Reviews (page 4 of 8)
It may have come on a bad day, but i've never heard of this album and I totally hated it. Sorry to any fans out there. Seems to me that there was some misguided hype around the time of its release (where it was built up for being something that it wasn't) before the band quickly revealed themselves to be unspectacular. Painful and a living torture to listen.
Couldn't understand why an album like this would be enjoyable for anyone until I saw the top comment on Getting Bright at Night: "Great song. Shot a lot of heroin to this entire cd" and then I got it.
Meh. This is the sort of forgettable rock that takes up way too much space on this list. Maybe it was influential or groundbreaking in some place or time, but I don't really care. Give me more jazz. Give me more electronic. Give me more hip hop!
Great album. Really good.
Waste of time, talentless American copy of decent British indie music.
This a pretty energetic and heavy post-punky sort of sound. Very much of its time. Perhaps I'll play this a few more times - I quite enjoyed it though it doesn't sound wildly original to me.
Average overhyped noise band from the early 00’s.
The Good: This is going to be an interesting evening! The Bad: I missed the memo that stated a Soiree can also be shit… The Ugly: Nothing can get uglier than the penance of listening to this… Noise… Shit noise… 1*
I didn't dislike this as much as I thought I would. Post-hardcore (good gosh there's too many genres) is a flavor of music I don't really care much for. But the harder punk elements and dirty production mixed with some more palatable. That said, I hesitate to say I like it. It's just not really for me. It's a fine 3/5.
прикольно
RAWK! One gets the immediate sense that this band needs to be seen live. It's an amalgam of Stooges attitude and energy with notes of grunge and early 2000s stoner rock. Overall a fun and engaging record that I'm glad I was exposed to. But not something I would put on any "great records" list, including this one.
I like Aaron North but this kind of sucked
Needs a few listens to appreciate, at times felt repetitive but every so often there's great bits to catch your attention.
316/1089 - I can't tell if the book shits the bed in the 21st century or if the internet + streaming + telecommunications act of 1996 + poptimism really did that much damage to cool stuff in mainstream music. At least I actively look for modern music I like and find it but a lot if people today are stuck in their nostalgia-spirals. Anyways, this was very average noisy garage rock.
The sleaziest Indie sleaze I've ever heard
Penance Soirée is a good album. Post-punk/hardcore. It’s loud and raw. I personally liked the middle of the best with Spike Island, Getting Brighter at Night and Big Sleep being the highlights but over all the album is a bit too long at 54 mins. It should be noted that The Icarus Line is just a poor man’s Death From Above and the lack of Canadian music on here is borderline offensive. If DFA was from LA, they’d have multiple albums on here. 7.8/10
Was this really good or am I just starved for any distortion at all? Call that the Sonic Youth effect.
I always felt that this was the music the 2 kids from High Fidelity created. I like it, but it’s incredibly niche.
I'd say this is an acquired taste, but only if you like noise rock. I like loud, I like metal, but I'm not that found of this.
just boring
Descent alt rock, but nothing inspiring me here. At times they sound a bit like the white stripes, or even Suicide, but that’s all I took away.
Gear: Moondrop Variations Artwork: 👩🏻🦱👁️🪱 Production: 🎛️📢🤏 Music: 🤯🌀😴 Rating: 🪽☀️(💥)/5
Thoughts before listening: Gothy indie pop or something I think. I never really paid these guys much attention. Review: Nope. Totally wrong on this one. This is punkish alt rock, pretty similar in vibe to stuff that I was listening to in the 00s like At the Drive-In or Queens of the Stone Age. This is okay although I'm not hearing any songs as good as those other bands, and I don't really see anything to justify their inclusion on this list. Feels like another swing and miss from the editors to choose a contemporary album that deserved inclusion. 2-stars
Why is this here? Like, genuinely. I'm not trying to dismiss this as irrelevant garbage or anything, even if I don't care for this album myself. I just want to know how this entered the radar of the people who made the book and why they felt this was a must-listen. Wikipedia says it was one of 2004's most critically acclaimed albums, but I know that that's a load of BS since I can name at least 10 albums from that year that are more acclaimed off the top of my head. Man, 2004 was a good year for music. It's a shame that only like half of the albums included on this list from that year even matter at all. Too much obscure noisy indie albums, not enough MF DOOM. Both Madvillainy and Mm..Food should've been included over... this. Whatever. This album's not horrible, I guess. However, I don't really see a reason to enjoy it that much. It's a bit too noisy for my taste. Don't get me wrong. It could be worse. I mean, this isn't even the worst noise album of 2004 on this list! That Liars album was WAY worse! However, this album still has moments on songs like "Meatmaker" that I did not enjoy at all. Some parts were alright. I thought "Up Against The Wall Motherfuckers" was a solid opener. The vocals could've been more annoying. They kinda reminded me of a more compressed version of Cedric Bixler-Zavala from The Mars Volta. In fact, this whole thing kinda feels like a noisier, worse version of his other band, At the Drive-In. The writing is certainly fitting of the album's sound. It's a bit too long. This isn't horrible, but I can't say that I enjoyed it much. 2/5.
This is pretty terrible. They sound like a really bad Marilyn Manson, and that’s not saying much to begin with. This band falls short on so many levels starting with the guitar work that is flat, boring, and weak.
Some songs are too long. Don't like the music.
Nasty rock very emblematic of early 2000s
Okay, not really into this sorta "noise rock", but I can see how it's an evolution of a sound that has been going on for decades. There's a straight line from the Stooges to these guys.
Would not listen to again.
the occasional enjoyable riff sullied by constant screaming and chaos Would I listen again: no Deserves to be on this list: maybe 1.9
Not for me, but not a bad album
This one track, Getting Bright At Night, was a great post-rock song. The rest of the album was pretty boring. Sometimes feels like early Nick Cave, Fugazi, etc.
