Reviews (page 6 of 8)
I truly believe that the singer ruined any chance of this album being good. I couldn’t focus on anything other than his awful vocals and it was disappointing because I would have liked to determine how much I liked the rest of it but it was too hard.
Rock vocalists suck. Didn't take me long to remember why I hated these guys at the time; to say I'm not a big fan of this singer - Greg Dulli - is an understatement. The music was worthy of better. Even instrumental would have been better (which the final song is, thankfully) since we wouldn't have to listen to these lyrics either, which were written by Greg Dulli. Annnd it got progressively worse as it went on - by the time I got to track 5 "When We Two Parted" I was ready to rage listening to these vocals - by Greg Dulli - which sounded like he was being disemboweled. For a minute I felt bad thinking of giving this a 1 considering some of the music is really not bad but all I can unfortunately focus on while listening to this is Greg Dulli. The vocalist's name is Greg Dulli, to spare you from looking that up. Pass. Due to Greg Dulli of course. 3/10 1 star.
Nah.
7/10. It isn't anything particularly remarkable, nor does it really belong on a list of 1001 must-listen albums, but I like its style. :)
Meh. Didn't vibe with this.
Meh generic rock of it's time, nothing special
Not bad, fairly classic early '90s sound. More Sonic Youth than Soundgarden. 3/5
Terrible name but half decent. 3.5
Quite enjoyed this
I thought this was very good. Enjoyed the album and listening to other related music after it ended, will definitely listen to more.
Nothing really special on here. Gave me smashing pumpkin vibes
Liked this a lot more than I thought I would. If I ever go through a breakup again I’ll have to add this to the circulation.
I had never heard of the Afgan Whigs before. I liked the music. I will definitely listen to the album again, even if it won't be one of my favorites. 4/5
Wasn’t really feeling this one.
I just got back to back albums with grating vocals, but good instrumentals (Meat Puppets was the other one). The lyrics are questionable... I wasn't paying close attention until someone mentioned it in the reviews and now I can't stop cringing. The album is supposed to be about a toxic relationship but still comes off very problematic.
The music is decent but ooof, those lyrics 😅
Some interesting moments.
50/50 Вокал вроде не плохой, манера исполнения нравится, но песни не заходят
Have vaguely known this band but never listened. Think I would have liked them more in the 90's, it now sounds dated. Still interesting though, good guitar and angsty delivery.
Ok album, I’ve had a long like not love thing with Afghan Whigs. Like a lot of the melodies of the songs, the singing sometimes detracts. 3/5!
It was good! I agree with the reviews that the music is great but i am not a fan of the lead singer's voice at all. The one song with a female singer is the best lol
Uninspired. Not at all interesting. 2 stars.
Good drums and guitar riffs.
This just didn't do it for me.
Very good album. Couldn't stop listening and got better the second time through. Will add this one to the rotation!
poison
Not too bad but the lyrics are a bit Edgelord.
Certainly something intersting going on here and worth further exploration. Passionate, vulnerable, honest. Faves: What Jail Is Like, Brother Woodrom
Hmmmm, these guys feel like two familiar bands mushed together, but I can't for the life of me pin down which two bands - it's on the tip of my brain. A bit of Trail of Dead, maybe? I feel like there's a slowcore influence in the mix. 🤔 I gotta say, some of the lyrics are just feckin awful - this definitely won't be getting a 5 no matter how much I dig the music. "Be Sweet", for example - great music, but _horrible_ lyrics. Annoying! This coulda been one of my top discoveries from the list with a different songwriter at the helm... Fave tracks - "Debonair", "Brother Woodrow / Closing Prayer"
This album contains cool 90s rock music themed around a breakup. I found the songs to be rather enjoyable.
Not very good. Didn’t like the music, vocals or arrangement.
Hey everybody! 😎😎😎It's the feel-bad album of the summer!🌞🌞🌞🤩🤩🤩 It's an artistic statement like Type-O Negative doing Summer Breeze. It surprises me whenever ideas like this get the careful, even superb execution that they do. Maybe they just sat down and said: "Let's write an album that will be critically acclaimed™," and that was the only parameter. It's really pretty bad. The concept is derivative if not ill-conceived. The playing is fine, but I feel like they're pushing my face into something I simply don't want (and never asked ) to look at. The singing, while true to whatever disturbed and unlikable character this is supposed to be, is obnoxious with no real redeeming quality. I'm not sure where this type of music comes from, just exploring the darkest places. It's just that there's no hope, it never let's up. It's not even like metal, where you get actual visceral anger. It's just the soundtrack of people being assholes to themselves and each other. Pretty lame. The effort that went into making this surprises me, because what do you think about yourself or your audience when you do something like this? I guess it's just going hard on your complaints, really really hard. Narcissistic. It's (again, this turns up a lot in the Critically Acclaimed® albums) like bad high-school poetry.
