Bookends

I find it a bit wishy-washy now. I used to live their music xxx

Hate em

“Bookends Theme - Reprise” has been one of my favorite songs for a long time, it always makes me want to cry. I really liked most of these songs, I love them. Sorry. I’m such a sap. But! I was a little disappointed in the record as a whole. Would still listen in my free time. 3.6.

A little maudlin at times but I do like several of the songs.

I liked this one quite a bit. The tone shifts organically between sentimental and groovy.

genuinely insane experience

Lovely soft sound but no awesomeness.

really masterfully written, not frilly or overly pretentious (except for the old people bit). was not expecting to enjoy

Found this very boring, but not actively bad

Boring. Almost fell asleep

Great album!

s.s., 1968 -> 3

Bit boring

I was familiar with some of the songs here, and I was pleasantly surprised by the rest. This is good, and they had some really cool and heavy sounds that caught me off guard. Music was better then. Many artists are trying to do too much these days. I’d listen to this over Kendrick Lamar every single day.

Bookends, by Simon & Garfunkel, is an album that I can’t say sounds bad or flawed, but simply isn’t really to my taste. I particularly found the A side less enjoyable, with unnecessary crooning and weird melodies. However, on the B side, there was mostly good tracks, including Mrs. Robinson, A Hazy Shade of Winter, and At the Zoo. All of these songs are upbeat, catchy, and easy to listen to. All in all, Bookends is an alright album. Best Song: A Hazy Shade of Winter Worst Song: Old Friends

While I have deep respect for Simon & Garfunkel, this album does not contain their best material (Mrs. Robinson being the only notable exception). One would think that the name alone doesn't warrant inclusion on this list, but there you go ... 2/5

Not what I expected from simon and garfunkel. It opens like a psychadelic rock album that shook my car speakers and goes on a strange journey. It feels experimental (Voices of Old People) and just strange at points. Stranger yet is that I ended up liking the whole ride.

Really enjoyed this one. Much sillier than I expected and those synths (?) on the first tracks go HARD.

Some absolute classics, and some tracks that are an absolute waste of time.

Side one is an excellent piece that represents what an album means to me. A cohesive piece flowing from one song to another, each a self contained story while being part of a bigger picture. It was painted with a gentle sadness that resonated deeply within me. An inspiring piece which if I ever make an album would be a guiding light. The story from youth to old age all with a gloomy background really touched me. The second side was also good, just different. Many enjoyable songs, A Hazy Shade of Winter was my favorite. It is simply not a cohesive piece the way the first side is. I’m giving this a 4 for the first side of the album, as it meant so much to me, and I don’t find the second side to be much of a detractor

I liked the album but I wouldn’t go as far to say I loved it. I’m stuck between a 3 or 4 star rating. It was very relaxing but some songs did just not stand out from the others. But I couldn’t say much bad stuff about it. I liked it

4stars

Ok

Cheers to you indeed Mrs Robinson. I really wonder what leads to these whimsically random song themes lol. Would give this 2.5 if I could

The most upbeat I've heard the duo, classic album

Beautiful album

Honestly, I thought this album was overwrought. Too much instrumentation, too many odd sound effects, and so on. The couple of classic tunes on this record are tunes that don't have these distractions. Simon & Garfunkel are best when they are singer songwriters, not trying to be the next Jefferson Airplane acid freakout.

While there are more than a few things on this album to appreciate (namely Mrs. Robinson, America, and the brevity), it's always just felt like another S&G project to me. I don't know if its legendary status is as well-earned as the duo's in general. IT IS THE POETRY OF DRUGS AND PROMISCUOUS SEX! But can we talk about The Graduate?! How good is that movie?

I found this to be much more engaging than any other S&G (or just S, or just G) project I’ve heard to this point.

It’s a beautiful album. I love the vocal harmonies and appreciate the generally understated instrumental and production. The writing is of course a highlight, very engaging.

Another S&G album, did we need it? Yeah cause of Mrs Robinson, but the rest didn’t grab me. Maybe the Zoo but I hope we are done with S&G

Another from the legendary duo. Not sure why, but it struck me today that these guys were making albums in the '60s, for some reason that's impressive. This one's great though, it's got a bona fide all-timer in Mrs. Robinson, along with a handful of other great tracks. It's not as impactful for me as Bridge Over Troubled Water (and maybe below Parsley Sage Rosemary and Thyme as well), but these guys are consistently great and enjoyable. Favorite tracks: Mrs. Robinson, Save the Life of my Child, Voices of Old People, Fakin' It, A Hazy Shade of Winter. Album art: Glamor shots by Deb energy. Two turtle neck boys, looking as if it's their first day on earth. It's a very good "band photo," as far as those go. Art Garfunkel looks like a bit a of a menace. 4/5

I miss this type of music!

Wholesome.

I'm a bit biased so this isn't an objective review. My auntie emigrated in the early 70s and left a stack of LPS that I kidnapped and devoured as a kid. They included Abbey Road, The Stones first album, Cat Stevens and amongst the others....this. I've now played this album so so many times and it's been a friend to me over the years when I'm happy and when I've been sad. Beautiful poetry superbly executed- poignant and sad, funny and bold. I know it inside and out and I guess by now it's part of me.

4.8 - loved this album a lot. Listened to Simon and Garfunkel a lot when I was young because of parents but never this album in full.

Honestly just a very pleasant time. Fave tracks: America, Mrs Robinson, A Hazy Shade of Winter 4.3/5

I was prepared to complain about this being their second best album. But three listens through... I still think it's their second best, but it's pretty damn great.

listened to again great album

I felt less than impressed with this album as it felt kind of disjointed and cobbled together for a "concept" album. Maybe the first half was the concept and the rest was a mix of unused Graduate recordings (aside from the tremendous Mrs. Robinson) and an audio recording of old people? Mrs. Robinson, America, Hazy Shade of Winter and Bookends themselves should warrant this a 5, but I hesitate. Maybe I can get used to an acoustic duo using a Moog bass? I'll give them credit for the contrast.

First off, America is a great song. Will always remind me of Almost Famous which is one of my favourite films. The rest for the most part is fine but there are too many goofy and weird tracks that throws everything off kilter. At least it isn't long so it was manageable.

Some classic tracks - America, Mrs Robinson, but the not so classic tracks are forgettable

gähn

Graduate leftovers are the best kind of leftovers.

As expected, very folkish music, which is not my thing. I don't find much at all of this album to be catchy/memorable. I will say that on a second listen it grew on me a little bit. I enjoy the whistles and happy-go-lucky sort of attitude.

a short, mostly gentle listen, not my favourite of theirs but still nice . assuming the big singles are bolted on to this edition ?

Beautiful music, with beautiful lyrics. The songwriting, the harmonies, the melodies its all almost perfect. Every song checking in at under 3 minutes makes feel so modern too. I couldn't help but sg along to the bit hits we all know too. Easy to see why it is in the 1001.albuns you must hear list.

