Reviews (page 9 of 15)
I liked parts of this album. Some snippets of songs were enjoyable to me, mixing what I think is hip hop and country in some passages. But that’s the problem, it was just snippets. And these snippets, even though enjoyable, were surrounded by jumbled mashes of in my opinion just irritating noise, rather than music. So because of this it’s a 2 star for me
Not my music taste at all - which in some cases can be surprisingly good, but this didn’t do it for me. Weirded me out sometimes
Truly one of the weirdest and most innovative mainstream musical minds today.
la copertina è bella
30 yrs after the 1996 debut, the height of my new found curiousity w ph I had nver heard it in it's entirety.....loved it, way ahead of it's time.
A classic weirdo album, pretty cohesive in terms of the sounds that Beck used while definitely getting out there at times. Fun stuff but not something I can revisit all the time.
Very familiar with this one. Anything Beck is involved in is always unique, as I can't think of too many artists who can genre-bend like he does. He's an alt rock artist through and through, but you also hear some hip-hop in the composition/lyrical delivery/sampling, as well as some folk, country, and elements of psychedelia (with modern uses). I guess in the context of this album's release, Beck had already broken through with "Mellow Gold" a few years prior. "Odelay" can be seen as an extension of this success, but it forges its own path and features the aforementioned genre-fusions all throughout. The singles slap (primarily highlighted by "Where It's At") with some hidden gems here and there ("Hotwax", "Jack-Ass"). It gets a little noisy at some points (call it wasted space or experimentation, whatever), but this is still a strong album that represents one of the more creative works of the 1990s.
Damn this list loves Beck. This one’s a classic though.
I enjoyed this far more than I expected!
Un poco de aire fresco. Posteriormente ha reafirmado su valía en los siguientes discos.
Not bad - a bit samey, but decent background music whilst working.
I remember this being released. It's innovative and sounds amazing. I always loved Novocane and Devil's Haircut the most from this album, but I've found the enjoyment in Where It's At much more now I'm "grown".
Old classic for me. Good memories.
Loads of fun, great.
This was awesome!!
I'm certainly enjoying the variety of beck on this 1001 list. But putting the whole blokes discography on the list is a questionable choice. Guero I understood, Sea Change was an awakening for me. Less songs on this one resonated with me. Except Novacane that shit blew the lid off the mahfucka.
Surprisingly creative and varied. I listened to this albums years ago and didnt get nearly as much out of it. Beck has musical depth beyond most bands I’ve seen from the mid 90’s and their influence is clearly for the next decade.
Some classic jams on this one. It definitely sounds like the 90s
Another Beck album, there are a lot of them on this list. It was alright.
78/100.
Devils Haircut, i can tell he’s blown out many speakers before. The drums are so good by one min in, groove is lovely. “Coming to town with the briefcase blues” is fab. the alien esq noise is fun. i’m gonna call it the bridge where he muffles his vocals really suits the lines “ Rock ‘n’ roll, know what i’m saying? Everywhere i look there’s a devil waiting.” makes it feel like it’s proper inner thoughts. The outro being so distorted makes a lot of sense, ends up as a scream track. Hotwax, i felt like i’d heard the intro before, looked the samples used and a dodgy site told me there’s 11?! not sure how but it all works if that’s true. The quiet drum break mixed with a synth and trumpet?? very wild. He’s basically rapping, “Sitting in the kitchen wishing i was livin like a hitman” can relate. So he uses the melody of jingle bells to sing “I get down all the way” i like it. Making “I am a broken record, I have bubblegum in my brain” was a choice for sure. There’s a lot happening, i’m kind of getting used to how much shit he mixes together. “I’m the enchanting wizard of rhythm” great way to end a tune to be fair. Lord Only Knows, i didn’t appreciate the mini heat attack as an opener but we continue. This is giving country ish at the beginning. I appreciate that he loves a drum break, they just are cool. I think i understand the screaming at the beginning now, because this is pretty much a solid genre, he needed something to throw you off. He’s a nonsensical straight story teller. This had Odelay repeated, i’ve been saying it wrong. The New Pollution, sounds off the bat like a it could be a tune for a dr. suess movie. I’m liking the groove and the melody of this one, that chorus is great. A sax has entered the tune therefore it’s banging. Then a little synth solo. The scream of the guitar only lasted for a second. I think there could be flute in here too?? I have no idea what he’s trying to say about this woman but i think it’s clear he fancied her??! Derelict, he loves a shocking intro, it’s a choice. Very distorted vocals. Very intense lyrics, “I fell asleep in the funeral fire” is so graphic. Just had to google what a fallow field was so I learnt something. There’s som sitar and chromatic scales going on from like 2 mins in, it’s adding a lot to the tension of this track. The rhythm of how he says “derelict wind” is a small choice but i really like it. Novacane, rock forward. Drums again are strong. He’s rapping again. This feels like he was deffo listening to big American rappers of the 90s. Im thinking there a samples in here too. He’s good at using them. Half way through there’s no more lyrics coming at you. Honestly it’s hard to write rap that fast for long so i get it. The last minute has almost ruined it, the wall of distortion was too much. The drum beat (808 i think?) saved it kind of. Jack-Ass, a ballad? funny name. I like it so far half way along it’s been a break from the fast pace of the album. The keyboard motif is nice. a chilled drum beat has come back for the last minute. Joined with a harmonica. “i remember the way that you smiled” is a beautiful lyric. The animal? noise that the end not my fave choice. Where It’s At, i’m glad this has the intro, it’s a good one. Again he’s built a great groove from the start. This is more spoken word, got like a fun melody to it. The chorus of claps are great. “That was a good drum break” was just said, told you he loved em. “Shine your shoes with your microphone blues” fave line. There’s so many fucking weird sounds all the time, and as much as I don’t love it they work. Two turn tables and a mic area all he needs clearly. The horns he’s adding in and taking out are stunning. This is a party song, even more impressive if it’s someone’s karaoke pick. Good crowd work opportunity. Minus, STRONG bass line. Just said karaoke how funny. This song happened so fast and distorted that it’s hard to pick apart. It’s very tight. He does however end it by saying “frogs, frogs” and I am a lover of that animal. The mix of screaming, distortion and alien noises play out the end of this track. Sissyneck, starts with a loud whistling. I’m assuming this is about being somewhat of a redneck. I like the chorus melody. The backing feels fitting, it’s country with a rap drum beat, something he clearly loves to mix. “Cause nobody knows, When the good times have passed out cold” is a sentiment I understand. He’s not here to comfort you. The ending makes sure of that. Readymade, indie is in my ears. “And my bags are waiting in the next life.” is devastating. The horns that come in feel contemplative like the whole song does. High 5, love the guitar but it’s outshone by a lot going on. This must be a lot of samples. This isn’t my favourite, but i can understand that this is unprecedented as a single track, let alone the album as a whole. “what’s wrong with you man? Get the other record. Damn.” A very fitting sample for this. Ramshackle, this after the last song is exactly what listeners need. It feels like this is as mellow as he can go. “We will go, Nowhere we know, ‘Till we find our one and all.” This feels like he’s yearning for a quiet space. The whole album does feel like a 26 year old has so many ideas that he’s got out but he’s still chasing something he can’t quite find yet. This song feels important and simple. Diskobox, if he ended it any differently it wouldn’t have made sense. The screaming, the distortion, the crazy noises, samples, alien sounds, horns, the mega drums and their breaks are all here to party. I for one cannot even make out a story and it doesn’t matter, this is just a culmination of what all the album is. I’ve never heard anything like this album but i may not be rushing to put it on repeat unless i really neeed a scream, so could be soon tbf. I’m giving it a 4, he intrigues me but im also very slightly scared.
