Reviews (page 3 of 8)
This rules in the same way that 70s grindhouse flicks rule
A bit cringe. Another example where instrumental versions would be an improvement.
It took three disjointed listens of this album for it to land with me. Drum loops and bass lines would grab me. Next, Dr. Octagon (Kool Keith) would be reviewing his latest patient in gross out fashion as he seems to specialize in medical issues that are not discussed in polite company. He shifts gears to visit the outer planets in an updated/forerunner version of Afrofuturism. The snippets were amusing and striking, and after bearing down a bit my pleasure rose. The rollicking organ driven “Earth People” licks off a three song streak that sent me bouncing through my empty classroom on a Monday morning. His Tracy Morgan style raps and vocals were endearing in a drunk, crazy Uncle manner. Aside from the anatomy lessons, Kool Keith references a bevy of fellow musicians ranging from the Grateful Dead to Kurt Cobain to repeating the chorus of Christopher Cross’ “Sailing.” Those links are immediately followed with lyrics about enzymes, eggs, LA nights and robots. It reminds me of R.E.M.’s “It’s the End of the World.” Definitely a word salad to enjoy. Unlike a comedy record, I believe Dr. Octagonecolgyst will get better with future listens. I’ll pick up on more of the jokes and musical references. Kool Keith has created an enormous collage that will reward multiple looks.
It wasn't the worst, but any interest was diminished by the sexual comments that come off more sexist than anything sexy. I tend to chuckle at songs with allusions to sex (i.e. Sabrina Carpenter) and maybe it's because it's a man and commenting on "cock" can automatically come off as weird, but it's the same ick as a man being a gynecologist. Why exactly do you feel a need to do this?
I've never heard of him, or it. The rapping is okay but, as usual, it's overlong and plaqued with nonsense.
dont know what depraved son of a bitch made this but im on the right track i guess. old school my ass
Not what I expected. Pretty solid old-school rap album. Nothing was familiar other than the style, but it was pretty good.
There isn't a "will not listen" option, so going with one star.
Things I don't like: the album title, the whole concept of the main character, porn sound bites, most of the weird lyrics, juvenile humor Things I like: how it sounds, his flow, some of the weird lyrics, Dan the Automator If I listen to this purely sonically, and pretend I don't understand words, I like it. But the lyrics are indeed there. Also, I absolutely refuse to listen to a song (by a dude) called 'A Visit to the Gynecologist' ...
Gawd awful.
You can hear Dan the Automator loud and clear. It’s honestly got a sound that was way ahead of its time for hip hop. It was vintage but new. The delivery was off kilter and stilted and that added to its charm and inability to be labeled as a singular sound. Kool Keith really hit it out of the park with this album.
This album, while very explicit, was pretty good. The overall, beats were solid and had a good groove. My expectations were low, it did over deliver.
This is so random. I genuinely don't know whether I like it or not. I suppose the creativity is absolutely off the charts, but the surrounding topics of some of the songs are just a bit odd... The whole concept of 'Dr. Octagon' being an 'extraterrestrial gynaecologist' is just weird, and some of the dialogue throughout is disturbing, especially in the song 'A Visit To The Gynecologyst'. I did, however, find 'General Hospital' somewhat amusing, with the last line being 'Oh shit, there's a horse in the hospital!'. This line alone is what the first star in my rating is for. The backing tracks, however, were great throughout, and they may be the only reason that this is getting more than a 1-star rating... With that, here are some of the songs that stood out to me more than the others (this in no way means I enjoyed all of them): Earth People General Hospital A Visit To The Gynecologyst I'm Destructive
Made me feel queasy. Back to school for the doctor.
I was not familiar with this artist nor album which reflects my paucity of knowledge of hip hop. This quickly lost me. The intricate lyrics and sci-fi atmosphere left me cold.
Just not my thing
Not big on rap. And the music is crazy filthy. But I love it. Been on rotation all day and I'm still trying to work it out. 4*
Not from the 60s, isn't jazz, isn't some experimental album that you have to listen to 7 times to get. However its some form of hip hop where nothing rhymes. Song - Earth People The chorus is jarring. "earth people, New York and California" "earth people, I was born on Juipiter" The whole album seems to be "what if I was an alien making music, with the same synth on repeat over and over, made no sense, had random samples, and made hip hop music, but also didn't know how to rhyme, and just threw in random space and science terms" 2/5 its listenable, enjoyable at times, but some of these songs are just rough to listen to
I always try to think of something positive, so ... um, let me think...they referenced Kurt Cobain twice... and I quite like Nirvana.
I love this album - completely bizarre, hysterically (and stupidly) funny, one-of-a-kind.
Lyricism was suspect and didn’t like the skits, but the beats and rap flow were sick
4.25 had to get past the intro them it was all gravy.
I thought the sci-fi concept was cool here. I tend to like records like this. I remember Ryan Adams did a record about a space war or something and I dug that too haha. A friend told me if I like this I should dig in to MF Doom and some Edan and some other stuff.
Not even 30 seconds in and I'm just like ughhhhh. Interstitials were annoying as fuck, which docked this to a 1* for me.
JFC this is terrible. Starting to question why I’m on this quest to listen to all of these albums.
Det va gøyere enn æ frykta, om enn ikke helt for mæ. Men det va hyggelig selskap i timen det varte!
judging by the name and album art im guessing this is some bullshit. well... didn't expect it to be old school hiphop which isnt really my thing but it doesnt sound bad... not gonna actually listen tho just skipped through
This is Tracy Jordan, right?
