Reviews (page 6 of 15)
Just such a great album throughout. The Real Slim Shady, The Way I Am, and Stan are probably my favorites. Never heard the whole thing throughout, and Kim was horrific but great.
I enjoyed “Stan” and “The Real Slim Shady” but the rest of this is just crude grass angry behavior. I don’t really care for it. This is also during the time in the 2001 rap Adams have skits and I really hate that. Albums are for music. I don’t care about your skits.
Love it. Own it.
Eminem ❤️
A little juvenile perhaps but first half is absurd (Stan’s an all timer) and you do get a sense both of Eminem’s outsider energy and his response to moral handwringing about rap
When I first heard this back at the turn of the millennium I thought it was some sort of novelty record for kids. In a sense, it is. Listening to the whole thing shows it to be nasty, misogynistic, crass and unfunny. Most egregiously of all, it made Dido into an international star. Not stan-tastic.
This is garbage.
A truly brilliant hip hop record. Great production coupled with amazing rhyme schemes and provocative storytelling. The content is provocative and also crass at times but hard to underscore the cultural impact it had on the world. Love him or hate him this album vaulted Eminem into Rap God status. The Way I Am, The Real Slim Shady and Stan are all timers from the catalog. Stan is such an original idea and Kim is a wild concept. I think most Rap are better in the moment; many have limited staying power. Some kid will listen to this in 50 years and it'll be their Dark Side of the Moon.
I'm just not wowed. All I learned about Eminem is that he hates everyone except his wife and daughter (and I'm not even sure about them). Too long, and most of it isn't that great.
I've already given one rap album a "grotesque misogyny" one-star review, but apparently some themes repeat themselves. Why'd I get stuck with this shit for my birthday?
So I’m finding it hard to reconcile why I struggled with this so much when I find Nick Cave’s Murder Ballads - a similarly transgressive album - to be so brilliant I think it lies in the fact that Cave’s work is more firmly in character whereas this feels like it is inspiring/inspired by your 15 year old shit head cousin and nothing more Stan gets it to 3 by itself but I’m not sure there’s much else to this
Solid
All the pearl-clutching on this godforsaken website prove the man's point. He's provocative, he's loud, and he's timeless. The language is a tool to enunciate the message. Focusing solely on it and rendering the art invalid due to its coarseness is wrong. Despite a few bumps on the road (dated ICP diss, bad Sticky Fingaz and Disaster features) the album is still a really great listen nearly thirty years after its release.
I legit cannot believe my parents let me listen to this at age 12 😬 I feel like I shouldn’t listen to it as a 37 year old. But the guy can rap
I haven't looked too deep into the lyrics, but the whole album seems to be about Eminem beefing with his critics, fantasizing about killing his girlfriend due to jealousy or something, and telling faggots to suck his dick. Kinda funny.
It's really interesting to hear songs from 20+ years ago and knowing the context of the artist today, Eminem has matured in many ways over the years (even though I also grew up in the same environment where the F slur was mainly used not in regard to sexuality but just the same as calling someone a bitch). It also odd seeing critisism coming from people aren't even the target demographic (this coming from a black dude who has dated men and women) like jeez man calm down before doing a whole disertation on how someone is inherently evil given one thing the say, research why the say something, music is a form of expression so there is going to be many ways things could be interpreted so the artists actual meaning can be easily changed. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Public Service Announcement 2000 - skit Kill You - 7.5/10: just dragged on; it had solid rapping, but it went on too long. Stan - 10/10: not only did it create a new word to describe people who are too obsessed with celebrities, but also Eminem's storytelling ability on this song is immaculate. I find this song to be ironic, mainly because the song was him trying to tell his fans not to take his lyrics literally, as it was just him expressing random things that came to mind, but in all the reviews of the album, people bring up the content of the lyrics. Also, Thank You by Dido is a banger in and of itself. Paul - skit Who Knew - 8/10, not a bad song by any means, but it's hard to handle the pressure coming right after Stan. The premise of the song is that he was using music to cope with his feelings, and he didn't think he would gain a cult following that would repeat the actions he rapped about. Trying to tell them it's not a good thing is really interesting. Steve Berman - skit The Way I Am - 9/10, it's an excellent single from this record and one of my favorite em tracks. The Real Slim Shady - 10/10. This is a classic, so it's no surprise it's rated so high. He also says, "We can hump dead animals and antelops, then there's no reason a man and another man can't elope." Once again proving that he is not homophobic, he hates everyone equally. Remember Me? - 7/10 it was just ok I'm Back - 8/10, the instrumental alone is a banger. Since Reeve's passing, he needs to find a new dude to rhyme their last name, preferably not Diddy. Mainly because I don't want to hear his name anymore Marshall Mathers - 9/10 see above message for reasoning. Ken Kanuff - skit Drug Ballad - 9/10 fantastic storytelling, but also really enjoy the cadence Eminem uses throughout this song. Amityville - 8/10 Bitch Please II - 10/10, this posse cut is probably one of my favorites out of Ems' discography Kim - 8/10 lowkey kind of goofy, sure the technical ability is there, but are we actually deadass Under The Influence - 9.5/10 iconic song, enjoyable D12 features Criminal - 9/10 great premise of the song, which only serves to say that people shouldn't take his lyrics literally
My best friend in high school refused to listen to anything else other than this album for a year after it came out. Needless to say (and much like the tuna sandwiches I had for lunch every single day in grade school) I'm okay if I never experience it again, even all these years later. Still, based on memory its a pretty good album. I liked the first one better.
I really don’t know how to rate this, because there’s no one else like him and when this came out it was SUCH a moment - that sounds wanky but it’s TRUE, I was there 👵🏻 - but also there are basically no occasions in life or moods I might be in where I’d actually want to listen to this. I’m listening to Kim as I write this. Is this music, or is it something else? I think for me, this is something to spend time with once and never again.
(3)
Eminem is genuinely one of the greatest rappers of all time and an absolute genius when it comes to rhymes. It’s unfortunate that he uses those powers to make music for dudes with poor emotional regulation who blame all of their problems on people not knowing “the real them”. Unfortunately, The Marshall Mathers LP has more of that kind of music than Slim Shady and The Eminem Show. The dude can rap though.
It has some really strong songs but other so not stand my test of time.
Sumt er ansi skemmtilegt og grípandi, en ofbeldislýsingarnar og hómófóbían eru verulega fráhrindandi og ég hef litla löngun til að hlusta á þetta aftur.
It would have been a lot better without the homophobic slurs
I do like a Couple of songs on here, but he’s not really my kinda muzik- did listen though
Yesterday was Kanye and today is Eminem. Entering the 200's has been quite an experience so far. I've never listened to this before. I was working in a behavioral health clinic back when Eminem came to prominence, and many of the kids I worked with would quote his lyrics. I was appalled at the time, and just refused to even listen to any of his songs. This turned out to be both a surprise to me, as well as exactly what I thought it would be. Musically I thought it was great throughout, and some songs like Stan and Kim were amazing lyrically as well as with the emotional response to both. However there were too many songs where violence towards women and homophobia were ever present, and it was just too much. Like with the Kanye album from yesterday, I'm not exactly sure how I'll rate this. I'm leaning toward a three, but truthfully I understand both the fives and ones.
WHAT AN ALBUM!!!! I had already heard some songs from this EP but hadn't listened to it completely. I will definitely listen to it again, what an amazing album!
Not really my thing.
This isn't bad at all, better than I expected, but it gets to a fucking point man where I'm like "I get it"
Great rhymes but yeah a bit anti-feminist…
Uh no. Can’t believe this is what my 10 and 11 year old kids were listening to.
This did not age all that well...
Boy this one is hard to rate in 2025. There's no denying the homophobia and sexism of the late 90s. But there's also no denying how impressive a vocal and lyrical performance this album is. Also impressively open and self reflective.
tbh I kinda worshipped Eminem from the ages of 10-12, then 15-17 (3 years in-between was all punk with a bit of crossover). What to say that hasn't already been said... There are MANY bangers on this album. Eminem is truly one of the greatest, it's not an understatement in the slightest. Nostalgia is def coming into play for me here but idk, the dude can write a rap haha. Also the production sounds like 1000000 dollars. Idk if this is a controversial or common opinion but Stan might be a 10/10 song. Do I like it? No. But it's extremely well written. Eminem basically is a voice actor and this is a radio drama. The imagery is impossibly strong, the sound design is actually really great (the scribbling foley throughout verse 1,2 and 4), the way verse 2 opens up spatially to create a sense of unease, and verse 3 puts us in Stans car with the tight "car" reverb.. like it's really fucking well done. Other thoughts - I think Marshall has anger issues he hasn't addressed. Kim is a way more fucked up song than Stan. Didn't he get sued over that one? If not, he should have. The vocal performance is really fucking good though. Album took a bit of a weird turn at Remember Me I felt, this song feels a little out of place to me Ken Kaniff skit is crazyyyy. Em is so fucking homoerotic and so homophobic (hand in hand, I guess). I forgot how many times the f-slur is dropped in this music. I think I kinda forgot how much of a shock factor he was. Honestly not sure what to rate this. Am I docking points just because he's... the way he is??
