Reviews (page 6 of 9)
I almost really like some of M.I.A.'s stuff, but it just doesn't quite cross the line between exciting and annoying.
11 shitty repetitive pop songs and “Paper Planes” which is actually a pretty good song.
Definitely not my thing.
fhfhbbb
excellent music
They could never make me hate you, M.I.A.
Bamboo Banga - This track layers like a house song. Promising so far. Kind of a silly chorus. BirdFlu - Bird sample is a bold choice. I like the ethnic flavors. The drums are cool but this one gets old fast. Boyz - I've heard this before. She hasn't shown her rapping chops yet. I think these very bold production choices would be better served with a more commanding rapper. Jimmy - A disco cut. I like the less maximalist production as compared to the others so far. Hussel - This sounds like Yeezuz before Yeezuz. The male rappers sounds better than her tbh. The chorus is kinda dumb. Mango Pickle Down River - They got the abos on this one. Reminds me of that petrol song lol. MIA sounds buried in the mix. Digeridoo is cool. I'm starting to get a third worldist vibe from this album. 20 Dollar - Death Grips vibe on this one with the synth. This is the best rapping she's done so far. Blue Monday interpolation is cool. She rips a lot of lyrics from the Pixie song Where Is My Mind. Says a lot that one of the more enjoyable tracks is ripping from two other songs. World Town - Has the same the production as fucking Shake It Off. Chorus is really annoying. Worst track so far. The Turn - Pointless track. Could have made this an interlude. XR2 - She sounds like she's falling asleep. Doesn't work with such an energetic beat. She starts dropping a bunch of acronyms, I guess she thinks it's clever. I found out she was 32 when this album dropped. Paper Planes - Her lazy delivery works with this production. It's properly airy and carefree. This track is a classic. The gunshots and cash register are iconic. Come Around - The flow on this one is actually good. They got Timbaland on this one. I would revisit this track. Overall production was really cool on this one but MIA didn't carry most of the time. She was buried in the mix and the only time she had charisma was towards the end. All this album needed was a more energetic performance. I'm curious to look at her other stuff and I will return to some of these tracks.
This was hard to listen to. Last 2 songs really carry the entire album but you have to get through tons of random sounds and random words to get to it.
Listening to these lyrics and remembering that she married a millionaire and her values seemed to change overnight! MIA is a little shit head and this album sucks.
There was some interesting production but a lot of it didn't really hit for me. Did not care for the Where is My Mind part either.
This album feels like it was made for me. I think M.I.A is the coolest. Like she's Tamil, im Tamil and idk much about her but I think she's prolly my fav famous brown person. And this album is named after her mom Kala which is literally my grandmother's name. My mom and MIA are like the same age so I imagine our Kalas are the same age too so basically this album is about my grandma. Also my mom's favorite dog growing up was called Jimmy. The sound of the album is just super homey to me
3/10 - Those of you in music league know my dislike for paper planes so I am not expecting much from this album. Well it was about what I expected. There were a lot of interesting sounds used in this album but I did not enjoy it very much. Jimmy was a decent song.
Some pretty crazy and interesting stuff on here. 20 dollar sounded like bladee at times and was just a pixies song at times. I don’t think there are any songs I really liked other than paper planes, but paper planes is such a great song
определённый драйв есть, даже меня взбодрило, но в среднем всё равно слишком гнусаво и похоже, чтобы прям целый альбом интересен был
I respect the craftsmanship here and she is a talented vocalist/rapper but this album is too much for me.
A mash up of various sounds and styles in some sort of mad scientist approach to music. But has as many hits as misses but it all comes together perfectly on paper planes. Still 3* overall
Paper Planes is singlehandedly carrying this whole album because although the rest of the songs were intriguing, they weren't that great. Listening to this album was a bit weird, the fourth song is just annoying and is not available, but apart from that, the rest of the songs just sounded like they would belong in a movie soundtrack while something intense is happening, possibly when people are on drugs and trying to do something in a crowded area.
First song was horrible. I tried to stay open minded but the second song is horrible and annoying too. By this point my ears are suffering. 20 Dollar is a cheap knockoff of The Pixie's Where is My Mind. Really wish this list would give me that album instead. Paper Plans is a song I knew already and is okay I guess. But by now I'm questioning the integrity of these songs and lo and behold, it's a ripoff of The Clash's Straight To Hell. The only possibly good thing about this album is not original.
Sound like a world cup songs tf
Wie auf dem Bauernhof: Eine Ladung Mist nach der anderen! Gackern, Kreischen und Jammern hat mit Gesang nichts zu tun. Dazu klopft jemand mit einer Stange auf einem Fass herum. Unhörbar!
This album definitely took me out of my comfort zone. I did enjoy the main hit, and thought it sounded a lot different than the rest, but I already knew that I liked that one. Possibly worth a relisten.
Ok kinda repetitive
I skipped every track!
A really interesting sound, and never boring.
If Arular was a raw spark, Kala is the wildfire. Released just two years after her debut, M.I.A.'s second album doesn’t just expand her sound—it explodes it. Where Arular felt like a snapshot of London’s underground, Kala ventures far beyond, weaving global rhythms, bold beats, and unapologetically brash energy into a sprawling, chaotic experience. It’s the sound of an artist hitting her stride, pushing boundaries even as her strengths and flaws grow more pronounced. Recorded across continents—India, Trinidad, Jamaica, and Australia—Kala digs deep into street music and traditional sounds, making its cultural influences feel genuine and embedded rather than borrowed. This globetrotting approach injects the album with a sense of restless energy and ambition. The production is Kala’s crown jewel. While Arular thrived on sparse, jarring beats, Kala embraced maximalism, layering Bollywood strings, African percussion, and dancehall grooves, often within the same song. Tracks like “Boyz” and “Bird Flu” are percussive earthquakes, while “Jimmy” struts with Bollywood disco flair. “Paper Planes,” the album’s sardonic centrepiece, combines gunshot and cash register samples to create a cultural juggernaut that’s instantly recognizable. Meanwhile, “20 Dollar,” with its Pixies sample, bridges worlds, teasing familiarity while remaining undeniably M.I.A. Each track pushes boundaries, even when the experiments occasionally overwhelm. What hasn’t changed is M.I.A.’s penchant for provocative, surface-level politics. If Arular felt like “a teenager cosplaying Noam Chomsky,” Kala is the diary entry after a round-the-world trip—broader in scope but still light on substance. Tracks like “Hussel” and “World Town” touch on immigration, capitalism, and survival, but rarely dive deep enough to fully realize their potential. Even “Paper Planes,” focussed on its critique of immigrant stereotypes, feels more impactful for its delivery than its depth. M.I.A. gestures toward global issues, but her voice—playful, defiant, hypnotic—often carries more weight than the words themselves. Despite these flaws, Kala endures because of its audacity. M.I.A.’s vision is fearless, her sound unpredictable, and her energy undeniable. This album is a global manifesto, pulsing with life and defiance. ⚬ Did/Do I own this release? It lives on an old iPod in my drawer. ⚬ Does this release belong on the list? Yes. This album was impossible to avoid for years, and even established artists tried to ape its sound. ⚬ Would this release make my personal list? You know what, yes. ⚬ Will I be listening to it again? In the right mood, this is an undeniable banger.
Really, truly bad. The one hit song is nostalgic for me but the rest is quite dull and laborious to get through
This album reminds me of a very specific time in my life. I'd just moved to Korea as a student and had somehow ended up DJing in a bar semi-regularly. I'd managed to get hold of an early release of this album and Paper Planes, so it got a lot of play at that time. I remember the excitement of that time in my life and how much everyone vibed on that song in particular. It was cool, the album is cool.
timbaland drops an all-time worst guest verse on the last song
Annoying noise. Not for me.
After the first track I was fully prepared to write this off as a cacophonous disaster. But MIA takes a pretty refreshing approach to nabbing music from Africa, the Middle East and the Indian subcontinent, which is great. What's less great is the massive throbbing bass around the 50-70hz mark. It's overcooked, and really drives the fatigue factor. Now, I love me some sub bass. My speakers can handle 50hz with little trouble, but subbass should really be there as a feeling, not a focus. Perhaps of she dialled it back a bit, this would be a higher rating because I like what she's trying to do.
I liked this - electic mix of rap, with international tones - Indian, African, British - cool album
Poppy Indian - British hip-hop
Cool
Started off terrible and thought it was heading for a one start rating but got a bit better mid way through. A couple of passable tracks
I knew I really liked the singles, but I had forgotten how good the album as a whole is.