Oh yay… another hour of hip hop. Yknow, there genuinely have been hip hop albums on this list I’ve enjoyed, but this is not one of them. We got off to a good start with a sound bite of a woman moaning “fuck my pussy doctor”. That gave me a huge ick right off the bat. Also, saying pee-pee doo-doo unironically in a track. Ew. What are we, 5? All it needed was a kid to run in and yell 6-7 to complete the experience. Earth people was slightly better as it was a complete track. I still wouldn’t say I enjoyed it though. No awareness wasn’t offensive either. Real Raw: best lyric, “computer tracks on your ass cracks” or “I battle any yeast infection”. Blue flowers - eh, was aight. I only have one question about Technical Difficulties. Who can stop a pepto bismol? A visit to the gynaecologist was so fucking creepy. Bear witness was ok, but that’s cause it only had one lyric. A track named after the artist. Hm. Well it was ok. Girl let me touch you - weird. Im destructive, wild and crazy, they cool. Halfshark… it aight. Im not gonna go into the rest of them, this was a struggle of an album. A lot of the time it was just really gross. 1/5 ⭐️ 105/1089
right up there with deltron 3030 and handsome boy modeling school, minus one star for being less playable in public
Definitely understand hear what made this influential for underground hip hop like DOOM and Aesop Rock. Overall pretty fun albeit a little long-winded, but definitely hits at most times and was overall a solid experience. 7/10
I can appreciate a flow but at the end of the day I couldn't stand the citing of random schematics. like a man locked in a cage
This is the kind of Hip-Hop I actually like! It's fun, creative, self-aware and doesn't take itself too seriously. The Dr. Octagon character is ridiculous and out-there. Yes, it does get a bit crude sometimes, but that's to be expected with Hip-Hop in general, and with this album in particular, as it is about an intergalactic gynecologist. More of this weird sci-fi Hip-Hop and less of the usual, please. Key track: 3000 Earth People Blue Flower
Honestly i kinda liked this. Could've done without the porno skit to start, but it had the right level of campiness for me to be fun instead of cringe. And the music itself was good.
get this shit off the airwaves dawg
Kinda lame but giving benefit because it was early in the game.
Wonderfully bonkers. 8/10.
This is so insane. Lol. 1-800-PP5-DOODOO. 😂😂 all these songs were written by a 12 year old
Was told this one is inappropriate to play at work. Doesn't matter that I work from home
Should be a 4 but it’s about 20 minutes too long and the gyno jokes have aged like milk.
Buddy of mine always hyped this album but I never listen to it until now. Pretty good.
step into the office of dr. octagonecologyst, the solo debut album of kool keith, member of ultramagnetic mcs. some surreal and creative rap music today; this guy has a flow that no other rapper seems to match. a point of interest on this album is sample usage, a good amount of sound clips taken from x-rated films. this album smells. this album smells like caca and wee wizz. but it's very riveting. just close your eyes as a rubber glove enters your butt. this is standard procedure.
Enjoyed this, interesting beats and a cool sci fi-ey vibe. Some retro scratching stuff mixed in with the more abstract hip hop I enjoy most.
Underground New York styles, crazy throwback beats and ratchet lyrics in the best way possible. MF Doom
That was the most uncomfortable listen I’ve ever had
This is good stuff but can really listen it once a year.
That was a trip
TBH I didn't even finish it
very weird and original, I like it
2/10
This album is all over the place. Avant-garde for the time perhaps, but isn’t my style.
Not my favorite type of groovy rap
Brilliantly mad and dark
Great mad stuff that only got made in the 90£
Fairly forgettable 90's hip hop by Kool Keith with off the wall lyrics and sexual humor.
One of the more original and inventive hip hop albums, with elements of psychedelia and trip hop amongst the standard beats. You tend not to get 40 minute concise albums in this genre and it starts to go on a bit in the last twenty minutes. I can't get TOO worked up by it but it was a diverting listen for the most part without saying a great deal poetically.
I put this one off for a long time because I didn't know when I would be in the mood for it but it was actually quite good. I really enjoyed the production and the premise and lyrics were pretty funny. If the concept really bothers you that much you should consider lightening up.
Far far too many songs
They were definitely trying to do something fun here but kinda missed
I’m afraid I was not high enough to appreciate this.
New genre; Fantasy Fetish Rap
Good technique over some boring-ass beats, with lyrics that sound like they were written by a horny 14-year-old boy. Cover art this cool shouldn’t be wasted on a product this subpar.
7.
I wasn't expecting to enjoy this, however I really dug it - great beats, great flows, wacky theme. Only complaint is that it overstayed its welcome a bit - even with a few skits thrown in, 20 tracks was quite fatiguing.
Not a big fan of this record. I liked the flow at times but it’s too… old school hip hop for me. Idk the production just fell flat to me.
Listens: Many Standout Tracks: Earth People, Blue Flowers / (Revisited) I know that people taking this Journey aren't going to look kindly on this album. Those. People. Are. Wrong. Yes, there's toilet humor, dick fart and sex jokes. Yes, it's absolutely absurd. Yes, it's juvenile. It's also wildly original, avant-garde piece of music that fuses a whole bunch of genres - including the budding trip-hop genre - emerging during the 90s. The samples are on-point and the whole thing was produced by Dan the Automator, who went on to produce such genius works like Deltron 3030, Handsome Boy Modeling School's So...How's Your Girl, and Lovage: Music to Make Love to Your Old Lady By. For all it's incredibly offensive subject matter, the album is still fucking awesome. Kool Keith brings to life a character that has serious moral and ethical problems and it just works. The whole thing just works. Also, how else are you going to cure your Moosebumps, if not by listening to advice of a homicidal, extraterrestrial, time-traveling gynecologist from Jupiter.
Listenable. Not groundbreaking to my ear, but some early trip hop and pretty great Dj breaks. 3.
Boo. DNF.
I kissed this when it came out. I really liked this much more than I do 90% of hipster rap. Dan the Automator does great work on this album. The album is too long but so were more hip.hop releases in this era.
This was a listen alright. Don’t care for the vocals or narrative though i’ll give it points for having a set in stone theme, i do however enjoy the beat and flow. Overall, not for me.
This is a very good album by a highly skilled rapper. It was very enjoyable, with good beats, but what makes it for me is the incredible wordplay and flows, though sometimes the lyrics don't make any sense. It is a little long, but still, a solid rap album. 4/5
whatever man
The perfect album for a 13 year old boy. Some funny concepts but overall waaaay too juvenile for me.
Nothing special, ultimately.
Never heard of, will never listen to again.
Kool
This was never living up to the cover but what a unique combination. Not sure if it all worked for me but appreciated the big swing taken.
