Funeral by Arcade Fire

Funeral

Arcade Fire

3.54
Rating
30876
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
31%
4
31%
5
22%
Distribution

Reviews (page 8 of 15)

Their best album.

One of the best

One of my fav albums from the ‘00s

One of the greats, classic of the indie rock genre. This is a favourite and has been for many years.

It took a little while for this one to fully register with me, and even now, I have to be in a very specific mood to gravitate towards Funeral over other records in my collection (the first 1001 entry I've had which I own on vinyl, as of writing). However, when such an opportunity comes around, this is a sobering listening experience, conceptually focussed on themes of death and the loss of childhood innocence as a result (thanks Wikipedia, I'm not feeling particularly free-thinking this morning). The album encompasses a wide range of emotions which ensue from the grieving process - denial, resentment, acceptance and a sense of emptiness after the fact. Sonically, there is ample variety on offer and there are bountiful layers of depth to unpack - an indie rock album at its core, but with some artsy, chamber-esque nuances accentuating it. Win Butler's swooning, at times warbly vocals initially proved an obstacle in which I had to navigate, but I've since grown to appreciate them as a fine accompaniment to the album, oozing with believability.

sorry but the allegations are too much for me

I really liked this in high school, and tbh I still know all the words to rebellion (lies) but this album is merely fine. Low 2.5

“Funeral”……aptly named. R.I.P.

Heard it before, classic 2000s indie rock. Going back to it I am struck by the intelligibility of the lyrics compared to much of the material coming to comparable acts today like Black Country New Road. I also forgot how bone chilling In The Backseat is, easily one of the greatest closers for a rock album ever.

I’ve never given this band a listen before. Glad I did. Not necessarily something I’d listen to regularly, but I can certainly see the appeal.

I love wake up! Great song. But I don't know that this album deserves to be on there outside of that song. Perhaps rebellion as well?

While I've heard all of these songs, I don't know if I've listened to the album front to back before now. Really solid.

About as strong of a debut album as a band could make. A real statement

Caught me by surprise, this was awesome! I could see myself editing this down the road and giving it the full 5 stars once I'm more familiar with all the songs. Not once did I think of skipping a track or feel antsy for it to be over. Beautiful.

Favorite: In the backseat

Appropriate title for this particular “holiday” (July 4th). Album itself isn’t bad-liked it better than I thought, though I’d likely not revisit it. Had some weak songs. Properly 2.5.

"Crown of Love" was good

Listened in the truck via YouTube music. Of their albums (other that We and Pink Elephant) I’ve listened to this one all the way through the least. This has some of their biggest songs, and after listening again, the rest of the tracks are great as well. I wonder how much Will was a part of their sound now that he’s left the band.

Had to look up the definition of milquetoast for this one.

When I first heard it, this album defined a sound and introduced me to a whole new genre. This is the epitome of the early 2000's Montreal, indie sound but performed at full volume on an arena stage. Somehow it's both small and massive at the same time. The songwriting is whimsical and nostalgic and every time I listen to it, it brings me right back to hearing it for the first time. I can admit having a huge bias for this album but I stand by it.

I’ve tried several times to get into Arcade Fire, but have never really succeeded and I’m not sure why because this is a perfectly enjoyable indie rock record; it just doesn’t really do anything for me personally.

Arcade Fire always hits the spot. It’s nostalgic and feels like late night driving music. Neighborhood #1, Haiti, Wake Up, and Rebellions are all exceptional tracks.

Heard better Arcade Fire and heard bettter indie rock. Just middle of the road for me. Forgettable songs - so much so I can’t even come up with a standout.

meh, not good not terrible.

Not really my thing

what a great album

9/10 Great album. The cover very well portrays how the album sounds. After a single listen I'm not certain what the concept is though I will certainly revisit because it is very good. Reminds me of BCNR

The album is an alternative masterpiece if I’m being honest. The drums, the guitar, the singer!! They are all soooooo good!! I wasn’t sure what this album would sound like, and I can safely say that it was really good! Not perfect, but great!

Its fine but I dont feel that much heart in this song.

I know that a lot of people love Arcade Fire and they have a great legacy... but I just don't get them. Maybe I'm not cerebral enough or whatever but it's just indie boys. Not bad but nothing special.

Seems ok, but not mybthing

Great sound, similar to a lot of stuff I'd listen to. Neighbourhood #3 was a favourite.

Not for me. Favorite Track: N/A

Pretty great, though I prefer Neon Bible

Not a particularly memorable album. Enjoyable to listen to, and maybe it was groundbreaking at the time, but I feel like nowadays it kind of just blends in? Fave songs: - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) - Une Annee Sans Lumiere - Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles) - Wake Up - In The Backseat

This is probably the last indie/alternative type album I really loved before I became fully formed as a hateful curmudgeon. One star off for reminding me of the last tiny glimpses of hope.

Okay, not great

It's alright, not very exciting. I like a couple of the songs

When I first heard this album at 17 years old, it was like a revelation. I had just gone through my biggest heartbreak yet, I was mortified of my approaching adulthood and I was more emotionally liable than ever. Arcade Fire seemed to embody all these grand feelings of young adulthood in their songs. Deep down, I really wanted to join a band like this. Not a beacon of the classic sex, drugs and rock 'n roll, but a bunch of nerdy multi-instrumentalists singing their hearts out over grandiose instrumentals. Not much later, I introduced the band to my then-girlfriend, and together we would fantasize about quitting our studies, forfeiting the prospect of futures in some corporate job and setting up a band instead, our very own Arcade Fire 2.0. In retrospect, I can say that in those last few years of my teens, this was probably my favourite album of all time. Now it's seven years later. I'm 24 years old, and my opinions have grown a bit more nuanced. I've long realised the flaws of this album: the line between anthemic and melodramatic can be a thin one, the lyrics are oftentimes rather on the nose and for a band consisting of such a diverse cast of musicians, they are not *terribly* creative with their arrangements. But in reality, I'm also really not that different from that 17 year old that fell in love with this album. I'm still going through new kinds of heartbreak almost every single year, I'm still pretty scared of the future has in store for me, life is still an overwhelming mess and, most of all, I still secretly dream to be part of a band like this. In my reveries, I manage to whip together a troupe of drummers, guitarists, violinists, accordeon players etc., we forget about what the world considers 'cringe' or 'immature', and we bundle together all the joys, pains and confusions of our early 20's and collectively scream at the top of our lungs to some hummable melody, all the while having Arcade Fire in the backs of our minds. Because really, what other band has ever caught these feelings with such force?

