Reviews (page 4 of 8)
Hip hop is not my thing but it was pleasant enough.
Look, I like classic hip-hop as much as the next guy, but I know shit when I smell it.
good, 3.5
Not my jam, pretty silly album title, a bit odd
I will never listen to this again
This was not too bad. I don't want a steady diet of it but this kind of music works great dropped into my mixes. Would revisit.
I think I’m drawn to bizarre absurdist narratives (if that isn’t an oxymoron). I could see myself allowing more time for this and admiring the flow and the energy. It’s not quite engaging enough yet but it was a weirdly interesting experience.
This was kind of clever and interesting at first but devolved into blather and juvenile BS long before the record ended.
I like absurdist, trip-hop, so I was drawn to this. It wasn't well done enough to keep me interested for an entire record, but I can see where Madvillainy came from, so that's cool. Or I guess Kool. DOOM's record is better, though.
My attention kept coming in and out listening to this. All in all, I liked it. (In the early days of this project, the interlude really surprised me in the rap genre. now I expect and enjoy a good interlude!)
I got into **Dan the Automator** somewhere around 2000 probably, so although I didn't hear this on release, it would have only been a few years after as a went through his back catalogue. Of course, he's the producer (and beatmaker) here on what is the debut solo album by **Kool Keith** of **Ultramagnetic MCs** fame and both parties bring a lot to the table on this quirky concept album; Keith with his cool flow and Dan with his futuristic beats that would lay a blueprint for alternative rap that can be heard in Dan the Automator's later work with **Deltron 3030** and **Handsome Boy Modeling School** and much further into alternative hip=hop, through the likes of **MF DOOM**, **Aesop Rock** all the way through to current artists like **JPEGMAFIA** and **.clipping** It's not my fave album in Dan's catalogue... the concept which at times is brilliantly absurd and surreal, also gets a little juvenile in places and like many hip hop albums of the era... it's too long and could easily have been trimmed. All in all though, this is really quite good and very influential!
0.5
First of all any as album with a track called "Halfsharkalligatorhalfman" automatically gets a pass for me. Honestly, when it leans on the alien sci-fi horror aspects, I really enjoyed the album. Some of it was sillier than shit, but it was too fun to deny, plus it gave me a midnight B-movie feel. When it runs down some of the more normal 90s hop hop. It was awaight. But the fun factor bumps this up a half star (7.4) ★★★½
The beats are too repetitive, but not bad. 3.5 stars
I think this is a really cool album. A few years before Dan the Automator worked with Del tha Funky Homosapien to create the futuristic alt-rap concept album Deltron 3030, he hooked up with Kool Keith to create this futuristic alt-rap concept album about a surgeon from outer space who experiments on humans. I get people may be a little weirded out by some of the lyrics here, but Kool Keith has a really interesting flow, and his bizarre, sometimes free associative lyrics were kind of a game changer in 1996, paving the way for guys like Aesop Rock and MF Doom in the 2000s. Dan the Automator's production is really interesting for the time too -- forgoing the popular styles of the time and creating something that sounds otherworldly. Highlights for me are "3000", "Earth People", "Blue Flowers", and the title track, but outside of the skits, I think this is a really strong album throughout. 4.5 stars.
Cool album. Album cover is cool. Everything about this album is cool to be honest… or ‘kool’ because the rapper’s name is Kool Keith. Very wacky, lurid, off-kilter comedy horrorcore vibes and rhymes throughout and seems very ahead of its time in the realm of alternative hip-hop. Beats from Dan The Automator are mint and the wonder show scratching from DJ Q-Bert is maybe even more of a star at this operating table. Skits are also great. A horse is in the hospital? Classic. Moosebumps? Classic. The one about Dr Octagon giving treatment to a gynaecology patient whilst pretending to be a woman? Classic.
I have not heard this album in a long time. I forgot how much I love the beats on this album. The only thing I forgot about and I never really like that much or like the little skits in between. I do appreciate that they’re in between the songs and not attached to the songs, but I’m not a big skit guy. But still a great listen Biggest Hit - Blue Flowers Miss - any of the skits Surprise - Bear Witness
Rap. Nice to hear a different theme but it didn’t do it for me. Production was nice.
bizarramente inesperado. muitobao 3000 é facil a melhor track e totalmente diferente dos iguais. nao querendo desmerecer o resto da bolacha, afinal sao tracks bem fluidas. 8/10
I loved this. Beats were great, lyrics were awesome. Fun to hear an artist that does not just do the same thing. Kool Keith has built a whole world. Seems like he also carries this character into other albums. I may listen to them too.
Ok
I got a visceral response when I saw this on Spotify. It was crap I dodged when it came out. But I have an open mind now, im not a teenager and actually, some stuff I hated back then I have grown to like. But then theres this... Sounds like the songs I was writing.. immature disturbing and looking for a rise. an 808 and slow flow cant save this.
Best concept album about a space gynecologist I’ve ever heard.
I wonder if I should create some rap music, because I’ve also never done disco.
Fuck my pussy Doctor!
Favorite Track: Real Raw
I hated this so much.
I was surprised to see this in the Trip Hop Essentials playlist on Apple Music, but after listening I definitely see why. This has such a specific and sort of eerie vibe that I really loved, I was really into the whole sound of the album. Also I only knew Kool Keith from being the sample in Smack My Bitch Up by The Prodigy and from a feature on a Jurassic 5 album, but he's really good. I really liked his voice, and he's got crazy flow. This album is a little bit long, but honestly that's fine by me cause I really just love the sound of it. Favorites: 3000, Blue Flowers, 1977
Snowiest winter morning yet. What a fun project but my feelings are conflictingggg. Bro had a concept and most definitely executed it. This album feels super experimental (idk if that’s true for the time) yet familiar. THIS feels like the hop in trip hop, I was bumping. The other side of the coin is like … why is your concept being an implied expert on women’s vaginas (eyeroll) type of mf who wouldn’t know his way w a damn map. 4 for instrumentals and influence but 2 for execution so.. 3 stars it is Bear witness - insane instrumentals 3000 - favorite flow No awareness - groovy and reliable Real raw - last 2 mins go crazy
type of lyrics I’m gonna be writing when I inevitably have a schizophrenic breakdown
Praskippinus porno gan geras albumas.
Yeee, no... I didn't want to listen to a podcast or an e-book.
This album kept switching between genuinely funny and super uncomfortable.
A weird as hell concept album. For bits and parts, the beats were good. And then the lyrics would start again. Call me crazy, but I don’t love hearing about rectums in my music. Pros- it’s certainly *creative* Negatives- it’s a LOT.
Actually liked the beats but then listened to the words and the misogyny and lewdness was just horrible.
No thanks
This album was one of the first that really opened my eyes to hip hop and made me see it in a new light. My buddy Brad introduced me to it in the late ’90s during high school. This album was on a whole new level. Up until then, about 99% of the hip hop I was exposed to felt the same, just some dude bragging about himself or grandstanding in the most prideful and arrogant way possible. But with this album, Kool Keith created an entirely new persona and was rapping about some wild science fiction stuff. Two other elements made me really appreciate this album. First, the production was intricate and heavily involved, far beyond just layering some samples and looping them. This was how I discovered Dan The Automator. Second, the scratching was next level, which led me to learn about DJ Qbert. From there, I became intrigued by underground hip hop and all the different elements of the genre, and my interest just continued to grow. Unfortunately, I have to admit that over the last 10 years or so, my interest in hip hop has really faded. But I still like to check in from time to time and see what Kool Keith is up to these days. To me, Kool Keith will always be the mad scientist of hip hop.
Fun production, very 96 lyrics, silly sexist etc
An all-time classic. Juvenile, sophomoric, profane, absurd - this is a record that embraces the chaos and rides the fine line of good taste. Grimy, left-field-sampling, synth-laden beats by Dan The Automator and tasteful, textural scratching by DJ Qbert compliment Kool Keith's non-sequitor free-association flow style as the inimitable, bizarre Dr. Octagon. THERE'S A HORSE IN THE HOSPITAL!!!!
Great beats and melodies, but I couldn't get past the juvenile dick, rectum and poop references, not to mention opening at least 2 songs with porn recordings. Not for me, couldn't finish it.
Trying to be funny and different over very generic beats. Maybe one or two tracks that were catchy but it was mostly just dumb
???