Lots of classic tracks on here from my basketball days. 12 year old rebellion. Stan is a fucking incredible song. Still holds up tbh. Some shit is pretty tough to listen to (Ken Kaniff). Kim is straight up terrifying. I love Eminem. Some of this shit is dated and/or pretty fucked up, but he is a lyrical genius.
Pretty good
Generally not my thing, but still a fun listen, and technically great.
I knew Kill you, Stan, and The real slim shady. First half was good. Now that I'm older I realize how immature Eminem sounds. I still like him over other rappers because of his energy though.
He’s the Bob Dylan of rap. I mean, look at all of the things he got to rhyme with “Amityville”. And he actually has something to say and you can actually understand what he’s saying and the backing tracks are put together with rock sensibilities.
I can see the humour and defiance in amongst the bleakness it good at what it does but not an easy listen.
There are so many problems with the lyrics, but the musicianship and wording is pretty amazing. Hate to support the guy, but it is an interesting album.
I like a couple of Eminem songs, but none of them are on here. The singles released from here did make a statement on the charts at the time though.
4/5
Undoubtedly, Shady is a great artist. Equally talented and honest, a proven lyricist and rapper. Because it is so well done and familiar to me, I do not dislike this album. However, I cannot relate to the themes as much as I did in my youth. He portrays a lot of anger and violence in this album, which may at one time during my angsty youth phase. I still enjoyed the listen, but it gave me feelings that I didn't care to feel any more.
This is really pretty awful stuff. Well over an hour of ranting.
The best
Outrageous, satirical, realist, and forthright, Eminem's magnum opus only gets better w/ age, no matter how 'of its time' his hatreds and vulgarisms are. 'You want me to fix up lyrics while our president gets his dick sucked?' Right he is to call out the engine of hypocrisy his country often runs on, but his wit and penned social-awareness only works b/c, as a technical rapper, he's indisputably a genius. It's more than the rhyming, tho 'taught 'em to swear' and 'daughter to wear,' or 'two kids, sixteen,' 'M-16,' 'ten clips each,' 'them shits reach,' 'six kids each,' 'Bill Clint's speech,' 'fix these streets' are prolific displays of the skillset. It's beyond his flow as well. It's his tone, as angry as it is resigned: urgent yet nonchalant, it's a dosage of deep clarity.
i will never enjoy this mans music. i don't even care about the lyrism, i find outrageous shit funny, this shit just sounds so bad. like a hate his aesthetics so much. the production so ass, the rapping so corny. all of the bar about people being offended by him and him not giving af reads so sensitive, shit corny af. buddy just stand on business. lame ass shit i'll never understand why he's so beloved stream boolymon thats real rap
I have to rate it lower for all the slurs and hateful lyrics
Gold such a good fucking album
4.5 (72:17, 18 tracks, (4 skits), 2000 third album) The album that ensured Marshal would be a cultural phenomenon. After this album no one didn't know who Eminem was. I enjoyed the Mel-Man productions far more than the horrorcore of F.B.T.
Despite having a distinct, somewhat nostalgic fleur, the album remains a unique and enjoyable listen both lyrically and melodically, full of catchy controversy (which does feel tired here as opposed to Eminem's later records) and BOPs. However, the record is bleak in the wider context of contemporary rap music, especially in terms of beats and basses. Further, songs like "The Way I Am", "Marshall Mathers", "Remember Me?" etc. sound dated and irrelevant to the modern ear. The impact of the record also remains limited to put it politely: clown-like trolls with technical flow faded away and lost out to thought-provoking lyricists / "weed&chill" hip-hop artists, with very few exceptions in pale Eminem wannabees. Thank you for the adolescence memories and IAMTHESLIMSHADY, don't want to revisit this again.
Really enjoyed listening to this again. I'm
Always wanted to hear a full Eminem album, and know more of his songs. And I'm damn glad I did!
Way too long to be a classic, he has about 8 fillers that could be dropped to make it a very good album.
Aw man huge huge step up from the last one - a lot more conscious and emotionally sensitive than we had come to expect from Eminem. The blatant homophobia and misogyny is rough here - unfortunately part of the 90s rap scene but it is a bit jarring now. Stops this from being as good as it could be. Key pieces to the puzzle here are Stan and Kim. Where before there is an aloof nature to Eminem's antics now there is genuine emotion and it makes you uncomfortable in a different (better - think a good horror movie) way.
thank you for bravely fighting this necessary and specific war against the insane clown posse, marshall.
This - https://youtu.be/1gC7M6DRwuE?si=cD7ZNDoB1q9_Vcc3
ambitious, hard to listen to, and so so angry. its pretty incredible that it did so well, to be frank. It's not my lane of hip hop but I appreciate his game.
He sounds like everyone I went to high school with. A few great bangers though.
This is truly a great album. Really creative rhyming schemes with a super adept delivery and flow to actually make them work. And then insanely catchy hooks to drive it all home. An interesting, humorous, and at times unfortunately poorly dated lyrical snapshot of that time, as edgy as the lyrics may be. Not to mention insane Dr Dre production.
Unfortunately very groovy with cutting lyrics. Coming a week after I listened to a Kendrick album, you don't have to look up the lyrics to hear what Eminem says or understand what he means. He is funny, horrifying and to the point.
There's...so much to unpack here, it's actually ridiculous. And unfortunately I don't really have the time or patience to get to all of it. There's no denying Eminem is a master of the form. He touches on so many interesting questions on this LP, about his place in the industry as a white guy, about the power words hold (or not), and within all of it is a ton of genuinely funny satire. For me, the actual sound of the music is pretty trash, so that drops it a lot. I also feel like at times, it's genius, and at times, it's perhaps too on the nose. What do I know. I'm giving it a three. Fave tracks: - Who Knew - The Way I Am - The Real Slim Shady - Marshall Mathers - Kim
Apart from nostalgia surrounding friends who listened to this in high school, I get nothing out of this but depressing thoughts.
Harder to listen to now because of the homophobia, but at the time of its release, one of the most important hip hop albums of all time.
Eminem is at the peak of his powers in this period. His lyrical genius and flow never cease to impress me. Just downright silly at times. This album would absolutely get him cancelled by today’s standards but barring some pretty outrageous songs, it’s a classic for a reason. Definitely deserving of being included in the 1,001 but there are other Eminem albums I enjoy more from start to finish.
Stan is the real star of this album
"Eminem" was an experiment conducted by the US Army to help recruiters identify & select pliable high schoolers for military service. Thank You For Your Participation in The Marshall Mathers Project. DMX does the shock-jock horrorcore thing with a bit more verve but The MMLP has its place on the podium. The further Eminem in real life gets away from the persona, the stronger the album is. It's always been intended as a meathead meta-commentary on violence in culture & music, it's explicitly responding to critiques on violent music WRT Columbine while also intentionally encroaching on the hostility and violent imagery found on DMX's stuff or in Southern Hip-hop. It's not doing an egghead critique on it, and some of that misogyny/homophobia is real but the characters of the album are so heightened and offensive that it all comes across as the Grand Guignol interpretation of the popular alternative aesthetics - sort of like Gravediggaz a few years prior. It's not much different than like, Crass. It's goading and wants you to clutch your pearls, real Howard Stern stuff, but it's funny. The characters are roundly pathetic and Eminem creates enough distance between himself and his characters that I think it registers. The beats are also hot, the features are good. It's a strong effort for something that is unambigiously pretty juvenile. I get being annoyed or frustrated at the music if you were a high schooler in 1999-2009 and had to listen to your classmates bump this constantly & also totally miss the album's generally ironic character but it has kept its teeth sharp with time which goes to prove that it is a big flex with real talent underneath. Favorite Tracks: Stan, The Real Slim Shady, Remember Me?, Under the Influence
One of those albums, that unless you have a massive disdain for hip-hop in general, I can't fathom not understanding the importance of at least 4-5 songs, much less the full album. Probably within the first 10 albums you would list regarding hip-hop, if you had to sit and create this list yourself of 1001 albums. As for the actual album review, it's Eminem in his bag both lyrically and sonically, it's him at his absolute peak, knowing the influence he has (whether he wants it or not) and weaponizing it in such an unbelievable manner unrivaled in music. I'm not a huge fan of horror-core at times, especially cause it's a thin line between shock value, and just plain corniness, but for the most part the line is toed very well. Not my favorite Hip-Hop album of all time, but you can't tell the story of the 2000's without Slim Shady.
