Reviews (page 5 of 14)
Ok. ★★
brings you in with the tunes then straps you in with the lyrics. first beach boys album and a great listen.
So good
Leuk, ik hoop dat er meer beach boys langskomt
I actually rly liked it. Didn’t kno they got down like that
c’è qualcosa di adolescenziale in questo album, nel vago impegno socio-politico dei suoi testi, nella lieve spossatezza psichedelica di quando prendi troppo sole al mare e nell’ombrosità di certe tematiche esistenziali. c’è la via del lago che curva morbida attorno al bilancino, dopo l’ultimo bagno della stagione, e surf’s up che si libra nell’aria. è la fine di un’era, l’ora di scuotere l’asciugamano dalla terra e arrotolarci dentro il costume bagnato, è già il fresco della sera e il tramonto un po’ troppo presto.
Không ngấm lắm. BÌNH THƯỜNG
not magical like other beach boys records, but still pleasant
Album #10 The Beach Boys: Surf's Up On paper, an album called “Surfs Up” by “The Beach Boys” should be the most generic-sounding surf-rock and sunshine pop ever created, relegated to only being played during yacht parties and over beach volleyball cutscenes in Top Gun. Yet the album cover indicates that there may be a level of irony to the nomenclature, depicting a warrior and his steed seemingly approaching the end of their journey, almost in a horseman of the apocalypse style. This album, much like The Beach Boys' crowning achievement, “Pet Sounds,” indicates why they were compared to the Beatles at the time. Not only can they create irresistible pop melodies, but they are also capable of experimenting with their music and exploring darker themes. One thing that always separated the Beach Boys from the Beatles, however, was just how unapologetically American they were with their themes. At the time, there was a great sense of post-war optimism in the United States, almost a sense of naivety, which appeared in some of the Beach Boys' poppier early albums. Yet in Surfs Up, however, much like the title of the album appears to take something joyous and make it melancholic, they focus less on American optimism and more on the cynical reality. Exploring themes of environmentalism (A Day in the Life of a Tree), death (Til I Die), and Police Brutality (Student Demonstration Time). Even the song ‘Disney Girls’, which at first may seem like a more traditional Beach Boys pop tune, has an underlying sense of sadness about it, and when examining the lyrics further reveals it is about a man who escapes his disappointing reality with fantasies of fictional Disney Girls, knowing that love will never be found in real life. No doubt the centrepiece of the album is the title track. Closing the album on such a sad yet beautiful note, the song includes some of the Beach Boys' finest imagery and lyrics. Yet my favourite song off the album has to be Long Promised Road. This song also explores the themes of depression and dissatisfaction of life, but what sets it apart from the others on the album is the uplifting and irresistible chorus, which encourages you to fight back and overcome your obstacles. Something about this album just has such an intriguing atmosphere about it. I never did consider the Beach Boys to be anywhere near the Beatles since I wasn’t as familiar with their discography, but if this album is anything to go by, then it seems as though the Beach Boys may have multiple albums which are capable of going toe-to-toe with the Beatles' best. Take a Load Off Your Feet and Student Demonstration Time in particular seem to be pointed to as the weak points of the album, and whilst I would agree, I don’t think either track is that bad. I also don’t agree with the criticism that they are thematically inconsistent, as to me, the theme of the album seems to just be general grievances and struggles, and a back and forth between cynicism and optimism, which can be seen in both songs. Best Songs: Long Promised Road, Disney Girls, Surfs Up Worst Songs: Student Demonstration Time Score out of 10: 9
Cam mid ngl, dar merge pt unele situatii, better than the other one def
A more mature beach boys record, not just about girls and beach days. Still has those great harmonies. I think I really enjoyed this and considering it is only 35 minutes long I am going to listen again. Also I am giving this 4 stars.
the dreamy atmosphere pulled me in and never let go. it was a very fun listen with catchy songs. a little too much choir but idk. it is one of the underrated the beach boys albums. it was beyond love and much more about our society. loved it
Favorite Beach Boys album. Melancholic feel
This is absolutely fantastic. The Beach Boys are a STAPLE of music history and I’m a HUGE fan of the album cover too
I’m ashamed to say that I’ve never listened to this one—only Pet Sounds. I’ve heard this is their second best album, though. The cover is absolutely hilarious. It’s like this guy in anguish with SURF’S UP 😎 written over his head. The Beach Boys have always been interesting to me in that way—they’re this band famous for writing about surfing and girls, but then they also had a member who horrifically drowned, they were managed by their incredibly abusive father, and Brian Wilson was in and out of mental hospitals. He also was absolutely obsessed with being better than The Beatles—and the two bands actually mutually inspired each other. The complexity of their songs is also insane. Good Vibrations, for example, is so basic on surface-level, but it actually has an insane amount of layers to it. This album wasn’t as good as Pet Sounds, but it is certainly fantastic. The songs are deeply thoughtful and introspective. The opening seconds immediately hook you in and refuse to let go. I’m just wondering wtf Student Demonstration Time is. At first it sounded like a hollow attempt at a protest song, and then like it was making fun of the four students who died at Kent…and I honestly can’t tell, it was written by Mike Love though, and he’s reportedly a jerk. The sirens were kinda cool but they were so out of place. Anyway, yeah. Bad sticks out more than good. So even if my main comments are about that song, the rest of the album is genuinely great.
A rather melodramatic album from the Beach Boys, but being the band they are, it still sounds more uplifting than I think it should, considering the sad and environmentalist message of the project. Songs like "Don't Go Near the Water", 'Disney Girls (1957), "A Day In the Life of a Tree", "'Till I Die" and "Surf's Up" are a great example of them trying some more melancholic melodies with some sorrowful lyrics. However, I think the baroque and psychedelic pop elements that characterizes their music so much subtract a lot of the seriousness the album is aiming for, and they bring a bit of an uplifting feeling when I'm expecting a gloomy and depressing experience, specially with such an awesome album cover that looks like that. The rest of tracks I think are fine, but didn't interested me as much. They keep the pleasant voices and the creative instrumentation, but there's not much more going on with them. Besides, there is the garage rock song 'Student Demonstration Time' which comes from nowhere. It feels super disconnected from the album and it is a very weird choice from the band to include in the middle of it. In conclusion, I think this is a fine album. It sounds great and I do appreciate the idea behind, even though I wish for a way more drastic execution.
This must be satire. Protect the water and feet. The other songs sounded like a school project. 2/5
Første gangen æ hørte på det tenkte æ «ka E det her???» men andre gangen æ hørte på det tenkte æ at det ikke e så verst. Det e ikke akkurat sånn æ hadde sett for mæ at The Beach Boys skulle høres ut, men æ like det likevel.