Alright, I want to start this review by acknowledging something that I find very funny. So, Dr. Octagon here is actually one of many aliases for a guy that's most commonly known as Kool Keith. He's had a decently prolific career and is considered to be one of the more... surreal rappers out there. This is some solid context for this debut album of his, Dr. Octagonecologyst. However, it also allows me to acknowledge one of his other albums. That album is called First Come, First Served; released under the name Dr. Dooom. Why do I bring this album up? Simple. It has one of the funniest and most bizarre album covers I've ever seen. Just search it up online. It's worth it. Anyways, I didn't really like this album as much as I hoped I would. It is by far the weirdest hip-hop album I've ever listened to. Of course, this isn't inherently a bad thing. Plenty of great hip-hop albums are weird. I like Death Grips, okay? I'm not against the idea of weird hip-hop, I swear. However, I just don't really vibe that much with this album personally. I will say that I do vibe with the production quite a bit. It's got this almost psychedelic feel to it and it's sonically interesting. I think Dan the Automater deserves praise for his work on this. The writing is where the album kinda loses me. The album is abstract and absurd, but it's also rather juvenile. The album's got these sorta uncomfortable skit-like tracks like "A Visit to the Gynecologist" that I just don't really align with personally. I get the appeal of it, and I could see someone else really vibing with it. It's just that that person isn't me. I'm also not huge on Kool Keith's rapping. Oh, sorry, Dr. Octagon's rapping. Sometimes he sells the vibe, but other parts feel kinda aimless and almost flowless. I don't know. I will say that the concept is also kinda neat. It hasn't really aged the best, but I could see the concept being executed in an early 2000s comedy film "This could never be made today, but god is it funny" type way, you know? Overall, I wish I liked this more. The ideas are interesting, but I don't really enjoy the execution that much. It's not bad, but it's not really for me. Low 3/5.
This didn't jump out at me any more than the other rap on the list.
Nope
Incredibly dated and sophomoric, but definitely exists in a more avant-garde place than a lot of rap at the time. Earth People is an absolute ear worm.
Fun, funky and unextected, though not consistently
I will not be seeing this dr again.
5/10 Its certainly different and interesting, but the lyrics are just so bad.
The reviews here made it seem so much worse than it was. I think it is definitely way more memorable than other hip hop albums that I have listened here, a concept album about alien doctor and his unconventional treatment methods
Long live the weirdos!
What bothers me the most about this album is that he actually has some good songs and parts but then he overlays it with the crude peepee poopoo and gynecology horror/humor that just makes me check out. If you had focused on the good stuff this would have been way more successful.
This went down better, lyrically, when I found out that this is Kool Keith and one of his alter egos. Sonically I freaking love it! There is some hardcore creativity going on here. Smooth in parts, hard when it needs to be. A dash of dark and mysterious trip hop vibes. Coming in close to having Halloween vibes. This is not just rap for rap sake. Like many albums from the 90’s, an hour plus is too long. I get it, the CD format allowed for more. That doesn’t mean that every album SHOULD be that long.
This is certainly creative, and there are a lot of intriguing sounds going on, but ultimately it was hard to get invested in the story of a crazy alien doctor.
1.5 Interesting concept for an album. Complex and some shock rhymes with 90s NYC boom bap beats - but complex rhymes doesn’t always mean good music (looking at you Eminem!).
- Who said it: James Joyce or Kool Keith? .... Take the test! "I got 9/10, but only because I know James Joyce. Really makes me want to listen to Kool Keith. Anyone can tell me where to start?" "Sure bro. Dr. Octagonecologyst. It's a really surreal album with Dan The Automator production. Keith uses an alternate persona, "Dr. Octagon", throughout. This album is extremely influential imo. Highlight tracks to me are Blue Flowers, Bear Witness, and 3000. But honestly, listen to the whole thing. Pretty incredible experience of an album." "Thanks dude! Been meaning to listen to it, love Dan's production on the original Deltron 3000." - 12y ago - Unfortunately, this online test no longer exists ... ah, the modern age .... Kool Keith is a treasure. Is it hard? Yes. Is it raw? Yes. - but - It's art and art is hard, sometimes raw, sometimes ugly. Buck up, youngsters. Don't be such a prude, go for the ride ..... -
Eeeeeeh, dann doch irgendwie zu speziell für mich
Overall Rating 2.53/5 (5.06/10). Probably the worst of the hip-hop albums I've gotten so far.
Weird but not bad. Good beats but some really out there lyrics.
influential, but not one I need to listen to before I die.
I like the music a lot. Gives Doom vibes with its zaniness, but it’s more focused on sex humor than random obscurities. Definitely recommend to hip hop fans.
Not terrible, but not a fan. At least it isn't Kanye.
I am a big fan of some of Dan the Automator's other work (Lovage, Gorillaz, Deltron 3030) so I was pretty excited for this one. However, sadly this is my least favorite thing I have heard from him. It is still good, and there are some stand out songs, but there are just too middle of the road songs, too many skits and too many songs that just feel like a bad joke. Overall, I enjoy the production and there are some standout songs, but there is also a lot of filler here. Low 4.
Oh shit there's a horse in the hospital! Having already pushed hip hop boundaries in Ultramagnetic MCs, Kool Keith created something even more futuristic here. His flow is wild, refusing to stay on the beat, spinning ridiculous body horror tales and throwing out words that only barely relate to each other. While this was bettered by later alternative hip hop artists with tighter flows and smarter lyrics (and who weren't just making poo poo jokes half the time), there's still a joy in listening to this untamed craziness. The beats have also not aged a day. Spacy and surreal, they add to the disorienting atmosphere while the excellent scratching gives the album a firm hip hop foundation. Uneven and silly because of the chances it takes, but still a blast.
One-trick pony, but at least it's a trick I've never seen before?
WTF do I really need to hear this before I die? Ohh shit. Not what I expected. Kinda dug it.
I really love nerdy, sci fi inspired hip hop records. While this album contains some dated lyrics, it is pretty damn charming. The dark, boom bap beats are awesome and the flows are unorthodox. The topics can border on absurd, but the album isn’t afraid to embrace its absurdity. Also, the album cover is perfect, especially for a hip hop record.
Jag lyssnar egentligen inte alls på hiphop så har aldrig hört talas om denna gruppen tidigare. Mitt första intryck var att det var helt okej, men det är ett långt album och för någon som inte är så insatt så smälte låtarna tillslut ihop och lät likadant.
Bra sound. Gillar old school hiphop och lyssnade mycket på det i mina yngre dagar. Inte längre dock. Jag är helt frånkopplad från den här typen av musik nu för tiden. Det dock inte utan viss nostalgi jag lyssnar på dunket och myser lite. Dock känns hela skivan som en enda lång låt. Jag kan typ svära på att samma beat återkommer hela tiden. Det gör det kanske inte, men jag blir inte superengagerad i min lyssning.
I'm not convinced this guy's even a real doctor. But his music's pretty good.
Not for me
36/1001 First listen. I can’t believe I’ve never heard of Dr. Octagon before. After tomorrow’s album I’ll be getting right back to this one. Killer Pushead cover too. 6/10
Ooh a concept hiphop album? You know how it is... you plough through 300 albums pining for a song about rectums, then you get an album full of rectal references. He should have called himself Dr. Proctagon! I found the theme and lyrics a lot more interesting than the usual gangster-hoe-AK47-muthafucker-I'm-so-repressed posing braindead shite (I have Dr. Dre today - oh joy). But I bet a lot of the gynae humour will have upset the Gen Z-ers. It definitely appealed to my sense of humour though. Best hiphop i've had album so far.
Not good
This was probably cooler in the 90s, a lot the production feels dated, but not old enough to be retro. Some good verses and tracks, but overall not really my favorite. The gynecologist shtick/skits didn’t really hit. Love that this probably paved the way for acts like MF Doom, but don’t love it for itself.
Reminds me of Delton 3030 with horror rap influences. First skit was actually funny, normally I roll my eyes or skip them I like the beats, the flow takes some time getting used to DJ-ing is impressive too
Not my favourite old-school hip-hop album ever
Funny. Weird.
Pretentious psychedelic porno fever dream.
< The Beatles Interesting vibes but kinda shitty
Nope
I can’t go TOO high on this one just because if someone walked in the room and I was listening to this I would feel embarrassed. That said, to tell you the truth, I liked this quite a bit. It got me thinking about my extreme distaste for Eminem. In a way, they share a lot. Both kinda shocking, horrorcore type stuff. This comes off so much better to me though, like I get the artistic idea of it at least. Maybe it’s just that Eminem’s artistic perspective is “what if there was the most fucked up guy ever and what if he was me??” and that doesn’t have legs in the same way a nightmare sci fi version of the same thing does. Anyway this was cool.
lame.
