Reviews (page 4 of 8)
Never heard Anthrax before although i knew it as a name.I'm not into thrash anyway but from what i've heard I do prefer Brazilian Thrash metal(Sepultura) over this one for sure. Some songs that i liked though: I'm The Law, Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.),great guitars, Indians could be a favourite, *One World is a nice agressive song but the singing sounds the same in all songs to me so it kinda ruined it, A.D.I/The Horror Of It All,was unexpectedly quite good,i really enjoyed it all 7:49 minutes of it. Overall is a good album not great but i listened to it with interest. 3/5.
Can be a bit samey, but mostly alright.
I'm still not a huge fan but do appreciate the aggression.
Pretty good stuff, I should listen to these guys more often
Some catchy tunes but a bit much for me.
Metal tolerance exceeded. Chelation, please.
I like metal, I'm just not sure what case this album is trying to make for itself.
Another example of an album where I can appreciate its individual qualities without particularly connecting with the music itself. I suspect context matters also, in the sense that this would have blown me away if I had listened to it thirty-plus years ago but now just sounds like a bit of a museum piece.
I rather enjoyed this - some really good riffs and didn’t descend into the excesses of some 80s metal. I have never been a fan of the double kick drums so that knocks it down a bit but still better than expected.
This kind of thing probably isn’t in my wheelhouse. I understand the legacy that a band like this has had on the scene, and it’s good to hear the clearer punk influences on thrash through an album like this this, but I found it repetitive after a while.
I love some metal, and this was pretty good. The guitars were aggressive, tight, fast, all the good things. I didn't really care for the vocals or lyrics, typically the Achilles heel of metal. But overall, really good album.
„Among The Living“ erschien 1987 und gilt als das stilprägende Album der US-amerikanischen Thrash-Metal-Band Anthrax aus New York. Aufgenommen wurde es in den Quadradial Studios in Miami und den Compass Point Studios auf den Bahamas, produziert von Eddie Kramer und der Band selbst. Musikalisch schließt das Album an die Energie von „Spreading the Disease“ an, erweitert den Sound jedoch um mehr Tempo, aggressivere Riffs und eine punkige Direktheit. Die Texte sind teils von Literatur und Popkultur inspiriert – etwa „Among the Living“ von Stephen Kings The Stand oder „I Am the Law“ von der Comicfigur Judge Dredd. „Caught in a Mosh“ gilt bis heute als einer der bekanntesten Songs der Band und als Hymne des Moshpits. Auch Stücke wie „Indians“ und „Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.)“ zeigen die Verbindung von sozialem Kommentar, Humor und jugendlicher Rebellion, die Anthrax von vielen Zeitgenossen unterschied. Das Album markierte den endgültigen Durchbruch der Band und festigte ihren Platz in der „Big Four“ des Thrash Metal neben Metallica, Slayer und Megadeth.
They're good at playing fast, but neither the music nor the storytelling got through to me.
The following review is based on actual events. The names haven’t been changed because none are mentioned. A few minutes in: This was actually pretty fun. A few tracks in: Okay, never mind. I’m tired of this already.
I think my problem with most thrash is the vocal. I didn't find this super interesting.
It's fast, fun, and catchy. Anthrax is just really good at what they do.
j’aime pas le métal, y’a trop d’hommes qui crient Medley est pas pire
Whilst this would not be the Anthrax album I would put on the list since I am a devout believer in a Spreading The Disease supremacy, Among The Living is a phenomenal, and underrated thrash album. Come to think of it Anthrax are very underrated as a whole. They never took it as serious as the rest of the Big 4 but they were just as talented. The drumming is some of the best in the thrash metal business. The riffs and solos, despite not being as good as a Megadeth for example, are still really great. And Belladonna's vocals are probably my favourite out of the Big 4, perhaps even in Thrash Metal as a whole. Some lovely basslines thrown in there too I'd recommend this album amongst others to people getting into metal because it's a very good and an accessible way into the genre Anthrax > Slayer btw
This is some also-ran garbage.
Some pretty good tunes here. I was expecting less from what I assumed was thrash. Some great tracks here. Pleasantly surprised.
It’s good, this genre just suffers cause at that pace all the songs just end up sounding the same, glad I heard it but if I want thrash I’m turning to Rust in peace by Megadeath
Really nice to get another sampling of another genre. Not quite what I want out of metal but man I do just love this genre of music.
I've been recently into guitar heavy songs with crazy guitar solos. I was under the impression that what I was listening to is very heavy and I must admit, I felt rather cool but this album makes me realise that I was listening to some light music. While the guitar is great, I am now dealing with a headache that I did not have when I started the album.
Never been the biggest metal-head. This didn't convert me.
This was okay, enjoyed the music more than the vocals. "Caught In A Mosh" and "Efilnikufesin N.F.L." were probably my faves on here.
Turns out the metal band I mostly ignored most of my life are fucking good.
If this is peak thrash, one would hate to hear trough thrash.
One of the greatest thrash albums ever released hands down.
Initially I was excited to see this come out today and I thought I was going to have a blast but unfortunately it’s all a bit tame and predictable. I have had a little experience of Anthrax back when I was in 6th form, introduced to them by friends but only really listened to the State Of Euphoria album. I liked that one so I was maybe expecting a bit more. It’s ok but not really anything special.
I think it's pretty decent but it's a lot compared to the stuff I typically listen to. Just way too much energy, which in some cases I'd probably gravitate to but wouldn't be called upon too much by me.
I am neither misunderstood or angry enough to connect with this album, though I am happy I have been exposed to thrash. Historically seems quite interesting, but not an album I enjoyed listening to
Barely takes a breath, crazy and blistering. Vocals sound 80s power ballad at times
Proper decent metal. Solid, not flashy. Plenty headbangable.
It's very old school metal. It's fine, and again I'm sure it was revolutionary for its time, but I have a hard time giving it too high a grade. 3/5.
As others said, this wasn’t as bad as it could have been, but it wasn’t good either.
Competent but not masterful. Doesn't quite match the interest and enjoyment of its contemporaries in Metallica, Suicidal Tendencies, or Testament. I would not have put this on the list.
I don't like metal music
I can enjoy a bit of trash metal (early Metallica, Slayer etc.). This album has the right overall sound and feel, but it's too monotonous. The songs aren't just that addictive and the production is also a bit flat. Like some Metallica albums - the drums are too tinny (they kick way harder on Dire Straits albums!) and the bass too modest, all to favour the guitars and vocals. I'm not sure about the vocals, they sound a tad well-behaved for the genre, to me. Not bad, just a bit average.
Thrash metal rock. By one of the best.
Caution, speed kills!
Meh. Too much for me, too much.
Lamentablemente planísimo para mi gusto. Nota: 2.5
Thrash metal? More like Trash metal! hehehe Big 4? More like big BORE! hihi What the fuck are these mismatched vocals lmao Kinda fits the super generic instrumentals and garbage lyrics tho
thrashy thrash thrash
Smeller.
It has some great parts, especially the guitar solos. They are equally heavy and fun. I would probably enjoy them as an instrumental band. The vocalist isn't bad but kind of generic and doesn't rlly fit this type of music. I would maybe see him on rock opera or something like that.
I dont think I need to explain why. Jk it was ok for a shit genre
This just isn’t my thing unfortunately. I never get hyped up by this genre, I just find it lame. Rating: 2.1
We probably need thrash to come back.