Very suspect lyrics but still bangs
I didn’t know what to put. I was torn whether I loved it or hated it. 3 stars!
Really wanted to like this.
Good angst 90s rock album I don’t rly hear the soul thing people say about this at all 7/10
Didn’t love it. Didn’t hate it
Never heard of them before, so that makes the review more interesting. Opening music and vocals - very interesting Gentlemen - great drums, technique, guitars and vocals. Loved it 😎 Fountain and the Fairfax - another great track 😉 ... excellent album from a talented band. It sounds brilliantly "unique". Worth 4 stars
embarrassing
Musically, right up my alley. Lyrically, not as much. Overall: not bad, not great.
Average
Severa very good, subtle and slow-burning cuts, but not a ton of the hookiness or anthemic-ness that would have made them obvious candidates for mass appaeal in the days of grunge and very early ALT rock. Best cuts are "Be Sweet," "What Jail is Like," "When We Two Parted," and the closer, which achieves a kind of gritty transcendence – one's always been a sucker the brooding, instrumental aspect of hard rock. Safe to say they deserve more and are well worth knowing beyond just this one record.
2-3 stars.
Musically, I love this. Classic '90s alt with a tinge of grunge is always a win. Lyrically, it's questionable. Obviously this isn't the first (or last) album to have unfortunate lyrics, and I get the bitter heartache, toxic relationship approach they're going for. But listening to some of these lyrics in 2024 makes me feel like this dude is not one I'd want to associate with. Anyway, standouts are Gentlemen, Be Sweet, and I Keep Coming Back - just need to ignore the lyrics for some of these.
Een nieuwe dag, een nieuw standaard rock album. Dit word echt een beetje genant. De afgelopen week zou als je het mij vraagt allemaal in 1 album passen. Het is allemaal nietszeggende rock. Ik denk dat The Afghan Whigs best wel eens heel erg pech kunnen hebben, want na 4 albums die vrijwel hetzelfde klinken ben ik er ook wel goed klaar mee. We snappen het: Rock is een belangrijk genre. Houden we dan nu alsjeblieft op met elke scheet van een rock band in deze lijst te zetten? Alsjeblieft? FAVO:
i like "Gentleman" too but jesus christ, enough with the singers who don't really try to be on key
Never heard of these guys before, is this EMO? I LIKE this moody sound a LOT, nothing I don't like about this so far. 3 stars. ANOTHER RAD BAND FROM OHIO, make that 4 STARS
sick tunes 4.2/5
The same song 11 times
Absolutely unhinged lyrics. I cut it off after Be Sweet.
Ey
One of my favorite albums ever.
Some bangers for the zen playlist oh yeah oh yeah
Yuck
I didn't really f with this
5/5 the emotional delivery won me over. i can hear dulli going through life events as he sings. the fact that the best song My Curse isnt sung by him speaks to the quality of the songs themselves and the band performance. i can almost hear the producer yelling notes to the band as they play only to be ignored.
Il y avait des passages musicaux vraiment intéressant à certains moments. Du rock typique 90s mais vraiment bien exécuté. Par contre à d'autres moments, ça devenait vraiment ininspiré et cliché. Mais le plus gros problème de cet album est la partie chant. Autant la voix que le contenu des paroles. Je ne pense pas que le chanteur a une voix si terrible que ça, c'est plus comment il l'utilise que ça fait tellement énnervant à tout le temps chialer. Aussi comme plusieurs ont mentionné, les paroles sont vraiment problématiques, le chanteur passe pour quelqu'un de toxique. 4/10
En verdad está bueno, los instrumentales están increíbles pero más allá de eso no me llevo más del álbum
I enjoyed it.
Hmmm, interesting one. Between a 2 and a 3 but going to go with 2 because none of the songs really grabbed my attention.
