Reviews (page 5 of 15)
Enjoyed it, not revelatory.
Good but too short.
Interesting. Although the censorship wasn't really necessary and the Saab Quentin song didn't really need doing twice.
Johnny has a lot of well written songs but in many cases the album versions feel tame. But when The Man in Black steps inside those prison walls these song come alive. All the songs seem up tempo and Johnny is singing like the rent is due. Highlights for me are a blistering version of Walk the Line and arguably the best version of Boy Named Sue. Lastly, that cover art is iconic.
Ooh nice
Great Songs: I Walk the Line, San Quentin Good Songs: Wanted Man, Wreck of the Old '97, Darlin' Companion, Starkville City Jail, A Boy Named Sue, (There'll Be) Peace In the Valley (For Me), Folsom Prison Blues Mid Songs: Bad Songs:
What a great album, the fact it was recorded live really helps, given the genuine reactions from the audience. Would listen to the whole album again
This seems like something I wouldn't like, but the old country sound was really nice and there was an incredible amount of charisma that showed every time he talked to the crowd
I mean it was just live at folsom, I dunno which one was first
With all due respect to Live at Folsom Prison, this shows so much more of who Johnny Cash was, while also just being excellent musically.
Det e så gøy (det e helt klart feil ord, men det e det eneste ordet æ har akkurat nu), men så e det så veldig for kort. Skulle ønske det va lengre, men alt som e der e gode greier.
My kids pulled out one of my copies of this album the other day so I played it while it was out. Yes I own mul
Look, it's not something against Johnny Case, but I don't really see the point in this album. "At Folsom Prison" was so good and the set list this time around isn't as great. I'll say 2.5 rounded up to 3 for Johnny Cash, but this seems like an unnecessary live album.
This is a good album no matter how you slice it up. The music, the concept all good stuff -- maybe a little repetitive since this was his second live album from a prison but hey ---
I've been meaning to give Johnny Cash a few listens I wanna get more into old country. He's a pretty iconic place to start I think. His vibe is impeccable I think. You tell em Cash. Maybe I will see that wanted man. You never know. I'll lyk if he's in Australia. Oh fuck yeah it's only 30 minutes I'm a big fan Mr. Cash. But also if this is a concert why are you playing for 30 minutes. But this was also the 60s so the tickets probably cost a dime. Fuck old people. I like how they're all telling stories it's a treat to listen to. Good speeding song ngl. The rover would love this. I like that it's live he has an amazing stage presence from what I can hear but I also don't gaf what he's yapping about on stage unfortunately. Me when I walk the line. I really like the way you can hear the audience. Big fan of what's going on. Oh I'm not the biggest fan of June Carter's voice. Bro has mad beef with this place. Justice for Sue lowkey. I know Folsom Prison Blues of course. Favourite: Wanted Man Least favourite: Darlin' Companion.
4 for the music + bonus point for performance.
I like him because i remember my mam!
One of country musics GOAT. Great voice, and music. His sound does and will span generations.
Classic live album great songs and very funny
I'm not the biggest live music as an album fan, but I definitely enjoyed that addition to this album. It felt less like a recorded live performance and more like a man in the back of a bar playing his heart out.
Absolutely amazing!
One of my all-time favorite Johnny Cash albums, easily a solid 5-star classic. That said, I'd skip the "Legacy Edition" entirely and go for the original vinyl (or standard release) instead. The bonus tracks featuring Carl Perkins, The Carter Family, and The Statler Brothers don't really add much value to the core experience.
This was a good time.
Really fantastic playing and a great atmosphere but a bit too much faff and a repeated song stop it getting full marks. Still a classic though!
One of the greatest live albums ever recorded. It’s impossible to listen to this and not feel how special this moment was to the men who were there.
Full disclosure, I am, and always will be a sucker for Cash, driving lonesome Southwestern highways in a car packed full of my family and pets listening to CDs of classic country punctuated my childhood at regular and memorable intervals. I have a particular penchant for his live albums, especially the great "At Folsom Prison". There is something about their exemplary status in showing the effect of music as a form of connection and communication, and in a prison with the purported dregs of society, an attempt by an artist very conscious of class to use it to reach and share a moment with those outcast, forgotten, and locked away from greater society. On "At San Quentin", recorded solely a year later, and missing a recently deceased member of Cash's band- guitarist Luther Perkins, Cash sounds older, more tired, and more disillusioned than on "Folsom". This isn't to knock the performance, as it's all still top notch, outside of a few small snafus vocally from Cash. It's really more of note to see how the outlaw country legend of Cash himself was formed- the infamous "middle finger" photo was taken at this set- and it's all the more iconic for it. A lean 35 minute album, with several tracks from the live performance omitted, and somewhat erroneously including both the first performance of and audience requested encore of "San Quentin", a two covers in "Wanted Man" and "Darlin' Companion", and some of his classics, the album stands out in its firsts of previewing newly written material - "San Quentin", "Starkville County Jail" and the first ever recording of the great "A Boy Named Sue"- with all the grit, beer suds, blood and brooding Cash is known for. An all-time great live country album, even if it pales in comparison to the kinetic social statement of "Folsom". Favorite Track: "A Boy Named Sue" Least Favorite Track: "San Quentin (Reprise)" - An unnecessary inclusion. "You put the screws on me, I'll screw right out from under ya... I'm tired of all that shit."
This may not be the best pure musical performance, even by Cash's standards, but the context elevates it to such an insane degree. Without getting on my soap box too much about how nice it is to hear outlaw country from a time when they were actually anti-establishment and not just a bunch of performative trope usage to familiar instrumentation and themes, the man brought his family band to perform in a prison. A lot of people cultivate or play up the outlaw image, but wouldn't be caught dead in a room with one of the thousand inmates Cash saw that day. A pretty limited track list and probably not the best acoustic environment (not to mention the mid-set re-tune), this isn't really the most outstanding and well executed album even in Cash's discography. But, the visceral human element is so absurdly gripping. From the famous middle finger picture to Cash's jokes with the crowd to a duet with his new wife June, it's just so much more than the music.
This album has great energy and you can feel the electricity of the prison crowd reacting to every line. Johnny Cash clearly commands the room, and the rebellious spirit of the performance is fun to hear. But since I’m not a big country fan, a lot of the songs just don’t do much for me musically even though I can appreciate the moment and the atmosphere.