Not quite my bag but not explicitly bad
My favorite thrash metal album from my favorite thrash metal band! I hadn't listened to this in years, but it was all still fresh in my head from the many times I played the cassette when I was a teenager. It's difficult to be objective here. I just think the whole album is amazing. If I were going to nitpick, some of the lyrics are a bit cheesy and over-earnest, especially when they are dealing with social issues. I prefer the fictional story driven lyrics like the title track, I Am the Law, and a Skeleton in the Closet, but really the music is top-notch throughout the entire thing. It's the perfect blend of clean vocals with some shouty choruses, and melodic instrumentation. I love it, and after I'm finished with this challenge, I plan on revisiting all the Anthrax albums I've heard before, and some that I haven't.
Really not a fan of the thrash and speed moments.
This was great. You definitely have to be a metal fan to enjoy it but I think it combines the heavy instrumentalism of the Megadeths, Metallicas and whatnot of the time and adds in some explicit and unfortunately largely still relevant social commentary instead of just being miserable and focusing on the personal experience. Of course both kinds of content are fine, but it's cool to see this kind of band get that far in to society's problems rather than just doing the traditional "I'm sad and mad" bits. I don't know how to quantify this but because of the all agreed upon (Im assuming) stances on drugs, crime, the treatment of native populations, the obvious callout to politicians with fascist ideas, etc, the band seem to be all super in to it. The instrumentation is crisp, the singing is rapid fire and pronounced with not as much full on screaming as some of their contemporaries. Favorites were "I Am The Law", "Indians", "A Skeleton In The Closet", and "Imitation of Life" though the rest bangs too.
When it comes to metal, I don't really have any love for anything before the early 2000's, Thrash especially. Giving this an honest listen let me appreciate it more than I thought I would, but this isn't going to enter the rotation.
Ultimately just not our vibe, although not as bad as expected tbh.
Speed thrash metal is far from what I enjoy.
An album I'd already heard a bunch before starting 1001. Has that 80s thrash sound but more punky. I don't love this album, don't enjoy the lead singers vocal style. A few highlights but not enough bite for me to come back to it.
The more punk metal of the early metal bands. A lot of the rhythms have real similarity to early Metallica riffs. Didn’t do any research to find out which ones were written earlier
Metal is not my thing. I appreciated the drum solos though
Nothing but coarse and raucous noise with eye-rolling lyrics.
Pretty decent. Some nice riffs, but production sounds a bit muddy and vocals/lyrics occasionally annoying. 3.5/5.
Eh. Fairly typical. A bit faster paced than most metal. Hard to get excited about it, also hard to give it a poor rating.
Not for me but solid. 5.1/10
Not familiar at all with Anthrax. Fun album, cool fast riffs, dumb lyrics. 3.5 rounded down Heard before? No Owned: No 11/1001, 11/46 (23%) Will I get? Yes
Some of the riffs are good. But I can’t stand the vocals. And the drums… all these blast beats… like, I get it… you can play fast…
Interesting to read it was dedicated to a Cliff Burton. Also never listened to more than one or two songs from Anthrax so curious to see how it is and readying myself for some relentless thrash! Much cleaner and easy to listen to than I had expected. Think the production is clean but EQ terrible. Some catchy hooks but just wasn’t particularly grabbed or enthusiastic. Felt a little empty, tinny or lacking substance at times. I’m all for metal but felt a kinda of hollow, cheap version somehow. Became quite tedious and relentless quite quickly and just missing that X factor. I think I realised when it did feature in one song - there are no riffs or breakdowns. It’s just the relentless distorted power chords and I guess that’s thrash metal. But just feels a little unskilled and repetitive. Thought we were getting a mix up with “medley” but no, same old. So bored by the end. I get it
The biggest problem of this album is the mixing. Wikipedia says the band and the producer didn't agree on the sound - to me it sounds like the producer isn't a heavy music listener and he just mixed this as a pop album. If it was my band, I wouldn't agree with it either. The result - everything is too clean for thrash music, especially painful with the back vocals totally not fitting in. But overlooking the the unfortunate mix, the music is pretty cool and interesting. It's mostly carried by the strength of the guitar, that still sounds interesting and fresh today. I agree with other reviewers that the singing isn't what I'm looking for, but it's not as bad as some people say it is. Overall, I'd probably go back to listen to this again at some point!
3.5
didnt care for the vocals a bit too theatrical, wish they were heavier lots of songs have have good moments, but feel too long liked: among the living, Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.), imitation of life
melkeen kuin metallika ja megadeth tämä bändi melkein lähestulkoon yhtä miltei samanverran toooosi lähellä antraxi on siellä.. the big 3... metallika megadet sekä antraksi iso 3. kolme isoa josta kaikki puhuu juttelee vesitonkan äärellä puhuu näistä kolmesta the three great ones the big boys heh.. kukakehtaa jutella metallista ja ei mainita näitä KOLMEA tärkeeää. podium paikka kyllä kaikki on näkyvillä heh... punk metal. come here you punks! huutaa poliisimestari (ei juokse, kävelee vaan vimmatusti) ja antraksin pojat näyttää keskaria ja huutaa takaisin: OTA KIINNI POLLA!!! KOPPALAKKI!!!! Medley: A.D.I. / Horror Of It All
Probably Anthrax's best album. Though I do prefer Spreading the Disease over this one, it doesn't detract from the quality of this one.
Not my type
Among the Living is an album I've known since it debuted, though it took a few years before I actually listened to the whole album. It's Anthrax's breakthrough album that solidified them as a member of the Big 4 of thrash metal, joining Metallica, Megadeth and Slayer. The big difference between Anthrax and the other 3 bands is that Anthrax was from New Your City and had an actual singer, who had more old school New Wave of Heavy Metal vocals instead of screaming and yelling. But Anthrax was just as heavy and had chunky riffs. Among the Living holds up today as it's so heavy, and filled with lyrics about societal issues, featuring an anti-war song about the massacre of Native Americans and an anti-drug song, called N.F.L. I think this album can appeal to everybody in some way or another. While I won't say it's a perfect album, I do find myself returning to it about every year for a listen or two. For metal fans, if you've never heard this album, it's a must. They also may have been the first metal band to get into rap music at the time, as Anthrax recorded I'm the Man during these sessions, a rap song that became a pretty big cult classic.
I love when metal is this fun. Clear tracks, tight arrangements, and of course energy for days.
Not very good.
Heard of Anthrax, but this was my first actual listen, and honestly? What a pleasant surprise. The thrash metal core (guitar, bass and especially drums) is SICK. Riffs sharp enough to cut bone and a rhythm section that hits like a freight train. And then there’s Joey. His vocals just don’t mesh with the band’s apocalyptic thrash brilliance for me. It’s giving glam hair metal while the rest of the band is summoning Ragnarok. I swear I could smell the hairspray. Lyrically, Scott Ian crushed it on “Indians” and “One World.” And Charlie Benante? HOLY. FUCK. Now officially one of my favorite drummers of all time. Just a complete beast. No notes. Pure drum god.
I liked this A LOT more than I expected I would. Lots of memorable tunes, and the guitar/bass/drums go hard. But I'm one of those people that don't like the vocals - it really drags it down. To me, it sounds like vocals you would hear from one of your friends singing along on the couch next to you. There's nothing technically 'wrong' with the vocals, I just didn't like them. They drop it from a 4 star to a 3, but really more like a 3.5 - this is above average.
This is hard to listen to
Never heard this and better than expected.