When this album came up I thought to myself "This is a band I always saw the name of but I can't think of one song they do." I was excited to fill out a cultural gap, as they were right in the zone of what I listened to when they were popular. When I heard the album, I understood the Wikipedia comment that they were always "almost famous". I wanted to like them, but angsty vocals, muddy playing between the guitar and bass, generally lacked the hooks of a good pop song, they were close, but just not quite there. Sort of like what AI would produce if prompted to create a guitar oriented power pop band from the 90s. It just lacked a soul.
Good rock album.
3.25
Viva Afghan
"Got a dick for a brain" -6/10
Listened to this earlier but kept losing interest, then listened to this all the way through in the car. Seems like a lot of emotions went into the songs. Some of the lyrics didn’t really hit though. There was a female singer at one point? Middle of the road 3. Edit -- this wasn't that great bumping down to 2.
enjoyed this! it was quite a fun listen, feel like I was engaged and didn't wanna skip anything which is more than I can say for most albums. I dont know that id listen to any of these songs often but as an overall album pretty damn good. 8/10
Really enjoyed this! My Curse was especially good. This isn’t the kind of music I usually listen to but it was excellent background as I read The Four Loves. 8/10
4/10 - I was not a huge fan of the singing most of the time. It was kind of unsettling. The last song wasn’t so bad and neither was the third song. But overall not great
Eh
Probably a 3.5 for me. First time listening, but enjoyed it. A bit chaotic in places but a nice dip into a full Afghan Whigs album.
Enjoyed, 4/5
I enjoyed this. Will probably revisit again at some point. Was not at all what I was expecting
It was ok - very 90s
Utterly forgettable. Here's a band name I knew, but could not name nor identify one song. Listening to this album did not change this. Not awful, but just....blah.
Saving this for when Jacque dumps me
I added “Be Sweet” to a playlist??!
Not bad although I do not remember a single thing about the album
Kinda good for the 90s grunge music. Would like to revisit this again in the future.
Hell yes.
Grungey goodness.
I never heard this, which surprises me given when it came out. Pretty good.
3/5 at best. didn’t really connect with it.
I had never heard of this band or this album. It's sort of a concept album about the dysfunctional end of a relationship. They have a grungy, alternative rock sound with varying levels of heaviness that reminds me a bit of Smashing Pumpkins, with a little Minus the Bear thrown in there. I thought this was a perfectly serviceable 90s rock album.
Kind of mid. To me it started out okay, but by the end it was a chore. I won't come back to this. It was all kind of too similar.
Wasn’t really a fan of them
It's okay.
Nontemarkable
twas ok
Not bad. 3/5
Album with ups and downs.
Pretty ok
Sure.
Another album of angsty, 90s alternative, if you've heard one, etc etc.
Þetta fannst mér nú ekki neitt sérlega merkilegt band og skil ekki af hverju það er á þessum lista. Þetta er ekki beint leiðinlegt og textarnir stundum skemmtilegir en mér fannst þeir heldur ekki góðir. Væbið sem ég fékk var að þetta væri svona bílskúrspabbaband sem verður aldrei meira en það.
Muy normalito...
Rating: 6/10 Started off great with the first few songs then became pretty derivative. The first few songs have an alternative rock feel which resembles much of the 90s but the band put their own spin on it at least. After this nothing of note really happens, it's listenable but nothing special. Favorite songs: If I Were Going, Gentlemen, Be Sweet, Debonair. Worst songs: What Jail Is Like, Brother Woodrow.
Good stuff. Pretty raw and seedy rock. I prefer the later albums with twilight singers, I think he perfected his style on those albums.
one of the best-written breakup albums of all time? have they not heard of Fleetwood Mac or, actually, countless other artists? I waited for the joke, It never did arrive sums up this album perfectly
I've heard of the Afghan Whigs but never listened until today. Sort of a post-hardcore / Alt rock combination. I had to warm up to the vocals, but eventually came around. Cool vibe and interesting arrangements.