I am of the belief that all music sounds better live and this is not an exception. It can’t be understated how much I usually do not enjoy country music, but I was actually pleasantly surprised. The songs were fine, though they were definitely not anything special. The saving grace of this album is the atmosphere it creates, how the crowd interacts with the songs and the interactions with the artist on stage. Additionally, Johnny cash’s charisma really shines here. With that being said, this is definitely a one time listen for me, it’s nice but it just doesn’t have that repeatability. Still, such a charming album, and by the end I found myself growing quite fond of it.
Highlights: I Walk The Line, Starkville City Jail, San Quentin, A Boy Named Sue, Folsom City Blues Lowlights: ---------------------------------- Johnny Cash showing humanity still exists in inhumane places. Great performance and banter.
Cash is great, live albums can be tough
First time I have listened. Very cool. The banter is very funny considering the audience.
Same as the previous one - raw, down-to-earth and wholesome experience, definitely a masterpiece ❣️
Love Johnny Cash!!!!!
The live prison albums by Johnny Cash are very unique and this one is really good. The banter between the crowd and Johnny Cash is pretty funny and I like outlaw country from that era, making this a very good album.
Amazing. What an absolute legend. Love, love, love the live element - chatting, joking with the inmates. His voice. His storytelling. It's all near perfection. Can't pick a favorite! I listened to this a few times back-to-back and it's now in my collection. Thank you, Mr. Cash for gracing us with your brilliance.
Very effective stunt, singing prison tunes to prisoners, didn’t think I’d jive with the stunt. But it works, it’s ramshackle, loose, loud, sad, funny, visceral.
the British documentary can be found on YouTube. worth watching.
Clearly this is one where the relationship with the audience is the point, more than the songs or the performance itself, and it is extremely moving. Hard to believe that Nixon invited him to play at the White House after this.
electric
Classic Johnny Cash. Good background listening music.
What a classic piece of history. A country star playing in prisons and recording it, all in the 1960s. What a fucking legend. The noises from the crowd and the dialogue in between is just so authentic and the old mics just give this record an incredible, nostalgic analogue warmth that can never be replicated.
очень спокойный такой вайбовый альбом мне оч понравилось но в плейлист не добавил бы
Ah, my final Johnny Cash album and my final album of the 1960’s. It’s been a hot minute since I’ve reviewed an album by The Man in Black, so I’m glad to see him today. Johnny Cash isn’t the type of music that I normally gravitate towards, but I appreciate his artistry and what his career did for music. I was talking to a friend of mine last night, discussing a documentary about the prison system in Alabama, so it’s apt that I would get this album today. Time for a trip down to San Quentin. I thought this live effort from Johnny Cash was fine. I’m picky about country music, and this album was a bit boring to me, but the live aspect of it was great. The sounds of the prisoners cheering created a really unique atmosphere for this album. I can't imagine what it would have been like to perform for a bunch of incarcerated men, and trying to give them an energetic performance without blowing the lid off the place and causing a riot. How crazy is it that the only choice these men were probably able to make that day was which song they wanted to hear Johnny Cash play? I liked Johnny’s gentle ribbing of the guards, and his banter made this performance really unique. Of particular interest to me was Johnny talking about how he didn’t like being told what to sing and where to stand. I think it goes to show that record executives and other people on the business side of music have been shit heads for quite a while, sticking their noses into decisions that should be left up to the artists. When it comes to the actual music on this album, I wasn’t blown away, but I didn’t hate it either. “I Walk the Line” and “A Boy Named Sue” are classics, and it was great to hear them in this live setting, especially as Johnny chuckled his way through “A Boy Named Sue.” The song that stood out to me the most though was “Wreck of the Old 97.” The guitar work was fantastic, and I loved how the percussion sounded like a train chugging along. I feel like the live aspect took away some of the emotional weight of the more serious songs on this album, but on “Wreck of the Old 97,” that weight was still there. While this album may not be up to my personal tastes, I think it’s an important piece of music and pop culture history. Johnny Cash has become like a folk figure of sorts, and this album shows just why that is.
Maybe not his best performance but certainly an iconic one. We see Cash's audacious solidarity with the prisoners over and against the label and the guards while not alienating or othering anyone. And the reaction to Folsom Prison Blues, wch is of course about a different prison and comes after a song written for their prison, speaks to the way the universal shines through the particular.
Likes: Cash’s attitude, charisma, and banter; great shuffling rhythms; feedback loop and interplay with the crowd Dislikes: sound quality is rough; including both cuts of the song San Quentin if cool from the perspective of leaving the performance as it was, but isn’t necessary: shortened version of Folsom Prison Blues Overall, a great record that demonstrates Cash’s greatest talent - turning casual shuffles and talkative lyrics into definitive statements of truth that resonate with many different artists
I really liked this one
4.8
Favourite Songs: Starkville City Jail San Quentin A Boy Named Sue
This is fine but I am just not a huge fan of a live album
It’s seldom a good idea to draw from the same well twice, but damn if the man in black doesn’t make it work.
Raw, rowdy, and basically Folsom Prison: Part II. Cash sounds great, the inmates are loud, and the whole thing crackles with energy. But as good as it is, it’s hard not to feel like the 1001 list didn’t need both this and Folsom when they cover such similar territory. A strong live record—just not a revelation if you’ve already done the first one.
excellent album, often absurd and surrealist in the content
Meh. San Quentin was a funny song but I’m not a big Cash guy
ehh 2
# Album Name: At San Quentin # Artist: Cash # Rating: 4/5 # Comments: Usual cash vibes Good live album Banger # Top Tunes: Walk the line / maybe sue / FPB # Would I listen to it again? Yes
4/5
4/5
vibes were immaculate and the audience were immaculate-er.
Strange to think that gigs like this used to be played in prisons. Can’t imagine it happening now.
Pretty cool very interesting
The booing at the guards got me
Glad the list accommodates the occasional live album. This is another one that - like Sam Cooke's Live at the Harlem Square Club - feels like a fascinating little window into another moment.
Heard Before? I knew all the songs but not this recording. Notes: - started off with the original release, then thanks to Allmusic, heard the legacy edition. - the revue format of the show is exciting. stellar performances from all the supporting acts. - some of the rawest, most thrilling versions of any of these songs. - production suited the material perfectly, gritty and almost overdriven. - one of the only live albums where I was happy to hear the crowd noise. - even the stage banter has replay value. I was riveted. - June Carter blew me away. Verdict: Original album: ho hum redux of "at Folsom Prison". Legacy edition: essential. Easily one of my favorite country albums and one of my favorite live albums. How did I not hear this before? Listen Again? Yes yes yes.
