Sail Away by Randy Newman

Sail Away

Randy Newman

2.96
Rating
23584
Votes
1
7%
2
24%
3
41%
4
21%
5
7%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 8)

Feel like I'm watching a Pixar film. Not bad but wouldn't go out of my way.

you got a friend in me

I'm not sure if it's his style/instrumentation in combination with his voice, or just because I saw Toy Story a million times as a child, but this album gave me some nostalgic vibes.

Musically spot on, giving a feeling of nostalgia in places and in others uplifting whilst still being able to be melancholic. The quirky lyrics; which in the title track Sail Away could be thoughtbof as racist; are delivered with Newman's Disney recognisable voice. Heavily American and too sickly sweet for me.

Interesting artistically but overall a nightmare to listen to with a few exceptions. Sounds like the score to a movie I don't want to watch.

Essential Tracks: Political Science (Playlist) Lonely at the Top God’s Song (That’s Why I Love Man)

American Folk, not my cup of tea

Gentle, sweet, fun and relaxing. Enjoyable!

Not for me…

Not it for me

Good melodies

Rating: 7/10 Best songs: Lovely at the top

Don't really understand how this is on a list like this. Its not bad at all, but it's not anything you couldn't hear anywhere. I will give it 3/5

If the goal of this entire project is to get me to find new music that I’d actually listen to again and again then this is it… 5 stars- super light and relaxing and fun

I'm going to be honest, I have no clue who Randy is. It sounds like a demo tape for a dreary musical, penned and perfromed by a frustrated accountant in highly paid, but soul destroying day job. The musical is a one man show about a miserable dude stuck in a highly paid, but soul destroying day job. It is delivered by a man that is absolutely living that role. Because he is. It inludes the original version of "You can leave your hat on" which sounds like a really miserable, midi backed tribute. Miserable. It's all miserable.

criminally underrated - massive talent on display

Look, idk, I'd never listen to this like at any time. It's too dramatic and somehow also not enough.

Enjoyable while sitting around the house. But felt like a Pixar movie was on in the background when I lost focus

I don’t like or hate this.

Total snoozefest

This album like much of Randy Newman's work at the time can be very misleading if you do very surface level listening. The title track on first listen does not read as a critical review of the American Dream and how it was presented to slaves who were victim of the Trans-Atlantic slave trade. Many of his songs are like and I think it has to do with his voice and the fact that he always has amazing instrumentation so sometimes you can get caught up in the song and miss the message. In a similar fashion, "He Gives us All His Love", when taken at face value does not seem to be a criticism of religion when in reality, especially with "God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)" in mind or the knowledge that Newman is an atheist, clearly is not just a testament of his faith. "Political Science", "Burn On" and "God's Song" are more on the nose with their criticisms but that does not make them any worse. They all are great tracks with compelling lyrics and instrumentation and I really like all of them. "Memo To My Son" is another song that took me more than one listen to understand but once you do it really fleshes out the song. "Dayton, Ohio - 1903" is a nice track that has some nostalgic vibes even though Newman is nowhere close to that old but it is still a nice track. "You Can Leave Your Hat On" is such a change of pace that it genuinely caught me off guard but it still was a great track and I really like the slide guitar on it which is done by Ry Cooder so no surprise it is great. I don't know where I heard "Lonely At The Top" but the song feels like I heard it before and it is great especially the sax. "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear" is another change of pace and is a fun lighter themed track that while not on the level of other tracks on this album on its own is still pretty good. I think my favorite tracks on this album are "Lonely At The Top", "Last Night I Had A Dream", "Sail Away", "Burn On" and "Political Science". I think my favorite of those is "Last Night I Had A Dream", the first and last verses are the best parts of any song on this album especially the guitar which again is Ry Cooder and the keyboard. I really like this album and to me it is a solid 9-9.5/10.

Not my jam

Not really my thing

Me ha gustado "Sail away" y en este disco está "You can leave your heat on" que es de Randy Newman pero se la quedó Joe Cocker. Interesante, hay que oírlo para mejorar en cultura musical popular.

Randy always gets a 3 from me. Its a lot of the same with 1 or 2 hits.

Satirical, critical Americana needs to be around more.

I really appreciate the political Americana element that shows up in Newman's work, and this had some great examples.

Not really my music. But it was ok to let it play in the background.

- slow piano music, not really my vibe but I respect it - He has an incredible voice - 2.5

- very distinctive voice - whimsical vibe

On the face of it yeah, Toy story soundtrack 12 times. Until you listen to the lyrics. Songs about slavery, death, pollution and nuclear annihilation. Delivered with a hug and a smile. Not exactly what I was expecting but then I did always know Randy Newman had a bit of wit about him.

Randy Newman is perhaps the most talented composer who has the ability to weave in factoids of life that either gets misconstrued, misunderstood or flies over one's head. Sail Away is the first example of Newman using the LP format to his advantage and rendering songs previously given to others back to its original (and probably preferable) form. Profoundly influential in its own way, Sail Away is the kind of album that only Randy Newman could make and, thankfully, he had plenty more up his sleeve.

Pas tellement mon genre d'album. Ça fait très typique album auteur-compositeur ou toutes les pièces sont très similaires. Il a une belle voix, mais c'est très vite monotone. 5/10

Thanks to Pixar it's impossible to listen to Randy Newman without conjuring images of animated films. Easy enough to listen to, but you'll be watching a Pixar film before you know it.

I liked two songs 'you can keep your hat on' and 'political science' so i give two stars. Maybe he was doing it wrong

Good album overall, I definitely recognised the "Toy story" vibes. Not sure I'll get back to it though

good album nothing like laughing while being sad

I wanted to like this album, but it just didn't vibe with me at all. Obviously, his voice is divisive at the best of times, but I wanted to look past that. However, I felt that there were too many clunky or childish lyrics, and the music itself seemed juvenile. It really did feel like a "My First Singer Songwriter" type of deal, rather than a definitive album.

Favourite songs: Sail Away, Political Science, Memo to My Son, You Can Leave Your Hat On Least favourite songs: God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind) 3/5

Sometimes being snuck up on is a kindness. This Newman is in every way less calculated, less cohesive. That makes it all the more American. Constant anxiety about sliding from atop, predictable results disguised in cynicism and two-minute pop song fluff.

Not the biggest fan of Newman’s bleak satire mixed with jolly melodies (though I can’t deny his craft as a songwriter), but once in awhile he decides to write one of the most beautiful songs ever written. With Good Old Boys, it was “Marie”, with this it’s “Old Man” and with Monsters, Inc. it’s “If I Didn’t Have You” August 30, 2023 (before work)

Kind of like Frank Sinatra lite.

Prediction: I won't like this. Result: I liked it more than I thought I would. But his voice is so unique, that it makes just about every song feel very similar. Still, I appreciate him as a singer/songwriter more than I did when I saw him as just a kind of cliched "writer of songs for soundtracks".

Always love me some Randy Newman

Clearly a talented songwriter, but his voice has become a meme for me. I just hear the family guy Randy Newman sings about what he sees bit.

