Reviews (page 2 of 7)
this hit great with the storm that was going on
Such a talent
3.5 Very cool, could see it growing on me. Scott-Heron’s singing voice is weird. It’s very atonal and blaring. Sometimes a little off key but very intense. He just hits the notes hard.
Unique but too much spoken word, ranting, preaching for me. Still enjoyed it because different but yeah not for me.
This was a bit more lounge jazz and less proto-hip-hop than I was expecting based on the Gil Scott Heron songs I know. The Bottle (which I had heard before) is a banger though.
As the title suggests, Winter In America is a slow (jazz), depressing, grey (blues) album. It hits all the buttons to make The 1001 Must Hear List; political unrest, substance abuse, and the spoken word. The Bottle (top track) and H2Ogate Blues are prime examples. A bit dated but certainly list worthy. (2.2*s) Scott-Heron & Jackson make a good duo.
Rough start to the Winter In America, picks up on Side B with a little funk and drum work. "The Bottle" is top track but I think "H2Ogate Blues" probably assisted with the album's success. Wild to hear the unrest with the "cesspool" government of the 70s when you compare with that of today's. Hate to think what it will be in another 50 years. Overall, this record was a little boring but different. The stripped down sound is not jiving with me but if this influenced hip-hop, I'll give Scott-Heron a fist-bump. Still not ranking too high at 1.61 stars...take a gill, Gil.
While I wasn't huge on any of the individual musical segments, I can see why this album is on the list. I imagine Winter In America struck a chord in 1978 and provided some fitting social commentary at the time of its release. It has the gravity to tackle some heavy topics while preaching an overall message of peace so I can see why it would be held in high regard from a critical standpoint. It's got quite a few minimalist spoken word sections which only get the listener so far nowadays. It does pick up some steam after a couple of songs and hits its peak with the middle musical tracks in Back Home and The Bottle. I didn't hate my time with Winter In America but I also don't expect I'll ever hear this again. I can understand why it endures within hip-hop and neo-soul samplings. It's a tough album to put a number rating to because the subject matter, artistic approach and what the project likely meant to its audience is wholly separate from whether I enjoyed the music or not. 1.63 stars
Snooooorrrrrreeeeee 2/5
Rivers Of My Fathers
First song sounded promising, but it all went down from there. Jazzy, and bluesy more than soul - it didn't move me much..
Oddly the groove and the message really resonated with me
Brilliant stuff, chill R&B/blues. For me it’s kind of background music but in the best possible way, I can enjoy this while doing just about anything or nothing at all. Lyrics bite. Torn between giving this a 4 or a 5. Still not exactly my genre. Basslines clinch it. The Bottle is a great single.
Not my thing
Oh wow, this was great. I particularly liked H2OGate Blues.
I like GSH but I really like him with Brian Jackson. Really nice album.
Я ледь його дослухала
was ok
Incredibly dull for most of the album. The bottle was a lot more energetic and h2oblues was enjoyable. I thought the last song was also pretty good but the album had already ended and some other song by this guy was playing which was significantly better than everything on this album.
Virkelig unikt album, jeg er vild med det og Gil stemme, blues, jazz og rap på en gang
Unable to open
Very coll record. Not the biggest jazz guy but in this context it makes it easy to like. Give me some more concise songs with vocals. Count me in on that shit. It goes down so much smoother with those elements. Its obviously not music made for my suburban white ass but I appreciate it all the same. The keys are huge here. They kick ass so hard. Flying all over the place. And sliding in between in places where its needed. Just slalomimg through with masterclass technique. And the vocals fit well too. The more rnb vibes are great. And ive seen some peoplr call this rap, in a way I get it. There are some more spoken word poetry sections and songs. I get it. But im not 100% convinced. Its a bit murky but I get it. Overall im very happy with what ive heard here. Really cool stuff. I love when things im not really into fires me up. Great stuff.
Liked it…for awhile 2.5
I loved much of the music. The singing just didn’t fit for me. His voice is fine but it just doesn’t blend well enough for my ears. In fact, the longer I listened, the harder it is for me to listen. 2
Politics just as relevant now as in the 70's. Loved the spoken word!
not for me
by chance the second gil scott-heron album i've listened to this month and this guy is just so awesome. consistently great, consistently relevant
Smooth and effortlessly cool, this was quite the discovery. I was weary if I would vibe with this, but Gil Scott-Heron's golden voice put any concerns I had to bed. He has a very laid back delivery and can see how he was a massive influence on hip-hop. He is able to be incredibly commanding without having to shout. The lyrics are very powerful and takes aim the government as well as focusing on the experience of being a black man in the US at the time. Adding piano and flute to the mix, the jazz stylings of Brian Jackson further contributed to the mellow vibe. The instrumentation starts out as sparse and gets busier as the album progresses, perhaps as a way to ensure that the listener is hanging onto every word that comes out of Scott-Heron's mouth. I've heard from others that this isn't even one of his best albums, so I look forward to checking out his other albums.
Groove leads you into a protest against social injustice. This isn’t a divisive record, it’s warm and welcoming yet it deals with some serious stuff in a way that is accessible to all. A wonder.
Mostly dull jazz
I think I prefer Gil as a straight up spoken word guy.
Man, I really wanted to like this. I do know about the revolution, even though it wasn't televised. But this one is.. ok. I don't find it annoying or anything. But it's just kind smooth jazzy and nothing in the music grabs me. I mean, it's professionally done, it's just not for me. His lyrics are meaningful and sometimes deep, but I feel it works better when he's got a a higher tempo. The Bottle is decent as the one here that moves the most, but there are better GSH albums. I'm calling it a three, and probably never hear it again.
USA, 1973: presidential corruption, unjust war with American aggressor, affordability crisis, soaring gas prices USA, 2026: presidential corruption, unjust war with American aggressor, affordability crisis, soaring gas prices Neat. This needs another listen. I was unfortunately a bit distracted this morning and I didn't listen as close as I wanted to
Got to assume the sheer lack of streams is down to this only recently being added to Spotify. Because it is well worth a listen.
