Reviews (page 4 of 7)
Love “The Bottle,” the rest a little too laid back for my tastes.
This album was nifty. The keys felt perfect for the albums theme, which was heavy, and strained, almost like they were yelling. It definitely had some great comments on the state of American empire at the time, and I appreciated this as some pretty good jazz. My favorite track was The Bottle. The Bass line is damn good
Smooth jazz with activist vocals
I respect the hell out of Gil Scott-Heron, but that doesn't make this a good album.
Extremely cool. Almost beat poetry really, and lyrically absolutely fascinating. I'd heard a lot about GSH, without ever really dipping my toe in the water, but this is a really great introduction. It's not my genre at all, but I can still appreciate it so much.
I like his voice and the songwriting more than the music behind it. The drum kit repetitiveness of the second track almost broke me.
Luckily I spotted the YouTube link in the reviews - doing a search in YouTube didn’t work (I really dislike YouTube!). Standouts were H2O Gate Blues - especially now! , and The Bottle. I didn’t like his vibrato on some of the other sons. Overall a 3
One of the most strikingly beautiful first listens of an album on this list so far. Gil Scott-Heron pours his heart out with Brian Jackson accompanying him for some excellent instrumental performances/lyrical storytelling. An anomaly in the context of this list, this record actually gets better with each song, leading to a captivating end. All the while, explorations of socio-economic hardships and the struggles of being a black American are told in ways both hyper-specific and universal, all at once. The opening "Peace Go With You, Brother (As-Salaam-Alaikum)" was a wonderful mediation on self-restraint, and anger pervading black male social circles. Little did I know this song would bookend the record! I don't have much to say on the lyrics of "Rivers Of My Fathers", but GSH's voice is superb on this one, and the piano work is sooo soothing. If I had to pick a lowlight, it would be "Very Precious Time". It's a lovely track with a bit of a twist in perspective on reflecting on young love, but considering the topics of the songs to come, this track sticks out from the rest just a bit. "Back Home" made me think about all the nice homely things I hold dear, the warmth GSH conveys through this track is infectious. "The Bottle" sets the bar for songs that are lamentations on cycles of alcohol abuse and cycles of social struggles that black americans are especially susceptible to - whether it's the 1970's or present day. "Song For Bobby Smith" followed by "Your Daddy Loves You" are heartbreakingly bittersweet songs that act as a tender pulling back of the curtains a bit. The latter especially just felt so universal, so humane - much like Stevie Wonder's "Isn't She Lovely". Somehow, it got better from here. Because "H2OGate Blues" rocked my world. A sprawling, colorful, vitriolic-yet-measured exploration of the United State's governmental wrongdoings, crimes, misdirection, and chaos all at once. While this song centers around Watergate and a number of crisis situations of it's time, I found myself making many a connection to the frustrations of this songs era to the times of today. American citizens attention being diverted by it's government, mentions of companies like Lockheed/Boeing skirting around the fact that they were profiting off the war in Vietnam. Paranoia on a widespread scale, the failure to stop fascism on the rise, the rich attempting to crush the lower and middle class. I'm in awe of how prescient and relevant these observations are. This is genuinely a top 10 song I've heard from my 550+ albums so far, and probably the best protest song I'll ever hear. The 1001 albums list giveth today, in a huge way. I encourage everyone to sit with this album, it's easily a 5/5 for me
great
This album was great! Like I had never heard this before and this is what i listen to the list for!
THIS is political music done right. clear and concise in its messaging without being too on-the-nose. a powerful message from a powerful vocalist
Un autre album que je réécoute une fois de temps en temps en espérant l'apprécier mieux. Ça manque un peu de fougue pour moi.
Ça groove, j'ai beaucoup aimé The Bottle Genre de proto hip-hop? C'était chiant à ecouter sur youtube mais c'est pas leur faute.
Dur à trouver mais j’ai bien aimé. Genre de pré jazz-rap groovy. J’ai connu Gil pour son poème qu’on entend dans « who will survive in America » de Kanye West. Un grand poète américain!
Buen disco. Buena música, buen jazz, buena voz de Scott, pero lo sentí extremadamente relajado. Me hicieron falta algunos temas con más punch, no solamente estos tan reflexivos. No malo, para nada. Pero quiero explorar más de Scott-Heron a ver qué trae en sus otros discos.
This album feels effortlessly cool. The political stuff at the end I'm not against but it did change the vibe of the album. Really well done and put together. Surprised I've never heard it.
So good. A poet that uses his syllables and vocals as an instrument playing with the instrumentals. I found the album really well structured and The Bottle makes me want to move. Brian Jackson flute playing, a thing of beauty.
Actually pretty good! Never heard of them.
Even if this is a full band, it still feels pretty stripped down and raw. Clearly political, and pretty discordant between feel and lyrics. A few great tracks, and quite a bit of competent filler.
Maybe a bit too avant garde for me? It was intense
I had to go to YouTube to hear this, and I'm glad I did. He was earnest and commanding, even though his singing wasn't great. The spoken word stuff was on point.
Seriously groovy stuff. Very few albums out there can keep that up as consistently as this one.
I absolutely loved the production and instrumental on this record. I had a very hard time connecting with Gil's singing. I just couldn't enjoy it. Despite disliking a large part of every song, I'm still going to think positively of this record and say that Gil's style just isn't for me. This album is incredible for hip-hop samples, I'm sure many people sampled it. 6/10
The Bottle was a big part of my dissertation. Great, important, influential song. Album gets a bit meandering, but everything remains honest and interesting and purposeful. Wish I had more time to listen to these outside work.
Beautiful & raw, they both inspired a future generation, many a sample taken! Gil Scot Heron's voice is unmistakable and I struggle to hear anyone else over the year's that sounded quite like him. Brian Jackson is such a talented musician and as a pair they were a dream team. Lyrics on H2Ogate Blues about the politics & turmoil of the States in the 70's could still be relevant in 2025- just change the names. The Bottle track is pure gold, the tune just grooves along, Gil at his lyrical best, Brian on his flute. Had the absolute pleasure seeing Brian Jackson and his band play a few years back where he covered a lot of the tracks on this album as if we were was back in the 70's again, still fresh - wonderful!
incredibly smooth
missed this due to technical problems
Damn Gil, you’ll get me listening to jazz yet. This was a truly great album, and still goddamn relevant.