Loved it

My favorite album by one of my favorite artists. Themes of growing older—“how terribly strange to be seventy”—that feel meaningful when you are young, and continue to resonate as you grown older. Some of their best songs are on this album: “Mrs Robinson,” “Punky’s Dilemma,” “Overs.” My favorite is “America,” which features one of the greatest lyrics ever written: “‘Kathy, I’m lost,’’ / I said, though I knew she was sleeping, / I’m empty and aching and I don’t know why… / Counting the cars on the New Jersey Turnpike, / they’ve all come to look for America.”

Boy, that was way weirder than I thought it would be. So many strange choices on display. S&G are undeniably great songwriters but the production here got in the way of the songs more often than not and I had to work to connect with the words. Also, the weird sketches? What's that about? That said, "Mrs. Robinson" is an absolute monster. Hard to argue against it.

The high points of this album are exquisite. America and the bookends theme in particular. But there’s a fair chunk which is far more lightweight and forgettable

Beautiful when it’s right, understated when it’s not. The music is of course deserving of it praise with the melodic harmony and janglet guitars. The hooks are a delight and the music really speaks to the sole. I love the hits and a few others, but could do without some of the fillers.

Truly a classic. It's been a long time since I listened to the whole album. Great stuff.

A little sleepy for me but not bad. I always loved "Hazy Shade Of Winter."

I really like the song old friends

There are some good songs on this album, but his work really doesn't resonate with me. This is the second of album of his (one solo, and this) that I've listened to it, and it's a bit of chore to listen to. I do think this album was better than the other though.

Ever since i was a kid I’ve loved S&G’s music. Their harmonies have always been some of the best and the most fun to sing. But a few years ago I really listened to the lyrics and realized just how “coffee shop intelligentsia” pretentious they were. This is a primo example of that. The second side is way better than the first. There’s a reason I already knew most of the back half and little of the first. Songs added to Spotify: 2

Some true hits and some definite filler. Overall rather melancholy. It was a time, it was. The three good songs couldn’t carry the album. L wanted to turn it off, J grew up listening to this duo so knew most of the songs. These guys have better albums, with an “s”. Team rating comes in at (1.4*s)

Given the subject matter of many of these songs, how does it still manage to feel so white and wimpy? I found this one a bit boring, they've gotta have better albums than this because they have a handful of good songs and they aren't on here. A Hazy Shade of Winter is good but is cancelled out by At the Zoo (elephants aren't even dumb). Not enough good ones to justify a higher rating or a relisten.

I'm glad this was short. The duo tries to explore some weirdness here like on the track old people talking...which quite literally is just that. Didn't get it. Seems like the studio threw on Mrs. Robinson, which is the only good song, after the fact to get people to buy it.

It's a sleepy little album. A couple of good songs but a lot of filler. Simon & Garfunkel are such a weird thing. I feel they belong in a conversation about music history because of the unique niche they carved out. Some of their songs are great but not for any of the reasons that line up with the genres or styles that I love. Bookends specifically did little to bring me back to S&G. 2.00 stars

„Preserve your memories; They're all that's left you“. Diese Zeile bringt die knapp 30 Musikgenuss auf den Punkt. Tolle Songs „Hauy Shame of Winter“, „America“ und „Mrs. Robinson“ integriert in musikalisch und lyrisches Gesamtkunstwerk, das einen Lebenszyklus beschreibt und schon 1969 die Frage stellte … warum sind wir hier. Danke Ihr zwei für dieses Album 😊.

Leiernder Folk Rock.

Bookends is a classic of folk and folk-rock but not the most classic Simon and Garfunkel album. It has great music - America, Mrs. Robinson (though that was previously on The Graduate soundtrack), and A Hazy Shade of Winter - but doesn't pack the punch of Sounds of Silence or Parsley Sage Rosemary and Thyme. It is also not as iconic as the follow up to Bookends, the quintessential and Simon and Garfunkel album, Bridge Over Troubled Waters. In a word, it's a great album but not the greatest Simon and Garfunkel album.

Meh

Wasn’t much of a fan.

Wie ein lieblichen Wein

This is a lovely, mostly breezy listen. A classic of its era and a high bar set for the genres of folk rock and acoustic pop. Bittersweet and whimsical, thoughtfully written. Several of Simon and Garfunkel's best songs reside here. I think I might have liked it better if they had carried the concept through the entire album. Fave Songs: Mrs. Robinson, A Hazy Shade of Winter, At the Zoo, America, Bookends Theme, Punky's Dilemma

A few odd tracks, old people talking being one. Some tracks seem out of place - Mrs Robinson for example. Overall an enjoyable listen with a couple of classics in there.

Beautifully written songs and excellent harmonies. There are some stand out tracks on this album like "America" and "Mrs. Robinson" being the most well know. The production is a little too slick and the inclusion of strange interludes and sound tricks is a bit of a turn off. Overall, though, pretty good all album.

A side was hot garbage. B side pretty good. 2.5

Good album. Not their best, many of the songs don’t offer much, but “America” is just a great song. Kind of saves the album in the end. 3/5 Might listen again

Album 346 of 1001 Simon & Garfunkel - Bookends Rating : 5/ 5 Favorite Tracks :America / Old Friends A simply beautiful album. I'm being blessed with some favorites, lately. I used to wear out some Simon & Garfunkel on vinyl back in the day. Loved all of their older stuff and then they came out with the Concert in Central Park album, which is still an all time favorite. Can't go wrong with them.

Not as sensual as "Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme". Still great folk classic. 4.5/5.

I'm a sucker for S&G and enjoyed this a lot. They didn't shy away from being heartfelt and soft and I love that. Nice harmonies. I think they just wrote songs they really liked and didn't try to be anything in particular. Not sure sure how to place the genre. Makes me feel nostalgic for something but I'm not sure what

Great stuff, classic Simon & Garfunkel

Great story telling in music

A solid, complete effort from the pop duo with what might be their most consistent and memorable work. Less "flashy" and quieter than some of their other key releases, it contains three of their best songs (America, Mrs. Robinson and the cool, Hazy Shade of Winter) and some other above average tunes that showcase their singing talent and Paul Simon's brilliant songwriting. Prefer this over, Bridge Over Troubled Waters.

Enjoyed this album so much

This is a brilliant work by one the great writers of his generation. This is the album that made me want to write poetry, that made me question the fictions I was being sold, that showed me music as a serious art form.

9/10

Uneven, but you can hear why they became a thing.

Made me cry in the middle of it with the song ‘Old Friends’

Some famous tunes, apart from that: meh

Brilliant, Brilliant, Brilliant. Every song is perfection (ok, maybe not "At the Zoo," but that song reminds me of old commercials for The Bronx Zoo, back in the 70s.)