Good, quick, soulful
"Winter In America" is not merely an album; it is a profound, somber, and deeply influential work of art that serves as a poignant time capsule of the American socio-political landscape in the early 1970s. Released in 1974 by the iconic jazz label Strata-East, this collaboration between poet-musician Gil Scott-Heron and keyboardist Brian Jackson is widely considered their magnum opus—a masterpiece of soul-jazz and a foundational text in the history of hip-hop and neo-soul . Its brilliance lies in its stark, unflinching lyricism, its masterful minimalist production, and the palpable artistic synergy between its two creators. ### 🎵 Musical Style, Production, and Core Themes The sound of *Winter In America* is defined by its striking sparseness. In a deliberate departure from their earlier, more fully arranged work, Scott-Heron and Jackson crafted an album of remarkable intimacy and restraint . The instrumentation is often minimal, relying heavily on Jackson's evocative piano and electric keyboards, subtly underscored by percussion, with Bob Adams (drums) and Danny Bowens (bass) contributing to only a few tracks . This stripped-back production, recorded in a small studio in Silver Spring, Maryland, places Scott-Heron's commanding baritone and poetic narratives at the absolute forefront . The music, rooted in jazz, blues, and traditional R&B, creates a hypnotic, melancholic atmosphere that perfectly complements the lyrical content . Lyrically, the album is a masterclass in social commentary. The title serves as the central metaphor: "winter" represents a prolonged, chilling period of stagnation and decay for America, particularly for its marginalized communities. Scott-Heron saw the assassinations of leaders like John F. Kennedy, Malcolm X, and Martin Luther King Jr. as the end of a metaphorical "summer" of hope, plunging the nation into an ideological and moral winter . The album explores the resulting despair, poverty, and political cynicism plaguing the African-American community and the inner city . From the poignant reflection on legacy in "Rivers of My Fathers" to the scathing political critique of "H2Ogate Blues," the album paints an unflinching portrait of a nation in crisis. ### ✨ Pros: The Unassailable Strengths * **Masterful Lyricism & Poetic Vision**: This is the album's greatest strength. Scott-Heron delivers his "bluesologist" philosophy with razor-sharp wit and profound pathos. The lyrics are dense with meaning, painting vivid pictures of struggle and resilience without ever becoming preachy . * **Innovative & Stripped-Back Production**: The minimalist production was a bold, creative choice that pays off immensely. By stripping away the layers, the emotional weight of the lyrics and Jackson's nuanced keyboard work are given space to breathe, creating an atmosphere that is both haunting and deeply personal . * **Perfect Artistic Synergy**: The collaboration with Brian Jackson is at its peak. Jackson's ability to translate Scott-Heron's poetic and political concepts into powerful, evocative music is remarkable. His piano and keyboard work provide the perfect emotional and melodic foundation for Scott-Heron's delivery . * **Profound and Lasting Influence**: The album's DNA can be heard in countless artists who followed. As a precursor to conscious hip-hop and neo-soul, its fusion of political and social commentary with jazz and soul set a blueprint for a generation of socially aware musicians . * **Commercial Success Despite Indie Roots**: Released on the independent Strata-East label with limited initial distribution, the album still managed to reach number six on Billboard's Top Jazz Albums chart and sell over 300,000 copies, a testament to its powerful resonance with the public . ### ⚠️ Cons: Potential Points of Criticism * **Dense and Unrelentingly Somber Tone**: The album's mood is one of persistent, melancholic reflection. For a listener seeking escapism or uplift, the unyielding weight of its themes can be emotionally draining. There is little respite from the "winter" it so vividly describes . * **Sparse Arrangements Can Feel Repetitive**: While the minimalist production is a defining strength for many, others might find the sparse arrangements—particularly the reliance on Jackson's electric piano—somewhat repetitive across the album's extended tracks, which often run over eight minutes . * **Limited Historical Context**: While a timeless classic, some of the most potent and specific political commentary (like the Watergate scandal addressed in "H2Ogate Blues") is deeply rooted in the context of its time, which might slightly diminish its immediate impact for a modern listener unfamiliar with that specific era. "Winter In America" is an essential, monumental work of art that stands as a powerful testament to the role of the musician as a social critic. Its strengths are so immense that any perceived weaknesses are largely a function of its unflinching artistic vision. It is an album that demands to be heard, felt, and contemplated—a true classic that speaks as much to the past as it does to the present.
I didn’t really connect with this, a totally fine listen. But I definitely see its downstream retrospective influence on other styles. And then H2Ogate Blues kicked in, and damn. Preach it indeed. It’s sad how relevant that number is today too.
Huh. Didn’t dislike this but just didn’t connect with what they were doing. I guess kind of r&b with some jazz influence? Seemed like he didn’t really write any lyrics and just kind of sang whatever came to mind. I was probably rounding down to a 2 but damn H2Ogate was a speech. Preach. Damn, scary how relevant that ish is today. Change a few names and the world keeps turning. Rounding up for that.
Thought I would like this a lot more. Odd that all his popular songs are from a different album. Not sure why we got this one. Still good enough for a middle of the road rating… I guess. 2.5/5
The bottle var heilt rå, og første låt fanga, ellers blei det veldig likt og kjedelig
Great voice with soulful sounds. Liberal use of stereo phasing effects which can get quite distracting. Some parts were quite slow but some parts were funky. Nice use of the flute. 2/5
You can tell just how influential GSH was to future artists. A true original. Such an important voice for so many. The songs themselves get a bit repetitive after a while, but I enjoyed it.
Such a beautiful, educational, and poignant album.
Как музыка это ни о чём. Лирику оценил, революционно.
own
the first song wasnt good so I skipped around and it was all garbage. If I could give this a negative score I would
ig weiss immer no nid.
Blues auf erträgliche Art
I can tell this album is doing something, but it is opaque to my tastes.
Slow to grab my attention but I liked it by the end.
I have not heard this before. A lot of my friends have been talking up Gil Scott Heron for a while and I’ve been meaning to check out his music, so here’s my chance. So this is a good mix of soul and jazz and blues that’s all cohesive, and I dig the laid back nature of a lot of the music that still has some fierce urgency to it.
I hadn’t heard o f Gil Scott-Heron. It was interesting. It reminded me of Leonard Cohen meets Curtis Mayfield with some Isaac Hayes mixed in for fun. His slower songs were very train -of-thought, like A Very Precious Time. I could totally see a Friday night brandy, some smoke and headphones with this on vinyl. My key tracks here were the upbeat ones like Back Home and the Bottle, both of which had the combination of his urban street smart lyrics and great musical skills. The flute, which normally I abhor in songs outside of classical (yep, no Jethro for me), was actually complimentary. This was a fun listen.
Random thoughts: * This is a cousin to Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On". * I think this album gets better upon additional listens. I passively listened the first time while cooking dinner and weird parts jumped out in that setting. Second listen was on headphones while working and I caught way more this time around. * Love the organ sounds on the opening track. * Clearly this is about the downfall of America and it crescendos with H20gate Blues. I need an updated version for today with 1/6/2021 Blues. Who would make this album? Beyonce? Anderson.Paak? * I especially liked The Bottle. Funky and upbeat and easy to grasp what it is about right away. * I've kept encountering Gil Scott-Heron and am glad to be formally introduced via this album. I didn't realize he was the "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" guy. You definitely need to go listen to this one too! * Solid entry to 1001. Glad to hear and learn more about Gil Scott-Heron. He'd be pissed to see hat is happening in America 50 years after his works.
Muy lindo álbum, es tremendo que con sólo una batería, un bajo y el impecable trabajo armónico del teclado y la voz se construyan canciones muy buenas y con letras que se ajustan a las vibras de cada tema, dándole al álbum un tono de crítica social potente sobre todo el magistral "Watergate Blues".