Dreadful. I nearly liked it and can see why it fits in with the strong rock themes of this book but it's mediocre and dull and inane. Can't really believe I made it to the end.
meh
Sounds well produced but not my thing
Some good headbangin' moments....some not so good, drawn out moments. It was okay.
These guys sound how my parents thought my music sounded growing up.
Solid album. On my first listen most of this was kind of meh, but it was growing on me by the last few songs. So I listened to the album again. It’s straight forward, noisy, heavy, sleazy rock. Nothing amazing, but I like their sound overall.
I’d never heard of this band, which is crazy because in 2004, this was the exact type of music I was listening to. Admittedly, a lot of rock music sounded like this at that time, which probably contributed to the flatlined-dead state of rock that we live in now. Penance Soirée is hardly listenable, and even if you allow yourself to bop your head to a segment in the middle of a sprawling nine minute song, not enough joy is supplied to prompt a revisit. There are no singles here. It wouldn’t be defined as ‘artistic’ by the majority. For the most part, it’s drudgery. I will say, however, that in the most literal sense, it ‘rocks.’ This whole album is loud and intense and chock-full of guitar freak-outs. It’s not a representative sample of this era’s rock music. It’s more of a deep cut, so I do appreciate the exposure via this generator. In 1001 albums, I want to get knee deep in different eras and genres, not just listen through the same classics I’ve already heard a million times. It’s obvious the singer was a led zep/ Jack White fan, but apparently the guitarist was enough of a Stevie Ray Vaughn fan to break a display case at a Hard Rock Cafe and steal his guitar. So, mirroring their music, his actions were insufferable, but then again, despite how psychotic causing a scene at the Hard Rock Cafe is, it technically does ‘rock’. Dude plays for NIN now, so at least someone saw value here.
Repetitive, noisy but boring. There's a reason this band aren't very well-known. A knock-off White Stripes/Royal Blood.
What of Audioslave did not have a great singer? The answer to that question is this album.
Gick inte att lyssna på någonstans. 1
not great, too loose
Are they okay?
That this was made in 2004 makes it sooo late to the party
No idea how this band passed me by at the time. It is fairly forgettable I guess so maybe they just disappeared from my memory
Ok album. No reason to be on here.
Meh … individually, each song was fine but I didn’t want to listen to 13 of them in a row.
OK post-hardcore.
A product of the early 2000s garage rock movement. I appreciate for what it is. There’s some songs that are rough on the ears for me. This was going to be a 2 star after the first couple of tracks but then there would be something to pull me back in.
...
It’s quite okay - noisy but still okay. Too bad I can’t listen to this on Spotify but have to listen on Youtube
nice. very in line with my taste. standout tracks for me: - kiss like lizards - getting bright at night - virgin velcro - seasick
Strokes-y, but sometimes better (and sometimes worse). Still a great record that I had never heard of.
2 Stars. I just want to skip every song. It's not bad per-say, just annoying and noisy - Not as dark as the album name and cover implied. Not terrible rock - Quality dropped rapidly on 2nd song
First listen
fun distortion. good energy.
Forgettable, boring, and generic. Next album, please
Best Song: Up Against The Wall Motherfucker. Compared to some of the other songs on the album, this one actually had some dynamism; it wasn't full speed all the time. Worst Song: Meatmaker. What in the Guantanamo Bay is this torture music? It sounds like there's several alarms going in the background. Overall: Sounds like a dozen other bands. It's not bad, it's just forgettable, and feels a bit generic to that early 00's indie rock sound.
Not bad at all. Not currently my thing, but this reminded of the hard indie/alt rock scene if the early 00's from whenst it came. Idek if they make actual new rock music anymore.
Like any millennial, I am often nostalgic for the 00s and my formative years. But please, no more mid 00s frat bro rock.
This wasn’t as bad as I feared. It definitely sounds of its era, and the lead singer has that bored rockstar drawl. There’s a lot of alt rock that sounds like a lame version of this (e.g. Black Keys, Cage The Elephant) and people love that stuff. At least this goes hard.
I liked the energy and grunginess, but as it went on it became more forgettable. Wouldn't revisit.
Just alt hard rock. Everything hit you in the face but not necessarily in a great way. Nothing was overly special or different, it just was.
No thanks. Too noisy & couldn't get into it.
This sounds like every single rock album made between 2000 and 2005. Absolutely nothing special going on here and it does not deserve to be on this list.
This was noisy and mostly annoying.
Not sure how I’ve never heard of these guys until now. Awesome grimy rock.
They tried
Would give this 3.5 if i could. Got a good groove when it gets going!
Awful
Sounds like a supergroup with the members of Jet and Cage the Elephant. Has all the raw power of such a collaboration, but is lacking in clear focus or sheer hit-making ability. Some great moments (the drumming on “Big Sleep,” for example), but not consistent enough to merit a 4.
What a cool find. I really enjoyed this album from start to finish. The band is tight and the songs work really well together. “Getting Bright At Night” was the highlight for me.
Vokal som Manson, Chris coenell, og Elias Rønnefeld, og en stemning som Rock Hard Power Spray, måske noget QOTSA, og Resedents i slutningen af albummet. En samlet bolion terning af musik som jeg er vokset op med da jeg blev gammel nok til at få min egen musiksmag. Fedt at finde lidt guld på listen igen!
Jack White’s low-fi skramlede Garage lyd, spillet med en Hardcore Punk attitude.
I didn't much care for this one, it was mostly indecipherable noise. A few tracks worked alright, but the overall package was monotonous. Maybe a little harsh on this rating, but there were a few times these songs rubbed me the wrong way. Favorite track: "Getting Bright At Night"
Mostly noise and nothing particularly groundbreaking.
I had only ever heard of these guys and I liked a lot of it, but it lost me after a while. Seemed like the same old trope the whole way through and I started to cringe a bit. But really, not bad at all.