I appreciated the weirdness
Hørte fem kedelige numre og gad ikke mere. Rap er ikke min genre.
2/5
I... I dont know what to feel. What did I just listen to? I inherently like the concept of an alien doctor murderer, but as a rap persona.... ehhhhh I don't know how it works out. It's a bit rapey isn't it? It's out there. It should probably stay out there, far, far away. A lot of the lyrics don't even make sense, they're just mashed up sci-fi-sounding concepts. Beats are pretty low key and dated, but fine. Theres a sci-fi feel to them thats kinda cool and interesting, but every song follows a pretty similar formula and the actual raps and rhythms become indistinguishable after a while. Also were the porno skits supposed to be funny? Cause they weren't really. But I'm not 12 so.... Standouts - maybe "3000" and I liked the instrumental back half of "Real Raw" and "Blue Flowers" if I had to pick. I just.... I dont want to hear this again. Any of it. It irked me more and more as I kept listening and the shtick became overbearing. The DJ was pretty slick, but that's the only redeeming feature I pulled out of my listen. Interesting concept but a total letdown. 1 star; I refuse to give it 2 just for cool "sci-fi noises"
I’ll admit I’m not the biggest hip hop fan… but this is everything I dislike about it all in one. Insipid is too good a word.
Can’t believe I never heard this before.
3 or 4 stars. Depends on how fondly I remember my time when submitting the rating.
Not great rap
Fun
There are a couple of seconds here and there that make me go "ah, that's a cool sample". But it doesn't last long and it is embedded in tons of lyrics, beats and scratches that I don't care about.
I have mixed feelings about this album. I love the beats and the samples and all of the music. There wasn't a bad song musically on the entire record. There were also some really good and fun and funny songs, and I totally bought into the Sci-fi concept. His rapping is at times so fast and I really enjoyed that too. On the other hand, some of the humor is very sophomoric. It felt like a Beavis and Butthead cartoon at times, and that's not a compliment. If I was a middle school kid I probably would think it's hilarious, but I'm not. Given the album title, I worried it would be very misogynistic, but I didn't think it was. I found it just silly. And it was also just a bit too long for my taste. This is a 3.5 and I'll decide tomorrow morning whether that goes up or down when it's time to rate the album.
Cringey, offensive, junenile...and yet I chucked a few times and didn't hate the beats/flow.
One of my objectives with this project was developing a deeper appreciation of hip hop and I have made some progress. However, this album made me rethink this objective. There is no element of anything that I appreciate about music here. I made it to the end, but doing so was painful. Instrumentation. I realize that I’m supposed to ignore the fact that there is none and focus on the production and beats. Even doing so, I found nothing compelling or interesting. Horrible. Vocalization. I know that this is rap and I should ignore the fact that there isn’t any singing. I like the idea of creating an album with fictional characters, however the story and juvenile humor here is just dumb. I have a rule of giving every album at least two listens. Often the second listen reveals something I’d previously missed. If this case, I can’t bring myself to do this. Apparently this album brings joy to others, which is great, but calling it music is a stretch.
Rad album, surprised I hadn't listened to it before. Surprisingly more influential than I expected.
Musically interesting. But lyrically, this album hates and degrades women. I see why he killed off his character later. Still. 1 star for the hate.
I’d never heard of Dr. Octagon until I started this project, but I know that this is one of the lowest rated albums on the site. Granted, I assume that calling your album Dr. Octagonecologyst is probably going to trim down your target audience quite considerably. However, the only thing I know about this album is that it’s not very well liked; I don’t even know what genre it is, but with a cover like that, I’d peg this as some sort of weird noise rock. I guess it’s time to visit the doctor! Ah, so this is a rap album by Kool Keith, interesting. I’ve heard Kool Keith’s name before, but I couldn’t tell you a thing about him. This visit to the Octagonecologyst was certainly a unique experience, and while I appreciate the strange vision that Kool Keith had while making this album, this just wasn’t for me. My initial impression of this album from “3000” was not a good one. I didn’t care for the odd rhythm to Keith’s flow, and his unusual rhyming scheme threw me off too. However, I thought the beats, music, and production were pretty good. I tend to enjoy east coast hip hop more than west coast, because I like that darker production sound on albums like 36 Chambers or Illmatic. Keith was able to take that east coast sound and morph it into this strange and alien-like album in a way that worked pretty well. As much as the first track threw me off, the rapping on the rest of the album didn’t feel as odd with the flow and rhyming structure. The beats and production were consistently pretty good throughout the whole album, but I just wasn’t into the weird lyrics, and I found Keith’s vocal tone to be really flat and unexpressive, which bored me a bit. The Dr. Octagon-ness of this album just wasn’t interesting enough to me to keep me engaged with this album for just over an hour. I respect the vision and the execution of that vision, but I didn’t particularly care for this album. However, the skit with the voicemail cracked me up. ‘1-800PP51-doo-doo’ will be burned into my brain forever, and I think this was the first time in my forty years of life that I’ve heard someone say ‘doo-doo’ while Pachelbel’s Canon played in the background.
Why do rappers refuse to release anything that's a solid 40mins? It's unique, interesting, funny at times but runs too long and I wouldn't be revisiting. 2.5/5. Raising to 3.
Was aight. Recognized more than I thought I would
i hated this i don't like hip hop i don't like weird sex and sexualization what is going on here nothing about this was something I would listen to again 1/5
haha, i don't know what this is. But I had never heard it before. The lyrics are... quite graphic. Beats are actually decent - got Insane Clown Posse vibes. I found it more comedic than anything.
nuh uh
Uhhh no thanks
Yuck. I worked with a guy who showed up one day wearing an "I might not a gynecologist, but I'll take a look" t-shirt. This album is the musical equivalent of that. Don't need this.
Pretty funky.
The beats and the music are ok, the lyrics are between weird and disgusting.
I kinda love everything that Dan The Automator touches, and this is right there with Handsome Boy Modeling School, Lovage, Deltron 3030, and even Pillowfight. I'm not a major hip-hop fan, but this is hip-hop that I can enjoy from end to end.
Some of the beats were fun but not near enough to save the album Rating: 1.3
Really strange album. Kool Keith is a total freak. This album (not under the Kool Keith name) exploded him into "guy who knows music" popularity and gave him the latitude to get a real deal recording deal with Black Elvis/Lost in Space but anything with Kool Keith is a freak object. He is a totally unconstrained artist shirking at anything resembling commercial or culturally acceptable. The beats on this are unshakably cool. The lyrics are goofy, nasty, juvenile. It's a direct rebuke of the street toughness commonplace in 90s hip-hop. "Earth People New York and California, Earth People I was Born on Jupiter." It's spacey - sonically and spiritually. Favorite songs: Earth People, Halfsharkalligatorhalfman, Blue Flowers least: alright i think A Visit to Gynecologist is a bad sketch funniest line "I will explain but you'd become more puzzled at the possibilities Earth ending trilogies, wacky stuff Like gas passing dinosaurs Morlocks drawing circles blindfolded Gave a lady some wrinkle cream out of rat poop" worth reading the notes on these verses, a lot of incredibly obscure 1990s joke pulls on it. A lot of grocery store checkout line jokes, as good of a document on the decade as a Art Bell Coast-to-Coast AM broadcast.
Ok, obviously a young man with a lot of imagination concerning the other sex. That is not so surprising. The surprising thing is that somehow this album found its way on this list. That is extremely surprising.
I probably have more patience for this than many since I used to listen to ICP. However, I have to admit that most of these rhymes are pretty stupid. Some creative beats though.