Inconsistent and juvenile but quite a fee tracks with great flow
Tiene buenos ambientes como el buen hip-hop. Pero hay algo demasiado oscuro y no le veo ni un rayito de luz. Tons no sé, me dan ganas de quitarlo pero luego agarra. Y hay personaje el doctor que yo creo que es proctólogo por que mencionan bastante el ano.
Fun album, I enjoyed many beats a lot, I don't think I would listen to this in my daily life tho, but it sounds cool
Mad, rude, weird, epic and absolutely full of nonsense. From a pure beats and flow aspect this is good. The concept is bat shit crazy and if thats your sort of thing then go for it.
Definitely creative, definitely funky, definitely weird. While it wouldn't be a rap record without juvenile and offensive lyrics, everything from the subject matter to the rhymes to the mellow off-kilter delivery reassures you that in no way does it take any of itself seriously.
I think if I’d heard it back in 1996, there’s a strong chance I would have loved it, but in 2026 I thought it was decent if overlong.
I don't know. It didn't do anything for me. 2.5 Stars Edit: Just read some of the other reviews. Kinda glad I didn't do a full on intentional listen on this one.
I like the concept, but I was a left a bit disappointed by the album itself. Despite the many interesting choices in production, very few tracks grabbed me. Favourite track: Blue Flowers
Uninspired shit. Not a single original thought here.
Where is MF DOOM?!
Great to revisit this, but listening to Automator always makes me want to listen to Shadow. top track: Bear Witness
The worst part of 90s Hip Hop albums are the skits. This felt like one long skit, especially because KK's voice is very one note. Beats are good, lyrics are dumb, Pushead art is cool. 2.5⭐️
Dan the Automator er sådan en fed producer, jeg ville ønske han arbejdede med mere interessante rappere
Jeg synes det er fed! Vildt gode beats, dybt underlige vers, idiosynkratisk. Stor 3'er.
Funny concept, but it was a bit too dirty and too long. It might work on a song or two, but a whole album was too much for me.
Not for me. The beats were great, the juvenile concept, lyrics, and humor did not age well.
I watched Louis Theroux's "Inside the Manosphere" last night. It's difficult to not draw a line between a lot of these 1990s rap albums featuring significantly misogynistic lyrics and these manosphere influencers who are little more than pimps and grifters. Similar thoughts extend to early Eminem and Biggy. On a positive side I really enjoyed the flow of the rapping, the sampling and the beats of this album.
first listen hilarious and fantastic production
Classic of the genre yet again, the ripple effects of Kool Kieth can be seen in a lot of great rappers (MF Doom, Mad Libs, etc.). While certainly not my favourite album, it's an interesting and fun one to listen to again. Maybe I'll listen to it again, but not for a little while. Highlights are Real Raw, Blue Flowers, and Dr. Octagon.
I like certain tracks which are trip hop vibes but the whole album is mid.
Again another hip-hop I haven't clicked with. Doesn't have the funky beats of Jurassic 5 or Public Enemy.
For me, the most offensive crime any art can commit is to bore me. I'd rather listen to a 3 hour album of carefully constructed railroad noises than some of the generic and uninspired britpop that found its way onto this list. Say what you will about Dr. Octogonecologyst, but this is one of the most unique albums I've come across from the 100 or so I've listened to so far. Sometimes it can be hard to review the albums on this list. If something's bland, there's often not much to say since you forget that you listened to it. On the flipside, everyone knows the impact and talent in Pink Floyd, so what can I say that really adds to the conversation? This album stands out and will likely be among the few discoveries I look back on with appreciation when complete with the list. It's aggressively tasteless and does not apologize for its bizarre themes. When reading the Wikipedia page prior to listening, I first thought this would be akin to the Insane Clown Posse or something. While it can be juvenile in tone, Dr. Octogonecologyst differs from the ICP in that Kool Keith is legitimately talented. There's a great fusion of psychadelic and electronic music into Keith's lyrics, mixed with a flowing set of vocals that leaves you unsure of what'll happen next. Ultimately, this gets a strong 4 stars as I reserve my rare 5 star ratings for truly groundbreaking albums. It'll definitely be one that I revisit. That being said, I completely understand the general reaction to the vile lyrics here. It's abrasive. Highlights: Earth People
A doctor... from the future... that can't spell Octogon? Maybe that's just the future's way of spelling it. Otherwise, fun little concept album featuring east-coast boom bap hip-hop.
Because Deltron 3030 exists, this one suffers by comparison. I like most of the weird flow and ideas, but the porn stuff loses me and is a real yikes.
oh shit there's a hoarse in the hospital
Temu version of MF DOOM. My first 1 star rating after 100+ albums.
Álbum de hip-hop um pouco datado nas letras, porém muito rico musicalmente. Tangzu Wan'er 2 Bass Editon.
Op zich verrast, maar niet helemaal mijn ding
Ok well that was a lovely beginning. This album sounds like something a 12-year old thought was funny. Some of the rapping is good but it's just few and far between all the unpleasant doctor skits.
I can't. I won't. Please don't. It wasn't noisy in my ears but also what are these lyrics? what are these sound effects? I am judging me for listening to it.
i fuck with this heavy. i love old school hip hop. i love a weird nigga with talent who doesn't take shit too seriously but is serious about his craft. the production is great. the lyrics are fire!! and it tells a story. I'm glad i was introduced to this nigga. anyone else who doesn't fuck with this shit either doesn't understand hip hop or is just racist
3.5
Þessi er ekki beinlínus ferleg, en hún er skrýtin án þess að vera áhugaverð eða skemmtileg. Eitt rennsli og tæpur tvistur.
Zaney and Crass. Gotta admit it's a unique concept. 3.7/5
2 sterne
+ Great beats, nice production, keeps the sound consistent for its long runtime - The long runtime, general theme of the album and ... questionable lyrics. Nothing wrong with being a bit edgy on your nicely produced hiphop record, but for such a long album AND including some pretty bad interludes, yeah that deducts some points.
a ton of fun
Made me wonder why anyone would make this. Also made me glad someone did
more crude, less talented version of mf doom. 3.5
Not my cup of tea
I liked this more than I thought it would. I love the samples and the music. Other than the song about the gynecology visit was just kind of silly and juvenile, the rest of the album was a vibe.