This was quite a surprise to me, because I fully expected to really like this, but for some reason it didn't quite vibe with me. Liked the spoken word H2Ogate Blues more than the rest. I liked elements of the others (including some nice bass), but the whole wasn't quite what I was expecting. Low three.
Stunning blend of soul jazz, blues and political consciousness. One of those albums that might not be that well known but has had a huge influence on music since. Covers everything from racial solidarity to alcohol addiction and the Watergate scandal and sounds incredibly cool while doing it. H2O Gate gets a special mention for being a proto-rap number.
Groovy. Tik per youtube.
Listening to H2Ogate Blues is 2025 is fascinating. So many of the issues Gil eloquiently brings up are still major issues today. It made me genuinely sad, and isn't that the purpose of art? 4.5/5
Jazzy Hendrix.
Very enjoyable.
Pretty cool, cat
A beautiful album. The music is elegant, and the lyrics are raw and real. It’s powerful and poetic, though I’m not sure it’s something I’d find myself returning to often.
Nice mellow vibe with some pointed spoken words … wish this was on a streaming platform so I could listen consistently
Bit wanky. Dangerously close to heavy jazz flute.
Dull aimless mixture of jazz, soul, and spoken word making something like Soft Jazz.
Great album for a certain time and a certain mood that remains unfortunately relevant. 4/ 5
No está el spotify
Hard to find! Smooth, jazzy. Happy that I now know there's a piano guy called Brian Jackson (iykyk). Not that exciting though tbh...
What really stands out to me here is Gil’s vocal delivery, whether musical or spoken-word. He really is a master at cadence and tone and it takes boring albeit pleasant track into something much more special. Also obviously he was spitting hard facts in h2ogate blues.
Actually enjoyed what I could listen to - album isn't available on streaming.
5/6
Well shit, this is just spellbinding, like this is the sort of thing that could probably make you a better person. I like jazz, but sometimes I sort of have a mostly intellectual connection with it, which frankly, may be a way to miss the point. But Winter In America, whether because it brings in some other influences, or because of the incredible poetry, or just because it is fucking immaculate art just completely shatters this sort of wall. While I understand this album is ultimately about The Black Experience in America, which I can safely say I am outside of, I honestly think the lens used here reveals some more universal truths about America in its many forms. I mean just listen to H2OGate Blues, Gil Scott-Heron is getting to the heart of some serious shit here. And frankly, a lot of it feels awfully familiar in a modern American environment. Gil Scott-Heron is really a genius poet and thinker and the evidence is all over this thing. This album is dense: it's juggling bitterness and tentative hope, it's exploring the patterns that America runs on, and often it brings it all to a deeply small scale, getting into how structural, social issues are almost always kind of people issues in a way. I really don't feel like I can analyze it effectively. But, I will say I can *feel* this thing, and it seems like it wants more than anything to be felt. And honestly, for as much as I've talked about Gil Scott-Heron, Brian Jackson is co-billed for a reason. His playing is incredible, he lays stuff down for Gil Scott-Heron without forgetting to get a word in himself: He is clearly a fantastic musician with incredible compositional chops. I have few if any complaints, and for a cold listen, I feel pretty confident about what I'm hearing here, I'm giving it a 5.
I respect this album much more than I enjoyed this album. It wasn’t bad to listen to, but it meandered a lot. There were a couple of songs that held my interest but that’s about it.
Beautiful music
3.5
Cool
Single. It is good though!
5/10 I'll concentrate on the bits that didn't grate terrible boy and we're politically charged so that I can give 3 stars. But some of it was god awful Jazz and the bloody stereo whizzing from side to side was making me feel sea sick.
Gil Scott-Heron está considerado uno de los padres del hip hop y el rap. Además, es uno de los mejores letristas americanos. Yo había escuchado su disco debut y me había encantado. Este, aún no estando al nivel, sigue siendo un buen disco de jazz mezclado con elementos de soul y blues. 3'5/5
My disaapointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined. God damn I was so badly looking forward to this, but just found it kind of meandering and mid. I don't think it helps that Gil S-H's vocals really start grating after a bit.
Couldn’t listen to the whole album on Apple Music. Listened to the title track though. Good sound.
Couldn't find the album on apple music, but listened to the single, and listened to his other albums. Fantastic artist and musician. 10/10 would recommend.
Most of the album alternated between good groovy songs and rambling over jazzy chords that I didn't like. But that ending was incredible and aged shockingly well over 50 years
Percies een jamsessie die toevallig is opgenomen. Met geïmproviseerde lyrics door iemand die geen lyrics kan improviseren.
This was great. Loved the mellow vibe and jazz piano. Then "H2Ogate Blues" came on and took things to the next level. Standout track: H2Ogate Blues
This album wasn't available on Qobuz, but I found it on YouTube. It's got a pretty laid-back feel to it. I personally prefer other Scott-Heron albums, but I feel they all have at least one killer track within each album - here the top track for me is The Bottle and also H2Ogate. Nevertheless, this album would probably do well on repeated plays.
Highlights: Back Home, The Bottle, H20gate Blues. In a nutshell: poetry with power. Gil Scott-Heron succeeded here where early Leonard Cohen failed: (a) variety and (b) purpose. Gil presents social commentary with a backing band, said band made up of organ, flute and simple percussion switch up the tempo on each song. As for Cohen, well, just don’t get me started on the Jaw harp again. This is an important recording, as is Scott-Heron's album “Pieces of a Man (featuring the hit track “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised”). The sentiment of H20 Gate Blues alone is as relevant now than what is was in 1974. Overall: 7/10
прик, претензий нет.
Very cool
Couldnt find winter in america album but i did find it was a song of the album The Bottle. There was even a joke in the album how people cpuld find his music in record stores. The album felt more like live recordings of a performance. Regardless, solid music
This album was hard to find, no link to it, but someone one youtube put together a version of it to listen to. Very pleasant album. Seems like the kind of album I would really enjoy after a few listens.