Deu pra ouvir nao pai
spox 3
Always loved him - ended up listening to this a few times and then I read up to understand the why about this album and now I love him more <3
There’s a hint of spring tucked inside the cold days of winter. A warmer breeze. A few more minutes of daylight. Small signs of what’s ahead. Optimism begins to stir.
The second listen is better than the first. And the third better still. Some albums you need to meet them where they're at - they're not doing to you. The grooves work better then the slow jams but overall an enticing stew. Tasty flute licks abound and when you are done you can't help but feel you have learned a little something and something...3.5 stars.
A mid to slow paced, sonically sparse, Jazzy and bluesy album. Nothing really wowed me. Three stars. As the link to the album on Spotify doesn't work, it can be found here - https://open.spotify.com/album/2wg5odL4oUsDISjIuNApyK Side one 1 "Peace Go with You, Brother (As-Salaam-Alaikum)" (4/5) 2 "Rivers of My Fathers" (3/5) 3 "A Very Precious Time" (2/5) 4 "Back Home" (3/5) Side two 1 "The Bottle" (4/5) 2 "Song for Bobby Smith" (3/5) 3 "Your Daddy Loves You" (3/5) 4 "H2Ogate Blues" (3/5) 5 "Peace Go with You Brother (Wa-Alaikum-Salaam)" (3/5) Total - 28 Average - 3.1 411/1001 212/411 albums reviewed were new to me
don't forget Brian Jackson! first few tracks sounded the same. picked up the pace a bit then lost interest at 8 minute long talky track. good Sunday morning vibes but probably wouldn't listen to again.
I'd probably say 4-4.5 for the album itself but I'm imagining I'll be looking into more of him
Not really what I'm into, but it was a strong political message and the good kind of jazz.
good mix of blues and jazz and funk, though i wouldn't say it excels at any of them. takes a good swing at it nevertheless.
This is one of those albums that is important on this list, as it seems to be both politically conscious of the time (discussing issues that relate (and still relate) to the black community) and influential. However, listening to this album nowadays, it really doesn't sound that special compared to how the sound would have sounded back in 74'. There isn't that amazing moment that blew me away; it's just a nice, easy-listening album.
Very cool. The guy’s voice can be a little much at times but overal great musicianship and lyrics. Nice surprise
it made me fall asleep while driving. 1/5
I liked the jazzy musicianship of many of the tracks. I didn't like the vocals, whether sang or just talking over the tracks. Ultimately if this was an instrumental album I would have given it a much higher score. 1/5
Not the best Gil Scott-Heron but still decent, The Bottle is really good and I like the bass here
Quiet, pretty and smooth but kind of amateur in a likeable way. Drums that fall off time, bass and keys not quite locking in. Didn’t hate it, but didn’t love it
Solid and I can see how it influenced rap acts to come
I have mixed feelings on Gil Scott-Heron's albums. His best tracks are out of this world good, and he's as important for socially conscious soul as he is for hiphop. Peace go with you brother and Back Home are good examples of this. And The Bottle is absolutely superlative. Watergate is a great spoken word/proto rap track. Torn between a high three and a four on this one. His singles might lift this to a four, I guess, but I'm not convinced this is an absolutely excellent album. It just has excellent tracks. So going high 3. But his slow stuff is painfully slow and whiney for me. A Very Precious Time is an example of that. I just don't have the patience for wrist-slitting tracks like that.
Not for me. The Bottle was an easier listen than any of the others, almost-Disco, but really didn't like any of the backing music tracks. The vocals were meaningful, but not especially musical. If there was a time for this style of music, I missed it.
Damn this album slaps. A full vibe throughout with smooth jazz mixed with strong blues/funk lyrics & beats. This is an album with something to say, it has a presence, and though not a lot here are gonna be favourites I'm excited to hear more from Gil Scott-Heron.
I did not like this. This was very dull.
smooth soul jazz plus poetry, not as urgent as Revolution Will Be Televised or Whitey on the Moon. A+ for The Bottle.
As my quick, only rating number, have indicated on my limited deep dives, this was an album I had more time for. Beautiful, exciting. Although little weird mixing on this record, it somehow worked.
as much as i recognize this is good music, it doesnt do much to me
7/10. Un disco muy lindo. Tranquilo y jazzero con buenas líricas y armonizaciones. No sé que más agregar, lo voy a escuchar más seguramente.
The highs make up for the lows. That could be on his tombstone, now that I think about it. Tragic that he would spend so much time in jail. Anyway, my favorite on here by far is H2Ogate Blues, which is legitimately excellent, and The Bottle is pretty good. All of side one should be disregarded with extreme prejudice.
Even though I've heard of Gil Scott-Heron (or at least his name), I've never really known much of anything about him, nor knowingly heard any of his and Brian Jackson's songs. (Technically, I suppose I *have* heard something from Scott-Heron, namely the classic "The revolution will not be televised", plus all the samples from his works by later rap/hip-hop artists, but until now I didn't have a name for the voice.) This album is a *great* introduction to a very talented and thoughtful duo, to say the least. As I listened, I kept thinking that *this* kind of musical social commentary is what several other 70s albums in this collection tried to do but failed in various ways--Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On", Funkadelic's "One Nation Under A Groove", Sly & The Family Stone's "There's A Riot Goin' On", even Fela Kuti's "Zombie". Admittedly, it's a little uneven at times, but very few tracks seem at all dated (except perhaps the acidic "H2Ogate blues", but it's an entertaining relief valve), and all of them feel just as relevant in 2026 as they likely did in 1974. A shame that the title track didn't make it onto the album proper, as it's arguably even better than the rest, and sadly as prophetic today as it was in Nixon's America (what a sad but true line "democracy is ragtime on the corner / hoping for some rain"). Probably the biggest accolade I can give is that, after reading about the album and Scott-Heron's/Jackson's history, I went and listened to their earlier (1972) "Free Will", which was also impressive, and while it's not as accomplished as "Winter in America", I'm guessing it was even more of an inspiration for the likes of Public Enemy as this album.
I've enjoyed "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" many times and at first was sorry we didn't get that. But this spoken word meandering with flute and keyboard grows on you and even the flaws (here, sometimes too talky) are likeable.
Pretty bonkers.
This is #day732 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… as far as late-night listening goes, this is quite an improvement over yesterday's Iron Maiden record. I'm not a soul kind of person by any means, but I don't mind this one. Jazzy and pleasurable overall. The music really sets the mood. I particularly enjoyed that tiptoeing piano. Nice and delicate. And then there was the spoken-word poetry piece... Not a fan of the vocals, though. This is a 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day733.
Gil Scott-Heron just has a charming way with his voice. I really enjoy it a lot. But what really makes the best songs on here interesting are the lyrics. They pack a heavy punch and contrast the sometimes almost aloof instrumentation. The best examples for this are Peace Go With You, Brother and The Bottle. Scott-Heron manages to portrait and dissect societal and political grievances on here so poignantly without saying too much, reducing them to their core essence and thus delivering a raw and all too visceral portrayal. Then of course there is H2Ogate, a scathing reckoning with the US government of the time. Other songs, like A Very Precious Time and Your Daddy Loves You don’t really have this explicit political nature but seem to be more about personal experiences but unfortunately, they left me rather cold. So yeah, Gil Scott-Heron was an amazing political singer and poet who i can listen to for a long long time. But in my opinion this album is a bit too uneven for me to fully embrace it.
