Either Or by Elliott Smith

Either Or

Elliott Smith

3.39
Rating
29562
Votes
1
5%
2
16%
3
32%
4
28%
5
19%
Distribution

Reviews (page 11 of 14)

3.5 - sonically pleasant and pleasingly sad, woulda meant more to me if I had listened to it in my youth. Some absolutely stunning songs, sometimes gets a bit same-y.

Depressing

Actually listened to this twice as i was sure i missed something the first time around. turns out, it just did nothing for me

7/10 Elliot Smith is my kind of music. I like this whole album but couldn't name you one track that stands out 3-14-2024

Exceptionally breathtaking.

I already love it. I knew I would. Somehow I missed this album in my Elliot smith days. He absolutely influenced artists like sandy(alex g). Speed trails and 245am were my faves.

It’s a solid album and I can understand the influence on current similar songwriting music more than I did before after listening. I don’t know that I would return frequently to it but I enjoyed it.

This was chill but it was a bit too dead at times. It was nice as background music but nothing too exciting.

Some cool sounds on here but maybe not exactly enough to keep me engaged for the full 36 minute length. Not sure what else to say, pretty subdued melancholic record that probably requires my closer attention to lyrics.

There isn’t anything in current Indie music that wasn’t already present in Elliott Smith’s music—the whispered vocal melodies, the foundation of acoustic guitar, the stripped-down arrangements, the gathering darkness, the promise that will never be fully realized. Maybe “Ballad of Big Nothing” says it all: “You can do what you want to/There’s nothing to stop you.” If only that was still true for Smith, but we can live present tense in his legacy.

2/5 at work and 3/5 at home , kinda boring maybe it was revoluntary once now it sounds like a radio song I won’t change the station on but will never look up

Even when trying to listen to this as hard as I could, I still tuned it out.

Either/Or as in either skip it or don’t listen to it. A bit bland, lucky for us it’s only 36 minutes long. Either snooze through it or poker stick. (0.8*)

I think this album is pretty good, especially for coming out in the 90's. It stands out as different for its decade and definitely inspired Sufjan Stevens, Rilo Kiley, and The Shins to name a few. I like his whispery vocals and introspective lyrics. Very vulnerable and melancholy, also a little haunting given his life story. This album is for anyone trying to cope with something, especially a moody teen. It holds up well, very emotive and beautiful. I dig it.

The art of the joyful melancholic. At first I was not into this album but as it went on, the style stood out as something I hadn't heard before. Smith is able to make a sad song sound also happy. Simple and smart writing. Pretty good stuff.

This sounded like a low-rent worse version of every The Shins song I've heard. I feel like I could have heard this at a coffee house and wouldn't have noticed. It wasn't necessarily bad, but this album was completely forgettable. A few minutes after this ended I'm not sure I could name a single song or tell you anything about it. 1.6 stars

This is a really good album. sweet and emotional vocals and instrumentation, with catchy and heartfelt songs. could've been a bit longer, and had 1 or 2 slightly forgetable tracks, nearly a perfect album, but doesn't have that extra specialty to push it over the edge when compared to albums like TPAB, MBDTF or Dark Side Of the Moon

Not for me.

Love. I want to curl up in his voice and take a nap.

I think if I was more familiar with who he is as an artist I would have appreciated this more.

I'm not crying, you're crying! There's something about his music that strikes such a deep chord. This will always be one of my favorite records of all time.

he's like, the graham crackers of rock music. Nothing wrong with him but its not what i am jumping out for. Feels very soft.

A sad, depressing masterpiece. Love this album. RIP Elliot Smith.

Quite nice album. Reminds me of Sufjan Stevens.

If you like listening to Indie folk rock while wrapped in a blanket while in front of a fireplace on a gray winter day, this album is for you. Oh, and I forgot...the blanket is heavy and wet, the winter cold seeps in from cracks around the window frame, and the fire's gone out. Yep, it's musically and vocally competent but there's no sunshine here folks.

I got nothing out of this album. It felt very generic and while I'm sure that makes it easy listening... I just didn't vibe.

New one for me. Not as sad or tragic as his reputaion would have you believe.

pretty good

I listened to this about two years ago and liked some songs, but was mostly bored 😕 Going to give it another try... Reading the lyrics while listening definitely improves the experience. Just pure poetry... Gets a bit repetitive but solid overall.

musica leve, quase melancolica, gostosinha

Really not my thing.

Pleasantly surprised!

Amazing songs for when you're in a sad mood

Really great soft album, enjoyed say yes the most.

Nothing to write home about, but it's fine.

I seem to be in the minority here but I haven't heard of Elliot Smith and am a little put off by the album cover. My initial reaction to the opening track is "this is nice" but pretty soon it has faded sadly into the background. I realize I'm not listening, try to listen, but pretty soon my thoughts and attention have wandered again. Not a bad album by any stretch but I'm super not digging it. Third try I found a little more to like but mostly I'm alternately irritated and bored with the tone and content of this album.

Love this. Reminds me of my lonely, misunderstood uni years.

