Reviews (page 6 of 8)
Almost every song sounds like the theme tune to Toy Story!
It was ok
Fans of the series “Monk” will have a flashback, because every song reminds you of it. But after a while it becomes quite monotonous, just like the singer's voice.
Randy Newman is one of America's GOAT songwriters - taking history, politics, religion, humanity, and family to task with a scathing yet subtle wit on some songs and bathing us in warm wholesome ditties on other. This album rules.
Good story telling is missing in modern music. This album reminds me of the more profound music scene that existed.
Very mellow and enjoyable
Eh. Randy's distinct voice works for a Toy Story soundtrack, but I don't want to listen to an album of his for pleasure. The sounds are quick and similar and don't offer a whole lot. I don't hate the songs but I also don't feel a need to listen ever again. 4.5/10 (2.25/5)
A lovely and tender collection of songs that made me feel like a 12 year old again. 3.5/5
Fulgte visst ikkje med her heller. Blei litt skremt når You can leave your hat on kom på
Solid album. Once you reset from the initial Toy Story/film score/etc. familiarity, this is a nice album. Newman is a good songwriter. Sometimes a simple piano and some good lyrics are all you need. ***
I was really ready to write this album off and was bummed when I got this album. 'Lonely at the top,' 'Political Science,' and 'God's Song' changed my mind. Sorry I doubted you, Randy. 4/5
To be honest I don’t really understand Randy Newman’s vibe, but this is really pleasantly composed, and obviously his vocals are totally unique and compelling.
Really heartfelt and sweet! I love Randy
alawys been a randy fan but i think in 2024 I disagree with his methods of getting his politics across (taking on personas)
kept thinking i was listening to a disney soundtrack😭 lowkey had to skip a lot just because i wasnt in the vibe… also rating this a 2, not necessarily because it’s bad, but just not my favorite style
Too many parodies of Randy Newman songs make it nigh impossible to enjoy Randy Newman directly.
No denying that he's a good songwriter, but there's not enough variation in tone here to keep my interest, and I don't particularly like his voice.
People who rated this only 1 star are idiots. Randy Newman is without doubt one of the world's greatest ever songwriters. Witty, funny, bitter, biting satire coupled with tunes of genius.
Easy listening.......3*
Something about Randy Newman singing 'You Can Leave Your Hat On' made me feel queasy.
Such a wonderful songwriter and composer. I enjoyed this, especially his ability to create characters in the lyrics. It makes sense that he was so good at film scores since so many of his compositions are 3rd party storytelling.
Nice one
Randy Newman just sounds like Toy Story to me. This was like an hour of that family guy skit where he "sits there night and day, just singing about what he sees." it's funny for 30 seconds, it's a nightmare for an hour.
Gran compositor, fuera de modas.
Well now Randy Newman, an artiste I've always thought I should like. His voice is unique in style and timbre. And indeed the theme to Monk, was superb. And there were some good bits here, but not enough. Preferred it to yesterday's offering, but only just. Still I feel I need to make that evident with my score, so it's a 3 from me.
What’s with that voice? Like he’s trying to sing like a spoilt-brat-child. Songs are dross too. Zero stars.
Oh dear. I'm confused. I was expecting Randy Crawford (not a good thing). Instead, I get someone who sounds like he should be singing the song from Toy Story. Turns out it is the man who sung the song in Toy Story. I don't mind that song in the context of the film, but all this was a bit wearing, he even managed to make another of his classic songs sound shite, until Tom Jones came along and did the definitive version in The Full Monty (in my opinion). On the whole it is underwhelming and bland. 1 star.
One part charming, one part jazzy, two parts disturbing; that's the Randy Newman cocktail. I've always admired Newman's ability to craft cheeky tunes that ease their way into mainstream consciousness, even if I've never been a big fan. Side note, I think it speaks to our lack of cultural risks these days compared to 30 years ago, when a major children's animation corporation could hire someone like Randy Newman to compose the music for the first Pixar film. Somehow, all those pieces fell into place, solidifying not only Newman's legacy, but also some of the most memorable music ever composed that virtually every human on Earth knows. What would be the equivalent of that today? Giving songwriting duties on Bluey to Yung Gravy?
Sail away to sleepy time slumber land.
What a sublime record.
"The Buddhists and the Hindu joined on satellite TV... "I cried when this lyric came up... Sad life we living in.. people in long long queues.... Stepping to their demise one by one... Monochromatic aberration... Always remove that shit in lightroom rainbows in every edge..
Probably Randy Newman's best album, sail away, is an excellent record.
Great
Don’t like it…what is great about it?
I appreciate what this man did for Toy Story but this album was kind of boring. Also, why is a guy from Los Angeles obsessed with singing about Ohio?
Favourite Song: God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)
It's fine. His vocals are surprisingly imperfect in quite a lot of places. Not sure if I find that charming.
The more I listen to this album the more I’m in awe of his truly singular songwriting ability and performance style. His tunes are often hilarious (probably the most consistently funny non-joke-song songwriter) but also sometimes heartbreakingly beautiful, bc he is able to paint an honest (and ugly) picture of how people think, feel and treat (mistreat) one another.
I'm a bit taken aback by just how good this is. The songwriting is off the scale. His voice can be a bit abrasive. It's a strong 4.5
Randy Newman is a musician that typically evokes strong respect. I only know him from music he created for Toy Story and the tv show Monk, but I had no reason to have doubts about Sail Away--and it was an enjoyable and smooth album that ended all too soon. He's a songwriter, first and foremost, and I'll be the first to admit his voice doesn't do much for me. But the music is unbelievably beautiful, as are the lyrics. Despite Sail Away's short length at thirty minutes, Newman accomplishes a solid album that flows and provides a range of emotions.
I don't particularly love Randy Newman's style, but I can appreciate his songwriting! I didn't recognize his name either, but his voice is unmistakable; the moment he started singing I said to myself "Oh! The Toy Story 'You've Got A Friend in Me' guy!" And from there, I even recognized a few of the songs on this album. This guy certainly has a knack for songwriting that goes along with that distinct voice. While I wasn't blown away, I will say that this made for an easy listening experience!