Everyone seems to hate the track Student Demonstration Time. I feel like it's the only redeeming song on the entire album. I'm admittedly not a fan of the Beach Boys—I think they're highly overrated. But I think this track is a brave departure from their typical Surf Rock format while they dip their toes into the Blues/Country genres; and I happen to like it much better than their typical happy, bouncy, quintet sound. So much more rockin'!!
LUV
Meh lol
Very old stuff, apparently when they were just learning to write and play. Pretty good though
Very different, but very good. I enjoy their music no matter what they do.
A solid addition to The Beach Boys creative period. A bit uneven as most Beach Boys albums after Pet Sounds, but enough variety and well crafted tunes to compel repeat listens. The standout track to me is Long Promised Road but there is hardly a skippable song in the bunch. Even the campy Take a Load off Your Feet and the somewhat confusing Student Demonstration Time warrant listens.
it was pretty good, some songs stood out and were pretty fun. the production on the album was really good but they have much better projects out there.
Never heard this Beach Boys sound before and it was fun and different.
Very solid. Great lyrics and bursting harmonies. I tried to think that they were overrated in their earlier days, but I undeniably get it. Better to be in on it than be a hater
Okay okay okay this is good right off the bat! Yeah, this is tight, better than the last Beach record I had easily! Fav tracks: Don't Go Near the Water Long Promised Road Disney Girls (1957) Surf's Up
Nice
Not a fan of the Beach Boys, their sound is just kind of aggravating. Till I Die was okay.
3 star in the realm of all albums. 2 star would be generous if rating Beach Boys only.
Not bad but kind of mostly had that generic Beach Boys sound.
It seems like I do not like the typical Beach Boys music. Those songs that are more famous seemed boring to me, and other less popular sounded better. The solo in Feel Flows is majestic, nevertheless. I am lacking context about the influence of this album.
Favorite Songs: 'Til I Die, Disney Girls, Feel Flows Least Favorite Song: Student Demonstration Time So different from their usual sound, but in the best way. The dreaminess, the vocal layering, the psychedelic production, and that damn flute solo?!
Interesting album. I don't know why The Beach Boys's music always give me a certain joyful impression. Might be a mistake because I didn't listen to many of their songs. This album is surely more psychedelic than joyful, enjoyable non the less though. Feel Flows and A Day In The Life Of A Tree are fun, but 60s psychedelic rock style production overall is a bit weird though.
The tracks pass me by but leave me feeling so cosy
Such a different experience listening on headphones (lossless) ❤️a day in the life of a tree
Some good stuff on here. Liked Feel Flows in particular. And Long Promised Road and Till I Die were strong. Till I Die like much of the album not the cheery Beach Boys of old. Surfs Up also great. That student demo track was bad. Not sure on the water, tree or feet ones. Will revisit this. Going to go 4 (just).
Really enjoyable. Long Promised Road Disney Girls and A Day In A Life Of A Tree (did it inspire Spiritualised?). Better than Pet Sounds?
A bit more of a mixed bag than its superior predecessor Sunflower, however there are enough flashes of Wilson's simplistic genius to ease this to well above average status. Has something of the feel of a musical equivalent of Kerouac's Big Sur - the end of era, the world weariness, the comedown.
Believe it or not, even though this was released in 1971, it was their 17th studio album. It definitely has a darker tone overall, previewed by the cover art, which looks like something out of a nightmare. It's not my favorite record of theirs, but the beautiful harmonies add to the melancholy feel of it.
This was soo far from my typical genres I had trouble getting through it. The music isn't bad, it just does not fit me. There were a few songs that felt like a crashout and somewhat sad, which is the exact opposite of what I knew of the band.
the beach boys peaked in the 1960s and they should stay there listening to the beach boys in 2025 is like watching star wars and expecting the hero's journey to feel new still except kokomo, which is not on this album, that song is evergreen okay also 'wouldn't it be nice,' that one gets a pass too
Not bad
This album was way different than the beach boys that I know and took me a bit to get into, but by the end I had relaxed into it. Very much matured past the initial explosion of them into the mainstream. Some of it was ridiculous, some interesting. Favorite track: feel flows because of the flute solo, with honorable mention to surfs up because it's of its beautiful complexity.
This album should be called 'The Doldrums'. I mean 'Surf's Up' sounds a bit more upbeat than the melancholic dirge of this album, maybe it was intentional given the album cover but I was expecting a prelude to Pet Sounds and was bitterly disappointed.
Guess I should have known based off the album cover, not the title
This album is proof there are too many beach boys albums on the list. Oh ok, there's only three. But maybe they're the wrong three. I dunno. I feel like this album is a mess. It sounds all out of tune and not in an Interesting way. It isn't bad exactly, but it's hard to listen to.
Helt greit
Greit nok, ikke noe jeg kommer til å sette på igjen tror jeg
Ganske overraskende at det har så kult sound. Noen tekster ganske interessante. Passe lengdee, rakk ikke kjede meg.
I just could not get into this, thought it was boring
On the first listen I thought "meh, beach boys." I listened to it again and it's pretty impressive. I did skip Take a Load Off Your Feet and Student Demonstration Time because those songs suck. The tracks are pretty layered and intricate and in a lot of ways this feels like a Beatles album. I also like the ironic "Surf's Up" title paired with the darker themes and music, at least by the beach boys' standards.
pretty dope, pretty vibey. didnt know the beach boys fucked like that. favorite song is probably Surf's Up, maybe Long Promised Road
Rating: 7/10 It's a solid album, and maybe the perfect recommendation for a Beach Boys record in the winter, moodier rather than sunnier. I'm not the biggest fan of this band but literally can't be anything other than a good listen
Something about these wispy backing vocals really gets me dude. I'm clearly missing something about the "best album ever created by mankind" but nah we're just pretty boring and a little annoying out here. I think I could actually fall asleep to this album 3.2/10
I went in expecting to hate this, but honestly wasn't that bad. 6 winter beaches out of 10 lizard wizards
fantastic album
So much weirder, darker, interesting and political than I expected
Day in the life of a tree had me chuckling. Sent it to Hunter
Ok 2/5
Haven't listened lately, but got into it in the early aughts through the magic of internet piracy. Never would have bought it... it really had very little critical or popular esteem until this century. But it's very enjoyable. Not up to the standards if Pet Sounds... but what us? And being a sleeper record, it has the strong benefit of not being played-out and overhyped. I dig it.
Imagine a group of 13 year olds who were given the task to create an art project about environmentalism. It’s not always focused. It’s mostly kinda dumb. But these kids have crazy musical talent. That’s what Surf’s Up sounds like to me. I’m not likely going to listen to this again but audacity in art should be rewarded.
Brian Wilson sucks ass on this album. His falsetto always makes the songs worse. Any track where he's involved as a writer or lead vocalist is bad. A lot of the tracks remind me of the Beatles but not as good, and I'm already not a fan of the Beatles. Long Promised Road and Lookin at Tomorrow are the only decent tracks. The musical compositions on this album are interesting, but overall it's a bad album. The album cover is sick though.
