Surf's Up by The Beach Boys

Surf's Up

The Beach Boys

3.29
Rating
28806
Votes
1
4%
2
16%
3
38%
4
31%
5
11%
Distribution

Reviews (page 6 of 14)

I have only passing familiarity with The Beach Boys ‘70s catalog, and this is the first time I’ve heard this album. In contrast to the often slight albums that came before it, this one has remarkable weight. And while the creative leadership has shifted from Brian (now engulfed in mental illness) to Carl, that shift seems to have reinvigorated the band. Carl’s numbers like “Feel Flows” and “Long Promised Road” are quite strong and affecting, Brian does not no-show, though, as he delivers two of the strongest songs on the album with “TIl I Die” and the brilliant title track left over from the aborted Smile sessions. These are surrounded by oddly curious and eccentric oddities that mostly work (Mike Love’s “Student Demonstration Time” is the notable exception). Pet Sounds is the Beach Boys masterpiece, but this album comes closer to those rarefied heights than I would have expected was possible.

Beach Boys funeral doom phase Am I the only one that likes Student Demonstration Time?

I enjoyed Pet Sounds more but this was an interesting breaking away from their signature, "Surfin USA" sound they got famous for. The topics were also broader. It was an interesting take and change for them!

Student Demonstration Time is one of the worst tracks I've ever heard.

The tonal whiplash I felt jumping from “Long Promised Road” to “Take A Load Off Your Feet” can not be understated. This is a much darker tone than I’m used to from The Beach Boys, with that one single goofy and more lighthearted song thrown in just completely randomly. Before I forget to mention it, that album art is absolutely Metal. I see it and think we’re about to start listening to Heavy Metal or something. This is the second of three The Beach Boys albums I’ve rated, and I feel about the same way ratings wise as I did listening to Pet Sounds, although I enjoyed this one more for sure. However, I do appreciate how tight this one was. No filler, which is always huge when I’m trying to pick a favorite song. That being said, I really liked “Student Demonstration Time” the best. Some of the songs on this album just straight up rocked, which surprised me. I really didn’t know they were able to sound this way, but I like it. The flute solo in “Feel Flows” is particularly noteworthy and stands out in a big way. This is by all means a darker The Beach Boys album, and it’s actually really good. A VERY high 3, nearing a 4.

For some reason I was unaware of this record; maybe I should have been paying more attention back in 1971. This is a departure from the typical surf/car music the group was famous for in the 1960s. Lots of social commentary here. Overall it’s pleasant listening, but nothing outstanding.

The Beach Boys? Creators of my first 5, "Pet Sounds"? This is a pretty dark album cover for those guys, based on what we've heard so far. I didn't know they took a detour into activism. It starts off with a bop, though ('Don't Go Near the Water'), even though there's an unpleasant lil interlude. 'Long Promised Road' is basically a proto-'Tubthumping' (mixed with 'The Heart of the Matter' - which I like). Then comes an 'I Can't Help Myself' style boppin' PSA about feet*. Sure, OK! You haven't lost me yet! 'Disney Girls (1957)' was covered by Eurovision superstar Alexander Rybak! I found it a little boring otherwise, though. Not sure what to make of 'Student Demonstration Time' lyrically, but musically I don't love it. Bring back the songs about feet! 'Feel flows' is pretty good. ('Feet flows'?) I like the alliteration, but I could do without the flute interlude. 'Lookin' at Tomorrow (A Welfare Song)' is no good - the instruments overpower the vocals. But that guitar part is definitely in System of Down's 'Aerials', right??! Strong ending because I like System of a Down's Aerials. 'A Day in the Life of a Tree' is a delight. Very Magnetic Fieldsy. 'Til I Die' is OK, a little depressing. 'Surf's Up' is good; it's almost like a parody of a Beach Boys song, possibly somewhat intentionally. More good sounding lyrics, which is always of value. I had heard exactly none of these songs before, and it's no Pet Sounds, but it was a pretty good album. I didn't know they had it in 'em! Highlights: 'Long Promised Road', 'Surf's Up' *Wiki says:: Jardine explained, "It's cute, but come on ... for some reason Jack Rieley liked it too and said, 'It's got to be on the album. That's definitely an ecology song.' 'Ecology? A song about your feet?' It's personal ecology."

Not what I expected, but interesting. The first song felt like a pushback against the fun beach music they were known for. The protest song didn't work for me - it felt like they were making light of serious issues.

What is this shit? Take a weight off your ears and give this one a miss!

Je m’attendais à détester au final ça va c’est ok même un peu sympa pour certaines

Would have played Surf's Up sooner had I known it was relatively somber for the Beach Boys. But then again, I ultimately preferred Pet Sounds.

'Feel Flows' is an amazing song, but the rest of this record is just okay. Enjoyed the ride, but won't be revisiting.

Feel Flows is such an evocative song, one of my favorites. this album, like many brian wilson joints, is pretty uneven.

Album cover made me think this would be a lot darker than it was. Good album. Beach Boys intrigue the fuck out of me. Sonically interesting and shit. Last 4 songs bang

This is not your Dad's Beach Boys album. Quirky, socially conscious, punchy, different. Written while Brian Wilson was dipping hard into chemistry and dperession, so the rest of the band is trying to fill in. Nothing hooked me to bring me back to it, but it's weird enough to listen to again. My Rating: 4/5

More like Surf’s Down… not cuz it’s bad cuz it’s sad.

4/5 The Beach Boys or the Blues-Rock Boys? - The social record isn't their forte, but it's refreshing to hear them step into the protest song space. - Interests in the environment, students, the marginalized, and others show up in these tracks. - The record was originally going to be called "Landlocked" and this album certainly feels like a surfer with cabin fever. It ain't your mama's Pet Sounds, but it's a fun tape nonetheless.

This is not The Beach Boys I know and enjoy. This more experimental, melancholic style just isn’t that interesting. Student Demonstration is a highlight! ⭐️⭐️

More pure excellence

It's like beach boys on acid

I liked it for what it is

I've never listened to this album (18). Some good melodies, but it's far from Pet Sounds.

Definitely a darker, more morose vibe than I would expect from The Beach Boys. I really enjoyed this album.

The Beach Boys always surprise me. I guess the name always evoked a sense of pretty boy pop, but there’s layers.

This is actually my favorite Beach Boys album. I think Pets Sounds is overrated. I think Smile is good but goes on too long. This is just weird enough and unpopular enough that besides a greatest hits of their early stuff, really hits. That being said, it's not my favorite album of all time.

I don't get it. I haven't heard of any of these songs. Why is it so bloody good? Beautiful melodies, gorgeous harmonies, heavy intent. Who knew the Beach Boys fucked?

decent. not typical beach boys, but elements - harmonising etc. not favourite album of theirs

Couldn't really get into this one.

Good listen, no particular favourite song.