Exceptional album. Highlight was obviously “Wake Up” but the whole album was great and pretty varied. Will defo return to this one and to Arcade Fire in general!

Oh, dear. It’s 2025 and all this bloviating baroquery – songs that sounded so clear-minded and agenda-complemingly progressive 20 years ago; part of the soundtrack to, no need to whisper it, change – sounds sickly-pretentious to the point of hostile-facetious. Not strictly Arcade Fire’s fault – though lighting the path for the nightmare of stomp-clap-hey, a subgenre of indie so indulgently anodyne that it killed guitar music for the best part of a generation, sort of might have been – but all the same … “Funeral” now sounds like just that, only it’s millennial optimism we’re grieving. I didn’t like this record. It was almost so many things but not quite anything – “The Black Parade” without energy; Dexys Midnight Runners without charm (nothing here comes even close to DMR’s “This is What She’s Like”) … ultimately, a fitting soundtrack to our squandered opportunity for, whisper it now, change.

Typical arcade fire album. Pretty cool to listen to but nothing special.

Rating (1-5): ✩✩✩✩ Will I be listening to this again: I will What do I like about it: I might change this one at some point, I didn' have much time... What I dislike about it: Idk Higlighted songs: Some of them hahah

Amazing 5/5

Yeah, it's great. I've heard this album like 5 billion times. It's an old favorite and it used to be a 10/10. Time does shift my opinion a bit and now it sits at a 9/10. Despite the fact that this listen was more routine than an interesting discovery, songs like Crown Of Love and In The Backseat still get me years later. One of the best albums of the 2000s (9/10, 5/5 on this scale)

Just quickly: I am with EJR here: 20 albums (for me) so far and only one woman in that run, but we are getting a second Arcade Fire record. Admittedly, it is an incredible record: aching, longing, mourning, aging, feeling (a lot). Reminder that songs aren't nouns but verbs. But meanwhile Aretha, Joni, Madonna, Lucinda, Diana, Stevie, Billie, Nina, Chrissie, Tina and so many more need some space in the algorithm.

Sitting in Montreal listening to this album. Almost got chill bumps. Incredible album that holds up today. This was one of grad school anthems, and nicely captures the frustration/successes web of that experience.

I liked but think The Suburbs is better.

Love these dudes.

While still great… not as good as I remember. Maybe it’s just the vibe that so many artists copied after this to a much worse extent has kind of worn on me.

wheezy thin vocals, cramped mix, milquetoast instrumentation- dictionary definition indie-rock. a lot of people connect to it on a real emotional level- but it's not reaching me at all. there's a couple of songs near the end (after the excrable neighborhood suite) that sond like if a different band covered them would be decent- so it can have an extra star...

Yeah I know this album. It's always just fine.

Love this one! Contemporary masterpiece with no skips. Rebellion (Lies) is an absolute banger of a song. Crown of Love always get me.

Intenso y aburrido

Not my kind of album. Really good overall tho

Perfectly delivered.

First listen I enjoyed it then lost interest with the second

Love this album. Flows well from song to song, the hits stand out but every song has something to offer.

I’d still love to know what exactly the folks from Quebec were drinking during the making of 𝘍𝘶𝘯𝘦𝘳𝘢𝘭, because this album sounds just as fresh and urgent as it did when I first bought it back in 2005 (I’m European — it didn’t even drop here until then). The mix of raw emotion, orchestral chaos, and suburban existentialism somehow feels timeless, like a soundtrack to the end of youth and the start of everything else. Even after all these years, it still hits with the same intensity — like a panic attack and a celebration holding hands. 𝘍𝘶𝘯𝘦𝘳𝘢𝘭 has long since earned its place as a modern classic. Whatever potion they stirred up in Montreal, it worked.

Uno de los mejores álbumes del siglo XXI y, probablemente, el mejor de 2004. El debut de Arcade Fire es su mejor álbum y también el que tiene su mejor canción: Rebellion (Lies). Una especie de indie, a ratos más rock, a ratos más pop, que resulta fresco y que combina a la perfección la calidad musical con el hecho de ser asequible para cualquier tipo de oyente. Una joya que recomendaría a todo el mundo. Y además, ¡Qué guapa es la portada!

Not for me

This a masterpiece!

Very familiar with this album. No bad songs and so unique. Love it!

so so so good. deserved the grammy

Crazy to think that Funeral is over 20 years old. I remember cooking in the kitchen with some music channel, maybe VH1, on the TV in the living room and hearing "Wake Up" (as it turned out) playing. I had to drop what I was doing and go to see who this was, and when the tempo change hit, the hairs stood up on the back of my neck. Notes from listening today… Arcade Fire produce a musical piledriver is made up of fragile sounds. The angular coda to "Une Année Sans Lumière" is superb. Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out)" is emotional, dark, yet uplifting and hopeful, catharsis. Throughout, the shimmering, wavering voices, accordion, piano, glockenspiel, strings and more create a beautiful soundscape. The tempo change in "Crown of Love" almost sounds like ELO; there are no blues inflections. "Wake Up" is where it all started for me (it still gives me the chills). The transition into the YOU CAN’T HURRY LOVE rhythm is smooth and seamless. "Rebellion (Lies)" has an insistent rhythm that encourages children to rebel against (well-meaning?) parents. Still a hugely uplifting album about loss and death.