I like Randy Newman. This is a great album. I really like Last Night I Had A Dream! Also Political Science of course.
Very weak
Simultaneously soothing and unsettling.
Zeer boring
I really enjoyed a lot of this, particularly Sail Away, Lonely at the Top and Political Science. Sharp satire, great songwriting, but very average singing. You know you're doing satire right when people completely misunderstand you!
Piano ditties And poetic ramblings Laid back listening
Well, I can't say that I expected to ever listen to a full album from Randy Newman of all people, but I'm kind of happy I did. Randy Newman is an artist that I've heard plenty of songs from before, but there's one thing in common with the context I heard them in. I heard them all in animated movies. But you know, I've always liked what I've heard. I always did like the music in the Toy Story movies. But now, I get to talk about his music outside of that! And I've gotta say, it's pretty solid. The sound is familiar territory, mainly in regards to the singing, which I should've expected given that it's still Randy Newman. It's pretty good though. His music is kind of like Bob Dylan's in a way where the songwriting is the main focus as opposed to the singing and instrumentation, because while both of the latter things are good, it's the songwriting that makes this a listen that's worth your time. There's an element of satire that I didn't expect to be there, but I gladly welcome it. It makes this music stand out from the movie stuff. There's a solid variety in what's written about, including religion ("He Gives Us All His Love" and "God's Song"), America ("Political Science" and the title track), and whatever "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear" is supposed to be about. The many short song approach aids in this variety. Overall, it's not amazing or anything, but Sail Away is a pretty good album that makes me appreciate Randy Newman's musical talents a lot more. High 3/5.
Soaked in the 70s that album - I prefer Tom Waits for this sort of thing
I'm not gonna lie, I was hoping it would start with that song that goes, "Sail away, sail away sail away sail away." Y'all know what I'm talking about?
Not a fan of his singing. Also quite boring.
It’s ok
It is a tad boring, but the vibe is there
He's a gem
Mahtava ääni ukolla. Soitanta vaihtelevan mielekästä.
Edellisen levyn kommentit: ”Paikoin muniinpuhaltelua, paikoin ok. En kuuntele toista kertaa” meni väärälle levylle… piti tulla tähän. D. Crosbyn levy taasen oli parempi. Välillä jopa mukaansatempaavaa rehellistä rokkia. Ja tähdet tosiaan meni väärinpäin. Crosby 3, Newman 2
Randy Newman makes good songs for movies and specific situations, but they're weird as an album.
Sail Away deliberately uses a hopeful gospel melody to hide the dark truth of the lyrics, while Political Science presents a humourous critique of American exceptionalism that is still relevant 50 years later. Also there's a song about a dancing bear.
The most American thing I'll hear today. It really bugs me how many of these songs just sort of end without ending. It's super disruptive. Okay over all though.
Nothing enjoyable about this album.
Nice
2,5
who fronted this guy cash to cut a record? garbage
3.5 stars. Singer-songwriter that is more orchestral than pure folk. Incredibly talented lyricist. The slow and 'quiet' nature of the music led to it not being quite as engaging but more an album I just appreciate.
A second Randy Newman album. This one seems less crude yet still his groggy voice and slow style of music makes this album a snoozer. Overall Newman shouldn’t have one album on this list let alone two. 4.3/10
Kitsch. The single Political Science does not come across as satire and, imo, highlights the "main character" syndrome Americans have. Arrogant af.
Excellent
rollo toy story
I don’t understand Randy Newman. Is it actually music or is it a parody of music? A satire of music? It’s not Weird Al. It’s not Mark Russell. But it’s also not, not those things. Is Randy Newman a comedian? Is he a singer? What am I supposed to do with these “songs”? Am I supposed to go, “oh, what a clever turn of phrase” and chortle. Is listening to this “music” supposed to make me feel smart? Are these like MadTV sketches set to music? Is this a music review or a clever parody of a music review? Is this cynical social commentary on the absurdity of music reviews? Maybe it’s a loving homage to music reviews that satirizes their cliches but also exemplifies what they do best? Do you feel smart reading this? Call me Pixar, I hope I’ve passed the audition.
Nothing on Short People.
The most interesting thing about this album is the lyrics, which cover a broad range of subjects like the slave trade, U.S. foreign policy and religion. Newman sings the songs with a semi-spoken delivery in his usual sweetly sardonic voice and the brass and strings sound like a Broadway musical. It's fascinating stuff but it's appeal is limited.
This album should be called 'so you want to make a 80s film montage'? Tracks such as: Old home town Goofy love Melancholy Big love, Nuclear holocaust!
Why? I don't get it
Family Guy has ruined Randy Newman for me forever. It's so very twee and idiosyncratic.
How on earth are there 2 Randy Newman albums on the 1001 list? The mind boggles, it's a parody of itself! "Randy Newman, sits there all night and days singing about what he sees."
Not as consistent as Good Old Boys, his follow-up to this, but Newman still sounds great across this album. The first couple of songs in particular are fantastic, and his voice and mannerisms are always fun but the songwriting does drop off a bit and it becomes less interesting later on
Bros yapping
Randy Newman definitely has his own unique sound, I’ll give him that much. Still, every song just sounds like it is something off of a Disney movie soundtrack.
Lonely at the top Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear You Can Leave Your Hat On God’s Song Let It Shine Dayton, Ohio I thought his voice sounded familiar. I find something so soothing and comfortable about his voice I could listen to it for hours. Great album very chill
Just not feeling it, he should just sail away
Well put together album. If I didn’t think of Toy Story the whole time I’d probably love it more.
