Spy Vs. Spy: The Music Of Ornette Coleman by John Zorn

Spy Vs. Spy: The Music Of Ornette Coleman

John Zorn

2.26
Rating
21940
Votes
1
35%
2
25%
3
23%
4
11%
5
5%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 8)

Ornette Coleman was a great jazz musician and his work deserves to be celebrated…but I’m not sure this is the way to do it. The beauty of the arrangements is lost in a cacophony of blistering drums and screeching trumpets.

Listened Before? No I usually won't go out of my way to find an album if it isn't on Spotify, but given the group hate this has sown, I'll make an exception. Opens on an absolute torrent with all instruments involved conspiring in an all out melee. In some senses it is damned impressive that despite them all running 1000 mph in different directions they sound coherent; particularly towards the end when it all comes back together for a punctuated finale. Track 2: oh... we're gonna do a whole album like this? Honestly this is pretty damned punk. Track 3: early standout for me. Actually starts out coherent and immediately deconstructs. I enjoy searching for the bassline as it noodles around behind the scenes tying things together. Track 4 (Good Old Days): is pretty sick to start with. Has a straight up metal breakdown out of the gate. Whoever is on drums is absolutely slaying. So far this reminds me of a much more demented Cuong Vu (if you like aspects of this, but want more structure, I recommend you check his work out). Paused for a minute during Ecars, because I realized this album is a representation of another Jazz saxophonist's compositions. I encourage anyone listening to this to pause and reflect on those songs and then hop back into this rendering. It is damned impressive that this hardcore rendering actually captures a vital essence of the original work while completely turning them on their head. I had not heard Ornette Coleman before, but will take a sidebar into his work later. Fleet Music is another standout. Love the punchy drum and bass that propel this in a very punk-influenced spirit. One of few songs here that feel like they are practicing measured restraint. Alright, so I understand the hate that this album got from other reviewers. This is a dense and unrelenting listen that serves as a sort of audio assault and does nothing to accommodate casual listeners. I think ultimately, that is the point. From what I can gather this is basically Hardcore punk stylization applied to traditional Jazz compositions using the original instrumentation. It is a wild ride that is punk through and through. That said, I rather enjoy hardcore punk and think that this is highly effective and a unique application of the style that I have never encountered previously. While I can't say there were any isolated tracks I would go back to and "enjoy," there were a lot of points in the record that I stopped what I was doing to appreciate the absolute chaotic energy on display. Underpinning the whole thing, the instrumentalists are incredibly talented making this enjoyable for me, and fantastic background music for my current task. I will absolutely come back to this and listen again. Not a perfect album, but something new that I am glad to have been exposed to. 4 / 5.

In my professional opinion, they should have played better so that this album would have sounded better. I hate John Zorn more than I hate Jim Zorn after listening to this.

Now I have a headache.

Annoying it's not on Apple Music! Or at least it's hard to find so had to go to Youtube for this one. Well this already isn't some early morning easy listening. Alright not gonna lie I did not make it all the way through on this one. A song would end and then immediately go into what sounded like the exact same jazz-thrash as before. I'm very cool with music like that but not an entire albums worth. 1.5 and rounding down. I won't be back. Also John Zorn is probably Jim Zorn's brother so he can go right ahead and fuck himself.

It was a struggle for me to finish this album, but I pulled through, knowing that I will never listen to it again! To me that’s just noise and it managed to gave me a slight headache.

Tour de force, tvö trommusett, tveir saxófónar og bassi. Aldrei dauð stund, bókstaflega. Hér er allt á yfirsnúningi. Fyrstu þrjár mínúturnar eru erfiðastar en svo verður þetta áhugavert. Já, gæti spilað þetta aftur einhvern daginn.

Wild. An uncompromising listen but always interesting and when the noise coalesces at times, it's fantastic. Gets far more listenable in the second half if you're struggling (and you can tell from the reviews who only listened to a few seconds then dropped a 1 on it)

did i get past the halfway point of this album. no. is there any reason to. i think probably also no.

Wow this may be to Avant Garde fir it's own good. It's difficult to think of a situation where I'd ever voluntarily put this on again, certainly not in a public setting. Could not be setbreak music, it would freak way to many people out. That said, they were definitely going for IT and trying something weird and new so theres that.

If I ever want to cause a panic attack I will listen to this again. I struggled with the lack of melody, lack of beat, it was too chaotic. It felt like brass players trying to one up each other.

This is the perfect blend of the New York-London-Tokyo punk jazz. The album itself approaches free jazz from the perspective of hardcore punk, particularly taking note of the contemporary innovations of thrashcore and grindcore. I loved this album and listened to it multiple times today - a new classic for sure! Was it aggressive throughout? Yes. Did it need to let up on the gas a bit and breathe in the second half? Most definitely. Did I love it anyways? Absolutely!

When I first started the record I thought to myself, "this isn't jazz. This is a hardcore album". Upon reading the wikipedia article, it became clear that it's not an accident. In fact it's the whole concept of Spy vs Spy. The production is exciting throughout. The drums sound killer! I have no familiarity with the originals so my enjoyment of the versions on this album are not what they could be, but I still loved the thrash and frenetic energy of the recording.

This is not an ensemble; it's a bunch of musicians playing random shit on their instruments for 40 minutes. How the fuck this made it on this list, I will never know. There are moments where you can somewhat hear the virtuosity of individual instruments, but the whole is not better than the sum of the parts. This is like listening to a bunch of children playing whatever the fuck they want on their instruments. My beginner youth orchestra sounded better than this. Maybe this is what jazz sounds like to aliens.

I can't say if Ornette Coleman ever heard this album, but I like to think he would approve. John Zorn and his band spin Coleman's free jazz in a new direction, taking influence from the 80s hardcore scene, with two (!!) sets of blistering drums, a heavy bass guitar, and short, quick compositions. With a different saxophone improvising in each ear you're blasted with a beautiful wall of sound. A pleasant and unexpected discovery for me.

p615. 1989. 1 star Intolerable and unremittingly violent jazz improvisation. My ears are bleeding.

What a cool and super deep rabbit hole!

Dear god. Made it 11 minutes in and had to stop. Was on YouTube so I couldn’t even read anything to distract myself. Kept thinking something listenable would come on eventually. It did not

Jazzin elementit: Blues, Ragtime ja Marssi Uuden ajan tekojen tuska ei näy blues puolella. Ragtimen synkooppinen rytmi on taas pelkkä naurunalaisuus, sillä maple leaf rag on näiden poikien mielestä klassista. Punkin sentään pojat luontavat yksinkertaiseksi, niinkuin se on. Klassinen ei siis 80 luvun lopulle käy ja punkkiin eivät pojat alistu. Puhallinsoittimien Tim bernen vasen ja John Stornen oikea ovat marssista kaukana. Halkaistu sotilas ei pitkälle kävele.. Ja kun looginen puoli ja artistinen ovat täysin irrallisena, saadaan mielettöman hauska trash jazz albumi.

Holy everloving shit. I am glad I read a few album reviews to understand what the intention of this album was. That was hard to listen to. I do recognize the experimental nature of the music, and there are some cool components to it, especially the fact that it's all improv I think, but that was extremely overwhelming with no breaks and not particularly fun.

I mean good for them for trying something new? But really difficult to follow

Warning: It's jazz. Bad jazz.

Alright I’ll be real, wasn’t expecting hardcore jazz. Not mad at it though.

