Reviews (page 3 of 8)
Hard rock, not terrible…
Pretty heavy but I actually enjoyed the listen
It was good
Forgettable. Makes me want to say something nice about the white stripes. I know this is really a “hater” review, but for top 1000? I would’ve taken something that sounds worse if it were at least interesting to listen to.
Well! That was crap!
1,479 monthly listeners... So, a bunch of '1001 albums' listeners, and The Icarus Lines' moms? Don't get me wrong. I'm 🎯here🎯 for the ahead of their time, misunderstood geniuses, and undiscovered gems, but sometimes the path less travelled, is lees travelled for a reason.
This album is decent but I have no idea what it's doing on this list. 3.3/5
O típico e triste caso de quando eu queria gostar mais de um álbum. Curti a capa do disco, o título dele e da banda, e eu aprecio Indie Rock. Queria que essa fosse uma descoberta lendária, queria que esse se tornasse um dos meus achados favoritos da lista. Mas não foi o caso. Há simpatia noise aqui. Não sou fanático por noise, mas talvez eu seja entusiasta. Gosto de Sonic Youth, gosto de Swans, e de outros grupos semelhantes. Mas achei tudo aqui bem pedestre. Nada chamou muito a atenção. Na verdade, o disco em si passou bem batido. Possui também seus momentos mais melódicos. Passagens que aprecio, até possui uma canção ou outra que vale a pena salvar e ouvir mais vezes. Mas no âmbito geral, o disco não me agradou totalmente. O grande problema é o quão derivativo tudo aqui é. Nada se destaca. E a sonoridade do álbum é dispersa demais, dificultando o apreço maior a qualquer um de seus muitos elementos. Uma pena. Mas a vida segue em frente. E a minha vida, especificamente, seguirá sem este disco. 2.5
Not in my edition of the book! 2004. 2 stars. Average US indie millennium garage band trying desperately to be edgy and original, and failing. Well done of its kind, but there is nothing essential here. The rule still holds true: if no-one is talking about an album 5 years after it's release, you don't need to listen to it.
Why is the a must-listen-to? Give me one reason
I like the sound of the album. Unfortunately there were only three songs (give or take) that I can remember enjoying.
quite fun,if not a bit lack lustre
Big and loud. The good parts and ideas are hard to hear under the monotonous noise but theres just enough to save this from a 1
generic sloprock. the MVs are cool
i’ve heard better noise rock albums before 3/5
Intense.
This band only has 1510 monthly listeners on Spotify for a reason. They do so much and achieve so little. The comically low listener count got me thinking. My high school had about 1600 students, which means that if some kids held an assembly, playing tunes, they'd have more views than these guys. A busker on a busy street would also get more listeners. I'm sorry to bully The Icarus Line, but it's just the fact that they're on THIS LIST that really gets me. A question came over me: about how many listeners are from this website? There are 61500 active projects at the time of writing. I don't know if "active" means that the account has been used in the last week (or something like that), or if it just exists at all, but for the sake of argument I'll assume the former. The likelihood of getting any one album is about 30/1089, ignoring the days where someone famous dies. (30/1089)6150≈1694 users receiving any given album per month. Let's assume half of the site uses Spotify. That makes 847 Spotify listeners that are coming from the generator... more than half of the band's listeners. Gee golly.
This grew on me, although I didn't care for the guys voice.
Not a bad album. I definitely see the inspiration they received from The White Stripes and The Strokes. Doesn’t really do anything new, but it is underrated considering the band has only 1500 listeners on Spotify. I enjoyed it but it’s not really my thing.
Meh
Música de menu de winning eleven. Mas sem ser inesquecível.
Barulhento
I am not sure why I have never heard of this band. It seems when the Screamo-rock period hit in the early 2000s they would have risen to the top of the Pool. I think, from the Wikipedia page, that the constant band member changes probably made them unpredictable and hard to book. But the music is good, a cross between My Chemical Romance, early adopts and INXS. Key songs for me include Seasick with the slower plodding rock and tortured vocals, and On the Lash with its wall of sounds and in-your-face attitude. This is definitely a listen again and explore more.
Random thoughts: * I listened to this weeks ago and all I could remember was that I disliked it. I couldn’t exactly remember why. * I listened to the 2 most popular tracks to remind myself. I still don’t like it. Not sure why. Maybe there just isn’t enough hooks. I was into so much rock music in 2004. I guess this is just too generic. * I won’t be coming back to this one. Really definitely not one you need to hear before you die.
There’s some stuff on this list so far that i kinda struggle to see it’s place for and this is one of those. No doubt passable but nothing came off too groundbreaking to me, and a lot of this record kind of blends together.
1001 albums to hear before you die 77# yeah.. this isn't worth it. The mix is not good. I like the noisy parts, but it's all so muffled it's almost shoegaze without wanting to be. Good riffs, mid vocal performance. This feels Jack White vibes all over. Never listened to a full album of White stripes but i feel it'll be better than this. Even though i like the sound of the guitars and the guitar playing too. It's raw, loose, whiny.
Nope
Not bad but nothing memorable
Booooo tomato tomato
If the Stooges really sucked:
Incredibly generic.
Boring album, nothing really set it apart from others within this same genre.
This album is ass, similar to the way sonic youth is ass, but with more screaming and noise and less all around shitty vocals and more coherent instruments in better tune. Still utter trash, another album with no place on this list. Does anybody actually like this band???
The Wikipedia page for this band was clearly written by a devoted fan, if not the band itself, because the music is not widely streamed, the article mentions no specific publications aside from the book responsible for this very website, and the music is unimpressive, if not irritating. It sounds like pretty generic early 2000's punk rock, with too much distortion and shrieking guitars that drown out everything else. This album is basically the White Stripes if their music had far less appeal, catchiness, or anything else that makes music enjoyable. Really, this album could be replaced by any other album of greater influence and repute among this genre.
Gnarly album but man WTF is that cover photo
idrk not my jam really
raaaaah
it was okay but not my type shi
Confused as to why this is on the list. There are a number of bands who have mastered better. Jesus and Mary chain, sonic youth, Spacemen 3 to name a few. This is mostly dull with only 1 or 2 good tracks.
There are some cool sounds but this sounds like hipsters to me and fuck that noise.