7th album with group. Before anything else I want to say that this is one of the best album covers of all time, up there with When the Pawn… and Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea. This album is pretty good but not as good as Pet Sounds. I will say though that Surf’s Up stands out as pretty good and wouldn’t feel out of place on Pet Sounds. Good Songs - Don’t Go Near the Water, Long Promised Road, Take a Load Off Your Feet, Disney Girls (1957), Student Demonstration Time, Feel Flows, Lookin’ at Tomorrow (A Welfare Song), A Day in the Life of a Tree, ‘Til I Die, and Surf’s Up. Bad Songs - Nothing.
Enjoyed a different sound than what I know of from them
Surprisingly, it really didn’t sound so great. It was a superficial take on The Beach Boys and really didn’t make a ton of sense.
I didn’t know they could do all that!! hell yeah
I just don’t like the Beach Boys
Poor
this is not what I expected beach boys to sound like. a lot "grungier" than I thought. pretty good
meh
First listen Saved 7/10 Top track: Surf's Up
First time listening to the beach boys. My impression - Beatles at seargent pepper vibes. Pleasant to listen to. Fav: long promised road
There are some beautiful tracks here but I just don't think it works as an album. The message and theme unfocused and disparate, and the tone is all over the place. Consequently, the stand-out tracks (I'd say Disney Girls, Take a Load Off Your Feet and the title track) did not elevate the album, but lamented how great the Beach Boys could be. Alas!
Title track is pretty good, the rest is very uneven. Not all bad, but surely not a classic.
Okay so...how do i be nice about this... The Beach Boys have literally never interested me. My main knowledge of them is basically from Full House and whichever songs I've heard here and there throughout my 20+ years on this planet. Their whole vibe is just...meh imo. Needless to say, i wasn't exactly excited to listen to this when i was picked for me. I actually ended up missing the past 3 days, oops, but I wanted to get back into it which means diving into this. Overall, it was okay...I guess? My main issue is honestly the singing voices, it doesn't vibe with me at all for the most part. It feels like I'm being held hostage by a barbershop quartet. I cannot say my life has been made better by listening to a song about feet. At the very least, I now understand why my very conservative dad hates them. Some quick positives: I can genuinely see myself coming back to Long Promised Road, I really liked that one. There are a few other I might come back to individually like "Til I Die", "Feel Flows", and "Lookin' at Tomorrow". It's just very hard for me to stomach a whole album of theirs at the moment.
I'm not sure if this was quirky or downright disturbing. It's a pretty lacklustre album either way. Two stars, with one star for the absurdity of some of the songs, otherwise it would be a one.
Artwork is absolutely sickening, really strange choice for The Beach Boys and I love it. I like the Beach Boys, but they’ve never quite reached the heights for me personally that the Beatles do, if we’re going to open that old chestnut. Honestly I think a lot of it comes down to the fact that I find their voices annoying a lot of the time. First few songs are an example of another thing that loses me about the Beach Boys sometimes, I just find the songwriting can be a little meandering, there are cool things happening in the chord changes and the production, but it just doesn’t stick for me. I hear how they influenced Fleet Foxes output heavy on this record though. I hated Student Demonstration Time. This brand of white guy blues music is the worst. The Beach Boys voices are way too soft and vanilla to deliver in this context. A Day In The Life of A Tree has some beautiful organ work, it’s in a really cool space, vocal arrangements near the end are gorgeous. Lead vocal I don’t really care for Chord changes are always so interesting and unexpected, wonder where that influence is coming from? Suspended harmonies in Til I Die are so sick. Brian Wilson is the vocal harmony master. Closer title track is a highlight. Record vastly improves on Side B. This was an interesting turn. I’ve only ever listened to The Beach Boys up to Pet Sounds, and honestly didn’t really think there was much of note beyond that. But this is definitely of note, granted not all notes that I like, but I’m intrigued by it. I think I might revisit this out of curiosity, it might have grower potential (except Student Demonstration Time, pretty confident in that one).
Love this album, the Beach Boys were on the path to Pet Sounds, you can hear the genesis of Brian's genius in this collection.
Not for me, and I love Pet Sounds, but that was just like a beach boys imitation for me
another cool album cover aha except not my favorite sounds... Beatles did it better
That's not my taste in music - But ok
Ik kende geen enkel nummer van dit album. Het is best een leuk album. Wel een vrij typische sound voor die tijd denk ik. Of in elk geval kwam het mij vertrouwd voor. Ik merk wel dat het niet muziek is die mij bij blijft. Ik vergeet het al snel weer
Weird. Lyrics sounded like they'd been written by an 8 year old.
Did not particularly enjoy this album Feel Flows as the highlight of these 35 min
Doesn't quite sound like the Beach Boys. Still has some good tracks though
favorite song-long promised road best song-don’t go near the water deep cut-a day in the life of a tree hidden gem-surf’s up
I am not sure how i feel about this album. It wouldnt be the first, second, possibly even the third BB album i would choose in a list of greatest albums. On the one hand, the absence of Brian is notable in the production. The vocals are not prominent, the harmonies and complex arrangements are absent except maybe in the last two or 3 songs. On the other hand, it is not the album i would have expected without Brian at the helm (in a positive way). I think i need more time with this. Another album I am not sure if the mix is muddy or my headphones are shit. Two stars reserved for a hivher ranking later.
Good and of its time. Easy listen. Nothing here particularly memorable for me.
Hadn't really heard much Beach Boys beyond Pet Sounds and the greatest hits fodder. This was unexpectedly great. In particular, loved Disney Girls and Student Demonstration Time. 228.
Ni surf ni up porque qué es este BAJON de album😭 osea esta bastante bien pero es muy raro el combo Beach Boys con introspección... creo que, una vez mas, tenía otras expectativas y eso me tiene biased. Me gusta la combinación igual de las voces de ellos con las canciones mas tranquilas, pero no me veo volviendo al album
Atmospheric, some brilliance and some half-assed notions. Hard to call it a great album, as it has one defining track and a couple other interesting listens. I can't imagine telling someone, "Hey! You got to listen to this record!".
I didn't like it on first listen, but it grew on me. Would be better listened to on a speaker.
