Reviews (page 5 of 7)
I really liked the first (and last) track. Serious headphone jam with the vibrato emulating channel panning on the keys. I really enjoy this musically, especially the more upbeat jams. But too often it slows down, and there I find the vocals a little over the top. The blues tune goes hard though, loved that track.
All I can say is Fantastic
There is some really cool stuff on here. These are the seeds of neo soul and rap. Not exactly something I would listen to on a regular basis, but I really dig pieces of it.
A really great album.
My first 5 of this project. I'm so impressed with the musicianship and lyricism on display - I'm also fascinated by the legacy of this record and it's influence on early rap and hip-hop. I had the stupidest smile on my face for basically the entirety of H20Gate Blues. The only knock for me is the quality GSH's vocals can sometimes be a bit of a distraction from what he's saying. But that's outweighed by all of the above. Playlist adds (if this album were streaming) - The Bottle, A Very Precious Time, Song for Bobby Smith, H20Gate Blues
not really my thing i'm sorry.
Goede vibes
It's a pleasant listen. Gil's voice is just honey. If we're all being honest the Bottle is doing a lot of the heavy lifting. But it's a great album for putting on in the background, just being seductively lulled by the Heron.
Hh
I enjoyed this album. I'd heard The Bottle before, really evocative of real life for many. Like the slow sound of Back Home and and Bobby Smith before the barn-storming H2Ogate.
Loved this album. Perfect combination of laid back/mood jazz accompanied by Gil Scott Heron's sublime poetry. All tracks are outstanding and 5 stars from me.
Day 0010/1001 of One Album a Day Unfortunately not on Spotify so will assume what I listened to on youtube was not optimal streaming quality. Even still, very groovy and enjoyable album. Fav tracks: Back home / The Bottle Least fav tracks: n/a
Great surprise for today! I was not expecting another hidden gem after more than 1000 albums, but I am happy I was wrong about it.
This is easily one of the best albums I’ve heard for laid-back, smooth, and soulful jazz. The vocals are outstanding, and the raw, minimalistic production adds so much warmth and texture to the overall sound. It’s a perfect blend of simplicity and depth, making the album feel both intimate and timeless.
The deep husky voice of Gil Scott-Heron soothes me and also riles me up - he represents a certain militancy of righteousness that is missing in modern art - and in a world were it's either centrist materialism, lightweight left politics and the loudest emptiest vessel of right wing militancy, both idiotic and terrifying - Gil Scott-Heron's type of tone of voice to bring some balance in the mix is missing - nothing to keep the Overton window to rocket to fascism. Sounding more like a poetry album than a pop record, as Scott-Heron's records tend to sound, there are some good r&b numbers, but it shines in his telling of the Watergate Scandal - chillingly prescient and reverberated in the politics of today. As music? It was rather enjoyable and interesting - but after listening to all these records so far - clear-eyed political views are actually rare, so this is a gem, specifically for that.
Feel good tones, but there's just too much lyrics for me to really catch.
The Bottle
Album écouté au retour des partys de noël familiaux, sur la route enneigée et sinueuse des Sept-Chutes. Ambiance parfaite et contexte approprié pour ce disque nommé « Winter un America ». Un album qui commence très doux avec piano, sons feutrés très jazz et quelques passages de flûte. Au fil de l’écoute, s’ajoutent des accents R&B et même un peu disco. Et ça revient plus doux avec une pièce qui fait ressortir l’orgue. Puis, l’avant-dernière pièce, qui commence par un petit cours rigolo sur le blues, se transforme en critique acerbe, mais tout de même drolatique, de la société américaine sous le King Richard Nixon. Sous la forme d’un discours scandé présageant ce qui viendra avec le rap, le texte devient une charge à fond de train contre les visées guerrières et interventionnistes des Etats-Unis, contre les scandales politiques (on est l’année du Watergate) et la cupidité des grandes entreprises. On entend les collègues musiciens qui rigolent et encouragent derrière. Un vrai tour de force ce disque. Bien dommage qu’il ne soit pas accessible sur les plateformes pour le réécouter facilement.
Wow. This is so good and worth seeking out. I don't think I've listened to a full Gil Scott-Heron album before (I've heard individual tracks) but it was absolutely amazing. "The Bottle" is the best track by far, but they're all good in their own way. Scott-Heron is so talented, and there's a reason he's considered so groundbreaking. Totally understand why this album is on the list.
(Denne er ikke på Spotify, men finnes på youtube). Røykfylt-bule politisk pratejazz som får lytteren til å føle seg smart.
Beautiful. This was a fantastic listen, what's really amazing is the equal collaboration effort between these two men. Brian Johnson going crazy on the flute AND the piano, shit was so gorgeous listening to it. Then you got Gil Scott-Heron with the heartfelt, meaningful, and potent poetry across the entire album. Both of them were inspirations to each other and as a result we got Winter In America. Also as a nice bonus I noticed a few songs on here that were sampled. A wonderful listen. Top 3 Favorites: Rivers Of My Fathers, Back Home, and The Bottle NO BAD SONGS 5/5
It’s unique but too slow moving for me I get it’s inclusion 100% but I can’t say I love it 3/5
great album, have heard -you daddy love you- many times on Wclk and never knew the artist.
it was nice background music, but not something I am going to remember or want to listen to again
Class
This album is not on most streaming services, but H2Ogate blues is a masterpiece that makes the search worth it.
This is gold. Never heard of Gil before, neither read his name. I was missing a lot. So much feeling, musicianship, control, and beautiful lyrics. I would give a 5, this could be 4.75/5. I just wanna save that 5th star for what really blows my mind (if any) Annoying that the album is not on Spotify, at least for me…
Hate when I have to listen to these on YouTube but very good
Album not available. Other stuff was aight.
i'm not too familiar with gil scott-heron's work outside of a few select tracks, so i had an idea what to expect, but not the full picture. i am a bit blown away by this one! very jazzy, very smooth, very soulful. some of these tracks are a little funkier and some are a bit more balladic. the poetry was quite nice and the vocals were really nice. the electric piano on here sounds so great. just a really cool, pleasant album that has great feel and soul.
