Reviews (page 2 of 8)
Interesting and passionate
This was so boring!
So fucking boring. Just crap
And now you don't
Boring album!
Man, I didn't like their other album very much so I was very disappointed to see this one pop up today. Am I insane for thinking this shouldn't be anywhere near this book? If the debut lined up the entire 2010s alt-pop slop run, this was just another nail in the coffin. Like milk and white bread. Frustratingly neutral.
I liked this, particularly the music and production Vocals were hit and miss for me, but on the whole it was good
Definitely a chill album. I think the vocals are meant to be the strength of this album but in reality they are pretty bland. The spacey beats were nice though. I appreciated the tempo change in "On Hold" which just left me wishing the whole album sounded like that. Overall, this album was okay. Forgettable at worst and mildy interesting at best.
Nice textures and imaginative sound. There's a lot going on and i think it needs to really be appreicated with no distractions. Prefer the female vocalist at lot more to the guy. Was hoping it would go up a gear; quite slow and sad at times. Good one to add to the collection though. Favourite tracks: Say Something Loving, Performance, Replica, On Hold, Test Me
Perfectly serviceable 2010s indie/pop, but somewhat uninspired and forgettable.
I listened to this twice because I thought maybe I wasn't paying attention the first time. nope- I just don't like this! I don't understand how a modern album gets added to this list with such an underwhelming soundscape. Generic pop- not even fun electronica.
Not bad, kind of The National. I like how there’s a guy and a girl and sometimes they sing together and sometimes they sing solo
more bland indie pop, dull as a teaspoon. I listened to three tracks and gave up.
Man, I had no expectations and this still fell short. How did this make the list?
I like Jamie xx’s solo albums and, when he is more prominent in this, I like it. However, I have never particularly liked the vocalists and this lets it down for me (the fact that arguably their most popular song, Intro, doesn’t have vocals suggests I may not be the only one).
I do like the xx’s output, including their solo material but this album isn’t them at their best. I’ve always liked when they play with space whereas this something of a more traditional album that leans less on creating the breathing room that gives the vocals to really cut through. I suspect they had reached a creative dead end at this point at unfortunately I think it shows. Both ‘dangerous’, and ‘say something loving’ have good use of samples, and I’m fond of ‘a violent noise’ but the second half of the album is very forgettable.
Kind of a mixed bag for me, but there were several tracks that were okay enough to keep me from outright hating it.
If the Room was music but I actually didn’t like it. Yeah, I don’t really get this. The vocalists are ass, instrumentals boring, and nothing really interesting or new happening that I couldn’t get from anywhere else better. Why is it on this list?
It's well-produced of course, but I can't help this feeling that I am not the target audience for this. In fact, I think this music isn't made for any type of human at all, but rather for stores. Not the customers or the retail workers, no, the stores themselves: malls, warehouses, fast food shacks, etc. I imagine a world that has suddenly been rid of humans, in whatever grotesque way it may have happened. In the parking lot bins, countless little things stir, although they have long lost their names. They scuttle around on a giant concrete circle, in the middle of which stands a solitary clothes shop. It is full off moth-eaten sweaters and trousers, its neon lights still beam into the night's darkness - green, purple, a hint of blue. I See You is playing on repeat, a leftover of some teenager's spotify playlist, now the soundtrack for the rest of history. The little things unanimously prefer the quiet parts.
This album was beautifully dreamy.
tumblr coded
Spreading positivity.
A pretty superfluous inclusion, not as iconic and just not as good as their debut. Though On Hold is probably the xx song I get the most repeat listening value from. On full listen I really find most of the rest of the tracks to be very tame. Its boring. 2.3/5
Das isch so langwiilig gsi
I had my first album by the xx (their debut album) very early on when I started this. I had to go back and look at my review, because I remember thinking that this was a band I'd heard of, but didn't know much about. I actually gave that first album a 5 out of 5 rating and talked about how much it reminded me of The Cure, which is why I think I liked it so much. So after listening to this album, I'm almost tempted to go back and listen to that first album again, because the band must have totally changed their sound. This album did not remind me of The Cure at all. In fact, it's very dance-y and almost electronic club music in part, and then slow and sort of boring songs in part. I didn't mind listening to it, but nothing on the album stood out for me and it's another album that I'm wondering how it made it on this list.
Good vibes but doesn’t excite me enough to be listened to repeatedly by me.
When this came out i had a 1 year old, so a lot passed me by including this. I'm a Jamie Xx fan and this was right up my street. A real mixture of styles and genre that reflect the lare night london scene, but as this is their third album it seems cohesive and mature. They know what they are by now and do it well.
There's some really good stuff on this one, but the whole album doesn't grab me like their earlier self titled album.
Dafür, dass diese Liste so restriktiv bei der Inklusion von neueren Alben ist, wirkt diese Nennung für mich ziemlich random. Das große Meisterwerk von The xx ist das Debüt (was immerhin auch noch kommen wird) und daran kam seitdem nichts mehr heran. Hier versuchen sie sich von dessen reduziertem Sound zu emanzipieren. Der Einfluss von Jamie xx's "In Colour" ist in Songs wie "Dangerous" und dem Einsatz von Samples in "Say Something Loving", "Lips" und "On Hold" klar herauszuhören. Das lässt die Songs deutlich tanzbarer und damit hit-lastiger wirken. Jedoch birgt dieser Weg auch die Gefahr, die Songs beliebiger zu machen. Romy und Oliver haben tolle Stimmen, die schön anzuhören sind, aber ihre Art zu singen ist keineswegs showy, sondern sehr zurückgenommen. Das kann auch schnell in Langeweile umschlagen, was leider im zweiten Drittel bei mir häufig der Fall ist. In "A Violent Noise" schaffen sie es dagegen nochmal, diese dunkle Energie des Debüts zu kanaliseren. Bleiben also 6 tolle Songs gegenüber 4 Misses (die Experimente im Closer gehen für mich nicht auf). Ich mag die Band wirklich gerne und war auch nach dem Konzert zu diesem Album ziemlich begeistert, aber diese Platte konkret ist für mich leider nicht mehr als Mittelmaß.
Das sind The xx? Na gut, ich hatte was anderes erwartet. Das Album finde ich sauber durchgezogen. Es hat eine klare Linie, ist abwechslungsreich. Es gibt mir nur nichts. Mit schwachen 4 Sternen kann ich also guten Gewissens rausgehen.
Ich hätte mir wirklich gewünscht, dass es mich mehr abholt, vorallem bei dem großen Namen, aber das hat mich wirklich nicht erreicht, wobei ich den Gesang am meisten mochte
Wow, how far they've come from the first album, really amazing. You can really see the influence of Jamie xx's incredible DJing on this one, expanding the sound from the solitary notes employed so much on the first album.
Background music.