I'm already PMSing and feeling down in the dumps and now you throw an Elliott Smith album at me? I've always found him overrated and depressing and I can't see my mind changing anytime soon. Nope, it’s not changed.

I listened to this a couple times. I'm not sure why this album is included on the list. I think this one may be in the category of 'you had to be there'.

Not really my style -- a little whiny, but cool melodies and nice sparse arrangements.

Too many notes

Headbanging folk music from a whisper. Some tracks sound like acoustic versions of hardcore songs, which makes sense considering Smith used to be part of a hardcore band and produced for his girlfriend's punk band. Parallels with Cobain are obvious.

This one I just couldn’t get in to. I’m all for dark, slow, brooding music and artists but I found myself not listening and trailing off with my thoughts more than I heard the music. As always, respect to Elliot Smith but not my thing. Choice cut:2:45 am

Though I'd heard the name here and there, I'd somehow never listened to Elliott Smith before (though I recognise the sound from films). As soon as you put it on, you can hear that this is on another plane of songwriting. Loved it.

Folky guitar and some good lyrics, but nothing truely great. This album may never change the world, but it might just change your day.

it was fine but it was boring. Figure 8 album was yugely better

Didn’t get into the album

I know it's coming but that last line of Rose Parade kills me every time.

A perfect album.

Just the right amount of sad makes me happy. Rest in power, Elliott.

Half listened, went ok

Solid Indie-Folk-Rock-album. Unfortunately not even a single song stands out and stood in my head. 2.5

Haunting and absolutely beautiful

Repetitive, uninspired, insipid, there is absolutely nothing to enjoy about this low-energy emo rubbish unless you need something to make guests leave your party when it's getting late.

First few songs on my first listen and I wasn’t too sure. The album got better as the album continued. 2nd time listening and it’s a solid album. Points of songs remind of Death Cab For Cutie and/or Reliant K. 3.5

there was some poetry here at least could i write poetry to this? n

Clever wordplay. Catchy vocal melodies, many of which have been rolling around in my head for years.

I was asleep on the plane but when I came too it sounded great. It sounded way ahead of its time and I’m adding it to the rotation

Good, sad, a little simple, I like his following albums more

It’s hard not to listen to this without thinking about how hard Elliott Smiths life was, especially the way he died. However apart from a handful of songs, ‘Pictures Of Me’, ‘Rose Parade’ and ‘Cupid’s Trick’ which is far and away the best song here, not only is ‘Either/Or’ a depressing album, it’s also dull arrangements for large parts.

More like a -3, but ok

Didn't quite do it for me.

Haunting and beautiful

Mm okay ja niet mijn ding.

Haunting tone to his voice. Can almost really like it.

Feels like the Monkeys got sad and inspired Elliot to share his sadness with all of us.

# Playlist track - Pictures Of Me # Notes - My first time listening to Elliot Smith and reading up on his story. - Great album! It's sad, yes, but not in an annoying whiny way. More like "Sea Change" sad. - Definitely listening again.

Somber and mellow, good for a rainy day and a blanket and coffee. RIP Elliot. I respect him but the constant need to double vocals on every track feels like hiding weak singing. The album is fine.

Loved his production and good melodies

Depression never sounded so blissful. Smith’s ditties are outstanding, candid, and punchy. Every song on this album is so good. It weaves in and out of slower and fast as well, keeping the listener engaged and enthralled. A classic album from a tragic soul.

This is perfectly pleasant, if not very exciting, and does feel like an incredibly long 36 minutes. Having said that it is certainly not worth stabbing myself twice in the chest over.

Again, it is mostly fine. I really enjoyed the last song, Say Yes, but not enough of anything else to pull this above the middle of the road three stars.

I never really connected with Smith's records. I realize there is something there for me, but i never quite catch it.

Had not heard this album or artist before. Nice album.

Very nice album!

An all time favorite for me. Alameda hit this time for me.

Elliott Smith's "Either Or" seems to answer the question, "what is the sound of one Beatle clapping?" Musically, nearly every song sounds like a remix of the other; same key, same -- I'm not sure what to call it, diminished modulation? -- chord progression trick, same vocals delivered through a string and tin can. Lyrically, I couldn't get into it at all. Look, it's not bad, and I can see how this would really be people's thing, but it's not for me.

Excellent. Not sure why I didn’t know him

Amazing album

It was fine, I could even see maybe liking it if I listened to it a few more times, but there wasn’t enough there to make me want to.

Enjoyable album, very calm and relaxing.

Nice indie rock arrangements that became the template for the 00s. Not really vining with the melody though which I thought was forgettable.

Ganske kjedelig

Elliot Smith might suffer from being too influential to the soundscape, because listening to this album it doesn't particularly stand out. Still great sadboi vibes.

Beautiful and depressing. A massage for the ears but dont obsess over them lurics

good, but not my cup of tea.

A lot of songs sound the same.