Not really for me
4.5 Had to listen on You Tube
*beep* I'm sorry, but the government you have elected is inoperable.
The first track was nearly unbearable. The stereo Leslie effect of the Rhodes piano was irritating as hell when using earphones. Thankfully, the rest was much better. The music, while supporting the lyrics with a relaxed and held-back style, is really good. The lyrics are more poems than song texts, with H20Gate Blues at the top. It's uncanny how that era and the current situation in the USofA are so similar in so many ways. While it's not my kind of music, I respect this record's significance.
This was a really easy-to-listen-to jazz/blues/soul album. Very good.
"All of your children and all of my children are gonna have to pay for our pay for our mistakes someday" Listened to B4? No Tracks Already Saved on Spotify: None Standout Tracks: Peace Go With You Brother (As-Salaam-Alaikum), The Bottle, Song for Bobby Smith (81/100)
Political and even on the nose for this current decade
This album is quite creative in its genre bending nature. The lyrics are also quite interesting and provocative. I'm not a huge fan of the piano and flutes on this album as the piano and flutes sound out of place with the vocals.
73/100. Winter in America is a subtle but important record, one that balances social commentary with gentle, expressive instrumentation. The album blends soul, jazz, and funk with a relaxed, almost meditative feel. One real downside today is accessibility. Winter in America has had a frustrating digital history, often missing from major streaming platforms or presented in low quality. It’s a shame, because it’s a record that deserves to be heard more widely.
Do not think his vocals are particularly listenable or engaging.
some funk, some jazz, some social commentary
This was very calming, but a bit boring at times. Anyway, great composition
Laid-back, smoky, and thoughtful. The sparse tracks make it feel more like a beat poetry night than an album sometimes, but there's still something magnetic in that. Spins: 1 No Spotify, No Playlist Additions.
I can see why people say they like this, I can see why it's important. It's not "good." It simply is not one of the best 1001 albums, or an album you'd need to hear. I'd never say to someone, "oh shit you gotta hear this album!" 2/5.
Smooth easy listen, but ultimately washed over me more than grabbed me
It was definitely something new that I enjoyed exploring, but wouldn’t seek out.
Overall, relatively forgettable album with the exception of the spoken word piece about Watergate.
This is probably the second best album relating to an African American community since Houmous & Chutneys infamous and supportive studio album ‘Were With You (All The Way)’ 4.0 5/9 The Bottle
Beautiful album. I'm surprised this isn't more well known - I had only heard The Bottle until now. You can see the roots of hip hop in this and Pieces of a Man. Lovely jazz piano and flute too. Had to listen to it on YouTube unfortunately, but I will look into getting a copy of this asap.
Really cool to listen to. Kind of like the best possible version of slam poetry at times. It's a shame this isn't on Spotify, because it makes it kind of hard to keep track of and return to, but this is definitely a gem. Fave songs: Really hard to do for this one, but special attention to "Very Special Time" and "Song For Bobby Smith"-- man oh man, those are beautiful.
The crooning and twinkling piano at the beginning was fine enough, but didn't do much for me. The spoken-word, slam-poetry style jams at the end, on the other hand, really hit for me.
Great sound and meaningful lyrics. The poetry-read style at the end was a nice change of pace and fit the rest of the album well. Really enjoyed this one!
Cool album. Enjoyed the lyrics and music. Standout songs: Peace go with you, brother The Bottle
Wow wow. Really loved this. Last track id a gut punch that rings true all these years later. Insane
Had never heard of this album, and although not something I’d seek out, I didn’t mind and enjoyed elements.
Un álbum de soul jazz en el que dos artistas muy distintos se complementan a la perfección. Por un lado, tenemos a Gil Scott-Heron, mayormente poeta de voz hablada. Por el otro, a Brian Jackson, pianista (y flautista) de jazz. El resultado es un sonido único hasta la fecha, al que Scott-Heron denominó bluesología (bluesology), “la ciencia de cómo se sienten las cosas”. Además de blues, jazz y soul, también hay elementos de música africana y voz hablada, lo cual, combinado con las letras africanistas y de corte social, hizo que este álbum fuera súper influyente en el nacimiento del hip-hop. No hay más que escuchar "H2O Gate Blues" para darse cuenta. Me ha gustado especialmente la diversidad de los temas, que van desde más animados y soul ("The Bottle") a temas más lentos y jazz ("Rivers of My Fathers"). Un álbum que definitivamente merece un puesto en esta lista y al que hay que poner en contexto y escuchar con calma.
Loved it. Not to knock Scott-Heron's poetry or whatever but I think the thing I liked *most* was actually Brian Jackson's instrumentals here? Would enjoy this almost as much if it was just a faintly jazzy/soul instrumental album. Best Song: Rivers of my Soul
This album wasn’t on Spotify so listened to Piece Of A Man instead. I enjoyed the album
This feels somehow both of its moment and ahead its time. Jazzy, soulful, political and relevant. A discovery for me as it’s not the type of thing I would generally listen to.
Didn’t listen
4.5
Unfortunatly I could hear only two songs of this album on my Streaming Platform but these songs are excellent jazz and R&B compositions.
Started very good, but kinda droned on as the album continued.
3 stars for background jazz.
Its bluesy and vibey, very relevant even to today's world and time. Sometimes a little to spoken and not signing for my taste.
Some soulful 70's jazz singing about the struggle. The Watergate Blues was my favorite and still relevant.
I really like his voice and his vibe. Some of the songs are a little too sparse, and it leans more into talking than music at times. Overall, it's cool stuff though! The Bottle was my favorite song on here, and I like the soul and meaning in what he sings about.
