Tellin’ Stories by The Charlatans

Tellin’ Stories

The Charlatans

2.94
Rating
23514
Votes
1
5%
2
24%
3
47%
4
19%
5
5%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 8)

Late 90s Britpop. Very standard fare.

There are at least 3 Charlatan albums I like more than this with “Some Friendly’ being their best album by far. However, I love them and can listen to this all day.

Great Britpop

not as good as i expected tho. i liked the simpsons reference

Old school cool

Výborný album. 4,5*, bavil ma od začiatku do konca. Skvelá atmosféra 90. rokov.

Lackluster vocals let this fade into the background which wasn’t the worst thing.

It was just OK for me.

2.8 just a b side oasis

Incredibly generic britpop. Why would I listen to this when I could just listen to the Stone Roses? Some OK tunes on this but most of this fell pretty flat for me.

Oasis but worse?

Sounds like four british boys with identical haircuts and outfits in a white void

Yet another subpar Britpop album. Don’t care for this at all. Uninspired Oasis knockoff.

Jak ścieżka dźwiękowa serialu dla nastolatków tamtych czasów. Wpada w ucho, ale nie jest specjalnie ambitna. Skoro Smashing Pumpkins dałam 6.5/10 równane w dół to tu nie mogę dać więcej. Chyba nawet dam 6/10, pomimo całej mojej sympatii do takiego grania.

Another bland Britpop. The music is alright, but it had absolutely no impact on me. I can barely remember a thing about this album right after finishing it Favorite Track - With No Shoes Least Favorite Track - Rob's Theme ⭐️⭐️

Catch up #11 October 20 2026 I was expecting another typical 90s britpop album in the vein of Oasis, and that’s exactly what I got. Not great, not terrible. Also not a total waste of time. The perfect 3/5. ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Veel beter dan verwacht. Relaxed maar toch goed

Tip: doe alleen swasi met al je vijf fingers om de score te bepalen, als je niet al een tekstuele review hebt geschreven. Je loopt de kans dat je score niet overeenkomt met je tekst.

fine. forgettable for sure

Really liked this one, they definitely sound a lot like the Stone Roses, real strong Madchester sound. Pretty consistent all the way through

Hubo varias canciones q me gustaron

More Brit pop/rock. Inferior version of Oasis.

Best Track - "How High"

While I didn’t love it, I am surprised I enjoyed this one a decent amount. I see Brit Pop and I just ready myself for disappointment, but it wasn’t a bad album at all. 3.25 / 5

It's alright. I can see why people like. Singer sounds like Noel Gallagher. Mid - I'll give it as most on this list a 3

Not too bad.

At its worst genetic sounding BritPop - at its best the better of the generic BritPop?

Very similar to Oasis. But on some of the song here that’s not a criticism. Some catchy tracks like North Country Boy and One to Another. Will be back for more listens

Again very much a lesser Britpop band. Fairly boring and validates my decision to fast forward through them on Jools Holland over the years.

A descent album, but personally I prefer the bouncier Madchester sound of their debut, Some Friendly. Any song off that one plays, you instantly know it's The Charlatans. This one, while by no means bad, just isn't as instantly catchy and unique.

Wait ... are these the cousins of Oasis!? More 90s recycled drek!

Already knew from the apostrophe in the title that this wasn’t going to blow me away. It’s discount oasis but I can only be so mad at a band that fills me with that good old new labour naive optimism.

It's good. These guys sound like Oasis; or does Oasis sound like them?

Impossible not to hear the Oasis comparisons, though not familiar enough with The Charlatans catalog to know if that was developed after Oasis hit it big, or if these guys actually influenced them. Either way, a pretty good album.

First listen

Me sonó a pop rock, con algunos toques estilo Oasis.

We need to abolish Britpop

Too similar to Oasis

Me hizo acordar un montón a Oasis. Me gustó pero no me voló la cabeza

I guess it's a good example of that kind of motown/northern soul influenced strain of britpop that they do. Kind of sounds like a perkier version of late oasis. There's nothing inherently wrong with it, but none of the songs made me feel anything and I didn't feel any differently when it finished

Surprisingly good!!

Not exciting but not terrible.

Bizarro world Oasis comin in hot

Fauxasis, ongeïnspireerd en beter door anderen

empezo a sonar y ya me sentía en inglaterra en 1997. las vibes immaculate

A pretty disappointing set of Oasis b-sides. The Charlatans are at their best when they're working a funky Madchester organ groove, so I guess it makes sense this is their first album after their keyboardist died. Take it off the list, add Some Friendly.

Man, I love Inspiral Carpets. 4/5

Pre-Listening Notes This list has quite a number of British bands that an average American wouldn't know. That can be good, but it can also lead to albums that have a questionable presence on this list compared to other albums that have critical acclaim and popularity when they came out, that missed the cut. I think of Lady Gaga's The Fame, Ramones' Rocket to Russia, and [insert your favorite example here]. I will say that replacing your keyboardist with the keyboardist from Primal Scream is a baller move. Post-Listening Notes Much more madchester sounding than the britpop I was reading about, in no doubt to Rob Collins's contribution to Tellin' Stories. That and the jammier sections in songs like Get On It, Only Teething and Area 51 (personal favorite on the album). Puts the album in a nice groove, especially from their signature track One to Another. It sounds mad familiar to me but I can't picture from where, especially that keyboard intro. The parts I don't like: North Country Boy is kind of what I thought the whole album would sound like, which to me would be that britpop dullness that this list gets good criticism for. Or maybe I just don't care for Oasis and for bands to sound like that when you're in (checks notes) 1997 when OK Computer and Urban Hymns came out. Tough competition. You're A Big Girl Now is simply not good and Only Teething takes a little too long to be a good song, with the best parts at the end and fading out. Overall, Tellin' Stories seems like a semi-important album for music in the UK and some parts of Europe. Maybe I'm too critical about its placement for how important the Madchester scene was. As much as I like to learn music and music history, that part is a bit of a blind spot to me other than the biggest names a yank like me would know (Primal Scream/Stone Roses). Madchester certainly deserves more spots on this list than the overly represented nu metal (we're lumping Kid Rock on that too even though he was more country than metal but it helps my narrative damn it). Tellin' Stories is underrated, and with the aforementioned really big albums that came out in 1997, easy to be overshadowed. Other than that, ladies and gentleman and benevolently powerful queer people we have another random British band that I didn't know about until this selection that gets a 4 ranking!!!!