Album cover 100% matches the sound. I feel like I can’t call Beck “Slacker rock” because this dude definitely doesn’t slack from how he bounces all around. Yet the end product feels…lackadaisical. It’s the type of album that a guy with multiple bongs on the coffee table and a divot in the couch (that he got for free off Craigslist) from where he always sits would bump. I can smell the stale air when I hear this album. The type of guy that has no ambition in real life but manages to engineer heinous contraptions and skillfully manipulate the scariest dealers in order to smoke 10% more weed 15% more efficiently would love this album. I guess I was too stone cold sober for this to click for me
yay Beck! 4/5
Decent album, quite like Beck
Funnnnnnnn
Overrated Beck. Critics and award givers missed the “Mellow Gold” boat and wanted to reward Beck. “Mellow Gold” is a much better album with a cohesive sound. This is a transition album with lots of experimentation. Not bad, just kind of average and all over the place. I would “Mellow Gold”, “Colors”, “Sea Change” and “Midnite Vultures” on as stronger albums well before a-ok “Odelay.”
Ok
Some decent tunes. But awfully inconsistent, and really just unenjoyable.
Fun to listen to. Beck is a musical chameleon. I have zero idea what the lyrics are about though.
Yes to the horns on The New Pollution! Can I have a GameCube and a copy of SSX3 to go with Derelict??
Wish I was cool enough to listen to Beck in 3rd grade. I really liked this album - though maybe not as much as I thought. It took me a couple listening sessions to finish and found the middle part of the album a little rambling. That said, Ramshackle is a sleeper hit and have been listening on repeat. Giving this a 4.
This was a very important album of my adolescence. All these years later, it still sounds somehow sent back from the future. Would I love it if I were encountering it now for the first time? I don’t know. I can’t actually imagine choosing to sit and listen to it all the way through anymore. Some of it gets pretty noisy. Still, it holds up—the epic Dust Brothers production, Beck’s off-kilter but weirdly poignant lyrics … and of course, Where It’s At.
I'd put Guero or Mellow Gold above this one but I like being in Beck's atmosphere so 4 stars
Most of the songs are so good that I forgive the others. I love Sissyneck.
so good, never gets old, will have this on repeat for the rest of my life
Day 85 - Jan 22nd?, 2025 In Beck we trust o7 4/5
Amazing production. Every song sounds like it's on the same album, even with a ton of different "genres". Awesome mash of folk with a Beastie Boys style of rock and hip hop
Great early career album. Has some of my favorite songs by him on it.
Ok. I guess. There's a couple songs that are still somewhat known. Saw Beck live, and his acoustic stuff is much better. 3 stars.
……….. 1?
Beck was a pretty cool guy
Great album, terrible person
Starts hard. Nice. Some songs are experimental in a good way, others in a not so good way. Novacane is hard on the ears.
Very good
"Who are you?" "I'm the wizard of rhythm" "Why did you come here?" "I came here to tell you about the rhythms of the universe" I didn't expect this album to be so good. It isn't my usual style but I could see it really growing on me over time. I'm giving it a 4 though because some of the tracks aren't as good as others.
Está bueno! Me recordó mi noventera adolescencia. Varios temazos geniales de los que ni me acordaba. Buen disco, sí lo escucharé de nuevo.
I listened to this on repeat when it first came out
Elska Beck þótt hann skuldi okkur tónleika. Mjög weird plata en á góðan hátt. Veist í raun aldrei hverju þú átt að búast við í næsta lagi. Gæti verið tekið upp í einhverjum kjallara í miðbænum. Hrátt, skrítið og töff.
Beck er snillingur. Alltaf frumlegur og með sinn stíl en samt í takt við tíðarandann.
Saw someone describe this as being as if the Beastie Boys made Revolver and I have to agree Favourite Track: Hotwax Least Fav Track: High 5 (Rock the Catskills)
A nice and summery album that feels very at-home in the 1990's.
Such a well constructed album. Love Beck. Love this album.
Pretty good.
This was a fun listen! I enjoyed the instrumentals, though vocal work was a bit here and there at times. 'Where It's At' was my fave.
Favorite Track: Devils Haircut
I feel like I just missed the boat on Beck. Maybe earlier in life it could have worked for me, but it feels basic, boring, and flat.
Solid Beck album but probably not my favorite. His lyrics get a bit redundant but the instrumental experimentation from track to track is ear-grabbing. The tempo is consistent which is good but it's a little too upbeat for my liking.