It was a pleasant listen. For me, not overly memorable and wouldn't feel drawn to go back necessarily but overall enjoyed my experience.

It's hard for me to get behind anything but Brian Wilson's singular vision with the Beach Boys - particularly anything after the aborted Smile sessions. Surf's Up (the song) is obviously a highlight, and there are other redeeming moments. However, most of it feels a little stale.

Jeg visste egentlig ikke at Beach Boys lagde album etter Pet Sounds. Alle vet at de prøvde å lage Smile, men jeg trodde at det endte der fordi B. Wilson ble cuckoo. Vel, så feil kan man ta. Do your research. Og dette er faktisk dritbra. Litt som Pet Sounds uten forventningene til å lage en Copernican revolution av et album, men "kun" en gruppe dyktige artister samlet om å lage en samling gode låter. De får dette til å føles veldig effortless, liksom bare look ma no hands, vi kan lage tidløs psychdelic baroque pop i søvne. Dette her er den typen album jeg kjenner kan gro på meg til å bli en all time favourite, og jeg er ikke langt unna å si at det kanskje er et bedre album enn Pet Sounds.* Til tross for hvor bra og viktig Pet Sounds er både for popkulturen, så vel som for min egen musikkhistorie, er det ikke et album jeg ofte kommer tilbake til lenger; det kan føles litt langtekkelig, til tross for at det er under 40min langt og smekkfullt av legendariske tracks, har det en litt overkalkulert pacing. Hvis Pet Sounds er en novelle med en singulær visjon, er Surf's Up en late-career kunstutstilling av en kunstner som ikke har noe å bevise lenger; deres plass i kunsthistorien er allerede fastsatt, nå kan de lage kunst for _seg_. I stor grad er det den typen album jeg tiltrekkes av i dag, se feks. min kjærlighet til The White Album, 69 Love Songs, og Double Nickels on the Dime. Surf's Up stiller naturligvis ikke i samme klasse i den grad det ikke er et "overlangt" album som en midwit sier hadde vært perfekt om det var en enkel-LP, men i mine ører spiller skiva på de samme kvalitetene. Og kanskje er det nettopp derfor dette treffer så bra som det gjør for meg. Skiva har én svak låt: Student Demonstration Time. Stilmessig føles den datert ut, i stedet for en moderne og fresh take på en klassisk stil som de sikkert håper at det var. Beatles klarte dette mye bedre, og starten kan minne litt om et misguided forsøk på å lage sin egen Revolution 1. De sterkeste låtene er til tider frysningsgivende. De tre siste Brian Wilson-skrevne låtene har en dybde til dem som de fleste artister bare kan drømme om å aspirere til. Første albumet i prosjektet som får full uttelling fra meg uten hadde jeg hadde hørt det fra før. *Jeg har nå hørt det i helhet to ganger på rappen, pluss B-siden en tredje gang, og er allerede villig til å si Surf's Up > Pet Sounds. Fight me.

Sterkt album fra Beach Boys. Både "Feel Flows", "Till I Die", tittelsporet og "Welfare Song" er blant mine favoritter i BB-katalogen. "Student Demonstration Time" er cringe, selv om teksten kanskje kan føles litt dagsaktuell om dagen. Brian Wilson gjør en sterk retur på slutten, som de andre har nevnt her. Skulle gjerne hørt hvordan denne skiva hadde hørtes ut om Brian var mer delaktig i produksjonen.

"Oh reality, it's not for me" For meg er dette kanskje den perfekte beach boys plata. Det er ikke den beste, jeg regner med at vi kommer tilbake til den senere, men denne skiva eksemplifiserer alt Beach Boys er. Beach boys er dystert og kaotisk, og det er lite som er så dystert, eller ihvertfall kaotisk, som Surfs up, og dualiteter og paradokser er overalt. Det er kun Beach boys som kan slippe en skive med, etter min mening, den beste låta noen sinne skrevet (Surfs up) sammen med hva enn Student Demonstration time er. Akkurat som figuren på albumomslaget, så handler tematikken i låtene om å kjempe en tapende kamp mot noe nedtrykkende og større enn deg selv. Long promised road, kampen mot sine indre demoner. Dont go near the water, kampen for et bedre miljø. Disney Girls (1957), å overvinne illusjonene rundt fantasier om livet og kjærlighet. Take a load of your feet er tilsynelatende en optimistisk låt om å ta vare på kroppen, men om man kjenner Brian Wilson sitt forhold til dette og hans besettelse av helsekost mens han ødelegger seg selv, blir dette også en sang om å kjemp mot noe man aldri når. En person som glimrer i sitt fravær i denne skiva er Brian Wilson, vel, ihvertfall frem til tidenes trio kommer helt på tampen. A day in the life of a tree Until i die Surfs up En litt ujevn, men spennende plate blir transformert til noe annerledes, uforutsigbart og sublimt. Låta Surfs up blir rekontekstualisert, fra en optimistisk revulosjonær låt om omveltning av iddeer , strukturer og verdier, til en låt om tapte håp og kamper. Tittelen blir kynisk og sarkastisk. Nå tenker du sikkert, hvordan kan man bruke ordet sublimt om et album som inneholder spor som Student Demonstration Time. Og svaret mitt til det er, jeg vet ikke. Beach boys sine skiver er alltid komprommittert, av labelet som vil kommersialisere, av Brian Wilson som ikke klarer å fungere, av uenigheter i gruppa, og denne skiva mest av alt, et jag etter å kynisk treffe en tidsånd. Og denne skiva klarte på mirakuløst vis å være en av de mest autentiske Beach Boys skivene, med et av de minst autentiske bakteppene. Og jeg tror det er kaoset som gjør dette sublimt.

original

Some moments of brilliance for sure (Feel Flows). Interested to see Brian Wilson was becoming less involved here, especially in production. Long Promised Road feels like it could be so much better but something about the production is holding it back. A lot of those songs, plus one or two that are just bad. Need to go through the discography from Pet Sounds to this.

I loved this. Sincere, but with the kind of edge that comes w experi mce. Maybe less innovative than Pet Sounds, but that makes sense since it was 5 years later. Disney girls is so fucking good, as is Feel Flows and don’t go near the water.

Man, I dont know how to feel about this album. On one hand, Take A Load Off Your Feet was WAY ahead of its time. To my ears, I hear happy, dorky alt rock like this everyday. Surfs Up is another mega track that needs at least 5 listens to appreciate (err at least it did for me) and its clearly the critical focus of the album (not to mention the most meaningful as well) Shifting to the shitty side, Student Demonstration Time doesn’t hold a candle to 4 Dead In Ohio and IMO, this song sounds incredibly corny. I thought it was an ironic song - an attack on politically charged music. Nope, its serious. Pet Sounds and The Beach Boys Today were so much easier to digest at first. This is inspiring me to take a dive into everything after Pet Sounds to hear what the heck was happening here. A note to my future self: dude, I tried. And I think I understood some of this, but there were some genuinely awful tunes here that I couldn't look past

I had never heard most of this album (Disney Girls was one). I really enjoyed it. A very different, somber vibe from the Boys (much closer to Pet Sounds in tone than Surfin' Safari), which I think suits their strengths.