Hard one to judge on a single listen. I have a good feeling that it's going to get more listens from me though. Fairly unique sounds, reminds me of early albums from The Streets
Not my vibe
Favourite tracks: paper planes
**Not a bad album, but not good either. Many tracks with just sounds/noises.
Paper Planes is good. The rest.. not so much. Can't stand it.
Why do I know this album? Oh ya Paper Planes the rest is forgettable.
Pretty good, felt more varied than Arular. Whenever there’s a mega hit on an album it jars me, there was no flow or pomp just BAM, Paper planes like a brick through a window
I thought this was interesting and well made but boy am I not the target audience for it. Stand-out: Jimmy
One song cannot save an album. But can make it a 2. Shout out to Mark Canha’s walk up song.
Kinda dig it. Not usually my bag, but this kinda did it for me.
Credit for originality - she is her own genre.
Definitely very experimental and abrasive and subjectively I think her début was better. However, I enjoyed a good few of the songs. ‘Paper Planes’ is by far the highlight.
Mais isso atingiu altas doses de chatura.
Terrible. Just noise for most of it. I feel justified being like the only person I knew who didn't like Paper Planes back in the day.
cool but a bit forgettable
Frenetic and unique production. Not something I’d sink into often but there’s some interesting textures going on. The songs that give me a more south Asian inspired vibe I like a lot (Jimmy). Lyrical content is on the whole pretty stupid and I would say is one of the weaker parts of the album - Missy or Nicki she is not.
A lot of this album sounds like it was made by a child. Occasionally some cool use of samples. '20 Dollar' was catchy. 'Paper Planes' was catchy. I hope I gave it a fair shot; I’m not sure I did. But even the catchy songs are self-important, image-obsessed, and arduously humorlessly political. This album came out a year after Kevin Federline’s similarly funk carioca influenced ‘PopoZão’.
I usually like music like this, but I found I preferred the samples to the interpolations. Verses felt a little too long. Paper Planes was the only one I really wanted to hit "repeat" on. 2.5 stars?
There's some songs that are interesting or vibey, but most of the songs are a miss for me. I'm holding out final judgement for the album after Paper Planes, but my opinion is low before we even get there. Okay, yeah. Paper Planes is still as good as it was when it came out. The rest of the album, though, ranges from bad to meh. The album never really feels cohesive, some of the instrumentation and style choices were interesting, but that was kind of it. Favorite Song(s): Paper Planes
I only knew the massive hit single from this album, so had no idea how great the beats and vibe were in the rest of the record. Really catchy and made commuting a little less terrible.
Different, but not great outside of a few
This is a Bamboo Banga. What a glow up from M.I.A.'s first album, which I enjoyed but didn't love. This one is loud, confident, full of crazy beats and sounds, and is just a kickass album through and through. Of course Paper Planes and Boyz are well known, but I liked the opener a lot, as well as 20 Dollar. This album is fully imbued with her Sri Lankan sound, which is cool for me.
Chaotic explosion of different sounds and genres from across the world, for someone less talented then M.I.A. this would have been a trainwreck, however the result of this album is something which is as equally accessible as it is experimental. 2000s hip-hop was starting to get stale midway through the decade, this helped revitalise it. It is definitely ahead of it's time, a lot of the hip-hop from the 10s and even hyperpop from this decade can trace it's roots back to M.I.A.'s 2000s output.
Not really my thing
I suppose they do what they do well, just not for me. 1
This didn’t help my hangover. Too much going on. Maybe I need to go and have a lie down in a dark room and give it another listen later.
There's a lot going on on this record. Maybe too much for just one listen, lots of world beats, rap and dance. So it will have to be based on first impressions, it wasn't dreadful, offensive or abrasive. Maybe if I have more time I'll give it another go just for curiosity's sake, as there was potential. So I'll give it 2 stars first starters.
Грустно, что из-за ее политики, постепенно эта очень влиятельная дама выпадает из дискуссии и вообще творчества. Этот альбом видится мне большим прорывом, благодаря которому существует миллион любимых артистов. Лучшая песня - Paper Planes.
3.5☆/5 10.22.2024
I was familiar with this one at a high level. "Paper Planes" was and is still on regular rotation on the radio. I dig her voice and you can feel her attitude, strength and message in her delivery. I can't say I enjoyed the opening handful of tracks, "Bamboo Banga", "BirdFlu", "Boyz", the repetition & incessant percussion were grating. "Jimmy" offers a view of what she's capable of doing, mixing sounds from her homeland and making a catchy song. "Hussel" and "Mango..." are a mess and sound like they were created in a rush. I was excited to revisit this one after 10+ years but I didn't enjoy the vast majority of it. Her limited talent is evident and on full display. This doesn't deserve a Top 1001 spot at all, it's annoyingly repetitive, doesn't stand the test of time, has insignificant influence on music that followed it, has only one song that anyone knows and sounds like an indie release that got lucky in 2007. One star maybe!
Drivel..like her last album
Paper Planes is undoubtedly a banger. But there's also a lot of incoherent screeching here. I imagine it's "not for me" in any case, and I have no beef with it being on the list as I remember it being super popular and talked about, but won't be returning to it.
Favorite Track: Paper Planes
Unique and highly bouncy in a highly disposable, fast-fashion sort of way, even if this meant to be the last word in DIY grittiness. One digs the artiness and free-flowing spirit here better than say the pretentious St. Vincent or silly Lady Gaga. Still, not exactly one's cup of chai, musically, but hard not to admire the energy and orginality, and one is just sympathetic go get why kids would like, especially a song like "Jimmy" which woulda been a hit in any era. But "20 Dolllar" is not only not twice as good as "10 Dollar" from Arular (the better record, reallly), it may not be half as good. Still, as fully globalized pop, it's hard to see this as much more than ephemera or as fully worthy of a spot on this list.
Probably the best Sri Lankan Artist ever… Paper planes blew up deservedly and a couple other cool tracks but overall not enough for me for an album.
This is my 100th album. Thank you for the headache and also recommending me 99 albums before I had to suffer through this one.
Great album, lots of world music styles! Really excellent
I dont even enjoy the good M.I.A. songs. I really struggled to find something good here but found next to nothing. World Town is a prime example, loud and annoying in all the wrong places and painfully monotone. However I'll give them this, its a pretty varied album in terms of sound, it just fell flat and annoying to me.
Inventive, original, irritating. When this album dropped there was nothing that sounded like it. And maybe for good reason. The sounds she chooses for this album are often grating and annoying. But Paper Planes, Come Around and the song with the rapping kids are all pretty great tracks. Also obligatory “MIA is a nut case now so good for her”
Another one I’m not quite sure about and can’t decide if I liked it or not. The initial attack on the senses calmed down a bit and I found myself enjoying it more the longer it went on. Still not sure if it’s good or not though so going for a middle of the road rating.
shit!
Really good alternative music but it is still experimental so a little hard to get into
Kala is great but the previous album, Arular is a superior album in my opinion. I wore both of these albums out when they were released yet they still hold up after old these years. The beat production was like nothing I had heard, sure there’s elements of music from around the world but the creative exploration displayed was unique to M.I.A. This was a period when artists like M.I.A., Major Lazer and Santigold were pushing the bounds of independent music production, a very inspirational time indeed.
A bit of nostalgia with the song Paper Planes, which is the best song on this album. The rest of the album is ok, but seems somewhat immature. She's a grinder, though, and she has had well deserved success. I'll throw a 3.5 at this one.
Sometime in the hazy days of my twenties, I was somehow at a house party in the Old Fourth Ward where I didn't know anybody. Maybe I knew someone, but they left early?? I don't quite remember, but that's how things were in my twenties. Anyways, they had a DJ who was infatuated with M.I.A. and mostly just played her first album in its entirety and throwing in a song inbetween in an effort to be a "real" DJ and have an excuse to bring two turntables. After his set, I spoke with him and all he wanted to talk about was M.I.A. Years later, I heard "Paper Planes" on Album 88/WRAS 88.5 and loved it, but didn't know who it was until I heard it again while watching Slumdog Millionaire. I didn't waste time in picking up Kala. My wife (girlfriend at the time) saw the cover and thought it was some cheap basement BS and even laughed when "Bamboo Banga" first started, but we have since fallen in love with this album. The rhythmic yells and tongue rolls of children on "Birdflu" and the hanina-na-ninna-ninna, ha-na-ninna-na-ninna chanting on "Boyz" is so refreshingly unexpected in it's sophisticated synchopation, not to mention the complex rhythms and layers of drums in the hand drum ensemble (which came at a time when I was active in and studying West African hand-drumming from Guinea). Once the Bollywood samples on "Jimmy" and the Australian aboriginal children off-time rapping on "Mango Pickle Down River" kick in, we see Kala as a hip-hop interpretation of world music. It's a celebration of and collaboration with the variety of sounds that make up the global human experience. "Represent the World Town" indeed. For her part, M.I.A. plays with phrasing that wouldn't work in traditional rap, adding an extra bar or a couple beats, or singing a free-form version of the Pixies' "Where Is My Mind?" on "20 Dollar" which ignores the trappings of needing to stay on the beat. It still works; she knows what she's doing. It's a party, and everyone is invited.