Had absolutely no idea this existed. Rare occurrence on this list. Not life changing otherwise. .
mid
Forgettable noughts rock, presumably on a label owned a friend of the lists author
Une écoute très cosy, qui me rappelait une époque où j'écoutais plus régulièrement des sons punk-rock. Contente d'avoir découvert ce groupe et du même coup le label "post-hardcore" dont le qualifie Wikipédia. Un bon dosage saturation / mélodie, avec un rock classique maîtrisé et des dérapages plutôt contrôlés à mon goût. Je me suis laissé embarquer : suffisamment classique pour être entraînée sans réticence, et décalé ("punk DIY" / expérimentation noise) pour stimuler sans me lasser au long de l'album. Pas une découverte renversante, mais un bon moment. Je me demande quelle était la force de la proposition à l'époque, mais je mesure un peu mieux la généalogie du punk rock, et ce qu'il y a pu avoir entre la génération The Clash et celle de Royal Blood, comme ce petit chaos aussi maîtrisé que subversif de la scène "post-hardcore" ouest-américaine des années 1990.
un style de musique assez éloigné de mes préférences, mais étonnamment un album qui passe plutôt (très) bien. petit coup de coeur pour On the lash, White Devil, et Getting Bright at Night, qui ont un petit quelque chose de vibrant, de dément, que j'ai trouvé sans même savoir que je le cherchais. un enchaînements de sons qui donne une vraie petite claque, avec des effets de distorsion vraiment intéressants, et évidemment une guitare électrique poussée dans ses retranchements. bref, étonnante découverte : 3.7 étoiles (arrondies à 3 par souci de cohérence avec mon appréciation pour l'album de Hendrix)
Not my genre of music at all, but it was easy enough to put on in the background. Just not for me personally.
Much better than I thought. A good loud album.
Decent album but not super interesting for me
Not for me, really
In 1997, the band Sleater-Kinney proclaimed "words and guitar, I want it", well this is words and guitar and I don't want it.
Had a few cool riffs and licks but did not really get into any song as a whole. It's like White Stripes / Iggy Pop without good hooks.
I haven't looked it up but I'd bet good money this album was removed from later editions of the book. It should be at least a little bit my sort of thing but I'm genuinely surprised by how unremarkable I continue to find it, even after multiple listens. 1.5
Well, I definitely don’t think this album deserves to be on a top albums list, but aside from that, I thought it was a pretty decent early 2000s post-punk, and noise rock album. You can definitely hear influences from bands like Sonic Youth and maybe even The Jesus Lizard, but they also really reminded me a lot of Death From Above 1979, especially since they were part of the same era. One element this album had that stood out was a glam side, which I thought was pretty cool and actually even made me think of The Stooges at times.
This was loud and noisy, interesting in parts but pretty dull in others. All in all, not terrible but wouldn't choose to listen again
LOVED
Couldn’t find it yo listen to
Too heavy heavy
Not bad, but it just sounds like every other American punk band
Missed these guys. Take the Brian Jonestown Massacre, Idles, Frank Black and mix them all together and this is what you got. The music sounds like the cover art. Interesting but not something I could play every day.
Never heard of this band but I thought they were a pretty good rock/metal band/grunge band. Good guitar and the singer had a good voice.
This was cool, something I’ve never heard before and kind of the goal of this journey. Kind of a mix of audioslave and queens of the Stone Age and something else. The bass is real crunchy, distorted bass isn’t something you hear all the time. Pretty good stuff.
Pretty good stuff. I liked it
This is fine but not really for me. Better than yet more early english rock though.
Enjoyed this quite a lot, never heard of them before
Is definitely above other noisy rocky punky albums of its kind. But ultimately not my genre exactly - might require relistens to fully appreciate
Too hardcore for my tastes. Pass.
A bit typical of the time and more screechy than I tend to prefer.
Raw, garage-ey rock
Bloody good noise rock with some absolute belters!
It's noise, You expect it to add something new but its just generic garage early 2000's noise.
noisy and not good
I liked this album, so much. It is fresh and has many good songs. I didn't expect to find things like that on this list, but I'm glad there are. It was hard to find the album, though.
Gets a bit annoying after a while. Rock
This album is borderline an assault on the ears. The aggressive guitars, hazy vocals and heavy drums make for an absolute bombardment of feral punk rock. There are so many really strong moments here but the hour long album lacks diversity or any moments of change, leaving it feel samey as you get towards the latter half of the album.
I absolutely hated this, can I do a negative number?
4/5
Noise. Penance or Punishment Party? Didn't love, can't hate. Previously listened: N Saved tracks: N Favorite tracks: none ⭐⭐
Sometimes my assigned album is a nice way to start the day. This is not one of those days. I just hear noise. Seriously, what are the criteria for this list? Well, I definitely did not expect that saxophone. Huh. Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): N/A ⭐⭐: Didn't like it, didn't hate it. Saved no tracks.
Among some pretty bad selections I’ve been getting on here lately
Never heard of this band but I guess they were pretty big at the time and were post-hardcore adjacent? They did a split with Ink & Dagger? Okay, sure. There's a couple of good songs here but this is just a bit boring. Like if someone who was in The Dandy Warhols got really into noise punk for a bit. It's fine, but the songs drag on and have no point, and I feel like that clashes with this style of more 'aggressive' music. Wish I liked this more because I'm starved for something in this list that's more in the vein of the style of noise rock/post-hardcore I really like but this was just decent.
Look, I have no doubt that these guys were a handful even by rock-star standards - Aaron North in particular seems to be chaos personified, and you don't have *this* many lyrics about heroin on an album without there being some, ah, active participation. But headaches or no, V2 refusing to promote this album at the time of its release was some stupid shit. Like, if you can't sell "Jet, but *actually* punk" to the world then quit your job already. Seriously, what a collection: Joe Cardamone's vocals slither all over the history of noisy music before hitting right in the sweet spot between Iggy Pop, Tom Verlaine, and Cedric Bixler-Zavala. The guitar work chases the same set of influences, with the occasional Albini ("Meatmaker") thrown in for good measure. The centerpiece "Getting Bright at Night" particularly feels like an attempt to update Television for a new generation - a worthy task if there ever was one. And "Spike Island" would have been a hit - Verlaine-esque vocals, suitably sleazy guitar, seedy lyrics, the works. The world was ready for this and I'm glad it survived, even if the band itself didn't.