I went through this when Sean recommended Feel Flows a while back. Excellent song. The album has other bright spots - Long Promised Road, Surf’s Up - but overall hangs together a little less than PS or Today.

Uhhhhhh… Nice vibes? Not an absolute all timer 5/10 14/09/25

I like the harmonies, but it didn't have the blissed-out feel-good vibe of other albums, or fun psychedelia. Kind of a boring application of their signature sound.

Long Promised Road has always been a banger, rest of the album wasn't quite as inspired

Interesting songs I’d never heard by them. I liked it but not loved it.

Album déjà réécouté pendant le week-end, une très belle découverte!

Not very “beach” but definitely they “boys” not necessarily a bad album but definitely something that reminds me of being stuck at grandmas and she didn’t believe in air conditioning.

Like it! Nice harmony

hot take: surf’s up > pet sounds ? i really enjoyed this album! i’ve let it simmer for a while and after having returned to it on several occasions i conclude that this is a 5 and that i really love the darker sound to it. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

For a long time Pet Sounds was all I listened to of The Beach Boys. I think this was the album I listened to next several years later. A very different listen from a wearier sounding band. The title track and Feel Flows rank among their most beautiful songs.

As a teenager, the very first album I purchased with my own money was by The Beach Boys. That was the start of my appreciation of their music and this album was certainly on the list of their many albums I purchased over the years.

A weird fucking album. Luckily, I like weird fucking albums.

Not what I expected from beach boys, and not bad

This was weird af

Best Track - "Long Promised Road"

Good OG BB flavour with some interesting synth parts and vocal phasor effects which reflect quite obviously the year of release. Some good pop tunes mixed with some more experimental numbers. Quite dark at times, references to the then current social and natural climates. Still some good "BA BA BAs" included!

Night vibes - Dreamy - Hypnotic. Algunas un tanto repetitivas

❤️: Student Démonstration Time 🙂: Surf's Up 👍: Disney Girls Long Promised Road

Sounds like they were into the White Album

Les Beach Boys en pleine forme (de création musicale).

Ahhh fait du bien, j'étais un peu sur un drought moi là et je commençais à me demander si j'aimais pu la musique ou j'étais juste grincheux. Je connaissais moins Surf's Up que Pet Sounds et Smiley Smile, mais Brian Wilson est encore absolument génial. Disney Girls me donne des frissons dans les magnifiques séquences d'harmonie. Les tounes écologiques et les thèmes d'introspection émotionnelle et deep revelations (encouragés par quelques hits de LSD et de schizo sûrement) frappent juste.

Les Beach Boys souffrent d’avoir pondu un chef d’oeuvre avec Pet Sounds. Tout le reste en pâli. Pas contre j’ai bin apprécié quand même. Long promised road est excellente. Student demonstration time suprenante avec le son garage rock à mille lieux de surfin USA.

2/1001 ~ First ever listen. Three tracks in, it sounds to me like a heaping spoonful of Rundgren, a dash of Yes, and …wow, did this just become an intervention? Given all the health drama I’ve been through this year, including multiple issues unique to each foot, the song “Take a Load Off Your Feet" sounds a little bit like a read. Anyway, Disney Girls, er DIZ-ooh-NEE Girls, lends a whirling Wonkatania wistfulness, and suddenly we’re student protesting at…the Red Dog Saloon? So far this album is an eclectic collection of sounds and ideas that feels a little like overlapping identity crises, or too many cooks in the kitchen bubbling up a soupy grey area—In a good way. I like how it sounds unfinished or in progress despite the definitive album title. Maybe this one's supposed to hang in the ether as-is, distant, like its vocal harmonies. 'Til I Die.

Really good, never thought I'd see the day that I enjoyed the beach boys

Had never heard of this album or the songs on it. I liked them though and still think the beach boys are great

Previously rated: The Beach Boys Today! (4/5) Pet Sounds (4/5) ********************************* I don't think I've heard a single track on this album before. Some of the lyrics here are a bit too on the nose for me, and associating the Kent State shootings with what was originally a comedy song ("Riot in Cell Block No. 9") was kind of strange. However, I think it deserves another listen because there are some interesting things going on here. It doesn't have the standout tracks that Pet Sounds has, but a lot of what's here beats the filler tracks on that album.

Surf’s Up would get 5 stars for the cover alone, but the music is fantastic too. After Smile failed to coalesce into an actual release, the Beach Boys would include an occasional song from those sessions on their next few albums. Surf’s Up was the last song to appear from Smile until the release of the full Smile sessions in 2011. It feels fitting as the last song from that era to come out. This whole album feels like the true end of the Beach Boys. They’ve moved on from surfing and girls to larger concerns about the environment and death itself. A progression the band was always working towards and became fully realized here. Bittersweet but a wonderful listen nonetheless

Basic with BB attempt at protest song

Liked this more than I expected. Listened through to Pet Sounds after Brian Wilson died and couldn’t get into it. This was more Neil Young than barbershop quartet. Felt ahead of its time.

🗯 Cracked sunshine, innocence gone — but still gorgeous. This isn’t the same Beach Boys of Surfin’ Safari or even Pet Sounds. By 1971, the counterculture had burned bright and begun to collapse, and so had Brian Wilson. Surf’s Up feels like the wreckage and the beauty intertwined — lush harmonies, but with an unmistakable melancholy running through them. Tracks like ’Til I Die and A Day in the Life of a Tree ache with existential weight, while the title track (rescued from the abandoned Smile sessions) is nothing short of breathtaking, a hymn to lost utopias. Even the lighter cuts (Disney Girls, Long Promised Road) carry a wistfulness that makes the whole album feel haunted. It’s a late-era triumph, proof that The Beach Boys could still conjure magic while standing in the shadows of what they’d already done. Verdict: Excellent (a bruised beauty, less iconic than Pet Sounds but still deeply moving) For fans of: Brian Wilson, Smile-era fragments, melancholy wrapped in perfect harmony

Reading the Wikipedia article about this album, it seems the critics reckoned three of the songs on this album were good. To my mind that's not enough to make this album great. I didn't really like any of this albume and I found the lyrics pretty trite. I suppose they had to release something from the failed Smile sessions, but frankly the best thing about this album is its brevity. Oh, except for the slightly weird cover.

Not the vibe we'd usually associate with The Beach Boys but we enjoyed it.

Liked this more than I thought I would!

🤏🏻🤷🏻‍♂️

Beach Boys going psychodelic, I liked it, some weird moments

Solid Album, the vibe was goood. Will go back.