Yuck
siii re 7,5/10
01) If I Were Going - 6,0 02) Gentlemen - 6,0 03) Be Sweet - 6,0 04) Debonair - 6,0 05) When We Two Parted - 5,5 06) Fountain and Fairfax - 5,0 07) What Jail Is Like - 5,5 08) My Curse - 6,0 09) Now You Know - 5,0 10) I Keep Coming Back - 6,0 11) Brother Woodrow/Closing Prayer - 6,0 TOTAL: 5,73 (57/100) Here's another band I never heard of. Looking through their discography I can see they had literally no album or singles chart success. They sound just like any other rock band of the era so I don't really get it what is it that is so worthy to be included on this list? Lyrics like "I got a dick for brain" are really groundbreaking.
Great music - not always a fan of the lyrics, but it's definitely a great '90s sound!
No está mal. Tiene una vibra grunge alternativa, algo entre Pixies, Bush y Soul Asylum. La mayoría de los temas son oscuros y pausados, con buena dinámica, lo que los hace entretenidos para mi gusto. En la primera escucha no encontré algún tema sobresaliente, aunque eso no quita mérito al álbum como uno que se puede escuchar facilmente de principio a fin.
Very impactful, emotional, etc. But drags on a bit and feels the same thing the whole time: either moody, slow, and loud or moody, slow, and quiet.
I started to listen to this album as background music when doing household chores. As, at first, it sounded more like a background album type. After a couple of songs, I had to turn it off. Couldn't listen more...
I had all but forgotten about this band, and I actually saw them open for Aerosmith in 99 as one of my first concerts. As young as I was at the time, I didn't pay much attention to them as it was primarily there for Aerosmith. 25 years later rediscovering this band, they aren't that bad, but I feel they aren't all that memorable either. I listened to most of this on my way home a few hours ago and don't really recall much about it. I didn't really feel the need to skip songs, but for a 90s alternative band, I'd expect to be a lot more excited to discover the rest of their catalog. Meh Favorite track "Fountain and Fairfax" 2.5/5
Fun and brash alt band, pretty cool vocals and I like the lead!. 3.3
Has its moments but sounds dated.
Enjoyed this one a bit, there is a pained and soulful yearning to it. Favorite track: "Fountain and Fairfax."
OK but not great, I'd say
Sounds like No Vacancy from School of Rock, but more cringe
This was pretty solid
I appreciate many of the reviewers reacting with disgust to the notes of misogyny that perfume this record; it gives me a bit of hope for society, I guess. So maybe I'm a bad feminist for giving the benefit of the doubt here. Albums written from a place of pain, or a desire to explore toxic relationships, doesn't mean they're strictly autobiographical. So yeah, these lyrics are hyper-masculine and not always empathetic to the woman on the receiving end, but there are moments of (what appears to be) regret and desire for understanding. "Tonight I go to hell/for what I've done to you." Then we hear a woman's voice on "My Curse," like getting the other side of the story, which is the real saving grace on this record for me. As for the rest of the album, the sound and production reminds me of the 2010s emo revival, particularly in the Midwest. It's a nostalgic sound for me; I could've bumped this at 16 alongside bands like Title Fight or Joyce Manor. But many of these songs are paced the same, and the lead singer oscillates between sounding urgent and sounding strained. I'm curious about revisiting and spending more time with this record. Maybe it's just been awhile since my last bad breakup. Highlights: Be Sweet, Debonair, Fountain and Fairfax, What Jail Is Like, My Curse
Fourth studio album! LOL. Didn't really understand this much. Songs 5,6, and 8 were meh at best.
This is surprising compelling. The pain and torment is clear with music that matches it well. Alt rock vibe that gets appropriately noisy when it needs. Really enjoyed it and plan to explore it more soon.
This album was just there, only a day after listening I can’t really remember anything about it, nothing about it was memorable. It wasn’t a bad album, but it also wasn’t good enough to be remembered.
3.5/5
I liked it, it was chill and a nice thing to have on while doing something else.
Will be adding this one to the rotation pretty instantly. 4/5
An non autobiographical alt-rock break up album by The Afghan Whigs. Perfectly fine yet a little on the slower side for me, but was an immersion in the methods of warfare in the battle of the sexes - a dark, dramatic wallow in lust, shame, guilt, despair, deceit and obsession that's framed in dense rock. Best: Gentlemen Worst: Brother Woodrow
This album was ok. I like the instrumental but I think they need someone else to sing. Except when the woman sings in ‘My curse’. I like her voice a lot.
4/10. Not my thing but it got more palatable as it went on. Some instrumental pieces I did like in the middle and the album felt well connected song to song which was cool.