What an album to start on! I’m a sucker for live albums and this might just be the best one I’ve heard. Cash is funny as hell, the crowd is lively, a guard gets booed! I haven’t listened to much Johnny Cash before this and I feel like I’ve been missing out. The music is so energetic, I can’t get enough of those drums and oo the guitar is to die for. I love this album so much.
Old Good Johnny
Great album, great live energy. Did not need “San Quentin” twice.
You know what, I actually really enjoyed listening to this album, I never normally like live albums but this one was quite good. Still think there doesn’t need to be as much cheering in the audio after songs but hey ho. Im sorry but Johnny Cash was that guy, I feel like he just was. I knew a few of his songs before today, walk the line being the only one I knew prior to listening to this album. However, I feel like I did enjoy listening to all the tracks, the overall performance was simple but very entertaining. A very charismatic performer, the songs make you feel like a cowboy roaming the wild west and who doesn’t want to be that. Standout songs ‘walk the line’, ‘a boy named sue’ and ‘San quentin’.
Live albums don't really do it for me in general but this one is fun I have to say.
There was so much joy in this! Is this something I'd seek out on my own? No probably not. But am I glad I listened to it all? Yes, absolutely!
i love a good live album! johnny cash is a silly guy... i don't know if it's just the version i listened to but the censor bleeps took me out of it LOL. johnny's music has never quite been my thing and he seems very tired and frustrated in this one which, like, fair. a couple nice ones here of course
No demi estilo
I love Johnny Cash and can respect his playing shoes for inmates but I’m not crazy about the recording and set here.
Great live album. And Johnny Cash is awesome.
Very enjoyable. Would listen again.
No private session used for Spotify. Love his voice. Nice to hear these songs in a different recording. Everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves, which is the point of live music. It's a classic for sure.
Mys pys. Lite insikt på nån konsert nån gång för länge sen
No notes.
Good.
johnny cash has powerful stage presence, also seems like a fun man, loved his attitude and integrity. not really my usual type of music but the liveliness and context (prison performance and his open judgement of penal system) made it even better. his comments and laughs made it feel humane! he was the first of his kind so giving it a 3 seems low. also since my initial listen my favourites have been “I Walk the Line” and “(There’ll Be) Peace in the Valley”, honourable mention “Darlin’ Companion”
Great performance, great energy. I like that they kept the stage banter in there as part of the recording.
Very cool that it was recorded at San Quentin. Johnny Cash is true Americana
he just talks :(
too much talking
Was pretty good. 3.5
Amazing storytelling, Boy Named Sue is a classic. A bit same-y for me but he's so charismatic it doesn't matter
Songs are great but not a fan of live albums.
Excellent album, improved only by the reissue including a ton of extra tracks. Love Johnny’s prison albums. Probably slightly prefer Folsom overall but this is great. 4.5
I like what some lyrics say, but nothing more. I didn't like it. The album has a repetitive rhythm and I can't help but feel like I'm listening to children's music
Not as good as Folsom Prison.
This isn’t something that I would put on just to listen to, I mean it’s ok as a live album, but it really feels more like an important historical document. Totally understand why its on the list, glad to have listened to it,
Gotta love Johnny
O Johnny Cash é um ótimo artista. Porém não achei este álbum muito bom. Por ele ser um cantor famoso esperava mais deste álbum, que é a gravação de um show que ele fez. As músicas são muito simples e monótonas, não é algo que eu escutaria sempre, porém não é totalmente ruim, é um álbum muito comum. Por isso minha nota é 2.5/5. Está na média, mas não achei muito interessante.
What a great performer. What a legend.
Not as good as Folsom but worth a listen
Another classic by the best
One of the most special live performances I've ever heard. His personality shines through in every song and segueway too.
Very nice, upbeat. Singer has a nice, slightly old, sense of humour. Country isn’t exactly my thing, though.
A clear rapport with his audience makes this a very enjoyable album
Imagine today’s version of this. It would suck. This didn’t.
I like Johnny Cash and this album is one of the iconic live albums made.
I've believed Johnny Cash is my favorite country artist for a while now, and this list has done nothing so far to change my mind about it. Even so, it's not like this piece of work is right up my alley. I respect the persona, the cadence, the energy. I think it's pretty cool how rowdy the crowd/inmates get. I'm not typically one to applaud censored music (I've been listening to the original release), but for this one it just puts you right in the middle of that historic moment. I'm from the other side of the world, but Johnny mentions this is being broadcast to England and I can just imagine myself in an English suburb watching this on a boxy tv. You can catch the full show on youtube, it's a different track list, feels just as raw as I'd hoped. This is the album that first features A Boy Named Sue, there's a lot of history here, Shel Silverstein being such a well known children's poet and making very adult poetry. If you're looking for a rabbit hole, go find the second part of that piece. It's amazing how far a good writer can go when they're not being held back. I think overall this isn't an album I'd listen to very often, but if I had a physical copy I'd give it an occasional spin. It puts you in a good mood, it's a fun listen. 3.6/5
Saved 4/31. His voice is incredible and I love the concept but an entire album hearing applause was too much. It took me out of the songs.
His live commentary was entertaining. Not sure that it added to this album specifically, but I could see how it would impact his performances. He was a great live musician, and that comes through in this live album recording.
not listening to ts
"so what do you want to hear?" A critique of 1001 Albums as a whole: I understood the significance of a johnny cash prison album from the other one I heard two weeks ago. I did not need to listen to two before I died.
i’ve listened to this before
I like his voice and the themes of the songs. Censoring swearing is so corny
CLASSIC LOVE IT
Excellent stuff.
I love Johnny Cash's voice and enjoy his guitar work. Not always big on live albums, but it's cool to hear his rapport and connection with the inmates.
This was such a fun listen. I've never been one to think I'd like Johnny Cash, but every track was so enjoyable. It definitely helped that it felt like I was at a concert. It was fun to hear him talking to the crowd and them responding. This album was amazing.