S+G have been a big part of my musical life. Their Live at Central Park has strong high school memories. Although I want to give this album a 5, they will receive a 4 because some of their filler songs are just ok.

This is a classic, of it’s time, really S&G in their prime. Also the first blast of synthesizer on an album. How can not recognize that fat Moog bass? Spawned two of my favourite songs of all time.

Better than the last s&g album. Just don’t really like them that much.

Really enjoyed that. The lyrics and harmonies are gold.

My favorite boys. It’s not even close. They make me so happy and so sad, forever and always looking for an excuse to listen to them

Great album by a great duo. There are few things to complain about if at all. I did find the 'skittish' bits unnecessary. Hence why I give it only four stars.

I loved this album growing up. Always wanted to be an old guy in NY sitting with my best friend on a bench. My mom had a soft spot for S+G so I listened to them a lot as a kid.

Random extra sounds Harsh track changes Overall lots of Great songs that I thought of in a different way.

Man this was a short album. This is probably one of the better ones from this era.

Nice enough. "Old Friends" is the kind of sentimentality that I can get behind (and is part of a nice segment of songs blending one into the other). "Hazy Shade of Winter" is nicely energetic, even if the lyrics are silly. "At the Zoo" is Beatles-level silliness. And even the more run-of-the-mill tracks have a certain amount of lyrical inventiveness.

I was not expecting the synth on Save the Life of My Child. The backing vocals were also a bit odd. Voices of Old People... Why is this on an album? The rest is absolutely lovely

Released in 1968, Simon & Garfunkel's "Bookends" marked a turning point in their career. Unlike the folk-rock of their earlier work, "Bookends" ventured into a more introspective, cinematic soundscape, showcasing the full spectrum of Paul Simon's songwriting prowess. Lyrics: Profound Exploration of Youth and Society The album's lyrical tapestry is intricate and thought-provoking. Songs like "America" and "Save the Life of My Child" grapple with societal anxieties, questioning the Vietnam War and the disillusionment of the youth. They employ vivid imagery and metaphorical language, painting a picture of a generation searching for meaning amidst social unrest. "Voices of Old People" utilizes spoken word snippets, capturing the wisdom and vulnerability of aging, contrasting them with the youthful angst of "America." Other songs like "Old Friends" and "Fakin' It" delve into personal reflections on friendship and lost innocence. Simon's introspective nature shines through, examining the complexities of human connection and the passage of time. Music: Evolving Soundscape Beyond Folk Musically, "Bookends" is a departure from their folk-oriented beginnings. Paul Simon's experimentation with pop sensibilities is evident in catchy melodies and instrumentation beyond just acoustic guitars. "Mrs. Robinson" utilizes a driving rock beat and soaring vocals, becoming one of their biggest hits. "At the Zoo" incorporates whimsical flute and playful xylophone, offering a lighter counterpoint to the album's heavier themes. However, the duo's signature vocal harmonies remain a cornerstone, adding a layer of emotional depth and melancholic beauty throughout the album. Songs like "Bookends Theme" are purely instrumental, utilizing introspective acoustic melodies to create a sense of atmosphere. Production: Subtle Nuance and Studio Innovation The production on "Bookends" is subtle yet impactful. Roy Halee, their longtime collaborator, utilizes innovative recording techniques and subtle overdubs to create a nuanced and layered soundscape. "America" features faint soundbites of news anchors and street noise, adding a sense of realism to the song's social commentary. The iconic bookends of the album, "Bookends Theme" (instrumental), appear at the beginning and end, creating a sense of cyclical structure and reflection. This emphasizes the album's introspective theme, bookending the listener's journey through themes of youth, memory, and societal examination. Themes: A Tapestry of Time and Reflection The album revolves around several central themes. "Bookends" is essentially a reflection on the passage of time, exploring nostalgia, the loss of innocence, and the search for meaning in a tumultuous period. The album also delves into societal issues like war, alienation, and questioning authority. Simon's keen observation of his surroundings and introspective nature permeate the lyrics, offering a poignant commentary on the complexities of human experience. Influence: A Legacy of Innovation and Exploration "Bookends" was a critical and commercial success, reaching No. 1 on the Billboard charts and spawning several hit singles. It solidified Simon & Garfunkel as one of the most influential musical acts of their generation. The album's influence extends beyond the charts. It paved the way for the blending of folk and pop elements, inspiring countless artists to explore deeper lyrical themes and experiment with production techniques. Pros and Cons: A Balanced Viewpoint While widely acclaimed, "Bookends" is not without its critiques. Some criticize the album's disjointed feel due to the inclusion of leftover songs from other projects, making the narrative flow less cohesive. However, this can also be seen as a diverse representation of Simon's evolving songwriting at the time. Another critique is the perceived lack of emotional depth compared to their later work, particularly "Bridge Over Troubled Water." However, "Bookends" offers a different kind of emotional resonance, one that is subtle, nuanced, and built on quiet contemplation. In Conclusion: A Timeless Work of Artistic Evolution "Bookends" stands as a testament to Simon & Garfunkel's artistic growth and willingness to experiment. It is a cohesive collection of songs, rich in lyrical depth, musical innovation, and introspective themes that resonate across generations. While the album may not possess the bombastic emotional grandeur of some of their later work, it offers a unique and nuanced exploration of youth, societal anxieties, and the complexities of human experience. Its enduring influence and timeless themes solidify "Bookends" as a cornerstone of popular music history.

Mrs. Robinson putting the album on its back for the 3-star

It's weird to me that something is called a concept album when it's actually one part concept album and one part random leftovers and unreleased tracks. There's a vague cohesiveness to the album because of the duo's general guitar sound and the sort of carnival sound that opens the second half (similar to the theme on the first half), but I still kind of feel like they should be considered separate entities. The first half—the concept half—was pretty interesting. It almost feels like the soundtrack to a short film that never got made ("Up: The Musical" given the theme?). The lyrics warrant a closer listen than I was able to give on the first go round, but musically it was enjoyable enough. I don't know if it's among S&G's best material, but for the most part it kept my interest. The "Sounds of Old People" track is at once arresting and jarring —fitting in with the theme of the album, but a little out of place as a non-musical interlude. The second half of the album contains a seemingly random collection of re-released tracks, unreleased material, and songs from "The Graduate" soundtrack. Of course, "Mrs. Robinson" is a classic song from the movie. I'm vaguely familiar with "A Hazy Shade of Winter" in that I recognize the title and know I've heard it but wouldn't recognize the song (until the chorus). It heavily borrows from Roy Orbison's "Oh, Pretty Woman." Similarly, "Old Friends" (on the first half of the album) reminds me a lot of the Beatles' "A Day in the Life," both in theme and some of the musical elements. Overall, the songs are a bit more upbeat, catchy, and energetic than the first half, but not necessarily as lyrically interesting. Speaking of musical borrowing, that's one of the other things I noticed about this album—musically, there seems to be a lot of repetition of other S&G work (or, elements from songs on this album are reused in later songs). "Save a Child" shares part of the melody line with the chorus of "Me and Julio." "At the Zoo" is similar musically to "Mrs. Robinson," and "Fakin' It" shares the same drum pattern as "Celia." That's not necessarily bad, but it's something that very obviously stood out to me. I enjoyed the album for the most part. The guitar work is interesting, and sometimes soothing, and the themes explored on the first half of the album work well as a cohesive set. And the catchier songs on the second half are fun to listen to. I'm not sure I'd listen to it a ton in the future, but it's a good album. I'll give it a 4/5, but it's more of a 3.5 for me.