Should be mandatory listening in civics classes everywhere. Imagine what GS-H would write about today's America, probably nothing because he already wrote it. It is still Winter in America. 4/5
Ok. Not as much spoken word as I expected. 2/5
actually really liked this
I have mixed feelings. The opening track was almost unlistenable with that quivering keyboard. But there were plenty of other excellent tracks, and you can absolutely see GSH's work as one of the building blocks of rap. "H2Ogate Blues" was my favourite track, though its legacy perhaps isn't as powerful as intended
Culturally not connected to this, so didn't get the message or struggle. Not a fan of performance art, spoken word or rap etc. So a 1
Good lyrics. Sad how we're still here 60 years later. And Watergate sounds trivial by comparison to the current corruption.
Lite jazz.
Good
A nice album!
I still fear the jazz
Uinspirerande
Not a fan of the first song but some of the others sounds like they'd be played in a café. Unobtrusive but not ones I'd Shazam
Really interesting album that was a mixture of jazz, soul, and spoken word. The H20 Gate Blues track was especially interesting and will easily remind you not enough has improved in 50 years, socially or politically. I will have to agree with some other reviews that stated the vocal track definitely overpowered the instrumental track, so for that I give this 4.5, instead of a full on 5.
A really solid mix of jazz and blues
Brilliant
Really liked this. H2Ogate was fantastic.
2.5
Enjoyable album, nice jazz. Nothing stood out to me.
very personal and emotional. it sounds original to gil, which i admire a lot.
Whole lotta Jazz flute in this Best Song: Winter in America Rating: 5.5/10 (Fine) Stars: 3/5
Such a vibey album. Especially like the use of wind instruments in the album. Favorite track: bottle other picks: peace go until you (kendrick lamar has sampled this song), a very precious time, winter in america, your daddy loves you
Nice to hear Gil Scott-Herons vocals on jazz piano. Some nice Melodie’s and backing but not quite grabbed by it. Vocals can be a little wavy at times and not necessarily any stand out or wow songs, but pleasant enough. First album not on Spotify (link - https://archive.org/details/0316_gil_scott_heron_brian_jackson_winter_in_america_1974__mlib) ‘The Bottle’ maybe stand out track (can’t add to list)
Great protest album - solid jazz fusion
Oke mi je ovaj album, ništa ono wow, ali nije ni loš. Znam većinu stvari, ali mislim da nisam u komadu slušala. Bit će neki prosjek, 3/5, 6/10
Hyvää jazz albumia mutta sitten aletaan pälätttämään ihan omiaan... jahas,,,, ei tommosta jaksa...
god i wish this was on spotify. absolutely excellent
nice
probably bc i just listened to bb king immediately followed by miles davis but i’m respectfully bored i need a complete vibe change
Not bad but definitely not my vibe and kinda irritating
Jazz
Cool for certain vibes but not as much my thing
Suuuuuper cool jazz and blues, tackling big social issues in such a smooth and enthralling way. Truly genius work.
Very of it's time, but loved it
This was okay. Annoying that it’s not on Spotify though.
this was actually really nice. I kinda teared up at point. It feels very laidback and genuine, it's nice. they cover watergate which is fun. it was nice :) 9/10
This felt like a journey more than just listening to tracks move by one by one. I gotta say The Bottle was my favorite, I'm a sucker for that jazz flute. Overall a good experience! Funky and introspective.
To quote the top comment on the YouTube link “😢😢😢😢😢 his music brings me to tears because it really shows the struggle of being a Black Man in America shit crazy man” @Omega_Gamer5
I absolutely adore Gil-Scott Heron’s vocals already as I’ve listened to a decent bit of his catalog so far so very excited with this pick. His style of vocal jazz is so smooth and addictive. Really minimalist and accessible jazz and beautiful melodies throughout. Always feels like you’re listening to him live and he’s telling you a personal story.
#603. Jazz 2/5: jazz
One of my favourite artists, beautiful voice, brilliant lyrics
I have to be honest - I'm not feeling it. Wikipedia says "Winter in America has been recognized by music writers as one of the prominent examples of early rap" and I'm sorry, what? This just sounds like smooth jazz - where the fuck are people getting "early rap" Music writers love to group black artists together, even if they're completely different genres. Anyway, I don't love it. I feel bad giving it two stars, but I never want to listen to it again, and that's kind of my litmus test.
I like the grooves of GSH songs (the bottle) but he’s a poet turned musician, so I think he can sometimes fall short as well.
I couldnt find this on spotify. I listened to a live version of a few of the songs, but the performances were kinda shitty. Not really fair but moving on
Not an easy album to find - Odd that it isn't on Apple music. Love how raw all the tracks are. I went into this with very low expectations based on what I read in the wiki (Just a keyboardist and vocalist -- Scott-Heron). The Bottle -- I can understand the rap influence Rivers Of My Fathers -- so raw. Piano solos were vibey Really want to revisit this on a free night with a joint and some good food with a few friends.
Solid protest album from one of the best / originals. Solid music. Great voice.
Instantly loved the intro Peace Go With You, Brother - so tranquil, sad and interestingly produced (listen in headphones). The rest was a bit more "your general jazzy sound" for me - pleasant, but unmemorable. Another gem is ballad Song for Bobby Smith. Album as a whole is about dubious politics and hard life of black americans
Not bad as background music, but if I actually focused on and listened to it, it was not great.
Unexpected
Gil Scott-Heron is still vastly underrated.
Unavailable
Couldn't find it on Spotify.
This was mostly incredibly boring. It was talk singing over piano noodling. The two songs where there was actually structure and other instruments were fine but nothing special. Watergate blues was interesting, it made me realize the US has been through shitty stuff before and came out okay, so it gave me hope for the future.
Pretty inspirational, powerful, prolific and well produced. I'm not familiar with Heron's work but the name has come in frame time and time again. I'm thoroughly impressed by this piece of work and love the occasional flute that adds supreme cool factor. Poet Gil Scott's words to music is so captivating.