My first time listening to The Beach boys, really enjoyed the sound and will keep on listening to some other albums The social and political critique, specially “student demonstration” feels very fitting to our current times. It closes with two very powerful songs: 'Til I die and Surf's up
Never listened to The Beach Boys before, so have nothing to compare it to with this album. It's different from anything I've ever listened to before, with the opening track "Don't go near The Water" being an almost... Psychedelic... Country feel? Following up, "Long Promised Road" is more classic Rock n Roll, but still twists into something less conventional with the synth/keyboard sound around it's half way mark. Already, after only two tracks, I like this album for it's pure novelty factor, blending various sounds and genres to make for something that feels both experimental and grounded in conventions. An album like this wouldn't be complete without a Ballad like "Disney Girls", which has many of the conventions of a song like this: slow drums, rising and falling guitars and soft supporting bassline all dreamily pulled along by the lyrics. "Student Demonstration Time" is a huge change up straight after Disney Girls and I really liked it. [I read other reviews regarding this song and was shocked to find it was widely hated, understanding that the sirens and lyrics themselves is what has caused the hate. As for it's sound, I did enjoy it, but it's lyrics and the political view's of Mike Love are easy to condemn.] Another album that has a lot of twist and turns in it's tone, I really enjoyed this one still. A further reflection: It is more than possible that, even though I have listened to lots of different music across the modern era, I still do not know enough to pick out the bad from the good, whether that be individual tracks or whole albums. Still, I continue to listen with optimism with each new album.
Listened to a bit of it; definitely different, but enjoyable.
Decent album, with some catchy tunes. But alot more serious subject, and delivery, which is not what i was expecting when i popped on a beach boys album.
Just some boat music boomers enjoy. Not the worst, not the best
Existential, ethereal, haunting.
I always found Surf's Up to be overrated. It's experimental and psychedelic (for Beach Boys standards, at least), but Sunflower is literally just that but fun. Shoutout to the last two tracks, 'Til I Die and Surf's Up, for being perfect songs.
Non mi ha detto nulla, ma non è brutto
Love this album!
Despite what the title may suggest, this is far from the "cars and girls" early-60s sound of the Beach Boys. Instead, it's thematically very dark by Beach Boys standards, despite musically sounding fairly light. "Student Demonstration Time" isn't that bad, it's just far heavier and louder than everything else on the album. I won't say this is a bad album, but it's not the best thing I've ever heard, either.
Good but not great. Overrated because they are beloved.
> the Beatles
Hat mich leider viel weniger gepackt als gehofft. Dachte immer, dass The Beach Boys genau mein Ding sein könnte. Aber nun ja.
Kurzweilig, aber ohne dass viel hängenbleibt.
Überraschend moody für Beach Boys-Verhältnisse. Nicht jedes Experiment hat für mich funktioniert, aber gerade wenn sie mit ihren Harmonien spielen, ist das schon ziemlich groß.
Stabil, aber nicht mehr
Hätte ich von den Beach Boys so nicht erwartet, aber hittet zwischendrin immer wieder. Würde ich nur das Coverartwork bewerten wäre das eine 5/5, so rechts aber doch nur zur starken 3
Good interesting album
I really don't know what to do with The Beach Boys. Sometimes I think they're better than The Beatles and other times I think they only served to deliver Brian Wilson into the world to bring us Pet Sounds. Surf's Up is a weird one. It has moments of sheer brilliance like Long Promised Road and the titular Pet Sounds castoff track but also Mike Love message-music slop like Don't Go Near the Water or the jarring and incongruous Student Demonstration Time. I guess it ends up falling in the middle because of the very high highs and terribly low lows.
Decent! More psychedelic than I expected.
The second best Beach Boys album right after Pet Sounds. Consistent all around, but there are a few weaker tracks on the A side. Overall very nice, and often overlooked. 8/10
This is such a disappointing album because the artwork makes it seem like it will have a much darker tone, and then goofy light-hearted beach boys starts playing. Also Student Demonstration Time is so hard to listen to. I actually went back and downgraded it on rym to 35 after listening to this
This isn't The Beach Boys album that I would have expected. Instead, it's The Beach Boys grown up and trying to grapple with the issues of the late 60s and early 70s. Or, it's them trying to keep their work relevant as the world grows up around them. I'm not sure which it is, but it's interesting enough if you can gloss over some of the weirder plays they have in this market.
Not really sure what they were going for there
These white boys need a wellness check
noice
I felt nothing really
this is not the chamber pop/choir sound that i associate with the beach boys so i found it a lot more engaging and enjoyable. fav tracks: feel flows
I actually really enjoyed this. A lot more psychedelic rock oriented than the other beach boys I’ve heard which felt much more pop. My gripe is usually that the music sounds too childish for me to ever choose to listen to it but this didn’t have that feeling at all really.
it sounds like if you were a student in the seventies when these campus riots were goin on with fascist cops killing kids, this might be a good album to listen to. or if you were on drugs. or if you are a musician now looking for ideas, like a film maker looking at Goddard or avant guard modern art, you might find some great inspiration. Maybe Pavement would listen to this and go oh shit i got an idea for an album. but for us plebs 50 years removed, its weird af. Might listen again, but will give a 2.
I don't get it.
My understanding of the Beach Boys' music falls into two camps: good-time pop claptrap ("Little Surfer Girl," "Surfin' USA," etc.) and ambitious, insanity-inducing epics (Pet Sounds, SMiLE). Because I don't care for their music, I've never thought about what lies between those points until Surf's Up. What a thoroughly strange album, starting with the completely incongruous album art and title. Even if it had a different cover, Surf's Up does not suit the music and themes here. In continuing with precedent, I didn't like it and actively hated "Student Demonstration Time." It has nicer moments, but none I plan to revisit.
Surprisingly enjoyable
loved the sound - especially Feel flows
Wow this is sad. Not to mean the music is sad necessarily, it’s just sad to hear how far the band falls in this stage in their career. Apart from the title track I don’t think there’s any strong song here. The lyrics are juvenile and the production is flat and boring. I mean man this is the Beach Boys I was psychedelic pop extravaganza. This is a very dull record which dos a disservice to the band’s catalog. One star.
Somehow the music meets the high bar set by its cover art.
Much more rock and roll than I thought The Beach Boys were. An album about environmental conservation, self-care, and protesting the Vietnam war and the treatment of anti-war protesters could easily come off as preachy in the wrong hands, but thankfully these hands are just right. Layering haunting and beautiful vocal harmonies throughout, this album gave me a much better appreciation for the depth of The Beach Boys as musical artists. Some excellent standout tracks for me include Feel Flows, Student Demonstration Time, and A Day In The Life Of A Tree.
Can't say I've heard many of these, but I was really digging the vibes. Will listen to a lot of these tracks again, especially A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A TREE.
Surprised I’ve never dabbled in this album. Like a few of their other albums and the cover looks familiar enough so it’s odd this one snuck past
This was interesting to be a Beach Boys album. No the usual Surfin Safari but not for the better
Yeah it’s becoming evident that I don’t see the appeal in this era of the beach boys. And I’ve invested hours trying to figure it out.
