Reviews (page 7 of 9)
very ambient sometimes, decent overall
hát kemény elalszok bazdmeg, de ez jó
Fine stuff. Not bad, not great.
I loved it. Seems like a German artist. Very calming. Would listen on psychedelics. From the 70's. Lots of cool instruments. Favs were Isi, Leb Wohl and Hero
Oh this one is though. Hugely influential and the dawn of new musical possibilities but still very much in it's egg, but the framework is there! Not allvsongs are jams, but its hugely influential and showcases early computers in music
I didn't realize that Rother and Dinger were so at odds that they decided to split the album. Why make an album at all together in that case? But the sounds really work together despite that. The ambiance of Rother's side prepare you somehow for the raucous jam that happens when "Hero" starts. I was definitely gravitating most toward side two, but the whole thing was a good listen, a surprisingly easy listen compared to what I was expecting.
This is among my favorite albums of all time. Whenever I return to these timeless musical landscapes, I want to stay in them forever. I also love their story. The main two members, Klaus Dinger and Michael Rother, were so very different from each other, nearly polar opposites. Dinger, an intense, manic, extrovert type, and Rother a more reflective, gentle soul. They didn't even particularly get along well, but I think their willingness to respect each others talents, and commit to finding a middle ground, despite their differences, is sort of remarkable in the egocentric world of music. I'd venture to guess their producer Conny Plank had a huge role in being a buffer between them, harnessing that tension, and finding the common ground that he could weave into a more cohesive whole. Together they developed a relatively simple, but unique formula, which centered around Dinger's propulsive motorik beat, like some kind of nuclear fission engine, and Rother's elegant and versatile guitar musings. Each song is a journey, ever moving forward. And like all the best Krautrock, you can hear them searching for their own sound as they go. I like all of their albums, but this one is by far their most refined. Solid from top to bottom, bearing songs that reflect each of their personalities and inclinations. The duality that they embody here is what I am so drawn to. It's as if they are able to capture two perspectives simultaneously like some kind of impossible MC Escher drawing going off into infinity. Dinger throwing his hat in the proto-punk ring is the cherry on top.
When Neu! is more ambient I find them the most easy-listening of anything Krautrock. Dare I say, it sounds pleasant. Of course the iconic Motorik beat is in full force, and I believe I prefer the slower ambient pieces of side 1 vs side 2. Overall though, Neu! is not my favorite Krautrock band but I can respect it. The fact that the album does not overstay it's welcome makes me rate it from 3.5 to 4 instead of down.
Listened to a few songs but was not my cup of tea
This was a really welcome surprise. I didn't know what to expect, but being someone who likes early electronic music especially Kraftwerk and Jean Michel Jarre, I loved this. Will definitely listen again, and will search out other music from them.
Relatively run of the mill 70s electronic music from Germany. Didn’t do much for me, though like many people, I found the first half much more pleasant and enjoyable than the second half. Honestly, doesn’t seem that revolutionary in terms of electronic music, sort of basic really. It was fine. Probably could go digging and find much more interesting examples for the time period that better warrants a spot on this list.
I really liked Hero. The rest of what I heard was pretty unexciting or anything I’d want to hear. Seems like these guys were trying something new back in day.
"Neu! 75" brought Claus Dinger to my attention, complementing my familiarity with Michael Rother's work in ambient music. The album's narrative of a reformed duo (ex Kraftwerk) individually shaping their sides based on their musical identities intrigued me The ambient part is has good as the punk part Really good album and discovery
Fav song: isi
I liked this more than I expected, especially the first half. Not sure how often I'll come back to it, but good to know it's out there if the mood strikes.
Leb’ Wohl is a bit too long and I don’t like the vocals. That’s about all I have against the album, it’s very good.
What a cool album. First half was more atmospheric/space rock, which I really enjoyed. Then it breaks into punk on the track "Hero," very cool now and must have been VERY cool in 1975.
kinda interesting but forgettable
I'm not sure what I was expecting, but this was better than that. Often dreamy, often with a little edge, it's an interesting listen. You can hear a lot of Joy Division in parts of this album, which I found particularly interesting.
I've not listened to Neu before (nor have I ever even heard of krautrock). I enjoyed the album ... most of the songs are instrumentals, and where there are lyrics they are pretty spare. I typically don't go for that, but Neu's music was, for the 70's, fresh. I'm just unsure of its relevance today.
Pretty cool album, I think I prefer the first side but the second side is still interesting. I definitely haven't listened to enough krautrock I'm definitely gonna explore some more.
Fun.
I completely understand that this album was not met with popular success based on the brief band bio on Spotify. That said, holy shit. This is an amazing album which I've listened to 3 times in the past two days. To say I'm impressed is an understatement. Everything about this sound is incredible. Atmospheric, electronic, cryptic, drum heavy, guitar driving. Absolutely loved it. I found that first track to be loaded with compassion and enthusiasm.
Is this really 'Krautrock'? Not sure this is romper stomper music it's more like Stereolab and Brian Eno discovered their long lost father. Regardless of whatever it's been labeled, it's really nice. Theres's some variety there with some hard stuff thrown in closer to the end, but the droning ambience of Neu! is really enjoyable. Evidently, both Dinger and Rother were early members of Kraftwerk which I never thought I'd appreciate, however the fondness I've got for NEU! 75 has inspired me to give them another listen.