Listening to this while driving is a dangerous passtime
Great riffs, odd singing!
Anthrax would have absolutely ruled as an instrumental band
I suppose I could have given this a 1
It’s 80s metal-y. I’m not huge on that genre.
When I was growing up, Anthrax guitarist Scott Ian frequently showed up on TV as a music pundit (maybe he's still doing that, idk I don't watch much TV these days). My knowledge of Anthrax is pretty limited beyond whatever incidental exposure I got from the clips used to prove his bonafides on those shows. It was always a little strange to me that Anthrax was (is?) held in such high regard but I absolutely never hear anybody talking about their music. With other "Big Four" acts like Metallica or Slayer, you will randomly see people wearing the band t-shirts or hear the music blasting from a car in traffic, but I don't feel like Anthrax has had that same staying power. Maybe it was all the line-up changes and new lead singers. Musically, thrash just feels like metal with a little extra punk sprinkled in and I can handle that just fine for the length of an album. But vocally, this album is very much 'of its era', with the soaring chorus vocals that were popular in metal at the time (think mid-80s Metallica, Judas Priest, etc). The grunty verses and borderline-falsetto choruses are my least favorite thing about this era in thrash/metal and my biggest hurdle here.
A very solid thrash album. Thrash isn't my favourite genre as it's the punkiest end of the metal spectrum, but this is good.
With this album I now have listened a quarter of the entire list! I wish I was as excited for this album as I am for this fact. I've never cared for Thrash Metal, not even when I was a metal-head. It is true that I like 'Reign in Blood' by Slayer, and I used to be a big fan of Metallica's early work, but I've never being interested in this particular scene, and I don't even come back to what I once liked. And it seems that my feelings haven't changed the slightest. This album hasn't done absolutely anything for me and it felt tiring towards the end. I can see people having fun with it. It is fast and a bit angry, but I like my angry music to be way more chaotic and noisy, and this record doesn't hit those nails for me.
Better and worse than I expected. Musically it’s ok, not that into the vocals. The whole thing is just a little homogenous.
I loved this record late middle school. This and State of Euphoria. But I left it behind and it really didn't age well for me unfortunately and isn't something I'd spin today. However! I look back on those times fondly and am thankful this music was around back then.
This is the furthest from my wheelhouse yet. I even considered skipping it altogether but decided giving it a try. Did not like it even a tiny bit. I just couldn't take it seriously. The musicianship and even the physical prowess of the players is admirable, of course, but the music felt like ridiculuos posturing to me.
Another one that I really want to like but I just can’t get into it or Anthrax in general. I love it musically (5 Stars!) but I either dislike their crossover style or the vocal approach so much that it cancels out. I consider myself a decently big Thrash fan but this pillar of the big 4 just isn’t for me. 🤷🏼♂️ (3.5)
I have never been a big fan of them I like a few of their songs and live they are a different beast I really like the instrumental just not so much the singing.
I was a metalhead in the 80s, this came out in my Sr year and it was a regular jam for me and my posse.. I think it’s by far the best Anthrax record, and will always have a place in my heart. That said, it has not aged consistent with my current musical taste, but still really enjoyed a nostalgic head bang!!!
Hailed as one of the big four thrash bands, this was the pivotal album catapulted the band to a world recognized act. Everything on this album speaks of speed and precision. The drums are super tight with speed, the bass in the same, complementing the guitar rifts. At times the 80s production is a bit too much for me along with some aspects of the 80’s metal singing style which I’ve often struggled with. The second I get caught up in that downside, the intense precision and speed of the instrumentation pulls me back in. 3.5
I read another review that described Among the Living as thrash metal bordering on punk rock and I kind of like that. This album shredded the legs of my acid washed jeans.
Have loved this album since I was 10-11 years old, favorite Anthrax album.
Not my usual style but was pleasantly surprised
The first minute or so of the opening track "Among the Living" wouldn't be out of place on any Black Sabbath album, but then it descends into Thrash Metal with it's driving rhythm. For me, (a lifelong Black Sabbath fan), one Thrash Metal song sounds like another.
Cringe
Jud Jud, Jud jud, biddley waaaaa. Smash smash smash.
Wow, this album does not give you the chance to catch a breath. Really liked i am the law, efilnikufesin and a.d.i./horror of it all.
Ok power metal album, not necessarily my jam, but didn't dislike it. 3*
Rating: 6/10 Great riffs but bad vocally. The choruses are especially bad and songs overly long in general, but the guitar riffs and drumming make up for this. I still think Anthrax should not be considered part of the big 4 of thrash, this album does nothing that Metallica, Slayer, or Megadeth have done better before it.
Thrash metal with some punk aspirations. The whole personnel is competent in their playing, but I can't help but feel that everything doesn't quite stack up to the other metal acts from around this time. I dunno, this didn't "bite" quite as hard. The vocals weren't as strong and the album as a whole was a bit repetitive. I'll never not be impressed by the drum work in any thrash metal work though, and Charlie Benante is no exception here. I don't know where Anthrax stands in terms of the overall metal acts hierarchy, but you can tell they're slightly a step behind of the top acts at the very least. Still competent enough to warrant a listen from metalheads and those slightly curious about metal, though.
1. living - 1.5 2. mozh - 1.5 3. lauu - 0 4. NFL - 1.5 5. Skeleton - 1.5 6. Indians - 1 7. World -1.5 8. Horror - 1 9. Life - 1.5
Music to collect Secret Tapes to (affectionate) Fav songs: Among The Living, Stuck In A Mosh
First album generated for me. Definitely not a thrash metal fan, had to skip through most of the songs.
Anthrax is the least remembered of the big 4 of thrash metal, and there's a pretty good reason for that. It's not that they're bad, just that the rest are so good. Among the Living is one of their better records, which can be very hit or miss.
One of the metal bands I do like.
Not my sort of metal
Pretty heavy, pretty heavy. Good stuff. Pairs well with riding Harleys and picking kids up from school
I think this would still piss off my parents in 2025.
gotta be one of my top ten favorite uncle/nephew bands
Fantastic metal album! Not life changing, but I can understand why it has such an impact.
Discovering my love of 80s thrash metal through this project
Dont like it Too heavy metal
Kick you in the face metal. Not my thing so much these days, but a fun listen anyway. 3/5
Not my thing at all
Thrash isn’t really my thing, but it’s not the worst thing I have ever heard. It’s not even the worst thing I’ve heard in the relatively short period of time I have been doing this challenge. It obviously influenced Faith No More. Of the big four, Anthrax aren’t my favourite, but I would rate them over Megadeth. The songs are too long, and at times are less thrash more playing fast, but overall i didn’t hate. It sounds more like heavy punk, and there is something a bit off about it. It sounds so poor compared to Reign in Blood which was out around about the same time. Overall, it wasn’t terrible but I won’t be revisiting.