More generic Britpop. This list has way too many of these albums. Almost all of them are the same. It's ok, I have no problem listening to it, but it doesn't really register.

If you can’t afford the name brand this basically tastes the same with only a slight chemical after taste

They sound comfortable jumping on the britpop train but it’s bland. I don’t like this even as much as sneered-at landfill britpop like Shed Seven’s Maximum High. Indie disco standout is One To Another

This felt like the late nineties.

Eine solide, aber unspektakuläre Platte. Tellin’ Stories wirkt wie ein Album, das genau weiß, was es kann – und was nicht. Die Mischung aus Britpop‑Schimmer und leicht psychedelischem Groove funktioniert, doch selten entsteht echter Sog. Die stärksten Momente blitzen auf, wenn die Band Tempo und Melodie mutiger anzieht, aber vieles bleibt im sicheren Mittelfeld hängen.

WOWIE! This is like Oasis meets the War on Drugs. I wonder if it inspired so much of what came after it, or if it was inspired by that stuff? This is damn good music.

Never really given them much of a listen before, but a central part of the 90s British music scene. A little different than I was expecting from the first track; a bit more grit and edginess. Ah spoke too soon. After this opener, it maybe drops off a bit to more of the Britpop/indie I was expecting. Ahhh and the classic ‘One to Another’ - nice. It’s a pleasant enough album and representation of the madchester time and scene, but nowhere near Oasis standard and don’t think I’ll come back anytime soon. (3.5)

A bit too much Britpop for me.

Very standard Britpop of the 90s, no idea why this was included in this list.

This was tough to get through. Value brand Oasis.

It was fine.

This sucked

Fake Oasis

This album is the sorta album I listen to an expect there'll be a hit to make it make sense that it's a one hit wonder album. to my surprise, there wasn't a hit on here. i question why it's on the list. but i did enjoy it!

You wouldn't be surprised to know that these guys were the supporting act for Oasis. This album is just an inoffensive Britpop album that is fine, but nothing particularly special or genre-defining.

I've never heard of this band before, so I have no idea what to expect from this album. • With No Shoes is a good opening track, I dig the guitar work. Some of the lines feel pretty Led Zeppelin-esque • I liked North Country Boy, it's energetic and doesn't plod along at any point. I really like the organ throughout the song • The title track is a bit of a step down in intensity, but it still sounds nice. The chord progression feels like a credits song • I really like the piano throughout One To Another • I'm really vibing with Area 51, it's a very cool instrumental • Only Teethin' is also good, I've enjoyed the majority of this album so far I quite liked this album, I thought it was a solid listen all the way through. I don't understand why it has a 2.9 rating here, I'd put it in the upper ranks of the albums I've listened to so far. The instrumentals definitely stole the show, to the point that I was often listening out for them over the vocals, but that's definitely not a bad thing. None of the songs stood out to me as being bad, but I definitely had my favourites. A really solid listen in my opinion. Favourite song: North Country Boy

I remember going to indie clubs back in the day and there were so many dudes trying to look like Tim Burgess. I kind of think that’s part of the reason the Charlatans stood out from the crowd. They had a couple of bangers but generally I have to go with mid

It was nice background noise, but like above average. I'm torn, I'll say a 3/5 but it's very close.

Has some good moments amongst the inoffensive.

This isn't a bad album, but it's not really remarkable in any way; it's just sort of there. It all sounds like stuff we've heard before from more talented artists only blander. The vibes are alright so I guess it's passable background music but there's very little to grab your attention here; just more upbeat pop rock with nothing to say. It's a bit of a shame that the author of the list's clear anglocentrism led to him including serviceable but not particularly noteworthy or impactful albums like this over more interesting left field picks. It is what it is though.

There's just no justification for two Charlatans albums on a list like this, and my choice is easily Some Friendly. By 1997 the band is technically improved. And they are recorded beautifully; the tracks are clear and lush. But, to my ears, this creates problems. 1) The lead instrument - the centerpiece of the sound - is not good. Technically, lyrically, and for me stylistically, Burgiss' significant musical weakness is exposed by the improvement everywhere around him. This exposure is heightened by the lack of Rob Collins' insistent Hammond blasts. The best parts of this album are instrumental. 2) Like many bands, as they got technically better, they accidentally swept away the pixie dust. There was something magical in the shambolic we're-not-exactly-sure-what-we're-doing-but-we're-going-for-it spirit that imbued Some Friendly. Here, by contrast, they sound like they're clenched tight - being very careful to play everything as well as they can. Ironically, something special goes missing. And, like I mentioned, someone special and really important to the overall vibe, WAS missing.

Relatively mid which is par for music of this genre and era. Not offensive, not necessarily fun, not really challenging, and not particularly political. It just is. 3/5

Al escuchar los primeros tracks pensé que iba a estar increíble, pero la verdad no. No está mal ni de lejos, pero pintaba para ser un trancazo. En general buenas canciones pero creo que había más potencial que lo que tuvimos aquí.

Me lembrou um pouco Oasis. Foi gostosinho de ouvir, por pouco não me chamou mais atenção, quase chegou no 4, mas vou manter no 3. Gostei do violãozinho deles, algumas vezes parecia Bob Dylan.

It sounds nice on the surface, but I have played it 4 times and hardly even noticed. No substance, nothing special, just quality mimicking.

