Reviews (page 3 of 7)
It was lacking tempo
Very nice. Sounded great, like the sociopolitical commentary in it. Really don't have any complaints.
more spoken word & less singing-overlaid on some repeated simple loops. was bored by end.
I wonder what did ukraine to this dude that he's tracks are blocked on Spotify. Not bad tho
Mitt eneste forhold til Gil Scott-Heron, utover noen enkeltsanger og å vite kæm han va, e egentlig slampoesien til Sarah Jones og «Your Revolution Will Not Happen Between These Thighs». Som jo mer e en nabo til Scott-Herons originale. Som jo ikke engang e på akkurat det her albumet. Men æ kom liksom ikke helt blindt til det, bare mest blindt. Så æ blei ikke overraska over at æ likte det, men æ blei kanskje litt overraska over kor godt æ likte det. Stemninga, musikken, stemmen, alt fungere.
DIDNT LISTEN- not on Spotify
Interesting... I liked the spoken word moments better than the sung moments—and unfortunately, there was a lot more singing than speaking. "The Bottle" was a lot of fun, and "H2Ogate Blues" was another high point, highlighting Scott-Heron's political poetry. I can absolutely see the influence he had on hip hop. Some of the flute and bass work throughout this album is wonderful. But I found side one to be uninteresting at best, and irritating at worst. So, some good, some bad. Certainly deserving of its entry on the list. A solid 3 for me.
This was a cool listen. Very refreshing to hear music done this way. Also doesn’t hurt that it was made in what seems to be the best era for warm sounding music recordings, the ‘70s. Makes me wonder why music like this isn’t more popular or isn’t attempted more. Could be the slight abstraction of it? Or the guts it would take to have a deep set of words and to just go for it with the delivery? But who am I kidding? It’s just the unfortunate truth that most listeners of music are very conservative and at this point in time, have no attention span to appreciate deep abstractions. I only know Gil Scott-Heron from “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised” so it’s great to hear something else and will definitely be looking out for some more material by him and his collaborator Brian Jackson.
3.8 A very precious time, kinda drags on. Liked almost everything else
It is a 3 because all I can find is a single, but I like Gil Scott-Heron
3.9
1 - TERRIBLE
Erg cool, zowel de sound als de boodschap. Pijnlijk hoe relevant een nummer als H²ogate nog steeds is
Nooit naar Gil Scott-Heron geluisterd, en dat bleek een grote fout. Wat een plaat. De man is duidelijk niet de beste zanger, maar z'n muziek is zo levendig en scherp. 'Winter in America' (het nummer in bijzonder) is helaas actueler dan ooit. Niet op streaming, dus tijd om deze plaat te pakken te krijgen.
It took me 10 days and a free trial of Apple Music to listen to this as it's not on Spotify. The anticipation has only made the disappointment worse. Messy, stream-of-consciousness jazz, that thinks it's infinitely cooler than it is. Just after announcing a 'blues' track, it's ruined by atonal chat over the top. I will never listen to this again. Jazz is exhausting.
Jazz poetry whose words stand the test if time and could even be more relevant today (2026) than when they were written.
Even though it's technically a compilation album, "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" is the only Gil Scott-Heron album that should be on this list.
2/10
Winter in America is a record that earns its place in the canon without quite earning a permanent spot in the rotation. The musicianship throughout is genuinely strong — Brian Jackson’s flute and piano work give the album a warm, jazz-inflected intimacy that keeps it from feeling like a lecture, and the production’s lo-fi rawness adds authenticity rather than detracting from it. When the music and the message are fully integrated, the results are compelling. “The Bottle” is the clearest example of that integration working at full power. The groove is deep and unhurried, the social commentary is woven into the fabric of the song rather than delivered from a podium, and the whole thing moves with a confidence that makes Scott-Heron’s cultural importance feel lived-in rather than historical. It’s the track that most clearly shows what this collaboration was capable of. The sticking point is the spoken word format itself — not a flaw in Scott-Heron, who has a genuinely cool voice and important things to say, but a fundamental mismatch with how this particular listener engages with music. When the groove steps back to make room for the poetry, the attention drifts. The music is at its best as a conversation, not a backdrop. A respectful three — important, intimate, and occasionally brilliant, but ultimately a record to admire more than inhabit.
Skaplig jazz, inte för mig
Not for me!
Not on Spotify
Immediately, I felt like I was in some sort of intimate, smoky cocktail lounge. Everything's just so free-flowing and casual. This is a good display of where jazz was at in the early 70's, given the freer and more avant-garde structure. Scott-Heron's bluesy/jazzy vocals over the mood-setting electric piano played by Jackson make for a great and comforting pairing all throughout. The storytelling and social commentary isn't (and shouldn't be) lost on the listener either, as Scott-Heron is convincing as much as he is charming with his words and delivery. Fun listen when I wasn't sure what to expect going in.
Gear: Grado Hemp Artwork: 👁️☀️🧧 Production: 😌👂🧈 Music: 🇺🇸✊🎷 Rating: ❄️❄️❄️/5
A marvellous album, combining jazz, funk, and a wise, dark poetic worldview
Only could find album title song, but enjoyed listening to it.
LOVE Gil, don’t get me wrong. And there were absolutely parts here that i also loved, but not enough unfortch😥
Pretty good album. A direct example of history repeating itself.
Amazing discovery
This is more of a poetry reading done to music, favoring more of the message in the poem to the music of the song. While this is usually a turn off for me personally, I feel like this strikes a political message which we need more of today. I probably won't be revisiting this anytime soon, we need more outcry and dissent over what is happening in the world today.
What a album! What a artist! Loved the bass lines!
I have a lot of respect for him…some of his songs are on my liked list. But this album was a bit much jazzing for me.