I've said it before and I'll say it again. Win Butler is a complete prick but him and his bandmates know how to put out solid albums.

I never liked Arcade Fire all that much because I was very anti-Pitchfork-core during the hipster era of the mid-to-late 2000s/early-2010s, yet I still always remember Funeral being the one album I felt some admiration toward. Not that it was a favorite or anything, or that I frequently found myself wanting to revisit it, but in my memory, I recalled it being a very good album. I just wasn’t much of a fan of the style, personally. Well, clearly I haven’t listened to it much since the early 2010s, because yeah…this really hasn’t aged all that well. The muddy production, the proto-stomp-clap aesthetic that now feels dated, the jug band instrumentation that feels simultaneously forced and wayyyy too up its own ass. Funeral feels full of itself. Now, there is the occasional undeniable song here and there– I’m no idiot, “Crown of Love” is gorgeous and “Rebellion” is anthemic– but beyond those moments, I’m surprised that this has held up so much. It is significantly weaker than its peers, not only from a production standpoint, but in its deep cuts’ songwriting, in the playing, and in the general emotional depth explored here. Sure, it has its moments, but comparatively, it’s worse than its influences like The Magnetic Fields, or contemporaries like Bloc Party, Broken Social Scene, or even the weakest Death Cab record. The most important thing Funeral has going for it is nostalgia at this point, and even that feels thin given Arcade Fire’s standing in the indie scene in 2025. I, however, have no nostalgia for this scene, this style, this band, or this album. This is easily their best record and I will stand by a handful of these songs, but that still leaves me lukewarm, especially since I did not need to hear 3 Arcade Fire albums just to realize even their best effort is a 6/10.

i love it

Still great

Better than I expected. I'd listen again.

I like this album overall—definitely had a few tracks like “Rebellion” on repeat back when it came out. The lyrics are strong and capture that early 2000s feeling of emotional shift, like in Garden State—grappling with loss, change, and a fading sense of innocence. I don’t listen to a ton of indie rock these days, but the nostalgia it delivers is undeniable.

I remember clearly when this record dropped. The first song I heard by this band was "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)," and I can still remember being lit up at the overwhelming energy of it, driving around in my car in LA with Indie 103.1 on the radio. It kinda reminded me of a rootsier PiL. There are only a few times in my life where my ears have pricked up quite like this. Upon hearing the whole thing, I was struck at the balance between lyrical and musical themes of twee, innocent adolescent energy and a sort of hardened, melancholy adult nostalgia evident in the record as a whole. The progression of the track listing is also masterfully considered. It reminds me of when albums were presented as a start-to-finish listening experience rather than to be parsed out and shuffled, which is significant given that this came out during the peak of the iPod era. What an absolutely stunning and epic debut. Extra points for titling your first big record "Funeral."

This indie rock album has an epic quality to it - the guitar combined with the old timey keys and violin makes it feel important. I also love that a few songs will switch the pace from slow to fast. I've always liked the range of emotions I feel when this album.

Great album!

Now my kind of style but I like the sounds

‘Wake up’ is such a exceptional track that the rest fade into the background; I feel it’s an indie artsy album which I appreciate but other than that one epic, it doesn’t do it for me.

It has nothing that makes music great.

On the surface, this ticks all the right boxes - sadly, I just found it a bit dull to listen too. For all the quirky instrumentation and offbeat arrangements, this is just straightforward akt-rock cosplaying as something more sophisticated. And the singer's voice annoys on most of the tracks. Interesting in places, but this is not for me - not sure what all the hype is about.

actual bangers ngl

this was an awesome album. OBViously i knew rebellion (lies) and recognized a few others from seeing them in concert but i really enjoyed listening all the way through and have to admit that idk if i would have done this on my own. favs: neighborhood #1, #3, wake up, haiti, rebellion (lies), and in the backseat.

All time fav

Hey! Another previously-listened-to-er. Me and this album go way back to five months ago, when I first listened to it on a whim through the last.fm recommendations. I really didn't like it. Something about the irreverent backing vocals and epic atmosphere of the album rubbed me the wrong way and came off as insincere. I don't negotiate with arsonists of shopping districts or game centres (I don't know which they're referring to - both are equally hipster), though I guess I can give these guys another go if the Dimermeister were to put me under duress. That guy's scary. Uhhhhhh. Maybe this one should have returned to me a little later as it doesn't sound different from when I last heard it. That being said, I can see the merit this time around. I like the guitar outro on "Une Anee Sans Lumiere". "Crown of Love" is pretty alright - the songwriting on that track is competent. I enjoy the way that the vocals flow together and the strings are very nice. "Wake Up" is a pretty respectable tune, which is significant since I had that exact song in mind while I wrote my previous paragraph. The crunchy guitars also give the song a nice bit of punchiness, so I guess the "epic" atmosphere is warranted this time around. The fittingly massive outro is decent as well. Harps/music boxes works surprisingly well with the song and I enjoy the change in tempo. Solid track. Man, I hate writing these reviews while I'm listening to the albums - especially when I change my mind halfway through the process of writing. There are some good cuts on this album, though I think a lot of the good material is being held down by one fatal grievance - the vocals. They're entirely shitty. "Neighborhood #2" is the biggest offender of this - a song which caused me to completely shut my brain off in order to get through it. Other victims of Win Baker include "Neighborhood #3" and "Rebellion", though all of the songs (minus the closer) are tainted by his presence. In all fairness, most of my favourite albums come from artists who I initially perceive as being shit-voiced, though I don't care enough about the music on this album to let it polish itself with future relistens. This is very narrowly escaping a 1 star, if only due to the instrumentals being competent and inventive. I had an entire character arc over the previous paragraphs, though I feel like I'm back to square one with this band. I need drink. Interestingly, the two other Arcade Fire albums that were on this list have been expunged from future editions of the book. I listened to "Neon Bible" a month or so ago and can't remember a single thing about it, so maybe that's for the best. That being said, I can vouch for this album as an inductee. I do know that it's both popular and influential. It's also pretty unique and dynamic, so I guess I'm grateful for having heard this one before I cunked it.