A very good album that I probably would not have listened to if it was not for this site
A genius
Not for me. 1/5
3.5? sometimes sounds uneven rather than varied, but grows in strength as it goes. jackson’s key/piano playing is great throughout, although i prefer the second half with the fuller band. hits its stride with “the bottle.” gil’s poetry also improves in the second half, both in his ability to surprise and the acquisition of a sense of humor. although i get that funny wasn’t necessarily what he wanted in an exploration of black life in america. his rhythmic timing isn’t exactly dead on, but i think that's part of his thing. replace a few names in h2ogate blues and dedicate it to jd vance rather than spiro agnew, and it’s perfect for 2025. even better that it’s live. lively, clever, sharp, true. the flute also pipes up around halfway, flits in and out, and is more than welcome to hang out. feels a bit heavy handed at times, but it’s good. it could grow into a 4 or higher.
Wow, so powerful, this album who is love and compassion well still acting as a call to action that still holds true today. Gill’s voice captures your attention immediately. He has this presence to him. You just want to hear what he has to say. It’s like pull up a seat. I think you can talk for eternity and I would just sit and listen. I love the moments where he has these jabs at America and the government at the time a poem about Watergate was incredible. It’s like the writing has been on the wall all along we’re still not learning our lesson. I can’t think of a figure in modern day they can speak with such heart and soul. Outside of the message in the vocals, there’s some amazing electric piano being played throughout this whole entire album that timbre has always been an arrow through my heart. My dream is to own one of these instruments. They sound so beautiful. This album and the German one we heard are definitely must listens before we die. They are thought-provoking and innovative. I only listen to this album once definitely need to give it a couple more lessons so this is a very on the surface review but I’m really curious on what’s next so this is all you get. Howard Stern’s penis Baba Bowie.
Some r&b n jazz is a welcome sight. Found it pretty relaxing, albeit nothing stood out to me and stuck to my ribs musically. I admittedly need more listens to get his music and his message to sink in Pleasant in my single spin 3 with room to grow
I only recently came across GSH actually through the unlikely source of Australian footballer and St Pauli captain Jackson Irvine, who hosts a wonderful monthly digital radio show and played The Bottle. I find it remarkable and frustrating how the messages in this music are still so relevant today.
I did not fully enjoy this. There were good moment but I think there is better Gil Scott Heron albums. The first that comes to mind is hi 2010 one.
Pas facile.
I can't get past Scott-Heron's voice, especially given a trebly vocal mix that makes it almost painfully reedy. Otherwise, this would be a particularly noodley but otherwise innocuous jazz album. Maybe it would help to be stoned, but I wasn't. I turned the volume down at first because the mix was almost painful. Then I got bored after about ten minutes and turned it off.
Once in a while you find music that you're really sad about not being on Spotify. This is one of those. The opening note of those record had me glued straight away. Having mentioned previously that I have a weak spot for electric pianos, hearing that overdriven e-piano with insane amounts of tremolo was just straight eargasm. I was a bit worried when he started speaking that it was going to be a weird album, but then he starts singing and it's just goes perfect along with the mellow piano playing, and overall dark feel of 'Peace Go With You, Brother (As-Salaam-Alaikum)'. The album continues along those lines for me. It has an overall dark and moody tone throughout the record, which fits me very well. The piano playing is very good, and somehow I'm just completely hooked to the very end (perhaps with the exception of 'H2O Gate Blues' which was interesting and a bit fun, but dragged on way too long). Going to have to be 5 stars for me. I very rarely hear new music that I instantly love, but this definitely did that for me. It's even more impressive that it is in a jazz/blues setting, which can tend to get quite samey for me, and I usually have a hard time finding what makes certain pieces stand out in those genres. But this is just very unique to me, and very good as well. Plus points for never having heard of Gil Scott-Heron either, all the more fun!
Things were not looking bright. The album cover looked boring and the album was not on any streaming services. That is 2 warning signs. The third came with the first electrical piano chord where the sound was vibrating from left to right headphone. I needn’t had worried, after my initial trepidation I was treated to a very good album. It’s just a perfect blend of blues and jazz and funk. Nice piano melodies, even the spoken word worked great. I’m a bit saddened the the political stuff is just a relevant today as back then. There is just enough production to make it nice but still feels very personal. “Song for Bobby Smith” is probably the best example of this. You also just have great funk pieces like “The Bottle” that makes you want to bop your head. This was such a good find and the type of thing I listen to this list for. Now I’m saddened this isn’t on any streaming service. Come to think of it, I gave Joanna Newson a 5 star after hearing her album for the first time on youtube. I will give this album the same treatment.
Right off the bat I noticed that Kendrick sampled Peace As You Go Brother in Section 80. Love the dreamy instrumentals in that one. Back Home and The Bottle were other songs I enjoyed here. Pretty good jazz and background music while working. Giving this one a solid 3.
Only put this off as long as I did because its not on Spotify. Unfortunately I realized after my second listen that the YouTube upload is out of order, but I'm not sure that has a big impact on the overall listen other than missing out on some sequencing decisions. I loved this album and its effortless jazzy/soulful swag. I don't usually give too much attention to lyrics when listening in the background, but thankfully I was able to pay closer attention today. H2Ogate Blues runs with the same characteristic spoken word political poetry that Kanye sampled on Who Will Survive in America. A great piece of political protest music that honestly left me feeling a little bitter that despite our deeply troubled times, we haven't had more artists stepping up to carry this same torch. For me this is a light 5. Rough around the edges, but packaged with care and enjoyable to listen to.
First song really tried to break my brain right out of the gate with the stereo manipulation. Recorded in Silver Spring, that's kinda cool. Love the bluntness at the end. No subtlety to his ideals.
Started off a little rough especially with that song where it sounded like he was just banging on the piano with no direction. But picked up nicely into a great soul/blues album. Especially liked The Bottle. That H20gate poem song at the end was hard hitting and very well done.
Wasn't paying complete attention to the political parts but was jamming out to most of it. Enjoyable stuff.
Jazz
Great jazz album (meaning a great entry in a genre I'm only lukewarm on). The end sort of drags after a very strong start.
Poetic, visceral, angry, loving… Gil leaves nothing out, creating poetry straight from his soul. Nobody else was making music liking this. A couple tracks drift, but forgivable because the album as a whole is a testament. Nothing’s changed but the names.
