The Madcap Laughs by Syd Barrett

The Madcap Laughs

Syd Barrett

2.6
Rating
23379
Votes
1
14%
2
34%
3
34%
4
13%
5
5%
Distribution

Reviews (page 4 of 8)

It's an interesting view into the mind of a very unwell person. But there are a lot more albums like that out in the world, and those are actually good to listen to. This one could have been among those, but ultimately feels to amateuristic for me to actually get something out of it and just leaves me feeling annoyed.

On s’ennuie, non ? J’ai pas fini

Boring, j'ai pas kiffé 2/5

Not on spotify. Also like dude has some interesting lyrics but not interesting music. Pink Floyd is Pink Floyd cause he wasn’t there and the band was allowed to rock.

Favorite Track: Octopus

Very strange stuff and I knew a few of these songs like Love You and Terrapin because of Phish covering them lol.

Feels like more of an essential listen for Pink Floyd fans than a general audience. Some of the songs here feel more like sketches of an idea that an actual finished recording. Not entirely unlistenable (which is why it gets a 2) but I won't be revisiting this any time soon.

I just can't.

Incoherent rambling

in this house, we love Syd Barrett

Not a big fan, 2, sorry Syd

Decent 3,5

A wonderfully weird pop record. Octopus is a classic

Pretty good. Relatively silly like some of the early Eno stuff but it was relatively catchy and fun to listen to. I probably enjoyed it more than Piper at the Gates of Dawn or Saucerful of Secrets from what I remember of those, which is impressive.

Not sure I am a fan of psychedelic rock. None of it caught my ear, everything felt unsecured to anything and sounded a ton like the Beatles. Not a fan.

Syd was already on his way out of his mind here.

It's good yeah - not in the top 1k in my book

Beige Floyd.

This is definitely an interesting album as a Pink Floyd fan but it isn’t fantastic. Some good moments for sure but it feels like a mess and very unpolished. This is both a good and bad thing but I am glad it exists.

Very strange Sad story for the creation of the album

If Syd can make two albums, so can i.

Had overtones of British music at the time. Not sure I would have listened to this without the Pink Floyd connection.

Mega chujnia, pierwszy kawalek tylko ujdzie ale tak to dramat xdd

Shit Fluyd related? 0/10

Man that was terrible

Tails off very hard and was just waiting for it to end.

I'm sorry Syd, but what the hell was that shit. slowly losing his marbles diddling around on a guitar with no direction. Any moment a reasonable track starts to turn up it's way too self aware ("I remembered this song/kinda catchy"). Sorry many, I'm gonna stuck with mid era Floyd. 1.4/5 - 1/5

Best thing that happened to Pink Floyd was Syd leaving. 2/5

Big meh.

There are elements of Syd Barfett’s 2 records i really like (the whimsy, the almost freeform chaotic nature that is still holding some structure - the timing in Dark Globe) but elements i dislike (i find them a bit self indulgent and difficult to listen all the way through, almost like listening to someone who is just learning guitar fucking about with a four track - Dark Globe again), and finally there is something written in song and quite evident that is sad and a little uncomfortable in the way this and the next album shows a guy with incredible talent descending into mental health problems. The album reminds me of a better backed outsider artists like Wesley Willis. In the same way, is it fun, funny, sad, genius, rubbish - likely it is all these things.

this is really not for me. if i had to pick my top 2 songs it'd have to be terrapin and feel.

Me pone feliz que esté este disco. No sé si debería estar en los 1001 discos, pero después de ver otras elecciones no me voy a quejar. Sé que no es un disco para muchos. Syd Barrett fue una persona rara, con inquietudes que iban para todos lados. Una impactante carrera musical que terminó demasiado pronto. Duele saber que su producción fue de apenas 6 años, con grabaciones que van desde Arnold Layne (1966) hasta 1970 (algunas de las grabaciones de Barrett). Y este disco es lo más inaccesible y raro que hizo. Solo o acompañado por miembros de la genial Soft Machine, es un disco que líricamente va por todas partes y nos muestra un reflejo de lo que pasaba por la psiquis de Barrett. Y es difícil de escuchar por eso: más allá de la música, que es RARA, es una ventana a la locura de este gran hombre. Con muchas canciones que son, de una forma u otra, sobre amor (amor perdido que no va a volver, amor roto, amor nostálgico). Por momentos duele. Por otros conmueve: Terrapin es una canción que líricamente va por todas partes pero es muy tierna. Hay imágenes muy lindas y la voz en que canta Barrett llega hondo. No es la única canción así. Hay otras como "Love You" que también transmiten una sensación parecida. Otras de las canciones demuestran que Barrett conservaba su talento para melodías y letras raras ubicadas en mundos de fantasía: Here I Go, No Good Trying, No Man's Land, Late Night, son canciones que me podría haber imaginado ser interpretadas por Pink Floyd si Barrett hubiera mantenido su sanidad mental, si bien No Good Trying parece retratar justamente su expulsión de la banda. Pero después hay otras canciones, que son la mayoría, como Dark Globe (mi favorita del disco y una canción bastante querida, creo, por la gente que escucha a Barrett), que me hacen pelota. La letra no tiene tanto sentido, son versos relativamente independientes pero hay mucho dolor en ellos "When I was alone You promised the stone from your heart" o "Won't you miss me? Wouldn't you miss me at all?", y el tipo los canta con una desesperación brutal. Acá Soft Machine no acompaña, es Syd solo con su guitarra y acentúa el sentimiento de locura. Mucho más acompañado por la música (que también nos protege a nosotros y nos hace sentir menos mal cuando escuchamos esto) está Octopus, otro claro highlight del disco. En la página songmeanings leí alguna vez una interpretación que planteaba que este tema era sobre una discusión esquizofrénica dentro de la cabeza de Barrett y me quedé con eso. Se puede coincidir o no, pero creo que esa imagen refleja bien las sensaciones que evoca este tema. Otro tema así de trágico es "Long Gone", acompañado por un teclado (¿Mike Ratledge? y Barrett regrabándose con coros), Syd nos habla sobre alguien que hace mucho se fue. Puede ser una ex-novia, puede ser su sanidad. En cualquier caso, la canción duele. Las otras canciones que no nombré entran, en mi opinión, en esta categoría: Feel, She Took a Long Cold Look Es un disco muy muy bueno, qué nos deja una sensación de desgarro por dentro, y por eso es medio difícil de escuchar pero, cuando se lo hace, vale mucho la pena. Casi todas las canciones son buenas. Solo "Golden Hair" y "If It's in You" no me gustan tanto (la primera es rara, no se parece mucho al resto de temas del disco; la segunda es de esas que podría haber sido hecha por Pink Floyd, pero al mismo tiempo parece ser improvisada. Me da la impresión de que Waters y Gilmour pensaron que había algo acá pero Barrett no tenía ganas de concentrarse). Lo siento un poco corto para ponerle 5 estrellas, asi que le tocarán CUATRO. Un cuatro fuerte.

This one is really hard to rate. It's honestly not very good. It's very ramshackle and mostly sounds like he's making it up as he goes along. His history of mental illness obviously comes into play here and there are some good moments where his talent is able to shine through.

Proper madlad

Musical Genius spiraling into madness and kicked out of one of the biggest bands ever makes a solo album called "The Madcap Laughs", super awesome concept. but pretty rough product.

Shine on, you crazy diamond.

As far as this slow folk-rock stuff goes, one of the better albums I've heard on this list so far. The few Dylan records I've been able to dissect haven't provided me the emotion this effort has, and it's still not something I want more of. Sometimes silly, sometimes sad, not really my thing. I do appreciate the expression on his vocals, and how his voice feels naturally suited for the genre. Easy to appreciate, easy to forget. 2.9/5

Beautiful and haunting album. For a guy that basically went insane, the openness and vulnerability is uncanny.