When I think of “indie rock”, this album is the one I think of. I’d say it’s the quintessential indie rock album. It’s so freaking good.

About the fourth time I've tried to listen to this. It's good music but really not for me. I don't know what it is but I can't get into it. I can appreciate it for the impact it had though

New, eclectic, brilliant. Knocked me out the first time I heard it.

Arcade Fire certainly plays a homage to mediocre music, and this album is no exception. Ironically, it's not a good album to play during a funeral, but it is perfect for teenagers driving for the first time in middle-class suburban neighborhoods. Hardly anything on here is good, or bad. Favorite Track: "Neighborhood #3(Power Out)".

Arcade Fire captured lightning in a bottle with this album. What a debut and something they've never been able to duplicate. This album is part of what introduced me to the whole genre of 2000s/2010s Canadian Indie. I'm forever grateful to this album because it was my gateway to most of the music I listened to during high school and university.

Regine is a wonderful singer, but I am deducting approximately 0.6 stars for her trying to be Bjork on "In The Backseat"

a truly beautiful album I wish wasn't so marred in my mind by some things that happened two decades later.

Intro is insane. I love the kind of buildup all the way through. I also enjoy the calm bit of production on the third track. The fourth I love the end explosion with the tempo becoming faster. I LOVE crown of love, especially the switch and the lead vocalists voice. The outro was very good too. Overall I'd rate the album a solid 8/10. Consistent throughout.

This was a pleasant surprise. I had low expectations going in, due to only hearing their radio friendly tunes and not really liking them. But I was incorrect with my first assumptions, this album is pretty stellar, especially for a debut. I hear Abba, Bowie, U2 and a British football match. I can see why this is on so many best of lists. Walked the best friend around the block twice in-between downpours, really nice Sunday morning listen. The generator has been throwing me solids all week.

The power, epicness, and emotion of the best songs here really carry it into greatness. I'm talking about "Tunnels, "Power Out," "Wake Up," and "Rebellion" These songs hit me hard and evoke genuine emotion with their beauty. The rest of the songs range from Good, to skip, but the greatness of those mentioned above overshine them all by leaps and bounds. Great album.

Interesting

A near perfect album. I'll never get tired of it.

I hadn't heard this album for ages! Great album.

ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh who cares

Probably a big album for my millenial peers, but this was quite a boring listen for me.

An absolute pleasure. Such a creative album packed with great songs! Slightly biased as I discovered the album in my teens, but always a 5/5 from me!

oh. oh no

Arcade Fire did not deserve an album on this list, let alone two

Arcade Fire was such a great band in the 00’s, A lot of creativity showing new directions in Indie land. And this is just the beginning

Nostalgia galore! Not sure if I should feel sad! Treading between dreamy and sleepy!

Pretty good first half but a super strong finish. Maybe I see the hype now.

Really nice. Apparently I listened to a song already from this album, but I don't remember it. 9/10

Not weird enough to be interesting, not melodic enough to be pop The single (Wake Up) is undeniable though, it is better than the rest None of it quite felt finished Made me want to hear Bowie, sometimes The Strokes Meh

Power out is a highlight, great energy and rhythm. Lovely vocal melodies and powerful rhythm work throughout. Some lulls prevent it being 5 stars.

No idea how some of you like this, it's utter, utter wank

Enjoyed this when it came out and it still holds up.

Doesn’t really grab me

Interesting and creative, but I didn't really like the singers. Wake Up was really good.

4.2 - Know this album really well and it's still great. Hard to be subjective with this as it has a lot of nostalgia wrapped up in it

Wow, I can’t believe I’ve been sleeping on this album for so long, so good, such a great vibe, a great world-building album. Wake Up is so euphoric. Fave Tracks: Neighbourhood #1 (Tunnels) Wake Up, Haiti, Rebellion 4.8/5

What a way to kick off a carreer. Super solid from start to finish.

It was ok

There were a few songs that felt like they bled together a little bit for me, but overall I really enjoyed the variety, instrumentation, and lyrics in this album. Favorite songs: Neighborhood #2 & #4, Une Annee Sans Lumiere, Crown of Love, Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies), In the Backseat

Lowkey stomp clap hey music

Kjeeeeedelig. Det va ferdigspilt for ti minutter siden og æ har bare en vag idé om kordan sangan va, og absolutt null ønske om å høre dem igjen.

Didn't do much for me at all, appreciated the baroque elements and a somewhat unique sound but found it very boring

This album really pissed me off.

Wake up is a banger

I'd only heard of the Band name name before, but I knew nothing about them. I'm enjoying this; it has this kind of ethereal melodic flow going. It also work pretty cohesively

Ei tästä jäänyt mitään mieleen, ei jatkoon.

I never got into Arcade Fire, and this didn't change that for me. I think the songs are fine, but none of them grabbed me or particularly stuck out. The music is good, the vocals are okay. There are far better bands and albums in the world than this one.

If you like Arcade Fire, this is going to work for you. If not, you'll be put off a bit by the whining. It's just OK to me.

Another one I expected more from but this probably requires multiple spins. Rebellion is an awesome song and the vibe of the song certainly fits the title. Ultimately this is indi, hipster, I like it cause no one else does type music.

Liked some songs but not all. 4/5 :)

Uninspired. This whole album could have been a prompt.