Not available on Spotify
I like his voice, but I don't really like this type of music. Although, the album was pretty upbeat and fun. Not terrible
Winter In America is a nice chill yet thought-provoking listen, incredibly smooth vocals from GSH, the piano flits between stuff I like and stuff that puts me off, and that's really the biggest weakness of an otherwise fine album. The Bottle was a welcome bump in tempo and energy. A good Sunday morning 3.
Did Gil Scott-Heron have the coolest speaking voice ever? Definitely up there. This was an interesting listen, to be honest I'd probably not be that unhappy hearing him read the Yellow Pages, but there's some decent stuff in there. The music is smooth, pretty easy listening, but the lyrics and the clarity of the vocals pack a bit of a punch. It's not as good as Pieces of a Man (which I don't think is on this list?), but it's a high 3/5.
-well this was a lovely listen for a cold November night. Also this is officially the first album I’ve gotten on here that I couldn’t find on Spotify -maybe not the most thrilling work I’ve ever listened to but it had a lot of nice and cool moments. The spoken word America diss track was a unique touch -Favorites are Peace Go With You, Brother, and Rivers Of My Fathers
Halfway through track 1, I decided that I would not like this album, I thought this is just Jazz and not for me like many other jazz albums on this challenge. I was wrong. as the album went on it grew and I grew to enjoy it. This album has far more to it than just jazz. it is funky and groovy with some great instrumentals and meaningful lyrics and songs. In summary the album is not one that I would run to put on again, but I enjoyed it none the less. Favourite song: Least favourite: Album artwork: Good cover
Great vibe album, shame it isn't on Spotify
Solid
Very 70s but also really quite funky. It also felt relevant in these times, in particular H20gate. Rating: 4
General impression: beautiful, pure, human Detailed review: After a bunch of albums that were merely good or interesting, how refreshing to get one that really bowls me over with its artistry. Oddly enough the album this most reminded me of was Songs of Leonard Cohen. Because the arrangements are clean and minimal, the pace is mostly slow, and it’s a space where the words and the human soul can enjoy the spotlight. I really felt this album and many of the songs just made me sit in reflective emotion. Of course Gil Scott-Heron has one of the most striking and memorable voices, and all it needs is some keyboard behind it. Deeper thoughts (context): I want more Score: 5 Number of albums left to review: 947 Number of albums from the list I’d consider “must-listens”: 31 (including this one) Albums from the list I won't include in mine: 23
Eh. Not my preferred style.
There is some great stuff here and some things that just kind of meandered along. Nice album with something for a variety of tastes.
A great album in it's own right but it gets extra credit for the Pieces of a Man omission
It had its moments but overall it really struck me as a parody of a lounge act in a seedy bar of the 70s
Amazing guy. Some top joints on here.
I’ll be perfectly honest…this did nothing for me. I don’t really like 70s jazz, blues, or soul, and this was the personification of all those things. I appreciated the lyrics, though.
Fantastic groove and a ton of soul in here. Really similar to Marvin Gaye's "What's Goin On" in the sense that it touches on some important political points at the time of its recording. Had to listen on youtube so I don't have favorite tracks, but it was a good vibe.
The only thing from Gil Scott-Heron I had listened to prior to this is Pieces Of A Man which is a fantastic record that I hope shows up later. His voice is really great. The piano and bass work here are both great. Major credit to Brian Jackson. His political lyrics are really hard hitting and are still relevant today especially on H2Ogate Blues. My favorite songs were Rivers Of My Fathers, Back Home, The Bottle, and Your Daddy Loves You.
Album Review: Winter in America by Gil Scott-Heron and Brian Jackson Winter in America, released in 1974, is one of Gil Scott-Heron and Brian Jackson’s most essential and moving works, blending socially charged poetry with soulful, jazz-inspired sounds. This album stands out in Scott-Heron’s discography for its powerful lyrics and atmospheric instrumentals, which capture the mood of a country in turmoil. Strengths: One of the album’s greatest strengths lies in its bold social commentary. Scott-Heron’s lyrics address political disillusionment, racism, and urban decay, offering listeners an honest and sometimes bleak look at life in America. Songs like “The Bottle,” with its infectious rhythm and searing critique of addiction and poverty, became an underground hit and an anthem of protest for many listeners. Meanwhile, tracks like “Peace Go With You, Brother” and “Your Daddy Loves You” show a more introspective, compassionate side, balancing the album with warmth and hope. The collaboration between Scott-Heron and Jackson is seamless, and the album’s production values reflect their shared vision. Jackson’s soulful flute and piano complement Scott-Heron’s rich, resonant voice, creating a hauntingly beautiful soundscape that underscores the themes of social hardship and resilience. The fusion of jazz, blues, and spoken word makes this album unique and immersive, drawing listeners into a world that feels simultaneously timeless and urgent. Limitations: However, Winter in America might not appeal to everyone. Its emphasis on social issues and the sometimes dark, introspective nature of the lyrics might feel heavy for listeners seeking lighter themes. Additionally, some might find the production slightly dated, as it carries the lo-fi quality characteristic of 1970s independent records. Final Verdict: Winter in America is a landmark album that encapsulates Gil Scott-Heron and Brian Jackson’s musical and social legacy. It’s a must-listen for fans of socially conscious music and those interested in the roots of hip-hop, as Scott-Heron’s work laid the foundation for later generations of politically-minded artists. The album remains relevant today, resonating with ongoing struggles and triumphs in society. Winter in America is not just a listening experience but a statement, asking listeners to reflect on the state of the world while celebrating resilience, community, and hope. Today I’ve been playing with the new Apple AI intelligence whilst listening to this album. Can you tell? 3/5 14/11/24
Jazzy but not that gripping
Trevligt litet live set
Totally new to me, good jazzy/funky sound
Kinda messy. The opening track was great, but the second half goes completely off the rails with some really, really long spoken word sections that I, a European, have literally no connection to. Uh huh, J. Edgar Hoover, Patrick Gray, Frank Rizzo. Who are three people who have never been in my kitchen. Watergate.
Overall really liked this. Got a little slow at some parts, but great album for this list
Some pretty boring stuff here
Undeniably great. He was a poet. He was a genius. Raw soulful singing, luscious music. Get into it!
Minimaliste, on prend son temps. La voix exsude l'émotion sans affectation aucune. Le message est clair, direct, livré sans complaisance mais avec un sens du rythme qui l'élève et lui confère encore plus de puissance.