Incoherent, loud, shit mixing.
There's a very cool album somewhere in there, and yeah, it's probably somewhere between Royal Blood and The White Stripes with a hint of something else, but then once every few minutes it goes totally edgelord for the sake of it and it gets hard to listen to.
Listened Before? N Well, this is telling something about my musical tastes but I ABSOLUTELY LOVED this album. Raw and brutal. Reminds me of early Nirvana. Absolutely killer. Added to Library? Y Songs added to playlist: Kiss Like Lizards
★½
Honestly this one hurt my ears sometimes, but it was also pretty cool.
Nope. Not for me. 3/10
Music to listen to while you feed your snake. This was pretty bad. They want to be Marylin Manson but are closer to Oasis. Every instrument is routed through a bullhorn.
Every track is the same, distorted. The lead vocal helps keep the band together. The sound does grow on you.
Pretty good, a but samey but overall great sound
Nah
At least it's not Kanye?
Half decent garage rock.
This one felt like déjà vu in leather pants. Between the sleazy riffs, messy distortion, and over-the-top swagger, it’s less “fresh chaos” and more “already done a dozen times by better bands.” I struggled to find any real spark of originality here.
Started off a little too garage rock for me but turned into some real cathartic dissonance near the end
Sweet! An album I’ve never heard from a band I’ve heard about for a long time! I honestly was a little underwhelmed. The first half of the album is just okay hard rock, the songs were forgettable for me. The second half of the album gets a little more experimental and definitely benefits from it. “Getting Bright at Night” was definitely a standout track. Also loved the Suicide nod “Meatmaker” 7/10
Vocals sit somewhere between Tom Verlaine, Iggy Pop and Trent Reznor. Instrumentals leave a lot to be desired - but kind of understand what could be considered shocking for 2004. No real standout songs other than maybe Spike Island
There are a lot of other Hellcat bands that people probably aren’t familiar with that are more worthy of being on this list. I never got hooked here.
Angry, dissonant rock. Maybe I wasn’t in the mindset to listen, but I did not like.
Loud noise, the band. Favorite song: n/a
Loud. Ok.
Black Rebel Motorcycle Drive-In? Tempted to say a low 4. Could have been shorter.
Well, that was an unexpected one. I quite enjoyed it, I don't know that any of the tracks jumped out as great songs, but I enjoyed the ride. Actually reminded me quite a lot of Jet, I'm not sure that they are a polite comparison as often they seem to get derided, but it's that heavier swagger that they have. These feel perhaps more American in tone, but it feels essentially the same. I quite enjoyed it, I'm not immediately seeking out more, but I would like to hear their big tracks to see if anything drags me in, which none of these quite did.
No es malo, pero no es mi gusto. rock con poco color.
2.5
There's a lot to like here: Noisey guitars, the drum sound, some interesting song structures. At first - given the first song and the release date - I thought I was in for a noisy emo treat, but the more I listened, the more it sounded like Buckcherry. In total, it probably lands somewhere in between Buckcherry and At the Drive-In, and that's not a positive. The vocals are a little too cock-rock for my tastes, and the songs often seem self-indulgent. It's ... fine. But I don't need it in my life. (An aside: Listening to this randomly brought to mind the fictional band from Almost Famous. I have no specific memory of what that band sounds like, but I swear it's something like this. I'll have to check on that.)
Listened, but mostly didn't like. Unclear why I needed to listen to this. A few catchy tunes doesn't outweigh the middling quality of the whole.
Meh.
2/5 - I didn’t need to hear this album, and I almost didn’t make it through. I’d like to either have some groove or some melody with my noise, and this had neither for me. Generally annoying, but I can see how some would find merit in it, so it’s a 2.
Love the pixies. classic punk and rock and from my home town. they have a roughness that's hard to emulate since any attempts at imitation become your own voice.
Cool but too hard for me.
I liked this album for the most part. I can hear lots of different influences in it and even though it's not the most original it's got some good energy. I don't know how often I would come back to it though. 3.4/5
Heard of this band, but never listened. I really thought of like Mick Jagger in the vocals initially, but then read about Iggy Pop leanings in the album and that was a better fit. Later, it reminded me of Closure in Moscow. I initially wasn't sure if I was feeling this because it's pretty derivative, but it did end up winning me over. I enjoyed this and would relisten. 3.25/5
took me quite a while to listen to the whole thing, but it was pretty cool
Not an album for me at all… honestly surprised this is on the 1001 best albums
Well, I definitely don’t think this album deserves to be on a top albums list, but aside from that, I thought it was a pretty decent early 2000s post-punk, and noise rock album. You can definitely hear influences from bands like Sonic Youth and maybe even The Jesus Lizard, but they also really reminded me a lot of Death From Above 1979, especially since they were part of the same era. One element this album had that stood out was a glam side, which I thought was pretty cool and actually even made me think of The Stooges at times.
Nie ma dramatu, ale do słuchania samemu, albo na kossach albo dobre głośniki w aucie
I will admit that I wasn't closely listening to this album, but I was really enjoying it. I didn't really pick up on anything special about it, but it's solid 2000s indie rock that had me jamming along pretty much the whole time. Favorite Song(s): On the Lash
I enjoyed it. Hard Rock and the back story was interesting. Not something I can just listen to all day. Decent though for a sitting or in a mix. 6.0
Enjoyed it on first listen but I think it'll take more to really get into it. It got a little long by the end.