Eh, singing over piano just wasn't clicking for me. H2OGate went pretty hard tho. It gets an extra star for that.
Loved this.
oh mein Gott, der sound ist lush, die vocals sind smooth, die texte sind relevant und die vibes sind immaticulate
Love this. A snippet of time showing music, politic, humour and it sad how much of what is being dealt with doesn't seem to have changes much in the interveening years.
This was really pretty. Very mellow
Dug the music, and the message, but the vocals were a little off putting for my tastes. Came off a bit too much like gospel or Christmas songs at times. 2.5⭐️
Man, I really wish the whole album was like the poetry/rapping track. That thing was worth the wait after those slow R&B songs.
this was groovy as hell, i loved some songs on this, overall a great album
Do you like Jazz?
Delightfully surprised and enjoyed greatly
These songs are long as hell! Alot of soul in this album
2026.08.23.
A very smooth blues/jazz/soul sound, makes you feel like your in the room. An enjoyable listen.
Excellent album. Why does every song have < 2000 listens? 4/5
i'd been lookin forward to this one, and im glad it didn't disappoint. it's pretty fucking bleak thematically, especially given how a lot of the topics covered havent really improved much in the 50+ years since its release, and so the music is often fittingly moody. gil scott-heron got a great voice both speaking and singing and the instrumentals fit perfectly, even when they swing in the total opposite direction to the vibe of the lyrics, like "the bottle" for example, which pairs a series of tales of folks drinking themselves to ruin with a slick funk groove. its a fun use of tonal dissonance for effect and i enjoy it. every single track here is so solid but i think my favourite might be "h2ogate blues", although that mostly just comes down to it having a more tangible anger and bite to it, which is a great change of pace at the end of this otherwise very melancholy album. again though.... always kinda hurts to be reminded how little shits really changed since then huh. yeesh. great album. im kinda bummed out now tho. mannnn.........
Won't play in spotify
Amazing voice. Great music to just lounge around to sonically. The message is powerful even today.
Pleasantly surprised by this. I liked his voice and loved the jazzy instrumentation. The political and social commentary was interesting too, especially H2Ogate Blues — it's crazy how relevant some of it still feels 50 years later. Not something I'd necessarily listen to again, but I enjoyed it more than I expected. And the flute kept making me think of Ron Burgundy! 😂
Labeled as R&B/Soul on Apple Music, this is starting out to sound like a jazz record. There’s something about it that screams early 1970’s, which it is. Not sure if Stevie Wonder inspired it or vice versa, but it sounds somewhat similar in theme, although more subdued, and with lesser songwriting ability. H2Ogate Blues is a standout track, incredibly timely despite being over 50 years old. 3.5 stars
I was a little bit surprised that it wasn't Pieces of a Man which I've listened to before and is excellent! It was good to hear something different from him though and whilst this wasn't exactly immediate, it's one I can see myself coming back to and picking up more from it each time. Hard to describe, a mix of jazz, funk and soul but not really any of those things definitively.H2Ogate Blues is a fantastic track though; this albums The Revolution Will Not Be Televised
I like their sound. It didn’t grip me necessarily, but seems like it would be a fun concert to go to.
A 2
No notes. The album said everything that needs to be said.
Schönes Jazz? Blues? Album. War sehr überrascht.
Bardzo bym chciała lubić taką muzykę. Ma duszę, ma przesłanie, ma sporą dozę artyzmu. Ale w żaden sposób to ze mną nie rezonuje. Jedyne co czuję prócz nudy to rozczarowanie, że nie jestem na tyle wrażliwa, aby wpaść w zachwyt. 4.5/10 równane w górę, bo dobrze wiem, że tym razem to ja jestem problemem.
Rate: 8/10.
Never listened. Expectations: Mid - Verdict: Great - I know Gil Scott-Heron from The Revolution Will Not Be Televised but I'm not familiar with any of his other work. The opener is very atmospheric and creates a relaxed yet slightly sinister vibe. River Of My Fathers is great with the piano and vocals dancing around each other beautifully. The songs here all have so much space that they can truly breathe and be absorbed by the listener. H2Ogate Blues is brilliant.
Just unbelievably smart and smooth and cool and warm and many other positive adjectives. It’s a fantastic combination of soul vocal stylings (as well as some really good spoken word) with a laid-down jazz style (as well as some funk and blues when they want it) to make this fascinating pioneering work, which also just sounds lush as fuck to listen to. By the time I got to “Your Daddy Loves You”, my emotions were getting swelled for damn real.
nao sou muito fã de musica mais spoken word. e por isos nao me pegou muito. a falta de instrumentos é meio estanha pra mim. nota 2,5/10
Soul, blues, jazz fusion, soul jazz, progressive soul.
His Album was not available on Spotify, so I listen to other songs by him. I did not know if he’s the one that did The Revolution Will not be Televised.
Absolutely phenomenal work
Very personal album. I can transport myself into a concert.
Impressive work of art (lyrically, musically, vocally, politically...), simply the genre and instrumentation do not really click with my tastes, so that only a few songs manage to engage me...
its was fine, cool but not super listenable
It’s a little hard to review a record like this. This is a moment in time piece that wasn’t recorded for me. But I do like it. Gil Scott-Herron is a great writer and his spoken word stuff is really cool. H2Ogate Blues is great - it’s not The Revolution Will Not Be Televised great, but it’s still great.
I started listening to this album with headphones on, and they're doing the thing where the sound is racing back and forth between the left and right channels, and I started getting dizzy. Definitely need to stay off amusement park rides at this stage of my life. I really only know the Revolution Will Not Be Televised album in the GSH catalog. Revolution / Televised and Whitey's On The Moon are great. But his is at best a hit or miss oeuvre. I wanted to like this album, I gave it a listen in good faith, I don't like this album. He's not a singer, and this album relies on him singing. The music has its moments, but ... it's just not happening.
This was a huge disappointment. I really did not enjoy this and I always held Scott-Heron in pretty high esteem. This was hard to get through.
eeeeokei, 7/10, no auto
Love the piano!
Interesting but not really my thing 2
Didn’t listen to it all. The bit I listened to was typically Scott-Heron.
It was a good album. Will I be listening to the whole thing again? Unlikely
This ruled, especially H2Ogate Blues
Politically charged lyrics tight ass band
Good.
Not the biggest fan, but wow H2Ogate Blues
This is what political poetry and music is about. I knew Gil Scott-Heron for "The revolution will not be televised". I thought that was good, but this album is top notch stuff. Great poetry, a great voice, jazzy music, and a strong political message. It can't really get any better than this, to be honest. The pain in his voice can only be matched by the pain he'd feel in nowadays political world. Peace go with you, brother. Your music spoke to countless people, and will eternally do so. Peace go with you, brother.
