Sail Away by Randy Newman

Sail Away

Randy Newman

2.96
Rating
23584
Votes
1
7%
2
24%
3
41%
4
21%
5
7%
Distribution

Reviews (page 5 of 8)

I never been able to figure out if Randy Newman is a crazy, slightly racist, corny sentimentalist for an America that never existed or a satirical genius. I liked, “You Can Leave Your Hat On,” but the rest of the album did nothing to help me solve the riddle of Newman.

I love Newman’s voice, whether he is being sincere or sarcastic. This one is really easy to listen to.

I think I like Randy Newman.

Sorry Randy you’ll always be the goofy Toy Story guy to me (2.5/5)

Wow, the tonal dissonance on this album is something else. I knew that Randy Newman had a thing for mawkish tearjerkers on film soundtracks, but I really wasn’t expecting the opening track on this to be about the slave trade. Yikes. We then crash zoom into a cabaret style song about a jaded and debauched star, followed by a supernatural number and then one about a dancing bear. Wait, what? We also get a cheery number about starting a nuclear war for the fun of it.

I probably don't care enough about the lyrics (that the perks of not being a native speaker) to love or hate this. It's mildly interesting, I wasn't blown away by it. I guess it belongs to this list because of the original version of You can leave your hat on? anyway.

I can't pinpoint exactly why I hate this, but I do.

Een man met een piano en soms wat strijkers op de achtergrond. Leuk voor een liedje, maar een heel album gaat wel snel vervelen. Het blijft ook een beetje in hetzelfde ritme hangen. Weinig variatie. **

This was ok, nothing really stood out. Kept wanting to hear You've Got a Friend in Me, but it wasn't on this album. 3/5

Ну ок, поёт мужик. Бывает и лучше

Really impressive when Randy has a whole band behind him driving the song - very reminiscent of the best songs from 'The Band' - bluesy, groovy and broody. His solo piano songs are OK, though for me feels like the prototype Tom Waits model before Tom Waits appeared. Best Tracks: - Last Night I Had A Dream - Drayton, Ohio - You Can Leave Your Hat On Worst Tracks: - Sail Away Rating: 6.5/10

6/10 A little different, I liked it well enough 5-7-2025

Stunning album. Most soulful white voice ever, and beautiful arrangements. Tracks subtle and charming. Can see why he does soundtracks. Fave tracks: Sail away, political science, burn on

no strong feelings about this one way or the other; in one ear and out the other

Really good resource to have on hand in case of serious insomnia.

Having heard the other Ramdy album, there is no need for this one too

How in the fuck are there two Randy Newman albums on this list? Nothing like listening to a dude who sounds drunk and thinks he’s witty play safe, old timey music.

One cannot underestimate just how awful and terrible this album was. This was my first do not finish and I think I skipped half of the songs I did listen to. american (insult) 0/5 stars. gross.

Ehh, not my thing. Don't love the singing style and the backing instrumentals are pretty boring. I think militant atheism doesn't quite work great when it's combined with music this normal and homely

Way cooler than I was expecting. It's the Toy Story guy with the goofy voice, but the songs are sharp and engaging af. Adding to the list.

Pretty good for chillout

Jeg er ikke den største Randy Newman fan, jeg kan ikke lide hans stemme, men det var en ok positiv overraskelse! Lyder som Elton John en smule

Elsker hans stemme og det lød godt, blev aldrig helt revet med men tror godt jeg kunne blive det efter et par lytninger

His voice was hard to swallow through an entire album.. 2+

Weird, whiny orchestral Pop, which only might be bearably at a dive bar, or lounge, complete with spirits and smokes.

First song his voice sounded retarded. Second song better but why listen to this when tom waits exists? Ended up being not great. Some interesting songs, overall probably a 1.5.

Toy Story guy, lyrics are kinda corny (especially on title track), yeah no I don’t like it

One of the most distinct voices. Quite simple piano songs. Many very short. Sweet and pleasant. The magic is in the lyrics, quite sarcastic for the sound.

smart, sharp, sarcastic - full of bite, full of great tunes

I was surprised at how much I liked this album.

Multiple albums from Randy Newman does not seem necessary

I tried, not my jam.

Ironic, fun. I liked 'Last night I had a dream' and 'Political science'

I get storytelling in songs, but the stories here didn't really draw me in, and I didn't 'feel' Randy as an enigmatic performer. This one washed over me without making any great impression.

I'm really unsure about this album. I want to hail it a masterpiece, but I'm not sure that it is. I want to downplay it as background music, but it's clearly far more than that. I think the lack of genre makes it a tough call to describe. I'll settle on superb songs, sung by a poor man's Bob Dylan.

Hate it, just reminds me of Toy Story

Easy listening. But brilliantly scathing and intelligent writer.

Cool songwriter and a great album to listen but do read the lyrics

Very sweet, particularly Old Man. Love the jazzy nature of Lonely at the Top and Last Night I Had a Dream - the latter reminded me of Hadestown. Love the piano riff on Memo To My Son. A Bob Dylan feel to both his voice and the music itself. God's Song is very Hadestown too.

It's not as good as the other album I had by him. This one feels way more earnest and twee, "root-de-doo, I'm Andy Newman" than his other one. That said there's a few nice tracks in here. 2.5 rounded up.

4/17/2025: Music isn't bad, but I can't get over his voice.

Really good album, what a really cool voice, it brings a really nice and jazzy atmosphere. I particularly appreciated "Last Night I Had A Dream" and "Dayton, Ohio - 1903".

Beautiful opener He gives us all his love - Beautiful!! Having a good time!!! Let it shine - Super nostalgic pokémon diamond/pearl nostalgy to it!

Sounds like Toy Story years before he did Toy Story.

this wasn’t enough to make me get over my issues with Randy Newman…. close, but no

Randall telling me that all Americans are happy and then about how lonely it is at the top feels politically insensitive right now.

I like the storytelling. He has a comforting voice. 3

Everyone needs more Randy Newman in their life

Maybe it's the times we're in but I did not enjoy such an aggressively American album.

I like Randy Newman music in movies, ‘You’ve Got a Friend’ for example is a true classic but listening to an album of his music is pretty repetitive.