Very cool beats and all, but the lyrics are often beyond cringe...
Based on the album artwork I expected this to be a metal album. Overall I liked this quite a bit. There are some odd sample choices going on and the subject matter is a little something, that are going to keep this at 3 stars for me.
Eh, the story is BS, but there's too many good things to ignore this one completely. 2 stars, the "story" really pulls this one down.
This was pretty good for me, I like the Dan the Automator production intt general and, in general, like the Kool Keith presence on top. Maybe I just had a soft-spot for off-beat, made up personas. I could have done with less of the interspersed porno audio -- but in general pretty ok
Either the album is too conceptual for my taste, or it tries to be more than it really is.
Fine if pretty bland 90s hip hop. Don't really have a lot to say about it other than that it didn't really strike me as memorable in any sense. It's cool in concept but I'm just not fond.
This thing felt like a bargain bin Enter the Wu-Tang cosplay. Same “grimy skits between tracks” blueprint, except instead of kung fu clips you get corny medical bits that aren’t clever and they’re just there taking up time. The whole album comes off like it’s trying way too hard to be weird, and it ends up sounding like someone dared a decent rapper to make a concept record and then forgot to write the actual songs. I finished it out of spite, not enjoyment.
This is one of the worst types of rap. Just a monotonous Casio beat in the background and incessant talking about nonsense that passes as music somehow. I don’t get who listens to this and likes it. How did this person or band become accepted as a musician?
Although the premise is a bit out there, the tunes aren’t bad. Interesting to read the lyrics which are quite a bit more science-y than most hip hop, and it’s delivered quite competently. It’s not something I’d be in a rush to listen to again, but probably good if you like that sort of thing
I truly don’t know how to feel about this record. There is something undeniable about the talent on this album and the idea is different to the usual fare. However, many of the lyrics are pretty juvenile and it kind of leaves me flat.
Plenty better hip hop albums on this list
Infantile and stupid. Simply an outrage. Rap, hip-hop, electronic music. There's always someone who's into space gynecologists and surgeons. All I can say is that for me, it was an absolute waste of time. My incomprehension of people, the critics, who rate this "comic-sound garbage" highly only grows stronger.
# Album Name: Dr. Octagonecologyst # Artist: Dr Octagon # Rating: 2/5 # Comments: Naw, not my thing at all. Too long. Poor overall. # Top Tunes: # Would I listen to it again? No
There are some decent grooves here but I really cannot be doing with the juvenile ‘pornocore’ or whatever he calls it.Just stop. Next
Wasn't as bad as I thought. I liked the beats
Musically, this is a surprisingly strong and inventive hip-hop record. Dan the Automator’s production is textured and atmospheric, blending dusty samples, jazz-leaning grooves, and off-kilter rhythms into a sound that still feels distinctive decades later. DJ Qbert’s turntable work adds another layer of creativity, and the beats often carry a depth that rewards close listening. The challenge is the concept itself. Kool Keith’s Dr. Octagon persona—a bizarre, extraterrestrial gynecologist—leans heavily into surreal, grotesque imagery and dark humor. It’s certainly memorable, but the subject matter can also be distracting and occasionally off-putting, pulling attention away from the genuinely interesting music underneath. There’s a lot here to admire from a production and creativity standpoint. At the same time, the album’s strange concept makes it harder to fully settle into. It’s the kind of record you respect more than you necessarily return to. Creative, weird, and undeniably unique—but ultimately more intriguing than essential. A three.
kool keith weird raps
Quirky
The skits in this album, just like most from this era of hip-hop, are painfully dated at this point (pretending to be a female doctor and basically raping your female patients... WTF). But if one is able to put aside the massive 'ick' factor, it's quite a slick record in terms of Kool Keith's rapping. Very surreal/avant-garde lyrical style, especially for the time period, and great production overall.
The forerunner of a lot of good rap music. Unfortunately the music itself is not that good. 2.5
Unusual concept. Kinda amusing in spots. 2.5 stars
Sounded good, but the lyrics made me extremely uncomfortable.
4.5/10
2026.02.25-26.
I have never heard of Dr Octagon, but he is my JAM!
Been meaning to listen to this one for a while, good thing I did cuz HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLY SHIT
great underground hip hop!!
A little slower than I remembered but still an absolute banger record.
558/1001
Cool, laid back, funny, very horned up. What's not to like? A very easy record to enjoy. A welcome addition to my, admittedly very small, stable of hip hop knowledge. Listening to music from unfamiliar genre's is like going on a city break and trying to figure out the public transport system, it's more fun that getting the train at home but you won't be doing it every day. There's plenty of nuance I won't understand about why this album is special because I don't know what's easy and what's hard when it comes to making music like this, but it isn't hard to appreciate the sense of humour and lyrical flow of `Dr. Octagon`. From the porn movie dialogue samples (`Intro` / `Visit To The Gynecologist`) to the tracks that read like one long role play chat-up line (said with absolutely nothing but respect - `Girl Let Me Touch You`) I was immediately considering what kind of mix I could drop using something from this record as I was listening to it. I'd never heard of Dr. Octagon before and I don't know how well known they are these days, the Spotify monthly listener sits at a respectable 91k listeners which is really not bad for an underground act that released their first record in 1996. All it'd take is one viral tiktok trend using a sample of theirs and they'd be off to the races again. But I digress, `Dr Octagonecologyst`, there's no dance-floor heaters, heartbreakers or all round crowd pleasers, but it's funny, clever, chilled and and a little sinister. `Bear Witness` is a standout banger which brings to mind `The Avalanches` best work. I'll be putting on again for sure.
это самый хорни альбом что я слышала, Мигель подвинься
beats are good. Vocals are ass
Based on the intro, I'm not going to waste my time on this album. Not sorry.
Zzzz entiendo su valor pero no lo pude terminar. 1.5
Cool production and flow. Really like this.