Despite never hearing of this dude, this album sounds familiar in a good way. Quite a few bangers. Looking forward to more listens as I feel it may move up.

nice mix of songs

Better than the last one, but only by a little

original depresso meneer ken vooral between the bars van rick&morty heb niet helemaal naar geluisterd

Good album.

Pretty good!

Literally listened to this like earlier in the week cuz I'm always listening to it and don't need an excuse to listen to it but will gladly accept one. Here we go again.

Good songwriter, good music.

Nr. 119/1001 Speed Trials 4/5 Alameda 4/5 Ballad of Big Nothing 4/5 Between The Bars 5/5 Pictures Of Me 3/5 No Name No. 5 3/5 Rose Parade 4/5 Punch And Judy 3/5 Angeles 4/5 Cupid's Trick 4/5 2:45 AM 4/5 Say Yes 4/5 Average: 3,83 Unusual vocal style. Liked this very, very much. One of my favorite discoveries so far.

It's Elliott Smith

Speed Trials - 9/10 Alameda - 9/10 Ballad of Big Nothing - 10/10 Between the Bars - 10/10 Pictures of Me - 9/10 No Name No5 - 9/10 Rose Parade - 9/10 Punch and Judy - 8.5/10 Angeles - 9/10 Cupids Trick - 9/10 2:45 am - 8.5/10 Say Yes - 10/10 TOTAL - 110/120

Not my type of music.

A couple decent songs

Nothing flashy. Just good melodies and song crafting. This hits the mellow vibe just right for me.

Elliot Smith was christened an indie saint upon his death years ago, and I’ve spent that time trying to hear and understand the greatness, but I don’t. His delivery is so droll and completely uninteresting to me. His songs put me to sleep. He’s been compared to other artists I adore, and I’m just left scratching my head, trying to figure out if we’re all listening to the same thing. Maybe someday it will click, but for now I’ll pass.

The lyrics are melancholy, but the end product is a warm, pleasant listen. Elliott died from an apparent self-inflicted stab wound to the heart (WHAT?!) at 34, after an argument with his girlfriend, so he clearly dealt with a lot of demons. There’s also speculation he was murdered so who knows for sure I guess. Sounds like he talked about (and attempted) suicide a lot, and also had addiction issues. RIP to this tortured soul I’m just now hearing of. Thanks for the tunes.

I would have loved this if I were a teen/20 something. The chord changes and arrangements are very emotive, plus the breathy singing with lots of reverb. It's an intimate feeling. However, it doesn't speak to me like it might have earlier in my life. I can see why it was popular though, with kids listening with headphones after going to bed and dreaming of their future.

A- 5/5 I enjoyed it D- 3/5 nothing spectacular. Good tho

Pretty good. This listen reminded me of living in Iowa City in the late ‘90s.

Elliott Smith is apparently one of those guys who will get at least 4 stars from me. I have very little to say about this except that I liked it a lot. I knew it pretty much already and I have had a certain number of beers so I’m going to end here.

Another solid showing from Eliot Smith.

Favorite track: Say Yes

Easy to like and definitely preferred over Figure 8.

All songs sound the same. A whispering singer, with lots to say.

Weezer se fosse bom Fav tracks: Alameda, Ballad Of Big Nothing, Between The Bars, Pictures Of Me, Rose Parade, Angeles, Say Yes Least fav track: Speed Trials

I like Elliott Smith’s music, but I can’t seem to really get into it.

An slow-paced easy listen

Non-grunge 90's alternative; not too heavy, not too light. Really solid, talented singer/song-writer. A nice album to put on an listen to start to finish.

I'm usually Elliot Smith favourable, but I couldn't get into this one for some reason

Very interesting 90s Indie - I really liked it, but it got a bit repetitive toward the end, especially because it is such a long album.

VERY hard album to review. I listened to it passively hundreds of times in college. I really liked it back then, and it was just in the air. The people in college cooler than me were all telling me to listen. Now… I’m a little surprised that I’m much less into Elliot Smith and his voice and his writing than I used to be. The spell has definitely lifted. This is the one where he wrote hundreds of songs for, right? It sounds like… he wrote a hundred songs, and he released 12 demos. The songs just smack you upside the head, like, this is really good in a subversive, surprising way. Every once in a while he has a song that’s a unicorn song. One you would love to have written. But… the delivery! Is kind of lame! I’m not nearly as into it as I used to be. Seems lazy. I used to think something magical was going on. Now it just sounds lazy and a little hasty. First record was like… wow this isn’t nearly as good as I remembered it being, with those rose-tinted retrospective glasses. This might be my most unpopular opinion TODAY. For where music is today. It’s that this album is prettty okay with some phenomenal songs peppered in there that pretty mediocre in their delivery. I’m pretty over it. Could have gone for a 4 but will say a conflicted 3/5.

Good songwriting. Could have been early foo fighters if they went easy listening.

bland pablum, trite fluff, absolutely not worth the time, money or energy to record. I consider it an insult that you or anyone would present this to anyone to waste time listening.