I throughly enjoyed this album by The Icarus Line! I’d never heard or listened to them before so that was fun to acquaint myself with a new band. Overall, I enjoyed this alt-rock/punk album and I would listen to it again in the future!
My ears disliked most tracks
Surprisingly cool, not digging the cursive voice in some of the songs but it balances itself out with an amazing tune in the back.
This album grew on me.... like flesh eating bacteria that needs to be removed so I don't die. It's like a modern version of punk, but I can't understand the lyrics so I don't know what they're angry about, and they had more effects pedals so the music is way more distorted. It's all just a big nope for me.
I was not previously familiar with the artist or album. This is a rock album with distorted guitars and heavy riffs. It reminds me of Wolfmother. While there's a bit of harshness that I don't care for, overall I like it quite a bit. I would listen to this again.
This wasn’t terrible but I’m not sure that I had to listen to it before I die either. I feel like this was some hip music snob’s idea of what was next in rock around the release of the first volume and then that prediction didn’t pan out as expected. I’d say the 1.4K monthly listeners for the band on Spotify is further evidence that this didn’t quite go the way people thought it would 20+ years ago.
Liked some of it on the first half of the album, then it started to drag a bit. Some good energy, but not much substance overall. 2.5/5 Probably won't listen again
It was decent
Я довольно придирчивый чел и к большинству рок-релизов после 2000-х отношусь с долей "фи". Но это... довольно неплохо. Эдакий гранж с примесью инди и нойз-рока. Вообще, заметил такую штуку, что многие пытались девяностовский гранж преображать в чуть более современное звучание в нулевых, продолжая всю эту тему. У кого-то получалось сносно (например у группы the Инсульты, a.k.a. Strokes) а у кого-то получалось так себе (Vines, которых я слушал здесь же) Тут чувствуется влияние и в чем-то Sonic Youth и Stooges и Velvet Underground. Не все песни удачные и хорошие да и манера петь у вокалиста с этими перекрикиваниями довольно типичная, нооо... тем ни менее, это весьма неплохой альбомчик
Youtube
picks: getting bright at night, on the lash
Had to look up why this was significant. Didn't sound significant. 2/5.
not bad
2.5
Not the worst thing I've heard on this list, but the singers voice kind of gets on my nerves.
Very noisy. There are bones of good music here. But it's too noisy. I liked the first song.
I’ve never heard of this band, and I’m glad about that...
not sure about this
dosadno i naporno, većinom nepodnošljivo. koji je ovo kurac?
Not as bad as some reviews here make it sound.
Unexpectedly rips! Never even heard of this band but I dig it
Didn't hate it as much as y'all but not anything I would seek out.
Favorite track(s): they all sound the same. Just because your production sounds like shit doesn't turn your band into The Stooges. Back to the Seven Nation Army covers, guys.
I'm almost quarter of the way through and only now am I realizing what a daunting task going through this list is turning out to be. I already feel like I've been doing this forever. These completely mediocre 2000s rock albums absolutely nobody needs to hear before they die certainly don't help, but the list seems to have an endless supply of them.
A bit like a pick and mix there’s bits and pieces of lots of things here. Garage rock, the stooges, 80’s UK post punk. Some great guitar playing and sonic youth style noise top it off. However, it’s not massively coherent and I’m not always convinced. That said it’s enjoyable enough but not hugely consequential
meaningless noise
2.5
Buegh
nothing stood out
Naw dogg. The other one star reviews said it all.
Generic noisey rock album. It had good moments but none of the songs really stood out.
It's fine, but I don't know why its on the list. Pretty standard post punk/garage rock from the era, with that wall of bass sound that was everywhere at the time.
Really liked this, great energy, feels at home with the rest of the stuff I'm into -punky and dark - will return to this for some deeper listens - but the first album on this list in a while (that I hadn't already heard) that really jumped out at me.
Solid🎸
Did not find these songs interesting
The garage rock songs were kinda okay, but there were more noise rock which I didn't like. Not sure why this album is on the list as it sounds like any other album from the early 2000s.
Seasick favorite song. Heavy alt early 2000's rock. Worth a relisten at some point.
Mjög fínt noise. Var svolítið í bakgrunninum með vinnu og droppaði upp og niður í athygli. Alls ekki eins slæmt og fónófílarnir láta í skyn hér á síðunni. Þetta er samt ekkert meistarastykki að mínu mati. En mér finnst þetta obscure og skemmtileg plata sem á alveg rétt á sér. Hvort hún eigi sér stað á 1001 platna lista má deila um. Ég hef heyrt verra hér.
Bara fínt noiserock. Flottur gítar og gítaróhljóð.
It's alright but I didn't think any of the songs really stood out.
Triple blind here. An obscure pull from the mid-2000’s “cock rock/butt rock” genre. Not bad if that’s what you’re into, but not noteworthy from what I could tell.
I thought this was related to Jack White somehow. The white stripes aren't my cup of tea, and neither was this, But I can't say it's terrible either
its probably 50/50 whether the fact that i just cant detect any distinct personality on this at all is the fault of the music or me just being unfair. my main cogent thought was just "yea, i guess some of these post-strokes post-white stripes garagey bands Would be interested in doing sonic youth worship." its moody and grimey and sloppy and not bad to listen to but it rly just slipped immediately off my ears. sonic youth were elemental forces of nature, the strokes and the stripes felt like actual people, this just feels like a Loud Rock Band to me. most memorable track is prob just the two minute tossoff where they actually try some synths
Had a super strong hunch that this album was going to blow based on the cover art, and well, what do you know.
My rating 2.8 The first song puts you off but the rest of the album is worth a listen.
It sounds like a mix of White Stripes and Jet, with a very '90s vibe. Cool. 4 stars.
It's the total opposite end of the popularity spectrum from yesterday. This band has thousands of monthly listeners. Big Sleep was pretty good, altogether, it is surprising to me that this album has lived in obscurity. It's too good to be so unknown. It's not the best album of all time, but it hits above its weight-class.
nah
Not good. One song that I could barely listen to...
I didn't appreciate someone blasting this at 6 in the morning to try to get me moving. Grubby and muddy and something to listen to when you're feeling cranky.
Did not like.
When to listen: working on my car in the garage, drowning out the neighborhood noise. Except I live in an apartment and I don't own a car. This is a situation where I can hear its influence on others, I can hear its influences from others, and I can see its value—just not my vibe.
