Penance Soiree by The Icarus Line

Penance Soiree

The Icarus Line

2.5
Rating
22884
Votes
1
17%
2
34%
3
33%
4
13%
5
3%
Distribution

Reviews (page 2 of 8)

I won't say that I hated this - there were definitely some cool parts here and there, and some solid garage rock energy. The whole thing did feel a bit put on to me for reasons that I couldn't quite pin down, and I think they should have cut this one down to like 35-40 minutes.

Pretty solid album, will definitely revisit outside of this list and also check out some of their stuff.

“Mom, I want At The Drive In.” “We have At The Drive In at home.”

Sleaze punk? I liked it, felt like an updated Hanoi Rocks with one foot in glam, one foot in punk

Yes - my cuppa tea

Pretty generic and boring

Liked this more than I thought. Couple weird tunes in there but overall it was enjoyable!

This was an awesome album. Punky, hardcore rock sort of sound. Reminded me of the stooges, QOTSA and other similar bands. Devo’d the only album I could find on YouTube had 3 songs missing but I still got a pretty good taste of this one

quedé nerviosita.

This album sounds like Axe body spray

There is no files in spotify or soundcloud for this album but i heard it on youtube. Its ok i think not that interesting but an ok album. But i liked the guitars!

Temu Soundgarden. The mix on this record is terribly muddy which makes almost all the tracks sound like a sludgy, undifferentiated mess. Just sounds like hollow angry noise.

Hi, I'm trash.

After Rolling Stones and Zeppelin… this felt like the little leagues. Driving rock… but nothing grabbing me. 2.5

Just noticed this is marked as Indie Rock. What? Noisy, but I enjoyed it more than I expected when I first put it on. 5/10 Acceptable

Boring, derivative, & labored, Penance Soiree is an album that doesn't have it all, & what it does have is forgettable & superfluous. The Icarus Line are essentially a punkier White Stripes, which isn't a bad idea in principle, but they can't pull it off b/c, well, they're a bad band. What's a bad band? A bad band is a band that makes bad music. Could I imagine seeing them live at a sooty, seamy venue in LA? Sure, & I may have a good time in the process. But that doesn't mean they're a good band b/c, well, I wouldn't want to go see them again. Staying power is mysterious but we generally know which groups have it. These windbags clearly don't. There's a nine-min song on this thing, a shitty excuse for a VU epic like 'Heroin.' Stupid.

On paper I should enjoy this album, I enjoy this era, I enjoy the genre's and styles used here but... this is just not it. For lack of a better review thesis, this feels way too "local band who somehow signed and got access to any musical gadget and gizmo they wanted" without building up the skills and repertoire to actually have an idea how to use them. The songs are not cohesive, melodic or centered. I don't think I heard a single chorus during the album. It's also really dated; I've never heard of the band or the album despite my social media algorithms putting me in this scene and constantly thrusting me in discussions regarding this era and style of guitar led music. On a similar point, there's also opportunity cost; you're telling me this can have a spot on albums you MUST listen to over My Chemical Romance, Evanescence, AFI, Billy Talent, Sunny Day Real Estate, Deftones, or many others that actually left a lasting legacy? I'd say no, spend your limited and valuable time wisely and go listen to Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge which came out a month after Penance Soiree and blows it out of the water.

Even if I got over how annoying this album is, all the songs just kind of sound the same too. I don't understand why this is so highly rated. It's just noise.

Noisy, almost a little sloppy, garage-y, kinda post-hardcore? I'd never heard of this band before but this is right up my alley. Felt like it would have fit in most action sports 2000's videogames. Will have to listen to this group more.

It's an interesting album, an experience I wasn't ready for. Noisy songs and great amount of felling, encompassed in a record I wasn't going to find on my own. My only gripe is the length, but other than that, a great surprise.

I'm going to give this noise rock a slight amount of credit because it generally still sounded like music instead of the screaming and banging of scrap metal.

Not a fan. Glam rock power pop metal.

lowk im scared of the intros they all sound like a summoning ritual 😭

Angry Young Men, I don't know what they're angry about but they're making a hell of a racket about it, whatever it is. I might have enjoyed this when I was fifteen, but it's doing my bonce in now.

Lite stökigt men inte så illa.

Det här var riktigt nice! Synd att det inte finns på Spotify.

It was okay but I didn’t really find it anything special or new.

Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers 3.6 Spit on It 3 On the Lash 3.4 Caviar 3.3 Spike Island 3.2 Kiss Like Lizards 3.4 Getting Bright at Night 3.3 Big Sleep 3.2 White Devil 3.5 Meatmaker 3 Virgin Velcro 3.4 Seasick 3.3 Party the Baby Off 3.3 Score: 3.3

I did not love this.

To be honest, I tried to finish this album but I just couldn’t. I wanted to enjoy it but I just couldn’t

I'm giving it a 3, because I would have liked it when I was 14 and into music like this. But I'm old now, and this isn't really for me.

“angular”

Not for me

Horrible

This has everything you want from a hardcore punk/noise rock record. It's loud, edgy and chaotic. I guess it overstays it's welcome a little bit but there were definitely moments I enjoyed. 7/10

Didn’t like any of it.

Started off terrible but improved. Slightly. Another questionable pick. 2.5

I don’t hear anything that merited this being heralded as required listening before one dies. Not unlistenable, but not necessarily enjoyable. Could have skipped it and slept just fine for the rest of my days.

#90 I actually kinda like the vibe this has. A bit too much noise at some parts, but it has a lot of good hard grooves. Highlights: Up Against The Wall Motherfucker, Spike Island, Seasick

not terrible but not great. I didn't hate it but did one of the songs use the phrase "flesh trombone?????