Recently, I had the pleasure of listening to the first recordings Elliot Smith recorded back in high school with the band, Stranger than Fiction. What was revealed it that even at an early age Smith was a self-aware musician, singer-songwriter that matured with each recording that eventually led to his work with Heatmiser. By the time he released his first solo album in 1994, he was already a seasoned performer and his growth of a songwriter was obvious and is highlighted on Either Or, Smith's third album. The feeling at the time was that Smith could be "popular", but he didn't want to be. A solidly consistant record that didn't need "hits" or heavy production to get the message across. I enjoy most of Smith's albums for different reasons and Either Or, rightfully should be considered one of his finest.

Really love this album, reminds me of being a heartbroken teenager driving around town

Melancholic Radiohead / badly drawn boy influence Enjoyed

Good for a mellow listen

It’s been my favorite album since last year

Ya mean, Dad band can make a top 1001 album?!?! This sounds like it was recorded in a dorm room. Wasn't horrible though.

If you think ketchup is "a little spicy" and enjoy contributing to public radio, I've got an album for you.

Speak up son!

Not for me

Nice background music. I like his voice. Never heard of him until now.

90's emo. Even though this was time period, and seems like it is popular, don't remember ever listening to this before.

Solid. To listen again

This is fantastic sad music. It feels like he's right in the room with you, but not in a "let me play my guitar at you if you like it or not" way

Jack Johnson vibes

Not really my preferred style of music

Have to admit ... this one really grew one me. Felt indifferent about it at the beginning but by the end was very captivated by the melancholic nature of the lyrics and the structure of the songs. Worth a re-listen.

I hadn't heard Elliott Smith in a very long time, thanks for jogging my memory. This is powerful music, worth revisiting.

Indie-Alternative-Sound der 90er - damit bin ich aufgewachsen. War mir früher etwas zu "soft", aber jetzt gefällt es mir sehr gut! Tolle, intime Produktion und super Songs!

Nice pop album. Soft and humble vocals and acoustic guitar.

Beautiful, haunting sadness.

Enjoyable. I didn't really know this artist, but the music seemed familiar. Then realised some of it featured on the Good Will Hunting soundtrack - that's it!

nice listen but didn't really pull me in.

Will revisit

No one does what Elliott Smith did better than him.

First time listening to this album, and wow it is beautiful and painful at the same time, you really feel Elliott’s pain and emotions. I appreciated him before from songs I had heard but sitting listening to this now I feel I get it. This is his masterpiece. Such a talent. Five stars.

Listened to it twice and sad to say found it dull and lifeless. Appreciated the innate depth of feeling and melancholy in the songs and a few songs were pleasant but on the whole not a vibe for me.

I just can't seem to get into Elliott Smith, even after all these years. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ It's fine; maybe I just need the right mood/environment to appreciate it.

I probably need to listen to this album a few more times. I love XO, but Either Or sounds like I’m listening to the same song over and over again.

I’ve have between the bars on my repeat playlist and was looking forward to listening to this album. I think I like it, might need to listen to it over time for it to grow on me. But I love his musical style and wish other songs had hit me the way between the bars did. Maybe it will take awhile.

I got more into it as the album went on. I think I've heard Rose Parade before. I wanted to re-listen to some of the tracks. 3.4.

Hauntingly beautiful. Not a fan of it reminding me when I was a depressed 14 year old (lmao compared to currently a depressed 38 year old).

ANGELES!

Nothing hooked me or stood out. Quiet but not soothing to my ear.

It's ridiculous how obvious of an influence this album was on a generation of songwriters. Being able to connect Either/Or's legacy by threads of current indie rock is a treat of it's own. Smith tells personal stories of sadness, addiction and loss by blending metaphors and direct connections of the places Portland had to offer him ("Alameda", "Rose Parade", a line on "Punch and Judy" about driving around Division street). A balanced mix of songwriter with acoustic guitar ("Between the Bars", "No Name No. 5", "Angeles") and punchy indie rock indicative of the 90's ("Pictures of Me", "Cupid's Trick"). Final track "Say Yes" is a sweet, if not overly optimistic reminder, that there is always something to hope and strive for even after events of resounding sadness because throughout it all we'll still "be around the morning after."

What is with all these sad ass albums? It isn't objectively bad but I have a hard time connecting with an album like this. Every song sounds kind of the same to me with the acoustics and sing songy voice.

I enjoyed Figure 8 when it came up earlier and really thought this could be the time I get into Elliott Smith… alas It’s fine, the song writing is generally pretty strong, and I especially enjoyed Ballad of Big Nothing and the anthemic Pictures of Me. My main issue is the sound - I know it’s lo-fi but that’s not an excuse for the snare to sound as shocking as it does on some of these tracks, and any vocal parts that go into Smith’s higher register sound like he’s trying not to wake somebody up from next door

I'm ashamed I've never given this album a chance before.

Its all very pleasant for those who fear confrontation and conflict

Boring and all sounds the same.

This sounds like the stuff Jan from The Office would listen too. Pushing the definition of melancholic to its limits. Not bad, but I’ll never be revisiting it again.