Pretty alright 90's British alt rock. Aside from the banger that is One to Another, not too special though. Faves: One to Another, You're a Big Girl Now

First time listening to this. Yes, obviously very Oasis-like, but I like Oasis, so cool. Real good record.

I didn’t realize how many of these 90s Britpop rock bands there were. I always just thought it was Oasis. It certainly sounds very much like a take on Oasis. Early on and it’s fine. This kind of music is always an easy listen and pleasant, but sometimes struggles to find anything distinct about it. There’s a generic quality to it. But it’s still catchy at times and there’s some good songs. I think it kind of slows down after the first few songs as it’s hard to hear much variety in it. Nothing is really a banger type song that grabs your attention, even if it’s all fine. I think the first 4 tracks are the best, and then I liked Only Teethin on the back half of the album. I don’t dislike any of this, but it seems generic so I think I’ll go a 2. Debating up to a 3 because it’s all just fine. But not sure it deserves a spot on a list like this.

Dime store Oasis.

Really good rock!

Slightly better than some of the britpop slog I have gone through 3/5

If this album was a sandwich it’d be a single slice of dry turkey on white bread with dollar store mayo

This album falls somewhere between Madchester and Britpop, with some solid guitar work and an oddly affected vocal style from lead singer Tim Burgess evidently heavily influenced by Bob Dylan. The recording was overshadowed by the death of keyboard player Rob Collins in a car crash when he was driving back from the pub with twice the legal limit of alcohol in his bloodstream and not wearing a seat belt. Reading the wiki article about this gives the impression that Collins wasn’t getting on with the rest of the band up to this point, but somehow they pulled together after his death and salvaged this record by patching together things that already been recorded with help from Martin Duffy from Primal Scream to cover the rest. The final track is supposed to be a tribute to Collins featuring a recording of his voice as a child, but it sort of meanders and fades out. The end result is mostly OK - three stars I guess, but not one I’d bother revisiting

Oasisish. I enjoyed this, but I'd rather listen to Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. 3/5.

2/5. Though I agree that Brit-Pop is a bit over-represented on the 1,001 albums list, I do also believe that people tend to be way too harsh on the Brit-Pop albums on here as a result of that. A lot of great albums did come from that movement. This Charlatans album is not one of them. It feels like a Brit-pop album designed through a paint by the numbers book. Also not helping things is the vocals which are at the best of times just okay and at the worst actively grating. I didn’t hate it enough for a 1 star, but there really isn’t anything here I’d see myself returning to.

Pretty good Brit pop album

cool, but it is kind a type of Oasis, and I'm not a big fan. TODAY'S BIRD: Bobolink

Another boring soft rock britpop album. There are at least a dozen other albums on this list that do the same thing better, and most of them earlier, as well. This album has absolutely no reason to be here.

A perfectly good Britpop album. But it's not Oasis, it's not Blur, it's not Suede, or Pulp, or even the Verve. Very much of it's time and thats okay, but it just doesn't wow me like the other Britpop bands managed to.

I got nothing out of this album

I really have nothing negative to say about this album. I got HUGE Oasis vibes from it. Very very solid all around and there wasn't a track on here that I disliked. Top tracks: With No Shoes, North Country Boy, Only Teething, Get On It

Can't say that I've heard of the Charlatans before this but I found myself enjoying this one quite a bit. It's not the best or most interesting britpop album I've heard, but it's a solid and rewarding listen.

I actually dug this a fair bit but it is so funny that this is on the list. It's just a pretty good BritPop album with a sad story attached to it (bandmate died mid-production). I know this entry is just me kvetching about the list but it is funny to see some of these entries and realize that the writers of the list were just putting their chips down on a handful of their favorite contemporary albums in the hope that they'd be canonized a decade or two later and they could boast that they were first on the scene. That is assuredly what is going on here lol. This is a reliable mix of good BritPop progressions with some more directly psychedelia influenced stuff, reminiscent of Brian Jonestown Massacre or Dandy Warhols. Certainly in conversation with them. Liked this basically immediately, in part because it was so familiar. Favorite Tracks: With No Shoes, One To Another, Get On it, Rob's Theme

This was so disappointing. The lyrics are nonsensical at times, the vocals are grating, some of the songs are too long, the music is bland and even they try to inject a bit of energy, the whole vibe just feels cringy. Their first album was decent and the second album (Between 10th and 11th) is very good. Much better than this reductive drivel. It’s not complete rubbish and it’s not actively irritating, but they have done so much better than this.

low 3.5 Tem algumas músicas boas, especialmente os singles, mas tudo soa um pouco parecido demais e dura mais do que o necessário.

really enjoyed this album!

Tough. Does nostalgia win out or objective reality? Nostalgia says 5/5. This is my eta. Objective reality is more like a 3. Some good songs but if I'd never heard this before I wouldn't go racing off to hear more.

Imagine wanting to be Oasis man. Even Oasis don't wannabe Oasis. Its fine.

Pretty bland, inoffensive Britpop. Nothing special.

Sixteen-year-old me would be giving this 6/5 and the 44-year-old version still has a finger hovering over a fifth, but I guess we've grown up, if only a little, since then. I still bloody love it, with One To Another an absolute all-timer for me and so much else on here besides despite the sad circumstances of its recording. Too big for its own boots, the sound almost splits at the seams at times - maybe it would have benefitted from tighter production, maybe it's just right the way it is given its flaws are some of my favourite things about it.

Why is everything on this list from the mid/late nineties Brit pop? Ugh. I can think of plenty of albums from that era that aren’t that are at least listenable. I try not to judge an album by its cover, but I knew exactly what dredge I was in for as soon as I saw this one without even knowing the charlatans. This is nothing more than discount Oasis. Which, given the fact that listening to Oasis makes me want to punch a Gallagher in the face. The only redeemable tracks are the instrumentals because I didn’t have to hear that nasally, whiney vocal that characterizes every Brit pop band.