This is fine, very much of its time. Like the instrumental but can't stand the singers voice. 5/10
One of the Big Four of thrash (allegedly)! The first track opens a bit more like doom metal than thrash, but the tempo eventually catches up. The lead guitar is immediately the star of the show, outshining the lead vocals as soon as it launches into its solo. The same is true for the next track. And the third track (I think I see a pattern in Anthrax's songwriting). The tone is so crisp and distinct from the heavily distorted rhythm guitar. It's a delicious texture combo and I can easily see how this genre was popular back in the day. Unfortunately though, the singing is generally not great – essentially being a series of warlike man-grunts/wails that attempt to add some singability(?) to the songs. The vocals are best when they follow distinctive melodies, as in the chorus of Caught In A Mosh (e.g.). A lot of the tracks definitely go on longer than they should. One World, A Skeleton In The Closet, and I Am The Law are all culprits. I would normally suggest that an album with longer tracks is better for background listening, but you can't exactly put this on while you study or while you're cuddling with your girlfriend. Maybe Anthrax didn't plan ahead on their target audience very well. Despite this, every track is pretty solid in isolation. Thrash metal isn't my thing at all, but I was still able to appreciate the quaint selection of loud noises. As a collective, they aren't quite as strong, since many of the tracks sound the same – so perhaps Anthrax is more of a single-oriented group. 3/5 Key tracks: Caught In A Mosh, Indians
No thanks
My favorite Anthrax album and probably my favorite non Metallica album from the Big 4 although Reign in Blood may be ahead of it. Anthrax makes thrash fun
Enjoyable in the right frame of mind
It’s just painful noise to me. Medley: A.D.I./Horror of It All began with some subtlety, but descended quickly into bombast. Yuck!
I want to rate this a 5 and that's what I'm going to do. I am the Law.
Great album 5 stars
Least favorite album to date. Not sure how they made the top 1000. Still, I got a really good workout out of it.
Why would I bother with this when I could just listen to Master of Puppets?
3.5 08.10.2025
I went in expecting to totally not like this, but it was better than I imagined. This just is not my style of music, but there were some moments that I really enjoyed, and there is some great musicianship on here. After a while everything just sounds the same to me tho and it kinda gets boring. So in the end, not bad, but not something I’d return to.
Honestly it wasnt as bad as I expected it to be. Kinda enjoyed it honestly.
Great album from start to finish. Standout songs: Caught in a mosh I am the law Medley
For whatever reason I never got into Anthrax when I first was getting into metal in the early '90's. Metallica, Pantera, Megadeth, but Anthrax never really hit my radar. And I'm wondering why it didn't. I was dorky kid who also played football, I should have been all over the in your face high tempo chugging riffs and double kick drum. It's not really my thing now, just like most of the rest of thrash metal, but I'm feeling like maybe I missed something...? Guess I'll never know. Maybe I should blow it past my kid, maybe he'll get to enjoy something I missed out on...
Vocals were too clean for me.
Definitely not for me, I am as far from Thrash Metal in my music taste as Moscow is to Montevideo. Still, some nice production here, even though for a non-metal fan a lot of this sounded samey to me. My favorite song was the title track.
Anthrax
Don’t really get the hype without being a bummer , the guitar is super impressive along with the drums but the vocalist ruins it , he sings way too slow for something so fast
In order to be among the living, you have to approach the situation as though you were speeding towards death. Anthrax took one more step towards metal immortality with this all killer, no filler collection of songs that waste little time in getting its points across and putting a stamp on them with the admittedly infectious musicality on display. For most bands, they would just rest their laurels upon this release and while Anthrax are most surely entitled to do such a thing, there would be plenty more of where that came from with them. Favorites: Among the Living, Caught In a Mosh, N.F.L., Indians, One World, Imitation of Life.
Thrash metal. Not when it's as generic as this
This was pretty good, but I much prefer other metal from the era
Lots of thrash, lots of fun. More bands should do metal covers of Joe Jackson songs
Haven’t heard this one in awhile. Still holds up for me
Not my favorite Antrax album but still top notch
I like this in small doses. A whole album is a big dose. 2.6.
I need to check out more of Anthrax's stuff. Personal enjoyment: 4/5 Relevance to this list: 4/5
Landmark album for me personally.
Great metal album
I’m not a metal fan, but enjoyed this one. Went hard during a risk of rain 2 run
Listened Before? Y FUCKING ROCK ON!!! This album is a thrash metal classic and one of the big four at their prime. What's not to love? Maybe some of the themes, but I don't care. This one is full-out balls-to-the-wall metal from beginning to end. Awesome! Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: Caught In A Mosh, N.F.L.
Does anyone else feel as if Anthrax would be a lot better if they weren't a metal band?
Thrash, but nothing memorable.
Favourites: Among The Living, Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.), Indians
Headbanger, metal, whatever, I always called this pissed-off-white-boy music since anger and outrage seem the singular emotion expressed - "What do white kids have to be so pissed off about? They were born white already." And it's a fairly large genre.
Not for me
Anthrax are a band that have never really done much for me and today’s album didn’t change that. It’s not bad or anything, I was quite enjoying it up to a point. It just didn’t hold my interest all the way through. Top Track - I Am The Law
Thrash metal is definitely not my jam. I tried it though. I can tell Anthrax is good at it.
licking envelopes rn
My Big 4 ranking: Anthrax (live) Megadeth (recorded) Slayer (4 songs) Ride the Lightning
I remember initially not being impressed with the album when I first bought it. This was an album I wore out in the CD player until it broke through to me. The style here is actually Thrash and coming from later Metallica, and even the albums they released at this time, I wasn't prepared for that and the roughness of it. It took some time to appreciate the awesome bass riffs here and Benante's drumming that doesn't sound too complex but is more creative than a lot of the other Big Four's songs at the time. It takes a special band to respond to Master of Puppets with a album containing a song about Judge Dredd. Awesome stuff. My only real critisicm of the album is that the last two songs should be swapped. Horror Of It All is too strong a closer to be the penultimate song. Highlight: Caught In A Mosh
Pretty influential when talking about speed/thrash metal
I don't listen to a lot of thrash metal but this I quite enjoyed this.
Urgh. These guys should just have released a single. I really don't see why this made the list
Never listened to anything by Anthrax before. It’s not really my sort of music, but my barometer for this type of music is ‘is it better than Metallica?’. This is, so it gets 2 starts.
Among the Living by Anthrax is a thrash metal classic that doesn’t just punch hard—it swings with personality. From the opening title track to the ferocious closer “Imitation of Life,” the album is packed with relentless riffs, spitfire vocals, and a sense of urgency that feels both chaotic and precise. It’s easy to see why this record helped define the genre. Tracks like “Caught in a Mosh” and “Indians” are not only anthemic but also carried by that signature Anthrax blend of aggression and groove. There’s a tightness to the musicianship that keeps it from ever spiraling into noise, with Scott Ian’s rhythm work and Charlie Benante’s drumming forming a rock-solid core. Listening to this again felt like stepping into a time machine. I first heard it in my late teens, and it made me feel like I could take on the world—or at least wreck my bedroom. Now, with older ears, I still love the raw energy and unapologetic attitude, though a couple of tracks feel a bit dated or lyrically clunky. Still, it’s hard not to admire just how fearless it all is. It might not be my absolute favorite thrash record, but it holds a firm place in that upper tier. A 4 out of 5 feels right for something that shaped a movement and still packs a mean punch.
Big production and riffs but vocals let it down for me.
Not an Anthrax fan..
Pretty decent thrash. I'd probably rate this higher if I spent more time with it.
High 2, but still a 2. Just felt flat; others have done it much better.
