1989 by Taylor Swift

1989

Taylor Swift

3.25
Rating
25904
Votes
1
10%
2
16%
3
30%
4
28%
5
16%
Distribution

Reviews (page 5 of 12)

I am not a fan of Taylor Swift. I do not like thinking or hearing about her or her music. And I feel like I have to explain this every time I say something like that: it's not because I dislike her as a person, or as an artist, or even as a celebrity. Sure, I'll razz her for how much she just loves to use her private plane, but it's not like I have much reason to make a big deal out of it. I would've had one when I was younger, however. When I was younger, I very, very much disliked Taylor Swift. It's possible I even hated her, though I think even then I would've thought "hate" was a strong word. Back in 2014 or whenever, I had the same problems with her that everyone else did: she dated a lot of men and wrote songs about 'em. Somehow, I'd bought into the line that it was somehow a bad thing that she wrote about her relationships — as if musicians haven't been doing exactly that sort of thing for years. It was obviously just a lot of celebrity tabloid nonsense, and back when I was a lot more openly emotional (aka: angry) this kind of stuff somehow mattered to me. At some point not too many years later, I realized none of this mattered and I shouldn't give a shit. That would've been the end of it, too, if Taylor Swift hadn't dropped REPUTATION not too long after and decided that everybody should care a **lot** about her personal life and celebrity tabloid nonsense. And besides a brief period during the COVID lockdown when she recorded her "more" albums, that sort of thing has basically been all she's written about ever since. Between that and the "(Taylor's Version)" re-recordings and the Eras Tour, her brand since REPUTATION has basically been just "ME!" And none of that should matter to me. I don't care about what goes on in the personal lives of celebrities unless it's some real egregious shit; if Taylor Swift wants to have her albums be "lore drops," ala the stuff on THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT, how does that affect me? But that's where we get to the thing that actually causes me to struggle with Taylor. In a word, it's overexposure. When Taylor embarked on her Eras Tour a while back, she quickly became perhaps the single most famous person on Earth. It felt like I couldn't go anywhere without hearing about her or how damn successful the tour was. Every day: "the Eras Tour is a nation unto itself! It's pulled in so much money, it has its own GDP! It's the most successful tour EVER!!" And it bothered me to walk through the Walmart where I worked and see so many damn books and magazines about her and how **just absolutely wonderful** she was. It felt like all of this shit was being forced upon me and it just really turned me off of her and her music. What's funny about that is that, honestly, if it weren't for this extreme level of overexposure, I figure I might honestly listen to her music more. I wouldn't call myself a super fan or anything, but I could see myself working some of her songs into regular rotation (besides Weird Al parodies and DragonForce covers, anyway). Earlier this year, I watched (the super extended edit of) the Eras Tour concert film ahead of a podcast I like covering it, and besides getting burned out by its length, it pretty much confirmed my thought. So, hey, maybe finally listening to an album of hers will further convince me...? Here's the problem off the very top. If we'd gotten the "more" album that's on here, that'd be one thing. If any of her earlier, country albums were on here, that'd be another thing. Heck, if RED was on here... But of course, **OF COURSE** the one we got was 1989. Of course we got the one released at the height of my Taylor Swift hatedom — the one where everything started going wrong for her music, as far as I can tell. The way I've been seeing it 'til now, if she didn't make the full leap to pop on here, and if it weren't for shit like "Shake It Off", REPUTATION wouldn't have happened, and I wouldn't have spent the next near-decade getting so exhausted. I have to admit, I was kind of dreading getting this album (as much as you **can** dread getting an album, anyway). But, I should give this thing a fair chance. After all, I know there's some damn good songs on here ("Style" and "Wildest Dreams"), so it can't be **all** bad. And, hey, maybe after 800-some words of preamble I should finally get the dang album already, eh? So, did it convince me? Uhm... Maybe a little? But not enough to actually go over the cliff and actually incorporate more Taylor into my listening rotation. 1989 is the kind of album where I feel like I can blame any lack of enthusiasm on it for two reasons. First, this thing has probably had a **massive** impact on pop music that I'm just not even aware of because I didn't listen to this thing at the time. For the longest time I assumed this album was on this list solely because it was "the one where Taylor went pop," and I pre-emptively dismissed it for that, but modern pop stars are probably still building on the framework this thing laid down. If I'm going "Eh, is it really that special?", it might probably be just because Chappel Roan and Sabrina Carpenter and so many people between them and this album have been playing from out of this thing's book. And after that, secondly, there's Taylor's **own** building on this sound. You can trace the "generic Taylor Swift sound" (aka Gracie Abrams) to this exact album, with the scattered fast-spoken-kinda-sung parts and everything. It's the kind of sound we'd go on to hear on LOVER and MIDNIGHTS and all of the billion deluxe editions of THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT... And, look, I'm no stranger to loving a band or artist for having one sound. It's exactly why I like bands like AC/DC, the Ramones and Motörhead. But I guess when you put it together with the kind of baggage I have with Taylor, it can be difficult to just enjoy it on its own without thinking of my frustrations. I mean, I do wonder what this music would sound like to me if I had no idea who she was. Listening through this album, I wasn't able to not think she wasn't just thinking about herself, which is a self-indulgence I've grown to loathe on more recent albums. But imagine how this stuff would sound if I didn't hafta understand it through the lens of Taylor "Me" Swift and instead could just take it as a bunch of character songs. Y'know, like how I've heard the "more" albums play out. I think it'd go two ways. For some songs, the outside context really helps things. "Blank Space" is a song that gets a lot of its appeal for being a reaction to the people who accused her of dating too much. It was her first "Yeah, maybe I **am** a bad guy" song, and it plays way better here than any of her attempts to do that on REPUTATION. Heck, I remember even back in 2014 I was listening to Todd In The Shadows reviewing this song and thinking to myself, "Yeah, this is all fair — get their asses!" I don't think it's a spectacular song in total, but, yeah, I can say I enjoyed it. Then there's the other side of the coin, "Shake It Off". This is a song where, for me at least, knowing anything about Taylor Swift makes it utterly obnoxious. Seriously, to this day it's my least favorite song she's ever done, and all because she's **FUCKIN' LYIN'** on this song. "I'm just gonna shake it off?" A song called "Look What You Made Me Do" would say otherwise! So would "You Need To Calm Down" and whatever equivalents MIDNIGHTS and THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT have. It's only gotten worse with age, because it's always felt to me like a big, forced smile and like she's rubbing it in my face how much she **TOTALLY DOESN'T CARE** when she plainly and obviously actually does. You wouldn't make such a point to tell me you didn't care if you did. At least the detached "Damn, it's 7AM" thing "You Need To Calm Down" scans a lot better, even if it has its own issue of "Me! And gay people, I guess — but mostly: me!" To be 100%, I skipped this song on my listen-through. I was willing to put up with "Bad Blood", one of her other worst songs ever, but not "Shake It Off". Consider **that**, eh? Still, combined they both drag this album down a point or so. No great album would have songs like **this**, in my mind. And I wouldn't even say it's that great of an album, anyway. It's absolutely not bad, and most everyone giving this thing a 1 are likely mostly just mad Taylor's on here at all. But, I'unno. The sound of this album can work in places, but it's just not one I'm all too into. I never wished for it to end like I have with some albums, but by the time this thing ended, I felt like the only reaction I could really have was a light "Yep. That's a pop album alright." And that's even with the excuses for this thing I listed above. And I know it's not because I'm a rock supremacist, or (if we wanna jump to a more extreme accusation) that I just don't like female pop stars or anything. I own Lady Gaga's ARTPOP, for goodness sake. It's just... Not my kind of pop. Not the kind I enjoy. My tastes typically skew a lot older or just weirder, and this... Well, just doesn't do it for me too much. "Style" **is** incredible, though. Lemme just take a paragraph out to say that "Style" is the best song on the album, bar none. If I were to work anything I heard here into my regular rotation, it'd be that. So 1989 wasn't as painful as I thought it'd be. It had its highs, and its lows (and even lowers), and in the end... I'm fine with it. It sure as heck hasn't convinced me I need to go listen to her stuff past this point (except maybe the "more" albums; we'll see when EVERMORE pops up), but maybe I might look into the earlier ones? But if nothing else, it proved my thesis at least a little: I **would** like more Taylor Swift music if I wasn't just so overwhelmed by her everything. I mean, give me some time. Let the hype and the Era Tour and the (Taylor's Version)s and everything fade away. Once she's no longer the single most popular artist in the universe... Yeah, I'll probably dig her. In any case, until then, please do not kill me, any Swifties who happen upon this. I am scared to death of you people and I'll fold like a house of cards if you come steppin' to me, so... Just be gentle, OK? Please?

This is a good album, but the overexposure of the singles has given me some major burnout from this track list. 3.5 bumped down to 3.