Next time I'm in LA I'll be listening to this album in stop and go traffic. Really captures the culture
This is very different from the first Beck album on here (Sea Change, #182). That one was great, but a major downer. This one is from eight years earlier, and it's much more upbeat. This is kind of an interesting album, it feels pretty hard to pin down a genre. It's kind of rock-y at times, but also lots of hip hop and electronic music elements, plus lots of sampling. I don't hate this album or anything, it's definitely an interesting listen. For some reason I just can't quite shake the feeling that it hasn't aged very well though. This seems to have gotten pretty significant acclaim at the time, but I don't think it's quite doing it for me. I think it might be the '90s hip hop elements that feel a bit dated now, plus the rap-rock thing that might have been a bit more novel at the time but is a bit played out at this point. At times he also slows it down and gets a bit more folk-y, and honestly I think I like that more. It's likely more related to my music taste than anything, but he does have pretty good range. Anyway, I'm glad I heard this and there's some solid songs on here, but I don't see myself coming back to this really. I do respect artists taking some chances though, and it feels like Beck did that here. Favorite song: Ramshackle Other: Devils Haircut, Lord Only Knows, The New Pollution, Jack-Ass, Where It's At, Sissyneck 1/13/25
Fun but dated, esp the "noisy" tracks.
Two cool songs but the rest are just meh.
Did not love the robot, feedback, aol dial up noises. Did like jackass and where it’s at has such great funk and beats.
Quirky, Meh, a few classics i loved
Unfortunately I have never liked Beck even though I am a guitarist and probably should be a big fan of him, and this album just kinda reinforced that. There would be these great beats and great bass lines, but he seems obsessed with squeals and high treble dissonance that just takes me clean out of the song. Also he sings like he’s bored and then I’m bored listening. I’m sorry.
genre: rock pop alternative 90s random. i loved it!
Rad album!!
3.5-4/5
This is an interesting mix of genres. Unfortunately interesting doesn’t necessarily equate to enjoyable. This is just a bit too weird for me. Still, some good bits.
I liked the sound of this. I listened to it while helping someone with a lettering task, so I wasn’t totally present. However, it was groovy!
In my view, there is such a thing as "too eclectic" in an album. In my view, this album is a prime example of that. Two stars because apart from a couple of tracks, I didn't really like it.. and all the random noises didn't help.
Look, i really wanted to like Odelay considering that i listened to the other two Beck albums on the project with Sea Change and especially Guero being some good albums but i just can't like this one. I personally feel that this album has a huge identity crisis as it just doesn't know whether it wants to be rock, country, hip hop or electronic. This causes the album to try too many random things with almost none of them working out in the album's favor. I typically like it when albums are more unique and weird but this one tries to be those things so hard that it just forgets to make an album i would enjoy listening to. Best Song: Devils Haircut Worst Song: Computer Rock Side note: Since i have done every Beck album on this project, i will rank all his albums here: 1. Guero 2. Sea Change 3. Odelay
Unique, even amongst Beck‘s oeuvre.
Beck is fucking garbage
It’s great. Some true masterpieces. But not all time awesome
Avant Garde end of the century attempt to bend the senses. Harmonies, heavy gain bass, record scratches, samples, harmonicas, organs, 808s, drum machines and reversed sitars. All stuff I love but not mixed together. But I see the stuff Beck likes. Loved folk, rap, rock,The Beatles. One song I like so far is Novacane but maybe because it reminds me a bit of a MF doom song. Apart from this middle song there’s not a lot I love. Just wished I wasn’t half way through. Non linear song writing/structure doesn’t do anything for me. If I think of why he made this album I’d have to guess: An ode to everything he loved and presenting the amalgamation of those influences in one person. Him. But like I say doesn’t do anything for me. You can find loads of cool sounds like the organ in Where it at or the 808s in Novacane. You’d find plenty to sample and reuse. So cool sounds but loads of annoying sounds done to be abrasive or attention grabbing.
i feel like 3 beck albums on this list is excessive
Another solid album from Beck. I liked the blend between country, hip hop and alt. Makes it a very unique record
Favoute song - devil's haircut
Really fun and creative album! Pretty all over the place creatively and genre-wise, but in my opinion that doesn’t hurt it. It’s constantly entertaining and inspiring. The Dust Brothers production shows clearly, as many of the songs are reminiscent of the Beastie Boys, in a great way. The album sounds remarkably fresh still, and wouldn’t be out of place if it was released today. The songs are catchy and memorable, with enough dissonance and chaos thrown in to keep you on your toes. Again fun to listen to, and can hear its influence resonating in many indie and alternative albums from the late 90s and 2000s
I moved.
one of the most experimental albums i’ve ever heard. i actually enjoyed it mostly
Visibly cringed at “I’m the enchanted wizard of rhythm” and the album never really won me back round after that
Some of the finest from Beck. To this day it still sounds completely different from most other rock that was coming out at this time, in a good way. And the album has some solid songs on it besides the hits that got radio play, like Lord Only Knows (which almost sounds like it could have been on Sea Change) and Sissyneck.
This album didn’t do a whole lot for me, it was very noisy - ironically. Some of the noises were nice and tricked me into thinking the overall tone of the album was going to change, but it always came back to the same surf grunge that has its place but is not with me. I will say that it took me Oceanside immediately. I could almost hear skateboarders, palm trees in the wind, tires squealing in the background and feel the heat radiating off of a West Coast asphalt. Very funky and good beats, I like the attitude, the energy, and the complexity of this album… But would not be my go to to get in touch with myself. It might be something about my 13-year-old self would be VERY into. That being said, the quality was good enough that I would be willing to explore more of Beck’s music to find my personal hidden gems. Overall: good vibes, musically talented, hidden innuendos, and various moods to appreciate for the casual, grunge loving listener.
cool
Trippy. I knew a few songs on this album. The songs resonate more when the hook is really good. It seems this would be better if you were tripping. Good album.
First listen. Ok. Not quite my cup of tea.
the first introductory notes had that distinct Beck sound, its interesting how that works. Pretty enjoyable album. I'm not much of a Beck fan myself, but I've always been able to appreciate his music. I like how varied he gets from time to time, sometimes its successful, sometimes not so much, but I like the effort (Hotwax has so much going on in it, especially the latter half). I can definitely say I've never been bored listening to a Beck album, he is wholly unique. My only other gripe is that the album runs a bit long, but its still fairly enjoyable.
Love this album. A little too much yelling and shrieking to give it 5 stars but nobody makes music like Beck. This album is a really good example of early Beck
It was okay. Some tracks were great but I have always felt like this album was overhyped.