Great artist, great voice, loved the pace
I’m surprised by how much I like this
Easy listening
This was really great. My first introduction to Randy Newman was the song ”Burn On” which appeared at the beginning of the movie Major League. I grew up in Cleveland and I love baseball, so I’ve always had a fondness for that track. But the more I heard Newman’s music, the more I really got what he was about. There’s really nobody else like him - maybe Tom Waits shares some of that same type of storytelling DNA. But it’s clear from this album why RN is distinct and revered.
I think i won't hate this so much. It's alright. not my favorite of his. 3 stars maybe.
loved it!
no puedo escucharlo literal son como canciones d pixar
It's hard to take this guy seriously, perhaps because his music has been parodied so much over the years. I quite frankly did not enjoy this album much.
I love LA! But not this album. Go listen to Joe Cocker's version of you can leave your hat on and you'll be a whole lot happier.
What a weirdo recording. Not a fan.
Toy story jo
No sabía que You Can Leave Your Hat On era de Randy Newman, y que su versión original fuera tan soft.
I’m not sure who this is for, but it ain’t me.
His voice is something. Usually a cool choice, sometimes just weird. A little heavy on the boogie woogie adjacent backing, but diverse lyrics, from horny, to smartass political to smart ass antireligous, to ironically? religious lyrics. Don't wanna hurt no kangaroo!
Love this man, love his melodic charm, his soulful lyrics and the way he shows his heart whilst still having fun. Underrated
I had a feeling that I wouldn't enjoy listening to Randy Newman, and I really wasn't wrong. Yikes! Possibly the most nasal vocals I've ever heard. Drab songs that I guess could be called observations if I were being very kind. Dull enough for 2 stars, but not quite bad enough for 1 star.
4.0
This dudes voice is like listening to that special guy in the street who seems to know everyone. It’s absurd that people enjoy this.
Newman is a scathing lyricist, though he does it in such a way that you wouldn't know it if you weren't paying attention. His traditional pop stylings on the piano make for a memorable backdrop to his commentary on American exceptionalism. Wrapped up with a wink and a smile, Newman knows how to entertain while also providing inspired social commentary. Few writers are as good as him.
Exceptionally dull, but not actively bad
Pretty uninteresting. Music for hokey movies.
I like the one where he sings sweetly about nuking the world.
Another artist with good lyrics, his own sound, and great skill. But not that appealing to me overall.
No. 189/1001 Sail Away 3/5 Lonely at the Top 2/5 He Gives Us All His Love 3/5 Last Night I Had A Dream 3/5 Simon Smith 2/5 Old Man 3/5 Political Science 3/5 Burn On 2/5 Memo to My Son 3/5 Dayton, Ohio 3/5 You Can Leave Your Hat On 3/5 God's Song 2/5 Average: 2,67 Nothing really remarkable. Didn't like his voice that much.
Chill album to listen to Standout songs: Lonely at the Top Last night I had a dream Political Science
At least it's economical and gets to the point. But I don't care for his voice and his whimsical takes don't resonate with me.
Boring
I know it’s more than Toy Story but it’s all I can see!
Awful. Polished, disney music
it's okay.
+1 because I feel like I’ve heard every single one of these songs before in another place. It’s hard to picture this now as NOT being a movie soundtrack. I think that points to his music being readily available in the cultural zeitgeist. -1 Also this is just SO AMERICAN. Is that a bad thing? I don’t know. 🤷🏼♀️ +1 it does tell a story with ups and downs which I appreciate in a good album.
2/5
Another interesting little listen from Randy. I mostly enjoyed the lush production on some tracks and the satirical songwriting (Burn On, God's Song, Political Science). A few songs really don't amount to much outside their title which leaves something to be desired. 6/10
Fabulous
I had a previous Randy Newman album that kind of rubbed me the wrong way - felt like a cabaret Elvis Costello - so I was reticent when this came up - but this is a hooter of an album - clever witty fun - with my favourite song of the month Political Science firmly setting the scene. Loved it.
The “She's So Crazzzzzzzy, Love Her” meme, but in reference to your quirky Dad who tucks his t-shirts into his jorts, makes an exhausting number of puns, has a big love for a mid-tier game show like Deal or No Deal or Wheel of Fortune, and is probably on the spectrum, but we’ll never know, because he doesn’t believe in “that millennial crybaby shit.”
Gear: DCA ÆON 2 Noire Artwork: ja, schon ganz cool Mix (2002 Remaster): ach von mir aus 🤷♂️ Musik: Diese Stimme. Ich kann einfach nicht. Ironischerweise bestimmt das Erste, was ich höre, wenn ich in der Hölle empfangen werde. Das motiviert mich genug, weiterhin auf mein Karma-Konto zu achten. Dieses Album macht mich also irgendwie zu einem besseren Menschen. Danke, Randy Newman! ☯️ Wertung: 🤢/5
i dunno singe songwriter, didnt care much, wasnt bad NNN
#223. This shit was goofy as hell. You'd have to be a very specific type of individual to enjoy this kind of thing, but unfortunately for Randy, I'm just a regular person and there's no way I could get into this. 2/5: wacky Song added to playlist: You Can Leave Your Hat On I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link
He's a talented songwriter, but a lot of the songs are almost like whimsical 'ditties" The only song above 3 stars was 'last night I had a dream' I'd put it on again, but more just as background music. 3 star
I went in fully thinking "haha funny toy story man" but no, this was a surprisingly engaging singer-songwriter album. It won't be a playlist boon, but I'll definitely be coming back to it when I'm in the mood. The opening title track is probably my favorite.
he's gotta be putting on that voice right? Buddy sounds like a cartoon character that just had an anvil fall on their head. Every time I would start to get into it, his voice would take me out.
I love Randy Newman but this was my first time listening to a full album. This was a great listen, highly recommend to anyone
2 - I don't remember much from listening this album. Maybe a 2 is a bit low, but oh well. Don't care enough to bump it up.
There's no question that he's a fabulous songwriter with a hugely impressive body of work but I can't help thinking he should stick to the one thing at which he truly excels because he's a mediocre singer at best & everything good on here has been performed far better by others
I don’t think I was listening close enough to get the nuance in his lyrics but I love his tonality and voice. Overall a good listen but doesn’t stand out to me.