I See You feels almost colorless to me. There’s a certain elegance in its restraint, but after a while that restraint starts to feel more like emotional distance. The sparse arrangements, hushed vocals, and understated rhythms create the familiar xx atmosphere, yet the album rarely surprises or pulls me in deeply enough. It’s not a bad record by any means—it’s carefully made, atmospheric, and occasionally beautiful—but I found myself admiring it more than actually feeling it. The mood stays so consistent that, for me, it becomes a little monotonous and even slightly boring. Almost everything is in its right place, but there’s not enough contrast, tension, or messiness to give the songs much color. Maybe that cool, minimalist quality is exactly what makes I See You appealing to some listeners. For me, though, it left very little behind once the music stopped.
Just kinda boring. Like I'm sitting in my bedroom, staring at the ceiling while LED lights slowly change colors Favorite Songs: Replica, Test Me
Why this album? I see that xx is in here - correct answer. If there's going to be a second xx album (which, I mean, sure), why not Coexist? So, anyway, a mildly unique indie electronica album. This one is the album that came after the wave of popularity, and I don't hear anything new or anything that must be heard before you die.
This is one I enjoyed, but understand it wouldnt hit the same depending on the space and location for sure.
Some of the singing really irks me.
Not bad just very bland.
Mehh I mean for pop it’s alright I just don’t really get how it’s in this list
Liked this, not heard it before
One of the few new albums I have purchased in the past 10 years. Have listened to multiple times and really like it - so was surprised by all the negativity in the reviews. I know all the songs sort of sound the same and like their previous albums - but i like the vibe so if it aint broke .....
Their most commercial of their 3 albums. Why not pick XX as their album for this list? That was at least new and different (and better). This album has a couple of nice tunes but also says; lets sell more records than we previously did by going more commercial and overly produced. Their minimalism was the appeal and novelty.
Most of the songs were the same drum beat and vocal style
As bland as a three day old microwaved bolognese that’s been in the fridge a little too long
Det hørtes omtrent akkurat ut som det ene albumet av dem æ har hørt på med vilje, så sånn sett va det jo ikke dårlig, men det va kanskje ikke kjempeinteressant heller?
love the xx
1. dangerouz - 2 2. loving - 2 3. lipz - 1 4. noize - 2 5. performance - 2 6. replica - 1 7. brave - 1 8. hold - 1 9. dare - 1 10. tezt - 0
Better than I thought, I'll have to listen again
Refreshing and cool down tempo electronic indie rock with alternating male and female vocals. Very listenable and relaxing, perfect for a rainy day.
Sounded like cold porridge
Solid electro-indie album from the 2010's. Weird it's on this list.
No Just no. The female vocals are trash like what is going on? This Album is trash
Their first album was fine, in it's time, but when it came up in this list I realized I had utterly forgotten everything about it (and I listened to it quite a bit). This is a much less fine album with one song that I remember and many songs that are also on the album.
# Album Name: I See You # Artist: The xx # Rating: 5/5 # Comments: Great modern album. Took a few listens to click in but i got there in the end. I wouldnt call it indie per say. # Top Tunes: I enjoyed the whole album. # Would I listen to it again? Yes
Sounds nice. Lyricism is weak. Vibe is cool. I’ll probably never listen to this again but it was good.
Oof, passable at best. Pretty music that just feels kinda empty. Hell, I felt empty by the time I stopped listening to it (track 8 out of 10). Not bad, by any means, but not needed here either. Exclude.
Pre-listening thought: I'm quite looking forward to this. A few months ago I was driving home late at night and heard the Jamie xx remix of Dopamine by Robin, which is fantastic. Ok, I've started listening and Track 1 is not what I was expecting. I hope it changes tack and gets better. Oh dear, into Track 2 and it has, if anything, got worse. Fair dues, it definitely got better the further through I got. The last 4 or 5 tracks were quite enjoyable. If I listened again there is a very good chance I would skip the first 4 tracks.
solid
Mycket mysigt album, dock är det ett band som verkligen håller sig till sitt sound och det kan bli lite långtråkigt ibland! Gillar Jamie XX väldigt mycket mer och det är alltid intressant att höra hans input i deras låtar. Gillar debutalbumet mycket mer så denna får en stark 3:a.
Hello gang, gårdagens album ”I See You” av The xx var en intressant lyssning. Jag gillade att det inte var likt något annat vi har lyssnat på hittills och de elektroniska dragen kändes uppriktigt väldigt uppfriskande. Jag diggade albumet överlag och förstår varför det är med på den här listan. Det präglas av sköna melodier och ljud som ständigt fick mig att spetsa öronen. Jag ger det en stabil 8/10!
Bra album! Blir en kort recension. Vet inte om jag ska ge 3 eller 4 stjärnor
Airy synth music with wispy singing. It’s just soft and boring background noise to me. I just don’t get into this kind of music. This is certainly not an album I needed to hear.
Helt ok. Jag gillar de flesta låtarna även om de börjar låta lite samma efter ett tag. De skapar en otrolig stämning live med vissa låtar som inte blir riktigt samma här. Men jag gillar albumet.
Maybe my brother is right and I should listen to Jamie xx
On hold va kul Beste sag: On hold
More modern electronic music. Nothing stood out.
Inte dåligt, men väldigt tråkigt och intetsägande. Funkar säkert när man är sugen på något melankolisk.
Not my thing, unfortunately. Nothing memorable
The album i see you by the xx is not the best album also not good I find it boring it has 1-2 good songs no more
Nice enough album but nothing really sticks out as outstanding for me here.
I like the XX, and have seen them live. But I was not really impressed with this album. In fact.
Okayy
ooh. another band i’ve never really listened to. looking forward to learning about them. and . . . it's fine. nothing i'll return to
What a drag, I was just waiting for it to be done
Really missing the rawness of their first album. Never got into this one as much.
Fairly boring and almost uninspired. No real energy to the performances. 2/5 Won't listen again
So forgettable I forgot I was listening to it while it was still playing.
Some of the production is nicely textured, but almost all the songs are boring. The vocals grate.
Music that makes me cry
Decent, but nothing outstanding.
General thoughts: Right at the moment I saw the combination of release year and genre, I was a bit hesitant, not saying newer is worse per se, but the creator of this list has demonstrated so far a lack of taste in some gaps in the history of music, in this case, in this decade and genre. Music can be minimalistic, can be slow, can be deadpan even, but you can never be boring, never, and this is boooring. 'I See You' is so plain and boring, and don't get me wrong, I like minimalistic arrangements, but this is not it, this album is spiceless and very artificial; the few signals of life get shadowed by the worst writing decisions I've seen. What I mean is, whenever I have a hint of hope for a track, they somehow mess it up. The lyrics are pretty mid; voices aren't bad, but same again, they dont add much life to the songs. Literally, what they did on "On hold" is what they're missing, not saying they need to sample or include rap, but to add some touch of originality that strays from its current state of background music. The album gets progressively worse, and the closer is the worst; they had a nice horn arrangement somewhere, used it for 10 seconds, and then threw it out the window. Outstanding song(s): On hold Weakest song(s): Test Me Cover: As bland as the setlist. Seriously, who suggested that cover art? Ed Sheeran? Real rating: 2.15
Hey this is my 1000th album! Too bad it's nothing spectacular. Tomorrow's had better be stunning.