I’m unabashedly at a 5. Haters gonna hate, hate, hate and all that. Here’s a quick story: the first time I ever heard “Shake It Off” was at a high school pep rally in 2014. I thought it was a little cheesy, & I didn’t know who was singing it. It was catchy as hell though, and the chorus got stuck in my ear. Once I got home, I googled it. Imagine my surprise to find out it was Taylor Swift, the country artist, and it was THE biggest song in the world at the time. As a 14-year-old boy, I fell victim to the classic “this is popular, so I’m going to hate it” trope, and I… was wrong. I was very, very wrong. Someone wanting to demean the type of women who listen to & enjoy Taylor Swift might write something along the lines of the following: “these are songs made for the Grey’s Anatomy-loving / idealized love & empathy generation of women who grew up with The Notebook as their favorite movie, a pink DS to play Nintendogs on, and who would swear by scrolling through Pinterest & writing down every thought they have in the Notes app as self-therapy.” Of course, tell this to any woman who actually enjoys Taylor Swift and they’d probably take it as a massive compliment. That’s modern-day girlhood for you. I wouldn’t have written something like this in 2014, but as far as my mindset back then goes, I probably was doing some kind of subconscious celebrity-driven misogyny (or just the whole “eww cooties” thing taken to a natural, if really flawed conclusion). I came to the realization that I was wrong in 2021, as a 21-year-old man, when Taylor Swift started to drop her re-recordings of all her albums in light of the ownership situation, giving me an excuse to actually listen to all of these tracks that I thought all of my girl friends (*please* note the space) had been overhyping for years, with a decently fresh mind, a good bit of empathy, and the realization that I was never going to stop the train, so I may as well take a ride on it, just for fun. Of course, I proved myself to be a moron, as one does with this sort of thing. They were all right, to some degree, and I found myself enjoying her stuff far more than I did from just hearing it in passing on nearly every commercial or radio station for years. Granted, I still think “Red” is a *really* mediocre (if not outright bad) album, but hey; I also think “Fearless” & “Speak Now” are *really* good, so it weighs out. When the “1989” re-recording came out in late 2023 (66 days before starting this 1001 Albums project), I gave it a listen, and a weird wave of nostalgia came over me, with every song feeling familiar, but only just now coming into full focus. I had forgotten just how many monster hits were on this thing; you would think “Shake It Off” would obviously be the biggest one, but “Blank Space” has more plays than it on Spotify (2.1 billion), and 4 of the tracks have at least a billion plays. I haven’t heard the album in full since then, but hearing it again now, with 588 albums across several decades & styles inbetween to sharpen & hone my musical tastes… yeah, this one’s still really fucking good too. I listened to the original version this time, since she got her ownership back, and let me tell you; it blows the re-recording out of the water. Good to finally hear this thing as it was intended. Taylor Swift is a good, if not great (albeit really self-indulgent to an annoying point as of late) songwriter, with her biggest strength being able to find one or two cutting lines that can immediately capture the modus operandi of a song through some striking imagery. Whether or not you agree or care about that modus operandi is another thing, but regardless, her lyricism comes out really well on this album, especially so on “Clean”, but every track has a gem of a line somewhere in it. Her production team on this (especially Max Martin, arguably hitting a peak) knock it out of the park with this sort of hybrid mix of an 80s new wave style with the production tricks & heavy synth work of the early 2010s, and while it’s certainly dated to 11 years ago, it’s the sort of soundscape where if you like it, you’ll really like it, and it clicked very nicely for me this time around. Some people would call this album a pop Bible, and while I disagree (it’s “Thriller.” “Thriller” is the pop Bible.), I won’t dissuade people from having that take at all, since this is probably one of the most influential pop albums of the decade. Much like Frank Ocean’s “channel ORANGE”, this album’s success & all the artists it inspired has opened up a Pandora’s Box of sorts. However, I think that Pandora’s Box has finally started to pay off – the new “big 3” of Olivia Rodrigo, Chappell Roan & Sabrina Carpenter (Billie Eilish is in there somewhere, trust me, she’s just not fully “pop music” to my ears) are a direct product of the wave that Taylor Swift started with this album, and they’re all expanding on it in a way that feels like a proper renaissance of radio pop music after it got really stagnant around mid 2019 into early 2021. I’m not saying we should thank Taylor Swift for their success, but I don’t know if we get to this point without this album. I’ve done all this yapping without talking much about the album itself, but it should be obvious that I enjoyed the hell out of it. I’ve come away from this with arguably an even greater appreciation for it, now having a much better sense of the styles she & her team were pulling from throughout this album, and with how well-crafted of an homage it all is. Yes, its commercialism can be used as a knock against it, and you could just as easily call it “corporate, overproduced nonsense that loses the soul of what makes music music”. I wouldn’t hate on anybody for that take, but it’s probably just a cycle that’s been perpetuated for years. I’d bet a dollar someone called “Thriller” overproduced nonsense compared to the heart shown by the Rolling Stones, or “Abbey Road” as such compared to the “true” musicianship of Aretha Franklin, or hell, Beethoven’s 9th Symphony compared to the earliest attempts at orchestral work. Musical tastes are constant & ever evolving, much like mine were between 2014 and 2021, and especially so since I’ve started this whole 1001 Albums project. All of this bullshit rambling preamble aside, I've grown to fucking love this album. If you can allow yourself to let loose and open up your mind for just 49 minutes (or 60 minutes via the deluxe), what emerges is a tightly crafted, well-written, well-composed & well-sung pop album that stands up with (and next to) some of the best of its genre, full of monster hits, which has probably shaped an entire generation, for better or for worse. It is probably the best Taylor Swift album, and it’s her at her pop peak. I know one of her COVID-era albums is on the list, and I’ve never heard that one before, so I’ll be ready when we get that one, but as far as "1989" goes, it’s an easy 5. By the way, did I mention that I'm older now than Taylor Swift was when she recorded this album? Yeah, she did this album when she was 24. I'm cooked.

Wasn't bad

Favorite Track: Out of the Woods

An entire album of overplayed earworms I’ve heard too many times to count already.

For sure an album of all time

Oh boy, take 2…I’m going to stick to my cranky old man policy and keep ignoring Ms.Swift. I am happy not knowing a single song of hers. Could be the greatest album ever and I’d still pass. She gets 2 stars for her celebrity.

this is probably her worst album but it's still too scientifically engineered to be enjoyable to call it "bad" per se. a 1/5 as a taylor album but perfectly acceptable in the grand scheme of things

Me suena a plástico.

Blank Space. Essa é boa, viu?

I was a fan of Taylor Swift's songwriting before this album. 1989 made me a full-on Taylor fan. I have complex feelings and opinions about T-Swizzle, but generally I think she is the among the best songwriters of her generation and I admire her for standing up against corporate greed in the music industry via her fight to reclaim the master recordings to her first six albums. A fight that she ultimately won in such a big way that it has literally changed the way the music industry works. Anyway, this record is full of bangers. Banger after banger after banger. It is an album that gave Taylor the confidence to become the cultural icon she was meant to be, for better or worse.

I've heard this album many times because my girlfriend is a huge fan. It's alright, a lot of catchy beats and nice vocal arrangements. I wouldn't go out of my way to listen to it just because I heard it somewhat often in my life. It's not something that I would put on but I don't hate it either.

Basic is what comes to mind

servicable pop music

As to expect from Swift, great songwriting and catchy songs. The so-called “Pop Bible” is a no-skip album to me. Altough it is very mainstream, making good pop music is also a craft to appreciate. The singles “Style”, “Blank Space” and “Shake it Off” are known worldwide, but the album has way more to offer. One of my favourite songs off the album - “Clean”, really showcases her ability of writing relatable but also profound. Even Imogen Heap, who worked alongside Taylor on the track, was surprised at her songwriting skills. Altough Taylor is one of the most famous musicians on earth right now, her talent is overlooked most of the time. I also really like “You Are in Love”, which describes the relationship of her producer and friend, Jack Antonoff and his former girlfriend. With its memorable bridges and phrases, 1989 remains one of the best pop albums off modern history. Really enjoyed revisiting this record.

Awesome album

Get over him girl

This album starts off strong with some uplifting tracks but soon melds into one ongoing synth with little differentiation. Did I enjoy it? Yes. Did I think it was just generic music to slowly sway to? Also yes. I didn't get a story, and I didn't get the heartbreak that everybody else did.

-this was one of the first albums i owned as a kid. soooo many great and iconic songs, probably Taylor’s most fun and listenable album imo -there are a few parts that are. very corny and rough. my god the Shake It Off rap verse. but i think it’s an overwhelmingly solid record and one of the most important pop albums of the 2010s -Favorites are Style, Out Of The Woods, and All You Had To Do Was Stay

Shake it off slaps

This is a pop record. It is as good and bad as every other standard pop record. There are a few great songs and lots of mid. If I was a teenage girl in 2015 going through a breakup I would connect to this album more. Fortunately, I am not.

Extremely mediocre and repetitive. I had heard these songs many times before and didn't realize that it was Taylor Swift. Also, there's like one theme in this album and it's "I'm too crazy for this world and that's why you can't love me." Well maybe do something about it then. This falls into my genre of people like this to fit in as opposed to actually liking it, just like the Grateful Dead currently. Just have the community and drop the cult of personality. This is a lot of sophomore year drama that really only exists because people watch too much reality TV and think it's normal to always be in an argument whereas that's extremely aberrant behavior. Just exist, be thankful for what you have, love each other, and be happy.

I was quite impressed by this album, it’s a pretty good pop record to be honest. I’d listened through the Taylor’s version before which now having heard the original, the original is much better. I don’t really need all the bonus tracks and frankly I prefer the older albums production as well.

So many songs I know. At this point I can’t tell if it’s a great album or I’m just losing it

for the meme of it

So, I listened. I knew like half of these songs already? Overall, cringe songwriting and the music sounds like it should be left in 2014 forever. This is the downfall of decent pop. Shake It Off and Bad Blood are not that bad.

Een aantal nummers zijn geschreven door Max Martin, de Zweedse pop producer, dus was dit ideaal om eens op te leggen tijdens mijn reis naar Zweden. Misschien dat ik de Swiftie hype beter begrijp na een volledig album te beluisteren, maar helaas. I'll never be a Swiftie 1.5/5

I can't say I've ever sat down and listened to a full Taylor Swift album. Partly because of my age, gender and taste in music. However, I was surprised how many songs I recognised. She's popular. For someone who has been accused (on many occasions) of being an uptight music snob, I've never really had a problem with her. She produces (writes as well?) catchy music. She appears to have ditched the country sound I recall she came onto the scene with. Anyway, the album. 1989 starts with an MC-808 beat and a song about New York. I'm sure there's a reason she started it this way, but there wasn't anything particularly inspiring about one of the world's most sung about cities. It's been done, love. It's been done. However, as the tracks went on, I actually didn't mind it. She knows how to write a good melody ('Bad Blood', 'Shake it Off' and 'Out of the Woods'). While the lyrics didn't particularly hit home for me, I could pick up on the vibe she was trying to give. I read a little about the album in an incredibly expansive Wikipedia article and nodded along when it go to section where it talked about synth pop. I've decided that my song I'm going to add to my playlist is 'Blank Space', upon second listen I realised I was listening more intently to the lyrics and enjoying the melodies more than yesterday (when I wrote most of this review). I'm sure it's a hit, but I'd not heard it before. In fact, the second listen found me enjoying the melodies more and more. Taylor Swift (and I'm sure a series of writers/producers) can write a catchy song. I understand why she's so popular. So, in summary, I didn't hate it. I'd even perhaps admit to others that I kind of liked it. Perhaps. 3 Stars.