A profoundly impactful debut album from one of the best, if not THE best rapper in the world. This album pushed basically every boundary that there was at the time, tested every limit, and came out as a piece of work that is still relevant today. #stan
Everything about this is perfect--except when it's deeply misogynist and gay bashing. He even makes fun of himself for being terrible and seems to try and have it both ways. Perhaps he is creating terrible characters and claiming it's just a song, but this LP in particular is supposed to be him and it's very cringy. When he has other things to say the album is much better--Stan is maybe a top 5 rap track--I'm just not interested in his feuding with Kim, or Xtina, or NSYNC. That said, he is still unparalleled as a lyricist and the album slaps. A 3.5 for me, but bumping for critical acceptance.
boooooooo
ugh
It was a pretty good album. I was able to find two good songs on it
I have never really been a big Eminem fan. I enjoyed 8 mile and can appreciate his lyrical ability but I don't like particularly his delivery. My bigger problem is him hiding behind his alter ego's to rap provocative statements that his less educated/ mature fans take a face value without realizing that Eminem does not actually mean it...
The Marshall Mathers LP It’s easy to forget what an impact Eminem had, and listening to this it definitely captures that specific late 90s MTV-Shock-Reality-Celebrity cultural moment in a way other hip hop stars didn’t - for the very obvious skin coloured reason. Often his comedic instincts are sharp, and when aligned with his dark horror influenced OTT style, his obvious technical skill and Dr Dre’s production and ear for a hook it’s very good. Kill You, Stan, The Way I Am, The Real Slim Shady, I’m Back, Marshall Mathers are all very strong. And in particular the triumvirate of Stan, The Way I Am and The Real Slim Shady are superb; excellent storytelling, hooks, production and delivery wrapped up in an OTT mix of melodramatic fun and emotional, confessional earnestness, baiting parental and media led hypocrisy, and studded with brilliant lines. But too often the humour slips into boring crassness, and his reliance on shock value, especially the casual homophobia that threads through several tracks, has aged poorly, reading today as more mean-spirited edge lordery than subversion. And the problem is that the album's high points are surrounded by a considerable amount of filler. At 18 tracks, with too many skits, the runtime stretches the concept thin, diluting the emotional and artistic punch of the good songs. Ultimately it feels like a mix of brilliance and a lack of editing. Undeniable peaks, but with a decent amount of flaws. Think it ends up at a high 3. ⚪⚪⚪ Playlist submission: The Real Slim Shady
It gets bloated at over an hour long - what could've been a strong 4-star gets diluted. For instance 'Kim' feels a less sophisticated retread of Stan, and basically reveals something if a narcissistic personality and becomes very grating. 'Under the Influence' is a pale 'Real Slim Shady' imitation with nothing new to say. He is also strangely preoccupied with dissing gays and ejaculating in bottoms. It's puerile, and unforgivably it's not funny. I'm sure Dr Freud would resolve.this preoccuparion in a matter of moments. Yet amongst all that are some all out bangers that have genuine crossover appeal - 'Stan', 'The Way I Am', 'Criminal', 'Real Slim Shady', 'Drug Ballad'. It's a shame. It's a three.
Так-то музыка весёлая, но слова отбивают всё желание слушать. 2 из 10.
“I make fight music for high school kids”- Eminem While Em is a talented lyricist, I think every track on this made me cringe. If it’s not the sexism it’s the homophobia. Anyone who says they “don’t give a fuck” that much is obvi bothered. 1/10
Many bangers, very few mid tracks
Few bangers in this album. Heavily influential at the time. Stan is such a tune and so different to what you’d expect from Eminem. Bitch Please II is another personal favourite
Overall pretty unmemorable and pretty boring but couple of bangers like Stan, The Real Slim Shady and Marshall Mathers but also some absolute stinkers like Kim. Not my kind of music really either which doesn't help.
Great beats, great sound, many songs surprisingly musical. The lyrics, however, while undeniably clever at times, are frequently misogynistic, egotistical, often clumsy and way too in my face in the production. Ya I know. It’s rap. I’m trying. 3.5
maybe the most offensive thing i have ever listened to.
3.0
Ughhh i'm so conflicted. Some songs are obvsious bangers like Kill You, Stan, The Real Slim Shady or The Way I am. At the same time the lyrics are really hard to listen to. Super homophobic and misogonystic. man i don't know. It is a classic tho and Dre's production def shines.
Even the skits are bangers. 6/5
If there’s an Eminem album that screams Multiplayer Halo it’s this.
Sin entenderlo todo todo, tiene momentos que parecen infantiles. Pero tremendos temazos. Y Stan eS TAAAAAN buena...
I listen to a fair bit of hip hop, but don’t think I’ve ever got through an Eminem album. Not sure why. His rapping is distinctive but there something about it I don’t like (too nasal?). Kill You is a bit unpleasant lyrically. I find the flow on The Way I Am as just too aggressive and hard to listen to. Remember me a bit rubbish. Skits also rubbish. Like the hits (other than TWIA) and a few of the other tracks though and some lyrics made me smile. 2.8
Can't argue that some of this is groundbreaking, Stan is a masterpiece n my opinion even if it unfortunately exposed us to more Dido. Lyrically great, funny and for the most part tongue in cheek (i hope).
Very adept and adroit lyrically although probably a little too horrorcore adjacent for me to really get into.
Behind the OTT violence and questionably immature/mature content, there was always a fun album waiting to break out here. When it’s good it’s great. It goes places where no artist had gone before, like it or not. Te wordplay and rhyme scheme is top drawer. Loved the Dre influence on this album, they made a great team. Maybe not a seminal album, but definitely a statement piece of it’s time, and one I was happy to revisit.
The rapping is good, but I don’t find any of the song concepts overly interesting. Fame, girls, violence, pranks… I dunno, with such gifted lyrical skill, couldn’t the output have been less juvenile?
Not my thing - but Eminem walked so Iggy Azalea could strut. I appreciate that.
The first track sets the mood for the rest of the album. The brutal “Kill You” makes you feel uneasy, as if what Eminem says might actually be true. I really hope that when he claims at the end of the song that he’s “just playin’ with the ladies,” he means it! Its intensity continues with the fabulous duet with Dido, “Stan” — arguably one of the most beloved hip-hop songs of all time. The track holds deep meaning for Eminem. The album aims to be a bold statement against everyone who disliked his work, his life, or doubted his talent. Besides his raw and often controversial language — which, by the way, drew attention from Lynne Cheney, the Second Lady of the United States from 2001 to 2009 — she even called for age restrictions on music sales after citing lyrics from “Kill You.” Despite all the noise and controversy, I really loved the production. The collaborations speak for themselves — featuring icons like Snoop Dogg and Dr. Dre. Curiosity: The word “Stan” eventually entered the Oxford English Dictionary as a noun. It’s defined as ‘an overzealous or obsessive fan of a particular celebrity.’ When used as a verb, it means to be an enthusiastic fan — as in saying, ‘I really stan this artist.’ Look it up!
Very dark. Brilliant lyrics, but hard to listen to.
Absolute banger.
Sophomore albums are always an interesting thing to dissect but lets go. Production wise, I really like this. The minimalism early in the album to focus on the actual rapping is great and illustrates Eminem's talent. By the half way point of this album, I had stopped really caring though. It's very dark and crude at points (which is fine) but super sincere at others. That juxtaposition is a little hard to digest sometimes but I understand why it's the way it is. I enjoyed the callbacks to earlier in the album too which is pretty nice and big Leo DiCaprio pointing vibes. Can't say I'll listen to it again but hey. Kill You Contextually, I know nothing. But now I fear that "Shady will fucking kill you". Stan (featuring Dido) One of the first Eminem songs I remember enjoying. The bassline is such a focal point, anchors everything and is a major standout. Lyrically, I think this excels in so many ways. The dangers of parasocial relationships are real, yo. Who Knew The production on this album is fucking tops. The Way I Am Oh man, I like this. "I don't mean to be me but that's what I am." Big struggling with popularity vibez. The Real Slim Shady Iconic. Remember Me? (featuring RBX and Sticky Fingaz) Meh. I’m Back Less meh but still meh Marshall Mathers I like this. Drug Ballad Got bored and skipped Amityville (featuring Bizarre from D12) This is okay Bitch Please II (featuring Dr. Dre, Snoop Dogg, Xzibit, and Nate Dogg) No, bitch. Kim A hard listen but it's very raw and real. Really like the music behind this. Under the Influence (featuring D12) This is fun but I don't care about drugs so yaaaa Criminal Aforementioned drugs do make you a criminal, Slim. Good narrative kind of explaining that lyrics are lyrics and not real things that he's gonna do.