Awesome
Some great conscious, poetic soul from my favourite soul singer "Gil-Scott Heron". Feels very mellow but definetly has some heavier moments lyrically. "Peace Go With You, Brother", "Rivers of My Fathers" and "H²Ogate Blues" are really good songs 8/10 Favourite: Rivers of My Fathers Least Favourite: Your Daddy Loves You
7/10. This is a good album. Although, I found it somewhat forgettable.
Gil is a unique jazz presence. I enjoy some of his later work, the music def has a vibe from its time (mid '70s) . I could have done without the political soliloquy at the end. Nothing against his points or speaking his mind, but the arguments fall thin today (or do they?)
Not really for me,
Jazz
Not on spotify?
Wijs album. Wel wat experimenteel en niet zeer toegankelijk. Blijft een tijdloze stem en de teksten blijven, helaas, zeer actueel. 3.4
EZ listening
Beautiful, human. Jazz/blues/funk/soul - really smooth, exceptional musicianship. Very political and of its time but still feels relevant today. Easy five stars. Wish it wasn’t so hard to find, but glad to have been introduced.
Bastante bueno, pero no pude escucharlo ni en Apple Music ni Spotify. Tuve que ir a escucharlo a Youtube. Ugh.
Good
This album came up the day after I had "To Pimp A Butterfly" by Kendrick Lamar, which has clear influences from Gil Scott-Heron. It's interesting to listen to, especially "H2Ogate Blues" in context of modern day America, where so many of the same issues are still present/have come back around.
Poetry. Grooves. Commentary. Loose and tight. Simple and complex. Gil + Brian are a nice combo. This makes two 'stripped down' albums back to back for me and I'm loving it.
This is a great sound, kind of like jazz small-combo music with soul (or rock) vocals. It's funky, chill, and positive – until you notice the politically-charged lyrics and Scott-Heron's haunting vocal delivery. The bass playing is great. Though overpowered slightly by the vocals and piano, it really shines in tracks like Back Home that have a more dynamic bassline. Same with The Bottle – man, listen to those funky staccatos. It creates such a fun, playful vibe throughout the albums even in the tracks with a lower energy and thinner instrumental texture. The flute is also a huge contributor to Scott-Heron's unique sound, having a particularly heavy impact in the gorgeously ethereal Your Daddy Loves You. There's a subtle Latin feel throughout, helped by the atypical percussion. I first noticed in track 3, A Very Precious Time, that the mixing (at least on the YouTube version) is subpar. Specifically, the vocals are too loud, which leads to both drowning out softer instruments and a messier production sound. I usually prefer the vocals to be used as an instrument working in conjunction with the band rather than a frontpiece, even if the vocals in question are delivering important lyrics. There's also the issue of this record not being on Spotify while other Scott-Heron records are. It suggests that Winter In America isn't a historically significant album – or at least not significant enough for consumers in the present day. My guess is it's another "personal fave" of Dimery's that slipped through the "importance" criteria. Luckily for Dimery, it's a darn good "personal fave". 4/5 Key tracks: Peace Go With You, Back Home, Your Daddy Loves You
spotify下架。yt上聽幾段是舒服的爵士。
This album is phenomenal. Absolutely singular and timeless and relevant.
Damn. This hit hard on a rainy morning. I can hear this reflected in Outkast, especially on Aquemini. It's there in Nate Dogg's singing, and definitely in some of the stuff put down by the Tribe and WuTang. I can hear some of the jazz influences in other artists like Jamiroquai too. The keyboards picked me up and then let me float down. The phasing/reverb was something else too. So much soul! I also liked the spoken word poetry. Finally this is an album from this list that consists of someone previously unknown to me that I am able to get into.
What a voice, what a message! Couldn't find the full album but the Winter in America piece was fantastic. I didn't realize his voice was so nice, having read him as a college student. The message never gets old. Especially not right now. Almost comforting to know that there have been trials and tribulations in the past that were made better with community and speaking truth to power like Gil.
Can’t find this on Spotify or Apple Music. But due to influencing LCD, I’ll give it 3.
Jazz? Didn't find the full album.
fine
The backing jazz piano/keyboard is nice. Kind of reminds me of something from Charlie Brown or Hey Arnold. That's about the only good thing I have to say about this. Not a fan of the voice and it's all just really boring. 3.75/10 (1.875/5)
I really like the sound of the music in this however the sometimes aimless vocals are irritating.
I'm mostly neutral on this album, except for the really interesting spoken word piece ("H2Ogate Blues" - it's like a little time capsule).
Pretty cool! Shame i could only find it on youtube. some pretty famous samples are from here.
(обязательное: не было на спотифае) вроде красивая музыка но голос такой я не люблю ну и реклама каждые сорок секунд тяжело)
This album isn't available on Youtube Music. I did listen to a few tracks of his other stuff, and it is very good jazz.
Nothing Memorable
This album starts off slow, but eventually culminates in the extremely impressive and thoughtful "Watergate Blues." Gil Scott-Heron is as talented a musician as he is in directly addressing issues of his time and ours. Incredible.
Deep and Soulful. It's amazing what they can put together with just a singer and the absolute minimum of accompaniment. If you like soul, funk, or R&B, definitely give this album a listen. I know I'm going to be seeking out more music by Scott-Heron and Jackson after this introduction.
Beautiful and moving.
A great album. Socially conscious, bold, great lyrics and flow. It just needed a tad bit more variety. Watergate blues was awesome. 4/5
Wasn’t able to find. But enjoyed some tracks from other album
I was a freshman in college when this came out and has a very special place in the book of my life. The bold truth of the poet's words will not be forgotten. RIP
Bit of a slow start but really did get rolling for me. Also goes pretty hard thematically/lyrically.
I'm sorry, the government you have elected is not operative.
Can’t find this - not available on Spotify?
Annoying one as I had to listen on YouTube. This seems like it was important for race and all that. Music is fine the last track was like poetry reading but maybe early for of rapping. Again it’s fine.
Still relevant in 2025.
Some of the lyrics are quite powerful - relevant - timeless, but too often everything feels a little aimless and ambling. I guess spoken word doesn't really draw me in enough to have the content overcome the approach.