Jazz hands everywhere. He is undeniable though.
not my usual music but overall pleasant!
mellow and groovy, great jazz/blues tracks here. really enjoyed this! favorites: rivers of my fathers, very precious time, h2ogate blues, winter in america
Started off a bit meh, once I got into it it was a surprise how much I enjoyed this
This wasn’t available on my streaming service so ended up looking on YouTube and being unsure which song was which. This was after listening to the song of the same name and liking it a lot, only to find the song is not part of the album. Between a 3 (for the music, a little too plinky plonky jazz) and 4 for the vocals and lyrics. Rounding up to remind me to try again. 3.5
It's a soul-ful album and definitely a politically charged album. I love the keyboard sound. I also like that some of the track sound like the kind of jazz where I wouldn't expect to have vocals, but there are vocals and they fit.
While I didn't love everything equally, but there was a lot to love and he was definitely a singular voice.
Listening to H20gates just makes me tired. & that Scott-Heron was a victim of Reagan's war on drugs - and likely his own demons - is just the icing on the cake. This fucking country.
This album was just ok, nothing to call home about. I don’t love the singer’s voice, it feels very scratchy to my ears.
Hard to find online... but fun and unique! Might listen again just to experience it differently, because it didn't really click this time for me. I liked his tangent about the different types of blues though.
This is why I sign up for this service. While this album is not on Apple Music currently, I found “the revolution will not be televised” and gave that a listen while searching. So excited to listen to this album on YouTube now. When I hear an album like this I always wonder how it took me so long to find it. This is great. Is this the record that gave us Public Enemy? As I listen to this I hear so much Chuck D. This is a great album.
It was alright. Don't remember too much to be honest.
Huge bump up for H20gate Blues
There is something so honest, confrontational, and emotionally sublime about Gil Scott-Heron's work with Jackson that you cannot help but be drawn into it on multiple levels. On the one hand it is a time capsule, but it is also relevant and poignant. Musically, it is mesmerizing. I'm no Jazz expert, but the mood created by both voice and keyboard is haunting and demanding. So, so, good. Peace Go With You Brother is exhortation, benediction, and desperate prayer rolled into one. There is a sense of pleading in this album that stands out against much of the rage, complaint, and rebellion in a lot of the albums on this list. Amazing.
Although there were some bright spots - mostly where the songs and style were upbeat - I found much of album overly tedious and tiresome to the point of wanting to fast forward through it.
This is a hard one to rate for me. It’s not really my cup of tea, but it is very important.
Glorious. This wasn't on Tidal so I went via YouTube. The additional live tracks on the rerelease are fine, but very much bonus material. Judged on the original 9 tracks, this is pretty much perfection. I was already a GSH fan, but this adds a spiciness to the chords and music that some of his earlier stuff missed. Compare the opener here to Pieces of a Man, for example - this is much darker and more complex in it's choices musically. H2O gate is biting and funny, The Bottle is harrowingly trance inducing. I loved this from beginning to end. 5.
I feel that I was not in the proper headspace to hear this. It is a great soul record of its own right yet I do not enjoy it as much as I do 'Pieces of a Man'. 7/10 [KEEP]
Really good.
Peace Go with You Brother (As-Salla-Alaikum) - 4/5 River of My Fathers - 2.5/5 A Very Precious Time - 3/5 Back Home - 3.5/5 The Bottle - 5/5 Song For Bobby Smith - 3/5 Your Daddy Loves You - 2.5/5 H2Ogate Blues - 2/5 Peace Go with You Brother (Wa-Alaikum-Salaam) - 3/5 Winter in America - 3/5 The Bottle / Guan Guanco - 3/5 Song for Bobby Smith - Alternate Take - 3/5
#291/1001. Some of the chiller songs seem to take over, but then there are the bangers, The Bottle (drowning in to it seemed to be the fate of Scott-Heron as well) and h2ogate: has anything changed in 50 years in America? Still looks like a cold cold winter over there.
бля хороший альбом, почему ток нет на спотике
while names like Stevie Wonder and Curtis Mayfield may conjure more excitement, something tells me Gil Scott-Heron is gonna be talked about farther in the future. this is some really beautiful, understated soul with enough lyrical depth to get lost in. love the jazzy flair. definitely gonna come back to this in the future. deserves to be one of the 1001? uh i mean. maybe? why was this chosen over Pieces of a Man? even I'm New Here could be a good oddball pick. this is a fair inclusion! just, why keep it to this one?
Great and sadly still very topical
Just meh. A heavy vocal album like this didn't do it for me. And it got pretty political there for a bit.
I knew this guy sounded familiar. He was the poet in Kanye West's Who will survive in America. This is a great, soulful jazz album. I love the political lyrics, and I'm a sucker for spoken word tracks so the second to last track was awesome. Loved this.
Not available though Apple Music and I’m not killing myself to track it down .
not on spotify so had to find low quality version. It was fine but the hassle brings it down a bit
Inject the sound of the Rhodes directly into my veins.
Five stars because Scott-Heron should be a household name in America
It's always a pleasure to get to listen to Gil Scott Heron. River of my fathers….some of Gil's most earnest, tragic, sad vocals. Really beautiful stuff.Gentle piano and a guiding drum beat. It's a long one but it is worth it. A definite highlight of the album. So much emotion packed in one song. Melancholy and gorgeous vocals continue into further songs like Back Home, also a strong addition. The flute parts are charming. There's an earnest, almost grieving mood to the album. Ah yes, and the bottle, a classic Gil Scot Heron song I've heard plenty of times before. A faster paced boppy song, but retains the sadness felt in the other songs. Your Daddy loves you also has beautiful lyrics, meaning and flute solos. Really lovely stuff. Song for bobby smith was slightly weaker but enjoyed the gentle melancholy feel to it. Gil Scott Heron's origin is as a poet, so great to hear some social commentary poetry in H20gate. Interesting how some of the topics are just as applicable today. (inflation, destruction of the middle class). Though I do prefer Gil's singing voice. I really hope there are more Gil Scot Heron albums on this list. I would love an excuse to go through his entire discography. These vocals are so beautiful, and the album as a whole has a beauty to it. It has to be 4 stars for Mr Scott Heron.