1. Never heard of any of this at all. Okay, we're off too a good start. Okay this is an oasis knock off god bless but we know who did it better.I mean i like it, but only cuz it sounds like oasis. Is this what all rock bands from the uk sounded like in the 90s? I have no idea. 2. yeah, this one's nice. 3. this one's nice too 4. Yeah i'm sorry but i'd rather just be listening to oasis. 5. God forgive me but i think im just gonna give up and go listen to oasis.

Blind album and artist. Some cool tracks I guess...?

Great album The start was incredible but it got more disappointing sadly

It's just part of knowing where you come from, being human Singing love songs can begin to fill your day Excellent record. Charlatans were on a storming run around this time.

I listened to this a while ago (and am only writing the review weeks/months later). I remember getting the whole britpop vibe from it. I want to say weak guitars, but a good amount of sporadic moments. Still, didn't stay with me... 3 Stars.

This is like being a British school kid at the start of the soccer World Cup. David Beckham is at the peak of his powers and he has a sweet mohawk hairdo. You get the same cut, thinking you’ll stun everyone at school with how cool you are. However you get to school the next day and everyone has the same haircut. Because you’re English, you whinge about it. And England loses the World Cup too, because they suck.

Opens up with an Oasis meets U2 style track. I didn't mind it, despite the excessive use of wah throughout. Bit after that they had some kinda country style song, and tuen another change up. It didnt really all gel together and they sounded too much like they were trying to replicate the sound of the time. Not bad, but not great.

If Blur's Parklife is in the conversation for greatest Britpop album of all time, this one should be too – it's every bit as good. While there's not a track I loved as much as "Girls & Boys" on Tellin' Stories, I found the LP to be more consistent and its slightly shorter runtime makes the prospect of listening to it again a bit more enticing. Like Parklife, I wrestled with giving it three or four stars – at the end of the day, it just didn't quite reach that level for me. Highlights: With No Shoes, One to Another, Area 51, How High, Only Teethin', Get on It

This was an interesting listen. The influences are indeed varied, though probably not as impactful as it is on paper. Britpop, hip-hop soul and rock sounds far fetched, but it eventually sits together as their own sound, I think. Hip hop might still be far fetched. It's a bit mainstream for my tastes, maybe too Americana influences, but there's a lot happening on the instrumental tracks. I must have heard the album 5 or 6 times and EVERY SINGLE TIME I'd take a peek at the tracklist as Area 51 played. Something special, feels a bit better than everything else. 2.9/5

2,5 - niet mijn genre

A goood album. Just not for me. Sounds like other albums that came out during this time.

funky and upbeat.

This list has introduced me to so many good Brit-rock groups, that I can correctly identify this group as average at best.

top 3 - With No Shoes, Tellin’ Stories, How Can You Leave Us. It’s alright, might need to give another listen.

Not bad oasis impression

Had a few distracted listens. Didn’t love it, didn’t hate it. Will try and have a more serious listen soon. Obviously there’s an Oasis vibe about the whole thing and I like most of Oasis’ stuff so I’m hoping a few more listens will give me more appreciation.

Terrible. Not a catchy song in the bunch. Uninspired and unoriginal. They sound like Oasis wannabe's, even though they came first. 1.5

I expected much less, but this was quite nice.

Damn, that keyboard/guitar riff on "One to Another" is like pure heroine. RIP Rob Collins - bad way to go. This was my introduction to the Charlatans... very Oasis-coded. But I dig it. Strong storytelling, crisp production, excellent musicianship.

2.5 rounded up. Inoffensive but also unremarkable

Feels like a mishmash of 90s rock subgenres, not really my thing

An enjoyable 2.5 star kind of thing

Look, this album is absolutely fine. There’s very little wrong with it. It was big at the time. I have no beef with The Charlatans… but this being an album I should listen to BEFORE I DIE? 🥴

It gets an extra star because I like One to Another. Everything else was bland.

Great guitar!

This album transported me back to a simpler time, it was a great album and just made me want to listen to more Alt Rock, after this album I went on a weezer binge

Y'all aren't gonna believe it, but this... Sounds like 90s BritPop Rock.

The first song made me worried this would be some Britpoprock trash. "North Country Boy" is a better song, though, and renewed my hope that this album wouldn't be a miserable listen. It definitely grew on me as I listened, and it helped quite a bit that the songs are all pretty varied, pulling from a few different genres/styles. It's still Britpoprock, but it's not really trash. I don't really have anything particular to say about this one. It's solid. Very British, but not bad. Favorite Song(s): Tellin' Stories

An often overlooked gem of 90s British indie that links together the Stone Roses with Britpop

Groupe inconnu. L'album commence sur un morceau dynamique assez accrocheur, mais malheureusement ne se poursuit pas sur le même rythme. J'ai trouvé les morceaux suivants inutilement longs, et j'ai fini par m'ennuyer. Pas de seconde écoute envisagée. =>2/5

Tellin' Stories is excellent Brit-pop, but I'm just not into the genre. It's not that I don't find the sound appealing, but it is terribly limited. So many of the songs on this album sound so similar to so many of the songs on other albums. That said, this is a very good exemplar of the genre. There are only two or three tracks on this album that stood out in any way, and those are the songs that most prominently relied on acoustic guitar rather than that samey, fuzzy Brit-pop guitar. "You're a Big Girl Now" gave off some cool Faces vibes. "Only Teethin'" seemed to channel a lighter side "Sympathy for the Devil" with some decent Hammond (I'm guessing). The final standout was the pretty "Rob's Theme" instrumental tribute to the band's recently deceased keyboardist. I was paying closer attention to the track list because I was listening to the deluxe edition, and I didn't want to give this record more time than necessary. Nothing offended me, but I didn't find much to be compelling either. Three stars.