Favourites: Devils Haircut, The New Pollution, Jack-Ass, Sissyneck
strange
Nice album...
Experimentation for experimentation's sake is maybe the most positive thing I can say about this. Boring and repetitive are soem of the less positive things to say.
Apart from a couple of good songs, the album is mostly bland noise.
such a mix, but generally really good. some of this feels like trip hop, but some is more rock. Negatives are i dont think the weird distorted screaming works too well, and some of the rap bits are really cringe. Favorite songs: first 2, novacane, sissyneck, high 5. Overall around 8/10
Love this. One of my favourite albums from my teens. Easy 5.
There's some decent songs here but it's clear his approach needed more work 2.5*
Brilliant album. Very groundbreaking at the time
I loved one song and appreciate the other - such yalent
Beck var länge sen. Världsklass när han är som bäst, men lite för ojämn. Fyra
i knew nothing about this album before hearing it. i assumed it’d be a country album and i’m glad it wasn’t. beck is a person who just makes cool music, idk why i don’t get into it more. great album i love how its kinda experimental, it makes it unique. highlights: devils haircut novacane minus
4.8
Meh
So many gems. Outstanding.
Feels like an extension of that Mello Gold, Loser era of Beck. I like Loser but not that much. Nothing really hit as a result. I prefer the more experimental Beck we got on Sea Change. Not that I’m comparing and contrasting but stating my preference as to why quintessential Beck did nothing for me.
Not a terrible record by any means, just a little too artsy for me. There are some solid songs here, but most are just too out there in my opinion.
This is a great album, definitely the best from Beck. “Devil’s Haircut,” “Hotwax,” “The New Pollution,” and “Where It’s At” are the best tracks. I kept listening to those on repeat because I enjoy them so much, which might be my 90s nostalgia talking, but they’re objectively good songs. The album falls off a little at the end, but overall it’s solid and worthy of its place on this list.
Day350 - i remember buying this and loving it and now revisiting it really brings it back
Some great tracks on here, but also a bit of Beck being Beck.
groovy. 4.5/5
Beck is sorta hit-or-miss with me... He offers flashes of brilliance but then muddles it all up with what can only be described as noise... I can appreciate an artist wanting to mashup genres, but it's always seemed to me that Beck mixes in one part glorious with two parts laborious... I'll give it a 2 because I do enjoy the singles, The New Pollution and Where It's At, but I really must flush the rest of this rackety rot...
Finally an album I’m familiar with. This is an interesting one for me. I had a weird Beck phase when I was younger. So, the nostalgia alone wants me to rate this high. I am reminded that I don’t like all of his work though. When Beck can show restraint he knocks it out of the park. When he doesn’t, I feel I’m getting whiplash. Then the anxiety comes in as I don’t know what to expect on the next track. Hell even on the same track you might be surprised how the song ends. Sometimes it works, and sometimes it becomes irritating. Overall the good outweighs the bad.
Pretty solid album for me. Some nice songs but nothing really stood out to me. Overall it was fine
Strange album. It feels like Beck was so preoccupied with jamming every possible genre, instrument, and sound effect into this record, that he forgot to actually make a cohesive album of good songs. It’s eclectic, and that’s not necessarily a bad thing in and of itself, but it feels so random and disorganized that it’s really hard to enjoy it. “Hotwax” is almost offensive in its attempts to capture some kind of backwoods country western sound. I think I can mostly sum this record up as if you took Modest Mouse, made them terrible somehow, and tossed that in a blender with every early 90’s white boy rapper. 1*. No bueno.
I can see why someone would not like this album. It's kind of all over the place and lacks a unifying sound or feeling. It almost feels like someone trying on several different styles to see where they want to go musically. Personally, I like that about this album. It's fun to listen to and I think Beck & co manage to venture into different genres without feeling like they're satirizing or caricaturizing them. Beck has a knack for writing catchy melodies into songs that are overall pretty weird. "Lord Only Knows" is a really fun twangy alt rock jaunt. I love the drums on "The New Pollution" as well as the brief flourishes from horns and woodwinds. "Derelict" makes really cool use of several percussion instruments to give almost an exotica vibe with an awesome tabla interlude halfway through. This was probably my favorite track. My least favorite thing on this album is the annoying almost-rapping he sometimes does on tracks like "Novacane". Beck is a very creative dude. He is a very weird dude. I appreciate that and I like that this album feels like shuffling through a million different radio stations. A couple songs aren't my cup of tea, but overall I find this to be a fun album. 8/10
Why on earth does he keep trying to rap. He shouldn't. Ever. Ruins many a good song on this album.
7/10
Beck's output gets better as he ages, but this is still an early one . Not much else sounded like this back then, although i can see how new listeners would be nonplussed. best tracks: jack ass , new pollution. 3.5
This is such an excellent album. Beck's creativity and genre exploration are so natural, and certainly helped me and countless other 90s kids understand that punk, hip hop, folk, country, disco, and any other shape of music can work together and sound fascinating and even beautiful. I whistle the intro to "Sissyneck" regularly.
Enjoyed a lot of this, it was a bit nutty and really fun
A very good well produced album. A little on the long side but I enjoyed it
I don't get it I guess. He try to be innovative and strange, but it doesn't work well resulting boring. Some songs are cool, but I wouldn't relisten this album
Didn't do anything for me.
Cracking album, but I did enjoy Guero more
I liked it a lot, but I wish it was a bit less quirky.
Lovely background music. No single tune grabbed me to make me want to repeat.
This album was peak Beck for me, not the biggest fan but this style of alternative rap rockish songs are what I like most from his discography. Favorite songs were: 1. Devils Haircut 2. Hotwax 8. Where it's at 7/10
I was not in the mood for this today, but I could tell I would like it if I were in a different, Beckier mood. Album cover: (B+) I like the mop dog, but not the font.
Not a fan
This is such a strange album. It's all over the place. I don't know anything about Beck but I didn't know he was so hip-hop? Why does this sound like a Beastie Boys record half the time? The other half of the time its soft acoustic music? Did he make this album at two completely separate times in his life? "Where It's At" was my favorite song, and "Ramshackle" was my second favorite song. These songs should not be on the same album. 7/10. Weird stuff. Pretty good though.