I'd never heard of The Icarus Line before this popped up on my list. I now look back on that as the good old days. Pointless noise.
It’s a really difficult one to get through. You can hear the germ of some ideas on songs like Getting Bright at Night, but most are suffocated by really unpleasant, distorted guitars. It’s a wall of noise which leaves you with a headache.
Not for me, liked a couple of tracks, but I disliked too many.
Solid opening track. Seasick was cool but it's weigh too long
I had zero clue what to expect with this album as I had never heard of it or the band. Surprisingly enough, I quite enjoyed the 2004 post-hardcore album on this list. I swear I've heard this vocalist before, but according to the internet he's not in any other bands so he must just sound like someone. Regardless, this album ruled. I'm surprised to learn at this moment that despite its critical acclaim, the band apparently has 1500 monthly listeners on Spotify. I listen to what I thought was some much more obscure shit with far more monthly listeners than that.
Least surprising review, but I dug this album. It lines up with music I already like so it was a nice addition to the list; however, it was not as good as other albums with 5 stars I've listened to here. Ultimately there are a couple songs that I'm adding to the track list and it is getting a good review from me, but it was certainly lacking at times. The most impressive part was there was a 9 minute song that I actually enjoyed.
Disco de mierda... Fucking hippies motherfuckers
This was chaos. I had never heard of them before. I definitely see the similarities with the stooges. Despite the insanity, I kind of liked it. 3/16/26
This actually sucks so bad
what the hell was this
This is the difference between salt and pepper. I know pepper is key in some dishes, but salt just has so much more impact. It blasts my taste buds and enhances flavors from savory to sweet. Pepper is pepper. I like it, I just don't love it.
All of this...and nothing. This is what I was hoping for. https://youtu.be/pWB4w4duj-0?si=xcj2Ai31GlrtJQ-F But in the end it just feel like something a major label wanted to be important. And in the end it has no cultural significance but also isn't a lost gem. It's not bad - at all. Some of the other songs are quite good. But irrelevant. It's solid and energetic. But that's it. No business being on a list that is in theory full of all times.
Has some cool moments but I thought it was pretty ahh
I enjoyed parts of it but it generally felt like a hard rock wash to me. 5/10
Interesting hard rock album. Most of it was hit or miss for me, but enjoyed some of the tracks. Highlights: "Caviar" and "Spike Island"
Didn't love it, didn't hate it.
It was alright, a perfect 3 star album. Nothing amazing, but I enjoyed listening to it. I don't think I will re-listen to this one though because I would rather listen to Bleach by Nirvana or The White Stripes debut that I feel have a similar vibe. This is probably the favorite band of one of the book editors. Favorite Track - Party the Baby Off Least Favorite Track - Meatmaker ⭐️⭐️⭐️
I don't think it's that bad, but apparently it shouldn't be on this list.
I found this on YouTube I like it!!!
3.1 2x
Yawn.
The only difference between this and Black Flag is that Black Flag did it first. Both still suck.
This was ok. I didn't mind it too much as background noise, but I wasn't really listening to it too hard.
It’s like a mix between indie garage and hardcore. It’s cool at times and obviously these dudes never would’ve broken through to the mainstream but a rockin’ album nonetheless.
decent
Forgot these guys existed
A middle of the road 3 for me
Never heard of this band before. Would I listen to this again? No.
Cositas de White Stripes, The Dead Weather y demás proyectos de Jack White. Cositas más hard rock / rock alternativo tipo Foo Fighters o The Vines. Nada original en lo que escuchás. Quizás tienen alguna vuelta en la construcción de los temas, pero nada que no se haya visto antes para el 2004. Y además, muy largo, de 53 minutos. Aún así, la verdad que buenas canciones. Dificil si te gusta el rock no coparte con algún que otro tema de este album. Suena genial el album también, me gusta la producción. Podría ser más puntaje, lo tira abajo la duración y lo que te hace acordar a otros proyectos. 6/10
pretty forgettable noise rock, seemingly only buoyed by occasionally pleasant guitar work. the immediate issue to me here is that it's just not *interesting*. you've got the classic american shouty-wailing angsty type rock vocals especially popular around the early 2000s singing about nothing, largely uninspired simplistic bass/guitar/drums instrumentation (barring the brief sax on "white devil" that gave me false hope), and a lot of bog standard distortion drenching the whole thing. it's just so unbelievably boring. i'm on occasion a fan of noise-oriented genres (i'm a trans woman after all), so even if we're talking about this album in historical context rather than as a standalone today, it's not even remotely representative or noteworthy.
First entry for Noise rock on the list and this is not the best start. The rock itself is very standard stuff. Like the middling parts of a soundtrack from the Burnout franchise. Except there's an added layer of noise on the top that really does help it in any regard really. It's not the worst thing in the world its just very repetitive and confusingly mediocre to be here. I really don't have much to say about this album it didn't offend me nor interest me. Ultimately made me feel "meh" and not much else.
ooooh I'm diggin this style. Kinda reminds me of The White Stripes or Jack White. I don't know. But yeah like the sound for sure. White Devil is dope! Sounds a lot like Marilyn Manson. This was great! 4 stars.
Not my type of music. Not horrible, just not my listening type.
Another album where it started cool and then waned as it continued.
Sounds like every other band from that era nothing special.
Doesn't go the places I want it to. This is the kind of music I theoretically like, but this feels empty in a way that I can't put my finger on. A simulacrum of harder, heavier stuff. Even when it gets a little inventive, it feels borrowed. Again, hard to say exactly what's not sitting right with me but it's just hollow. Better than the 2 I'm giving it but deserves to be dinged for its pillaging.
Let the record show that I once did sound for these guys in Manchester. My place in history is assured. In truth, there's not much to get excited by here. It's all a bit too much.