Fastest f slurs/second
Insane follow-up from his first album. How fame came fast from someone who was speaking his god damn truth. Is Eminem so scrutinized because he reveals how fucked up white Middle America is? Did he shatter their porcelain perception? Also helps listening to this knowing he sobbed at his daughter’s wedding. He is a lover boy regardless of his profane lyrics.
Extremely unique. Hard for me to fully enjoy just from a groove perspective, but definitely a singular work.
Some iconic tracks, but to me, there is too much false anger of the Slim Shady persona.
Better now than when I was 13
It's definitely a classic of the genre, but I am not Slim Shady's target audience.
Well, I'd have to say that this kind of music isn't exactly my bag. I did listen throughout and for what it is, it is well produced and aside from most of the lyrics it is clever and thoughtful.
I go way back with this album. I don't feel a need to listen to it at this point in my life, but I've had great times with it.
Wow! It's been a long while since I heard this album. It hasn't really aged well. I mean Eminem's wrapping style is still fun, the popular tracks from this were definitely filled with a certain nostalgia, and the beats were pretty damn good for the most part. But wow! I think another reviewer called it sophomoric. I'd have to agree the misogyny, homophobia, and violence are over the top even for just shock value.
Adolescent drivel. I hated this clown when I was a teenager and he was topping the charts. Still can't stand him now. Beyond irritating. 1/5
Know this album VERY well, listened to it a billion times. Definitely still fun, but it's filled with a lot of dated pop culture references to stuff that isn't relevant anymore which kind of dates it a little. Still a fun listen years later though, 4.5 stars.
Started as a 4 with good story telling like in ‘Stan’ but then as album went on I lost the plot, it became more edge-lord than Eminem. I can still appreciate the talent but it’s long and there’s that sloppy skit which made me want to stop listening all together.
A Classic
40 year old me is not as big of a fan as 16 year old me.
It jumps between being really raunchy and very aggressive. It's very jarring but it definitely puts in perspective eminems emotional state at the time. "Kim" especially is honestly horrific to listen to, very good, but I hope I never have to listen to it again.
Gear: Fostex TH610 Artwork: 🌲🏚️🔳 Production: 👨🏾⚕️🌿🌟 Music: 🖕🏻👱🏻♂️🖕🏻 Rating: 🦸🏼♂️🦸🏼♂️🦸🏼♂️🦸🏼♂️🦸🏼♂️/5
Reading the song titles I didn’t recognize many, but it all came back to me on listening. A lot can be said about the quite horrendous lyrics, but my opinion would be that personas are quite common in rap and could/should be separated from Eminem himself; even says it in ‘Stan’ he says things just playing, and Stan might need counseling if he can’t seperate that out. Should rate down for some of the crass things but he does rap with mastery and nostalgia also plays a part here.. 4.5/5
Il est chauuud
Du bon rap de gwer comme on en fait plu
Eminem, premier sur la lutte des droits gays et ça c'est magnifique. Je savais pas que les sons venaient de cet album à la base et très sympa de les écouter dans un nouvel ordre et ptn c'est fort
Twisted, Batshit insane and dark themes. But you cant deny the lyricism, story-telling and the rap ability of Eminem (at least before he started releasing dumb shit like "just lose it"). 4/5
There’s no denying the brilliance here — Stan and The Real Slim Shady alone are enough to prove Eminem’s storytelling and rhythmic precision were on another level. You can practically hear the hours spent with the dictionary, mastering multisyllabic rhymes and internal patterns. But it’s also an album that can be hard to love; the same unfiltered honesty that fuels its genius is often wrapped in deep offensiveness and chaos. Sometimes I hate him, sometimes I’m amazed by him — and maybe that’s the point.
The only Marshall Mathers LP is Infinite.
Overall: 6/10 Eminem was huge with me and my friends in middle school, when we were all just getting into rap music. I remember finding his lyrical style hilarious and really liking his voice and flow. Maybe it's because I've been hearing these songs for my entire life, but they don't have the impact on me in my late 20s that they did in my early teens. I still find Shady to be a very talented lyricist, but he surprisingly doesn't have a lot of range. I'm still going to give this a decent rating because of nostalgia. These songs have been important to me my entire life and I don't want to punish the album for being overplayed. I will quickly talk about Stan though, which I think is Marshall's magnum opus. The concept of a crazy fan sending him letters that get increasingly unhinged is such a creative idea and I think he nailed it. I wish more of the album was like that song. Fav Song: Stan
Eminem is talented, and his rhymes are entertaining, but I just don't like this at all.
W kulturze często mówi się o tym, jak kluczowe jest drugie solowe dzieło. Udanych debiutów jest mnóstwo, ale to drugi utwór często decyduje o tym, czy artysta osiągnie stabilny sukces, czy będzie zapamiętany tylko z jednego dzieła. Eminem nie tylko przebił sukces swojego pierwszego albumu, ale też zaczął marsz do tytułu jednego z najważniejszych twórców naszego pokolenia. Przełamał mnóstwo różnych barier i wyniósł rap na nowe wyżyny. O tym, jak wielkie kulturowe znaczenie miał ten album niech świadczy fakt, że jeden z utworów stał się inspiracją do nowego słowa, które z czasem zostało wpisane do słownika oxfordzkiego (mowa oczywiście o "stan"). Problemy ze złością i gniewem oraz rozdrapywanie prywatnych ran w przestrzeni publicznej na stałe wpisane jest w twórczość Eminema i ten album jest tego świetnym przykładem. Jednocześnie pokazuje człowieka, który odkrył ciemne strony sławy i ma do niej cholernie niejednoznaczny, ambiwalentny stosunek. I radzi sobie z tym wszystkim w jedyny sposób, jaki zna ze swojego życia - gniewem i agresją. Bardzo emocjonalny krążek, choć wyjątkowo nie jest to z mojej strony pochwała. Wszystko przepełnione jest bardzo niezdrowym gniewem, agresją, toksycznością. To wciąż album pełen bangerów i absolutnych hitów, które na stałe wpisały się w kulturę naszego pokolenia, ale jednocześnie ten album wydaje mi się zwyczajnie niebezpieczny. Nawet jeśli w kilku miejscach próbuje przestrzegać przed destrukcyjnymi zachowaniami. Nie jest to dla mnie jeszcze peak Eminema, także zostanę przy czwórce. "The Eminem Show" i "Lose Yourself" z 8 mili to wciąż jest absolutny top jego twórczości dla mnie. Choć nie ukrywam, że z czasem przestałem śledzić jego nowsze wydania i w zasadzie już od "Encore" znam tylko pojedyncze utwory. Anyway, dobry album, ale wciąż nie topka. Piątkę zarezerwuję dla "The Eminem Show", o ile się pojawia na tej liście.
I think this is his best album that balance on his angry/funny persona. There are so many hits that I remeber from my teenage years and they still hold up pretty nicely. 5/5, almost 4.
It's a decent album, with Stan being the standout track. I know The Real Slim Shady is very popular, but I don't find it very interesting. I feel that the track featuring Snoop and Dre is one of the best on the album other than Stan. Many of the other tracks really aren't anything special to me.
Like a Shakespeare comedy written by the human id
A bit of a story with some actual musical elements. It wasn’t totally offensive and completely unexpected.
An all-time classic. Is it too edgy and angry? Yes, but it is very much an excellent product of its time. There are misogynistic lyrics in this album as well, but due to the sometimes absurd lyrics it is hard to take too serious. 'Stan' is one of the greatest rap songs of all time and very inventive, along with just a great cohesion in the album. 5/5
Tracks 1-8 really hit; masterfully produced, akin to old folk murder ballads the story-telling is shocking and raw, but similar to Greek tragedy; satirical and relatable. Slim’s hamartia is on full display. Track 9 feels like a forced cameo and 10 is a path back from the detour. On track 11 we, once again delve back into the beautifully violent and shocking catharsis of Mathers. 12-15 present more detours and cameos… and then we are faced with the deus ex machina; the full force of Mather’s violent psychosis on track 16. The emotion is palpable. Tracks 17 and 18 are similar to a choral ode.