So much beauty contained within 45 minutes. The songs are actually entrancing and mesmerizing, with the 'Neighborhood's and 'Rebellion' being quite phenomenal. I wouldn't call it a completely perfect album, as a little steam was lost in the second half, but the highs are so high that this deserves one of the greatest honors.

Dork and I are in disagreement when it comes to the best Arcade Fire album: Dork thinks this the best one, whereas I argue The Suburbs is the superior choice. Regardless, what we do agree on are they are both 5 star albums. Neighbour #2 is our favourite song, but the album is a cohesive, enjoyable ride from start to finish.

Decent, not my thing. A little spineless to be honest, like it lacked some semblance of any grit or strength. The best we got was the final song (In the Backseat). There's been better by Arcade Fire that's for sure, but it might just be hard to measure up to the Elbow album which is also in the generated lists and the Arcade Fire song Afterlife. 2.5/5 stars

Ok emo pop

It's a good record, a very artsy variation of indie rock, they're not afraid to mix different instruments and they build very beautiful musical pieces, specially with the strings sections they include. It also encapsulates a sort of nostalgia with the music and lyrics. The whole concept from the first part is interesting enough. That being said, while I appreciate the album, I didn't really connect with it that much. The best song for me was the very well known "Wake Up". "Neighborhood #3 Power Out" was also pretty good, with a higher intensity than the other tracks.

Alright actually

I had never listened to this before, the opening song blew me out. Such a strong emotions coming from it, it must have been great to see them at a festival. The rest of the album is very good as well, so 5 stars it is.

thank you generator gods! i was starting to worry i just dont like music lol. this album is so beautiful to me, and everything flows so well together, such a great execution of theme.

Listened before?: Oh yes, many times. This one's a favorite.

pretty good chill

Emotional, theatrical, and sweeping. It’s grand without being overblown, and the energy feels raw and real. A strong halfway marker.

one of the greatest albums of indie music.

Excellent

Not as good as I remember, apart from Wake Up

Great indie rock album. I like a different one from this band better, but this captures the sound and feel well enough

Perfection. My gateway album to a life of beautiful music and incredible live performances.

Tunnels is amazing man

A rich and well-made album, though not one that made a strong connection with me. I appreciated the big and heartfelt sound, though. Best song: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)

too folksy for me

I still don’t really like Arcade Fire but I got a lot of nostalgia associated with this, my brother used to play a lot of these tracks when I was growing up! I think Neighborhood #1-3 are the strongest and actually kinda remind me of Modest Mouse in places, which is unexpected! Fuck Win Butler for sure tho

I've never been a diehard AF guy but everytime I listen to this one I really enjoy it! Sorry!

yea sorry but this was a certified crying on the floor album for me . love this bugger but honestly i think i outgrew it and this band is so despicable on so many levels LOL

Neighboorhood #3 (Power Out) is a Tour de force! But I am still not a fan of the singer’s voice. I preferred The Suburbs over this record. I did not like the overall sound and the occasional yelling eg on Wake Up frustrated me. Haiti and In The Backseat annoyed me too. I don’t know what exactly it is that put me off.

Nothing special, very much the sound of the time, but I didn't mind that today.

Wow, that's educated me, immensely talented band clearly, terrific sound, wonderful songs, great intensity, beautiful delivery 👌

Fun, and I like the sound, but too similar throughout to be an all-timer.

Ahh, Arcade Fire. I had a real phase in 2010 of listening to Ready to Start incessantly (with msn's "listening to" feature very casually turned on) because I wanted to be seen liking it, but not, as it actually turns out, because I liked it. Fast forward to 2025 and I have never listened to this album before but found myself walking a familiar path. Whilst professing to be pleased and allowing anyone within a two metre radius to get a peek over my shoulder at the subtly displayed album cover all day, I secretly yearned for the simple pleasure of a singalong banger. No more. This is my truth. This is precisely the kind of indie rock miscellany that I think I should think is cool but truthfully found formulaic, forgettable and... boring 😭 By the end of the day I was self-medicating with Louis Prima. I am going to be brave and admit this is a 3 for me - and my teenage self should thank me for the growth.

Chefs kiss

No private session used for Spotify. I have listened to this album in the past and I do like it. It's got a lot going on as far as instrumentation, tempo and key changes. Bit dramatic, but it works.

Seems like any other indie alr rock group at the time. Definitely inspired by neutral milk hotel. I can see why people like this but I like In the Aeroplane over the Sea a bit more than this.

Dritkjedelig klimprepop.

Already in my regular rotation. Classic.

Listenable.

Fav: In The Backseat Least Fav: Neighbourhood #4: (7 Kettles) Those last couple songs were so much better than the rest of the album

Pretty nice vibes.

This album is so beautiful and charming. I've been listening to this daily for an entire week and I didn't get bored of it. I love the little melodies the play with different instruments such as piano, violin and even xyIophone; I love the chord progressions, I love the execution of the changes at the end of the songs. I love everything from this album, and I'm glad I can finally give a confident 5 stars after 165 albums (I have to add that this is could be the third 5 stars, but didn't have the confidence to give the other two albums the proper score)

Hard to listen knowing there have been sexual assault charges brought

Ok, low-key rock

Mostly noise and a very, VERY whiney "singer" caterwauling over non-,elodic beats. Not the worst thing I've heard, but I would not recommend it to anyone.

Well I tried to like it. It's all over the place, not at all an enjoyable listen.. Lyrics are kinda stupid. Voice is mediocre. Very hard to sit through.

This is a strangely beautiful album; at the same time both recognisable and familiar in soundscape, and unexpected and often challenging, in lyrical terms and also harmonically. This is (forgivably, on this occasion) a concept album of sorts. The first half speaks to the struggles of a neighbourhood under stress and makes lots of reference to relationships with parents: Family members are referred to, one way of another, on virtually every track. This is a very mature sounding album for a debut. If I have a reservation it’s a very slight one, about the production, which is suitably grandiose and theatrical but at times a trifle overcrowded. Fun fact: the recording and mixing of this album was entirely analogue. Less fun fact: the album’s title, and much of the subject matter, was inspired by family bereavements experienced by band members at the time.