Love it !! …. At San Quentin held my attention from the start, I was excited by this choice. I like live albums and this one feels direct and unpolished in a way I enjoy. I did not really know what to expect, but I stayed with it. I like hearing the reactions and the atmosphere. It sounds real. Cash sounds comfortable being there and that comes through. It is not slick and I would not want it to be. I enjoyed it because it feels honest and present. 4 stars 😊
Cash is King
The music was pretty decent but the entertainment value of the album itself bumps this up a notch.
wow that entire album put a big smile on my face. listening to all the chatter and happiness amongst Johnny and crowd - amazing. What a treat that they recorded this and released it.
Great man. Would've been awesome to have seen him live.
Fav: San Quentin (Reprise) Honorable mention: Darlin’ Companion 4/5
Too long, listened to some. Liked their little jokes.
Very good. Haven’t ever listened to it before! Amazed at how this ever came about
What an awesome and intimate performance by Johnny Cash. 5/5
I think a 5? Quintessential live record that is enjoyable more because of the performance than necessarily the music
everything kind of sounded the same, but country's not bad!
What an album!! That was just enjoyable to listen too
Loved it, no notes.
This is the first time I've listened to this kind of old-fashioned music, and it's quite positive and interesting in places. The live performance itself is memorable for the interaction with the audience. Rate 5/10
A classic live performance. Great music and great dialogue between songs. What an atmosphere.
There's probably an argument that if you've got the Folsom Prison live album on the list, you don't need this too. However, they're both fantastic – and if I have to give one the edge, it's San Quentin. (Cash is pretty funny here, but the real comedy genius might be the prisoner who shouts "get on with it!" during the intro to Walk the Line. Did he have somewhere better to be?)
When to listen: Not sure I would again, not because it isn't amazing just because I don't need to. Great album, great music, but it just... is.
There’s something so epic about singing outlaw country live in a prison. Good stuff Johnny Cash
Imagine being arrested and when you are in the prison, Johnny Cash do a show for all the prisoners.... He was genius and he knew it.
Happy to get this album this morning. Didn't expect the "Legacy Edition" to be 2 albums. I'm actually enjoying this first album. I'd say this would normally get a 3, but given its a live album, recorded in a prison, gets it an extra star.
Arguably one of the best live albums ever recorded, not just because of the unique setting. Cash is a great performer, an entertainer with a heartwarming attitude that knows exactly how he deals with the problematic setting here.
So much love was put into this performance. A true classic.
Completely incredible. Cash's voice is divine, the humour between songs and the honesty of the prison system. Wow wow wow.
Actually so cool
The Good: Nothing The Bad: My mood The Ugly: Fucking look on my face as I realize I am getting screwed… I have been looking at this journey the wrong way… this is not meant as a journey to appreciate music. No sir, it isn’t. Instead, we are on this journey to see how long it takes before we start contemplating that maybe, just maybe, we have better things to do with our time than to sit around and let the likes of Mr Dimery fuck with us… When I saw the album cover, my first thought was “but, I’ve already listened to this…” to find out that I was mistaken about the prison where it was recorded. Now, don’t get me wrong, I can appreciate that there are plenty of people who rank this album very high on the list of album one needs to listen to before one dies, and I will not sit here and pretend that it isn’t so… Though technically this is not a greatest hits album, which would exclude it from the list, it gets pretty close to it… and still a monster album such as Saturday Night Fever is not on this list, because it is an amalgamation of several artist… Out of spite I am giving this album a 1* and I really hope that tomorrow a smile is on my face as the next album is being presented, as I am finding the past 2 weeks to be the worse so far in this journey that is starting to turn into a fucking nightmare…. Playing the album Pulse, by Pink Floyd to get the bad taste out of my mouth… Also, listened to the album and I can’t, in good conscious, raate this 1* However, seeing as I still don’t understand why this album is on the list, I will bump it up…. the album should be at least 3*
Great with the crowd
Iconic performance! But - as always - I rate it down just because it is a live album. 2,5
Listened to the OG release and had a few criticisms about brevity, but then realised this is for the Legacy Edition which captures pretty much the whole gig! Straight off the bat, this is a much better edition. June comes across as a fierce performer in her own right, not just John's wife. The warm up tracks by Carl Perkins and the Statler brothers are a fantastic addition. Overall this pitches it up into "one of the greatest live albums ever" territory. Very atmospheric.
I'd love more live albums from prisons. What an absolute legend. I love Johnny Cash. I hadn't listened to him in a while and this hit just right.
Its incredible this and all of the other prison albums ever got recorded, let alone performed. Truly incredible. This is such a classic live album, the way that he plays into and for the audience. He gets them. He plays songs for them, shows empathy for their condition and creates a truly human experience for them. Brilliant. His band is tight, the songs are perfect. The lyrics hit home. He plays his big songs, he plays new songs and old timey classics. He blew it out of the park with this one.
This was awesome, I'd never listened before. A live album like this really put you there.
Johnny Cash is always great! Ring of Fire!
Classic! Favorite track: boy named sue other picks: wreck of the old, I walk the line
Yeah, it’s a bop. I don’t know if I’ll ever not loathe pop country, but old timey country western like this? It’s all right. It certainly has its place.
Johnny Cash is a pretty cool cat and a great entertainer. Man, he's also proving himself to be a king of outlaw country. I knew he was an outlaw country kind of guy, but this is a whole other level. I'm not the biggest fan of live albums, but this one is definitely worth listening to. Cash has a great time interacting with the crowd and is clearly there for them and to have a good time. And the bits and moments between songs don't take away from the actual songs themselves. Favorite Song(s): I Walk the Line, Boy Named Sue
I liked it, would listen to again, and might even go listen to more Johnny Cash.
Great fun
This album is so charged with tension and emotion, anything could happen. Johnny Cash understands the prisoners so well, and has them so hooked they could riot any second. Love this album.
Huge album. There won’t be many folk/country albums I am rating five stars, but the songs, the banter…it’s all gold
Lots of fun! I love how Johnny's character comes through in the recordings.
Don't like this style of country particularly. Very samey. Much prefer Johnny Cash latter output. That being said, it's a unique album and interesting listen between songs.
Singular voice that somehow matches the content of the songs perfectly. And although the sharp, steady guitar playing evokes dusty, spare, empty places, the angry warmth of Cash's singular, authentic voice is strange comforting company. Although I appreciate it, I've never really connected with it, and so have never put it on.