Randy is the John Prine of piano jazz standards, with his penchant for irony and blunt storytelling. It’s hard to divorce the man from his Pixar scores though, and while there’s some great songs here a lot of it is really muddled in between. I get adding it here but Randy might just be a greatest hits guy for me.

Toy Story Ass Music

A little too close to sounding like Live Laugh Love populism but it sounds good enough for the most part.

I don’t know. I honestly think Newman’s lyrics are great. But I veer wildly as to whether I’m enjoying a song or not. So I’m either all in or all out. Too much whiplash for me. 2.5/5

Randy should not just be associated with Toy Story

I played this album of nice well-crafted songs a couple of times, but really didn't think it a *great* album. It's just not my thing.

Read some reviews, one said "too many singer songwriters, not enough Coltrane" which I agree with. Came at this neutral, the point of this for me is exploring outside usual zones, and it's pretty good.

There goes Randy Newman again singn' 'bout what he sees...and I have no qualms about this

At some point in life Mr. Lin-Manual Miranda must have gain many inspiration in Newman's sing, which obviously...didn't end well. Still, they did sound similar! Come on, don't deny it! It's so distracting I'm not even listening to.the music sometimes. Sorry, but a 2.5/5 is all I have in hand. Old Broadway tunes.

Another banger in a row.

If you could take a New Yorker cartoon and turn it into music, it would be this.

3.5* 85%

Bien senti, dépouillé, dans la tradition des chansonniers qui racontent des histoires

To be honest, it took me a while to get that these songs were satirical. Poe’s law and all that. In my defence, the idea that America is the land of the free and that slavery was actually doing the slaves a favour is the type of shit that a lot of Americans are actually stupid enough to believe. On Newman, I don’t think I’ve ever listened to his music other than the Toy Story theme, so wasnt’t sure what to expect. He’s clearly a good song writer, but I generally prefer the covers of his music to his own performances.

Was nice and quick but they all sounded the same

I’m always feeling a little randy to be honest. Sail Away was a highlight, Political Science was great. Just enjoyed the whole thing.

Well written and composed. love when music is very harmonically functional, but still adds a bit of spice. But it don't really stand out to me. it's nice to listen to in the background.

I really tried but every song just made me think of toy story and I couldn’t get past it.

God level.

diese stimme, wirklich spannend randy newman zuzuhören. aber auch sehr geeignet für den hintergrund.

Besser als gedacht, mit netten Songs. Und wusste nicht, dass er hinter so vielen anderen Lieder als Komponist steht

I want to like Randy. His lyrics are pretty clever and funny. However, it just doesn't do it for me. The music style and his voice just don't resonate with me.

Randy Newman is like an iron fist in a velvet glove. Underneath all that chirpy vaudeville tunefulness is a deep sadness about the world and nostalgia for how it might have been. He applies his wistful, emotional voice to slavery, the threat of nuclear war, religion and fame.

+1 star because imagined it was Eric Cartman singing <3

I quite like Randy Newman, it's the second of his albums I've had now. I can't fully get into him; I've engaged with about half the songs per collection I've heard so far, but the ones I have engaged with I genuinely enjoy. I wasn't a fan of You Can Leave Your Hat on, compared to the Joe Cocker version.

It's very good, but not my taste. Favorite song: Dayton Ohio 1903

Amazing. Lyrics usually go over my head so I’m lower on legends like Cohen etc but for some reason Newman’s always hit me hard. He tackles tough themes while providing a beautiful unique sound behind it. Rating: 4.7

5/5. Putting on a Randy Newman record no longer gives an air of ease. There is now always a sense of sarcasm and underlying meaning in each song and after listening to this album with that in mind, it's such a dark and pessimistic energy. And I love it. I don't know how to describe it but knowing there is some blunt energy behind simple lyrics, it feels like it is meant to go right over the head of those without reading comprehension. Yes, some lyrics are pretty obvious, and some songs also don't have a an extra deep meaning, but the album as a whole feels some much more intense. Every album I listen to is always a joy to listen to multiple times to gather all his intentions. Best Song: Sail Away, God's Song (That's Why I Love Mankind), Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear

Thoughtful (sometimes funny, sometimes biting) lyrics

Boring. Same song all over with diferent lyrics but mid at best.

Nice vibe across the album with a few stand-out tracks

I found this boring and uninteresting. Yes, it sounds like a Disney soundtrack, but for me, that doesn't justify it. Not for me.

Stick to the movies

with Nilsson is a great songwriter

It's like a mix of Bob Dylan and Tom Waits. I like it.

Solid album, such a unique voice. A couple songs like Burn On that really stood out but just a solid middle of the road album for me.

the very definition of middle of the road

It’s all familiar yet I don’t think I’ve ever heard it before.

Prolific song writer but most of his music is for movies. A good listen.

Cool. I wanted to listen to an album that made me feel like I was in a Pixar movie. Decent though

So confused by this album, talks about serious adult stuff but sounds like I’m at a children’s fair.

Really quite depressing

As with his other album on this list, I really don’t know what excactly to think of it. It’s okay, but also kind of boring, or at least a little “off”.

Oh, so this is where You Can Leave Your Hat On comes from, interesting. I liked the vibe. Listenable

You've got a friend in me was all I could think about

I still find his voice irritating there are are a few nice songs on here he is a good lyricist I added a couple to my playlist.

Mostly piano and voice with some orchestral backup and thought provoking lyrics. Lonely at the Top My favourite is God's Song (Why I Love Mankind) which is deviously dark

ja dit vond ik wel leuk! stonden meer bangers op dan gedacht

Like listening to a Pixar movie about Monk

Hilarious

In a nutshell: satirical Dr Seuss. Randy Newman is a little like Leonard Cohen - a fantastic songwriter with a horrible singing voice. But compared to Cohen somehow Randy's voice has barely aged between this album and recording the theme for Toy Story in 1995. In context of the 1970s, Sail Away is an evolution of orchestral pop. It's removed from the likes of Henri Mancini and Bobby Darin. Arranged beautifully, lyrically dark. The album is a smidge over 30 minutes. Randy's voice is what is stopping me from giving this album a higher rating. Overall: 4/10

Excellent. Great songs and lyrics. You kinda have to be into singer-songwriter stuff, but if you are, and if you can get into Newman’s voice, there’s no reason this is not a must-listen. Some of the lyrics really knocked my socks off. ML #90

Beautiful songs, funny songs, heartbreaking songs. Political Science more relevant than ever. Five stars.