Bog standard Brit pop rock, nice but standard stuff. Not sure if groundbreaking back then, but solid

Sounds like a bad mix of oasis and the stone Roses. The vocals of the singer really started to wear on me, combined with the uninspiring music and lyrics the total package became very bland and forgettable.

As soon as the tape rolled I assumed this would be another homer choice of a 90s British band that nobody cares about except the curator. But I actually kind of liked this one. It's pretty basic garage rock, bit grungy, bit britpoppy. The singer's voice sounds intentionally nasally, like he's imitating someone imitating John Lennon, but I'll overlook it. Forgettable, probably not going to listen to it again, but it was nice enough.

Thought this was better than expected and remembered. Second half of LP really took off for me. If I could give it a more granular score would be like a 3.6 or thereabouts but I'll round up to 4.

It's not bad, but I don't think I really needed to listen to this. Very bland pop rock

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

First 4 tracks are strong, it can't be sustained but decent Britpop.

Sure why not

North Country Boy and How High are the stand out songs here but the rest is all... a bit flat.

Good bit of britpop

I’m not familiar with this band but I enjoyed their music well enough.

It's nice enough. But it really sounds like everything else.

Like it 3/5

The Charlatans. A band that was, for some reason, linked to the Madchester movement and sound, even though they were from the West Midlands. This is arguably their best album, despite the loss of Rob Collins to a car accident during recording, and even now it still sounds and feels great. Peppered with shades of the 60s, this is a good album. And while it's not entirely one I'd buy, I'm still going to give it a strong four and a half stars.

Good 90s Brit pop.

I like it when an album I love, but haven’t listened to for a while, drops on a Friday. Rather than have a brief reacquaintance over lunch, you can invite them back into your life and stay around for the weekend. This got several plays, and even another spin on the Monday morning before showing them to the door and waving goodbye! The Charlatans carved out their own special place amongst the many Britpop bands of the time, and this album was them at their very best despite the sad loss they encountered. This a classic. Strong tunes, grooves and production. Standouts are ‘One to Another’, ‘How High’, ‘Tellin’ Stories’ (great strings sweep in) and ‘Get On It’ (builds to a superb outro). An undisputed big 5 stars.

Probably my favourite Charlatans album, heavier guitars than usual, and a strong set of songs.

I enjoyed bits of this album but not enough, even with the Britpop nostalgia, to really want to listen to it again. A high 3.

Knockoff Oasis.

I genuinely don't understand why this is here. I guess some of the melodies are nice but it feels like music I'd hear at a Greene King.

Unremarkable. Not sure why this was included. Already forgot most of it.

Just another boring Britpop band!

I was all about this at first because it was 90s rock nostalgia though I didn’t know any of the songs. Then it was kind of the same thing over and over.

Middle of the road for me

Banger album. Every single song was good, with the mellow-ish melodies, good guitar and drumming, and decent singing making for a great rock album. I can be very picky about my rock, and this album just hit the spot. That said, none of the songs were close to being a great one that would make a top-rock-songs list, so I have to keep it at a high 4.

A bit to noisy for my tastes, and it felt mostly samey throughout. However, I liked the energy to it and can understand why someone would rate it higher. Favorite Track: Area 51

This was my first listen to any of The Charlatan's work, and it's been sort of centering in my understanding of the 90's Britpop scene hearing an act that seems far more influenced by the Stones and rock's blues roots than their far more overtly Beatles-indebted contemporaries like Oasis and Blur. I overall wasn't impressed with much of the first half of the album, but felt it came more into its own in the latter half, where tracks like "How Can You Leave Us" and "Get On It" grabbed far more of my attention. Overall, a solid showing, but I feel it's another example of an album that does more to highlight the value of its influences than it does make any strong statements of its own, while the contemplative songwriting and lyrics are a credit to the experience. Favorite Tracks: "How Can You Leave Us", "Get On It" Least Favorite Track: "North Country Boy"

After two consecutive listens, I don't think I could name a single distinct thing about this album. It's by no means poorly executed, but I just feel like I've heard this exact 80/90s Brit rock album 1,000 times from 100 artists. Hyperbole? Sure, but this is easily the most bored I've been listening to an album on this list. At least albums I straight up didn't like had something for me to chew on, even if it was bitter. This was just the epitome of milquetoast for me, utterly forgettable.

This is one of those albums that’s pleasant to have on even if it never really blows me away. The Charlatans sound confident and comfortable here, with a few catchy moments that remind you why they mattered in the Britpop era. At the same time, a lot of the tracks kind of blend together, and nothing hits quite as hard as you keep hoping it will. It’s a solid, easy listen, but more background-music good than life-changing good.

Never heard of this one but liked it so much!!

Great grooves. It vibes like crazy. And yet, I listened to it three times through, and it just fades into the background. Perfectly pleasant to listen to, but the songs don't stand out. I feel like they have better songs than the ones on this album. Ok, not necessarily better, but with catchy enough hooks to stand out more. It seems worth listening to it again sometime.

I’m just gonna protest the britpop slop that’s on this list. This is just a shittier version of an Oasis record. Lazy 2

Highlights: One to Another, Only Teethin', Rob's Theme Having heard only their hit The Only One I Know, the last thing I expected was to hear them imitating Oasis. And I don't really like Oasis all that much. Heck, Britpop in general (unless it's Blur). Funny how the vocalist also sometimes sounds like Bob Dylan - especially on Get On It because of the harmonica. The album overall isn't offensive to my ears, but it isn't anything special either. It's a digestible version of Oasis and that's enough since they can at moments be better than the original.

Pleasant listening throughout the day

3/5 Solid, nice groovy garage rock-ish type of album, but with higher production quality than your typical garage.

Pretty darn good

Great UK britpop/alt rock album from the late 90s which became a cult classic. They were more original than Oasis, with better songwriting and which resulted in a more compact album. One to Another stands out as a hit song. I think I slightly prefer their more psychedelic rock sound from the early 90s but this is a great album from the era. Rounded up to 4 stars .