Had to listen on YouTube. Overall a banging sound. Transported me away from my four walls. So relaxing but soulful and filled to the brim with jazz language Will need to be relistened to many more times
Really good, keyboard playing was great and Gil was an amazing poet
This album gave R&B lounge. The songs had a good flow and were relaxing to listen to. Definitely lots to read between the lines within the lyrics. Favorite Lyrics from H2Ogate: "Mayor of Philadelphia, whose ignorance is surpassed only by those who voted for him" (sounds familiar)
forced singing voice a bit. lots of focus on vocals and seems shout-singing at times. lovely jazzy music, but there's better out there.
Maybe it was the version I listened to, but the production is absolutely abysmal on the electric piano on the first track. The vibration of it and its constant changes in volume made the song positively unlistenable and I almost stopped the album entirely. However, I persisted and found some really great (parts of) Jazz/R&B crossover gems. Nevertheless, not one of the songs came even remotely close to justifying its length, with many tracks ending with two or three minutes of repetition. Additionally, the slow jams were less jammy and more drifty, leaving me frustrated – as did this album as a whole, because it has a lot potential. Addendum: H2Ogate was a beautiful take-down of Nixon. 2.0/5.0: Disappointing
interesting music with a lot of lyrical substance. that said, the beat poetry thing doesn't really work for me and the songs were too long to stay fresh over the entire duration
GSH has an incredible and unique voice, and agree or not, he delivers his message effectively.
Very Soulful. Powerful lyrics as well, society sucks man. Love the hard panning in the Rhodes Piano at the beginning, very Spacey, but not Kevin Spacey.
I really like the contrast between the chill vibes of the music and some of the heavier lyrics. And always good to know that the problems we have today have been persistent for decades. Not depressing at all Felt the mixing could have been better. Vocals seemed to really overpower the music, though that could easily be a problem of the YouTube version I listened to.
Generally pleasant listening and I enjoyed the commentary in Watergate Blues, but quite a snoozefest at times
Not the best a little boring
I like Gil, solid album of him doing his thing.
Whoa this one was cool. Politically charged with similar themes we can relate to today. It blurs the line between jazz, blues, and soul. I would have never found this album on my own. Good listen.
Some solid songs here.
wow, fantastic. wish it was streaming. 4.5
An album that proves streaming services are not all that. I hate that I can't listen to it on them but some really beautiful jazz/soul music. An unfortunate missing credit of Brian Jackson who I understand is "instrumental" (sorry bad pun) to the music with gil's melodies/lyrics. Just beautiful and sobering and life affirming all at the same time.
7/10 - when he wasn’t talking/singing it was really good. The poems were sort of interesting but I didn’t like them musically. Some of the panning was wild. Overall I liked it though
Pretty chill. I’m sure the lyrics were profound but I wasn’t paying bc much attention. Strange vibes for the gym
nope
Great voice & message. I'd like to revisit this one. 3.5 stars.
it's pretty hard to deny the impact that Gil Scott-Heron had on Black American music of all stripes. his spoken-word poetry is widely viewed as an early ancestor of what we now call rapping, and it's rife with social commentary that's possibly even more relevant now than it was at the time. his influence on hip hop can also be felt deeply through the albums he made with Brian Jackson, including Winter in America. admittedly, it's not my favorite of Scott-Heron's works. I find it a little bit samey; his preference for singing over spoken word for most of the material (save for the electrifying H2Ogate Blues) leaves me a little underwhelmed. that being said, I can't deny that the music is extremely forward-thinking. Winter in America's legacy is well-preserved through its frequent use as a source for samples in hip hop production, a testament to its evergreen sound, typified by spacey electric pianos and flutes. decent 7/10.
Decent album and you can certainly see some hip hop inspiration from this but not something I’d go back to anytime soon. 6.5/10
I enjoyed this and am glad I listened. I had heard of Gil's song "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised", but I had not listened. This is very good. But... it's not my thing. I like some R&B and some jazz, and this is a good combination, but I'm not the typical listener. From my viewpoint, I'd give it somewhere from a 6 to an 8 out of 10, depending on my mood. Converting to stars, and rounding down... 3 stars.
Interesting jazz album my wife and kids hated it said it was boring
Poetic jazz. The revolution will not be televised.
Fav: The Bottle Least Fav: H2OGate Blues So hard to decide a fav and least fav, consistently good quality
Ok,
The subjects that this album deals with shows you how little American politics has changed in 50 years. Having said that having a interesting/deep subject matter dosent always make a great album, this had some high spots of real blues, but also a lot of lows which were just a bit dull...it's probably one of those "inspired so many other artists" albums but overall it's just a bit meh....it'll sling a 3 just about
nee nee nee... had hoop omdat ik 'the revolutions will not be televised' wel OK vind... maar dit was echt niet te harden
There are albums that achieve classic status, transcending time and retaining a fresh sound even decades later, regardless of any graininess or lack of high quality production. However, Gil Scott-Heron's "Winter in America" is not one of those albums; it is firmly anchored in a specific time period marked by cultural and political turmoil. The album conveys what was then viewed as a provocative message advocating for black empowerment, envisioning a future where "the system" could be dismantled. Scott-Heron's voice is both gentle and rough, while the album itself varies in its arrangement—sometimes sparse and at other times sounding like a rough first draft. The emphasis appears to be more on the message, where parallels can be drawn to Bob Dylan's poetic roots. This is a heavy album, provoking deep thought amidst a backdrop of cultural unrest and frustration. The most poignant aspect of this album is some of what Gil Scott-Heron is raging against is still relevant today. (While the message is a 5, the construction of the album is a 3)
Wow
Miércoles hermosamente frío en San Juan. Toca en el día de hoy artistas y disco por completo desconocidos. Suena chill, con un cantante muy cálido y un piano que nos ayuda a viajar a través del disco. La segunda mitad sube un poco más y por momentos se pone más funky (The Bottle es el mejor ejemplo) y cierra con una intervención poética, el spoken word yankee. Buen disco.