Potser s'ho van passar d'allò més bé mentre l'enregistraven. Per l'oient, però, escoltar-ho és més un repte que un plaer. I per disfrutar-lo s'ha de ser molt fan del free jazz o de les improvisacions de caire més provocatiu. Entremig de les improvisacions i enfrontament d'instruments, hi ha algun tema que destaca, com 'Feet Music' o 'Mob Job', però tot plegat és força complicat de pair

An interesting selection for this list, I had thought the list was based on what are considered the best or landmark albums, not sure this fits either category and perhaps added for shock value. I read elsewhere that Ornate Coleman has not made the list and yet this has, very odd and I wonder on the integrity of the selection. As to the album, it is a very tough listen for those unfamiliar with the more free-form / avant garde styles of jazz. The first few tracks are particularly challenging with a cacophony of noise seemingly each trying to outplay the other band members. However it becomes more accessible with later tracks and even sometimes a tune breaks through. I am intrigued on the appeal of this type of jazz and will consider exploring further.

This is the worst thing I’ve heard in my life. Reminiscent of a school jazz band before the conductor has arrived, it could be used as a cruel and unusual punishment method. The only reason it gets 1 star is because it isn’t possible to give negative scores.

Very nice

It’s never a good sign when I see that I’ve been generated album by an experimental saxophonist. You might not believe it, but it’s not really my scene. Smooth jazz trumpet, sure. Experimental saxophone, doubt it. Songs I already knew: none Favourites: none When was the last time you listened to an album that’s existence made you angry? This sounded like a bunch of people playing their own songs on their own instruments as fast as they can without a care in the world for what the other band members are doing. I feel like people that enjoy this are also the people who somehow manage to find beauty in a wet floor sign in an art gallery. If you’re deaf, you might be able to tolerate this. If not, stay away. It’s not worth harming yourself by listening to this mess.

Sounds like a bunch of kids playing random notes and beats. Not for me.

This is a lot of chaotic noise. I’m only on track one. We’ll see how the rest of this goes and whether I make it all the way through. Five minutes in: Ok, I’m hearing some actual melody. Six minutes in: Never mind. Nine minutes in: I’m tapping out.

Solo lo he encontrado en YouTube subido a las bravas por un usuario. Unos 40 minutos de jazz. Empieza demasiado arriba para mi gusto ¿heavy jazz? Esto es infumable, supongo que habrá quien le guste pero le meto una estrella y listo.

I don't know how to describe it properly, but this feels like screaming into a pillow without having to open my mouth. This genre of music is more effective than any kind of ADHD medicine and always seems to calm my brain. I want to grind this album up and snort it. Hopefully I'm not alone on that one. I can't believe someone listened to Ornette Coleman and went "hmm.. this jazz isn't quite avantgarde enough for me" and then recorded this. Absolute madman. I grant this a 4/5, but also fuck you John Zorn.

All throttle, no brakes. The musicianship here – no, the *athleticism* on display here is amazing. Sprinting through a marathon the whole time. I *like* Ornette Coleman. I love *his* free jazz. I love what he brought to music. There's a purity in his performances. Zorn's interpretation is too much. Now I'm going to listen to Trout Mask Replica to cleanse my palate.

I actually had a slight headache when I started this. Somehow, I couldn't get myself to stop it. The headache ended up going away! Like the music absorbed it? Still, I can't imagine listening to this except on rare occasions. The weirdest part of the album was Feet Music when it went all 'normal'. I think the artist of cover also did a cover for Coldcut that same year. Hope that album's on the list.

This isn’t it. I’m not into these instruments, except the drums.

Skronky. It's great, but it's not the most accessible jazz album ever.

Not for me

Mostly a lot of fun, but not really for me massively, would be great live.

So, finally got round to it. This is fun, it seems more structured than the other John Zorn album I’ve ever heard, Naked City. It’s a shame the only way I can listen to it is on YouTube, cos I’d like to revisit it more often. C’est la vie

Chaotic greatness.

While I can recognize the importance of the work in the Sphere of All Musical Endeavor.... I really just do not enjoy hearing these noises. I've even seen John Zorn in concert, and it's just as unbearable.

Unlistenable

I need to hold 1s on other albums so I have something to mark this one with

Ornette coleman is one of the more controversial but interesting jazz cats. He formulated a system of music called harmolodics which he could never quite explain but was to do with removing the limitations of key, rhythm, tempo and harmony. So, this explains this. John zorn is an excellent interpreter of coleman and a great avany grade composer in his own right. This is an excellent interpretation with a-list musicians of the highest quality. Dimery clearly doesn’t understand this type of stuff. I suspect he read some reviews and felt oh this better go on. 1 star for it being here. 5 stars as a work of music. 1 star for its danceability. 3 stars.

Proof that music is best live. They are... totally smashing it with improv; yes a great performance and in tune collaboration... if you can handle it. there are some very good build ups drops and crashendos in this polyphony. great to drop in and experince this briefly, and I was also glad I could get out when I wanted to after a few tracks, without losing my cover charge. a document in jazz high energy improv. yet not something I'm like to go back to ... so very hard to give it a number. 5 for quality, 2 for wanting to listen again, 3.5 overall? not fair.

John Zorn - from another planet. I’ve got 4 Coleman cd’s & 1 lp, & I thought they were difficult enough listening, but Zorn makes Coleman’s music even more challenging. Mind you, I only have 1 Zorn cd - The Big Gundown - where he plays the music of Ennio Morricone - and that’s a much more relaxing listen than Spy Vs. Spy. Still, I got through this, without knowing any of the Coleman originals, because none of them are on any of the 5 releases I own. I wonder if knowing the originals would help? I don’t mind the cacophonous approach up to a point, although I reckon the AllMusic reviewer, Scott Yanow totally nails it : "The performances are concise with all but four songs being under three minutes and seven under two, but the interpretations are unremittingly violent. The lack of variety in either mood or routine quickly wears one out". I really liked Feet Music & Mob Job, the 2 longest cuts here. Anyway, I’m gonna go back to this one day when I’m totally off my face & see what that’s like.

interesting that there are no Ornette Coleman albums on this list, but John Zorn's tribute to Ornette Coleman... Dimery's bias towards white, critically lauded artists continues? John Zorn has carved out a little niche for himself in music, but I disagree that you really need to hear his stuff to lead a fulfilled life. I feel like Wynton Marsalis spent the 1980s championing 'straight-ahead' jazz, attempting to set jazz in aspic and stifle any sense of innovation in the form. But Zorn showed that there were still people pushing the form into genuinely new areas that built on the traditions of the form (in this case, free jazz). Zorn's crossover between free jazz and hardcore is convincing, even if borderline unlistenable. Moments of melody poke through the noise to hint at structure, only to disappear again into the unrelenting aggressive noise. It has been influential -- I am going to see Party Dozen this week, I'm sure they were highly influenced by this album. But it's exhausting to listen to. The only track I came close to really enjoying is Feet Music.

I like jazz and many of free jazz in general but I was deeply disappointed in this album. It is actually a tribute but was way overdone. The first half is practically unlistenable and not accessible at all, it improves a bit in the second half but it is still messy, noisy without any direction or harmonies. I managed to listen to it but it was enough for once in my life, thank you very much.

Dude took Ornette's music and made it even crazier. That's saying something.

The "I listen to everything" kind of people are crying in a corner right now.

Kick ass jazz album that won't let you breath for a second. Love it. Glad that John Zorn is in the 1001, even if it's a tribute album.

Noisy, not enjoyable

I was curious to listen to this album, as I had heard that John Zorn was a talented and innovative saxophonist and composer. However, I was very disappointed by what I heard. The album is a tribute to Ornette Coleman, a pioneer of free jazz, but it does not do justice to his legacy. Instead, it is a chaotic and noisy mess that tries to combine free jazz with hardcore punk, thrashcore and grindcore. The album consists of 17 tracks, all composed by Coleman, but performed in a very brief and intense style by Zorn and his band. The tracks range from 1 to 4 minutes in length, but they feel much longer due to the lack of structure, melody and harmony. The saxophones are constantly screeching, squealing and clashing in stereo, while the bass and drums provide a frenetic and erratic rhythm. The music is so loud and abrasive that it gave me a headache after listening to it. I understand that Zorn wanted to experiment with different genres and challenge the conventions of jazz, but I think he went too far with this album. It is not enjoyable or accessible to listen to, and it does not capture the spirit or the beauty of Coleman's music. Even more frustrating that Coleman himself doesn’t have an album on the list! It is an insult to both jazz and punk fans, and a waste of time and money. I would not recommend this album to anyone, unless they want to torture themselves or their enemies. I give it 1 star out of 5. (Lost an extra star due to this being picked over an actual Coleman album)

Excellent jazz!