??? "original list was made. I've still only gotten 1 jazz album on this list, but there seems to be an endless supply of late 90s to early 00s British rock bands that I have to slog through to get to good albums." britpop halt...c

Got PTSD waiting for Champagne Supernova. The Rose Bowl can go to hell

This one I like. Kind of like Oasis meets punk and part grunge.

idk wasn’t my vibe, a bit too punky

I was never really a fan. I went in feeling optimistic but nothing really stood out for me. Elevator music with lyrics.

The Charlatans by numbers. A couple of acceptable tracks but mostly way past their best. A 2.5 for me

Some iconic songs on there from my youth, but stepping back from the nostalgia it's a pretty average rock album.

Second to third line players, trying hard but not making a difference

Generic britslip

ok this was fire.

I’m a big Britpop fan but have never enjoyed the Charlatans. This time was no different. Their music just washes past me and I find nothing to latch on to. The magic from the 60s they are trying to replicate gets lost in translation while I find the other Britpop giants are able to do it successfully. Terrible what they had to go through though behind the scenes. Rating: 2.3

Less good Oasis

I've never heard any song from The Charlatans before (that I remember) and it was a nice surprise. Overall it is a great album and based on Wikipedia, it is one of their best which is a good entry point to the band.

Britpop that sounds more influenced by the Stones (and maybe some Dylan) than the Beatles, while integrating some hip-hop influenced grooves and additional neo-psychedelic elements. The band is at its best when the psychedelia is at the forefront to create a full, layered sound. Songs are well written and have good hooks and instrumental components - but there’s something about this that fails to excite me…it’s all just fine or good. Maybe it just doesn’t stand above the rest of the crowd doing similar work. An acceptable listen, but not a vital one.

Sigh... this felt like a slog to get through. Unfortunately, it just sounded like Wonderwall over and over again but in varying fonts. The opening two tracks were my favorites, with the slinky guitar in the back of the second track being the star of the show. I don't think I will remember much about this album tbh.

I Hear Our Day Is Comin' 1001 Albums Generator 210 (1/21/2025) Another piece of completely unimportant and unmemorable britpop that made the list due to its authors' biases. Seriously, I will probably forget I listened to this album in a couple months. With No Shoes and One To Another are both solid tracks, but nothing else really lives up to them. I feel like britpop (for the most part) is more of a "song" genre than an "album" genre, since most of these songs really blend together (and blend together in the greater tapestry of britpop in general as well). While there are some good moments, I find much of the album to be completely unremarkable and mid, so I guess that lands it at a 2.5/5, which I will round up to a 3. Favs: With No Shoes One To Another How High Least Fav: You're A Big Girl Now

off brand oasis

Pretty good! Reminds me of Green Day a little bit! Overall I would listen to them again!

A fun, pleasant Brit-pop album. Enjoyed it all, but it never quite punches through to sound like much more than an impression of other, better bands.

Day 161 I quite like the Charlatans and still listen to their best of album ‘melting pot’ often, always found them a fine band who never quite find their identity and instead tried to sound like whichever Manchester band was most popular at the time, sounding like Stone Roses on earlier albums and trying to be Oasis here. Still a decent enough album but nothing special Highlights How High One to Another

I like it and I can tell they took a lot of inspiration from oasis

this felt very late 90s/early 2000s movie soundtrack like. personally, i like this kind of music, however, this album didn't offer me anything new or amusing and i'll probably forget about it tommorrow. it wasn't bad though, just nothing influential in my opinion

North country boy ❤️ I pierwszy numer też super a reszta raczej forgettable

I had listened to several albums by this band many years ago, and I think it is telling that I didn’t remember any songs. This is bland, and that’s coming from someone who generally likes britpop. I guess I should revisit a couple of their other albums to see if anything reminds me of why I listened to them in the first place, but it’s not looking promising

Of all the average britpop albums on this list, this has to be the most average. Favorite track: One To Another

Inoffensive, nothing special. But the album doesn’t belong anywhere near this conversation. 2.5?

I liked this ever so slightly more than the other inessential Britpop artists I've received (Shack, Doves, etc.). They're basically Dollar General Oasis with a bit of bagginess thrown into the mix. Decent energy, a few good melodies, and certainly nothing I needed to hear before leaving this world. 3/5

dawno nie sluchalem czegos tak mialkiego jak tellin stories of szarlatanow, krazek z 97, wiec czasy gdzie muzyka czarna zaczynala byc modna dla bialego czlowieka, co slychac rowniez tutaj, bo ciekawego okreslenia na gatunek tego albumu podaje wiki, hip hop soul, pierwszy raz spotykam sie z takim okresleniem, ktore ma nazywac ciagoty do r&b, nie wiem czy samemu bym wpadl na takie okreslenie, bo bardziej pasuje mi tutaj zwyczajny britpop, ale jeszcze dziwniejsze jest, ze nie kojarze w ogole nic zwiazanego z szarlatanami, a to ich piata plyta w dyskografii z trzynastu jakie udalo sie im nagrac od 88 do czasow wspolczesnych, wiec dziwne ze zespol na tyle popularny zeby byl na mainstreamowej liscie albumikowej jakos sie mi nie przewinal, ale nic nie stracilem, przynajmniej po odsluchu tej plyty, bo zadna z historii na niej opowiedzianych nie zaciekawila, byly podane mialko, a wrecz w tak denerwujacej postaci, ze ostatni trak, robs theme, ktory okazal sie instrumentalem byl najlepszym utworem plyty, to troche niezbyt dobrze swiadczy o rokujaco popujacej bandzie, na plejke dodam tylko wspomniany trak

Enjoyed this

Big standard indie rock, perfectly fine. 2.5 rounded up.

Kinda just a stereotypical 2000's alternative band.