This album is like you’ve just ended a toxic relationship with a girl who was a bad influence, dragging you into a damaging lifestyle of excess. You’ve woken up feeling like a new man, you’re here to live clean, and you’re maintaining a positive outlook on the world. You’ll never forget where you’ve come from, but you’re more focussed on where you are going.

Has some great tunes and you can see why it was such a hit. Bit also, so filler tracks that you'll want to skip

Has the hits. Is adored but don’t think ground breaking. Folklore is a better album

But why?

Taylor jumps into pop music and drops the country. I do not like Shake it off, "getting down to this sick beat" While playing the least interesting part of the song grates the song overall. Maybe the starter of releasing not the strongest song as first single of TS projects Bad blood OG without Kendrick is good. But the remix was better. It takes guts to jump music generes when you are the best at your own, I give kuddos for that, but this album is way overhyped IMO 3/5

7/10 girl you are not a vibe

A lot of hits. Extremely catchy and very well produced album

I really like Taylor. Like all artists I don't like every song, however she does have a very unique voice and style. When you hear her music it is not usually a remake of another artist's work; she writes.

Sorry Swifties. This isn't my thing at all. I've heard worse but this wasn't made for schlubs like me.

I understand why this album is on here, but I did not need to listen to it before I died. The only thing the songs have going for them is that they’re catchy - and all the catchiest songs I’ve already heard over and over on the radio. I should admit that I’m not really a pop person so I’m definitely not the target audience. I found the synths and drum tracks cheesy. I’m sure she can sing but they’ve done so much to her vocals it’s like they don’t think she can. The whole thing seemed overproduced. Didn’t feel like a single real emotion in the whole album. I’m not giving it a 1 because I will absolutely sing along to the catchy ones. I just don’t think being catchy is the same as being good. Fav song: Blank Space Least fav: How You Get The Girl

Iconic I’ll give it that. But sometimes it feels very generic. I know it’s about the music more than the lyrics but I made the mistake of listening to bad blood too closely and it’s just so vague. Maybe I’m too harsh. Specific rating -3.8 Fav song- blank space Least fav- bad blood

I can't even lie, love taylor, but I am not a 1989 girlie

It’s not my favourite Taylor swift album- I don’t think the lyrics are quite at the level some of her other albums reach. That being said it is banger after banger- I found picking favourite/least very difficult cause almost any song on this album could be my favourite on any given day. Favourite song: Out of The Woods (or Is It Over Now? if we include bonus/vault songs) Least: All You Had To Do Was Stay

I tried, listened to the whole thing. I appreciate musical talent and songwriting prowess ecc but if I never hear a TS song again it will be too soon - girly bubblegum pop noooot my thing ICK.

This is better than expected. I can see how it taps into an empowering perspective for young women.

I once lost an argument comparing Bob Dylan to Paul Westerberg. They are in fact not on the same level. The Replacements leader captures nostalgia for a specific moment of doubt and change and uncertainty that we all navigate. Bob writes about something unknown and it somehow becomes universal. That same person years later presented my argument back to me on the form of Taylor Swift. At the time I didn't "understand" TS. Not that I do now but I recognize game. And I can't ever know what it's like to be a a xten year old girl - I do know what it's like to hear Sixteen Blue as a teenager. And I know how great it feels to return to that moment - for only a moment - through a 4 minute pop song. And that is how music transcends - 4 minutes at a time. This song a a greatest hits album for most people. It's the moment Taylor Swift became Taylor. Even I can pick up what she's throwing down.

Those spice-less food memes sure are accurate. It is extremely unfair that other "Pop" artists and projects fall into the same category as her. And I'm not even talking about 70's pioneers or 80's kings or queens of the genre, but contemporary acts that get a minuscule percentage of the attention that she gets...

Awesome, largely mellow album, full of pop hits. Simple, clean music.

Ladies and gentlemen this album IS season 3 of your favourite young adult series

Carefully crafted pop, with a human feel, especially joyful on Shake It Off

Okay so yes the lyrics are vacuous and I’m not really into the valorization of the female fuckboy thing, but finally listening to this helped me understand her superstardom better. It’s fun!

83% Best: Blank Space; All You Had To Do Was Stay; Bad Blood; I Know Places; Clean Must-Hear? Sure

Great album! Catchy music!

this album is very entry level for the genre, very easy to get into it because of the recognizability of the tracks, i enjoy a lot of the songs because i think they’re fairly catchy, i think it’s an important album for modern pop as well, great listen

Always wondered why people go on about Taylor Swift so much. And now I know 😊

Some great hits and fun melodies but let down by the lyrics, which get a little self-pitying. FS: Blank Space

A wise woman once said, "we are all Swifties". On some levels, I see truth to this philosophy - the hits are HITS. Blank space, shake it off and style are pop perfection. That said, I'm afraid for me the rest of the album is overhyped. I hated the opening track and found a lot of the lyrics blood curdlingly earnest. Perhaps it is because I am British. Also, every time I hear Taylor Swift say "you should have been getting down to this sick beat!" my skin crawls. It wasn't even a sick beat!

Masterstroke pop transition. Tight fucking hooks and breakdowns with soaring background vocals. I am particularly partial to the "boys only want love if its torture" bit. She is definitely singing "lonely starbucks lovers" and not "long list of ex lovers." Can't fool me.

Weeellll no soi fan pero esta bien

So this really isn’t my thing but I am guilty of saying that I’ve both listened to and enjoyed this before the list brought it up… I’m definitely not who this is written for, but it’s unmistakably good pop songs. I’m not sure there’s much more to add. Its like a Greggs Chicken and Bacon baguette. There’s nothing more you really need to say about it. It is what it is. A nice sandwich for the masses. It’s no where near as good as Folklore / Evermore, but they are totally different styles. Probably more my cuppa tea. But I’m not gonna whack on Folklore to make up dance moves with my daughter, that’s what this record is for. And not to pour scorn on the equivalent mega pop stars I grew up with in the 90s, this is MILES better musically than say Britney Spears, Steps, Spice Girls, etc. Pop music has come a long way!

This is the big Swift album I guess, most of the songs I know were on here I think. Though they are pretty much all big at this point. Being called 1989 when the first riff kicked in I expected it to really lean in to 80s pop and after that it didn't really, maybe she was born in 1989? Of the tracks I didn't know welcome to new York was the best. Taylor Swift is definitely the best of this sort of pop but the tracks without a hook are a bit washy and lyrically its a bit too relentlessly about relationships failing meaningfully.

Quite the pleasant suprise. Shake It Off, Blank Space, Out of the Woods, and Bad Blood are solid, and great examples of the genre. I could have sworn these were more recently originally released than 2014 - so fairly enduring. Welcome to New York was alright too. The production was good too, refreshing and not overly complex. It is funny how much I fairly genuinely enjoyed this album, and disliked Evermore. This one was good enough for me to listen to the re-recorded Taylor's version. Didn't notice any differences. By then, I'd had my fill though. I know you should write about your life experiences, yada yada, but I think here she managed to also capture a sense of fun and irony with (a majority) of her lyrics. Perhaps unlike some of her other stuff, which is fairly maudlin, pedestrian, and lacking some self-awareness.

I enjoyed the previous "evermore" Taylor swift album we had on the list, so was willing to go into this with an open mind. I was pretty surprised by how many songs I recognised, but I don't really like any of them! It's so teenage girl pop. I'm definitely not the target demographic. I kept checking to see how long was left. All signs of a 1 for me. Sorry Taylor, I do think she can write, which is more than a lot of her contemporaries can say, but this album just ain't for me. I'll stick with evermore 1

We love her.

imagine dragons for girls

Blank Space Style Shake It Off Bad Blood

Not much for pop, but Tay Tay I do like. She’s a true songwriter and performer. This album has some classic pop writing. Good wholesome fun

Meh, some songs were B from the Ps but it just sounded like a very long jcpenney ad

T swizzle is the shizzle. I stole my sister's vinyl copy of this album to listen to it. Best grindcore album, second only to Pig Destroyer's 2004 masterpiece, "Terrifyer". The album Terrifyer is widely regarded to be the best grindcore album of all time, for obvious reason. 1989 was good grindcore too, but I would've liked more breakdowns and guitar solos. Also their blastbeats seemed a little lacking. Still waiting on Terrifyer (Scott Hull's version) btw.

Could give a shit

Some of this is decent, good even, but the vast majority is just modern pop drivel.

Best Song: Out Of The Woods. I like the layered rhythms and the driving chorus, but I think the writing in this song is the best on the album, from even just a purely aesthetic view. The staccato feeling of "are we out of the woods"and "are we in the clear yet" really gives a feeling of running and driving purpose. Worst Song: Bad Blood. I really dislike the chorus, especially how it sounds like it was designed to be sung by a crowd and therefore can't stand up on its own merits. Overall: A very solid pop album, although it does feel like a mix of megahits and forgettable tracks. Lyrically and tonally it is pretty one-note, but it does that note pretty well.

I wasn't looking forward to this and, while I wouldn't go out of my way to listen to it again, 1989 wasn't as bad as I thought. I listened to the Taylor's version of the album as I do respect Taylor thumbing her nose at a controlling record company. I was going to complain about it being overlong, but the original was nearly 30 minutes shorter, so I won't. Ironically, the only song I would like to hear again aside from Shake It Off - which was good fun, is only on Taylor's Version - New Romantics. Overall though, most of the album is just generic, mass market, pop that I feel I could get from anywhere.

I tried to listen to this with an open mind. I get that it's probably better than your average pop album made by a former Nickolodean kids star, but at the end of the day, it's still a pop album made by someone who might as well be a Nickelodeon kids star. Plus, she's a Florida Panthers fan, and that is unforgiveable.

One of my preferred Taylor albums

This is a turn I didn’t expect

is great pop album 5/5

Catchy boppy pop. Not for me.

Best. Album 💗

Better than I expected but still not a Swiftie

This album is incredibly catchy all the way through. I'm really enjoying the non-singles much more than the tracks that were singles, but there's a number of songs I can see myself going back to again and again. Best of the singles for me are probably Style and Bad Blood. Having never listened to the album itself it's much better than I had been anticipating. I think this gets a 5 from me. Haha, the Jack Antonoff-produced tracks practically struck me in the face with their Jack Antonoff-ness. But I did like them. Standout non-singles. Out of the Woods and I Wish You Would.