In my head these were more chaotic noise rock but this is somewhere between a grimier Stones, didn't like it as much as I'd hoped
I thought I might like this album, as I looked it up before I listened- but was disappointed
6/10
I think that these guys (and critics of the time) thought that this band's sound was more novel than it is. It sounds like a Soundgarden cover band hired a Cedric Bixler-Zavala soundalike to play heavy brit rock songs. There are some times on this record which are very impressive (the second half of Getting Bright at Night) but more of this felt purely derivative. 2.4/5 -> 2/5
So this album has just been removed from everything that I have, apparently. The only place I could find this album was on YouTube, but it was of poor quality in my opinion. That doesn't really matter that much though, since the album is just a lot of sound. Like a big wall of sound. Not in a good way either per se. I did like some tunes, but it didn't come across as one of the albums I must hear before I die.. this should not be on here. 4 / 10
Dit is geen gezellig album voor de zaterdag ochtend zeg, pfoe. Snoeihard en een gigantische bak herrie, zo zou ik dit album omschrijven, staan ook niet op Spotify en zijn verrassend moeilijk te vinden op YouTube, maar volgens mij heb ik het correcte album geluisterd. Tsja, wat kan ik zeggen; dit is gewoon niet heel erg mijn muziek. Het is zo snoei en snoeihard dat ik er gewoon niet echt de schoonheid uit kan halen. Ik kan gewoon heel slecht nummers hier uit halen, het is een bak met herrie en overstuurde gitaren met een schreeuwende zanger er overheen. Probeer daar dan nog maar eens iets moois in te vinden of enthousiast te worden van een los nummer. Dramatisch vind ik het alleen niet, het is gewoon echt niet mijn stijl en dat is prima. Om een 1 te krijgen moet ik het actief kut vinden, nu is het meer gewoon een soort herrie als achtergrondmuziek, maar irriteren doe ik dan weer niet. Tsja, misschien ga ik ooit nog eens post hardcore waarderen, maar voor nu is 2 sterren voldoende.
Indie sleaze. First track off the album is pretty good but the rest is a muddy mess, I suppose cynically called garage rock.
When I was a teenager I think i would have found this self-indulgent moaning profound. Not so much now, but still enjoyed it.
Bang average angst rock, it sounded fine but at the same time I didn’t really care all that much for it.
A surprisingly good punk / art rock album. I am uploading this review quite late as I wasn’t able to log in over the weekend. I really enjoyed the heaviness of the first half of the album from ‘Up Against the Wall Motherfucker’ ‘Spit On It’, ‘On the Lash’ and Caviar’ As those tracks became my favourite in the album, for some reason the second half didn’t intrigue me as much but It allowed me to understand the grungy atmosphere the band built for this body of work. The lyric in Caviar ‘true love hits like death from above’ stood out to me because of the song’s subject matter of addiction/ critique of beauty from my pint of view. The drums and sleazy guitar riffs! Those for seamlessly alongside Wattsons talk-singing. To conclude this was an excellent album to get me into the more ‘heavier’ sounds of early 2000’s rock. Not to forgot the well composed cover with the red thread and singer in motion! 4/5- Another great rock album -GEMV (26-7.02.2026)
Pretty mid
Only solid and probably shouldn't be on this list
This was a grungier knockoff of the White Stripes. Some of it was pretty good
Reminds me a bit of NIN. Good Energy.
Pleasantly noisy. You can feel that Strokes-era energy.
I cannot believe I didn’t hate this but I did not. It’s like dirtier strokes or the white stripes
The album sounded a bit generic. Some songs were really solid.
Yawn
Review - I had high hopes after hearing the bass tone on the first track - a punky mid-00s band I'd never heard of? But after listening to the whole album I can see why I'd never heard of it. Maybe an interesting mix of styles for the time, but the mix of almost interesting rocked up 90s indie with the vocals and swagger of late 80s hair metal is absolutely not for me. Rating - 3.5/10 Need to listen? NO
Enjoyed this one a lot, strong start and good energy throughout, low 4
Eens met Jean, ik weet niet wat dit op de lijst doet
Whatever, was ook veel te lastig muziek vinden en vond het behoorlijk kak
Blijkbaar heeft de band recent eindelijk dit album op bandcamp gegooid (volgens de band zelf voor het eerst op hoge kwaliteit in digitale vorm verkrijgbaar). En... tsja. Het is een soort garage/indie rock, best standaard voor die tijd. Soms wat noisier, soms ietsje cleaner, maar vrijwel volledig slecht geproduceerd. Instrumenten klinken stroperig en opgeblazen, de vocals klinken als een Iggy Pop cover act. Er zit in ieder geval energie in, dat moet ik ze geven.
Absolutely not
Not bad, but nothing special. I had never heard of this band before.
Like darker and noisier Jet. A little too drug addled for me. Every song devolved into this dude whining. Couldn’t finish don’t give af about your scumbag lifestyle. Sonic youth fans probably love this.
Ahead of its time. Class though
Hard to pick between 2 and 3. There are more than enough points where I wanted to quit on this album but there was enough good to keep going. I definitely don’t love this but I’m stuck between “okay” and dislike
It is not a great sign that (due to my own failure to make sure the looping feature was on) i failed to notice when this album ended. Overall, I like the sound! Would not mind listening to it again! It's just not really clicking 🤷♂️
I first listened to this album as I struggled to get A Ranks in Sonic Racing: Crossworlds. I listened again on a walk around my apartment complex. With the prominently black and red cover art, heavily distorted rock sound, and youthfully emotive male vocals, I can't help but compare this album to the work of another early 2000s rock band, The White Stripes. To be clear, The Icarus Line are doing more here than merely being clones of The White Stripes, leaning into a further level of distortion and heaviness than I would expect from Jack and Meg. This is also the first time on this list where the device on which I listened to this album drastically changed my perception of it; while I appreciated many of the grating and distorted soundscapes they created throughout this album on my first listen, sometimes they pushed the limits just too far to the point that I lost track of what I was hearing or it started to sting my ears. However, when I relistened to the album on headphones as opposed to our bluetooth speakers, it clarified some of the experience for me and allowed me to gain a better appreciation for the flow and atmosphere of the album. I really respect the chaotic energy and consistent sound curated across the album, and while some moments still don't grab me too strongly, the songwriting elsewhere is incredibly compelling and keeps me deeply invested in the experience of this album... when I could properly hear it. Highlights: Spit On It, On the Lash, Spike Island, Getting Bright At Night, Big Sleep, Seasick, Party the Baby Off
Penance Soiree is a pretty decent Noise/Garage rock album that remains consistent throughout most songs, and that consistency made me feel a little bored halfway through, although I still did enjoy it to some extent. 3.7/5
Ugh. Wtf?!?!