J'aime beaucoup les Beach Boys mais peut-être pas mon album préféré
Je ne connaissais pas cet album, je le trouve vachement moins jovial que ce qu’on connaît des Beach Boys. On en parle de la pochette mega obscure ? Sinon; les voix sont toujours aussi cool ! C’est un peu triste
J'ai vraiment beaucoup aimé! Plein de pistes sympa, j'ai même hésité avec 5/5. Totalement ma came je pourrais réécouter
The title track is an undeniable masterpiece. Probably the last one Brian Wilson ever wrote, when you consider where things went for both him and the band in the 70s, 80s, and 90s. "Til I Die" is every bit its equal, too. On the other hand, it's fascinating that Mike Love, of all people, has the two overtly "socially conscious" songs here. Even though they're not very good, the uncontroversial politics of each is comically to the left of where he is today. The whole thing is a wildly mixed bag that feels funereal in a way. The Beach Boys never really struck gold again with original material until the deservedly derided "Kokomo" in the late 80's. This was the beginning of their transition to beloved legacy act, in retrospect.
Excellent songs of the current events of the time and the POP culture of that era. In my opinion their best LP. Although Pet Sounds is a technical masterpiece. I find Surf"s Up to be more enjoyable.
Buzzy and mellow
A very chill if occasionally melancholy listen
I love the album cover because to me it shows a usually powerful figure looking weak and defenseless under gloomy, dark blue cloudy skies, the silhouette of the rider on the horse, holding a spear but without the grit to continue, perfectly showcasing the “End of the Trail” sculpture and it couldn’t be more fitting. Using a defeated, weary rider on horseback creates a strong contrast and represents exhaustion, disillusionment, and the end of an era. It’s not the carefree surfer image I expected from The Beach Boys actually, it’s the complete opposite of their earlier songs, and it matches how mellow and depressing the album feels. This is one of the most interesting albums in The Beach Boys’ catalog because it comes from a time when the band was shifting away from their surf-rock identity and moving into something much more reflective, political, and emotionally complex. You can really feel that transition all over the album. Everything carries a sense of maturity and melancholy. Overall, this album is a heavy listen. Not everything hits for me, but some songs are really nice to listen to. It feels like the sound of a band trying to rebuild itself, sometimes falling apart in the process, but still managing to create something meaningful.
Have a hard time to the cause off why this album is on this list! Maybe it’s just me.
way more depth sonically & lyrically than anticipated
War gut, aber auch schon wieder vergessen? c
The Beach Boys making a "Can we talk about the political and economic state of the world, right now?" album was something I never knew expected and it wasn't too bad.
нормалек, без негатива.
this one is pretty hit and miss. the trademark harmonies are still in many of the songs, but some of the songs fall flat. in fact much of the songs don’t sound like the beach boys at all.
2 stars
Armonías encantadoras, y divertidas. Definitivamente no es mi estilo, pero puedo entender el gusto que la gente le pueda tener. Kinda sounds like the beatles Mi fav Lookin at tomorrow
A very refined version of what people know and love...I am not one of those people.
Why did they record this album???????
one of my favorite albums of all time.
Didn’t realize The Beach Boys had range like that, enjoyed the album
Enjoyed this. Having never listen led much to Beach Boys this was more than I expected.
ooof. noen middels sanger som gjør det til et album som dessverre ikke er 5/5. men har en av tidenes sanger - surfs up
Don’t care for it it that much. A 2.
Very cool album. Album art is off the charts, music is arranged and crafted so tastefully and the vocals are fire
Bumbabumpbum
Better than I expected. Not a typical Beach Boys album.
Eh
Very nice. Not the sound I expected but still proggy and interesting. The Beach Boys always surprise me and they deliver.
Cant go wrong with the beach boys! Though i wouldnt put most songs in my playlist but i can admire the charming touch that they can bring. Favourite song: Feel Flows HM: Student demonstration time, Take a Load Off Your Feel
I found this album strange. It’s dark and serious compared to the Beach Boys songs I’m used to hearing. Student Demonstration Time was the most interesting track on the album. Overall, didn’t love it, didn’t hate it, and it was interesting to hear a new (to me) beach boys sound.
What a weird, great album.
Did not enjoy
This was full of underrated Beach Boy hits. Didn't know a single one, and mostly had thought the Beach Boys were strictly surf rock, but this far different from what I typically know them for. Great record.
This could be the album that insufferable Beach Boys fans will fawn over as the Masterpiece that Pet Sounds isn't. What people like Andrew Hickey don't see or get is that this album is one of the Beach Boys lesser quality albums. This album suffers from the lack of awareness that Brian Wilson required to keep The Beach Boys floating, but since he was in his depression era the boys moved out on their own and tried to create multiple solo-style singles instead of BB records. You don't catch a glimpse to what shows as a glimmer of good production until the last three songs of the album where the wonderful harmonies of the BB return and remind you of what made them so great. This is an okay album. For the Beach Boys. 3/5
I don’t know The Beach Boys’ music very well, but Surf’s Up seems full of well-crafted songs. Still, for some reason, it doesn’t really leave a strong impression on me. I do like Student Demonstration Time, though it feels quite different from the image I had of the band. Maybe this is the kind of album that only longtime fans can truly appreciate.
A fun day at the beach and no I'm not kidding
It appears that the beach has been replaced by acid…
Nice tinniness. Easy listening.
This was the most 'Beatles' that I've heard the Beach Boys. I've only ever listened to a couple of their albums all the way through. This one I wasn't even aware of. Much more ambitious and experimental than what I knew by them. Have to admit I prefer a little less of Brian Wilson on the vocals. There are some kooky tracks but also some real quality too.
I was surprised by the tone of this album. It wasn’t bad, just not what I expect from The Beach Boys.
Three star with a boost for the best Beach Boys album art! If I want to listen to a weirdo Beach Boys album I’d listen to this.
Just because Brian Wilson exists doesn’t mean everything he ever did needs to be on this list.
Brian Wilson is a genius.
Good listen
Hey! Student demonstration talks about IV! This is so different than the sound I usually associate with them. There are a few beachy jams on here but there’s a lot more variability and musicianship on here. The sound is dripping in California vibes with lyrics to match.
The biggest disservice to The Beach Boys is having the worst name ever. If they had any other name I think I they’d be way more successful. I get the marketing and stuff but got damn they can’t make this hippy bullshit and be called Beach Boys. The sounds are so interesting that they make. I love the production. Every move feels so intentional. I don’t know if I’m actually hearing that or just buying into Brian Wilson mythos. They’ll make an amazing song and follow it up with something that sounds like it belongs in a Skyrizi commercial. Take Care of your feet. Disney girls is really cool. This feels like a band trying to shed their old skin and come into a new decade… apparently it kind of is according to wiki. This is another band that feels so steeped in the American songbook that every little shift in their history led to massive changes and overhauls. Overall, solid listen.