Melkein neljä. Bookends theme ja mrs robinsin kyl 5/5

A fantastic collection of songs that’s slightly dampened by a pretty weak concept. The first half is a kind of concept album but not really, and then the second half is just outtakes from The Graduate soundtrack - I think it would work better for me if it was either a full on concept album or just dropped the concept entirely. Voices of Old People adds nothing for me, and At the Zoo is a slightly weak closer after everything else. Pretty much every other song is great though, very strong 4

I haven't really listened to much Simon & Garfunkel honestly, it's not something I've been exposed to other than their extremely well known songs such as The Sound of Silence. This album really had the feel of a soundtrack to a musical. I was pretty skeptical at first but probably had my biggest flip in opinion mid-album yet - I ended up really enjoying this one. Listens: 2 Fave Track: Mrs Robinson Rating: 4

A great S&G album (as most are) with some great tracks. A nicely varied listen, built with two clear sides.

A little strange and sometimes sad. I kind of enjoyed it.

Well, it has Mrs. Robinson, which is an all-timer. I love S&G, but this album is a little strange. I actually liked the weird at first, but then the songs didn't match the noises.

Moitié musique de film des années 80 moitié road trip

Quite good - not perfect - but very good.

Simon & Garfunkel are more or less lifetime favourites of mine. I already knew this album and have listened to it many times.

2.5

Let's just say that this is not the best complete S&G album However, it is a good one and has some great harmonies and several very special songs (America, Mrs. Robinson,...) 4 star at least

I wasn't sure I understood or liked folk and folk rock until I heard this record. A brave concept record on Side 1 about the cycle of life. Love the "Voices of Old People", so much audio verite to relate to there. The bookends them breaks my heart every time. The album deserves a 5 just for "Bookends", "America", "Mrs. Robinson", "and "A Hazy Shade of Winter". Still not sure if this or BRIDGE OVER TROUBLED WATER is their most complete album. All I know is that those two albums are easily in the top 5 of folk records for me. I've always enjoyed Simon's albums more than Bob Dylan's, and today's listen through just calcifies that thought for me. Brilliant songwriting. Excellent acoustic guitar. Amazing harmonies. Stories you can relate to. It is all here!

iconic

Very neat and beautiful texts, voices and pleasant arrangements. And of course Mrs. Robunson...

Their harmonies are fantastic, as are their lyric writing creativity. And, of course, this album evokes memories of that time in my life, making me feel nostalgic.

Rating: 7/10 Best songs: America, Mrs.Robinson

An all-time favorite. Such an amazing album.

-Save the Life of My Child is a different sound than I’m used to from S&G -America is a great song -I recognize Old Friends, I find it very say and moving -Fakin It is another great song, reminds me of the Beatles -Mrs. Robinson LET’S GOOOO -A Hazy Shade of winter is also really good too, high energy -At the Zoo, another fun song I recognize Overall a great album and enjoyable listen. It was very short, which I don’t think is a positive or negative. Definitely an album I heard growing up.

A slightly mixed bag, has some unbelievably good songs and some that are good not great. Overall probably not where I’d start with Simon and Garfunkel but worth listening to anyway

Very interesting. Some I knew as classic. Very simple songs imo

This was interesting! Hadnt heard of them or seen this album cover. Released in 2009 definitely had me curious. Not really my style of music but overall I enjoyed it!

Eh.

Classic. Jette bra!

I already knew Mrs Robinson and hazy shade of winter. It was enjoyable but not exactly for me. 4/5

i absolutely enjoyed this album through and through. personally, i wish they kept that sentimental and sorrow feeling that started in the beginning through the entire album. other than that, its an absolutely perfect album. 9/10

Just as I remember...great.

Several songs that I thought were on this album are actually on BOTW. I’m not sure I needed a 2 min track of old people talking but it still had its high points (America, Mrs Robinson, Hazy Shade….I even like the zoo song). 3.4

3.4 Not the snoozefest I was expecting. Bonus points for the cover inspiring a generation of lesbian haircuts

I love Simon & Garfunkel so much. This album is fantastic. The two hits (America and Mrs. Robinson) are undeniable and certainly the two highlights of the album, but the other tracks create a deeply vivid and melancholy image of life in the United States. Relistening to this album I formed a new appreciation for Save the Life of My Child - it’s a great tune with a great story penned by Simon (somehow underrated as a songwriter in American music). Also a weird observation - “America” reminds me much of Vampire Weekend’s “Hannah Hunt”, like an older relative of that great song. It sounds like a product of its time, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t relevant today, anything but that. It doesn’t quite have the end-to-end perfection of Bridge Over Troubled Water, but it’s an incredible album from an important duo.

Weird shit. Not necessarily bad as whole tho

meh. another fourth studio album. where does this end? I'm not sure that I've heard their version of Hazy Shade of Winter. The Bangle's version is just sooo good!. But I suppose if there's a song that follows Mrs Robinson, many people would rightly forget about that song. I'm almost tempted to give this album one star for including Voice of Old People. How dare they include me without my permission? Was there ever an obituary that said, "He performed on Bookends"... that would have been fitting.

I was tempted to take a star off for a lyrics that refers to \"South California\" (Punky's Dilemma), though the album was very challenging to rate as I didn't expect the uneveness on the first half. Why \"Voices of Old People\"? And tracks like Overs and Old Friends are sleep inducing. However, America, Mrs. Robinson, Hazy Shade, and At the Zoo are monsters, with tracks like the Bookends Theme and Fakin' It showing strong support. When it hits it is beautiful, catchy, melodic pop with sweet choruses.

Considering their abundant talent this album was underwhelming. The two tracks I recognised I enjoyed but the rest was uninspiring. Just scrapes a 3*

It was fine. A bit dull and not as good as some of their other albums we've had.

Great songs, beautifully sung.

'twas a bit dramatic and a tiny bit twee. Master Simon fancies himself a Brit on this one. It's a bit like some Beatles albums: absolute gems interspersed with twee early 20th century vaudeville ditties.

Boring. I know I’m dull, bat that was another level.

As much as I want to dislike S&G I just can't. They are too talented. This contains some of their most famous songs and very good they are too. A mid 4.