I love rock and there’s some good sounds here. But this just didn’t hit with me. Sorry.
Noisy and bad
Starts off strong, ends up a morass. This suffers from the same fate as a lot of early 2000s rock where everything mushes together with no variance in sound. It's a shame because the band is like Gang of Four meeting the Stooges for a grungier take on post-punk. But that line can't hold for an hour run time, and it just falls apart by the end.
i really did try to listen to this album - after previewing each song about to give it a full listen - my migraine said nope
I thought metal is not my thing but I enjoyed this very much
as somebody who has just come out of a test tube an hour ago, this is the most unique album i've ever heard. it doesn't sound anything like katy perry at all!
I listened to this and I think I kind of liked it, but that was a week ago and now I could not pick it out of a lineup.
kinda just noise
Wasn't as bad as others are making out (not to me anyway)
sympa sans plus
belle découverte
Sympa on dirait les White Stripes mais c'était un enfer de trouver l'album donc qu'est ce qu'il fout dans la liste
This is actually pretty great!
00’s Alternative Rock ⭐️Getting Bright At Night
Aldri hørt om, hører uten å søke opp. Det begynner lovende, fine texturer, men beveger seg gradvis fra noise rock-nærliggende til å bli mer post-hardcore med metal-innflytelser. Etter hvert blir det mer blues, Spike Island er ikke mer enn et steinkast unna Led Zeppelin med fuzz. Det er flott at det er variert, men det beveger seg på en måte lenger og lenger vekk fra et interessant lydbilde. Det blir litt bedre igjen, og på skivas lengste låt gjør de sin beste Spiritualized. Jeg liker Spiritualized veldig godt, men jeg har jo allerede merkevaren hjemme...? Høres vokalisten mer ut som Marilyn Manson eller han som synger i Korn? På garage-pastichen White Devil er det definitivt MM. Tror albumet hadde vært bedre om de aldri sang, for vokalen drar alltid musikken i en datert retning hvor dårlig pop skulle inn i "alternativ" musikk. The Icarus Line kaster alle innflytelsene sine på veggen og ser hva som henger igjen. Resultatet er ikke bare et variert, men et varierende album. Det hadde nok funka bedre om de tok lydene de åpenbart er tiltrukket av og bare jamma i stedet for å huke av bokser på et genre-kart. Jeg liker aspekter av dette, men de klarer sjeldent å bryte fri fra sine egne konstruksjoner. Resulatet er at musikken føles påtatt og uten identitet. Og på bingoen min kan jeg krysse av for enda et post-90-talls album som ikke har noe på denne lista å gjøre.
Startet lovende, som et litt røffere og mindre retro Jet. Kanskje litt nærmere The Datsuns. To band fra rock revival-bølgen jeg holder høyt. Litt Iggy-aktig vokal oppå det hele. Men så rakner det litt. Det er litt som musikk og vokal splitter lag på "Kiss Like Lizards". Skjønner at det skal låte tøft, men syns det låter litt flatt. Begynner å minne mer om grunge. Kanskje det er fordi jeg måtte høre plata på Youtube. De prøver seg på noe dronegreier utover dette, men det funker sånn passe. Liker "Getting Bright At Night", men "Big Sleep" føles igjen litt som om vokal og instrumenter ikke spiller på lag. "Meatmaker" høres ut som en parodi på Suicide, men det virker bare malplassert her. Som om bandet gikk tom for ideer.
Litt nice egentlig
Pretty obvious White Stripes clone. Not terrible on its own but just pretty unremarkable.
Das war toll!
This is so 2004, it actually is painful.
What a fucking racket
Don't hate this. Won't be listening again though. 5/10 so rounds up.
Noisy
Was pretty sick of it by the end
Loud and aggressive, this album certaintly has bangers. This might be the lists' most least known addition, barely cracking 50k plays on spotify. I think it's actually pretty good, but runs on a little too long. Also not really sure why it was even chosen for the list anyway
3 spaced out
This album was so unremarkable, it was noisy with bad vocals. I like grunge but this was just a bad, boring album.
Post-hardcore punk amplified by metal noise, distorted guitar, and powerful vocals.
This was a mess. There's good noisy rock, no doubt about that, but this here felt like something where nothing sticks out and some guys would just write the music the way to anoyther other people.
Non disponibile su Spotify Italia
At times this sounds like Primal Scream fronted by a low energy Bono. Somehow it’s not quite melodic enough, whilst also not being quite industrial enough. It feels like it needed to lean into one or the other a bit more to connect. Whilst there are glimpses of promises it all just falls a bit flat and boring.
I had never heard of The Icarus Line when this album popped up, and I wish it had stayed like that.
It was always a concern it would happen one day. I hoped it wouldn't, but it really did feel inevitable after all this time. I didn't want it to be true, but I have to admit: I may be turning into my mother. This was just noise. So much noise you could barely hear the vocal. Seriously, the vocal was so low in the mix, I have no idea why they would choose to do that on purpose. The weird noise that sounded a bit like a squeaky duck getting further and further away from the microphone at the end of Meatmaker might have been my high point. I thought this was shite. 1/5
- a few ok riffs ... the vocalist is .... nondescript. Somebody please tell me why I should care about this. -
As one of the more obscure albums in the project, I was excited to listen to this. It was too industrial / heavy for my tastes, but it was still cool to listen. Some cool moments in this, even if I did struggle with it at times.
not my cup of tea
Garage rock with a bit of grunge. The vocals remind me of Geese and early Radiohead. It's fine, but doesn't really stand out in any way and I don't think I'll come back to this. 2.5/5.
Pretty good album for being so noise-rock-focused. Definitely preferred when the album leaned into rock more than noise, but the energy carries through in a very palpable and entertaining way. Could be a little shorter, but very solid overall. Top tracks: Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers, Spike Island, Virgin Velcro
Band and album I had never heard of in a genre I like. It was good! I liked the sludgy elements added into that early 2000’s garage rock sound. Favorite songs were Up Against The Wall Motherfucker, On The Lash, Getting Bright At Night, and Seasick.