I enjoyed this. I'd heard most of this album before, but not in a long while. I feel like this sonically captures the essence of modern youth culture of London, where South Asians, West Indians, Africans and more all grow up together. It's a well-produced, creative blend of kaleidoscopic global influences, but the rapping delivery reminds me of a yobbish teenager writing lyrics in a notebook and performing it for her mates after school, which helps keeps it feeling more immediate and not overly slick.
This one made me a bit nostalgic. Being from Trinidad and with Trinidad's population being about 40 percent of people of Indian descent (dot not feather) I grew up watching shows called Mastana Bahar and Indian Talent on Review. We also got a decent amount of Bollywood movies on TV and certain radio stations would play music in Hindi. As a child I took an interest in listening to Indian music even though I could not understand Hindi, and I always liked the sounds and rhythms. The sampling of Sri Lankan music on this album reminds me of those days. She presents a unique sound with combining what I am going to guess are Bangra and Chutney rhythms mixed with hip hop and electronic dance music. I think she is innovative and original. If M.I.A has not already done it, I think there is probably a collaboration with Santigold that should probably happen.
A bit messy, not really my thing tbh but can appreciate it, Paper Planes is obviously a massive tune and didn’t realise til a good while after that it sampled The Clash
Fun pomo stuff: an original blend of big boomy beats, hipster interpolations, slacker rapping, sewn together sound collage production and revolutionary posturing. Paper planes is A+ the rest more of a B/B+...
This was one I somehow missed when I was younger. I had heard "Paper Planes" but that might actually be one of the ones I enjoyed less on the album. I guess that explains why I never sought out more of her music. I thought this was a very fun album. Would be a great album to have on in the background at the right party. There are some songs I REALLY enjoy on here but overall feels a bit more like a strong like than a love.
gods have forsaken us
Very much not my normal taste and I was only aware of Paper Planes before, but I thought this was fantastic Maybe it was the smattering of rock samples littered throughout but this was great from beginning to end
Versión rara de Where is my mind ... Y Paper planes me sonaba ....
Banger
Pretty tight. M.I.A. And daft punk should make an album
Well, that was unique. I now understand M.I.A.s appeal is her production, not her lyrics. She's actually quite talented.
Artistically, this album was densely packed with vibrant and interesting sounds that really makes it stand out. The Indian samples were also a cool touch that added flavor and depth to the tracks. With it being diverse it definitely requires an acquired taste since I can see how many people would put this off since it sounds so different. With that being said I personally don't see myself listening to this album religiously but a few of these songs are definitely going in the playlist. Top 3 Fav: Come Around, Paper Planes, and Boyz Top 3 Worst: no bad songs 3.25/5
The only low point on this album is Paper Airplanes and that's only because it was overplayed to death and back when it came out. Overall Killer album
So I recognized Paper Planes, but even the recollection of the song as a popular single wasn’t enough to connect with. A lot of the experimental soundscapes seemed like different instruments that couldn’t improve upon a boring composition. The lyrics were forgettable and the delivery wasn’t great. 2/5.
I thought I was going to vibe with this a lot more than I did. It was just okay. 3/5
I didn't have a particularly positive feeling for this album across the first few tracks, I thought it was overly percussive in an irritating way, but I was surprised to hear distinctive indigenous Australian singing voices on Mango Pickle Down River - none other than The Wilcannia Mob, who I'm familiar with. This led me to read a bit more about M.I.A. and how Kala came together, earning an additional review star out of respect.
Irrésistible et irrévérencieux, transpire de confiance et d'effronterie tout en étant super dansant
Paper Planes is an all time lighting in the bottle hit.
Paper Planes was the only song from this album coming in, and it still slaps. I found the rest of the album to be enjoyable as well, maybe not always at the same standard and a few songs dropped the ball. Overall though, I enjoyed this album and was bopping along most of the time.
Not every track is great, but I'd say it still holds up well.
Awful.
It's like listening to the world's most aggressively British marching band, but the musicians are all on ecstacy and playing Casio keyboards for children.
2007... let that sink in. Ver voordat experimental hip hop merchants als Danny Brown, JPEG, Death Grips of BROCKHAMPTON zich op de markt gingen begeven, kwam M.I.A. met deze cocktail van rap, dancehall, techno, industrial, en allerlei exotische stijlen. En het alle mafste; het komt uit het brein van een Britse vrouw met Sri Lankese roots. Die demografische en geografische isolatie laat de stamboom der hip hop op haar grondvesten schudden. Uit puur evolutionair oogpunt kun je haar ontwikkeling zien als een vorm van 'spontaneous generation', ofwel 'the hypothetical process by which living organisms develop from nonliving matter'. Zo voelt het een beetje. Er valt moeilijk een vader of moeder van haar stijl aan te wijzen. En eerlijk, ik heb sinds haar ook weinig muziek gehoord wat te bestempelen valt als haar nakomeling. Een zonderling, in de positieve zin van het woord. Wat een gewaagd album, gezien de tijd en plaats van release. Er gebeurt zoveel dat het moeilijk is om dit laag voor laag te analyseren. Het begint direct met een explosie genaamd 'Bamboo Banga', een excentrieke dance rap song die toewerkt naar een climax waar je niet stil bij kan blijven zitten. Haar gevoel voor timing is waanzinnig. Ze liegt niet, het is een absolute 'banga'. Maar zoals bij meerdere nummers op deze plaat moet je jezelf ook vaak afvragen of het niet de meest schunnige/platte muziek is die je ooit hebt gehoord, of dat het briljant is in al zijn eigenaardigheid. Het gaat vaak bijna over de top, en balanceert constant heel knap op dat randje. Bij het tweede nummer 'BirdFlu' gaat ze er duidelijk overheen, alsof je je als luisteraar bevindt in een volière in Artis. Maar dat houdt het zonder meer interessant. Het zal de Nederlandse luisteraar dan ook niet heel erg verbazen dat een later album van haar is geproduceerd door The Partysquad, want dat 'foute' dance tintje hoor je hier ook al wel terug. Neem ook zo'n nummer als 'Jimmy'. Ik heb nog nooit iets gehoord wat ook maar een beetje die stijl benaderd. De quirky Boney M.-achtige break, de schele coupletjes, en de Italian disco piepjes en ploepjes.. Je weet eigenlijk niet goed wat je er mee aan moet. Maar aan het einde van de rit heb ik - zoals met het merendeel van de songs - zonder meer behoefte om ze nog eens te beluisteren. Ik hou van muziek die je brein kietelt, en dat doet ze fantastisch. En de songs hebben altijd nog net genoeg structuur om je bij een eerste luisterbeurt aan vast te klampen. '20 Dollar' is zo'n ander voorbeeld van haar lef en durf, en is zo progressief dat veel pop artiesten van vandaag zich er niet aan durven te wagen. En gewoon even 'Where Is My Mind?' interpoleren in het refrein, props. 17 jaar oud dit album, ongekend. Maar natuurlijk is 'Paper Planes' dé eyecatcher van deze plaat. Het nummer dat M.I.A. ondanks haar extravagante aanpak - waardoor ze zich allerminst in de mainstream bevindt - in één klap wereldfaam zag pakken. Ook hier liet ze weer zien dat je je als hip hop artiest niet hoeft te limiteren aan soul, jazz en funk samples, maar dat ook alternatieve rock een uitstekende bron kan zijn. Dit nummer zou ook altijd 'ahead of the curve' zijn, een curve waarvan je je af kan vragen of hij überhaupt ooit nog komt. En ik wil guns absoluut niet romantiseren, maar wat klinken die schoten in het refrein altijd lekker. Wat een trip is ''Kala'', een bumpy ride. Hier en daar is het me iets te hobbelig, en wordt het bijna ongemakkelijk, maar zeker driekwart van de songs ga ik vaker bij terugkomen. De aantrekkingskracht is enorm. Haar latere albums (vooral de eerstopvolgende) begeven zich vaak in nog wat gewaagder territorium, waardoor ze altijd een 'lastige' artiest is. Maar haar ethos vind ik fascinerend; dat ze na het scoren van een wereldhit in 'Paper Planes' doodleuk een avant-garde en industrieel monster van een plaat (Maya) maakt. Een 'pop' artiest naar m'n hart, en precies het tegenovergestelde van een Taylor Swift, wat dat betreft. 8,5/10 Highlights: Bamboo Banga Jimmy 20 Dollar Paper Planes
Super vet. Plaat als geheel nog nooit eerder zo gehoord. Nummers zitten boordevol gekke geluiden, crazy beats, stemmen en vreemde momenten. Mango Pickle Down River is heerlijk rustig nummertje met mellow beat, maar ook met een spacende didgeridoo en een soort groepje kinderen wat half kletsend, half rappend het nummer bij elkaar raapt. Het pistoolschot en de rinkelende kassa in Paper Planes zijn net zulke geniale vondsten om een beat mee samen te stellen. Daarnaast zitten de nummer vol met wereldse invloeden. Bollywood samples, Afrikaanse folk muziek en funk carioca (braziliaanse funk, moest ik opzoeken). Zo maakt M.I.A. een plaat die met zeer weinig te vergelijken is. En my god, hoe lekker is het gebruik van een stuk uit Where Is My Mind in '20 Dollar'? Altijd al fan geweest van Paper Planes, en weleens meer geluisterd van M.I.A., maar mezelf nog nooit eerder gewaagd een heel album. Dat is jammer... want ik ben fan. 8/10 Highlights Mango Pickle Down River 20 dollar Paper Planes
Big hit single when it came out, great for its time, but now sounds boring almost a decade later. Others do Asian influenced pop better (Talvin Singh, Asian Dub Foundation etc). This is mid.