The hits are undeniable but the filler is too. Not a bad listen but I'm not wholly convinced.

solid stuff right here

A concept album that only covers one side while the second side is random singles, kind of funny.

Amazing album

A couple songs, but another one of those "classics" I don't get. Helps me figure out who put this list together

Una de las mejores bandas que lee escuchado, pero de este se rescatan América y Eleonor Rigby

No notes :)

Heard of the artist, not the album. 1968. Pretty chilled vibes. Low 4.

Een vluggertje met Simon & Art, maar vooral met Simon, natuurlijk. Het album met de iconische cover die illustreert dat Jan een coltruitje niet zou misstaan. Hij opent met de theme song, die ik ondanks de mooie melodie nooit echt begrepen heb. Qua stijl had deze beter op het meer folksy 'Sounds Of Silence' gepast. De eerste helft van het album is net de moeite waard door 'America'. De rest lijkt een hoop inspiratie te halen uit Sinatra's jazz pop, met hier en daar vleugjes Big Band. Dit kan goed uitpakken, maar op deze plaat zorgt het een beetje voor een inkakker. De gospel in 'Save the Life of My Child' is wel nice. Voor het echte vuurwerk moeten we lang (wat is lang op een album van een halfuur) wachten. Vanaf Fakin' It, die weer iets meer de folk rock roots van Paul Simon doet oprakelen, wordt het stukken beter. Het laatste trio red het album behoorlijk, met als climax 'At the Zoo'. Het voelt bijna als een kinderliedje aan, maar de intelligente lyrics tillen het naar een iets hoger niveau. Het is zo'n nummer die door z'n geringe lengte, catchy progressie, en upbeat ritme, moeiteloos drie keer achter elkaar afgespeeld kan worden zonder dat hij in kracht verliest. 7/10 Highlights: America A Hazy Shade of Winter At the Zoo

Ik had hier al geen zin in maar heeft me ook niet mogen verbazen. Ja, tuurlijk. De samenzang van beide heren kan prachtig zijn. Maar dit is toch gewoon een saaie plaat? Of moet ik zeggen: concept-album. Dat schijnt het te zijn maar kan ik niet uit mijn luistersessie halen. En geldt zeker niet voor de gehele plaat. En "Voices of Old People"? Ga toch weg. Wat is daarvan de toegevoegde waarde? Misschien ben ik wat te kritisch. Maar aangezien er in '68 zoveel goede muziek werd gemaakt snap ik niet dat dit een hit is geworden. Highlights America Mrs. Robinson

I have listened to this album more times than I can count

estupendo albúm, muy bonito

Some phenomenal songs surrounded by utter garbage. Will continue to listen to their greatest hits album rather than this junk

Solid classic S&G album. America, Overs, Mrs. Robinson, and At the Zoo are my favorites. The spoken word tracks are neat little intermissions and I always like when an album has a theme/reprise. Only note is that I wish it was longer than 29 minutes.

39 and listening to this in full for the first time. Lyrics hit me like a hammer.

I actually didnt like it as much as I remember

Excelente!

Highlights: Bookends Theme, Overs, Mrs Robinson. A concept album that haphazardly explores the chaos of life. However, the duo seem to ditch this great idea at the end of Side A. Side B sounds disjointed, even with the inclusion of runaway hit from The Graduate “Mrs Robinson”. The album would have more impact if the duo dedicated themselves to one theme and given more time to overcome their writer’s block. Is it me or is Paul’s vocals mixed louder on most songs compared to Art’s? I noticed this when reviewing Bridge Over Troubled Water. Overall: 5/10

I enjoyed it! Funky in the beginning, but overall good.

Not their best work

Just lovely.

When I listened to this album for the first time a few years back, it didn’t really make much of an impression on me (except for Mrs Robinson, a song which I love) Looking back I don’t really know what I was thinking, and upon revisiting this album I have found it to be incredible

I could give this a 5 but I'm going 4.5 because of old people talking. Under half an hour and some great songs in that time though. Genius really.

6/10 Highlights: Mrs Robinson America Hazy Shade of Winter

Me gusta

Bookends reminds me of my dad who, to his eternal credit was a big Simon and Garfunkel fan. This album reminds me of my childhood, which is ironic as the concept behind this album is about youth and ageing. As I listen again as an older man I’m consumed by regret for my life but optimistic for the lives of my children. Perhaps I’ll play it to them?

Muy bueno

Some of this album wouldn't be out of place in a 21st century. The opening took me aback.

sharp haircuts - bad music

interesante ngl, fr se siente viejo pero no soy así de old perd0n

Right in my wheelhouse....soft rock, great lyrics with a heavy dose of folk to complete the set. One of the best ever duos.

Good and mellow

Classic, but not for me.

Not a fan at all.

One of my favorite musical duos of all time, but I've never actually listened to this whole album. They're just so incredibly talented, and every song is at minimum interesting to listen to, if not a certified banger. The guitar work paired with their harmonies and *also* great lyrics? Just an all-timer. I don't think it replaces my favorite album from them though.

3.5 stars. A little short (under a half hour) but still enjoyed it, decent folk rock. "Fakin' It" is the standout. "Mrs. Robinson" is a classic. "A Hazy Shade of Winter" is also good.

Meh

Enjoyed it

Solid folk rock album. None of it grabbed me but I liked how it sounded

Unspectacular. I do not really understand why they are lén tiến. This album was a snooze fest but it was tolerable. I was not minding how boring it was until the speaking and then the ode to Jesus.

Good

About a 3.5. Some very strong songs. Was a lot funkier than I was expecting. Classics, also.

Enjoyed the lyrics and storytelling in the songs, but aside from Mrs. Robinson, Fakin’ It, and A Hazy Shade of Winter, didn’t love it. 3/5.

Tipo parte che sembra mega peso e anche la copertina non aiuta, ma; c'è un ma: non è così. Mrs. Robinson capolavoro giustamente valutato.

The upbeat tunes are legendary.

Having only listened to “Mrs Robinson” before taking on this album, I thought this would just be another classic Simon & Garfunkel album with only acoustic guitars and signing. But as soon as “Save the Life of My Child” started, I realised that this would be an entirely different affair than I presumed. A lot of that classic folk sound is still here (“America” and “Old Friends”, for example), but this is probably the group’s most psychedelic effort, which makes for a vibrant and almost cosmic experience Favourite tracks: Save the Life of My Child, America, Old Friends, Fakin’ It, Mrs Robinson

Mrs. Robinson A Hazy Shade of Winter (original)

4 recommendations, 2 Paul Simon records. I think that's enough

Pleasant listening

Good album. I knew several of the songs from their greatest hits album. The others were good. I’d give this 4 stars.

Haven't listened to Simon & Garfunkel in a very long time. I remember first hearing them in the mid 1960s. I had forgotten just how good of voice Art Garfunkel has. Very enjoyable.