This album will come in handy once my insomnia starts acting up again. I can't take this guy's music seriously. I keep expecting "You've Got A Friend In Me" to start playing.

The music was nice, but the vocals were off-putting.

Is Randy Newman's playing it cool after his parents just walked in on him taking bong rips with his buddies or does he always sound like he's singing in slow motion and on the verge of laughter? I liked this album, that first song is f'd up. Randy may be a blazer, but what's with the first song "C'mon, little wog, jump on my boat and come to America where we just sing about Jesus, eat watermelon and buckwheat cakes...? Despite the questionable lyrics to some of these, I did like this album. I think RN is a genius... this album is trying to say something, but I'm not patient enough to unravel this... but Malcolm Gladwell did a good job dissecting the following album... Check out that podcast here. https://www.pushkin.fm/podcasts/revisionist-history/good-old-boys

I just wrote for “Good Old Boys” that a full album of Randy Newman is too much Randy for me. And that’s the case on “Sail Away” too. But it’s interesting to see how much farther his career in film goes than I realized. I may not like Newman in straight album format, but his accolades for scores and original songs for film are well deserved and impactful.

The best thing about this album is that it reminded me to go re-watch Major League.

I have railed against bad voices used poorly many times before. I feel obligated to point out that Randy Newman does not have a good voice. However, he uses it quite well.

I'm actually astounded at how much I liked this. I've never listened to Randy Newman before, I mostly know him as this un-serious caricature of a performer. This really took me by surprise and I'm definitely going to listen to more of his stuff.

Not a bad album. Standouts in Sail Away, Lonely At The Top, and You Can Leave Your Hat On.

Perfect level of snark, but with his voice I had a hard time getting Toy Story out of my mind at first.

Just always sounds like toy story haha

This feels like Disney music for old people, which is not as bad as it sounds! There's a certain whimsy that Randy Newman brings into your standard '70s pop, and that's where most of the album's charm comes in. It was a fine listen overall! Standout tracks are Lonely at the Top, Last Night I Had a Dream, Political Science, and You Can Leave Your Hat On.

America's favorite lounge singer. His music is okay, but his voice is....not great. I listen to his music and I wonder if he was just biding his time until Disney made him the soundtrack for all of their Pixar movies.

I enjoyed the first two songs so I thought this was going to be a better album for me than the last Randy Newman one that come up on this list, but I was wrong. His vocal style just doesn't work for me outside of animated movies, especially when you listen to songs back to back in an album

Some good ones. Tho some of them improved by covers I like his voice

I just can’t. I can’t listen to Randy Newman’s voice. I can see how the songs themselves are good but I hear him and nothing but Toy Story fills my mind 3/10

Really great album. Highly underrated imo. The title track is one of the best songs of the 70s. 8-9/10

Some artists have generic voices. But Randy Newman is the only person with a Randy Newman voice. I can’t decide where it sits in the scale from pleasant to unpleasant. I don’t think I would ever sit down and think to myself, “yeah, I’m in the mood for some Randy Newman.”

Sail Away (8) Lonely At The Top (6.5) He Gives Us All Love (5) Last Night I Had A Dream (7) Simon Smith And The Amazing Dancing Bear (5) Old Man (6.5) Political Science (6) Burn On (7.5) Memo To My Son (6) Dayton, Ohio-1903 (7.5) You Can Leave Your Hat On (5) God’s Song (That’s Why I Love Mankind) (6.5) Let It Shine (8) Maybe Im Doing It Wrong (6.5) Summary: Sluggish, slow type of vibe. Very few stand out songs; OVERALL: 6.5/10

Just alright

If you’re the guy the likes You’ve Got a Friend In Me way more than anyone reasonably should, you might like this album. Sail Away is more of that kind of sound, but I hesitate to even like that song to begin with. This album is not good. Sure the orchestral/chamber sound of this album is pretty good. It gives the album a unique flair and it sounds objectionably nice. There’s a few guitars in there that switch up the sound but I have a thing for slower and more stripped back tracks (even though I won’t complain for a few rock-laden tracks). However, I will reiterate, this album is DOGSHIT. And it is all because of Randy Newman’s god damn voice. Holy shit, it is unlistenable. And it’s like actually crazy because the lyrics aren’t that bad. Sometimes they are tacky and terrible but, like on the song Political Science (the only track I somewhat liked), they are insightful and witty. But none of that makes any difference when the vocals just suck. The vocals feel so out of place and terrible and I just don’t want to listen to this. The vocals seriously made me want to just go to bed right now. But I persisted and was left with total, agonizing garbage. I never want to listen to Randy Newman’s voice again. I’m giving this a 2/10. Borderline unlistenable.

Toy Story 17

Apart from "Lonely At The Top", the extraordinary "Political Science", and closer "God's Song", the satire quickly wears thin on all the other tracks. Or it sounds very *thick* instead, depending on the subject matter at hand and the way Randy Newman laughs about it. Musically, there are a handful of good songs ("Last Night I Had A Dream", the delicate "Burn On" , "You Can Leave Your Hat On"--of Joe Cocker fame--and maybe the title track opening the proceedings). But that group of tunes is not necessarily the one that can boast having the best lyrics though. In other words, it seems like something is always missing in this full-length release... Under that light I'm not including this record in my own list. I'm glad it helped Brian Wilson to get through one of his infamous bouts with depression. I tend to interpret this interesting anecdote as ultimately showing how fragile Wilson's mental state was--given that many parts of this album are actually pretty f*cking hopeless and sinister. But this here isn't why I'm rejecting this LP as an "essential" one. I'm only rejecting it because Randy Newman's usual little tricks already sounded a bit tired by 1972. Later *Good Old Boys* was a bit more mordant. And that eponymous album a couple of years before *Sail Away* had a clearer focus at least. So maybe they're better entry points into Newman's oeuvre, as different as they are... Besides, who in 2023 really thinks there should be *three* frigging Randy Newman LPs in a list of the best albums of all time? Who? Especially when you need room for the likes of Coltrane or Mingus, as another reviewer has aptly pointed out on this app? Or room for relatively newer stuff that already has all the earmarks of a masterpiece? There's not even a single Big Thief album in Dimery's updated list! Jeeze, if you want to understand how you can combine stellar songwriting with terrific musical compositions, that's the way to go. I'm sorry, but as "smart" and "pert" as he is, Randy Newman doesn't have the stellar chops of an Adrienne Lenker. "Quaint" and "trite" can find their way into such a list. But they can't let one single artist take up three slots all by himself. Not by a long shot. 2/5 for the purposes of this list. Which translates to a 7/10 grade for more general purposes (5+2). Next please. Number of albums left to review: 495 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 239 Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: 115 Albums from the list I will certainly *not* include in mine (many others are more essential to me): 148 (including this one)

I might just be a sucker for a singer-songwriter with a distinctive and slightly off voice, but god damn this album really did it for me. I need to listen to more Randy Newman and I’d kill for a Mountain Goats cover of Last Night I Had A Dream.