This music has no balls. The singers voice is grating as are the vocal harmonies. I have no clue why this type of watered down terrible “rock” music became so popular in the 2000’s.

too much arcade fire in this list

Rebellion (Lies) = amazing.

Favourite songs: Haiti, Rebellion (lies), Neighbourhood #2

I kinda missed this album when it came out. What an absolute shame that was. I'm normally not someone for the melodrama nonsense. I like a fast upbeat tempo, but this one really does it for me. It's an absolutely beautiful album.

Don't really have much to say about this one

Don't really have a lot to write, didn't really enjoy it.

Classic 2000s indie music. Different than some of the other stuff out there and I liked it

Every song in this album compels you... To skip it. It starts OK but by song 3 it is painful, each song is 4 minutes too long, only Rebellion is fine in its entirety. I am giving it two stars because songs in isolation could be bearable and here and there there are some interesting sections (in Power Out, Kettle and wake up) but I would rather pay thousands in quarters playing a Mortal Kombat clone while on fire than listen to the whole album again.

Hated everything about this. Whiny, plaintive, fluffy drivel. Almost DNF. Not for me.

Couple so so mid tempo indie rock songs….but otherwise pretty boring I’ve seen them live and the songs are better in person than on record across their discography But at the end of the day just another boring hipster band who spent too much time with other hipsters from Mile End in Montreal…..then other hipsters from other towns saw them, and now here we are….a world famous boring hipster band. I’m certain this review will infuriate baristas everywhere

An all-time favourite. This was a game changer when it was released, and has an energy that very few albums of its era can match. Perfect from start to finish.

I find the lead singers voice irritating. Music is pretty mid.

The music is great. The singing is not for me and the lyrics are playful but not moving. If there were an instrumental version of this album I would listen to it.

This is not enjoyable to me.

Feels like they're always building to something but it never comes.

Acceptable. They are good but not my thing really. But I can't really say anything bad about them.

Incredible live band. But never really been sold on this album despite the wonderful singles

Admittedly above average for noughties North American indie-rock fare but this album tries so hard to be grandiose I think it should be diagnosed with BPD.

Shorter, sharper and more varied than The Suburbs. A strong album .

Solid indie alt rock record. Helped define the indie aesthetic in that decade.

I forgot I was even listening to anything because this album faded into the background so much.

This doesn't sound like 2004. I hate that there are albums on this list that are from the 2000s while still sounding like other records on this list that are way older. This is not bad but youbvould have chosen way more from the 21st century.

I really liked the sound of this one. My standout would be Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels). I love the use of violin in that one, and the lyrics spoke to me in a weird way.

The instrumentation is quite nice, but the male singer makes it a drag to listen to. The best song was Rebellion (Lies).

Considering I don't like indie rock this is pretty good.

I don’t like this album as much as I did when I first heard it as a teenager and Win is a sex pest and all, but it’s still such an excellent listen. Front to back it’s great. Such high energy, so inventive. Regine’s vocals are elite. Power Out and Laika- holyyyyyyyy. The Tunnels riff was one of the first things I ever learned on guitar. One of the easiest 5’s this site has given me

A few good songs. Never got super into them though. Crown of love is my favourite song on this album

Correcto

Not too bad. Not really my style

Solid album.

Riese Fan vode Produktion, super abgmischt. D Lieder hend mich immer wieder überrascht mit interessante Entwicklige und sind generell sehr abwechsligsrich. I gwüssne chamer mega in klang itauche, bi andere hingege chamer richtig abga. "Une année sans lumière" het mier glaubs am beste gfalle, aber die vier "Neighborhood"-Songs sind au mega nice. Definitiv es Album wonich irgendwenn wieder mal lose wird.

no easy, aber recht unspektakulär.

The days when the meta was to pretend that you were smarter than you actually were. That's the only way I can explain anyone rating it higher than "fine"

music to "find yourself" to after you realize that you are gay

Dind't like it when it came out and I still dont.

Cannot tolerate Win’s voice very long. 0 from me.

Fantastic anthemic indie debut

very mid pop punk record. nothing in particular stands out

Was this groundbreaking for 2004 or something? Snooze

I fucking love this album

A very solid 3 for me

Wasn't very engaging for me, kind of forgot I was listening to it as I did other things.

OK. I just gave Bob Dylan 'Blonde on Blonde' a 4, which arguably should have been a 5. But now I'm hearing this album and wanting to give it a 4, but feeling a bit sheepish that if this is a 4, then is this really in the same bucket as Dylan Blonde on Blonde? So for that reason alone, this falls to a 3. Sorry Arcade Fire. You just aren't Dylan.

Great album.

Okay I had high hopes. Everyone loved Arcade Fire. I like them. Not this album though.

Album sounds good, but to me it feels 2004 unlike some other 2004 albums. Draggin for me. First listen all the way though, familiar with the hits. Time's been unfair I feel like, very millennial boom stomp to my 2025 ears. Maybe it'll sound like a banger in a few years.

Weird coming at this from knowing the suburbs incredibly well, I guess quite a lot of people would say that this is their best album, its definitely better than Neon Bible, but also worse than the suburbs. I like that its more creative/less traditional than the suburbs, with the distortion and experimentation on the vocals. Synths are also really good, guitars too. I think Arcade Fire are amazing at a certain type of feeling in songs, which is quite hard to describe, but quite close to nostalgia. Favourite songs: all except maybe the first one. Overall around 8/10

Not a fan. Not sure why.

Always a good listen. Big fan.