A pleasant listen and obviously a very influential album but it doesn’t really do it for me. Interesting to get a snapshot of the state of American politics in the 70s.
Viber med dette. Pianosporene var litt dølle.
Positivt overraska!
Den her var bare jævlig. Stygg sangstemme, men noe jazz- og RnB aktige backingspor. Leste nå at at fyren driver med spoken word og at plata handler om afroamerikanske temaer. Hjelper ikke. Drit!
Hørt hjemme i stua (og på nach på fredag haha). Drithyggelig!
Kul fyr. Liker de drømmende sporene bedre enn de politiske.
Its a slow to start but picks up with that 70s funk and groove. Best track is H20Gate Blues! This track alone is so relevant today, as it was 50 years ago!
Sorry, mit Jazz kann ich nichts anfangen.
A little slow musically, but Scott-Heron's voice and message are profound. He should be more universally revered and is one of the truly great musical poets of our time. 4/5 Will listen again
The keyboard playing on this record is really good; Peace Go With You Brother is my favorite example here. Gil Scott-Heron also has a great voice, though it seems like it's more effective when he's doing spoken word rather than singing. Overall, pretty good jazz record that I would for sure come back to. 4/5
Very pretty album but also I don't think I ever wanna hear it again. Each piece on its own is very nice but as a whole I get bored. 2.25/5
Meh?! Nice enough vocals but it was all very bland for me
Well talkative not my thang and also from another time and black , jazzy kinda but no thx
I thought it was an awesome album, it's neo-soul it's afro-jazz. It's protest, but it's also grounded in experiences.
What a prohetic piece of poetry, especially H2Ogate Blues and Winter in America. The fact that so much of this is still relevant is honestly depressing, but Gil Scott-Heron does such a good job articulating his frustrations from the time. I also really loved the song Daddy Loves You, as a new father. And The Bottle has an amazing bassline and is just a great song. This album blew me away on many different fronts and I wish it was a bit easier to listen to. Still awesome though.
Enjoyed this one. What a wild time it was when Gil Scott-Heron wrote these songs. Glad that as a society we’ve sorted out all those problems and learned our lesson….
Soulful, jazzy, political, Wouldn’t say I was blown away on first listen but I’ll definitely come back and listen to this again
Pretty nice.
It's winter in America.
peace go with you - amazing whole thing amazing tbh
Listened to "The Revolution will not be Televised" instead since this one isn't available (is that cheating? Idk). Soooo good
Pretty solid, title track was good, probably won't return
01) Peace Go with You, Brother (As-Salaam-Alaikum) - 6,0 02) Rivers of My Fathers - 5,0 03) A Very Precious Time - 4,5 04) Back Home - 5,5 05) The Bottle - 6,5 06) Song for Bobby Smith - 4,5 07) Your Daddy Loves You - 5,5 08) H2Ogate Blues - 4,5 09) Peace Go with You Brother (Wa-Alaikum-Salaam) - 4,0 TOTAL: 5,11 (51/100) Current ranking: 757/824
boring
Thought this started promising... But then... it didn't really go anywhere for me.
Smooth, pleasant, easy-listening. All around 3 stars, but I’m bumping the score for the sick as hell time-capsule that is H2Ogate Blues.
2/3. Cool album. Caught my ear the second I recognized that Peace Go With Your Brother is the song that’s sampled on Poe Man’s Dreams on Section 80. I think this album proves that I have a soft spot for Rhodes pianos and flutes, but I also thought the prototypical rap on H2O Gate Blues was very cool.
Amazing album. Gil Scott-Heron is the man. Fave Tracks: A Very Precious Time, The Bottle, Your Daddy Loves You, H2ogate Blues 5/5
album existiert nicht, der song ist VOLL GUT
Nice listen, really liked his style
Really smooth, chill album. Back Home was my song and first listen of the album with The Bottle and A Very Precious Time being my other highlights
Not really for me but I can appreciate the work. I enjoyed the electric piano work and the overall jazz feel
This was fantastic but it’s so hard to give a high score to something so inaccessible. And yet
who will survive in America?
My favourites were Rivers of My Fathers, Back Home and Your Daddy Loves You. It was too bad Gil Scott-Heron didn't sing on H2Ogate Blues.
Album #1,039 Had to listen to this one on YouTube. Starts off pretty slow, but good jazz piano/organ playing. Singing is hit and miss. Then gets a little more upbeat before finishing off with some beat poetry about Watergate.
I hadn't heard this before. I like it!
4.5 stars
I LISTENED.
This Heat Pere Ubu Outsiders Nation of Ulysses Mars Trojans Black Dice Todd Terry The Germs Section 25 Althea & Donna Sexual Harassment a-ha Dorothy Ashby PIL The Fania All-Stars The Bar-Kays The Human League The Normal Lou Reed Scott Walker Monks Niagara Joy Division Laurent Garnier The Creation Manuel Göttsching Rammelzee Sun Ra Scientists Royal Trux 10cc Eric B. and Rakim Index Basic Channel Soulsonic Force Juan Atkins David Axelrod Electric Prunes GIL! SCOTT! HERON! Everytime I hear GSH, my mind goes to LCD Soundsystem. In a good way, obvs. It then goes to my disappointment at buying this record about 10/15 years ago convinced it had ‘the revolution will be televised’ on, only to find it didn’t. Don’t know why I didnt check. I think I was just swayed by how mega influential and respected it is. And they’re all right, those that love it. it’s an amazing record. One that kinda changed things a bit for me. Kinda forces you to appreciate the lyrics of it, and I think the more stripped back jazz / blues alongside it really helps. Works so well. I think America in 2026 could learn a lot from this record.
Piano led soul/blues. Seemed like a nice version of this sort of music but not a genre that really appeals to me. The H2Ogate blues was my favourite, the loose and angry feel gave it a bit of edge. Otherwise I'm not sure if come back to any of it. 2.5.