I’ve heard this album a few times. It’s got that 80’s feel to it. Even the vault songs are good. Best songs are “Shake it Off, Style, Blank Space, and Clean. 1001 album worthy: yes 98/179

First, and foremost, billionaires are inherently unethical, and Taylor Swift is a billionaire. I realize she was far from billionaire status when this album was released, but nevertheless, it needs to be taken into consideration. With that being said, she's clearly not as bad as most billionaires. Now, Swift is the most polarizing musician in the United States Of America. If it's not her misogynistic haters who get a boner listening to Morgan Wallen, it's her cult of Swifties who would have you convinced her diarrhea tastes better than pizza. It's very hard to have any views on here that fits in between these two, but I'm here to let you all know I fall into this (ever) so shrinking demographic. What we have on this album is some great Pop songs which have endured more than a decade. Some of you won't admit it, but you'll catch yourself singing the chorus of these songs to yourself. Thankfully, Swift, at the very least, ditched her Country Music career. Favorite Track: "Shake It Off".

I forgot how insanely catchy this album is. The fact that I was able to sing along in some capacity to every single track came as a shock, but in retrospect is completely unsurprising given how often I used to listen to it. Catchy lyrics and an easy to listen to sound are two of the things that Taylor does very well. I do feel as if it generally lacks the depth I often look for in the music I listen to, but I’m willing to overlook it due to how /fun/ it all is. However, due to how catchy the lyrics are they did have a tendency to start to grate on me a little bit towards the end of each track, and while I was generally able to overlook how corny they are, in certain tracks such as Bad Blood it was particularly apparent. Overall, while I will not pretend this album is some sort of lyrical or musical masterpiece, it’s very good at being what it is: a fun collection of catchy pop music. Favourite track: I Wish You Would

Lots of her most iconic songs that are wide enough in appeal to say even less than just silence. For being so lyrically focused, the emotional content seems to be as dense as a walmart valentines day card. Lots of focus on decentralized general want, revolving around simple wishes of keeping a romantic connection, although the order and arrangement of the songs does not suggest any conscious consideration on her part. "This love is good/This love is bad" Given the level of the popularity of this album it makes sense to have on this list, now I can be an educated hater.

Favorite song: Wonderland (on DLX) and Out of the Woods Nostalgia. It's fine. It's better than a basic corporate pop album but it's not fantastic. It was perfect when I was 7 and I still know all the lyrics to most of the songs but outside of that context it's just classic Taylor Swift. Bad blood has a really good music video, it's just really fun and Kendrick's verse is still good. Wildest dreams can burn and die. I really don't like 'How you get the girl's it feels too corporate pop. The ending to 'I know places' feels very anticlimactic and like it doesn't quite fit the vibe of the end of the song. By the end I was just tired of it.

Good pop songs about bad break-ups

THE GUITAR BUILDUP TO STYLE UGH Probably my 3rd favorite T Swift album. Fun, loud, has a big sound to it that almost feels like NYC in an album

Always love Taylor!

Catchy tunes, but this is fluff from a narcissist.

I own this one… sorta. The first time I heard these songs, it was courtesy of Ryan Adams, who covered the album in its entirety. And it’s great! The arrangements were vastly altered, and while the brainless Swifties were quick to condemn his work, Taylor herself heaped high praise. It had surprised me that he described her album as “perfect”, and given his popularity at the time, that is a bucket of respect. Since then, he’s been Me-Too’d, and who now gives a fuck what he thinks? Me. I still listen to his album on regular. First time I’ve sat thru this version. It’s good, and she’s a great lyricist. Not sure what’s all the hubbub about her, why the vitriol and social media madness. To hell with all that. I hope she keeps kicking ass!

First time I’ve listened to an entire Taylor Swift album, although I’ve heard plenty of her songs. It’s a fairly well done album full of pop nuggets. It was a fun listen.

personne ne m'avais jamais dit que taylor swift c'etait aussi bien !!

Average songs that are over produced.

Surprisingly enjoyable. A well crafted album, mixing the crowd pleasers with some slower tempo songs

Blinding headache after 3 tracks. Felt like I was stuck in a shopping mall.

Perfect poptimism, Taylors lyrics, Antonoffs production. Tay Tay at the top of her game.

Was surprised by this. Pop music bangers. Not really my thing but the quality is undeniable

Perfectly palatable pop. Similar to La Roux or Chvrches from the same period.

Why is this even on here?

Despite all the metal and hip-hop I enjoy, I have to admit I do like Taylor Swift a lot (currently wearing my favorite T-Swift muscle shirt). And for a while, 1989 was my favorite record from her (eventually dethroned by Folklore). After a re-listen today (Taylor's version, obviously), I'd say that opinion still holds up. In fact, the entire album up through "Wildest Dreams" is pretty much some of her best work to date. "Out Of The Woods" and "All You Had To Do Was Stay" are two of my favorite TS songs ever. And the singles "Blank Space" and "Shake It Off" were worldwide hits for a good reason. On this record, it felt like Taylor found a magical balance between catchy songwriting and her signature narrative lyricism that would continue through her discography to this day. The biggest complaint I have about this album is, like most TS albums, it runs a little long. There are definitely a few tracks that could be cut from the tracklist, especially "This Love." It is far and away one of the most inane songs she's ever written. The lyrics are atrocious, the song is boring, and I skip it every time. But I bet there are a ton of fans out there who would consider it their favorite, and that's the fun thing about music.

PRE-LISTENING: This will be the second time I have listened to a Taylor Swift album. I listened to one of them a few years ago the day it came out (Google tells me it was called Midnights.) I have also heard at least some (maybe all) of Ryan Adams' version of this album. Here goes! LISTENING: Catchy, I get it, it's just not for me. My wallet and I are grateful that I basically missed this phenomenon with Maggie. Enjoyed it more than Supertramp though.

I really like a lot of this, but I have the same issue with this as most of her albums. The songs start all sounding the same and blend together. I might get to 4.5, but the engineering/producing keeps it at 4.

J - 3/5 Best Track - "Bad Blood" F - 3/5

I don't see how Taylor Swift ever became popular or how millions of people unironically like her music. The lyrics are uninspired and basically every song has the exact same music on top of her annoying, shrill voice. I completely understand why this album is on the list, being one of the most influential albums and artists of the 2010s (if not the most), but how Taylor Swift became this influential and loved is beyond me. It's deeply disappointing that nowadays there is a set formula you can follow (chord progressions, melodies, etc) to have your music noticed, and the fact that many artists follow this formula for every single song they make shows that they don't really care about making good music or new music, or authenticity, but they just want to get rich & famous as quickly as they can. It's a relief, of course, to see modern artists that don't follow the same formula for every song, and there are plenty of those, mostly towards the rap side of popular music, but back before my time, every artist would pour their heart and soul into everything they made. Taylor Swift, on the other hand, doesn't even write her own lyrics. It took a team of Hollywood writers to write all the lyrics, another team of musicologists and actual musicians to write the instrumentals and make them using a computer program, and another team of sound engineers to expertly autotune and basically curate Taylor Swift's voice, all to create a generic, boring song whose entire purpose is to get stuck in everyone's heads for a week and then be forgotten. It took one man to write Bohemian Rhapsody (and another 3 to perform it, I'll give her that), in all its complexity and grandeur, and it still survives as a well-known and well-loved song 50 years later. If you can't even make your voice sound good with autotune and a million filters, it's time to switch to playing bass.

Before you come to me and says "no i won't listen to anything you say, this IS shit", please consider my age and the environment i grow up: i am 16, grew up listening to western popular music and 1989 is, for me, the pop album of all time. there's the perfectly catchy melody and sometimes bit of complex, and very 80s flashback. and everybody here hates 80s synthpop, am i right? (it functions better when you are staying in NYC during the summer with your family members cause when "welcome to new york" hits the only thing you can do is to pray for the school year to end (i think i said before that i'm asian. and actually my finals are still a week away.) so you can take your plane ride and land in JFK ASAP.) (and for ppl who hate Bad Blood: ok so i admit the version featuring Kendrick is indeed better, but literally i had beef and has been backstabbed by one of my moots so the original version never age for me. if you don't like it just pretend you are a 16 years old who get traumatic from a very serious beef which invloves things such as willingful devotion, mistagged misandry, overly politically conscious radfems and a bunch of moot who believed in that moot's lies and helped to spread them that began a year ago and the said 16 years old never recovered from the beef. that's why it speaks for me.) 5/5.

The hits were hitting and the rest was…well, missing

I am far from a Taylor Swift hater but this is her at her most radio-friendly and unoriginal

Dá pra entende a importância da pessoa no mercado, mas não é minha vibe!

I just don't get it.

eh, I knew a swiftie once and this has soured any chance of enjoying her music Will I listen to again: 0%

Die krankzinnige aantallen 'plays' op Spotify. Die nietszeggende nummers. Ik snap het echt niet. Niks voor mij. Ik word te oud. "Shake it Off" is wel catchy, "Wildest Dreams" in de verste verte wel interessant qua productie.

Gotta long list, Starbucks lovers …

It's not too bad. I'm not really a fan. But it's not too bad. My wife and daughters really like her. I'm pretty indifferent. Hence the 3 stars. I by no means think it's bad. I just don't think it's that good either.

Eat the rich.

In my wheelhouse.... Talented singer -songwriter. Mainstream pop, but in the good sense

well it's a flaweless pop album. too bad i'm not into pop music

If this album was a spice, it would be sparkly flour

This is what a pop record should sound like. Incredibly high standards across the whole album, bona fide sing along bangers, great production.

def taylor’s best album. usually dislike her stuff but i liked/sang along to most of the tunes on this album. “wildest dreams” might be my favorite. lots of good memories associated with the songs on these album. 5/5!

You may or may not be a fan of Taylor Swift, but it is really hard to deny that this is simply a really, really good pop album. This is the first Taylor Swift album I’ve ever listened to, and honestly it won’t be the last. I may be a rock and metal head at heart, but I’ve always recognised great pop stuff, and this is totally that.

This belongs on this list way more than any of the Leonard Cohen albums. If I was a woman Id probably find this a little lore enjoyable.