I was shocked this was on the list. It's ok, I didn't mind it in the background, but wouldn't go back and listen more. There were some high spots - I liked the little kids rapping that was cool to see, and some of the themes were interesting just because they are so foreign to me here in the US.
Okay now THIS is a bop man, some of Kalas songs really just get you to move, very reggae recession funk, maybe even with some 80s Russian funk thrown in there. Im sitting here just jamming, rocking my head, only about half way through. Not surprised this album is so funky with the likes of Diplo and Timbaland producing the album. Some of the songs use some very unique instruments as well, I believe i here a didgeridoo in Mango Pickle Down River. After finishing the album, yeah, this is a good one, not every song is amazing, but the ones that are slap, i mean Paper Planes alone has almost 1 billion streams on spotify, that song was HUGE in the late 2000s. Fav Song: Jimmy (honorable mention is Paper Planes of course) 3.5
Welcome back, Alex. We're in a tough stretch of albums right now, this one included. Some times I wish I knew the criteria to be on this list or is it just a random pull? Whatever. This album really didn't do much for me as the dance/electronica genre is mostly annoying to this listener. But man, I loved the song Paper Planes. Immediately added to my list of favorites songs from this site. Great tune. Jimmy and Come Around were decent enough, but the rest was, well, not very good. Going with a 2.5 for Paper Planes. Not rounding up. Looking for the next big "surprise" album. Hopefully something this week. 2.5
2.5 I’m writing this review with intense COVID brain, so apologies for any incoherency. Anyway, everyone knows Paper Planes is a certified classic, but I didn’t realize that M.I.A. had more to her credit than that. I guess this was a pretty critically acclaimed release though, with professional music critic/asshole Robert Christgau - a dude whose opinions seem to be on the Wikipedia page of quite possibly every album we’ve seen so far - even calling it the best album of the 21st century. Yeah, not hearing that. I’ll certainly give the album credit for its unique beats, a lot which seem to have taken influence from the local music of various Eastern countries (African and South Asian especially), but the end result for me basically teeters back and forth between “decent” and “the most annoying thing I’ve ever heard in my life”. There’s definitely a certain charm to the music, especially as things kick off with Bamboo Banga, but it’s run pretty thin by somewhere around the time M.I.A. starts asking where you were in ‘92 (I was -5). Her take on Pixies with 20 Dollar is somewhat novel and something I have to touch upon as a fan, but it’s totally easy to miss - I didn’t even pick up on it until three or four listens in. Fortunately, this thing is largely saved by Paper Planes. It’s an absolutely great pop track by all accounts, and while The Clash certainly deserve credit for it’s foundation, I can’t deny how great of a job M.I.A. did of building upon it (though Straight to Hell is also a certifiable banger). On paper, the gunshots and cash register sound effects feel like they should come off as corny, but the whole thing is so damn catchy that you can’t help but want to send your finger to the air in time with the bullets. Needless to say, far and away the highlight of the album, and its end placement almost feels genius in the sense that it gives you something to look forward to. With one great song, a handful of decent ones, and quite a few stinkers, I think I’m going to land in the middle with my album rating here. I don’t know if she ever went on to do much after this, but I do know she torpedoed her career a bit with anti-vax rhetoric and a Donald Trump endorsement, so I’m not overly eager to check it out.
I immensely dislike Hip Hop. I don't know if this is good or bad but I just can't get through it as much as I try.
I didn’t drink the M.I.A. Kool Aid in 2007 and I ain’t drinking it now.
not as bad as I expected. electronica + hip hop + Hiphopnica
Ningún interés. Mezcla de??
A little too experimental for my tastes, trying to sound unpleasant for a lot of it. Paper Planes is the only one that’s listenable, but it’s more suited for background on commercials or TikToks than actual listening
This album already gets points for me for paper planes. This came out and got really big when I was around 18, and was a huge club anthem at the time. Then there are all the little nods to other songs and artists I love -- Iron Maiden on the cover, Modern Lovers, the Pixies, the Clash... probably more that that I didn't pick up on the first listen. Then it's just kind of a cool album, very experimental, the samples are cool, I like her vocals. This one won me over.
Es entretenido! Aunque un poco largo y tuve que esperar mucho para escuchar Paper Planes.
m.i.a. is insane now just like everybody else but this still holds up
Extremely unique album. A mix of so many different styles. Something a bit electronic vibes, but oldsh style, some part almost a bit folkish , a lot of influence from pop, a lot of rap.
Truly a masterpiece
Album 1 Star Paper planes 1 Stars
I’ve heard of M.I.A. before as a rapper/singer/producer, born under the name Mathangi "Maya" Arulpragasam. In fact, Maya’s big song “Paper Planes” is off of this album Kala. This is her second studio album, named and themed after her mother and the struggles she went through. I will say this album is very experimental, for better and worse. She plays through a variety of world music styles with a heavy amount of sampling, and the result varies for every song. Some songs are good - the aforementioned “Paper Planes” with the samples of gunshots, cash registers and The Clash’s “Straight to Hell”, “Come Around” with its sole Timbaland production credit, “Jimmy” with its electronic disco melody, and “XR2” with its rave music groove. Other songs are terrible - the first three tracks of this album spring to mind, especially “Bird Flu” with its egregious bird noise samples. Then there are songs that fall somewhere in the middle for me - “Hussel” and “Mango Pickle Down River” have solid melodies, though nowhere near as engaging as the preceding “Jimmy”. Also, I couldn’t ignore how “20 Dollar” sounded like an electronically-filtered hodgepodge between New Order’s “Blue Monday” and the Pixies’ “Where is My Mind?”. There is one unifying element throughout this album - Maya’s vocals. I’ll admit, I do not like her vocals and delivery - it’s not for me as it doesn’t come off as raw or emotionally drawn as it should. Not helping matters is that she has a very minimalist lyrical style, which combined with the experimentation can distract from whatever messaging she may have been trying to convey. At the end of the day, it’s certainly not a boring album. You will be engaged through the whole listen, regardless of track-by-track quality. But I don’t see myself returning to this anytime soon.
Did this thing just open with a Modern Lovers reference. This thing rules so much. It’s sonically varied and interesting and catchy and chaotic in all the best ways. I don’t know if I would have had the song with Australian kids rapping, but, hey I dunno. Jimmy is one of the craziest songs ever. When those 70s disco strings came in a fucking cheered.
This really was not for me
Interesting album. Very ambitious in style, but some of the songs are a little too scattered. When it works, it really works. 3/5 Probably will listen again
This is a sonically dense and textured albums. So many new and interesting sounds, samples, references, and interpolations of other songs and styles just come out of nowhere but it's all united by M.I.A.'s creativity and politics. Also, THAT FUCKIN Groove.
I prefer AIM, but this album is still very good
4/5. A shock of sound threw me off at first but each song stands alone as a testament to mixing pop and electronic to multiple different cultural styles while still sounding fresh and new just as if it came out today, not that it's very old. I enjoyed this album more than I thought I would on the first song but it really grew on me, once I got the energy it was giving. This is going to be a repeat listen for sure and probably bump up to a 5 from what I'm feeling but right now it is a 4 cause some songs didn't land fully. Still great though! Best Song: Paper Planes, Bird Flu, Boyz
A lot of interesting sounds and samples but the songs take so much time to develop they end up being too long.