Lots of pootling about on the keys. Meandering, lots of analogies and metaphors, very political, but not overly interesting - more of a manifesto than a music album. Appreciate its place in history. Would have preferred The Revolution Will Not Be Televised
Didn't think I would enjoy this, but was pretty good. I recognised "the bottle". All felt very genuine. 3
113/1001 First listen. Sounds like it’s being made up on the spot. Just generic noodling. I’m sure there’s more artistry here but it’s over my head. 3/10
Real good stuff, it gave me a sense of time and place. The flute, hand drumming, spoken word poetry. Most of which I tend to detest, but this works! Very cool, prescient, sometimes easy to hear, sometimes challenging. 3.5
Smooth sounding jazz (both the music and the singer's voice itself). While it does have its groovy moments, it's just not for me.
Politically relevant musically soothing
guay aunque lo escuche desde youtube de un link de reddit
Very smooth Nice long song Calming
Really great music and passionate lyrics, not so great production or vocal delivery.
Jazz poet, hoo boy, glad I've not got to listen to it because Spotify doesn't have the album.
Gonna give it a 3 for neutral because it wasn't on Spotify to listen to and I can't be bothered to seek it elsewhere.
Not my type of music.
This wasn’t available on tidal but I was able to listen on YouTube. Love!
Solid but no showstoppers.
Strange choice - I'd have thought Revolution Would Not Be Televised or either of his first two studio efforts would've been a more prescient pick. I think this is a bit wonky
she moves with a purpose
Not available in this region.
It's so cold outside but this warmed me
There were some concepts in this album I thought were quite cool.
Jazz and proto voiceover elements. Good protest songs. Will listen again.
Kind of boring
The blacker the berry
Right off the bat, this is cool as hell. I'm not familiar with the album although I've heard bits of it here and there. Sits nicely in the junction of jazz and soul. H20 Gate Blues is amazing. Not much changes I guess, but if anyone is making a song like this now I would like to hear it. Not something that I would listen to very often, but when I'm feeling right for it this would hit hard. I wish I'd gotten it in the summer time, feels like a summer time album despite the name. Had this down as 4 stars, but after H20 Gate Blues I'm calling it 5 stars. Moved by this album and will be checking out some of his other work.
I love the lyrics and the music. What a great discovery.
Not my kind of music.
Gil Scott-Heron is a badass
Not on Spotify
A lot feels kind of boring. There is absolutely some great stuff on here, but too many songs feel too similar to each other and often very slow and long. 3/5
I had to find this one in a YouTube playlist as it’s not on Spotify, so excuse me if I miss a track or get the order wrong! The first track, Peace go with you brother, is an interesting piece of music. I don’t dislike it, but it reminds me of sleep asmr. I’m sure if I searched “smooth jazz sleep sounds” I could get a similar effect. Rivers of my Fathers has some good piano, it’s definitely what I would class as elevator music though. Not in a bad way, I just feel as if the way to enjoy this is standing in an elevator or in line at a theme park. Very precious time is the same as the rest. I like this guys voice, but this album is making me so tired. It’s also like 10pm at this point, but am I a bad person for wanting a bit of urgency? Finally! Back home is much more like it. The flute, the more upbeat tempo, yay! The Bottle is actually really good! I enjoyed this track a lot. Oh yay. Back to the slow ones. Song for Bobby Smith. Yeah. I’ve already said all I need to say about these slower tracks. Going into Your Daddy Loves you. I usually hate parent to child songs, but this one had some musical intrigue. H2Ogate blues. I don’t really like the spoken word intros to tracks anyway. I just realized it’s 8 minutes long. I’m 2.5 minutes in and it’s just been spoken word politics. I’m not against a good political track, but I feel like I’m listening to a speech. Actually, I’ve been slightly unfair. The poetry in this track is really good. It also… relates well to current events. The title track: I enjoyed this a lot. No notes. I feel like I’m missing a track or two, but I took what the YouTube playlist gave me. Overall, I think I was slightly harsh on this album. It has some great lyrics and musicianship, it just ain’t for me at all. 3/5 ⭐️ from me, but it probably does deserve higher. 20/1089
Horatio Velveteen but without the charisma.
interesting and experimental, but probably not going to be a repeat listen for me, 3 stars, pretty crazy how the last song feels like it could be written today since so many of the issues are super present still
It's amazing that this makes the list but not a single entry from Lonny Liston Smith, Mahavishnu, Billy Cobham, nor Stanley Clarke (just to name a few). Perhaps it's the lyrical content that "sets this apart from the pack." So once again Mr. Dimery, why poke around hidden corners in music with blinders on? With that being said, interesting album that finishes strong. Great collaboration between Gil and Brian.
Great sounding voice and piano.
This is one of those albums that I think would probably be a 5/5 on a second or third listen. It has so much of things that I like, it just didn't quite hit the point of clicking for me. Don't get me wrong, this album is fantastic! It's jazzy, chill, carefully arranged, thought-provoking... It's honestly hard to find a real flaw in it, but unfortunately my gut isn't telling me 5, and I have to respect the gut.
This is a powerful album both in terms of content and in terms of being beautiful to listen to. Gil Scott-Heron's voice is amazing and is backed by Brian Jackson's smooth performance. It's a pity that the album is a little difficult to find - unfortunately, the issues this album tackles are just as pressing today as when it was recorded. "H2Ogate Blues" makes for an... interesting listen in 2026. Favorite track: probably "Rivers of My Fathers"
2.33
It's obviously brilliant, but not something I'd put into rotation. If anything it might be too smooth, and without some more edges it kinda all blends together.
An okay album, I liked Back Home the most.
It started out pretty good. I liked the funk, but the improv jazz and spoke word parts weren't very enjoyable. It's also dated, very much a product of its rime.
Really very good. I need to have this one in the collection
It’s a pleasant listen, but I can’t help but feel that this album is spinning its wheels at times. The song structures feel very unchanging. The record often becomes a formless ramble backed by some nice instrumentation. It was cool to recognize the first song being sampled on Section 80 by Kendrick. Also, Andre 3k absolutely embodies the spirit of Scott-Heron. Cool listen.