First song - really annoying (almost upsetting rapid panning between left and right). Other than that it's the most dull easy listening album 0/5 (can't select 0)
Not available on Spotify now
Wow!
Winter in America is a studio album by Gil Scott-Heron and Brian Jackson, originally released in 1974. Oh man, anyone reading this, please check out the other releases under the Strata East label (or even the Strata label). Seriously one of my favorite labels. Anyways, this album is amazing. The songwriting of Scott-Heron combined with the composing of Jackson is total perfection. This is funky but not an in-your-face funk. More of a stoned with the lights turned down at night type of groove. There's lots of jazz in here too. I mean, those opening notes of the Fender Rhodes oscillating through each speaker is just so groovy. Scott-Heron preaches some real stuff on here too, as he always does. I really wish "Pieces of a Man" was included on this list. If you dig this and haven't heard that record yet, do yourself a favor and throw that on next.
Enjoyed some of the more melodic stuff, but the spoken world wasn’t my favorite.
Great music, just wouldn’t listen to it regularly
It was okay
Mostly annoying
The album wasn't even on Spotify, but I found the title track and it ended a long streak of good albums ...
first three songs felt very strong, then it continued into simply good
Good instrumentals, not a big fan of the singer unfortunately
This has a nice vibe and it's way more musical than what I had heard from Gil prior to that, but I can't say that it's something that really interest me.
Smooth jazz-funk soul album, but it feels more like background music rather than a groundbreaking album.
The overall vibe and sound are really nice and appealing. Unfortunately, I found no stand-out tracks or something I would listen to again. Great and charming album, tho.
I generally enjoyed this, but I doubt I would listen to the entire album again. Some tracks stood out, but others seemed to be filler. Also, there was nothing about the revolution being televised, so I'm docking a point, giving this 3 stars.
Good. It’s interesting that the second to last song is more of an 8-minute speech than a song, and I didn’t like that this wasn’t on streaming (not that I docked it any points for that), especially considering that a majority of Gil Scott-Heron’s work was.
Клевый инструментал
This album is a vibe. The music is so stripped back and it has such a delicious sound. Meanwhile the lyrics tell a different story. The struggles of the African American community through the 60s and early 70s are brought to life through the incredible voice of GSH. Fantastic album.
Just beautiful. Another album from a genre that I've paid little attention to. That may change now, and this album, for sure, is going into my collection. Five stars from me.
Reminiscent of Lou Rawls
Very enjoyable, lyrics scarily still relevant. Song for Bobby Smith has something special to it, is like an ear orgasm
Such a cool album. I liked the paired down jazz at first, it got a little old in the second and third tracks, but then it really started picking up. We start getting incredible flute and piano play which in retrospect sounds like a quintessential sound of the 70s. Then H20-Gate blues comings out the gate with a scathing yet resonating political critique. Then the gloves are off from there. I never thought I would be so into an album like this but I absolutely loved it.
I was gonna give this one star but then H2O Gate Blues came on and I got a kick out of it
Note: Not available on Spotify or Amazon Music -- had to go to YouTube for this one. Jazzy and real. The message is the groove. Lovely.
Production that is full of life and a political message that is still relevant. Great album.
Dull as ditch water
An excellent blend of Blues, Jazz, and Soul.
I can imagine H2O was groundbreaking. The rest is boring.
Good but not my cup o tea
not my cup of tea.
It’s fun to listen to him call out all the political criminals on “H2Ogate Blues”, but apart from that this was a loooong listen for me. Doesn’t help that I can’t stand the flute and struggle with jazz appreciation. I would have given it one star but that song, which is way towards the end, bumps it up to two.
joo varmaan väärää albumia tuli ottoon mutt herra ainak8n ilmestyi yhteen biisiin...aikaa muuttaa mieltä KUUNTELIN OIKEIN. trust the spotify hakutoiminto... idgaf rn.. fr bro idgaf rn... voisi rotan peppuakaan välittää tästä asiasta tällä hetkellä. kuunneltu tavara oli kovaa settiä... varaston uumenista kaivattu esille aarteita.. varsinaisia joulupukinjättämiä lahjoja.. ei kakkapökäleitä vaan säkistä.. säkistä uutettu ulos makeata.. namipäivä on namipäivä on... winter in america
The best are the spoken word protesty ones, which I guess he was getting away from at this time, the sung stuff is not sung all that well and kinda corny but the instrumentation and heart are alright.
Nice, but not really what I felt like listening to right now.
Best Song: The Bottle. A song with one of those rhythms that feels unbreakable and somehow inevitable. Groovy. Worst Song: Peace Go With You, Brother. Took a little too long for the album to get off the ground. Overall: Groovy, soulful, political. Lots to like, although it has enough meandering moments that it doesn't leave as strong an impact as I wish it would.
Interesting sound, very mellow, but not my cup of tea - Jazz poetry? No thank you
I wanted to like this album more than I did. I can't say I remember a single one of these tracks. While listening I know that everything sounded good, but there wasn't really anything to grab onto.
Yes.
very nice, h20 gate blues highlight
6.5/10 A lot of this was jazz with blues & soul influences, good but not great, but really rescued by the vocals and electric piano in particular H2ogate was alarmingly relevant nowadays too Best: H2ogate
Echt goeie
a bit too long i think but very good groovy + psychedelic
Someone on youtube said '50 years later it's still winter in America' and i thought that was pretty heavy
1.5
Difficult to find to stream but worth it. H20 Gate Blues is still powerful 50 years later.
Wished this was on Spotify. From what I'm hearing on yt, sounds like something to vibe to
★★★½
Nice find
Talent and skill is undeniable. Really incredibly interesting to see this album isn't on Spotify or streaming besides YouTube.
Soul jazz fusion. Ni fu ni fa.
Jazz.
Boring
Solid 4, loved H20 Gate Blues
Relevant then, equally relevant now. The only thing they got wrong? The revolution WILL be televised.
When I think about this list, this is the kind of albums I hope to get every day. Some far, far away artists I couldn't be able to hear about for the rest of my life. Yet this was so good. The sensual tempo, the clear lyrics, the simple joy and love in the message. Even the 8-minute rant about US politics was enjoyable. At first I thought it's a clear 4 star album, but I can't see the reason to not give it 5 stars.