I should never have listened to Say Yes before the rest of his stuff cos the rest of it's good but not in the same way and it took me way too long to appreciate it. That being said this album is gorgeous and the heavier moments come at perfect times and Say Yes as a closer is just stunning

Lekkere nummers, gewoon goed

Couldn't distinguish most words. Instruments overwhelmed vocals. Not for anyone clinically depressed even if they're on meds.

Kind of slow but worth another listen

A pleasant listen, if a bit dreary.

It's generally ok I guess, I like the guitar. However, I'm not into this sad kind of music atm and his voice is so monotonous. Angsty teenage me might've liked it more but present me is bored tbh

Die Lieder „Say Yes“ und „Between the Bars“ gefallen mir recht gut. Mit den andren Liedern kann ich weniger anfangen.

Feines Album, ruhig, aber nicht fad

Speed Trials: I have no idea what's going on but I like it. I really like his singing style. Alameda: I like this one. damn sad though. serious sad Ballad of Big Nothing: what a title Already. it's good too Between the Bars: I'm still not sure who he's singing to. sad but lowkey kind of romantic. Pictures of Me: I'm not sure about this one. I get it but also shut up. you know. No Name number 5: your name on my cast (*side eye*) this might cross into too much sad boi Rose Parade: This might my favorite so far altough I'm still not in love Punch and Judy: I gotta say the production on the whole thing has been really good and consistent too. Angeles: I think I might be too tired to understand this one Cupid's Trick: whut... 2:45 AM: okay nice ending I guess.

Not my type

Ooh, a late 90s singer/songwriter I haven’t heard of! ***three tracks later*** Oh, that’s why I haven’t heard of him…

Pretty good little album. I think I prefer it over the last Elliott Smith I had about two weeks ago.. the songs just seemed to make more of an impression on the first listen. On the second listen I think it grew on me with recognizing the melodies a little more. 7/10

Ganske kjedelig

Really feels like a bridge from the 90’s Britpop-influenced indie music to the modern indie sound. Not what I was expecting Elliott Smith to sound like, a very bright and full sound with generally powerful vocals. A few misses for me on the record, but I loved the songs I liked off it. Top tracks: Speed Trials, Alameda, Ballad Of Big Nothing, Rose Parade, Cupids Trick

Enjoyed it but wasnt head over heels, perhaps i wasnt in the sad girl headspace that i need to be in to enjoy

I liked it more than I thought. Gets better on repeated listens. I can tell a lot of modern bands were inspired by it, but the style doesn’t connect with me. Like I can tell it’s supposed to be sad, but doesn’t make me sad. Something is missing but I’m not sure what it’d need to bump up to a 5

Beautiful

It's not my taste but it's a band that makes music

I understand why this could be a great album. But at the moment I don’t feeling it :)

-i Have heard of elliott smith -but i have never heard this album specifically -this is very indie sad boy music which i do like -i like how soft and nice this is -his voice is distince but very soft -these songs feel very sweet and relaxing -90’s indie is truly the best and this is a good example of it -overall i actually really enjoyed this album! -i had heard say yes before and its probably my favorite on the album -easy solid four stars

This is Smith's third album, and contains some of his most famous songs. A few of these songs were in the film "Good Will Hunting," including the original "Miss Misery." That song received an Oscar nomination, and led to Smith's first few televised appearances. The success of the film propelled Smith's career. Smith's songs, with complex orchestrations and earnest, compelling lyrics worked well with the film's themes.

This is an easy 5 for me. Listening to this as a teenager when it first came out was formative for me.

Good stuff

Really enjoyed this, will listen to more Elliott Smith.

Some really nice songs in there and I would maybe come back again and listen. Got a bit tiresome at points but it was short and had some interesting chord progressions.

221223 16:30 4.5

Love this album and this artist!

Easy music, 3.5 stars. It was pretty samey. Stand-out: Angeles

The older brother of depressing indie music. Can see how it has influenced so many other artists. Enjoyed it

Well, ain't this purty? The style of playing and singing fewls like its been copied countless times, to the point where as the album went on it was starting to feel a tad derivative, despite it being the origin point, and that did start to sour the album, even though it's quite short, but that doesn't stop that there are some really pretty chord progressions here, and the more stripped down nature reminds me of Nick Drake, but 90s-ified. Just something that's really chill and relaxed, while still having this uneasiness to me, like something else is wrong and you don't know what, and I really enioy those types of albums. Am I rambling? I'm rambling.

Next 5 songs played by my Spotify Algorithm: Dinosaur Jr. - Goin' Home Fugazi - I'm so Tired Guided by Voices - As we go Up, We go Down Nick Drake - Pink Moon Sebadoh - Soul and Fire

Wel oké maar erg saai,

Niet echt mijn stijl

Vind deze heel lauw.