Nice blend of jazz, smooth singing and political elements.
mehhh. it was a cool vibe but i'd like it to be more funky
This was great, I just didn’t really connect with it. There’s obviously the strong racial messages in this and these kind of albums are very important for that. It’s good!
Outstanding. Tremendous work; political and a blistering commentary on the United States.
listened to the revolution will not be televised since winter in america wasn’t on my streaming platform
I thought this was great. It was almost like he was talking about America today in an album that’s over 50 years old. As a girl dad the song Your Daddy Loves You was quite the tearjerker as well.
I only knew his spoken word songs and was excited to learn that he could really sing. This album was smooth! H2Ogate Blues, The Bottle and Your Daddy Loves You were real standouts.
i couldny find this album.
Vocals pretty good. Music good too. But overall not gripping me enough to be good to great.
It’s alright in parts, but overall a bit boring.
Thoroughly enjoyed this despite only having row-res Youtube audio to listen to. "H2Ogate Blues" is a masterpiece - if you're considering passing over this as it's not on any streaming services *at least* give that one song a listen.
Can’t hear the whole thing in the US but love him
2/1001 Banger opener, I really dig that kind of atmospheres Somehow it doesn't feel too quiet (as I tend to think of, for example, Lonnie Liston Smith's stuff) Gil's voice is very addictive H20Gate Blues is the obvious highlight here, but the more musical titles are all good and I can definitely see myself listening to this album a lot Oh and of course, that's the "The Bottle" album Fuck it, 5/5
Not on Spotify. gg
Ah, nice enough sound but toooooo laid back for me, zzzzzzzz...
Great vocals, great backing. Was that a flute? Count me in.
Этого альбома не было, послушала другой. Приятный легкий джаз,но с политическими и социальными веяниями. 6/10
Fine
Some really boring mellow jazz with barely-sung vocals. I especially dislike the intermittent parpings of the flute. I like the lyrics, a whistlestop tour on race and inequality in America, but not enough to listen to this album again instead, of, say, reading a book about it.
Really good
Never heard of this album or artist before, and frankly this cover is throwing me for a loop. I've no clue what to expect. Is this going to be a psychedelic album? Soul. Jazz. Blues. Dead wrong on my prediction, though I can respect this spread of genres. Not my cup of tea, as usual. I enjoyed this as something to space out to, though there was nothing in here which held my attention or impressed me. There's a lot of dead air on these tracks, and many of the songs are stretched out to hell and back. If I am to be positive, I think the piano numbers are pretty nice, and the vocals from Scott-Heron/Jackson are both well-suited to this genre. Book time. Influential within African-American music. Scott-Heron is widely considered to be the "godfather of rap". Particularly influential with regards to its subject matter. Yeah, sure. These guys seem to have earned their stripes. I cosign this inclusion.
I’ve never listed to a full GSH album before and this was a great experience. He’s got a lot to say and it’s all worth listening to. And the music is phenomenal.
Loved it so much! Had to listen on YouTube and sure wish I could add it my collection on Pandora!
I like this album quite a bit. It is relaxing, smooth, and has a lot of beauty in it. At the end, I didn't feel like I heard anything that "new," but it is something I would definitely put on in the fall or winter around the house or to start a day.
Loved this one of course. Curious to hear what else this guy's done
Gil! Scott! Herron! What is a more fitting album for Christmas besides Winter In America? A lot of very calm and pretty songs. I prefer the other Gil Scott Herron album I've heard before though (I'm too lazy yo look up the name but it's the one with The Revolution Will Not Be Televised). Overall a very good album but I would have enjoyed a few more up beat songs. Low 4.
Ok- the political stuff was lost on me though.
Le gars il a raison, c’est vraiment Winter in America ici! Écoutez cet album en marchant dans une tempête de neige, ça améliore les deux activités drastiquement!
A solid soul album. It's maybe not the best out there but it's good enough. A little slow and simple at times but otherwise great lyrics, great keys. Great bass lines. Not really a lot more to say about this one, I don't think it was exactly groundbreaking or worth listening to all the time but I liked it enough for today. 3.5/5 but rounding down because it doesn't make it to 4.
Jazz/R&B,Funk, not sure.
A historical snapshot which continues to tell the story of America today. Some fabulous jazz and blues to enjoy, sometimes the voice felt jarring against the music.
A bit of a slow starter, but has some great tracks and heavy lyrics. I love a bit of jazz flute, keys are beautiful, and H20gate is brilliant.
Why have I not heard of him before?
We got There's No Place Like America Today on July 4 and now this on the solstice? And he thought things were bad in 1974? Anyway, cool album. They don't make 'em like that anymore.
3.5 - Good
Soulful and mindful. Love the accompaniments and Scott-Heron's voice is spectacular. Sounded more modern than 70s and its conscious lyrics aren't out of place in 2025.
couldn't find this on spotify so i just listened to the most popular songs by the artist the revolution will not be televised 1971 soul, jazz, r&b sounds united states
Beautiful
Absolutely amazing. Have found a new artist to follow and love.
A very slow jazz with some little touches of funk and blues. My favourite songs here are 'Back Home', 'The Bottle' and 'H2ogate Blues', because the first two are very funky and the last one is a blues track with a heavy political message. The rest of the songs were very slow and moody jazz that didn't engage me at all. Quite of a shame that I feel so neutral about it. Researching about this man, I found out that he is a very famous person because of his political views. And I understand why, as I pointed out, I liked 'H2ogate Blues'. Knowing that, it makes me feel a bit disappointed about it, as it made me wish the album was more political focused. At least I think the worst parts are tolerable.
Righteous and groovy. Love the Rhodes vibes. Late night feel.
A true original singer
Great album, Scott Heron is a one of one
Great voice, nice easy listen
This one was a smooth, easy listen from start to finish. Nothing flashy, just a laid back vibe that worked well in the background. A Very Precious Time stood out for me and was the best track on the album. H2O Gate Blues was a nice bit of political commentary too. The rest of it was solid but didn’t really grab me. Honestly, I’m surprised it was this album that made the list and not The Revolution Will Not Be Televised. I like that one better, personally.