Baffling inclusion considering how completely unknown they are, but overall a decent surprise. Very strong start, sorta loses momentum, then picks up on some cool experimentation
Fav: Up Against The Wall Motherfucker Least Fav: Meatmaker The same song copy and pasted. Should’ve been 30 mins but thankfully the one idea they had wasn’t too bad
Mérite une réécoute. 3,5/5
1.5
I have never once wondered “what if Fun House was indie sleeze” - it’s alright! I’ve rated albums lower but this is the first I’ve thought “there’s no way this is anyone’s favorite album” - no shot it deserves to be here
Pleasant surprise of an awesome album I've never come across. All around enjoyable. 3.5/5
Am I missing something? Very run of the mill
Shitty rock Album
A cacophony that didn't make any sense to me. Average but may listen again when the mood takes me.
Loud and raw Not in a good way
I actually don't know how to rate this one, all i know is i like half of the songs on there. very solid garage rock
On the surface this looked like the exact kind of thing I love, noisy punk with a bit of garage and hard rock influence AND a cool cover? Sign me up! What I got was something a lot... milder? It's more mid tempo type of garage punk ala Stooges than something with more legit fire and drive to it like many of the bands I love, but it is a fun time none the less so I still think i won listening to this one and also it being so different than the typical 1001 album pick
Solid sound, if a bit disjointed. It did feel overall cohesive. Not a bad listen!
super fun and heavy, diverse too!
I can't tell you how these guys stand out from the sea of 1990s "post-hardcore" bands but they do and I dig it.
Another mystery band and album, one of the things I enjoy about this project, even with the duds (and certainly much more interesting than the 7th Leonard Cohen/Beatles/David Bowie/etc album). I'm not sure I'd exactly call this a dud, but it's also not all that compelling, except perhaps that I would have guessed it was from the 90s and not 2003/2004. There's a few good titles to their tracks (especially the opening track), but I would be hard-pressed to distinguish most of the tracks from each other, and there's unfortunately a bit too much Marilyn-Manson-esque sound for my tastes (mainly the guitar and the lead singer, although at times (especially in "Getting bright at night") I was more reminded of Jane's Addiction). "Spike island" was probably the most accessible song of the lot, and I'm not entirely sure what it was about, like most of the album. Regardless, shame on their label (V2 Records) for letting them hang out to dry, neither promoting the album at all and even forcing the band to pay for the music videos. And kudos to the "1001 Albums" reviewer, who apparently spent the time to interpret the largely-unintelligible lyrics and declare that "Kiss the lizard", "Getting bright at night" and "Big sleep" form a 20-minute "odyssey" centered around "a caustic love song"; almost intriguing enough to listen again (but only almost).
Another band where I can't tell which is the album name and which is the artist. Doesn't really matter; this wasn't that interesting. They played some music and screamed for a while. I think they were upset about something.
Title of first song turned me off.
Interesting but not enjoyable.
No, sorry not for me.
It was alright
Not as bad as the global reviews but still not good
This is a weird one. Maybe I just need to buy the book to see if the editors announce their motivations adding an album to the list. But this album, while acclaimed at the time, doesn't appear to have been wildly influential. The band, who sound like they were mostly a regional act with stints opening for bigger bands on tour, has largely been forgotten (1,995 monthly listeners on Spotify). Not saying there shouldn't be some underground stuff on the list but I'm always left wondering "why *this* one?" Anyway, all that said, I enjoyed the album. 3.5 rounding up.
2.5
*Penance Soiree* Starting from the opening track I thought I was actually going to like this album. Starting from the second track I realized I am going to hate this album. Honestly this was really a mixed bag of songs that I liked "Up Against the Wall Motherfucker", "Spike Island", and "Getting Bright At Night" a bunch of generic 2K aughts rock "On the Lash", "Virgin Velcro", "Party the Bsby Off", and utter crapfest... Pretty much the rest of the album. The Crapfest won the overall rating for me. (4.4) ★★
Mediocre indie from 00s. 2.5 stars
I thought there were parts of this that were kind of cool -- "Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers", "On the Lash", "Spike Island" -- but a lot of it was pretty mediocre. It sounds like a lot of other stuff at the time, so I can see why it may have gotten some praise from critics like Drowned in Sound and Tiny Mix Tapes, but when you dig deeper, the songwriting isn't very good -- it's just like this mid-2000s garage-y noise rock without any legs. 3 stars.
3.5
Quite the hot and noisy 00s indie landfill entry. Whether it’s yelpy Pitchfork party jams or extended hardcore suites it just does it super run of the mill and average like. Not one riff or melody that sticks. It might have a place on NME’s top 1001 albums coming out in May 2004 but definitely not here.
I also once dropped all the pots and pans in my kitchen and called it "music" Seriously, this was awful
I really wanted to like this album. Hardcore and rock are usually right in my wheelhouse, but this one just did not land at all. Instead of feeling powerful or raw, it leaned too far into the noise rock side of things without the depth or craft needed to pull it off. The problem is not the chaos itself but the lack of direction. Good noise rock, like what Sonic Youth managed to do, has an edge of talent and structure behind the mess. Penance Soiree feels like it’s trying to go for that vibe but ends up sounding sloppy and hollow.
I think I'm just mad its not on Spotify. Some interesting melodies, I guess it sounds like a noisier deftones? I don't think it goes harder with the screams, it has a weird rock and rolly-vibe, but the guitar is so noisey
Bra första låt men blir lökigare med tiden. Sångaren är typ den som drar ner betyget. Helt ok överlag, inget super. Önskar det varit lite tyngre, sångaren förstörde en del för mig. Tkr den är average, säkert 2,5.
it's not that there's no post-hardcore on this list, but what there is is a strange bunch. a lot of genre classics and staples ignored in favor of... this? either way it was a nice find. i like noisy, i like raw, i like punk. it is kind of bogged down by the garage rock revival qualities but there's enough noise to make it a more pleasant listen than anything The White Stripes ever did. not essential though deserves to be one of the 1001? it's not bad at all but no. not important enough. sorry :(
Not good.