As someone born in the early 90’s, it came as quite a surprise when I realized that Randy Newman had produced a lot of music before he ever wrote the score and original songs for Toy Story and the theme song to Monk. As far as I knew, that’s just what he did and was known for. But I’ve known for a long time now that he did have a career long before doing either of those projects. I just had never heard anything he had done besides them. Until now. I had no expectations going into this, except that it would be piano-heavy and it would sound like Randy Newman, with his very particular sounding voice. I wasn’t disappointed. This was actually quite good. He’s such a clever lyricist, and his composing and arranging skills are excellent. His lyrics are witty, insightful, and can be quite cutting. The latter of those qualities I didn’t expect from a man I’ve always associated with a song that celebrates everlasting friendship from a kids movie about talking toys. That said, some of these songs do have some schmaltz attached, but he still somehow makes them work and I don’t cringe. Some songs do carry that warm tone I expected but some can also dabble in satire (see: “God’s Song,” “Political Science”). And “Old Man”? Holy shit what a touching and horribly sad song. Beautiful and tragic. This was a great surprise of a listen, and a very welcome one. We all need some Randy Newman in our lives. 4 stars. Standout tracks: Sail Away, Lonely at the Top, Old Man, Political Science, Burn On, God’s Song (That’s Why I Love Mankind)
Although this is not the kind of music I listen to regularly, I enjoyed this album very much. Randy is a brilliant songwriter and his lyrics are a kind of multi-faceted. You can understand them one way or another, depending how well you can read between the lines.
When I was a kid I genuinely believed that Randy Newman was mentally challenged, because of the way he sang. He sounded just like the Down’s syndrome kid down the street. I have never been able to shake this impression of Newman. No matter how well written and composed his music might be, to me he will always be ‘that special needs guy’.
While it wasn't bad, it was too much Randy Newman.
Nicknames are for friends, and Randall Stuart Newman does not have a friend in me. Boring music, self indulgent lyrics about the struggle of being famous, and fantasies about living in rural early 1900s America are enough to put me off. I can't believe that this is the guy who did the soundstracks for multiple Pixar films, films I loved as a child and still do to this day. Childhood ruined.
I was bracing myself for it to be bad, but it was ok
I really just can’t get into Randy Newman. His piano playing is pleasant, but his voice is incredibly annoying. Even though he’s been a songwriter for other artists, I just really can’t see his talent the way that others do. He does tend to have solid humor in his work, but he’s much better suited for children’s music like Toy Story than adult-oriented rock.
After listening to two Paul Simon albums, I was convinced that my supposed hatred for singer-songwriter style music was completely unfounded. This broke me. I regret being optimistic.
Love his voice
Clearly an incredibly talented song writer and performer. Just not my thing.
the movie song voice.
Should have stuck to Toy Story. Like a poor man’s Tom Waits
Randy Newman has an unmatched soul to his voice
I was familiar with Randy Newman with his song from the movie Toy Story, but I had not heard anything from this album before. I would say this is a bit of an acquired taste. It's primarily Randy's singing and piano accompaniment, with more instrumentation filling in on certain songs. I like Lonely At The Top but the other songs pretty much leave me wanting more. Not sure I would come back to this one.
Pretty good, fun listen. Took me too long to realize it’s the dude that sang the Monk theme song.
Hell no. 1.66
some genuinely beautiful stuff in here
Favourite song - You can leave your hat on
This is an album that forces you to pay attention. It's a giant smile on the same face as eyes that tell you to fuck off. I need to check out his 2017 album Dark Matter to see if his satire and sarcasm bite as well for recent history.
This list might turn me into a Randy Newman fan. Quitevthebraconteur
Was pleasantly surprised by this one. Not in love with his voice, mainly because I associated it with Disney soundtracks, but it did start growing on me. The instrumentals and composition was wonderful throughout. 3.5/5
- all i can hear is you’ve got a friend in me
Randy Newman just sounds like such a goober - but in a good beloved way. Enjoyed the listen
Randy Newman is in a category of 1. I think his best songs are the ones where he says the quiet part out loud. Writing in the first person of a particularly kind of person singing their inner and intrusive thoughts.
This was delightful. I was a child when Toy Story came out and only new Randy Newman from that soundtrack. I always wondered how he could work as a popular musician. Turns out it's by writting short but involved pieces with biting satire. I don't know if this is the peak of his powers but Political Science and Simon Smith had me rolling. There's little I love more than someone smiling while they tell you to go f--- yourself.
Pixar’s fave wordsmith is at it again
A songwriting masterclass. On the surface, it feels bright and smiley but there's darkness and shadows everywhere. This is what I want from a 70s LA record.
If we had half stars this would be 3.5. This one really surprised me. He’s got a distinct style of writing that people might call simple, but man there are themes there. Last Night I Had a Dream I could squint and see Tom Waits. A few misses but lots of hits. Also - 22 academy award nominations for score writing and boy you can tell. Every song seems written like it’s a scene in a movie. Enjoyed this way more than I thought I would.
He's got nice songs I just can only hear toy story
Well, they say the world's your oyster Man, but oysters ain't for me You're the belle of the ball But you ain't my cup of tea They always vote you Best in Show But this doggie disagrees 'Cause I like life in Paddy's Pub... There's a place for me, it's the place I go Where the beer is cheap, and the lights are low It's Paddy's Pub I like Paddy's Pub Let the record show The greatest place to go Is that bar called Paddy's Pub... [Harmonica Solo] I like life in Paddy's Pub...
A bit slow for my taste, but the guy has a charm and an unmistakable voice that's easy to listen to.