Just noise with some yelling over the top

Penance Soiree The Icarus Line 2004 Genres: Rock Styles: Indie Rock 1. Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers (★★★★☆) -Contexto: habla de adicción y de una relación tóxica y obsesiva. El narrador mezcla imágenes de drogas, mentiras y vigilancia (sentirse espiado, "escuchado en la oscuridad") con un deseo posesivo y hasta violento hacia una mujer. Hay una sensación constante de persecución y culpa religiosa ("me van a crucificar"), como si el personaje supiera que va a pagar por lo que hace pero no puede parar. 2. Spit on It (★★⯨☆☆) -Contexto: es una bajada de línea contra la industria (musical y corporativa en general). Enumera, casi como una lista de quejas, todo lo que mantiene a la gente encerrada en el miedo y la ignorancia: ejecutivos que no se hacen cargo de sus errores, empresas que solo buscan plata, "esclavos de la industria" que matan el arte por un sueldo. El estribillo "Prevent awareness" funciona como grito irónico contra el conformismo. 3. On the Lash (★★★★☆) -Contexto: trata sobre la sensación de que algo siempre estuvo mal en la vida propia, y la necesidad de escapar a través de la noche, el alcohol y el movimiento constante ("hay que salir de este pueblo ya"). Hay una idea fatalista de perderse a uno mismo de vez en cuando como parte inevitable de vivir, pero también un pedido de sanación al final ("empecemos a curarnos"). 4. Caviar (★★★★☆) -Contexto: describe, desde una mirada fría y cínica, a una mujer que busca drogas y algo parecido al amor para escapar de su realidad, y a un narrador que se aprovecha de eso vendiéndole "protección" y drogas. Es una escena de explotación y desesperación nocturna, con un trato transaccional disfrazado de intimidad. 5. Spike Island (★★★★☆) -Contexto: retrata el consumo pesado de drogas (heroína explícitamente) como una forma de anestesiar el dolor. Aparece una pareja que se dice "estar juntos" pero en realidad está cada uno perdido en su propia adicción ("estamos solos, vivimos juntos, fashionably numb"), mostrando codependencia y aislamiento emocional pese a la cercanía física. 6. Kiss Like Lizards (★★⯨☆☆) -Contexto: habla de la autodestrucción y el desapego emocional. El narrador quema puentes y relaciones a propósito, se muestra incapaz de sentir empatía real ("quiero sentir lástima por vos pero los dos sabemos..."), y cuestiona el sentido de la vida y de morir sin dejar huella. El título alude a un afecto frío, "de sangre fría", como los lagartos. -Comentario: más ruido que música; mal uso de la distorsión a mi gusto. 7. Getting Bright at Night (★★★☆☆) -Contexto: funciona casi como una canción de amor invertida o de resignación amorosa. El personaje jura que no se va a volver a enamorar mientras describe noches sin dormir, drogas y autodestrucción, pero al mismo tiempo admite que no puede evitar sentir algo y le pide a la otra persona que no lo abandone. Es un tema de nueve minutos que la banda describió como algo intencionalmente ambiguo entre el amor y el hartazgo del propio Cardamone. 8. Big Sleep (★★★★⯨) -Contexto: describe un estado de disociación y fuga de la realidad producido por las drogas, donde la línea entre pesadilla y vida despierta se borra. Hay una búsqueda existencial de sentido ("mostrame algo, mostrame la vida") mezclada con la sensación de estar fuera del propio cuerpo, y un cierre que roza la autodestrucción como forma de pasar el tiempo. 9. White Devil (★★★★☆) -Contexto: es una declaración de independencia y desprecio por el status, la plata y las escenas musicales "de moda" (menciona directamente no querer saber nada de Nueva York ni de quién tiene más guita). El narrador se planta como alguien que no le debe nada a nadie, que no tiene amigos reales ni busca atención, y que prefiere pelear su propia guerra antes que aceptar su lugar dado. 10. Meatmaker (★★★★⯨) -Contexto: cuenta la historia de alguien atrapado en un ciclo de consumo, arrestos y encierro ("se droga, lo encierran de nuevo"), que no tiene amigos reales y al que ni su propia familia quiere cerca de sus hijos. Hay un tono amenazante hacia el final (habla de asfixiar a alguien mientras duerme), reforzando la idea de una persona ya consumida por la adicción y la violencia. 11. Virgin Velcro (★★★★☆) -Contexto: retrata encuentros sexuales atravesados por las drogas (menciona el éxtasis) en un ambiente de fiesta callejera. Los personajes buscan pertenencia y placer inmediato en cuerpos ajenos como forma de escapar del vacío, mezclando vulnerabilidad, autodesprecio ("solo me amo a mí mismo") y una crítica velada a esa cultura de excesos de la ciudad. 12. Sea Sick (★★⯨☆☆) -Contexto: es una canción de arrepentimiento y culpa dentro de una relación que se rompió. El narrador reconoce que "la cagó" y se plantea el dolor de haber lastimado a la otra persona, con imágenes bastante oscuras de autocastigo antes que hacerle daño a ella. Es el tema más melancólico y confesional del disco, marcado por la resignación ("ya fue, olvidate"). 13. Party the Baby Off (★★★⯨☆) -Contexto: cierra el álbum con una escena caótica y perturbadora de vida doméstica atravesada por drogas y violencia (se menciona golpear a alguien, pastillas, una madre que "vive en el infierno"). Funciona como un cierre descontrolado y casi punk, mezclando imágenes de fiesta ("sacate toda la ropa") con un trasfondo de abuso y descontrol familiar. -TOTAL = ★★★⯨☆ (3,62)

Some songs are tolerable and some really grind on you. Between 1 and 2 and I see no reason to fight for a 2 but let it play and stopped having the urge to skip so will toss it a 2. Very unclear why this album is on here. Radio that played after was really not bad.

Ehhhh, something I probably would have enjoyed more if I had heard it in highschool. Made me want to listen to Thursday.

Solid but unspectacular version of something I generally like. Noisy guitar rock with a punk/metal edge to it. Bass player is good which is critical. Guitar player is also solid. Vocals are fine but a little lacking.

This seems to be pretty good of its kind, but it is not for me.

ick. either the singer sucks and the production is mixed to drown him out or the production sucks.... or both.

Our group chat seemed to have settled on the thought that this album was a great example of whatever it is. I don't know about that. I struggled to listen to it. Wikipedia says its possible genres are alternative rock, post-hardcore, garage rock, and noise rock. I would've said I liked three of those genres but I guess maybe I'm wrong? I did not like this.

Is it good? Yes. Do I like this kind of gritty early 2000s alt rock? Yes! However, this doesn’t sound so substantially different from the stuff that the hives, the strokes, the killers, etc. we’re putting out at the same time, so how does this merit inclusion in that context? Idk. It was fun either way.

If the satanic panic of the 80’s had a house band, this would be it.

Lots of energy but not for me.

I like the fact it was something a bit noisier and venturing where this list doesn’t often go. Unfortunately, the album itself lacked anything really memorable: no standout tracks, meandering riffs that never really hit; and a lack of vocal hooks. A shame.

Falls into the pile of crap that seemed to emerge during the indie rock revival as a second wave after the initial ‘the strokes are the new hot thing’ from NME. This felt somewhat soulless, with some aggression coming through but with seemingly very little to say. I’m Not averse to post-hardcore but this is too tame in comparison to some of its peers and not melodically refined enough to bear repeated listens. Not sure what the fuss is about really as there are many more in a similar vein that would benefit from being on this list over this album.

I was poised, ready to give my first 1-star review until I started to just get into this a little. The noise rock of The Icarus Line made me think of At The Drive In, a band I haven’t given two hoots about for 20 years. An assault on the ears, yes, but there were some tunes in there. I can’t say I wasn’t glad when it finished though. 2/5.

Judging by the opening title track name I was expecting a hardcore punk thrash album, but it didn’t quite turn out like that. What should have been a two minute banger plods on for 4 and half minutes without going anywhere and the lyrics come over as self consciously edgy. The album doesn’t really improve much from that point. Even though there were moments of inspired weirdness there was just too much generic indie style noodling around and the overall effect didn’t grab me. Yawnsome rather than awesome.

o famoso rock perfeitamente parametrizado e gravado pra vender identidade rebelde e roqueira no início dos anos 2000 é sem graça, é ruim, é cansado, é completamente esquecível

a capa é bonita garage rock, né. vai um pouco na linha do white stripes e tenta deixar mais barulhento. deu certo não, btw. achei fraquíssimo!!

Pretty hard....a little feeling of Marilyn Manson.

I'm sure someone likes this but it definitely wasn't me. 1/5

The Icarus Line seems to be very concerned with texture and feeling more than anything else. A lot of this music is unsettling, especially rhythmically.... the riffs are all off-kilter and either razor sharp or serrated, all the better to tear your ear-flesh. I was very into indie rock in 2004, and I have never heard of these dudes. Apparently their record label didn't want to support them - and I get it. These songs are really interesting and will absolutely appeal to the more extreme garage-rock folks, but beyond being way too noisy for a general audience, they make your skin crawl just a bit too much. "Kiss Like Lizards," for example, has a bizarre elliptical verse riff, which transitions into a completely unrelated chorus, a move very reminiscent of prog. All while sounding remarkably like early Stooges. And the vocalist sounds a bit like the singer from Jesus and Mary Chain.... I’m kind of torn on this one- I understand intellectually that this is good, and in my wheel house. It doesn’t connect with me. THREE STARS

I've heard that anti-depressants work in a way that the person under prescription feels emotionless. No depression neither happiness, just a blank state, which is what I feel about this album (hope this doesn't sound absurd or cruel). For everything good that I can say about it, there is something that counters it: The voice has a nice tone and also great screams, but the times it hits a catchy or memorable melodies, or impactful performance are very few, with much of what he sings feeling mediocre or forgettable. The guitars sometimes do play some nice riffs, but just as the voice, there are not much of them with most of the guitar work being passable, including the solos. The rhythms also falter from this "sometimes good, but bland in its majority" problem, where sometimes it is very energetic, and others are just alright mid-tempo. The production has a lot of distortion, sometimes adding a powerful tone to the music and others it is so noisy that totally trash the sound, suppresses some instruments and becomes incredibly messy. It is possible that this aspect may be the most impactful one, as there is a big chance I'm losing some great moments from the instruments on these muffled parts. When it comes to giving it a rating, my feelings toward this album are incredibly close to the point where I neither feel positive nor good about it, but if I have to choose a side, I think I'll go with the positive one.