Mellow, introspective, and fantastic.

Rock viejuno muy lento.

No sabía que You Can Leave Your Hat On era de Randy Newman, y que su versión original fuera tan soft.

Goddamn brilliant - captures more about American life and history than I learned in all of my years in school

Political Science is one of the all time great satires. This is a great album.

Most songs on this album are very short wich means that it is hard for them to get stuck in your head. It feels like the songs vanish the moment the next one starts. Exceptions are the title track, Last Night I Had a Dream and You Can Leave Your Hat On. A lot of them are also not very good written and downright boring! Especially Political Science does NOT fit on the album. This is not a song that belongs on this record. It doesn't fit the vibe/feeling of the album. 2/5

Wasn't sure how I was going to feel about a Randy Newman album, but I was pleasantly surprised. Good solid sound and nothing that's disappointing.

Solid album, high three. Some good songs, but it suffers from the same fate as most Songwriter albums, sounding repetitive after a while.

Feel more like he's a parody or novelty performer. 2

Never thought I’d go with a 4 on this, but turns out, it’s a great record.

Gentle. Pleasant. Sank without a trace.

Mumma för alla födda i en saloon.

Niet mijn ding, maar begrijp dat het goed is. Af en toe mooie satire.

Toy story music

I liked it. Similar to what I know from Randy Newman.

I want to like Randy Newman as a cooler Billy Joel. His songs are clever and he gets right inside the characters. Some is great, but perhaps like Dylan, others cover him better?

I saw randy Newman and was like great can’t wait to suffer through this. Was totally wrong and thought it was awesome truthfully it comes from a bias of him singing about 2 places that are sentimental to me: cuyahoga and Dayton ohio

Appreciate the musicianship but I hated this and unlikely to ever try it again. Dirge

Alsjeblieft, Randy, dit is gewoon echt niet goed te praten.

Ik kan hier met moeite m'n ogen bij open houden....🥱

Dit zijn slaapliedjes! Wel best mooi hoor, maar bepaald niet enerverend.

Sail away and keep going. You sound like Billy Joel after a stroke. And asking Woody to ‘just leave his hat on’ is really weird.

this ain't no Pixar soundtrack

Immediately recognized his quite distinct, if a little goofy sounding, voice for some of my favorite movies when I was growing up. I never checked out his other music before this, but I was pleasantly surprised with how much I enjoyed this one. As an Ohioian, I was surprised to hear two sounds about my home state, a reminder that our river burned not once but twice.

Poignant, but very downbeat. Listening to it this morning, the Mrs. said "Does he sing any peppy songs on this? Come on, Randy. Pick it up!" So I pulled up the one song on the album that takes me back to when I was kid: "Simon Smith and His Amazing Bear." The only reason that it does is because the first time I ever heard the song was on The Muppet Show. It's always weird when you hear a song as a kid and then hear it again when you're an adult. You're transported back to that time in your life. It's only happened a few times for me, and this was one of them. Randy is obviously well-known for his Disney soundtracks (trying to scroll through all of the albums to this on Spotify was almost impossible because of how many versions of the soundtrack to Toy Story 4 there are), but his wit is on fire for this album. "Political Science?" very little like it these days. I felt it was a very melancholy album, but it was definitely what he was going for. Enjoyed it a good deal.

Newman can tickle the ivories, and sometimes his voice and is magical. And the other times his songs are just okay, or even weird. I found this album was up and down. His soft songs (often with orchestra accompaniment) were better. On side one I really liked Sail Away, He Gives Us All His Love, and Old Man - I didn't really care for the others. Side two was better overall - I liked Political Science, Burn On (maybe because I love Major League), and Dayton, Ohio 1903. You Can Leave Your Hat On was good, but Joe Cocker covered it better. God's Song had some pretty shrewd lyrics. The album was good more often than it wasn't, but it still felt about average. Closing in on 3.5 maybe.

This album is very similar to the other Randy Newman album we got, Good Old Boys. Neither are bad albums, but I'm unclear why I needed to hear both (and I'd give the edge to Good Old Boys). With limited space in the 1001 albums, there should only be multiple albums by the same artists if either they are essential (e.g., Led Zeppelin) or if each album demonstrates very different sides of the same artist (e.g., Tom Waits...yes, I said it). Some artists tick both boxes (e.g., the Beatles and David Bowie). I just feel it was unnecessary to have two Randy Newman albums on the list (I'm also very sensitive to this issue right now since we just heard our THIRD Kraftwerk album). That said, there were certainly some good songs on the album. God's Song hits hard (and ironic given that this album also has "He Gives Us All His Love"). Political Science is amusing and Sail Away is thought provoking. Most notable song: Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear, but only because I remember the Muppets version: https://youtu.be/SK1HVj3qM-k :D Giving it a 3 because it's not a bad album, but definitely not essential.

Solid. Nice album. I feel like I’m watching a Pixar movie while listening though…..

Beautiful composition throughout the album, has a feel of orchestral music yet with pop/rock/blues influences. Amazing pianowork and I didn’t know you can leave your hat on was initially recorded by him.

Ayyy the Toy Story guy again! How does this guy write such quality songs, but sound so freaking goofy at the same time.

Every track is imbued with a certain… randynewmaness. If you love that sort of thing, more stars. Me, no.

Great voice with even greater wit. "Political Science", "Let It Shine", brilliant lyrics all along.

I cannot deny the wit/braininess on display here, it's just that I find the music boring.

Bought this, very nice

While I can appreciate that he is talented, his songs have a depressing nursery rhyme vibe about them.

I don't need an entire Randy Newman album. The entire time I was just thinking about how Buzz Lightyear finally learned that he couldn't really fly.

Decent, the lyrics kept me more connected than most songs and there were some nice bits of music

Great lyricist but can be a bit annoying with that music hall shtick. I was going 3 stars but some of his wordplay is so acerbic that I found myself smiling frequently.

Feels like I’m listening to a Disney soundtrack,

The only time I’m going to think about this album is when I think about Max thinking about this album. I’m sorry man, but not all of us can be culturally astute like you.

This album did not have a friend in me. In fact it barely made my acquaintance. My relationship with this album can be best described as one of those half nods you give to other dudes on the street when you awkwardly make eye contact. Uncomfortable, but not the most uncomfortable thing in the world.