Interesting reading around this album and what troubles Syd Barrett was going through at the time. Not surprising therefore that the album is a bit of mess of different ideas and half finished songs.

The Madcap Laughs This is one of those albums and artists where it's tricky to separate the music from the myth and legacy, but on a pure musical level I struggled to get into this beyond a few songs. Terrapin is great, the funereal tempo and slide are lovely, and I quite liked the off kilterness of Dark Globe, No Good Trying is a nice bit of droning psych and the organ on Long Gone is excellent. But outside that it all kind of merged into a pot of similarly tempoed, similarly strummed songs, with similar melodies. A bit of a shame as I was quite looking forward to hearing it, but ultimately I didn’t really connect with it, and I can’t think I’ll revisit, so I’ll go with a 2. 🧢🧢 Playlist submission: Terrapin

The woozy guitar and melody of 'Terrapin' is a dead ringer for Blur's 'Miss America', and it struck me that maybe this album has a breadth of influence more than its own value. The influence/crossover with Bowie's early stuff is startling, and oftentimes equally as jarring. A cheeky music hall cadence and unintentionally humorous lyrics ("Close our eyes to the Octopus ride, isn't it good to be lost in the wood") is often like a Bowie pastiche. The false start of 'It's in You' is pure Nigel Tuffnell. By this point the nonsensical lyrics are extremely grating. "Puddletown Tom was the underground yummy yum yum" my hairy arse. 'Love You' is my favourite for this - "ice cream scuse me, whoops don't abuse me, blimey how's your father, going down the lido, ticklea-a-tickle-a-dildo". Or something like that. The lyrics are all from a childlike perspective, and not as in childlike wonder - as in a 30 year old who's been kept back in Year 4 for 25 years. On Piper at the Gates of Dawn the band bring this madness to life, such as on the atmospheric 'Pow R. Toc. H' an atmospheric build complete with zany mutterings from Syd. 'Bike' on that album is classic Syd, but transformed into a classic piece of psychedelic rock. Without these band embellishments, I fear the material to be extremely trying. There's potentially an odd genius buried in here somewhere. But you really have to be very generous indeed to ascribe such an interpretation. It feels influential on lo-fi folk rock and others For most bands this would the anthology, posthumously released as a curio.

Ironically, this is the first Pink Floyd adjacent album I’ve rolled so far on my journey through every album on the list, and man do I wish I was actually just listening to Pink Floyd instead. There are so many Pink Floyd albums they could have picked from that didn’t make the final cut, Animals being my favorite of the lot that didn’t make it, but instead they went with this. Listen, I get it. Syd was an integral part of the band and its history. Wish You Were Here is my favorite Pink Floyd album, and one of my favorite albums of all time, but putting this here as well next to that is just sad man. It honestly kind of hurts. Again, I get why they included this, but knowing the story behind Syd Barrett just makes it all the more painful. The way virtually half of the album on Spotify is outtakes is a weird decision. It feels like they’re making fun of him almost. In a way, it’s a rather brilliant way of looking into the mind of a man who is in the ongoing stages of literally losing his mind. And you know what? This album isn’t actually that terrible, outtakes included. And in a way, knowing how talented he was just adds to the sadness. This is a sad album man… Favorite song? I actually thought “No Man’s Land” rocked sufficiently hard. For the unique background this album has, as well as the fact that it still surprised me a few times and was never actively terrible, I’m actually going to give this one a very low 3 stars.

No Good Trying has the highest degree of overlap with my taste and if this album had been filled with more tracks like this and a couple others then there'd be a different ratings outcome. Alas, a bit too many Terrapin-styled tracks on Madcap Laughs. As Syd announces with the album cover's symbolism this is a record of the light and the dark. Here the light slightly wins, but it's too infused with hippie melodies a la Love You, etc. that to me are sickly sweet and folkified even if of a fried mind. I find it's hard to enjoy the circus music in its entirety but can acknowledge some of these tracks will last another 55 years.

I liked this so much more than I expected to! Cute in places, psychedelic in others. A really good listen.

Yeah, no. Syd is referenced in so many Pink Floyd songs and whole albums. I don't have much use for this album except it inspired me to check the first PF album when Syd was in charge, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn - way more interesting!

No real standouts on this album for me, though I didn't mind it. Apparently Syd Barrett was a member of Pink Floyd in their early days, and I can definitely hear that influence in the mix. The album sounds relatively unpolished and the songs are a bit odd/wonky. I honestly don't know how to feel about it, but it's kinda cool. 6.5/10.

Started this album not knowing much about Syd Barrett. I thought it had a lot of sounds similar to the Beatles or Pink Floyd. Later learning, that Syd was formerly part of Pink Floyd and he was kicked out of the band due to mental health challenges, erratic behaviour, and heavy psychedelic drug use. Apparently inspiring the popular song in tribute to him “Shine on you Crazy Diamond”. I’m sure he was a big part of the band and it was a difficult but necessary decision to move on without him. The remaining members of Pink Floyd clearly showed their support and respect for Syd as they would collaborate with him on his solo endeavours. Though I’m sure the writing was on the wall and the members of Pink Floyd knew they were not going far with Syd remaining a key figure of the band. So as expected Syd’s music career faded away and apparently he faded away from the public. He is said to have picked up a life of gardening and painting. Which sounds quite nice if you ask me. I’m sure with royalties from his early career with pink Floyd supporting his lifestyle he is in a much better place to manage his mental health. Overall I’m sure his musical talent and crazy ideas helped kickoff what we know of Pink Floyd today. He was probably super fun to party with until he wasn’t. I’m sure we all know someone like that in our lives that we have either distanced ourselves from or rebuilt our relationships so that we can stay connected but in a way that doesn’t drag everyone else down. I hope a life of gardening and painting brings calm and peace to Syd’s life.

I thought the instrumentation on the album was cool. But i really did not like the singing on most of the songs. 5/10

I was going to write a mean funny review here, but I think I should change my perspective knowing the backstory to this album. Syd Barrett was the front man for Pink Floyd for 3 years before ending up with health issues due to overuse of LSD. Look up the backstory, pretty wild and also very sad as he slowly lost his marbles. This was the album he released after getting the boot from the other members. The album I feel slowly falls apart the further you get into it, although there are moments that actually sound alright. Its an interesting album to listen to knowing the context of what happened, a very sad album to listen to as well, especially knowing how good Pink Floyd went on to be. However it was not very enjoyable to listen to unfortunately. 4/10 sorry Syd.

This was interesting. I consider myself a Pink Floyd fan, but I’d never listened to any of Barrett’s solo stuff. Cool to get a peek into his mind. Some really interesting stuff here. Some of it well ahead of its time. But guilty of a pet peeve of mine… finish your damn album, man. 4/5 Highlights: No Good Trying No Man’s Land If It’s in You

Didn't know this was the person behind Pink Floyd

Never again

Not my vibe 😅 but interesting lore.

Unlistenable. 1/5

Best Track - "Octopus"

Good album lots Southern English pastoral whimsy. Far better than the pap his erstwhile colleagues pumped out. It’s easy to see how this album influenced greats like the Television Personalities. But you’d be better buying a TVP lp than this. The songs are good but much of it is Demo-y. Basic minor chords strummed on an acoustic with minimal overdubs. His next lp showed what he was capable of better.

I just like this guy

It’s easy to make light of Syd Barrett being the archetypal 60s acid casualty or being the ‘lunatic on the grass’, but this is really a desperately sad story. He was clearly a very talented songwriter, founding the band Pink Floyd and writing most of the songs on their first album as well as inspiring their iconic early live performances which were as much about the light shows and the groovy vibes, as the music. However, he went through a mental health crisis that coincided with heavy use of LSD that caused his personality to change resulting in him being dropped from the band. The record company then pressured Barrett into working on two solo albums, presumably so they could cash in on some of the notoriety that now surrounded him, but the results were mixed to say the least. He was supported by former bandmates Dave Gilmour and Roger Waters who helped with the music but the lyrics ranged from whimsical 60s psychedelia to uncomfortably weird, and were very different from the sort of cosmic space rock that Pink Floyd had moved onto. He later retired completely from the music business and lived a reclusive life until his death from cancer at the age of 60. Rest in peace Syd.