It's not as boring as the other xx album, that's one positive. It didn't have the beauty of the other album they have on here either however. I didn't really dislike any part of this, but it feels like such a forgettable and inconsequential release that I find it hard to say much about it. Did it do anything wrong? Did it do anything right? Who listens to this? Have those people ever heard other music?
As with their other album, I'm finding this just way too stripped back and wafty. Particularly in the vocal delivery, which stays the same across the whole album. I don't mind some of the musical / atmospheric elements per se, but they don't have any real impact outside of a very gentle texture. It's hard to engage with this when it's so slight, and again, as with their other album, it's just so fucking boring.
Some cool tracks here but some others are really boring
Nice, chill album. Almost a more modern version of The Smiths; interesting that this was recommended right after Morrissey.
Good when woman. Bad when man.
god so corny
This was THE tumblr girlie band. They are quite good, did enjoy it. 4/5
my first thought was "this is adidas store music" (as someone who was frequently buying soccer things there in 2017). i liked the beginning half of this album more than the later half. it was also such a jumpscare to hear the choral sample in "lips" - the composer of that song came to our school and i had to sit through a 15 minute performance that was pretty much exactly like the sample it was awful.
nah
Maybe not the best xx album, but very interesting and worth a listen.
Actually pretty good but trails off near the end.
The first one was boring drivel. This one is too.
Boring
Slightly funkier than their Ambien-soaked debut, this album too falls victim to the fact that the singers sound totally disconnected from the material.
почему-то прям очень неприятные для меня ребята, что он что она(
Solid album. Favorite tracks: Dangerous, Say Something Loving, Brave For You
Loose cool energy, solid beats, and the xx formula: hushed, intimate, R&B-ish.
There’s an integration that works here between the smoky back rooms and the dance club. And having said all that, it’s nice to chill out with on the back porch.
Skipped first track. After that it was nice, chill, but mostly background. 3/5
Un álbum muy variado y si se nota la evolución en la música que producen a este entonces Tiene canciones muy potentes, personalmente mi favoritas son Dangerous y On Hold Su propuesta en general es buena, se reinventan sin perder la esencia que los hizo volverse un grupo tan aclamado en la escena indie Reescuchable, bastante recomendable y se disfruta Me atrevo a decir que es el álbum más divertido de los que tienen hasta ahora
i mean its alright like, overrated af imo. it was a good listen, but why tf is it here, why does this album have to be here, never heard of this guys in my life, why oh why do i have to listen to them before i die, there are so many more artists from this time that are more worth listening to before you die.
Empieza con un temón de Fifa, cosa que no esperaba decir de ningún disco de esta lista. Es de 2017 y no es ni el mejor álbum de la banda, raro. Como disco me gustó bastante, pero me molestó que esté en esta lista, cuando me toque el primer álbum seguramente le de mejor nota, pero este no es más de un 3.
Some a bit boring some really nice
The xx is just the Millennial version of Everything But The Girl.
I like The XX, and I was into this album when it came out. It definitely expanded their sound, and incorporated the success that Jamie XX had with his solo debut album (excellent uses of samples). I get that there might be some hesitancy on more recent albums and their inclusion on this list, but The XX have had a big impact on music and culture in the last decade.
zou niet misstaan in een lift... behalve misschien als je echt veel verdiepingen hoger moet...dan zou ik toch een trap overwegen
i turned it off. hopefully they don't see me any more
I think I'm too old for this
i liked it. if i was emduring a breakup or experiencing heartache i could see the vibe being impactful. but all i can focus on was the distorted reverb applied to strings. (especially in Performance) even though i love strings in almost any form (sampled, live, tracked, midi, emulated via synth) i cannot *stand* that artistic decision _(⁑⧘ 」∠)_
Idk if I have much to say but this is like so 2010s
I didn't find anything to like here.
I think this album is an improvement over their other on this list, but it does get fairly bland. I love a good duet, but I feel like we got 10 pretty ok duets.
2010's indie at some of its best. 4.5 bumped up to 5.
I’m at a 4.5 that I’ll bump up to a 5. Most of the top reviews on the site describe this album as boring, or some of the other million synonyms for the word. It’s a description probably borne out of both the older skew on the site & a certain disdain for 2017 production. The former may just be a generation gap, but the latter is one that’s loosely understandable almost a decade later (we were really hanging onto the ‘boom’ part of ‘boom/clap’ for a while). I wouldn’t characterize this as boring, but I think I see why it’s easy to call it that; this album isn’t doing anything remarkably unique in the totality of the 2017 indie space. It is, however, unique to The xx, who normally specialize in letting the emptiness of a minimalist soundscape set the tone. That emptiness is replaced by a bit more than usual; sort of a lo-fi version of ‘90s house with some of the trends of mainstream pop at the time. It’s slightly jarring at first, but once you settle into it, it’s generally nice, and every production choice works hand in hand with the lyrics & vocals (most apparent on something like “A Violent Noise”). This album’s biggest strength is in that production, but it’s accentuated by the songwriting. I think the mistake here is confusing ‘simple’ for ‘boring’; a lot of these tracks are expressly straightforward & laying themselves out without much additional room for interpretation. It’s mostly centered around finding connection & trying to overcome the tension that comes with it, whether it’s a lack of comfort, self-prophesizing cynicism, chasing highs or coping with lows. I think these are very simple concepts, but the execution behind them is what makes the tracks work. It’s consistently strong execution that pulls the most out of everything it can. If you’re not inclined towards the actual soundscapes in the production here, you probably won’t like this, but if it’s not as big of a deal, it should be easy to recognize the intentionality behind every choice. All of the little backing synths & microbeats swirl & melt in ways that drive the pulse of each track. The weak spot here is that even with how much I like the execution, a few of the earliest tracks do still feel like they’re not doing anything past the basics. I still won’t classify them as boring, because I liked them, but I think “Dangerous” feels a little plain (though inoffensively fun) & “Lips” just isn’t super compelling past a regular sense of love. The album hits a good stretch from “A Violent Noise” onwards, but I’m not super sold on “Test Me” as the closing track. I just don’t know if you should end an album about connections & a desire for acknowledgement on one with such unanswered undertones. I honestly think it could’ve been the opening track. Regardless, I think this is a pretty good album. I don’t think it’s as good as “xx” was, but that’s a hard album to top. My biggest comparison here is in how much this feels like an Everything but the Girl album, with Romy sounding distinctly like Tracey Thorn throughout most of her verses. It feels like a naturally carried torch from Idlewild’s controlled tones & the baseline electronica of Walking Wounded, and I just can’t help but enjoy it for that reason. Mileage will vary, as always, but I think this does enough to warrant bumping it up to a 5, at least for my tastes. I’m glad it’s on the list.
Een soort Suzan en Freek van de indiepop? Op een bepaalde manier klinkt het precies zo qua samenzang, maar of het echt een setje is heb ik verder niet gecheckt. Wel duwen ze er een boel extra elektronica in ten opzichte van het duo uit de Achterhoek. Het is allemaal heel gladjes geproduceerd, maar afwisselend genoeg dus ook deze keer luistert het prima weg.