Honestly the beats, background music, and production are what makes this hold at a 3 star. The lyrics are just terrible even if they are clever and fast.
I love Eminem way more than a 44 year old male should.
Can’t imagine the rampant homophobia on this album aged all that well. “It was a different time” sure grandma, let’s get you to bed. Like most rap albums I’ve encountered it’s too fucking long. I hope Eminem has seen someone about his anger issues and is in a better place now.
Really good rap album, but I think it's before Eminem got really good at chopping. He's still dealing with a lot of demons here.
i liked it more than i expected
Great production very charismatic can see why its popular. Some make feel cool some sad some disgusted what a roller-coaster. Not all what im looking for in music but can appreciate the production
Dazzled by the brilliance, put off by the cringe
Without 'Stan' this would get 1 🌟 Without the Dido sample on Stan this would be a 1 🌟 And I'm not even a Dido fan! Pointless, just pointless. And didn't he mime at Reading? Actually this IS a 1 🌟. He's annoying.
Eminem is a unique figure in music and pop culture. So popular, so many classic hit songs, yet so few good albums? This album is such a good example of that rule. Stan is fantastic: a wonderfully well written song, depicting some dark themes in a surprisingly tasteful manner. It had a wonderful bass-line, and an awesome sample from Dido to string it together. The Real Slim Shady is also an infectious, groovy, and funny early 2000s rap hit. Some pretty left-field lyrics, but sat within that territory of what you’d expect from someone like Eminem. The Will Smith bar is hilarious and always will be. Notice how I’m talking about the 2 biggest hits from the album, though? Off the bat, Kill You is just an uncomfortable listen and it doesn’t get any better from there. I know part of his whole thing is, “if you are listening and not enjoying what I’m saying I’ve still won”, and he is right, but doesn’t mean I’ll ever listen to this album from start to finish again. Always here for some classic Dr Dre production though!
He didn’t just say what I think he did, did he?
I understand Eminem is huge and he his album is one of the best, yadda yadda. Couldn’t listen for more than 15 minutes.
Pues mira, eso de que tengas “family issues” y decidas curar tus mierdas y traumas en un pretendido envoltorio artístico dónde acabas tomándola con los maricones y las mujeres, para sorpresa de nadie, para luego esforzarte en cada entrevista en aclarar que no eres homófobo ni machista, que es solo una licencia artística, y que estás jugando entre la realidad y la ficción, a mí no me convence. Y eso que “musicalmente” es un álbum mucho más accesible y soportable que el resto de hip hop que he escuchado, por eso no le pongo un 0. Y, vosotros me diréis qué oculta esa obsesión por la pollas del señorito cishetero blanco. Ahí lo dejo.
Innovative fresh disturbing a showcase for his talent to evolve.
Just a classic
Three cool tracks and severely diminishing returns. Loved his lyrical gymnastics to start with, but Jesus is he obnoxious. “Kim” is a fucking disgrace.
He definitely has his own style. ★★★★
I have a soft spot for Eminem because everyone around me used to listen to him when I was younger. Even still, this album is a brand of edgy 2000s shit that just hasn't aged well.
I kinda hate that I enjoyed this as much as I did but there were so many of his better songs on here.
Not a fan of rap but I didn’t hate this.
Tricky, some great bits, a lot of silly bits. 3.5
Good when just listening horrible for multi-tasking
There’s a lot to unpack with this one - more than I’m willing to type on a phone. I was 23 when this album came out and its music and fans didn’t exactly match my vibe. Listening to it now I admire his vulnerability, even if I don’t like much of the substance. Some young white dudes did not know how to process this album in a healthy way and it showed. There is no doubt a thru line for a certain type of incel whose origin story can be traced back to it. Both they and the Eminem of 2000 could have used a hug. Still though, the boy got flow and a self deprecating humor I like.
Putting aside the talent and discipline for a moment—imagine having the fucking nerve to write this shit down?? Eminem doesn't give a fuck—the man is operating outside of society. He is at large; he is free.
<3
The violence towards women is a lot but there is so much genius. How do I vote if I don’t want to listen to most of it again but want to give it its due? Ps he knew: “little groupie bitch get off me go fuck puffy” -marshal mathers
really crazy to listen to this album with some distance. certain tracks are staggering - intensely wry lyrics spat out with that snide voice of his over earworm beat after earworm beat. 'stan', 'the real slim shady', 'drug ballad' - these and a few others have staying power I wouldn't have acknowledged without giving this a good relisten. that said, about half the album taps the well way past dry. the boy band bashing gets old, the self reflexive gay jokes annoyingly front and center, and holy fuck the song 'kim' should not have made it onto the release. jesus dude. all said though, a seminal album in which the quality sustains its influence.
Well really good rapping That dude got text Kim is unbearable wtf thats heavy
Well that sure is offensive, which I guess is the aim. Presume the anger of his white underclass US background is real. So meant to shock the middle classes? I am not trying to justify the fact I enjoy his ability to write a good rhyme, while displaying that much supposed hate at the world. The subject matter is all part of the package and he does it well, he isn't to my imited knowledge an actual violent person so it's a form of artistic expression. Like any horror or thriller book/film. It's more a reflection of the bad than It's the cause. Guess it can be seen as both therapeutic (pro art)and dangerous (ethical) and really depends on the listener. 4 Star
the back half feels like drinking sour milk stan still rips though
Cracking album. Brings back early teenage years. Very inappropriate listening for someone of that age, or any age for that matter. But still, giving it a 5.
Some (many?) of the lyrics don't exactly hold up to modern sensibilities but overall I enjoyed my listen
There is some good stuff in here, some of the well known hits are very enjoyable. However there is a lot in this album that doesn't age well (most notably the lyrics). Rap music has progressed from this. None the less, the nostalgia element of some of the songs retains a 3 star.
I don't think I've ever actually listened to an Eminem album. There are some enjoyable songs, but its hard to ignore the rampant homophobia and needless violence throughout. I have no idea how much of this is supposed to be taken literally, what is and isn't in character as Marshall Matters, or if this is supposed to be some sort of meta-commentary, but it definitely hampered my enjoyment of the album. When did i become a woke snowflake?
It's a raw and controversial album, but still a very acclaimed and incredible record. The highlights are the most known songs, but the rest play their part too, despite the lyrics and sounds.
Where did the notion even come from that this guy had something of value to say? Was that a narrative pushed by the film, the media, or just a collective hallucination? Because these are some embarrassingly childish lyrics.
Love this one, Eminem at his finest
wordplay like no other. this album felt like a raw exorcism of his own psyche. suburban rap at its finest.
Not big and not clever.
Some great stuff, although it falls off in the back half, and way too much bigotry. Interesting portrait of a furious young man.
Yikes! Sorry for me classics, but a little too offensive for my delicate little heart. Heh
This album falls off a bit for me at the end, but 'Stan' is undeniably GOAT'd.
1. public - 0 2. kill - 0 3. ztan - 3 4. kneuu- 1 5. zteve -0 6. uuay - 1.5 7. Shady -2 8. Remember -0 9. Back -1 10.Mathers - 2 11. Ken - 0 12. Drug - 0 13. Amityville - 0 14. Bitch - 2.5 15. Kim -1.5 16. Influence - 0 17. Criminal -1
Despite some lesser tracks after track 12, it remains an excellent album and certainly hallmark of my teenage years
What a fun album. It was nice to listen to an album where I had a knowledge of some tracks but discovered new ones.
Brutal lyrics, but highly entertaining.
i feel bad for liking this over dark twisted fantasy
classic
Rampant misogyny and homophobia abound. But at least unlike a lot on this list Eminem is clearly aware of his surroundings and can be genuinely funny and catchy on some of this. The self awareness still grates when it makes no difference to his approach. And I don't need a 6 minute song about him basically trying to murder his wife when he spent tut second track criticising this on Stan.
Hmmm. Great beats, often enjoyable rapping, Eminem is a really funny guy with some clever lyrics that make him stand out from other rappers, but man does he like to just go off on some rant about nothing and just try to say as many trigger words as possible. He spends so long trying to convince everyone on here that his words aren't a problem and that anyone who's bad will be bad regardless, but he protests too much. I'm certain he knows he's lying but he's made a career out of it so doesn't want to change now. It's a shame cos when he tells a story, like on Stan, it can be really quite moving
After many years of loving this, some parts can stand out as corny at times. For example, I think Em’s chorus writing ability is a clear low point. I’m not sure if it’s cause I’ve heard all of these choruses before but sometimes they do hit. However, when I listen closely I think those choruses can be on the annoying side. Speaking of annoying, I think this record just goes on too long. It’s very of the time to make a 18 track multiple skit album, but it takes away some of its staying power because of that. That being said, for 18 tracks, this thing is consistent. Tracks like Bitch Please 2 get overlooked because of the massive hits on here, but would be huge hits on a different album. Overall, I think this is a top 10 rap album of all time. I don’t think it represents the genre as a whole to be the best rap album of all time, but I think it’s consistency and cultural impact make it one of the greats.