Album: At San Quentin Artists: Johnny Cash First spin mood: I was really excited when I saw his name pop up because I’ve never really listened to his music other than the popular songs (ring of fire lol). So it got me thinking that I can see what’s all the motion behind him. With this being a live album it exposed me to the great performer he is, the way he interacts and gets the crowd going. Feels like you have been life time friends. I enjoyed the music a lot especially a boy named sue, walk the line and wanted man. I felt like San Quentin the song was a bit of a milk from being arrested for picking some flowers haha What it stirred in me: curiosity and mystery One lyric or sound that stayed with me: definitely the plot twist in a boy named sue with that being his father, so wholesome yet fucked Where I was: working outside in the trenches on a snowy day, pretty shit weather but music always has a way of making things lighter What I felt: I felt cool to get an in on Johnny cash
great album
bella, anche il fatto che sia in live in prigione, il fra mi sembra un tipo simpatico e in generale apprezzo questo genere e queste vibes
I usually hate live albums--I can't stand the artists' chatter and the audience reactions, but I quite like Johnny Cash's plain-spoken criticism of the prison system and law enforcement. His attitude backs up the music.
This is alright, though I definitely feel like I didn't need two prison-based live albums from the same artist. Plenty of the songs are good. The raucous energy of the crowd adds something. But then it gets kind of annoying having all the cheers after every bad thing Cash sings about their prison in "San Quentin". The in-between banter is mildly fun at best, and cringe-worthy at worst. "Huh, the record producers want me to stand in a particular spot, but I do what I want man" seems like a cheap way to get a cheer from your (literally) captive audience. It's a good listen overall, but not more than that. 3*
Johnny Cash’s singing and lyrics are amazing - the guitar on this album was just very boring. Like taking a Casio and pressing the preset beat and doing a full album to it. He’s witty and fun and great - and all the songs probably sound twice as good when recorded in a studio. For some this version might be their favorite! But not as much for me.
Listening session: january 9th, while fixing up a wooden cabinet at my parents house Listened to before: many times, mainly when my father listened to this when I was a child Thoughts: this album is such a classic and even though I’ve heard it many times before, it was nice to listen to it front to back again Favourite tracks: A Boy Named Sue, I Walk the Line & (There’ll Be) Peace in the Valley
That was wild! This is the Johnny Cash I think of when I hear his name. Not sure I've heard another live album or an actual live performance, for that matter, where the same song was played twice in succession! I guess if the inmates are yelling at you to play the song again, you play the song again?
Was really good. 4.1
Not as strong as At Fulsom, but can listen to it top to bottom. Would love to check out the film and full set list. Boy Named Sue
I really liked it, it was fun! The folk influences make everything feel so lively.
я не хочу знову слухати кантрі Джоні кеша
Johnny Cash is Johnny Cash. You won’t be surprised at what you hear when you listen to one of his albums. The biggest thing for me with a live album is the artist and crowd interactions. If there is no interactions then there’s no quality to the album. Plain and simple. This is an album that makes you feel like you are there . Choice cut: A Boy Named Sue
Another re-listen for me. This one is somewhat (rightfully) overshadowed by the Folsom Prison album but Cash was electric in both musical performance and commentary.
Great sound. Unique voice. Recording a live performance at a prison should be a requirement for all musicians.
Johnny Cash's prison albums are great, but really feel kinda dated. However, they are still a fantastic listen, and better than most of his studio stuff.
Maybe it was just the sound quality, or the fact that I've never been in prison, but this didn't resonate with me at all.
4.0/5 - I like the personality of Cash, fun album, classic tunes. Liked the immediate encore of San Quentin.
Why is this all Johnny Cash albums, if the next one is also Johnny Cash I’m gonna be so mad
This was great! I think the only thing I had heard off here prior was the "Boy Named Sue" rendition, but this whole things was awesome!
A classic, easy 4 stars. I enjoyed the music as well as the banter throughout the album.
lots of talking but the songs on their own are good cash was a funny guy
The vibe is spot on. Production quality is (perhaps understandably) a little meh, especially in the first leg of the record, but adds to the atmosphere. Curious to see the visuals now.
Live albums shouldn't be on list. There was another Johnny cash live album on this list. That's way too much. I gave the other one 5. This will have to be less
30. not bad lots of speaking
I don't normally enjoy live albums, as they are usually inferior to studio recordings of the same material, but this is a fantastic exception.
Incredibly good. All of it. The idea, the music, the fact that it’s live.
Essential piece of country music history, I grew up on many of these songs and the electricity and chaos of hearing them at a show like that really just makes them all that much more dear. This album is though, more importantly, an invaluable anti-carceral document. The degree to which we have dehumanized incarcerated people is brought into harsh focus by evidence of when it didn’t use to be like that. Not that prison has been good or effective at any point, but whoa holy shit what do you mean this abolitionist artist was doing shows IN PRISONS? WHAT DO YOU MEAN?? Listening to him talk to them like peers, like they’re just playing in a bar? Bringing music and levity and respect to these people who are being very explicitly denied those things? That made me cry hard a couple times in and of itself, culminating in his performing San Quentin (which I forgot he had written the night before?!) the cheering is so loud and they play it twice in a row :’) I just think we could all stand to be reminded more frequently of our history. We consider the past barbaric in a way we’ve improved on, but that’s just not the case. As the technology to punish people has advanced, we have applied it to our carceral system at every turn, and we’ve lost the plot of our humanity entirely. People have always been people. And everyone alive deserves dignity.
Johnny Cash was such a good performer! A good album, but I question why there needed to be two of his prison series on this list when the man had something like 70 albums Fav songs: I Walk the Line
Nice change, interesting concept of an musician performing at a jail. Don't think that happens any more
Another album I would never, ever have listened to, if not for undertaking this listen of the 1001 albums. I probably won't reach for it again, but it was really interesting to listen to. I enjoyed the stories and camaraderie.
The Man in Black Challenging the system!
folter . jeder song ist gleich . san quentin am besten ig
Absolute classic Johnny Cash. At the peak of his creative period.
Throughly enjoyed the chatting and crowd work between the songs. You could tell this was Cash wanting to play the show on his terms and for the people.