Hrm. OK, see, here's the thing: ARULAR was obnoxious. Incredibly so. That's what my review on this website of the album was about, and thinking back, it's really the only thing I can remember (besides "g'lang-a-lang-alang"). Despite that, however, I never found myself crossing over into annoyance at it. For sure, I got close a few times, but at the end of the day, I kind of just recognized that this was thing and I hadda accept it. KALA ended up being a different story. On the whole, I actually found it a whole lot less obnoxious than ARULAR. Although, as a result... I was kind of bored by the whole experience? Perhaps it's because M.I.A.'s whole "world music dance hall," "nasal monotone voice" thing isn't as shocking as it was the first time? Honestly, as much as I know I should, I can't muster up enough of a hoot to actually check. Hell, I don't even care enough to interrogate the thought I kept having throughout that it felt like big critics go gaga over this kind of music specifically because it's obnoxious on purpose (I **really** can't see what Robert Christgeau saw in this). Frankly, the only song I really paid any attention to was the big single, "Paper Planes", and that's just because, instrumentally, it remindedme of Post Malone's "Sunflower". And maybe I recognized a vocal performance from a mashup? But otherwise... Like, y'know, some part of me wants to be generous and give this thing the same 3 I gave ARULAR. M.I.A. doesn't **deserve** that kind of generosity, but that's besides the point. I could slap it with a "maybe it'd go off better in the club" and use that as the justification, 'cuz I really don't hear how it's any better or worse than ARULAR. But let's not underesimate how damn uninterested I was in this album. I hear this kind of beat work on the last album, I heard these nasally monotone vocals on the last album... For sure, there's something about this album that I'm missing. Something in its conception, or just some "media literacy" intepretation that'd make me like it a lot more. I just really don't care, though. Lemme jus' cross this shit off with a 2 and never hafta think about this damn anti-vaxxer ever again.
Despite more recent controversial comments, this album is still pretty damn good, and a definite step up for Arular. 4.5 down to 4.
I’m only at a 3, which is kinda disappointing. I don’t think it’s a bad album; I’d recommend it, honestly. It just never really clicked for me as a fully cohesive one from front to back. I think there’s a lot of repetition here, but it’s really supplemented by an energetic vocal performance and a lot of great production tricks. However, sometimes those production tricks either didn’t hit as well on a few tracks, or became an outright hindrance with some awkward mixing between the percussion and the vocals or the synths that felt just out of balance enough to be distracting. I think I liked this album better when it was more focused on being a sort of pseudo-dance record; the heavier beats, the deeper percussion mixed closer to the ears, and the vocals that had just enough processing to blend in without feeling too overdone, and that’s about half of the album. In other words, I liked the songs that feel distinctly modern and about 7 years ahead of schedule for 2007 – super experimental stuff for the time that feels very common now. The other half ranges from “just not really doing it for me” to outright bad on “Hussel” (just REALLY flat for me) and “20 Dollar” (extremely overdone production, and I really did not like the “Where Is My Mind?” interpolation, even though I’m normally a sucker for that sort of thing). When the album hits, it hits really well – Bamboo Banga is a good (if slightly long) opener, Boyz feels like a great sports hype up track, Paper Planes is an all-timer, and XR2 is a perfect 90s club throwback. For me, it just only hits about half the time, and that’s why I’m at a 3. For someone else, I can hear how it might be a 4 or even a 5, but for my tastes, it just never got up there. Very solid 3 though.
Very enjoyable album that has a few sections reminiscent of 1982ish Kate Bush and of Eno/Byrne's My Life in the Bush of Ghosts.
Der Sound ist fett, cool und anders. Rhythmisch und kompositorisch mal was anderes, obwohl klar Pop. Die Lieder sind aber zueinander recht ähnlich. 2,8
One of the very few things this list does is expose you to music you're not familiar with (extra emphasis on 80s and 90s Britpop). Some things you hear and check it off your list knowing you'll never hear it again. I've been familiar with M.I.A. since she exploded with Kala. I haven't listened to her until now and wow. A sonic, multi-layered eargasm that is not something I would voluntarily listen to, but mission accomplished with this entry - I'm glad I listened to it and will add it to my que's. 4.5/5
I didn't make it very far into this one. I remember Paper Planes being a big single at the time and the rest sounds like what I would expect the rest of the album to sounds like. Not really my thing. Also not really anything special.
It's a banger. I first listened to this album back in like 8th grade a ton, still sounds cool and fresh today, and you can see a bunch of influences play out.
Toni Basil's granddaughter does D&D
This album came out of nowhere! There is a real global journey feeling going on. It's raw, energetic, and full of surprises. The beats hit hard but remain playful, almost like a soundtrack for a chaotic, vibrant city. There’s a mix of rebellion and joy in every track. The soundscape is wild yet grounded. It really started to grow on me.
Fun, “Paper Planes” +1, shallow
2.5/5⭐️ Paper Planes is a banger, Pixies cover is shit, rest is super mediocre/forgettable. And why are all these songs so long?
Wow that was irritating as hell..
One really good tune (Paper Planes). The rest seemed to have some small degree of undeveloped promise and are well, just annoying after 30 seconds. One star.
That was a lot of work to get to the Paper Planes song. Everything else on this album blurs together into noise soup. Paper Planes is still great.
My two least favorite genres are world and hip hop. And this is hip-hop that samples more world music than anything else. Paper Planes has some parts of it that are sort of listenable (I can see why it's a popular single at least) but this is not for me and I hated most of it.
Yeah that was pretty good. I should have assumed it was decent because the rest of the comments were so negative. 3.16
Hip hop with an African feel. I didn’t like her previous album and I didn’t like this one either. I think it’s just not my style of music. I don’t think it’s bad, I just don’t like it.
Each song is repetitive and unlistenable. I guess you'd have to be in a dance club and on a lot of drugs to like this music. One positive is that each song is unique...but I can't handle this. Paper Planes is ok, but if you like this, listen to the original, Straight To Hell by The Clash. It's so much better.
i just love MIA and wish she would come back with stuff like this - such a creative and unique album that oftentimes has little to no melody outside of her voice yet still hits with meaningful and intentional lyricism calling out international affairs.
I really wanted to like this more than I did, this was incredibly innovative at the time it came in regard to the sound and particularly the attitude, and the plethora of other things that were fresh and new about MIA and the music she was making. Some of these songs are really great like the opening track there are definitely some bangers here but overall I don't think she truly understood the ways in which she was pushing the envelope. That opinion is largely influenced by how her career has gone since this time as well. Ultimately I think she sort of accidentally stumbled onto a massive and innovative sound that informed a decade or more of pop music to follow, and I think I love the music that she influenced a lot more than her music itself. That being said though the miserable old fucks on here that only wanna hear the same 50 blues-based white guy artists can get fucked she's getting a perfect score
Mango Pickle Down River! I liked that a lot.
I mean I'm not sure you can get much cooler, in terms of the image she's developed here. For whatever that's worth. Not sure how many of her collaborators have actually "never seen a map" haha. But yeah super catchy. Super different. At least among mainstream options here in the United States. She also just has fun musicality and I like her melodies. mOnD0 ExTra bonUs points for the Pixies and Clash references 😍
Never heard anything from her, except Paper Planes, and i wish i never had
Was pleasantly surprised. The album was much more than just their hit Paper Planes. The album has such a distinct and fun sound. In some ways it is very reminiscent of the early 2000’s and in others it feels quite fresh.
I did not enjoy this at all. Even back when this released, I never understood the appeal nor the praise it garnered.
M.I.A. used to go hard af. cool album but a bit too dense. Additional star for paper planes.
fan vad det här är tråkigt. paperplanes är ju bra men inte tillräckligt bra för att rädda upp den här skiten.
All I wanna do is *bang bang bang* and *cash register sound* and a tell people that their covid vaccine has a 5g chip. Paper planes slaps everything else involved does not
Horrible!!
Oh Jesus. My first association... PAPER PLANES. Turned from a dancefloor favourite to an annoyance. Also, hasn't she turned into a bit of a conspiracy nutjob lately? Anyway, on to the music. Phew. I appreciate the layers expertly laid on top of each other and all sort of making some sense. Nothing here is a coincidence. You can also hear loads of influences. First two that come to my mind have a connection, even - Tom Tom Club and My Life In the Bush of Ghosts. The thing is: So many of the choices made are just so annoying to my ears. High-pitched repetitive samples. Give me a claustrophic feeling of being on some sort of trip without an off button, when I've only had a glass of beer. Which of course means there IS an off button to what I'm experiencing. Jimmy is weirdly annoyingly catchy in a way that might make me want to come back to it in the same way I sometimes need a dose of Gwen Stefani's Watcha Waiting for. But by and large, I never want to listen to this album again.