I know so many of these songs from the covers. The originals were better in some case and not in others. Also a could weird distractions in song list the lowered overall experience.

I mean yeah, definitely was a Simon & Garfunkel album. Felt very weird to have a Bookend Theme in the middle of the album and not ~bookending~ it.

Would not revisit this album. it’s giving beatles too much for my personal taste. i can see how other people could enjoy it. a few of the songs sound pretty.

Melody. Simplicity. Storytelling. Harmonizing. A bit of sentimentality but generally balanced with humor, irony, and some cynicism. Good song writing goes a long way.

I was not expecting such an interesting and experimental record, especially for its time… sometimes it felt like this could have been made in the 80s or 90s

***** Ingrained in my childhood. Gentle melodies and superb lyrics for everyone.

There is probably a time I’d listen to this again. But it wasn’t what I was looking for yesterday.

Very boring no thank you

Made my spirit sad.

Simon & Garfunkel’s only concept album has some of their best songs, but I wish I enjoyed the overall experience more

Was.. okay

Classic but partially the album is boring

Mrs Robinson is what I recall the most. A classic by now.

Big fan of these two. what's not to like? They never fail to put me in the best mood. harmonies are great, songwriting is great. no notes. Great from start to finish

Definitely an album in the 60s.

Awesome

4.5-5

good album. Some songs are an acquired taste. Music represents the decade well.

Surprisingly funky at times, and with some interesting lyrics that seem to fall into kids songs almost. The talking was an interesting add, but I didn’t love it.

Neh

Not really my thing. Has some Beatles similarities. The song Old Friends has some nice strings.

Intricate production techniques, incredible vocal performance and unique track listing

Ah, Simon and Garfunkel, One of my mom's favorite music artists. While i don't like them nearly as much as her, I'd argue Bookends is a pretty decent album. The songs had a slightly energetic yet relaxed feel which i really liked. The album was also well paced and didn't drag on for too long. Its a pretty decent album for what it is. Best Song: Fakin' It Worst Song: Save the Life of My Child

Timeless

I had only heard the hits and liked them, so I was kind of excited to listen to this. Man, was I disappointed. Mrs Robinson is a classic, same with Hazy Shade, but there was only one other good song (Falun’ It) and one other listenable song (At the Zoo). The rest was boring and tedious.

Muy bonito. América.

Songs are short and satisfying. Folk rock with some interesting bits. Chill

Save the live of my Child Bookends theme tiene una melodía al principio guay América- reflejo se broken dream

I have to listen to more S&G, Old Friends made me cry damn

I've always made an assumption that Simon & Garfunkel were just average 60s folk musicians, but they are so much more than that. I think I just heard a synthesizer which blows my mind for a record from 1968.

I thought this album would sound more folky but it surprised me. There were a few stand out songs and some songs that were just annoying.

Easy going late 60s album with Mrs Robinson on it.

Interesting concept album with an intro and interludes giving the experience a "living in the city vibe." Nothing extremely standing out lyrically, but it had some solid moments.

I think I’ve only heard Mrs. Robison on this record before today. The front half of the record took a few listens to grow on me. The last 3 tracks are a high point on the album. Didn’t change my life but a good listen.

It was fine. Not my thing. Glad I heard it tho

It was N interesting listen. Some of the songs are very beautiful whilst others are strange, like sound of old people talking. The transition between songs isn’t great with very abrupt changes. Some songs had good use of dissonance and also some kind of abrupt changes. As a cohesive album it’s not one I’d listen to regularly but had some nice songs. I did enjoy the experimental style and the experience.

It's Simon and Garfunkel, what more needs to be said? True classic.

Musically great, a bit too folky for me. Reminds me of the beetles with the weird talking tracks. A hazy shade of winter is a hidden banger. Also mrs. Robinson

3/10 Only good bc mrs. Robinson Weird and scary first song

Excellent mastering and use of voice as instruments. Opened up more music than just their most well known “mrs robinson” for me

Like soft rock

First time hearing this album, although I did know some of the songs. Interesting mix of spoken word and songs.

First time hearing this one. Not bad.

Super short - less than 30 mins. I was surprised I only knew 2 songs. Comforting and reminds me of my parents.

About what is expected from any Simon and Garfunkel. Nice to listen to but not my style

Pretty good stuff here. I know it's a great album. But I just wasn't in the mood for it.

"Bookends" by Simon & Garfunkel, released in 1968, is a masterful exploration of life's complexities through the lens of poetic lyricism and acoustic folk-rock. The album is a thematic journey that navigates through the various stages of existence, from the optimism of youth to the introspection of aging. The opening track, "Bookends Theme," sets the tone with its melancholic beauty, while iconic songs like "Mrs. Robinson" and "America" showcase the duo's storytelling prowess. The intricate harmonies and Paul Simon's introspective songwriting create a timeless and evocative listening experience. "Bookends" is a testament to Simon & Garfunkel's ability to craft profound narratives with musical elegance. Its enduring appeal and cultural significance earn it a solid 4/5 for its emotional depth and contribution to the folk-rock genre.

I love "Cecilia" and "The Only Living Boy in New York" as much as anyone but Bookends is far and away the peak of Simon and Garfunkel's time together. A daring, emotional, conceptual A-side about life and aging backed with a B-side full of the finest singles they ever put together. Just fantastic.

I do not wish I was a Kellogg's cornflake floating in my bowl. nor do I wish I was an English muffin.

America and Mrs. Robinson are the only two I was familiar with beforehand. I like Is Voices of Old People the first attempt at ASMR? Mostly pleasant folky tunes that sorta float away once they are over, except maybe Hazy Shade of Winter and At the Zoo.

Lot of experimental stuff on here that I (a) wasn't really expecting and (b) doesn't really work but boy wow America is one of the best songs ever written huh

Not a fan of Simon. Not a fan of Garfunkel. I knew the combo of the 2 wasn't going to be good for me. Thought there were 3 songs I would call OK; Mrs. Robinson, A Hazy Shade of Winter and America. The Bangles do a much better version of A Hazy Shade and Susanna Hoffs is one good looking lady. There as nothing I found exciting about this album, other than remembering Susanna. Pretty bland and boring to me. Won't revisit. 2