Not as "extreme" as I thought it would be, honestly. This record having one of the lowest global scores on this app, I was already aware of its "reputation" through some of the reviews left here. I was expecting utter chaos. Well, chaos is there, there's no arguing about that. But good music is there too, as "tiring" as said music may be for some virgin ears. Oh, by the way: wikipedia rants about the supposed "grindcore" and "thrashcore" influences on those Ornette Coleman covers, but I gotta say that those influences sound quite superficial to me. Maybe I'm deaf to them, I don't know, but I'm relatively familiar with those genres, so I don't think I'm talking though my hat here... Indeed, it seems to me that the so-called "punk influences" on *Spy vs Spy* mostly came from the fact that John Zorn was hanging out with members of that scene at the time. But essentially, what we have here is more like an amped-up and sped-up version of free-jazz, which doesn't owe a lot to hardcore punk, except for a few quick, subliminal rhythm patterns once in a while. As a matter of fact, and for the first four or five tracks at least, you can easily link this work to the free-jazz giants of the preceding decades. You just need to add more amphetamines or cocaine to the mix. Symbolically speaking, of course... Things get even more hectic in the middle of the LP though, somewhere between "Enfant" and "Ecars". Zorn and company are making a mean and wonderful racket there, and aspirin is highly recommended by that point. Yet starting with "Feet Music", Zorn and his musicians let things breathe a little again. The proceedings are not exactly "mellow" there, mark my words--but there's a film-noir dimension to some of those cuts that's, well... interesting. Those last cuts would rather illustrate frantic action scenes, instead of melancholic ones, obviously. But once again, we're not so far from certain other jazz traditions that also hailed form NYC. Now the real problem with the presence of this record in Dimery's list does not come from the record itself, very ironically. As "weird" as *Spy vs Spy* is, it is what it is--not worse than plenty of other "experimental" recordings out there, and probably even better than many others. No, the real issue stems from the following situation: a) There's no Ornette Coleman album in the 1001 Albums book. Yet every jazz fan knows how much of a pivotal (and controversial) figure he was at the turn of the sixties. It's a little as if the book had selected an album made out of covers of Bob Dylan without selecting any of Bob's original albums. Including *The Shape Of Jazz To Come* in the book would probably have been enough. Yet, like so many jazz masterpieces--especially in the subcategory of free jazz--said album is conspicuously absent from Dimery's work. b) I'm no more of an expert about John Zorn than I am one of Ornette Coleman, but I happen to have a couple of friends who know him quite well. I can't say that I've dug any further after the evenings we spent together when they played some of Zorn's works to me (it was a long time ago, and I only have a blurry memory of what the music sounded like). Yet I'm adamant they never told me about *Spy vs Spy*'s existence. When it comes to Zorn's hardcore-free-jazz and film-noir-oriented work, they probably played *Naked City*, with its reference points going from Ennio Morricone's soundtracks to the Cramps and B52s gothic strands of 50s rock. And they surely played excerpts from the "world-music-oriented" collection of "Masada" albums--summing up a lot of the man's overall sense of sonic adventure. Those albums (*Naked City* and the *Masada" collection) have even been the starting point of two of Zorn's most famous side-projects as a group member--side-priojects actually named after those LPs. Which probably proves how important those records are in his discography. To put it in a nutshell, it appears that Dimmery's inclusion of *Spy vs Spy* is a disservice not only to *one* artist whose name is associated with the project, but to *two* of them, both Coleman and Zorn. Besides, it doesn't take an expert to quickly get that this record is a very poor entry point to know more about those two legendary musicians. It's too "niche", and not much more than an anecdote compared to the greater picture I'm sensing here--once again, both for Ornette Coleman and John Zorn. So I'm gonna have to do my own research elsewhere, I'm afraid... I'm still giving a 3/5 grade to *Spy vs Spy* according to the purposes of this list of "essential" albums (translating to a 8/10 grade for more general purposes--5+3). Because I feel like the record's global score is unfairly low, given what it really is and the sort of audience it aims at. Yet I can't argue with the innocent listeners who have been confronted to the album without having the slightest contextual elements in hand to understand the global works of the artists who originated this music, in one way or another. Which is why I don't feel like it's necessary to include this LP is a general list of "essential" albums. Let potentially interested people come to it through other (and longer) paths. Exposing it like this, without any preliminary caution or explanation, is only exposing it to ridicule from the masses. Which is pretty unfair. Number of albums left to review: 417 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 269 Albums from the list might* include in mine later on: 142 Albums from the list I won't include in mine (many others are more essential to me): 178 (including this one).

Its John Zorn. Dont know what I was expecting and I was still bored.

Ummmm yeah, so that just happened. I feel like my eardrums were violently assaulted by crap and will never be the same again. Sucks so bad. No wonder everybody else hates it too.

God god awful

I like this in theory but I'm not going to listen to it again

Is not longer available on Spotify, was unable to listen to it

Finally, my prayers for one of the insanely weird and inaccessible albums from the low rated list have been answered! This is jazz on acid. Not acid jazz, jazz on acid. It does bother me that Coleman himself is not included, and I would cut this album to make room for one of his, but I would cut other albums first. It’s just insane and brimming with energy, too, especially the drums and sax. I can tell why people dislike this one, but I love it.

I mean I guess I should have known punk jazz was a thing. Music like this feels like it's to be experienced, and not enjoyed. Two drummers in a band is always intense, and on this album just the beginning of chaos.

this is one of the worst things i've ever listened to in my life

well, they tried something different and while it's not particularly good or enjoyable, it's still a way more interesting inclusion in the overall 1001 list than the ninth fuckin' Neil Young album or whatever. I liked how about 22 minutes in, the album got much more listenable. I could swear I heard bits of the hawaii five-o theme in there too... interesting. favorites: I'm not currently looking at the track list but I think it was called like feet music or some shit? what the fuck haha

Crazy and infuriating, but occasionally a nice melody or rhythm shines through. I was expecting more spy music. YT link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zCHB5LLPQ3s

I had no idea what to make of this! Not really my thing tbh... chaos total chaos! Sorry I still don't get jazz

I just think it's complete nonsense. NONSENSE NONSENSE NONSENSE.

Interesting and weird, but the novelty wore off after about 5-10 minutes. Still, happy to know that this exists. I would have never known if not for this book.