Metal and me do not mesh
Heavy metal vibe / bad lyrics. Not a fan
2004 Never heard of this, but it's a banger... Full of filthy bass and definitely purchase material. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ twice Revisit ✅️ Very, very good ★★★★☆ (8/10)
Karmeeta meteliä ja melua! Sitten ihan järkevääkin tilutusta ja rokkia nopealla tahdilla.
Fist listen. No problem with this, none at all.
All the songs sound the same and I didn’t enjoy any of them.
Nicht verfügbar auf Spotify
I was under the impression that these 1001 records were curated by a panel of respected music critics, but sometimes I come across a record that just makes me scratch my head as to why it was included. Icarus Line’s Penance Soirée is one of those for me. What impact did this record make on anyone? Like, noisy garage rock is not an unknown genre to me, and in the 20+ years since this album’s release, this is the first time I’ve ever heard of this band or album. Not only have I never heard it, but I’ve never heard anyone mention it, and my friends are music nerds that listen to weird shit sometimes. I’ve never heard of another band or publication mention them. If this was some landmark achievement for the genre, I feel like I should’ve heard of it long before now. I’m not the end all, be all of music listeners, and it’s certainly plausible that some bit of arthouse greatness slipped under my radar, but I still think it’s weird that this obscure record—that I can’t imagine has made much of an impact on too many people—has made it on this list…and especially more so now as I’m actively listening to it. It’s not that it’s altogether bad. There are bits here and there that are interesting. But the songs kind of drone on without going anywhere. Nothing about this record really moves me at all. It’s not bad, but it’s not what I would call good either. For as much audio space as this band takes up, I don’t really find it rich or compelling in any way. I’m mostly just curious: what about this record stood out so much to whoever curated this project that they would include it? There are many worse albums on this project, but some of those I actually understand why they would have been showcased here; this one is a head scratcher and a hard 2 stars for me. 2.0/5
I don' understand the hate.
More like the Icarus lame. This was just ok. Not terrible but just there. Musical purgatory. Top Tracks-ish: "On the lash," "Kiss like lizards"
--Up Against the Wall Motherfucker...huh. At least this will be interesting --Spit On It...oof this might be a slog --On a Lash...this almost sounds like a song --Caviar...okay, I like the bass groove on this one. Not much else --Spike Island...I feel more connected with what they're trying to do here. This is still strange but feels like a complete song --Kiss Like Lizards...there's a cool guitar solo buried in the random noise --Getting Bright at Night...9 minute epic with a build. I like this more than the random loudness of other tracks --Big Sleep...takes two minutes to get going but then it's pretty good --White Devil...channeling Marilyn Manson here. Not a compliment --Meatmaker (US version)...wat --Virgin Velcro...this one lost me with the title. It kind of rocks, I guess --Sea Sick...slog of a song on slog of an album --Party the Baby Off...it has the cadence of a pop song
I wasn't feeling this at first, but by minute 35 I began to understand the vibe of this album. Still not my thing, but not bad.
Gefällt mir. Ao in die Richtung White Stripes/Black Keys
I have never heard of Penance Soiree by The Icarus Line nefore and have no idea what to expect here. lets give it a go. Favourite track: I couldnt pick one. Least favourite track: everything was just so pointlessly loud and yet boring at the same time. I could happily never listen to this again. Album artwork: Not a fan
Iggy pop, White stripes intersection
generic rock, nothing too good or bad
This is dull. Affected vocals and very samey instrumentation. Over produced and light on ideas and melody. Not a lot to like about this posuer alley.
Could immediately tell the stooges influence. Overall album was good but didn't wow me. Had some good bass in many songs. I would listen to again.
Good surprise guitars go deeper 3.5
It's alright, but just made me want to listen to Mclusky
Best tracks: On the lash and Spike Island
Sometimes I don’t understand the purpose of this project
tuneless angry noise
Not bad, good solid rock/punk
Not my cup of tea
Not on Spotify and I think I see why.
I got some Jet vibes from a few songs on this album. Given the fact so many music critics do not like Jet, I think that would not be seen as a good thing. The vibes are very, very strong though. From the opening track on to about half of the other tracks on the album. I find it to be very odd this album was included in the book. The music does rock and is a band I had never heard of, but how the hell did they end up in here? Was there money exchanged because the record company didn't support the album? As I feel I do so many times, I am working it out as to how The Icarus Line are different from other bands in the early-to-mid-2000's? Sea Sick gave me some strong Alice in Chains vibes, which I also did not expect. This is fine, though I'm not sure what this represents that hasn't already been in this book.
a wall of incoherent noise.
Yeah this was super not for me. Who is this for?
it's fine, maybe i'll give it another go.
There isn't an inch of space on this album; every last moment is filled with some sort of sound. I think that's why the song structures all feel so flat, and no track stands out to me. They need a chance to breathe.
Excellent album
First few tracks kind of go awesome mode, fun anger-packed rough rocking album that appeals to my inner violent sensibilities
Nope, not needed before dying. It may have expedited my death. Noise.
I just couldn’t
generic noughties garage rock
Wow! This one came out of nowhere. Felt like I'd just seen a killer live act from an awesome garage band. Pure energy and attitude.
Somewhat appreciate the punk noise, but nothing memorable here.
never heard of this. now i know why
какой ужасный перегруз
Album was a nothing burger, not sure why it's on any list. Too generic 2000's absolutely no standouts or reason to listen again.
This was a pile of shit ⭐
Very good.
ok
More Noise Rock than Garage Rock - an angry and depressing album. Was this really one of the best albums of 2004 - I hope not.
great. never heard before.
It’s fine not great not too bad.