Kinda creepy why is he so obsessed with this gynecology but its good
This sounds good musically, but the lyrics are truly stomach-churning. This album is ultimately quite vile when it comes to the lyrics. I actively disliked listening to it because of its content. I guess I'm a huge prude / loser.
May be the sickest shit I’ve ever heard
The skits get a 1 star because they are gross and cringeworthy. That and the juvenile lyrics about poop rockets and gynecology keep this from being higher rated, because the music/rapping were otherwise excellent.
Just no
What a silly sausage. I think I might just sneak this into the threes, on the basis that it's quite good fun, but it's also outrageously puerile and at times outright horrible. A mixed bag.
It's... not very good. Beats are okay if a bit flat. The horrorcore rap is not enjoyable to me at all. What is the point? MF Doom did characters way better and he is not even on this list. 2/5
So weird. So offensive. Beats are ok
#44/1001 🇺🇸💀🥼👽 Musically i love this. Less keen on the subject matter but i guess that this was the 90s (no excuse - it's just silly). It's better when he's not talking about medical procedures. Best tracks: 3000, Bear Witness
pretty dull monotone album not sure what it brings to its genre or the music world in general
2 out of 5. It had a flow and the album art gets a point.
The production and turntable work are the strongest parts of this. The rapping is fine and I can have a fun time with juvenile lyrics and subject matter, but it gets a little exhausting over the course of a full hour. I didn’t hate it but was kind of relieved when it was over. Obligatory “this is kind of misogynistic” knock.
I would never seek this out but it was a fun listen
The only thing I liked about this album was the smooth beats and mixing of the instrumentals. The character work and story doesn't work for me. It's woman-hating, sexualizing, all-around icky.
Lots of crazy shit going on and you know what I'm here for it Favorites: 3000, Earth People, I'm Destructive, Waiting List
The edgelord tendencies haven't aged particularly well, but Keith's flow is exceptional, the scratching is sublime, and the production is a treat across the board. Always good to be reminded what hip hop can do when not tied to trap beats. And while the stream-of-consciousness lyrics combined with the pulp/sci-fi/kitsch backstory would go on to influence some of my favorite rappers of all time, I just wish Keith's consciousness wasn't so juvenile and, well, gross (tongue in cheek though it may be). A keystone of underground rap and a refreshing counterpoint to the gangster rap that was dominating the scene at the time, but others would take this concept to more satisfying places.
I lost weight listening to this.
Not bad, some good moments here and there. I do appreciate the creativity and abstraction of these raps but in the end nothing really stuck with me. Likely will take many listens to have any of these stories be interesting to me but I dig all the rap styles on here. At least there’s some interesting sounds in the backing tracks although a lot of the beats can be quite bland. The biggest stand out has got to be the amazing scratching of Q-bert! This was a decent listen and makes me wonder how it all fits in Kool Keith’s career but I would say that this is not essential for me but I can see why it may be for some.
Definitely not my thing. Ridiculous and rapey.
Blind album and artist. I love the instrumentation style and beats, but i did not like the lyrics or vocals as much as some other artists and albums.
Anfangs fand ich's ziemlich gut. Bin pro Rap-Konzept-Alben, die Beats waren fett aber irgendwann nach 30 min hab ich mich schon gefragt wie breit man dieses originelle Thema treten kann (ich würde sagen etwa 30min) und die folgenden weiteren 35min hätte es nicht gebraucht.
Überraschend unterhaltsames HipHop Album.
Wer hätte gedacht, dass Konzeptalben über außerirdische Gynäkologen gut sein können... But here we are Beats fetzen richtig rein "Like my cock"
Hooray for a hip hop album! This list needs more hip hop.
Interestingly a rap album without an excessive amount of profanity, with the complete degradation of women, and without 100 uses of the dreaded asterisk word!! Is it raunchy? At times yes, but for rap not excessively so, and the lyrical flow is smooth and fast and the backing beats awesome. Harkens back to old school east coast rap. Solid.
I have never heard this guy before. It was pretty good.
5/16, 31%
It’s interesting going through this list as a hip hop novice. I’m familiar with stuff played on the radio and a few big names, but can feel totally lost when I encounter something off the beaten path. That was definitely the case with this — had zero knowledge of Kool Keith or any of his many pseudonyms. Musically, it instantly worked for me… trip hop is the most natural connection between hip hop and the music I like best. Loved the jazz foundation. Loved the spooky sci-fi sounds and samples. The lyrics were definitely a shock having no idea what I was heading into. I’m used to gangsta rap braggadocio but wasn’t quite sure what to make of dinosaur farts and violating medical exams and Donald Duck giving head amidst the more accessible sci fi and horror tropes. Honestly I was a little disturbed that I was so into it. I think it all worked for me because once upon a time I was a historian of medicine, so I know that the vast power we give to doctors is pretty contingent. Right below the surface are all the weird mad scientist tropes and the juvenile violence of cutting people open just to see what’s inside. I like that true character of Dr. Octagkn blows all those subtle distinctions apart. Yeah, asometimes it’s silly or a little sick. And agree with everyone who says most rap albums of this era could be shorter. But I also appreciate that this era allowed for stuff that got sooo weird.
Sick beats and unhinged rhymes. Kool Keith was wayyyyy ahead of his time, and you can still feel his influence on modern rap. Great pick for the list.
What the hell was this? I was expecting to really hate this album, I mean, it’s a rap album about a gynaecologist from Jupiter, and I’m not much of a rap guy, but for some reason, I kind of enjoyed it. The lyrical subject was quite bizarre, but I'm usually more of a music guy, and this album had many solid beats.
About 30 seconds in, you have a pretty good idea what you’re about to experience. To me, this album was clearly made by a very talented rapper and producer (it’s instantly apparent we’re in the same solar system as Deltron 3030). But they chose to focus those talents on shock rock and gimmicks, which I find off-putting. For a conceptual album, it’s pretty flat, with not much being developed after the first few minutes (at least until you meet Doc Oc’s 208-year-old shark uncle)! Also, I lost count of how many times he said “doo-doo.”