Not as good as Neon Bible (the only other I heard) but still a cool project. The thing that brings it down for me is I didn’t like the sound that this one has as much as I liked NB’s. My isssues with this one are that the tracklisting was a little bit over the place and sometimes I could barely understand what was being said (though that might be my AirPods) which is problematic when you are listening to a concept album, which this is. and the first half of the album was a little choppy. But the saving factor was that the 2nd half was really awesome. Despite those complaints, to me this is a good album. Just a little bit flawed sadly. Favorite Tracks: Wake Up, Haiti, In The Backseat, and Rebellion (Lies)

I tried listening to this but kept falling asleep. There is some undeniable talent in this group, but it's just not my kinda thing.

I'd given up on albums before this came out. Familiar with so many of the songs but never paid attention until now and fired up the first track. Wow. Glad to find this gem and will put it into regular rotation

Great album. One of my favorites of all time.

What is this

Really good music. Didn't grab me as emotionally as Neon Bible. Good new band for me though.

This was ~ok~. It's just a little Indie for my tastes. There was randomly a girl on the last song? I don't even know if she was in any of the previous songs. I would probably like this more if I gave a good look at the lyrics but since I work while I listen to all of these albums, they're sometimes probably not getting a fair chance.

Good one, in my memory it was even better than 3 stars...

Wasn't a big fan, nothing stood out for me on this album

Not bad, just not for me, vocals are a little drowned out and honestly its boring, high 2

It was sick.

Not too bad.

Favorite Track: Wake Up

I don't love this kind of whiny, tremulous vocal style - it's objectively quite similar to things like Bright Eyes that I loved when I was younger but nowadays I find it a bit overly fey and annoying. The music is good, very competently composed, but feels like it's designed in a lab to be uplifting and appear on tv adverts. It doesn't feel very organic or interesting. But I don't tend to like indie songs that have multiple guitar parts all strumming a single note over and over like that. Track 2 (Neighbourhood #2 (Laika)) is a bit more interesting and punky. But of course I don't generally like shouty punk either. The guitars just sound very thin. A lot of small lines of colour on a blank background. A general issue I have with this genre is there's no standout "bit" in the song that it builds to and you get a sense of intense joy and satisfaction from when it finally happens. Like the really brilliant guitar or vocal part or lyric towards the end of the song. It's just stuff happening all the way through and then it's over. So I just fundamentally prefer the structure of, for example, rock or blues songs. Track 3 (Une Annee Sans Lumiere) is very dull to me. I'm not sure why I would be interested in this bland vocal or guitar picking. Although having said that the fast bit at the end is more interesting. Track 4 (Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out)) is just nothing to me I'm afraid. Apparently it's one of their singles. I don't know how they choose a single as nothing stands out. Track 7 (Wake Up) is more interesting - like the aaah aaaah aaah chorus. Rhythm guitar is slightly more interesting, with some chords appearing. Still hate the guitar tone. According to A this was one of their big singles. This one did have my foot tapping a bit. And some almost cool lead guitar licks. Like the change of pace at the end of the song. Feels very white and very early 2000s. Which it is, so fair enough. I don't like the vocals, guitar sound, instrumental sound in general or the structure of the songs. I would never choose to listen to this again and don't think it will grow on me with repeated listens. Although having said that it does pick up towards the end of the album. Wake Up and Haiti are better (I like the switch to the female vocalist and the bass line in Haiti). Rebellion is decent too in that generic uplifting 2000s indie way. In the Backseat (the last song) was pretty good and vocal was a bit Bjorky, which is cool. Like the strings. The back half of the album bumps it up to a weak 3 stars overall. I assume everything on this list is going to be competently made so I will rate based on subjective enjoyment and likelihood I would ever listen again. I'm just not sure I like indie much.

It's okay. Good to listen to while one is doing other things

It's funny I never got into this band as they were huge in my college years and I listened to a many AF-adjacent bands, but there was always something missing for me. I can't put my finger on it. Listening through this album gave me nostalgia for the era, but really just made me want to listen to any other millennial alterative album. It's fine.

pretty fine record. Nothing that particularly blew my mind, it was less impressive expected, this being a pretty popular and well loved record. Favorite track: wake up. Overall score: 5.0/10

Recognized a few songs, but the album didn't make a strong impression on me.

Day 1. So far so good. Not really my taste, but I can def appreciate it. Neighborhood #3 is good. The guitar and drums are really good, the vocals are not for me but not too distracting. Neighborhood #4 is better actually. The girl voice in Haiti is good.

I thought this album was a fun listen. I enjoyed the lyricism and found that it was easy to follow. My favorite was Crown of Love. I don't think I would necessarily reach for this album time after time but it definitely had a few songs I could see myself listening to again! 3/5

Damn near perfect album, only thing that takes it down to a 4 is "Rebellion." Just not my cup of tea.

Not for me

Very close to a 4 for me, but somethings not hitting my ears right. Definitely parts of it is Win Butler's vocals I don't think are very good. Wake Up is a classic, and I generally enjoy most of the rest of the record, especially everything after Wake Up, but yeah, just not quite doing it for me.

I’d forgotten how heavily this albums leans on talking heads, it’s a very good album though, songs flow past worth repeated listens.

Was more interesting than I remembered...

4.5. I like this one. Will listen to again.

16/1001 Solid album, not the peak of its era & genre but able to hang at the big kids table. I honestly liked the single and more pop stuff better overall, but the rest of the album was good. This isn’t really a full 4 star album, maybe closer to a 3.5 but rounding up because 3 seems too far off.

operatic and turgid; exhilarating when it works, but twenty years on, the seams are showing. a lot of the bigger swings, the "our love is how we'll survive," the communal singalong shit, REALLY falls flat after having your frontman exposed as a cheating sex pest.

It’s not bad. But it’s not great either. The whole album is a lot. Arcade fire as a band is quite a lot I find. Rich in melodies, instruments and vocals. I think some songs would be more impactful for me if some of it would have been toned down.

Good and interesting album.