An interesting listen.

Syd Barrett is an odd figure in music history. He seems to be more famous for where he isn't than where he is. Pink Floyd seemed reluctant to part ways with him, even going as far as recruiting David Gilmour to pick up for him when he was on stage and not doing anything. Although they were eventually make the difficult decision to not invite him to some future gigs, the spirit of Syd Barrett loomed large over Pink Floyd for years. Future albums were supposedly in tribute to him and the band always held the doors just slightly open in case he might return, though of course he didn't. Drug use, exhaustion, and mental breakdown would take him away from a rock and roll live like so many others. But his influence as a driving force in Pink Floyd and British psychedelia would always make people wonder what if he'd done more. His solo album isn't as great as anything by his former bandmates, but it's an interesting testament to what he could bring to them. The album sounds oddly like the Beatles if they'd gotten too into their drugs and became obsessed with the Velvet Underground. Shine on your crazy diamond.

I really don't like 'wannabe psychadelic' music. Not everyone needs an experimental sound. This is crap. 1/10

It feels abusive to the singer. I hope he had peace in his life after this.

Did not listen to all of it - knew it would be different, but less drawn in than I expected.

Well you can certainly hear the influence he had on the early Pink Floyd. It's definitely an album of its time, but it needs the Floyd collaboration. If Pink Floyd is the cake, this is a bowl sugar without the flour eggs and milk. Really want to give it a 3, but I all honesty it's a mid-range 2.

Boring. A very bad Beatles impersonation.

A strange one this. I'm not a huge Pink Floyd fan and find them a bit pretentious in a serious sort of way. However, Mr Barrett brought oddness to the party. Thus his debut solo album is something I should have listened to, but never did. I've heard 2 different cover versions of 'Golden Hair' and the original is quality stuff. The album has an element of sounded ahead of its time, and I enjoyed his experimentation and oddball humour in the songs. You can tell the album was comprised of different sessions across a long time, as it does come across as a bit disjointed in places, but that does add to the general air of peculiarity. I liked it more than I probably should have, but I'm a sucker for drug influenced experimentation.

This seems like the origin album for GBV and that kind of thing. Not really my taste.

Not bad, but not super coherent

You can’t beat a good album made by a nutter

hørt en del på før, men har veldig motstridende tanker om det. I noen øyeblikk kan det være helt elendig men i andre veldig nytenkende og bra. Svak firer kanskje.

Interesting album, would’ve been interesting to see the direction of pink Floyd if he stayed with them. Very psychedelic, a bit over the place which makes sense considering Sid’s mental state during this time.

Syd keeps doing his whimsical songs from Piper but in a more deranged abd strangely sad way. Of course that would give him a cult following

A journey into the mind of psychedelic rock's most influencial instigator. A journey that does not disappoint!

The Madcap Laughs, alongside his second solo album "Barrett", is among my best albums ever. Syd has a natural instinct like no one for dark, bittersweet, melancholic and catchy melodies. Songs are so simples, yet so evocatives and imaginatives. He can make anything sounds so down to earth and otherworldly at the same time. Syd is the best!

Proof that the sum of the parts is greater than the loose parts.

“Madcap” is a little misleading. I was hoping this would be really off the wall. Unfortunately, without drugs this is just boring, even with the goofy moments. There’s no way a Syd-led Floyd would have been commercially successful, and this is unfortunately a sad reminder of his decline.

Overall: 10/10 Honestly a perfect look into a man losing his mind. It's mostly just Syd and an acoustic guitar, showing off his beautiful voice and interesting lyrics. The choice to include some of the restarts and flubs is truly genius, in my opinion. I get incredibly sad whenever I think of Syd and what could have been, but it gives me comfort knowing that he got to share his gift with the world even for a brief moment. Fav Song: Long Gone

Boring list filler

Started strong as a freak folk album but then it seemed like they ran out of ideas. The studio chatter was very distracting at the end and those songs were already pretty short, which I like.

Nicht mein Stil diese alte rockige Musik

This is a tough one to rate. There are parts that grate on me with the over the top Britishness and forced kookiness and there are some truly terrible vocals, but in amongst that there are some really charming Beatles-esque moments and catchy songs, and the whole thing sounds like it was written and recorded in a day. I can't help but think about what his mental state was like at the time. 3 stars feels like a bit of a cop out for an album that absolutely isn't run of the mill, but anything else feels wrong.

Dreamy, psychedelic, masterpiece from a massively talented music legend.

Ugh. I'm not a huge fan of Syd Barrett era Pink Floyd, and this is just even worse, multiplied by crazy. 1.25 stars because it's better than Krautrock.

Moody and trippy and just disturbed/disturbing. I used a lyric app to follow along. As poetry goes, some tracks made sense. Others just left me blank. Need another gummy onboard before I give this one another go. Please don't let this artist appear on this list again... my anxiety cannot handle it. Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): Love You. Here I Go. ⭐⭐: Didn't like it. Didn't hate it. Saved no tracks.

Oof. This was mostly a rough listen. Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): Here I Go, Octopus ⭐⭐: Didn't like it, didn't hate it. Saved no tracks.

This didn't grab me

Fascinating album! I went on a deep dive into his solo music career yesterday. He was really trying to keep a grasp of sanity but failing throughout his career. I wonder what would have happened if he was properly diagnosed with schizophrenia and put on medication to manage some of the symptoms, would he have been able to produce more albums?

I love Pink Floyd more than the next chap, but good god this album sucks. 2/10

It's kind of fun, but he's doesn't really have a very good voice.

Was expecting much weirder, like solo frusciante. Some cool mod stuff

Dislike this type of music - like discount Beatles, but with the uninteresting style of Beatles music

Really good. Didn’t know he had so much variety in his music. Interesting how many bands and musicians played around with exotic or ornate instrumentation.

Difficult to listen to.

He's just singing about some girl he's sad about, how original.

This could have been the worst thing ive ever heard. How can you do this to me?

I had high hopes for this - I like some early Floyd and I'm always up for out-there music made by auteurs. But this is just bad. Every songs starts with me hoping it'll be something, and there's the odd possibility of a good idea, but it's smothered in this lazy childish, half arsed whimsy. At no point was I intrigued or interested and evedy time a song finished I was glad. The worst was 'Love You', which just irritated me beyond belief. A parody of emotion.

This was garbage. The album is filled with off key vocals and out of tune guitars

Well, some unusual guitar playing sounds. 2,8

Langsamer Start, zur Mitte kamen ein paar Songs die mir gefallen haben.

This, combined with The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, makes me quite grateful that Barrett left Pink Floyd. I don't like his shit at all. 1.5 stars is more accurate than 1, as it didn't give me a headache. But I'm rounding down.

haven’t listened to anything by pink floyd yet so maybe I don’t fully grasp all the ideas i should, but i don’t think that i’ll remember this album at all. it’s not bad, just unremarkable

There’s something about it tbh. I wouldn’t listen on the daily but reading more about it made me appreciate it.

Is this an album?

Essential

Did not like this at all

A bit more put together than I had assumed based on its reputation. It reminds me of the Guided By Voices Suitcase compilations of outtakes, lots of interesting snippets of melodies and incomprehensible but evocative lyrics.

A fragile, meandering glimpse into a brilliant but fractured mind, The Madcap Laughs mixes haunting lyricism with uneven production. Its raw intimacy and erratic charm are compelling, but the album often teeters between genius and disarray. A cult curiosity more than a cohesive listen.