Ik vraag bij MJ Cole om vergelijkingsmateriaal en krijg direct daarna deze plaat. Het is wellicht geen garage-house, maar ook dit album combineert een moderne beat met meer gevoelige zang en rustigere muziek. Er komt nog eens een wat klassieker instrument voorbij. Zelfs de hoes heeft dezelfde kleur. De beats en vooral de bassdrums zijn wat minder heftig, waardoor je wat minder tegenstelling ervaart. Het is daardoor wat saaier en het doet wat aan jaren '90 artiesten als Seal denken. Dit gerecht had wat meer peper kunnen gebruiken. 3,5 ster.
Dit doet me iets denken aan een moderne versie van Everything but the Girl. En die zangeres werkt op mijn zenuwen. Ik heb hetzelfde bij deze zanger en zangeres. Het is neppe emotie die ze erin leggen, ik geloof ze niet, artsy fartsy dromerig gedoe. En dan staan ze er ook nog 2x in. Tja, het is wel typisch zo'n snobbandje natuurlijk. Er zitten genoeg momenten in om even wat meer los te gaan, maar dat doen ze dan niet. Misschien een keer met een extra elektronisch beatje ofzo, maar dat vind ik echt te matig. Avicii of David Guetta hadden hier wel raad mee geweten gok ik. Het is nu vooral heel veel slappe hap (of zoals Eric al zegt, het had meer peper kunnen gebruiken). Ik ga dit 2 sterren geven, dit is niet aan mij besteed.
Sounds like an album trying to sell me shoes and overpriced shirts
This album was OK, but it was a bit on the dull side. Sounded like if David Guetta started an indie rock band. Not a ton to say about this record, it kinda played, a couple songs were interesting, maybe even good, and then it was over. Low 3/5
Music for a soundtrack or for a sad teenager to listen to on the bus while staring out of the window. The track Performance was extremely underwhelming, a very straightforward metaphor, if it even rises to the level of metaphor. Jejune. The same goes for Brave For You, its moral and message is something you might see in a cartoon for children.
Harmless enough but very samey. In fact not only is this album samey, it’s also pretty much identical to their first album which *also* appears on this list. Marking down as a 2 as I don’t this this one has any merit being on here
..
I liked this, better than the first album I got from them. Still nothing better than 3 stars, but three really listenable songs that might make my playlist
Meh
pretty nice, mellow
Überraschend gut, konnte man sich gut anhören und war sehr chillig
Nicht ganz so gut wie die ersten beiden Alben, aber liebe die Beats von Jamie xx. Vor allem on hold und I dare you sind top.
Mega Stark, könnt ich mir pausenlos anhören
oooooooooooke
++: Dangerous, Brave for You +: Performance, Replica, I Dare You, Test Me +-: Say Something Loving, Lips, On Hold -: A Violent Noise 5,0/10
Not my favorite of their projects.
Someone singing over your mum’s Pure Moods CD
I literally had an album by The XX yesterday, so I'm just going to copy and paste my review from yesterday: "More boring indie slop. The singers sound as bored as I am. At least its only 38 minutes but it feels twice as long."
EDM-house really took over the mid-2010s huh, or maybe since this is my first "The xx" album that I might actually be describing their niche sound? It sounds so of its time and also very "modern" (in that I'm reliving my teenage years) that I'm still a bit turned off by it. I'm not sure how to describe the album but to me it's uncomfortably familiar: the dance-adjacent production and the ambient synths. I think trite is a better word; I heard elements of this album from listening to Top 40 radio every day as a teen.
It might take a few listens, but the first impression is really good
The XX are a special and unique band. I'm not mad about the bad reviews - just sad for those who don't see it. This isn't my favorite of their 3 albums, but that probably says more about the quality of their first 2 albums. I See You (I can't believe it's been 9 years since their last album!) has by far their most expensive sound. Some tracks sound like they skipped straight to the Jamie XX remix, which isn't always a good thing for me and may grate on some at times. However, underneath that production they still write some of the must nuanced and modern love songs; songs about knowingly ignoring red flags, only realizing your feelings for someone when you say something out loud, and losing someone you never had but thought you would. Every track feels so personal and real. I struggle to understand how anyone can say they lack feeling - Performance and Brave in particular feel so personal it's almost surprising they would put it to record.
This was good, the XX are quite an enigmatic band and I remember being pleasantly surprised they announced another album, eg after a hiatus and Jamie had done some solo work, etc The aforementioned producer's influence is clear as this is a dancier record than they had made previously, but retaining the ethereal sound and dual vocals which make them a distinctive band
So dull
Seems to me that this British indie pop group could have come up with a better name than xx. Anyway, this is a rather recent album with a few nice tracks. I don’t think the male singer is very good - or maybe he’s trying to sound laid back deliberately.
Very weird to hear the xx with vocals! Two vocalists, even! They're both competent; the lyrics are kinda grade schooly, but they're clear! and the music is good. Nice album. Very chill electropop; maybe a bit too chill, but I suppose it has its place. Highlights: 'On Hold', 'I Dare You' (apparently they sang these both on SNL, which I have exactly 0 memory of. November 2016... what a time) Lowlights: 'Performance', 'Test Me' (zzz)
Overall: 5/10 I'll have to agree with the reviews on this website that the majority of this album is pretty boring, but there's a few gems on here that I actually love. The vocalists voices go well together and they're pretty chill. I prefered the first xx album, and I won't be listening to anything else by this band, but this album wasn't the worst thing I've ever heard. Fav Song: Dangerous
I liked it more than I thought I would!
On the one hand, the danceclub beats and broader sonic palette add some interest and dimension, but the songs aren't quite as good as their debut. 3.5/5 I'd keep the debut on the list and omit this one.
"Say Something Loving" and "Replica" are my favorites.
This is a pretty uninteresting album. I didn't feel anything from it, musically it didn't grab me, and I didn't notice anything thematically engaging. It very easily fell into background music even when I tried to hold attention. Even as someone who listens to ambient music at times I found this to be something that bored me.
unexpected but really liked it
Eugh I mean the first track was good and the songs that have music videos are ok the other songs just sound the same
Poppy, fun
It’s hard for me not to write about this album in the context of The xx’s 2026 tour, whose sole purpose seems to be reminding the general public “hey guys, we’re totally still friends and totally still a band and totally not breaking up any time soon!” Notably, The xx are not performing any new music on this tour, nine years after I See You came out, instead emphasizing solo cuts they’ve made in collaboration, including Romy’s “Enjoy Your Life” and Oliver Sim’s “GMT”. The tour emphasizes how great The xx are/were as a festival act…and at least inadvertently advocates for a not-so-secret agenda of mine: emphasizing just how great I See You is. Full disclosure: I write an album of the year list every year and I See You was my favorite album of 2017, and looking back it still holds that spot. Also, I’m huge fan of The xx and while this is an entirely subjective opinion, I think this is their best album. On a pure gut wrenching level, I think this album dispatches ambiguity in favor of directness (or at least, as close to directness as they can get) that accurately describes the loss of control and difficulties in maintaining self-esteem in adult gay relationships (especially on songs like “Say Something Loving” and “A Violent Noise”) that frankly often hits close to home, with the band’s best solo performances to date from Romy (describing the grief in the face of the loss of a loved on “Performance”) and Oliver (describing generational trauma on “Replica”) serving as additional highlights on the album. Beyond the lyrical/vocal highlights, this is clearly where Jamie was starting to flex his might as electronic producer extraordinaire to complement his bandmates’ guitar skill in austere indie and R&B styles to transform them into something slow but maximalist on this album (see the insanely sexy “Lips” or the energetic vocal sample chop on “On Hold”). The sleeve of the vinyl record of this album is a reflective metallic surface, designed to reflect the audience whenever they held it up. It’s funny, because while I of course see parts of myself reflected in this album, these days I hear just as much confidence from the members of The xx, pushing their sound to places they’d never thought to explore before, embracing a new era that may never happen. I want new music from The xx so badly. I’m not sure I’ll ever get it. But when I see them again in a few weeks, rest assured I’ll scream along just as loud to “Say Something Loving” as I did in my car 10 years ago. The xx always made music for feeling above all else, and I’ll never stop feeling this music deep in my chest.