Lovely voice but only a couple of good songs. The start of the album was agonisingly slow.
This album really grew on me. At first I found the vocals a little too earnest, but the messages from 1974 are unfortunately still relatable in 2025. It's an interesting mix of jazz, blues and soul with great piano/B3/Rhodes playing. Liked Songs Added: Rivers Of My Fathers H2O Gate Blues
If Sly Stone sang Lou Rawls, it would sound like this.
Beautiful, but ultimately not my jam.
Had to listen on YouTube since it’s not on streaming. Really nice soul record with some spiritual jazz backing. Must add to the collection.
Sucks this album is not on apple music 🫤. Some sweet flute vibes.
Album wasn't available on spotify. I listened to some of his other Albums and enjoyed them
Exceedingly groovy. I enjoyed it, having come to it with no preconceived notions, no knowledge of the artists other than knowing that Gil Scott-Heron is politically active.
All-time classic!
Jazz and Poetry seem a lot like peanut-butter and chocolate.
Favorite Track: The Bottle
Spotify doesn’t have this. Giving it a four for his poetry.
First song I recognized! Shoutout to Anderson Paak (NxWorries) for Suede The Bottle, Back Home.
ok
Pretty meh, but good musicianship
Cool stripped down sound, jazzy and thought provoking.
Slavery in America was fundamentally an institution of familial destruction - of obliterating the natural bonds between parents and children and spouses and lovers, selling human beings as livestock to highest bidder at any moment, negating all sense of identity those essential bonds create. *For in the last days men shall be lovers of their own selves, blasphemers, without natural affection.* So it is unsurprising that Scott-Heron, prophet that he is, is so preoccupied with the loss of family here. On nearly every track he gropes for something or someone to hold on to - brothers, fathers, uncles, cousins, sons, sisters, first loves - and all elude him. And when he confesses on "The Bottle" - after recounting the tales of covetous winos around him - that he himself is one of the hopeless husks hanging outside the liquor store, we understand that the chains were never really broken but rather just changed form.
Woah. I am in a loss of words. Literally. My bad brochacho.
Yet another album not available to listen to…
Not on Spotify
This was an interesting listen. Lots of cool grooves and melodies, but mostly not blowing my mind. The one stand-out track for me was H2O Gate, which was really stellar, in terms of writing, performance (so good) and just overall groove. Three stars overall.
Excellent. Hope it pops up on Spotify one day
??? hmm war ok aber sagt mir nicht wirklich was? c
Really great album, lyrics and Vocal performance are spectacular, backed by smooth jazz and lovely piano. Just wish it was on streaming, nevertheless, a really worthwhile listen, and one that I would revisit. 4 Stars.
Wonderful. Wish it was on spotify.
Better than Coldplay
This album gave me the feeling that it was going to be spectacular at first... but as time went on, I don't know, it seems that from the middle of the album onwards it lost its "spice," something that was making it incredible, becoming just good. As if something sweet had become watered down. I'll give it 3 stars.
behöver nog egentligen lyssna igenom det igen... men bra?
no bueno
Not really my thing- not a huge jazz fan, but the politics did feel fairly current.
A nice jazzy and funky soul album, that's largely melancholy. It was odd I couldn't find this in Spotify so I had to pull it up on YouTube. I think that the sum of the parts is largely good here, though slow for the majority. Big big standouts though, when they decide to pick up the pace, Back Home and The Bottle. If they could've taken that energy and made it a whole album we'd be talking about a 5/5. Piano on this is also exemplary.
Listens: 3 Standout Tracks: The Bottle, H2OGate Blues, Winter In America This album was fantastic. I am visiting my folks for Thanksgiving and they were surprised when I put the album on. My dad shouted, The Revolution Will Not Be Televised! Which 1) True, and 2) is not actually part of this album, but close enough. The Bottle is the standout track for me. The music is somehow upbeat despite the subject matter. I though H2OGate Blues and Winter In America are also both amazing. I think I was reading a YTM comment on one of the tracks, and there was some mention of Gil Scott-Heron's music being sort of proto-rap/hip-hop music, and I wasn't really sure how that was the case until H2OGate Blues came on. The entire track is basically spoken word song with loose rhyming. And, none of this is to mention how prescient and relevant the track is in today's America. My only sadness about the whole thing is that this is not an official album on YTM, only a user-uploaded playlist, which makes it tough to reliably save to my library. It's too bad there's no official album in YTM.
This shit ain’t on Spotify, so we’re running Johannesburg instead. Gütentag mf. This motherfucker is smooth. Vibey ass music for work
Sometimes it's just not possible to compare an album to those around it, when the musicianship and the songwriting are both so excellent that it wouldn't even be fair to cast anything else into its shadow. My favorite track from my (first) listen is "H₂Ogate Blues."
What a treat. Slightly familiar with Gil Scott-Heron before this (about as familiar as anyone else) but never explored his more melodic work. My goodness, what an artist. Paired with Brian Jackson and you got PB&J. A healthy, smooth, salty yet sweet treat combination that can be enjoyed at anytime of day. The bookends of "Peace Go with You Brother" were by far my highlight.
I wish it was on streaming services. Excellent album.
Really good album. I hadn't heard it before but have heard other GSH records. I put this one in the library.
Not bad.
This was better when on in the background
Interesting album. Very contemplative, and of its time (the mid 70s… lots of electric piano) Good jazz playing but most of it was a little slow for my tastes. I did enjoy the uptempo numbers. H2OGate Blues was fun and clever. It also showed how little things have changed in a lot of respects.
Best Track - "H2OGate Blues"
About as bad as it gets, sounds like a pub singer on a cheap keyboard.
Pretty chill and smooth jazz. Lovely and relaxing.
Hard to find but the stripped down soft jazzy blues was precisely what I needed after a tiring day. Watergate blues is excellent and painfully prophetic.