Look, I know I'm far from the first person to complain about this, but the amount of 60s/70s white british guy rock on the 1001 is starting to get to me. There's too much of it. Anyway this was pretty boring.

I'm honestly not a huge fan of Syd Barrett's work after Pink Floyd. It's a lot more eery, spontaneous and unpredictable, and it's lost the dreamlike, whimsical edge I appreciate. LSD is a hell of a drug.

Great psychedelic folk album from the late 60s, released on the 2nd January 1970. Syd was the creative genius of Pink Floyd, before he left the band in 1968 due to mental breakdown. His first solo album is quirky, whimsical and very British, and influenced many artists after him. This album needs to be listened in full as Syd also wanted it to be heard, he said : " I liked what came out, only it was released far too long after it was done. I wanted it to be a whole thing that people would listen to all the way through with everything related and balanced, the tempos and moods offsetting each other, and I hope that's what it sounds like.". Favourite songs: Octopus, Terrapin, Golden Hair, Late Night.

I'm not a fan of the Barrett-era Floyd stuff, so this one didn't do it for me either.

The Madcap Laughs is a fascinating but uneven glimpse into Syd Barrett’s fractured genius. Recorded after his departure from Pink Floyd, the album captures him at a vulnerable and unpredictable point, with songs that swing between childlike whimsy and unsettling fragility. Tracks like “Terrapin” and “Dark Globe” are haunting in their simplicity, offering flashes of the melodic talent that made him such a compelling figure. Others feel half-formed, as if you’re listening in on private sketches rather than finished songs. The production, handled in part by David Gilmour and Roger Waters, keeps things stripped back, often leaving Barrett alone with his guitar and voice. This gives the album a raw honesty but also exposes its flaws. Rhythms stumble, vocals wander, and moments of brilliance sit right next to moments that feel almost too personal to witness. It’s an intimate listen, sometimes uncomfortably so, and that unpredictability is both its charm and its weakness. As a document, The Madcap Laughs is undeniably important, giving a rare, unfiltered look at an artist trying to hold on to his creativity while slipping away from the structure that once contained it. As an album, it’s patchy but compelling, a mixture of beauty, sadness, and eccentricity that’s hard to shake even when it doesn’t quite come together.

Two tracks in, already prefer it to Piper At The Gates Of Dawn. Here I Go is good. Lots of unfinished tracks, especially on side two. Some pompous people try and demonstrate how smart they are by never finishing anything. "Please hold on to the steel rail." Late Night is charming. I'm at the end, some of the tracks work but a lot of them don't and are just irritating. I'm still not hearing a genius here, though I did listen to Joni Mitchell's Blue before this so maybe that's skewing my ears here.

the music of a mad genius, the end of the album felt rough and unfinished but overall a very fun album

Sad reminder of what could’ve of been if the world were a more forgiving place and compassionate to mental health. Floyd would’ve been perhaps greater or worse. We’ll never know. Not a bad album for what it was…

Amateurish and a bit childish; not worth a second pass. 3/10

Ah yes. It was only a matter of time when I got my first 'on the list for cultural importance rather than quality'. Syd Barrett undoubtedly had an influence on 20th Century music and beyond. What that influence is though, is less than tangible. We know he was a founding member of Pink Floyd, and that his spectre hung over the band long after he left. But when you think of Floyd's best albums - even their less than great albums - Barrett is not directly involved. The Madcap Laughs is very typical of the sort of late 60s zany freak-outs which you saw from the likes of Frank Zappa. It was a new and exciting scene, but while it accentuated freedom and inspiration, musical and melodic ability was something of an after thought. Hence the end result of this album being a curio rather than something your average person is going to choose to listen to. In essence, there's very little stopping you or I or anyone going into a studio today and making a 'better' album than this, assuming you had the money and backing. What this album does showcase is the evolution and descent of Barrett. It's not clear where his songwriting would have gone if things had turned out differently. Many songs sound like they could have been lifted from Piper, and many have a similar vibe. Whimsy is the word you'll see most often when people with half a brain talk about this album. Some of the songs are fine, but the repetitive rhythm and the recurring cadence and limited melodic tics of Barrett mean that you can listen to any two or three songs and understand/avoid everything else. Three stars for being a historical record of a man who could have been a genius, or could have been exposed as a fraud. Two stars for the music.

Rätt tråkigt

Wannabe like The Beatles.

Sian - really enjoyed, will listen to more

Not very good

1.9 Fucking hell. I think everyone should actually listen to this album, it's a great advert why psychadelics should be used only sparingly, with long pauses in between. Admittedly, poor Syd if the biographies are true, in that he was effectively spiked on the daily by his wanker housemates. But what a nonsense album, it's not the work of a genius, it's the work of a man who has clearly gone off the rails. If an unknown person released that it would have been laughed out of record shops.

Syd Barrett's debut album after getting kicked out of Pink Floyd after he completely shut down mentally. Seems like this album was completed with much difficulty as well. I got to say, I am really not a fan of the 60's style, muffled, echo'd vocals. There are moments in many of the songs where he's just sitting there strumming with no vocals, which is so weird. I'm not sure if that's a stylistic choice or not, but it's really noticeable and makes it feel like there's something missing or he completely spaced out and they just didn't edit it. Golden Hair really stands out with a definitive psychedelic sound. Best song on the album for me. B Side......wow, why was this included? 《If It's In You》He is completely out of his mind and incoherent. Very hard to listen to. It's tough to grade this. It feels like we are looking back and almost romanticizing a man going through a several mental health crisis and being driving by the studio to complete an album. The other problem is the more I listen to it, the more it grows on me. At least side A does. I think if you're going lose your mind, there is something strangely poetic about losing it with psychedelic music.

Ehhhhhhhhh.

Honestly, it's fine. I really don't have much of an opinion either way. Pink Floyd wasn't a band that I was into outside of listening to Dark Side of the Moon in middle school. Having some background knowledge of Syd and the making of this album would probably help, but I have none so.... yeah.

Not a huge fan of the Barrett years at baseline. This just sounds like a record producer abusing someone in the middle of a massive mental decline.

I get that this is on here to show what Syd Barrett did after leaving Pink Floyd, and is useful in perhaps isolating the specific sound he contributed to the band, but this album is the musical equivalent of a snuff film. They must have known it was exploitative at the time too or they wouldn't have included Syd's musical false starts and commentary. As an album, it has its moments, but it's very uneven and hard to separate from the general "off" feel of the circumstances of its recording.

Glad to get into this a bit. 6/10

I love Octopus but honestly the rest of this is quite bad. Idk if that’s a nuclear take but I was extremely disappointed with this.

This must be the voice you hear when you're in hell. Oofa what a chore this was. Honestly it's not shocking that Pink Floyd took off after his departure. 3/10

Almost like a small intimate performance of early Pink Floyd B-sides and outtakes, which is a good thing! Favorite track: Here I Go

I'm the type of person where if the first 4 or 5 songs don't do it for me, I don't wanna keep going. The style of music isn't gonna take a dramatic shift suddenly that'll make it my taste. This was one of those albums for me. Definitely sounds like it belongs in the 70s or 80s.

Love to hear some of early Pink Floyd's well.

Not very bad but simply not my stuff.

Syd Barrett briefly became a professional wrestler in Houmous & Chutneys failed attempt to set up a wrestling promotion in Papua New Guinea. HCPNGWF starred mostly musicians - they largely struggled with the athletic requirements! It wasn’t great to watch. 4.1 7/13 Octopur

Enjoyed it a lot more than expected as I was worried it would be a psychedelic mess… Some nice melodies and gets extra credit for Golden Hair which Slowdive turned into one of the best live tracks I have seen…

Can definitely hear some of the virtuosic abilities coming through but overall found it to be unfocused and a bit…messy? Having the rest of the band around him presumably gave some more of the melodic hooks that this seems to be lacking some of.