It was a good listen. Catchy, introspective at times, and had good story telling.

I enjoy his voice, probably because it makes me think of toy story. Only lyrics that stood out was singing about America, and then multiple songs about Ohio.

Newman at his best. Before the jokes, Academy awards, etc. Pop songs hiding dark hilarious satirical messages. One of the best to ever do it. Sail away is so beautiful and feels even more devastating now. Last Night I Had A Dream is an amazing and disturbing song. I want to hear it in an A24 trailer. Love Randy.

I can’t say I love his voice but this album definitely kept me engaged over a weekend. Are Americans allowed to be this sarcastic?

This album was a biting satire that sent up American exceptionalism and even flirted with the absurd.

This is a Randy Newman album I didn’t know and felt more earnest than the others.

pleasant singer-songwriter

2.5 поради Sail Away ....Се друго е под просек :)

Very boring album except You Can Leave Your Hat On striptease song. 1.5/5

Sharp, witty and musically sophisticated album that blends social commentary with satirical storytelling.

RIP Ueck. I forgot Burn On was on this album. 5 stars for the tears. (And honestly it's a 4 star album without the nostalgia. Newman is a fantastic lyricist, whatever you think of his voice)

Never took much notice of Randy Newman but knew he was a good songwriter and responsible for a few notable MOR songs. Not forgetting his notoriety as a result of Toy Story. More popular in the US rather than here in the UK me thinks. This album is a good example of his talents. Not an album I hate and I think any self respecting music fan should have at least one RN albums in their library to touch all base’s. This album would qualify for that job if I ever come across it cheap. 2.9/5 23/2/25

so mid. every song uses the same formula. just lullaby melody piano intros followed by boring vocals. like for god’s sake can you do something interesting for once. at least it’s still bearable

Okay, it’s okay, it could be better and it could be worse

I can’t quite decide if I like this or not. I would probably have to give it another listen, but I don’t think it would be a top priority. I hear the wit in his lyrics, and the instrumentation is unique. But there were plenty of times where my mind wandered, and I just wasn’t that interested. Really a mixed bag.

You don't listen to Randy Newman for his voice; you listen to him for the atmosphere and the incredible satirical messages he conveys in his short songs. I know this album well, and even though it's over 50 years old, I now truly appreciate how timeless his message is.

omgg niin omaleimainen artisti.. artistilla on oma leima ymmärtää heti että oook. reino uusimies.. en tykännyt tästä kovinkaan paljon vähän ehkä kyllästyin tähän schtikkiin.. schtikki meni vähän nyt överiksi.. oot nii vitun pimee. mut ei se mitää. kaljaa suuhun kaljaa alas masuun litroja litroja. sitten tupakalle smuuh smuuh.. ääni kuuluu vaan smuuh smuuh kun imeskelee tupakantumppia.. tupakka jo kauan aikaa sitten palanut pois.. tumppia imeskellään. tupakantumppi grind kun maksaa liikaa prkl meni verottaa tupakkia. miksi tupakkia mentiin verottaa niin pirkuleesti nyt tupakantumppia nuollaan. sail away

This is a tough one. I was not in the best headspace for this at the moment. Sleepless nights glaze you over some. But I liked what I heard. I'm also born in 94 so toy story has told me I must like randy Newman more than anyone else. So I'll give it the benefit of the doubt. It's good. Also that song from the opening of major league is here too. And as a wisonsinite loosing our beloved Bob uecker it was a trip. I like this. But I need to re listen for sure.

The cynicism of Newman in this album is a strong suit. His horrible cartoonish singing with uplifting, happy sounds combined with the venom of his tongue scathing many sacred things; that's the magic here, and it's exactly why it's a wonderful record that says fuck you to Americana.

I was familiar with lots of his songs but never listened to an album before this. Loved it, Randy's music is one of kind. Lots of decent tracks and unique tracks.

Rly good

Hey, I know the Dancing Bear song from when Scooter and Fozzie performed it on The Muppet Show. And I prefer that version. I don't mind a Randy Newman song now and then, but a whole album of them wears out its welcome before it's over.

If you ever thought, “I wish every song on Sgt. Pepper was like ‘When I’m 64,’” this album is for you. It arises from the counter culture but in an old timey facade. You wonder if he’s serious or sarcastic or cynical, and it’s probably all three. Just don’t expect a transition over to “Lovely Rita,” because it isn’t coming.

I don't know much about Randy Newman apart from his big hits (Short People and I Love L.A.) and movie tunes. This album is exactly what I thought it would be, distinctly Randy Newman, and basically a soundtrack for every family drama from 1968 to 1985. It isn't bad music, it just isn't my cup of tea.

Ok I know now that Randy Newman is a movie composer among all other things. And yes this album sounds like a movie soundtrack. But in fact while listening to it I felt like I am watching a movie rather than just listening to movie soundtrack album that is just a supplement to some movie. Also loved this chill vibe.

This is not a great album but it is really funny because of how bad it is. He literally just observes things in his lyrics and it is so stupid. After listening to his other album on the list it made me dislike him and this album didn't do him any favors. Hopefully there are only 2 of these albums and I'll only hear him in Toy Story (WHERE RANDY BELONGS!).

It's like if Bob Dylan made the Toy Story soundtrack.... and was also kinda bad. Really boring most of the way through. I like his voice and songs like Sail Away and Political Science do enough to make me not absolutely hate this, but the rest of this is just a slog.

It is possible to be interesting musically and lyrically while making a political and societal statement. This album does not do that for me. His lyrics are clearly very sarcastic, but he bashes that sarcasm over your head with a comically oversized mallet. I liked Political Science.

2.5 i really didnt care too much about it

Randy is such an underrated artist. Like a nerdy Tom waits.

This album is just ok. I don’t think Randy Newman is really my jam. He has some songs that are pretty decent, but he’s a little too quirky for me I think. Even though some of his subject matter is actually quite serious, it still has kind of a corny, show tune-y vibe for me.