Not big and not clever.

I somehow ended up listening to this twice even though my first assessment was "this is just noise". On the second go around, I'm prepared to upgrade it from "bad" to "miscellaneous", but it didn't change my life.

Garage rock, noise rock, and post-hardcore built from scuzzy guitars, heavy bass, pounding drums, and sneering vocals feels like stumbling into a grimy bar where the band is already playing at full volume and everyone seems to be enjoying the chaos except me. There is plenty of swagger, menace, and sonic grime, but for me the deliberate roughness often becomes more abrasive than exciting. The album has a strong personality, yet I found myself more conscious of its attitude and noise than drawn into the songs.

685/1001 2026.08.21 🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑

It was aight. Some decent grunge tunes, not super memorable.

i liked this quite a bit! 3.5

OK, weird and fun!

Noise rock like this which is designed to cross over into the mainstream always has a pretentiousness problem. Musicallly, this one's a solid album though, even if a bit boring.

Bof! It annoys me they are missing the é in soirée. What’s a soy-ree?

Damn I got a band inspired by Black Flag straight after listening to their album. This one is a bit better but I still don’t really enjoy this genre, I don’t feel anything from it.

rock slop

Really enjoyed my first listen of this album

i'm sure this is more offensive if you're a fan of the bands they are apparently taking heavy inspiration from but like... this is perfectly fine. nothing special but the average score seems a little harsh

When I started this I was worried it would be a bit much for me for listening on the way to work but I was pleasantly surprised. Defo not something I’d reach for usually but I enjoyed it. I liked the way it sounded moody. I specifically liked on the lash and spike island. I felt that had more of the sound I liked. I did feel like I was in an all saints advert. This almost sounded like a rocky Jeff Buckley album. Not sure I’d listen again but glad I have.

Really liked this, so much to it. Unusual that I enjoy an American band this much. Would listen again.

Every song sounded the same

*Penance Soiree* is the 2004 album where the notoriously volatile LA band The Icarus Line channeled their chaotic energy into a dark, sleazy, and critically acclaimed masterpiece . It's a record that sounds like a dangerous night on the Sunset Strip, captured in all its hedonistic, nihilistic glory . ### 🎤 Lyrics and Themes: The Sleaze and the Sorrow Lyrically, *Penance Soiree* is a deep dive into the underbelly of Los Angeles nightlife . The album's title itself sets up a central theme: a "soiree" of indulgence and a "penance" for the inevitable fallout . Frontman Joe Cardamone delivers stream-of-consciousness narratives that mix carnal desire with existential dread . The album explores a world of chemical escape and transient connections, often with a darkly poetic touch. The song "Caviar" vividly paints this picture: *"Looking like she needs a miracle / Out here so late just looking for a drug"* . These are not tales of glamorous rock excess, but of hollow desperation. This nihilism is even more direct on tracks like "Kiss Like Lizards," where Cardamone wails: *"Who's gonna miss this flesh when I'm gone?"* . This line, as noted by several critics, captures the album's core blend of rebellion and a bleak sense of impermanence . His vocal delivery, often compared to a blend of Iggy Pop's raw lust and Nick Cave's seedy narratives, is key to selling the material . ### 🎸 Music and Production: A Wall of Sonic Sleaze Musically, *Penance Soiree* is a massive step forward from their debut, evolving from post-hardcore noise into a more expansive and decadent "scuzz-rock" sound . The album's sound is a potent cocktail of influences, blending the ferocity of **punk and hardcore** with the druggy, sprawling grooves of **Spacemen 3** and the sinister swagger of **The Stooges** . - **Guitar Work:** The twin guitar attack of Aaron North and Alvin DeGuzman is a defining feature. They create a disorienting, fuzzed-out wall of sound on tracks like "Spit on It" and "Big Sleep," where each guitar often seems to be playing a different, chaotic tune . However, the album also showcases their ability to be melodic and chime-like, as heard on "Spike Island" . - **Rhythm Section:** The bass and drums provide a "jackhammer" foundation, locking into heavy, sinister grooves that underpin the guitar chaos . - **Vocals:** Cardamone is a chameleon, shifting from a cracked, libidinous croon to a desperate, rage-filled scream. His performance is "wanton and libidinous," and his pleas (like "Why can't I get some fo' free?!" on "Up Against the Wall") are raw and compelling . - **Production:** The album was produced by Michael Musmanno and mixed by the legendary Alan Moulder (known for his work with My Bloody Valentine and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs), with one track mixed by Ken Andrews . The production, mastered by Howie Weinberg, is designed to sound huge and punishing, rewarding high-volume listening . The result is a record that is "visceral" and "dangerous" . ### 💿 Critical and Cultural Influence Upon its release, *Penance Soiree* was met with widespread critical acclaim, garnering a Metacritic score of 81/100 . Critics praised its raw power and the band's commitment to a dangerous rock aesthetic. It was hailed as a "masterpiece" and one of the best rock records of the year . The album has since been recognized in the book *1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die*, cementing its status as a cult classic . Its influence is that of a touchstone for raw, uncompromising rock, proving that a band could be both critically lauded and resolutely cult, as the album barely cracked five figures in sales . ### ⚖️ Review Summary: Pros and Cons **Pros:** * **Visceral, Dangerous Sound:** The album delivers a potent, feral energy that is rare in rock music. It's an authentic and "unrepentant" hard rock record . * **Strong Songwriting:** At its core, *Penance Soiree* is lauded for its songs. A central trio of tracks—"Kiss Like Lizards," "Getting Bright At Night," and "Big Sleep"—are often cited as a "holy trinity" that showcase the band at their peak . * **Stellar Production:** Alan Moulder's mix gives the chaotic sound a powerful, defined punch without sanitizing it . * **Compelling Thematic Cohesion:** The album's exploration of hedonism, nihilism, and decay creates a unified, immersive, and sleazy atmosphere . **Cons:** * **Song Overstays:** Some tracks, particularly the sprawling nine-minute "Getting Bright at Night," can feel like they overstay their welcome, with droning sections that may test patience . * **Inconsistent Moments:** A few tracks are considered misfires. The experimental "Meatmaker" was criticized for sounding like a "washing machine" rather than a successful drone piece, and tracks like "Big Sleep" and "White Devil" were noted as being "cloying melodically" or lacking in hooks . * **Derivative to a Fault:** While the band uses their influences well, some critics point out that they don't always transcend them, with a "limited" well of ideas that can make some tracks feel like standard issue . *Penance Soiree* is a document of a band operating at a creative peak, capturing a specific brand of decadent, dangerous rock that feels both timeless and very much of its era. It's an album for those who want their rock 'n' roll dirty, intense, and uncompromising.

I enjoyed it, but it was pretty good alternative rock or whatever genre it is, but I don’t think it really deserves to be on this list, nothing stood out to me as revolutionary or changing music, but I’ll still give it a 4

I feel like this was an 80s hair metal band trapped in the body of an early 2000s Alt rock outfit. Could have been worse, could gave been better.

I would've given it a 3, but then it turned so loud and obnoxious and not in the cool Iggy Pop way. This isn't bad at all - it's Jet but better. It's the whole Death From Above 1979 feeling, just more cluttered. It's hell for the mixing and mastering engineers. Maybe I don't know shit, but I do know that I don't really want to go back to this (5/10, 2/5 on this scale)

Good crunchy alt rock sound.

Had never heard of this band/album but it blew away whatever assumptions I would’ve had about it. 2004 rock and roll at its core. This was at a time when there was a resurgence in straightforward rock music. The perfect cruising album.