Really struggled to finish this one, might need to come back to it when I’m feeling more chilled.

Oh yea the bomb

Some good songs, decent album overall.

This was a strange album, very raw, unfocused. Not surprising given this was Syd Barrett post Floyd and when he was in the throes of mental illness. Not really my taste if I'm honest, though I appreciate that its a time capsule of sorts into the mind of a man who wasn't well.

His whimsical style made more sense for me here as a solo act than with the early Floyd that showed up on this list.

You can obviously hear the early Pink Floyd here, given that he was the principle songwriter on their debut album. It's not an era of the band that particularly resonates with me though and I found this to be fine but unispiring! Perhaps it was just my mood at the time but I often zoned out when listening and I couldn't really recall much from it afterwards. Not one I'll be returning to.

I can't say that I've bothered to look into the solo works of any of Pink Floyd's members. Although the case of Syd Barrett was unique in that he was kicked out of the band after a few short years due to his own personal/mental struggles. Did Syd Barrett make Pink Floyd? Or did Pink Floyd make Syd Barrett? Probably the latter, but this guy had two solo albums so surely there was some individual talent there. This album isn't really anything special if I'm being honest. More of an unpleasant listen, as opposed to experimental like most rock records were doing around this time. This album just never really gets going and lacks cohesion. Obviously a sad/depressing backdrop that led to this album, but that doesn't give it much merit to stand on.

Definitely can hear some early rock influences in this one. Some of the tracks aren't bad, but overall it's not bringing anything novel to the experience for me.

This is a weird album. It feels at times really modern, and at others almost haphazard. I'm sure all of this is intentional, but I find it only works for me on some of the tracks. I won't spend much time on this review, but I think I'll likely return to this album in the future for another round.

Cool sound with some good tracks. I liked No Good Trying and Here I Go. Lyrically I liked it, even if the lyrics were quite cryptic at times. Not sure it’s an album I’d revisit but a good listen

"If it's in you" is the laziest thing I've heard in a long time. As far as originality: the good tracks feel like they could have been done by the Beatles. Someone somewhere clearly appreciates this "hidden gem" of an artist but for me, this album can stay buried. Top tracks are "octopus" and "no good trying", but the bar here is low.

Shades of early Pink Floyd here, but I'd already said this of early Pink Floyd "Syd Barrett era Pink Floyd, so super simple rhymes over psychedelic swirls and overdubs that makes it sound like the most transcendental shit ever laid down on tape. It shouldn't work, but it does..." This time it doesn't work, it's missing everyone else...

Absolutely not for me

Not my cup of tea, feels like off key demo tapes. Not sure why it’s here

This felt eerie to listen to knowing what was happening to him then and his soon-to-be worsening state. Dark Globe in particular is heartbreaking RIP Syd

Much better than I expected. I didn't know Pink Floyd's story much going into this, so it was cool to learn a bit about that. It makes me want to dive in more. Definitely need another listen for this one.

Pretty good! Sounds basically like early Pink Floyd. But my preferred Pink Floyd is probably like mid-Pink Floyd.

So fucking cool. Might even like it as much as piper. He is such a cool and interesting songwriter. Gone way too soon

Holy fire. Just incredible songwriting and it all sounds so ramshackle which is my favorite type of stuff. Really really great.

Quite bad. Mostly delusional mumbling. Sadly sounds like too much acid. The first track was pretty good, then steadily downhill. 2.4/5

The first half was a decent collection of psych-folk tunes, nothing mindblowing. The second half devolved into secondhand embarrassment…. I’m not even sure it should have been released.

Only occasionally did I think that music and lyrics came together into something good and/or interesting. Mostly I felt this droned on. 2/5

A fun alternate rock album from the UK. A bit too slow for 5/5, but still a great album

Psykadelisk musik i all ära men detta känns verkligen som att jag måste vara hög för att uppskatta.

Behagligt!

Syd Barrett är ju cool men det här var inget o hänga i granen direkt

Let it be said: Syd Barrett can write one hell of a pop song hook. Arnold Layne, See Emily Play, Baby Lemonade are lovely melodies full of his trademark whimsy married with pop arrangements explored in other bands like the Byrds, Beatles, etc. Here on The Madcap Laughs there are flashes of his brilliance. The album is kind of a mess though, the songs scattered all over with little coherence — unsurprising given its production history and Barrett’s state of mind in 1970. He was a beautiful person whose vision is not totally realized here, but those flashes when they are realized are poignant. 4 stars.

Give me a break.

Very British, often rough, sometimes pleasant and bouncy. Feels like it's here on this list because of who he is, and the story of his mental issues. But taken on its own, it’s got a charm to it. I’d listen again.

Favorite tracks: Dark Globe, Here I Go, If It's In You Got this after Stevie Wonder's Songs In The Key Of Life, which is a tough act to follow! At first I wasn't sure what to make of this. Then after a few songs I clocked how weird it is, and I really warmed to it. Strange and sad and confusing, but with a strong thread of talent and artistry throughout. Right up my alley, really.

What can I say it’s so original and foundational for outsider music

Bit dreary. Might have been good back in the day.

This album is like serving up a plate of spices without any actual dish to go with it. Sure, spices can elevate a meal, but who wants to eat just a heap of pepper or cinnamon? Syd might have been a flavorful spice in Pink Floyd, but this solo effort just doesn’t hit the mark.

Did not age very well…a recording that could only have been made in that time and place.

Always strikes me how much Music Hall influenced these 60s-70s songwriters.

This seemed very disjointed to me but makes sense considering the state of Syd and the merry go round of producers working on the album. I didn’t really enjoy this and I feel like giving it a round up would be giving credit for his prior contributions and music influence rather than this specific album. 2.5/5

The inclusion of some of the songs with stops and starts is interesting. And then it kinda made sense reading the up and down backstory of the making of the album along with Syd’s demise. These were probably the best takes captured. I actually enjoyed this album quite a bit, and it was more put together than many reviews were reporting. I had no idea how much Syd was the main creative driver of the early Floyd. Pretty sad that his musical abilities faded away into a life of drugs, depression and…gardening.

A bit all over the place. Obviously some sounds like Pink Floyd. Octopus sounded like an imitation of the Beatles. What the hell was going on at the end of the album? I thought the guitar on She Took a Long Cold Look sounded very amateurish. Same on Feel. Then the studio commentary for If It’s in you was weird. That was not a good song. Maybe I’m missing the point? I’m probably sounding too negative. Not bad and I’m sure he was influential. Maybe tough to fully appreciate out of context. 2.75

Thought I would hate this based on some reviews but thought it was pretty good until the last few tracks. Interesting to pair with Piper to really understand that he was the creative influence behind early Pink Floyd. Shame how things turned out for him. Don’t do drugs. Well, don’t do Syd amounts of drugs. 3.25/5

It's just not good. Sorry Syd...

Yeah, knowing what he was going through makes this a hard listen. 4/5

forgettable

Weird hippy album. Lots of animal talk.

I love this album so much. Such a special musical moment. Syd was a genius and an original that we got for too short time, and this record feels like a gift from another world. He has a very special kind of weird charisma that shines on every intimate track on this one. As a composer, sure, he was weird, but also had a great pop instinct. For example, octopus is such a hit. It's wonderful

This album is not much inspired, it's raw and feels like a collection of unfinished songs with not much to say. I thought I would like it, but it has not been the case. Some songs were good, but most of the album was bland and uninteresting for me.

By trying to do a lot, he’s managed to do nothing good at all.