He has a cool voice and a couple songs were ok. But this was very very boring.
Coincidentally an alright summer album
Gio introduced me to Gil's 'Pieces of a Man' about a decade ago. I remember having the album on repeat, but I didn't explore much outside of that album. I wish I did since I liked 'Winter in America' album a ton... the music was muted and reflective (with a little lively energy from H20gate Blues).
Gil is the man. If you liked this, check out The Watts Prophets. Also, Freddie Gibbs did a dope cover of the title track.
Oh to be sat in a piano bar, drinking martinis and flirting. Cool cats in every booth.
I enjoy Gil Scott-Heron especially his spoken word pieces. Seeing this today was a bit of excitement as I started listening. I heard him singing. He has a good singing voice and the the piano matches his easy singing. These songs are really good and I enjoyed hearing them.
Pretty groovy and chill, could have been a bit higher energy sometimes, but I liked it (and higher energy might actually be the wrong feel for it).
Some zip to this one
A solid album, but a little sparse and low energy for my taste, especially off the heels of Hot Buttered Soul last week. H20Gate Blues and The Bottle slap
A thorough bore.
This is pretty cool and jazzy.
The Good: Knowing we aren’t alone this winter… The Bad: It’s fucking summer here… The Ugly: Hyphened last-names… too progressive! Yeah, the above is a direct nod to Hot Tube Time Machine… which is a lovely movie about a bunch of friends who travel back in time, when things were more fun… Not this album… It let’s us travel in our mind, and makes us ponder, to a certain extent, what we are doing… I really like the album, and yet, I have very little desire to listen to the album with much frequency… maybe because this is not the kind of album you play as background music during a party… I do have a desire to go buy one of his books… 4*
Liian jatsia minun makuun
# Album Name: Winter In America # Artist: Gil Scott-Heron # Rating: 4/5 # Comments: Cracking little listen. I will need to come back to it. I could only find a copy on youtube. # Top Tunes: # Would I listen to it again? Yes
The lyrics for H20 haven't aged a day
I'm not the biggest fan of the blues but this one was quite enjoyable.
1. peace - 2 2. riverz - 1 3. time - 1 4. home - 1 5. bottle - 2 6. bobby - 2 7. daddy - 2 8. bluez - 1 9. brother - 1
Dafür dass es Jazz ist, echt okay!
Artsy... I hear emotions, but it's a little too minimalistic in sound.
Favourite Songs: Rivers Of My Fathers The Bottle
Schönes Soul-Album, ziemlich jazzig.
This was smooth asf. Makes me wanna learn piano
Ég hef gaman að þessu, séstaklega H20gate með tilvísuum í Spiro Agnew og olíukreppuna, sem og leiðbeiningunum um hvar megi finna þessi plötu í plötuverslunum. Grínlaust, töff og gott stöff.
One Poet + One Jazz Pianist - maybe not the two together. I love protest music but what makes protest music last, is its timelessness - not sure this record shouldnt have been left behind in the with Watergate. Brian Jackson though has some grooves.
Also fine, not my favorite. It has some raw passion but vocally loses it a bit and is a little grating for me on rivers of my fathers
I’m writing this about a week after I listened, so forgive me if details are a bit sketchy… the album has a nice sound that is relaxed and jazzy, a modern comparison is probably Charm by Clairo. H2ogate Blues is a funny take on Watergate too. It was a bit samey though in places, so it possibly lacked more ideas than that relaxed jazzy sound. A good listen, but probably not more than 3*.
This record has some fantastic moments on it and serves as a compelling critique of 1970s America. 'H20 Gate Blues' is an amusing takedown of Nixon's America, album highlight 'The Bottle' highlights the problems of alcohol abuse. I enjoy the overall sound of the record too.
This is a solid jazzy soul/blues album, based around the classic piano, bass and drums trio, with occasional flute guest appearances. The lyrics deal with various aspects of mid-70s African-American life, which makes it interesting as a historical piece, although musically I liked but didn’t love it. ‘The Bottle’ was my favourite track, having the best beat, a fantastic bassline, and a cracking flute solo, plus great lyrics examining alcohol abuse, drug addiction, crime, etc. ‘Your Daddy Loves You’ was another highlight. ‘H2Ogate Blues’ was funny, but I’m not really a fan of spoken word tracks. Strong 3 stars.
What a total pain to track down since it’s not on the main streaming apps, but honestly, it’s worth the hunt. There’s something so special about the way Gil Scott-Heron’s deep, gritty voice locks in with Brian Jackson’s Rhodes piano. It’s just pure chemistry. Tracks like "H2Ogate Blues" and "Your Daddy Loves You" hit hard, and you can’t talk about this one without mentioning the classic groove of "The Bottle". Sure, the production is pretty stripped-back and his vocals aren't polished in the traditional sense, but don't let that put you off. The songwriting is so sharp and socially relevant that it still feels vital today. A total masterpiece, plain and simple.
Not on Spotify
Some really good R&B and Soul on this. I hadn't heard this before, but really liked it. 7/14/26
Not to get political, but because this album is EXTREMELY political, I'll say that Talking Heads said it best when they said, same as it ever was.
Not sure that I will think oh let’s listen to that again but I liked it.
Interesting - I like some of it, but for me it was a little too long. Also it wasn't on Spotify, so I had to go to YouTube. Not as good as an experience as Spotify.
no lo escuché completo pero me estaba gustando mucho, hasta la mitad me doy un sólido 8/10
I’m a little embarrassed to say that I hadn’t heard Scott-Heron sing before. I was really only familiar with “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised”, so I assumed this album would just be more of that. But no! This guy’s got some pipes! Jackson’s work on here rocks. Rises to meet each song where it’s at. The instrumentation is consistently great across the album. I’m familiar with Scott-Heron’s influence on hip-hop, but this also signaled his impact on soul. I don’t think it’s hyperbole to say both genres as we know them today would not be the same if Scott-Heron’s work was disappeared from history. “The Bottle” is a straight-up banger.
Good record. Dug it.
Smooth and groovey, with thoughtful lyrics and interesting vocals. Glad to have listened to it, even if it was a little TOO smooth for my sleepy morning drive.
Kind of sounds like he is just making up lyrics as the song goes on. I also don’t know how to describe it but he sounds like he is fake singing. He also doesn’t really go with the background music. This is like a 5/10 jazz album without the singing but like a 2/10 with the singing. The longer it went on the worse it got. I am now convinced someone was playing at a jazz bar and this guy just like walked in and started singing and no one stopped him. 1/10
This is very good. Powerful, jazzy, bluesy, political, poetry. A great listen.
Very nice album; well done, a pleasant listening experience. The H2Ogate blues song was particularly noteworthy.
I liked this album. Little bit of jazz piano, jazz synthesizer, jazz flute. A lot of variety in the soundscape. Crazy how so much of the lyrical content is still relevant today. Not a huge fan of long talking or lecture sections in any album, no matter how relevant.