I discovered Randy Newman in 1977, when “Sort People” was a hit. I wondered at the time how so many people could miss the point that it was a song that tore down prejudice. I picked up the album, and loved it. Then I picked up his previous album “Good Old Boys”, and really enjoyed it, also. New man’s lyrics are cutting, and cynical, and tend towards demonstrating absurd by being absurd, often not in an especially nice way (“Short People” and “Rednecks” are good examples). Anyway, on to Sail Away: I know (and own) 3 of the songs here, the title track, “…Hat On” and “Political Science”. All are brilliant. Musically, this has an old-time sound, pretty relaxed. Primarily piano and strings, sometimes lapsing into an almost New Orleans / slow-ragtime feel. I don’t know music theory, but the piano is captivating neat little melodies. It is all very concise, 12 songs in 30 minutes. Newman has a tendency to present these cynical, sarcastic observations on human life, then kick you in the gut with a crushingly sad song. “Old Man” is such a song, a song about dying alone (or almost alone). It is all wonderful but it is also music you need to pay attention to, to think about. Bottom line: 5/5, I’ll need to fill out my collection.
I kinda hate this Toy Story asshole.
When I was a kid I genuinely believed that Randy Newman was mentally challenged, because of the way he sang. He sounded just like the Down’s syndrome kid down the street. I have never been able to shake this impression of Newman. No matter how well written and composed his music might be, to me he will always be ‘that special needs guy’.
No.
Have never been able to get into Randy Newman. All his songs sound exactly the same to me.
Sólo por el tema inicial, que da título al disco, "Sail Away" ya merece la pena. Una sarcástica canción, evocadora en lo musical, que como si fuera un canto de sirena que quisiera atraer a los navegantes/africanos mira con sarcasmo hacia el pasado exclavista norteamericano. En su ecléctico estilo, Newman regala potentes canciones de rock a medio tiempo, como "Last Night I Had a Dream" (con Ry Cooder a la guitarra slide) y la sensual "You Can Leave Your Hat On", que más tarde Joe Cocker, y una película, convertirían en éxito mundial. Pero sobre todo en "Sail Away" Randy Newman sigue entregando canciones pop acompañadas de una cuidada orquestación en las que lo mismo reflexiona con cinismo sobre los peligros de la fama inalcanzada y siempre perseguida ("Lonely at the Top"), que ofrece una amplia y divertida sátira política ("Political Science") o una de las más amargas canciones contra la religión ("God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind)").
clever man.
Very meh... One number everyone knows, a few good ones, a lot of forgettable ones...
This was nice and chill. I think I need to give it another listen
I can guarantee almost everybody has heard Randy Newman at one point in their life, whether they realized it or not. Even I was surprised to learn he was the guy behind You’ve Got a Friend in Me. But at the same time, I feel like I knew that at one point and just forgot. But it’s cool to see him included on this list, because I wasn’t aware of any of the actual music he made. In the span of about 20 years, he went from a regular songwriter and composer to the mind behind the scores of some of Disney’s most massively successful animated movies, and then some. It’s pretty impressive. But really, if you listen to his most popular work, the sound you hear on those isn’t too far off from what this sounds like. Just lots of soft jazz influenced pieces of orchestrated piano rock. Where this album excels at the best is either when it is at its most involved, and there are more parts playing at the same time. Or when it is the most stripped back. Often times this is just Randy playing the piano and singing. And this combination is really lovely. Randy’s got a great voice. Explains why that Toy Story song has remained such a nostalgic classic for so many after all this time. I don’t really know what this album is essential to, if anything at all. But it’s a decent time, and rather short, so there isn’t a ton for me to complain about. Rating: 6/10
It’s hard to not think of Randy Newman as that Toy Story fella. I did hear one other song by him a few years ago called Short People, which I found very witty as well as catchy. I’m optimistic about today’s album. Let’s listen! Songs I already knew: none Favourites: Political Science, God’s Song There is something very unique about how Randy Newman plays the piano. It’s almost a little saloon-style, like a modern day Scott Joplin. His vocal style is also very unique, and the lyrics are as witty as we have come to expect. I wouldn’t say that any songs blew me away here, but I did enjoy everything I heard. Certainly, nothing sounds bad.
Great songwriter.
I actually like this a lot surprisingly. Love the melodrama and newman's tonality. 4 stars
Motr nonsense . Couldn’t stop thinking about Toy Story.
Kinda underwhelming. His voice got annoying
Lyricist supreme and it’s all here: funny, ironic, acerbic and playful. Ry Cooder, too. Superb.
Randy Newman produced an album called 'Sonny and Brownie' by two veteran blues men, Sonny Terry and Brownie McGee. The album is a masterpiece and not on this list. Their version of Sail Away is definitive and devastating. Listen to it now. This album is good, his voice is limited, but it's about the lyrics and music. Old Man is a horror. Political Science seems like a good idea. 3.5*
Randy Newman writes those ditties that he writes with a distintive style. This is an early glimpse into what's coming later in his career (even before "Short People"!)
Randy Newman's music has kind of made me hate Randy Newman. I always thought for the most part he just did the nice songs for the Toy Story movies but my god his non-soundtrack music is insufferable. Only reason this is getting 2 stars is because it's not completely unlistenable. Plus I gave his racist "concept" album 2 stars, and this definitely wasn't worse than that (though not much better).
Great songwriting
hmmm... surprisingly boring
Songs blend into each other. I don't mind them but didn't set my world on fire and not sure I quite tuned into Randy's voice well enough to capture the depth of the lyrics
Third album was the charm for Randy Newman, who really gets it right here. Great slice of life vignettes that sound as though they were written 50 years earlier, sung in Newman’s plaintive dry voice, accompanied by himself on piano or often brass band arrangements. This is Americana before there was such a thing.
Randy Newman just isn't the same when it isn't Toy Story
2.9/5 Best Track: Dayton, Ohio - 1903
I don’t know how any it through an album of someone singing in that voice
No sabía que You Can Leave Your Hat On era de Randy Newman, y que su versión original fuera tan soft.