Really great album of top-notch early 70s psychedelia on top of its iconic cover. Blah blah blah Student Demonstration Time sucks.

Not much here. You can tell Brian Wilson didn't have much involvement in this album. Only decent song is Surf's Up, and it doesn't rank up there with the Beach Boy classics.

je suis bien neutre par rapport à cet album

This is such a cool album cover, but the album doesn’t really hold up for me. It’s trippy, psychedelic, and all over the place. It’s definitely unique and pretty fun at times, but I’m not sure if I’ll ever return to it.

'Toothpaste and soap will make / Our oceans a bubble bath / So let's avoid an ecological aftermath.' The Beach Boys weren't the only artists in '71 to bemoan ecological catastrophe: Marvin Gaye in fact did it more classically on 'Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology).' But no one did it as romantically or as heavenly as the grown-up and fed-up group once inclined to preach an all-is-good ethos on tracks like 'Surfin' U.S.A.' It's now Surf's Up and all is not good: 'But now my branches suffer / And my leaves don't offer / Poetry to men of song.' In good faith, I can't say this is on par w/ Pet Sounds, which in its own way is just as dark and daring as this one, but I applaud it for its originality and for its moments of unusual beauty, especially tracks 6-10.

Brilliant album. Better than Pet Sounds in my opinion.

A lot of psa on this album, which, in addition to the harmonies that always seemed very light hearted, makes the album seem almost silly. 3/5

The artwork goes insanely hard. The album itself isn’t my favorite, but it is pretty decent – it’s sonically a bit all over the place, with occasional lyrics about environmentalism and social justice somewhat bringing things together. The unique arrangements and effects across the board are ultimately what sell the album for me – I can’t really see myself coming back to any of these songs individually in the future. Highlights: Take a Load off Your Feet, Feel Flows, ‘Til I Die

Not too bad for a beach boys album

Certainly a more mature sound then I am used to from the Beach Boys. Ultimately not my flavor.

Album cover was the best part.

I don't think I'd ever seen this album cover before. Very funny.

Når Beach Boys siger at man ikke skal gå i nærheden af vandet, så skal der lyttes! Jeg kan ikke svinge mig op til mere end 3 selvom jeg nåede 2 lyt. Det er så fint, me. Ikke mere end det.

The Beach Boys go dark. Det lyder mere interessant end meget af det andet jeg har hørt fra dem.

Stupendous

So far ahead of their time Jesus what a great album, stuff they sing about prevalent today 50 years later

This isn’t a bad album, not by a long shot, but when you set it against the full weight of the Beach Boys’ catalog, it doesn’t sit near the top for me. What is interesting is how much more inward and aware it feels compared to their sun-bleached early work. There’s a personal, almost confessional tone running through it, paired with a sharper social consciousness that you don’t always expect. It reads like a transitional record, a moment where they’re still carrying the harmonic DNA everyone knows, but bending it toward something more reflective, even uneasy. The commercial reception backed that up: it charted well, enough to show the public was still listening, but the material itself signals a band in the middle of an artistic pivot. Familiar, yet distinctly not; a break from the past without completely abandoning it.

Not my fav from them

also really good

Awesome songwriting and some beautiful mature sequencing. Wasnt quite sure what the picture was like so far after pet sounds.

This album was so fine and I LOVED it!!!!!!!!!!!! Especially the song "Looking at Tomorrow"! I'm obsessed with it

A perfect album. Good variety, plenty of tongue-in-cheek with songs like Take a Load Off Your Feet, tasteful use of synths in Long Promised Road and Student Demonstration Time, classic Beach Boys sound in tracks like Surf’s Up, but overall the album’s sound is more progressive, dynamic, and experimental while still being quite listenable.

Best track 'surf's up'

4 stars I was not familiar with this album at all. I was skeptical. Having only really listened to Pet Sounds all the way though and finding it somewhat overrated (but still good), I wasn’t sure a 70’s Beach Boys album would do much for me. However, I was pleasantly surprised. The album does contrast with expectations of The Beach Boys in a way I feel works. Starting with “Don’t go near the water” has this surreal experience that something is off. It ends up being pretty consistent. While the album does not include anything nearly as perfect as “Wouldn’t it be nice” or “God Only Knows,” I feel like the flow and pace work better than Pet Sounds. Who knew? It’s still not at all perfect. But I managed to enjoy it all the way through on multiple listens- even songs other complain about like “Student Demonstration Time” I found to be fun and effective. I felt like “Surf’s Up” felt a little out of place on the album, but it may be because I’m familiar with the Smile version having heard Brian Wilson Presents Smile years ago, and knowing how it was supposed to fit more within the flow of its original context. But it is still an interesting track and fits in the same kind of unexpected feeling of the rest of the album. This was a pleasant surprise.

I grew up with a Beach Boys Greatest Hits tape. I loved it. I still do. But that was almost the entirety of my knowledge of the Beach Boys. Then Almost Famous came out and introduced me to Feel Flows which became an instant favorite. But I still never looked into any other Beach Boys beyond what I knew to that point. The cover of Surf's Up doesn't look it would be anything related to fun and sun and surfing. It looks dark, ominous and brooding. And so it goes with the album - this isn't the polish pep I was expecting - even with the cover casting a shadow. Other than Student Demonstration Time - which catches my attention for being kind of ridiculous in a bad way - once I can separate myself from my summer sun expectations, this ends up being a pretty great record.

Є щось таке у музиці біч бойз, що важко артикулювати. Мені цікаво до них повертатись інколи, хоча не зовсім прям мій стиль.

There's something a bit uncanny about this record, like a couple going through a divorce putting on a rather convincing smile in public, through which you can only see the cracks when you already know they're there. But sometimes you've got to ease it with metrics like "cohesiveness" and "consistency", and simply realise that if 90% of these songs are pretty bangin', then that must mean it's a pretty bangin' album too.

Very good and cozy music

Loved it! As always with The Beach Boys I come for the vocal harmonies, some heartfelt lyrics, and a little camp. This album delivered all that and then some. Favorite tracks were Long Promised Land, Disney Girls, Student Demonstration Time, and Surf’s Up

Best one yet. Buying this. That one occasion that Charles Manson and drugs had a good influence.

Overall, really enjoyed the album. Had a lot of great songs, especially Disney Girls and Surfs Up. There were a few weirder songs, but overall great.

Listened to this one forever ago. Still liked it enough. Not as instantly recognizable or memorable as other Beach Boys outings.

Beste nummer verpest met abrupte fadeout

Juste students protest

Back at it with the albums. First catch up, Surfs Up, Beach Boys. I really tried, I’m a BB fan, but think one isn’t good. The production is very good and every thing sounds great but the actual songs, a bunch of stinkers. And then, suddenly, we reach the end and Til I Die and Surfs Up are right there with Brian’s best work. Surfs Up in particular is brilliant. This is the end of the classic BB period and almost falls completely flat but for the end. Good enough to earn this one a 3/5

nice enough

I never liked the Beach Boys sound, and,while this is different, I didn't like it any better.