An extremely weak set of songs that sort of wannabe the Strokes, Soundgarden, maybe early White Stripes. Relentlessly stupid and boring.

Just…no. Bad, leftover grunge meets bad, leftover hardcore = bad pick for this list.

just not great, i really didn't like it

It’s my kind of sound, but hadn’t heard of the band before, and probably won’t listen again

I don’t think this record is inherently terrible, but I just kept thinking “these guys aren’t good enough to pull off what they’re trying to do”. Best example, the build in Getting Bright at Night was pretty cool. And then that drop just did not deliver the energy it needed. I felt a lot of the album was like that. A lot of noise and set ups, but very little payoff that warranted the aggression and grate of the music. Didn’t hate, and I thought it improved throughout the record. But overall felt very try hard. Some cool ideas, but didn’t execute. 2/5.

bunch of noise

Absolutely not!! I’m not a fan of this genre or this style of music.

This was fun. Not super original or anything but fun. Probably would have been cool to see these guys live back in the day. Some of y'all are miserable.

I love it ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ "Getting Bright At Night" my favorite ❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤🖤

Judging on the listeining counts on spotify for all of the tracks the only ones that ever listened to this were the guys that use this website. I think the album is solid. Dunno why it should be on the list but hey there are a lot worse album where i'd say this. If I had to listen to it again I would not run away screaming. I guess that counts as a compliment.

This is the second album from LA-based hard rock band The Icarus Line. Some of the songs remind me of Led Zeppelin, although the lyrics on this record are somewhat juvenile. There’s a bit too much screaming here, along with a few decent tracks.

This album might be critically acclaimed, but it definitely wasn't popular, 'cause I've never heard of it. Rightfully so. It's generic noisy 2000s rock if you ask me, right down to the color scheme. Idiot Walk, Icky Thump, Penance Soiree. Zzz. Slur count = 1. Mass/count intrigue: "You take too much pills"

hätte 2004 dazu getanzt

Removed Album #37 (List: https://pastebin.com/cSThNiK9) From the Vault #31 (March 26, 2026) Another day, another album me never heard of. Me musical know-how don't work too good. Anyways, this is obviously an indie rock album going by the cover, likely with a garage rock influence. There's nothing this album can be other than that, right? They don't have this album on YouTube Music. Man, it sucks to be a peasant right about now. This was a bleak listen. I like to think I'm altruistic and fair about the albums that I listen to despite having a sub-2.5 rating average, but come on. What the fuck are we doing here? I'm antagonistic towards garage rock by default, and this album unfortunately embodies many of the traits I dislike most about the genre. The guitars aren't as blown out as some of garage rock's worst offerings, but they're still really, really terrible. There isn't a single good riff on this thing. The guitars dick about aimlessly, occasionally going full wacko mode when the album decrees it, but never in a coherent or complementary direction. Not to mention the wailing. The fucking wailinggggg. The guitars are a total write off, and their complete misfire doesn't leave much room for this album to redeem itself. There's very little to these songs beyond the poor guitars, scuffed percussion and shitty, directionless vocals. Overall, the album's a complete junker. So, why was this album removed? I can already kind of tell, but I shall feign ignorance nonetheless. This was included in the original 1001 lineup and pulled from either the 2013 or 2016 editions of the book (I don't have a scan of 2013). The book entry says that this album is "...the perfect punk statement." It's also an advancement in the band's sound and the album opener is apparently a diatribe towards commercial punk musicians. That latter tidbit is kind of strange. Punk as a movement has more or less been dead since the 90s. It's strange to be getting all territorial about it now. "[The] ambition and experimentation earned Penance Soiree acclaim far beyond California's hardcore scene. Metal magazine Kerrang! called it a "stand against tedium and mediocrity," and even the conservative British newspaper The Daily Telegraph admitted that the album possessed a "do-or-die intensity." Wikipedia reveals that this album is "one of 2004's most critically acclaimed releases", apparently. The album was also undermined significantly by their label, who made no effort to promote the album. Despite this, it received respectable reviews from a number of critics. So, why was this album removed? It's a weak pick on just about every front. The band isn't prominent, the music isn't good, it wasn't popular, it isn't aesthetically unique and it doesn't have any significance or influence in music history. The only thing really going for it is the love of the critics, which once again is only modest. We're pulling this. In place of this album, I humbly submit "Millennium" by Backstreet Boys for inclusion on the list. I've never listened to the album and I am ostensibly not its target demographic, though I think its standing as one of the best-selling albums of all time and the surrounding boy band phenomena makes it a necessary listen.

Nr. 11 og 12 kunne jeg ikke finde på youtube, men er stadig ret sikker i min rating. Hold kæft et lorteband

Virker som et ret bizart valg til listen. Måtte gerne have larmet mere. Den her slags plader bør ikke være særlig meget mere end en halv time lange.

Very noisy. I liked it a lot. A bit too long maybe..

Sounded like they were trying to combine a lot of artists together, I specifically got an Iggy Pop vibe. Decent album.

It’s really a shame that this album has weaker moments. At its best moments, this album has some near perfect tracks, particularly ‘Getting Bright At Night’. However, so much of this album is generic, pretty much the entire second half feels like filler with a couple decent moments. On the other hand, I did particularly enjoy the Noise Rock-focused parts with guitar feedback, I think it made the album more interesting and gave it depth. Although I was very disappointed at the lack of consistency, at least I’ve discovered a few new songs that I really enjoy, though they were few and far between!

I could have lived my whole life peacefully without listening to this album.

I had heard of this band before, but apparently I'd never actually listened to them. After hearing this album, I'd prefer to go back to that. Their own record label thought this album was trash. It's only claim to anything is being added to this list for some reason.

Shrieking over speed metal just doesn’t do it for me.

2/5. Just an exceptionally boring post-hardcore album, offers nothing that you can’t get a far better version of from other artists in the genre. It has the loudness and angst to make you think it is making some big emotional statement, but it’s more-so a cardboard cutout, it might seem like the real thing from a distance but with any closer analysis the illusion is broken.

Occasionally fascinating but I really do draw the line at albums that sound like they recorded it in a bathroom.

Insert eye roll here

Why would you make this album in 2004? Why would we listen to it now?

Didn't love it. Had some good moments but drifted a bit too hard into the punk/grunge side for me to really connect with it. Fairly hard core for what was labelled just alternative. Didn't hate it, just not my favourite genre.

Never heard of thsi group but it was OK

Bad garage rock from the early 00s. Not enough fury to be angry, not enough rhythm to be catchy. Very forgettable which why this group was forgotten amongst their peers.

Medio heavy metal no

Underrated favorite of mine, shame they never caught on with the wider public. They have some great songs and their albums are overall enjoyable. It's like Hardcore, but not quite. Good blend of different influences, hear everything here from Black Flag to Suicide. I honestly enjoyed it a bit more the past few listens. Kind of want to give it a 5 just because of its low rating here but I'll refrain.

Some good songs but pretty forgettable overall.

Maybe CDs ruined music. Being able to store more information and create overly long albums of mid music. This does not need to be an hour long.

I really enjoyed this one. I don't know if it should be on this list since others were doing this style in the '90s, but I'm glad it was there so I could listen to them.

I thought something was off when I saw the most played song on the album has ~77k listens on Spotify. Then I listed to the album and understood. It leaves me wondering how this particular album made this list.

Nothing novel or unique, but an interesting more hardcore take on early-2000's alternative.

This was too mindlessly noisy for me.

not for me

Didn’t stand out

I had never heard of this band before, cool to I find that on this list outside of jazz and international.

Really liked this one

Wow! ..... how completely uninteresting.

Good record

나쁘지 않고 평범했다. It wasn't bad; it was ordinary.

Кто такие чем знамениты? Мне понравилось, гаражненько. Последние две песни тооооп.

Какой-то гаражный рок

не понимаю, как они оказались в этом списке, звучат в принципе нормально, но не зацепили, 3 поставлю

Even as background music this wasn’t my vibe

Harder prog rock Nirvana-ish? I know there’s a better way to describe the sound but I can’t think of it.