- Hey! The first album I've gotten that I'd literally never heard of before! It's also not available on Spotify! This is a deep cut, is what I'm saying. - John Zorn is a name that's familiar to me, but I've never heard his music. Ornette Coleman I have delved into on occasion, though he's an artist whose work I tend to respect more than love. - So, as an experiment, I thought I'd try to reconstruct the tracklist of this on Spotify with Ornette Coleman's original recordings. See how they compare with Zorn's covers. Spotify's missing a couple of the Ornette tracks (like Feet Music and Space Church), but putting together the stuff they DO have, the playlist is about 1 hour 45 minutes. "Spy Vs. Spy" is 41 minutes. Zorn really must've cut these compositions to the bone. - Here's a good thing I'll say: the drums are immaculately produced. They just THWACK in a really satisfying way. - Here's a negative thing: this is just noise to me. I truly don't get it. I accept that it's probably going over my head, that Zorn may be operating on a level I just can't comprehend. But 15 minutes in this is just a bunch of sounds. Every track is the same. There are no dynamics. Everything is at a 10 all the time, in chaos, in volume, in speed. I'm sure some people like that! And that's great! But oh boy am I finding it unpleasant. - I'd be interested to know the reasoning behind putting this in the 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. I mean, I'm guessing the answer is "a bunch of people who contributed to the book like it." But a quick glance at its Wikipedia shows little critical activity; 2 reviews, one of which seems to have a lot of qualms with it. It doesn't seem to be a particularly revered classic. Though I'm not a free jazz aficionado, so maybe I'm wrong. - Okay, "Ecars" and "Feet Music" are good. There's like, a groove to these, kinda, if you look really hard! It's not a lot, but it's enough to ground the chaos and give you something to latch onto. - Okay, so this actually picks up a lot in the back half. Instead of trying to obliterate any sense of melody and rhythm, Zorn and crew start allowing for moments of tunefulness to offset the chaos, and it makes the whole thing a lot more interesting. - Still not really my thing, but a very interesting curio nonetheless. Glad to have listened to it, even if I liked it more in theory than practice. - Great fucking album art.

I fear I'm going to sound like I'm damning with faint praise here, but I'd most likely take this over another 60s/70s generic psych-pop album. It's got a fire under its ass, that's for certain. After the initial shock wears off, and you really pay attention, you can tell these songs are just... songs played at 3x the speed. Fast. Almost a reckless abandon to it all. It's cool, it's a total freak out. Favorite track: "Peace Warriors"

It was an interesting listening experience, and I didn't hate it, but I don't think I ever need to listen to it again.

Honestly just bizarre. Not really something I would listen to normally but kind of glad I listened to it this time. Added to playlist: not on Spotify

not my kind of jazz

idk this shit wasn't even on spotify lmao

traumatising deja vu

3.6 - On the syllabus of some college "Jazz Appreciation" seminar, I imagine this record would be assigned as an optional listening activity. There'd be an asterisk next to the title with an explanation that the university owns only one copy and it's shelved within some forgotten basement archive. If I had taken this course, I'd treat this optional assignment as an opportunity to suck up to my professor during office hours ("Professor, how do I make sense of this album within the free jazz movement??") The first half of this record sounds like violence - like watching a conveyer belt full of live puppies being dropped into a meat grinder, or experiencing a high-speed train derailment upon an active volcano. Somewhere around the middle, the vibe relaxes to a frantically-paced bebop. I think I actually like this?

A jazz combo falls down the world's longest flight of stairs, then sets up and starts jamming on the mezzanine.

Damn even if it's bot easy to listen that i love it

Pretty chaotic energy in this one, not a lot to love for me personally aside from some generally nice drum action

Weird as hell but strangely infectious! Don’t know what it says about me that I preferred this to any other jazz album I’ve had generated for me in the past 10 months, but I did. It’s fun and interesting and made me want to wiggle like a worm.

Whoa. Undeniably frenetic, chaotic, manic. I wasn't sure if this, 494 albums in, would be the first album I couldn't sit the whole way through (Roots by Sepultura was the only other contender). However, once it calmed down, there were some redeeming features. The later tracks were pretty listenable to, the experimental nature of them notwithstanding. I can understand the shade being thrown the way of this album, and whilst I probably won't listen again, I am glad I experienced it.

Literally just noise

Because I had to go to YouTube to listen to Spy vs Spy, this ended up being a hilarious listening experience: Every 7 minutes or so, the completely uncommercial free jazz squall on this record was interrupted by YouTube ads, as if to say, “This atonal jazz nightmare acid trip was brought to you by 1-800-FLOWERS.” There was also a commercial for schizophrenia medication, which felt like an extremely cynical attempt at targeted marketing on YouTube’s part.

This album will make you feel like a normie. If you didn't think you had limits, meet your maker. Bold move of Zorn to start off with the 3 most chaotic tracks where even after so many listens, I can barely discern any rhyme or rhythm to anything anyone is doing, not just as a collective team, but even on their own. After that, however, gets a bit more accessible and you can start to see the appeal. I think "Enfant" is an excellent example of how all the instruments interplay with each other. Zorn was heavily inspired by the short rampant nature of hardcore, and it certainly shares the spirit, often feeling like it's releasing tension and emotion, not necessarily for the sake of itself. There is melody to be found here. There is purpose, and there is teamwork, but it's rare yet welcomed with open arms. "Feet Music" for example has very gothic undertones with its slow and heavy drum beat and dark mood. I don't think this album does what it aimed to achieve very well. I do find much of it to be failed improv, and I think the only reason why I'm biased toward certain tracks is just because I could make a groove out of it, and I wouldn't appreciate them as much alone. Yes, Zorn is a very talented musician and there's a lot of genius here, and since it's not repetitive by any means and full of noise, I'm sure you could train your ears to like this record, or at least if you're used to Zorn's style in general. But at that point, it feels like you're sucking up to him more than he deserves. I do believe this is a good example of avant-garde jazz to experience, and thus a worthy entry on this list, although Naked Gun would certainly be a better candidate for allowing mainstream audiences to understand the appeal a bit better. But the effort and talent is there, and I can't give it too much shit, especially since I can find new things to like on each listen. Favorites: Good Old Days, Enfant, Cars, Feet Music, Space Church

20 Minuten Kakophones Saxophon, dann teils melodisch/rythmisch interessant.

if jazz and punk had an illegitimate bastard child - this would be that bastard child

Chaotic speed jazz. I dislike.

have to find version off spotify

It was not music. The only cool thing is the album title.

Utter garbage. Sounds like a middle school band warming up. Nobody is listening to anyone else, they're just trying to make the loudest noise. That's not music. It's angering. Someone needs to confiscate Zorn and Berne's saxophones. Those poor instruments are being abused and need to be saved. I had to break this album up across three days just to get through it because I could only handle about 15 minutes of the chaotic noise before I had to take a break. I hate this. I hate every minute of it. I hate that it's on this list and I hate that I had to give it my time.

Very avant-garde stuff, the description as jazz from the perspective of hardcore punk is very apt. I think this was more fun for the artists to make than it is for listeners to sit through. I added one more star because they are clearly virtuoso saxophonists.

unbearable listen 🔥🔥🔥it’s cool but it’s just a bunch of covers. if you’re going to subject me to free jazz at least give me ornette coleman himself and not some dick rider i’ve never heard of.

I have no idea what to say. This was utterly unlistenable, super speed jazz grindcore. Just ... an to the senses. But unlike some of the albums on this list, it definitely isn't boring. It's sort of shockingly awful, and there is a lot of musical talent making it this terrible to experience. I will actively avoid hearing it again for the rest of my life. But at the same time I'm glad I gave it a once listen. It's impossible to rate but let's go with 3/5 because it's interesting.

Despite the fact that I like Ornette Coleman, I was set to not like this album, since it's difficult to reinterpret the work of such a distinctive artist. I think what makes this album really work is the drums, which help bring focus to the chaos of each song. The drums thunder throughout and it makes everything seem much more coherent. I will say that the tone on the bass can be a little muzak-y for my taste, but it doesn't do much to harm the overall sound of the album 4/5

The scorching hot tomato from my toasted sandwich burnt my mouth whilst listening to this. I don't know which experience I enjoyed more. I don't mind the whole wall of noise thing, within the context of a song. But not for 40 relentless minutes. I know people say art needs to be challenging at times, but you wouldn't go to a restaurant because it had a challenging menu. You go because the mojitos are nice.