Nostalgia from Toy Story is the only thing I got from this

This feels like an homage to 50’s musicals. Now that I’m thinking about it, let's make this a motherf***ing musical: It’s Cleveland in 1972. The son of an Ohio coal-miner longs for more in “Sail Away”. Next, we turn our attention to a Cleveland business mogul in “Lonely at the Top”. He has learned the hard way that being successful isn’t all there is in life. We go back to the son of the Ohio coal-miner in “He Gives Us All His Love”. As he decides to run away from home, he looks back at his father with gratitude, singing about all he’s given up for their family. Later, the Cleveland business mogul has a dream that no one remembers who he is in “Last Night I Had a Dream”. He wakes up and finds that it was just a dream, but grows concerned with the meaning. He soon finds out that his father, who he had a complicated relationship with, has passed away. As the coal-miner’s son makes his way to the city of Cleveland on a bus, he stops in a bar. There, he does a number called “Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear” with drunk patrons as they wish him good luck in the big city. We turn our attention back to the business mogul at his father’s funeral. Feeling lonelier than ever, he sings “Old Man”. He now has no one. Next, we go back to the coal-miner’s son on the bus. He runs into another coal-miner and they sing a ditty called “Political Science”, remarking that no one likes a coal-miner, despite them doing the hard work to keep society chugging along. Back to the business mogul, as he now faces a deep evil. Without anyone in his life, the last connection he feels is with the city of light, city of magic, his city, Cleveland. A company is attempting to get approval for dumping waste into Cuyahoga River. Our business mogul knows he must stop this company and do something to save the city his father taught him to love, singing “Burn On” to showcase it. Back to the coal-miner’s son. Or should I say, back to his father, as he learns his son has run away. He begins singing “Memo to My Son”, explaining that he believes his son will do well in the big city if he keeps his head screwed on right. He’s proud of him for running away. Back to the business mogul as he stands up in front of the local congress in Town Hall. He begins to reminisce about old times. How you could be best friends with an entire city, before everything become about moving fast and building up. His nostalgia appeals to the congress and the entire Town Hall breaks out into applause as he finishes singing “Dayton, Ohio - 1903”. They decide there will be no dumping waste into the river. Back to the coal-miner’s son as he finally arrives in the city of Cleveland. At the first diner he sits in, he spots the most gorgeous woman he’s ever seen in his eighteen years of living. He’s infatuated, and she teases him with “You Can Leave Your Hat On”. The two kiss and she asks to go back to his place. He’s only just gotten off the bus from rural Ohio! She scoffs and walks away. With a goofy smile, he realizes he’s made it. Back to the business mogul as he packs his bags to leave the city he loves so much. He’s given them everything, he realizes, and now it is time to go. He needs to find a new reason to live. Maybe that’s a woman, kids, he’ll never know until he tries. He walks out the door as “God’s Song (That’s Why I Love Mankind” finishes. As one Cleveland man leaves, another arrives. One legacy set in stone, another brewing with potential. Such is the City of Light, City of Magic. Cleveland calls us all. Fade to Black.

Good voice, chilled out but didn't get into it. Stand out- Last night I had a dream

Randy Newman has such a recognizable voice, especially if you grew up with Toy Story. Didn’t like the god parts, but they were still not bad songs. Enjoyed the whole thing, but it got repetitive, just a bit. Not a very exciting album. Lyrically it’s wonderful and thoughtful. The chords and structure go hard as well. Mid to good. 3/5

Recognizable and unique voice, but it is so so dinner theatre.

I don't know. Randy Newman is a good songwriter, but this whole album feels a bit 'middle of the road' to me. No my jam. 3/5

It seems harsh to rate a childhood icon so poorly, but I find it hard to imagine I'd ever listen to this album again. For some reason, it reminds me of that scene in Billy Madison where he calls Steve Buscemi, and Steve is holding a gun while putting on lipstick and listening to some easy-going doo-wop. This feels like the album I'd be listening to if I were to be putting on lipstick while holding a gun (for reference: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qzYeDm1Vpxs) I did give it two stars (not one) because I feel like some of these songs would be fun to sing with friends while playing piano, and they had a bit of a feel-good American innocence vibe (too bad most people wouldn't know them). I also found "Last Night I Had a Dream" to be kinda fun and funky, and "Memo to my son" got me teared up a bit (but not enough for three stars).

I feel like the concept of Randy Newman is more interesting than actual Randy Newman.

He seems to have a knack for writing songs with layers - there's a pleasing, mellow surface and a perplexing, sometimes dark underbelly. Listened a couple times through, very enjoyable.

This is a very nostalgic album for me. It reminds me of my Stepfather and the tremendous impact he had on my musical horizons. He was always exposing me to music such as this, that was just outside of my capability to fully grasp initially, but which grew on me over time when I was eventually able to start putting the pieces together for myself. Not to say that I didn't enjoy this straight away as a teenager though. My high school friends and I felt somewhat out of phase with our present era - old souls perhaps - so Randy Newman's more timeless, less rock oriented sound appealed to us in that way. Randy is fucking vicious, he just wraps it up in these beautiful arrangements so it goes down more easily. It's far more scathing that way too. Really messes with you emotionally so you're not even sure how to feel. He's a bitter motherfucker - and I feel that - and I also admire him for exploring lyrical territory very few others are brave enough to tread. He really confronts some of the darkest and most difficult corners of human weakness, hypocrisy, stupidity, evil, frailty, desire, fear, hubris, inadequacy, and sometimes even just mundaneness. He's always playing characters to voice these concerns, but you know he's in there somewhere, full of self loathing for being part of it all himself. And that's why it works - he's not above it. No matter how horrible these characters sound, he always makes it relatable, almost appealing, in some way. We're all guilty of being these imperfect, deeply flawed idiots, but at least Randy Newman recognizes it, is honest about it, and writes these gorgeous songs for us so we can at least all laugh about it.

I know the name and only really knew the song from Toy Story, but I'm definitely getting a bit of a more accessible, less bleak Tom Waits style of storytelling. Or perhaps Tom Waits is a darker Randy Newman? It's somewhat comforting music, I'm not sure what it is. Definitely a guy you'd wanna walk into a bar and listen to on a piano, but at home not really my thing.

Tja. Mh. Recht generisch, weiß nicht, was das hier soll.

This is a really well done album. I don't know what the fuck people are talking about Disney. That makes no sense to me. Did they even listen to this?

Randy Is probably the best at making a catchy tune with a very dark or profoundly hilarious undercurrent. A true legend.

Exactly what I expected.

Beautiful album, but a little too mellow for my liking. Great piano playing and vocal abilities on display though.

I couldn’t make it past the first two songs, I feel like I’m listening to a depressing Disney movie soundtrack

Long before Randy Newman sold his soul to the Disney corporation, Newman was considered a legitimately talented singer-songwriter musician type who produced critically acclaimed records. His early 70's albums are interesting and quite good, but then he had a big hit (Short People) and things blew up from there. Then for whatever reason Disney came calling and yes, he sold out to the mouse. Sail Away is an okay enough, can't say I didn't like it, but it's hard to listen to the songs without thinking about Buzz and Woody.

Pop agradável, mas nada marcante.

Not much of a fan of Randy, but this can probably grow on me if I hear it enough. Standouts: Old Man Others: Everything else Rating: 3.5

I guess I'd forgotten that Randy Newman did anything but Pixar movie music and "Short People," and that's too bad. These were songs to listen to again and again, each time finding those brilliant little hidden gotchas that lurk under the affable, delightful surface.

This was very enjoyable. I found myself repeatedly asking, “Now, what film was this in?”