Had no idea what to expect, but really liked the energy of this one.

I tend to like music in this vein, but this one didn’t quite do it for me. A kind of garagey post-hardcore, but it lacked the punch it felt like it was going for. Just seemed like it should be this intense, chaotic, energetic music - at moments it was, but it wasn’t consistently there. Maybe it comes through better live. The main thing that I was impressed with was the guitar work, as the noisy, chaotic, feedback-laden playing was quite gripping. The rest of the band just didn’t match. Staying almost exclusively in mid-tempo tunes didn’t really help either. Overall I like the idea of this band, but found the execution missing something.

Entirely forgettable

So pretentious) Just go listen to deftones, limbizkit or bri'ish punk

Gotta be in the top 1% of baffling inclusions on here. Not bad but also not very good, certainly any QoTSA is better. I'd love some more context for this selection.

Buah vaya disco guapo. A lo mejor en algún momento puede ser demasiado ruidoso, pero vamos, poco rato y el resto merece totalmente la pena. Mis favoritas On the Lash, Caviar y Getting Bright at Night.

Ruido raro, podría ser peor pero no repetiría.

Mucho ruido. A veces me daba la sensación de que cada miembro del grupo estaba tocando una canción distinta.

Great find. I listened to it twice.

i may listen to it again later, it was fine.

Whenever Wikipedia lists this book in the description, I know it’s bad. The album is much like the cover: dirty, confusing, and offensive.

there is no shot this is top 1001 all time

Looked these guys up on Wikipedia. The singers name sounds familiar. I may have interviewed him for a podcast? I like this album so far. It’s my kind of noise and energy. Opening track was great. On track two and I like that one too. I love an album like this where it starts good and gets better. Track 4 “Caviar” grabbed me right away and I’m in now. This is great. I was not expecting “spike island”. It’s still raw but very melodic. It’s almost like the opening track was their “process of weeding out” and if you stay the album just keeps getting better. And now “Kiss like lizards”. This album is fantastic. I love the contrast in this album from brash and hyper, to almost pop melodic, to a slow lumbering heavy rock with distortion and then unexpected clean tones. This album is a masterpiece. On “big sleep”. I would have loved to have seen this tour. “Seasick” is a great song.

Album koji kao da ne može odlučiti šta bi najradije bio. Ima nekih kvalitetnijih dijelova pa mi se zato provlači u trice, jedva.

The aural equivalent of mud. Not quite completely unlistenable, but much closer than was necessary.

Brief review. I’d never heard of them, and sometimes that leads to a pleasant surprise. Not today. I didn’t like anything at all on here and can’t image how it’s on the list.

No es del estilo q me gusta la verdad

not as good as Joni Mitchell’s Blue

insane pull for the list but like.......they were kind of onto something here! anything can be party music if it's about partying! that long song kicks ass!

It's alright.

Did I need to hear this? Maybe, maybe not. But it wasn't horrible.

This album was amazing. I've never heard them until now and I loved it. This sounds musically like At the Drive-In some and the vocals sound like someone I can't put my finger on. Will absolutely be listening to this again

Mostly sounds manufactured and pretentious. "We dress, sneer, and sound like this because we are a rock band!" Some of it is ok, but once again why this album and no Tool?

Tylsä ja yllättävän ärsyttävä, huono. 1/5

Just noise, and not the good kind

Surprisingly noisy and forgettable.

Initial impressions: a poor man's Shellac; sub-par At The Drive In; Jesus Lizard's younger, disappointing brothers; an unfunny Killdozer; grunge, but gone mouldy 15 years after the event. Hmmm, I've heard thousands of records like this. Not sure what makes it stand out from any of the above, more talented noisy bastards. I think you had to be in the moshpit to have fond memories of this. Merely okay.

Fanns ej på Spotify men borde hitta någon annanstans

This is #day690 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… well, yeah, that was fucking noisy and, I must admit, unenjoyable for the most part. I have nothing else to add, except that I'm not a fan of garage rock. This is a 2 out of 5. Looking forward to #day691.

Yet again this list churns out another artist I have never heard of. In places, it was an enjoyable listen with hints of Royal Blood and Mudhoney. Decent music, but I really didn’t like the vocals, it doesn’t seem to match the vibe. I guess this one may grow on me with more listens.

Nice to hear something new, and that takes you on such a fun ride. One of those albums the manages to sound like everyone and no-one at the same time. Which in the end actually makes them rather original. I just really enjoyed the organised chaos of many of the songs, where they flip between vocals or bass or guitar in the lead, never really feeling like you know where a song will go. I like being kept guessing.

Not into it. It's punk/rock so it has noise and raw energy, but doesn't have any catchy melodies. These songs don't have a lot of plays on spotify. I don't know what it's doing on this list.

I can get behind noisy, angst rock but this just comes off as a charisma-free version of Alice in Chains. A good portion of the Wiki article is dedicated to winging

Like a grungier White Stripes with none of the catchiness. Might be a high 2, low 3 but my expectations were low so grading up for today.

Not for me

There were moments when this approached something like decent garage rock, but most of it was pretty uninteresting, unintelligible, and noisy. What I picked up of the lyrics wasn’t great. While not consistently bad, it’s not something I feel the need to return to. 2.5

En 2004, la fameuse formule du "post-punk revival" tournait en boucle sur toutes les ondes avec des groupes impeccablement coiffés, vêtus de petits blazers étriqués, qui réinventaient la poudre en pillant gentiment les formats les plus polis du Velvet Underground ou de Television. C'était l'époque où le rock jouait la carte de la sécurité sous couvert de coolitude absolue, et c'est précisément dans ce climat d'autosatisfaction générale qu'a débarqué The Icarus Line. Leur deuxième album Penance Soiree est un manifeste de pure haine amoureuse dirigé contre l'industrie du disque et le puritanisme ambiant, un cataclysme sonore que je place volontiers parmi les plus belles anomalies de ma discothèque personnelle car le rock n'a pas besoin de sauveurs en cravate, il a besoin de criminels prêts à saigner sur scène pour une idée. N'attendez pas de moi que je démonte ce disque piste par piste car ce disque ne se découpe pas, il se subit et s'apprécie d'un seul bloc, comme une mauvaise fièvre dont on ne veut pas guérir. Le son global de Penance Soiree est un miracle de dégoût et de fureur maîtrisée, le duo de guitaristes tisse une toile de larsen absolument insupportable pour les oreilles chastes, alternant entre des riffs lourds et poisseux dignes du Black Sabbath, et des stridences aiguës qui rappellent les plus belles heures de panique provoquées par Drive Like Jehu ou The Birthday Party. C'est une agression permanente, mais une agression d'une élégance rare, presque aristocratique dans sa décadence. La basse, quant à elle, impose une tension rythmique qui vous prend directement aux tripes et ne vous lâche plus pendant près d'une heure d'assaut ininterrompu. Au milieu de ce chaos instrumental qui ferait passer la plupart des groupes de métal de l'époque pour des enfants de chœur en pleine répétition, la voix de Joe Cardamone s'élève comme le hurlement d'un possédé en pleine crise de sevrage. Le mec ne chante pas, il éructe, il crache sa bile, il feule, passant d'un murmure menaçant de prédateur nocturne à des cris gutturaux déchirants qui mettent à mal ses cordes vocales à chaque fin de phrase. C'est du sleaze punk de la pire espèce, injecté d'une dose massive de noise expérimentale qui désorientera fatalement le grand public. Et c'est précisément cette absence totale de compromis commercial qui fait la grandeur de l'œuvre et explique son statut de disque culte auprès des esthètes de la déflagration. Si je décide de lui attribuer la note très solide de 4 sur 5, c'est parce que ce projet frôle le chef-d'œuvre absolu tout en conservant les défauts inhérents à sa propre nature destructrice. Par moments, l'album se regarde un peu trop sombrer dans son propre néant sonique, s'égarant dans des expérimentations bruitistes qui peuvent étouffer l'efficacité brute des morceaux les plus directs. Et pour bien comprendre l'impact de ces types à l'époque, il suffit de se souvenir de leurs prestations scéniques légendaires, souvent à la limite de l'émeute ou du fait divers criminel. On parle d'un groupe dont le guitariste de l'époque, Aaron North, s'est illustré un jour en brisant la vitrine de protection d'un Hard Rock Cafe en plein concert pour s'emparer de la guitare fétiche de Stevie Ray Vaughan afin de la brancher sur son propre ampli. En fin de compte, cet opus reste une boussole indispensable pour quiconque cherche à savoir ce que signifie réellement faire du rock sans filet de sécurité au XXIe siècle. C'est bruyant, c'est mal élevé, c'est parfois d'une vulgarité magnifique, mais c'est surtout d'une honnêteté artistique terrifiante. C'est une œuvre majeure, injustement boudée par les charts mondiaux mais chérie par tous ceux pour qui la musique doit encore être synonyme de danger public et de frissons interdits. Une véritable messe noire à laquelle je vous conseille vivement de participer, à condition d'aimer l'odeur du soufre et des lampes d'amplificateurs qui crament en direct.

