie the song together making it in my opinion the best on the whole album. As for the rest of the album it’s also very good I think the opening track is relatively weak compared to the rest but it made up for by the fact that it’s followed by long promised road which is a phenomenal song. All together it’s a very good album, especially for its time but due to the generally similar sound of a lot of the songs I just can’t give it 5 stars but it’s a strong 4 stars A medium 8 out of 10
Cool ass album cover - Did slightly disappoint but still gives some brownie points, only one song reeally caught my eye, ear thing that was Student Demonstration Time otherwise I can accept that this style of music is just not for me 3.5/5 Ill flip a coin to see If I round up or down as a 4 seems too geneorus and a 3 seems too harsh.
Wasn't bad but I didn't enjoy the album at all. If it was on at a party I wouldn't complain, but I'd never willingly listen to this.
I had written a little about the first half of the album but it has been deleted. Overall the album was alright though certainly not what I expected from the beach boys, I thought it'd be much more upbeat and less melancholy, I don't know if this was more common for the beach boys or if this album was different. I did think that with it being called 'surf's up' it might be referring to a surf ending rather than just the beach saying. The songs were largely not too exciting, some were relatively pleasant, disney girls perhaps being a favourite alongside student demonstration town. The album art is really cool. 60/100
The waahp wahp at the start of Disney Girls made me happy. No idea why he's on about Tootsie rolls though. Boring. When I write these I listen out for things I liked or interest me. Nothing on this album did that. I know The Beach Boys are supposed to one of the greats, but this did not do that for me. I suppose it's a case of recognising how good it would've been when it was released. 2.5 A 3 to recognise the impact of this band on history i suppose.
Decent, over quickly, better if it wasn’t live but a couple of bangers
had a promising start. didn't like a few songs, but it's quite good.
Not good
First time listening to a beach boys record. I recall a random fact that includes Charles Manson and music.
A strange experimental album from a talented group of musicians who seem to have simply been left behind.
Really liked this one. Probably the only Beach boys album I'll listen to again. Definitely not what I expected.
It's no Pet Sounds but "Beach Boys political protest album" works more than you think it would.
I'd never listend to this album before, and frankly didn't know TBB other than their usual "Surfin' USA" stuff. Surprisingly this album is very different to that vibe. Less "perfect world", more seriousness. "Long Promissed Road" is probably my favourite song on that album. All in all a solid 3/5 for the whole album.
Fairly dull fare here. A couple of glimmers of the brightness we know from their earlier work.
Totally different than the Beach Boys sound we are used to! Nothing stands out to me on this album. I think I couldn’t get over Brian Wilson not being involved on this one?
Trying to ignore their history and back catalogue when listening to this, which is difficult to do! Not much of the signature harmonies in evidence on this collection Mostly they sounded like other middle of the road soft rock bands from this time Confusing and disappointing
I don’t generally love The Beach Boys, but this was really good.
honestly not a fan and all the tracks kinda meshed with eachother and there was no key standouts in the album
non mi piace
This album is actually so good. Listen to this album in the morning and found myself singing it all through the day. I don't think The Beach Boys get a good enough wrap for the quality of this album. No skips. Favorite song: long promised road (close second Disney girls)
SO UNDERRATED ARE YOU KIDDING ME
Smor X2 Iskreno bolji su bili dok su furali klasican surf rock i malo psihodelije
Interesting instrumentation and production, mixing the beach boys quartet sound with newer pop-ish electronic sounds and organs. Track Highlights: Student Demonstration Time, Feel Flows,
I love this. The lyrics, the sound. I love the beach boys.
Part of that run of albums from Sunflower to Holland in the early seventies that was the Beach Boys prime. Yes there were better albums earlier and many great singles but I don’t think there’s a four lp run in their discography as brilliant.
Achei Disney Girls bonita e Student Demonstration Time é bem divertida
The boys were getting a little political and I was digging it. Not what I expected from the BB's. This might even get added to my library
Surprisingly good for the beach boys. I was really starting to think I wouldn't enjoy anything these guys made. This album is much more interesting sonically and lyrically than anything else I have heard from them.
Hm
Definitely not pet sounds.
Loved Feel Flows, probably because I recognized it from Almost Famous.
It was interesting. Not the beach boys songs I know for sure!
Muy buen album y tremenda portada
Never heard of this album before I think it’s quite good A Day In The Life Of A Tree is my favourite song in this album 8.5/10 2025/12/27
Weird post-60’s beach boys
i really liked the first song of the album - don't go near the water - and the rest of the album did not stand out to me much
cool album!
This led to an extremely in-depth discussion with friends about the value of The Beach Boys. I don’t think I understand what they were trying to do on this record, and therefore don’t really understand The Beach Boys catalog I have friends who love this record, but to me it sounds like a joke. Overall three stars based on friends and opinions
So nearly a masterpiece. The production is slightly ramshackle, to my ears. A couple of the songs aren't quite as good as the others. But when it's good, this album is really good. I love Long Promised Road.
2.0 (33:49, 10 tracks, 1971, 17th album) Psych Pop I'm not a fan of Psych Pop and the Beach Boys didn't do a lot to help this. Not the worst album by far in this genre but some of these tracks were just week (or filler? "Student Demonstration Time" is abysmal On a positive - the album cover and it's introspective "end of the road" tone is welcoming (especially if you're going to to title your album Surf's Up.) On the negative - Album seems pieced together, no cohesion. Keyboards are terrible. Too slow - I figure if you're the Beach Boys just stay true, record another feel good clean album (by album 17 they had grown weary and tired, see above in positives) and let your fans come to your concerts to hear your hits.