It's interesting in parts but I wouldn't listen again. I like his voice but not much you can get into
Those first few songs are some of the most relaxing soul music I've ever heard. I loved how sparse they were and how the singer's voice filled all the empty space. The rest of the album is just some good music. It's Gil Scott-Heron, so it's almost guaranteed to be pretty good, but admittedly I wish they just kept the energy of the really quiet first half.
Still relevant 50 years later.
I probably need to listen again and focus on the lyrics because that appeared to be what this album is known for. The music was fine but didn't really move the needle for me.
2.5 - I'd rate it higher if doing so on just the message and lower if doing so on just my enjoyment of the music.
Niet op Spotify, ik heb deze versie gebruikt: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7yiTP6QNhf0 Er lijkt bijna een soort disconnect te zijn tussen de muziek, die bijna ambient, jazzy en hoopvol is en de duistere, heftige lyrics en de manier waarop de lyrics gebracht worden? Interessant vind ik ook wel datik niet de grootste fan ben ban Gil zn manier van zingen? Ik krijg bijna het idee dat er 2 verschillende albums in 1 worden afgespeeld ofzoiets. Het is een aparte gewaarwording zo. Ok, de tweede helft van het album klinkt eigenlijk al weer een stuk beter! H20gate blues, zoooo dat is een blauwdruk voor latere Public Enemy zeg! Hele minimale instrumentale stukken en gewoon Gil die minuten lang uitlegt wat er allemaal fout is en gaat. Heel interessant en heftig nummer ook. De politieke boodschap van Gil is sowieso nog steeds relevant, ruim 50 jaar na dato. Deprimerend, en dan nog steeds de soulvolle funky jazzy soundtrack. Indrukwekkend album, ik weet niet of ik het snel vaker zou luisteren, maar het is wel goed om het een keer gehoord te hebben. H20gate blues is, denk ik althans, ontzettend belangrijk geweest voor hiphop. FAVO: Back Home, The bottle, H20gate blues
Enjoyable, the more I hear of Gil, the more I like it. A true pioneer.
Winter in America It’s such a shame this is a YT listen as I think it would be something I’d return to a lot if access was easier. I love the rippling electric piano of Peace Go With You, Brother, setting up the floating jazzy feel of the whole album, with Rivers of My Fathers leaning much more into piano jazz, and I love how it patiently and tastefully unfolds over its 8 minutes, supporting it’s lyrical themes of history and cultural identity. A Very Precious Time on occasion with a slightly anodyne electric-piano jazz feel, but on repeat listens it really grew on me, again the jazz-tastefulness is appealing to me. Back Home is really great though, with excellent bass and piano and lovely flute accents. The Bottle, the one song from this album I was previously aware of, is also of course excellent with a similarly superb bassline and flute and latin-dancey rhythm against the sad despair of the lyrics. I love the downtempo soul-jazz of Song for Bobby Smith and especially Your Daddy Loves You (despite some Ron Burgundy-isms on the flute on occasion), sandwiched between The Bottle and the truly excellent H20gate Blues. This is more in the vein of his proto-rapping style, and is typical of GSH in that he somehow manages to make/sing/rap social commentary in a way that isn’t at all heavy handed. I guess the continuous flow of images and ideas keeps it interesting and stops it getting bogged down in bad sixth form poetry or cringeworthy slam poetry. And I love the return of Peace Go With You, Brother, bookending the album beautifully. It’s a great album, one that I’d never heard before and is easily a 5. 🇺🇲🇺🇲 Playlist submission: H20gate Blues or The Bottle? I’ll go The Bottle
From the top it's very soulful. Some of it is very jazzy. The lyrics are solid - some of it is very loving and some of it is very political (of its place and time, but applicable more broadly). I'm quickly enamoured of Brian Jackson's playing and arrangements. The whole is tasteful and sensitive, varied but coherent. It's Good, 7/10.
Love the DC references.
Truly awesome record. I didn't know Gil Scott-Heron at all, but it's amazing how much of our current period is reflected in this album. H2OGate blues is the most obvious connection here, but there are a lot of our current musical tendencies (jazz rap, neo soul) embedded in this. I love this record because GSH is very much doing his own thing, but he's obviously tied to a larger tradition (soul, blues, jazz). The best music, to me, is individual and subversive while tied to something larger, and that's what this one does. Wow.
Ts Don't exist
Just how blind America? The limit does not exist. Was this written in the 70s or yesterday? The names have changed but the atrocities are the same (and we seem to have added a few to the list). This one track makes the album. Thanks, fellow users, for the call out of “Pieces of a Man”, I'll be listening to that next. -- Reporting back: yeah “Pieces of a Man” is a better album. Wow. What an artist. Both of these albums should be on this list.
RATING: 5/10 HIGHLIGHT: H20 Blues LOWLIGHT: Rivers of My Fathers
This album felt serious but beautiful. I enjoyed the instrumentals and lyrics.
Wow.
Зима в Америке без нашего газа холодная
Challenging listen.
I, too, have the H20GATE Blues... Isn't it amazing how history rhymes?
cant listen to the album.. .-.
Easily the best jazz-related LP I've drawn so far. I'm not sure I can explain why - it's just 100% cooler than the usual noodling. Oozing confidence, without ever trying to impress. Contains a lot of the things I usually moan about with this sort of music, but I can't deny I enjoyed listening to this, already being a casual fan of some of Gil Scott-Heron's other work.
Ngl I thought he was a new singer
This was a good enough album without anything overly standing out for me. Faded into the background at times. Top Track - The Bottle
Unavailable
Cannot find
I am a Kendrick Lamar sample identifying machine on this list and here we are again. What a sick origin for Poe Man's dreams. This album is beautiful. Just feel like I'm floating listening to this, is this going to be the like fourth 5 this week? Crazy. Just absurd keyboard instrumentals, a beautiful voice, the songs are all amazing. Good pull, list.
3 - good
Was not expecting to like this so much
4 de 5 Soul, jazz y spoken word componen ésta obra de Gil Scott-Heron, sobresaliente por su instrumentación minimalista y sus letras cargadas de una puntual crónica social, de la comunidad afroamericana durante los años setenta y la desilusión de el país americano en esa misma década, todo contenido en una atmósfera melancólica, íntima y a la vez, cálida. A destacar: Track 3 - A Very Precious Time Track 4 - Back Home Track 5 - The Bottle Track 6 - Song For Bobby Smith Track 7 - Your Daddy Loves You
A nice soul album. Nothing more, nothing less
Couldn’t find :(
Beautiful!!
Ok
6/10 - I couldnt hear the full album due to Spotify restrictions but the few songs i did hear were decent
Watergate Blues sounds like a description of today
This album is as much Brian Jackson as Gil Scott-Heron. Gil had a unique voice but is a bit off at times. The slower songs with Rhodes keyboard are more about the lyrics/ poetry than music and are not that great. The more uptempo and jazz songs with piano are good though.