Never again
Decent music, but the lyrics are plain awful
This is my first time listening to this. Never had much exposure to this band back in the 90s. To be fair, I listened to it twice. I really enjoyed it the second time around and think it is deserving of the acclaim. It takes you on an emotional journey with some dark undertones and a Velvet Underground feel.
ну чё-то опять ни вокал ни музыка не вдохновили
boring post-grunge midtempo 90s alt rock that never made it to the radio. Imagine a really muddy recording of stone temple pilots' filler tracks with the hooks taken out. A real dirge. Some good guitar parts here and there, and when the vocals veer into screamo territory it's more compelling, same when it slows down and spaces out into a more shoegaze sound. Favorites: be sweet, when we two parted
Devin and Angela will hate this! Too angsty. I like it, but have never gone all-in on the Whigs.
Fine. It definitely sounds like an album from 1993.
Afghan Whigs are a band whose name I’ve heard a lot, but never really checked them out. After this listen, I think I’m good. Honestly, there’s nothing wrong with the music, but it really doesn’t move me. They sound like pretty much all the other 90s alt-rock bands. Nothing objectionable but nothing inspiring either.
Ooof. Like a lot of the reviews on here, this band has always been on my periphery, but I’ve never checked them out. It wasn’t what I was expecting. I was expecting a band that I’ve always thought I’d like if I checked them out. I got a whiney guy that didn’t sound fun.
It rocks. Timeless sound that could have been made any time the last thirty years. Great voice also. But I have no interest in listening to this self professed asshole no matter how self aware.
Some great stuff. Slow burn. Enjoyed
I remember hearing about the Afghan Whigs. Now I know I wasn't missing anything.
from midwest. alt/grunge. ‘Debonair’ from this album. nothing seems very remarkable to me.
Rating: 6/10
Really good stuff
An above average grunge record featuring a characteristic distraught vocalist (that reminds me of Trent Reznor) and an anthemic hard rock sound that's both gritty and accessible with plenty of pop hooks, instrumental choices (e.g. acoustics), and song structure that mimic their tamer contemporaries in alt rock and alt country. The tracks were fine. Very little jumped out to me, and it did fall back on too many pop cliches. A few tracks like "Now You Know" sounded like filler, not offering anything substantial besides venting break-up steam. But there's diversity, started with stronger tracks, ending with an appropriate closer, and was a sufficient length. But most importantly, it sounds genuine although a bit derivative. Although I didn't care for it much, there's more style and completeness than many grunge and alt rock contemporaries at the time. Favorites: Gentlemen, Debonair, My Curse
Heavy, slightly dark, very nice
I didn’t have time to listen to the full thing. Will listen tomorrow
3.5 stars. Dark lyrically (good break-up album) and less grungy than other 90's alt rock. Has some duds including "What Jail is Like" and "My Curse". But it's mostly a good listen and standouts are "Gentlemen" and "Debonair".
Interesting subject matter marred by a lack of tunes...
On this album, I primarily like the energetic vocals. It was nearly something I was very excited about, but fell just a bit short on creativity.
The Whigs were first a party opposed to an absolute Catholic monarchy in England in the late 1600s. Later, the Whigs were a party opposed to an overpowered executive in 1800s America. Still later, the Afghan Whigs were a party opposed to the dominance of Persian hair pieces. Or were they a party opposed to the centralized power of the communist government in Afghanistan in the late 1980s? Alas, these Afghan Whigs were just an American alternative rock band fond of unnecessary h’s. But they’re more fun to listen to than anyone describing the history of various Whig political parties. It was Rick McCollum’s guitar and John Curley’s bass that carried “Gentlemen,” but Greg Dulli’s vocals actually grew on me over the course of the album and a second listen. Similarly, I first thought the guest vocals by Marcy Mays on “My Curse” brought things to a screeching halt, but those too got a little better as the emotion and intensity built. I loved the haunting atmosphere of the closing track “Brother Woodrow,” and found myself not wanting it to end despite its over five minute length. It was a fitting coda on an album that felt very much like an album - a cohesive collection of songs carefully crafted to be listened to together, apparently inspired by Van Morrison’s “Astral Weeks” in the use of recurring melodic riffs and lyrical imagery.
There is an erraticism here. The Afghan Whigs alter between chaotic noise and a tight sound. Unfortunately this is all fronted by subpar vocals.