I am a fan of heavy metal and it has been a long time coming for me to dip into Anthrax. This is a good album. It's interesting to hear the state of the genre in 1987. You can certainly hear the influences of hardcore in the rhythm structures and Iron Maiden throughout. Great riffs, fun songs. Standouts for me were the Judge Dredd-themed 'I Am The Law' and 'Medley: A.D.I/Horror of It All'. The most interesting thing I found about this one is what the recording sounds like. The drums and bass are very clean and prominent and Scott Ian's guitar sounds a little bit thin and distant (I had this cranked on Spotify in my car; maybe it sounds thicker on vinyl). Some texture is missing from the guitar sound, but that may be due to this being early in the evolution of thrash recording. Modern Metal frequently features distorted vocals as well (Death's Scream Bloody Gore also came out in 1987, so the style was somewhat new, yet) but I was surprised to hear Joey Belladonna singing in more of a Bruce Dickinson style, mostly in his upper chest range but occasionally pushing to a high belt (possibly a falsetto mix? I can't do it well, so I'm not sure). In all, a classic of heavy metal but one that will sound slightly less heavy by standards 38 years later. You can hear each musician distinctly, though, and that's a treat in the case of Anthrax.
Tuhti rässilevy joka osaa nauraa itselleen! 3/5
Varsin menevä metalli/trash?-levy. ainakin on tuplabasaria. 3/5
US 80s metal. Fast guitars and shouty vocals. Pretty standard for the genre.
This is a great thrash album. Wonderful energy--it just keeps going. I like this a lot better than the other Anthrax album on here. This reminds me a little of Rust in Peace--it just keeps coming. A few stand out tracks here, including the first one.
Прививка от столбняка если бы она была музыкой
3/5. I can definitely see the influence this album provided for the rock and metal genre, but listening to it is very clear that this was the first one. The different sub-genres of metal are usually fairly rough starting out. No one nails it out of the park on their first try but I do got to give respect where it is due. It's a bold album, doesn't sound great at times, and other times is a classic in moving the genre forward. There is a mix of garage punk and heavy metal throughout the album and it's good for what it is but a genre that was perfected by other bands already. The guitar is the best part here, driving each song. With even a little less energy from the guitar, this album would drop significantly. Best Songs: Indians, Caught In A Mosh, Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.)
Favorite track: "Medley: ADI/Horror Of It All"
For years I thought this devil worship music, and to think all they wanted to sing about was the plight of the Native Americans. Who knew?!
I like metal (and punk and hardcore and hardcore punk). Anthrax is not my favorite, but I enjoy them more than 90% of this list, so they’re going to get all the stars in comparison. If I’m honest, I’ll admit that some of the lyrics are so ridiculously unsubtle and blunt that they feel like parody when they scream about “crying for the Indian.” I prefer RATM for actual protest songs, I guess. The instrumentation is great, if not challenging compared to a lot of metal on this list (like Sepultura). Still, it’s not Britpop or Prog.
4.5 stars really. Great riffs, and a powerful album for understanding that being an angry rebel delinquent actually stems from being more grounded in reality. Very relatable in many ways.
One of the greatest thrash metal albums of all time.. an absolute masterpiece. In 2005, the Among the Living lineup reunited for the last and recorded a show at the Starland Ballroom in Sayreville, NJ and release as a DVD Alive 2. I can actually be seen moshing during Indians.. such an incredible time!
The percussion, the guitars, the thrash, I like all of it. The music is fantastic. Except… I cannot stand the falsetto high note vocals. It’s not quite Dio but it’s not good.
Pure 80s metal. Too pure for me.
Liked this WAY more than I expected to. I'm not a huge metal guy, but if it was all like this, I'd probably listen to more.
Classic metal!!!
This album kicks ass. It starts fast, ends super fast with Imitation of Life. A must listen for anyone who says they like heavy metal. 3.72/5 stars = 4.
Thrash metal. Not bad but nothing special
Kareoke, huligan-körer. Taffliga gitarrsolon. Jag gillar verkligen inte sången. Inga låtar som står ut. Pinsamma texter; sämst Indians.
I don't hate any tracks. I don't love any tracks (tracks 2 & 8 were good in that at least they were memorable). It sort of just sits there, no flash, no grab, and a bit of fury. But after 3 songs, I was a bit bored. Could I listen to this once in a blue moon? Sure if on random-album mode. Would I choose to listen? Nope. But if it came on I'd probably listen to 5 (plus track 8) tracks before going, "okay, that's enough." Track 8 at least had a change of pace (at the beginning), there's that...and oddly, that's probably my fave track. The rest just blends into the background of yelling and heavy drumming. (2nd listen, I also liked track 2. Yeah, I'd be in the pit for that!) Just read the backstory to this album...RIP CB. Still: ⭐⭐⭐(2.99999...)
Repeat listen
I want to like this more as it is clearly the start of a movement and inspires some great albums but its just slightly too chaotic for me.
I've listened to Anthrax a lot so I'm biased on my opinion. So let's go back in time when I first heard Anthrax. I didn't like them compared to the other big four in thrash metal at first. Joey Belladonna's vocals and the backing vocals were different and their style is closer to hardcore punk than heavy metal. After a while it grew on me. Metallica, Slayer and Megadeth had their bay area thrash metal style while Anthrax is from New York. Of course they sound different. Anthrax got awesome riffs and excellent drumming. Joey's vocals are a nice change from the otherwise harsh vocals in thrash. Among The Living is probably their best album and probably got their best songs on it. This is a good introduction to something different than Metallica.
p563. 1987. 2 stars. This is what you get if you cross Motorhead with Iron Maiden. Well done of its kind, but there is nothing here that hasn't been done before and better.
this fucks
Decent thrash album, Anthrax is the best out of the big 4 if you ask me.
Tricky. I feel like it's in line with most albums of its type I have listened to. I'll give it a questionable 4, as I've enjoyed it more than less, it was a good background listen.
I'm not well versed in speed metal, thrash or whatever this is. But it does not sound much out of date at all. Perhaps due to how little the genera has progressed or maybe how ahead of time these guys were. Possibly a bit of both.
Demasiado ruidoso para mi gusto
I can definitly see the appeal, and it was fun to read the comments on YouTube by other listeners, but overall it isn’t for me.
This is like Metallica if you took Lars Ulrich and made him lead singer. Yes, I am trying to say the instrumentals of this album absolutely rocked but the singer was atrocious. The breakdown in I Am The Law was incredible though. Once you get used to the bad singing, this thing isn't so bad. Good listen. It definitely grew on me as the songs rolled by. I'd rate this a 3.5 if I could, but alas. You can have your 4.
The recording and production for this album really feel like they left everything sounding really flat (odd given Eddie Kramer supposedly helped produce this, perhaps it was a bit of a styles clash?). Very disappointing that no matter what I listened to this through I could practically hear the energy being filtered out. It doesn’t look like there are any listings of this marked as a remaster from what I could see on Spotify either. A pretty decent if repetitive album if I put my feelings towards the production aside.
Superb the guitar work on my highlight tracks, and the instrumentals throughout the album were solid to great. Many songs had a good momentum that thumped along and switched up at the right intervals. Enjoyed the solos on NFL and Skeleton in the Closet. The lead vocals don’t gel with me. Lyrics are generally quite basic too. Highlights I am the Law, Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.), A Skeleton In The Closet, Medley
Never have I come so close to falling asleep listening to metal. Truly ridiculous that anthrax is considered one of the four foundational pillars of thrash metal.