Good beats, very poor themes. Has his 7xl been invented yet?
super sexist at times, but super interesting sounds behind the rapping itself. I appreciate the way it committed to the bit like nobody’s buiz.
bad
Niet voor ons
I really enjoyed this. I like that its both funky and has many great trip hop moments, especially Blue Flowers. I thought the scientific wordplay was really clever. My only complaint is a second half that dragged a little bit. Shave off a couple of songs and this would get a higher rating from me.
Kool Keith's collaboration with Qbert and the Automator is brilliant. This album represents some of my favorite work from all of them.
i am not the audience for what keith is doing here. however, automator fucking freaked it.
Groovy.
Strong and mostly consistent. Dan the Automator really gets to flex and that's usually a boon to any project
Just sort of a masterful object, the exact kind of hip-hop curio I adore. "Blue Flowers" is the only song I knew going in and it's still my favorite of the tracklist but goodness gracious is this whole thing wonderful. By which I mean Dan the Automator is firing on all cylinders and Kool Keith is meeting the moment with inspired crudeness and off-kilter rhymes. The incipience of a movement that would go on to foster some of my favorite music ever but jeez unlike some other proto-genre highly influential albums this one really holds my attention and lingers like the best of what follows. Cool! Insane! Incredibly produced! Love it! Favorite new discoveries were "3000", "No Awareness", "Real Raw", "Technical Difficulties", "Bear Witness", "Halfsharkalligatorhalfman", and "Waiting List (DJ Shadow/Automator remix)".
It's impossible for me not to love Kool Keith and his nonsense.
So very of its time, for good and ill. A little long, a little repetitive Song(s) added to my 1001 Bangers playlist: Earth People, Dr Octagon, Halfsharkalligatorhalfman
a great hip hop album! a little too long, i think dan the automator gets the pacing a little bit better on the deltron albums
The beats were there but the flow and rhymes missed the mark. Didn't care for the delivery and I'm not sure if they want to be nerds or womanizers. Either way, it didn't work for me.
pas mon style mais sympa à écouter
Um álbum que faz zero sentido sem contextualização. A produção é muito evocativa e bem executada, mas não estou totalmente convencido do flow do doutor.
Absolute classic from the greatest MC of all time
Disgusting intro track. And not in the "stank-face" kind of way. No – this is one minute of awful sexual foreplay with a lazily recorded beat put over it, marking the start of a so-called "groundbreaking"(?) hip-hop record. Girl Let Me Touch You is a full-length track that, lyrically, is exactly the same. Is it bad, though, that it kind of sounds to me like generic 90s hip-hop for that reason? Yes, at least Dr. Octagon is rapping about science some of the time. But the music is so horrendously bad (on most tracks) that the lyrics are pretty heavily outweighed. Sorry, poetry fans. The audio part of music is much more important than the literature part. One major exception is Blue Flowers, which despite being heavily carried by its nifty synth-string part, stands out so much from the crowd that it deserves recognition. The instrumental is darn good, and I would've liked to hear more cool melodies in other parts of the record. Waiting List – which I think is a bonus track – is also notably better than most of the record. The synth line and very soft keyboard flutters in the right ear are big standouts. It's a good time to remind everyone that interludes are generally bad unless they contribute interesting musical ideas that are recapitulated later, or otherwise add to the atmosphere and build-up. As with the vast majority of the genre, Dr. Octagon fails to achieve any of the potential positives of interludes. But the interludes aren't even necessarily the worst part here. The seven consecutive tracks from A Visit To The Gynecologist (yes, this is a real track title from the list of the 1001 best/most important albums of all time) to Halfsharkalligatorhalfman (again, a real track title) are all bad and completely forgettable. "Earth People, New York and California / Earth People, I was born on Jupiter" is a pretty weak pair of lines the first time it's played. But, perplexingly, it was selected as the über-repetitive lyric in the chorus of a five-minute-long track (Earth People). At least the bassline is kind of good, even if it doesn't vary at all throughout the song. 1/5 Key tracks: No Awareness, Blue Flowers, Technical Difficulties
This genre and culture aren't meant for me and it does nothing for me. I didn't make it through a single song. 1.5/5
Fucking awful
Good not great, but enjoyable as a snapshot of the time.
i think this is about my 12th album and there hasn’t been one women involved… so many men. as for this album… it sounds cool. i like the album cover. innovative and interesting sounds the gynecologist song is gross and misogynistic.
the first album i genuinely couldn’t finish, not for me at all
01) Intro - 1,0 02) 3000 - 6,0 03) I Got to Tell You - / 04) Earth People - 5,0 05) No Awareness - 5,0 06) Real Raw - 5,0 07) General Hospital - / 08) Blue Flowers - 6,0 09) Technical Difficulties (Remix) - 5,5 10) A Visit to the Gynecologyst - 3,0 11) Bear Witness - 5,0 12) Dr. Octagon - 5,5 13) Girl Let Me Touch You - 5,0 14) I'm Destructive - 5,5 15) Wild and Crazy - 5,5 16) Elective Surgery - / 17) halfsharkalligatorhalfman - 5,5 18) Blue Flowers Revisited - 5,5 19) Waiting List (DJ Shadow/Automator Mix) - 6,0 20) 1977 - 5,0 TOTAL: 5,00 (50/100) Current ranking: 755/808
Some good beats but that can't save the absurdly juvenile lyrics and pornographic intro/skits.
This was pretty good. A few five star moments, a few awkward moments. This album might be the first time I enjoyed those bits or skits or whatnot between the songs. I will likely come back to this album in future.
Yay!
This was a lot of fun. It made me laugh out loud.
Soooo sexual…/bathroom humor/gore but also like good music…?
3+
Wild concept album. I enjoyed it now as much as I did when I first heard it back in the 90's. Yeah, the lyrics are out there, the clips from porn movies are interesting, and the skits... oh man the skits. This is a big conceptual swing for Kool Keith's debut solo album. It may not all work, but it is never boring.
Rapping varies a lot song to song but the beats and scratching are always dope. fav tracks: "Real Raw", "Bear Witness", "A Visit to the Gynecologist" (The drums in particular on this one are crazy)
One of the things I'm enjoying most about this project is getting to know more hip-hop. I like this, and I think it must have been influential on other stuff I've heard. The constant rectum jokes were a bit much after a while though.