Not really the type of music I would see myself listening
6/20 J'ai eu l'impression d'écouter la même musique en boucle pendant 30 minutes. (Accentué par le fait qu'il joue, en effet, déjà deux fois la même musique). La musique n'est pas désagréable a écouter au début, mais au bout d'une ou deux chansons, ça commence a taper sur les nerfs. Ce ne sera pas la note minimale quand même, mais on s'en approche malheureusement. Ce n'est définitivement pas pour moi.
love live sessions, not much a fan of country music
I feel like back in Johnny Cash’s day, prison concerts were more of a thing and apparently good PR and a hit record to boot. I can’t imagine anyone doing that in this day and age. Imagine Taylor Swift at a women’s correctional facility playing songs while inmates make friendship bracelets and call it their “personal accountability era”. Actually, we all know the Swifties would eat that up, but besides the point. Anyway, I did not enjoy this album, not a fan of Cash, but it was interesting to say the least.
An iconic album in history due to being recorded inside San Quentin prison. Johnny Cash has one of the most recognizable voices and this album is full of popular songs that are supported all along the way by the cheers and laughs of the inmates. Cash is one of those unique artists that will never be duplicated.
The man in black commanding the stage and the audience in a way few performers ever could. Both Cash and the band were a little out of tune and out of sync in places but the overall effect was a fun, rollicking good time for all of the murders and rapists in the audience. Great sense of being there with this album.
This is little more than a Johnny Cash publicity stunt. Man in black performing in a prison....again... how bad ass. What annoys me most is all the banter, 30 minute album (thank goodness) of which he yammered on about nothing for a third of that time. Even worse, this isn't interesting storytelling banter, it was nonsense...look at us, we're in prison, I got arrested too, screw the man...blah blah blah. Insufferable, if you're going to record concert for release just perform the damn songs with minimal banter. The songs were actually good, cool versions of Boy Named Sue, Walk the Line and Folsom Prison Blues. It's a shame the lead ins took longer than the song.
Not my thing
One of my favorite live albums
The prisoners are the stars of the show.
Definitely a good glimpse into why Johnny Cash is so revered. The songs can be a little same-y but the performances and the rapport with the audience and band are great.
really makes you realise how great country music can be. very remarkable live album i must say!
The second of Cash's live prison albums, following Folsom Blues. I only listened to the original release here (33 mins), not the full set, though I will have to do that too. Great live album, as expected and deserves the hype. I Walk The Line and A Boy Named Sue featured and he gets his Mrs and friends up on stage too. He's pretty funny and charming in the interludes, makes you want to hear more of this sort of shit.
Johnny Cash is on fire in this album and is quick with a joke. The music sounds good and his voice as well. I just wish I was more into country as a genre, it’s not really my favourite. And to whatever producer or engineer that bleeped out his swearing: f*ck you
Ignoring the 1 octave vocal range, this is a great live album. Humour and some great uptempo music.
It was a really fun and simple album, i love his style of storytelling. Now its not an album with songs i’d listen to on the regular, but they are for sure great songs
This album is not my usual type of music, and thought I would not like it when I heard the beginning of the first song. However, I really enjoyed the first song, Wanted Man, which really changed my perception of the album as a whole. I disliked the second song, Wreck of the Old 97, but I think that’s because it’s a more fast paced song as compared to Wanted Man. The third song, I Walk the Line, was better than the second one, but because of the fast pace of the song, I again did not like it was much as the first. The fourth song, Darlin Companion, was a duet with his wife, and I really enjoyed it. The two voiced meshed together beautifully and I really liked the calmness of the song. The fifth song, Starkville City Jail, was very good as well. The little background story Johnny Cash told beforehand was funny. I did not like the sixth song, San Quentin, was much, but to me, it seemed more of a monologue to appeal to the audience, and less of a song, similarly with San Quentin (Reprise), the seventh song. The eight song, A Boy Named Sue, was again, not a song I enjoyed very much. Majority of the songs seemed to be used as storytelling devices, which is something I do not particularly enjoy, which is probably the main reason why this album is not up my ally. The ninth song, (There'll be) Peace in the Valley, was a song I did enjoy. It was more musical than the other songs that I did not like, and I really liked the beautiful background vocals. Finally, the last song, Folsom Prison Blues was upbeat and fast paced, but surprisingly, I enjoyed it. It was a good song to end the album with. Overall, the genre and style of music was not to my taste, but I was still able to appreciate the album, especially after learning about the backstory and creation of it.
I just can't make myself like it but I appreciate it
Second live Johnny Cash album I’ve been assigned in almost as many weeks. I’m becoming a Cash convert. The banter is as much as a star as the songs. 4/5
It's a great live album. Johnny's music is a remedy for the soul. It's a great sounding album, for the fact it's from the 60s and recorded in a prison. The only bad thing I can say is the fact that there aren't more songs. 5/5
Classic. Haven’t listened to it in forever.
Not quite the album Folsom is - that one is more primal and Cash isn’t quite as off the rails. Certainly understandable as Luther had only been dead a few months. The legacy edition is the better version. A Boy Named Sue is hands down the draw to this almost as great great album.
It must have been a great day to be a serial killer in San Quentin that day. I mean, Johnny friggin’ Cash played a concert for them. Those lucky undeserving (BLEEP).
its just ok
Country music is still not my cup of tea. But I was surprised that Johnny Cash was signing this type of music. I was under impression that his discography was super close to NIN cover
This is how you do a live album. The audience energy makes the whole thing better instead of being distracting. Cash's interactions with the audience might just be better than the music.
Iconic live album, delivered with authority, grace and humor and raucously appreciated by the captive audience. They had a ball. No scramble for tickets for this one!
Fav: A boy named Sue Very entertaining and visual album, felt like you were in the jail stomping along with him
Groundbreaking and a good storyteller, but better albums exists
Not my taste, personally. But ideal to hear in a prison in the late 60s, I guess.
Very enjoyable live album. Johnny at his peak and a great band keeping up with him.
liked it, was not my cup of tea but was still quite fun.
Día 4: mmmm el country realmente no es lo mío. De todos modos debería escucharlo una vez más en otro ambiente que no sea el gimnasio porque no es la combinación ideal. Por otro lado Johnny Cash se manda un unipersonal en el medio del show, lo banco.
I feel a bit underwhelmed. I had really high expectations because of how good the Folsom Prison album is, but I just feel like that was much better. There is some great stuff here, the songs are all great and Cash’s performance is strong, but I feel like it lacks that Folsom energy. It’s still a pretty good live album, though. 3/5
Me ha encantado.
mta falação, mta alegria por parte do pessoal privado de liberdade… bão
mais uma dele na prisão, hein. novamente, bela setlist, apenas criminalidades e a plateia enlouquecendo. esse aqui parece bem mais divertido que o outro. o público e o próprio cash tão bem animados. mas ainda eh johnny cash.