Nothing special, but refreshingly short. Somewhat ironic considering Mr Newman’s professed opinions on short things.

You've Got A Friend In Me mies. Vähän samantyylistä musiikkia, "orkesteripoppia". Ihan ok. Parhaat: Political Science, Dayton Ohio - 1903, Sail Away

Nice little collection of songs that showcase Newman’s knack for sarcastic Americana. Stand outs are the title track, Political Science, Dayton Ohio, You Can Leave Your Hat On (his version way better than Cocker’s cover), and of course the Major League classic “ode” to Cleveland, Burn On.

Cinematic production, but Newman's voice is too much to bear.

His piano skills are excellent, but his voice/singing style drives me nuts (in a bad way). Some songs are ridiculous, some have very poignant lyrics.

Political Science was a great tongue in cheek fun song about mass genocide and there's a couple others I enjoyed but on the whole....just put the Toy Story in the bag bro

Stick to Toy Story bub❗️

Handful of songs that are alright. Really not my thing

My husband dubbed this "Toy Story B Sides"

Nice little album, Always had a bit of a soft spot for Randy Newman, his songs are pop culture with all the various movie soundtracks he's done.

Nawet niezłe. Lepsze niż to ostatnie rendiego. 4/5

croonalong

Yawn. I couldn't even get through this one.

Randy Newman is een beetje hit-or-miss voor mij. Klinkt op sommige platen echt te veel als de Toy Story muziek. Dit album was m net niet voor mij.

Ole Randy. This one wasn’t as fun as the other one on the list but it still fun. More chill.

Only giving it a 3 and not a 2 because he’s the genius behind Toy Story, Monsters Inc, and Cars

pixar king, i think i am a randy newman fan now <3

randy newman is a bit of an enigmatic songwriter, his humble songs and his unique voice can make first-time listeners curious as to what he brings to the table. this album, while not his best i feel is generally solid for the most part. straightforward feelings about the world, mild critiques and satirical, nostalgic views on american culture, with the occasional religious nod as well. both his lyrics and his songwriting techniques seem to take great influence from gospel.

Outstanding songwriting

Still cannot escape the Toy Story connection - preferred it to the Good Old Boys - and would make this a solid 3.

Sail Away I think I preferred this to Good Old Boys, although I broadly feel the same; on some listens and with some songs it’s really engaging and with others it seems to pass me by. The comparisons with Nilsson are more apparent on this than Good Old Boys, and not that I need to prefer one to the other but I do find Nilsson’s version of vaudeville-pop-rock generally more engaging. Although Newman is probably more interesting lyrically, Nilsson is more interesting and varied musically and melodically, which helps the songs stick a bit better. There are some great songs on here though, probably more than on GOB. Sail Away is a real grower and a great track with a great sardonic lyric, He Gives Us All His Love has a lovely downbeat feel. Last Night I Had a Dream is a nice bluesy bit of rock pop, building and falling very nicely. Burn On (Major League!) and Dayton, Ohio 1903 are both great tracks along a similar theme. Memo to My Son has nice jauntiness and God’s Song is an excellent religious take down. Maybe I need more time to get into Randy Newman, there’s lots I do like and I could see myself getting into him, but I still can’t quite help zoning out from time to time and after 4 runs through I was keen to listen to something else. Although I preferred this to Good Old Boys I’m not sure it crosses into the 4s, so I’ll say a high 3. ⛵⛵⛵ Playlist submission: Burn On (because of Major League)

Against some odds, I ended up enjoying this, on account no doubt of the stripped back arrangements of the majority of the tracks. A gospel feel pervades, and scathing or humorous lyrics take things up another notch. There is still some of the Broadway schmaltzy arrangements, but this just tips to a four for some superb tracks, not least the title track.

Fantastic. Wish I had spent time with this earlier. Plan and hope to fill the time gap with many new listening's.

Folky piano singer songwriter. Good music for a lazy day.

One of the most beautiful and distinctive voices in all of music. You’ve got a friend in me!! He’s an absolute legend and this album perfectly matches his tone and personality. It’s so warm and easy to listen to. Toy Story anyone??

Too much murica

In which Randy Newman goes dark. Like real dark. If you're only knowledgeable with Randy's work through the Disney catalog you're in for a treat to hear what a drug-fueled, drive in a dystopian 70s era is like. Hearing it from the same voice that sings 'You've got a friend in me' puts you on edge. 3.5/5

It's fitting I generated this album the day before a tyrant takes over one of the most powerful countries of the world. The politically charged album had all of the classic Randy Newman lyrics, and sounds, as well as the "Disney" genre mixed in as well. His voice goes good with his music(even if it is a rough singing voice), and this album is more relevant today than it was when it was first released. Another note: Newman has that ability to provoke nostalgia in his music. Favorite Song: "Political Science"

Very uh I guess like a musical? Like should be an actual musical. Not really my kind of music. Also sounds so much like toy story, dude kinda phoned it in LOL Meh For me, like what I would listen to? 1/5

Sail Away ist ein kleines Meisterwerk, das seinen Hörer auf eine Achterbahnfahrt aus Satire, Empathie und introspektivem Humor mitnimmt. Randy Newman schafft es, schwierige Themen so charmant zu verpacken, dass man sich ertappt fühlt, während man lacht. Ein Album, das auch 50 Jahre später nichts von seiner Relevanz verloren hat – kurzum: ein zeitloser Klassiker mit Witz und Tiefgang!

I really hate this, but I can appreciate how someone could love it for all the things I can’t stand: the irony and sarcasm of the lyrics, the wretched strings and silly horns, not to mention one of the worst voices in the business. Ostensibly it’s offbeat and old-times and not designed to be taken too seriously, but it just makes me nauseous.

When I listen to Randy Newman, I immideately think of 3 things: Toy Story, Major League, and Family Guy. Totally random which one I think of, but they change how I hear some of these lyrics lol

It's a jungle out there

Sounds like Ray Charles with an extra chromosome

Something about the piano and the orchestra and that dumb stupid voice of his puts a silly little smile on my face

Nice background music. Didn't leave much of an impression.