Ouch. Debut or not, that was tough for me to get through. Penance Soiree, theoretically metal tinged punk has two (2) listenable songs, (Spike Island and Party the Baby Off) the rest are harsh skippers, save yourself the time. (1.4*s) Take off all your clothes…
This album has me truly baffled. How did it get on the 1001 list? How was it a top album of 2004? How does it get so much praise? I feel like The Icarus Line and Penance Soiree should be an unknown artist/record if not for it popping up on Spotify's Discover Weekly playlist. There is zero appeal to it and nothing stands out as a quality or interesting piece of work. Mostly just a noisy POS. Although not the worst thing I've listened to, this is probably the first time I am really doubting the list. You could poll 100 people and I don't think any of them would have ever heard of this band. Get out of here...0.91 stars.
Decent hard rock album. It's a little whiny and suffers some of the tropes that always affect noisy hard rock from this time period though. Most of the songs sound the same so even if I didn't mind them individually there are diminishing returns as the album continues. After 30 minutes the whole thing is played out and you are ready for it to end. Even despite that I found most of it competent and didn't hate the listen. Always good to see a local band from LA hit the list even if I wasn't familiar with them previously. Might ask around as I expect I have a couple buddies that would enjoy this and might know of The Icarus Line. This isn't really my genre but I expect I would have enjoyed them had I caught them at one of the smaller venues like Chain Reaction (RIP) back in the day. I've mostly outgrown a lot of this and don't expect I'll revisit The Icarus Line but maybe it'll show up at a friends house without me knowing. Either way I can't complain about some new music that's a little more modern than most on the list, even if it somehow is 20+ years old already. Was 2004 really that long ago? 1.85 stars
Niet mijn ding 1,5
The story of this album in this band is really interesting, but I don’t think the album itself is very good
Amazing album. A mix of sonic youth, killers, franz ferdinand, white stripes and a few really good bands. Dont know what year this came out but this is good
Lotta noise...
Sounds like a noisy training session.
Would rather just listen to The Stooges
Ok album but a bit punky for me
Not my bag baby
Based on just the title of the first track, I'll bid a blind nil. 200 points for me!
This was rough. Didn’t get it at all.
It’s OK, when they let things like melody and song structure shine through it’s actually quite good but too often it gets a bit tuneless in the name of being a bit hard edged. 3
When it's good, it's really good. First five songs are great, but the album becomes a bit messy with noisy chaos instead of the songs and hooks that make it good to start with.
Pretty good, maybe yet again not memorable but overall I lied it. I'd say 3.5
Questionable lyrics; nice sound.
Right up my street and a strong album.
This albums biggest accolade was that it was included in this list....
Not for me
average. bit too samey towards the end lowkey
Yay.. Yet another indie record, how many more of these will I have to endure? Once again, just few songs in I see absolutely nothing special about this, some Stooges influence, cool, some hardcore punk influence so at least it is a bit different from other indie offerings I got, but still I mean this is below average for me, not terrible but I can survive fine without this thanks
I actually liked this album. I was a little worried when all I saw was 1 & 2 star reviews. I hadn't heard of the group before. The Icarus Line are loud and aggressive. I particularly liked "Getting Bright at Night"
I both enjoyed this album and was frustrated by it. On the positive side, the raw energy is undeniable. The band fully commits to a hardcore-leaning garage rock sound, built on thick, grimy riffs that feel more thrown than carefully placed, which only adds to the album’s confrontational edge. The vocals are passionately angry rather than polished; snarled, barked, and often deliberately abrasive. It reinforces the sense that this music isn’t meant to comfort or impress, but to provoke. The near-total lack of fine tuning, whether in the performances or the production, feels intentional rather than careless, giving the record an almost live, on-the-edge quality. That roughness perfectly complements the anti-establishment themes running throughout the tracklist, making the album feel less like a collection of songs and more like a sustained act of defiance. The lyrics lack subtlety, but that's by design. Spitting on society and the music industry, observations on over indulgences of life's pleasures, calling out the superficial glamour of LA life, themes of dysfunctional intimacy and need, commentaries on destructive behaviour and people with toxic traits, being caught up things you don't want but can't shake. It's a middle finger to social constructs and contracts; and thematically the band keep this up with such conviction that you can't help but respect it. On the more negative side, the album feels much longer than it should. And, speaking strictly from a musicality aspect, it can get repetitive and the songs really start to blend in together. There's virtually no variety on display, and things never seem to slow down or speed up. So this is where my frustration with it popped up. I often think albums like this need a good bit of trimming. For example: I got Slayer's album 'Reign in Blood' on this project a little while ago, which I gave a 5/5 rating to, and it clocks in at just under 30 minutes; whereas if it was around the length of this LP (54minutes) I probably would have given it a lower rating. There's certainly enough here that I enjoyed it enough; protest anthems with unapologetic conviction? Yes! Sign me up. But 'Penance Soiree' is just a little bit hard to listen to as an entire body of work. Maybe that's by design. There are certainly similar and better albums I could probably stack beside this one. It is still worth diving into, though. 3/5
not availabe so idk
Not what I was expecting. Didn't listen to it all. Maybe it got better?
Sigh.
Not knowingly listened to them before but really enjoyed it, right up my driveway
Not good enough in any of its genreblending to stand out. Little to no relistenability. Passes for rock but might as well be alternative. Sadly don't listen to this before you die. The White Stripes had better percussive elements, the Hives had better grooves and melodies, the libertines and Strokes had better lofi vocals. On to the next.
This album is intense and gritty. I can hear the quality, but I’m not interested in returning regularly.
At this point I have to ask what the criteria is to get on this list?
Not my cup of tea. Aggressive in an un fun way. I would not listen again.
Noise pollution
The Icarus Line ist eine US-amerikanische Rockband aus Los Angeles. Penance Soiree, ihr zweites Studioalbum, wurde 2004 veröffentlicht und überwiegend 2003 in verschiedenen Studios aufgenommen, darunter Sunset Sound und Platinum Audio in Hollywood sowie Eden Studios in London. Das Album bewegt sich zwischen Garage‑, Noise‑ und Post‑Hardcore‑Rock. Die Musik ist roh und intensiv, geprägt von verzerrten Gitarren, treibenden Rhythmen und der markanten Stimme von Joe Cardamone. Zu den bekannten Songs zählen „Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers“, „Spit on It“, „On the Lash“, „Kiss Like Lizards“ und „Getting Bright at Night“. Die Produktion verzichtet auf übermäßige Politur, wodurch die aggressive Energie der Band erhalten bleibt. Das Album spricht Hörer an, die einen direkten, kompromisslosen Rocksound bevorzugen. Bewertung: Ein konsistentes, dichtes Rockalbum mit Fokus auf Ausdruck und Intensität.