Solid but unspectacular

I can see myself walking out of a theatre during the credits of a mediocre British romcom while this music plays. The people in front of you aren't moving fast enough and you swear that the diet coke the person three seats down from you spilled is starting to seep into your shoes

This was a decent listen. If I were a 12 year old in the UK instead of the US in 1997, I'm sure I would have been real in to this and real nostalgic about it now.

Never heard of this band, and yet they have nearly 15 albums under their belts, most of which were successes. I'm vaguely familiar with the scene they were birthed out of, and my reaction to this album is the same as to other "Madchester" records coming out of the UK in the 80s and 90s on this list: The Stone Roses, New Order, and the Chemical Brothers to name a few standouts — I really love the blending of classic rock psychedelia with danceable grooves and incredibly catchy writing. This album definitely delivers on those fronts, and this era in general paved the way for the dance punk and IDM waves a decade later that injected intense manic energy and a more straight-forward dance sound, a favorite era of mine musically. And shout-out to Tony Wilson, co-founder of Factory Records who coined the term "Madchester." Legends saying legendary things!

I liked this album! Had a good vibe!

64/100. A solid enough Britpop record, but it kind of gets lost in the crowd. Feels like it’s telling stories you’ve already heard before, just with a slightly different accent.

8/10 consistent sound

Shite Oaais copycats

++: One to Another, Get on It +: With No Shoes, How Can You Leave Us, Only Teethin', Rob's Theme +-: North Country Boy, Tellin' Stories, You're a Big Girl Now, Area 51, How High 4,6/10

Boooring........

The last!! What a journey and perhaps fitting it ends on a brit pop album. Now what I'm going to do with myself it's over?

A good britpop record that follows the appropriate formula. I enjoyed it but will forget I listened to it by tomorrow.

A by the number Brit-pop album. Perfectly fine but nothing stood out. So why is this 3 star album getting 4 stars. This is our last album and we all got together to listen to it. Album 3, Experience 5.

It’s pretty standard britpop. But I like britpop! I wish I had heard some more of them back in the 90s. I may rated a tad higher because it’s our last album! We finished!

It's fine, I guess? I'm just really really bored

dont know

Well, somebody listened The Roses' second album + Oasis: they learned their lessons well, but not the most original sound

Uhhh ja i mean det er bare britpop litt mindre variert enn supergrass albumet men its got the riffs ykyk catchy ofc som alltid vokalisten høres ut som liam gallagher godt tegn det men jes litt kjedelig deler så uh 3/5

Reminded me of a less angry and less drunk Oasis.

Pretty safe music. Sounds like discount Oasis (makes sense, since it's from the same era and genre). The album plays it quite safe to the point where it's almost a bit generic. OK album, but not one I'd play again soon. 5 / 10.

YEAH I loved this. Only Teething and Get On It were my favorites.

Un énième album de britpop mais cela reste sympa à écouter !

Quite a nice sound. Enjoyed it a lot more than expected. But retrospectively like the madchester sound more now than did when was happening. Probably enjoy this more than oasis, Yeah it follows the usual influences of what became britpop, but does it in a pleasant enough way, with an fluid and variable sound and with vocals that have a smooth flow to them. Nothing groundbreaking but this is a good listen for me, will be following up - 4 Star

I don't really like Britpop

3.5. some good tunes

An Actually good britpop album. It had some really nice guitar, and the vocals were genuinely nice to listen to. Leaps and bounds better than anything oasis ever made Very strong 3 almost a 4

just sounds mildly irritating, like a mosquito I don't want it and it sounds the same almost always

Me: Mum can I go and see Oasis Mum: We have Oasis at home Oasis at home: To be honest that probably shows my lack of knowledge on this genre of music but oh well. This was alright, I think the title track was probably the best on the album but none were incredibly better than the rest, I can't say I love Brit Pop but this was fine. I incorrectly thought I had finished this album yesterday but hadn't listened to the last three songs, which I must say were some of the better ones on the album. I still can't give this the full four stars but it was closer than I initially thought. 66/100 Score edited 11/01/26

I thought this was pretty good when first turning it on but it soon became quite boring, Britpop isn't exactly the most expansive genre and this album just felt incredibly samey. Unsurprising that these have been forgotten over the years.

171 Es como la versión acuenta de oasis, y no me gusta oasis. Tuvo sus momentos loquillos, pero... meh? Me hace pensar en el sesgo de esta lista una vez más.

Honestly, I don’t have a strong opinion on this album. People will probably attack me for this, but it basically feels like 2000s Oasis. Yeah, I know they came first, but that’s the best comparison I’ve got. Solid but not something I would return to. 7.5/10.

Other than their single, 'Can't Get Out of Bed', which I loved, I had no strong views on The Charlatans until seeing them live at a festival in 2004 when they completely blew me away. I came away a full blown fan, digging into their back catalogue and looking forward to each new thing they did. They've never released a bad record - in fact, some of their later records are my favourites. There aren't many bands these days that can get this far into their existence and still release truly great records. Tellin' Stories is a glorious pop record with a giant sound that needs to be played loud. Wonderful stuff.

It is perhaps uncharitable but my feelings about the Charlatans have not changed much since their existence in the 90s - I always felt they were a poor mans Oasis mixed with Stone Roses - all that media-created "baggy" thing ?? It's palatable but uninspiring.

Perfectly acceptable britpop that isn’t overwhelmingly good or notable. I liked some stuff, but mostly it just flowed through like corn or lettuce. Anyway on to the next one.

fun psych britpop stuff

This album did nothing for me. It was so bland and generic, they might as well have been called wonderwall cause they sound like a mediocre oasis cover band. Honestly I relistened to the album to try and find something to take away from it and was left empty handed.

These guys were openers for Oasis for some time. So imagine going to an Oasis concert, because you hate yourself, and who's their opener? Pretty much Oasis. You die from boredom instantly

A generic British rock band/Oasis clone. It didn't sound terrible, just kind of whatever.