“The Bottle” runs away with this LP - that bumble-bee bassline alone unmoored my eyeballs - but this is a sweet record. The quietness of “Song for Bobby Smith” stuck close to me. Heron’s voice doesn’t bang it out with his contemporaries in the song forms he’s playing with here, but I like its matter-of-factness, his talking the melodies - he plays to his strengths even here. The record’s atypical for Gil Scott Heron, more tuneful, jazzier, less rap, less fierce, and deserved more than today’a inattentive playthrough and the later, urgent skip across for better grasp. “Winter in America” is a terrific title. Brian Jackson’s work is sometimes luminous, bell-like in its resonance; cheerfully Broadway elsewhere. But are the songs strong enough to make this a great? One listen was not enough to convince. Skipping through again, I hear much that is exquisite, I don’t think I can bear rating this a three a day after giving Def Leopard a four, and “Rivers of My Fathers” might pay back its duration, so to conclude….
Mostly aimless jazz noodling, not great apart from The Bottle and some Watergate ranting later on. On Amazon Music if you're looking for it
An excellent blend of spoken word and jazz that mixed thought-provoking and vivid lyrics with a wide spectrum of sound from relaxing to upbeat. What's really sad, is that the messages of this album could easily be repeated today and ring just as true. Top tracks: Peace Go With You, Brother; The Bottle; Song For Bobby Smith; H2O Gate Blues
Day260 - music is the best way to get your message to the people so why is this not on apple music?
Not bad for a lazy Saturday morning. I enjoyed it and loved the H2ogate blues.
Eh this is fine.
Staat niet op Spotify Wel raten omdat die anders niet in de lijst komt Ff op youtube geluisterd, klinkt echt nice
Chill, not chill. The kind of thing I usually enjoy but at least today it felt like slogging through a boggy marsh. Undeniably pretty, though.
This was not only an incredible listen, but a lucky one. It was lucky because this album is not on Spotify, which is where I look for new music, and so without this project I probably never would have found this album. I have listened to Gil Scott-Heron before, but this album what honestly *that* good I've reevaluated him and hold him in a much higher respect. This album has honestly raised the bar for me going forward. Disregard any five stars I've given in the past, this is the new standard. Under the YouTube video there is a comment that says: "Gil was a prophet sent from God to deliver a message that nobody was ready for, and all he was doing was delivering the word. He wasn't perfect, but he was God's warrior. He screamed and hollered and I don't think he ever told a lie." And man, I thought that was really something. The Vibe: Sitting in a lounge chair and drinking something brown from a shiny glass after a day that was so long and hard you need to stop and replay the whole thing in your head.
Extremely important voice, but this is also a bit of a snooze fest musically. I said what I said.
First listen. Decent.
This is one of those, yeah, sure, the political part is good, it’s interesting, you ever read Nixonland? It’s like that. But uh. The music? The fun of listening to this? Not really. It’s just not an enjoyable album.
Very soulful, very genuine stuff. Scott-Heron’s voice is so smooth and easy listen to. I thought the arrangements were lovely as well; funky, jazzy and full of great grooves. Such a tight band. The first three tracks, while slow, are still interesting enough to hold the attention of the listener, but when it picks up with “Back Home,” that’s when I really started to vibe. This was great. My only gripe is that for some reason, this is hard to find. No Spotify, no Apple Music. Found it on YouTube like others must have. Bummer it can’t be included in my running playlist. Four stars. Standout Tracks: Back Home, The Bottle, H2O Blues
Just powerful stuff.
I adore "I'm new here", Scott-Heron's late masterpiece. I also enjoy some of his earlier songs. But this, at album-length... It's not bad, but doesn't engage me at all, I'm afraid.
Very random compilation?
Ratings: 5: I will happily play this album anytime 4: I may occasionally play this album of my own free will 3: I will happily listen to this if someone plays it in the background 2: I will tolerate this if it is playing in the background 1: I will leave the room if someone plays this in the background I enjoyed this. It's unfortunate it isn't easy to find on streaming services (at least on Tidal). Wish I had more time to sit down and listen carefully, but on to the next album.
3.5 but Im rounding down. There wasn’t anything too memorable and I could on find this album on a Youtube Video.
If these did not get added to the great american song book, they should have been. Plus one of the more compelling political slam poems I've heard. And what a wonderful voice.
Very relaxed music and great singing with political messages, but still nothing I‘d listen to often.
too inconsistent. also not on spotify.
Despite lacking anything as iconic as “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised” or “Whitey on the Moon” this record is far more musical and even given Heron’s obvious vocal limitations, this is just oozing soul.
THIS is how you do spoken word. Talk about meaningful topics. No one wants to hear your singer-songwriter self loathing and relationship issues.
Couple of good songs, The Bottle & H20 Gate Blues, but overall a bit too plinky plonky jazz
This surprised me as I'm used to the spoken-word recordings of Scott-Heron. Poetry is still great & I really got into his singing voice, raw as it is at times.
Thanks to the reviewer who directly linked to the youtube link. After a long stream of pleasant albums, this one felt like what I came here for. mind blowing, beautiful, out of my normal wheel-house. 5 stars.
This one is complex. The music is solid, and seems like a good background groove album, but the lyrics seem to demand focus. It seems to be doing what it's doing well, but I'd prefer something on either edge of what it's going for. H2OGate Blues specifically stands out as a track that lyrically wants me to pay attention, but the music was given a different prompt.
The album is not available in Germany. Individual songs were pleasant to listen to
Not my thing at all
I had never heard of this album nor these artists. What a politically charged and timely album despite being 50 years old. I particularly liked the tacks Back Home and The Bottle. I really loved the song H2O Gate Blues - such a powerful song about the events in 1974. I’m not huge fan of the flute in jazz, I always think of the awful Zamfir, but it works for this album. Overall, a soulful and delightful album.
I had not heard it before, was very good.
Like a melding of blues, jazz, and soul. Interesting to listen to, as Gil is a poet, but also one of those genres that you really have to be in the right mindset to enjoy fully. Let's just say it didn't catch me on one of those days. I really hate flute music, and it was featured heavily here, along with really strange song structure (as is the norm with jazz), and not great vocals. Overall kinda boring. Favourite songs: The Bottle, Winter in America, Back Home Least favourite songs: Song for Bobby Smith 3/5
A great and groovy album! Worth the listen!