It's German from the 70s? Uh-oh. The Wikipedia intro calls it krautrock? Double uh-oh. It all stems from "Faust IV," our first exposure to krautrock. I wrote in that review, though, that by the end of its awfulness I still didn't know what krautrock was. Then I didn't enjoy Kraftwerk. But Kraftwerk didn't sound like Faust. Then I think I skipped listening to Can. Then Neu! popped up, and my not fully earned anti-krautrock bias kicked in even before the first notes. I'm immediately dreading how bad it's going to be, and thinking of what other neu albums I could review instead? Something by The New Pornographers (several five-star albums)? Or "New Wave" by Against Me! (keeps the ! quota)? Or "The New Romance" by Pretty Girls Make Graves? But, I had to try Neu! first. And it turns out... it wasn't Faust. It wasn't Kraftwerk. And then I read about krautrock. And found out that "the term 'krautrock' was popularized by British music journalists as a humorous umbrella-label for the diverse German scene... although many so-labeled artists disliked the term" and "broad genre encompassing varied approaches." Well, yeah, now this makes a bit more sense. I can't get a handle on what krautrock is because it is too varied to even be a genre. Faust, Kraftwerk, Can, and Neu! all sound different. And Neu! doesn't sound terrible. It doesn't sound good either though. And it's not good isn't all the same. The first half of the album is completely different from the second half. The first half is boring piano-prog, the second half is boring rock. Nothing really stands out. Nothing feels avant garde, or experimental, or any of the other things that supposedly tie the genre together. I went back and listed to Can after "NEU! 75," so now I'll have to go back and write about how that one isn't like these either. I still don't like krautrock, as far as krautrock is a thing. I've gotta stop pre-judging based on a first impression. Gonna practice just listening and giving things a chance. It won't always work out, but sometimes at least I'll be surprised.
I saw this was described as krautrock and was dreading it. I saw this got not 1 star reviews and I was curious. Was it just me or did the first track feel like it could have been written by Mannheim Steamroller?! Is Mannheim Steamroller krautrock?! Anyway, not what I was expecting, but still not my favorite.
It’s been a couple days since I listened to this album so the details are fuzzy. However the one description I remember is timeless. It’s hard for me to believe this album was made in 1975 because it sounded like it could have been from the 2010s. Also apparently 75=3 because their albums go Neu!, Neu!2, then Neu!75. I suspect there is a Neu! fan out there, a real die hard and also a super nerd, that has come up with some number system where 75 does equal 3 and they wrote an amateur thesis about it. I’m looking for you Neu! super nerd. Find me. I need to read your deep insights.
11/1/23. Never heard of this group and didn’t know what to expect, did not see mostly instrumental songs coming. However, very interesting soundscapes that are soothing yet don’t let you get too comfortable. Consider me a fan.
The progression of songwriting is a step up from NEU! 2 and a very good listener from start to finish. I really like the use of piano and dips into some nice meditative ambiance.
I liked some of the slower, proggier sections. This album was a little dull at parts however. Fun stuff for the mid 70s.
I have never heard of this band before, but being a fan of post-rock bands like Sigur Rós and Mogwai, I quickly saw this as a big influence on their sound. The album is divided into two distinct halves, each showcasing a different side of the band’s experimental style. The first half of the album is more ambient and melodic, with soothing synths, piano, and guitar creating a dreamy atmosphere. The opening track “Isi” is a perfect example of this, with its hypnotic rhythm and ethereal sounds. The second track “Seeland” is a slow and somber piece, with mournful guitar lines and sparse percussion. The third track “Leb’ Wohl” is a farewell song, with spoken vocals over waves and piano. The second half of the album is more aggressive and energetic, with distorted guitars, fast drums, and punk vocals. The fourth track “Hero” is a proto-punk anthem, with Klaus Dinger screaming over a wall of noise. The fifth track “E-Musik” is a 10-minute groove, with a catchy bass line and funky guitar riffs. The sixth track “After Eight” is a reprise of “Hero”, but even more chaotic and wild. I love the contrast between the two halves of the album, as it shows the versatility and creativity of the band. However, I prefer the first half more, as it is more relaxing and immersive. I think this is a hugely influential and important album in the history of rock music, as it paved the way for genres like post-rock, ambient, punk, and new wave. It deserves to be in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die1, but it isn’t quite a masterpiece in every part. Some tracks are too long or repetitive, and some vocals are too harsh or unintelligible. I would give it a solid 4/5 rating, and recommend it to anyone who likes experimental and adventurous music.
Wtf
I didn’t mind it as much as I thought I would when I read it was Electronic, but it was so inoffensive that it failed to push any boundaries. Entertaining and enjoyable in some parts, bland in the rest. 2/5
Neu was so busy trying to see if they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should. The A side is interesting. They create some beautiful soundscapes almost punk/electronic/ambient mix. The B side is more pink or post punk. It’s a bizarre mix. 4.8/10
Was an interesting listen, some good sounds But unsure of the overall idea
ISI - 7/10 Seeland - 7/10 Leb’wohl - 7/10 Hero - 8/10 E-musik - 8/10 After Eight - 8/10 TOTAL - 45/60
Another so-so installment. Side A is atmospheric space rock and pleasant to listen to. Side B is some early post-punk and rather influential I presume. Still only a 3 as nothing blows you away and I'm not sure I appreciate the contrast
Good sound, not what I usually like or listen to but good
I'm not sure what to say about this album. It's interesting, melodic, kind of electronic rock. It's not kraftwerk electronic music. It's like early new wave I guess. It wasn't bad, just kind of forgettable
if I was stoned I would totally like the first half of this. the second part just gets repetitive
This album surprised me. I liked it more than I expected to. Isi was particularly good. Most of the songs were just instrumental
75! out of 100! Cool sounds and easy listening.
скучамба так то
Recently got way into krautrock and liked Can a lot, especially Future Days. Also some of Cluster's stuff. This is right in line! I'm excited to check it out completely... First two tracks I'm already sold, Seeland especially is just a vibe. Especially the end with the rain... this is so good! Also, end of Hero with the airplane. Love the inclusion of field recordings. Especially for 1975, this was so influential! I was digging the spacey music and then Hero kicks in and wakes you up! I didn’t really appreciate that song before, but in context it’s pretty cool. Just based on its influence, recording quality, and my personal preference, this is an easy 4. Maybe even a 4.5, but I need to make sure that's not just recency bias kicking in, since I've been getting into this music much more lately.
I loved this. Right up my street. Listened through again immediately, and will dive deeper into Neu back catalog.
This might have been a 4 start record if I was already familiar with it. How have I never heard this? 5 stars to 1001albumsgenerator for telling me about it.
It was fine but a bit boring.
Never heard of them, but pretty good, especially the first half. Upbeat background music for work.