The first half of this album is really great, I love the noise elements, but everything from Getting Bright At Night and onwards just kind of meanders and isn't super captivating. It just sounds like a modern version of the Stooges, which is fine, but not my thing. Still a very good album though. High 4!

Derrière le bruit, il y a des trucs pas si pires.

complete noise, nothing worth listening to, really, when basically all the songs sound alike mediocre, at best

Noisey rock music buried in feedback. It sounds pretty good. It's not great and far from original but it rocks and it's fun. Play 'spot the influences'- I started to but got bored so I just laid back, closed my eyes and listened. Not a bad way to kill an hour- let it bleed, I reckon.

THIS IS SUCH A CHORE TO GET THROUGH. Like it sounds like a charisma-free slurry of other bands.

Never heard of them. Pretty unterrible sometimes melodic punkish rock. I didn't mind it 2.5 stars

Mix of 80's no wave, vegas cock rock and hardcore 90's grunge. I hear influences from Sonic Youth, Temple of the Dog and Alice in Chains but it is nothing new or exciting except one song. The majority of the album is unoriginal and kind of boring. No reason this should be on the list.

usually enjoy post-hardcore but i'm afraid there's just not any juice here. the song titles and the tone all reflect that they quite deeply want to be Saying Something but i can't feel any of it, it's over my head or not there

I only recognize this artist's name, and I don't believe I know any of their songs. So this is my first time listening to the artist and to this album start-to-finish. I kind of like the noisiness of this, and the riffs are pretty solid. I'm not sure I enjoy the vocalist's style. This might require a few more listens for me to decide whether I like it or not, but I'm also not sure I feel compelled to listen to it again. This isn't bad, but it's also hard to rate on only one listen. I'll add this to my list of albums to listen to again, but with a note that I was uncertain about it.

I was close to enjoying this, but I just couldn’t get there. It reminded me of my other bands at different times, but every band I thought of did it better.

(Decent 6/10) I don't like being that guy, but this is basically Iggy Pop but 2004. The production is pretty good, but I really couldn't find myself to feel compelled by the vocals or the songwriting for the most part. The times this record shines for me is when it tows the line between sasscore and noise rock, "Kiss Like Lizards" for instance. The album also takes lots of cues from 60's garage psych and the second half of the record really digs deep into it. Which would be neat, but honestly I can't help but feel like this sounds like Jet but messier and noisier. There's aspects to this record I find interesting but overall it really failed to captivate me beyond the first handful of songs.

NHB. Not bad

Muito barulho, to velho pra isso.

I'd love to say I went into this with an open mind but I absolutely did not. Ended up enjoying it more than I expected even though it overstayed its welcome and is pretty reductive/forgetable. RYM: N Saved a song: N

Could not listen on vacation, will listen later

Ok - not really my thing, heavy guitar and angry singing

Something about it doesn’t work. The music is good but the singer - his style and delivery - feels out of sync far too often. Like he’s just screaming over top of a recording. Perhaps intentional? Certainly distracting. Hit your post, man. Carry a melody or two. I’m all for discordance if it sometimes offers relief. This never does. Props for Getting Bright at Night - Billy Corgan would’ve done it better though. 2/5

Could’ve trimmed some of the fat. I was ready for it to be done a few songs before it ended. That said, I did enjoy most of it. I love the raw production.

No (screamed incoherently).

Too much angst for me, maybe listening to it in the morning was a bad idea...

Didn't totally hate it

Perhaps a bit of an odd choice for the list but I really liked this. Snarly garage rock revival with lots of post punk edge thrown in. Really great

Hmmm. It definitely sounds like a band trying to ride Jack White's coattails, and yet I found myself enjoying it. Granted, I'm a White Stripes loving elder Millennial, so I might just be in the correct age range. I wouldn't be surprised if it didn't hold up with younger audiences.

One of the last couple of songs reminded me of Metallica. The rest was very meh.

I love when I get something I’ve never heard of at all like this. Noisy garage rock, I’m down with that. But by the end it wore on me, a bit too much classic rock in there for me.

Maybe it’s not as bad as I feel it is, but it ruined my streak of FOUR women, and therefore I have nothing but disdain for it.

Took some time to appreciate this a bit. I had no previous experience with this act so I had no idea what I was in for. I like what they’re going for with their modern approach to The Stooges sound with some sleaze and fuzz to their sound. It didn’t fully hit for me but I didn’t hate what they did here. 3 stars

It was not as bad as people were claiming it to be on here, but its inclusion on the list is truly mystifying because it is not a good record, that's for sure. Messy, boring, and immemorable.

Extremely annoying sounds with production that sounds more like the 19th Century than the 21st Century. Favorite Track: "Spike Island".

“Can I get some White Stripes, Mom?” “We have White Stripes at home.” The White Stripes at home: Can’t believe these jokers have the nerve to compare themselves to Black Flag and The Stooges in their Spotify bio

Never heard of this before so this was a first time listen. This band really liked The Stooges. That was my take away from this. The whole album is almost like a love letter to The Stooges. It wasn't awful but there was something kind of generic about the sound. It could have probably been overcome by recording or mixing it differently I don't really know the technical side. I think ultimately I'm left no different than before I heard it.

loud and noisy, as it supposed to be. but also veeeeeery boring and not at all impressive

Ehhhh… ok

They make a good sound but they don't use it to their advantage. Some of this album I liked but a lot of it was just noise. 3½

It all started to the same by the end. I remember when this album came out it got a lot of buzz and I never quite understood why. Very underwhelming. 2.5

2.5. Decent mid 2000s noise rock.

I really didn't care for this album and I can't explain exactly why. Eventually I started to kind of dig some of the songs and when I looked at Apple Music to see the song name I realized the album had ended and it was playing music from other bands.

3.5 - I've never heard of this band, but I thoroughly enjoyed this album.