A true classic.
Prefer Folsom but definitely special in its purpose and place.
Beautiful background story I didn’t know of yet but I discovered the country style here annoyed me a bit. For me the songs are too specific. But I enjoyed the interactions in the songs and discovering all about this initiative, really heartwarming. Such a legend.
i loved this, maybe country really is my thing. god bless john cash indeed, this was such a cool album and wow when he sang san quentin... so electric.
While I love attending concerts and shows, with rare exception, I do not particularly care for live albums. I’m not there, I don’t need to hear banter with a crowd I’m not a part of.
great companion to 'Live at Folsom Prison' and some comedy skits inbetween
Pues me gustó, me interesó más que gustarme. Sobre todo me gustó la canción donde dice que San Quentin You were hell to me o algo así. No es mi estilo pero me interesó
This is a full concert recorded that Johnny performed at San Quentin PRISON! It doesn't cut any of his interactions with the crowd; you can tell Johnny Cash is incredibly charismatic & likeable. I really enjoyed the music, his voice is so recognizable and consistent. The song Starkville City Jail was particularly memorable (& funny)—it's a true story about Johnny going on a peaceful walk, picking flowers, then getting arrested & thrown in jail. The crowd was laughing along to each line. San Quentin offered some interesting criticisms on prisons & how they "[do] no good." Really bold of Johnny to shit on San Quentin while performing there! It didn't register for me until now that he was performing at a prison. -> The crowd clearly resonated with this song, asking him to play it again & he immediately did! He also cheekily had the (prison) guards get him a cup of water in between. He got a ton of applause after the reprise. A Boy Named Sue was another memorable song—really strong storytelling. Apparently written by Shel Silverstein??? I do think I would be able to pick up more details about the music in a studio version, but I think hearing him live really brings me there and helps me get a better sense of the kind of person Johnny was.
I think live albums are great if you already love the music. Hard to listen to while working, which is how I go through this list.
Would sound better if it wasn’t all live
Didn't realize this was actually recorded in the prison. Classic Cash, fun to have his interludes.
not my type of album tbh but still a good one
Cash is a master at storytelling
The album is an overall great listen, it has a consistent light mood and joyful beat through the 10 tracks and I like his lyricism all the songs on the album are pretty well written and I feel like he’s telling me a story each song. His vocals aren’t dramatic but he is a good singer and I would listen to the album again, I even added songs like wanted man, I walk the line, San Quentin, and wreck of the old ‘97
all the different versions of this have such different track lists, so I listened to the original which has bleeps on it when Johnny swears in front of the sensitive ears of San Quentin prison. I was born in 1989 so I grew up with Johnny Cash as a child and then when I came of independent musical taste age all Johnny Cash was doing was that awful series of cover albums with Rick Rubin's record label.
Track 1 - 9/10 Track 2 - 8/10 Track 3 - 10/10 Track 4 - 10/10 Track 5 - 9/10 Track 6 - 8/10 Track 7 - 8/10 Track 8 - 9/10 Track 9 - 9/10 Track 10 - 10/10 Overall - 9/10
The songs are great, but the banter is greater. His talking ties everything together perfectly, although the censorship beeps are very abrasive. I would have Luigi Mangioned to get myself to that gig.
non penso la musica da cowboy faccia per me, testi troppi letterali e descrittivi; ogni canzone mi sembra uguale alle altre (?) ma forse solo perchè non sono appassionata e nemmeno me ne intendo di questo genere, forse è più divertente da cantare che da ascoltare; però il piede si muove nevertheless it's kinda starting to grow on me, sono come delle barzellette, delle storie cantate A boy named Sue kinda Olivia Rodrigo vibes nel narrare
Super fun! His live stuff is great, even the conversations with the crowd.
Grandios!
My quest to find a Country album that is actually worth listening to has so far been fruitless. But today we have Johnny Cash, the dude everyone who hates Country music, likes. I've heard plenty of Cash songs before - I don't dislike him, but I don't love him even as much as those other County haters do. Next up - I think only an exceptional Live album should ever be on this list, exceptional both because of the performances, the songs, and the surrounding circumstances. Unplugged In New York for example. Will this hit the spot? It gets off to a solid start, by bringing other artists and some of their hits. Thankfully the opening songs are not Country, so it gets me into a positive mood. There's good crowd noise, banter, interaction. June Carter brings the first Country song, and it isn't terrible. It's flirtatious and fun. She then raps out some farm-related poetry. You have to wait a while for Johnny to join. Cash is better than most Country vocalists because he doesn't sound Country - no whining, no hootin' and a hollerin'. He doesn't exactly have a voice for melody, but he gets his point across clearly. The up-tempo songs work because they boil with energy, and there's none of that dreary violin or steel guitar nonsense. A lot of the inherent garbage of the genre is here - the same melodies and rhythm which you can immediately pull from memory and instantly craft a new song from. It's the intensity and intent of the performance which makes that garbage tolerable. The majority of the songs aren't interesting in the slightest - the best ones are either the big Cash hitters or the Carl Perkins songs. But again, the performances are great and the banter is solid. Throw in the circumstances and it's worth the four stars. Normally this would be a three star album, but for cultural significance you have to throw in that extra star. I never need to hear the whole thing again, but I'll slap a couple of songs on my rotation.
The best of Johnny Cash live. You almost feel like one of the prisoners watching the show! Contains the best recording of Walk the Line.
Alright, I’ll walk the line. An iconic album.
Johnny Cash is a great unifying force and never disappoints
Really good classic country. You can feel the energy from the inmates as Cash not only delivers an excellent performance, but also chats and jokes around with them between songs.
Really enjoyed the set list. I liked hearing Cash talk with the audience. It’s an easy listen and I can see myself listening to this album again
A classic recording.
tftfygy
Live Interaktionen fand ich funny und der ein oder andere Track war ganz nice, aber irgendwie klingt Cash sehr müde und das hat mich etwas irritiert. Ich kenne das Live Album „At Folsom Prison“ und da wirken die Songs deutlich schwungvoller
can't believe i got country on day 1
I had this version as a teenager and then I bought deluxe edition. Way superior! I Still Miss Someone is an absolute banger! How could they leave this off the abridged version?! In fact, it took me a little while to adjust to the deluxe version, so perhaps it's just that I got too used to something. Anyway: Cash is on fire here, his banter is great, he sings with heart and is joined by a series of special guests (Carl Perkins barely gets a mention on this version!). A boy named Sue is famous in its own right and San Quentin is a well thought out song (both versions, yet they couldn't chuck in 'I don't know where I'm bound'!?). Love the shout out to the warden at the end! Yet. Still, I want the deluxe. 5 stars!