Trochu jako KGLW, ale na mě trochu víc elektrický
This genre is my least favorite genre
A decent album for a different person
-never heard of this band or artist so im excited -so far its just very instrumental which i’m going to be honest isn’t my favorite -first song bored me a little but i like seeland so far -okay loving these ocean sounds -okay so there is singing now but it sounds like when you have to stick your tongue out and go ahhhhhh at the doctor -hero only song so far that sounds SICK -FINALLY SOME SINGING -i do not give 1 stars lightly but this literally sounds like anything else i have heard so -no offense! but like some of the songs feel too long for what it is
Monotonous. Tip: Don’t call your album New! With the year on the cover. Unless you want to guarantee that it’s soon dated. It’s like labeling the pastries in the case “Fresh for October”.
The are some albums which cross your path at precisely the time they are most needed. And so it is here, this morning, our plane taxiing at Logan airport , through the early morning mist, the bleary-eyed flight attendants barely keeping up the appearance that we’re all on a flight, rather than in bed. And as I— in the “still in bed” camp— put this album on. Exactly the right space. The sounds of drifting back to sleep in the early morning, the sun creeping up the walls but never enough to disturb. I wish I could have been just by the ocean, wherever they had been, when they recorded the waves on “Leb Wohl.” That is truly perfect. This reminds me very much of Eno’s work, but just a touch more song-structured, and more dynamic than I thought it would be. Even at its loudest “Hero,” recall the same droning, never-ending records from something like Bowie’s Berlin period. I was gently coaxed by this record, and then I was brought onboard. For being both gentle and alluring, I can think of no better. 4/5
Perfectly okay instrumental music, I got bored with it pretty quickly after the first two tracks.
Pretty decent background music!
3.5/5
Not bad
Ahead of its time. Mixture of repetitive rock and amience tracks
Woah this was quite fun! Apparently both of these guys were in the Kraftwerk lineup at some point and I can really hear that. I also read someone describe it as deconstructed rock music. I really enjoyed the more ambient sections and the heavier moments less so but it was a really interesting and exciting album which I had never heard any of previously.
I really enjoyed this. Quite an unusual album set-up of song lengths and styles and the way it built. Enjoyed the prog-slow building-ness of it. Will listen again
Pretty good. Not something I'd rush back to but definitely enjoyed it
An amazing atmosphere, with juxtaposing sides that compliment each other in the strangest, perfect way possible. Different from the band’s other works but a welcome change
Pretty good, preferred the more chilled electronica in the first part of the album
amazing album
Fun bookend songs but very repetitive in the middle. I like it more than Kraftwerk but not by a whole lot.
crazy original, singular, and mesmerizing, and its variety and progression
Painfully slow, this genre is just not my thing at all. First half felt like yoga studio background music. Hero is a banger though.
For a casual listen it's probably going to be a no for me, at least for now, because I do believe that this is music that will grow on you. However, this album is definitely a yes as it comes to study music or while lounging and reading a book or something. It's good music and will definitely look more into NEU! To get more familiar with their work
The start of this album is pretty different to a lot of other albums, it had some chill instrumental tracks that were just fun to listen to. The rest of the album had a completely different style, it feels like the tracks should be on two different albums. The songs on this album aren't nessicarily bad they just don't gel together with the first half and the second half of the album being so different. I'd say I enjoyed both halfs of the album tho I just don't see the artists vision for why it was composed the way it was.
Ya not bad. Less noisy than the other krautrock album Ive listened to Makes me wonder what the genre even is
Soulless music that’s easy to ignore.
fine but more focus/sleep music
Krautrock. Ni fu ni fa.
Sin más. No creo que quiera volver a escucharlo. Krautrock, kosmische musik, experimental rock, psychedelic rock, proto-punk.
I know this album and enjoy it
I quite liked this one, short and sweet. Has a dreamy quality
This album I found kind of boring. It seemed like it was going to get better about halfway through with the song Hero, but kind of petered out after that.
Pretty good stuff. Chill, but good. 3.5/5
About as good as Krautrock ever got. Love the progression from soft to loud to soft again in particular. B+
I really enjoyed that, even though it was a bit bipolar, with the first few tracks being all floaty, ambient tunes, almost hypnotically peaceful, followed by - surprise! - we're a punk band now
I felt obligated to rate this higher because of the clout that Neu! generates in the critical space, but this one kinda put me to sleep. Idk, very vibey and spacey which is cool, but I need a little more energy out of my krautrock. Just not really my favorite, but certainly cool and worth the listen
Still fresh after almost 50 years. Neu! is a building block for so many of my favorite bands; I feel like if anything, their influence on psych/experimental music has only gotten stronger. Really have no complaints. This thing is phenomenal and covers so much ground.
I mostly appreciated how much of the groundwork of many of my favorite genres was laid down on this record, but was generally pretty fine with this album. It had a great vibe but didn’t really grab me in the way I was hoping. Still a fun listen, this is a very strong 3 from me.
Beautiful album. Leb’wohi was a little too atmospheric to the point of being dull, but everything else was excellent. Some tracks were punk, some were Kraftwerk jr in the best way possible, some were just pretty. Might not make the regular rotation but anyone with an appreciation of music can get something out of this
This was very reminiscent of Kraftwerk, and I have very similar opinions on both in that I'm very indifferent to them. Kraftwerk is slightly more interesting but both just feel like cutting edge 70s projects that other innovations in electronic and rock music have left behind. This album in particular sounds like a very prototypical version of 2000s radiohead where the building blocks are there but it hasn't been developed enough. I'm sure this was highly influential to German dance music or something in the same way Kraftwerk practically invented electronic/computer rock but I don't think it really holds up anymore. However, this made me go back and listen to man machine which I think I have a better appreciation for now; feels like the progenitor to all of 80s synth wave. Really liked the model off that album.
hero топ, остальное хз
Слушайте, нуууу... интересная история. Не совсем этого я ожидал. Наверное, краут-рок - это всё ещё очень широкое жанровое описание музыки. На первой половине был эмбиент в перемешку с дрим-попом. На второй же - уже какая-то более рокн-ролльная даже история, с непонятными иногда воплями вокалиста. Ну... такое. Ещё и ощущение, будто она вся написана под один и тот же паттерн ударных. Концептуально, но заёбывает что-то. Со второй половины E-Musik прикольное. Особенно когда начинает беспорядочно звук туда-сюда ходить под влиянием эффектов. Короче интересно, и даже слушать приятно.