Can't listen 1

It’s cool stuff that I’m glad exists. Works especially well for things like soundtracks. But listening to a whole album all the way through is a bit much

Highlights: "Broadway Blues," "Space Church," "WRU," "Ecars" It's some combination of Coleman's craft and the way the giant room echo multiplies the heavy dueling parts that save this from provocateur saminess. It can be exhilarating, but maybe not groundbreaking by 1989. It's more expository of something groundbreaking. Again -- again -- where is Coleman's Shape of Jazz to Come on this list? Albert Ayler? Sun Ra? What is it about these editors that they have to filter jazz taste through rock and pop tie-ins? It's just insulting to their readers.

This album is the soundtrack to a panic attack. It's as if a bunch of incredibly talented jazzbos got together and all played their instruments as loud and fast as possible without any regard for what anybody else was playing. Everyone is good at what they do, but doing it together is just an assault on the ears and it makes me very anxious. I could barely get through this one.

Jesus christ no, why

I got through about half..I just couldn’t. Thrash drums and screaming sax in a way I can’t follow or ‘get’

Challenging, yes, but entertaining. The speed, intensity, and dexterity with which these talented musicians play is CRAZY. Not good BBQ music, sure, but I'm glad I heard it and would be open to hearing it again.

No nyt oli kyllä kunnon jazz mäiskettä :D Aika helvetin kaoottista mutta silti kyllä oudon hyvä

Unable to listen - not available on Spotify. Rated on expectation.

This is either genius or awful and I am not smart enough to decide which. So I guess the question i need to ask myself is... did i enjoy listening to it? And again, I don't really know how to answer that. The first track was like a worldwind of noise, i felt like my brain wanted to leave my head, not sure if it was in a positive way or not. Then a few tracks in at 'Good Old Days' there was a run of somewhat enjoyable and melodic noise occurring for a while, which eventually just mushed up into one big lump. I feel like I've become less intelligent after listening to this. I am questioning what melody is, what music do i actually like? IS this music? Is this noise? I just don't know. Am I better having listened? The album isn't on spotify or amazon music currently, so i had to find it on youtube, i may not revisit this again, is that because of what it sounds like or because it's not handy to stream? I just don't know. I don't know anything, i don't know how to rate it, i don't know if i like it? is it a 1 or is it a 5? it can't be a 3, because it is not middle of the road. As someone born with a heart defect, i could imagine having a heart attack while 'Word for Bird' played. I think I'm going to give it a 2/5, but it could be a 10/5, i just don't know anymore

Interesting because it has bright moments but overall is a little busy for my tastes

Ich mag Jazz, aber dieses Album hat mich nicht abgeholt.

Ninguna canción disponible en Spotify. Imposible calificar

Even this was a bit out there for me. I’d have preferred just an Ornette Coleman album.

Preferred the game.

Waaa… I braces myself for this record being often at the bottom of the rankings but whoa this actually blew me away. Death Metal but jazz … the drum sound is earth shatteringly awesome and amidst the swirling chaos is order and precision. Not for everyone I guess but I loved it.

Well that was something. plus ca avancait, mieux j'appréciais. highlight Feet Music. But hey, drugs were implied for sure 4/10

Two alto sax, two drums, one bass: John Zorn + Ornette Coleman = awesome!

Wow. I couldn’t find on Spotify or Apple Music. Tracked it down on YouTube. When I started I thought someone was playing a joke on me. Sounded like a cat fight. I listened a while longer and by another 20 minutes I started to think it was brilliant. Then about 10 minutes later thought it was awful again. This one is a ride.

I like that you can at least hear the Ornette come through. Probably not revisiting this one.

Absolutely joyous.

I just didn’t get it.

This was very unique, and kind of awesome. The only way it is that, though, is knowing that Zorn and friends went in to record a jazz album as if it was a hardcore album. Otherwise, this is just a bunch of noise.

You t was fine but I’m not really that into jazz. It all sounded the same to me

I've never had an album give me literal anxiety before. Like what the hell did I just listen to. That being said, this album is either a 1 or a 5, and there is no in-between. Screw this, I'm giving it a 4. Does it sound like children messing around with random sounds and bashing on drums? Yes, yes, it does. Jazz is awesome.

Ecars, Feet Music, Broadway Blues, Zig Zag and Mob Job. The last 5 songs are great but the first 10 is a cluttered piece of a trump diaper. Two sax and two drums do not sound good.

pros: aggressive drums, second half adds interesting sounds to the noise. I did need to hear this. cons: first half sounds like random noise, the good parts are too short except on good ole days. songs with good parts: good ole days, feet music, broad way blues, space church, zig zag, mob job

Didn't know this kind of hardcore jazz existed but I'm a big fan. Love the drums and overall chaos. Enjoyed the whole album but the first ten songs were my favorite. 4.5/5 FS: Good Ole Days, Enfant

Hard to enjoy this style of freeform jazz. It is very complex. I like it more than many other albums on this list though. 2.5/5

I found this fascinating but there's little chance I'd ever re-listen :)

As much as I want to be hip enough to do so I cannot handle noisy jazz

Not enjoyable

That was certainly something

This shit is off the hook. Amazing guitars. I actually like this better than Ornate Coleman.

When art is so confusing only a few people enjoy it then it’s hard to consider it special. You shouldn’t have to be a jazz or music scholar to understand what is going on here but it seems that way. The free jazz composition of playing impromptu may work with one person playing at a time but when multiple people with the same instrument do it then it sounds like this chaotic mess that it is. Call it what you want but enjoyable is not one of those words. 1.7/10

Yeah I hate John Zorn

Avant-garde Jazz that was not my sound at all.

- Jazz on crack honestly - Couldn't find it on Spotify, L - Entertaining, but would definitely not go back to

- Frantic, aggressive, free jazz - Sometimes the dueling saxophones reach a nice groove, other times it’s chaos - Disclaimer: only listened to 30 minutes of it

Azz: sassofono e batteria per 41 minuti è troppo. È troppo anche per 5 minuti.

10am - too much 10pm - loved it This is not background music

This was pretty remarkable - I don't know that I'll listen to it regularly, but it was quite a feat to take one of the most experimental jazz performers and somehow make it even more out there.

Jazzy noise

More intense workout disguised as music is impossible. Pretty dense but also pretty special interest. 2.5

I....um...I....oh god it just keeps going, why? What did I do to deserve this. Am I supposed to hate it? Is is supposed to be some sort of test to see if I'll listen to the whole thing? It's clearly more abstract and important then Kid Rock, but I'm still going to have to hard pass on this.

Not a fan at all.

Jazz caótico. No se distingue del ruido sin más. Un 1.

Jazz rápido.

This was awful. It sounded like a group of people who have never played instruments before went into a room and tried them out. There is no reason for this to be on this list. If I could give a lower rating, I would.

I kind of knew what I was getting into here, I've dabbled in some of Coleman's more well known albums (The Shape of Jazz To Come, Free Jazz, This Is Our Music etc) and once owned a cassette of Zorn's Naked City from back when I used to just read the reviews in Rolling Stone and Spin and buy music sight unseen (sound unheard?) Some of those albums turned into discoveries of some all time favorite bands and artists. They Might Be Giants self titled debut and Camper Van Beethoven's Our Beloved Revolutionary Sweetheart are couple of examples, Naked City really isn't. I liked some of it to an extent but it really wasn't my thing. The Coleman stuff though I can honestly say I've enjoyed over the years, I'm no expert but free jazz doesn't just sound like a bunch of noise to me as it apparently does judging from many of the reviews here. Maybe the negative reviews lowered my expectations a little but I did enjoy this. Am I gonna put it on during a party? It would have to be the hippest party I've ever been to so probably not but if a couple of like-minded friends came over to toke I might see what they thought.

0/5 They say that "Those who can do, and those who can't, teach." This guy should have been a teacher. It was such auto-musical-erotic-ego-stroking-bullshit. Even Spotify wouldn't host it, and they have every Pitbull single!!!! 🤣

Jesus fucking Christ what a pile of runny horse shit. No wonder it isn't on Spotify: IT'S NOT MUSIC!!!