Not a big fan of the vocals on this.
Too loud; did not enjoy.
Inte lyssnat mycket på Afghan Wigs. Kanske borde ha gjort det på 90-talet. Det är ok och ganska meningslöst. Inget fastnar. Teflonrock. Fountain and Fairfax är hygglig.
Upp och ned. Vissa låtar är bra andra sisådär. Texterna är råtöntiga. Men man är för gammal. Det är ett "breakup"-album och thats a young mans game.
Bortser man från de pubertala delarna så var denna helt okej. Lite svajig bitvis och sången är inte alltid klockren, men instrumentellt gillar jag det överlag. Stabil trea.
Poor man’s Nirvana or Foo Fighters. Didn’t enjoy it
2.5 stars
Not good. The vocals were really bad on this one.
Not a big fan of the AFghan Whigs. This solidifies that fact.
Great Great moments all over. Couldn't completely catch everything on first time but I should listen more. Emotional. Some really high moments and overall good album experience Final song phenomenal.
It's a highly regarded album, (In 2008, writer Bob Gendron published a critical and scholarly exploration of Gentlemen) but I dunno, I just couldn't get excited by it. Maybe it's a lyrical album, but I'm sure I care enough to explore further. Good guitar sounds, mind you
Bitter break up man songs full of entitled indie angst.
Decent enough, and some great guitar sounds, yet at the same time strangely somehow not enough to be very memorable.
The thing about dub is getting lost in its bouncy, offbeat rhythm and going along for the ride. The cutting of sounds and samples gives a homemade quality. The deep base groove is like a relaxing heartbeat. The sway of reggae takes me away and the electro wooshing on old synths is like a sprinkling of hundreds and thousands. What a shame this isn't dub.
I'd heard of Afghan Whigs, (and keep reading it as "Afghan Wings", I dunno, dyslexia), but never listened to anything by them. The album is decent enough, I enjoyed the guitars and bass riffs, but still all quite forgettable.
Tienen personalidad pero no me emocionan. 3/5.
It was a good album kinda grunge-y
I quite liked this album, but would have liked it more if it weren't so depressing. My favourite track was "Fountain and Fairfax".
Atmospheric link between the beautiful melodic of the 80s and the angsty poetic of the 90s
5.5/10
It starts with noise. That threw me off and I like. The song gentlemen has a great groove. Really digging this record. Great grooves. Great song writing
Could see myself coming back to this one. Didn't blow me away, but it's very solid. Closer to a 4 than a 3.
Mid. Sad boy alt rock. Honesty the lyrics were funny sometimes. But really just feels like a heart broken dude singing some BS with some good instruments behind him
This wasn't the worst thing we've gotten but it was bad. Loud and annoying. Really not sure there were any redeeming qualities here.
The vocals really ruined this for me. A “holy shit” breakup album. This was intense, lyrically. And it’s musically very different than the other Sub Pop grunge bands of the era. But I couldn’t get past the voice.
Bro what.
Didn’t really like it. Maybe it’s just the guys voice, but not for your boy.
I never need to hear that again lol
Reminded me of The Wallflowers in a way but also kind of boring
Grungey, boring, kind of dissonant. guy's delivery sounded a bit like nine inch nails?
not for me
So good
Despite being a fan of later album 1965, I'd never really dived into the Afgham Whigs catalogue so I was excited to give Gentlemen a whirl. There's something honest in the way the band go about their business - a standard four piece with piano/organ adding some depth and minimal production tweaks; you imagine the band might sound like this live. Honest, too, in the confessional song writing of Dulli, somewhat tormented and driven by libido, struggling to maintain relationships - I'm not sure I would want to hang out with him. A decent record, from a decent band making interesting music.
lots of catchy riffs that made this v enjoyable. excited to re-listen at somepoint.
Another band that I have heard of, but have never listened to. Honestly didn't actively listen to this, but I did listen in the background. It was decent and I liked some of the songs on there, but there was nothing that really jumped off the page at me. Again, that's probably my fault for not listening intently.
Here lies an album that sits in the grunge genre but with oddly funky elements
This has not aged well. Musically fine, but the lyrics were rough
Okay, but not something I'd listen to again.