A loud, aggressive blast of noise rock and post-hardcore energy. The album delivers raw intensity and chaotic guitars, but not every track leaves a lasting impression. It’s more about attitude and sheer force than memorable songwriting. A solid listen for fans of gritty, confrontational rock, though the relentless volume may wear some listeners down.
I decided to listen to the first Icarus Line album before this one, as I have owned that one since it came out and remember being a bit disappointed with their second album (Penance Soiree), at the time. I do like this second album quite a bit, now, but I do see why I would have likely been a little less enthused when I was younger. The first album is much crazier, more energy, closer to screamo and post-hardcore of the time. The second album is definitely an "evolution" and makes complete sense. It has almost no screaming, darker mood, slower but still the southern rock inspired sounds and riffs.
This sounds like what happened to Black Flag after West Coast hardcore punk died. The lead singer sounds like Jack White. This is like glam hard core. The lyrics are reminiscent of Nine Inch Nails. This guy sounds so much like Jack White that I'd believe this was one of his side projects if I didn't know better. This is as close to liking hard core as I'm going to get. Getting Bright at Night could be a Nine Inch Nails cover. And it turns out the guitarist is NIN's touring guitarist! You can tell. There's some Rage Against the Machine influence too. That feels more like a shared ancestor situation. Meatmaker is feeling a little more "noise rock" than the rest of the album, that is not a good turn. Party the Baby Off sounds like a Stooges song. Also, pretty good.
An extreme case of the 'why is this on here's. It's just got bog all to it really. It's not bad, so it's in the twos, but there is literally nothing to really make it stand out in any way.
54 minutes of my life I will never get back. We need a 0 star rating.
I had never heard of this band before at all, but thought the album was pretty good. Fits with the Strokes/Arctic Monkeys/White Stripes rock revival that was happening at the time but a little more punk/thrash than those other acts. I thought the album was at its best when it leaned more into standard rock structure (white devil, spike island, etc)
1.3 How can something so noisy be so boring
It was really exciting to get this recommendation, considering I've never heard of this band. Love it and would listen again.
Decent indie post punk.
Didn't finish listening to it. Got through the first couple of songs, but they failed to catch my attention. 2 stars and not 1 because I don't actively dislike the album, I just did not find anything to really like
Uninteresting and unremarkable noise rock from a band I've never heard of. Got bored within the first few minutes and it never recovered.
These guys took the good parts of other better bands and made them less interesting and good.
Got better towards the end but largely lacking anything memorable. Loved The Stooges throwback but its not The Stooges
well...
Unmemorable 00's band so many better albums in this genre/age. Felt uncomfortably overwhelming whole album. I liked one song went to check Spotify turns out it was auto playing after the album had finished.
This album should have the 'rock' genre stricken off of it, because this does not rock in any way, shape, or form. Just depressing.
Can’t really put my finger on a single thing this album has going for it. I’m not sure I’ll remember much of anything at all about this record. Maybe it’s good to put on in the background, but it certainly wasn’t easy to follow along with what the guy was singing about. It seemed like the band was into their general aesthetics as much as they were into the substance of the music they made on this project. “On The Lash” was alright? This just wasn’t hitting for me. The constant saturation wasn’t an additive feature to give the music more texture or character, it just made it all blend into a gritty wall of sound. The closest Ive come to liking anything like this was enjoying U2’s “Vertigo” passively as a kid. James Addiction, this album, and anything else that sound like it have never done it for me. If you couldn’t give up a rigid allegiance to rock n roll in 2004, maybe you got something out of this. 2/5
Never heard of them before - doesn't seem to me that they add much to the world of rock music - mediocre
That was a refreshing experience. I never heard of this band but the record is really good. A little bit of Noise Rock and some Post Hardcore are exatctly what I need.
very bass-heavy, love the voice (kinda raspy, sexy) mixture between alt, punk rock, hard rock, metal, goth metal not well-known at all somewhat reminds me of deftones...
Unexpectedly enjoyable noises
Y’all made it sound so terrible. It was fine. Like Jane’s Addiction in a dive bar club.
I don’t know what this was
Bruh i ain’t listening to all that.(again)
Loud rock band with a debt to the Velvet Underground and the Stooges. Good blend of melody and chaos, but honestly others have done it better
Ei uppoa
Välillä ihan ok menoa, mutta liian paljon huutoa ja epämääräistä mökää. Kai tämä just taittuu ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Only 1,600 monthly spotify listeners, and probably a lot of them are from this project. Almost listened to Icarus Falls by Zayn instead (awesome album btw) Honestly, I like this. I hear some Stone Roses, some U2, some Rolling Stones. It's a lot better than the reviews make it out to be. I can't focus on the lyrics much as I'm revising at the same time, but I really like the sound of the songs!! Overall: 4/5
Pretty good, fairly heavy album but an enjoyable listen.
Started ok, got boring quick
Nah
2/10
Okay, like a worse Strokes but more noise rock oriented.
I just found the whole thing exceptionally grating. 1.5/5
Honestly very overrated on this app. It's a decently enjoyable punk album where they get noisy on quite some early songs. Punk isn't really a genre i generally enjoy so i didn't love it, but that doesn't decrease any quality of it
Distortion to a chaotic extreme. Somewhat offputting
Wasn't the worst I have heard but could of done with out it.