4.3 - I enjoyed this more than I ever thought I would.

Peak pop Taylor Swift. Don’t overthink it, just enjoy it. On this listen I was impressed at how crisp the production is on Blank Space and Shake It Off. Style’s instrumental almost sounds like a Weeknd track. Out of the Woods and All You Had to Do Was Stay could both easily have been singles. I had forgotten how cringey it is when she says “this. sick. beat.” Bad Blood is also a bit cringey but also undeniably catchy - I actually really like the Kendrick Lamar version also. Wildest Dreams is surely a Lana Del Rey song. I can’t quite get over how every song here is so catchy - you could pretty much make any of the first 10 tracks singles, I’m surprised she didn’t milk this album more tbh. The last 3 tracks don’t add much for me, but there is just so much good pop on this album. It deserves recognition as a great record. Fave Tracks: Welcome to New York, Blank Space, Style, All You Had to Do Was Stay, Shake It Off, Bad Blood, Wildest Dreams, How You Get the Girl 4.6/5

I'm not the target demo here. I get that Taylor and the producers massively changed the pop sound for years with this album. After the fact, this album sounds like every single other pop-princess.

Not my music, but definitely some catchy tunes.

I can’t not rate this a 5. This is just an amazing album. I gave 5 stars to Lorde, and I’ll give another 5 to Swift. What can I say, I like Jack Antonoff

I’m not a swift hater or anything but this all sounded super dated to the mid 2010s. Like a compilation album of songs that played in commercials for the gap.

How easy is it to judge the world's top artist of the last... 10 years, maybe? "The bigger the star, the bigger the target", said Michael Jackson. I'll try to be fair in my judgement as I do with all the other artists and not just drop hate on her work for no reason. In a technical aspect, the album is very simple. The songs structure is very repetitive and predictable, almost screaming "2014!". This is not exclusive to Swift, neither to the last decade, since I could say the same thing about, for example, Buddy Holly. The part that really makes me downgrade this album is the lyrical aspect, they can be unbelievably bad sometimes and sound very silly, even for early 2010s standards. What I can't deny, though, is Taylor's authenticity. I don't deny for even a minute that she really lives, believes and feels what she sings. On the other hand, that relates to another negative aspect of this album: its worldview is extremely broken and a general reflex of post-modern society's view on relationships. Everything and everyone is discardable and partners are often seen as just "players". With all of that, this album ends up not being an artistic disaster, but supports values I can't stand to. Its significance to the last decade certainly can't be denied and almost sounds like a soundtrack of that time. 5/10 (I analyse arts through a christian worldview, which, as a christian, I believe is the correct way to interpret the world.)

I refuse to listen to this woman. Worst thing to happen to music.

FIRE 🔥🔥

I liked it more when I was 15.

It was very interesting to listen to this album because even though I have only heard a few songs from it out in the world, I am really familiar with these songs because I have listened to the Ryan Adams cover version album dozens of times. So even though the instrumentation is different and Ryan made them sound like Ryan Adams songs, the lyrics are the same and the melodies are similar enough to make it feel like I have heard these songs before. I found myself tapping my feet and when I compare them I realize that these are just good, well written songs in either version. I am not a pop music kind of guy really but I have always respected Taylor Swift for being an artist who seems to really be true to her own vision and talent. I'm not likely to play this again but for what it is and the audience it is intended for, it's as good as contemporary pop music can be.

This is what the one star rating is for

I would give anything to never hear Shake it off again

First time that I've listened to a Taylor Swift album. Catchy tunes. Don't need to listen to them again, but I now understand some of the appeal.

Odds are - that when 70% of your fanbase is girls between the ages of 5-25 you are not going to appeal to old dudes raised on Jam bands, blues and old school rock and roll. This did not beat the odds. It wasn't awful but I wouldn't go as far as to call it enjoyable.

Validated my disdain

This album is worthy of study. This record transitioned T Swift into icon status. Iconic gets tossed around willy-nilly these days, but she's an icon now...Elvis, The Beatles, Michael Jackson, Madonna....icons who caught the whole world's attention for a number of years. Taylor is on that list now, and this album started that movement. There isn't a cheat code to this, its a bit of magic...but ultimately you need catchy catchy catchy songs, and this album has that.

I’m not a Swiftie by any means, but I can respect the insane impact it has had on everything after this.

Not the kind of music that I usually listen! The only reason I gave it a 3 ;-) Nothing against her, nothing against her music, she's obviously a talented woman... but this music is, for me, the kind of music I compare to a gum, you chew it and you through it away when finished!

this is honestly a pretty tough album to rate. i think it’s one of the best pop albums of all time both musically and culturally. but the original release doesn’t have New Romantics on it, only being included on the deluxe. which is absolute insanity. still great though and probably my 3rd favorite taylor album

I liked this album. I've not listened to an entire album by Swift before. I like almost all of her radio singles. The non-radio singles were mostly strong, but by the end, the last three felt like just a bunch of 'Taylor Swift-isms' thrown together and they weren't as strong as the rest of the album.

I've heard some of these songs before, but not by choice. Trying to get through the album only served to reinforce my belief that everything Swift does is manufactured for wide appeal. The songs sound like they're put together by focus groups and industry execs running algorithms to determine how to sell as many copies of the album as possible. There's no soul in it. Someone knows what they're doing though, because this mediocre product does sell millions of units no matter how empty and disposable it is. Which is fine for them and Taylor, but it means nothing to me. If people like it, good for them.

The boiled, unseasoned chicken of the music industry

I will admit that I have a soft spot for Blank Space. It's a great pop song and a guilty pleasure of mine. There's a couple other tracks I didn't mind but this music is really not my bag. If there has to be a Taylor Swift album on this list, this should be it. I already listened to evergreen on the list and that one was baaaaaaaaad.

I dare you to commit suicide while listening to Shake It Off

Even if you're not a big fan of her music, it's hard to deny how impressively Taylor Swift pivoted with this album and became an incredible musical juggernaut. And it's equally hard not to enjoy all of the singles on this and subsequent albums; it almost feels like she's somehow created greatest hits albums with each new release. She's managed to combine her undeniable success with a seemingly genuine personality and very savvy business sense, and created a lasting 21st phenomenon that seems rivalled only by Beyonce (and probably only Madonna and Michael Jackson from the 20th century). I've never listened to this album in its entirety (although impossible to miss all the singles), so that was nice to experience. It's definitely not music for musicians or even songwriters, but it's certainly entertaining (and I'm confident that the numerous videos on this album are equally so, although I wasn't able to watch them).

This is a good album, not gonna lie. But listening to this fills me with rage at what an insecure fuck put together this list of 1001 albums because he clearly doesn't love the ladies. This album should be on this list. But to include this 2014 album and not include Robyn's 2010 Body Talk or even 2004 Robyn is just outrageous--pop supreme. Elsewhere, when I get yet another Bjork album I'll rail against only one Patti Smith but for now I'm gonna play tiny dancer Robyn to clarify the air.

Definitely not my favourite Taylor Swift album but I can’t NOT give this 5/5. Every song on here is at minimum good with many iconic hits. Top Tracks: This Love, Clean, Wildest Dreams, Blank Space Bonus (deluxe version): You Are In Love

Fire so many bangers

There’s a reason Taylor has the absolute reign over pop music stardom, and 1989 is proof positive. All the way through the album there’s just incredible pop hits and her lyrics are the sharpest they’ve been. It’s very easy to pile on Taylor, especially for her more recent lack of editing, but this is a certified classic album, no matter how you slice it. Only knocked it down a star for some of the more derivative songs.

This album slaps. It’s great until the last 2 songs

(возможно лучший ёё) альбом с невъебенными бангерами. Здесь нет вот этого греха поп-альбомов, типа "вот вам песня на три миллиарда прослушиваний и кучу недоделанного гавна - тадааа, альбом!" Нравилось на релизе, нравится и сейчас. Лучшая песня - Blank Space.

TOO Pop!

Literally invented pop

I never heard a Taylor Swift song that didn't sound like a shampoo commercial. Some parts are catchy, and other parts feel contrived to the point of being a turn off. A couple good songs ("Blank Space", "Style"), plenty of skips ("Welcome to New York" for SURE, "Shake it Off"). I don't think anyone cares what I really think here so I'm going to shut the fuck up.

You can’t listen to some of these songs and not feel the need to dance or just feel joy. This isn’t my favourite Taylor swift album but it is up there. Very enjoyable.

Overrated, overproduced girl pop. But it's very accessible, and at times, catchy and nostalgic. So I won't give it a 2.

Quite generic radio pop of it's time. Presumably good stuff in this category. I liked the Ryan Adams song to song version of this album way more.

I tried, I really did but couldnt really listen this

Plays like an expensive producers pop record, sounds like it's put together by a committee, produced to sound current with retro sound. This has all the ingredients I dislike in modern popular music. Ms. Swift has a pretty voice.

it can get to all feel the same sometimes but beyond that its fun

The height of 2010s pop. There are so many hits on this album, so many songs which are era defining, artist defining. Yes, the production a bit thick for me. It feels that in the final minutes of "How You Get the Girl" every sample they could find in the synthesiser is being replicated 100-fold. And perhaps this isn't an album which I really really engage with on a deep deep personal level. I think I bond more with her later works (e.g. Evermore) where she really strips it all back. But this is still absolutely phenomenal. Perhaps the best pop album of all time.

This album is hard for me to rate. On one hand, this is pretty cut and dry pop music. It has some catchy tracks, some decent vocals, and some well written lyrics. On the other hand, I know it speaks volumes to a lot of people. Unfortunately, I am not one of those people. A lot of Taylor Swift's music is a window into an emotional state that I personally have very little experience with. I have been extremely lucky in love, and have experienced very little heartbreak, betrayal, or any other classic themes featured heavily in Swift's song writing. I am also not a mega star, with a lot of eyes watching me all the time. I don't have "haters" but can appreciate the mantra of shaking them off. That being said, I can still objectively listen to the music. 1989 is a good pop album. I know a lot of people will give this a 1, a lot will give it a 5. I think it's clearly not a 1. It's catchy enough to at least warrant a 2. I like the music, I like the messages, I do not resonate with the emotions portrayed, which is not necessarily a bad thing, and I hate to give a point off for it. Melodically it's not too interesting, it's just 80s inspired pop. At the end of the day this is a 4/5 album, I'd be confident in saying between 7.5 and 8/10 on a 10 point scale. It's objectively good, for some people this will be fantastic, for others it'll be fine. Still for others this will be awful, and they'll rate it extremely low for no real reason aside from being closeted iconoclasts who will argue that they are not in fact iconoclasts, but "enlightened". Get a life. 4/5.