# Playlist track - Gentlemen # Notes - I had that cover SO much. - Enjoyable album, but doesn't hold itself all the way. The final songs are not very interesting. - I had high hopes for this, because I really like their album "[[The Afghan Whigs, Do The Beast|Do the beast]]" from 2014. That's on me, I guess.
I've heard it several times, I like it.
Great album, really enjoyed the sound and the concept.
ok
Ermmm, it was kinda good? I think? Some parts were good and others sounded like a demo. I think this one is a two but the good bits alone could be a 3
Musically and melodically this album may be worth 3 stars, its pretty solid in that regard. But the singer is HORRIBLE. Just an annoying tone, shitty lyrics, pretty much everything about the singer is like a caricature of shitty 90's alt rock. It seems unfair to rate this 1 star when the band is decent, but I just can't get over the front-man being so shit.
Gnaz gut eigentlich
Interesting to hear this band, having known of the name for a long time. 'Gentlemen' was my favourite track.
Nope.
A decent rock album, but didn’t leave any impression on me.
I like it, I swear I've heard this group's name before but I can't say I'm familiar with their work. This is just some solid rock music, not much at all to distinguish it for me but the riffs and melodies are strong. Some solid bangers in here. Not everything has to be remarkable to be good, and that's what this album is: good rock. Favorite tracks: If I Were Going, Be Sweet, What Jail Is Like, I Keep Coming Back. Album art: Yellow/sepia style photo of a boy and a girl. Why does this seem like a fighting couple? They both look so weary. For some odd reason, the art on Apple Music is animated - not sure why exactly they picked this album to do that, but then again we just had Doggystyle and that one was animated on there too, to a much more extreme variation. Decent cover though. 3.5/5
Honestly, I really really liked it
Feel like this albums gone under the radar - some great tracks, but in a nutshell you take one look at that album cover and band name and instantly skip Maybe these were the inspiration behind esteemed British Rapper Afghan Dan...
Instrumentals are fairly good but that front man is a tosser. Rather listen to afghan dan. 2/5
Not for me
2.5/5 Annoying voice and mixed like shit
def gave off the 90s vibes. wouldn't skip it if it came on randomly, but also wouldn't go out of my way to listen to the whole album again.
weird album, especially the vocals, but not super bad, on the edge between 3 and 4
ehhh some of the music itself was fun but I could not stand the lyrics or the vocals. I ended up ending it a couple songs early sorry not sorry 🙈
Decent but much better out there with this style
It goes hard but the singer needs autotune.
A bit downbeat for my tastes
This album was a scuzzy revelation when I first heard it and I loved it for that.
Not bad
No convence, grunge? indie?. Flojo
4.5/10 Mid grungy alt rock. Starting to think that the author of this list is really basic with a huge bias towards bland, competent guitar rock Musically fine but the rhythm (especially drums) are just “there” not really doing much beyond chugging basics Works better as a consistent album than individual songs Not a fan of the male vocals nor the lyrics, feels like a spurned guy formed a band with his friends and now play pubs Best: My Curse
I didn't get to give this album as much focus as I would have liked, but I really enjoyed it when I was listening. I love the style of the guitar. I love the vocals, the messiness of it all I think this could be something that grows on me
too rock-y
alternative rock and grunge of this genre is quite competitive for me and this is not the best. maybe i just personally don't like the grungy sound mixed with the soul influence this clearly has, i feel it removes a little bit of the angsty sound while keep the angsty lyrics. also the vocalist was not my favourite. still a decent listen though.
I just could not stand this one. The vocals were not good at all, and the music was very blah
New music that I liked!
A progressive grungy alternative record strait from the pit of toxic relationship despair. The Afghan Whigs use heavy breakdowns, punchy picked bass, screaming fuzzed-out guitars, gritty and grinding organs, and unpolished angsty vocals to paint the very image of a broken romance. Topics swing wildly from regretful musing of hurt, defiant pushes against entrenched relationships, and confused confessions of romantic addiction. In the end, it feels like we started exactly where we began. This was my first introduction to the Afghan Whigs, and I really liked what I heard. Stand out tracks include: When We Two Parted, What Jail Is Like, My Curse, and I Keep Coming Back.