I’m still more in the appreciation stage for Newman than I am the enjoyment stage, but damn, do I appreciate a lot of this. 3.5/5

he saw a vampire AND a ghost... that's so scary man what the hell

I cannot take an album by Randy Newman seriously.

I didn’t expect to like this but it grew on me

The soundtrack to Pixar's early release dream shop

His vocals are nice, but instrumentally there isn't much to write home about. Short but pleasant.

It was okay. Not a huge fan, though I appreciate his work.

I found myself enjoying this a lot. Newman is an excellent songwriter and underneath the jaunty melodies and Tin Pan Alley style arrangements is an album of blistering social commentary full of cynicism and sarcasm, all delivered in his trademark style and with a good dose dark humour.

The songs and songwriting are very good. But we’ve had his voice drilled into our collective conscious by Disney, which has probably done Randy’s catalog a disservice. I enjoyed this once I could separate my brain from Toy Story.

I hate Randy Newman's singing. Automatic 1 star

I can’t stand Randy Newman. 1 star

Not a very engaging singer, in my opinion. The songs are fine.

There are two kinds of people; people who need a second Randy Newman record to get the point, and the rest of us.

Otra entrada de Randy Newman que se aprecia dentro de la lista, alejándonos un poco del canon británico que en ocasiones transforma a este ejercicio de escuchar 1001 álbumes algo tedioso. Creo que este trabajo de Newman me gusta más que "Good Old Boys", el cual fue el otro LP que me recomendó esta página. Las composiciones de Newman destacan por su lírica sencilla y cruda pero encantadora. Antes de escuchar este trabajo no tenía idea que "You can leave your hat on" había sido escrita originalmente por la persona que escribió parte del soundtrack de Toy Story. Recomendable, pero no imprescindible.

Don't really enjoy Randy Newman much, and this isn't doing much to change that

Beetje een vreemd album. In de gevoellige, stille stukjes (met name in het begin van het album, maar ook de laatste track) weet deze articulerende Dylan-adept best een keer een gevoellige snaar bij me te raken, maar die mooie stukjes worden helaas afgewisseld door een soort blije Rik van Sesamstraat gaat naar het circus liedjes. Hij klinkt wel een beetje alsof 'ie zoals men hier vroeger zei 'unne ongelukkige' is, een persoon met geestelijke beperking zeg maar. Ik vind het best een leuk album om een keer te ontdekken, mede ook omdat het vrij korte liedjes zijn allemaal en het album is (exclusief bonustracks) slechts een half uur, maar heel goed of bijzonder is het nou ook weer niet. Ik geef een milde 3 sterren voor de moeite, met name omdat je hier echt bizar makkelijk doorheen komt.

Fine, I guess. Just Randy Newman singing what he sees.

Really liked it! Fun music

Brilliant songwriting. Randy Newman, the geeky looking kid who turns out to be the smartest person in the room. A biting, rye sense of humor with a tender heart underneath it all. This is 5 stars all the way.

You know how some voices for no reason irk you to no end? This is that voice for me.

The man has written some great tunes in his time - I mean, for half the time o had the Toy Story song in my head. He’s very easy to listen to but I don’t want too much. However, I didn’t even know he wrote ‘ You can leave your hat on’ which I’ve always loved. But let’s face it Joe Cocker did it better. And always reminds me of 9 1/2 weeks. Now there was a film!!!!

I can take only so much of his voice at a time. I love ‘You Can Leave Your Hat On’. I’m glad he wrote it so Joe Cocker could cover it!

Here's an artist I should know a lot more about, so I'm glad to have him on the 1001 list (twice!). This was great. Caustic, unapologetic, funny, Newman tells stories with admirable efficiency. And while the arrangements were sometimes over-the-top, they were also always right on — I realized there were these sweeping string arrangements after the fact. Loved it.

Droll irony is a shtick that gets a old if there's nothing else to back it up. And while I don't hate his voice, the compositions are rather slight. The Kinks did this kind of thing way better.

Bo-ring.

easy listening

el tipo ya hacía musica de películas antes de hacer música de películas

I have never heard a Randy Newman album. This is sort of a mix between "smell your own farts" and "is he being snarky or racist" type of music. This is actually a good album though. I'm not sure what all the songs are about (except Sail Away) but they are short and catchy. He can definitely write a song but I also see why he isn't everyone's cup of tea. The songs, despite being about heavy subjects, can sometimes come off as light and a bit tossed-off. I knew a few of these songs from covers by other artists. I enjoyed this one and can't decide if I want to put it in my personal collection or not.

Nothing randy about this album

This album was not terrible. I got through most of the tracks. It loses a star from me for all the god mentions.

Andra plattan med honom. Första var väl okej men den andra suger.

While I liked the slightly sardonic lyrics, once I got over that this was the Toy Story guy, I found that the music didn't do much for me. For 70s American piano, I preferred Billy Joel.

many (most?) of Randy's most well known songs. Didn't discover any new ones

Not bad per se, but there aren't many standout tracks/moments. Just kept wanting him to sing his pixar songs.

Randy Newman isn't a conventionally good singer but there is a quality to his voice that lends it character and makes it interesting. I don't know much of his work but from what I've heard, I like his song writing. (Short People is probably an exception.) There's nothing that really stands out here but it was an enjoyable listen.

You can leave your hat on?!

After taking up a residency as the musical mascot for Disney animated franchises he has been known as a crusty but affable buddy. Entirely wholesome and inoffensive. Going back to 1972 for this record it is indeed pleasant and inoffensive, like the soundtrack to puppies wrestling with kittens on a fluffy feather blanket. As for myself I would tend to slip into psychosis after encountering and failing to escape from such inert exhibition.

Well shit Randy, I didn’t expect such cynical humour from the dude who did the Toy Story soundtrack. Forgive me, for I was not familiar with your snark. Randy crafted a hilarious album that holds a mirror up to religious Americans that gives them the opportunity to see how dumb they actually are, sadly most are too dumb to realize they are the joke. This was great fun, I really didn’t expect a tune like, Last Night I had a Dream from Randy Newman. 4 stars

Really enjoyable. Have to listen again when I can pay better attention to the lyrics.