Just an all round great thrash album. I told my Dad a known thrash enjoyed i was listening to this today, he proceeded to listen to it as well as he hadn't listened to it in a few years. When I asked him for a review for this he called me a faggot 8/10
Of the Big 4 Thrash acts this is the one I am least familiar with, and that's a shame because I was able to enjoy these guys straight away unlike Megadeth where learning to enjoy/tolerate Dave Mustaine's voice has the same timeframe as learning to enjoy running. Unlike basically every other contemporary metal band, Anthrax's band members all seem to be good people for some weird reason? Anyway, this fucking rocks. I loved heavy metal in high school, Iron Maiden especially, and if I wasn't hyperfixated on them I would have adored this if I had listened to it. The album doesn't have a great amount of musical range but the band know what their strengths are and they excel at them. Each song had me looking up the lyrics, the chorus of each song is catchy and the whole thing is thoroughly entertaining. As far as criticisms go, Side A is better than Side B which becomes apparent on relistens but it's not by a great margin. There wasn't a song on here that I didn't enjoy, I couldn't sit still for the entire album and each time I finished it I wanted to start it again. I love this album. Highlights: Among the Living, Caught in a Mosh, I Am the Law, Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.), Indians, Imitation of Life
High octane, speed trash, intense rock. Keeps your energy way up. I've been learning I'm a fan of this style. I liked the message of the lyrics too. Well done
Perfect! Heavy and noisy!
Helt klart spännande. Första metal-albumet jag någonsin lyssnat genom. Rätt bra ändå. Vet inte om det är min musikstil eller ej. Trivdes litegrann. Förvånad själv.
Sori vaan, mutta en pitänyt yhtään.
One summer, this tape was permanently borrowed from a friend's older brother (by said friend), and we skated the weakest curbs in our suburban town to it. I tried some other Anthrax on for size later on, and even though some of those albums are arguably better (e.g. Persistence of Time), they never quite fit or brought me back to those small ollies and aborted kickflips. But Among the Living still does. "Caught in a Mosh" and "I Am the Law" are my favorites — no surprise there. We were the perfect demo for hardcore, popular horror fiction, and comic books. We weren't yet picking up on subtleties in the text, so something like "Indians," which now feels a bit too simplistic, actually got us thinking about Indigenous politics. "Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.)" hits different now, but it's still a cracking track. Songs like "One World" and "A Skeleton in the Closet" are excellent glue tracks — they might not stand out like the singles, but they showcase how tight Anthrax are and deliver exactly what you want from a band like this. And so back to me: I turned out to be a better skater and snowboarder a few years later, and I'd find music even more crushing than this. But I'm always instantly filled with joyful nostalgia to be Among the Living whenever it comes on.
It was fine? A lot more chanting then I expected. I really can't tell the difference between "good" and "bad" versions of these old metal albums. 6/10
Ow. Bad singing can be good, but...
Grow your hair and headbang. I did it once before, but I can't think of it anymore
pretty good thrash
cringe lyrics and vocals
Just noise to me but can appreciate it
hardcore!!
I never really liked a metal album until now. Most of the time I feel like it's just indiscernable noise and there is no song structure, but I really liked all of these songs and found that there was something to follow. I would definitely listen to this again - I'm shocked at how much I liked this!
These vocals are not my thing. Very NYHC. I do like the music though, even though most tracks are too long. They do sound kinda samey after a while. Nice, but won't revisit.
I've never given Anthrax a fair chance because I cant get past the vocals. I'd lump Anthrax in with Megadeth where if they had a good vocalist, they would be an incredible band. That said, this album is super solid. No bad songs, a lot of punk influence comes through. Fun and catchy songs, good hooks and riffs. After a couple listens, the vocals weren't as annoying.
not what i usually listen to, but also didn't suck. imitation of life and i am the law are definitely going on my playlist. all the songs kinda sounded the same, but im sure that would fade with a few more listens.
Pleasantly surprised
Great
Not as good as Megadeth and Sepultura, but likable enough. Won’t pursue any further, though.
Le thrash metal c'est généralement rigolo une chanson, 2 max. C'est pas du mauvais thrash en l'occurrence, c'est juste rigolo une chanson, 2 max.
I really wanted to like this more, but singer annoyed me and tracks very samey.
Its ok only thing id they all sound the same. I listened to an extra 30 mins of Anthrax as I didnt know the album ended
It's thrash again. I still don't get it.
Great to go back in time and listen to this one. Not nearly as heavy as I remember it…
I'm not a big fan of heavy metal
2/5
Nice metal album!
As one of the big 4, this is really the album that cemented them as a top thrash metal band. Fast, pummeling riffs that don't forget to groove and hilarious lyrics - it's what I want from my metal bands. Also, there's a song about Judge Dredd - what's not to like? Best Tracks: Caught in a Mosh; I Am The Law; Indians
I like the sound of it but not the vocals and lyrics
Oh baby, it's Anthrax time. I haven't listened to this whole album before, but I am quite familiar with the group as a whole. As a teen, I wouldn't have considered Anthrax to be heavy metal based on the vocalist's delivery, but with time and a greater context of the album as a whole I can't think of it as anything else. Caught In A Mosh is the main single that people would recognize, but I recommend Imitation Of Life as a personal favorite. Something about the tone that accuses the listener of not thinking for themselves was more pointed than the usual recommendations of freewill you usually hear
Saw Anthrax open for Iron Maiden in the early 90’s - they are even better, live. That being said, I haven’t really listened to much of their catalog. I enjoyed this - really liked One World in particular.
Among the Living by Anthrax surprised me — I didn’t hate it! It's full of intense headbanging energy and a lot of shouting, which isn't usually my thing, but I found it more listenable than expected. Thrash metal isn’t a genre I typically explore, so I appreciated that this challenge pushed me out of my comfort zone. While the album overall wasn’t exactly to my taste, I did notice some tracks had a punkish edge and occasional melody that made them more engaging. That said, many of the songs started to blend together for me. The album tends to stick to a single tempo and sound, with little variation in riffs or rhythm, making it hard to distinguish one track from another. Favourite tracks: “I Am the Law” and “Caught in the Mosh” were decent — not instant favorites, but they stood out a bit. Least favourite: By the time I reached track 9, Imitation of Life, I felt like I’d heard enough. Album artwork: Odd, but in a good way — I actually really like it. In the end, it’s not an album I’d revisit, but I’m glad I gave it a try.
No. Just, no.
Anthax is one of the best thrash metal bands, their discography is great! Among the Living is one of their best-known albums, the fiery guitar in their songs is what makes them so well-known in the genre. In fact, I think I am the Law is one of their greatest. Their lyrics express the rebellion that everyone should have.
I'm thinking 4 but I'm going 3
Thrash metals really not my thing. I don't mind the intros when its just drums / guitar riffs and slowly building up the tension - but really don't like it once the vocals kick in and they up the temp. Although lyrically not quite as dumb as other examples on the list (although that's a very low bar) and the delivery is much clearer.
Among the Living I didn’t mind the sludgy, Black Sabbath-esque opening to the first track, but oh, yep there it is, the double kick drum and power chords combo and the ensuing musical moribundity. It does get a little more interesting when the tempo shifts back and forth, and I didn’t mind the solo, but ultimately it’s pretty much a rehash of every other thrash metal song. Which is also true for the rest of it, despite their perhaps being a slightly broader lyrical palate than some of their peers, and the odd occasion like on Indians or One World where they create a more memorable hook/chorus. Obviously it’s not my thing, but I didn’t dislike it as much as say Sepultura or Venom, and I can see if you do like metal and thrash this is a good example, but for me a it's a very Partridgean shoulder shrug when he’s introduced to the man who’s just revamped current affairs, as I can find very little to be interested in. 🤷 Playlist submission: Indians
This has confounded some of my expectations for the better. A dash of being a little light-hearted and not singing about the putrid stench of baby's rotting flesh, goes a long way. Not to the point of thinking it's a good album mind you. From a critical standpoint it's still overrun with bland chainsaw guitar chugging that does it's best to kill any interest elicited by melodic intros and breaks. I give it credit for making me realise what genius Black Sabbath were. I could edit together a cracking couple of songs out of it. A shade behind Rust in Peace.