This is very fine storytelling. And not just in the lyrics. The music itself tells a story. It is no surprise that Newman has been so successful as a film composer. His songs themselves are cinematic. The opening and closing tracks are deviously beautiful: lovely melodies bring you in and then the lyrics kick you in the teeth. I'm sure I knew it at some point but maybe I'd forgotten that Newman wrote "You Can Leave Your Hat On." Listening to this album, it struck me how similar Randy Newman and Tom Waits are. I would love an album where they cover each other's tunes.

I like Randy Newman’s music and knew “You Can Leave Your Hat On” but the rest of this looked unfamiliar - but as I listened I kept have moments of recognition. This was a lot of fun (and a little bit of shock when you realize what some of the lyrics were about) to listen to. Really brilliant! I like this each time I’ve listened to it more and more… glad to have it in my library!

Couldn't stop thinking about Family Guy.

Un compositor com n'hi hagut pocs, però les seves cançons normalment brillen més en veu d'altres artistes. Aquí l'exemple més clar és 'You Can Leave Your Hat On', infinitament potenciada anys després per Joe Cocker. La seva veu rasposa i arrastrada té cert encant, però

This is a brilliant album and I have always loved it

meh, not a big fan of this kinda orchestral pop. Sounds like a cheesy film soundtrack

Not a fan.

This was a fun album to get since I’ve only ever known randy Newman from movie scores and was never familiar with his actual music career. You can definitely see the career trajectory from this though since both are really well made and pleasant and just feel cozy and comforting. It was just a nice half hour and I especially liked the first track.

This album starts off strong but slightly fizzles out towards the end. It's still an enjoyable listen. 3.5/5

Weer zo'n album vol Randy Newman-klassiekers, de ironie druipt er weer vanaf, maar het zijn leuke jazzy songs met mooie arrangementjes. Tussen het zwarte wereldbeeld vinden we zowaar ook oprechte vrolijkheid, niet voor niets nummers die we beter als covers kennen: Simon Smith and his dancing bear en You can leave your hat on. Een soort kruising tussen Bram Vermeulen en Drs. P maar dan uit Amerika.

Deze keer maar eens naar een paar teksten geluisterd van de beste man. Want daar draait het om, werd mij uitgelegd. Eerlijk. Ik ben niet heel erg onder de indruk van de teksten. Niets mis mee hoor, maar ook niets bijzonders. Het is vooral een prima plaat op de achtergrond om bij te werken. Iets fijner Good Old Boys die we eerder al gepresenteerd kregen.

Ik vond het meer muziek voor een soundtrack van een film of een tv serie. Blijkt dat die beste man inderdaad heel veel soundtracks op zijn naam heeft. We hebben al eerder een album van Newman gehad, dat paste prima in de categorie schijtlollige teksten op de piano. Dit is wat ingetogener. Doe mij dan toch maar de schijtlollige versie. Dit vond ik maar saai. 2 sterren voor de moeite

весь альбом казался каким-то невыносимо долгим, 40 минут тянулись пару часов по ощущениям отдельно хочу отметить He Gives Us All His Love - нежно, красиво конечно отмечу You Can Leave Your Hat On, ощущения примерно как обнаружить Empty во Вселенная бесконечна. а ещё там очень дерзкий текст. я бы назвал это репом 70х весь альбом вряд ли рекомендую к прослушиванию, но отдельные треки стоят внимания

The Pixar guy gives us a half hour of bright piano pop. I don't really see the appeal. The instrumentation was all pretty bland and predictable, but at least there was diversity. "Last Night I Had the Dream" was the only one that sounded cool. Even the critically acclaimed "Sail Away" was too simple and boring. It's not awful and its short length and pop-style make it easily digestible, but I see no reason to revisit.

Абсолютно офигенный композитор и он хорош в кино. Но отдельно слушать тяжело, хоть все и звучит вкусно

Интересный факт из биографии артиста, который я совершенно случайно узнал до прослушивания - оказывается, это автор саундтреков к фильмам Pixar, а именно Истории Игрушек, Тачек и Корпорации Монстров. Вау, вау, вау. Второй интересный факт, который возник во время прослушивания альбома: охренеть, оказывается, это не Джо Кокер написал You Can Leave Your Hat On (музыка из стрипухи/кабаре/для секса, вот это знаменитое начало с саксофоном). Не отходя далеко, у Кокера конечно поярче аранжировка получилась, в оригинале есть какой-то блюз вайб больше. Мне понравилось, могу сказать, что готов альбом переслушать. Понятно, почему автор потом ушёл в написание саундтреков, с оркестром он хорошо умеет работать, это классно. И кажется, что впервые за долго время, появился альбом с глубокой лирической составляющей. Тоже в плюсик.

Мне нравится пианинка там, где она добавляет атмосферы, а не является центрообразующим инструментом, так что тут выше 3 автоматически поставить не могу, но вроде красиво

Alright, so I've had some time to sit with Randy Newman's Sail Away album, and I gotta say, it's not half bad. I mean, sure, his voice is never not gonna make me think about Toy Story, but hey - that's not necessarily a bad thing. The album has got some real gems on it, like "Sail Away", the title track, and "Political Science," which are both super catchy and will have you singing along in no time. And Newman's lyrics are just top-notch. He's like a musical wordsmith, weaving together stories and observations with a wit that's both sharp and subtle. Now, I will say that the album isn't perfect. There are a few tracks that kind of blend together and don't really stand out. But hey, nobody's perfect, right? And the songs that do hit, they hit hard. All in all, I'd give Sail Away a solid 3,5 out of 5 (but as .5 stars aren't available on here I'm gonna round it down to a 3). It's a fun listen that'll make you laugh, make you feel, and maybe even make you ponder the state of the world a bit. And who knows, maybe after a few more listens, I won't even be able to think of Woody anymore. But let's be real, that's probably not gonna happen.

God’s song was the only real highlight here for me. Dayton 1903 annoyed me.

pretty great. He made fun music before Toy Story. 4 stars.

Its quite the disservice but every song just sounds like "you've got a friend in me"

I really like Randy's voice and it is partly because of the nostalgia of toy story and other Disney music. Also when I went on a family trip to California in like 2004 we had some kind of Disney flight and listened to the Disney radio the entire 10+ hours or whatever to San Francisco with hours of him chatting about writing Disney music and then the songs... strange behaviour but we didn't have TVs so this reminds me of that fun memory haha. I think he is super talented and I like the overall vibe. However, I don't like how twee some of the songs are and I don't like the religious themes that creep in.

Well I guess I enjoyed this! Its hard to not think every Randy Newman song is aimed at kids, and I'm not sure its just the Toy Story influence. He's just got quite a comical voice and style! Clearly a talented musician too.

I do like Randy Newman, he's got some belters but the filler tracks were a bit lacking on this for me.

The simplicity of the song structures and the narrative lyrics/singing style comes together on this one so well. Opting for the piano, but not moving in the pop/soft rock direction, makes Randy stand out among his peers. His voice is unique, almost goofy at times, giving it a light-heartedness that is the polar opposite of what someone like Dylan does with his serious gravel, for example. Newman is also the master of the everyday. There's nothing epic or world historical in his lyrics, but they still transport the listener.