Can admire the ambition here, wide range of influences. Ultimately though I just didn't enjoy it.
There are certainly better albums from the 2000s, but this one FEELS so much like the era in terms of living in a neoliberal, post-globalization world. The speed in which the exchange of currency occurs, which has led to a rapid exchange of culture, language, and perspectives, is so well-captured on 'Kala,' the second album from Sri Lankan rapper M.I.A. from 2007. A real murderers' row of producers, including Diplo and Timbaland, who would help usher in sounds from every stretch of the planet to create a real sonic constellation. The first side alone is almost unrelenting in its intensity. By the end of track two, you already have enough information to determine if you'd vibe with M.I.A.'s artistic vision. I know tons of people who take issue with her bratty vocal delivery. In my view, this tends to wonderfully match the nonsense words and sounds she offers ("na na na" on "Boyz," "a-nee-nee-nee" on "World Town"), which is a cross between school-girl taunting and pidgin English, the combination of such over layers of beats presents a totally interesting and important musical innovation. What does "bamboo banga" even mean? Does it even matter since it sounds so deliciously cool, especially since it takes over two minutes to get to the chorus? Other times, it's just plain nonsense ("live in trees, chew on feet, watch Lost on cable"). The first side of the record - really, the first four tracks - are really where the flavour is. "Bird Flu" is absolutely relentless in its intensity with its propulsive rhythms, acoustic percussions, trills and yelps from all sorts of voices from all sorts of ages. "Boyz" is like the world opening itself up to you after spending hours on an airplane and now you're confronted with a crush of people, cacophony of noise, and rush of colour. "Jimmy" would have to be one of my favourite tracks off the record with its Indo-neo-Disco hook and quivering yearning. The strings that come in at around 2:40 both mount tension but echo the kind of gasp-y shallow breathing M.I.A. would do at the final moment of the song in between sobs. Not to say the album is front-loaded, but there is a greater cohesion of sound after "Jimmy" and a slight dip in energy. But this brings us to "Paper Planes." I recall we all agreed that this was the Song of the Decade. A brilliant use of a Clash sample and another instance in which the words don't offer any particularly deep insight into the Immigrant Hustle, but that doesn't matter since the high levels of swagger and attitude mean any misstep is instantly cast aside. The pairing of gun shots and a cash register in order to make a link between violence and profit - not just in terms of individuals, but whole systems at play - is amazing. I saw a review on here that stated that everyone, immigrant or not, could relate to this song. We've all moments in our lives in which we're "sittin' on trains/every stop I get to, I'm clocking that game." We're lamenting the long commute that we have to embark to even START our work day and we're imagining a better life for ourselves where "everyone's a winner." "Come Around" may be the album's one skip, if only because it sounds the most convention and features a Timbaland verse that really didn't need to be there. M.I.A., on the other hand, is the sharpest she's sound on the record. Her ability to enunciate and add in those bratty flourishes at exactly the right moment as she imbues youth vernacular is one-of-a-kind ("Sidekick rings, 'what's up, holla!'/text the address, 'I'll see ya later!'). I liked 'MAYA' and 'Matangi' just fine, but 'Kala' is absolutely thrilling; it's all over the album art. You simply had to be there. A
Pretty fire
We let her get away with too much because of an accent and good production.
Ahead of its time. Packed with catchy alternative pop music in a time where most pop music had trouble standing out. (at least for me) *Heard before
Genuinely awful
- a star because she endorsed Trump
Paper planes is the only thing really worth it. Waste of time outside of that
I listened to this and forgot to rate. It’s cool to hear the fusion of hip hop and eastern sounds but overall not something I return to outside the 2-3 times of year I hear paper planes in public or on the radio. 2.5 rounded down because weirdo
Paper Planes was probably the only MIA song I knew before this album and though I enjoy that song and that vibe, the rest of the album just sounded like a lot of the same and just not as good.
Paper Planes, XR2, Boyz, and some of her older songs off Arular give the je ne sais quoi of late 2000s high school (Dansex) & early college (pimp plaza). However, I imagine if I weren't in this prime demographic when it was released, I'd find this album very abrasive.
Aside from Paper Planes and maybe 2 other songs, this entire album is garbage. truly annoying noises put over nonsensical lyrics. sounds like "thirteen year old's first time using fruity loops program" and feels even worse.
There is definitely a step up here from Arular to Kala. But at the same time, not all the songs are "Bangers". I mean, "Boyz" is one of the more insipid songs I have heard. Random thoughts: "20 Dollar"... I am still torn on this track. I like the vocalizations, but then I grew tired of them. I felt like I needed more off of it. "World Town" seemed like the anti-"Hollaback Girl". It took the vibe of that song and made it much more. "Come Around" was a pretty good ending for the album. It's interesting in that the randomizer had the two M.I.A. albums selected sequentially to listen to. I might have been more annoyed if they were separated far apart. But listening to them one right after the other you really hear her growth as an artist, and why this album is the one that stayed on the list. Top tracks: "Bamboo Banga," "Jimmy", "20 Dollar," "Paper Planes," "Come Around"
Well it finally happened. The list randomly chose two albums back to back from the same artist. Bad random generator! Easier to compare though. I didn't get drawn into this album as much as MIA's debut. The opener Bamboo Banga was so-so; felt like she was trying too hard to be catchy instead of being fiery in her lyrics and letting the music flow from it. As the album progressed I changed my tune slightly - lyrics still very clever, but the beats still didn't mesh as well as on her first album. Maybe she was trying to integrate too many different styles? Sampled too much? Definitely collaborated too much - I don't want to hear Afrikan Boy and Timbaland, I want to hear MIA. Probably too many people wanted a piece of her or wanted to be involved in this album after the success of her first album. Still a good album and this woman is still incredibly talented, I just didn't dig it as much as her first one. Paper Planes though, what a tune! I've always loved it. Other really pumping songs were World Town and Xr2.
Once again, the 1001 Editors removed an album by a modern artist in lieu of a more recent album. In this case, they removed her debut, Arular, and replaced it with this second album, Kala. I liked Arular more - it resonated with me more than this album and had a much harder edge, which I suppose is consistent with M.I.A.'s view that Arular was a more masculine album and Kala was more feminine (Arular named after her father and Kala named after her mother). On the plus side, I preferred the more organic drums on this album. And of course Paper Planes is super catchy (when I heard Arular I had no idea this was her song even though I'd heard it before). I'd probably give this album a 3.5. Since I went with a 4 for Arular, I feel like I should go with a 3 for this one (particularly for having auto-tune in 20 Dollar - auto-tune is almost always an automatic one point reduction for me - but the lyrics are powerful and MAYBE including lyrics from Where Is My Mind gets the point back?). I'll go with the 4 because I continue to dig her style. Favorite Tracks - Bird Flu (love the drums), Boyz, Mango Pickle Down River (fun song with a cool groove), Come Around (I could do without the Timbaland spot, but the rest is very cool).
Not as good as the first album but a banger.
Das Album versucht, eine einzigartige Mischung aus Techno, afrikanischen Klängen, ABBA-Beats und Hip-Hop zu präsentieren. Leider wirkt das Album insgesamt unrund und kann nicht wirklich überzeugen. Der einzige Lichtblick ist der Track “Jimmy”, der stark an ABBAs “Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!” erinnert und zumindest etwas Begeisterung weckt. Die restlichen Songs, wie “Mango Pickle Down River” und “World Town”, sind jedoch enttäuschend und erreichen nicht das gewünschte Niveau. Musikalisch bietet “Kala” eine interessante Vielfalt an Einflüssen, die jedoch oft nicht harmonisch zusammenfinden. Die Techno-Elemente wirken manchmal fehl am Platz, während die afrikanischen Rhythmen und Hip-Hop-Beats nicht immer gut integriert sind. Der Versuch, verschiedene Genres zu kombinieren, führt leider zu einem unausgewogenen Hörerlebnis.
This is so incredibly maximalist at points that I want to turn it off, but it's not exactly unenjoyable. There's some great biting cynicism and satire baked into the lyrics throughout the album, and I don't know of much else that sounded so punk in that way since Rage. All that said, I don't know that I would have listened to this again on purpose if I weren't participating in this project...
nothing horribly wrong, i'm just not very interested in that kinda music...
Not my favorite MIA album, but there are a few songs on here I really love.