Speed mental kings! Sounds very dated but still great for the genre.
Tämähän oli ihan perinteistä kasariheviä yhteiskuntakriittisellä tvistillä. Muuten ihan samanlaista melodista kitaranvingutusta.
aaaany skeletonsssss yow yow yow
Some cool riffs and grooves, but not into the vocals
This album has fantastic musicianship and energy. Lyrically, many of the themes from 1987 still hold relevance today in 2025. The songs themselves have an almost punk feel to them, making me feel hustled along as if in a mosh pit. While I appreciated the individual aspects of the album, however, somehow it didn't coalesce into something I see myself coming back to listen to again.
I prefer my heavy metal to be a bit closer to home really.
I was surprised by this album and really enjoyed it. Loved the Stephen King references on the title track and "A Skeleton in the Closet" as well as the plea for justice for native Americans on "Indians." Made me want to get in a mosh pit and thrash around.
Iron Maiden meets Black Flag. Love the face melting solos, driving drums, intense bass and rhythm guitar. Vocals and lyrics are occasionally goofy but still technically impressive, appreciate the Stephen king references too. Surprised how much I enjoyed this
Day500 - i’m feeling thoroughly thrashed and ready for the next five hundred albums
Rocks
I can respect the talent but this wasn't for me
Not my scene at all but far more listenable!
This has all the right ingredients to be a pretty killer album - slightly let down by vocals IMO.
Very loud even when the volume is low.
A little bit too intense for me.
As serious as a lot of thrash metal bands can be, Anthrax just feels more fun. Yes, the lyrical subject matter is still pretty doom and gloom, but the vocal style brings a bit of levity. Constantly underrated. Among the Living is Anthrax firing on all cylinders. Absolutely deserves to be here.
I usually hesitate to say this about any genre but yep, I feel moved to say that thrash ain’t the genre for me. I can kind of appreciate that it’s good for what it is and they’re technically proficient but I’ll leave this one to the snakebite drinking headbangers
Went in blind and was surprised that I didnt hate it! Like with most metal- I appreciated the instrumentation and technical skill but didnt love the singing. I actually did like some of the sonhs though. Overall- decent album
3.2
Like if a funeral doom vocalist shit all over C-tier thrash.
Un álbum que me aburrió. Con excepción de un par de breakdowns y riffs, y el propio sonido de los 80s, no es un estilo de música que me interese.
not for me... never was much of a thrash fan
Nothing noteworthy, but it was not unbearable. Got my toot tapping occasionally, but that is the maximum positive i can give. Would not even remotely listen to this again
I did have a metal phase and this would’ve slapped back then
Thrash metal just not my thing. Not the worst example this has thrown up, you can hear the lyrics and though it’s very repetitive song to song there isn’t the epic glacial plodding or ultra angry fly sounds of others. But a waste of 50 mins for me. 1 Star
## In-Depth Review: *Among the Living* by Anthrax ### **Overview** Released in 1987, *Among the Living* is Anthrax’s third studio album and a landmark in thrash metal. It marked the band’s full embrace of thrash, blending East Coast hardcore energy with Bay Area technicality, and stands as a defining record of the genre’s golden era[4][5][3]. The album is both a tribute to their influences and a bold statement of their own identity, featuring a unique mix of humor, social commentary, pop culture references, and relentless musical energy. --- ## **Lyrics** ### **Themes and Storytelling** *Among the Living* is renowned for its eclectic lyricism, which draws from a variety of sources: - **Pop Culture & Fiction:** - “I Am the Law” is a tribute to the comic book antihero Judge Dredd, capturing his uncompromising nature with lines like “I am the law, and you won’t fuck around no more”[4][6]. - “Among the Living” and “A Skeleton in the Closet” are inspired by Stephen King’s *The Stand* and *Apt Pupil*, respectively, reflecting the band’s love for horror and literature[4][6]. - **Social Commentary:** - “Indians” addresses the mistreatment of Native Americans, with lines urging respect and recognition of historical injustices[4][6]. - “One World” warns of nuclear annihilation, echoing Cold War anxieties. - “Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.)” is a protest against drug abuse, inspired by John Belushi’s death[4][6]. - **Personal & Everyday Struggles:** - “Caught in a Mosh” channels frustration and communication breakdown, using the mosh pit as a metaphor for life’s chaos[4][6]. ### **Style and Tone** Anthrax’s lyrics on this album are notable for their mix of serious and playful tones. The band often uses humor and irony, even when addressing weighty topics, which sets them apart from their more somber thrash peers[6]. Critics have described the lyrics as having a “childish veneer” or “cartoony tone,” but this youthful energy is also cited as a key part of the album’s enduring appeal[3]. ### **Pros** - Wide thematic range (pop culture, social issues, personal angst) - Memorable hooks and catchphrases (“I am the law,” “WAAAARRRRDANCE!”) - Balances humor with genuine commentary ### **Cons** - Some lyrics can feel juvenile or simplistic, especially compared to the more cerebral work of their peers[3][7] - Occasional reliance on clichés or “kumbaya” messaging (“One World” criticized for this)[7] --- ## **Music** ### **Instrumentation and Songwriting** - **Guitar Work:** Scott Ian’s rhythm guitar delivers razor-sharp, palm-muted riffs that drive the album’s energy. Dan Spitz’s lead guitar provides fiery, melodic solos that add technical flair[5]. - **Bass and Drums:** Frank Bello’s bass is thick and punchy, anchoring the sound, while Charlie Benante’s drumming is a tour de force of double bass, fills, and relentless speed[5]. - **Vocals:** Joey Belladonna’s soaring, melodic vocals set Anthrax apart from other thrash acts, who often favored gruffer, harsher styles. His delivery is both powerful and catchy, making choruses instantly memorable[5]. - **Gang Vocals:** Group chants and gang vocals are a signature element, lending a communal, anthemic feel to tracks like “Caught in a Mosh” and “Indians”[3][5]. While some find this energizing, others see it as repetitive. ### **Song Structures** The album is packed with high-tempo thrashers, but Anthrax also incorporates breakdowns, tempo shifts, and melodic interludes. The songwriting is tight, with each track offering distinct hooks and memorable moments. However, some critics argue that the album peaks too early, with the title track setting a standard that later songs don’t always match[3]. ### **Pros** - Precision and energy in every performance - Memorable riffs and solos - Melodic, accessible vocals - Dynamic arrangements (breakdowns, tempo changes) ### **Cons** - Some tracks feel formulaic or less inspired than the standouts[3][7] - Gang vocals can become monotonous for some listeners[7] - A few songs are criticized for “gray masses of palm-muted monotony”[7] --- ## **Production** ### **Sound Quality** Produced by Eddie Kramer (noted for work with Jimi Hendrix and Led Zeppelin), the album boasts a crisp, powerful sound. The production allows every instrument to shine: guitars are sharp, drums are thunderous, and vocals are clear[5]. Unlike many thrash albums of the era, which often suffered from muddy mixes, *Among the Living* is sonically balanced and impactful. ### **Atmosphere** The production enhances the album’s intensity without sacrificing clarity. The mix supports the band’s high-speed attack and ensures that even the busiest passages remain distinct. The clean yet heavy sound was innovative