Love this album. Such interesting sounds used and great lyrics as well
Wasn't my jam. Not sure why
Beck has an almost poetic way of blending genres and creating wild and creative beats while also throwing in nonsense for lyrics ( catchy nonsense). I think he's trying to influence us all on a subconscious level we don't full understand yet. A true artist.
Not terrible but really a disappointment coming from just having listened to Guero. Devils haircut and Where its at were highlights but you can kinda tell he was going for a couple more radio friendly singles with those.
Going down to Houston, To the house of dance. Going down to Houston, To get me some pants.
Jack-Ass is pretty good. Most of the songs ending with some weirdass sounds really not my thing tho.
Too stripped back for me
Worse than the other Beck album
Some good, mostly forgettable. ‘Minus’ is a highlight but a lot of it feels like background music. Quite strange how it flips between genres.
Better than Guero!
I freaking LOVE this. Every track goes a different direction but they're all so seamlessly put together. Drums in the back are awesome, and whatever tf he decides to do with his voice always pays off. The word gruff is a great way to describe this Fav Songs: Devils Haircut, Minus, High 5 (Rock the Catskills)
Pretty good.
Hate the cover, but love the originality of the songs.
This was a fun and interesting listen. You get mix of different types of genres that will have you either pondering, intrigued, or turn you into a smooth brain with drool dripping from your mouth. And I love that! I can't ever get bored listening to this guy. Top 3 Favorites: Devil Haircut, The New Pollution, and Ramshackle No bad songs but the second half of Novacane turned me into a retard with all those weird sounds and I'm still trying to figure out if it's the best song or the worst but probably the latter. 3.50-3.75/5 3.50-3.75/5
Beck has always been one of those interesting artists who I never quite fully warmed up to. The talent is obvious, and the music is usually interesting. But something about it never grabbed me. I always thought he was trying too hard to sound like he didn’t care. Maybe that’s because I never took the time to sit down with an entire album. I like Odelay quite a bit with this listening. I’m not sure I’d ever add Beck into my regular rotation, but I’ll be glad to hear these songs when I run across them again. https://open.substack.com/pub/richcain/p/project-1001-odelay-by-beck?r=4ztyq&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
Typical Beck fare. Has the futurama song on the album but it’s a good easy listening jam for a chilled morning
Mostly good. 3/5
Lil - 7 Eva - 4
For me, the deeper cuts on this album didn't sonically cover any new ground from the singles off of it. It was a little ho hum for me.
Love this album, came out the year i graduated and i went to see beck and no doubt at the shoreline not long after. Listening to it again, i was struck by the consistent tone no matter the song.
Manic and experimental, wild and weird, there’s nothing quite like it. So many of these songs (and the entire album in general) feel haphazard and randomly stitched together and yet everything clicks. Every sudden genre switch, every vocal effect and every sound effect feels like it’s right where it’s supposed to be.
Hell yeah. Great album.
Experimental, different sounds, 90’s
Almost a 5
The 90s is my black hole. Neither mine nor my parents era, but you hear of it as a great time for indie/alt rock (depending on if you are British or American). Neither label fits. The bands aren't independent and the only alternative about the rock is that it doesn't rock. This fits the bill for the genre. It has a heavy experimental side and hip hop influence but deep down it wants to be a rock record. But it doesn't rock. It just screams LA bubble
What a banger!
alr its been awhile but I miss finding new music I like Beck? idk i've listened to him some but never more than like 2 songs lmfao Devils Haircut Hotwax The New Pollution?! Where its At Sissyneck!!! Ramshackle!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This album rocked?! it was such an odd mix of rock, punk, hip hop, and then some melodic acoustic comes in from the top rope?! Crazy Work GG Some songs were weird and this wont be a constant front to back relisten but it absolutely deserves a spot in this list
I remember my friend Peter bringing “Loser” around in our medical school study area (maybe there was subtext?), and it blowing up everyone’s well-coifed Pet Shop Boys-like heads. How do you follow up being so original? Then this messy, groundbreaking, nonsensical masterpiece arrived and cemented him forever as the best poet of slide guitar. And he’s still doing it oh so well. Foundational for him and for all of us listening.
90s classic. This album sounded so fresh when it was released and although it has lost some of that excitement I had when I first heard it, I still think this is an excellent album front to back. The production is rich and the songs sound fantastic. High Five
A pretty great album, probably a five for how much I loved it in the day. Still very strong.
Indisputably one of the best albums of the mid 90s. I remember being quite intrigued by the nonsensical lyrics back then - yes - he actually is singing about his time being a piece of wax that's falling on a termite that's choking on the splinters. Oh, OK then. It's not about the lyrics - it's about how the sound of his voice fits in with the music, and the music is delightful.
Loved this album—the way the genres blend and the diversity of sounds used is incredible. I'll probably have to give it another listen, but man, songs like "Derelict," "High 5," and "Lord Only Knows" were some of my favorites. There were a few tracks in the middle that weren’t as amazing, yet they were still good. I think I’m feeling a 5 on my first listen, might bump it down to a very high 4 though.
Finally, something good!
Not for me.
Super fun album. It feels like going to a party unstuck in time. There's something for everyone in here
3.5.
Beck is one of the rare artists who defies a genre and defines his own music. Personal enjoyment: 4/5 Relevance to this list: 4/5
Vorige Beck album was dodelijk saai. Deze is dat eigenlijk ook, ondanks de poging om het spannend te maken met een ongevraagde schreeuw tussendoor. Ik ben er van overtuigd dat dat er alleen maar in zit om te zorgen dat de luisteraar niet echt compleet in slaap valt. Novacane is een bizar nummer met rare bleeps en bloops ofzo. Maar ook een soort dikke hiphop kick? Bizar nummer. Maar wel interessant, kan ik van veel van Becks muziek niet zeggen! Maar WAT is het idee om eerst dat bizarre nummer te hebben en dan meteen weer de meest zaaddodende alternative rock aller tijden er vlak achter? Weet Beck iets wat ik niet weet? Dit album is dus eigenlijk toch minder saai dan gedacht, het is zelfs vrij experimenteel. Jammer alleen dat het niet heel goed is... FAVO: The New Pollution, Novacane
Loved it
i fw this heavy
own
A transcending blockbuster that is like any other. The perfect sophomore album (yes he had One Foot in the Grave) in the mainstream to crush expectations and cement Beck's legacy as an artist that cannot be matched.