I aint a hater man but I don't think it held up very well

Lots of her hits but seems a bit hollow from a depth perspective. In the 3 side of a 3.5.

Yeah I heard someone say Taylor Swift sounds like unseasoned chicken once and I have to agree. Like how does she have such a massive following?

Really enjoyed this - reminds me of year 12!

Insanely catchy and enjoyable pop music. About 10 years late to the party, but damn 'Blank Space' is a killer track.

It's been described as a modern pop Bible - and it probably is. Almost every song could have been a single; and more than half of them actually were one. I ended up listening to Taylor's Version. Is it cheating? Probably. Do I care? No. What will you do? Fire me? Go ahead.

come on now .. this is peak modern pop

3/5 decent pop

It all started off quite pleasant and then lost its way halfway through before sort of just ending with a whimper.

Je ne suis pas une personne qui écoute beaucoup de pop, mais j'admets que j'aimais déjà plusieurs des chansons de cet album. Elles accrocheuses, addictives, diablement le fun (et difficiles) à chanter. Je comprends pourquoi Taylor Swift remporte tout ce succès.

The second most hit dense pop album ever. She's not my favorite, but her prowess is undeniable.

Good record

I tried, it didn’t stick

ONE OF THE BEST ALBUMS EVER ! SLAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!

Listens: 1 I do not much care for or understand the popularity of Taylor Swift, but I do recognize that she is both a cultural phenomenon and wildly popular. The subject matter of the songs on this album is not something I am interested in. The music is largely synthetic, which, while I do not inherently have any issues with (being an enjoyer of all manner of the electronica genre), I imagine she did not solely create. This may be a disingenuous criticism though, because I imagine Lorde or Lana Del Ray also fall into this category of working with producers to create melodies, and I enjoy some of their music. I may just need to listen to the album a few more times before really casting any further judgement.

I wish I could rate this with 0 stars

leichtes geträller im popkleid - schlager à l‘américaine?! die zeit geht im flug, und dann ist dann gut.

Für mich belangloser Pop, für andere das Höchste. Lässt mich etwas ratlos zurück, erklärt aber vieles.

I do not understand why is so much ado about Taylor Swift, when music presented on this album is just... an avarage pop music.

Never been a Swiftie and this did not convert me. It’s the most generic pop music.

This was actually harder to get through than I thought. I’ve heard most of these songs in isolation, but in one big lump their repetitive and over-produced nature really wore on me. I like her more recent folksy stuff far more. Standout track is: “Style”

Not much for modern pop but as the genre goes, this was a good album. At least Taylor can really sing without being breathy as compared to some of the other pop stars out there.

Having a teen girl and a pre-teen girl when this album came out means that I heard the album a LOT. And the previous albums, and the future albums. So I know the songs. But one thing that always struck me about Taylor Swift was how she stands up for herself, without becoming a terrible person. She charted her own path and has enjoyed huge success in doing so. And with each new sound, she never went off the rails as so many young female artists have. She was, and is, someone that I didn't mind my daughters listening to, singing along with, and looking up to. Granted, a lot of songs have dealt with more mature themes as she (and they) have grown up, but I'm not a total curmudgeon. One note though: Rather than this album as originally recorded, I queued up 2023's "1989 - Taylor's Version". Because fuck you, Scooter.

Álbum muito nostálgico para mim. Ele é consistente nas virtudes e nos defeitos, o maior sendo a repetitividade dos refrões, que são cansativos. Tem bons momentos.

Undeniably excellent album.

Honestly didn’t hate it

didn't get it, thought she's meant to be a pop writing genius... I didn't like anything on this

An emotionless void of an album that is saved by really good production and a few pop hits

You all already know my thoughts in detail about this

Some hits. Some duds.

Hard not to love this one, given how catchy so many of the tracks were more than a decade ago. They're still pretty good and hold up well for me. Taylor has great vocal work and the instrumentals are quite fun! 'How You Get The Girl' was my fave from this set.

sucks ass

Pretty much the only Taylor Swift album I have listened to. It has fun bops and is real reminiscent of 2014, a fun time in my life.

Sooooo many bangers wtf

I like a bit of Taylor. Harmless fun

First time listening to Taylor on purpose but I have definitely heard all the tracks before. 3.8 stars

When 1989 came out, I wanted to hate it. I remember when Taylor’s first album came out. Back when she was a teenager (so was I). Back when she was country. I was all like, “I hate country. I hate Taylor Swift.” I felt the same about the other 3 albums. But then 1989 came out. I was ready to be like “I hate country. I hate Taylor Swift.” But then I heard “Shake It Off” for the first time, and I was like 😡…🎷🌝 It’s not a perfect album, but the great songs are great and the hits hit hard. Pretty fun overall. But it’s not as good as Folklore.

This album was deserving of all awards it won!

If one wants to chart the moment Taylor Swift morphed from omnipresent country princess to omnipresent pop behemoth, look no further. 1989 was the denouement of an ongoing shift in Taylor's upward trajectory, where she reached the peak of her powers in the first decade of her career. Of course, given what has happened since, there was little and lots to know in regards to where she'd head but none of that would have been possible had she not made the full splash as opposed to dipping her toe in the water. Favorites: Welcome to New York, Blank Space, Style, Out of the Woods, I Wish You Would, Wildest Dreams, This Love.

I know more songs from this album than I want to admit.

Naja, ich werde kein Swiftie!

A lot of fun catchy pop music, that despite being about break ups a lot of the time, was pretty fun

Sorry don't agree with her manipulating fans to line her bank balance so refuse to listen

I have to hold my tounge and say it is a very well produced album songs vary a lot for being pop and tons of singles all diferent styles so that shows me versatility as an artist. Not bad Im not a swifty thibgy but have always respected he songwriting and her as an artists not my cup of tea cause I dont like pop but couldnt get away from this on the radio so kond of was fed up but as an album in order its great story telling and I have to objectively give it 4/5 as much as I would love to have given it a 1 because I heard shake it up a billion times

Standard Taylor Swift. Some bops, some not as good. Would listen to as background.

Yaaaaay I’m listening to TV tho

Been on a Taylor-break since last year’s Tortured Trash Can Debacle, and I thought maybe I just wasn’t that into her music anymore in general, but I was wrong. Just loved this album as much as I always have. HOWEVER: ‘Welcome to New York’ is still terrible and I hate it so much; I don’t understand how ‘How You Get the Girl’ made the cut, while ‘New Romantics’ didn’t; and, if for some reason you felt the need to listen to the Taylor’s Version of this instead of the original, I encourage you to stick to the original.

Before I knew what I know about her I loved this album.

Listened once to Taylor's version, listened once to the original. Sorry, Taylor. Not exactly my speed, but I still enjoy this. Wildest Dreams, Style, Blank Space are my favourites (the latter two I knew before this listen). I am giving everything here a fair chance! When this was coming out (2014) I was graduating from high school. Some friends were driving to Edmonton to see her. They invited me, but I turned it down because the tickets were too expensive at $80. Knowing what I know now, I wish I had gone.

There are three songs I really liked on this album, "Style", the self penned "This Love", and the Imogen Heap produced "Clean". There were a couple songs where the chorus would catch my ear while the rest of it just felt like uninspired pop ("Blank Space", "All You Had To Do Was Stay"). The rest is really the kind of Max Martin pop I really stay away from. Then there's the egregious errors a) the fkg cheerleader beat on "Shake It Off" (I just don't like that particular brand of pop whether it's Taylor, Avril, Gwen, Chappell or even Toni Basil)... b)"areweoutofthewoodsareweoutofthewoodsareweoutofthewoodsareweoutofthewoods areweintheclearyetareweintheclearyetareweintheclearyetareweintheclearyet" gave me a fkg headache... and c) "Bad Blood" which everytime Taylor acts like a bad ass, it just comes off like high school drama. Ultimately I don't like this album, but it's not horrendous. Just the hype around it makes it feel like it is. (5.85) ★★½

Not bad. I just feel indifference towards it. 2.5 stars

I'm not the biggest pop fan, but I unironically think this is a really good album. A lot of pop music for me is sort of style over substance, and while I don't always find Taylor's lyrics that relatable, I think she's a solid songwriter with a knack for crafting catchy melodies. I think the first 9 tracks on this are all good songs, and think there's quite a few highlights, including "Blank Space", "Style", "Out of the Woods", and "I Wish You Would". I think it kind of fizzles out at the end though. 4 stars.

Absolutely perfect indie crossover for Tay Tay. Not country like her earlier stuff, nor tacky and cringe like Reputation or totally snoozy like her Folksnore albums or as bad as her most recent stuff. Just the perfect Tay Tay Goldilocks zone. (although she does come close to matching it with a certain album called 1989 Taylor’s Version). You have a clutch of songs that feel completely sensational. From the widescreen allure of Welcome To New York, pop juggernauts of Blank Space and Shake It Off plus Style which totally smokes in a neon lit 80s way. It’s not too long at 13 songs and 48 minutes but the weaker half definitely pales massively to all the best stuff. But the best songs and overall production and vibes are so good and the vocals so vivaceous. A 2010s Thriller with some filler.

Some shrill moments, but classic moments as well. Anthemic boldness make it a good listen

This is the one Taylor Swift album I know. Times were different in a weird way then as I know the Ryan Adam’s version the most so hearing this was interesting as the songs took on such a different, but layered and satisfying turn that I hadn’t realized before. I could also have been high.

Flawless 21st century pop. The perfect balance of excited high energy and introspective low energy, of earnestness and snark, of wide eyed innocence and winking experience. This is Taylor Swift announcing to the world that she’s coming for the top spot.