J'ai l'impression de me trouver dans un film des années 80 – ce n'est pas désagréable du tout!
In between bouts of atmospheric repetition that lulls you to sleep, there’s a bit of fun energy here. But boy do you have to work for it. For a mostly instrumental album, I needed something a bit more involved to keep my interest. This one just wasn’t it for me.
Enchanting soundscapes made for quiet contemplation and moody night drives.
different. mostly instrumental tunes. honestly, most of it was very relaxing, almost to the point of being hypnotic.
This was trying to kill me. I was driving and it tried to lull me to sleep.
Nice background music. Just another “Why do I have to listen to it before I die”, though.
I'm more and more sure I don't like Krautrock
Interesting, not amazing. Had seen the cover before and expected more straight ahead krautrock rather than the folkier stuff it opened with.
so sick of these ambient noise albums. Who picks these for a top album?
Beautiful, long rock songs that would be perfect to listen to on a road trip. “Seeland” has that ‘driving through the country’ feel to it. The vocals on “Hero” are wild. I love the contrast between the soaring music and the crude wail of the singing.
I've been thinking a lot very recently about velocity in music and dynamics and tempi in music. For me I rarely write something that is thought of as a "fast" tempo but with "soft" velocities / dynamics. Almost like the two are inherently correlated and it's mandatory for them to match eachother. But it's not the case at all... you can have some softer parts and play them fast. Conversely, you can have harder parts and play them slower. This band does that right out of the gate, and it's a little weird to me but I like it. "Isi" sounds like a soundscape, like a track you would hear while watching the "TV Guide" channel late at night. It's got that Peanuts Christmas Piano sound but also, surprisingly- double bass drums? But the double bass is incredibly softly played (and recorded)? I love it. Very different. I enjoyed the meditative "Seeland". I liked the album. 3/5
Really enjoyed the first half as was falling asleep. Second half kept me awake.
Interesting album, relaxing and would fit well in today's charts
Ca fit vraiment avec le style et c,est quelque chose que j'ai décourt sur cette liste et que j'aime bien. Je ne sais pas si je vais en réécouté un jour, Kraftwerk etc. mais celui-ci est assez bien fait et pas trop long. Il n'y a pas d'inégalité dans les chansons et ca sonne tr`s bien. 4
An interesting mash of synth and prog. I’m still fairly new to Neu! and didn’t know what to expect, but found myself nodding along to most of this album as it hit some interesting and unexpected grooves. Hate to say it but the instrumentals mostly decimate the tracks with extended vocals, wish the whole thing was pure instrumental flow as that’s where the band seems to find its most inspired songwriting and overall synergy.
I really enjoyed this album of pleasant background music until we got to Hero. The vocals on that song were bad to my taste, and lucky me it was 7 minutes long!
really good listen, none of the songs scratched the mental itch for me though.
Five stars cause I fkn love saying KRAUTROK also the second half of this is much better than the first
One of the most beautiful albums I have listened to yet. This definitely gives a sense of tranquility while also being experimental. Highly recommended!
Absolutely glorious. Why do I leave these albums unlistened to after discovering and loving one record by a band? I guess there's lots of examples where that would be a let down, but not here. The debut is fabulous of course and so is this. That beat in E-musik is just perfect. Drilled into my psyche. The ambient stuff is gorgeous. What's great about sticking a Krautrock album on is Spotify generally throws up a great load of stuff afterwards, there's so much wonderful stuff in the genre to discover, in many directions (obvs krautrock is a reductive term). Reminded me to go back to Harmonium, another project Rother was involved with, Deluxe is a cracker.
There’s something here, but I’m not sure what. I waited two days to rate it to see if anything stuck. It hasn’t.
Decent listen, hit and miss. Was good for passing time.
Human needs to be humble about their voice...would be a better album if stupid human voice is not involved. One star added for the first half.
Never listened to Neu before but really liked it. Rhythmically hypnotic and futuristic sounding even at nearly 50 years old.
This one surprised me. Somewhat dystopian and desolate it still packs a punch and I enjoyed it. Hero is a banger! I can definitely hear how this influenced Bowie. Solid album.
YAWN!
Genres: Krautrock, kosmische musik, experimental rock, psychedelic rock, proto-punk Formed: Düsseldorf, West German in 1971 Run time: 6 songs, 42 min, 45 sec Neu! consist of Klaus Dinger and Michael Rother, both former members of Kraftwerk. Thomas Dinger, and Hans Lampe both played on side 2 of the album. This is their third studio album. After a break from the group Rother and Dinger had diverged in musical direction. Side 1 caters for Rother's ambient taste. While side is a more aggressive, rock-influenced style with Dinger switching from Drums to Vocals and Thomas Dinger, and Hans Lampe both brought in to play drums. The album is not particularly popular. The most played track 1, “Isi” (an instrumental) having over 2.3M plays on Spotify. . Track 6, “After Eight” is the least played with just over 305k plays. It has a definite Punk vibe, which fits nicely with the timing of the album. The tracks all have German names, so I was surprised when the vocals were sung in English. I imagine side 1 being great for a chilled walk in the country, while side 2 would be great for driving at speed! Listen Again?: Yes and I’ll be trying their other albums. My Rating: ****
how bout neuoooo
Krautrock. Ni fu ni fa.
Mind blowing the progress
Up until the vocals entered the picture this struck me as something like the soundtrack of a Wim Wenders film... which is not at all a criticism or complaint. The vocal component really didn't add anything for me. Rather the opposite. I remain unable to fully get behind the Krautrock.