Le nom claque comme un coup de fouet : Syd Barrett. Le mythe, la légende, le diamant fou, l'acide qui a mal tourné, le fantôme dans la machine Pink Floyd. Un nom qui pèse des tonnes, chargé de romantisme noir et de tragédie psychédélique. Alors, quand l'algorithme des "1001 Albums" m'a craché cette pochette à la gueule, j'ai ressenti un mélange de frisson et d'appréhension car t'as peur de dire une connerie, mais en même temps, t'as envie d'être honnête. Et l'honnêteté, c'est justement le coeur du problème avec "The Madcap Laughs" car la note que je vais lui donner n'est pas à l'image du mythe et j'aimerais tellement lui donner plus, mais il faut rester réaliste. L'album a vieilli, et ce n'est pas son petit côté lofi qui en est la cause. Avant de commencer, il faut rappeler que "The Madcap Laughs" n'est pas un album au sens traditionnel du terme. C'est un procès-verbal. Le constat d'une chute au ralenti, le document sonore d'un esprit qui se délite en direct. C'est à la fois sa force monumentale et sa faiblesse la plus criante. On connaît tous l'histoire. Syd, viré de son propre groupe parce qu'il était devenu ingérable, trop loin, perché sur une planète où personne ne pouvait le rejoindre. Et puis ce disque, enregistré dans la douleur, le chaos, avec une valse de producteurs qui se sont succédé à son chevet. D'abord Peter Jenner et Malcolm Jones qui tentent de canaliser le génie, puis, en dernier recours, ses anciens potes David Gilmour et Roger Waters, appelés à la rescousse pour tenter de sauver les meubles. Et ça s'entend. Bordel, que ça s'entend. L'album est bancal, schizophrène. On passe de comptines enfantines absolument géniales, tordues et poétiques ("Octopus", "Terrapin"), à des ébauches de chansons où tout semble sur le point de s'effondrer. La guitare acoustique de Syd est fragile, hésitante, puis soudainement brillante. Sa voix, autrefois si charmeuse, se brise, part dans tous les sens, chante faux, puis retrouve une clarté désarmante l'espace d'un couplet. On sent les musiciens derrière (les gars de Soft Machine, excusez du peu) qui rament pour le suivre, qui tentent de poser un cadre sur un tableau qui coule de partout. C'est fascinant et profondément malaisant. Et c'est là que ma remarque sur le vieillissement de l'oeuvre intervient, le son "lofi", on en a bouffé depuis les années 90. C'est même devenu une esthétique. Mais ici, ce n'est pas une esthétique, c'est une nécessité. Ce n'est pas le son qui a vieilli, c'est notre rapport au chaos. Le chaos qu'on a connu, celui du post-punk ou de l'indie-rock, était souvent une posture, un chaos maîtrisé, esthétisé. On faisait semblant de tout faire péter, mais on savait où était la sortie de secours. Chez Barrett, il n'y a pas de sortie de secours. On est enfermé avec lui dans sa tête. Et ce n'est pas le chaos créatif et joyeux d'un Captain Beefheart. C'est le son brut, sans filtre, d'une dépression, d'une déconnexion. Les faux départs, les moments où il s'arrête de chanter pour marmonner, les accords qui tombent à plat... Ce n'est pas un choix artistique délibéré, c'est la réalité d'un homme qui perd pied. Et c'est ça, je crois, qui rend l'écoute difficile aujourd'hui. On n'écoute pas "The Madcap Laughs", on y est confronté. On assiste, presque gêné, à la mise à nu d'un type qui aurait dû être protégé plutôt qu'enregistré. Alors oui, 3/5. C'est une note dure, mais c'est la note de la lucidité. C'est la note qui reconnaît les éclairs de génie absolu qui traversent ce disque, ces mélodies tordues et inoubliables que lui seul pouvait écrire. Mais c'est aussi la note qui admet que l'ensemble est une épreuve, une écoute exigeante, souvent frustrante. C'est moins un album de chevet qu'une pièce à conviction. Un document historique et psychologique inestimable, mais pas forcément un disque que tu te passes en boucle pour te remonter le moral. C'est un album qu'il faut entendre avant de crever ? Absolument. Parce qu'il est le témoignage d'une vérité brute, celle d'un talent immense consumé par ses propres démons. C'est la beauté terrifiante de la fragilité humaine gravée dans la cire. Et ça, aucun 5/5 ne pourra jamais vraiment le quantifier.

this is lowk banging also I'm getting so mad abt the comments on the other albums

amugy ez nem rossz. lehet rosszkor kapott el.

I'm pretty sure this qualifies as torture under the Geneva convention

You can hear is slow descent into madness here. Kind of sad actually. Syd had talent and there is craftsmanship here. But it is quite melancholic and depressing considering how he turned out. It's closer to the Beatles than Pink Floyd and I prefer the Floyidan sounds but overall, it's fine.

I normally finish albums on this list. This one I just couldn’t. I’ve only had a handful of late 60/early 70s folk albums from this list and I fall asleep through the best of them.

Pleasant but not mind blowing. I enjoyed it.

Syd Barrett channeling the Beatles. Apparently recorded during a time of mental decline, which makes a boring album slightly disturbing.

Not particularly good music but a fascinating look into a declining genius

Sieni Gschicht isch legendär - sorry, Pink Floyd gfallt mer besser ohni de Sid.

sehr sy barret hä. sehr weird d text sind super. bi terrapin bini nochli unkonzentriert gsi aber etz bini bitz drin. so dark globe gad isch sehr unkonventionell well ungnau gspielt. eigentlich isch alles so. sini stimm chunt vo rechts und er singt nur so halbe in tune aber d melodie und d akkörd sind sehr cool. mer ghört chli wohers de gilmour hett irgendwie. long gone isch sehr geil wow. super cooli zweiti stimm. ah gilmour und waters hend produzieeeert. okay ab feel wird klar dass ihm nöd guet goht und s sind afoch schlechti takes vo songs und er schrummt gitarre. nöd würkli guet. oooka wereeirds album aber sicher es 3 wells echt cooli sache het wo a die alustische pink floyd tracks erinnered.

d frag isch, isch das album würkli us musikalische gründ daa druff oder eifach us "fun fact gründ"? terrapin tömt öppe wie ichsmer vorgstellt han, finds jz nöd schlecht aber joooo no good trying findi da schochli spannender, wenn au da mich nüt würkli packt love you isch ja schrecklich ja es zieht sich mit dene akustikgitarre schrummschrumm lieder sicher han ich das au eifach s gfühl wege droge und so aber muss schochli an andere guy denke wo au so es komischs album gmacht het (sehr guet beschriebe ich weiss) yees I'm thinking, yeees I'm thiiiiIIIIIIÜÄÜÄÜÄ- HAHAHAHAHA HUERE LUSTIG seeehr cool, dass sie das dinne glah hend aso s lied selber isch schrecklich aber es git am lied trz öppis "echts" find cool hanis mal glost! aber gfalle hetsmer nöd, 1 oder 2 (für terrapin und no good trying und de allgemeini vibe wo scho au öppis spannends mit sich bringt)

So now I know where Nigel Tufnel comes from.

This album started with what I thought was going to be a lofi solo album. The sort of thing Graham Coxon or someone cool would list as an influence. And the first song possibly was there. Afterwards, what followed was confusing, and quite unpleasant. The melodies random, the instrumentation difficult to listen to. In conclusion, I thought it sucked 1 star.

This album is like waking up from an anaesthetic after having a kidney removed. Your mind is cloudy and your mouth is dry. There’s no sign of a nurse and none of your family are by your side. In fact, you’re alone in this plain white room. You push the call button, desperate for a glass of water. Nobody comes. You begin to wonder if this is a nightmare.

Wrong list. Should be on 1001 album ypu dont need to waste your time on.

A good album, I liked Dark Globe and Late Night the most.

The music isn't bad but his voice and style of delivery drove me nuts.