4/10 I’d never heard of this band until now, and the tag of “post-hardcore” was somewhat intriguing. This is their second of 8 albums released over 18 years as a band suggests that they were at least able to maintain a decent fanbase for a good period of time. Unfortunately, what it appears that post-hardcore means, is that a band has bought all of the equipment of a hardcore band, only to write and perform some fairly middle-of-the-road indie songs with it, in a confusing and slightly jarring blending of style and tone. Across the over-long record, they do prove themselves capable of moments of real quality; Kiss Like Lizards is an excellent track, as is Virgin Velcro, and if those two tracks had been used as a starting point and the rest of the album developed from there, this could have been an original and exciting album, but sadly, those moments were few and far-between on and album that not only spent too much of its run time lulling, but also outstayed its welcome quite significantly. There are some solid riffs in here, and I think the drumming is largely excellent, but the standard level of indie songwriting doesn’t manage to be hooky or engaging enough to work, and the fact that it’s shrouded in a wash of noise and distortion doesn’t really help it either. The production and instrumental tones would be great in the right context, but apart from occasional moments, it feels like they are mostly unable to find that context. As a result, the record does feel a little lacking in intention and direction, which is only exacerbated by Joe Cardamone on vocal who seems intent on trying to sound cool, but just isn’t able to sell it in a way that I find convincing. And when a band doesn’t manage to sound completely convinced by their own material, it makes it hard to connect with as a listener. Up Against The Wall Motherfuckers - There’s a decent swagger to this and I like the rhythm of the riff. When the beat kicks in it’s got good weight and power to it, but it’s a little bit on the bland side. It kind of feels like fairly middle of the road early 200s indie being performed on the equipment of a heavy rock band. There’s some decent bits and pieces in there, but it’s just not vastly exciting and lacking in pace or intensity, one of which I feel it needs more of. Spit On It - I can’t get on board with the production here, there’s too much high end distortion and noise that makes it quite hard to listen to and everything else gets lost underneath that, but it’s not done in an artistic or particularly intense way, so it juts sounds messy and hard to grok. At least it’s pretty short. On The Lash - This is a bit better, tonally, but still feels a bit like an indie band who’ve picked the wrong producer for their project. There are some really nice touches here and there, particularly from the drummer, who plays powerfully and with cool flourishes. But the rest of the band kind of feel like they’re just playing by numbers really, and I don’t feel the emotion or passion in it, despite it seemingly wanting to present as aggressive and furious music. Caviar - The groove here is much more satisfying and for the first time, it feels like everyone in the band is pulling in the same direction. The noise and grit of it works much better and there seems to be much more intention and throbbing intensity to what they’re doing. There are some cool guitar riffs in there too and the drummer gives it a really engaging thrust. Not bad. Spike Island - Now we get our first real moment of respite from the noise. It’s quite musically straight and bland though and there’s a sort of mundane guitar solo that just meanders along while everyone else continues plodding on. The underlying rhythm is ok, but doesn’t really offer much development or range. I’m not really sure what they’re trying to say with this, and it doesn’t really feel like they’re sure either. Someone ought to give vocalist Joe Cardamone something to believe in. Kiss Like Lizards - There’s a very Queens Of The Stone Age riff in this and this is the most interesting thing that they’ve done thus far, including some 11/4 time! Lovely stuff. There’s loads of range and development of musical ideas on this one, and even the vocals feel like they’ve started to get a bit of life to them in places. It’s got great drumming, interesting riffs, and tonally it feels really coherent in a noisy, on the edge of falling apart way, particularly as it crumbles to the end. I really liked this one. Getting Bright At Night - A slow burn of a track now, but it’s also one of the most egregiously middle-of-the-road indie tracks on the album so far. They try to hide it with some sweeping noise, but even abandon that after the first minute and a half. Some of the choices of rhythmic combinations between the instruments here are totally baffling and create a really incoherent, messy sound. It’s almost like all of them are trying to play different songs at the same time. It does improve, but it’s incredibly one paced and plodding, and boy oh boy does it drag. How on earth they think they’ve got enough in here to justify a 9 minute track is completely beyond me. A lot of it is aimless meandering and I’m not really sure what they’re actually trying to achieve. It finally does something after 6 minutes, but what it does then is still quite boring, despite having a bit more punch and weight to it. Big Sleep - The sneering vocal does just seem a bit try-hard doesn’t it? When this finally gets going a minute and a half in, it’s got s decent bit of punch and I’m convinced that Jeff Watson on drums is far and away the best member of this band. Agin, it kind of feels like a fairly bland indie track put through heavy guitars and punchy drums. There’s not much in the way of melodic writing and the noisy stuff feels lacking in intent or direction to me, which is a shame, because noise music can really work in the right context. This just feels a bit like a slightly unsatisfying union of styles and is quite boring as a result. White Devil - There’s a slurring, swampy cool to this, and it’s better than some of the other stuff, but I’m still not buying what Cardamone is selling with the vocal. After a while, the lumbering, plodding groove just starts to weigh it down too. Unconvincing. Meat Maker - Noisy and quite cool, this would work really well in between better songs as a sound design focused interlude. The bass work and clashing tones work are great and it feels like a pulsing, building monster. But it just feels a bit of a shame as there’s not been enough good stuff around this to make it shine. Virgin Velcro - This is better. Cool grooves, great drumming and riffs and a lot of dirt and punch. The vocal works better here too. I think the slow down towards the end is an interesting way to end it. It’s not an amazing track, but it’s pretty good, and if this was the starting point for the record, pressing forward through stuff like Kiss Like Lizards, we could be cooking with gas. But we’re not. Seasick - While being quite plodding, the general thrust of this is still not bad. The noisiness seems to be serving a bit more of a purpose here and there seems to be a bit more intent and direction to the songwriting. But good god, is this too long. It just goes on and on and on. And in the end, I’m just kind of getting lost in the soupy, swamp of a mix. Party The Baby Off - Back to some generic indie-rock stuff played through the backline of a hardcore band to finish us off. It’s not very good, and frankly this singer thinks he’s cooler than he really is. Big old meh bucket.

I hadn't been aware of this band prior to this album. It's got some good/interesting guitar work: think of the dirty, bluesy but still firmly hardcore riffs with the heavy filmy bass that you can find in garage rock bands everywhere now. Vocals are not fun. I repeat, they're not fun. A real drag to listen to. He's expressive but lacks any genuine talent or unique qualities that would make him consistently listenable. One real positive for this band is how they leverage dissonance and purposeful breakdowns — there's some really cool bits where the instruments fall apart asynchronously but in an artful and pleasant way. It's a lot of noise though. It's tough to get through unless you want something aggressive, messy, and barely on the wheels.

This was a lot of noise… not necessarily bad noise, but a couple listens through and no real desire to dig further.

Odd but ok

I love post hardcore! Listening to this album made me want to pick up bass again.

They tried too hard for attention and had too little to offer.

fairly abrasive all the way through - i didn't particularly enjoy this one

I’m pretty sure all of the streams on Spotify for this album are coming from the people on this website. I didn’t hate or dislike this album at all, I just don’t know why it made the list.

Abrasive just for the sake of being abrasive. Very unpleasant to listen to. There are a couple spots that I enjoy, but not even a full songs worth.

There's way worse on this list with higher overall ratings than this. That said its nothing remarkable, 3/5.

fun album. It’s like a less grungy discount Nirvana.

Pretty noisy, didn't get a lot from it

Penance Soiree by The Icarus Line plays less like a cohesive post-hardcore album and more like a slow-motion, brick-walled train wreck that leaves you begging for the silence of the credits. From the sandpaper-rough, overly compressed production of "Up against the wall" to the outright unlistenable noise of "Spit on it" and "Kiss like lizards," the album suffers from a severe mixing crisis where the vocals feel completely devoid of emotion and buried under a heap of garbage. While fleeting moments of competence emerge—like the decent guitar hook on "On the lash," a slight recovery on "Spike Island," and a hypnotic, creepy vibe on "Meat maker"—they are quickly swallowed by bloated progressive rock experiments like "Getting bright at night" and baffling filler like "Virgin velcro." Ultimately, the record’s inclusion on the 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die list feels like an elaborate, out-of-touch joke; it's a painful exercise in sonic irritation where the absolute best part of the album isn't its actual conclusion, but simply the fact that it finally ended.

53 minutes of non stop screaming

Jack white if he has had no slept for 3 days -The angry stripes

Len Houmous once said The Icarus Line are the Go West of the new age. 3.9 1/13 Up Against The Wall Motherfucker

Not enough distinction between noise and music for me. I’d love to hear this remastered with a more vocals forward mixing, but as is…. I’m overstimulated. The first song was great and I had high hopes. Not awful, but not good either.

How do you make noise rock so bland? I don't know but just when you think something different is going to kick in, it goes back to bland. Boring.