This was severely disappointing. I can't listen to this without comparing it to other albums by the Beach Boys, and by comparison, this sucked. Perhaps, taken on its own without a comparison to their other music, I could like it. Unfortunately, my brain just doesn't work that way. This was not the version of the Beach Boys I like. Ugh...⭐⭐?

This is another album that over the course of time has somehow inexplicably built steam in the critics eyes. Its easy to see how this influenced other groups and blended genres of music later on, it doesnt mean this is A. good or B. something someone NEEDS to hear before they die. I suppose you NEED to hear this if you want to hear the last gasp of a once great pop group.

It was kinda out there, but not always in a way that I liked. The latter half was definitely better, but didn't really amaze me that much.

Haven't listened to much of the Beach Boys, not at all what I expected. Fun, nice listen with some interesting effects going on.

D Strand büebli once again, und das es stückli besser wie s letzte Album. Aber jetzt doch au nüd Wellebrechends. Go with the flow und 3 hang loose

boyzboysboyz gemütlich wie immer, aber halt au nüd speziel guets. es gid es abgrundeti 3 sandkörner für e neui beach am ne schwizer see.

Not a fan. The songs were all over the place in terms of tone and instrumentation. I appreciate some of yhe messaging of the songs, but overall a dissapointing entry from the Beach Boys. 1.5/5

It's pretty cool, cover is sick

Not a fan

Nothing too marvelous imo. Some pretty neat vocal harmonies

listened to again great stuff

I didn't dig this. Maybe good for it's time but I was bored.

I didn’t actually hate this, which I fully expected to. Some of it really works - Long Promised Road, Take a Load Off Your Feet, Disney Girls. A lot of it is twee though and deeply outdated. Low 3.

I'd rather listen to my parents have sex than put this album on again. There are too many heinous moments to count: 'four martyrs earned a new degree, the bachelor of bullets'. 'Trees like me can live if all this earth can give is pollution and slow death'. I don't have the words to describe my despair when I realized they'd written a whole song about feet. Was this popular among anyone who wasn't being viciously bullied in the 70s? Hateful 1* from me.

This is kind of a fascinating album. The band’s beautifully arranged harmonies are still mostly here, but the lush multi-instrumental production from the Pet Sounds era is not. This is the Beach Boys in full on image reinvention mode. No more of that carefree ‘Surfin USA’ stuff; now the Beach Boys have something important to say: “Don’t go near the water”, “adults are phoneys”. Some of it is effective - and even poetic, but I can’t help but feel a song like Student Demonstration Time has totally missed the boat by 1971. Aside from being abjectly horrible, it sounds a bit phoney coming from a band like the Beach Boys - and plain baffling on an album that also espouses the importance of good feet hygiene. Equally important messages, I guess. With that said, I’ve always found the Beach Boys so endearing, and the same applies here. I really love the song Surfs Up - it’s the only high point for me on the album. And I do admire the group’s attempt to rail against the public’s image of them. It’s just all a bit in vain here. ⭐️⭐️

Hmmm. Unlike a lot of albums I've gotten lately, I am glad to have heard this one. But what a weird collection. Until we get to the Brian Wilson productions at the end, it's almost a sine wave: Long Promised Road, Disney Girls, and Feel Flows are good; Don't Go Near the Water, Take a Load Off Your Feet, and Student Demonstration Time are not. And the last three - the production is reminiscent of the glory days, but the songs feel like excuses for recording, rather than the point of it.

p234. 1971. 4 stars. Parts of this have not aged well, and several of the tracks stray into faux eco-hippy nonsense - but when it's good, its brilliant. It is 32 degrees in the UK, clear blue skies, and this is the almost perfect soundtrack to a lovely day.

Really surprised by this one. Had not listened to much beach boys beyond Pet Sounds and couldn’t believe how evolved their sound was. Seemed very ahead of their time

Filled with industrial electronic beats and typical Kanye lyrics I would say this album is great listen with standouts on the album being On

nem rossz. kicsit indifferens vagyok ezzel

The final two songs are fantastic. The rest suffers from a decided lack of Brian Wilson's influence.

Very cool listen. Gotta respect when a band with the clout of The Beach Boys decides to try something new and undefined -- and, they do it well. I don't think it's perfect, but it's very unique and very solid. Fave songs: - Don't Go Near The Water - Long Promised Road - Take A Load Off Your Feet - Student Demonstration Time (side note: why does everyone hate this?? It's kind of a total vibe???) - Lookin' At Tomorrow - Surf's Up

I did not expect this type of sound from The Beach Boys it was interesting!

Like the song "'Til I Die", the vocal harmonies sound too retro to me.

I was previously only familiar with their hits. This album showcases a lot more range and I found it really engaging.

This album subverted all my expectations for The Beach Boys. Everything I thought I knew about them no longer stands. Off of just knowing their hits I was prepared to hate this album, and wow was I pleasantly surprised. Awesome album with awesome songs, I didn’t know my beach brethren had this in them.

Un disco con baladas psicodélicas, por ratos tiene sonidos más viejos de lo que realmente son y no puedo evitar pensar en la etapa psicodélica de los Beatles al escuchar este trabajo. No tengo un tema que considere mejor que el resto.

Some songs I really liked, overall gut composition but not my favorite and only saved 2 songs to my playlist

That was a great album although the feet song is weird.

Spécial spatial. Prod pleine de surprises. 3.75 étoiles

This is a bit of a revelation. I'm generally a Beach Boys skeptic but this is excellent. Only really knew Feel Flows before but but will need to revisit this

Hmm. Some really good (‘Til I Die and Surf’s Up), and some really really bad (opening track, the one about feet, and the Tree song). Never really understood the critical love for The Beach Boys, but did a bit of deep dive once this album popped up and now I understand better the musical genius of Brian Wilson, even if I don’t love all of the music. There were spots on this record that were sonically beautiful, but some of the lyrics are just putrid. So this one for me was a mixed bag. At times during the listen, I was thinking a “2” at best, but then there was some truly genius tracks, and I was thinking 4. Guess I’ll have to settle in the middle. The 2-3 great songs save this for me and I’ll give it a 3, bordering on a 2 for a third, bordering on a 4 for a third.

It’s ok

real enjoyable. paced well, short and sweet. had to remind myself it was the 70s.

Lowkey mid. As a beach boys fan, idk how I haven’t heard this album. Only like 2 decent songs. The 70s were a time I suppose

I’ve never really been a fan of The Beach Boys, the instrumentation is good in this album but I just can’t get in to the lyrics, they are often a bit to in the nose

#666. <insert Steve Buscemi "How do you do, fellow kids?" meme here> What is happening with this album? This shit is fucking weird, and not in a good way. 2/5: yikes

Fuck me, not another Beach Boys album. I'm starting to feel like it's me that's wrong. The previous BB albums I've reviewed were largely shite, occasionally dipping into bearable. This particular album was more bearable than shite, but it's still a long way from something I would willingly seek out and listen to.