Interesting jazz album. Liked the layering of saxes.

Phew that is some intense trumpet screeching. And the drumming. I'm exhausted just listening to it. I can't say I'm a free jazz aficionado but I can see a place for it in 1950s Otto Preminger films.

Oef, deze was vrij pittig om te luisteren. Wel heel ongestructureerd en chaotisch. Toch ook wel cool bij vlagen.

Good jazz

Ikke tilgængeligt

I like John Zorn, but why this album? Why not Naked City or Bar Kokhba? Anyway, it was delightfully chaotic and pleasantly unpredictable. "Good Old Days", "Enfant", the playful "Ecars", the romping "Feet Music" and the epic finale of "Mob Job" are my favs here. 4 Oh's out of 5 Yeah's

Truly a heartbreaking album. Story goes that a recording room filled with Jazz musicians were about to record and all suffered fatal heart attacks. They immediately started to blow air into their instruments and flail around near the drums trying to signal to the people outside the recording room to call 911 for help. Unfortunately, the sound engineering thought this was Free Jazz and kept recording. This album is a product of that fateful day.

I had to put this off for a few days - it came up at the weekend and there were too many people around the house for me to listen to it without having to explain why exactly I was listening to *THAT*. It's full on, that's for sure. The opening track in particular is really quite difficult to get through. It does get a bit better after that - a bit like how the pain from a dental abscess declines once the antibiotics kick in a bit. That's unfair. There are some decent moments on here and the sax players certainly know what they're doing. Most of those moments come when no one's thinking too hard about drumming I imagine. I doubt I'd listen to it again, but it's not entirely without hope and, hell, it's better than My Bloody bloody Valentine or T Rex, so it's a three.

Not on spotify

Well, that was certainly an experience. I've never heard of John Zorn or Ornette Coleman before, and I'm not a big jazz listener, so this album was pretty much lost on me. I did enjoy a few of the songs though: "Good Old Days," "Feet Music," and "Broad Way Blues" were the standouts to me, and everything else pretty much sounded the same. This album was different from the few other jazz albums I've encountered on this list, but it just wasn't for me.

I want to give this less than one star. Ouch.

TIDAL didn’t have Spy vs Spy but I listened to his top tracks and love it. Brought visions of the pink panther.

Chaotic, frenetic, and unable to finish the album.

Maniacal in the best way. Not for everyone but I'm glad this was on the list, I've got a new avant-garde jazz catalog to dive into now.

Had to get this from someone

This is fucking mental, I love it. The longer it goes on the more I love it. Hilarious that I got this the day after Adele. Obviously it starts off sounding like a jazz band falling down the stairs, but then you adjust. Kind of glad for the Spotify fail as it forced me to listen on headphones, and you can really pick out the intricacies. Can't tell because YouTube smooshed it all together but the song I think is Good Old Days is absolutely banging. Several more bangers later on but I've fully lost track by then. Thrash jazz, fuck yeah baby!

Well well well, this album! I knew a little bit about it going in; namely that it sounds like a high school band warming up, turned into an album. I can understand why anyone would shut this off immediately. The chaos was anxiety-inducing for me at first; I felt uneasy as I pulled out of my driveway and started my commute. But hear me out...it actually gets better. The chaos winds down; a couple instruments start playing together, and something resembling music rises from the ashes of the first 10 minutes. I started wondering if the initial chaos was simply to make you that much more grateful to hear actual music, that it sounds amazing by default? You might not like having freezing cold water dumped on you, but you would love it if you'd just been pulled out of scalding water. I can't hate this album for that. It's an experience I'll surely remember!

Just pure chaos idk who sits down and listens to this I'm sure its technically impressive but damn its genuinely headache inducingly unlistenable.

Listened to part of the album. I thought it was just noise, definitely an acquired taste.

What a cacophony of insanity, which seems to never slow down the whole way through. And now of course I’m curious about the original, which somehow inspired this remake.

oof not for me

Que coño es esto Turbio y raro,el disco no se puede escuchar,pero he buscado cosas de este señor y es mu raro todo. La resaca no ayuda (PSP)

Lolol!! I'm not sure what kind of mood you'd need to be in to listen to this. You couldn't need to concentrate because it takes over as a wall of sound. I guess it's interesting to listen to to spot any patterns or rhythm in the total chaos. Maybe you could use it to unwind tension or anger?? Weirdly enough there's a Radiohead track "The National Anthem" that ends like this so I guess i has influenced others?

I was dreading this but it was actually really good. Idk why it’s so poorly rated.

Not in Spotify

This is really wild. Not something I can see myself listening to regularly but I dig it. Super chaotic and punky which is an interesting take on jazz that I haven't really delved into much. I love the drumming in particular.

Whoa, that's got some real frenetic stuff on it! I definitely appreciate what the artists are doing here, but it's a bit much for my ears.

Well well well...Once you make it past the opening onslaught, there's a lot to like here. It's certainly unusual and definitely intentionally off-putting. It's interesting though, would definitely listen to it again, not very often though. Looking forward to reading some of the other reviews for this one!

Not on spotify, not going looking.

John Zorn is a criminal for this, a massive musical terrorist unchained

This opens with an absolute cacophony of noise. And it really doesn't get better... but you do get better at listening to it.

Absolutely anxiety inducing less than a minute in. He certainly is doing his own thing and I—kinda—like it, but also I one hundred percent understand how someone wouldn't. It sounds like every musician was given sheet music for the song and told to just get through it as fast as they fucking could. I don't think I'll ever listen to this again, but it was surely interesting to hear what thrash and jazz would sound like together. In that sense, he did a great job, but music is no good if you can't enjoy it and I can't imagine where this could be enjoyed or who would ever seriously put this on. The timing of the drums rarely match up with the brass, which is not necessarily a bad thing, but it isn't done particularly well on this album. Also gets a tad repetitive. It looks like people are really hating on this album and all I can say is that I get it, at least more than most people it seems. 3/5

This is some "in your face" - jazz music. The start was hard to get through, but once you get there the songs get better (or you get used to it). This is far too experimental for me, but I enjoy this more than listening to any hiphop album we've had so far. 2.5/5

I guess the motto for the first half is that art isn’t supposed to look/sound nice, it’s supposed to make you feel something. Very interesting album, love that we had it, probably won’t listen again.

CHAOOOOOOOOOOS, not in a good way

The first half is a solid 1, way too much noise. The second half of this album was just listenable enough to appreciate the musical ability and earn an extra star but is was very close.

Way too experimental for me but has some nice moment every once in a while

Jesus Christ.

Possibly the worst one I’ve listened/been subjected to so far

Some people said listen to the end and you would be surprised. I was. It is surprising this ever got released, ever got onto this site and I ever had to listen to it. Not least until the end. For the UK people amongst us, this is the joke band from Jazz Club on the Fast Show.

Bottled insanity. Not sure whether I like it, but I'm damn sure that it exists in the world. That someone said "how about Ornette Coleman...but hardcore?" and then executed this notion has helped me to love the human race just a little more.

Not supported on spotify

Avant-garde experimental jazzy is never good.

Difficult one to like. Free Jazz is so unlikable to the average user. I have no clue if this is good or bad....

Andy told me not to listen to this and I trust him

Absolutely ferocious, one of the noisiest projects I've ever heard. The drums in particular sound fucking mega. I love that it's so relentlessly aggressive for the first 22 minutes and then just suddenly pivots to the swaggering groove of Feet Music, then just back to 100 again

very mediocre experience - free jazz is fine by me as a genre, and I appreciate its value - but this is all over the place. too tame in parts, and too wild in others. there’s just so many more free jazz albums I’d rather listen to than this.