The album cover had me very interested. The intro quickly had me concerned about what I was in for but then the great beats hit on 3000 and I was back in. Earth People was awesome, bringing more great flow and spooky beats and Real Raw put DJ-Q-Bert’s scratching skills on full display. This album has some fantastic stuff here, really entertaining and exciting beats. Fitting that I listened a week out from Halloween so that definitely added to the enjoyment. My gripe with the album would be the inclusion of the aggressive sexual skits, the gynaecologist skit was pretty gross but even that had some impressive scratching worked in. The character itself had me drawing comparisons to MF Doom’s work. Also, I really liked DJ Shadow’s appearance at the end. Frustrating, this could be a 5 but Girl Let Me Touch You felt so out of place the gross moments took me out of it. Just wish they leaned into the horror and remained focused on that even if it was hokey at times. Still super happy to be introduced to this. 4 stars
I've never listened to this album, but I knew one or two songs (5). Really great production, not quite sold on the raps yet.
i like the concept but not the execution. i'm not a fan of the rap style or actual content. but i think this shows that horror rap needs to be way more of a genre than it is because i need this but good lmfao
not my cup of tea
Beats are great, but the lyrics don’t do it for me 3/5
3.63
Five stars for delicious weirdness and production. Minus points for lyrical content.
Digging this a lot
Solid 90s weirdy hiphop. Sounds a bit Prince Paul by way of the Gravediggaz.
I think I’ve heard this album before, but it’s been quite a while. It was not bad.
Kinda shit
The idea of a a sci-fi, comic character, rap persona is interesting, but this album, alas, was not.
Very gory record that teeters on the edge of uncomfortable to straight up appalling. Despite the negative aspects, I can still appreciate the talent in both: sticking to a theme so random that all the references left me confused about how Keith came up with them, and two, the lyricism, albeit quite out of pocket. What I tend to find confusing when going through reviews is that people seem fixated on one negative aspect and then just associate the album with that. Is Dr. Octagonecologyst on the same lyrical ability as Kendrick Lamar's To Pimp A Butterfly? No. But that doesn't make it any less enjoyable to listen to. Fav tracks: Real raw, 3000, Blue flowers - revisited 6.5/10
I felt like the beats were lacking in this album. Dudes flow was good. He dropped “doo-doo” a couple of times and I really enjoyed it. I couldn’t fully vibe with this though.
Lol one time while in the commercial kitchen making candy I put this album on and everyone asked me to change to something else. Strong quit scaring the hoes vibes when this is played in public. Kool Keith and Dan the Automator, how can you hate it? One of the earliest rap concept albums and, as far as I am aware, the first to revolve around a central fictional character throughout the entire thing. This is a cinematic sci-fi soundscape.
makes me want to read the lyrics
Haven't heard of the guy before but the title and cover art made me sceptical... I gained some confidence when I saw that Dan the Automator produced it and yeah, the beats on this are really good. But the guy's rapping and lyrics are not good, hilarious even. The lyrics feel like somebody's rapping an Uncyclopedia article to me (shoutout for mentioning Copernicus randomly). It's comedy rap to me. And yet I can't hate it, "so bad it's good" type of thing. Gotta appreciate the weird theme that's never been done before and hasn't been done since 3/5
Fun listen, and a couple really good tracks on here. My favorite is probably Earth People. It does start to wear thin after a while, but overall decent.
„Dr. Octagonecologyst“ erschien 1996 als Debütalbum des US-amerikanischen Rappers Kool Keith unter seinem Alter Ego Dr. Octagon. Produziert wurde es größtenteils von Dan the Automator in Zusammenarbeit mit dem DJ Qbert. Aufgenommen in mehreren kalifornischen Studios, gilt das Werk als ein Wendepunkt des alternativen Hip-Hop der 1990er Jahre. Musikalisch verbindet das Album abstrakte Beats, Sci-Fi-Samples und schräge Jazz-Einflüsse mit surrealen Texten über außerirdische Medizin, Zeitreisen und bizarre Operationen. Songs wie „Blue Flowers“, „Earth People“ und „3000“ wurden zu Kulttiteln des Underground-Hip-Hop. Kool Keiths assoziativer, manchmal grotesker Sprachstil kontrastiert dabei mit Dan the Automators sauber strukturierten, futuristischen Produktionen. „Dr. Octagonecologyst“ wirkt bis heute wie ein Sound-Experiment, das zugleich Humor, Horror und Science Fiction zu einem eigenständigen Klanguniversum verknüpft. Es begründete Keiths Ruf als einer der exzentrischsten MCs seiner Zeit und inspirierte zahlreiche spätere Künstler im Bereich Alternative Hip-Hop.
I understand it's legacy - and help create a sub-genre...but so so so much better 90's hip hop out there that this isn't. From Tribe to Jurassic 5 this aint it. Ramblings of a super horny 16 yr old boy into weird science fiction - idk, i'll pass.
Hmmm
I love weirdness and this has a lot, so that's the strong point. There is some interesting music and good beats, but the scratching is superb. (Which still seems like a strange thing to write.) I find most of the rapping slow and pedestrian. REPETITIVE! I like the alien schtick, but no need for so many butt jokes, dick, jokes, fart jokes, etc. Was glad I've been exposed to it once, but doubt anything here will make the rotation. Solid 2 is all I can muster for it though.
It's weird. Some great beats with interesting musings on top -- but still weird. Runtime might be a tad too long. Did I mention it's weird?
Real Raw //
I was pleasantly surprised with this album. Good flow, good beats, good songs. Okay, the idea and the concept are a bit out there, but the result is pretty good. Some of the spoken word skit style songs are a bit pointless musically and purists may skip them, but it all adds to the vibe and the story, so it’s not the worst thing in the world. A couple of songs are not quite as good, but this album packs in several bangers. It’s fun, it’s well produced and it’s entertaining. Discovering slightly more obscure music like this is a perfect example of why I wanted to work through this list 👍
First Hip-Hop album on this list! I know this album, but never listened to it. Really reminds me of "Deltron 3030". Just don't like immature lyrics, but I read that's Kool Keith's character and his sense of humour, apparently. Ah, looks like Dan the Automator produced this, so "Deltron" connection is established. Good hip-hop albums which I just rated 3.5/5.0 on RYM, could go either way here.
What a bloody masterpiece. Loved every single moment of it. Yes, it did feel like it was getting a bit long towards the end. But I loved the bonkers nature of it. The samples. The irony. The persona. How the music describes and informs the character (heavy synths on some of the tracks). The conversations. I can understand some of the samples and things might be a bit uncomfortable, but I found them very funny and didn't feel the need to take them too seriously. It's a great record. Very much in the MF Doom sort of style as well.
It's strange; some 90's hip-hop really does it for me, and some really doesn't. This one doesn't do it for me. There are elements of the acid-tinged production that I appreciate, but it stagnates extremely quickly to the point where it starts to actively annoy me after a while. The lyrics also get to me pretty quickly; I'm not prudish or humorless at all, but I was not feeling the crassness of this one tonight. Perhaps I'd be a little kinder if it were half as long, but an hour-plus of the one-note soundscapes was too much for my tastes. 2/5
Langweilig. Die Songs waren nicht packend und kaum auseinanderzuhalten. Der Skit am Anfang hat schon etwas abgeschreckt.
Does not work. The sophomoric toilet and sex-related humor is neither clever nor creative. Don’t care to hear ever again. 1/5
Well, this exists...
ew no
Det är inte särskilt bra rap. Det är inte särskilt bra i övrigt. Känns halvhjärtat. Var känner jag igen blue flowers ifrån? Samplat från eller till någon annan lät? Stråkarna känns oerhört bekant.
Oj, här kommer det sannerligen en riktig överraskning, kul! Förstår vad den gör på listan då den ju är en klassiker som verkligen lade grunden till den lite ”svårare” hip-hopen från början av 2000-talet, typ MF Doom, El-P och Aesop Rock, som man i ärlighetens namn fick kämpa lite med för att börja gilla (undantaget El-P som jag forfarande har väldigt svårt för). Den här tycker jag dock är riktigt bra, om än lite ojämn, särskilt eftersom jag är svag för scratchingen i ch produktionerna överlag.
The music sounds so good even though the lyrics are so awful, confusing. 2.4.
Personal enjoyment: 3/5 Relevance to this list: 4/5
this is weird but I actually enjoyed it. I think there's something really smart here but it's buried under layers of like 13 year old boy humor
Weird lyrics, weird topics. Kinda utopic. Nice vibe for a silly car drive.
Pretty interesting and eclectic sounds put together for a hip hop album.
Dr. Octagonecologyst is of its time. I was uncomfortable, to say the least, but it isn't like Kool Keith was the only one out there doing this in 1996. And then he dissed disco, which I cannot abide. (I'm mostly joking.) Aside from that, this was a weird album. Some of it was catchy and interesting. I love a theme/concept, and I suppose I can't complain that the album kept to one. I enjoyed the "General Hospital" skit because I am a daytime soap opera fan. But I guess that's about it.