This album is like when you are hitchhiking long distance and you get picked up by some reeeeeeaaaaallly sketchy dudes. The car reeks, there is a half empty bottle of whiskey rolling round in the footwell, and some alarming sounds are coming from the engine. The driver and the shotgun passenger seem oblivious to this. They don't really talk to you at all. You tell them you're heading to Wellington, but you know that is a long way, so any progress they can provide is great. They don't react to this at all, so you're pretty sure you are going to get murdered. You scramble to tell interesting stories to distract them, and hopefully put them off murdering you and leaving your corpse in a ditch somewhere just out of Pirongia. They seem to enjoy the stories, but you really do wonder how long you can keep this up.
A great live album. That set the standard high for how to do a live album. A classic
cool album but not the type of music i'd listen to. Still very catchy and fun !
muhe mõnusa häälega mees, kuulasin rohkem taustamuusikana aga meeldis arvestades et ma väga kantriinimene pole
A ouvir poesia
non sono una fan del country
Deepe, rusty voice vs the first prison album. Seemed fun.
Not a Cash fan, but can respect the unique venue where this was performed and what it said socially.
Pretty good overall. They literally played the same song twice in a row. Lots of fun banter.
pretty good, fav song was a boy named sue. i liked how it was live and you could hear the crowd and johnny cash speaking to them. but this also brought it down when a huge chunk of a song was just the crowd talk and not the guy singing
I had always wondered what the point of a live album was, but this gave me an answer: it's something /kinda like/ attending the concert in person. The multiple pieces of banter and tangents give this album a presence that I haven't found in any other live albums I've heard (not that that is very many). Johnny Cash has a voice like a warm blanket. Maybe it's the Texas girl in me, but I could listen to him talk or sing for hours.
I'm usually wary of live albums, but this is rather good. It was entertaining, loved the storytelling within these songs, and Cash was engaging, with a voice I could listen to for hours. I found it uplifting, and it made me smile.
Lots of energy and atmosphere. Classic album.
Loved it. Even better than the other prison album. Personality for days and great performances of great songs. Love how rowdy the prisoners get. "Aww, you don't really mean that....." Great Cover Art.
music is so powerful. listening to the prisoners cheer and interact with cash is something really special. it makes me that much more aware that THIS is real country - not what the modern “country singer” posers are doing. so many moments gave me chill. favorite tracks: - folsom prison blues - san quentin - a boy named sue
Fun to listen to the crowd noise and Cash is king
Goes hard as ever
Great snapshot of our society at that time and good listen
i love these live johnny cash albums
What are you doing to me here? Johnny's prison tour was an unheard of - before or since - statement through music. But the albums were largely trash. The correct answer is to put Folsom on here and leave the rest to the dustbin of history. But no, you want me to honestly rate this album not knowing if you're going to give me all 4 (please no) or just this one. And I'll have to drag The Man In Black. Diabolical.
Not sure we need multiple live Johnny Cash recordings on the list, but it's a solid album none-the-less. The banter on it is fun as well. 3/5
2.5
2.5
This is #day490 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… here's to my third and final Cash record, meaning I'm ticking off yet another artist. Cash must be the only kind of country I can actually listen to. What else can you say when I found my foot tapping to "I Walk the Line"? Is it the name? The voice? The charisma? Who cares? This is a good, fun live album, and I'm giving it a strong 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day491.
legendarno, jako dobro i zabavno. ježio sam se od nekih reakcija publike
Always a good listen
I'm happy for the nice San Quentin folks who got the reprise, but I don't think I needed it. Fascinating hearing "fuck" bleeped in a live context!
love that he is singing about prison to a prison
I was introduced to this album when I was eleven years old, when it showed up as my folks Columbia record club selection for that particular month. I listened to it a lot more than they did, as I was really enamored with A Boy Named Sue. Listening to it today was a stroll down memory lane, and although the production quality isn’t great with it being a live album recorded in the sixties, I really enjoyed it, (and hey, it’s Johnny Cash!) Four easy stars.
Really fucking enjoyed this - the live aspect added to the album for me and it's so damn cool. Big fan.
C'mon, man. It's Johnny Cash. I didn't like this one as much as the original Live from Folsom Prison, but it's still so much better than 95% of everything else ever recorded.
Sprightly, shame the cussing is bleeped as I feel it will be more authentic. The man had some attitude and front on him, fun to hear.
My 6th grade teacher rolled this album out to us and introduced us to A Boy Named Sue. I was excited to listen to this one again
rv/g
Good!!
Johnny Cash is the man. An interesting listen even though it's live. I'd rather listen to one of his studio works then this again, but I'm still giving it a floor.
Incredible. Not sure how often I’ll come back to it but it felt so immersive.
Not into country music. Love Cash's voice but that was about it.
At least the prisoners liked it
Well, it's Johnny Cash. You know what you're going to get and this delivers. Honestly can't believe that the prison allowed him to sing anti-prison songs to prisoners in a prison, but I guess things were different back in the late 1960s!
The original ten-song album didn’t really do the entire event justice, compared to the full concert. The original short version is fine to experience the album the way the world first heard it. This version is how it was meant to be heard.
I'm just not a fan of live albums and this was no exception. I thought Johnny Cash showed a certain amount of chutzpah with his opening song of, "Wanted Man" in a prison. While I was listening to "San Quentin", I wondered if the guards were side-eyeing each other with uneasiness as I know if I was there, I would have been uneasy. Then Johnny did a reprise of the same song, what was he thinking? Best song: "I Walk The Line". Most known song: "A Boy Named Sue". Worst song: "San Quentin"
I did not enjoy Johnny Cash's music very much (not much of a country fan personally), but what an absolutely incredible stage presence, even through a recording. Very few live recordings really improve music for me, but Johnny Cash really knew the vibe of the room at that prison and molded it. Listening to the crowd response to "San Quentin" literally from the San Quentin audience was a really cool experience, and the reprise was just plain funny. I'll never see Johnny Cash live, but I'm sure it would've been an incredible yet down to Earth show. 4/5