When gil Scott heron died the number of white boy comments, ‘oh I understand black culture, I just don’t want to live near them, I’m sure they’re and I’m not racist, but…' drove me nuts. It’s not directed at you. That’s ok. Can you enjoy it? Yes sure. Is it important. Yes. But don’t tell me you get it. You don’t. You can’t. It is powerful. It is important. But it’s speaking to its people. If you’re white middle class, that ain’t you. Listen to it yes. Listen to its message. Yes. But you’re a peripheral listener. Still, 3 stars for what I can appreciate. 2 marks off a 5 star, deducted because of the white hipster factor and the album he did before this is better.
Well, what a surprise. To be honest all I knew about Gil was The Revolution etc. This is something else; his voice is extraordinary, quite a range, he can rap it and croon it. The simple stripped back instrumentation is superb, Jackson can play. H2O Blues is extraordinarily prescient, take out the Watergate references and you could release it today. Back home is beautiful, and The Bottle equally cool, Precious Time is 70's smooth. Wonderful record.
I like this record; it's quickly recorded jazz-funk/soul, mostly sung and pretty right-on. I'm not sure what makes this specific album the one you must listen to (other than The Bottle, which is, admittedly, a classic), but why wasn't it any of his other early albums? I would argue that The Revolution Will Not Be Televised or Whitey's On The Moon are more influential songs. But maybe too political, too racially explicit for this list? 3.5 stars, rounding up, because I don't mind a bit of 70s jazz-funk/soul.
great album
One battle after another
Pre Thoughts: I LOVE GIL SCOT HERON. I'm excited. 1st Track : peace go with ya brother. Man what an atmosphere. I love the mood this album and just this era of Jazz puts me in. It's a state of political disillusionment and unease regarding the WaterGate scandal and just the fall out of Vietnam and the cold war. America! The international Jekyll and Hyde The land of a thousand disguises Sneaks up on you but rarely surprises Can't you see it? Can't you feel it in your heart? Love it. Banger, wish it was still on Spotify and I didn't need to bootleg it. Want the Vinyl
Winter In America is one of the few albums on this list that, for some reason, is not available on Spotify. In any case, the collaboration between Gil Scott-Heron and Brian Jackson was clearly inspiring, even if I don't think the “minimalist production” was the best possible approach—in my opinion, the vocals in particular would have benefited from some post-production work in places. In any case, the result sounds almost like a live recording and, stylistically, lies somewhere between jazz and soul in my opinion. As for the songs, “The Bottle” is a very remarkable piece (and the only single from this album), while the rest is mostly easy listening. Not bad!
Hard to find the album on Spotify. Ended up listening to individual songs from other sources.
Good stuff
3.5
3.5
*Winter In America* I'm actually really surprised this one was picked for the 1001 over *Pieces of A Man* not only do I think that is a better album than this one by a pretty decent margin, but if it wasn't for "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" i probably would have never heard of Gil Scott-Heron. This album though is really good and I do like it's soul groovy Jazz feel. But I think the two tracks that really stand out the most are the ones that really have a bite to them which is "The Bottle" and "H₂Ogate Blues". 8.4 ★★★★
Cool blend of soul and jazz. Nice laid-back atmosphere, with some beautiful vocals. 4.5 stars
I think this is probably a great album to a lot of people, but it's just too far out of my wheelhouse to get any real enjoyment out of. 70s soul is just not my favorite to begin with, and the incorporation of jazz-funk and spoken word doesn't really help. "Peace Go With You Brother" was my favorite. 3 stars.
Musically this is quite lush - smooth, sumptuous, snazzy, silky dinner table jazz. Vocally it’s a lumpier and less lush mixture though. Gill I guess is best known for spoken word but he opts to sing mostly on here and he is no George Benson - his vocal chops are pretty average and leaden. Scrub the vocals out and you have an album I could have a very nice steak and glass of red wine to. There are still a couple of potent highlights though, namely The Bottle and H2Ogate Blues which is where the album really gets sizzling and is sort of a direct to video sequel of The Revolution Will Not Be Televised: Ronnie Scott’s edition.
Peace Go With You, Brother // Rivers of My Fathers // A Very Precious Time // Back Home // The Bottle // H20 Gate Blues //
How many times have I heard Gil Scott-Heron's name and never listened to a note of his music? Many, many times. This was almost exactly what I expected while also not being quite exactly what I expected. That doesn't make sense but I thought this is what his music sounded like but did not know this is how we got there. Brian Jackson lends a lot more electric piano than I would have anticipated hearing. I use Spotify, so it's a bit annoying this is not on Spotify and I had to listen on YouTube. The songs are well-written and some of them are a bit more sleepy than I had imagined. Maybe the sleepiness is just the fault of the electronic piano. I don't know if I would give this album five stars but it deserves a place in this book. Some of my favorite tracks were: Peace Go With You, Brother A Very Precious Time Back Home The Bottle Your Daddy Loves You
Yess more jazz!! Also some amazing piano on here. I wish I knew more about the political context of this album before listening to it because I feel like that definitely influenced the lyrics a lot. Fav songs: back home, the bottle
I am a fan of the musical passages in this album. It is a nice laid back blues-jazz feel which are a good counterpoint to the political points that Gil echoes throughout this album.
Nice album, I really like his voice, and his spoken word
On balance it was ok. Some really turgid stuff at the start but picked up a lot by Back Home and The Bottle
What do I say, it's one of the best albums I've ever heard. A whiplash of an album to listen to through this current political climate, lots of feelings swimming around right now, a mix of I feel so lucky to hear such great music that is so heavy but so easy to love, and nothing in this country has changed in fifty years. This is one I will keep revisiting and a highlight of this entire project so far, this really did a number on me.
I really enjoyed this one. Gil and Brian Jackson work together really well- I love the mellowness coupled with the poetry. There is just a tiny hint of There’s a Riot Going On here but that’s plenty. The highlight for me has to be “H2OGate Blues.” It’s funny and incisive- and it depresses me to no end that we’ve found ourselves back in this poem again. FOUR STARS
All good and heartfelt and meaningful and I was eavesdropping the entire time. The two tracks that piqued my interest were The Bottle and H20Gate Blues.