Of it's time, although feels strangely contemporary in some ways due to it's easy international flavour which is the fashion now. Despite MIAs descent into lunacy, this is still largely a thrilling listen and Paper Planes is an all-timer
Just interesting enough for 2 stars or D+.
It feels like recently I got her other album. Did she need two albums on this list? I dunno... completely forgettable.
it’s cool just some of the songs aren’t fully there
Wasn’t as into this as I thought I would be. Paper Planes is great though
Wow, what an album. I don't think I've heard anything else remotely like that. The mix of so many genres and it not feeling laboured or forced is incredible. I always think the sign of a good album is when you feel like you've only been listening a few minutes but you've actually listened to the whole album. Added to my playlist and will be a regular listener.
I couldn't seem to vibe with this, apart from Jimmy and Paper Planes. Otherwise, I found the rhythms and vocal off-putting.
I knew I liked Paper Planes but hadn’t bothered to explore her music any further. What an idiot. Whilst there’s a clear debt to The Clash (and Adam and The Ants on Bird Flu) it was a joy to discover The Wilcannia Mob (and realise Die Antwoord had clearly had a dip in that river). Loved it all, immediately played it again and am pretty sure it’ll be on heavy rotation this summer.
Fresh and consistent. I enjoyed it. “Paper Planes” is of course fire.🔥
I liked it, it was a fun album.
I didn't have any preconceived notions about this record other than remembering the artist appearing with Madonna live on some telecast. (Looked it up, Super Bowl halftime, apparently kind of notorious because M.I.A. flipped the bird at one point.) I generally like dance music if it's inspired and interesting. This was definitely interesting! Her delivery can be a bit droll or mechanical at times, which reminded me of Grace Jones, actually. Interesting record. Glad to have ended up listening to it.
Like the various world rhythms & some of the samples. But somebody sing something.
Sweaty dance party Of bangers produced crisply With fun sounds and styles
Not MIAs best album but its the one with Paper Planes…
Way better than expected. I enjoyed her sound.
Once a culture darling/favourite. She rubs people up the wrong way but her musuc is different and interesting.
I liked the spaceman version of the pixies
This is amazing. M.I.A herself is good enough but what really shines on this album is the great production. These beats are so good, excellent stuff!
7/10. After two songs I was leaning a 3/10. Which emphasizes how unbalanced I thought the album was. Had some really good stuff (Hussell, Boyz, World Town, Paper Planes) and some horrible stuff (Bamboo Banga, 20 Dollar, XR2) for me. I think because I’m not big on the electronic pieces. What took it from 6 to 7 was that Jimmy and Mango Pickle Down River were fun and kept me engaged.
Started off hating this. Then I quite liked the Mango Pickle Down River. Then I continued hating this. The didgeridoo saved this from being a 1.
Bold to put your only banger as the last song on the album. Simpsons: No
Not sure an album could be much more unlistenable than this. At times the songs would give a hint of being something decent, but then just turn into absolute shit. Paper Planes is OK, the only coherent track on an album of random sounds.
I honestly thought I wad having some sort of fit listening to this. Not good at all I'm not even a fan of paper planes, which is the only one I knew
This is why I started doing this! I would have never thought to listen to M.I.A. if it wasn’t for this list and I’m absolutely vibing it. Such a different sound for me and I’m loving it. I knew Paper Planes and I think Boyz too but it’s all such a good sound and beat.
This is relentless shrill fucking noise. HARD PASS.
She's back. That gobby girl who you want to talk to, but you know she's smarter and tougher than you. The mix of hip-hop beats, electronic blasts, random sound effects, samples from around the world and bratty rapping are all present and correct as they always are on her albums. She's not doing anything different on this album as she does to other albums and I'm glad. Best Tracks: Bird Flu; World Town; Paper Planes
3.75
Nicht meine Richtung
è già il secondo suo che ascolto, comunque viene molto apprezzata dalla critica. Oh comunque bello. Con 'Paper planes' perla finale, 4.
3.5
Hey, this one has Paper Planes the song that's kinda good because it borrows from Straight To Hell. Otherwise this album is just as meh as the other M.I.A. album on this list. Please let there only be 2.
Bold and fully realised
Do people actually pay money to listen to this?
Extra star for how big of a hit Paper Planes was, but not a great record overall.
Best Song: Come Around. I'm just a sucker for that Timbaland influence. Worst Song: Mango Pickle Down River. Good for these kids getting featured on an album like this, but I'm really not interested in listening to this kids bop stuff. Overall: A fun and banging album that, thankfully, knows exactly what it is. No mid-album slow down breaks, no random ballads. Just upbeat, bombastic pop hop. Unfortunately, some of the chosen beats and samples miss the market, registering more as annoying than enjoyable.
Great album, been listening to it for years.
🚮 jimmy xr2
Ok
Paper Planes // Come Around 2.5/5
This album had the energy of a hyperactive toddler. At one point, bridge is rhymed with didge (as in didgeridoo) and I fucking love that. This was a lot of fun. 4 stars
Was just okay. Some beats are pretty good, but there's nothing here I must listen to again. 2/5
I've listened to this album some years back and I thought I liked it, but this time I found it kind of annoying. I'll be generous and give 3 cos at least it's not boring.
This is probably my favourite hip hop album so far... but still not something I'd want to listen to again.
M.I.A. walks a VERY fine line between annoying and intriguing. It sounds like something I should hate but her music just fascinates me.
I kept waiting for something to happen. Anything. A hint of melody. A variation in the beat. She travelled the world and this is what she came back with? She obviously didn’t hear any singers in hear journey.
Well that was a fun record, carried by a fresh voice in this sea of mostly anglo-saxon white men making music. An important record, would come back here again.
Really interesting stuff throughout, 20 dollar was cool , where is my mind reference
I want to like this, as a more abrasive Gorillaz, and there's a lot to admire. But it's hard work. Her voice is not that expressive, in a presumably deliberately monotone, and her DIY beats and samples don't often result in memorable moments. Having said all that, I may be too old to get it.
Obviously very cool and probably super innovative for its time, felt a tiny bit repetitive at times but I think I just need to listen to it in the right setting
Not for me
Second album of hers I've had. I had heard Paper Planes before. It's interesting. She's Sri Lankan and mixes world music with hip hop and electronica. So it's like a world trip hop fusion. Its not bad at all. Favourite songs: Paper Planes, Mango Pickle Down River, 20 Dollar, World Town, Come Around, Bamboo Banga, BirdFlu, Hussel Least favourite songs: The Turn 4/5
Great stuff
first song sucks ass. second song sucks too. the trend is continuing. i could not finish this album. Even their popular song Paper Planes could not save this.
BOM DEMAIS!!!!!
a 2000's charli that raps as well. also paper planes is one of the best songs of the 00's
Evidence that Robert Christgau lost his dang mind in the mid-2000s. Best album of the decade? Performative poseur nonsense.
this album is so insanely hype that it got a bit old. I never knew I could quite have my fill of bangers like this. but I like the sound, it's like a forbidden concentrate of 2007 juice that I only got watered down versions of back then. and hella bri'ish🤘
Not the most inventive songwriting, but what saves it are the well designed sonic layers behind each track that reward you for being attentive
Sannerligen unikt men det behöver inte vara bra för det. Väldigt jobbig musik. Fult cover, dryga låtar, tråkiga texter…
Cash register gunshot song good, the rest of the album forgettable. 2.6 stars
Not bad
“Paper Planes” is the clear star of the album. The rest was pretty good.
Very unique and full of bops
I'm pleasantly surprised. I know M.IA. through her radio releases, primarily Paper Planes (which, ironically, is one of the weakest songs on the album in my opinion). They're catchy, but they've never really grabbed me enough for me to seek out a full album. I can now say that was a mistake. This album is really, really good. Taking a cornucopia of interesting sounds, cultures, experiences, and ideas, she's able to weave this really catchy tapestry of sound that has kept me bobbing my head and tapping my toes. I think the first two songs got a little repetitive within themselves, but that is a small niggle, and one that does not portend further repetitiousness throughout the album. Each song sounds different, but still work really well as part of a coherent album. This is a great album. 4.5 stars.
Rap meets rave? Genesis of drill? Quite liked it, initially felt innovative but then got a bit repetitive and formulaic.
Never heard of this before at all. Very novel Pixies half cover on 20 Dollar kind of summed this all up really. It’s so abrasive challenging it kinda feels like a pixies/pj Harvey/albini vibe in the hip hop genre. There’s something about it I like but I’m not sure exactly what, however, there’s not one song that really nails it, or at least not on Day 1 listen. Suspect I may listen again, perhaps a grower, but not a high score for now.