This if fine, witty here, sure, and biting there. And one's a firm supporter of curmudgeonliness and cynicism in many forms and okay with dudes who sing despite having indifferent or even poor voices. But this feels oversold, overdetermined and overdone. The best song "Dayton, Ohio," is a nice little set piece, but not quite the slice-of-life high art he appears to be reaching for. "Leave Your Hat On" isn't terrible either. For a guy so obviously playing for laughs, he does take himself awfully seriously, no? Would he even have made it on Tin Pan Alley? One's not so sure and really struggles to get into this at any more than a level of passing interest. The cover shot might be the best thing about the record. And whatever hipster cred or critical rep he had was lost with the Toy Story work (about which he seems way too proud).

Mellow and chill vibes

A whimsical album with a couple of classics but not enough to grab attention over the whole record.

Jazzy folk or folksy jazz, doesn't matter. Great tunes.

Left foot right foot left foot right foot

Love the juxtaposition between the wholesome sound and the lyrics. Pretty sure I had heard "You Can Leave Your Hat On", but never really paid close attention to the lyrics. How in the world is the Joe Cocker version more famous?

3½ / 5 A pesar de que siempre se agradece unas baladas, tampoco me pareció de otro mundo, o sea; está bueno, hasta ahí (todo el tiempo me pasé pensando en lo mucho que me sonaba a canciones de disney... es literalmente uno de los mayores productores de canciones para disney jsjja)

Gonna be honest, I don't know much of Randy Newman's work from before his time at Disney/Pixar. The arrangements will definitely sound familiar to many and Newman's slow, Southern vocal style is hard to mistake. The whole album is pretty touching and reflective, if not a bit corny at times. Interesting to see Newman's songwriting ability on display, even way back when.

With some of the albums in this project I don’t personally enjoy them, but I can see why other people would. This isn’t one of those albums.

Blind album, know the artist from his soundtracks. Wonderfully delightful album, exactly what I would expect from such a notable name. Great track list and was very emotional and happy throughout.

Album number 3 for this challenge I own on vinyl, and boy, is it a good one. This will probably be the longest review I write on the site, but it's worth it when it comes to this guy. For people who don't know me, I worship at the altar of Randy Newman. Besides Bob Dylan, he's easily my favorite songwriter of all time and I feel his contributions to the pop AND rock canon rarely get their deserved due. With his old age and recurring injuries, I've come to a really harrowing realization: I'm going to cry a lot and probably shut down mentally for a few days when Randy Newman dies. To explain why I'd have such a strong emotional reaction for an 80 year old man I've never met, let me explain one key reason Randy is a legend: I don't think there's a single other songwriter that sums up the worst parts of the human psyche in a way that makes you almost sympathetic to his characters by the end. Warren Zevon is the only other example that comes to mind, and even he can get too self-centered and cynical to get the point across the same way this guy does. No, Mr. Newman uses a dopey Southern accent and New Orleans R&B piano riffs to deliver the most sobering songs about slavery, subjugation, adultery (and... dancing bear? I ran out of atrociously terrible things present).... and it's some of the most brilliant songwriting I've ever had the pleasure of hearing. Even outside of politics he's extremely compelling at writing down-to-earth and overwhelmingly human depictions of loss and grief: just listen to "Old Man" and "Memo to my Son" as proof of that. The part that makes this whole album brilliant isn't really the biting satirical tone itself, thought that plays a part. It also isn't the subjects themselves, as clever as they can be (the title track is effectively an ad roll to join the transatlantic slave trade, for example), but where this album's strength really lies is its ability to make you think. Yes, Randy's songs are case studies, but how many people do we know that act like the racists and adulterers Randy postures as? How often have we engaged in awful behavior that we tried to justify, looking like complete hypocrites ourselves? Sail Away (and any Newman record worth its salt) is a series of unflinching takes on what humans are capable of, and sometimes the world needs that mirror as a reminder to do better. Please listen to this guy's full discography, you won't regret it. I'm going to cry a lot when Randy Newman dies. 9/10

I can only hear his You've got a friend in me' when hearing his voice. Decent enough but nothing to have me coming back for more

I love the new word cloud feature on this site. Very funny that my first thought on hearing this is that I just associate Randy Newman with Toy Story and sure enough, that along with Pixar/Disney etc. are some of the most mentioned topics. The market researcher in me finds this fun Anyway the album is quite nice, not too remarkable or notable so I probably wouldn't listen again, but a pleasant 3*

music for pixar cartoons. Bit slow for me

musically talented for sure. But i didn't really like it.

I was never a Newman fan. Some of his Pixar soundtrack work is listenable, but this isn't!

Liked this one more then the previous Randy Newman album. Political Science, You can leave your hat on, Maybe I'm doing it wrong were the favorite tracks.

11.- You can leave your hat on: striptease

This is a dude who's seen some shit wearing a smiley plush mascot suit at a run down theme park. Harry Nilsson runs the ticket booth. The balance of levity and depth these artists can pull off is amazing, but I also really appreciate it. Like no doubt it takes commitment, resolve, and thick skin to be different. Definitely carved out his own weird brand of cool haha. Love it.

Instrumentals were occasionally good, but other than that doesn't stand out

Randy Newman is bonkers to me. Unassuming and I think for the most part misunderstood. I don't necessarily like his music, but it's singular and unique and worth listening to with care.

Soothing and sweet. Randy Newman was just what I needed today. Great calming album.

An album like this was really needed on a day like today. The Disney-esque quality to this music was uplifting and comforting on a day when the world is going to hell.

I only knew Randy Newman as the guy who wrote songs for Pixar movies, so this was a bit of a surprise. While the music is fun, there's a dark undercurrent woven into in the lyrics that make this more interesting than you expect. That said I'm really not a fan of his singing.

I grew up listening to this album, and grew to love it more and more as time has gone on. Highlight songs: Sail Away Burn On 4/5

we know what we're getting with Randy Newman. So no surprise on this album. It was enjoyable as a one off listen. Won't be listening again.

I enjoy Randy Newman in small doses. This exceeded my USRDA serving for one sitting.