for its time and contributed to the album’s accessibility and enduring appeal[5]. ### **Pros** - Clean, balanced mix with every instrument audible - Retains raw energy while offering clarity - Powerful drum and guitar tones ### **Cons** - Some may find the production too polished compared to rawer thrash albums - Belladonna’s vocals occasionally get lost in the mix, especially during gang vocal sections[7] --- ## **Themes** ### **Key Motifs** - **Rebellion and Authority:** Songs like “I Am the Law” and “Caught in a Mosh” explore themes of authority, resistance, and frustration with the status quo. - **Social Justice and Awareness:** “Indians” and “One World” address historical and contemporary injustices, reflecting a socially conscious edge. - **Pop Culture and Escapism:** References to comics, horror, and celebrity culture (e.g., John Belushi) infuse the album with a sense of fun and relatability. - **Mortality and Loss:** “Horror of It All” is a somber tribute to Metallica’s Cliff Burton, adding emotional depth to the album[6]. ### **Balance of Fun and Seriousness** Anthrax’s willingness to blend serious topics with humor and pop culture references gives the album a unique personality. This approach makes the album accessible and enjoyable, even when tackling heavy subject matter[5][6]. --- ## **Influence and Legacy** ### **Impact on Thrash Metal** - *Among the Living* is widely regarded as a cornerstone of thrash metal, helping to define the genre’s sound in the late 1980s[5][4]. - The album’s fusion of hardcore punk energy, technical thrash musicianship, and melodic vocals influenced countless bands in the metal and hardcore scenes[4][5]. - Its success helped bring thrash into the mainstream, alongside albums by Metallica, Slayer, and Megadeth-the so-called “Big Four” of thrash[5]. ### **Cultural Influence** - The album’s pop culture references and humor set Anthrax apart from their peers, making them more relatable and broadening their appeal[5]. - Songs like “Caught in a Mosh” and “Indians” became anthems, with phrases entering the metal lexicon and live shows becoming legendary for their energy. ### **Enduring Appeal** - Decades after its release, *Among the Living* remains a staple of Anthrax’s live sets and a touchstone for new generations of metal fans[5]. - Its blend of energy, technical skill, and personality ensures its place as one of the defining albums of thrash metal. --- ## **Pros and Cons** | Pros | Cons | |----------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------| | Iconic riffs and solos | Some tracks feel formulaic or less inspired | | Memorable, melodic vocals | Gang vocals can become repetitive | | Tight, energetic band chemistry | Lyrics sometimes juvenile or simplistic | | Balanced, powerful production | Occasional loss of vocal clarity in the mix | | Wide thematic range (social issues, pop culture, humor) | Album peaks early, with later tracks not always matching the opener | | Influential and accessible-bridged underground and mainstream thrash | Some critics prefer more serious or raw approaches to thrash | --- ## **Conclusion** *Among the Living* is a thrash metal classic that stands out for its infectious energy, technical prowess, and unique blend of humor, pop culture, and social commentary. The album’s strengths-memorable riffs, melodic vocals, tight musicianship, and crisp production-have ensured its enduring influence and popularity. While not without flaws (occasional lyrical immaturity, some formulaic tracks, and a tendency to peak early), the album’s personality and impact far outweigh its shortcomings. *Among the Living* remains a must-listen for any metal fan and a defining statement of what makes thrash metal both thrilling and fun. > “We wanted to make a record that people could go crazy to, but also something that felt fun. Thrash didn’t have to be all doom and gloom-it could have energy and life.” > - Charlie Benante *Among the Living* captures that spirit perfectly-fierce, fun, and unforgettable.
What a pleasant surprise! I don't own and even don't know this album. The image of Anthrax din not appeal to me. And I think I listened to one other album when I was of the right age, but that wasn't my thing. This is! The star of the album is absolutely drummer Charlie Benante. His drumming is phenomenal, he really carries the band and leads them through the tempo changes smoothly as grease. Best songs? I guess the obvious ones: Caught in a mosh, and Indians - that has a nice hommage to Iron Maiden. And maybe the medley. Great!
Not bad. It’s a step up from punk but not quite metal. Thrash seems slightly more composed than punk in my eyes.
Anthrax's "Among The Living" does not fit into my usual musical preferences, so this was an adventure. While the album features a few intriguing hooks, aggressive guitar work, and driving drumming, I found the lyrics and vocals to be on the weaker side. I cannot state how good or bad this album is within the thrash-metal genre, but it is clear that it does not resonate with me. Kudos to those who enjoy it.
Good
I think someone who likes metal would like this, however I do not like metal. I can appreciate this is a good representation of the genre.
Certainly mosh-able, but I find the vocals to be weak. 50 minutes of thrash metal is too much for any mortal man. Standout track is: “Caught in A Mosh”
I've just heard something worse than this album yesterday that I gave a 1 star to so I felt I had to at least give this an extra star since it wasn't as bad. But still not something I would listen to again since this made me feel like I was having a heart attack.
Among The Living - 3/5 Caught In A Mosh - 5/5 I Am The Law - 5/5 Efilnikufesin (N.F.L) - 4/5 A Skeleton In The Closet - 2/5 Indians - 5/5 One World - 2/5 Medley: A.D.I. / Horror Of It All - 3/5 Imitation Of Life - 3/5 Average score: 3.5/5 (rounding down)
não é ruim não é bom é só metalzão
é decente! bem trashzera e tem umas partes bem hardcore/punk que são bacanas.
decent metal band. Not my genre but appreciated it
A blast, but I still think it's weaker than the best albums from the others in "The Big Four." Some cool song concepts, though.
Out of the Big 4 of thrash, Anthrax is the one that didn't catch my attention as much as the other 3, but this record is amazing and packed with energy.
Better than Coldplay.
I'm a grown up.
Rough, like crazy rough. Love Scott Ian, not a fan of Anthrax
i only knew them from the tony hawk pro skater 2 soundtrack before this. not a big thrash guy but this is pretty great.
Meh. I like some of the instrumentals here, but not a fan overall.
Bad production. Terrible drums. Terrible vocals. Not sure what I'm missing but not sure I feel I've missed much with Anthrax.
Way better than expected. This kind of goes crazy, kind of a vibe. Caught myself head bopping without realizing about 3 tracks in and I hardly stopped head banging.
Bueno
You know, I didn't anticipate this being the first time I enjoyed thrash metal, but it's nice to finally have an in to the genre.
Enjoyed this more than I thought not being much of a metalhead, but can see the influence of this on bands who came later. Decent.
slapped
Don't bother with much thrash now but this must still be one of my most listened-to albums ever. It's super fun, bouncy and catchy, very cartoony, two songs based on Stephen King stories and another about Judge Dredd. A proper classic for me, they don't deserve the shit they get
Didn't particularly enjoy this and I normally like this sort of thing
Not my genre
I've never heard an anthrax album all the way though. It's pretty awesome.
could i write poetry to this? y i did. it was bad middle school poetry but that’s not their fault
A great album by one of my favorite Metal bands.
Super fast drums. Cool riffs. Vocals you can understand. Good enough for a 3 from me.