I could wax poetic about Elliott Smith for days if anyone would listen. When I find someone that will, we usually get along. A lot has been said about how sad his music is, but I think it’s very overstated. His music to me is about the mundanity of life. It’s not a bad or sad thing. Yeah sometimes it’s hard to get out of bed, but that’s whats so relatable about it. More so than the love songs that are so overdone by almost everyone else. Mundanity can be just fine. His music is about everyday people. I find some of it empowering even, but I’ll write more about that when I get to XO. Either/Or grew on me over the years after I first became a fan. It’s not quite as ornate as XO, and it doesn’t rock as hard as Figure 8. What it does do is explore the stories of various people. I assume some of them are about himself in the third person. When I first moved to Portland, I listened to Either/Or again while it rained on my car. I literally walked down Alameda with my headphones on listening to it again. I didn’t move here because of my love for his music, but it gave the place a little extra familiarity that it wouldn’t have otherwise had. Easiest 5/5 rating so far.

Rating: 10/10 Classic indie-folk album. What a masterpiece from Elliot Smith, so melancholic and emotional, you really feel his pain throughout the entire album. The singing is fantastic, the lyrics are fantastic, and instrumentally it is incredible as well. There are many memorable melodies on here too, each song sounds special in its own way while keeping the same theme throughout. Favorite songs: Pretty much all of them. Least favorite songs: No Name No. 5, Punch and Judy.

It took me four songs to realise that it was a new song x

Great vibes

Sad and lovely album. I've listened more to his later stuff, was good to get into this one instead. He really set the scene for the earnest singer-songwriter wearing his heart on his sleeve. Tragic end of course, and he never seemed a settled soul. At least we have these albums to remember him by.

Конечно, слушать Эллита впервые - круче, это прям срывает башку но альбом великолепный

у него такой нежный голос что слышать слово fucking как-то даже неловко...

элиот смит король ночных автобусов

Would definitely want to listen again.

Indie-folk. Un rollazo de cuidado...

Un poco rollo. Le doy un 3 porque me gusta la música de este estilo.

I've never heard of this band before but he's great! Listened through the entire album without a bad thought. I really like 2:45, angeles and between the bars. Really nice music with lots of great guitar. Might be one of my favorite albums here so far.

I really like the vibe on this album. Rose Parade is very pleasant. But then all the songs are pleasant. I think I've heard one or two of his songs before but I'm surprised I'm not more aware of Elliott Smith. I think a lot of indie bands have been trying to produce this sound lately. Elliott Smith was way ahead of the curve. And then he died :(

hit and miss, not too bad. 3.5

Such an awesome find! So gripping and meaningful.

Ethereal, moody, dirge-y. Some good melodies and a very certain vibe. Could grow on me. Best song: Alameda

Oh man, I can smell damp shoes and wet hoodies. Portlanders don't wear raincoats or carry umbrellas! Perma wet cotton is where it is at for months on end. And dark. No sun. And this music reflects this. Like a quiet walk home after a house party, with a light drizzle. Just enough rain to make your glasses speckled but not enough to get you truly wet. I'm a bit surprised I hadn't listen to any Elliott Smith, really, till now.

I’ve enjoyed Elliott Smith for years but never have listened to his albums front to back. I really like this album, but there are definitely highs and lows on this album. There aren’t any “ugh! Skip” songs but some don’t grab my attention. Say Yes, Between Bars, Alameda and .05 are my faves.

Ugh, such a low energy affair, especially after yesterday’s Iron Maiden album. This is what I expect an Art Garfunkel solo album sounds like, with a few random F-bombs thrown for a cheap bit of excitement. No thank you. I’m putting Maiden back on.

Sadboy singer-songwriter just isnt for me

Hard to come up with the words to adequately praise this album. Whew. It's like a beautiful gut-punch. His vocals are so sonically pleasing and fit the music/lyrics perfectly. The production is surprisingly complex for such a stripped down sound. I've spent more time with XO but this one is just as good if not better. Credit to Tessa for tuning me into him back in the day. His death hit her & some of our friends harder than me, but spurred me to dive in and really fall in love with his music. 5 - All-time classic

I liked it better at 37 than I did when it came out. I know it was indie and probably somewhat DIY but if the production was a little better with more crisp vocals it would sound more clean.

I enjoy the simplicity of the album. It’s not over engineered, it’s not over instrumentalize, just good songs.

It's fine. The genesis of the sad bastard mopey indie that I really didn't like during the early aughts. Probably wouldn't go to any great lengths to acquire or listen to this again.

It's not unlistenable, which is better than other albums on this list but I just found it very samey. It didn't strike a chord with me. I found it a little boring if I'm totally honest.

Really liked it, will add it to my rotation

Sad vibe but I'm here for it. Less moody more verge of angst, but somewhere between the two. "Between the Bars" - this song has been haunting me for years!!!! Very Deathcab for Cutie - Could see Seth Cohen really enjoying this.

Look, dude's story is super tragic. Talented but tragic. But that's partially because dude was a total mess and nobody around him seemed to do anything to help. Well, that shows in this album. It's also a mess. Smart and compelling at points... but a mess. And nobody around him did anything to help dial it back. I'd say that was a symptom of the times but we're still letting talent and madness run rampant without caring enough about the person to help them. See: Kanye. Anyway, it's an alright album but it could have been and should have been better. Smith should have had the time to refine his work but the folks around him valued his work over his personhood. And that taints the thing for me.