Was ein geiles Album :D Mega chillig, genau der smoothe Sound den man braucht. Das Ende mit dem Gesabbel hat leider einen Stern gekostet
Pretty good. Too bad it seems challenging to find online.
Aside from being annoyed I couldn’t find this anywhere but YouTube, I liked this. There were occasions when I wished the songs were instrumental, but mostly I thought this was very good.
Whelp. H2Ogate Blues hit pretty hard. Isn’t it disheartening that it’s 50 years later and we’re in the exact. same. thing? I listened to this at some point last year. I like it then, but liked it more now.
H2ogate Blues is a must listen to track in March 2025. Otherwise this was a tough listen for me. ‘ Daddy Loves you ‘ is the kind of song this fella to played for his kids and was added to the album in error. Like Ben Folds Five without the humour or dare I say it, soul.
Record picks up after first couple tracks and is a really good soul/blues/jazz fusion. "A Very Precious Time" slower love song. "H2O Gate Blues" witty lyrics. Standout is "The Bottle".
It's a bit laid back jazzy to captivate my ears. Though perfectly nice groove there's also a bit too much jazz flute. Extra mark for The Bottle though.
Great album, 2 legends of the game.
maybe eh gut, aber not on spotify also werd i's eh nie hören
Very listenable. Not on Spotify.
I can see how this album has become buried over time. It absolutely defies categorization when we seek to categorize everything. Still, despite being hard to find (look on YouTube) it is worth the search. Especially the last track, H2OGate Blues, early hop-hop?
I don’t particularly care for the beatnik-type jazz poetry, but I do like his lyrics. The “Watergate Blues” are an oddly chilling yet comforting reminder that nothing changes.
Piano jazz is not my cuppa, but this is quite peaceful and pleasant. The two best songs are “Bottle” and “H2O Gate Blues” which make this album worth listening to. Gil Scott-Heron, where are you when we need a song about this admin?
H2O Gate Blues is good, but not something I want to listen to repeatedly. The rest of it's a bit too free-form/jazzy for me. Can see the talent, but it's not my bag, baby.
Not my thing hate Jazz normally but this was quite liked this it was chilled
I had to listen on YouTube. But it’s a very nice album, which I enjoyed quite a bit
I am pretty sure, without researching it, that I will be a minority voter here. I did not like this that much. It felt contrived and I hate that. I don't want to be preached to through my music and I don't want it to feel like it was produced for the effect of "being something special." I hate when albums seem to try to make something sentimental on purpose and I never shook that feeling here. Aside from that it is not particularly special in jazz or blues or spoken word... A truly great album can't be forced. It happens naturally, often to the surprise of the musicians. This one felt forced, like it was supposed to be a blockbuster. But I didn't buy into it. Again, the three star rating is tough. I won't kill it with a two but it is no more than a two and a half.
Political posturing from a more prosaic time. It's not a bad album, it just feels dated, and unfortunately, the message has become diluted.
This is not my sort of music. I have never had anything better between my ears. How is this so hard to find?!
27/02/25 I do tend to like my jazz albums. I don't think this was one that really excelled though.
Enjoyable listen! GS-H and Brian Jackson really compliement each other, jazzified! Great blend!
Very nice.
I hated this. 1/5
++: Rivers of My Fathers, A Very Precious Time, Back Home, The Bottle, Your Daddy Loves You, H2Ogate Blues +: Peace Go with You, Brother (As-Salaam-Alaikum), Peace Go with You Brother (Wa-Alaikum-Salaam) 7,7/10
Absolutely incredible. Loved this.
Loved the message, didn't quite enjoy the music though.
This left me really looking forward to the end of it, which is a shame as I was keen to hear this! Not my cup of tea it seems.
Like some of this, mostly the upbeat funky ones. The slow songs didn't do it for me as much.
Interesting
Evocative poetry that feels like a time capsule and timeless at the same time. Gil is forever a legend.
It is very enjoyable and still worryingly relevant.
themes of social consciousness, family, addiction, politics. most of this album was just ok, but to me the best songs on the album were “the bottle” (that bass line slaps so hard) and watergate blues… and those sound nothing like the rest of the album.
Great variety of cool Songs:) thx!
Not my favorite.
Good but really didn’t stand out
Sadly not on Apple Music so had to listen to a 40 min video on YouTube but it was worth it, good album
low 4, some good songs but also some bad ones
What a gem!
This album was taken off Spotify, listened to Johannesburg instead. Best jazz so far
Fairly classic 70's spoken jazz.
Not available on Spotify but I've heard this before.
Album not available on Spotify.
good, but i couldnt find the whole thing
This is so chill.
Wasn’t expecting to like it as much as I did
previously sent
Not available on Spotify, but found a link from another review (thanks!). Nice mellow jazz blues fusion, good vocals. Not sure I really clicked with the political message, perhaps it’s still a relevant message? Need to be in the right mood for this. That said I did enjoy H20 Gate Blues at least.
No
Albums that aren’t on Spotify can be so difficult to access. It took me nearly six months to return to this one, track down the full album on YouTube, and resume my 1001 project. This experience reminded me how crucial platform accessibility is for music discovery and appreciation. Listening to the album as one continuous video helped me focus on its cohesiveness, but it also made it harder to identify individual tracks since I couldn’t add them to my “liked” songs. Outside of that, I really enjoyed Gil’s voice throughout; the smooth, expressive quality carried much of the listening experience. I did find myself losing interest toward the end tho, as the extended narration began to drag a bit.
Amazing, just plain simple amazing. The record is lush with jazzy production and full of actually relevant lyrics, timeless lyrics. The combination of jazz and poetic lyrics has been so refined and the two complement eachother so well. The longer insteumental pieces didn't feel like a drag and were soothing and complementary to the tone and mood of the songs. Overal this record was very balanced, an excellent intro and outro dust free songs that are timeless in terms of message and overal amazing production. The only negative thing I can say is that this record might be harder to listen at times, perhaps its not a daily listen, but definitely something to return to from time to time. Favorite song: peace go with you brother. Overall score: 9.2/10
Unavailable on Apple Music
This is a different kind of record. I like it.