Thought she was taking the piss for most of it... Almost unlistenable. Quite like paper planes, probably been on an advert. Overall, quite annoying.
I love Paper Planes-who doesn’t?
deep bass beats and cool rhymes. Don't love her voice, but yes Paper Planes is dope (even tho the beat is ripped from The Clash)
This was better than the MIA we had before, possibly weather having an effect on how I'm reviewing it. Felt the back half picked up a bit. Not sold on M.I.A generally
So, I had this album and completely forgot (hence my confusion over paper planes). I remember not really liking it at the time but on this relisten I thought it was great. There is something about modern musics played on lesser heard instruments that I really enjoy.
Had some moments.. But just a few.
Such a wonderful collection of joyous noise by a world music master. I’d rate it 5 stars even without Paper Planes, but that just shoves it into the stratosphere.
Pretty enjoyable if you don't make too much of it.
Strange and all over the place..
1. bamboo - 1 2. birdflu - 1.5 3. boyz - 1 4. huzzel - 1.5 5. mango - 1 6. dollar- 1 7. uuorld - 1 8. turn - 0 9. zr 2 - 1.5 10. paper planez - 2 11. come around - 1
Paper Planes was the only good song. 1/5
5/8/24. Familiar with M.I.A. and admittedly have never listened to this album, only the radio track Paper Planes. After an initial listen, it was just okay. Perhaps I should listen again in the future, but didn't vibe with it. Thought a lot of the songs were a bit boring.
Butt-Head: Check it out, Beavis, this dumb album generator thingy just gave us our 666th album. Beavis [mimicking Bruce Dickinson]: 6! 6! 6!…The number of the beeeast!!!! [they both head bang] Beavis: heh-heh…Satan is cool. Butt-Head: uh, Beavis…did I ever tell you that I, like, walk the path of the left hand? Beavis: uh…I don’t think so, Butt-Head. What’s that? Butt-Head: uh-huh-huh, let me show you. [Butt-Head slaps Beavis across the face with his left hand] Beavis: Ow! What the hell, Butt-Head! Why’d you do that? Butt-Head: I told you, I walk the left handed path, butt-munch. Beavis: I still don’t get- [Butt-Head slaps Beavis again] Beavis: Cut it out, Butt-Head! This sucks. Butt-Head: uh-huh-huh…you’re a dumbass. Beavis [sheepishly]: so..uh…Butt-Head, what album are we supposed to listen to? Butt-Head: uhhh…it says “Kala” by M.I.A Beavis [unenthusiastically]: …huh. [they sit in silence momentarily] Butt-Head: uhh…don’t just sit there, fartknocker… put on the record. Beavis [mumbling under his breath, annoyedly]: Why don’t you put it on, dill-weed? [They argue for a while over who is going to put on the album, with Beavis eventually acquiescing, and then listen to the record] Beavis: Hey, uh, Butt-Head…like, don’t get me wrong…it would have been cool if we got some Slayer for our 666th album…but this album is kind of awesome. Butt-Head: huh-huh…yeah, it definitely *slaps* [He slaps Beavis once again] Beavis: Dammit, Butt-Head…You know what? You can, like, slap me all you want, but it’s not going to stop me from getting down to these beats, butt-wipe. [Beavis starts twerking as “World Town” plays in the background] Butt-Head: …dumbass.
this album is wild, the production has to have been an inspiration for Yeezus. the songwriting is lacking at times but boyz, jimmy, 20 dollar, world town, xr2, and of course paper planes are all strong moments. aggressive synths, unique percussive sounds, a sample from the pixies and the clash, and afro/indian world influence make this a fascinating listen, with its main detractions stemming from repetitive songwriting and some songs cooking up a clogged mix. the absolute highlight of Kala (and the song probably competing with Hey Ya (ironically from an album i got 2 weeks ago) for best pop song of the entire 2000s) is paper planes. sampling the clash (!!), Mia created one of histories most triumphant tracks. tell me you arent tapping your foot from the start with those sampled opening notes. tell me "i fly like paper get high like planes" isnt one of the most stylish opening lines you've ever heard. tell me these lyrics haven't gotten more relevant every single year since 2008. tell me that the whining guitar, the childrens choir chorus, the finger-snap percussion, the spoken word bit "i got more records than the KGB" don't create a densely layered and intriguing atmosphere. you cant tell me any of that because this song compels you to believe it all just like the bang bang bang kachink hook compels you to bust out the finger guns and mime along gunshot-reload-cash register open. bombastic, iconic, singular, eccentric, and catchy. there is no other song that sounds like paper planes.
Terrible
Yet another album where the famous single is vastly different to the rest of the album. paper planes: 4/5, the rest: 2/4. Makes... 2.166666
Had headache, dnf
mucha variedad de estilos, ritmos y sonidos. Me gustan la combinacion de muchos sonidos, pero no hay correlacion ni orden, no se lo que intenta trasmitir con ellos mucho pontecial pero la ejecucion es mala
It's impossible to listen to, hip-hop with too much experimentation and unattractive vocals.
Didn't expect to like this.
BANGER album. Good vibes throughout 7/7
I thought MIA was supposed to be good and interesting...
Straight up banger !
Club dance poppy. I also love her voice. I should give this one another listen, might become a 5?
Look, I get it. It's a Sri Lankan fusion of rap and world music and that was new and unique, but man, this is pretty jarring. I feel like this album could be played by militaries to torture prisoners. It's just so noisy and busy in all the worst ways. For the sole reason that Paper Planes is a banger I'll give it a 3/10 (1.5/5)
There's a weirdness to this album. Jimmy is the highlight besides the huge hit Paper Planes. And the one song where she recites the lyrics to Where is my Mind.
Wasn't a huge fan
Kinda same-y
We wouldn’t have Death Grips without M.I.A
Paper Planes is easily the best song on this album. Other than that it’s kinda just okay. Not bad. Not good. Some interesting beats. Some silly lyrics
Not my thing.
A good album, I liked Boyz and Jimmy.
Y’know, after checking out two albums I think M.I.A. is starting to click for me in a real way. Paper Planes takes me right back to my uni indie club days of course but I’m digging a lot of the other tunes too. Those I might’ve found a bit shrill and annoying before suddenly seem refreshing, inventive and fun now. Also, why is the track with the Aussie kids so great? It makes me smile every time. Let’s say 3.5 / 4 stars
I'd not come across this before but really glad I have now. Loved how distinctive and different it sounds. Really tribal rhythms and her voice is brilliant.
This album is crazy in the best way possible. There is so much going on sonically and almost every song is makes you bob your head. A very unique style that pulls from M.I.A.’s Sri Lankan roots as well.
I played & danced to this album a ton when it dropped. It's an in your face, high energy commentary about politcs, war, immigration, government, drugs, and violence. Loved the beats & multicultural representation. I'm usually not a big fan of sampling, but it's done cleverly here. 4 solid stars.
This gets real annoying real fast. Only saved by Paper Planes.
2- Stars (4/15)
That's not my taste in musik. Musik?
Perennial example of an album included because of one massive track. plenty of these from the 80s and 90s too - this is just unlistenable nonsense, but an extra star for that massive song
For some reason this just hit different than Arular. Was is the Pixies reference? Or the greatness of Paper Planes? I can’t say right now, but it was a whole vibe.
Not sure what the big deal is with this record apart from having Paper Planes on it. Interesting use of sound effects as beats, but that's nothing new. Maybe I'm biased against MIA since it's hard to separate the art from the artist for me here.
Most unique album generated so far. Was not really in the mood for it, but it had me pumped by the end regardless.
Álbum con sonido interesante, música para poner de fondo, 6/10
Such a cool and different hip hop album from what commonly goes main stream. MIA's culture and place are a huge part of what makes her so unique. I can understand why someone wouldn't jive with it, but her lyrics and flow with the non traditional beats and samples make it so interesting to listen to. Love this album.
Big fan of a blend of musical styles, and this did it very well. I do wish that the lyrics didn't lean on hooks so much, quite a lot of the songs started to feel quite repetitive. 3/5. My name is MIA and Young Fathers was my idea.
Sometimes pretty interesting, sometimes pretty bad. Paper Planes is so good though. The sound of the summer in the common room.
Not great but 1 good song
Not sure
Really enjoyed this one. Very different
not for me
This is trash
I’m about to be MIA from this site. I know I’m not going to like everything but this has been some run…ouch.
I tried
I remember being so disappointed with this when it came out. Paper Planes was such a massive bop, nothing else on here could come close. But with a bit of distance, I can enjoy the rest of the tunes without those sky high expectations. Still nothing great, but a decent album after all.