Stuff i neither like, neither dislike

Excellent, intelligent and funny

I'm so confused about this album, First off have get around that I'm totally expecting a "You've got a Friend in Me" every other lyric, but then, the musicality is actually awesome but then I get super confused about what this dude is actually singing about? Its painfully american but then am I like is this just proud to be an american type of vibes or is this downright the level of ignorance and pride of america that became maga? I'm glad I got this album bc I totally would have never listened to it otherwise, and its good. But at the same time I think its probably negatively dated. 1972 man, I could totally see this have came out recently. Lonely at the Top is a bop Also side note I really love the photo of this album cover.

No short people? No reason to live

I find sarcasm works well in short bursts. Short People, for example, a great insight by Randy Newman. Musically its appropriate for the lyrical themes but you have to be in the mood for it.

I don’t get the love. Average at best

I feel bad rating this kind of low, as I feel like I was distracted, talking over it the whole time. But, frankly, I don't know if this is worth a revisit. First off, I know what Randy Newman sounds like, so that aspect is covered, and two, it kind of is the same thing the whole album. There's minor differences, but not enough to comment on, and that leaves it feeling kind of bland. I respect Newman, and this isn't bad, but I see no reason to return to it.

I can't hear Randy Newman's voice without wondering what Woody and Buzz are up to. Exploring the early part of Randy Newman's career is a delightful way to spend a rainy afternoon or evening with a few adult beverages, just don't take his lyrics too seriously, his dry wit sometimes is taken a bit too seriously.

I like but don’t love Randy Newman. I feel the same about this album.

I appreciate authenticity and the clear ability to write a solid tune. Almost a softer Tom Waits, if that makes sense? However, people can’t deny that the Toy Story generation may have drawn their conclusions and this guy is a little comical, as a result.

Bland and inoffensive, and not very interesting

It's incredibly interesting to listen to Randy Newman in the 21st century, when his contribution to film, particularly Disney films, has far outweighed the cultural impacts of his earlier, solo career. Especially when you consider that the man who wrote a satirical song about "dropping the big one" would go on to write "You've Got a Friend in Me". His lyrics are often dark, and focused on a changing modern world, but I couldn't help but not feel particularly affected by it.

Iskreno, nisam upoznata s njim i ovo mi je baš lijepo iznenađenje - pogotovo kad sam skužila da je za Pixar i Disney masu radio, skroz kul. Jako ugodan glas ima, osjeti se Dylanov utjecaj i ima smisla skroz. Opet masu zanimljivih informacija, recimo kako nitko nije htio čuti za njega dok nisu Dusty Springfield, Peggy Lee i Judy Collins snimili njegove pjesme. Malo sam zbunjena - po nekim informacijama je on "preradio" dosta stvari na svojim albumima, dok u drugim izvorima čitam kako su njega oduvijek glazbeno pokradali, tko tu koga jebe? Btw ja faking ne mogu vjerovati da je You Can Leave Your Hat On njegova stvar - toliko o tome. Samo za tu stvar rispekt do poda, mislim realno nema puno ljudi na svijetu koji nikad nisu čuli za tu stvar, a ne čuje se često baš da je njegova. Uvijek me smeta religijski aspekt u glazbi, ali hajde, pretvarat ću se da He znači nešto drugo .🫣 Mislim da je ovo jedan od glazbenika koji je malo nepravedno prošao ispod radara. Kužim da nije neka glazba koja se prodaje, but still. Ovo je, recimo, meni zanimljivo stilski usporediti s Ute ili taj djir neki, više umjetnički, mjuziklasti i meni je ovo za tri kategorije bolje od Ute. Political Science stvar me jako nasmijala, totalni vrh! 😁😁 Okej, nije nešto što bih mogla satima slušati, ali stavljajući u kontekst žanra i činjenice da dolazi iz obitelji kompozitora za film, plus rispekt za par pjesama na albumu, ocijeniti ću s tim na umu. 3/5 ili 5.5/10.

Ma ograničen sam ko balkon. Dosadno mi sve, nije me pogodio do sad niti jedan album osim onih koje sam već znao Brzim guglanjem sam saznao da je ovaj tip radio glazbu za dosta diznijevih filmova. Figures, tako mu zvuči glazba Nema šanse da ću slušati ovog kvazi Dylana Preskačem sve pjesme do you can leave your hat on, da vidim koliko je bolje to cocker odradio Masu bolje. 1 brate Randy, žao mi je

6/10 Zanimljiva boja glasa i izvodjac koji, nadam se, ima nekih zivljih i zabavnijih stvari ali ovako mi je ipak previse laganica na jednom mjestu. Simon Smith mi je mozda favorit, volio bi i da je ostatak albuma u slicnom tempu. Takodjer, nisam znao da je izvorno njegova You Can Leave Your Hat On. Bez obzira sto mi je malo prespor, uzivao sam vecinu vremena i zainteresiran sam cuti jos neke njegove albume.

I like a few Randy Newman songs, but this is the first time I have listened to 12 Randy Newman songs in a row. It is a pretty big ask. Fortunately most of the songs clock in at less than three minutes.

The Good: it seems we are going on a sailing trip… The Bad: nobody clearly explained to us where the trip is heading… The Ugly: once we reached our destination we realized we are all screwed… WOW. I’ve listened to this album many times over the years, but since starting this 1001 journey, at least for with several albums, I’ve started paying attention closer to what the lyrics actually mean, and this album is a gut-wrencher. I always appreciated Randy’s songs, the ones that I was very familiar with, but today I shed a tear during the ¨Old Man¨ song, what a harsh story he is telling there. And most of the songs on this album are just that, in your face, harsh stories, but told with such simple charm that you need to really make an effort to find out what’s really going on. And by that time, you can but only applaud the genius of Randy. 5*

I love Randy Newman’s voice and I respect his ability to write short, powerful songs. He has a distinct style too. His piano melodies are almost as distinct as his voice. The highlights for me were the opening title track about slavery and the haunting closer “God’s Song (That’s Why I Love Mankind).”