Song interesting song writing on a few songs, not sure on the execution

An alright listen. Nothing super amazing or horrible about this for me. Just felt like another okay album.

Didn't really enjoy this, I think it's mainly because I don't like his voice (sorry Randy).

Enjoyed the listen, Newsman’s piano playing is great

Randy Newman's music is the equivalent of walking down the street and overhearing random people's conversations. Mundane and irrelevant to you. It has no significant bearing on your life and quickly forgettable. Listening to an entire album is the equivalent of waiting in a long line and having to hear the guy behind you carry out the boring details of his life.

Beautiful. Gentle and sweet, just perfect for cooking to. I loved this. Also had not previously known that 'Simon Smith..' and 'Leave your hat on' were his songs, not those of Georgie Fame and Tom Jones. My favourite was God's Song' - very moving.

4.2 - Newman’s uncanny knack for penning easy, instantly relatable classics is fully here. He explores sex, love, death, war and existence with a childlike frankness, similar to Shel Silverstein at his most sincere.

Nice enough

Bit of a bore?

Satirical, funny and poignant, some heartfelt moments but could fun a little one note sonically

Wow. So darkly satirical. I don't have anything original to say, only that the glowing positive reviews out there mirror how I feel about this.

not a fan of Randy Newman

Holy jesus fuck, how bloody miserable is this stuff? His Toy Story schtick got old despite the magic, this is just miserable and all a bit samey

Political Science kind of a banger. Rest is just not for me. Not offensive or anything. Nothing I would choose to listen to again. Also the 2 non-remastered tracks that Spotify has are better than the remastered tracks, not sure if that holds true for any others.

Not much interesting here for me. Favorite track: Lonely at the Top

Just makes me think of Toy Story. Not a huge fan of it TBH, even though on paper it seems like I should. Maybe like 2.5 stars?

Very Disney esq, a tad to Jesusy, not bad just don't think I'll listen to again

Real chill, didn't grab me. I can't stop hearing Family Guy's version of Randy Newman.

It is a nice album to listen to but I'll never listen to it again. Each song is kind of a worse version of you've got a friend in me. No standouts on this album (bad or good)

This has definitely helped improve my interpretation of Randy Newman which was just Toy Story man and being made fun of in Family Guy and South Park. I can say for sure Newman is more skilled as a songwriter than a singer, but at least he isn't too annoying. About half of Sail Away is not for me, but there is some good songs like the title track and Old Man than make me want to listen to again for a better opinion.

Love this album.

Very nice, chill album, would listen again

A kind and soft affair. It’s very own private concert.

I expected more from this album being familiar with some of Newman's work. It fell a little flat for me. 2/5

Not the Randy I was expecting

I can see absolutely why other people love Randy Newman. But I just don't click. Perhaps a result of associating him with Woody and Buzz. Sorry Randy.

This man is a treasure

Really good album with great piano lines and good voice

Best Song: Old Man. A nice, quiet sort of lullaby. Worst Song: God's Song. This is really more of an interesting poem than a listenable song. Overall: Pretty one note. And that note is extremely nasal.

I really liked this one. Not sure I've listened to Randy Newman outside of some Toy Story movie soundtracks and this was really good. Maybe you have to get past his vocals? They're distinctive enough that if they hit you wrong they'd ruin the whole thing. But they don't for me. He feels like the flipside of the Warren Zevon coin. Does that make sense? Anyway. Good stuff.

I love Randy Newman, probably one of the sharpest, cynical, funny songwriters in American popular music. That he can combine drollery with poignancy, often in the same song, is impressive; married to lovely, jazzy piano arrangements, it's stellar. Sure, he's got a funny voice. It fits the music. Would a song about the slave trade like 'Sail Away' fly today? It's probably too glib to suit today's climate, despite its brilliance. A great collection of characterful songs by one of the best to ever do it.

My wife turned me onto this one many moons ago and it's still my favorite Randy Newman anything I've ever heard. The lyrics are interesting and suit his voice, and the instrumentation (or, basically, lack of drums and guitars) really stands out from so much of the pack in the singer-songwriter space. Lots of favorites here and glad it made the list!

I want to like Randy Newman more than I do. Maybe I'm not yet cynical enough. I'm sure I will eventually get there; I do recognize the talent and the wit. 3.5

This is pre-Disney Randy Newman, I know, but the most memorable song for me was Lonely at the Top, which had a very “didn’t make the cut for the Toy Story soundtrack” vibe. I dare you to listen to that song and tell me you don't visualize Buzz Lightyear head hung low, thinking about Woody being upset with him because of some imagined power struggle.

Oh I know this song. And this one. Oh he wrote this one too? Wowsers. I feel poorly educated for not knowing Randy Newman's catalogue. My bad. And having such a unique voice, what a talent. No need to keep your hat on Randy, go flaunt it.

The going line on Randy Newman, the performer, is "Those that don't like him just don't understand him." There's no dispute on Randy Newman, the songwriter: He's one of the premier songwriters of his or anyone's generation. Even if your mileage varies on Newman as a performer, his songwriting genius is on full display here, notably on the title song, Political Science, and You Can Leave Your Hat On. Personally, as a performer, I find him to be the poor man's Warren Zevon. Most of his best songs were made famous performed by other artists. Newman going Disney hurt his reputation more than helped it. I prefer to remember everything he wrote up to "I Love L.A." Or maybe I just don't get Pixar Randy Newman.

This album splits me in two. Generally speaking, I love Newman's musical style, and I think he achieves a sort of genius with some of his lyrics and their commentary. And while I think he dominates his niche genre and there are some definite killer tracks in this album, there's also a lot of pretty meh stuff in my opinion, and that's what's keeping me from a 4.

Really lame. Can't really get into his style of music or his voice. 1.5/5

Not sure what to make of this. The first thing the kids said is "That Toy Story Dude". Yep, sure is. I had no idea he did anything except the Toy Story theme. But yep, he sure did. This. And probably other stuff too. It was...well....Toy Story, although with some racier lyrics. I did appreciate "I saw a vampire, I saw a ghost, but you are what scared me the most". Classic. So as an album of adult oriented Toy Story themes, not bad.

bleh. this was like listening to that uncle who loved to play the piano, but never any good songs, just weird ones he made up.

Randy newman just has a special way of writing songs. Nobody else sounds like him or has songs that sound quite like this. The second track Immediately made me think of monsters inc and toy story. My criticism of this album is that most of these songs sound the same. Not an awful thing in this case. Solid 5/10

The lyrics are worth checking out, but musically it does not engage me.

Pretty good. Songs about religion and doing the full Monty. Some of these are also very funny. last night I had a dream and political science were big highlights.

Not the biggest Randy Newman fan. I can see how people could really like it, just not for me.

Sound like a mix of the Toy Story soundtrack and curb your enthusiasm

I said in my other Randy Newman review, but I get why Disney hired this guy. His is the template of Pixar movies so this album, unsurprisingly, sounds like that. It isn't bad, it's comforting, but it isn't exceptional. 3.5/5

Just easy listening and smooth. Enjoyable.