While all 90s hip hop sounds a bit dated at least, a lot of it has some kind of memorable hook that makes it relevant today. My immediate impression of this album was that it just felt like an artifact of the 90s and didn't really feel relevant. I did like the artist name "Dr. Octagon", but the album title just made me roll my eyes.
Yikes. That was a little too pornographic for my not-so-Puritan ears. Couldn’t finish it.
Not my Cup of Tea, but it’s Fine.
You know the beats are fire, and honestly carry this album. The lyrics are weird and abrasive, and yet... it kinda works. Just a weird album, but manages to be good at times. I enjoyed more as it went on.
A Visit to the Gynecologist is one of the worst songs I’ve ever heard, rest of the album pretty cool tho.
Wow, Ross from friends with a friend that thinks they can rap.
Total talentless garbage.
Strange early hip hop concept album. Beats are pretty good. Lyrics aren't the strongest and drift into some weird themes. Not a bad album, and can see how it influenced other artists. 3/5 Might listen again
I found it generic but I'm sure this angry 90s hiphop sound has a dedicated audience
Unexpected this. It is quite nice to find these hidden gems that the one album a day program reveals. I am a big fan of genres that swing off of techno and big beat, such as trip and hip hop. This is a near perfect blend of rap and hip hop that just grooves so well AND is super funny and just naughty enough to be a little "extra." I get why I had never heard of it, too... off the mainstream. But here it is and here I am to enjoy it! Yeah, this ... Just plain great fun. Mmm those drum beats just ... kick.
The actual rap is fine here. The beats suuuuuck though. They are biting as hell.
One extra point for the beats and bass being great. Other than that, cringe and lame as hell.
I like the concept but did not enjoy the execution. The sexualization of medical providers in this album is really unnerving as a healthcare worker
Icky. Such as in the track Girl Let Me Touch You
Not excited; did not complete.
A good example of smooth 1990s hip hop, Dr. Octagonecologyst, is good but long. Also I wonder where the artist, Dr. Octagon, got his degree and how hard he studied in fucking. According to his excellent wikipedia page, "Dr. Octagon is an extraterrestrial surgeon from Jupiter who uses space technology and primitive tools to perform medical procedures on his patients, some of whom die as he conducts his rounds, while others are murdered by his careless, barbaric acts. Octagon also practices as an orthopaedic gynaecologist and seduces and engages in sexual intercourse with his female patients and nurses." Doesn't sound like a strong doctor to me. This is a good album to play in the background of a chill after-hours party. Top tracks: "I'm Destructive," "Earth People," "Dr. Octagon"
No idea what this is. "you can call 1-800-pee pee 5 Doo Doo" lmao This is one of the weirdest ass rap albums I've ever heard. Very different from what I usually listen to in hip hop. Scott said it's like if Adult Swim was rap and...yeah, that's 10000% accurate lol. That said, I'm actually surprised I stuck with it. I didn't actually love it, I thought it was good, and fine, but just didn't tickle my pickle, exactly.
Final thoughts: I believe this album deserves to be on the list because, for me, it opened up a lot of doors to more, uh, "alternative" forms of hip hop. That being said, it's very uneven, too long, not as funny as Keith thinks it is. ******************************************************************************* --Intro...oh my --3000...meh --I Got to Tell You...interlude --Earth People...I like the sound and beat, his flow doesn't always work for me --No Awareness...Kool's flow seems better here, fits more with the nice production. Sir Menelik seems to be having issues getting each syllable out. tbf, there are a lot of syllables --Real Raw...the first 3ish minutes are boring. Then someone starts scratching (Q-Bert?). it elevates it a little --General Hospital...skit --Blue Flowers...the sample is my brand of weird but the way Keith raps on here kind of forces each track to sound too similar --Technical Difficulties...not for me --A Visit to the Gynecologyst...oh my --Bear Witness...instrumental. It's good --Dr Octagon...the cool production continues but there are so many words! There are so many syllables I can't tell if they're on beat. Or if they're even supposed to be on beat. Sir Menelik again! --Girl Let Me Touch You...here we go, I like it when Keith allows himself to breathe --I'm Destructive...something with more of a rock feel --Wild and Crazy...probably my favorite track. the simple, driving bass beat really ties it all together --Elective Surgery...skit --Halfsharkalligatorhalfman....it certainly fits the theme --Blue Flowers Revisited...not sure you need to revisit anything when your album is already over an hour --Waiting List...starting to feel like I'm in a waiting room --1977...I do like this but it doesn't really belong here. And, again, this album is long. cut this one and put it on something else
This shit is crazy. Hilarious. What a flow.
83% Best: Earth People; Real Raw; Bear Witness; Wild and Crazy Must-Hear? Sure
Pretty chill
Actually really enjoyed this. Not a huge rap fan, but it was fun and interesting.
-1.5 million stars. W.T.E.F. The only possible way this could’ve influenced any other artist .. was to actually make good music? My ears hurt. I felt some of my brain cells actually pop. The people who voted this into existence should be beat out of it. This made me Almost not want to participate in this venture anymore…
Thoughts I had while listening to this album: - That intro was definitely used in Porn. - I need to wash my brain out with bleach. -GROSS - I guess that voicemail was kinda funny. - Did I just single-handedly kill feminism by listen to “A visit to the Gynecologist?” - *googles* how to permanently delete history from Spotify algorithm? This album is awful and the masters should be destroyed.
Good bears but lyrics were nothing special.
Guys 20 tracks? 20? Maybe there was some fat on this thing with skits that have poo poo and pee pee jokes. I guess this guy has influenced just about every big time rapper. But it's kinda jumbled nonsense. Have you heard how Phil Collins came up with Sususudio? He had a track and was making a melody with pure noise and just kept the noise? Well I have half a mind to think that's what this guy did but didn't admit to it.
Meh, some of it is alright.
Why’s this guy just made an album about gynecology
Sounded good for a hip hop
Not my thing
I judged a book by its cover and was right
Kinda ass ngl
Enjoyed the beats but this album was not my usual cup of tea.
SO GOOD
Okay so this is the juvenile kind of rap. To be honest, I couldn't make it through more than three tracks. Childish and irritating.
Cool beats, wildly imaginative. Not something I would frequently listen too, and quite offensive at times.
Great production and flow. I just don't think it's super distinctive from the other records at the time for me to give it a higher rating.
keeping the rap alive
Oh hell yes
I like his rap style but it gets a bit tired
Surprisingly good!
New to me and pretty interesting. While listening I read there's also an instrumental version, I listened to it on YouTube and preferred it. The raps are ok but the beats are where it's at. I would put this in the rotation if I had easier access to the Instrumentalyst version.
245/1089 - What if Deltron 3030 but porn noises and crappy. I noticed a Bartok sample which was kinda cool in Blue Flowers.
4/5
Tis too long. Ablation is recommended.
I'm not sure is some of the skits and stuff are meant to be funny, but not really. There's sort of a concept of a character it seems, but it sort of feels like they're saying whatever. The flows and like hyper-scientific medical lyrical miracle type shit is not it really in my opinion, but I'll definitely award them for creativity. Also some of these beats are great with the synth basslines, which makes them quite unique. I Think there's some features that are actually worse than the main guy. There's also some more non-rap influences, like some of the trip hop and rockier songs. Also not too sure about some of the chorus singers, they just don't sound too good and are often too happy and slightly ruin the mysterious beats. Favourite songs: 3000, Earth people, real raw, blue flowers, and probably loads more that I missed as its quite long. Overall around 6/10
eh, alright
Had a “WTF!” reaction to every other song. Really fun and interesting
Classic. Fun for the whole family.
This was pretty bad. I only gave it 2 stars because the production is pretty good. The rapping here is all over the place. I found the concept of the album pretty childish and honestly dumb. The delivery does nothing to help here, the flow is pretty off and mediocre, he's often off beat in an annoying way. The verses are also pretty mediocre, repetitive, simple and just not good. The concept again does little favors to help the writing. The production on the other hand is great, most of the beats go super hard. Good sample selection, raw drums and excellent scratches. There are some beats that aren't as good as the others (the "Blue Flowers" one was pretty annoying), but it works pretty good most of the time. If this had been an instrumental album, I might've given it 3 or 4 stars. The best tracks was "3000". "Girl Let Me Touch You" was pretty bad, kinda creepy and the chorus is so bad. "Halfsharkalligatorhalfman" was also so dumb conceptually, I couldn't take it seriously, but wasn't good enough to be funny either. The skits are also all over the place.