WHAT A GLORIOUS WERIDO. I know Earth People from a Andrea Parker DJ Kicks album, and Blue Flowers from... somewhere.. but have never heard all of Dr. Octagonecologyst. Yup, just as bonkers. Effing love this.
Sixty-five minutes was a bit much but I found it to be a decent album.
I'm pretty impressed with this. It seems very original, well written music and an almost movie-like soundtrack background. The lyrics are frequently juvenal, but aside from that, this might be the first non-Beastie Boys rap album I'd listen to again.
50. interesting
Bad bad rap
Das piores coisas que já ouvi, nunca mais quero ouvir.
Better than I was expecting it to be, but also nothing really stands out and it just drags on and on. The skits are lame, the production is neat, but the flow is inconsistent and the theme gets old real fast.
This is a weird, and cringe, concept album. I'm sure it was well received 30 years ago, but porno like dialogue to open the album sets a bad tone and the gag gets old really fast
Нет ну это пиздец доктор октопус какой-то за что
DR OCTAGON!!! Holy shit, I never expected to find Kool Keith on this list! God I love this album. I took my younger, religious, high school aged brother-in-law and his friend to a Kool Keith show about 20 years ago. Keith was throwing porn magazines out at the crowd and just being the crazy mf'er that he is. The boys left. I fully expect all you tools on here to savage this album. Get moosebumps.
If you're a rap fan, chances are you've listened to this one already. It has a mythical status for a reason. To other reviewers who cannot comprehend what is going on here - yes, Kool Keith is an acquired taste. You also likely heard Dan the Automator on Gorillaz, Handsome Boy Modelling School, Deltron, etc. - and yes, most likely loved his work. So, what gives? You're stressed out by the concept of a spacetime travelling Dr Octagon and his half shark half alligator blabbering? What, world needs more love songs, more bling raps? Fuck off and grow a spine you sensitive, easily offended hypocrites.
Who is listening to this, and what’s going on with them?
Some beats are not bad but the album is overall disturbing.
Bruh, what is this flow, and who decided this should be on this list?
A pleasant surprise
A little one note but I vibed
This is definitely the most bizarre thing I've heard in a long time. Tracy Morgan meets Clown Core. I can't say it's good? The beats are neat, but this is just really out there. Kool Keith, you're an odd duck. I am a hip hop enjoyer but never really got into MF DOOM and the like and this is firmly in that square of the chessboard. Incredible flow but too weird and nasty. Oddly it sorts of compels you to keep listening? 1.5/5 rounding down
"Don't know how this is on the list." Did you try fucking googling it? lol Never in my life have I been exposed to a more intellectually uninterested music "fans." If you're reading this and it upsets you AND you're still under the age of 25, its okay. Your prefrontal cortex hasn't developed yet. There's hope for you yet. If you're over the age of 25... enjoy arrested development I guess? Anyway, the flow is great but the samples are where I'm digging this album. Constant references to pop culture and hip hop in general. Very proto MF DOOM.
Fun listen. It's weird and juvenile, but also innovative and refreshing. 4/5
Is this a joke?
Overall: 8/10 This was such a cool album. A lot of the beats reminded me of the stuff RZA does with Wu-Tang. Keith's flow and lyrical prowess reminded me a lot of Andre 3000. Basically, he's reminiscent of a bunch of stuff I enjoy, and that rocks. This is also such a strange concept for an album and I have to applaud him for being so out there with it. There were times that I kind of lost the plot but then he's bring me right back in with some crazy rhyming scheme. Great stuff. Fav Song: Blue Flowers
#247/1001. Mo' wax! I had an era when it was my go to label, ah the memories...some first dj gigs / spinning vinyl on bars on Friday nights, music changing from style to another style during a pint - to be honst still more or less my style to entertain, hats off to DJ Bunuel. I recognized the trip-hoppy mood and the murky samples, I can place them exactly to summers -97 and -98, spotted some of the songs as well. Initially I remembered it to be more turntablist, so perhaps I mix it with Qbert and others from that era (Qbert featured here, so not totally a wrong memory). Didn't really remember the tongue in cheek humour of the lyrics and the whole character though. But when and where and for whom would I play this Blue Flowers or the whole album nowadays? With these kitchy exploitation samples? A nostalgia trip worth a 3.
New discovery for me, and I'm sort of surprised I'd never come across it before. The bad first: it's absurdly juvenile, and at times very creepy (not in a fun way). The porn skits are...a choice. Would I play this loud on the stereo if my wife were home? Probably not. BUT. The beats are sooo good, and the flow is sooo good, and when he's rapping about weird, abstract, sci-fi stuff instead of doodoo and peepee and "let me touch you there," even the lyrics are pretty cool. I think my fellow MF Doom fans would be into this. Some of the beats are wild. "Blue Flowers" is fantastic.
I like the commitment to the character, but track after track the shock value starts to wear thin.
? twas ok
Listened to first 5 songs and couldn’t get into it. Not the biggest fan of lyricism, rhythm or vibe
KK is a beast. This is not his best imho, but even so it’s better than most. Curious to see what else has made the list
This would have been awesome if I was 11 with severe learning difficulties.
Real music that you would hear in your friend's older brother's room type of album. I do not have the patience or time to waste in my miserable life to listen to some bullshit hour-long, twenty track forgettable album from the 90s. DNF
This is my jam. Kool Keith is super weird and I love it. Love Dan The Automator too. The skits could be dropped if you ask me.
niet mijn ding
I liked the first half of the record, but then it became too long and my attention span is fucked up, tbh. Nice production, though.
Not my jam at all. Not awful but not thing really grabs me or stands out.
Silly 90s rap. It's pretty clever, but also raunchy.