I grew up hearing Randy Newman being the voice of Toy Story / animation from my youth. 1995's "You Got a Friend in Me" was a true revelation for storyteller music and his voice is forever synonymous with that part of my life. There's something to his voice that is so immediately attractive and enjoyable. There's not many songwriters that naturally have voices like that that are so unique and have such a special sound. It's so approachable, friendly- jovial even. He sounds like a friendly uncle who you only see a few times a year for family events and when the family event starts to devolve into political discourse, he's there in the corner of the room hitting some chords on a piano and offering a respite from the conversation. "Be as happy as a monkey in the monkey tree." It's a beautiful sound and album, but it's only a 3 for me because I found that I got a little bored in the second half.

What I´ve learned: The well known "You Can Leave Your Hat On" by Joe Cocker is only a cover version😉 Never heared of Randy Newman before but this album is definitely worth a listen! 3,5

The musical Larry David, with the handful of moderately amusing insights served with way too large a side of smugness and self-satisfaction, from an artist who clearly thinks he's the smartest guy in the room and thinks he should be a much bigger star. These are samey, both in the smart alecky and sonic senses. The songs don't add up to much, but to sour jokes / tired-seeing plaints only he's amused by, none of which merit the brass and strings. And for such a supposedly accomplished lyricist, there's a lot here that's prosaic and flat, with mostly predictable rhymes; for instance, what does the song "Dayton, Ohio, 1903" actually tell us about either Dayton, Ohio or 1903? Mightn't it have been just as accurately entitled "Afternoon Tea with the Missus and Me"? (One understands this might be a reference to the Wright Bros or a local serial killers, but, again RN seems the only one in on the joke, which is perhaps how he likes it. [So better to spend time with the related GBV song.] Writers get no credit for writing in character if the characters are inscrutable.) Best things about the record are the "You Can Leave Your Hat On" (which has best line on whole record "Take off your dress / yes, yes, yes, yes") and the cover image. One is not surprised that his offerings sunk like a lead commercially, but finds it odd that his critical reputation seems to have been sustained. One thinks he is properly rated – the market got him right, for the most part. Even one album by this guy in this book/list seems one too many.

alright, some of the songs werent my kind of thing, but others had a nice funky sound.

Randy Newman is so cool, and this album has most of my favorite songs of his. In addition to having a unique voice and a niche genre (Orchestral Pop), he's part poet, part humorist, part satirist, part spirit guide - a little bit of everything.

I don’t know much of Randy Newman aside form his contribution to Pixar films, but this was a fun album

This freaky ass boi told her to leave her hat on 😭😭😭

He's no Bob Dylan but his singing is nearly as bad

I feel bad for Randy Newman. He did songs with important topics and great lyrics and now everyone knows him as the Toy Story guy.

9/10. Great album. Sail Away is fantastic and no real drop off from there.

I thought I knew Randy Newman. That first song about how God loves us fit in pretty well, but then Randy said we should nuke the whole world because America gets bullied, and things just got dark from there on out. I'm sure it was satirical, but it surprised me anyway. The one about why God loves us from His perspective was just depressing as hell. Anyway, I jammed to the whole thing. The melancholy, Americana/soul really fit well with me sitting on the porch in autumn listening to the music. A very good vibe. I actually just really like this album, even in spite of its depressing nature. I also really appreciated that the theme seemed to progress naturally from optimism to pessimism, and then he revisited the opening song at the end with the now-realized melancholia. Standout track for me was 'Dayton, Ohio - 1903'.

This sounds like the type of music you'd hear in a hotel lobby while you're checking out. Some dude in the corner playing the piano and "singing" songs that all sound the same. Randy Newman will forever be GOATed for his Toy Story soundtrack, but this album just ain't it.

Randy has a real knack for writing pithy little songs. Some are hits, some are misses. All of them sort of wistful.

I just can't do his voice. Maybe it's the Toy Story link, but it feels like a kids album. His voice is not a good singing voice at all, and not in an interesting way like Morrissey or a lot of metal, just in a lazy soft way. I'm amazing this has made the list And now reading the wiki on it, the critical acclaim bit is madness. Are you sure Spotify has the correct album?

A disappointing snoozefest

In a parallel universe, where Randy Newman was never born, people never kept their hats on when having sex. The "hat" section of PornHub remained empty. The hat fetishists suffered greatly. It was, by all accounts, a miserable way to wank. Two permissions to wear a hat out of five 🎩🎩

Folky. Very Americana.

I really enjoy the melancholy nostalgia that I hear in Randy Newman’s voice. It brings a lump to my throat without really trying.

I liked this. VERY obviously Randy Newman. He has such a unique writing style and voice that you can tell 100% that it's time. I liked his songs and the pace of the album.

Not for me

This album is a masterpiece of sardonic wit and musical craftsmanship. Newman's signature piano-driven melodies provide the backdrop for his cynical, yet insightful lyrics that explore themes of power, corruption, and the American Dream. Songs like "Sail Away" and Good Old Boys" offer biting social commentary, while tracks like "Lonely at the Top" and "Last Night I had a Dream" delve into the darker aspects of the human psyche. The albums' blend of humor and pathos makes it a timeless classic.

Sail Away // Last Night I Had a Dream // You Can Leave Your Hat On //

Liked it more than I thought I would. Very inoffensive!

Not for me

Didn’t do a lot for me.

Randy Newman fucking hates god

I don’t think this album is for me

It was delightful and at times irritating. He is definitely a master song writer with an distinct sound and delivery. When it works its awesome movie music. Not all of the 17 songs work...specially the spritual/god crap,

It still baffles me that this is "Toy Story" song guy...

Better than I expected but didn't do anything for me.

I do not like Randy Newman. Short People is a banger though!

альбом колыбельных для детей. вообще не мое, но это точно не говно. а ну и да, ебать я ахуел что одна из этих колыбельных усилиями моего любимого Джо Кокера теперь ассоциируется со стриптизом ) что доказывает каким был пиздатым старина Кокер, но его альбомов в этом списке нет....

yet another album with every song sounding the same. randy newman gonna randy newman, i guess. at least this one doesn’t have gratuitous use of the “n word”, so there’s that.

Just had one of his albums last week. One was enough.

Great songwriter. Less of a compelling performer.

Unique voice. Sort of soothing. Didn’t hate it.

Just ok, glad he found his niche with animated movies

Randy Newman's success is an enigma. But at least we got the Toy Story theme song from it.