Hip-hop with electronic music vibes. Solid delivery, good hooks and riffs. Seems to be a concept album about the character Dr Octagon - an alien gynecologist? Kind of humorous lyrically. Makes me think of MC Chris and MC Frontalot as well. Definitely some Beastie Boys influence. Also reminds of early Beck. Notable tracks include 3000, Earth Power, Bear Witness, Dr Octagon, Girl Let Me Touch You, Wild And Crazy, Blue Flowers (Revisited).
Weird album. I kinda liked some of the beats and flows but a lot of it didn't really work and was stuck in that late 90's/ early 2000's shock humor that has not aged well like at all. Also those porn samples were a choice. 3/10
和Fugees那张感觉有异曲同工之妙吧,都是那种低气压的另类嘻哈,不过这张对于电影化的采样还有奇妙的概念,也算是抽象嘻哈的鼻祖了?对电子的运用很到位,有几首蛮triphop的,感觉算是地下名盘的程度,但我没那么喜欢。
Best Song: Bear Witness. The scratching on this track is on another level. Worst Song: A Visit To The Gynecologyst. Strangely, I'm not a huge fan of perverse medical Mickey Mouse. Overall: A really weird grab-bag of ideas. Honestly, I loved lots of the sampling and scratching, and even the floating, free-association rap style was good. Sadly, a lot of the sex humour feels really dated, and you just have to kind of cringe until its over and you can get back to the good parts. Still, I appreciate this level of dedication to silliness, and it is still a listenable album.
I love hip hop, especially 90’s since I grew up with it but there has to be better options in the genre to expose people than this. There could be a list of 1001 hip hop albums to listen to and I still wouldn’t listen to this.
This is one of those albums you understand why it’s influential, but I personally just can’t bring myself to love. There are some great beats in here, and the rapping is solid enough, but I personally don't feel the hype quite yet. I will say that it’s a perfectly funny album though when it comes to the skits, like "Oh shit there's a horse in the hospital!" is an incredible one liner that does nothing but helps you power through the album. This will definitely be an album I keep an eye out on though for future relistens, since I'm sure my opinion will radically change once it properly hits.
Highlights: 3000, Earth People, Blue Flowers, I’m Destructive
Now I understand the Neighbourhooh shoutout!
Interesting concept but not really my jam
It's decent music and a shake-things-up-enough listen, little weird sometimes, but nothing's really giving it the spice to stand out amongst everything else. Just sort of at a level of consistent but not particularly enthusiastic "good"
Fan of Dan the Automator, although this isn't my favorite project of his. However, this is still a great hip-hop record. Love it!
I can only imagine that whoever wrote this list of 1001 albums to hear before you die must have been having a laugh by including this. Kool Keith pretends to be a time-travelling homicidal alien gynecologist so that he can hide behind a “it’s not me saying this, I am just playing a character” defence for including samples from porn films and descriptions of surgical violence. The backing tracks are good, but the vocals and themes make it feel like a novelty album that wore its joke thin within the first couple of tracks.
Good rhythm and style, just not my groove.
I'll give it a 1. Felt like the lyrical, miracle, spiritual kind of rap.
This is a weird one. Music for when you’re at the bar tooooo late.
Noch amüsant, viel abwechslung
Roskaa!
Semmone. Muutama hassu laulu
Olipahan taas kuraa.
Taustamusana ihan ok! Tunti oli kyllä tälle albumille vähän liian kauan, alkoi toistaa jo itseään.
This album was like he took all his random internal intrusive thoughts that no one should hear and made them into music. The production was ok.
what a wholly perverted album, lmao. god this was so unpleasant to listen to. i'm not a prude but also i don't really want to listen to an hour of a dude talking about sexually assaulting people. why is the word rectum mentioned so many times? this whole album is about jamming your dick in girls asses without consent the album. it sucks because the beats are actually pretty sick and i wish each song wasn't about buttholes and stuff. the beats are really the only thing barely keeping this from a 1 for me.
Hip-Hop
Not sure how to feel about this one, it certainly should be considered art. However I find the choruses to be overly repetitive and uninteresting. The rest of the lyrics are very good! With that said the lyrics really are the only interesting thing going on, the beats are incredibly simplistic and I simply do not understand the appeal of record scratches. The album is at it's best when treated as a story first and music second.
Please make it stop!
I'm sorry...what? Dude's got issues.
Treading the fine line between stupid and clever. I wasn't listening closely enough to be offended, but the grooves are pleasant and I can definitely see its influence on others.
I don't like that album, I don't hear anything interesting here. I guess it is just not my type of rap music. I just don't see anything interesting here. 1/5
This is something a white boy would swear up and down is legendary but once you finally listen to it, it feels like you're under psychological torture. Not my cup of tea, off beat and clunky.
Never heard of Dr O … will probably never hear him again.
I don’t understand why this is on here with such heavy hitters from the rap/hip hop world
“Call 1-800-PP5 1-Doo Doo, I’m in your corner.” Dr. Octagon is a homicidal, extraterrestrial, time-traveling gynecologist and surgeon. My old job! I would have loved this back in 96.
Guy's more of a proctogonologist??
always heard about dr octagon but never knew the music. kind of like hip hop weird al? or ween? or some sort of rick and morty thing? funny enough, as well as some slick dj shadow beats, but not reaching back for it.
Wow that intro was something to listen to at 7:45 in the morning on a Thursday. Okay I did not like this. Why the hell did it have to be so long?
Brilliant. I love the fusion of culture in music, and I love seeing what inspires artists. The concept album (almost prog?) nature of this record is so sick, but I love so much how it fuses comic book culture and lore into rap music and tells a really cool story. The beats are cool and poignant. The lyrics and dark, twisted and funny. Its really an album that you can live in. Its a whole universe within a collection of songs. I'd also be remiss to not mention the influence this record had on the GOAT > MF DOOM.
Rectum word count is off the charts. Brilliant & sick.
this is fun you should revisit
This is an interesting record, but I’m not sure it rises to the level of “must hear”. The music is great, love the beats and Keith’s flow, but the lyrics/concept are basically what you’d get if you locked 10 12 year olds in a room and told them to write dirty jokes. I’m not offended by the content, just by the lack of humor or originality. Great beats, great flow, puerile rhymes.
Bored me to death.
Rap/hip hop. Listened to Blue Flowers (really interesting strings/electronic background beat), Earth People, Intro. Lyrics are good but not my style.
No I’m so scared by this and I find it grating this is something a weird guy would like and I don’t like how sexual it is
I think perhaps if I were an alien creature from Jupiter who did not have any command of the English language or any understanding of human sexual politics I would enjoy some of the beats on this. However in real life I'm a female Earth Person, so, you know. It's not like I'm coming to this exercise expecting to hear a whole lot of respect for women from every album in the compilation but the lyrics on this one are just flat-out *gross* in addition to being dehumanizing. Not a pleasant listening experience. Redeeming qualities? That organ vamp on Earth People? The fact that it (eventually, finally) ended? I don't know. Final verdict: a strong piece of evidence in favor of the theory that the world might be a fundamentally better place for women if men were forbidden from making music. And possibly from practicing medicine as well.
O jezu, to było na granicy dziwnego i obrzydliwego. Same utwory są proste i chwytliwe, powtarzające się "refreny" szybko wpadają w ucho. Ale cała ta otoczka jest odrzucająca. Czy muszę słuchać fragmentu porno jako wstępu? 4.5/10 równane w dół, chociaż spokojnie same kawałki mogłyby mieć 6/10, ale ten "superzabawny" koncept kosmity-ginekologa odejmuje więcej niż jedną gwiazdkę. I piszę to jako osoba, która lubi dziwne rzeczy.
Maybe if I was still 14 years old? "Halfsharkalligatorhalfman" is kind of fun, I guess.
Loved it. It was fire all the way through with that THICK 90s funk
Hip hop with electro, with medical/scifi imagery. Seems to straddle a space between Beastie Boy/Public Enemy and Eminem, but also foreshadowing Gorillaz. Lots of scratching like nu metal used soon after. Some other house/dnb/jungle influences in there too. Overall quite impressive. Rock/metal crossover in I'm Destructive Best track - Earth People, Real Raw, I'm Destructive 4 stars
Too long although I can see its influence.