There’s a reason why my eldest son is called Elliott

I was reminded how much I enjoy Elliot Smith. I will be revisiting this. It was great.

Never heard of this, or him, before. Needs more listening to rate but say 3 for the first listen

Covers of these songs would probably be more appealing.

Best I can say is, “it was ok”. No memorable tracks. Not bad not good.

I don’t listen to Elliot smith anymore

Good background music for a calm vibe but nothing really stands out. Kinda basic in the end.

If I had had a bedroom pop phase – I never did – but if I had – i don't know why I never had one – does discovering Radiohead count? – but if I had – and I could have had – and if I had heard Either/Or at the same time, I would have loved it. As it is, I like it, but the possibility for me to truly love it has already passed.

angeles tune uit good will hunting <3 verder beetje tranqi maar wel lekker, muziek past niet echt bij de cover. cupids trick ook best leuk

it wasn't as depressing as i thought it would be

Pop style that doesn’t align my preferences but good guitar and atmosphere

I just had "Pink Moon" a few days ago. Is this album generator trying to give me depression? I flip between preferring this album and "Figure 8" pretty often, but both are so incredible that it doesn't even really matter. Up there with "The Glow, Pt. 2" and "Illinois" as one of my favorite whiny indie rock albums for losers.

It wasn't anything exciting, but it was good. I can see why it was critically acclaimed; the writing is good. It didn't blow me away, but I appreciated it.

Billie reccomeded this so I actually listened to this one. Will definitely be relistening - warm slow music. Vocals are billie eilish before she was even born - very chill, stripped back

Somehow reminds me of a 90s version of John Lennon's later Beatles songs. The ones i don't like, unfortunately.

Good album. I'd rate it higher except for the fact that Smith’s voice has a very limited range, and that leads to many songs sounding very much the same.

It wasn't anything exciting, but it was good. I can see why it was critically acclaimed; the writing is good. It didn't blow me away, but I appreciated it.

I've been meaning to check out this artist for a while now and I wasn't disappointed. It was like a delightful combination of Radiohead and Sufjan Stevens, two artists I really like. I loved the vocals and the chords, and pretty much every track on the album. Definitely will be listening to this one again.

Too emo for me.

Nearly a perfect album

Quite good, if not as good as Figure 8, but definitely more typical of his sound.

1. zpeed trialz - 1 2. alameda - 1 3. ballad of big nothing - 1 4. betueen the barz - 1.5 5. picturez of me - 1 6. no name - 1.5 7. roze parade - 1 8. punchk and judy - 1 9. angelez - 1 10. cupidz trick - 1 11. 2.45 am - 1.5 12. zay yez - 1.5

Very distinct sound and voice either you like or you love. It’s cool but I couldn’t do an entire album

Nice tone to his voice.

A nice gentle album. It reminds me of Sufjan Stevens.

pretty sick. Was a vibe fr

Pretty good 3 4 It bores me a little but I think I'll like it in time

The songs were fine, but all sounded very similar so didn't catch my ear.

This album brought back memories from my teenage years. I have a specific memory listening “Say Yes” during a busride in early morning after a rough night of party with a heartbreak. And btw thanks for Orange County to first introduce me to Elliot Smith!

😴😴💤💤

Excellent album.

Very personal feel with the layering of his voice and the foward-ness of his vocals in the mix. Singer/Songwriter or indie folk is not my style, but this was not bad. Very depressing songs though.

Not a genre I'm interested in

Quiet, indie rock. Not for me. 1/5

Excellent collection from a guy who left way too soon. Between the Bars is a standout on this album-also really liked No Name No. 5 and Rose Parade.

Beautiful Melodies little replyabaility bar angeles and between the bars 3.6/5

Too whiney imo

Not bad, easy listen and melodic music

Not for me…

Music and vocals was hard to distinguish. Boring.

I like this album, but none of it sticks in the mind and to be honest I'm not fussed if I hear it again, but it'll be fine if I do. So 3 stars.

perfect in every aspect of the word

Jeg lyttede til det her album først da jeg var på arbejde og efterfølgende da jeg kom hjem og skulle læse. Jeg kendte ikke kunstneren, men havde godt hørt hand navn i et afsnit af Rick and Morty (Tiny Rick afsnittet). Jeg havde regnet med noget melankolsk akustisk guitar og hvad der nu hører til det, og det var også delvist rigtig. I sidste ende sagde albummet dog ikke mig det helt store.

rose parade <3

Nice ethereal background indie

It's no surprise that Elliott Smith wrote and performed some of the most gorgeous music in his lifetime. Either / Or is a standout demonstration of his work as a singer-songwriter.

Good but downer

absolute perfection. an album you genuinely need to hear before you die. the lyrics, vocals, guitars, all of it crafted with such care. such an incredible, beautiful, spine tingling album.