Gil has such a capticating voice, and Brian's keyboard work always matches the tone of the songs perfectly, whether that's being light and jazzy or more upbeat. Soulful and smooth, really enjoyed giving this one a listen.
Great night driving music. Great message. Not much has changed
Oh my god.... Was.... Interesting? Too slow, waaaaaay too slow... It was good to hear it, just not something I want to hear again, sounded so dull and monotonous that I was dreading the next track
Jazzy R&B. A kind of Bar Blues.
Not on any music feed but a reviewer kindly posted a link to a YouTube version. This was a great mix of music and poetry and brought me back to those dark days of Watergate. Others have said this is not his best work so I will explore further.
I can't say I listened closely, but this was all pretty great. A solid 3 and maybe more than that once I listen again.
I love these guys...
This seems custom made for me to hate. Just a big jumble of things I don't like in music. I guess I can see how a certain type of music can might like this, but I'm not the type.
I'm 4 minutes in and still wondering when the first song begins. Seems like just one long introduction. So, without further ado, I'll categorically state that jazz musicians can't write actual songs. Fast forward a few times to see if anything changes - nope. It's the most boring form of jazz on the market. Why do people like this stuff?
Raw emotion and political messages. Last track feels like an electric shock after the smoothness of the tracks leading up to it.
I just had “My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy” a few days ago; up until the second to last track on this album, the spoken-word “H2OGate Blues,” I hadn’t made the connection that Gil Scott-Heron was the artist featured on “Who Will Survive In America.” I was pretty delighted when I realized that - I had never heard of him before. H2OGate was the highlight, and I wish there had been more spoken-word style pieces here, but the whole thing was great. Definitely an artist to explore more in-depth.
Like "What's Going On", this album is as enjoyable to listen to as it is poignant, and as reliable a relisten as any GSH album. Loving this one as much as I ever did.
So glad I got to hear this today—too bad it's so hard to find. It deserves better. Jazz for sure, but also much more here and definitely a good snapshot of the early 70s in America.
I have dabbled in some of Gil Scott-Heron's music before, but wow, I need more of this. What an great way to ease into a morning! How could it not be a great day now?
Timely and enjoyable. A great listen.
This album did not have a clear genre for me, but it not only great to listen to it was also compelling. Really terrific and really sad that it isn’t available on my music service - but thankfully in our digital age I found a way. Too bad that such an important album isn’t readily available. Still it really makes me glad to have embarked on this project to discover finds like this.
I had only known samples from 80s rap from him. This album was deep, sonic, and entertaining.
4.5☆/5 07.09.2024
Loved it. Great poetry, great vibe, beautiful music.
A little too laid back.
A Gill of Scottish Heron please.
springtime in paris
Enjoyable but spent most of the time wondering why it wasn't Pieces of Man, I think there's some history to dig into here.
Only available on youtube Song 1 Song 6 Song 8
I really enjoyed it.
Political jazz music. Nah. It’s like combining squash and oatmeal. Not a good combination for me.
The first third was a bit rough. I didn’t like his singing and wished it was instrumental. It really picked up in the middle and I can see some real solid talent. The poetry near the end was FIRE and notched it up a star!
It wasn't available on Spotify....altho he had a ton of other music on there. Not everyday listening type stuff....fine background jazz.
Jazz with an ethereal/spacey lean
Gutted this isn't on Spotify... Really enjoyed that and would love to listen more but YouTube is a massive pain. By far the best non-spotify album that's popped up, great lyrics and great tunes.
4.5/10
Trop minimaliste. Manque d'improvisation pour cette musique apparentée au Jazz.
Decent music and vocals just not my vibe
Oh man, listening to this on headphones was headache inducing. The constant fade from left to right channel, pulsing back and forward. Why would this be considered a good idea. I need some panadol.
Gil Scott-Heron and Brian Jackson’s piano and rhodes work prove what a great team they are and warrants their continued collaboration for the multiple albums after. The pairs vocals sound so raw and exposed and really fits the narrative of the lyrical/poetic output. The Bottle is a stand out for me. 3.75
Spotify didn't have this one. I had to go to the Youtubes. This is mellow grooves. At some points, it sounds like Mr. Roger's. I love The Bottle, that bass. Groovy as shit. I'm getting funked up on it.
I love Bobbi Humphrey's flute playing on "Harlem River Drive" as well as the relaxed feeling of cruising the barrios of 70's Manhattan that the song conveys. Each time I listen to it on YouTube, it is followed by tracks from Gil-Scott Heron. (No brain, not Jill Scott.) The algorithm (algoRHYTHM, anyone??) got it right this time. I couldn't name a single song I heard, but I liked it. Time to dig in with a focused listen. I think Gil is a little loud in the mix; at least, I'd like to hear the backing music a bit more as there are some tasty tidbits in there too. His singing isn't amazing, but he makes do with the art he has. The jazz is smooth but not elevator music, and many of these tracks sound live, at least partially. The playing is phenomenal, especially the piano, flute, and congas. The spoken-word genius delivery of "H2Ogate Blues" reminds us that the good ol' days weren't as rosy-colored as we'd like to remember. Even then, he talks of current stolen elections, stacking the Supreme Court, inflation, war for profit, and politicians "whose ignorance is only surpassed by those that voted for [them]." Mic drop. Sadly, this struggle remains and rings true even today, a persistent winter in America. Peace go with you, brother. This is the jazz music I like with a message that remains fresh and revolutionary. Winter In America just oozes intelligent and soulful art, and the rhythm makes you move. A unique and hip take on jazz, poetry, and spoken-word mastery.