Old Toy Story sounding ass

tranquilo

There’s no denying that Randy Newman is a gifted songwriter and arranger, but his voice might be the hurdle some listeners can’t overcome. For those who can, Sail Away walks a fine line between whimsical and just a bit too silly, and most of the time it maintains that balance well.

A real american twang

Con un piano y poco más, disco tranquilo de escuchar y apacible

Randy Newman is overrated imho. He has a few good songs that make him stand out, but other than that it’s nothing special

Ganz alt, eher boring

I really like Randy Newman now, he's a great at arranging songs and a pretty good lyricist. This might grow on me over time, would love to hear more albums from the guy.

Good music. slow and southern. He's known from toy story.

Is it considered blasphemous to say that most every Randy Newman song sounds the same? I'm sure people think he is charming or even a genius but I seem to be missing something

It's a pretty gentle album. There's some interesting songs that question faith.

Not my bag, but solid songwriting. Randy Newman has become a bit of a joke, but cool to see where it all started.

This is so cheesy and Newman's voice is so silly that I can't tell whether it's supposed to be treated as a joke or not. But as a serious piece of music, it just doesn't do it for me. Part of what makes great music great is the depth of sound, and especially the interplay between different instruments. I hate to damn an entire genre based on missing just one aspect of musical performance, but it's a really important one, and it's just very hard for one guy singing with a single accompanying instrument to match that kind of color. The singer-songwriter style often work well as a change-of-pace track to break things up on an otherwise full-sounding album, but this is an entire record of Randy singing over his own, fairly light piano accompaniment. "Political Science" is probably the standout track, in part because it's clever, but mostly because it actually has some solid sound behind it. And there's some other nice compositions on here, but the thin production and Newman's voice just don't do them justice.

Way better than expected. The man knows how to handle a bass line, and the lyrics are refreshingly wry, satirical and occasionally heavy.

When you know Randy Newman can produce a song as magical and eternal as You've Got a Friend in Me, everything else he does is really disappointing. Maybe that's unfair as it's an impossibly high bar to hit a second time, let along be held to overall, but yeah, Sail Away is passable by comparison, and even then only because of the first two tracks plus Political Science. They're nice and sweet, I do like his voice more than most because it's authentic and easy, but 2/5 for the overall memorability of the album.

Meh. Title track is good, as is Political Science, but I don't like the songwriting enough to overcome the sketchiness of his voice (which is great at within a pretty small range and not great otherwise). It's pleasant, but not a lot more than that. Squeaks a 3.

I just personally really dislike his voice. Instrumentation was… fine. His songs all kind of sound the same.

Hard to listen to Randy Newman's voice since his Pixar-related hit: You've got a Friend in Me...

Liked it. Love his voice, phrasing and chording.

Enjoyed more than I thought

Very hokie. Reminded me of toy story

Can we get something good please.

I'll pass

This felt like B-sides from a Toy Story movie. There were some gems in here, but all I could think of was Monk and Pixar. A lot of tedious tracks as well. But some good ones. I'm thinking a light 4.

Yeah this is randy Newman—not bad, just too slow and too much tuba for my taste

I’m not too familiar with Randy Newman and didn’t know what to expect. This album was a biting satire that sent up American exceptionalism and even flirted with the absurd. I’m also quite partial to Los Angeles orchestral pop so this album appealed to me musically as well. Overall this was a perfect album for me.

Hate it. But can't argue against it.

Not a fan

Nista mi se nije isticalo na albumu

Ej, pa on je napravio soundtrack za Toy Story? Monster Inc.??Dajte ovom čovjeku medalju! Uglavnom, dobar album, nije za repete, ali je okej, i taj glas njegov mi stalno u glavi kao da pjeva "You've Got a Friend In Me." I mislim da to neće nestat. Toy Story među najjačim trilogijama +1 (jer je i četvorka isto napravljena, iak može i bez tog dijela - al je dobar, nije nužno kao trilogija ali nije okaljalo toliko franšizu.)

A whole album of Toy Story songs 😅

Ha una voce da colonne sonore disney e c'è 'You can leave your hat on' Non molto altro.

I absolutely loved this album, and I had never heard it before. The arrangement was so clever, the lyrics were so wonderful and touching and thought provoking. I will definitely add this to my rotation.

Ef fólk fílar You've got a friend in me, þá er þetta plata fyrir þau. Voðalega kósí og vinalegt og gæti flest passað inn í Disney teiknimynd.

4 stars - its classic Randy Newman. I'd definitely say he has a unique voice and his early albums, such as this, are a lot better than newer Randy Newman

Long before I had a friend in Randy Newman and Toy Story I was burning in with Major League! One of the most distinct voices.

Great 70's piano led rock but with dark fucking lyrics which can tend to get over looked as the melodies are sometimes so great. For example, the title track is sungfrom the point of view of a slaver singing about how great life is in America to slaves from Africa who are bound there. Another about how the US shoudl just drop nuclear bombs on everyone that way no one could criticise them for dropping bombs on everyone. Like I said - dark. Best Tracks: Sail Away; Last Night I Had A Dream; God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)

Nice surprise. Randy Newman has a new fan

Not familiar with Randy Newman's stuff but the style in this album really reminded of his famous song for Toy Story. Not my particular cup of tea but I do think I need to give it a couple more listens to truly appreciate it.

Love Randy Newman's style, very enjoyable listen throughout

This was a pretty boring album that felt like an endless Toy Story song. It was like listening to polished, censured, and sanitized "Americana" music.

I wasn't all that familiar with Randy Newman beyond "You've Got a Friend in Me" from Toy Story. That's a great track and perfect for the movie, although completely irrelevant for a review of Sail Away. I couldn't help but feel like the aforementioned song would be next, such is the idiosyncratic style of the music, maybe mainly driven by Newman's distinctive drawl. You Can Keep Your Hat On was ok but the rest of the album faded a bit into insignificance. Not an unpleasant listen but don't feel like I need to come back to this one.

Now I finally understand this Family Guy joke (Season 2 Episode 3) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ARP6dXMlWQ8

Randy Newman is a pretty incredible talent and I like most of the songs on this album. It's just really hard to listen to an entire album. It starts to get repetitive pretty fast. If I heard each of these songs interspersed throughout a day or so of listening to music I wouldn't mind as much but when you listen to them all in a row you start looking for the "skip" button. 3.5 stars

I think, to a certain degree, I'm generationally preconditioned to have a positive emotional response to Randy Newman's voice. His contributions to Pixar films aside, Newman really does have a very comfortable and easy delivery that seems somewhat designed to put the listener at ease. That's why it's so jarring when he comes at you with a song like "Political Science" and drops lines like, "They don't respect us/So let's surprise them/We'll drop the big one/And pulverize them." It feels out of place. But, honestly... it works. His delivery disarms the defensive cynicism that protest songs tend to provoke in me. I enjoyed this album a lot. Way more than expected.