Čakal som, že to bude horšie ale stále to znie dosť staro. Neboli tam zle pesničky a prizmurujem trochu oči lebo to není môj žáner.

I loved this

When I think of The Beach Boys, I think of their classic surf rock sound. This was something else, a combination of pretty good production, near psychedelic vibes, combined with the idea of summer or islander energy. I was pleasantly surprised when I heard effects popularized in dub or other Jamaican genres, giving me that gringo-beach feel. I wasn't very impressed with the social pieces, they felt overproduced and in that sense, not genuine either. Still! Pretty decent listen, I'm glad I heard this other side of the band. I'm not gonna actively look for this record, but if I spot it at a good price, I'd buy it.

Beach boys: depression edition.

3.5/5 - really liked Feel Flows but rest were just ok for me. Maybe I would have more appreciate if this wasn’t my first beach boys album?

Meh, being more mellow doesn't really work for The Beach Boys.

Not a fan of this album.

I feel like this album misses the arrangements of Brian Wilson. And though the themes are darker and more serious than early Beach Boys, that does not by itself make this album great. Honestly, for me, this album is fine at best. Lyrically, a lot of the songs feel weak to me, and the harmonies just aren't as robust as they are with Wilson.

Something different than their big hits. But not for me.

Probably my favorite beach boys album. Imcredibly creative song writing and melodies.

Not as depressing as the album cover makes it seem, although it is most definitely a darker sound for The Beach Boys, I love the atmospheric spaces they make in the instrumentation along with the echoey vocals. It feels like music for walking along the beach at night, that half sort of peaceful/haunting vibe.

Turns out i'm a huge beach boys fan

Loved this - different side to The Beach Boys, but reflects the changes music and culture went through in the 60s into the early 70s.

dont touch the water?

This really blindsided me. It's a big change from conventional Beach Boys sound, which doesn't completely work. It feels a bit insincere, as if they're trying to get with the times and grow out of their niche, but there are growing pains. It's an inconsistent and flawed record, but it is interesting. My favorite part was the last 3 tracks ("A Day in the Life of a Tree", "Til I Die", "Surf's Up") which are actually all the Brian Wilson-written songs on the record. I guess that goes to show that when I say I like the Beach Boys, I'm really saying I like Brian Wilson. I think the rest of the album needs to sink in for me, and will get better with re-listening. It sits around a 3 or 4 for me after one listen, so I will round up with the expectation it will grow on me.

Tremendo registro histórico. Mucho más psicodelico de lo que me esperaba, igual me gustó.

Mehhh. Not The Beach Boys I love.

You would think after 17 albums they would know what good sounds like..... clearly not. T

Preferred the movie adaptation

9/10 A post Smile BB album, which means it will be uneven, maybe weird, and doesn’t have as much Brian as you’d like. Tick. But this is better than I remember - great even - and is right up with Sunflower for me in the “second best BB album” competition. Carl’s contributions are excellent, stand out songs. Second side of this album is ridiculously strong (shock horror that’s where the Brian stuff is). Best: ‘Til I Die

5/5. Absolutely amazing!!!

I reckon this was great at the right time. Some dreadful lyrics though

Really enjoyed it - I will have to listen to more beach boys

Ei niin hyvä mitä aikaisempi Beach boys levy. ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Tämä oli kyllä hyvä! Vaihtelevaa ja miellyttävää meininkiä koko levy!

I much prefer this album to the previous, kitschy “in their sound” Pet Sounds. This was simple, classic, and delightful.

Still Sunflower for me 5/10

A more psychedelic Beach Boys but also they're more environmentally conscience? They should have made the whole album Feel Flows.

Incredibly flawed in the first half (long promised road aside). Second half hits all the depressing highs.

good compositions and harmonies, but not my favorite. Too manufactured trying to find the right slot.

The Beach Boys weren't my favorite band. I'll say that because of that, I didn't listen to a lot of their music. And with that I found this album surprising because of its difference.

A couple good songs but really kinda cringey or corny.

2- Stars (4/15)

I enjoyed this one, though I have to say that I'm looking forward to Pet Sounds as it's my favorite Beach Boys album. This one had a lot of tracks I'd never heard before, and they weren't all what you'd think of when you think of the Beach Boys. More somber and less sunshine sometimes. I also really like the album art. Standouts: Feel Flows, 'Til I Die, Surf's Up Rating: 3.75/5

Another album that's meant to be a classic. I've never got any further than quite liking it.

Listened in the truck via YouTube music. This was an interesting album and sounds like a band trying to be The Beach Boys. The vocals are not in full swing with all the harmonies. Some tracks do feature their signature vocal sound but others are way more sparse. Subject matter is environmental and political and kind of funny. Till I Die I had heard before. Really solid song and interesting artwork for the album compared to the name.

This album was pretty good! I hadn't heard any of these songs before so it was nice to hear some new beach boys!

what if the beach boys were moody?

Never thought going to the beach with some boys would be such a snooze fest.

A few days ago I was discussing with my brother how I think I just don't get the Beach Boys and the Beatles. He concluded that maybe I just don't like the 60's sound. Strange, because I like Cream, Hendrix, the Doors, Zeppelin, Zappa... But I will now contend that when people claim that these two bands competed to be the best, it's trying to be the best in something I have no space in my heart for. This kind of music was a race in what is something of a tech demo. Who can layer the most impressive soundscape, the most complicated harmonies? Does that yield the objectively best music? To people invested in that race it does. That would not be me.

Some experimental songs really hit hard. The lyrics are really well written. Great work, Mr Wilson and crew. Just not completely convinced by the album as a whole. 6,5/10 fav songs : Student Demonstration Time (which is just the BB version of Revolution) & Surf's Up

It's OK but not earth breaking.

This was actually one of the strangest albums in this project. It felt like a psychedelic children's album. I kind of liked Don't Go Near The Water and Lookin' at Tomorrow (A Welfare Song). I found the first half of Surf's Up annoying but then it gets good at around the 3 minute mark. Strange vibes.

I know the 60's were gentler times, but there's a lot of PSA in this album that feels a bit silly at times. It's OK, but I was looking for a riot.

I appreciate all of their experimentation with sound and melodies, but it never really comes together for me.

konczy to trzydniowa passe trzygwiazdkowa serdeczne gratulacje

This album is full of theatricality, which makes of it something great and a very diverse album. It is such an enjoyable album that catches you from start to begging. I have to admit it has impressed me.

weird, noises, eh. Too old.

This reminded me of the first time I heard Odessa by the Bee Gees, in that I had very specific expectations based on what I was used to from the band and was very wrong. This album title seemingly alludes to the era of surf pop being over (everyone loves a good pun). Despite being very different to my favourite Beach Boys albums, this does stand up on its own as a different type of good. It’s almost proggy, and way more intricate to those poppy surf bops.