The album started off kinda dragging for me, quite contemplative and melancholy. They were working out their troubles, but I couldn't stay engaged. Unfortunately I found the music a bit boring and repetitive at times, and the vocals were not that interesting either. Every line seemed to end with a word containing extra syllables added, like smile became smah-ha-hile, girl became guh-huh-hurl. But I was craving something more lively and melodic, less droning music and meandering melisma. “The Bottle” brought some energy, finally, with its bouncy bass line and funky flute. a dolla-nine, get a bottle o’ wine! a dolla-nine, get a bottle o’ wine! a dolla-nine, get a bottle o’ wine! a dolla-nine, get a bottle o’ wine! Then we were back to another soporific number after it ended. The only other one that grabbed me is “H2O Gate Blues”, which I quite enjoyed. The more things change…
Couldn't really get into this. It sounded like a few guys doing a rough rehearsal. The talent was there, but the songs just didn't go anywhere. No dynamics. The bottle song sounded like they were trying to practice one section of of a song over and over. Two chords for seemingly ever.
interesting piano-based jazz/blues, with a political cracker in H2Oblues
Virkelig fede arrangementer og Gil Scott-Heron lyder altid vildt godt. Watergate nummeret var en banger
Jeg kender i virkeligheden mest Gil Scott-Heron for spoken word ting, men han synger jo pisse godt. Super fed plade, "beatsene" lyder meget forud for sin tid og sangene er rigtig gode!
Faktisk fed nok! Rimelig politisk! Skod regering de har sig, der i USA.. Også i 1974.
Cool poetry and instrumentation, it’s just what I needed actually. Very good album.
The piano and bass players put on a master class in this album. The spoken word isn’t really my cup of tea, but I can appreciate the cultural impact made with this album. H20 Gate blues was pretty prophetic given recent circumstances revolving around the American government. Can see how Gil is considered by some to be the godfather of rap. High 3 rating from me based off of personal enjoyment, but can see where someone has this as a 4 or even a 5.
Sadly this is almost unlistenable to me, it’s everything I don’t want in the music I listen to.
Na moral vai toma no cu, que álbum foda, tá maluco. Estou ouvindo pela quarta vez pra tentar escrever sobre ele, mas não consegui colocar em palavras que descrevam a altura a qualidade dele. Sensibilidade, melancolia, descontentamento, êxtase e humor. É um álbum que tem alma. E vai toma no cu o Spotify também, que é o primeiro álbum dessa lista que não tem na biblioteca e um dos melhores que ouvi até agora.
Phantastic electric piano, but a liitle bit too 'fusion' for me.
The album was only available, though I found the title single. I’m now a fan.
Wouldn't usually be my type of thing but I really enjoyed it. Nice and relaxing then watergate blues appears and it’s just as relevant as ever.
Smooth, chill blues-y soul/jazz album from the mid-1970s with messages that are still relevant after 50 years. It was a pleasant listen overall and the production of the album is really great. I liked the spoken word elements less so, so I'll give it a 3 instead of a 4.
Album not available in my region :/
wasn't on spotify, had to go onto youtube for this one such a good album both poetically and musically, start to finish
50 years later the same issues are largely unaddressed in America, it’s a great album even if I’m not going re listen.
I used to be into Jazz funk and this admittedly is quite early- 1974. Some fine musicianship. Doesn't really do anything for me know.
I think I'm going to bump this up to a five simply for how concise it is. I'm not sure, I just really liked each of the tracks and the whole sermon of H2OGate Blues.
It was already pretty clear to me which genres I pay attention to their lyrics and which ones I don't, but it stands out more on this album than others because it has both cases. Like, when it's doing its soul jazz thing—and it's primarily it's soul jazz thing—the lyrics kind of pass by entirely in favor of the melodies and instrumentation. This is where I hafta give all the shout-outs in the world to Brian Jackson. Fantastic stuff; amazing stuff, all around. It's a sound I can really go for. But then when it's on its proto-rap thing on "H20gate Blues", and Gil Scott-Heron sounds like the guy who asked who will survive in America and stated that the revolution won't be televised—damn. The rhymes! The delivery! I don't wanna just say "Wow, it's enjoyable," 'cuz I feel like that kind of ignores what he has to say poltically, but seriously—it's really damn enjoyable to listen to. This guy, with this voice—I really like hearin' 'em go off. So, hey, that sounds like a pretty good 4 to me. If only I coulda listened to this album on Spotify, though. Thankfuly there's YouTube uploads, but I can't imagine why it's not on Spotify. Oh, and if my group could've gotten this album in winter, too, ans not the first day of June, that woulda been really appropriate. But then I'd still be in Canada, so y'know, ultimately, whatever.
Jazz with a (at the time) current message, which also happens to have some great instrumentals.
I’m at a 4.5 that I’ll bump up to a 5. I just thought this album felt really encapsulating to me – it had some lulls early on, but I never really felt bored, I just felt like I was always waiting for the instrumentation to take another step up. They kinda broke down that expectation over time, and I think after getting a bit of energy with Back Home and The Bottle, the rest of the album was gliding for me in terms of the soundscape, the vocals, and ultimately, the comforting feel of the album. I really think the last 5 tracks (not counting the reprise of Peace go with You, Brother at the end) are just that damn good – Song for Bobby Smith and Your Daddy Loves You, in particular, gave me the same feeling as say, watching Mr. Rogers or Bob Ross. They just felt reassuring in an authentic way that isn’t often recorded in music, in part because there’s no swirling bombastic instrumental behind them, which helped a lot. H2Ogate Blues is a great critique of the politics of the era, and it’s wild how well I think it’s aged into 2024, especially with the damn Reagan diss about a decade early. I’m just kinda grumpy that this isn’t on streaming, because I’d add every song here if I could. Regardless, it’s a really nice 44 minutes, and I kinda just found a bit of bliss in it. I enjoyed the hell out of it, and I feel good with a 5. It definitely feels like it should be on this list.
Great jazz
Listened to it on youtube. No thoughts really.
Not my cup of tea
Not on Spotify
No está en spotify
Not bad... a little repetitive.
I wanted to be annoyed because I had to listen to this on YouTube but these guys were just too groovy
Not my thing but it was kinda interesting. Had to listen to it on YouTube which sucked.
Jazz and poetry. Enjoyed.
Couldn’t find the entire album and could only listen to the title track & bottle. Smooth Cat with a conscious.
As always powerful words from Gil. Never really heard him sing which was really nice. Tackling important topics and expressing the importance of love
Not on Spotify
Nice. Revisit in the future, especially if it makes its way onto Spotify
It's Gil Scott-Heron. Always 5 stars.