Last three songs are 5/5, the rest of the album is 3/5
I thought I knew the Beach Boys, but this album showed me a whole new side of them. I liked the slower, more thoughtful songs and lyrics.
neocekivano
Good! Not Pet Sounds though. Surprisingly jangly and twangy.
A beautiful and distinct somber affair that remains recognizably Beach Boys. The music is very well composed and the lyrics are introspective and darker. It's not what you'd expect from the Beach Boys, but it's a really good album.
Slightly melancholic, dreamy, lovely arrangements.
I didn't think it was bad, but it didn't really grab me. Maybe this needs a second listen sometime for me to get it.
Big surprise, another 70s album and you know what? I like it. It's interesting and creative, showing off what they are known for, and showing off what they are looking forward too. Solid 4* rating.
Not really my style of music, but the production is nice (apart from the ear-piercing Student Demonstration Time.) Maybe I could find more to enjoy from this if I listened a few more times, and the detail makes it seem like that might be rewarding. It manages to do a 'generic sound' in a less predictable way that I anticipated.
Better than expected
okay, I see the appeal but not for me
é um álbum gostosinho, só achei que não tem nada aver com a capa
- beach boys ei oo koskaan ollut erityinen suosikki - suurin osa tän bändin biiseistä kuulostaa tosi naiiveilta - albumitaide on ihan siisti mutta ehkä turha rajun olonen tälle bändille/albumille - tän levyn parhaat osiot oli niitä jotka ei kuulostanut perinteiseltä beach boysilta - ei sytyttänyt
This one is not bad. I actually like a lot of these songs I haven't heard more than their popular ones.
Did not find this at all interesting
Overall, I enjoyed the sound and the somewhat experimental vibe of the album. For a first discovery of The Beach Boys, I really loved their vocal harmonies, which are as polished and recognizable as ever. The themes explored give an insight into the social and cultural climate of the time, offering a sort of time travel back to the 70s. It also helped me understand what pop music was like then, although this is a more artistic and introspective form of pop than a commercial one. The album cover is incredible — perhaps even visually too perfect, as it doesn't entirely reflect the diversity and inconsistency of the musical content. Indeed, Surf’s Up contains some very beautiful tracks, both profound and accomplished, such as 'Til I Die or Long Promised Road, which stand out for their sincere lyrics and intricate arrangements. However, the album also suffers from a few weaker tracks. For example, Don’t Go Near the Water tackles an interesting subject but does so with an almost simplistic, caricatural approach, which makes the message less impactful. Other songs like Take a Load Off Your Feet seem a bit anecdotal or out of sync with the rest of the album, lacking the depth present in the most successful tracks. Despite these irregularities, Surf's Up remains a significant and ambitious work, marking a period of transition for The Beach Boys: between their lighter past and a quest for more mature artistry.
I lived it
Best Song: 'Til I Die. This has that ethereal, wispy vocal quality that I expect from a Beach Boys song. Worst Song: Student Demonstration Time. The one thing the Beach Boys are good at is their clean vocal harmonies, so why put the vocals behind a buzzy radio filter? Overall: Based on the view count, this isn't even a popular album amongst Beach Boys fans, so why am I listening to it?
had no idea about this album before listening. i love the idea of an evil beach boys album where they still go to the beach but this time its bad. helps that it was like 30 minutes and the music was decent too
I really don’t get the Beach Boys. And there is whistling. No thanks.
Maybe it's the recent run we've had but I found a lot to enjoy with this album. Most of the songs pretty catchy and the album felt consistent throughout
I enjoyed it. Different from what I expected from a Beach Boys album. Good, but not enough to push it higher.
It was ok. Inoffensive.
Quirky album. Harmonies are always spot on and can carry even subpar melodies. Feel Flows is a classic. Not their best effort as a band.
OoooooooOOOOoooOooooooh
I had never listened to The Beach Boys until I generated Pet Sounds earlier this year and it blew me away. This one doesn’t hit those highs but it is still really good and at times brilliant. Only two tracks let it down for me, Take A Load Of Your Feet and Student Demonstration Time. On the flip side it ends with two absolutely belting songs in Til I Die and Surf’s Up. Top Track - Surf’s Up
Pretty great! Liked this one a lot.
Wonderful album. The most adult version of the Beach Boys. It’s more complex and hits different to all the others.
Not The Beach Boys I’m used to at all - which I’ve never been a fan of but this was pleasant surprise. Some songs had sound similar to Ben Folds Five others had a Beatles vibe. Also liked different and new Beach Boys instruments - horns, woods or reeds? Enjoyable album
This is an odd album. After Pet Sounds — still one of pop music’s great miracles — the Beach Boys somehow stumbled their way here, five records later, to Surf’s Up: uneven, intermittently brilliant, and often baffling. Brian Wilson was still around, but mostly in spirit; the lush harmonies and meticulous production that once defined the band are largely absent. His presence flickers to life in the final three tracks, though — and when it does, you remember just how far ahead of his peers he once was. The title track remains magnificent; “A Day in the Life of a Tree,” sung (rather alarmingly) by their manager, is merely… memorable. Still, there’s much to enjoy. “Long Promised Road” is a genuine highlight, full of that bittersweet Californian glow the band once bottled so effortlessly. Less successful is their sudden bid for social relevance. Manager Jack Rieley apparently urged them to tackle serious issues — an odd idea for a band that built its empire on surfboards and sunshine. The result, “Student Demonstration Time,” is a clumsy blues-rock detour, complete with sirens and moral confusion, crashing through the album like an uninvited guest. Oddly, its message — penned by the now-MAGA-inclined Mike Love — seems to be that it’s better simply not to demonstrate. In the end, Surf’s Up is a curious mix of beauty and misfire — flashes of the old magic, shadowed by strange choices and the growing sense that the world, and the band, had both moved on.
More like The Blech Boys. Seriously. What am I missing? Critics and listeners alike seem to adore the Beach Boys; I don't get it. Their early stuff is just "Waaah-waaah-waaah" saccharine surf shit, and the rest is electric, psychadelic racket. I absolutely hate it. 1 star though I'd give it much less if possible.
They've matured and are experimenting, with decent results
обложка обещала многое, в итоге это очередные недобитлз
Solid listen! I respect what they're going for, though it didn't quite bite for me.
Classic.
The Beach Boys never miss. Their vocals are next level
I can see where it might've been the early 70s version of alt /indie rock . I respect their exploration and experimentation with different musical genres, but the music sounded very dated, and a bit hokey at times.
Mike Love’s Student Demonstration Time might have been well-intentioned at the time or might have been a preview of his right wing future. Either way, it’s a jarring song. Brian Wilson’s A Day in the Life of a Tree is maybe the worst thing he ever wrote. Don’t Go Near the Water isn’t great either. The pro-environmentalist songs on this record just come off as lyrically clunky. And then there’s ’Til I Die and Surf’s Up, where Brian achieves transcendence. A real up and down, all over the place record. 3.5 stars but I don’t think I can get to 4.