Listened Before? N Simply great! Literally. Simple and easy to listen to. His voice is soothing. I'm familiar with his soundtrack work, of course, but this early recording sounds nearly identical to much of his modern stuff. I loved this. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: Burn On
These days, I do appreciate the number of people who just misinterpret Randy Newman so much (no concept of satire). I want to like more of his songs, but his older stuff (this album) makes him sound nasty to the point of misanthropy. Then, when he tries to sound sincere, it’s impossible to believe it.
Can’t stand Randy Newman. He’s ruined most of Pixar.
I like sad songs but this was a hard pass
Toy story singer was pretty good but not my type
I just can't get past my distain for Newman's singing voice
1/5!
Don't let the camp of Randy get in the way of this album. The emotions are there. This is a better listen looking out the window with a drink. Technically 3.5 stars.
Great story teller through song.
Great compositions
Jeez. I understand why Pixar hired him. Even writing solo, every song feels like a villain introduction. Incredible.
So soish
Never listened to an album by Randy Newman before, although I of course (who does not?) knew a few of his songs. Guess this is one of oh so many nice albums out there, which I think are ok, maybe even good, but which I will never search out for listening.
good instrumentals
It's actually not that bad but every single song is the same and the racist album was general better outside it being so racist.
listened to again hard not to love this guy and his funny little sentimental songs but then again i grew up on toy story
No sabía que You Can Leave Your Hat On era de Randy Newman, y que su versión original fuera tan soft.
Dayton, Ohio
This was fine
Not for me
Having trouble understanding why this is on here when it’s basically just a not-as-good version of Good Old Boys which is also on this list. All the potentially good things about Randy Newman songs (biting lyrics about America of the past and present, beautiful instrumentation, saying the title of the song in one line and repeating it in the next line, etc.) are done better on the other album.
Kinda boring at best. Maybe I would appreciate it more if I was a God-fearing American
As a God fearing American, this was pretty g— Just kidding, this was boring and weirdly religious. Uncle Randy with the increasingly common L
Oh no not this MF again. Here we go toy storying again. I don’t like this guy, i gave his last album a two and i will give this one a 1. please stop putting this guy in front of me. my patience are starting to run thin
No jaa. Lempeän ja samettisen kuuloista, ihan kutsuvaakin. Jää kuitenkin yllättävän laimeaksi. Kai kaipaisin vähän lisää rockia, tosin miksi sitä olisi tänne tungettu.
Hahmoilla olisi enemmänkin sanottavaa kuin jaksan kuunnella. Musiikillisesti osaan nykyään samaistua New Orleans/Dixieland-rakenteisiin, joten homma toimii.
Randy Newman just casually gets it.
Nice and compact album, extremely American, but with an original vocal by Randy Newman. It wasn't as boring as I would have thought, but ultimately I will forget everything about this record in few hours. Pretty nicely spent time though.
Mjög fín!!
Toy story guy is legit! 👏
Zoals Randy Newman betaamt, parels en keutels samen op één plaat. Maar wat een parels!
Classic singer songwriter- 2 excellent songs you will recognize and the rest are easy to listen.
disney
Holy WOW it is incredible how similar his sound from 1971 sounds to his Disney-Pixar soundtrack work. His voice is like a warm hug! Wholesome and even silly at times isn't really my bag, but how can you resist this guy! Favorite tracks: Sail Away, God's Song
Maybe it's because I grew up with the children's movies he sung on but I just can't take this seriously. When I picture the scenarios he is singing about I see Woody and other characters from Toy Story.
I didn't expect to like this album. I thought it would be twee and corny but it has depth. I mean, wade through a few 80s/90s electronica records and you'll give extra points to any album just for using actual instruments, but I wasn't expecting to shed a little tear on the bus to work
I wasn’t sure what to expect with this album but I’ve been pleasantly surprised. I like the subversive lyrics, the piano music, and yes, even the scratchy voice. I'm giving it a 3 but make that a high 3.
Headline: This album is mid. Nothing about this album was necessarily bad about the album aside from the fact that it was insanely boring. I had a hard time being able to follow it. It lacked originality throughout the project as many of the songs just sounded the same. I really like Randy Newman and don't associate him solely with his work with Disney, although that is an important factor. This album just wasn't it though. Again, this wasn't a bad project, it was just not great.
Коллекция саркастичных, колких песен об Америке, боге, детях и голых женщинах. Музыкально совсем не впечатляюще, но истории интересные. Лучшая песня - Sail Away.
Not bad. Gets bland at times but deep lyrics.
I might have enjoyed this album more if I was not snowboarding. It was too slow for snowboarding
It's kind of funny to realize that Randy Newman already sounded both old and old-fashioned in the early 70's. That said, it's definitely not bad music, although the arrangements are a bit sparse for my taste. Fine for background listening.
Bang average
listened to the first 3 songs, not my thing so i tapped out
I can respect the musicianship, but I just cannot get into this vaudeville ragtime cabaret sound. Sounds like an old-timey film score. The satire's good but feels somewhat stale 50+ years later, and almost none of it meshes with the instrumentation. Meh.
Standouts- "Sail Away," "Lonely At The Top," "God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind," Lyrics/Vocals -2/5 (lyrics great, vocals not so much) Instrumentals- 4/5 Vibes- 3/5 Overall- 3/5 This album was weird, to put it simply. Randy Newman is often times associated with Disney, and truthfully I can see why he's made so many songs for Disney. His music just has that feeling to it. It was by no means a bad thing, but it does I feel detract from the album itself when you're constantly thinking of Toy Story while listening to this album. The album felt humorous in many ways and I could sense some satire in some of the songs on it, but if you can't get past the "Disney vibes" then this will be lost on you. I think overall this album was okay. It was fun, but I wouldn't consider it one of the best albums of all time.
Wasn't impressed.
good
I think he was very lucky to have had a song chosen for the Toy Story film. I think his voice and style is so distinctive as to render it dull. Also special mention to least sexy version of “You Can Leave Your Hat On”. No, just no.
Beautiful songwriting and arrangements. WEIRD songs. Very good.
Songs of hope, "Burn On" nicely satirical, a pretty good album.