Buckle up you chuckle fucks we are headed down to the fifth layer of hell as we experience anger in music form. Normally I like jazz but not in the context of being held captive in the sunny resort town of Guantanamo Bay in the off season. I can only imagine the sort of people who would intentionally subject themselves to this with enjoyment would own an assortment of gimp masks and the number one item on their to-do list is a bit of dick and ball torture.

I'll just start by saying, there are no innovations of thrashcore and grindcore, I mean wtf!! lol On the other hand this was not as terrible as it may have been, it has its moments and you can hear the commitment to their music even if it’s pretentious and not that good. I'll give it a couple of stars because I was able to finish it lol. That feet piece was a nice rest in the middle of the storm. Who of you uploaded the record to YT and then blocked the comments? lol

93 / 1069 It grew on me, deserved a second listen. Went from half a star to 3.5. A lot going on, very interesting, need to check out some of his other stuff.

Jesus fucking christ. I like me some Jazz, I like me some punk, I like me some experimental music. But the three combined?!? This should be interesting! Despite being 17 tracks and each song having an average of about 2 minutes, this thing flies by in a heartbeat. I can't follow the music for shit, even with regular jazz i face this problem. But this gives me a good laugh. It just sounds like one big flurry of let's play 100000000000 notes in a second and sound as ugly as we possibly can. Ecars sounds like an actual jazz song though, thumbs up. I appreciate the effort, but yeah, this ain't my bag. Key tracks: Word For Bird, Peace Warriors, Feet Music, no just kidding, I just like the titles. 4 out of 10

a jazz band but much more violent than normal jazz

Lopetin kolmannen biisin kohdalla

Hengästyttävä pläjäys. Vaikea saada noin kompleksista setistä ite irti, kun musa ottaa susta kaiken irti

wait, why does this fuck? I would NEVER listen to this in my car or anything like that, but it's a cool piece of shit.

Nothing against Jazz, but this is just Drums and Sax on speed. Utterly horrible. 1/5

Would love to hear the author's justification for this one.

No thank you. Album cover fucks though.

This is not what I had planned for the weekend.

It's strange to hear Napalm Death and grindcore in general being cited as an influence and inspiration for a jazz artist tribute album. It's also interesting that the folks at 1001 did not choose any Ornette Coleman albums for their list, despite his winning the Pulitzer prize for music. So I took a listen to some of the original Coleman tracks that John Zorn covered. They are much more listenable, and needless to say, much longer.

Ornette Coleman's brand of free jazz can be described as "challenging" to listen to. Having John Zorn, the self-proclaimed enfant terrible of American avant garde and improvised music cover Coleman's work is sure to raise eyebrows. I'm surprised that 1,001 included this album from him, I would have thought they would have added something a bit more accessible such as his brilliant The Big Gundown which covers the music of the legendary Ennio Morricone, or even The Naked City. Both of those albums showcase the brilliance of the musicians and are less cacophonic and dissonant. If you're a bit adventurous and interested in something more experimental I would suggest giving those a listen. I note that this is one of the lowest ranked albums on this site, and understandably so because it won't be everyone's cup of tea. But if you dissect the music and listen with an open mind what they've achieved is pretty impressive. There are only 5 musicians here, but the two sax players, two drummers and one bassist create a holy hell assault on the senses. This is not my favourite Zorn album, but since its probably the only entry from him, I'll give him an extra point for audacity and originality so he gets three stars.

it's too hectic for my taste, but i can tell theyre talented.

I like the same. But this is too frantic for easy listening. I appreciate its existence but won't be listening to it much more to be honest

To much for me

John Wick in a pig farm.

A challenging listen. Part genius, part endurance test, part Stockholm Syndrome, part jazz band falls down staircase.

find the tune, win a prize

It’s jazz

This is chaotic evil!!!

First half is nearly unlistenable. Second half is a bit better, especially \"Feet Music\". Not my style at all.

Spy vs. Spy confirms my long standing belief that there are very few Zorn albums that are easy to listen to. This is some blistering avant-garde jazz, played at tempos that would make the most talented hardcore punk band blush. However, this just isn’t as well executed as other Zorn albums like Naked City or Kristallnacht. Not bad, but there is better stuff in this lane.

3/5. Saw a description of this album that was “jazz in the form of hardcore-punk” and that is the most accurate one I could find. It’s honesty fairly enjoyable and interesting but not a repeatable listen without feeing like your head is gonna explode.

I know this is one of those lowest rated albums, so pretty keen to hear just how shit it is lol. Ok could only find a few songs on YouTube, and yeah it's pretty anti music. 2/5.

Didn't hate it like I thought I would. There are plenty of moments where you can actually grasp a tangible melody. It all sounded fine - sort of standard fare for jazz records by this point. But there are definitely times where it is all a bit much. If they got rid of the ridiculously high tempo or the two drums playing it once, it just would've been more enjoyable. Also having a very painful earache before and during listening was not particularly helpful either. I'll give a 3 but it could easily dip into the boundary above or below for me. A decent record.

Completely insane. Compelling, true, but almost unlistenable. 2 stars.

??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

Abrasive

1. Where are the jazz police when you need them?

Typical not-quite-chaos of OC, hard to listen to

Aaaarghhh! Kill me now!

Dit is een van de ergste dingen die ik in tijden heb gehoord. Dit is muziek om door in een gekkenhuis te belanden. Ik kan werkelijk niet geloven dat iemand dit als beste album indient.

I found this baffling, intense, gut wrenching, and cool as hell

Not on Spotify, big L because it sounded cool

what did i just hear

Chaos! That's the first thing that comes to mind during the opening track of Spy Vs Spy, an aural assault that continues through the album. It reminds me of before band class when everyone blows on their instrument independent from one another, trying to drown each other out. If you made a movie about a character that goes on an extended bender, then their life spirals out of control, freaking out until they die, this would be the "music" for that soundtrack! I was going to stop listening during the first track, but the masochist in me kept me from turning it off. Bad decision!

Some of this isn't godawful, but most of it is.

Pretentious. Artsy. Crap!!!!!!!

Couldn't make it past 14 mins.

yikes. if this is considered jazz then i am not a fan. this sound was worse than nails on a chalkboard. this is not music 🤨🤨🤨

what the fkng hell was definitely down for some cool jazz, not this absolute and utter mess. Would - or could - have been amusing if there was one 45 second passage like this to start the album, then it settled into something listenable, but it does not - it's a chaotic violent garbage plate of musicians who might know their jazz but they play it like they've been on coke for 48 hours and in between have been fed pixie stix. Or the creatures from the movie Gremlins but sped up to 16x the speed and insanity. What an exhausting disaster. I tortured myself and made it through. This is unquestionably in the small runoff for worst albums I've ever heard. 1/10 1 star.

Un asalto a los sentidos y es como si el jazz fuese pasado por una trituradora metálica

this is pretty chaotic for me but giving credit where credit is due, these are talented musicians

Not for me

This was intense! Interesting and exciting but 40 minutes of it may be just too much at once for me. 3.4

Mad. Avant-garde jazz that I admired more than I loved..

Sounded like a jazz band falling down the stairs.

When my mom complains that all jazz sounds made up, this is what she must be referring to. I love it

Heard it before?: No Enjoy it?: Unless it’s in the ambience to fill silence I just don’t care for jazz so no Favourite song: Didn’t have one

First time listening to avantgarde jazz.Even though it is not my style I enjoyed it. Great find.

"The album itself approaches free jazz from the perspective of hardcore punk, particularly taking note of the contemporary innovations of thrashcore and grindcore." aka a bloody racket.

Good album.

It sounded like a bunch of 1st graders got released into a room full of jazz instruments and were graded on who could make the loudest noises. There were moments of harmony far and few between, I will slide this though as a 2. Could only find this album on YouTube.