4 I’ve always been a Simon & Garfunkel fan, and this album just so happens to connect two of my favorite movies as well: The Graduate and 500 Days of Summer (ironic, if you’ve seen the latter). The song Mrs. Robinson here obviously was composed for and largely featured in The Graduate, and the Bookends Theme was used more subtly, but perfectly in one of 500 Days’ best scenes, aptly bookending a romantic period for our lovably toxic protagonist. I digress, this album is fantastic by its own merits and not just because of how its songs were used in movies, though admittedly, it’s a bit disjointed. Side A largely outshines Side B, mostly because the songs are connected as a sort of concept album, with Save the Life of My Child, America, Overs, and Voices of Old People/Old Friends illustrating youth, young adulthood, middle age, and old age, respectively, which are then literally bookended by the two Bookends tracks, which I assume refer to life and death. Side B is a compilation of songs that were written for or around the time as The Graduate, though only Mrs. Robinson ultimately made it into the film. The songs on this side are also much heavier than anything on Side A, but fortunately, they’re all pretty enjoyable as well, so it’s not a huge deal, though the shift is definitely noticeable. Going into this as a big fan of Mrs. Robinson and the Bookends Theme, I actually walked away with a newfound favorite in America. The song really resonated with me, probably partially because it’s supposed to embody my current stage in life, but it’s also hard not to relate to a song about a young man from Michigan leaving home to see the country as an ex-Michigander, newfound LA transplant myself. Old Friends was another one that really stuck out to me as well, both because it’s a great song and because it served as a bit of reminder of my own mortality, giving me a bit of existential dread in the process (“Can you imagine us years from today/Sharing a park bench quietly?/How terribly strange to be 70”). I really don’t have anything negative to say about any of the songs though - I even kind of like Voices of Old People as an interlude, though it could definitely stand to be a bit shorter than two full minutes. Really solid album and a nice reminder of what I like about these guys. Could probably be organized a bit better, but it’s still really enjoyable nonetheless.

Better than I thought it'd be. Still a bit too mushy for me.

p147. 1968. 4 stars. Quality 60s folk-pop, infused with melancholy and only let down by the amount of filler on it. When it's good it's very good indeed, and Paul Simon is an underrated guitarist.

Weird but not unpleasant album

For such a well-known, classic album by one of the all-time greatest musical duos, I didn't rate Bookends at all. It's certainly not bad but it didn't move me in any way.

Groaned when I got this one and surprisingly loved it.

Mrs. Robinson -- classic and delightful. America is covered by First Aid Kit and it's cool to see the origin story.

Like it

Sleepy 60s poetic stuff. I'm not civilized or in touch with my feelings enough to appreciate it.

A few of the songs are classic, I just can’t get over the production, it’s not Inspiring to me. Probably a product of its time.

Ms Robinson was good, the rest was not catchy enough to make up for the feel good sixties folk sound I can never stand...

It was cool, the First half of the album is weak, One good song only, the second half is stronger, way better. All around, is quite ok. I liked, listened to some stuff that reminded me of The Beatles somehow and I enjoyed. But an album with 3 or 4 good songs only can't have a higher note than 3. But I liked.

3.5/5

Good album, but not their best and the "concept" stuff/audio recordings and so on really falls flat for me and makes it less enjoyable to listen to imho...

Didn’t feel like I was At the Zoo, more like A Hazy Shade of Winter with Old Friends with Voices of Old People in the background.

expecting 3 stars. fun and weird at once. nah, too boring and overplayed, 2 stars.

There are not many songwriters better than Paul Simon. One of my top three.

There are a couple of standout tracks and I accept that the songs are well written (not sure about that cornflake lyric though) but it just passed me by in general and didn't really grab my attention.

2 highlights, sonst nicht gut

Pretty good vibe.

Never listened to a S&G album before. Exceeded expectations despite not being a huge fan of folk-rock. Nice instrumentation and production. Wordy lyrics but not annoying. Pleasantly surprised to hear the original Hazy Shade of Winter. Might listen again but not likely to immediately seek out more S&G.

- Such a surprising album. I've always knew Simon & Garfunkel from songs that are a lot more melancholic. - The cacophony in "Save the life of my child" blew me away. I thought that there was something else playing on the background. - "Mrs. Robinson" is still as fun to hum as ever.

Great album. 3 stars

Classic, what can I say?

It's just a bit funny to me that these guys were the biggest rockstars in the country for a while, but I get it, this is great. It's really short at just 29 minutes and does not waste any time in there (one might argue that "Voices of Old People" does, but I think it's an interesting choice as an interlude). This is the album after Parsley, Sage, Rosemary, & Thyme, and I think it's a bit more uneven but has a tighter narrative and higher highs. There are a few songs I don't love on here, but the best moments on here are truly great ("America", "Mrs. Robinson"). I could possibly see this coming across as a bit uninteresting or pretentious even. I like a more positive spin, and think it works as a beautiful, simple reflection on living and aging. Fun fact I learned here is that "Mrs. Robinson" was the first rock song to win Record of the Year at the Grammys (1969). Favorite song: America Other: Overs, Old Friends, Bookends Theme - Reprise, Fakin' It, Mrs. Robinson, A Hazy Shade of Winter, At the Zoo 12/27/23

Mrs Robinson is super overrrated, but still a solid album. America is amazing. 3.5/5

A few great songs, america mrs robinson. A lot of the others pretty good with some interesting lyrics (at the zoo) and always melodic. Quite a few of the songs and the album itself a little dijointed.

Easy listening.... 2 stars, nothing great

A true classic. I saw „The Graduate“ at least five times because of this music!

Bis auf die bekannten Hits ein konzeptloses gezuppel ohne durchgängiges Konzept. Die Stimme von Paul Simon klingt dünn und fad und macht es nicht besser. Garfunkel hilft da wenig.

Meistarastykki, ég segi nei. En vissulega mjög góð plata. Allt er ljúft en miseftirminnilegt þó. Mrs. Robinson er flott lag, en America er toppurinn á þessari plötu.

3.5/5

First half of the album is beautiful and sad Latter half of the album is more fun, feels like singles

Haut mich nicht vom Hocker.

Simon has always been a brilliant writer and arranger but this one is the softest of the soft folk/rock. One wonders if the producer enforced whispering in the studio for fear that rock music might break out. It's very good. Mrs. Robinson and America are utter classics that have served all of the mountainous praise they've received over the decades. In places, it feels pretty emotionally flat (Punky's Dilemma) flat. For a concept album about coming of age, that's a problem. Critically acclaimed, though - so what do I know?

This album is solid. It has a couple classic songs on it, but I cant say that I care to much for the rest of it. Definitely not bad tho.

Never listened to this one before, a few surprises. Obviously it's Simon and Garfunkel and it's Mrs Robinson, but I found the album a curious listen. Being called a proto-concept album makes sense, in that it's slightly confusing, with old people talking in the middle, and someone walking into the tailors shop setting off the bell with a cheery "Good morning Mr Leach, have you had a busy day?" in the middle of a song. What's going on? So I can't give the album a perfect score. Hazy Shade of Winter is ace though, I always forget about that one. I will have the Bangles cover as well. That riff sounds equally good picked here with an acoustic sound as it does as a full electric lick.