If you ever... thought to yourself... man, i haven't had a good headache in a while! well... i have the record for you... put this cow patty on... and let nature take its course... if you like headaches... if pain is what turns you on... if grooving, or being sexy is NOT your thing... if you think it's cool and rebellious to whine over a cacophony of "sound"... to my, old fuddy duddy, ear... it reminds me of Jane's Addiction... but less tuneful... so basically... if you enjoy that sort of thing... you would give this album five stars... "Spike Island" is a pretty good song... easily the best on this hockey puck... "Kiss Like Lizards"... lol... is this a mating call for young folks back in the early 2000's??? all i can say is it take major COJONES... and a dodgy ear to have the chutzpa to go and put this sort of thing out... i would imagine this song is like the anti viagra... for young folks with too much wood... listen to this... and bring it down a couple notches so you don't kill your girlfriend during a netflix and chill... on the bright side... "Getting Bright At Night"... is sort of good... but 9 minutes long... "Big Sleep" is a pretty good rocker... must be said... as is "White Devil"... the opener "Up Against the Wall Motherf*ckers"... is an ok opener... the rest of the record is noise... i THINK they were trying to make a more modern Exile on Main St... but... The Stones were raw... and TUNEFUL... with swagger... and panache... where this one is the opposite... five stars if you are under 45... two stars for me... for the songs i mentioned...
I don’t really like it, it’s very heavy and grungy and I can’t understand what they’re saying or what it’s about. It’s not awful just not for me. By the third song I was ready to give up with it. The singer sounds very whiney and kinda sleepy like a high person complaining about something
Noisy and uninteresting.
Una ventosidad largaaaaa
It is really not as bad as I was expecting. I was expecting noise, but there was some ok songs in there. 70% noise and 30% okay. Not going to lie..had to skip lots of tracks though. 2 stars
muy punki para mí
Nope, it's not very good. Way too dissonant, nothing particularly iconic or standout, and just way too loud without any hell yeaa moments. It is kind of funny that my favorite song here is Big Sleep, because that's the same name as my favorite song from yesterday's Simple Minds album too. That coincidence was far more interesting and exciting than this album was.
Ugh. It gets one point off the bottom because I feel these guys feel whatever these terrible feelings being expressed are, but this kind of grooveless fight club music just doesn't do it for me.
Here is a band I had never heard of, and lo the album kicks off with a song called “Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers.” I am primed to be a fan despite an element of surprise: Based on a quick glance at their name, album title and cover art, I was expecting, I dunno…icy North Sea ambient? Chamber folk electronica? (When this album came out, I was fully immersed in the early-aughts rock revival, which leads me to wonder how I missed it, given the critical accolades it earned.) Anyway, I like but am not blown away by this. There is a ramshackle quality that appeals, but the band occasionally veers into the studied iPod-ad rock territory of The Jets or Wolfmother, two forgettable acts from this era who had their moments in the spotlight. I also don’t discern a strong individual identity from this band, rather a carefully coiffed collective sneer.
I listened to this without knowing anything about it and 8 hours later cannot recall one hook or bridge. My mental note was sounds like a band influenced by Spoon who has literally heard nothing else but can't write a catchy song. Inoffensive but forgettable and should not be on the list.
I've never heard of this band. And based on the play counts on Spotify, neither has anyone else. This album is...OK? I feel the Strokes did this 00's garage/rock/punk thing better, though.
You could tell the influence of acts like Nine Inch Nails and Nirvana in this. I felt like "Kiss Like Lizards" would have been something Nirvana would have covered. Pretty sure they had me at the first track. I like how a lot of the songs blend into each other. The term for this band is "aggro punk,"which is an interesting blend of ideas. The idea of punk (to me) implies the songs should be a bit shorter. But the electronica side makes the songs stretch out a bit, like in "Getting Bright At Night", which I really could hear the Nine Inch Nails influence coming out. Overall, I enjoyed it. Is it derivative of other bands? I can't really say, but the influence of some of them was fairly obvious. Top tracks: "Up Against The Wall Motherf***er," "Kiss Like Lizards," "White Devil," Getting Bright at Night"
Derivative is a word that comes to mind for this album. More noise than garage rock, but not very unique in my opinion. It sounds like a mish-mashed combination of a bunch of bands and sounds, from Fugazi to Drive Like Jehu to Jet to Iggy Pop to all American punk and garage rock bands that sound British (intentional or not). I did enjoy the thumpy bass and some of the guitar work. I started around mid 2 but rose closer to 3 after a few listens. But it's a weak 3.
Another one that made me regret my commitment to listening to every album on the 1001 twice. The noise was brutal and sometimes it seemed like they went out of the way to make it sound miserable (ugh to the last two minutes of Seasick). A fair number of tracks could have been good if they didn't drench them in noise (e.g., On the Lash, Caviar, Spike Island, Kiss Like Lizards, White Devil), but most of it was just obnoxiously noisy. Also, didn't like the whiny sounding singer. Not much redeeming value to this album, and glad they removed it from the 1001. LEAST favorite tracks: Spit on It (apt lyric: "This sucks"), Getting Bright at Night (had some good moments, but the noise outweighed the good), Meatmaker, Virgin Velcro, Seasick.
this was insane finding out that like this wasn't on spotify - so i listened to it 50 days later... i'm shocked this was removed cause it was lowkey cool but i get why.
It was a noisy alt rock album, not worth the time it took listening to it and finding it online as it wasn’t on Spotify for me.
Quality early 2000s alt-rock. This record shreds, including some hard rocking guitars and wailing vocals. Reminiscent of The White Stripes, with some of that grunge feel that Seattle gave us. This record slaps, as the kids say (I think).
This is so mediocre. There's nothing particularly interesting. No hooks. Just a bunch of bland rock. I don't care.
Sick album. Love this.
Never heard of this band before. Album not on Spotify. Not on YT Music, either. Don't appear to be a popular band so curious to see what makes them worthy of a list spot. I am enjoying the first couple songs after finding a YouTube playlist of them. Noisy, unpolished, grungy, but surprisingly original too. Not quite sure exactly what I'm listening to, but clearly there's some passion in this band. I mean the album is garbage, but it's beautiful garbage.
Ok 2/5
A minor drop in the wave of millennial garage rock revival. Howling vocals, amazingly scuzzy guitars, big banging drums, driving riffs and touch of electronica. Good fun but pretty generic. A bunch of LA dudes had the brilliant idea of being the Stooges.
Engelske Ivar Nikolaisen. 3,5/5