New to me, pretty good working music
Annoyingly not available on AM or Spotify. GSH tries his hand at heartfelt jazz, and does a passably good job. You can feel the lived experience in the lyrics and the way he sings them, and the electric piano makes you feel like you’ve been transported to a 70s lounge bar.
note on spotify... # crazy
People rightfully point to Scott-Heron & The Last Poets as the progenitors of hip-hop, but Gil is the more explainable & precedented phenomenon in that he's carrying on the legacies of folk like Marvin Gaye, Curtis Mayfield, & Sly Stone. Never a great singer, he yet doesn't need to be, nor does he have to be a great lyricist, even tho the lyrics are more front & center than the voice. This is a record/an artist of religious vivacity, + a keyboardist in Brian Jackson w/ enuf Jarrett & Monk in him to distinctly impress. 'Rivers of my Fathers / Could you carry me home?' Afrocentrism certainly didn't begin w/ Heron, & he's not only that kind of artist ('A Very Precious Time'), but one's gotta count him amongst the best movers of those perspectives.
Pretty darn good and the end message felt relevant even today.
I listened to this YouTube playlist, not even sure if the tracklist is correct: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSSNXW9EANA&list=PLDIxWXRU4UDpUpAB4vMTUroYuvodq118L Felt like a weird open mic/musical/adlib thing. Was ok, 3*
really close to a 5, the chocolate girl song was a bit weird, can't believe I've never listened to this guy before will def get on his other stuff
Yes yes more of this please!
Talented musicians. I loved the song The Bottle. A few other songs were enjoyable, but about half I did not care for.
As sharp and soulful as it gets! Favourite tracks: Peace Go With You, Back Home,
Couldn't find it on Apple Music.
Scott-Heron isn't much of a singer, but I like the flutes on this a lot, actually. Like a lot of people in the reviews, this one's making me want to revisit Pieces of a Man, an album which I definitely didn't know how to appreciate the first time I heard it. H2Ogate Blues goes a bit more into the spoken-word poetry of that album, and I enjoy it here, so hopefully I'll better appreciate his work in general now.
4/5
I was unable to listen to this on streaming platforms so I listened to the next album " the revolution will not be televised " funky,smooth and full of soul. I dig it.
You'd almost be thinking that history repeats itself.
fine ig
Went back and forth on this one. 3.4.
Personal enjoyment: 2/5 Relevance to this list: 5/5
"Four more years..."
Review - a good album but not on streaming services which is a pain. Score - 6/10 Need to listen? YES
Okay, I get that the book editors never intended for anyone to actually listen to every album in the book, but now that people are doing so, it would be great if future editions gave some consideration for the accessibility on streaming platforms. This is especially frustrating because it is hard to see his influence on future music in this record. I ended up having to piece this together, one track at a time. In this case it was worth the effort, but it was annoying. I digress. On Winter in America we are treated with “the godfather of rap” who provides thought provoking lyrics delivered over some incredible piano music provided by Brian Jackson. Beautiful and soulful music with a message. This was a good album, but the most interesting part was listening and thinking about its place in music history.
Crazy funky. Sticky icky and kind of exactly what I wanted. Well produced, well written, and well compiled.
the album is not available on spotify
A satisfying listen
This is SMOOTH, and overall just really pretty. Awesome jazzy sounds and I love how soothing his voice is. The flutes (for example on "Your Daddy Loves You") sound great on here. "H2Ogate Blues" is my favourite from this album I think. I loved the poignant lyrics and the sort of hiphop vocal delivery. It's a shame that this album isn't on Spotify, otherwise I would return to this often.
I like the part where all of the problems still apply to modern politics and nothing has gotten better. Spoken Word segment is great. Title track is amazing. Title track is also not actually on the album
Winter in America es una obra de una honestidad profunda y una reflexión social necesaria. Aunque no conecté tanto con la metáfora climática del título, el álbum destaca por su realismo y su capacidad para retratar la calle. En piezas como "The Bottle", el ritmo te atrapa de inmediato, pero al prestar atención a la letra entiendes que no es una fiesta, sino una crónica del alcoholismo; esa dualidad es una genialidad que solo los grandes logran. La instrumentación se percibe como una conversación íntima y orgánica entre el piano y la voz, manteniendo una claridad que permite apreciar cada matiz. La voz de Scott-Heron tiene una fuerza y calidez que impone autoridad, especialmente cuando transita entre el canto y la palabra hablada, dándole al disco un aire más agresivo y moderno en su mensaje que otros trabajos de su época. Es un álbum que, aunque puede llegar a ser pesado por sus temáticas, resulta fascinante por su factura artesanal y humana.
Interesting Jazz slash proto rap, that sometimes feels more like a spoken word record with an improvising backing bad. The socially conscious lyrics are very interesting and surprisingly relevant today, but as a music album it doesn't do very much for me.
Some great songs.
Not on Spotify
i don’t like jazz
mmm no es mi tipo jazz muy tranqui yno esa en spoti 1/5
You need to save this in a vault
Really good, more than what I was expecting from this genre / time period. Too bad it isn't on Spotify honestly -- I'd sacrifice 100 albums on this list for it easily.
this is great, i love a lot of the keyboards on here but obviously the main focus is the lyrics. really is sad that this was released in 1974 and virtually nothing has changed since then...
Pieces of a Man isn't in here..... That one is a little less mellow than this but it's just as great so I would recommend it. This album was great. I only knew 'The Bottle' and that song is great. iT'S ALL GREAT.
Not my jam
This was pretty nice. Not the kind of thing I would normally go for, but a nice listen. some real toe-tappers particularly at the beginning.
Fun voice, interesting stories, cool music behind it. I just wish the musical interludes didn't make me feel like I was hanging out in the backrooms.
I find that this is an extremely rich album with a lot of different elements. Its got gospel, jazz, blues, and probably some others that I missed. Didn’t love it, didn’t hate it but I definitely enjoyed my time with it.
Es ist eine reduzierte Mischung aus Soul, Jazz und politischer Lyrik, die atmosphärisch stark ist, aber nicht immer dramaturgisch trägt. Die sozialkritischen Texte wirken zeitlos und Stücke wie „The Bottle“ stechen klar hervor, doch insgesamt bleibt das Album stellenweise zu zurückgenommen und verliert zwischendurch an Spannung. Trotzdem ein wichtiges Werk seiner Ära, nur nicht durchgehend fesselnd.
I was skeptical of this album until he came in hot with the politics at the end. Energy-crises blues continue to this day I’m sorry to report.
Ok tier
Sympa mais galère de trouver l'album
This album, is not on Spotify. But I found it on YouTube. I'll listen to a few. I'm a little behind. I do like the sound of his voice. Kind of sad lyrics on this first track. Oh that wasn't the first track it was Winter In America. Rivers of My Fathers is pretty too. Really Jazzy.
Good jazz, but his voice is a little too present for me!