I was ready to shit all over this album, as I'm fully Taylor-saturated by now. But as much as I try, I can't dislike almost anything on here. It's poppy and a somewhat guilty pleasure for me, but a real pleasure at that. Peak Taylor right here.

pls don't bring me back to the feeling of being in a forever 21 in 2014 ever again

Honest to god I've been deliberating this for a week and to the surprise of everyone but especially me, I've decided to challenge my prejudices and be positive even if I find this album slightly to moderately annoying, shallow, overproduced, american etc, the girl can make a catchy tune dammit. Also I've been under constant attack by extremely mid albums recently which in turn has caused my average rating to fall and make me look like a hater. Which I am, but shhh don't tell anyone!

Sometimes, I roll my eyes at Taylor Swift's music because there are certain things about it that annoy me: her muddled metaphors, the cliché turns of phrase, the way she overemphasizes her cheesiest lines. All of these things are on "1989," but her strengths are more honed than ever too: her ability to write hooks that stay in your head for years, her soaring vocals, the way she takes vulnerable feelings and amplifies them into stadium-sized emotions. I can't help but get swept up in it. And the things I roll my eyes at on other albums of hers kind of become charming quirks when the songs are this good. The production takes cues from 80s pop, but gets pumped up with big, Max Martin drums. The music is bubblegum pop one moment, sweeping melodrama the next, and Taylor Swift carries it all with confidence. An irresistible album for me.

I've been wanting to hear this one from start to finish for a while now so I'm glad to see it pop up. "Shake It Off" is a really great piece of pop music. It had its time in the spotlight but since then I've heard it randomly and I've had this thought linger that this song is so good for what it is. It's not some deep lyrical piece, but it's an incredibly catch song with a lot of quality elements and one of the better pristine poppy tracks of at least that decade. The pop-hip hop groove is great, the melodies are impressively catchy, that brass part is so infectious, those little laugh faux adlibs are adorable, and it doesn't take itself too seriously. It sounds like she's having fun sitting there in the studio and it is so glaringly more genuine than a lot of her other tunes. This is a side of Taylor Swift that I desperately want more of. Even if she made more tracks outside of this style but took the authenticity of this track and approached her other songs in this manner, I would be way more into her stuff. Unfortunately, many of the other songs are hard for me to get through. The intro "Welcome To New York" sounds like a fake song that some Gen Z'er made to make fun of "millenial music". It tries to be expansive with huge synths at 00:44, I guess to show this big grandiose version of the city? The production doesn't do it any favors; the kicks don't kick you, the snares don't snap, and the claps are the most perfectly aligned "keyboard drumset" nonsense you can imagine. It's so vanilla. The lyrics are her usual bland variety: "It's a new soundtrack, I could dance to this beat, beat forevermore The lights are so bright, but they never blind me, me Welcome to New York, it's been waitin' for you" What was the purpose of this track? I don't think it came from a great set of lyrics, I don't think it came from a great melody either, as the melody sounds more like it was bolted on rather than baked in. It sounds like it was made to check the box of having a "club song" on her record. Or rather a "song that girls will play before they go out to the club". This is my least favorite reasoning to write a song- album playlist pragmatism. I'm surprisingly annoyed by the chorus in "Out of the Woods", as this soft-pop style doesn't really ever present musical elements that are annoying to me but that chorus is kind of grating to hear over and over and over. And it's not even that catchy of a phrase that it could be played on repeat a few times and then everyone on earth will be humming it for weeks. At the end where we get a full like 32(?) measures of it from 3:07 to 3:50 is particularly annoying. "areweoutofthewoodsyetareweoutofthewoodsyetareweoutofthewoodsyetareweoutofthewoodsyetareweoutofthewoodsyetareweoutofthewoodsyet". I really don't want to dislike Taylor Swift. She's a polarizing figure in my friend groups, and honestly I don't ever really let that influence me too much; I can enjoy acts that none of my friends like, and I can dislike acts that all of my friends like, and yet every time I go to give Taylor Swift some time I always get let down. She has a great voice, she has all the producers she could ever want to work it, and hell she is a pop star who writes her own songs (or at least has some effort in it? I remember this being a thing years ago and I don't know if she still writes as much). That should be enough to churn out great tunes over and over forever and evermore, and yet that's not what happens. "Shake It Off" is a truly great song, and there are some other hits on here that people love- like "Blank Space", "Bad Blood", "Style", that I feel like are inflated by her fan base and are just OK pop tracks. The repetitive and formulaic choruses just frustrate me to rate this any higher than a 3.

1989 is Taylor Swift's fifth studio album, and the work that marked her transition from folk/country to more synth-based pop. The album was incredibly successful, both in its original release, and in the (Taylor's Version) re-release. In 2016, it won the Grammy for Album of the Year and for Best Pop Vocal Album. Swift writes great, uplifting pop songs, and she has become an international superstar because of it.

I get why she’s super popular, but her stuff isn’t for me. Some is cringe. Some is good that’s all I can say.

1989 is full of melodic pop bangers, it can’t be denied. Having two 9 year daughters, I’ve been over exposed to her, so listening to it today didn’t really hit. But she is the undeniable Queen of Pop. She’s not The Beatles, but she might be Michael Jackson 8.6/10

I am pleasantly surprised! I was totally prepared to give this two stars but it refused to allow me to hate it.

I just had 2 five star albums in a row so I was expecting something bad to come next. Unfortunately for me, it happened to be an "album" with everything I hate about my generation's music taste (so worse than I expected). After listening to the album I do think I was slightly over exaggerating but I still didn't enjoy. To me it feels pretty corporate and unimpressed. It also isn't very relatable but that is probably because I'm not the target audience. Still, I had to listen to this on the radio for years so my brain is programmed to hating it. Would be a 1.5 but since it's overplayed to hell and back I'm giving it a 1.

genuine struggle listen

Jag tycker TS är grymt överskattad och det här är ett av hennes sämre album enligt mig, tråkig, förutsägbar pop. 1 av 5

I will preface this review by stating that I was expecting much worse. In reality, there are many cool pop hits with solid hooks. The lyrics are not something to write home about, but of all of the Taylor Swift records, I was glad to get this one.

I gave Led Zeppelin IV 5 stars because recognized most songs as hits, and by that logic TS also deserves a 5

This album will never be anything less than a five to me because of the countless number of times that my daughter and I have belted these tracks out together over the years.

good pop

I'm neither a Swiftie nor a hater, so I have a hard time getting excited about this album either way. It was probably the first Taylor Swift album I listened to all the way through when it was released, and I enjoyed a few of the singles. At the same time, while it's decent enough pop music, it's also very typical Max Martin/Jack Antonoff/Ryan Tedder fodder, and all of the songs blend together after a while (which is how I feel about most of Taylor's music — the same two or three melodies over and over). I think Taylor deserves to be on a list like this, but more so for her impact/influence than her actual music. I think she's a competent songwriter, and I appreciate the vulnerable singer-songwriter lyrics. I can also appreciate how she's played with genre and her image over the years. For whatever reason though, I've never really connected with her songs the same way I have with other artists (or the way so many fans have with her). Even if not many of her songs have resonated with me personally, it's hard to deny the impact she's had on the music world. She has obviously influenced an entire generation of artists (for better or worse) given the endless copycats you can hear now. But I think her real strength is in her business acumen. She and Beyonce are probably the closest thing to a Madonna or a Michael Jackson we'll see in the 21st century. As for the album itself, it's fine. It's perfectly serviceable pop music. It marks a turning point in her music where she starts to shift from teen star into a more mature artist. And a few songs have decent staying power (and meme power — Starbucks lovers, etc.). When comparing the original album to the "Taylor's version" re-recording it's clear that her voice has improved over the years, though she'll never be a powerhouse singer. But this album is also really long and repetitive. Besides the singles, there's not a ton that stands out for me. After listening to it a couple times when it first came out, I haven't had any desire to listen to it again, and I had zero memory of the non-single tracks after putting it on for this listen. 3/5 — decent but not amazing

Blank Space Style Out of the Woods Shake It Off

The Queen of Im14andthisisdeep. Like come on the lyrics on bad blood are abysmal. But pretty good for an eighth grader! Rating: 1.4

While her type of music isn’t my thing, I do think Taylor Swift is a talented musician and songwriter. This album, though, is just formulaic pop at its worst and when it’s at its best it just seems like outtakes from CHVRCHES’ The Bones of What You Believe.

Brilliant slice of pop.

I guess I am the only one who doesn't get it. The songwriting isn't great, the musical arrangement isn't mindblowing, and these songs are not particularly catchy. I understand that sometime we all feel like a little girl in a big girl's body, but sometime after your early 20's you have to move on. I got 50 year old dudes telling me that Taylor Swift is the new Bruce Springsteen (who I also don't quite get, but that is a different story for a different time). As with any artistic endeavour, music is subjective...I guess I just prefer to turn to Sara Bareilles, Tori Amos, Fiona, or Tegan and Sara when I need my angsty girl pop fix.

Wildest dream is a banger but rest of the album did scratch the itch

Very nostalgic, I remember being a kid listening to this. Not as big on pop now, and I barely listen to her. Still solid. I wasn't planning on ranking this so high but I can't help it. So many catchy hits that I somehow remember every word to even though its been years since I heard them. Highlights: Blank Space Shake It Off Bad Blood

I know you would probably expect me to be very hard on 1989 considering that the person who made it has one of the worst fanbases ever but i don't really think i can since i don't hate this album all too much. Don't get me wrong, its not perfect but i was expecting quite a bit worse. The music, while not something out of the ordinary for contemporary pop, is serviceable and has enough variety. Taylor's vocals were also pretty good as well but the lyrics have a certain cringeiness to them and they cause the songs to feel like they are in a weird order. Its by no means an amazing album but it has enough good elements for it to get a pass from me. Best Song: Style Worst Song: Clean

I suppose it had to happen eventually. Whenever I talk about this "1 album a day" project with a friend he always asks, "any Taylor Swift yet?". I have never knowingly heard her before. How is that possible? I don't listed to broadcast music. My listening is normally "limited" to within the 3,200 hours of my own collection. "Expanding my musical horizons" (in the scope of "modern music") is why I am listening to recommendations from this site. So onto this, "1989" and Taylor Swift. Her voice is good, although it seems a bit over-processed. It is being manipulated electronically to a degree I find irritating. A shame as I suspect her voice doesn't need it. The tunes are catchy. I suppose that's good. But it's all a bit fluffy, even dare I say it, "Disney". I'd probably categorise it as "relentless, formulaic synth pop". It isn't that we're "not at home to Mr. Emotional Engagement", he isn't knocking at the door, in fact he may not even be in the same postal code. Is this the best she can do? I hope not, otherwise I am struggling to understand all the hype about this artist. Timeline... I've now got as far as track 6, "Shake it off" and my patience is wearing thin. The whole listening experience is starting to grate. A bit of variety would be welcome. 2/5. Unimaginative, over-produced, fluff. Decent vocal talent wasted. I'm sure it sold very well, but there's no depth.