Always GsH
A very pleasant listen, that's three in a pretty short timeframe that would fit very nicely into the movie soundtrack category
Jazz.
Political and poetic. The voice grabs me but musically I find it a bit flat. Sorry.
hermoso! 8/10
Well, some of this is a stone groove, and I think maybe Benjamin Clementine is a fan? But I much prefer Benjamin. Gil's voice is cool but the tracks, dare I say, get a bit boring. Emma would love the flute solos!
I like him but don't like the ultra slow jazz style of most of this album. One big exception is the live track, 'Watergate Blues' is great.
‘Bridges’ by these two is a 5* for me! I unfortunately only had time for a few songs from this so anything other than a 3 would be unfair.. i really like their aura
What is bro yapping about? Half of this didn’t even feel like music, lots of talking with indiscriminate jazz in the background. The tracks without drums were very boring which felt like most of them. I wasn’t keen on the flute sprinkled throughout either. I feel like if I read about what he’s talking about I’d ‘get’ it more, but I don’t want to have to research to enjoy an album the first time. For some reason I predict dad will like this though 🔮
what happen?
Such a shame this isn't on Spotify because it's fantastic. I am going to have to track down a copy on vinyl. Only know Gil from revolution will not be televised and though I knew he had a great voice, I didn't know he had such a great soulful SINGING voice. The electric keyboard is also delicious. Also, The Bottle is a banger, and H20 Blues is an absolutely classic Gil excoriation. Just consistently brilliant. Four more years! Four more years!
I would have enjoyed more tracks like H2Ogate Blues
Listened on YouTube because the album isn’t available to stream. It was ok, but I’m still not ready to rate it. 3/5 for now and will relisten another day.
Jazzy and soulful with an excellent voice and beautiful piano! There's not much I can say negatively about this album, but I just don't see myself going back to listen to it in its entirety again. 3.5/5
Did I really need to listen to this? Yes it has social implications and messages. Yes it paints a picture of a guy disappointed with the civil rights movement. But, the delivery and craft does not hold you
Nice!
Generally not a big jazz fan, but he has a big voice without screaming. It's engaging.
wow. i get it. relevant message of the times and likely still important today. but not this musical approach, and certainly don't need the soulful poetry lecture.
Oh shit! So excited for this one. Love this artist. It’s a relief to find this beautiful recording posted on YouTube. Undeniably great. He was a poet. He was a genius. Raw soulful singing, luscious music. Get into it!
This was a unique listen. A mixture of 70s political poetry, jazz, blues and soul. Very much a product of its time. The vocals and piano often seem out of sync for the first 15 minutes, giving off a strange vibe. It's like they were on different pages of the same sheet music. While it's not necessarily what I was anticipating, it's exactly what I was expecting (if that makes sense).
Beat poetry over jazz just isn't for me. The words and music often didn't mesh and that made for an uncomfortable listening experience.
Nice.
This was a bit of a meh, especially in comparison to the revolutionary Pieces of a Man. Plus I couldn't find it on Tidal nor Qobuz had to resort to youtube. Anyway did not find it in anyway essential. One great song that I know, The Bottle so that helped but the rest didn't connect 2.5 stars
Non on Spotify.
2.5
A really great album by an artist, I must admit, I did not know. A shame that is isn't available on Spotify, but found it on Youtube. Will be dipping into his other records but since I listen either on Spotify or on my stereo I will probably not hear this record again ...
The album is not offered by my streaming service. I have listened to a few tracks that have been released on other albums by the musician. Scott Heron has a good voice. I liked some tracks, others less. Overall, however, this is very exciting. I'll certainly listen to it again. 4/5
This feels like the earliest stages of Kanye.
Album not available on spotify.
Kendrick sample in the wild (from probably my favorite Kendrick song) on the first track went hard. The watergate song was pretty troll. Overall I really enjoyed it but gotta -1 for not being on spotify
This was good. Funky & groovy. Wasn't expecting some troll slam poetry lol.
I love soul-jazz fusion. I love the vibe of this record. But there are hundreds of albums from the genre that deliver better music than this one. Brian Jackson is competent; but not extraordinary when compared with his peers. Gil Scott Heron isn't a musician as much as a lyricist who dabbles in singing as a means of delivering his lyrics (ala Dylan). The inescapable fact is that music critics are, and always have been, writers of words. Writers of words love lyrics and lyricists. Gil Scott Heron may have been a tremendous lyricist (I'll leave that discussion to those who listen to lyrics). But as a songsmith, and a vocalist? He's pretty mediocre, because that was never his priority.
Relaxed and warm jazz ambience from the piano, with a touch of 70s funk from the keys and electric organs. Woodwinds add a classic 40s element both tonally and to the harmonies - but god I hate flute noodling. The jazz crooning vocals get pretty grating at times. Higher tempo songs with a strong bass parts popping along and melodically connecting the changes are much stronger than the slow ones that just dwell in washy unresolved chords. They're playing with the contrast between the form/content: loungey vibes and funky fusion are the delivery mechanism for GSH's angry portraits of the persistent injuries to Black life post Civil Rights era and poetic condemnations of the failures of the imperial American state. The point of the contrast being that the backing music is drawing from and adding to the deep well of Black creative tradition that expresses that and transforms it to something sustains and inspires nonetheless. A poetry album that paves the way for the wordy native tongues school of 90s hip hop and backpack rap to follow (lets not talk about the thousands of cringe slam sessions too). Favorites: The Bottle, Peace Go With You, Rivers, H20 gate blues
So much fun. So so much fun. I had to explore YouTube to get the full album but on top of really needing something to help me work, it was just a delight.
A solid album combining poetry and jazz. Lyrics are eloquent and expressive. Production is minimalist, which helps to deliver the main message against political corruption without any distraction.
It's cool. A nice groove for me while ad lib cooking a dinner. Subtle overtones of R&B, soul and a serano pepper. Nice.
Wildly inconsistent in terms of quality and was such a chore to listen to
want on vinyl !!
Blind album and artist. This album might be the perfect example of why I wanted to try this project. Expand my horizons and try new music and I really really liked many parts of this and glad I tried it. Its not my typical style of what I enjoy but its different and new.