Big influence for some of my favorite bands
Cool background music I guess
Better than the other one. But again really long and no words but when he did sing it wasn’t very good
If you can’t sing, then maybe stick to instrumentals. The first couple songs were kind of nice until the guy started singing. It does not deserve a 3 or more. 2/5
Was an easy, albeit surprising, 5/5 until the last track. Now it's an easy 4/5.
NEU!? Don’t you mean: “NEIN!”? Unfortunately this German piece of krautrock history is excellent, so my otherwise well-thought-out joke falls flat. If we could only pretend “After Eight” wasn’t part of the album, NEU! 75 would be the flawless masterpiece it deserves to be.
Grote inspiratie voor The Sex Pistols, David Bowie, Sonic Youth en Radiohead blijkbaar. 3x achter elkaar gedraaid. Helemaal te gek!
Ik moet dit denk ik nog eens een keer luisteren. Hoorde wel erg toffe dingen maar moet het nog eens met meer aandacht tot me nemen. Vooralsnog een ruime 3.
Beetje wisselend van kwaliteit.
Wow. Interesting.
De ellos tengo el "Hallogallo" en mi lista de canciones que me gustan. Alguna dosis de rock progresivo de este Krautrock siempre puede ser interesante para mí, no me importa un tema que necesite 10 minutos o más para desarrollarse. De este 75 de NEU! ninguno dura tanto. "Seeland" tiene unos aires U2 por los que lo mismo habría que preguntar a la banda irlandesa. Las olas de "Leb' wohl" casi son más música Ambient que otra cosa, aunque la música Ambient en teoría no se inventó hasta 1978 con el disco de Brian Eno "Ambient Music for Airports". Luego parece que se anima, entiendo que es parte de la dualidad que tenían los discos de vinilo con su cara A y B.
While it is advertised, as a relative of Devo, I found it was an interesting exploration into early electronic music. It was slower building than other artists in the genre. I enjoyed it, though I didn’t find it a new gem.
Really good! I especially love the side 1 tracks. Standouts: Isi, Seeland, Leb' Wohl, Hero. Singles: -------------------- Isi (Failed to chart) 3.5
Beautifully produced with some interesting music concepts. But ultimately a boring listen all the way through, and after the first listen it became sort of a tiresome relisten.
I really liked this. It was fun and fresh sounding. I can see why this album inspired a lot of other artists.
Interesting but not my style
Pleasant surprise! Will add to my ambient options.
A good listen for work. Relatively wordless. Not 5 because its a little too fast paced.
Boring
that was fine ambient whatever music until dude started screaming incoherently toward the end there
This was intriguing. Had no prior knowledge of this music but somehow was surprised by the sound.
Perfectly pleasant to listen to, but why does it make this list?
Not sure what to think.. Average I guess
Top Three Songs: 1) Leb’ wohl 2) Seeland 3) Isi Bottom Three Songs: 1) E-Musik 2) After Eight 3) Hero
F**king love NEU!
good while working
What the fuck is Krautrock?
The building blocks of krautrock. Abrasive and forgettable.
Это лучший в их дискографии альбом. Если дебют построен на импровизации, и он довольно-таки непонятный в некоторых местах, второй кажется каким-то недоделанным, очень сырым, то третий... Очень свежо данная музыка слушается для середины 70-х, просто на одном дыхании. Тут нету песен лучше или хуже, круче или слабее, тут надо слушать всё! Один из лучших альбом в краут роке, и я его всем рекомендую.
I've listened to their debut before which was alright. This one was similarly alright. "Hero" let it down a bit, regardless of whether or not it was a catalyst for the punk invasion that was soon to follow. First track was the best, rest were pretty skippable but not offensive. 2.5*
The first two songs were 4/5. Relaxing atmospheric sounds. The other three songs weren’t bad, I’d give them a 3/5. If I could do half stars I’d give this a 3.5/5
Sounds like the soundtrack to a movie that I would fall asleep halfway through.
Garbage
Rating: 6/10 Best songs: After eight
I enjoyed this album more than I expected too. The opening, Isi, felt a bit adolescent to me, or maybe just unsophisticated compared to my last generated album which was straight electronica. But really this album goes on an interesting journey and all of it is pretty good. I think I'll even like Isi better on a second listen with the additional context. I do think this album belongs on this list and I'm happy to have heard it. I might check out some of their other work. 3.5 stars.
I listened to this last Friday and - if I'm being honest - can't remember a damn thing about it now that it's Monday. That's not typically a good sign.
Jeg kan dessverre ikke sammenligne med bestemors vulva, men jeg synes det manglet litt futt. Krysser fingrene for Kraftwerk i fremtiden!
The first has of that album had me wondering if I was listening to an generic White Noises To Fall Asleep To album
This was fascinating but confusing album. The first half is a mellow ambient sound like a mediation app would play for sleep sounds. Its a clear influence on electronica and is quite pleasant to listen to. The second half is more aggressive and clearly influential of punk. I'm not sure where I land on it as a whole album, but it was quite interesting.
Really liked how this started off with the first half as ambient music with Brian Eno vibes and then flipped to a Wire-esque art punk/proto punk sound. This is the kind of obscure diamond in the rough kind of album I was looking for from this list. It’s amazing also that this one is 50 years old and sounds like it just came out yesterday.
Not for me.
First few tracks pleasant ambient music, the second side slightly less so and Hero (a track wikipedia claims is influential) is just crap! Not a great album IMO
lightly repetitive background music with a small amount of dicking around- like if someone wanted to turn Tago Mago into into royalty-free music. like drinking a krautrock-flavored lacroix
2.5/5 Had to listen to it twice to even notice what was playing
Completely new to me, but this really was something!
Interesting sound but did not super enjoy it.
I've never even heard of these guys but I kinda dig this!
I really liked this one
Don't really get this at all.
Good music, not really feeling it currently though.
Hmm... I can definitely see why this is influential, being basically post-punk before the punk movement had even really fully taken off, but I find it mostly either boring or annoying, with only snippets of an enjoyable album peeking from behind. I could totally get why someone liked this, but not really for me.