My inner 13-year-old kid liked this record. My current 29-year-old, not that much. Three stars seem like a fair rating. It is full of unnecessary skits and overflowing misogyny, but it also gave us "Stan".
10/10 no notes
The shit that Eminem did with some these beats is INSANE. I can still smell the weed I smoked listening to this.
When I think of Eminem all I think about is that millennials are so offended when someone doesn't think of him as like the king of rap lmao. He's like alright, his vocals are better then the beats he's rapping over, it's kinda sad how lamish the beats are at times... though it's def a good album, def a bit too long for just hearing Eminem's voice but it had The Real Slim Shady on it so really does my opinion matter?
Listening to this album reminds me of the fact that there are 13 and 14-year-old boys who listen to his music and take what he says seriously. Like all of the blatant misogyny, homophobia and just low-life stuff he raps with constantly. Some of the backing tracks are golden, and the hits are hits for a reason. If you relate to this guy, grow up, and maybe then you'll be able to talk to women.
4.5/5
Bad cheese doesn't age well.
Shocking yet humorous album that has very catchy tunes. He is definitely one of the best rappers in history. Must listen album for casual listeners as well as rap lovers.
This is not the Eminem album I wanted to listen to. Feels too late in his career and full of self referential stuff. Not a fan of the genre but you have to respect his wordsmith skills.
Do not play whilst driving. Great album back in the day. A bit grating listening to it many years after.
I can't say much more than what I did back when we listened to the other album on this list from Eminem. Its perfect for the late 90's early 2000's but its so juvenile now and just edgey for the same of pushing buttons. Not one lyric on this is considered art in my opinion, just a razor sharp brash statements. Sure they are clever but, in the way that is almost trashy. The beats are one dimensional, computerized. The features are lame, the skits are stupid. The ONLY shred of redemption on this album is Stan. Long form allegory about this fan base that he developed. So dark, so raw, so creative.
Best Song: Stan. A phenomenal example of storytelling in a song. Went on to have huge culture impact. Worst Song: Kim. No one wants to listen to a domestic violence skit with a terribly sung chorus. Overall: A weird album that shows Eminem's immense talent and quirkiness, but then also his immaturity on other tracks. There's a sort of irony in an album containing a song like "Stan", which expertly points out the problems with fan culture and the way that his fans in particular are prone to misunderstanding his lyrics, and then on that same album having "Kim", which never contains even a wink or nod to acknowledge that the song might be about anything other than the legitimacy of violent misogyny. Hard to blame fans for missing satire and subtext when the actual text is so loud and clear.
Great album
It's a great album
Good albums, the skits are also good, not annoying unlike in some albums. 3
Angry. Not my type of music but I enjoyed a lot of it, hated a lot of the rest of it.
Rouuuuuggghhh
Pretty good! Every lyric is so clearly articulated, all the swear words really pop. Eminem was popular growing up and some college friends were obsessed with him. I noticed that I paid attention more to this album than previous ones, and it felt like he had some kind of message about life’s hardships to share. Fine but wouldn’t reach for it myself.
Helt ok
Half of the tracks on this album are self-aware bars about how bad of an influence Eminem is on the "kids". Feels kinda like Fight Club. Is it a chicken or the egg situation? Did Eminem get popular because of the state of society, or did the state of society reach where it did because of Eminem? I'm leaning far more towards the former. With that being said, I still hate Eminem's sound. The fast sporadic rap style and rhyme-schemes he uses have always been grating and annoying to me. Even when I was the prime audience for his work as a white middle-class middle-schooler I still felt the same way. THAT also being said, as an adult it's just that much more tiresome to listen to lyrics that are clearly aiming for an edgy shock-factor. It feels like a peek back into the early internet, or 2000's comedy movies... Terribly un-enjoyable album, but Shady didn't cause Columbine.
I started this journey with a "judge the album by how consistently truthful it is" and this... happens to be the most truthful album I've heard yet. Incredibly challenging to listen to (that's the point), "Kim" is the worst there, and "Ken Kaniff" is a close second. Clearly he's enjoying playing the line between "am I insane or is it all a joke?" and he runs both directions while exploring that theme. It's immature, incredibly vulgar, disrespectful, violent, misogynistic, homophobic, racist... but again, that's the point. In a world devoid of morals because it's rejected God, this kind of behavior is, idk, expected. The beats are awesome and would be a pleasure to listen to without any lyrics. I'm going to knock a star off because the guest appearances seem like clowns next to Eminem's effortless flow.
Stan still an interesting tune
Ikke like fengende som det var for 5-20 år siden, men fortsatt ett av de beste albumene noensinne. Kommer til å komme tilbake til det resten av livet.
Angry. but you definitely listen to it!
As soon as you see how the trick is done, the magic is gone. The Marshall Mathers LP, lest we forget, carried enough clout back in the day to cement Eminem's megastar status AND make Dido an international star, despite her mediocre output. No mean feat. A quarter of a century on, though, and the trick is pretty obvious now. The self-referential, self-reverential, how-outrageous-can-I-be childishness just grates now - his delivery follows a fairly clear template, maybe it sounded fresh back then, but over-exposure has revealed it for what it is. How did we ever fall for it? Even Dre and co's West Coast grooves seem pretty stilted decades later. Dated and juvenile rap that recycles the same sylistic hooks ad nauseum, over pretty uninspired hip-hop backing - not for me.
Textbook Eminem here.
8/10
Harder to listen to than I would have expected. Undoubtedly a talent, overall worthwhile addition to this list
Could be good but is too weird.
Liked it at the time and like it now. Drugs Ballad I still listen to regularly, really illustrates the Dre production with the speed change.
Insanely talented but seems like a weird, broken man
These might just be the worst lyrics of all time
It’s a good album for what it is, I just don’t think I like what it is. Some great music, some lyrics that just don’t age well and it soundtracks a part of my life id rather not remember. Respect (some of) it for what it is, but didn’t enjoy
escutava muito eminem quando adolescente e fiquei feliz de poder escutar esse album novamente. eminem faz fácil um rap tocante e Stan foi minha faixa preferida com muita carga, com muita vulnerabilidade
I don’t even know what to say about this one… I really respect Eminem as an artist. But goddamn this dude is angry. Some of these songs are incredible how raw and open and honest he is with the lyrics. But other songs are very gratuitous. Just like any other rap album, I’m sure this is a reflection of the world he was living in. But some of it hasn’t aged well at all. Half of this album is really wild and great, and the other half did literally nothing for me other than make me cringe. Probably could’ve been amazing if it was shorter.
Wow. This was pretty tough to get through. Much like his other albums, this one shows off his talent as a rapper, but also his desire to make shocking music. When it’s good, it’s done really well. But his imagery of violence and sex are hard to get through. 2/5 Won’t listen again
The guy rips his heart out on the album, and just sits there bleeding, sending banger after banger. It's deeply personal and it ain't pretty, just as art should be.
It's strange to listen to all these songs without the censorship. I'm used to the radio edits, where when I sing along I include the pauses and sanitised lyrics. This one is tough to rate because logically I can hear how smart the lyrics are, and when it slaps it really slaps, but I can't get over his immature it is. Even if it's a persona, it's tough to take seriously.
5 star MC. -4 star misogynist.
Man kan skrive essays om hva Eminem hadde og si for kultur og hvite gutter mellom syv og noen-og-tjue rundt millenniumsskiftet. Hypen begynte å renne ut rundt Eminem Show, og omtrent alt han har laget etter det har vært et slags forsøk på å overbevise seg selv og verden om at han fortsatt var relevant etter det ble akseptert at hvite kan lage hip hop og det konservative elementet i samfunnet fant noe nytt å skape furore over. Går man tilbake og hører Slim Shady LP, Marhsall Mathers LP, og til dels Eminem Show, finner man faktisk noe substansielt under edgen, men det er tydelig at nisjen Eminem klarte å fylle var helt avhengig av at han var et element som ikke ble akseptert. De fleste sporene på MMLP er en direkte respons til mediespetakkelet som blusset opp i kjølvannet av suksessen til SSLP, og det funker i stor grad jævlig bra. Likevel må jeg slå et slag for Remember Me? og Bitch Please II, som er mer typisk bravado rap tracks med tvilsomt kvinnesyn. Sistnevnte har verten av Pimp My Ride rappe: Bitch, please, you must have a mental disease, so assume the position and get back down on your knees. Altså come on, det her er nesten på Dylan nivå (Hear the one with the mustache say Jeez, I can't find my knees). Alle album hadde vært bedre uten skits, og dette er intet unntak. Det lider også av CD-syndromet som i stor grad slår ut på hip hop- og metal-album fra CD-eraen hvor de alltid skal maxe ute antall minutter du får plass til på en enkeltskive. Det ligger en del nostalgi i skiva, men jeg mener den tåler tidens tann. Ems beste, uten tvil. Noen duds, men pakket med gull.