Very good music really enjoyed the overlaying harmonies and many instruments chosen, a bit sad for my liking though

I really liked this album. I have heard of this band before, but I never listened to them until now. I enjoyed all the songs and rock.

Not bad, just very over the top.

Cool vibes but not entirely for me Songs added to Liked Songs: Une Annee Sans Lumiere Rebellion (Lies)

4 Stars (11/15)

i was 4 years old when funeral was released, and my canadian gen-x parents are responsible for the fact that some of my earliest memories include this album. wake up used to scare me to the point of tears, because it included the lyric “turn the summer into dust”, and my birthday is in the summertime...kids say the darndest things. it’s the first album i ever cried to (and maybe the only one i’ve ever cried to out of fear). funeral has followed me around ever since - into adolescence and adulthood and bedrooms and hallways and first-love passenger seats. Can’t Be Normal About It/5.

An extra star from me for being half of a concept album.

Why does every rock album from the early 2000s sound exactly the same? You could have told me this was by Modest Mouse and I wouldn't have blinked. It's... fine, but pretty forgettable.

It was fine. I'm not a huge fan of this style of music. Rock mostly feels bland to me. It didn't draw me in. However, I can see how this was elevated and a higher quality version of this type of music. 4/5

I liked this better than Neon Bible and I gave that one 3 stars, but don't think this one deserves 4. If the vocals were a little bit better/less whiney it may be a 4.

I feel extremely neutral toward this album. Sort of has that modern indie / alternative sound. Wake Up is obviously the standout track.

I liked this one. The mixing of French into a couple of the songs was a good nod to their heritage and origins. The theming between the songs flowed well.

Neighbourhood #1 (Tunnels): i love this so much, this might be my new favorite song 4.8/5 Neighbourhood #2 (Laika): this might be an album full of unskipable songs, i love this song 5/5 Une année sans lumière: it’s a bit like a very chill interlude, but i love the end of it very much 3.2/5 Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out): i’m a big fan of shouting in songs, and i like the lyrics 3.4/5 Neighbourhood #4 (7 Kettles): i love the instrumentals and the vibe of this song, i just don’t know what it means 3.7/5 Crown of Love: the change of rhythm surprised me, i love the background vocals and the lyrics 3.8/5 Wake Up: i love the lyrics of this song so very much, but i have to listen to this when I’m sadder 3.9/5 Haiti: it’s one of those songs where the lyrics are crushing but you don’t notice it when you just listen to it 4.1/5 Rebellion (Lies): love how it blends with Haiti, but it’s a bit repetitive for me, has a fire instrumental tho 3.2/5 In the Backseat: i like it, i don’t know why tho… i just like it, it’s nice i like it 4.3/5

Excellent. Pioneering

This came out around the tiime I stopped reading the music press, and within a year nerlynevery indie band sound like this and I still don't know why.

7.5/10. Great album by a great band.

Better than I was expecting. At times it can get a little generically “indie” sounding, but the songwriting is good and the arrangements are especially well thought out.

There are plethora of interesting elements in this album. Tempo swift from 3/4 to 4/4, layered accordions/choirs/strings, modal shifts etc. I like some depth of an album, and I also like that they don’t fixate on death. But I’ll have to say.. I’m very picky about vocal performance.. and their primitive voice does affect the enjoyment a bit 😂 5 stars for the album, and -1 for vocals.

Glad I finally got to see what all the fuss was about for Arcade Fire. It was pleasant for sure but not exactly my style. I saved a few songs and would be happy to revisit them. Respectable 3.

its gonna be a no from me dawg. the only song i enjoyed was neighborhood #3. everything else felt like an experiment in a garage. never understood the Arcade Fire hype and well... guess I still don't

It wasn’t bad, but a lot of it was just washed out sound in my opinion. Not enough variety for me to give above a 3.

2.5 but I’ll round up to 3. Pleasant, but I didn’t feel blown away.

I was familiar with Wake Up and Rebellion before giving this album a listen from front to back. I didn’t necessarily get the reasoning behind naming a bunch of tracks the same thing but I also didn’t read into it. Chill rock and folk vibes that made for a really enjoyable experience. I’ll definitely be checking this one out again and might do a deeper dive into Arcade Fire in the future.

I've never really listened to Arcade Fire before (besides the previous album we had on this list), so this was my first time listening to this album. I absolutely love it! It is a perfect Indy album. Songs are varied enough but still maintain a standard sound. It's a good length with some standout songs, but it works better as a full listen. This is another example for me that I typically enjoy bands debut albums the most.

You can hear the self-importance oozing through the speakers.

This is a band I had never heard of before with a full string section and I am pretty sure I heard a French Horn. I feel like it is a bit of the Cranberries meets Belle and Sebastian but whatever it is ... I like it!

There’s only a couple songs on here I liked.

Did not like.

cool instrumentals i fw heavy! but the vocals arent really my thing. negligible for the cool instruments

The second half of this one really gets rolling. I’m more a fan of their later albums though.

I half enjoyed this. Some of the songs were a bit grating.

This album is pure nostalgia, I immediately rated this 5* because I got so excited that one of my fave albums was served up to me as soon as I embarked on this 1001 journey. I then came to quickly regret giving it 5* as it isn't a 5* album, and am thrilled to have found the edit function. I will however give it 4* with the caveat that this was a time and a place and I still think this is an excellent album but I'm aware that it holds a special place in my heart, therefore inflating the rating perhaps.

It's pretty good, im not personally a fan of the Wake Up song though.

Great cleaning-the-house music. Enjoyable but not memorable

Aside from Wake Up, which was used by U2 to introduce their live shows, i was completely unaware of Arcade Fire. This album definetly fits in the indie rock category along with acts like Foster the People and Friendly Fires. Some of the songs took on a droning noise parade feel like Haiti. Overall ok but not really my cup of tea.