OK Album
This is a weird one for me because I expected to enjoy the rock half more than the electronic half but I felt the rock songs were really poorly done, I know this is one of those proper “music nerd” albums but it’s just not for me. 3/5 though because the first half is cool.
Weird, eclectic, and yet interesting. Each song seems like a different genre. 3.5/5.
Meh.
Not at all what I thought I would get in this listen but I found it actually quite good. It's a bit background-y, for the most part, but a couple of livelier tunes are sprinkled in to spice it up nicely.
Second half much more listenable and lively than the first but still lacks edge
Another great album. I had never heard of Neu! The Wikipedia helps explain the bi-polar quality of this album. The two sides are very different, but I like both a lot. I may actually enjoy side one more, but that's from a perspective that's almost 50 years after the album was released. Given when it came out, side two is the more amazing side. It's punk rock a couple of years before punk rock! (For anyone that listened to this on Spotify, track down the last track, "After Eight". It's good.)
Damn these Krauts can rock. An album from the A and B side era that could have come out at any moment since. Both sides are excellent. The first is ambient before Eno and a pleasurable journey around some mellow melodies. The second half is edgier, rockier and disruptive to the point I almost got delirious with all those hard edged sounds.
3.5
sounded like wii music
pretty ok 3
It’s a vibe. I dunno if it’s good or not but it’s a vibe nonetheless. Opens with Wii Bowling music, ends with distorted mumbo jumbo. Sure, why not?
Actually beautiful! Loved this album. Worth a consideration on buying. 4/5
Since this was the 70's and this album was released on vinyl, I am assuming the first 3 songs were on side A and the remaining on side B. The switch from tranquil soundscapes to something more punk rock is a little jarring in the streaming age, but I have a feeling it worked well in the vinyl age. This feels very ahead of it's time I can se how this album would influence many musicians. The song Leb' wohl is so peaceful with its sounds of ocean waves and metronome. I feel like I could meditate to this.
Brilliant
Esperava mais para ampliar o gosto pelo Krautrock. Algumas faixas funcionam bem como ambient. As com vocal destoam.
I love it. I'm not really familiar with any NEU! material that came later, but this seems like a perfect ending to their original trilogy of albums with the A side expanding on what was and the B side showcasing what could/might be. The proto-punk of "Hero" seems jarring at first but it's anchored in its depths by a groove that feels quite at place with all that came before. The whole album still gets better every time for me. There are a couple of brief vocals I find myself at odds with on the A-side, otherwise, this is nearly a perfect album for me.
Not much to say, but love where this goes, great album for ambient sound and texture
Spotify didn't have 'After Eight' available, sadly. Overall it was good, Neu! would fit right in with the indie scene of today, but I'm a baby and songs longer than like 5 minutes (that aren't by Meat Loaf) test my attention span.
Some nice atmospheric music in the first part, 2nd part was ok.
Nothing I wanted to hear again but I will give it points because it was ahead of its time for its sound.
This was surprisingly pleasant and innovative stuff!
Didn’t actually finish the album but the first part had very cool slow piano, not what I expected at all
Elske krautrock
some of the songs have weird backing vocals that are not suitable for sleeping cool though
One of the best and most seminal krautrock albums. Motorik for days.
Krautrock is something that’s never really triggered anything with me, not sure why, I think mainly due to how non-descript it all is. Each track blends into the other to such a degree that it’s indiscernible the differences. However, this was pleasant enough. The bar is that I wouldn’t actively seek it out, but also wouldn’t switch it off if it was on. Take that as you will. Standard three star review.
I think actually I just don't like krautrock that much. does some cool stuff but it's just not for me. I don't think I would ever really come back and listen to this again. best tracks: hero, isi, e-musik
Not for me.
Fav tracks: Isi, E-musik
Score: 70 Album Art: 60 This is pretty good rock music for 1972. Lots of great ambient sounds in the background of the songs. Sometimes they go on for a little too long but not the point of irritation, they are still nice to listen to. Not sure why the last track isn't on Spotify but it is worth listening to. Fav tracks: Seeland and Hero No least favorites
A mix between white noise soundscapes and German Mick Jagger yelling. It starts off a real snoozefest in the first half - calming, instrumental, drone music if you like that stuff... THEN he starts mumbling secret messages into the microphone while ocean sounds play in the background...THEN the beat kicks up and he starts yelling like a freak while playing punk rock... THEN it turns into Silent Hill on the PS1... THEN I had to go to Youtube to listen to the last song, and it's back to The German Rolling Stones. I actually liked the second half. 2.5/5
It was alright. First half nearly put me to sleep while driving though.
2.5 stars
Olen jostain syystä tyytyväinen siitä, että olen kuunnellut tämän. Albumi ei kuitenkaan ole kovinkaan kummoinen. Tykkään tavasta, jolla tunne on olemassa tällä musiikilla, se on rauhoittavaa ja pakottavaa. Jotenkin paljon kiinnostavampaa kuin the Sonicsin ensimmäinen albumi joka oli ilmeisesti myös proto-punkkia. LCD soundsystem tulee mieleen varsinkin Hero biisissä. Harmittaa ettei Murphy huuda näin paljoa, saisi laajemman skaalan tunnetta kuin se laiskan lörpsökkä laulanta, joka artistista myös toki.
Interesting but I did not like it enough to buy it.
Disco pausado, relajado, con reminiscencias de los 70. Un tanto de la época. Fácil de escuchar, pero no destaca especialmente
Enjoyed this. Great music to work to...
Album sperimentale, niente di così brutto, niente di così bello
3.5, had its moments but no Kraftwerk
I really liked the first three songs - they were so calm and I felt like I could fall asleep to them. It lost me a bit in the second half though.
I'm confused.... what is their sound.... oh they're a German group, ah right, that explains it. You either love it or hate it, and i hate punk and post punk, and moreso German interpretation of punk and post punk... so you can guess where this is going. It opened well with isi, quite liked that track... and then I was transcended into a sea of tranquility in the relaxation room at the Spa... and then a blast of post punk guitar and smash smash drum rhyrhm woke me up again... tbh not the worst album I've ever heard, but I sure won't be listening to it again, it's just so inconsistent swing in sounds for each track.