At some point in early 2013, “Save The Life Of My Child” was played to me through tinny earphones by a wide-eyed fellow music enthusiast. “Listen to THIS!” he enthused with his wide eyes, in disbelief that the blaring Moog intro came from a Simon & Garfunkel record in 1968. I didn’t appreciate what he was trying to tell me at the time and was a little nonplussed, but re-listening now it does take me aback coming after the featherweight “Bookends Intro”. The point is, here are Simon & Garfunkel beginning to shift and expand the edges of their fields of experience. It was 1968 and concept albums were as popular as dope, peaceful protests and armpit hair. The first side of “Bookends” cycles through various stages of life, from youthful anxiety into blossoming romance and sliding despair, to somber estrangement and finally ruminations on aging. It’s bookended by, duh, “Bookends Theme”. “Save the Life of My Child” is indeed unlike any other Simon & Garfunkel track I know: bold and brilliant. Also pushing the envelope to lesser effect, “Voices of Old People” is some recorded audio of… well, voices of old people. It’s Art Garfunkel’s only writing credit on the album, bless him. “Old Friends” is a beautiful vignette, all romantic strings and deft character portrait by Simon: “the sounds of the city sifting through trees; settle like dust on the shoulders of the old friends”. Poignant, beyond-his-years stuff. And in between it all is my favourite Simon & Garfunkel song of all time. “America” is absolutely stunning: a symphony, a Great American novel in under four minutes, “‘Kathy, I’m lost’, I said, though I knew she was sleeping; I’m empty and aching and I don’t know why” is such an amazing slide into despair at the end of a gently hopeful couple of verses. By the time the duo are in soaring harmony, counting the cars on the New Jersey turnpike, I have shivers all over: a truly amazing moment. Following such a thematically satisfying first side, we move into a more disjointed second half, but with stronger individual songs. Four of the album’s five singles are here, showcasing Simon & Garfunkel at their most accessible. I’d never been too familiar with “Fakin’ It” until now, but it’s a great catchy reflection on impostor syndrome, striking a lovely balance between pithy singalong and profound introspection. “Punky’s Dilemma” is the best song with “cornflake” in its opening line until a certain Tori Amos track twenty-something years later: it’s a surface-level feelgood ditty with the horror of the Vietnam War lurking just underneath. “Mrs. Robinson” is an effortless hit, one of the poppiest numbers the duo ever made and one of the first I ever associated them with. “A Hazy Shade of Winter”, first released in 1966, ups the energy for a very biting rock-leaning number, and “At the Zoo” is some lovely light relief coming at the end: I love the way it builds up along with the central swinging hook. It’s a shame the duo didn’t commit to making a full album from the “Bookends” concept, but the songwriting is so incredible across the board that it can only be a five-star record (yes, even with “Voices of Old People”.) Bravo.

01) Bookends Theme - 8,0 02) Save The Life Of My Child - 6,0 03) America - 8,5 04) Overs - 8,5 05) Voices of Old People - 1,0 06) Old Friends - 7,5 07) Bookends Theme - 8,0 08) Fakin' It - 9,0 09) Punky's Dilemma - 8,0 10) Mrs. Robinson - 10,0 11) A Hazy Shade of Winter - 9,5 12) At The Zoo - 8,5 TOTAL: 7,71 (77/100) I know it's a concept album, but I can see no point in track #5. On the other hand, "Mrs. Robinson" is a classic and my favorite. So, this is the first album that has lowest and highest mark on it. Oooh, and I know "A Hazy Shade Of Winter" too :-) I don't know why, but I kind of expected more.

The more I listen to Simon and Garfunkel the more I can’t help but feel that Garfunkel was holding Simon back the whole time. Everything’s lovely but not really all that inspiring to make me listen again 3.0

Je sais que c'est un album mollo, mais messemble qu'il manque un peu de oumph. Aussi, j'ai manquer mon bus en l'écoutant, faque ca risque d'influencer mon score

It's fine 3/5

I don't know much about Simon and Garfunkel, but this album sounds a lot more hippie, psychedelic 60s than what I *thought* I knew about them, which was more of a old-timey folksy 60s sound. Old Friends is a highlight of the album, a beautiful, haunting examination of the strangeness of old age by a young man. Now that these guys are, I presume, in their 70s, I'd be fascinated to know their thoughts on this song. Punky's Dilemna is the low point. A dumb song about being a cornflake or an English muffin. I'm sure there's an allegory or metaphor in there that I'm missing, but the song isn't good enough for me to examine it any closer. Mrs Robinson is the most famous song on this album, I think. I'm of the age that I know the song through The Lemonheads cover. A lot of times, the original can be a touch disappointing (Berlin's version of Metro being far inferior to System of a Down's cover, as an example), but I think this one holds up. I prefer the slightly more upbeat/electric Lemonheads version, but this is decent. Also, I had no idea A Hazy Shade of Winter was a cover! Overall, decent album. Not one I'm going to put on a normal rotation, but it's definitely "good" for what it is.

These songs are short, sweet, and pretty. I wish there was some more breathing room between songs. I wanted the "Bookends" intro to be longer; the tone of that guitar is perfect. I guess there is the reprise. The arrangement on "Old Friends" was a little saccharine for me, and the short length of some of these songs made them feel fleeting and at times insubstantial. I'd rather that than a song overstaying its welcome, I suppose. Some of the sound effects and added dialogue were nice ideas, but ultimately took me out of the music and struck me as kind of corny. This tracks with my overall experiences with Simon & Garfunkel albums. "Mrs. Robinson" is an all-time banger though.

Regarded by many as a classic album, I can’t deny that it does have some incredible songs that are still played regularly today. Personally added two more songs to my music collection. However feels like the mid section gets a bit ‘rambly’ and unfocused. 3.5/5.

That was truly awful. I have no idea how they became popular. The Lemonheads cover of Mrs Robinson and The Bangles Hazy Shade of Winter were far superior to the ones on this album.

Борис Моисеев и Сергей Пенкин заебенели нетленочку 6/10

I mean side-one is weird. I didn't care much for the 'concept-album'. But side two pleasently surprised me. So all in all a decent album

While this album is not catered to my music taste I certaintly cannot deny the value this album holds to other people. The calming beat and vocals with a great vibe makes this album a 4 or 3 for me. Not something I would listen to again but still a good album!

Before going into this project, I’ve already listened to this record. I think its pretty damn great, and its a classic of course. Thoughts: Nice! Favorite Songs: Old Friends, Fakin’ It, A Hazy Shade of Winter, At the Zoo

Truly beautiful album and quite a few songs I was previously unaware of. Fakin It was a standout.

Some classics mixed with some not so classics.

Surprising discovery

Des bangers que je connaissais (Mrs. Robinson, Hazy Shade of Winter), d'autres que je ne connaissais pas (Save the life of my child, Overs), mais de façon générale un excellent album.

Encore le biais onomastique, mais au-delà de ça, un très bon disque de chansons douces-amères qu'on prend plaisir à réécouter. C'est cool.

Love America

I could probably listen to them sing a phone book. So calm, so peaceful. Not my favorite album from them but loved America.

A nice break after the last two albums.

Classic.

actually quite interesting