Are they trying to break the Guinness World Record for loudest garage rock? The Sonics beat them to it. This record sounds like easy listening metal as one reviewer put it. There's a bit of punk in there too, but it's nothing too interesting.
Just generally not feeling this one. It feels if the White Stripes were a noise rock band, but more on the classic blues rock sound vs White Stripes' alternative side. And I'm pretty bored with that classic blues rock sound. Singer sound's like the singer from Jet as well (Or one of those late 2000's garage rock bands), and while I do like Are You Gonna Be My Girl?, it's not a voice I am really enamored with here. Overally, this is generally just fine, but this is definitely an album I'd drop from the list for a more important/influential/better album.
This album initially gave the impression it was going to be quite interesting musically, even if the vocals weren't up to much. However, it soon descended into pretty typical American alt rock drudgery.
decent but too long
I really like the guitar sound on this thing. It's full, organic and gritty. The rest? Garden variety, abrasive melodic noise post hardcore that adds nothing new. A poor man's At The Drive In.
Album #1,014 Noisy, industrial, and grungy. The singer sounds like the singer for Jet ("Are You Gonna Be My Girl"). Some cool songs like Spike Island, but also sounds that are just shrill and unpleasant to the ear.
It was iight, bass lines were more than iight. 2.9
This is so close to a lot of music I love from the same time but the mix is so bad and it feels like it’s trying so hard to be like an innovative loud take on the white stripes and queens or something; lot of Jet but louder here. Even worse, it sounds like the proto of every 2013 on “we’re keeping rock and roll alive!!!” Band ala rival sons or royal blood. Just like obnoxious two note riffs held out while drums go nuts type music. At The Drive In just does it better. Idk there’s a lot I love here, this would undoubtedly go hard as an opener for any of the above that I wasn’t expecting but then I would go home and listen to the album and be like oh never mind. It’s good, truly; I think in a different mood this is a 4 but I’m hitting a stagnant 3.
This went on way too long and the vocals really annoyed me - every vocal line was so repetitive and the intonation was really grating.
Way too much for me but I can see how some would enjoy.
I did not like this.
Meh
Meh
Couldn't find it
2/5
This album should be up my street as it has a lot of elements I like (rock, punk, experimental) but for some reason it manages to be rather bad, regardless. Songs are rather random, it lacks the energy I want in this king of album. They seem to try hard, but fail... Some OK sections but all in all just noise for the sake of it.
"Penance Soiree" by "The Icarus Line" was an album that immediately challenged my expectations. Judging by the cover alone, I was anticipating something closer to electronic or techno (shoutout to Moby), so the actual sound came as a surprise. I'd never heard of the band before, but I wasn't put off by that going in. Musically, there are clear similarities to bands like "The White Stripes" or even "Rollins Band", though it's harder to pin down a single genre- garage rock or post-hardcore probably comes closest. The songs tend to blur together a bit and can feel somewhat monotone, but despite that, I could see myself returning to this album at some point. It's not an everyday listen, and I'd need to be in the right mood for it, but it held my interest enough to warrant that.
Not quite as bad as I expected but still didn’t really like it 😅
This album is a horrendous cacophony, steering between punk, metal and post rock. I will not be searching out the rest of their catalogue…
Idk pretty mid. I’m in a sleep deprived, overworked and angry mood because of it, so this album fits the vibe. But the harsh sounds legit hurt my ears wtf, I don’t like that. Seems like a blend of Queens of the Stone Age and NIN which is sorta neat. Nothing stood out to me as a banger. Probably won’t listen to this album or artist again tbh. Couldn’t make it through the last 2 songs I had enough. 2.75/5
Shortly after this album came out, guitarist Aaron North quit the band. Engineer Alan Moulder suggested that he audition for Nine Inch Nails' live band. According to Trent Reznor: "He shows up, he looks shitty, he's got junk equipment, he looks like he's just got up and I want to punch him. And then Aaron starts playing and on the first note it's like, 'You're the guy.' He wasn't trying to be me, and play like I play. He played and chaos came out." My experience listening to The Icarus Line was similar. At first I hated it and was planning on giving it 2 stars. But the more I listened the more I got into it. It was like an aggressive blend of punk, indie and noise rock. I'm really surprised by how much I ended up enjoying this one by the end. I'd listen again if I was in the right mood.
Not as bad as the 1 star reviews claim. It's not offensive, pretty punchy rock music with some interesting segments.
I’ve never heard of this band before but I like them!
Correcto
This type of music is just not for me.
First impression was bad (new metal) but it’s actually not that bad.
Not very impressed. I was excited to listen to this based on the Wikipedia description, but unfortunately was a mild example of this garage punk rock. Not really sure why it's notable enough to be on this list, but not an awful listen. Something new by a band I didn't know, at least.
I wanted to like this but I just didn't. If I wanted to listen to this genre, there are other bands/albums I would reach for first. The whole album just blended into one long, loud, wine. I liked Spike Island but that's about it.
Just noise
This wasn't a pleasant album to listen to in the morning. The mixing (or maybe lack thereof) makes the distorted guitars almost hurt my ears. The singing and other instruments didn't help it at all. I usually try and find some positive parts of an album even if I rate the whole experience as low. I didn't find anything this time though.