Still not really into Randy. But this one was more of a 2.5 for me so I'll be generous and round up
Eh
So if you can get past hearing a Disney song in most of the songs the album is not bad. If I had heard the album before Monk and Disney I think I would have enjoyed it more. Every artist has a music and singing style but with Randy Newman and how popular and overplayed his more recent songs have been it’s really hard to get past it.
Sponsored by Disney
1. zail auuay - 1 2. lonely at the top - 0 3. he givez uz all hiz love - 0 4. lazt night - 0 5. zimon zmith - 1 6. old man - 1 7. political zcience - 0 8. burn on - 0 9. memo to my zon - 0 10. dayton ohio - 1 11. you can leave your hat on - 1 12. godz zong - 0 13 let it zhine - 0 14. maybe im doing it uurong - 0
It's brilliant lyrically but a bit boring musically. C'est tout.
Not for me
This is Randy Newman in his prime.
Randy Newman has a very recognisable sound, which isn't a bad thing, but that does mean that every time I hear Newman I instantly think of toy story 😅
Newman is a very clever songwriter, so perhaps the fact that I was unable to offer this album my undivided attention during this listen (and as a result, assuredly missed several witty lyrics) led to my apathy. But this sort of went in one ear and out the other. Newman has never been a favorite of mine; his singing style just isn't for me. His arrangements are typically very strong, though, and what I heard here was well-crafted, but borderline dreary. I won't go so far as to say I disliked this (mercifully short) listen, but I'm not sure it'll stick with me.
4.5/10 Highlights: Political Science
3.5
One of the most interesting musicians of the past 60 years who will now forever be most known for the least interesting part of his artistic output. You just can’t sing along to a lot of his songs depending on who the particular narrator is.
Enjoyable, listenable and a good gateway into more Newman. Added.
idk if ill finish this but sail away- yeah ummm classic randy. 4 ig lonely at the top- i like the horns. i like how hes sad. 7 he gives us all his love- oh is this about god or whatever. i thought it was gonna be about an absentee dad. dunno why. guess i should just make my own music. 3 or 4 boring last night i had a dream- the keys are nice. DREAM ON DREAM OONN. its ok 6 simon smith and the dancing bear- i like how he has a dancing bear. 5. itd be a four but he gets points for writing about a dancing bear old man- me. oh he got dementia. or hes dead. or dying. ok. 4 ig political science- its nice but its wack. i hate the way i talk. anyway. i like the music and i like blowing up london. sorry. 7 burn on- i like this. cleveland is the city of magic???? 5 or 6 memo to my son- i like him hating on his son. its kind of cute. 6 dayton ohio 1903- enough about ohio. 4 you can leave your hat on- boring 3 gods song- boring too sorry god. 3 let it shine- let it grow. i think i said that before. it basically is let it grow though omg. umm 2 or 3 maybe im doing it wrong- maybe. um yeah its whatever 3 or 4 dayton ohio- i dont wanna listen to this again dude. i still dont give a fuck. 3 for making me do it again you can leave your hat on- i dont careeee sail away-ebvwnqdwlkvjbrkhjo its kind of hit or miss but it really starts to overstay its welcome favorite track: lonely at the top
maybe i just have a deep affection for newman's voice because of disney. but pretty good
It's an OK album with a clear highlight on "You Can Leave Your Hat On." Forgettable, but I'm unsure if the album's objective was more than that.
Signer songwriter, solide kompositioner, hyggeligt
Das ist nicht so meins. Die Instrumentierung ist gewöhnungsbedürftig.
It’s alright. Not really a fan of Randy Newman, but the album wasn’t bad.
Woody from Toy Story singing 'You Can Leave Your Hat On' was not on my bingo card.
So apparently the guy who wrote 'You've Got a Friend in Me' also wrote and sang 'You Can Leave Your Hat On'. The more you know!
Had Sail Away gone on for a song or two more, I’d have lowered the rating. Clever move by Newman keeping this at just half an hour. He’s a good songwriter but I’m never fully invested in the album whatsoever. But who can resist the warm fuzzy embrace of Newman’s cozy vocals.
Never heard this album before, but I generally have a soft spot for Randy Newman, particularly the super ironic "Short People". He's a skilled musician and writes intelligent witty lyrics. I enjoyed listening to this record.
Sounds like childhood songs like you story and shit. I liked it:)) didn't give it as much attention as I should have tho
nice :)
these tracks are like one-sided chats that wander without much direction. his songwriting's clever, but it's hard to see its broader influence on music. and honestly, after 'you've got a friend in me', it's tough to take his voice seriously. it's got that New Orleans R&B touch, but overall, it feels more like background music for a film than a gripping album. respect his talent, but it's just not doing it for me. singer-songwriters need to something special for it to click with me as a genre, and randy certainly does not. only bumped up to a 2 because 'you can leave your hat on' is slightly nostalgic to me due to it's fame.
Randy Newman's songs are the music equivalent of a cartoon in the New Yorker. A slight sketch with political or social commentary that makes you go "hmm." They're all witty but sometimes they lack a fully fleshed out feel. Enjoyable but not fully satisfying in my opinion. Some topics he covered are probably a little poor in taste for a white man to sing about.
Burn On is a classic from the Major League Soundtrack. Many classic standards
Randy Newman was born to be a satirist. I mean, his name sounds like a parody of American names; ‘Hi, I’m Randy Newman, I went over to the new world to become a New Man and because I’m horny as fuck.’ But satire is draining. There are always gonna be people who don’t get it, or people who get it but think you’ve gone too far, or who get it and don’t think you’ve gone far enough. For the record, I think he gets it pretty much perfect. The irony is always there, enough to make you ask enough questions to be truly subversive, but with enough leeway to lull people into a sense of security, ‘No, man. I’m just singing about how great America is.’ In my eyes, Randy Newman’s great problem is also his second greatest gift, which is his mastery of melody. His melodies and arrangements are consistently beautiful and lush enough to draw people away from the lyrics, which are his great selling point. To a certain sort of politics or writing nerd, this stuff is top notch. I am no exception, I think he’s one of the greatest lyricists of the 20th century. Sail Away is probably the best Randy Newman album, because it typifies what his early sound was. The jaunty piano, orchestral arrangements, well constructed melody, musical lightness, and lyrical bleakness. But perhaps because of that culmination sense, I think it’s also the one I come back to least. It’s still great, but I love the rawer 12 songs and more character driven and darker Good Old Boys more
Fun little album that somehow had me thinking about Toy Story the whole time.