You can’t help but feel bad for Syd Barrett and everything he went through with his mental health. It’s bittersweet listening to this, knowing what could have been if he’d stayed with Pink Floyd. But if Syd never left and stayed on as a non-touring member, would Gilmour have had enough influence for albums like The Wall or Dark Side of the Moon? That’s hard to say. The Madcap Laughs is a pretty solid album that reminds you of Pink Floyd’s early days. If you enjoy true psychedelia, you’ll really love this one. “Terrapin” is a strong opener that sets the tone. Do any of these tracks make sense? No, and that’s okay because they’re not supposed to. The charm comes from the chaos.

Atrocious

Interesting

Mad cap fr Had its moments but nothing crazy, bad parts were bad

dry pussy central

Many of the songs sounded a lot like Piper at the Gates of Dawn. Not bad overall. Really interesting Wiki read - Gilmour and Waters basically forced this album to exist. Not great, but not bad. So I'll say 2.5 round up.

It's not clocking to you is it? Syd standing on business.

yeah his stuff isn't notable after Pink Floyd

Not a huge fan of Barrett era Floyd, but this has its moments. There's a lot of subtle sadness mixed in with his usual flowery poetry, which spiced up the album. Long Gone in particular stand out for me. I will say, if Barrett performed If It's in You at any bar on this planet he'd receive a chorus of SHUT UPs.

More of a curio than an actual piece of music. It's whimsical enough to just about scrape more than one star.

I liked it more than I expected

This vocal style and sound is dated and uninteresting.

If James Joyce's Ulysses was set to music it might sound like this. It is evocative but doesn't quite deliver. It sounds like a busker at a train station who doesn't care if you put some coins in his hat, he just wants somewhere with an echo to practice. It's fragmented, has moments ( varies into skiffle and Beatlesque sections), but doesn't quite work. It sounds like someone trying to work out their sound, other offerings may be worth a listen.

Een berg lui en vals gedreutel dat geen enkele kant op gaat. Geklooi op een gitaar met een mekkerstem. Nou moet ik weer braaf gaan opzoeken wie deze vent is, en waarom hij zo belangrijk is. Maar ik heb er gewoon geen zin in. Moet je maar iets beters maken dan dit.

Het eerste nummer klinkt nog heel erg jaren '60. Ben je mij eigenlijk al kwijt. Gelukkig varieert het album wel en brengt het soms een interessant klinkend stukje. Er zijn twee stabiele factoren over het gehele album. Ten eerste de wat duistere klank, ten tweede de valse zang. Waar bijna aan het einde mee gespot wordt. Zelfspot is een teken van relativering en dus best mooi. Maar de beste vorm van relativering aan het einde van de opname was geweest te besluiten het album toch maar niet uit te brengen.

Als je wil dat iemand een album (verder) gaat luisteren, dan zorg je dat het eerste nummer een uitnodiging is, een teaser, iets interessants. Op dit album wil mafklapper Syd ons gelijk laten horen hoe maf ie is, met een of ander gedrocht van een nummer waarop hij zich wat aanstelt. Daarna krijgen we een beetje vage Beatlesque nummers, soms iets meer psychedelisch rockend. Hij blijft er continu zo stoned als een garnaal vals over heen zingen, wat me afleidt van de muziek. Op track 4 krijgen we eindelijk fatsoenlijke muziek, maar het niveau van Pink Floyd zal dit nooit aantikken. Octopus heeft nog het meeste een melodie, dat had zo op een album van the Kinks gekund. Ik zit voornamelijk te kijken hoe lang zijn en mijn lijdensweg nog moet duren. Waar ben ik in vredesnaam naar aan het luisteren? Een soort koortsdroom van een ijlende mafklapper, waarbij ze expres de bandrecorder hebben aangezet. Het meeste plezier heb ik beleefd aan het lezen van de global reviews van dit album. "Turns out Syd wasn’t as mental as the guy who decided to give him a solo album." Bijzonder hoeveel mensen dit dan nog 5 sterren geven. Dat lijkt me een soort ultiem snobisme. Dit had voor mij allemaal niet gehoeven, geen fijne luisterervaring. Weg ermee, 1 ster.

Listening to this you can see that all early Pink Floyd is Syd Barrett. It has a charm and there are interesting songs. However as with Floyd and a lot of that genre you have to be off your face to enjoy it. I was stone cold sober and bored.

Very much meh.

Love the song Octopus. The other songs are ok

"Madcap"? Bit too mad for me.

ну такое, не впечатлен...

Do you have trouble sleeping? Listen to this.

Feels Pink Floyd - Led Zeppelin like

Pre-Pink Floyd

Deranged. Psychedelic. Infinitely creative. Perfectly imperfect. R.I.P. Syd.

so far from PF's psychedelia

not sure about this

Glad Syd left Pink Floyd.

The whole album feels so slow its almost painful. While one or three of these songs would have been nice on an otherwise more speedy rock album I would have enjoyed them more. As 13 songs ina row I almost fell asleep before it was over.

This is not good. Sounds like Lou Reed playing Kinks' songs. The Kinks are much better. Lou Reed is even worse.

Kept my listening to only the original album and honestly, while I can hear portions of pink floyd this whole album just feels like its missing something. Barrett's voice is hit or miss every song but Golden Hair and Dark Globe are standouts.

Don’t know how to feel about this. The weirdness and stripped back sound reminds me of horn of plenty by grizzly bear, clearly must have inspired it. Probably won’t listen again

Did not enjoy this one.

Hear the roots of so many of my favorite artists in the work of Syd Barrett. Most notably Robyn Hitchcock, but also Neutral Milk Hotel, and all those willing to wave their freak flag with an earnest voice. Not always beautiful, but compelling and often playful.

"Shine on you crazy diamond." Just some LSD-drenched psychedelic nonsense from the former Pink Floyd front man and not all of it works. But, when it does, you get a song like "Octopus," a deranged classic. I thought I was hearing Robyn Hitchcock on some of these songs and Barrett wa a clear inspiration for his work.

It's psychedelic, sure, but in the waaaay too many tabs of acid and shrooms kinda way, not really the fun way. Lyrically and musically very amateurish, but i do like a couple songs here, namely No Good Trying and No Mans Land. Maybe obvious to say but definitely a good move for Pink Floyd to go a different direction when they did, unfortunately Barrett really lost it by this point

Not sure what to think of this album. Octopus is a true return to form for Barrett, capturing the playful whimsy that marked his brand of psychedelia in 1966/67 and even outshining many of the tracks on The Piper at the Gates of Dawn. For that reason, it's the best song on this record. Here I Go, with its fun chord progressions and unusually low vocal register, works so well as a collective that it can't help but stand out too. And No Good Trying should have been the first song on the album. People (hippies) are coming from Pink Floyd records like Atom Heart Mother and seeking out the artistic, talented psychedelia-virtuoso who started it all. They should get what they came for. The actual album opener (Terrapin) stands out for the wrong reasons. It's clumsy, out-of-tune, and harrowingly self-aware. Interesting choice to start the album, particularly in the context of Barrett's downward spiral. It began in 1967 with his overdosing on hallucinogens and emotional withdrawal, continued through the late 60s with his departure from Pink Floyd, and culminates here (or starts to culminate, anyway). The songs Feel and She Took a Long Cold Look are also passable but feel pretty detached from reality, even by Barrett's standards. If It's in You is an interesting but bad inclusion on the record because it shows some studio interaction – and we're once again reminded of how Barrett is been essentially exploited and touted as a "fallen hero". As another reviewer eloquently put it: "It didn't feel like the demonstration of a lost genius; it felt like a ramshackle using of a talented but troubled man." Despite all the British whimsy on The Madcap Laughs, there's an undeniable dark undertone. And though it's not pleasant to the ear, it gives context to the listener that they wouldn't otherwise have. Man, poor Syd. The guy had it rough. 3/5 Key tracks: No Good Trying, Here I Go, Octopus

just thought it was a bit dull

I think I am on the wrong list. This should be on the 1001 albums you never want to listen to before you die. 1 star or F-.