Pretty cool
Bit twiddly
A pleasant enough album, clearly made with a lot of love and care but talented musicians. Not something I'm really going to be coming back to but I'm glad I heard it.
Funky, Jazzy, nice live/improv situation. Enjoyable, but not incredible.
Amazing song.
WHO WILL SURVIVE IN AMERICA
Not on Spotify
Never really like him, but compared to new stuff, he is tolerable
not my kind of jazz but amazing nonetheless
Very lovely '70s soul and jazz feel to the music. Slow and intimate. The lyrics of course stand out. They tell stories, it's easy to see how Scott-Heron is regarded as a major influence on hip-hop.
Lidt et søsygt lydbillede hvor både højre og vestre sterio udgang flakker fra side til side. - Det var ret fint. Ærligt lidt i tvivl om hvordan albummets numre er delt op da jeg kun kunne finde den i en video monkey udgave, som ikke var opdelt.
Er der overhovedet nok instrumentering på nogle af sangene til at det kan kvalificeres som musik? Gil Scott-Heron stemme kan lyde mega godt. Den gør det desværre ikke på det længste nummer. Meget politisk album. En 8m25s prædiken om Watergate er bare ret uddateret i 2024
Favorite Tracks: Peace Go With You Brother
- All of the slowest, most brooding tracks are solid 5s. This includes "Peace Go With You, Brother," "Rivers of My Fathers," and "Song for Bobby Smith." Each is engaging, melodic, and haunting. - Some of the other tracks felt like more generic soul. - "H2Ogate Blues" is fantastic and sadly just as relevant now as it was in 1974. - Gil-Heron's voice is unique, even for soul. Smooth, but with enough of a rasp to give it some weight. Usually 100% with it, but some of the more prolonged notes start to feel pressed and approach being out-of-tune.
Definitely lives up to its title as an album with a very wintery feel. It didn't hit me with any particular standouts but it's a pleasant listen overall.
Couldn’t find
Spotify was unable to find the album, but I did find one of the tracks on the album: "Your Daddy Loves You". Jazz-soul-funk. Not for me.
A fairly boring album from a musical standpoint. Doesn't move the boundaries on a jazz or blues front, nor from a production standpoint. About the only thing that differentiates this album from others is the lyrical subject matter. Perhaps would have been better as a poetry chapbook. Currently unavailable on any of the streaming services in the U.S. Had to make do with an album length file on YouTube, so it was not a pleasant listening experience. Perhaps having better access to it would have increased my rating.
Fantastic album this late winter morning. Here sipping my coffee, this album was a joyful, sardonic and bitter delight.
he's good in every thing he did
I liked it very much. Most of the tracks are fun to listen to and i loved the use of the jazz flute on various songs. Best tracks: "Peace Go with You, Brother (As-Salaam-Alaikum)", "The Bottle"
The man is a legend, the album is not available to stream so I just listened to everything else in his catalogue. I heard The Bottle 42 years ago in a basement club called the honky Tonk, on a Sunday night. It took me 10 years to track it down and I thought I was onto someone special, and I still am.
I enjoy some of GSH's stuff and some of these songs were great. But this one felt a bit too coffee-house, open mic jazz night. 2.5 rounded up
A fantastic gem popular at time but mostly forgotten since then. His spoken word tracks, such as the famous "The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" inspired a wave of advancements that led to the emergence of hip hop. He still has that at here. Obviously the closer "H20 Gate Blues", but his smooth voice and lyrics are the forefront all throughout. We do see a shift toward long ambient jazz instrumentals. They're immensely beautiful, creative, and most importantly, lively. It feels improvisational. And with how minimalist most compositions are, the tracks are pleasant to leave in the background. I was satisfied with the lengths of all the tracks. It started off reminding me of Stevie Wonder's prog soul. It picks up with 2 incredible lush funk tracks. The next 2 tracks were pretty forgettable, especially as a followup, but still pleasant. "H20 Gate Blues" was a powerful closer but maybe could have been cut a bit shorter. Enjoyed the reprise that circled back to the beginning track. Favorites: Rivers of My Fathers, Back Home, The Bottle
Great piano shit. No real standout tracks though except maybe H20gate Blues lmao
A very slam poetry jazz/soul album. Often a little much, but lots of good piano and organ.
Fantastic. This wasn't made recently??
I really liked this - soul, jazzy, bluesy, fun time rock - great vocals, nice keys.
ok
I’ll have to come back to this one later—on a second, third, or fourth listen… the moment I heard it wasn’t ideal, and this is certainly the kind of music that should be enjoyed at a leisurely pace, in the comfort of a nice sofa, with a drink in one hand and maybe even a book in the other! It definitely deserves another listen - I promise ;-)
not4me
Onhan tämä hieno artisti. Mulle ennalta vieras levy tosin. Tykkäsin. 4/5
Todella kova. Tunsin GSH:n hienon debyytin, mutta tää oli uusi. Pitää kuunnella vielä uusiksi, nyt 4+/5
Erinomainen levy! Kiinnostavia tekstejä ja hienoa leikittelyä musiikkielementeillä ja tyyleillä. 4/5
This was a really cool album, never heard of it before. It was jazzy, funky, bluesy, everything you'd expect from a 70s funk album. The political bent of some of the songs show how things stay the same, some of the things he said are still true today. Overall a good album
Beautiful 4/5
That was very nice music
There was a little bit where I was like 'hmm maybe Gil Scott-Heron has a consistent vibe and you only need to hear the best few', and then I changed my mind shortly after. I think I didn't fully grasp this but I'll be coming back to it. music: appreciated. (⌐■_■)
Pretty radical stuff I’m surprised The Man let this guy live as long as he did. Maybe he didn’t get enough mainstream exposure or something. I knew Scott-Heron as a poet and of course knew the big one, but listening to this got me pretty interested in his collaborator here. Cool and creative musically.
"And there are 3,000 shades, And if you take these 3,000 shades and divide them by 6, you will come up with 500 Meaning there are at least 500 shades of the blues" I really disliked this album, it was tiring at times, distracting at others, and overall the sound did just not mesh well for me. I enjoy instrumental jazz as much as the next guy, but adding vocals ontop can really ruin the listening experience for me, especially if they're slow, pervasive, and not melodic. 1/5
I'll listen again
Album not in spotify.
Not available on spotify