He has an interesting style. Includes a couple songs I didn't know he wrote!
did not like. too mellow. maybe wasnt in the mood
At first I thought “ugh, why isn’t this just You’ve Got a Friend in Me” but by the end I enjoyed it more than I thought I was going to.
Cayahoga River slaps.
Esto está aquí sólo porque esta puta lista está centrada en esa cosa etérea e inabarcable que es la cultura norteamericana. Nadie sabe describirla, pero al escuchar este disco sabes que esto es algo que solo le podría gustar a esa gente y a nadie más.
Unremarkable elevator music, with a voice familiar from anyone with kids in the Toy Story era.
big differences. some songs are great! most are not...
A Classic one more than a great great album
Surprisingly fun album, I really liked the humour and satire throughout.
Ok. I couldn’t get the Toy Story song to go away though so this colored things
Randy Newman is an inimitable genius. There's a few tracks on here that I don't particularly like, but the strong ones are superb.
I don't really like Randy Newman's style.
I started off enjoying it but eventually thought his voice sounded goofy. He seems like a nice guy though.
Great bluesy stuff
Cool album! Sounds a lot like the Toy Story soundtrack throughout.
Don't like it. This man and this style have simply been eternally connected with Disney movies. Even though there might reside some quality in there, the whole album doesn't really catch my interest. It all sounds the same, boring, cartoonish, and goofy. Don't really understand why this man is on the list to begin with. I find his voice also pretty annoying. Like don't get me wrong, nothing bad with returning to your childhood, but this just isn't the way for me. Couldn't listen more than once. 3/10
This is disturbingly religious in places, and that's not OK. His voice is annoying. His songwriting is grand. Tom Jones did a better version of "you can leave your hat on".
I really don't like his style. His song writing in pretty formulaic. I'm not a fan of his singing voice. And his lyrics pretty much come across exactly like they made it out on Family Guy. I feel like he Rafi for adults.
It feels like he would be in a random park making up these songs while watching strangers or picking out random autobiographies at the library. It felt comforting like a weighted blanket.
How has someone who has written lyrics for over 50 years still write some of the worst lyrics I've ever heard?
I assume a lot of people will have issues with Randy Newman, but I've never been one to. I like his tongue-in-cheek songwriting, especially here, though I do find "You Can Leave Your Hat On" weird, even from his character-sketch perspective. Favorite tracks: "Dayton, Ohio 1903", "Memo To My Son", "Political Science"
Best lekker wel G. De man van Toy Story hatsaaa. Toch wel weer drie sterren want het is niet speciaal, maar ook niet slecht
Wel prima
There's more in here that I liked than I anticipated, but singer songwriter albums just really do not do much for me at all. There are some really nice jazzy vibes that reeled me in though. Favorite track: Let It Shine
Not very many necessarily bad songs, but every one sounded the same
As a massive Toy Story fan I surprisingly never delved into Newman's music outside of his film scores. This is a nice set of simple, satirical, and clever songs.
I never thought I'd ever listen to two different Randy Newman albums, but here we are. Can't imagine I'll ever be going back to this, but it's fine just like the other one.
Familiar with most of the songs, never listened to as an album before. Nice stuff. The single version of Last Night I Had a Dream is a killer. music: appreciated. (⌐□ ̮ □)
Definitely didn’t expect to love a Randy Newman record as much as I did this one. Political Science especially good.
Listened Before? No Album Art: 3 / 5 (Oddly oriented profile in purple. No love, no hate) Along with Dylan and Cohen, Randy Newman is one of those incredible talents who succeeds as a vocal artist in spite of his voice. He is an amazing lyrical storyteller who writes undeniably catchy hooks and even sweeter melodies to accompany them. I haven't listened to any of his professional solo work, but I have come to appreciate his range through the many Disney / Pixar soundtracks that the kids are constantly listening to. Lonely at the Top is a surprisingly cool track. Interesting instrumental choices that give it a wholly folksy vibe, but it works so well. Last Night I Had Dream takes a hard left turn at the minute mark. Starts almost bluesy / jazzy and while it retains that core vibe, it drops into a show-tuney piano blitz. Burn On is backed by a horror movie-esq dissonant piano that gives over to a woodwind section doing the same. This is a tough one to give a proper score to. Beautiful compositions with immaculate production, and I found the album to be pretty enjoyable start to finish. That said, I feel nothing compelling me to come back for a return visit. It makes sense listening here that Newman has become such a staple for soundtracks -- many of the compositions are layered and have show-tuney aspects to them. This isn't to say that the songs shouldn't be taken seriously; there are some great lyrics in here. God's Song is a high point of the album as is Burn On. All said, I would give this an objective 4 / 5 on musical quality. On personal enjoyment this falls around a 3. Added to Library? No Songs Added to Playlists: - God's Song (Rainy / Tired)
Good whimsical album with an iconic voice. This is just a happy album that I could definitely see popping on during a weekend morning. Probably a 3.5, but I'll round up.
His voice is just so funny to me that it is tough not to laugh during the songs. But musically wise I do like the style. This was also short and sweet at a cool 30 minutes.
Wow I gotta say I did not expect to like this as much as I did. Really thought his goofy voice was going to ruin it for me. He has a sort of sadness/melancholy to his singing and background of songs. Really kinda hit. I listened to a bunch Toy Story songs afterwards too. Pixar really nailed it getting him for their songs.