Love me some T Swift but I hear it so much she doesn’t get my 5.

Lovely stuff

I freaking love this album, it's my 2nd favourite by Taylor. "Welcome to New York" is a great intro, and then? "Blank space", "Style", "Out of the woods", "AYHTDWS", "Shake it off", "I wish you would", "Bad blood" - bangers. "Wildest dreams"? One of the most beautiful pop ballads. "How you get the girl"? Amazing. "This love", "You are in love" and "Clean" are a bit slower, but stole my heart. "I know places" and "Wonderland" are wonderful. "New romantics" is my favourite song from this album. Vault tracks are so beautiful, "Is it over now?" made me fall in love with Taylor. I give it 10/10

People will hate Taylor Swift and 1989 on principle and while I went in with said stance I will concede that the album is completely fine. This is tightly designed pop music that is showing its age 10 years on. Ultimately the album references for me a time in popular music which I am not positively nostalgic of. 1989 targets a young audience and leaves a saccharine impression but at the end of it all you cannot completely deny the sweet tooth for catchy, massive choruses. Rating: 3.5

I sat on this one for over a month after it was generated, because I suspected I was going to hate the listening experience, but have successfully isolated myself from pop music for so long that I wasn't certain. There's also a certain reluctance to contaminate my music recommendation algorithms, you know? Anyway. Thirty three days later, I finally sucked it up and gave Taylor Swift a listen. Shallow. Hollow. Overproduced. Prepackaged and sanitized for popular consumption. I know I haven't quite made it through 10% of the albums on this project yet, and a few of my all time favorites are still in the future - so I'm going to go clean my ears by listening to one of those. Todd Rundgren, save me!

Taylor Swift gets a lot of hate and I get it but some of these songs are pretty damn catchy. It’s not the music I like but I can see the appeal

Can’t deny she’s a hitmaker

Sorry Kyle, it's good

Robotic production I hate jack antonoff

Never listened to this album before but turned out I knew most of the songs already. It's pop for pre-teens so not really my thing, but a pleasant enough listen anyway.

Hell to the no

Njen najbolji album

First listen to this entire album. Was only familiar with "Shake It Off" which is an enjoyable tune. Leading up to that track, I was not moved much by any of the first five tunes. "Blank Space" was okay. After "Shake It Off" not much moved me. Sounds like computer generated music. The album simply did not move me. I do not believe I will listen to this again. Just not my cup of tea. That is what is great about music, there is something for everyone. This is not for me.

Only heard two most recent Taylor albums in full but never this one except for the singles. The title of the album is so funny considering how 2014 it sounds (and looks when it comes to the album cover). This particular brand of pop music is not something I like, it just sounds so juvenile. I don't want it to look like I hate the album just because it's Taylor (hell, I thought Midnights was an OK album) but she really just doesn't make music that appeals to me in any way 1/5

After just listening to Frank Sinatra this is very much of the same vein. Pop music designed to sell that's sort of out of step with pop culture but so produced and slick it doesn't matter. I can't imagine how she goes about picking a single when any one of these songs are completely interchangeable. But of course that's the point and what makes her a genius. When everything is at the exact same caliber she can't go wrong.

I'm not trying to be a hater for the sake of hating Swifties but this album, even (taylor's version) doesn't feel written so much as engineered. The electric drum kits boom boom bat us through focus-grouped pop bangers. There's a ton of hits on this album, but they all just sound flat.

Didn’t disappoint. Many enjoyable tracks, really liked her musicality and the lyrics. Whilst I appreciate her candid approach to write about experiences of love and breakups, juxtaposing all her songs together just felt cringe. ‘Oh what are you up to now, girl?’ On their own they are catchy and I would listen to them on repeat, but collectively they are less than their sum. Is a TS concert going to be like a coaster ride of her love stories?

Great pop album

Comin in hot with my first review (hi everyone) to say I love this album. It’s by far her best imo (although folklore is up there). Very good nostalgic, emotional boops. No skips, no notes

Look, the woman writes bops. Been doing it since 2008, since Love Story. The people have spoken and I’m here for the radio singles: Blank Space .. and Style … and Shake It Off … and (the bridge into the chorus of) Bad Blood … and Wildest Dreams. I acknowledge the rest of the slate was AI-generated generic—though excellent house remix fodder! Anyway, keep it up, Tay-Tay! (I still will be rooting for the Eagles 🦅)

Not my favorite Taylor Swift album and maybe a few fillers here, but overall, 1989 really demonstrates what Taylor Swift does best. Her songwriting that transports you to a specific moment in time, with all the textures and people and places. Her mastery of creating a bridge that stays in your head and shapes the trajectory of the entire song. Her NGAF dorkiness that just makes you want to let your freak flag and cheesiness come out (cue: Shake It Off). Giving this a 4. No haters allowed.

I guess this is good if you like bland 2010s pop, which I do not.

It's too cloying for my taste, but these songs are just undeniably great

The pop bangers on this album are all-time incredible—Blank Space, Shake it Off, Bad Blood. Rediscovered All You Had To Do Was Stay. A couple duds there snuck in at the end but not enough to kill the vibe.

love that this list keeps surprising me with artists I’ve never come across before

More of a 2.5. It was fine? A bit of a slog after Bad Blood and I was glad it was over.

No matter how much I have tried, I just can't muster up any significant respect for Swift beyond being able to collaborate to create pop hits. I don't find any artistic significance to her work, and even trying to listen to her as pop music, I find her version unchallenging and bland. The best two songs off this album sound like Lana Del Rey rip-offs. I like plenty of pop music, but there is a way to do pop music in a way that isn't so entirely predictable and surface-level.

The thing I like about TS is that when she's derivative (maybe always) she puts her whole self into it. It's literally not for me, but the people it is for get all of it.

Can't stand her shit music

Taylor Swift is definitely one of the most hateable figures in modern pop music, both her music and her personality. But as much as it's cool and trendy to hate on her music, I stand by that while inconsistent, her discography does have some genuinely great stuff. However, this album is not that. This is the side of her that while inoffensive, is super generic and the lyrics are often really cringy.

I've never listened to a Taylor Swift album which is surprising considering many of my most respected colleagues are obsessed with her music. I've always felt I was not the target audience I suppose. I do appreciate that she was one of a few billionaires not sitting on stage during the inauguration. I most enjoyed the first track of the album. The 80s style synth was well done. It reminded me a lot of Stranger Things soundtrack artist Michael Stein who makes modern music that sounds more 80s than actual 80s music. The rest of the album didn't really resonate with me. It's certainly something I would be happy to dance to when just the right amount of drunk. Ex: Say I start drinking at 4pm. I would love this album from like 4:45 to 5:30. I've also never been disappointed, hurt or angry enough with another person to really connect with these lyrics. Considering the insane sales and devoted following, she's obviously doing something right. But the same can be said of Fireball whiskey.

Never having actually sat down and listened to more than the occasional Tswift song, I really had no idea what to expect here. 1) I would much rather listen to 1989 than literally any Metallica album. There's some catchy stuff in 1989, it's really not that bad. 2) I feel like I could write some (any?) of these songs. There's a complete lack of depth to everything on this album. It's hard to explain, but it just sounds like ultra produced sound effects behind a simple (albeit catchy) melody, every, single, track. Simple doesn't always lack depth (Sufjan Steven's anyone?), so that's not the problem. It's just boring and extremely predictable pop music. 3) I most definitely did not hear anything to inspire the widespread and creepy devotion of Swifties. It's just slightly better Katy perry and/or Pink. All in all, it's not bad. But that's as good as it gets. 🤷‍♂️ Chappell Roan, Tegan and Sarah, and Lana Del Ray all do it 10x better. We don't NEED Taylor Swift to be great, so I'm still confused after having listened to this album. It's a niche that is already filled by many others who have managed to make badass, fun pop music. Whatever, I tried. See you at the super bowl, Taylor.

I would never have listened to this album except that Ryan Adams released an entire cover album of it when it came out. I'm glad he did because I would have missed out on some really masterfully written pop songs. This is not the kind of music I would normally listen to. But I can't deny it's good. The pedigree of producers is top notch. The synthy 80s style maximalist pop and vocals are really fun. And it's catchy as hell. I'm not a Swiftie by any stretch of the imagination, but I will defend this album.

Taylor Swift could write catchy songs for any milieu from Music Row to Madison Avenue. (Welcome to New York, for one, sounds like it was written for a chamber of commerce.) She churns out hooks and hits, and this album is full of both. Style and Wildest Dreams shimmer despite some weird phrasings (I blame the Swedes), but most of the hits are a bit goofy. She needed a few more tries to make an album with no overtly embarrassing moments. Two of the better tunes are relegated to the “deluxe edition” (capitalism!): You Are in Love, which evokes Secret Garden-era Bruce (complimentary), and New Romantics, which unbelievably was never used in an episode of Girls (lol).

Not my favorite Taylor but still a good pop album.

An album loaded up with well-produced pop bang-hers, most of which I am not particularly moved by. Welcome To New York and Style are pretty good. She does have better albums later on so I will be giving this one a…

Ugh. I guess I have to listen to an entire TSweezy record finally? This is the worst kind of disposable pop music. Produced by committee, enjoyed by masses of drooling children. Engineered to the lowest common denominator. The beats are catchy of course. They’re perfectly calibrated to sound good over the speakers in a Starbucks or in a VW ad or some fucking place. This isn’t music. It’s a commercial project to turn people into millionaires and millionaires into billionaires.

Never thought I would say this about a Taylor Swift album but... I liked it, it was enjoyable.

Super nostalgic. Love blank space