Yeah this was not my thing. It felt more annoying than anything.
The heck was that??
Never listened to this album before and I really did enjoy it. Some songs I absolutely loved but others I just couldn’t get into. Spanned so many genres which was impressive but as an album felt a bit inconsistent
Not at great as I remember. Super creative and some good catchy beats, but the use of random electronic sounds kills it for me. Gotta run to turn it down!
Talented but nothing I need
It's not awful, and it has some very interesting parts and nice hooks here and there, but on the whole just isn't something that holds my attention. Certainly better than Sea Change, but I think I just don't like Beck.
I tried liking this, I really did
Such a versatile artist. Not his best album, but still good.
Jagged, kaleidoscopic LP which meanders between Hip Hop, Folk, Grunge, and Pop. Lots of Breakbeats, Scratching, Riffs, Distortion, Samples. Standout Tracks: The New Pollution, Where It's At, Devil's Haircut, Lord Only Knows.
This record holds up! Fun flashback to my high school era.
Not my favorite Beck
Not bad. Not good. Only ended up adding one to my playlist but some others had good sounds and that’s good enough for a 2 for me!
No private session used for Spotify. I love this album, I was amazed by what it blends musically. I got into Beck previous albums and became a fan of the Dust brothers. I love every track on this album.
I liked this, but it's not my favorite Beck album.
Didn’t recognize any song titles but I sure knew the tracks as soon as they played! Great mix of styles and sounds, really good album! I didn’t love every track but having a hard time finding negatives, would easily listen again, and therefore giving it 5/5
ight
This album was fun. Def not my favorite but I enjoyed it. Some people talk about Beck like a guitar god and I'm not sure about that. There are fun guitar licks and parts and it's very good, but this album didn't have me go that far. Anyway, I did enjoy this album. I'm definitely willing to try more Beck. However, what the fuck was "Computer Rock." I hate ending albums with songs like that lolol Liked Songs: "Devils Haircut" , "Hotwax" , "Lord Only Knows" , "Novacane" , "Where It's At" , "Minus" , "Readymade" , "Ramshackle"
liked songs: Derelict Some of the songs were more annoying to me than anything else. There are definitely interesting things happening, but I don't understand how this makes any list of the best albums ever. 2
I would've thought that I liked Beck, but now I've listened to the whole thing. And I still think he's neat, but this mostly isn't good music.
Cool sounding album, but it gets boring really quick.
Ei lain huono, pitäisi kuunnella uudelleen. Yhden kerran perusteella 3/5.
Listened to some later Beck stuff lately and he's fundamentally the same musician as always, he can write a catchy riff and beat, uses a lot of fun samples. It's not something I'd want to listen to a lot, but a beck song now and then is nice
I grew up listening to this album but unfortunately it hasn't aged well. Only the hits have stood the test of time, including: Devils Haircut, the New Pollution, Where it's At, and High 5. Outside of those, the songs were underwhelming or too "experimental" for their own good. 4/14 songs is not a good ratio (1.4/5), however the quality of the good songs bumps the up a tad. 2/5
Paar aardige nummers, het album begint leuk met devils haircut bijvoorbeeld, maar de meeste nummers niet zo interessant.
Probably 3.5 stars. Beck is good at expressing the mood of the country.
Was ok, didn’t wow me
Some absolute classics and clearly a very strong album but I've always struggled a little to really get into Beck. Relistening to this album hasn't changed that view- think it might be my fault though...
Nothing screams 90s louder than Beck. Never got into him.
Beck is Beck. I do like how he plays with genres, but I never seek out his music and it never really sticks with me. I don't think this will be an exception.
Similar thoughts to the previous Beck album, probably needs a few more listens to appreciate. Generally it was very noisy. Devils Haircut is huge 3.5/5
Had 2 beck albums now and enjoyed both, felt this was better listen as a whole. Tailed off a bit but overall great listen
Do you know I’d forgotten all about this album! I used to listen to this all the time way back when. Very clever, very musical and very enjoyable, thanks for the reminder!
Unforgettable innovation
It was a long time ago. I don't remember it, but it was probably good.
I thought I knew Beck based on some of the songs that were released and played on the radio that really doesn’t capture his weird, eclectic style. An enjoyable listen.
Beck is such a weird dude, and I love it. This album is so unique it’s hard to describe exactly what I like about it, but it do. Looking forward to nailing it down in a few more listens.
Forgotten
Another 'whatever' album that I will never think about ever again
People that like this honestly have their head too far up Beck's ass to see that this album was crap. Just all over the place and none of it was really all that great. Pretty disappointing considering that he's a really talented musician and has plenty of awards. 4/10.
Not bad, not something to listen to often, but for once it was a nice record
Love the hits but not a fan of the sings towards the end of the album.
Love the sound
Wowwww this album is all over the place. Hate and love the album but I'm not sure which side I'm on. The mix is amazing on this album but annoyingly amazing? I don't know. Would have picked 2 stars but went for 3 because it's so unique.
Some fun moments and some singles I loved, but felt quite all over the place as a whole album. Possibly didn’t have the optimal listening situation today though.
I'd heard of Beck but never really listened to him. I found this album very disappointing. I couldn't get into it. It seemed very disjointed.
Good god this album is annoying. Before I listened to it I would have said I was a fan of Beck’s based on the singles, so I was surprised to find how much I disliked this onslaught on nonsensical noise. Just awful.
If you’d asked me ‘what style of music Beck is’ I’d have probably have said Indie. So I was quite surprised to listen to this album. Is it erm rap? I’m not quite sure what it is. I sort of appreciate that it’s quite different and complex. But still it wasn’t for me on the first listen. On the second listen I started to like it more from ‘the new pollution’. There are some definite classics. I started to think he sounded like the bloke from Fontaines DC (though obviously the other way round). And that made me like it a bit more. But yeah probably wouldn’t listen again.
One of the best albums of the 90s. So inventive, so melodic, so fun, so different to other popular albums at the time. And just so good.