I have their first album somewhere on CD. This isn’t as good as that, although there are touches I quite enjoyed
This album was in heavy rotation ~10 years ago - I loved the fire and ice dynamic of Oliver and Romi's vocals set to light and airy tracks - and then dropped off / fell out of favor somewhat quickly. Listening today, I'm reminded how great it was and wondering why it fell off. Maybe because its ambient and moody? Maybe because it started to feel cliched i.e. the proximity to music used for the cheesy-fake emotion scenes in shows like the Bachelor? Favorites include Violent Noise, Dare You and Test Me. I would happily put this on any time. 4/5.
It's a bit soporific, heard a lot worse. Gets quite samey
Wow! Only knew one song from them and it was instrumental… This is amazing. Great voices and instrumental composition aswell with some digital overlays!
This is fine. Very similar to the last xx album this list gave me (xx). Nice chill music. Very samey. The production irks me a bit here and there. The male vocals are better for me this time around, if rather nondescript. The female vocals are more nondescript this time than I recall them being on xx. I even listened to a bit of xx again and this album is just kinda middling in comparison. Music was better on that one, vocals are kind of a mixed bag in comparison - I was right in remembering that I liked Romy Croft's performance more and Oliver Sim's less on that album. Middling for me overall.
Achei mais comercial e menos autoral em relação a outros álbuns do The XX
The production is gorgeous here, you can really tell this was released not too long after In Colour. Though that is definitely a better album. Feels like Jamie xx might be doing a lot of the heavy lifting here. Doesn’t overstay its welcome at least
Some really interesting ideas here that I just felt were ruined by repetitiveness nonsense. Some of these songs truly could have been 30 seconds long.
Actually not as terrible as I had braced for based on the reviews. Just sounds like one long song though. But it’s probably good music to fuck to.
Meh
Quite some time back I had to The xx’s debut album generated. I had seen it being praised on several occasions but I mostly found it to be pretty underwhelming and boring (although I might listen to it again sometime in the future). I feel similar about this album. It’s really repetitive and doesn’t change much sonically. The vocals are really monotonous and subdued, and overall not really engaging. There were some pretty moments in this (I liked “A Violent Noise” and the outro to “Replica”), but overall this is just a boring album to me. Luckily the runtime is quite manageable.
Didn't really find much of note or interest here. Felt middle of the road trying to be emotional. Might need more listens.
What elation I had when I opened my 1001 project and saw that this was my next record. I'm already on my second listen today. I love The XX so much, and I was a little surprised to see this one on here, but I'm happy it is. Hoping that their self-titled is also somewhere in the list. This album captures so many moods and has such beautiful fluidity. The group's vocals harmonize so well with each other on every track and they know how to dance so perfectly with the intricate, yet spacious, music compositions they've created. From the jump, "Dangerous" is engaging and uplifting, with such a fun beat, layered with complementing elements. Every track thereafter is its own, yet is a critical piece fo make the album a complete story. "Performance" is such raw emotion, always gets me, such a beautiful song. The sequencing, engineering, production, performance, all of it, I absolutely love it and will play this record many more times before I die.
The only on I know from these guys is Intro. I really like the way GPT described this album. The xx are masters of restraint: guitar lines that barely move, bass parts that feel like a pulse in a dark room, vocals that sound close but guarded. On I See You, those elements are still there, but they’re surrounded by horns, samples, brighter synths, and more rhythmic energy. The album feels less like two people whispering in a bedroom and more like two people trying to carry that private sadness into the outside world. Say Something Loving is pretty. Has a really pretty emotional build up. I only gave the first album I got from these guys 3 stars? hm it was their xx album. The one with Intro. Lips is really pretty too. Lots of texture here. I don't know man, this album is actually really growing on me. I'm giving it 4 stars.
very good
I was surprised to see this album instead of their debut but it was a joy to hear. You can really hear the soloists they’ll become. The sound has developed so much from the first album.
I really tried to like this today, but it kind of just doesn't land with me. It really just feels like when indie went bad. I like the electronic elements, and even some of the pop stuff, but it just feels like some appropriation of what was once really good music. The album ended and a Yeah Yeah Yeahs song started playing, and for a second I thought it was The xx, and I was like "Ohhhh this is a cool song. This must be the big hit that everyone likes. Its definitely familiar" and then I realized I was listening to Karen Os vocals. It was all clear at that point.
really fucking boring
A few good bass lines and some interesting ideas here and there, I think I will revisit
Ahh yes FIFA 18. Not a bad album, dos equis but 3 stars
“Oh! Its finished” was our most pertinent observation.
This was one of my favorite albums the year it came out. It’s a solid album and maybe the xx’ best album.
Fine, just kinda the xx.
Espera más, me gustaron 2 canciones
Legitimately loved this album. Seems like something I would like to try to make.
Minimal use of drums makes this sound like amorphous blobs of tones with vocals. This album did nothing for me except make me mad that I didn't just listen to Hall and Oates instead.
That's creepy!
This was fine, just didn’t hit the same as their older stuff, a little too pop for me this time around.
Probably the most "meh" album I've listened to so far on this list. Not bad, not good, just did not stir anything in me at all. Really, really, really boring.
I fell asleep listening to the last few songs on this album, and I have absolutely no desire to revisit it to hear it out. I wouldn't call this DNF though - I really did try to get all the way through it. Just wasn't my thing. At times I thought - that's a great baseline, or this is a fun little melody, but then the song carried on without it.
When I hear this, I think that this is the definition of indie music. Throw in some shoegaze, some ambient/dreamy textures and this is the outcome. It’s okay and that’s all this is. I liked their other album more than this. It had a bit more backbone to the record. I just felt like something was missing from most of these songs here.
I liked it when it came out but it hasn’t aged well. The first album is better.
No one would be upset if this was playing in the background. 6/10
Album 233. I See You (https://open.spotify.com/album/6Zw6NKh3oIUhDRMOyBmsUU?si=3BwmnTF0T56Wb4wL0U44iw) — The xx (2017) Good. Same vibes as their debut xx album. 3/5 Liked: — On Hold
Nothing on this list should be less than ten years old. Especially when it’s this boring and lame. The “best” songs remind me of bad modern Broadway musicals. The worst songs are uninspired generic techno beats with a vocalist on Quaaludes. It’s telling the only 5 star rating I saw was from someone who knows the band personally.