Jeg vet ikke om jeg klarer helt å komme meg inn i greia til Em. Stan og Real Slim Shady er knallgode, og de fleste gjestene er et velkomment avbrekk fra Eminems litt slitsomme stil. Tekstene gjør meg flau, men beatsa er førsteklasses. Så er albumet CD-alder langt, og det kan være at det er skjermhjerne jeg sliter med, men så er jo en del av skitsa og låtene rene fillers
Eh, denne er vrien. På en side, så er dette et lite mesterverk av et album. Hiphoppen tok over albumformatet etter rocken, og dette er en av de best konstruerte albumene der ute. God historiefortelling, bra musikk, gjennomført konsept og en meget god flyt og form på albumet. Jeg prøver å kose meg, men man kommer ikke unna den enorme mengden med misogony og homofobi i dette albumet. "Faktisk så er det ikke Eminem som er misogyn, det er Slim Sh-" bla bla bla bla. Jeg vet det er et forsøk på å fortelle noe om sin egen samtid, å satirisere og sjokkere, men det er ikke godt nok. Dette er intet ironisk feministisk prosjekt. Dette er et album som egentlig fortjener langt mer, men det er vanskelig å gi bedre karakter når albumet får meg til å føle og tenke på alt annet enn musikken.
Wigger
One of the best albums ever made 10/10
The actual beats were good, but this album did not age well.
Prime Eminem is GOATed
Too much cussing.
Listen - it hasn't aged fabulously but there is some drops of good in here.
Old school Em is the best. Hot take here, but this is his last great album. I like the Slim Shady Eminem. Not really any of his other stuff. I don’t want seriousness, I want to hear him rapping about popping pills, slapping bitches, and not giving a fuck. And this is what we have. He’s one of the best rappers ever.
Look, this was a groundbreaking album when it came out and one that will be remembered forever in hip-hop history. Unfortunately I am a 26 year old man now, and the lyrics of this definitely have showed their age since when I thought this shit was cool at 11. Genuinely childish and immature, retarded and half of the skits are just completely unfunny now. Especially the Ken Kaniff shit. Imagine trying to portray yourself as some macho straight guy and then you go into the studio and make noises like you're sucking a guys dick. Eminem is definitely as closeted as it gets. No wonder Eminem is such a cringe lord today, it turns out he always was but we just had rose-tinted glasses when we were kids. The song where he acts out kidnapping and murdering his ex-wife is just disturbing and retarded. I'm still giving this a 4, but fuck me some of the songs on this thing were a struggle to get through. I do still listen to Amityvile, Drug Ballad, Criminal, and Kill You on a massively regular basis. So many hits on this thing.
My mum was right to stop me listening to Eminem. Young boys should not be listening to music where the main subject is kidnapping torturing raping and dismembering your bitch ex wife. For every track on here I fondly recall as just kinda goofy you get to a B-side track that you just listen to and go what the fuck man. Also 90’s/00’s rappers fucking HATE gays.
This album is corny overrated and aged like milk but is still somehow kinda okay. Its crazy to me there was a time this idiot was considered the GOAT. What were people thinking, seriously, how many references to fucking his Mum are on this thing? Mr Mathers has a major Oedipus complex. He also approaches the album with this, you can't cancel me for being homophobic when its not so much we're trying to cancel him but people were begging him to write about ANYTHING else besides his Mum, his ex or gay guys and nothing has changed. Your goat has the depth of a puddle. He knows how to write a catchy song but thats about it. Also Kim might be the worst song ive ever heard. That being said it still has its moments and is catchy as hell. 5/10
Like a pizza cutter: all edge, no point. Is there a word for bad nostalgia? Because I cannot seem for the life of me to put on rose-tinted glasses when looking back at the 2000s. I grew up with this album and Eminem in general and frankly I've never enjoyed it nor has it grown on me. Two decades later I am really, really listening to the lyrics and I am sincerely struggling to get through this. "Satirical" rap doesn't excuse how crude and dogshit this is and good production doesn't save this at all. This is 72 minutes long and I needed multiple breaks to get through it. Corny music enjoyed by dickheads.
I remember the controversy around this album at the time but had never actually listened to a full album. It was a shock then to discover just how nasty, misogynistic, homophobic and centered on violent fantasy this album was. A hour of this is just boring, once you become desensitized to what he's saying. I'll give a low 2 but only because I acknowledge that Stan is well written and the last track ended on a slightly less sour note than everything else here.
He's so angry.
Classic era Eminem.
Ich check den kulturellen Impact und die Technik, aber es ist und bleibt frauenfeindlicher Scheiß. Macht echt keinen Spaß.
Rich Evan voice: Embarrassing!
Strong 3 / Weak 4 I understand the (maybe) satire and use of persona(s) on the album, but still, some of these lines are pretty… intense 😬. It does sonically sound pretty decent.
A couple of good songs (Stan Real Slim Shady) and better production than Slim Shady LP (eg Bitch Please 2). But mostly, this suffers from the same lack of direction that the Slim Shady LP had. It only has a couple of things to say. Stan is a standout song with something unique to say and done in an interesting way. The rest of it is basically "you can't shut me up!"
The thing about Eminem is that he was that generations panic music. I was not a fan of the music but I did enjoy the fuck you attitude. Just like most moral panics it subsided and the world continued to turn and those who claim to love free speech will continue to try to use the power of the state to squash free speech.
Not everything aged well on this, but the hits are there and still solid. The Way I Am - that’s my jam on this album
Aside from Kim this album is fantastic. MMLP is a more Mature Em which I appreciate more at an older age. Slim Shady is still my favourite!
The production is damn good and his flow, wordplay, rhyming and delivery are brilliant and totally distinctive. An incredibly talented rapper with nothing to say, but a million ways to say it, Eminem give us a window into the ugly feelings, vile prejudices and idiot ideas of 90s dirtbag masculinity, even in the way his focus shifts to reacting to his own fame. There WERE a million guys just like him, grown men with the personality of Cartman.
*2000. *Clever lyrics, catchy tunes, thoughtful tracks, and plenty of ridiculous over-the-top profanity in between. *This is a long one (1 hr, 17 mins), so tried to hurry through it, but ended up listening to most tracks. *Fun, irreverent, and classic Eminem. RATING - 8/10
There are some classics on this album but they hard carried this album to the 3 stars. In reality, it’s a 2 star and I will not be explaining myself further. Please stop saying this is better than the Slim Shady LP because it’s not.
Didn't get through this, puerile and mysoginist nonsense, made with a load of skits that just seem..... juvenile in the worst way. Barely any musicality in it to redeem it
Amazing album.
One of THE definitive rap albums of the last 30 years.
Meh. Rap’s not my fave. Some beats are cool but nothing special. Questionable lyrics.
The production on this album is undeniably high-quality, filled with catchy beats and memorable hooks. Even though I’m not a fan of Dr. Dre and don’t follow his work, I have to admit that he’s a top-tier producer. Now, onto Eminem. I know my opinion might be outnumbered by the masses, but I’ve always struggled to see him as a timeless musical legend. His wacky, silly, and goofy wordplay, laced with provocative and sarcastic humor, just doesn’t resonate with me. It feels more like satire with a level of maturity that specifically targets a young adolescent demographic. Sure, it’s a phase we can all relate to at some point in our development into adulthood. And yes, maybe his music spans generations, but it’s also a phase that we’re meant to grow out of. As one generation moves past that stage, another younger generation steps in to take over where the last one left off. But here’s the thing: if you found yourself relating to Eminem at 20 and are still listening to him at 60, that might be a pretty good indicator that you never really evolved or grew up.
Amazing
Raw and no bars held for any disgusting theme. R*pe, incest, murder, domestic violence.. were we ok? Poor Marshall Mathers.