I definitely am a bigger fan of other Beck albums, but nonetheless a cool album if not a little chaotic!
Great album reminding me that the 90’s is my favourite musical decade. Beck puts together a broad range of tracks which flow really well as an album. He’s gone on & consistently delivered a great collection of music touching many music genres..thank you Beck 🙏
Oh-Delay, apparently would have been the underlaying meaning of the title of this album. Although it only came out 2 years after Beck's previous album, with the hit single Loser on it. This is a real eclectic mix of style often described as hip-folk, where we can hear Beck's monosyllabic voice rapping and singing. And it's this mix of styles that I couldn't really get on with. I'm glad I listened to it a few times, but this antithesis of Kurt Cobain I could not get on with. Give me Eels, give me Weezer.
For as much as I'm a fanboy of the 90's alternative scene, I never had this album or listened to it. Only the hits that are on Sirius/XM Lithium and Alt Nation from time to time. It's excellent and one I'll be going back to from time to time.
For some reason, despite knowing next to nothing about Beck, I've always been put off by him; or something like that. Doesn't make any sense. This weird preconceived aversion tainted part of my initial listen to Odelay, but I quickly came around to it and gave it an immediate second listen. It's great! Eclectic in a way I wasn't expecting. The hip-hop and turntablism influence was an interesting surprise that I quite enjoyed.
Está bueno, diferentes sonidos, me gusta eso
I listened to this album a bunch. I think Becks biggest flaw is inconsistency, because the good songs on this are incredible. And then Rock the Catskills is one of the worst songs I’ve ever heard in my life.
3/5. I don't think I really have an issue with this album, and the songs are good but there is a weird sense I get from listening to Beck in general. Nothing to do with the guy, just a vibe like my ears don't like it when I can agree it is very good. Opinions are allowed of course, and my opinion is that I don't like the album even though I do enjoy the listening experience. It's not quite pretention but it's not authentic either. The songs are well-written and unique and the genre changes are wonderful, love that. Just don't think I like the album though, just the feeling. It's getting a 3 because I can't move it either way honestly. Best Song: Devil's Haircut, Lord Only Knows, Where It's At
I have a similar feeling on Beck as with Beastie Boys, especially this earlier stuff. The highs are bonkers high and the mid stuff is pretty mid. It's tough to put together a full album of music that at times is just incomprehensible word salad and strange metaphors--maybe there are too many tracks. As far as a full album I would go 3.5, but Devil's haircut alone bumps it up to 4. I think he gets better after this with Guero (also rated a 4) and Sea Change, but I'm surprised he is never really at a 5 for me.
No strong feelings, some odd tracks
Still bonkers, still just as creative 30 years later
Horrid.
This album and its predecessor, Mellow Gold, really opened my mind up musically in high school. One thing that always captivated me was Beck’s ability to explore numerous musical styles while maintaining his distinct sound. “The New Pollution,” “Derelict,” “Jack-Ass” and “Ramshackle” are favorites of mine from this classic. Sea Change, Mutations and Modern Guilt are my favorite Beck albums but this one is right behind those so I’ll give it a 4.
Beck has only gotten better over time. I was a huge fan of Mellow Gold when it came out. This one was the next evolution for him. This doesn't have some of the gloomy, weird style songs that were on mellow gold, but still has some of the flavor. I think it's more mature, but he's still figuring it out. I like New Pollution as a favorite "hit", and Readymade as the deep cut. Not my favorite Beck album, but I'll give it a solid 4.
It would be fun to write a song like Beck. *hits blunt* *Drum machine and dial-up modem sounds begin* Slipshod ragamuffin tumbleweed Buckshot toilet paper killer bees Defcon one inside mi cabeza Por favor güey, leggo my Eggo *Theremin solo* This irreverent Mad-Libs style of lyrics doesn't bother me from Beck, though it might from someone else. On his early albums, it quickly became established that this was basically his whole deal. Don't look to this album for lyrical insights. But this is still a fun album that pulls from a lot of different sources to end up with something pretty inventive and cool.
A unique, retro sound from a unique guy. Beck always keeps things interesting and original. I like Devil's Haircut and especially New Pollution. I was never a big fan of Where It's At.
It turns out that 54 minutes is a lot of minutes to listen to Beck. I've always thought that I'd love Beck if I put in some effort, but I've always bounced off his music. Here I am, bouncing off it again. Yeah, it should be on this list, but I won't listen to it again.
Epic!
Not even sure what I just listened too. Mostly a mess with a few songs not too bad.
If it ain't perfect, it ain't far off.
Solid 3.7
Not terrible, but not something I’d come back to and listen to again. Made the mistake of listening with AirPods in—the instrumentals are a bit screechy and tough on the ear that way. Probably better on just a regular speaker.
# 346 : Good album, I like it, it has a hit or two. Would not buy this, but would listen again. Favourite track ; Devils Haircut
Not my type of music
Lyrically meh sonically yeah
Haven’t revisited this one in ages. Still holds up. Not better than Sea Change or most of his other stuff for that matter, but still a fun listen.
Nice variety
I’ve always somewhat liked Beck. This album sounds like what Kid Rock would be if he were less trashy. For some reason, that realization makes me like Beck a little less.
So different from other rap/hip hop albums. 3.5 that could be rounded up or down depending on the day.
I haven't listened to this album in a while and I appreciate it more in the context of this project.
Might be tempted to go 3.5* if it were an option. Enough stuff I don't like on this album, though, to prevent 4*. Some noisy nonsense here and there. I like Beck, but I don't LIKE like Beck.
While Beck has some really iconic songs on here, this still just feels like surreptitious propaganda for scientology.
The best of Beck's joke albums.
Hadn't heard of Beck before so was glad to listen to this artist, particularly the variety of styles and sounds this album contains but a bit too chaotic for me tbh
It takes a lot for an album to wow me... this one did not succeed. Had a few bangers (1).
Not for me
I’ve always liked and enjoyed a lot of Beck’s more well known songs, and I liked Mellow Gold when it came out. Yet after that album I never really listened to any of his releases in full. So Odelay is my first one I’ve checked out from start to finish since Mellow Gold. I’ll be honest, this album started off great, but quickly descends into a bit of chaos in regards to direction. I’d be enjoying a song, and then I would find myself becoming downright annoyed by the next, or from some of the sound effects used. The excitement I had when this pick popped up is gone, and I’m left with disappointment. 2.5 / 5
Sorry but I just don't get his music. Most of the songs on this album are repetitive and a little boring. The only one I liked is Where it's at.