you're probably thinking the same thing I did: "who the hell are The Icarus Line?" well, despite their current status—inactive since 2017 following the death of a key member, and currently sitting at fewer than 1,500 monthly Spotify listeners—I was surprised to find that a lot of critics were very positive about this album when it first released. you can check Wikipedia if you don't believe me; 4.5/5 from Allmusic, 4/5 from Alternative Press 7.8/10 from Pitchfork (huge numbers to get from them in 2004), and a perfect 10/10 from Drowned in Sound. so, to what do we attribute The Icarus Line's niche status in rock music: a band significant enough to be included in 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die (right next to Arcade Fire's Funeral in my copy, by the way) but one which has otherwise been forgotten by the vast majority of rock fans? well, while I do think this band makes a great noise when they really get going—seriously, this album is really loud—I feel a bit like I've been hung out to dry by the songs themselves. they're serviceable, but most of them aren't terribly memorable. you've got the opener, which is memorable by virtue of being the first song you hear; there's the very punchy "Spike Island" and the 9-minute mammoth "Getting Bright at Night", which goes through a ton of interesting dynamic phases; but beyond that, a lot of the material here feels a bit redundant. there's some additional sonic experiments towards the back half of the record (the saxophone on "White Devil", all the electronics on "Meatmaker") but by that point it's too little, too late. there were a lot of bands making this sort of bluesy, noisy garage rock at the time and delivering better songs alongside it; The White Stripes had released Elephant the previous year, and Death From Above 1979 would release their tremendous debut a few months after Penance Soirée. it's a little unfortunate; with stickier melodies and riffs alongside the (admittedly really interesting) barrages of noise The Icarus Line cook up, this could've been more than just a footnote. decent 6/10.
First couple of tracks I was quite enjoying this. Unfortunately that wore off by track 4. By the end I was dying for this to end. Is this the worst album on here? Not by a long shot but it’s way too long and there’s just nothing interesting or unique about it. Top Track - Up Against The Wall Motherfucker
Många feta riff tbh och bra vocals. Inte riktigt en 4a men bättre än en 3a också. Slutgiltig dom: 3.7.
Couldn’t finish listening
What a yawn! Plodding and limp.
Very generic nothing stood out. Sounded like an early 2000s punk album.
This is bad. Don't like the singers voice and the guitars sound like grating metal.
Poo
Noisy but 2hiny
Jack White as produced by Ross Robinson. 1.5 Aaron North is often alleged to be an ‘interesting’ guitar player. I’d say he is more like Noel Gallagher playing with more confidence and less responsibility but still essentially a musical dullard. This is all energy and attitude without anything going on underneath for 53 minutes. Tiresome. 1.5/5
Een boel irritante jengelherrie, die (begrijpelijkerwijs) niet op Youtube staat. Af en toe is er een rustmomentje, om iets schoenenstaarderigs of Britpopperigs te doen. En dan gaan ze weer. Ik vond er niks aan.
Als je de feedback-piep op je album laat staan, dan ben je moedwillig je eigen muziek aan het verpesten. In 2004 nog... Een nummer als 'Spit it on' is niet te luisteren. Zonde, want aan nummers als 'On the Lash' hoor je dat ze best wat in huis hebben. Nee, best boek, dit is geen 'verklaring van muzikale onafhankelijkheid'. Dit is kopieergedrag een aantal decennia nadat dit al standaard werd gedaan. En nee, best boek, dit is al helemaal geen stellingname tegen verveling. Ik verveel me net zo sterk als bij de mede-copycat Dwight Yoakam. Gaaaaaaap. 1,5 ster
Dit had in theorie best fijne muziek kunnen zijn, als het niet zo'n pijn aan mijn oren zou doen van de matige kutkwaliteit. Het is blikkerig en schel aan alle kanten, ik krijg er gewoon koppijn van. Ik vermoed dat dit expres is, dit is wel zo'n band die in een klein zaaltje op standje gehoorschade wil spelen. En dat is denk ik zonde, want op zich had ik deze chaotische noise rock best ok kunnen vinden. Ik hoor er wat At the Drive In in, een goede vleug vuige rock n roll a la the Datsuns. Maar het subtiele sneeuwt nu totaal weg onder een muur van herrie. Ik weet niet zo goed wat ik hiermee aan moet. Het heeft potentie tot een 4, maar als ik het nu aan luistergenot af moet meten, dan kom ik niet hoger dan een schamele 2. Ik zou graag een 3 geven, maar ik vrees dat ik dit absoluut nooit uit vrije wil nog eens op ga zetten.
This sounds like a mash-up of every early/mid aughts band - and it is not a success.
Not going to give it a 1 because there is some redemption here. Yes it is derivative and pretty par for the course of this era of trying to usher in the “new rock” unsuccessfully with a lot of noise. Some of the songs were cool and I stopped to listen but a lot just sounded like the background of a busy brain.
Each song has an intro that sounds like it’s setting up for some cool, heavy shit. Then each song proceeds into generic 2000s indie garbage.
This is one of those albums where the reputation overshoots the experience. Based on the reviews, I expected something actively miserable. It’s not that. But it’s also not something I particularly enjoy. The aggression feels intentional rather than expressive, and the repetition comes across as confrontational without giving me much to latch onto emotionally or musically. I can appreciate what they’re going for. There’s a stance here, a rejection of polish and accessibility that feels deliberate and sincere. But sincerity alone doesn’t carry it far for me. The songs don’t stick, the textures don’t reward repeat listens, and the overall effect is more exhausting than compelling. So no, I don’t hate it. But I don’t like it either. It lands in that narrow space where respect for intent doesn’t translate into enjoyment. A two-star record for me: tolerable, occasionally interesting, but not something I’d choose to revisit.
up against the wall motherfucker garage rock 2004 united states
eh
Energetically solid. ★★★★
This is a tough sit. Goddamn, it is TEDIOUS. I don't even want to expand on my notes lol. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions - On The Lash - White Devil
Not for me!
Started strong but quickly grew grating and tiresome.
7 What are they shouting for so much!
Tortura não é entretenimento
Good grief man. Rename the book 1001 ways to torture me, This is bloody terrible. Less than zero stars.
Very hit or miss song to song for me
Oasis meets Jane's Addiction. Solid but not exceptional or outstanding.
Nothing wrong with this! Dragged a bit but was interesting enough.
I found this album super repetitive. I liked the first track, but it everything just sort of blended together after that.
Very familiar with the album. Used to listen to it all the time in college. Always felt like the album was soundtrack for a night out with too much partying, evoking some rowdy, devil may care shenanigans. 'getting bright at night' kind of starts to slows things down a bit for the rest of the album looses some momentum but it's like a breather before rally of the last song, ready to do it all again.
It's not terrible but why is it on the list?
No idea what the heck it was except that it was noisy and bad..
Fun album! (3)
They're rock, with some industrial influence. They come so close to having a good hook, and stop short, which keeps them from getting too deep into your head. Will definitely look for more from these guys.
Didn't interest me at all.