?/10, недоступно в спотике, скип
8,50/10 Muy buena album, divertido, buenos ritmos, no aburre. Tiene momentos en los que es mas tranquilo pero tambien otros con solos se instrumental que quedan excelentes, te hace mover la cabeza apenas escuchar el ritmo
Muy bueno
not on spotify
Very pretty, but entirely too long.
I put this on and kind of forgot I was listening to it. I'm not sure what that means but at the very least it wasn't offensively bad.
The rabbit hole down YouTube to listen to this is well worth it. The keys, the flutes, Heron’s voice all work so well together to create a cohesive smooth still thematically relevant listen decades after its release. Likes: Peace Go With You, Brother; Rivers of My Fathers; Back Home; The Bottle; Songs for Bobby Smith; Your Daddy Loves You
Дуже поважаю пана Скотта-Херона. Музично в нього завжди все на топ-рівні. Але коли він починає заходити сильно в споукен ворд, він мене втрачає. Тут теж є такі моменти. Музика дуже стильна.
Гіл Скотт-Херон це моя любов, причому як ранній, так і пізній матеріал. Можливо його останній альбом я люблю найбільше, але і тут клас. Кайфовий джаз\соул, політизовані тексти.
Solo he encontrado una lista en Youtube para intentar oírlo. Sonaba bastante bien, pero al no poder seguir bien por donde iba no he podido disfrutarlo. No sé cómo puntuarlo. Lo dejo en un 2.
Na žalost bla primorana poslušat na youtube. Prva polovica albuma se mi je mal blendala together, medtem k prvi komad na Side B, "The Bottle" mi je izstopal. (Velikrat tko vidiš, zakaj so določen komad izbral za single z albuma.) Konkretno izstopal je tud predzadnji komad, k je v bistvu spoken word, "H2Ogate Blues". Mogoč bi me preostali album bolj pritegnil, če bi blo vse spoken word? Ker ta, ta je bla pa res dobra.
Really cool jazz, soul, blues almost folk? This is real American music. Its hard to give it a label, I want to say soul and gospel, but it even has some elements of folk and blues to it. Maybe its vocals, which are good, but really unique. He kind of croons and cries, but also has a touch of apathy in his voice. It kind of reminds me of Andre 3000. Which I guess is why this is such a huge influence on Hip Hop because he definitely raps on a few songs. H20gate Blues is a song that every American should listen to. It should be required in history classes for high schoolers. The social commentary, the songs about love all kind of make this record really solid.
You can hear the influences of this album in thousands of releases that followed, by a huge range of artists. Musically it is beautifully put together, so easy to listen to. I don't think anyone would claim that the vocals are the strongest part - the message being delivered is clear though. A classic album, I was not disappointed.
I hated this. It wasn’t on Spotify or Apple Music, so I had to listen to it on YouTube, which is annoying. I just wanted it to be over.
This was a real treat. I had to use Youtube to find this album and listened while attending all day volleyball tournament at Christian high school. This is important because I spent about 4 more hours exploring this artists work once the album was done. I was previously familiar with this artist in name only from Losing My Edge. (I should recognize LCD style in general made the spoken word format of this artist more approachable from get go). I previously thought Whitey on the Moon was a Garett Morris-SNL skit. I did not know some many lines from OBAA were taken from The Revolution Will Not Be Televised. How did I grow up never exposed to something that seems now so culturally relevant? Thanks, dad. So the album was great. I thought the collection of his work was even better. I seem to be a sucker for political and social commentary right now - Public Enemy earlier in the week - likely owing to disaster that is Trump 2.0. We also circled the moon this week making Whitey even more relevant. I needed this yesterday. 4/5
So en Banger eif nöd uf Sporify
Good, good. 3.7
not sure I listened to the entire album as it was not available on Spotify. I listened on YouTube. It is just a spoken word/poem reading. Definitely impactful but not anything that I am going to listen to
The song writing is terrific here. His singing voice got to me a little after a while.
Не чув про таких) Соул-джаз, мудачливий музончик)
Great listen.
Man what a good album. Loved how stripped down and raw the album felt. I’d only ever heard the revolution will not be televised so was pleasantly surprised at Gil’s singing voice
Was difficult to find this album. Ended up using YouTube so it wasn’t ideal to listen to in the car. I feel like I need to spend more time with this one to truly appreciate it. It’s smooth and cool and jazzy, but then politically charged and spoken word. Not sure how to rate … not my personal taste, but also objectively interesting and the artist has a lot to say. I’m gonna give it a 3, although it probably warrants a 4. I also understand a lot of folks think this isn’t the most representative music of Sot-Heron’s catalog. The Revolution Will Not be Televised (which I do know and think highly of) might’ve been a better place to start.
Can’t find the album anywhere
next album we've got a little mood change, a groovy soul album that's centered on... well, the american dream. with the current state of affairs, gil essentially asks the question. "so what did all this shit lead up to?" meaningful, creative, melodic, dreamy... it really hits a lot of the checkmarks in my mental music goal list. it's full of life, and even with the relaxing and arguably warm sound... it's very somber and cold. i absolutely dig that sweet sweet rhodes. a very different way to talk about the state of the world, less rage and more... i don't know. exhaustion. like a simple "what are we doing?! what are we even doing right now?" i react the same every other day.
2.2 1x youtube
Best discovery so far
Je connaissais que The Bottle et c’est finalement la meilleure, pour le reste c’est sympa mais sans plus (demanderait peut-être une écoute supplémentaire)
Loved his voice. Enjoyed the jazzy, occasionally bluesy, soulful politics of this album. The things I liked here have me bumping my rating up a bit so I’ll rate this a 4/5
This is exactly what I signed up for. Something I'd never even been aware of that turns out to be a gem. Just great jazz piano playing with a soulful voice singing great lyrics. Never heard of it before and suddenly it's a favourite.
Great album.
Still relevant
Favorite Song: Your Daddy Loves You
I've heard some of his spoken word stuff but this is the first time I've heard Gil sing. He's got a very nice, soulful voice and it worked well for this kind of chilled out soul/jazz. This one doesn't appear to be on any of the streaming services but it's easy to find on youtube and worth a listen.
really nice
I love Gil Scott-Heron in theory. In THEORY.
Familiar with the name but can't say I've ever listened to Gil Scott-Heron. Man I have been missing out, this is excellent. I listened to some of his other recordings and Pieces of a Man should be on this list also. Chuck D and Public Enemy borrowed heavily from these cats. Highly enjoyable.
un clásico del jazz de podría decir? malísimo que no esté en spotify
I am not a fan of Jazz at all so while the social issues presented are important I don't listen to this style of music much. 3 stars or C.
So damn good. This is about to launch my Gil Scott-Heron obsession era. Favorite track: The Bottle 4.5/5
I didn’t like
This is really great so far. A bit jazzy but definitely no jazz overload, which can get too much for my philistine ears. This really showcases his wide variety of talents, Gil had an amazing singing voice as well as lyrics/poems that hit to the heart of America, both at the time and present.
This album started off well and then it slowed down and dragged on for a bit. The instruments were well played.