Very political. Kids were surprised they were singing about the same things we are protesting noe
Great album
This album was way too heavy for me for Beach Boys’ fare. Call me basic, but I’d take Good Vibrations over this any day. Hell, I’d take Little Saint Nick over this! I didn’t love the vocals although some of the harmonies were nice. I think I suffered from expecting traditional Beach Boys and getting whatever this was instead. Chalk that up to my ignorance of Beach Boys’ lore, but I still don’t think I’d like the album even if I was prepared for it. Definitely looking forward to The Beach Boys redeeming themselves with Pet Sounds!
I Much better than I expected. Had a jam-bad feel for parts of songs, sang of the Kent state incident and anti-war, more relevant than I realized.
Gloomy and a little dreary, an end to the innocence. More experimental than earlier works, more stretching and expanding. Enjoyable
Oddly interesting. Sometimes sounds unfinished, other times perfect.
me gusto y no lo conocia
nunca dejan de sorprenderme
You wouldn't pin the Beach Boys as Psychedelic music, yet they can be far more trippy than any psychedelic music I can think of: This album in particular is like watching a Disney movie on acid. This isn't my favorite of the Beach Boys but it's definitely an interesting work with very strong moments ('Til I die) I don't know what's going on with the mixing/mastering of the album, but some songs are really suffering from imabalanced mixes and inelegant distortion. Bordering on being bad enough to deduct a star.
3.5 Certaines chansons étaient vraiment hyper chouettes ! C'est juste que le rock /pop psyché c'est pas trop ma tasse de thé alors quelques chansons par ci par là carrément avec plaisir mais un album entier c'est trop pour moi. Mention pour les harmos dingues (qui sont un peu la signature du groupe). J'espère juste avoir autre chose que du rock pour mon prochain album car ça fait 4 de suite
The boy band grows up.
It's no Pet Sounds, but it's actually a really good album, I had a good time with it. Doesn't overstay it's welcome. 4 Stars.
My doorway into the weird, wonderful world of mid-period Beach Boys. Worth it for the title track alone.
Not too bad, a lot slower than I expected form the Beach Boys 2/5
Good album. The Beach Boys sound like they're trying to move on from the Surfin' USA sound that they were known for. Not entirely successful, but it's fine
Not a bad album, glad I listened to this one. I might actually like this one more than Pet Sounds, which I've never really loved all the way through.
It's still quality pop, but somehow not at the level I expected. Lacks the "happiness" of other Beach Boys albums. That's not necessarily bad, but I wanted to hear some Beach Boys :)
I hadn’t heard a single song!
Pound for pound there’s more genius in the Beach Boys than the Beatles
Probably revolutionary music for the time. Makes for excellent grocery store songs in California.
Album 29/1001 Never heard any 70s stuff from the Beach Boys before. While not hitting the heights of Dennis' solo work later in the decade, this still has some interesting stuff on here. Favourite song: Feel Flows 🧘♂️🧘♀️ Honourable mention: Long Promised Road 🛣 Disney Girls 🐭👧 'Til I Die 💀🪦 Lookin' At Tomorrow (A Welfare Song) 🔎🗓 Surf's Up 🏄♂️⬆️
Not their best work
Why am I not listening to one of the good albums that The Beach Boys made? Some ok songs, but I expect more from this band. Not their best work.
It's a bit of an uneven mess, but the highs are so high ("Feel Flows" and "Surf's Up" especially) that I can't help but love it overall
Woah this wasn’t what I was expecting even with the unusual cover for a beach boys album. This was super weird but amazing nonetheless, the messages of environmentalism were great for a start but musically it was so engaging due to how unique and psychedelic it was, it has the classic beach boys sound in there with the harmonies and obviously the distinct voice of Brian Wilson but it’s completely altered with the production and overall sound of the album, the effects on the vocals, the wah sounds I would never normally associate with the beach boys and the weirdness of some of the songs (like the tree one) really create a surreal environment. Honestly in some ways this is better than Pet sounds and is arguably better dated but it doesn’t have the consistency of pet sounds due to how experimental it is and I personally prefer the former anyway. This album as an example of not being consistent has songs like take a load off your feet and feel flows which a feel a bit too odd for my taste. However, when this album hits (and it does quite often) it hits hard especially for a first listen. Favourites: almost all other than the ones mentioned. Overall, 8/10 (maybe 9 but not quite from a first listen point of view).
The Beach Boys are sooo cute and cool. Wow I really love the song Disney Girls. And I want to start a riot. And I want to save the trees. And I need to give my feet a break. It’s all just so true!
I listened to this on the train back from Boston looking out the window having existential thoughts about life, relationships, the demise of society, raising children, the inevitable implosion of the earth into the sun, and it was a surprisingly good soundtrack for that. I may have listened to Long Promised Road 10 times but who’s counting. I had always avoided The Beach Boys and now I know I was wrong. 5 stars for conversion!
To soft
1000 albums to listen to before you die they said. That doesn't necessarily mean they're good! A car crash is unpleasant, but you feel compelled to look at it! There are some really good songs on this album - Long Promised Road, Feel Flows, 'Til I Die are really diverting and demand repeated listening. Surf's Up is bonkers, but intriguing. Songs about dirty water and student demonstrations are well meaning but the songs are difficult to listen to, and I lost interest on songs about feet and trees! Not a complete waste of time, and I'm glad I listened to it, if only to realise how beautiful and how bad the Beach Boys can be on the same album.
top
Beach Boys but interesting. A little campy, and the end is lacking, but it is still good. Only 33 minutes
Best beach boys album I've listened to.
Good music, but BOY do those lyrics ever lack subtlety.
Echt een heel goed album! Mooie melodieuze liedjes en goede teksten. Meer diepgang dan ik had verwacht...
Not as good as their other stuff
What an album, what a band.
This one has their harmonies but overall it really doesn't do much for me. I had all weekend to listen to this one and didn't listen more than once:
A weird ass album full of good ass pop tunes that I can't quite put my finger on. I'm preaching to the choir here, I'm sure, but it should be said that The Beach Boys were way more than Pet Sounds and the early bring-your-babe-to-the-beach tunes.
The Beach Boys are consistently overrated. This is not their best work by a far shot. But it's not a terrible album. I'm glad I listened to it before I died, I just don't know that I needed to. Influence 3. Quality 3. Hits 1. I wasn't mad at it, but I really just didn't care 3.
A lot wilder than I expected, in a good way. I was expecting an entire album of Surfin' USA but it was nothing like that. Lots of avant-garde pieces. Not all of them were hits, but more than I would have imagined going in.