Not my favourite beach boys album but fine. Won’t be on regular rotation

Gentle, surf tinged pop with great vocal harmonies

Meh? It seems weak for the Beach Boys. I'm not much of a Beach Boys fan, but this lacks the engineering and composition that makes them fun and engaging.

-second Beach Boys album i’ve heard. really good, i’d say it might even have more variety and range than Pet Sounds -it did have a less cohesive feel than Pet Sounds however which made it kinda tough to connect with every song? still glad i listened, it expanded upon my Beach Boys knowledge -Favorites are Don’t Go Near The Water, Long Promised Road, and Student Demonstration Time

A really unique and relaxing listen. Nice and low-key melodies while still mixing in some summery/teeny bop classic Beach Boys. Much more sophisticated and mature sound. Straightforward and generally unremarkable lyrics, but still fun to put on and close your eyes to. Top tracks: Don't Go Near The Water, Disney Girls (1957), 'Til I Die

Dare I say the album art might be by far the best thing about this album.

despite never listening to this album before (why THIS beach boys album???) for some reason I have every single song downloaded? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ anyway there's some weird mixing and a lot of vocals are directly in my right ear and it just doesn't seem like i'm listening to the beach boys a lot of the time? favorite song: "feel flows" overall: 4/10 (sorry y'all)

If anyone mentions the Beach Boys, you automatically think of sun, surf, sand and girls (in roughly that order) sung by fresh faced, smiling Californian dudes. Alarm bells already start ringing with the cover to this album depicting a defeated spear carrier on a dying horse, looking like a Scandinavian death metal illustration. Whilst the music sort of sounds like the Beach Boys of old, the subjects include death, student riots and pollution with only a couple of moments where Brian Wilson’s genius shines through (notably in the title track which was a hold over from the legendary lost Smile album). It’s the Beach Boys Jim, but not as we know them.

That is interestingly different from the other Beach Boys albums I've listened so far, it feels "darker" and less "Oh hey I love the sun in the sky and girls on the beach". Maybe it is linked to the time when it was recorded (early seventies). They don't play doom metal either, don't get me wrong.

Solidly good album overall. Enjoyed how Don't Go Near Water was an almost satirical take on their early work. Great harmonies throughout the whole record.

12/07/2025 Apparently I don't have an issue with the Beach Boys.

Ethereal and very mellow.

So I’m familiar with a lot of The Beach Boys work because they were one of my first memories of hearing and liking a band. My grandmother gave me a few best of cassettes and a golden oldies cd and that was my earliest memory of music. But that being said I never actually got into their actual studio albums cause I grew up WAY after their prime and compilation cds were everywhere. But my point is that this entire album I had never seen or heard before. The cover is so dark and gloomy, my immediate assumption was that this was from their branching out period where they strived to get psychedelic with their sound and I was so happy to be right. That first track “don’t go near the water” how have I never heard this/never been on one of their best of albums. The song subject matter is still relevant to this day, it’s kinda dark and gloomy, but it’s also so creative and with that wholesome BB charm. Honestly this whole album really blew me away. I assumed this era in their history was underwhelming or embarrassing cause music documentaries and album sales would make you think that The Beatles were just annihilating them and they are always pitted one another in “music textbooks”. But honestly this is equally good. The amount of talent and creativity is all over this super fun album. My only problems are as always I struggled with some of the slower songs, so there are just a few skips. And because it’s the BB and they have their super nostalgic and crystal clean harmonies, which I enjoy in all their pop hits, but for their “edgy” psychedelic album they should’ve taken risks with the vocals. Don’t try and sound like other bands, keep doing what your doing but maybe less falsetto harmonies. I think that would’ve added a cool dynamic to this album, but what do I know. But to end on a positive, this album did force me to dive deeper into their catalogue to find more gems like this album. Definitely go give this album a listen.

Fun synths, interesting lyrics. Liked track 3

interesting

This was my third Beach Boys album in a month, but all three were different enough to be interesting. The typical Beach Boys sound is here, but it's generally tempered compared to some of their earlier stuff. The environmental message was occasionally cloying but came from a good place.

Even mid level beach boys is better than most of the other stuff out there

This album is pretty great. 1001 album generator is giving me a much greater appreciation of the Beach Boys and their brilliance. Such rich, tangible and fully realised songs. This album is full of great, fun songs, a few that are just okay. I really love Disney girls, beautiful song, I’d even say it rivals Something by The Beatles. I really don’t like the way ‘Lookin’ at tomorrow” sounds, the production is very nauseating for some reason. What a great, weird cover too! Fav tracks - Don’t go near the water - Long Promised Road - Take a Load Off Your Feet - Disney Girls - Student demonstration time - Feel flows - A day in the life of a tree Worst track - Lookin’ at tomorrow

Alright. Ok. Ok.

Enjoyed it more than expected

Save the trees! And the water!

I’m not a beach girl

This is definitely a different Beach Boys than Pet Sounds.

Wow... I'm NOT a Beach Boys fan but this sounds nothing like a Beach Boys album (until the final track Surf's Up). A ton of psych influence, overt social and environmental lyrics, more diverse and experimental sound. All fused with the solid studio magic perfected on Pet Sounds. I don't love it all but it was a very pleasant surprise.

80/100. Surf’s Up feels like The Beach Boys looking inward, not just musically, but emotionally. Musically, the album offers plenty of beauty. The harmonies are lush, and the arrangements often drift into dreamlike territory. Not every track holds the same emotional power, and some moments feel more like transition pieces than fully formed ideas.

a nice chill album but sorta empty. probably good for the time but it's missing something now

I can't say I'd listen to this again, or that any track really stood out to me, although Long Promised Road is probably the highlight here. For me, the production sound was phenomenal. The songs didnt even have to do it for me, I loved the production enough that it kept me engaged.

9/1001 The Beach Boys - Surf's Up Heard Before? ❎ Revisit? ✅ Melancholic Beach Boys is the best version of the band. Here, it sounds like a warning of the hippie dream gone wrong. One or two dude here and there, but overall an excellent album.

3/5. Not as subtle or beautiful as some of the other Beach Boy music I like more. The harmony work seems less ambitious.

Well constructed songs and it sounds like a response to other top albums of the late 1960s. Not my favorite but was great to listen to other songs from The Beach Boys I hadn't heard before.

Better than Coldplay

Ya, OK whatever. Not horrible, but no real interest in hearing this again,

Instant classic and immediately purchased on vinyl. An album I hadn't really heard of before but was awesome. It seemed more like a prog rock album which was a nice surprise given their other albums. An amazing album front to back.

I liked this. Not entirely what I expected.

Best goed, niks bijzonders

Beach Boys are woke???