Easy to bop along to, very quickly forgotten.

I like Britpop and this was completely forgettable, as a record and a band. It’s 10 minutes after I finished listening and it made absolutely no impression at all I don’t remember a thing. Crazy that this would be on a list of albums of must-hears before you die.

One of the better britpop bands, I like the beats and Bob Dylan vibe to a lot of the songs. 3 stars

I once had a roommate with a rear end so large, I had to help her wipe her butt because she couldn't reach around, and wipe it. Her waist was itty bitty too.

I liked the spacey instrumental songs Area 51 and Rob’s Theme. Otherwise pretty boring britpop. Lacks any edginess and the vocalist has a somewhat nasally voice with limited range and poor dynamics. Decent musicianship but nothing exceptional. Another “why is this on the list?” album.

Britpop der eher unscheinbareren Sorte.

Krass, wie stark das zum Teil nach den frühen dreckigen Oasis klingt, obwohl es die Band schon wesentlich länger gibt. Trotzdem auch ein gewisser Experimentierwille. Mir hat nicht alles gefallen, aber hier waren einige richtig starke Songs drauf.

War nett. Passte, war aber auch nichts besonders tolles.

Anfangs noch eher bei ner 3, kam der Spaß am Album im Verlauf. War gut, war cool, für mich aber dann auch nichts komplett Weltbewegendes.

Ist halt Standard Britpop, macht schon Spaß, aber ist jetzt ehrlicherweise auch nichts besonderes

(insert obscure British indie rock band here) sounds just like (insert obscure British indie rock band here)

Unfortunately not all britpop is as good as Pulp.

60's inspired britpop album. The vocals are a bit too nasally for me and often sound like the singer is doing a Bob Dylan impression (particularly on Get On It). My favourite track was the instrumental Area 51, which has a nice rhythm and psychedelic guitars + keyboard. Not bad but not very memorable.

Is this an oasis b side album? I liked the instrumental.

These guys didn’t even try to hide how badly they were ripping off Oasis.

Getting some Britpop fatigue here. This was just OK.

It wasn't bad, just a bit Oasis-at-home

Fun, some catchy songwriting, but mostly just 'fine.'

A Charlatan is something like a fraud or an imposter. These guys are Oasis impersonators, but they're not as good. I don't even like Oasis. They're the most overrated band in music history. The Charlatans take some creative side steps that Oasis would never have, so that's in their favor. Favorite song: how can you leave us.

I mean…. I did like it, but it does feel more like an album, as opposed to an album I need to hear before I die.

Couple of great tunes, but mostly just a generic indie album to be fair. Underwhelming to say the least.

6/10 Favorites: How High Only Teething

Sounds exactly what I expected from a British rock band in the late 90s. While that doesn't mean its bad it does mean that I feel I could listen to any of 10 other bands and get the same thing.

Sometimes I wish I could go back to 1997 and listen to music like this come out in the moment again. I never heard of The Charlatans back then, but like I said in my Oasis review, there's something so nostalgic about this album to me. I just find comfort in the mid to late 90s rock sound.

A bit aosisy but decent

it was called "baggy". it is dire.

This largely felt like second rate Britpop; a subgenre that I already don't hold the greatest level of affection for. The vocals are a clear attempt at aping Liam Gallagher / Richard Ashcroft and really began to grate before too long. Instrumentally, it threatens to become mildly interesting when it plumps for that swirling, loosely psychedelic style of riffage, however whilst sounding like it's being played in your next door neighbour's bedroom. "One to Another" was the only real standout, vaguely encroaching into stoner rock territories.

They have an interesting sound and a couple of good covers.

Didn’t enjoy this very much.

3 Didn’t finish it I dunno why it’s a 3 out of 10 but it is

Didn't really get excited about this one in any way

Don't really care for the vocals but otherwise not bad. Nothing special I'll be coming back to listen to though. Is this 1001 UK Albums or what? This is predominantly a list of UK bands' albums, hmmm. 2.5/5

Pleasantly surprised by this album. Thought I’d pegged it with the first two songs but they really take you through a plethora of different sounds, genres, musical elements. Lots of great variation, song writing is strong- satisfying progressions. Really enjoy the blues, soul elements coming through. Feels 90s and slightly dated at times but those times are short lived for me. Throughout the album they’d bring in a new sound and I’d be like ‘okay sweet, that’s where we’re going now’, then next songs another slight tweak or element- bongos or horns section etc. kept me on my toes Nothing super groundbreaking, but definitely enjoyable. I had fun

There are many Britpop bands on this list. I think "The Charlatans" are good, but not as interesting and special to be on the list. "Only Teethin'" is a great groovy track that I adore, the rest is nice, but nothing special, at least to me.

Enjoyable pop but uninspiring.

Þetta var nú bara prýðilegt. Ekkert meistaraverk en mjög fínt að hlusta á. Lögin voru svolítið svipuð. Samt verður þetta plata sem ég gleymi mjög fljótt.

Well, they were definitely influential on Oasis...so that's something?

Pleasant Britpop with a bit of jangle, then it totally veers off into oddities

obligatory oasis mention

I was indifferent to this when it was out. Indifferent now too. Some good, some bad. Would I listen to it again? Probably not. Why? Because the 90s were generally a shit time for British music.

Like Oasis light, which is not really worth it.

I have an unfounded and unfair aversion to Tim Burgess - I think it was when we launched that cereal - but he's one of the best Britpop singers I think. There's a really good energy to a lot of this album, particularly on the big hits - North Country Boy, One To Another, How High and Tellin' Stories, and a lot of that is carried by Tim's vocals. All in all, it's not clever, but it's in the nostalgia sweet spot for me, and I think it stands up pretty well all told.

1 out of 5 Like Oasis but with no talent and much worse.

This alt-rock album feels like riding a bus through drizzly suburbs—muted, reliable, a bit washed-out, steady boredom.