Interesting
Could listen to this all day! There's a sound here that's been an influence to a lot of other bands, including my fav The War On Drugs!
para mimir
Weird elevator music
It's very lush. It's very cool.
Sin más. No creo que quiera volver a escucharlo. Krautrock, kosmische musik, experimental rock, psychedelic rock, proto-punk
Boring AF
Good to listen to in the background. I thought the first half was really beautiful and interesting and the second half was not as good.
Some of these songs were really interesting. It's labeled as an electronic album, but I could hear some rock in there too. Pretty cool album for 1975 though. Feels ahead of its time. Nice album to wrap up the week.
Krautrock. Seems a bit derogatory, no? Apparently it's a broad term for German experimental/psych rock bands that incorporated different electronic and ambient elements. Can is in that group, and after Tago Mago last week, I've got an appetite for "kosmische musik"--yes, I am going to distance myself from the other genre label as it was invented by none other than the English as a "humorous umbrella category" that many artists underneath that umbrella didn't appreciate. Let's do better. Never heard Neu, they (at least on this album) lean into the low-key/ambient side of things, which isn't a bad thing at all. Only six tracks and an average runtime of about seven minutes. I was hoping I'd pull more out of here to save, but the double-edged sword of ambient stuff like this is that it inevitably transports and I have a harder time grasping tracks as it's one long odyssey. Still, this is a good one. I look forward to some other kosmische stuff, maybe Kraftwerk? Favorite tracks: Seeland, E-Musik. Album art: NEU! What else am I supposed to say about this? 3.5/5
Favourites: -ISI -Hero I don't really like just instrumental music, but the ones that had some lyrics where kinda good
The first half was chill and the second half finished with a more frantic energy. I liked the buildup of this one, definitely ahead of its time. E-Music was my favourite but I really enjoyed this whole album. Can see myself returning to this one, another great new discovery from this project. 4 stars
Me gustó
Tal vez si se le preguntara a Neu! por sus influencias, las negarían todas. Pero se puede trazar un camino, tan ligero como el aire, que -como dice chusen- arranca desde el impresionismo francés, pasa por The Velvet Underground y los atraviesa a ellos. Lo fundamental de esta música es, precisamente, su delgadez, su fisonomía maleable; como si no proviniera de ningún tiempo y no habitara en ningún espacio. La Historia, en el disco, parece pasar por el costado. Los sonidos aparecen, desaparecen y vuelven a aparecer, con una cadencia blanquecina, y su estatuto es el de la fugacidad. Así, parece que esta música solo existe para ella, a pesar de que tanto detrás como delante tiene un sendero, al cual ella cierra los ojos.
Disco pre-Neue Deutsche Welle, un movimiento q me gusta mucho, y de la misma época que Kraftwerk. Tiene bastante sinte y es algo más psicodélico que Kraftwerk. Siento que es el disco perfecto para escuchar mientras uno va pisteando por la ruta con su auto... al menos la primera mitad, despues se va medio al choto con la experimentación y el rock en mi opinión. También le noto (y ahora estoy hablando x hablar) algo de impresionismo frances en el piano, y siento como q hay una influencia importante de eso en "Leb Wohl". Como dije antes, me gusta mucho este género, pero se va al re carajo con "Hero", siento que si quiero escuchar algo como esa canción, pongo un Iggy Pop o un Bowie. 6/10
me gusto no entendi mucho el concepto siento pero me gusto hallo susi guten morgen komm wir spielen komm komm komm
I have mixed feelings, I was originally pleasantly surprised, I really like "Leb Wohl" because of how lovely it sounded, the "Hero" came on and it got weird, very weird
It had my attention from the very start. I was curious about it and I felt very satisfied at the end. Will be listening to a lot more Neu!
Last song wasn't available but this was pretty good. First half was pleasant ambient, second half more rock.
pianon pimputusesque style album. menee biisistä toiseen = mahtava konsepti. tuo hero kappale keskellä vähänä kakka vaikka ok biisi .. meikä poika vähän skippaili kahden minuutin cooldowneja pitemmpien kappaleiden loppuun ei nyt ehkö ollut paras kuuntelukerta kelpo teos kiinnostava varsinkin aikakautensa takia e-musik
Loved this, already in my frequent circulation list having listened to it quite a bit since Friday. Love that whole simple repetitive beat sound with lots of layers over the top. It must’ve sounded like the future listening to this for the first time back in the mid 70s. Never realised they were originally in Kraftwerk, surely making them some of the most influential musicians going. If 4.5 existed I’d give it that - loses 0.5 pt after it slightly loses its way in the middle
This went by really quickly and didn't leave much of an impression, I think lots of the sounds reminded me of BBC educational programmes/look around you? Not much like kraftwerk so I'd clearly not understood krautrock before. Yeah it was alright.
Unfortunately bland. Too much like background music.
Enjoyed the first 2 tracks but mostly because its inoffensive background music. The rest of the album was shite.
Quite enjoyed this for the most part.... Think I preferred the first 3 songs to the rest. The more atmospheric ones were better then the punky ones imo. Without those songs I probably would've given it a 4. Still enjoyed it though Bet this was pretty innovative in 1975. Very public service broadcastingy again
Weird in a good way. Not good enough to enjoy however
Banger
pretty good, enjoyed the sound!
Very chillax (!) with one head banger track (?)
A relaxing morning listen. Not bad at all.
First three tracks were a snoozer, last three were more interesting.
Nice background music. 1001 albums you want to hear in an elevator or Dr’s waiting room.
The last Krautrock album was solid, this one not so much. Not bad, I could see listening cases, but overall not for me. I guess I'm glad to have become aware of the genre.
Is the term 'krautrock' acceptable in 2023? Either way, this is a fine example of it (or whatever term we should be using). Driving futurescapes of tracks with a few mellower, ambient moments. Great to run to and think of concrete skyscrapers and monorails. Apparently the two band leaders each had different philosophies for this album, so split it down the middle, with one taking side A and the other side B. Frankly, I didn't notice any great difference. Maybe the second half was a little more crunchy and rocky, but I liked both. Rating: 3.5/5 Playlist track: Isi Date listened: 22/01/23
post psychedelic atmospheric early punk tycho + sex pistols
Giorgio Moroder meets Mike Oldfield.