It was okay. The person listening to his album should have a working knowledge of The Watergate Scandal in order to understand “H2Ogate Blues”. “The Bottle” is really good.
This was a really good album, the vocals were great with interesting lyrics to back then up. The beats were awesome too
Man, a really fun vibey blues/jazz album. His voice is a little grating to me, but it doesn't put me off all of the time. The bass playing is excellent, and the keys are orgasmic. Brian Jackson made a new fan today. The music is incredible and also topical while still being pretty relevant, somehow. A really enjoyable album that I would be willing to listen to again and again. Favorite Song(s): Rivers of My Fathers, Song for Bobby Smith
Great album. Soothing instrumentals contrast with a strong political rhetoric which remains valid today. Gil's vocals are outstanding and you believe the message he is presenting. 8/10
What a unique and interesting blend of music! Never heard anything quite like it. He uses subtlety really well with tons of room for the vocals and keys to breath and do their own thing. I also thought the live, spoken word style track toward the end of the album was super cool. This was something brand new to me and I really enjoyed this discovery.
My introduction to Gil Scott-Heron was through the song Me and the Devil off his more recent album I'm New Here. I had that album in my rotation for a long time, but it's been a while since I've given it a listen. I absolutely love the jazzy electric piano riffing with Gil Scott-Heron's heavy soulful singing on Winter In America. The Bottle is a killer track; the flute soloing is amazing. The spoken word blues/jazz poetry of H2O Gate Blues is also phenomenal and is sadly incredibly relevant even with its outdated references. Also, I don't want to diminish Winter In America, but I do have to say that I'm surprised Pieces of a Man isn't in the list as the track the Revolution Will Not Be Televised is absolutely amazing and rather important historically as it’s considered one of the predecessors to modern hip-hop. I think Winter In America is going to lead to a bit of a deep dive into Gil Scott-Heron's work again today.
Only listened to 1-2 songs because not on spotify. Those were okay.
I was previously familiar with Gil Scott-Heron but not Brian Jackson or this album. This is a sort of funk/jazz/blues mix with almost proto-rap on top. It's a very interesting sound, including sounds from many years both before and after its release. The social commentary is pointed albeit a bit dated now, well after the fact, in the case of H2Ogate Blues. This was a fun listen, and while I would listen again, I'm not sure I would seek it out specifically.
Shit
Had long, boring lulls.
Not my favorite. The instrumentals were alright... But I didn't like the singing
Amazing album. It’s a shame it’s not on Spotify, this is an exciting introduction to Gil Scott Heron for me, I’m excited to hear more from him after this too. Smooth music, intriguing lyrics, it’s crazy to hear this stuff from years ago, a lot of these issues were years ago, some problems seem tog et fixed but others stay the same. Four out of five stars
10/22/25. Great discovery today! Really enjoyed the musicianship on this. With the vocal delivery, it helped create hip hip. I always listen to the music first which explains my rating, but I'm sure once I grasp the lyrics I'll like this even more.
70s jazz, R&B and African. Influential on rap and hip hop. Very relaxing. Not loving the vocals.
not on Spotify had to listen to my own album. still sounds great
Pretty good. Nice Watergate Blues throwback
Very nice. I might have to buy on vinyl. 4 *
Sho nuff groovy, now hit the lick one time stick!
Probably not my thing tbh but there was quality and I liked the political message. I wouldn't listen to it again though
It was alright, on the funky side of jazzy. Not my favourite of this genre but still quite listenable.
Smooth, thoughtful, and exactly what I needed on a Monday morning. It’s jazzy, but not the kind of complicated jazz that sends my ADHD brain running for the skip button. Gil Scott-Heron’s voice is warm and poetic, his lyrics full of quiet power, and the whole album feels like a calm conversation about chaos. Timeless, soulful, and grounding.
50 years later and still talking about oil shocks
An album that I thought I should like, but just couldn't get into it
I enjoyed this, jazzy, bluesy and a bit of soul. A relaxing listen. But nothing exceptional to push it to one of the higher ratings.
Was alright, but nothing to get particularly excited about
Good stuff
Found it pretty dry
All too appropriate.
I don't mind it.
Gil Scott-Heron.What a discovery! Liked it. Especially the tracks with more than piano. Those were a bit too intense for my liking. But generally so good! Sad also that politically the world has not improved and Americans find themselves deep in an endless winter.
3/5 no album on apple only single
Musically solid. Good groove.
This one’s not on Spotify but I hope that doesn’t deter anyone from listening to it. I had it on vinyl so I was good but it’s on YouTube if anyone else needs it. Hot damn, when Gil Scott Heron and Brain Jackson get together magic happens and this album is certainly no exception. A gorgeous jazz/r&b album about the tumultuous times for the black community in the midst of the civil rights movement in the 70’s. 8/10 Favorite tracks “The Bottle” “H2Ogate Blues”
Really nice voice, not usually my favourite genre.
Mixed reviews here - appreciate what these chaps are doing and I love GSH’s voice and prose. There was more than one stinker on this album including ‘Very Precious Time’ which was a difficult listen.
Great lyrics and great music. "The Bottle" is timeless, not to mention how many of the topics still being salient to this day.
Utter dreary dirge
One of the most interesting albums on the list so far. Very cool funky/jazzy/blues type sound, and the influences on modern hip hop are cool to see as well. Still feels relevant despite being from ~50 years ago. Very cool and not something I would ever have been aware of prior to starting this project.
great stuff on here. i yearn for a modern revolutionary spirit that can hang with mr scott-heron’s work.
Couldn't listen
Never heard this before today. It's pretty chilled out nice music with some great lyrics. Seems kind of political in the message. Nice beats with some other spacey synth work that is really nice. I wouldn't mind listening to this again.
Finally got around to this and I loved it - such a good album. Solid songs, great musicality.