Don't know why TWO of this acts albums are in this list. Granted, there are 2-3 passable tracks with better tunes, but this to me sounds like stripped back bedroom laptop recordings without a great deal of substance or 'wow' moments. Not my cup of tea, sorry.
I was expecting myself to say something pretentious like "not even close to their first album" It isn't... but, god damn, they know how to play a chill mono-voiced sound to perfection.
I have no idea why this is on the list. There is nothing special. It’s not bad. But it’s boring pop music.
A fine indie pop album, but that's just it, it's fine. Incredible Hall and Oates sample on On Hold
Pleasant for cooking
Didn't mind it and I always find electronic music helpful to focus .
This didn't really click for me. It just sounded a bit generic or even corporate to my ears. I wasn't a big fan of the vocal performances, and I wish it leaned more into the weirder, dreamier, or poppier places it could have gone.
It's fine, but yeah... this being immediately taken off the list after one edition makes sense. I don't think it's even a particularly essential album in the context of The xx. It's ok though, I just don't ever really come back to this over their debut or Coexist. So.... glad I had a reason to give this another listen but yeah. Excited to hear their new stuff whenever that's out, though!
It’s not terrible, it’s quite pleasant, but that’s about the best I can do for it as it was just a little bland, like Everything But The Girl reinvented for the next generation. Ironic band name really as they are getting The ⭐️⭐️
Ew. This is the type of music I would think of if I said I dont like modern music. I dont say that now but maybe 10 years ago I would have. Its not horrible I guess. Like its not a thing I would even think about if I was shopping at the jc penny and it was on over the speakers. But sitting here and listening to 40 minutes of it really got to me by the end. Its just so generic. I dont hear anything new or interesting. Its the popcorn marvel movie of music. Its fine to like it but i just cant see it as fine art. Its art of some kind just not good art for me. Its just so smoothed out. Its perfect. It makes me feel like a robot made it. It grosses me out. I just cant really find anything worth it for me. The music just stinks all around. But its not a 1 star stink I guess. It took a long time for me to get mad at it at least. Only in the last 2 songs did I get the come on wrap it up feelings. If it went on much longer I might have been able to justify a 1, but as it is if I heard it I just wouldn't notice it instead of fly into a blind rage. Still not good though
Second album proposé après xx que j’avais plutôt apprécié (noté 3/5, sympa sauf voix masculine). J'ai un peu moins accroché sur cet album, je n'y ai pas retrouvé les ambiances qui m'avaient séduit dans le précédent album. Le premier morceau et sa section de cuivre m'a plutôt déplus. L’accompagnement s'améliore par la suite mais sans retrouver le niveau du premier album. Je ne suis pas sur d'avoir envie de l'écouter une seconde fois. =>2/5
Easy to listen to, with some songs grabbing your attention like Hold On. But mostly it didn't grab me.
For one song it's fine, but man, this album drags on. It kept feeling like it was going somewhere and then just never arrived.
I liked it, but not sure that I needed to hear it before I die.
I see another brilliant album.
I'm not a fan of The XX and I wonder how they became popular. Every so often you realize that maybe the music you like is not the same that other people like.
Nothing too crazy, I enjoyed the female singers voice for a couple songs so I will bump it up to 2 stars.
I liked the sound, although, it could use some beat drops or something to break the songs up and make them a bit more unique.
It’s fine. Easy to listen to background noise but it’s dull. Nothing remarkable
always liked them
Totally new to me. Music lacks something, but I like the vocals. Disappointed that one track was in that crappy Essex nightclub style, but fortunately just the one.
Insufferable drivel. I hated every second of listening to this. Jamie xx has done far more interesting work separate from these two vapid nothings.
I hate the XX
I enjoy the minimal production and both of their voices, very enjoyable vibes.
Enjoyable! Quite liked it
Not a fan. Anytime I'd start liking it, they'd start singing again and I'd have a bad time all over again. I just need singers to actually sing the notes instead of dropping off the moment they hit it.
Downvoted by your standard thick prog/dad rock loving American. If having to listen to British albums annoys you then maybe this list isn't for you. Oh and be quiet, you are all annoyingly loud.
Does an album need to be perfect to get a 5? Because while this album is pretty dragged out in my opinion, it's still an amazing indie rock/indie pop record. Like I'm not sure what else to say, I think this is going to be a relisten for me in the near future
Enjoyed the production and creative sampling, and the different feel of this album to XX. I do like her as a vocalist and think she steps up to this more expansive style, but I think his voice worked loads better in their early more confined sound.
I didn’t really leave myself much room to manoeuvre by giving their debut 3. This didn’t really develop that sound in an interesting way for me and feels a bit disjointed.
Jamie is still carrying the other two, but in trying to reach his level they've actually regressed. While I appreciate the craft, I wanted this to be over for most of it.
I kind of hated the singing on this. It sounds like they're trying a lot harder than the first album and it rubs me up the wrong way. Production really good in places, like the drums on track 1.
Great album. Not my favourite XX album (the self-titled one gets that nod) but it’s right up there for me and happy to have this on in the background while making dinner or hosting a dinner party.
I wasn’t familiar with The xx, and although I’d seen their album *I See You* before, I hadn’t actually listened to it. In terms of their basic sound and vibe, The xx remind me a bit of the Eurythmics - in other words, *I See You* isn’t half bad for an electronica album. The “trick” here, as there, is the use of real instruments, which simply make everything sound more alive. Add to that Romy, a singer who strikes a good balance between emotion and control (and in this respect, too, reminds me of Annie Lennox). Did I actually like an electronica album? I have to admit that after the rather weak start with “Dangerous,” there’s quite a lot of good stuff to follow. It’s not exactly my new favorite album (it’s too quiet for that, and the concept doesn’t work with more drive - see “Dangerous”), but it’s a very pleasant surprise.
As a gateway into a particularly appealing form of electronic pop with terrific vocal performances, you’d be hard pressed to argue that the xx doesn’t belong on the short list. Olive Sim and Romy Madley Croft’s vocal melodies highlight Jamie Smith’s danceable soundscapes making this record thoroughly enjoyable. Not all songs work perfectly but they all have something to say. Say Something Loving, On Hold and I Dare You are the standouts for me. 4/5
Jamais écouté avant. Quelques morceaux assez accrocheurs, ambiance dance mélancolique, ne suffisent pas à effacer l'impression d'un album mesuré au millimètre, calibré et lissé à l'extrême, où chaque beat, chaque ligne de basse, chaque nappe de synthé, chaque harmonie vocale, est exactement là où il doit être, dans les cases prévues à cet effet. Résultat : toutes les émotions sont stérilisées et on s'ennuie ferme. Franchement dommage, d'autant que la production impeccable et les quelques fulgurances pop laissent penser qu'en prenant plus de risques, en lâchant les rênes, il y aurait des choses à faire... Top : Lips Flop : Brave for You
вау. скучно
What a pleasant surprise it was to see a The XX album (from 2017?!!!) and it’s thrown my listening schedule into disarray. Talk about a unique sound. Who else has produced such moody music, and can replicate the vocals of Romy and and Olly Sim? Some of their tracks can be a slight dud, but the power of the others (want to be on a road trip screaming Dare You) definitely overcompensate. And even then, this is an album I’ve overlooked from them.