This was really uncomfortable to listen to. Feels like an "emperor has no clothes situation" so kudos to Zorn for getting away with it but it's a big "no thanks" from me. To make things worse I just listened to a Jimmy Smith album so my jazz expectations were too high for this noise. I am having a medium good time trying to imagine someone who actually likes this album and is trying to tell me how their favorite song goes. I can picture the panic in their eyes as they let out their third squeal in ten seconds and realize exactly how untenable their position is.

Well, I made it through the whole thing! I skimmed some of the reviews beforehand and was understandably apprehensive haha. At first, I found it a little too chaotic for my liking. The energy was always super intense. The album grew on me, though. Either that or the second half of the record is actually more digestible to the average listener. "Good Old Days" and "The Disguise" were really great. So was "Feet Music". The rest I'd either actively avoid or just wouldn't go out of my way to listen to, but this is far from the worst album on this project.

Doesn't exist on Apple Music

This is an extreme musical example of the Marmite principle - and I wanted to slather it all over my morning bitterly toast, then lick the knife. Granted, you can’t listen to this all day, everyday: it’s an assault on your brain and ears which doesn’t leave you much choice other than to turn the volume firmly down then rip off the knob or jump right in and let the chaos wash over you. But. It’s chaos built on a foundation of incredible talent and musicianship. Two saxophone, two drum kits and a bass guitar all improvising and able to remain in some Free Jazz hive mind state. Most of the album is so perilously on the edge of descending and unraveling into an inaudible dirge - but they some how keep enough tension between them to keep walking along the tightrope. However there are also examples of more traditional harmonies and jazz rhythms (Ecars, Feet Music & Mob Job) to show that these are a group of musicians right at the top of thier game. And fuck me, rather this than Oasis, The Manics or The Stones. At least they won’t die wondering “What if…?”

You can hear the effort that goes into making these sounds with those instruments. As a counter-point as to what music 'is' vs. 99% of material on 1001's albums, i think it's inclusion on the list is justified. Sure it's not easy listening, but bloody hell do I wish I could thrash a drum kit/sax/trumpet like that.

The incessant pitch of the alto sax took me back to a time filled with undiagnosed PND - I won't be listening again no matter how talented the musicians

Sounded like if a saxophone played the drill instructor in Full Metal Jacket

Had some moments when it was less manic, but this is way too avant-garde for me

This gave me a stroke...

Ghastly.

I see what they were doing and its value to the world of music as a whole. Punk jazz does seem like it'd be cool. Honestly though it sounded like 40 minutes of a raccoon playing on a trash can lid.

Really not a fan. Couldn't make it all the way through.

1 star for not being on spotify also FUCK THIS LMAO I LOVE JAZZ BUT THIS IS AN ATROCITY

You know what? Fuck you. 3 stars. After reading some of the more informative reviews here and putting this LP in context, I'm willing to give it a decent rating for being completely different than anything else I've heard on this list. While the first half is an absolute auditory mess (and I would bet more than a few of the people here don't even listen for more than 5 minutes), the back half shapes up into some pretty energetic improv work that had my toe tapping. It may not be an easy listen and it does take some understanding, but at least it's not another tepid Britpop or Bob Dylan album

Bat shit crazy but wonderful

Bonkers, but joyously so. I'm so glad I found this!

I'm glad that someone made this and it exists. I don't ever want to listen to it again. There's something about it, like when you go to an art gallery and see some pretentious shit and think, "My toddler could do that." But there is some subtle difference. This is the musical equivalent of Tate Modern finger painting.

Initially I wasn't going to listen to this as it wasn't available on Spotify, and I couldn't be fussed with YouTube ads, but was persuaded to I'd give it a try... and wow! On the surface it's audacious, annoying, violent, batshit bonkers, some kind of avant-garde post-punk jazz! But within that utter chaos there's something beautiful, a raw talent. The more I thought about it, the more affection I felt towards it. 3.5

Can't find this easily on Amazon. I'm not going to spend all day looking. After reading about it, this seems like one of the author's pet albums. I don't care even at all. Would give it 0 if I could.

Not a fan.

I guess it deserves credit for conjuring images of the series I used to read in MAD Magazine. But it sounds like a big jazz band conducted by Animal from The Muppets with Animal playing every instrument. At the same time. Without any overdubbing.

It’s like if porno music was angry while high on crack cocaine. Oddly enough, I’m kinda about it.

The drums sound like bullets firing out of a sub machine gun and the trumpets sound like finely tuned squeaking dog toys. I couldn’t differentiate the first three tracks from each other I didn’t mind the fourth track until the last minute then the album continues to fuck up for the remaining half an hour. Maybe like two minutes of this sound would’ve worked at the end of some heavy jazz rock album to send the album off on a confusing bang but 41 minutes is painful. Jazz and punk are both at the opposite ends of the musical spectrum really there’s no similarity between the genres so it doesn’t work; but I appreciate the album and the sound it’s trying so hard to achieve not enough to save it from a 1/5 though which completely deserves to be in the notoriously bad bottom 10 albums.

My parents did it

i mean, i'm impressed by it and its left a mark on me, but fucking hell that is an assault on the senses. stressed me out but still better than any country music and john fucking lennon.

John Zorn has made a work of genius that will transcend the ages. I went into this record completely blind and naive to what music could truly be. This damn incredible soundtrack feels like it has taken my aural virginity. My ears are bleeding for the first time, but it feels so good. My darkest desires have been set in motion, like a runaway train about to meet an explosive crescendo at the bottom of a rocky ravine. My windswept hair has Zorn's semen brushed through it and his dick is hanging out of my slack jaw as I listen in complete awe and adoration. I lust as it slithers its way into my psyche, into my trousers. If I could, I would marry this record so hard, that it would think that it's been fucked sideways by its own grandchild in the back of a station wagon heading 1000 miles an hour into the centre of the sun.

I really enjoyed this! Of course, by enjoyed, I mean I tolerated it. By tolerated it, I mean I'd rather have all of my skin chipped off with a cheese grater, whilst my dad mixes lemon juice with his own urine and pours it onto my raw, skinless body. All the while piranhas bite away at my feet, the piercing shrill of a whistle is blown in my face relentlessly and a montage of my worst ever erection moments is broadcast on giant TV screens to every major city in the world, than ever listen to this ever again.

This is the sound the world makes around me when I have an enormous hangover.

Very much not for me. I can appreciate the talent of the music, but cannot listen to the full album. Sends my ADHD into overdrive.

Yeah, this ain't it, chief.

kansikin jo kertoo, että saksofonimelujazzia. ei toimi mulle.

Tässä on yksi hyvä puoli: rummut eivät swengaa, minkä takia musiikki ei varsinaisesti ärsytä. Itseasiassa ne hakkaavat melkein kuin hardcoressa. Toisaalta torvet kuulostavat erehtymättömästi avant-garde jazzilta, mikä on huono homma. Yhden hitaamman, blues-pohjaisen biisin melkein ymmärsin, koska sen pieni koukkaus formalismiin teki tämän musiikin ylemmyydentuntoisesta ironiasta hetkellisesti lähestyttävämpää. Ansaitsisi ehkä plussan ykkösen perään.

1/17, 6%

First track - is nuts Second track - is also nuts

I hate jazz music

This album is TERRIBLE!!! I personally enjoy listening to most forms of jazz, but free jazz is where I draw the line. The only interesting thing about this album is the cover art.

Its either a 5 or a 1. I do not know what to do with this.

This was a violent assault of unending frantic insane noise. 2 drummers and 2 saxophones competing to be heard over each other. Making it through this was a miracle, though there was a slight tuneful reprieve around 24 minutes.

Fuck off John Zorn. It's not big and it's not clever.