FWIW, I don't see the change as such between Side A and Side B. A distinction without a difference, thankfully?
I actually liked a lot of slow minimal ambient stuff. With the right singer it could’ve been really cool. Didn’t like the more conventional rock songs with lyrics as much. 2.5- 3
I don’t think krautrock is for me. Maybe this album is important somehow but i found it incredibly boring
I forgot I was listening to an album multiple times. Then something would happen and it would scare me. The last song was especially creepy. Karl, we can add Krautrock to our podcast.
A band I'd never really heard before, but I absolutely loved it.
A bit nothingy. Good nothing, mind. A decent record.
Not a fan. First songs function well as background music and fade away quickly since there is nothing really interesting happening. The last songs, on the other hand, stay in the foreground but in a bad way. Just a bunch of noise.
Cool use of phasing. Both halves being two mini-albums probably works even better on vinyl.
Boring
This album starts very chill, gets a bit annoying halfway and ends chill again.
Bit of an odd one. Very decent background album
Unexpectedly enjoyable
Old
good enough in the background but didn't manage to hold my attention.
This is sublime music to work to.
Krautrock always sounds better when you're travelling. Having missed listening to this album the other day, I decided to listen on my train journey into Bristol. It was getting dark, the evening felt brooding. The first track accompanied the walk down to the station; second track the train was delayed; third still waiting; fourth and fifth were the train journey itself; and the sixth was the walk from the station to the pub. Overall, turns out it was quite a fitting album for my journey. Enjoyed it. All that said, I'd expect listening in a different environment I would have scored it less.
3+
A pinnacle of krautrock, featuring 6 great extended tracks. The first half is bright, calming, and atmospheric. You can hear the influence it would have on Eno and the development of ambient music. The spacey synths are very Eno-esque. We see a shift in the 2nd half to something faster, harder, and reminiscent of the works of post-punk artists like The Fall. I'm personally a huge fan of "Hero". The vocalist still feels like an accessory to the spacey guitar and the signature motorik beat. Despite being 42 minutes, it really flies by.
Background music, quite good
Delightful! We love underground basement vibes
Interesting album. Certainly doesn’t sound like it’s almost 50 years old. I can see how this was influential. At the end of the day, I don’t necessarily need to listen to it again. For me, it doesn’t go at the top of a list, but I recognize what I’m listening to.
no tengo idea que pretendía
It's like a perfect blend of garage rock and prog. Krautrock (of Kossmischemisik to be PC) is fun. It can kind of blend in a bit after a while, even as it attempts to be abrasive, but it's a great introduction to what is a fun and exciting subgenre. Can are miles better though, and what I'd go to for a hot of this.
Couple alright songs but a weird album to put in the punk genre
Electrónica, ambiente.
Wow, what a great listen. Some parts feel like I’m listening to a John Carpenter Escape from New York track, others feel more punk like The Stranglers… just great. 4! T3B 1. Hero 2. Seeland 3. Leb’Wohl
Great instrumental.
I liked the first part, the nature sounds were a nice touch. It was soothing and mellowing in a new age sort of way. Then it became loud and raucous. I did not appreciate the contrast too much.
10/10 I listened to there first three albums and loved their third (this one) the most but all were a 10/10 super fun electronic/psych-roch
I didn't know what to expect here but this seemed really ahead of its time. Enjoyed
Radiohead vibes before Radiohead existed.
Ambient and atmospheric at start. A lot of similarities with other krautrock bands I've listened to before. The second half has more tempo and the song Hero is more in line with proto punk. Krautrock isn't really my thing but I get why this is a good album and the production is great.
Interesting
It appears that the canonical lens to listen to this album through is that of two halves. The angle works well enough, but the band also makes a first-rate piece of interleaving work. The energy doesn't feel at all disconnected from the ambient bits. Every krautrock album needs a distinguishing mark, and I found this one's in the opening piano work. Wish that had stuck around more enduringly, perhaps as a subway to the texture.
None for me, thanks. Way too boring and repetitive.
This was strange, but I kinda liked it. It was like a cross between prog rock, punk, and stripped down electro a la Kraftwerk. I'd probably listen to a couple of tracks again. 2.5 stars (wish this thing had half stars for rating).
A magical little record. “Cosmic music” is spot on. Both halves are chock full of interesting ideas and transportive passages, albeit in be very different ways. Worthy of some repeat listening.
Very chill but I don't really care for it all that much.
Super
Har bara lyssnat på NEU! lite sporadiskt tidigare, men denna platta är ju alldeles fantastisk.
Pretty sick! Listened to it twice and I’m listening to it right now.
Notes - Krautrock legends Neu’s 3rd album - Split in half because the 2 members of the band wanted different things out of their sound - First half is more melodic and ambient, second half is more rock - Driving bass and drums with repetitive guitar/synth parts - Love the use of rain and wind sounds across the album - I like that its in 2 distinct moods - But there are enough common elements that it still sounds cohesive - Really good “getting shit done” music Fav - hero - Love the vocals on here, kinda sounds like the guy from the Jesus lizard Least fav - After eight - Sounds like hero but less good 5/5
Nice soundscape, quite pink floyd-y but nice and snappy, liked how it built up over the course of the album. You can hear the Kraftwerk in there too. Great friday morning listen.
First song didn’t catch me
snooze
Etwas plätscheriger Krautrock. Hero kann ich beim besten Willen nichts abgewinnen. ISI gefällt mir noch am besten. Gute zwei.
Melkosta päristelyä. Aikaansa edellä. Hyvää krauttia! 4/5
Tää on kova! Vitosta hipoo.
Tykkäsin kyllä tästä. Mukavan seesteistä menoa monessa biisissä. 4/5
Loved this. I don't usually go for Krautrock, but this is great. Could listen to it all day - brilliant as ambient music.
Catchy tunes
Smoothness