I don't like when rap just sounds like an endless beat with a guy talking for the whole 4 minutes
Surprisingly good
To start. Kinda trying to be edgy, skits are bad and doesnt flow nicely. Not sure the hype but the dj was alright
I quite enjoyed his vocal stylings and flow. I couldn’t abide the concept album thing, whether intentionally juvenile or not, I just didn’t want a full album of horror and porn, I give him credit for doing something different but I just didn’t need the content, but that’s a personal taste. Musically I enjoyed the album a whole lot more that I could the holistic experience, hence only 2 Star
I have a pretty high tolerance for dumb and fun in my music. For instance, I like Motorhead. This was a little too much for me since probably a good 25% is gibberish and the whole thing is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of what a gynecologist does, but I guess I don't really know what alien gynecologists from Jupiter do. The music is ok, but not breaking down any walls. I'm not a big fan of his flow. I was able to listen to it twice without hurting myself, so I won't give it 1 star.
Part way through and I can tell this is a solid 2 for me. The rapping is okay, though not my thing. The spoken interludes are just awful.
1/5 - Hard pass
This is truly a bizarre hip hop record about the fictional character Dr Octagon, who is described as a homicidal, extraterrestrial, time-travelling gynecologist and surgeon with a dark, absurdist and juvenile sense of humour. I don't know whether the purpose of 'Dr Octagonecologist' is to be funny or as offensive as possible, but the mix of medical/hospital speak with both gross-out and overly sexualised humour gets old rather quickly. While there are some decent beats here and there, the lyrics are pretty lame and forgettable, and there isn't even a modicum of profound statements here, it's just one juvenile rap after another. Yeah, nah. Dr Octagon isn't for me. My arse is fine, thanks. Best songs: None
Does this moron not know Jupiter is a Gas planet? I wish he had been born on Jupiter, this album wouldn't exist then. Drivel, apart from 'Blue flowers' which I had in a playlist, but it's made me realise it's only interesting because of the sample used. . ..
90s rap, feel like if you are into that you’ll like it. If you’re not you won’t. I can appreciate it for what it is but it’s not an album I’ll be rushing back to.
Olipahan tosi paska levy
Def not for me. DNF.
*Underground hip-hop record, like the different sound to his cadence *The skits are silly and take away from how good the songs are
In a nutshell: the 80s called, they want their beats back. This album encapsulates everything bad about hip-hop: skits (Intro started as creepy track then it flipped into a porn voiceover. Wtaf?), clichéd backing beats and loops (reminded me of early hip-hop, like RUN-DMC), questionable lyrics (of course some are going to be sexist and misogynistic). It has not aged well. The only worthy thing of note is the flow. Sounds good to me. Just listen to 2pac and DJ Shadow. You'll get more bang for your buck there. Overall: 1/10
What is it with people (men) thinking that forcing a reaction out of someone makes your work worthy of praise? Such a cheap way to get attention. Disgusting. Duran Lantink this u??
Some clever rhymes, too reliant on vulgar themes. Similar beats and rhythms to Gorillaz but not as good. I’d recommend Delton 3030 instead.
i am going 2 stars on this one. 1 star for being bad. 1 star for entertaining me with the nerd / comicon / sci fi / porn lyrics. poor mans Wu-Tang
Not my jam. Maybe I’m too old but there are no songs with any real meaning here.
someone check his hard drive ASAP.
DNF
Ei huono, muttei mitenkään erinomainenkaan. 2,5/5.
Not as good as i remembered.
Sexually deviant alien doctor. Got it.
It was around "Halfsharkalligator-Half-man" where I began to suspect this man is not a real doctor. Absurd. Flow comes and goes but this goofy ass album is here for good.
I know the song Blue Flowers from a video game (Grindsession?) and have always liked it. There were lots of tracks on here where I really enjoyed the production. The skits I could have done without completely; the one in the doctor's office was pretty gross. Overall, there's a lot on this I would come back to though. 3.4/5
Listened to this for another list. I scored it pretty low for that one, mostly because of the terrible skit. The skit is still terrible, but I did sorta dig the goofy lines + the trip hop instrumentation. 2.5/5
Very interesting - is this where Frauenarzt got his idea from?
Not just another rap album, it was a bit different. Unfortunately you can't read good for different. Earth People was the only decent track on it. And it was just toooooo lllooonnngggg. It became boring. 1 it is
Dr Monotonist
What was this pillock thinking? Totally tasteless. The lowlight being his gynaecologist song. I love to find out if there are any females who actively choose to listen to this would really get off on the lyrics. A depth lower than anything Old Bob Dylan or Steely Dan could plumb. 0 stars if I could.
So glad that this is over - really had to push through. To begin with, the first track was lowkey concerning but then the moaning stopped and I thought we might be looking at a improvement (or an anomaly) however when I got to 'visit to the gynecologist' i realised that whoever wrote is actually sick in the head and does not deserve to be on this list - pointless muisc -agressivley vulgar and sexual verging on glorified assault - promoting a gross sexualisation and objectification of women.
oh no
This was weird. I came in fully expecting to hate it but I liked the album. Really great musical production and strong rapping. Lyrics are bizarre but I guess that’s part of the appeal. Can’t say anything about importance so let’s say solid three.
I guess I'm a sucker for juvenile humour then, because despite not being a huge hip jop/rap fan, I loved this album.
Crazy
I know, I know, 90's hip hop is my jam but this shit gets on my nerves
75
Nothing here that I couldn’t get from Madvillany. Good record but probably won’t come back to it.
OK some dodgy lyrics but really enjoyed this album, some great music
I like the pacing / production / scratching and the lyrically delivery. Not mad keen on the alien concept but it mostly goes over my head. Nice to have a DJ Shadow mix.
That was weird, in a better way than your usual macho bravado rap, way. Some good scratching, but most tunes weren't up to much though.
Interesting well executed concept
Easy. One of my faves.
makes me feel very sad
Dès que je commence à apprécier de plus en plus le rap et le hip-hop, on me balance cette bouse au visage. Un rappeur sans conviction sur un instru turbo ringard? Qui est-ce qui peut être excité par ça?
So out there with the beats I loved it
This guy a lyrical genius! Love the timbre of his voice and the beats are just weird enough.
What seems to be a talented rapper let down by really poor quality content.
rap hecho por un theatre kid que tiene una personalidad paralela que cree que es un alien médico y lo produjera el productor de gorillaz