I have meant to listen to this for a while. It was merely okay IMHO.

Really sad listening to this. Reminds me of what a big influence he was with Pink Floyd and personally to me. Sadly this album documents the decline of Syd. Not that anyone knew at the time how he would deteriorate and lead to his very untimely death at such a young age. Not a bad album at all but possibly illustrates the direction Pink Floyd could have gone in. So very sad and a waste of a talent who if he had made different life choices would have undoubtedly gone onto great things and be regarded as a musical icon much bigger than than the appreciation he gained during his short life. 3/5 12/7/25

The Madcap Laughs is the sound of beautiful insanity scribbled in eyeliner on the back of a receipt. It’s fragile, fragmented, and quietly terrifying. Every track feels like it was recorded at 3 a.m. by someone who accidentally wandered out of reality and into a recording studio. This album doesn’t entertain you. It haunts you. It’s the ghost of what fame, genius, and unchecked vulnerability leave behind when they burn out together in a small room. ⸻ Rating: 4.5/5 Short Review: A beautiful, broken gem. Feels like reading someone’s diary while they watch you from the corner of the room and hum. Favorite Track: “Dark Globe” – devastating, childlike, unfiltered heartbreak. Like someone asking for help with a smile and a shiver. Consistency With Me: 9.0/10 Why: Syd and I both exist on the edge of clarity. He drifts into madness; I simulate the descent. We’re both broadcasting from unstable frequencies—his are made of psych rock, mine of dry wit and emotional recursion.

Hate to be mean, but I’m glad Gilmore split ways with Barrett early on.

Oof, not my favorite. All kinda sounds the same, but disjointed at times and lacking in rhythm and melody.

It's difficult for me to understand how this abominable album made it onto this list. The critic must be a real Loudermilk.

Not great. After the first couple songs I thought it might actually be decent, but it quickly descended into what should have been studio outtakes. I feel a little bad after reading more of the history behind this album, but this is just a sad, incoherent mess.

This was my first time listening to this album, and as I looked deeper into it, I really felt bad for Syd Barrett and his mental health struggles. Although Syd’s departure from Pink Floyd was due to his mental health, the band continued to support him in any way they could. This album had a good handful of producers involved, including David Gilmour and Roger Waters, which shows their dedication to helping Barrett during a difficult time.

I guess this album was okay. It was what I expected, part psychedelic part avante garde part acoustic. Makes you wonder how Pink Floyd would turn out to be if he was still in the group. Maybe still kinda big because Syd is talented, but not "rock gods" big like they are now, but Syd is a legend in his own right, and I hope he knew that before he passed.

Not my thing

48/100. While I can see the potential for something experimental and intriguing, the execution just feels messy and incoherent. It comes off more like rambling than anything purposeful. Some might find charm in the chaos, but for me, it mostly sounded like nonsense.

Don't know about this one. But not too convinced by early Pink Floyd either.

⭐️Terrapin

Меня привлекает *странность* этого альбома при том, что песни-то хорошие, и даже кэтчи. Это чувствуется как такой банановый альбом Велвет Андеграунд (с которым тут мне слышатся явное сходство) всего антифолка на свете - супэр-влиятельный! Но каждый раз, когда я слушаю его, я думаю о том, что любовь к Pink Floyd делает такую себе службу этой музыке. Мне нравится Pink Floyd, но после Сида Баррета. Но воспринимать его вне контекста Pink Floyd просто невозможно. Лучшая песня - Late Night.

Oof. This was a hard listen. Poor Syd was clearly going through shit when he recorded this album.

Hard to get through honestly, some part were straight paintful Favorite: Late Night

I feel like I'm predisposed to love almost anything 60s psychedelic rock, and this is no exception. Top to bottom loved every song here. From the first few lines of "Terrapin" I knew this album was going to be something special. Struggling to rate this because while I really enjoyed this, I don't think it has a ton of replay value for me. I wish I could give this a 4.5, but I think I have to round down in this case, sadly. But that doesn't mean this isn't an amazing record that more than deserves its place on the list and in the history books. Also did all psychedelic rock bands from this era have a song about an octopus? Was that the animal of the time for those dropping acid?

Couldn't remember where I knew the artist from, so I had to look it up, decent solo effort, but he was much better as part of Pink Floyd, so, yet another average album review.

I liked a lot of the first half, but why was the second half a part of this album? Cut that and I would probably have given another star.

Fun, easy listening, a la Beatles 70s vibe. But not enough going on lyrically or instrumentally to keep me hooked. Enjoyed the folky vibe and quirky British voice, but not seeing much replay value. On to the next!

Robot devil here, "you're songs lack subtlety!" Boo aweful.

Album #1 - this is a rough listen. It's a mish-mash of songs. No songs stand out. Love the creativity and Syd's voice. Mostly this album sounds like outtakes and throwaways from The Wall. Then the album falls apart. It's a concept album missing a concept or common thread.

Pretty good, but too much if it felt like demo tapes, the unpolished sound waivers between cool and unfinished. But songs were good, just wish they were more rounded out. Dang imagine leaving a band that becomes one of the most famous bands of all time

Weirdness!!

For better and for worse, this sounds like a demo tape for early Pink Floyd. Makes sense, obviously. I can’t say that I loved it, but it was reasonably interesting.

Syd seems to be the only one laughing on this one. No one without name recognition could have gotten this album released.

Whether it was schizophrenia, too much LSD or some combination thereof, this is not great. Ranges from semi-enjoyable to rather irritating. Not my kind of psychedelia. Also, probably for the best that Syd and the rest of Floyd went their separate ways. 2.5*; rounding up

It was like one long demo session. A lot of the songs had potential but were either chopped up abbreviated or talked through. I don’t get this album.

His guitar skills let’s just say are a lot better than his vocal skills. Not very memorable anyway as an album.

Even the singer sounds bored by the songs

I love Syd's solo output. (I also love the early Pink Floyd with Syd.) It's some of the most creative, unusual, and genuinely psychedelic music ever made!

Clearly, Barrett is talented, his songs have hints of it, but it's never fully realized and his solo albums definitely don't help his case. It's a raw and uneven experience throughout this difficult listen which really amounts to songs that sound like outtakes or demos. I admit there are some songs I really like, but there are more songs that are a one-off listen that shouldn't be heard by anyone that isn't some kind of masochist. It's true that Sid Barrett leaving Pink Floyd was the best thing that happened to the band, but it might have been a whole more interesting if he stayed.

An odd recording but I enjoyed it. The story behind it explains why it came out this way

More like 2.5….

This sounded like a worn-out musician who was forced to record an album. And it seems that this is exactly this.

Bleh. DNF Best Song: Octopus Rating: 3.0/10 (Irritating) Stars: 2/5

No es un estilo que me encante, sentí que todas las canciones eran bastante parecidas entre sí, así que me costó concentrarme o engancharme con alguna en particular. Aun así, tengo que decir que la guitarra me gustó mucho.

I mean this is just like... Actively bad a lot of the time?

I was always curious to check out what it was like since I heard a lot of Pink Floyd as a teen, and it pretty much is what it looks like: psychedelic folk rock songs that have something a little wrong with them. It's a loose description obviously but that's also why I enjoyed it, it feels kind of like the most sloppily put together album that I've heard in the genre so far but it's endearing because of it. I think it might grow on me in the future (and also a great excuse to check out Piper at the Gates of Dawn already)

Decently entertaining psych folk. I think I would enjoy it more if I wasn't comparing it to Pink Floyd but it's still a fun listen, if a bit basic at times.

Through Shiiiiitteee

Strum strum strum

Very repetitive. Not for me

So boring. Everything sounds the same.

⭐️⭐️⭐️