Gross porn plot intro Does not get better. Needs to stay in the 90s and not return
I dig this a good amount
The obligatory rap related misogyny but without the good tunes. Overall boring.
This was a good album and I love that it was produced by fan the automator! It felt like it was part of the universe where deltron 3030 was and it was such a different type of rap album, but in a good way!
What white bread, silver spoon honkies are giving this 1 or 2 stars? This is pretty solid hip-hop. We have a mini satanic panic going on in the reviews here. "disturbing" "disgusting"... how about you grow up and quit crying about naughty language.
Meh - 2/5
Dude, I honestly thought this was going to be rock or metal but it's hip hop, rap? But I dig it!! super love this actually. This is a 5 star album man.
I wanted to like this but in the same year are Jay-Zs and Eminem's debuts. In addition we already had Biggie, Tupac, Snoop, and Dre all releasing hits, this was a big disappointment.
Great classic 90s rap album. 3/5
i don't care if you have a sexual fantasy of being an evil alien OBGYN. I just wish you would quietly jerk off about it instead of getting me involved 😭
no idea what to rate this. the album's content is gross, misogynistic, and juvenile, but the hip-hop production and editing is top notch. i also think the album art is pretty cool - reminds me of some darker video games and fantasy media from the late 90s. ultimately the album is too long and inconsistent to really make me want to come back to it, ever. let's leave this behind in 1996 where it belongs. favorites: i got to tell you, earth people, bear witness, dr octagon
One of my favorite alt-rap albums. Weird, surrealistic and brilliant. Nothing accidental happening here.
On the face of it this should be something I'd enjoy. There were some bright moments, but in general I was left quite disappointed. It was still listenable but just not good as I'd hoped (or even expected).
The moment I saw this album pop up here, I thought it was made up. Like, I thought now the generator was fucking with me. Honestly, I’m so fucking over this random goddamn hip-hop albums that run over a fucking hour. Like, goddamn, I haven’t heard of you before and you expect me to have the mental capacity to withstand your shit for 20 songs, give or take? Doesn’t help that this album’s lame as fuck. To be fair, I appreciate the dedication to center the whole album around the abstract concept. There is this weird sci-fi, grimy vibe to it that holds the album together. Unfortunately, it holds as well as tissue paper. The charm died for me not even halfway through, possibly because of the terrible lyrics. Seriously, I hate these songs where the singer repeats the title of the song over and over again. I find it hysterical that apparently this is considered by some to be one of the best hip-hop albums of the 90’s. I think they need their head examined… by a real doctor, preferably. Favorite track: 3000 Other hits: 1977 (it was the end of the album)
Still weird and wild, like it more now than I did back in the day
3/5
3.1 1x
Un peu trop long, aurait pu être resserré, mais très bon. Un album de rap avec de la personnalité.
It was great! Very old school a bit too much for me but the beats are so exciting and special it is unbelievable
9/10 haven’t listened to this one again in a very long time I remember hearing Blue Flowers in a tv show and loving it so much I decided to hear the rest of the album while I would say that said song is the highlight of the album, that isn’t to say the rest of the album isn’t absolutely superb
Sort of like a perverted MF DOOM
Amazing beats, some decent tracks but the lyrics are both out of time, and mostly average at best
Oof, just bad.
I’m betting this album wins out for the most mentions of the word rectum. While you ponder that, I’m gonna go dial 1-800-DOO DOO like Dr. O encourages, because that’s what this is: complete and utter shite.
I’m quite sure some of the talent here is lost on me, as this isn’t really my tempo. Found this at times distracting and childish, so didn’t love it.
WTF. Giving this a 1 for the track “A Visit to the Gynecologyst”. Just completely creepy weird.
I found the underlying story/character really took me out of this album. A couple of the skits were just bad and the album felt really overstuffed. There's enough here that they could have stripped out a bunch of stuff and made a solid above-average album. But they didn't do that... 2.25/5
Would there even be a lil Wayne without Kool Keith? Weirdness level 11/10 and I’m here for it.
It’s weird because I feel cooler than I did this morning after having listened to this but also like more of a dweeb knowing that I wouldn’t have if not for this.
boring. The guy says its name like 13 times in the album
I admit, I've never listened to a rap album before. I...am not sure this was the right place to start. This is bizarre. This is f'ed up, man. (Thank you, Genius, for letting me read the lyrics while listening; and "thank you", Genius, for all the "helpful" annotations.) It's scatological, it's sexual (and not much of it consensual), it's alternately stream of consciousness and articles from Scientific American. And...I liked it? I didn't hate it. I'm not likely to listen to it again, but I'm not necessarily sad that I listened to it once. (Compare that to "Iron Maiden", earlier in this project, which I really would have been fine never hearing.)
Never heard before, very good, would seek physical copy ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (but probably a 5 really given more listening)
This album has always been one of my favorite hip-hop albums, so I was already quite familiar with it. I gave it a refresh just to be sure – and yep, it’s still great. I reckon it’s not easy to get into that kind of sound ; it’s a demanding album that requires at least a basic hip-hop culture to be fully appreciated. It's also super weird (as always with Kool Keith, who's clearly a mad bastard). It’s abstract / ambient hip hop, and you have to listen to it that way. Don't expect any banger - it’s low-key, sometimes even a bit jazzy, with a lot of attention going to production and atmospheres. It’s an experimental / concept album with metal-esque artwork, disturbing themes and lyrics, haunting loops, and an overall gloomy mood that makes it close to horrorcore (with a big grain of salt, because it's also full of silly jokes, absurd punchlines and hilarious lyrics... "Oh shit, there's a horse in the hospital !"). It may not be Dan the Automator’s best work, but you can feel QBert’s presence all through the album with his phenomenal scratches. As for Kool Keith, he was still a bit rough around the edges at the time (it was his first solo album), but his droning voice contributes greatly to the general unease the album tries to convey. Still a classic in my opinion, but clearly not the album I’d pick to introduce someone to hip hop.
Cool. It's playing for the second time now. This falls neatly into what seems to be my golden age of hip hop. Interesting beats, flows, jazzy and trippy samples cooked to perfection and not a gangsta in sight. Lyrical themes are 𝘩𝘢𝘳-𝘩𝘢𝘳, instead, but I can choose to not pay attention. Good stuff.
This is some low quality entertainment.
I know this came first, but this album reminds me a little of MF Doom. The production style is similar. The lyrics have interesting wordplay and are worth reexamining. The only issue I have is the way Kool Keith raps. He raps with no energy at all. I don't know if that's his style, but it took me time to get used to.
Usually I wait until the end until I rate an album, but there is no need in this case since there is nothing that can redeem the first 4 songs. One star for the beats, that are actually nice
Sophomoric lyrics about poo poo and magnificent beats. What’s not to like?