Mieć taką piękną okładkę i nagrać płytę bez żadnego wyrazu to trzeba jednak umieć
'Til I Die and Surf's Up are sufficient for this album to qualify as being rated 5.
Decent, definitely not the BB I grew up on. Would give it a relisten
Some good tracks, but a bit disjointed.
Vibes!
Quite a dark, moody, and crazy over the top variety of sounds/instruments from a "typical" beach boys album, so in that sense its a bit refreshing. Unfortunately it didn't really resonate much with me. Lots of environmental references and it comes off a bit chintzy. Fave track was "Surf's up", and least fave is "student demonstration time" -- da fuk was that?
Love it
Day 82 First listen- The album was enjoyable and I liked the harmonies. I probably need to listen again because I got distracted a lot. (3/5)
Sonoridade interessante do beach boys, uma versão deles que não conhecia, essa mais blues e rockabily. Mas definitivamente não mudou a minha vida
Damn. My long review got eaten up by a reloaded page. Suffice to say that this is a pretty underrated album, grand in scope and theme, and feels like a true group effort with Brian mostly on the sidelines.
Næææh... Hører at det her er noe, meeen ikke noe for meg.
Never been a Beach Boys fan. Mid.
The Beach Boys are psychedelic on this one! Groovy.
Um belíssimo disco. Rico instrumentalmente com seus sons psicodélicos muito bem construídos, formando um painel que se encaixa perfeitamente com as harmonias vocais tão características da banda. Uma música ousada, comparativamente à predominância da surf musica ingênua dos Beach Boys.
1. Don't Go Near The Water - 1 Lyrically this track is awful. It's so unpleasant the rest of the track, which is very light and melodic, cannot make you look past the terrible writing. 2. Long Promised Road - 4 It's overall a bit better that Don't Go Near The Water but the lyrics are still a little weak at parts and instrumentally this is almost more like Buddy Holly & The Crickets 1950s style than 1970s style rock outside of the bridge, which has a solid guitar solo in it. 3. Take A Load Off Your Feet - 1 Really poor. Instrumentally not great, lyrically poor, it's a completely forgettable and uninspiring track. 4. Disney Girls (1957) - 2 The bubblegum pop I've come to know The Beach Boys by. The thing is, it's not a particularly great style of music. An absolute lullaby. 5. Student Demonstration Time - 6 Guitar solo in the middle of the song is the best part about it. Lyrics aren't horrible but aren't great either. The pace and tone are way too dated. Still the second half of the song is much more enjoyable when the background choir comes in. 6. Feel Flows - 3 Instrumentally odd. It's not bad but it's not instrumentally fantastic. Vocally it's a little bit of that bubblegum pop or do-wop style that I don't tend to enjoy about The Beach Boys. 7. Lookin' At Tomorrow (A Welfare Song) - 5 Instrumentally very enjoyable and lyrically so at the beginning as well until the lyrics just fade into onomatopoeia. I love the sound of the lead guitar on this track and it's paired very well with the bass, which really lead the song on well. Just felt the ba ba ba and bip bip bip part of the lyrics are so unnecessary. It killed the enjoyment of the track for me. 8. A Day In The Life Of A Tree - 1 Incredibly boring track. Lyrically boring, instrumentally it sounds like a track you'd hear at a county fair. The worst track on the album so far. 9. 'Til I Die - 1 A lullaby. Lyrically extremely weak and repetitive. 10. Surf's Up - 2 Like two songs in one, the second of which is very melancholic and contains gibberish for lyrics. It's very cookie cutter barbershop quartet like Beach Boys, which I have never been a big fan of. Not a great track to end the album. Average Rating: 2.6 Adjusted to 5-Point Scale: 1.3 Rounded Down: 1 Star
This album started quite promising, but towards the end it sounded too much like the same old Beach boys
This doesn't fit into my idea of Beach Boys. Happy joyful nonsense is my basic picture of Beach Boys and even artwork of this album goes off from this image. Basic concept can be found throughout this album but takes band to rather different direction. Not bad, not good.
Latter day Beach Boys, I've not heard almost anything beyond Pet Sounds! Sadly this ended up being background music, couple of songs grabbed my interest, but otherwise did nothing for me. Good nor bad.
...
3.9
Better than their other material for me. Still not mind blowing
I liked this!! Long promised road and student demonstration time in particular but probs need to listen to more again tbh
Brian Wilson was/is a legend!
This was really fantastic. So ahead of its time. Fav Track: Student Demonstration Time 8.4/10
Not sure what I'm listening to here. Pass.
Beach Boys har været en stor inspiration til mange af mine favorit musikere. Det er derfor heller ikke en overraskelse at jeg er vild med deres album Surf's Up.
Добротный спокойный альбом. 7 из 10.
Dated
Die Beachboys mal etwas ernster.
Not at all what I expected. Interesting message. A bit far out there.
This is too dark and heavy for The Beach Boys. I guess this is what you get when you cross The Beach Boys with psychedelic rock and the politics of the early 70s. It ends up being pretty good. Even the cheesy songs like A Day in the Life of a Tree work well enough. Til I Die and Surfs Up are the best of the bunch. And yes, Student Demonstration Time really is terrible.
So who was gonna tell me this was better than Pet Sounds?? 4.5/5
Based on the artwork, this might be the strangest death metal album I've ever listened to.
A good album with some messages that are still very relevant today, not all of the songs were terrific but they were all pretty good.
The Beach Boys' production quality is out of this world
Way ahead of its time Every song is enjoyable. It may rival Pet Sounds. Loved it.
Good vocals and some catchy songs, but overall, not quite to my taste
This is an amazing, eclectic collection of sounds. Seems like the beach boys are of the other side of pet sounds. I feel like Ween listened to this album and got some inspiration. It's good, but is never think it was the beach boys. They are literally singing don't go near the water in the first song.
I think this might be the best beach boys album
What a departure in sound! This was the Beach Boys reinvented, largely without Brian Wilson and it shows. If I didn’t know that it was a Beach Boys album I would have had no idea. I primarily know and love their early to mid-60s output, so this was wholly unexpected and certainly not unwelcome. There are a couple of songs that were dated stinkers even at release, so I teetered on a 4 or 5 on this.
Yes, it's uneven, and yes, the misses here miss wildly - I can't tell whether "Student Demonstration Time" is an earnest attempt at a Doors song or a parody. And the production and related turmoil swirling around the group is constantly evident here, for better and worse (I'd like to take this opportunity to point out that Van Dyke Parks remains a fart-sniffer of the highest order). But the meaning of the Beach Boys has always been, like the sport they represented but mostly didn't actually practice, in moments of transcendence, and those are present in spades here - all the more impressive for being carried out mostly in Brian Wilson's absence. And if there's such a thing as "hitting wildly" then "Feel Flows" does it.