Experimental, genre-bending, playful, and joyous. Easily one of the best albums of the 90s and an all-time classic.
I’m not super into Beck, but I do recognize the appeal behind his melding of genres (i.e. rock, folk, hip-hop, etc.). I have no strong feelings toward this record. It do be what it be. Favorite track: Where It's At
Not a huge fan of Beck, but an okay album
Beck at his weird and wonderful best
Classic
Always liked beck, this is weird and fun
I love Beck
This album was so annoying and pretentious it was painful to listen to. How this man won a Best Record Grammy I will never know. Almost every time a song sounded like it was going in a nice direction, it diverted in a nonsensical, unpleasant way. I hated this record. I award Beck 1 star, and may God have mercy on his soul. Notable Tracks: - Hotwax - only notable because of how much I despised this song - Minus - a decent punk song 2/10
I never really got into Beck at the time so was intrigued to see if the passing of time would have changed my opinion. I thought this was alright but not spectacular.
4 - a lot of this was really unique and fun, one of the songs (without knowing the artist) I figured out it was the same guys that did loser
A classic album, though this is the first time I've listened all the way through in one sitting. Beck is a master at smashing together a bewildering array of samples and genres. At times noise rock, country, punk, folk, electronic, it's hard to define. The singles get stuck in my head forever, and even the lesser known tracks are never boring.
нормис из 90-х
Brings back memories of my college years
Mellow Gold was a much better album and meant a lot more to me than this album. Just doesn't suck me in the way the other album did. 3.5
Good stuff. I can see why Jorge loves him, but outside of the hits I wont add him.
I own this album and have no memory of listening to it, which is a very bad sign. A re-listen reminds me why: while singles like "New Pollution" and "Devil's Haircut" pointed to a new, slick 1960s go-go boots stye, Beck is still a very immature artist here, pushing the boundaries of engineering and production in ways that sometimes work and sometimes come across as obnoxious and needlessly provocative. The standout tracks (Devil's Haircut, Where It's At, Jackass, Ramshackle, New Pollution) are simply outstanding, but the rest of the album lacks focus.
Único, atrevido, diferente
Beck is a consistently good songwriter and musician. I’ve owned Odelay since it’s release, and although enjoyable, it’s not something that has gotten much play over the years.
I like this album. It’s not one I listen to much but I still like it. I think it’s fun. There is something to be said about music that’s fun. I think that it coming out when it did in terms of where I was in life at that time makes me rank it higher than I might otherwise but I also think it is pretty decent even apart from that.
I loved this album when it came out. It was so different than anything else on the alternative landscape. Listening to it now there are a lot of hits but also quite a few misses
Bonkers. Bloody bonkers. But brilliant. Beck's best?
Reputation precedes it. Some moments of really good stuff and then some songs that sound more dated now. No doubt influential but nothing I'd be raving about.
Hoe hebben mensen dit ooit 3.5 gegeven, pretentieus. Mijn tweede 1
I was almost willing to give this a 3, but the last three songs all sucked so much it earned a 2
Loser is a bit of tune. But not on this album unfortunately. Nothing really standing out to me here, but still nice enough. Simpsons: Yes and a full on guest star in Futurama
Solid 3 album throughout. High 5 was a strange one that stood out, seemed very different to the rest of the album.
This was like scrambled eggs; it was all over the place. Parts were ok, although some of the songs sounded like what I imagine alien messages from another galaxy sound like.
I only knew Beck as the head from Futurama before this. Becks throwing a load of shit at the wall with this album and it almost all sticks for me. Love the use of sampling in this which I don’t always. Just really enjoyable for me, will have to listen to more Beck
A stonking album, full of killer tracks and complete zaniness, a classic.
As many have pointed out, Beck was in the right place at the right time, and that really allowed his career to flourish, more so than your average white guy-hip hop-rock-electronic-folk album, in which I'm sure there was more than you'd think by 1996. Beck just did it really well, setting the bar pretty high. It's weird, but not bizarre, it's heavy, but not destructive, it's poppy, but not bubblegum. It just is a well rounded 90s album that perfectly shows the landscape of a new era in a post-Nirvana world, and while some of it feels a little too of its era for me, much of the album is at the very least catchy, and I really enjoy the folkier moments hinting towards future Beck endeavors. Just a solid album that has held up very well, and was certainly an inspiration for many artists of the 2000s.
When Beck and later this album were popular, I didn't get it. Maybe it was me or the whole Beck / hipster / Alternative thing just ground my gears but I get what he did to music in this period. The 90s were weir man. 3.5/5
This Beck album is decent, but it kind of suffers from having a very late 90's sound in a way that I also didn't like in the late 90's. So even though it has some songs I love, as an album it's kind of just average for me. 3/5
Learned that I never listened to this whole thing before. It's good! I'm not surprised though. I really like Midnite Vultures and a few other of his albums. 4/5
Always respected Beck more than I truly loved him. He’s one of the few artists who’s combined rock and rap near-seemlessly, probably by sticking to college rock instead of metal, and this is probably his best collection. I just never feel like pulling it out. B-
Love this album. Beck is a weird dude with weird lyrics and sometimes I don’t know what he’s saying, even if I know what he’s talking about. Just great music that was a product of and driver for the other quirky, alternative stuff that was happening at the time. He’s a unique artist that is instantly recognizable. While I like a couple of his albums a little better, but this is still a classic and one I will return to many more times.
Goede experimentele muziek. Zou het zeker vaker luisteren.
Gear: Abyss DIANA MR (vegan) Artwork: 🐕🧹🪣 Produktion: 🎧😐🆗 Musik: 🤗🤨🤪 Wertung: 🐕🐕🐕/5
Not a fan of the singer's voice or the grunginess of this album, seems too scratchy.
better than i expected! beck is fun.
Good good album
Awesome album, all great songs, except one, but I won't tell you which one I didn't like, it's an easter egg of mediocrity, but the rest is 5-star awesome!