Bastante bien, punk rock rollo white stripes, hay una cancion infumable. 3 estrellas. No puedo escucharlo en ninguna plataforma más que youtube video

Hey AI program, generate the single most generic “hard rock” album possible. I mean, like, zero originality. 53 minutes of totally bland genre cliches. Nothing about it that has any value whatsoever unless you are looking to set a cheesy TV show in a “tough” bar and need establishing music. I mean, complete garbage that no one should ever listen to unless they hate themselves and want to be punished. Can you do that? *Here’s “Penance Soirée” by The Icarus Line* Little on the nose, don’t you think? Stupid robot.

Jesus! Where was this album in the early 90s?! It fits perfectly into that decade; feeling a bit like Jane's Addiction meets The Doors (vibe), The Cult (guitar), and punk/grunge vocals like Mudhoney and The Stooges. It's a bit of a gyp for the band and music lovers that this album came out in 2004 instead of 1994 where it would've made them wildly famous. This may be the best of the almost 300 albums I've listened to on the list so far. Going to add some of these tracks to my daily rotation.

It was fine, punk adjacent, nothing too exciting.

Just feels like a mashup of a thousand other bands - but nothing really jumps out. I can hear Soundgarden, White Stripes, Jesus Lizard, Sonic Youth, The Stooges - just to name a few. Not worth having to sit thru this album ever again.

Seemed pretty average?

Pretty good !

Heard Before? Finally, a real surprise from the list! Completely unfamiliar. Notes: - instantly sounds like it was released exactly ten years too late. - dirty, claustrophobic, buried-vocals mix perfectly suits this kind of noise and aggression. bass tone is monstrous and the drums are a blur of cymbals. i love it. - songwriting just isn't there. I'm not necessarily asking for pop structure, but some hooks would be nice, or a dive into mathy complexity. instead we get an endless barrage of forgettable riffs. - i was expecting the surprisingly enjoyable nine-minute "Getting Bright at Night" to close the album, but it just keeps going after that for no discernible reason. - there's a sax solo somewhere, and a noise coda on "Seasick" that mixed things up a bit, but too little too late for me. Verdict: If your two favorite ever songs are "White Heat White Light" and "Raw Power", this is your album. Listen Again: Probably not. I gave it a good twice over today, but I know too many similar-but-better albums.

Sunday, 24 May, 2026 Solid album. I’d listen again. But it didn’t blow me away. Better albums in the same genre.

Kind of reminded me of white stripes and black keys but if both of those groups were way more self serious. The production was interesting. It felt like they were bursting through the speaker. Still, nothing stood out to me.

Not especially good harder Indie rock. Didn't like most of it very much

The opening track was the worst but the rest didn’t get that much better.

Loud and obnoxious - but could've been worse. Jeez, what kind of series is this?

One of those bands that if you wait two days to review them, you’ve completely forgotten everything about them. 4/10

Errrrrrmmmmmmmmmmmmm - what now?

Ok but not sure I'll listen again

Ummm. So respectfully I would need a lot of money to listen to this album again. Did not like.

4/10- This sounded heavily influenced by early 2000’s rock (White Stripes, Franz Ferdinand, Interpol, The Strokes, etc.). On paper I should have liked this more but this felt loud without direction.

It feels like pretty middle of the road garage/noise rock from the early 2000's. It's a bit of a copy of the White Stripes, but just worse. It's not unlistenable by any means, but it is a bit one note. 5/10

I hate when there is stuff that I can't read about in here.

Love me some good ol' loud rock. All the boomers on here just lost their hearing so they can't appriciate this. Borders on noise rock which even I can't listen too but overall it's great. Absolutely love it. Think the latter half of the album has more hits too. I thought that White Devil was the best off the record with the addition of the saxophone. That's a pure 10/10. Virgin Velcro and Kiss Like Lizards are two more stand out tracks but all 13 tracks are enjoyable to me. 4.5/5

A pretty good album, I liked Spike Island and White Devil the most.

Why is the mix quality on Spit On It so much worse than Up Against the Wall Motherfucker? Its quite a jarring jump from the first track to second. I like the attitude of this album. Fave Tracks: Up Against the Wall Motherfucker 3.9/5

Just really bland and dull Best Song: Spit On It Rating: 4/10 Stars: 2

Based on when this came out I'm sure I would have been *OK* with seeing this band open for someone I liked (At the Drive In maybe?) But, I wouldn't buy any merch or seek them out - unless they blew me away!! Even then that high of remembering how good they were live would only last about a dozen listens - MAX

Although it was loud it didn't really grab my attention, won't be returning to this one. Another random inclusion on the list.

Pretty solid album from a band I'd never heard of before. A bit too much "noise" for my taste to hold me through an entire album, but man, I've heard worse on this project. There's some nice fuzz and hard guitars. Penance Soiree gets better as it goes on. I was skeptical after the first couple tracks but the album ends strong. I added a couple bangers to a playlist. Standouts are "Getting Bright at Night" "Seasick" and "Party the Baby Off." A pretty decent 3/5 for me. Prooooobably won't check out any more of these guys, but definitely wouldn't turn away if I heard more.

A weak attempt to be like other bands with more talent.

meio pombo, meio qualquer coisa meh

This... isn't really for me. It's fine.

I dunno, this just sounds like an average rock album by an average rock band. Don't @ me, but I can't really hear the significance of it, I'm sorry to say. Meatmaker is kind of a different and interesting track, I guess.

Almost interesting, noisy, whiney....not for me, but better than Sonic Youth

Rate: 10/10.

Ушеразрывательно, но увлекательно

Holy Shit

Could not listen...

boring; sort of reminds me of geese tbh...

Finns inte på Spotify

por la portada me di cuenta que era un estilo de heavy metal. No me disgusta, pero prefiero algo más tranquilo.

No le presté la atención que debería, pero no me llamó especialmente la atención

This was cool - I appreciated the balance between a raw sound and a more polished sound.

New band and album for me, really great noise/garage/indie rock sound, love it, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

meh meh. like a boring nin or something.

It's okay.....

It is genuinely surprising to me when a post-2000 album by an American band pops up and I have never heard of the artist, but this is one such album. About halfway through the opening track, these guys sound to me like nearly all the other "hot" rock bands of circa 2004. The second track sounds like noise for noise's sake. This might have appealed to me more back in 2004, but as an old man this doesn't really do anything for me. On track 6 ("Kiss Like Lizards") I noticed a headache coming on that I am pretty sure is caused by this music. I didn't really like this at all but it feels more like 2 stars than 1.

Noisy but listenable. Pretty enjoyable. Breath of less polluted air after out of step.

This album was very 'Mechanical Animals'-era Marilyn Manson with a hint of Queens of the Stone Age. I hadn't heard of them before and enjoyed this morning's listen!

Oh my {edge}lordy! I actually didn't mind it, felt a bit like if Marilyn Manson joined The White Stripes?

Will listen again

Never have heard of The Icarus Line. If there was a 3.5 I’d give it. Definitely intrigued , didn’t want to get over my skies but loved what I heard. Need a couple more listens

No private session used for Spotify. This is straightforward rock, absolutely nothing stands out about it. Why it made it this list makes me question this entire endeavor.

Wasn’t too keen on this. Sounds like so many other bands from around that time.

Too noisy

Just sounds like a worse version of better bands, and it’s overlong. Noise noise noise with nothing interesting going on. Melts together into a grey bore. Hard to believe they’re not on this list because the lead singer looked and dressed like a young Nick Cave and we know the guy who made this list has a boner for anything Nick Cave lol

listening to half-hit wonders that nobody's ever talked about again, that is truly the penance soiree for us millennials

Remember after Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater was an outsized hit, companies were scrambling to get a share of the extreme sports dollar? And there were all those off brand skateboarding games? If you told me this album was joint-released as the soundtrack to like Danny Way’s Sk8 Quest or something, I would believe you.

More musically interesting than the typical hipster slag.