"I See You" has many many lyrics, but absolutely nothing to say - a descent into generic indie pop shit. While the xx's first record was not earth shattering, it at least played with the electronics a bit more and didn't sound entirely like lovesick duets. As mentioned, this album (outside of Performance and the sampled bits of On Hold) reeks of copy/paste late 00s, early 10s indie pop - look no further than the horrible track I Dare You which sounds like kings of leon (the most talentless shitstain of a band on gods green earth). Really grating on the ears and pandering. 1/5
músicas que tocariam na renner
If you're gonna write shit like this, you'd better be Cindy Lauper. Or at least Madonna.
Lame.
I really liked their first record which would have made a better addition to this list. With that said, there are a handful of strong songs here but also too many that are decent but fade into the background. This has a stronger dance feel which seems to be where Jamie XX true passion lies. Replica and On Hold are probably the best tracks here.
2/5 - I could not recall one thing from this. Why is this here?
из легендарного 2017 с душой. в свое время как-то не обратил внимание на сей шедевр
I don’t really know what to do here. How does one be unbiased when they just don’t like the type of music they are hearing? Vocally weak but fitting for the type of music. The music has glimpses of dancehall beats and it definitely leaves the door open for remixes to bring life to some of these stale songs. Am I comparing this to the Black Eyed Peas? These guys lose Pet Shop Boys? These guys lose Armon Van Helding? Tie or whatever his name is Wet Wet Wet? Is that a band? Either way, these guys win. It’s just….this album….and being selected for this list….i just….i don’t….. it’s meh
A solid album, start to finish. I especially liked Say Something Loving. Nothing that I wouldn't want to hear again. 4 "consistently great singing" stars.
Meh, kinda pop drivel.
Great vocals and nice easy music!
Yeah, I mean, honestly, I have no idea why this on the list. Their first album is the only one I would ever consider essential listening. It's fine. It's rich and lush, Romy probably sounds at her best here but this doesn't compare to the rest of the list. This was a great album for 2017, not much else.
Some albums that came out within a year of "I See You" by The xx that were not included on this list, and are much more deserving: 22, A Million - Bon Iver Lemonade - Beyonce Blonde - Frank Ocean Damn - Kendrick Lamar Flower Boy - Tyler, the Creator Obviously, it's hard to get a sense of what music is important or worthwhile in the moment, but this album sounds dated now, and it hasn't even been 10 years since its release. I believe music like "I See You" will be the "Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree" of the 2010s—doomed to be remembered as an apt representative of the tackiest of its era.
Great vocals and cool beats. Reminds me of 80s New Wave but with a newer sound.
First album was great. More of the same here. No evolution. A bit dull
2/5
They've been popular for so long, and I even dated a girl who had previously dated one of the singers, and STILL this is the first time I've actually listened to the xx. Or perhaps not, because it's not the most memorable music. Has the potential to be really great but sort of misses every opportunity to be exciting :(
Utterly inoffensive, perfectly pleasant but not very interesting. A generous 3.
Didn't finish but seemed soulless. Terrible lyrics
I like every album this band put out. Good vibes.
Forgot how much I love On Hold!
I remember liking their debut album when it came out. This is pretty enjoyable as well. Love the vocals.
From other music I've heard from The xx I was expecting better than this.
Sunku vertinti. Viena man patiko, bet visos kitos išvis nepalieka jokio įspūdžio, onet blogo.
Not that interesting actually, ⭐⭐⭐
Catchy techno-adjacent dance-y with a slight trip-hop bent. Singers Romy and Oliver tag-team with soulful vocals, and steer it a bit toward house and adult-contemporary. One or two songs get a little annoying.
Relaxed with a bit of pump. Nice experience.
They tricked me again I liked this one better than the first album we had from them, I thought the first song on the album was actually good and almost made me forget what I hated about them. I think the vocals have a bit more energy put into them this time, they’re pretty pleasant for the most part. I Dare You is also alright, have definitely heard that one before and is probably better than any track on the first album. After the high of that first track, they go back to their old tricks of whispering softly, not taking any musical risks, and just being the La Croix of modern pop. It’s just so boring, feels more like the music they’d have playing in a shopping center or apple commercial than something they intended people to listen to. I’m more upset that I actually got my hopes up and thought they turned a corner Again it’s still not as bad as I remember them being, and maybe I was a little too harsh in my initial review, but this is absolutely not my kinda music. Pretty certain this will be my final time listening to these people by choice
I would kind of vibe with it and then get that overwhelming feeling that this would play in a Macy's
I like this album and hate this album. I love how it sounds, but there are moments where I just despise how it sounds. I’m so torn on how I feel about this album that it just has to be given a 3.
Again The XX is not really my type of music but it is an enjoyable listen. The soul sounds of the music provide a a smooth backdrop for both singers. Their harmonies and interplay back and forth on the songs makes the album a cut above other soul albums. Loved the lyrics on many of the songs but the music wasn’t that engaging to keep me occupied and the song became forgettable. Overall I liked it, but how many times I would listen to this album is likely very low.
Not in my edition of the book! 2017. 2 stars Pleasant but instantly forgettable electro-indie pop. No idea why this is on the list?
This one just existed.
When I heard the first few beats, my immediate impression was 2 pushing 1. But this was better than that. Kind of reminds me of Everything But The Girl where it sounds like dance/club music at first, but it goes deeper than that. It's solid music with a club veneer rather than club music with lyrics. Wasn't love but still a pleasant surprise.
When this came out it wasn’t my favorite. I am a little surprised to see it here, but it is British so… The thing is, it’s actually grown on me. Maybe I am just nostalgic for the feeling of this time, but I found myself really getting into this album. So 4 it is. My cheerleading continues. Boolean: yes, actually very glad to hear and hear again before I die.
Not for me
The xx passed me by a little bit, think I've said before that I dont think their quiet sparse sound is the best option for that sort of thing. This album must be a later one I'd reckon as there is a bit more going on, which is a potential straight situation when your whole thing is not having much going on. Was very listenable, first track particularly came together quite nicely. Unlikely to return to it mind.
I bought into this album a lot more than the previous xx one, some years back. Dreamy, relaxing, and then sometimes diverting. Lips and Performance were my favourite tracks. I had a surprisingly pleasant listen.