It's sad that given all the great albums that have been left out this list, in and outside the hip-hop genre, they decided to put this generic and immature rap album, but okay
-this is like some shit Jesse Pinkman would listen to -the concept seemed kind of entertaining to me. and there are a lot of genuinely good boom bap songs on here, though it kind of overstayed its welcome and had some dull moments. probably wouldn’t relisten but i appreciate it -Favorites are Real Raw and Half Shark Alligator Half Man
i like rap but this is just terrible
i am so tired Y'know, I somehow expected more from a character that calls itself the "paramedic fetus of the east." Like, I'd heard so much about the shock raps on this thing, I was fully prepared to bring that "There's a difference between Eminem doing it and Bizarre doing it" line from my review of 'The Marshall Mathers LP'. 'Coz I really do not have a problem with "outdated shock raps" as long as they're done in a properly entertaining way, and as long we know we're not supposed to be rooting for the narrator. Eminem, for all the headaches the Slim Shady persona has brought him, has the wordplay and flows to pull it off. Dr. Octagon, on the other hand... Lemme tell you, the first time I was ever introduced to Dr. Octagon, it was through one of Rap Critic's "Worst Lyrics I've Ever Heard (This Month/Year)" videos. There was one where he spotlighted the song "Octagon Octagon", where the lyrical conceit was that everything was an octagon for some reason . . . and based off of that and the aforementioned "paramedic fetus of the east" descriptor, I thought it was just some random nobody using a character to be an edgy little shit. Imagine my surprise, then, when I find out it's actually an alter-ego of **Kool Keith**. Like, that's a name! I know that name! To some people he might be one of the GOATs, for all I know! I mean, I'd never heard any of his work besides a brief cameo on that Jurassic 5 album, but come on. People **like** him. So maybe this Dr. Octagon experiment will actually be better than that one song would make it seem...? Here's the thing. There's a difference between Eminem doing shock raps and Bizarre doing shock raps — and as it turns out, there's a difference between Bizarre doing them and **Dr. Octagon** doing them. Like, I spent the entire album waiting for something that would inspire so many offended reactions, but . . . but there's nothing! Besides maybe the gynecologist skit, there's nothing here even remotely shocking or offensive! Like, he says "doo doo" and "butt crack" a lot — is that it? Is that the shocking part? Where's the rape? Where's the murder? Where's the **anything** to provoke some kind of reaction? But, OK, it's not offensive. For most artists, that's a good thing. What about the rest of the album, then? Is there anything beyond its nonexistent shock value? I'll repeat: there's **nothing**. I mean, I am actually shocked by how overall **boring** this album is. It's to a point where, legitimately, during one of the songs in the back half, I nearly fell asleep. Which doesn't sound too unusual; even on albums I've liked there are times where I find myself wanting to close my eyes during a first listen. That's just a consequence of my AuDHD. But, no, this was different. All those other times, when my eyes closed, I could still focus on the music if I wanted to. With his album, I was legit fighting off conking out entirely. I straight up missed "Wild And Crazy" because I was trying to keep myself awake. The beats . . . gawd, they are so dry and nondescript. I've heard lowkey beats before, but none with as little going on as these. There's not a single memorable one in the lot. Even the one interlude that samples classical music or whatever, which I'd say is the best beat here, isn't particularly notable. Not even any of the scratching on, which I think is very good, can save these beats. Then there's Kool Keith himself as Dr. Octagon. And, like, as I always say with these rap albums, I am not a lyrics person. My brain being the way it is, I struggle to parse out meaning on the fly unless it's really obvious. But, let it never be said I don't make the effort to try anyway. I actively followed along with these lyrics, and lemme tell you, even with my chronic inability to understand metaphor . . . I had no idea what the fuck was going on on this album. In the middle of "No Awareness", I legit had to ask, out loud, "What the fuck are you going on about?" Like, cool you know big technical words — what does any of it mean? And this goes for every song on the album, really. He says a lot of shit, but none of it connects into anything meaningful. I was never able to conjure any specific imagery, or really even figure out what this Dr. Octagon character was supposed to be like beyond being "the paramedic fetus of the east." What was I supposed to take away from any of this? But here's a counter to that question: why should I give a shit about what any of this means when Kool Keith clearly couldn't care about **his own performance**? Y'know, some people just have rap voices; they were born to spit. JAY, Biggie, 2Pac, Eminem, Kendrick, Dre, Wayne . . . and way more. All those kinda guys, they rap, and they sound natural and like they care. Maybe Kool Keith sounds better on other records, but here? Oh, gawd, it sounds like he's just talking. And he happens to be doing it to a rhythm that matches the beat. And it's so **boring**. Like, even if he **was** spitting some 'Slim Shady LP' caliber shock raps, it wouldn't have any impact. He wouldn't be Freddy Kruger, like Slim Shady comes off to me; he's just be . . . **some guy**. Calling himself "the paramedic fetus of the east" for some reason. Seriously, if he was even slightly entertaining in his delivery I might not have had so much trouble trying to stay away. And I just gotta wonder, what is this album even doing here on this list? That question normally has no impact on what I think about an album, but seriously, I have to ask. 'Coz what's so special about what Kool Keith does here that it's something I just **had** to hear it before I died? What makes it a "classic" that I hafta "respect?" What exactly am I missing here? Are we really gonna pretend that this album is on the same level as records like 'The Blueprint', 'Illmatic', 'Born To Die', 'Me Against The World', 'The Chronic', or any other album like those? Does it really deserve to share space with those? And, like, if you wanted to put a Kool Keith album on here, why not just put a Kool Keith album on here? Why you gotta throw it over to his uninteresting OC? Even from the very little I heard of Kool Keith on that Jurassic 5 album, I know he can be a much more engaging MC; there has to be **something** better in his discography. Like, I don't care if this thing was his solo debut; he **has** to have done better, before or after. And if that's the reason why I'm considering checking out the rest of his work, then, well...! Look, I don't even know, man. This thing is largely just plain boring. And unless you're Kid Rock or scum like Kofi Olimede, I often find that I end up disliking those kinds of albums way more than the ones that're just straight "offensive." They're obviously far worse, but, damn, at least you're making me **feel something**. With Dr. Octagon over here — nada. Nothing. Not a damn thing. These sides are neither fantastic or glorious, and these angles sure as hell ain't awesome or stunning. I was honestly trying to figure out something I liked enough about this album to bump up the score — again, the scratching isn't bad, and I did sort of like "Halfaligatorsharkhalfman" and "1977" . . . but, no. No quarter. This felt like a waste of my time. And I really do hope that Kool Keith got better from here, 'coz if this is still representative of his sound . . . well, goodness. So gimme a damn octagon apple, eh? 'Coz I wanna octagon keep this octagon doctor the octagon hell away from me. (And also be octagon thankful I didn't write the whole octagon review like this! I had the octagon thought, believe me! But it wouldn't have been octagon worth it!)
Pretty decent 90's hip-hop. 3.5 bumped up to 4.
I’m at a 2.5 that I will bump down to a 2, even though I genuinely liked about 7 of the tracks here. I don’t know, man. That’s just aggressively mediocre to my ears. Kool Keith had a good feature on Jurassic 5’s “Power in Numbers”, but he sheds that general style here for the eccentricities of Dr. Octopus, the “homicidal, extraterrestrial, time-traveling gynecologist and surgeon”. I am not a big fan of Dr. Octopus. This isn’t a Slim Shady situation where the over-the-top nonsense loops back around to genuinely witty wordplay with a party flow & an enjoyable vibe. Dr. Octopus, as a character, is crass, a rapist, and an all-around generally terrible alien with not a single redeeming quality to him. It’s not enjoyable to hear about his escapades, and there’s never really a comeuppance for it. It’s kind of just torture porn, in a way. Of course, I’m prone to give some degree of leeway since it is still so over-the-top that you can’t imagine Kool Keith advocating for any of this, but it’s aged really poorly into 2025, and even for 1996, this just feels like shock-jock perverted humor to some degree. I just don’t fuck with the lyrics that much. On top of the lyricism being an issue, what really drags this fucking album down is the beats, vocals, & flows. It’s just the most dry energy I’ve heard from a mid-90s rap album yet. Kool Keith does not have a rap voice like a Biggie, a Jay-Z, or a Tupac, and it desperately shows. He’s relatively monotone throughout the whole thing. It wouldn’t be a major issue if he just had a normal flow, but of course, Dr. Octopus being the alien scumbag that he is, simply refuses to glide on the vast majority of these already dry fucking beats. It’s a very “stream of consciousness” style of rap, but it just doesn’t work, especially with the verbosity on so many of the early tracks diluting the theming of the album. Ultimately, I just didn’t like it that much. It’s not the worst album ever, but… fuck me, it’s just boring. The shock jock value doesn’t draw any humor (and that’s like, half the songs), and it’s an hour long, which just means it drags the fuck on. If it were shorter & tighter, I might be more inclined to barely bump it up to a 3, but… nope. It’s just not a good album experience. I don’t know if this should be on the list, really. If I’m ever thinking that, then something just isn’t clicking. Hence, a 2.5 bumped down to a 2. If it clicks for you, then good on you; I hear the appeal, but it's just not there for me. It's a shame, because I do think Kool Keith is GOOD at rapping, based on what I've heard. I just don't really like Dr. Octopus, which makes me kinda disappointed.
This was fucking weird. The guys got flow, for sure. The abstractness/surrealism/non-sequitur character of the lyrics makes it somewhat hard to tell if he's one of the greats, or uses these "features" to obscure the fact he can't maintain the flow and have substantive, meaningful rhymes. Second to none turntablism too. This is hard to rate, but I'm going ⭐⭐⭐
Not for me.
They had me at "Half shark-alligator, half man".
I'm not a fan of rap, but this was a fun album and not all that objectionable. The nonsensical parts and techno babble were fun. Thematically, it kinda reminded me of a Rob Zombie album. There are, however, way too many instances of "anus", "rectum", and other butt-related references.
Fat beats and samples. Pretty good rapping. Mediocre bars and weak skits. Cool to hear something that I’ve never even heard about from a genre that I’m pretty into anyway!