Truly an album that grows on you with each passing listen, as Carl Wilson takes over during his brother’s decline. There’s hints of all sorts of genres to come, from yacht rock to indie folk, all encompassed in 10 tracks. And other than one absolute eye-roller, the music here is another step ahead of what anyone else did. Good album.

life-affirming pop music with one beyond obvious blemish

An enjoyable experience from an artist I've never really checked out in any capacity. This very much has proto-progressive rock tendencies without being clearly identifiable as such, falling into a strange stylistic category of psychedelic pop rock which is that bit more challenging and unconventional than you'd expect. The songs take on a bittersweet, high-key yet bordering on melancholic approach, which is always a welcome juxtaposition. My main criticisms of the album would be that the production is somewhat suspect in patches - the vocals can become a bit scratchy/overbearing in the mix, and it does hit a bit of an impasse in its mid-section - "Student Demonstration Time" is a minor dud with these production issues becoming quite glaring.

This is a bizarre mix of what people love about the Beach Boys while also being a victim of their desire to expand what they can do. A lot of the base songs sound pretty interesting but the way something is mixed or arranged is sometimes a detriment to something that is otherwise pretty cool. I was pretty shocked seeing this album cover, and that it was a Beach Boys album.

I'm trying to give this a listen... I can't do it.

Another Beach Boy album. I can see their place in history, but nothing very exciting or interesting time personally.

Two Beach Boys & one Brian Wilson album since he died 15 days ago, STOP. As my previous comments have stated, I cannot get into them. This album is horrible.

3.6 - First half all good, last 4 songs not so much

Surprisingly creative music, almost more like the Beatles or Donovan type of sound compared to the early Beach Boys.

This is really not my favourite Beach Boys record, but even their more lacking ventures have some real highlights.

Prachtige harmonie. Ben maar tot de helft gekomen. Dusss een save for later

Pretty good, not as good as pet sounds though

excellent, and quite different from what I remember listening to at 13

Weird fun but good!

this is the third the beach boys' album i get here... don't think they're for me

Didn't enjoy it. 1 star

Weird and wonderful

A great album though I found the mix had the voice too high in it

Escuché el álbum yendo al trabajo con una temperatura de 0° , no lo conocía y aún así no me dejó morir en la fría mañana de buenos aires, gracias brian wilson

The simple title of this one made me think it might be a straight-forward early Beach Boys album. But this early 70's release has some interesting minor key arrangements and psychedelic touches alongside the always beautiful vocal harmonies. Some fairly lame lesser tracks drag this rating down compared to the strengths of its better songs. Standouts: Surf's Up, 'Til I Die, Feel Flows

What the hell did I just listen to? Some nice harmonies but there's a lot on this that is downright goofy. I'm coming to the conclusion after listening to 2 Beach Boys albums (with one of them being Pet Sounds) that I do not particularly like them. Favorites: None Would I listen to it again: No

Really waffled between thinking Brian Wilson was the most overrated artist of all time (don’t go near the water, Disney girls, student demonstration time) to kind of liking it (long promised road mostly but the last few songs were ok).

3.5 Kinda getting a sad clown vibe from this one. Very, very cool cover. I always thought of the beach boys as sort of a pop band without a whole lot of substance (and it always seemed they (or some form of the band) would play any venue in their later years to get a paycheck). The more listens I get in, the more I can appreciate the great songs they have written, pioneering production and a bit of a darker side to keep things interesting. Will check this one out again

I think this is my first listen. I may have heard it once before but I am in no way familiar with it and don’t really know what to think about it. It is both awful and brilliant at the same time. The vocals, the harmonies and the production are so stripped back and don’t have that fat sound that the Beach Boys usually go for. Although Feel Flows has that fatter sound. The songs are ridiculous: Take a Load Off Your Feet, Student Demonstration Time and A Day in the Life of a Tree. Disney Girls (1957) is an unexpected slow waltz which jars the flow of the album. It gets a bit psychedelic for my tastes on side two and dips into that Pet Sounds vibe. It also has the fatter sound that I associate with the Beach Boys. I really can’t decide if the album is genius or junk but I would listen to it again.

feels not like the beach boys. something off about this one, not awful but doesnt seem as good as others of theres.

My second Beach Boys record in a week and it may be weird to say, but I prefer this to Pet Sounds. It just sounds more fresh to me and less dated and this I would absolutely call a world class album.

today's the day I learned The Beach Boys had 17+ albums. lyrically it feels quite experimental and whimsical. I was not expecting some kind of an environmentalist rock record. it's strange. I can't really get into it but at the same time there is something intriguing about it that keeps pulling me back in. 3.5

Inoffensive. Needed more Brian and less Carl Wilson. I sorta liked “ Take a Load Off Your Feet” and “Student Demonstration Time.”

Great album

74/100. Feel Flows is great. A few other good songs

After a brief absence, back to your regularly scheduled programmin’ (of “what’s-next?-I-don’t-know!” jammin’.) In that week off, Brian Wilson passed and this was the album that appeared on the day of his passing. It is also now my favorite Beach Boys album. A complete and total surprise. Brian Wilson, you’ll be missed — loved listening to this bizarre, aggressively political, anti-beach party Beach Boys record. “I'm a leaf on a windy day, pretty soon, I'll be blown away. How long will the wind blow? How long will the wind blow? Until I die; these things I’ll be until I die.”

Ha! get it.... like surfs UP

Darker tone.

I actually liked this better than any other Beach Boys album I’ve previously listened to. Getting out of their cornball wheelhouse did them a real favor.

Nothing particularly stood out.

Piaciuto più dell’album precedente

I don't surf though.

Overall: 8/10 The only reason this was on my radar at all is because of that incredibly depressing and beautiful album cover. It's so NOT Beach Boys that you can't help but be drawn to it. The music inside fits the cover surprisingly well, with this being a bit of a melancholic departure for these guys. Honestly, I'm surprised this album isn't more popular. It obviously isn't their best work but it's very artsy and shows that Brian (RIP) wasn't the only member of the band capable of making these types of artsy pop songs. I highly recommend it to any fans of The Beach Boys who want to hear something different from them. Fav Song: Take a Load Off Your Feet Least Fav Song: Student Demonstration Time

Interesting sound!

Didn’t even sound like them.

It was ok

I know I’m being influenced by Brett’s opinion, but this album isn’t that good. It is some sounds from The Beach Boys that I like (upbeat and funky) but it’s overall erratic. There’s one song that has emergency vehicle sounds in the background - who wants to listen to that!?

gemütlich

Yeah, this is a trippy album, an example of rock and roll music at the time. I thought it was good, though, and will listen to it again.

I was a Beatles girl so I never got super into the beach boys, but it they truly are the epitome of 60s psychedelic beach rock

very fun, though some songs had a similar concept

Some of the best Beach Boys songs with a lot of filler in between. 7/10

I like it 3.5 stars