Knew what to expect going into this after their last album, which incidentally has grown on me since my first listen. Don't think this is quite as good, but still a good listen. Recognised "on hold" but the rest was new to me. Somewhere around 3.5
1.7
Yes, the second "The xx" album. Surely when you think of the totality of all music ever written, you would have to include TWO ALBUMS FROM THE XX. SURELY THEIR TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN RELEASE IS ONE OF THE THOUSAND MOST IMPORTANT PIECES OF ARTISTIC EXPRESSION EVER RELEASED IN THE HISTORY OF HUMANKIND. YES THIS IS A VIABLE INCLUSION AND WE ARE RICHER FOR HAVING HEARD THIS MASTERWORK OF PURE DIVINE INSPIRATION. I am in a Kia dealership. I am about to sign a 9.8% APR financing deal on a brand new Kia Soul. The engine will wheeze it's final breath in 11 months, but I will be paying 620 dollars a month until 2024. "Dangerous" plays through a static-y speaker as I sign the papers. Signatures of resignation. As the boxy, poor decision lurches off the lot, I can't remember a fucking thing about that song because it occurred to me as dealership background noise. Much in the same vein as clicking pens, dry coughs, and muffled torque wrenches. What I won't forget; however, is the poor gas kilometrage I get in this bad boy and the embarrassed looks I get from cringing passerbys. I miss my PT Cruiser. 0 HIGHLIGHTS: Brain Damage-amage-amage
The XX - a band beaming in from a different dimension! The first album was a solid 5 stars, but this feels a little bit like a faded copy, similar but less ambitious Its now more like dinner party background music, which is just fine, but less satifying for a closer listen in headphones
I’m 16 albums in to this now and yet another album I have to ask the question, why do I need to listen to this before I die? Can think of some artists poorer albums that are better than most on here I’ve reviewed so far. Not a dig at the site, I know it’s created from the book. It’s just filler music, it has no substance or weight, the lyrics are garbage and make little sense It’s instantly forgettable
I stopped paying attention 15 seconds in and then came back and thought the same song is playing
Immaculate production, mid songwriting
It's fine trancey, melodic EDM. A few good songs, but overall kind of disappointing. It doesn't really blaze new ground or even refine upon 90's and early '00's electronica. Not as good despite having more powerful production tools. Interestingly, the tracks I liked the best ("Performance") were the ones that set aside the MIDI instrumentation and used physical strings to create the sounds that were then processed. That sounded cool and was a more unique sound that would have been prohibitive with earlier tools. But... it still falls behind other contemporary bands like Glass Animals.
Wow c'était archi nul.
Pablum is the word that comes to mind for the vast majority of this album. Ground down to the simplest easiest to digest basic pop music. However, the final track Test Me absolutely saved it. That was quite good.
Standouts Dangerous Performance
None of the songs stood out. Decent indie/electronic. Appreciate the mixed vocals. Couldn't tell if any "hits" came off this album.
I See You is essentially a pop record with its themes and production. It's not ultra-hyped, glossy pop juiced with synthetic hormones in order to appeal to the tween market, but it's still pop. The arrangements and presentation have opened up to hail the listener in a particular way that signals a desire to connect. That is, if records can be said to have desires, and I think they can. This album wants to communicate its feelings. It wants you to know things about it. It lets you know it sees you because it wants you to hear it. Tracks off this album can be played in cocktail bars and chill clubs without losing the mood. Not strong enough to tip the scales of my own personal preferences, but not a crime against my ears either.
It wasn't in my book...but dayum was it great.
Never got around to this one before. I love the debut by The xx and was expecting to enjoy this. Unfortunately it didn’t hit me on my first listen. I’m very happy I gave it another go. Dangerous, Lips and Replica were great but On Hold blew me away. Amazing album. For sure I’ll be looking for vinyl
Listening session: may 9th, while cleaning Listened to before: no Thoughts: this was just boring, not something that belongs on this list in my opinion Favourite track: On Hold
Not my fave xx album but good
Kind of boring
Nicer groove
dreg
Nah man this is boring. I thought about giving this a 3 but there’s just way too many people in this genre that prove to me I don’t have to convince myself that this album is good. It is not good. It is boring. And derivative as fuck.
ja is ok. bissi langweilig. 2/5
Bangers maar niet xx
Yllättävä musatyyli, mitä lie hienommalta nimeltään mutta olkoon nyt sitten indie poppia. Ehkä vielä yllättävämmin pidin tästä kovasti! Pitää kuunnella joku kerta kuulokkeilla. Hyviä biisejä, iso äänimaisema pienellä bändillä. Mielenkiintoinen, tunnelmallinen. 4/5
this is THE xx album, the first on here does not even compare
I mean, it is not like it is unbearably bad, and maybe it would be worth the list if was released 30 years before, but it really doesn't make sense in this context. 6/10
I found this pretty bland. Just not my kind of thing.
This is #day634 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… we're still talking about albums you must hear before you die, right? I kind of understand the band's debut being on the list, as it was in the spotlight in the late '00s indie/electronic scene. Still, I find its inclusion questionable. But having to hear another one? I mean… The formula isn't holding up here. It all just blends into one characterless nothing. This is a 1 out of 5. Looking forward to #day635.
The most energetic piece of the XX's oeuvre, which isn't saying all that much considering how low-key their output is. At least this one has honest-to-God rhythms on it! The interplay between both singers is one of the strongest points of this album. It functions almost as a core feature of the individual songs and their themes rather than a background elements that it was on the previous 2 releases. The hidden details in production also move this album in a more unconventional direction without losing the accessible indie pop sound the XX built themselves on. Of course, this album has the usual XX issue of not generating enough energy to kick the songs into the next gear and make them true standouts in the indie pop realm. It's especially true in the second half, which is where the bulk of the slower (than usual) balladry is stored. The album would really benefit from them being spaced out in this regard. With all of that said, this is still a solid consistent album nonetheless, one that I can confidently say is the best album in the XX's catalogue. Key Tracks: Dangerous, Say Something Loving, A Violent Noise, I Dare You
Opaco, da sueño
Not my style. It doesn't hurt either.
Interesting record. Not my style and probably nothing I would seek out, but I can see the appeal
This is very plain. I don't see myself listening to it again.
Very enjoyable and unfortunately for other albums, this artist has some bias working for them
Review - this album is nowhere near as good as their debut. Maybe the production was wearing a bit thin, or it's just that the juxtaposition of their calm quiet voices and the increasingly bombastic production was a bit much for me, but stylistically I just found it didn't work for me as well as their debut does. Some good songs here and there but a lot of forgettable songs. Just have their debut on the list. Rating - 4.5/10 Need to hear? NO
Well somebody made some money and bought some new toys. This band’s debut album was on heavy rotation in my house when it was first released. I loved the simple but effective production touches that dressed up the clean guitar lines. The melodies were beautiful and catchy. There was a sparseness, a use of silence to create drama and longing that underpinned the sexually charged vocals. When I started this album I was afraid they had lost there way and honestly I think Dangerous is just a mistake despite them obviously being proud enough to start the album with it. Similarly I could dismiss the next two songs though they’re fine enough. However with A Violent Noise and the aching Performance the album takes a remarkable turn. They suddenly rediscover what makes them great. The drama, the sexiness, and the compelling interplay of loud/quiet, noise and silence return to their palette, and the rest is incredible. I had to listen to it twice just to be sure I liked it as much as I did. Their sound has grown and they have a lot of tools at their disposal. Interested to listen to the album between this and the debut and to see where they go in the future.
Well produced album with a collection of songs I found fairly forgettable.