Possibly my favorite album yet, this is perfect top to bottom. I had listened to a bit of Elliott Smith before since I knew that he was a pretty big influence on Phoebe Bridgers, but for some reason I hadn't really given much thought to this album as a whole. That was a mistake, this is incredibly good. First, I get the Phoebe Bridgers connection. Part of why I like her so much is how she writes incredibly powerful lyrics that are about highly specific, often mundane parts of day to day life. Smith does this really effectively too, and I can totally see how this album influenced her later work. "You're sitting around at home now waiting for your brother to call. I saw him down in the alley having had enough of it all." He just captures these little specific life moments so well. The album is definitely sad. Spotify's artist description says that Smith has a "distinctively melancholic sound", and that's probably a pretty apt description. But it has these small moments throughout that bring in bits and pieces of beauty or optimism that makes this all come together. And then "Say Yes" just totally brings it home at the end. It's definitely not a "happy" song, but it's upbeat sounding and romantic and real. The guitar has this poppy sound. It's a distinctively Elliott Smith song, even though it sounds pretty different from the rest of the album. "I'm in love with the world through the eyes of a girl...I'm damaged bad at best, she'll decide what she wants, I'll probably be the last to know". The album is a bit short (37 minutes for 12 songs), and Smith consistently ends songs a little before where you might expect other artists to end them. It works, there's no extra fluff, he gets across what he needs to. Say Yes is a great example at the end, it finishes a bit abruptly but it's perfect. Truly great album, one that I knew of but never gave enough attention to before this. I'm glad I finally did. "You can do what you want to whenever you want to. You can do what you want to there's no one to stop you." Favorite song: Say Yes Other: Speed Trials, Alameda, Ballad of Big Nothing, Between The Bars, Pictures Of Me, No Name No. 5, Rose Parade, Punch And Judy, Angeles, Cupids Trick, 2:45 a.m.

Very calming and chill. It's kind of like Bon Iver meets the Beatles.

My only preconception about this one is the vague notion that Elliot Smith music is sad--probably because of that one Rick and Morty episode. First Impressions: If yesterdays album felt like fall, this one feels like the dead of winter. The first couple songs are slow and sad to the point of bleakness. Its not until a few tracks in that theres a more up-tempo song, and even that one is not exactly cheerful. "So sick and tired of all these pictures of me....Everybodys dying just to get this disease". And that was just a short breather--its right back to the sad n slow after that. Oh yeah, this is a sad breakup album for sure. Its all heartbreak and loneliness. Could probably use this to induce a cry if needed. Some of these songs I think would be nice to try and learn on the guitar, but I'll have to try and pick one that isn't too sad, cos damn, I don't want my friends to worry about me. Maybe "Say Yes" ? Objective score is 4/5 but personal enjoyment score is 2/5. I'm too tight wound for the slower pace to really resonate right now, and I don't want to feel sad like this. But it's probably worth returning to in a different mindset. I will give 3/5 to try and reflect that feeling, rather than as a sign of being just "okay"

Some songs are way too whiny. If he used his full voice on every song, it would have been way better.

Chilled and deep, probs would have meant a lot to me as a troubled young boy

If I could give this album 4.5 stars, I would, but I'm rounding up to 5 stars, because this album and Elliott Smith, in general, is one of my favorites ever. I just think that "Either/Or" lacks cohesion and flow through it. "Figure 8" is extremely cohesive and flows the entire way through it, from song to song, and feels like one complete piece. "Either/Or" feels more like just a group of random - but very good - songs. Still, songs like "Rose Parade" give me goosebumps nearly every time I listen to it/them.

Actually very solid even though it's folky

I think there’s a lot to like about this album, but I don’t feel a need to listen to it again. Luxuriating in sad music is for younger people.

An absolute all-timer for me. Fell in love the second Cynthia Mason put “Say Yes” on a mix tape for me my freshman year of high school - same year the album came out. What a great time to be a disaffected teenage mope. I know Smith can be polarizing. Count me firmly on the pro side of the spectrum with this album squarely at the top of his canon - though I’ll listen to X/O any time. Genuinely made soft acoustic a punk rock experience.

Teenage/young adult angst becomes musically incarnate. Unfortunately, unlike other angsty contemporaries, Smith forgot to make any of the music fun. Most of the songs sound like the same sad bastard music, nothing stands out. I would need to be in a very specific mental place to enjoy this, like in my parent's basement right after my girlfriend broke up with me and I got fired from my job at Burger King on the same day.

This is a classic, though I am biased and already a fan of Elliott Smith. Elliott and the quiet dynamics of his songwriting are on full display here. Overall, a moody and depressing (to me) feeling album. "Say Yes" is still one of my favorite songs and it brings me back to my freshman year of college every single time.

Overall, this album was fairly decent but not exactly my favorite genre. I recognized some of the songs from Good Will Hunting which is one of my favorite movies. I think this connection raises my appreciation of the album but I still find it too "whispery" for the most part.