Stan and Real Slim Shady are Classics. A lot of provocative lyrics. I remember listening to this on my neighbors porch as a kid.
It is a very recognizable album with corrosive thoughts (real but angry) all over it. While its causes thought and is clever I really don't enjoy listening to this album.
Eminem’s willingness to put his different personas on display, especially the blatantly noxious ones, is the most interesting thing about this album. The juxtaposition of one song against another (as in the comparison another listener already made between “Stan” and “Kim”) really makes you think about Eminem’s intentions. He obviously wants you to realize he doesn’t mean everything he says, but he also meaningfully reflects on the consequences of what he says. There are no easy answers and many points, both for and against this album and its songs, are valid. For me personally, the density and sheer playfulness of the wordplay, the whiplash of the content/subject matter, and Eminem’s unfuckwithable flow are enough to score this high points and deem it a must-listen (#213). One point deducted for the too-high volume of misogyny (whether he means it or not) and a few completely unnecessary tracks.
Wow! This is actually a really good album. I'm even a bit surprised. Clever and fun
Along with his debut album, Slim Shady LP, this is Em's best work. Cartoon violence, angry, sarcastic, purposely dumb and clever lyrics in equal portions.
In general, rap/hip hop is not for me, but Eminem changes the game. His songs are fun and easy to follow. Sure, times have changed, but this album will always be on point. Though listening to this album at 8AM is an interesting choice I made 👌
This album made me appreciate Eminem as an artist. However, this album also did not inspire me to buy more Eminem albums. I hope he's processed his anger.
This is a great album. It's also really hard to listen 25 years after its release.
I had this on repeat when I was younger. I'd say the same as all of you, but this hasn't aged well and now I feel ancient. Cheers, Album Generator :( Stan and The Way I Am still slap so I'm meeting my review halfway with 12 year old Darren.
I liked this when I was young and there's still some good songs and it was important 25 years ago but I'm going to rate it through modern lens
Genuinely embarrassed that I used to listen to this as a ten year old with my parents within earshot. I begged for this album for Christmas, I think my parents actually might have taken it off me after hearing some of the lyrical content. Found myself cringing a bit at it today, I don't think you'd get away with writing an album like this these days. Am I woke? Some bangers on here right enough though, Stan still slaps, but there's so much filler too.
Not my fave tbh, but nostalgic.
I kind of hated it but can’t deny how massive this one was culturally. The way I am is a great track. And the production is iconic
funny and entertaining i suppose. but on the same note also the most obnoxious shit ever. don’t study and listen to this at the same time
Better than i expected, but I got bit tired of the all dicks and bitches towards the end
Eminem is an artist I have very mixed feelings about. On one hand, he’s an extremely skilled rapper and has some very insightful songs, but on the other hand, he leans too much into the humorous side. This album — or more precisely, its hit songs — were played so much on MTV and other music TV shows back in the day that they’ve gone stale in my mind.
Hit songs have wore through, rest of the tunes don't really interest me at all. Not enough music and way too much "lyrics" for me to enjoy this. It's like watching a juggler or contortionist who perfected their art, after the first few tricks I'm bored and mind wandering I can't really follow the act anymore. He is a very talented lyricist, witty with his words and jackhammer with his lines, these are practically the same reasons (but ones applicable to the guitar) I don't listen to Yngwie Malmsteen.
Surprisingly (to me) arresting. Can be pretty self-aware. I love the stripped down directness. Fuck off his disgusting homophobia. Rhymes rule.
I’m a little conflicted because usually I hate hip-hop. But Eminem, with his beats and choice of melodies and samples, slightly won me over. I can even appreciate that he’s speaking as a character in a character sometimes but the themes really worry me. And he may have mellowed over the years, but this still feels quite anrrogant and in your face. And I really don’t like those little inserts.
I was impressed by Eminem's raw ability to rap and he channels his anger well and even has a sense of humor—though I don't think he's funny. By the time I got to Marshall Mathers, I also realized he can fuck off.
OK, yeah, we get it. You're a complicated, misunderstood genius or whatever. Can you untie me now so I go listen to music by people who don't only talk about themselves? This dude can rap better than just about anyone, and some of the beats are pretty cool. But christ almighty, the amount of homophobia and misogyny you have to wade through...it's just not worth it. And yeah, I get that he's playing a character inside another character who's killing another character or whatever, but I don't give a shit.
I just couldn't stomach this right now. I made it to Slim Shady.
this album is the antithesis of pride month. it's completely original, and i mainly enjoyed it so i'll give it brownie points.
What a pile of edgelord drivel. Horrible lyrics. If you enjoy this and have finished puberty then I'm going to think less of you.
Lekkere rap
Classic album. It's got all the greats. But the skits are dumb.
18 tracks, a lot of shit, but some really good ones to balance it out. Plus he added stan to the lexicanum. 2.5 stars
kiintoisa katsaus
Very good album, some tracks that im glad i listened to but are pretty visceral and upsetting.
a melhor parte é a produção do dre
Wow. I’ve listened to this album for hours and hours back when I was 14-15 I loved the explicit lyrics, I loved the whole vibe. The Marshall Mathers LP felt raw, rebellious, and unlike anything else at the time.
This felt very 2000s. The fictional conversations between the music company 'suit' felt cringe, and is that... what....? I had to skip that. But in other senses I liked some of the 'hits'.
Strong memories of driving down to Wales as a 13-year-old and listening to this cassette on my walkman in the back seat while my dad listened to Radio 2 on the car stereo. Bleak holiday times. Some very skilled rapping. And probably the very first hip hop album I truly go into. Hard listen now though. Can't really justify such intense homophobia and violence against women, even it's it all in this purposefully offensive persona. Very first couple of seasons of South Park.
The skits/or interludes are pretty awful. But some class songs in there! Very nostalgic stuff!
nasty piece of work, white trash rapping, influenced too many kids in the total wrong way. He had a talent, could have been something, made a difference - instead he didn't. Sounds worse now then when it was first released.
I didn't like him when I was young and I still don't like him now. 1 extra star for Stan
This genre is a big no for me. Not enjoyable at all.
One of the greatest hip-hop albums of all time. He continued to piss people off by dumping his own insecurities, fear, anger and hatred into our ears. The fact that 'Stan' was a UK Christmas number one and is now shorthand for an overzealous fan, shows how he had pretty much conquered the world at this point. He'd never be as good again. Best Tracks: Kill You; The Real Slim Shady; Criminal
Man he’s such an asshole but I really relate to how much he hates people. It's a troubling and intense ride. I can't really rate it higher but I do think it's an important and exemplary piece of art.
I'm a total hypocrite. Normally disgusting lyrics are a non-starter for me. But the thing is, the first like eight songs here are complete bangers. And I also like Eminem, like, as a person and an artist. A lot of the lyrics are definitely rough, but the rhythms are good, the melodies are good, and it's a perfect time capsule of the millennium. A high 3, if I'm being completely honest.
First of all, I hate this. Entirely putting aside the arguments about negatively influencing children, I hate it because it's got that "haha just kidding" shit that inspires the most insufferable so-called humor coming out of dudebros at the bar. I think the outrage I feel is mirrored back at me. These fucked up, angry, cruel, gross lyrics are coming out of impoverished, abandoned communities that live in survival mode. It's flipping off the hypocrisy of the rich and the lack of solidarity from the middle class. There's a lot of pain, violence, and cruelty that festers in poor communities and I think Eminem reflects that. At the end of the day, I find it to be artistically impressive but immature and repulsive. Glad to have listened to it for the music education aspect though.
Some good beats. Great wordplay and flow. Also though, the misogyny and homphobia wrapped up in its little, rage bait, satire bow is hugely unpalatable. I love hip hip and this dudes talent is massive, but it''s fucking gross. Not a Stan....
Some bangers but overall just too dark and angry for me
I've listened to this before. It's very angry.
It sounds great and I get the appeal, but the edgelord lyrics are rough to sit through. I’m not a prude or easily offended, I just know when someone’s trying way too hard. It’s just a pretty cringe listening experience.
I never listened to this when it came out because it was not my thing and i was preoccupied with life, so it was quite interesting listening to it now 25 years later. I was pleasantly surprised and it started off really well. All songs up to Slim shady were pretty solid and i really enjoyed it. then a few average songs and Marshall Mathers was ok. Then I had to endure the sound of a dick being sucked. Whats the deal with sounds of someone getting their dick sucked. This is the second rap album on this list where i have had to endure that. that put me off a lot. i feel like the first half was very good and the second half was average. It was a definite 4 stars and ended up a 3.5
Again problematic lyrics but his rapping is top notch and stan an all time great