I don't know what to do with Randy Newman's music. Yes, I like his work with the Toy Story music for Pixar. I have a hard time not hearing the parodies of Newman when I hear him perform on his own. Sail Away left me feeling many of the same things as the previous album I reviewed from Newman. The one track I knew from Sail Away is my all time least favorite song from Newman, and I will drop this album to 2 stars for that track alone. I don't think I want to hear anyone trying to flirt that way in a song. Ick!

Musically charming, understatedly elegant arrangements. Sly, unsentimental, frequently cynical lyrics. Randy Newman is a treasure. Fave Songs (All songs, from most to least favorite): Sail Away, Last Night I Had a Dream, Memo to My Son, Lonely at the Top, God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind), Political Science, You Can Leave Your Hat On, Old Man, Dayton, Ohio - 1903, He Gives Us All His Love, Burn On, Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear

Americana with southern roots. Hints of trad and Dixie jazz from the brass and southern rock in.the guitar. Dr John light. Bit too god-y in places for me.

A fascinating album, full of clever, cutting lyrics and crystal clear imagery. Highlights for me were the devastatingly dark "Old Man" and the wry humor on "Political Science". The original version of "You Can Leave Your Hat On" takes on a whole new meaning with slurred lyrics evoking a sense of drunken sleaze adding a dimension that is absent from the more famous Joe Cocker cover version. I found the production to be a bit uninspiring at times.

Думаешь, что этот альбом похож на саундтрек к какому-нибудь мультфильму. А в итоге оказывается, что исполнитель после написал саундтреки к мультфильмам Pixar. Пхех.

2/5 not my cup of tea

RaNdY NeWmAn DoEs DiSnEy SoNgS. What a weak, embarrassing take.

My review of this album: yeah, sure. It's music, it's certainly not bad, but the overall style isn't for me. Feels kind of slow, simple, and plodding, with repetitive chords and slow bass-lines. Again, it's really not bad, but it didn't hold my interest.

I didn’t realize so many if his greatest songs were on this one album. Political Science and Sail Away are tremendous. Lonely at the Top and Burn on are also classics. Great album overall.

A very underrated songwriter who I don't know a ton about. But lots of musicians rave about him.

My knowledge of Randy Newman was limited to Toy Story and that Family Guy bit making fun of him, so this is better than I expected. His lyrics have a vein of dark satire about America, such as enticing people into slavery and nuking the world. His voice must be an acquired taste though.

Strong effort. The music is particularly strong. Newman's lyrics are less bitter and cynical than later efforts. From the start, Newman's music was cinematic (no surprise given his background).

He may not be the greatest singer, but Randy Newman is a brilliant songwriter and I think his voice works incredibly well with his writing style. At this point in his career, he's probably thought of mostly as a movie score/song composer. His ascerbic wit is on full display on this album. I think it's great even though my 2 favorite songs of his (Mama Told Me Not to Come and I Love LA) aren't on this record.

Randy Newman wrote some very creative songs but not the most fun to listen to. "Sail away" was eerie when I realized what it was actually about. If I was a bigger lyrics person maybe this could be a 5 but the music itself is just not fully there for me.

This one I guess is peak Randy Newman, at least of this particular aspect of his singer/songwriter persona. And I like it, a lot of it is pretty funny, the music is all solid and some rises to a higher level. But there is the issue of the kind of condescending sneer behind a lot of the satirical lyrics, this attitude of “let’s channel how these idiots think” but without any hint really of pointing to a better way.

This guy is basically a machine churning out songs for movies that stick in the mind long after the movie has faded...... I think he also works as a film composer so that would make total sense. As an album though, Sail Away is a collection of short but sweet songs showcasing Randy's vocals. Loved it.

A collection of short, simple, beautiful songs by 'the Toy Story guy'. A number of these songs (all written by Newman) are well known for versions having been recorded by others. Here they mainly comprise piano with strings. The simpler versions highlight the quality of the songwriting and soulfulness of Newman's voice. Simply lovely. Rating: 4.5/5 Playlist track: Sail Away Date listened: 21/06/22

Dig the voice, but this all sounds like a Pixar movie. Somehow this man has no soul whatsoever. Old Man sounded awful but the song was sad. Also, this dude was born and raised in California. Why he sing like NoLa?

He's a good song writer, but this collection didn't hang together for me. Also, why the strings? They don't add anything. I love sarcasm as much as the next man, but does every line need to be dripping? This album got me thinking about who could be a Randy Newman fan. I'm fine hearing any of his songs, but who in 1972 ran out to buy this album and played it until it wore out? Wiki suggests that Brian Wilson did, but maybe he's the only one.

It's inescapable that Toy Story has done for old Randy since it's very difficult to separate him from the film. What some perhaps don't know is how many well known songs he has written (mainly for other people)....... for example halfway down the list is 'You can leave your hat on' which was a huge hit for Joe Cocker from the film 9.5 weeks. This music is 'One man and a piano in a smokey bar drinking singing about his troubles in life' which some may find dreary but in the right circumstances is soothing to listen to.

You got a friend in me

Really enjoyed the album, defo my bag and the satirical songwriting was great.

Boring af

Randy newman fatigue

https://youtu.be/EftDLxJ0bEo?t=188

So many quirky songs but the OG version of You Can Leave Your Hot on is quite good! I'll have to say my favourite is Political Schiece because nobody wants to hurt kangaroos.

J'ai entendu le générique de Monk tout du long, désolé Randy

j'ai entendu la chanson You've got a friend in me de Toy Story tout le long perso

It sure was a Randy Newman album

just boring, really poor effort and awful vocals

For me and probably many others my first thought was: "oh, it's the Toy Story guy. This could be fun". It isn't. There's some charm that comes out once in a while, but overall I was pretty uninterested. I can see why others might be into this but I will pass.

There are a couple of great songs in here, but a whole album of Randy Newman (even if it is only 30 minutes) is just too much. Best track: Sail Away

Interesting songs

Gotta 😆 in the first 10 seconds I heard “you Got a Friend “ in my mind and BAM it is the same artist!!

I've never been a fan of old randy, and maybe it was because of a hilarious family guy bit making fun of him but it was an accurate bit because he kind of sounds like he has a little jello in his voice. Not my style.

"Is this the 'You've Got a Friend in Me' guy?" Yes, yes it is. The guy has a signature voice, instantly recognizable and forever immortalized by a Pixar song. But hey, he's more than that. There are quite a few excellent tracks on here. I can't say that I was blown away overall, and after a little while I found the music slipping into the background for me (happened on both listens). I guess that just happens with a voice like his. But it's a good album, no denying it! And I just love the lyric "he's happy as a monkey in a monkey tree." Well done, Randy! I could see this growing on me. Favorite tracks: Sail Away, Last Night I Had a Dream, Dayton Ohio 1903. Album art: Just a headshot, but the angle is unique I guess? He looks like a Bond villain version of Elton John or something, I don't know. Not sure what I expected the guy with this voice to look like, maybe a Burl Ives snowman? 3.5/5