While "Gentlemen" doesn't tap into my personal brand of angst, it does capture familiar emotions and interpersonal struggles. As an album the songs feel less like a few singles taped together with some b-sides and more like a deliberately written tribute to waning relationships, and what's left in their wake. I would have preferred to hear more female vocals in the album. The choice of a female lead in "My Curse" and supporting female backup vocals in "Now You Know" were a welcome / needed change to the onslaught of Greg Dulli. Even after channeling my (thankfully) distant disappointment and pain vis-a-vis romance, I still only find myself sympathizing for the imagined subjects of the songs, never quite reaching the point of empathy. Finishing this album left me with a nagging desire to go listen to some blown-out Mitsky songs.
Meh
This was a bit disappointing. The first time I heard the Afghan Whigs was a snippet of a song I don’t remember the name of, and it made me interested in their music, although I never really checked them out. This album just kind of felt like background alt-rock music. I’d still give it a 3, and I feel like a lot of the albums I’m listening to recently have felt like they’re seeping into the background, so it might just be my attention.
Really cool and some great songs. Intrigued by this band
Better than I remember Afghan Wings, but still for this list probably a 3.5
I understand it. I see its place in the canon. I appreciate the sort of “we dumped in some of all the ingredients in the cabinets but we worked on it to make it palatable but also new” style. And.. for me? It’s just okay. It feels like I should just go listen to the Replacements.
The instrumentation, the vocals(mostly), the riffs, the bass, it’s all great for the most part. But, the lyrics.. they can be unbearable at parts. This one is one I MAY come back to but not for the song writing.
One of those albums that is very American rock, and another one that doesn't hold much on interest to me, with not US Rock tastes. The lyrics, as others have said, are rather trite but the music is trite too. Nothing interesting, nothing discovered. It hardly sold even in the US, and there might just be a reason for that.
Irresistibly heavy, heady and at times hedonistic, Gentlemen is presented by Afghan Whigs approaching ascendancy. It's almost hard to find a flaw with this record, apart from it being not long enough. But it is best that things are this way. It gives off a feeling of warmth and comfort, oddly enough. Appropriate choice of color palette for the album cover, too.
Very angry. Some dark lyrics and broody songs.
Very different and I think I quite like it! A bit wailing in places, but there’s some great Melodie’s in there as well.
It’s not really my style
I was listening to a lot of music in the 90's. I did not listen to this. Now I have and I understand why. Average 90s rock, shitty vocals, no thanks. The only song that stood out for me was My Curse (no surprise, alternate lead singer).
Not a great listen. I’ve never heard of the band and will likely never listen to them again. I’m going to reserve scoring a 1 for albums I can’t face listening to the whole way through. But this isn’t far off.
No idea who the artist was, sounded very 90s. Generally found it to pretty meh and left feeling there was a reason I hadn’t heard of them if this is a key album.
Amazing
3.75
Hm, da gibt's mMn deutlich bessere Alternative-Bands aus der Zeit.
a little too grungy for my tastes, but still a great album - 8/10
Definitely not a "must-listen" album by any definition. A few okay guitar hooks, but awful, nails-on-chalkboard vocals.
This was decent. It had parts that I enjoyed, but I didn't quite get into it like I would have liked.
Mostly fine, except for I keep coming back which grated my soul like nails on a chalk board. Bruh needed a vocal coach or something
Boring
I didn't find much in this beyond middle of the road early indie.
Never heard this band before but still makes me feel the 90's nostalgia feeling creeping in. This was a good record and still sounds good 30 years later. Album cover is a little bit creepy, reminiscent of another album I discovered from this list, Throbbing Gristle's D.O.A.
This was on track to be a solid 4-star album. Solid jams, great energy, lots of attitude... But it quickly outstayed its welcome. By track 4, the intentionally atonal wailing that was such a vibe in the early-to-mid-90s had blown past "nostalgic" and was well into the "shut the hell up already" zone. Shame. It had a lot of promise.
I feel like I would have really loved this record circa 1996 as a 14 year old. As a 41 year old I was not into it. It wasn’t bad per se - but not something I’d want to return to.
Davhteberst das is nix für mich aber war tatsächlich gut
I hate my girlfriend
Yeah, loved it - such a great sound and Dulli is a fantastic vocalist. listened to a few of their other albums back in the day (had 1965 on tape!) but never this one
No. 73/1001 If I Were Going 4/5 Gentlemen 3/5 Be Sweet 3/5 Debonair 4/5 When We Two Parted 4/5 Fountain And Fairfax 3/5 What Jail Is Like 3/5 My Curse 3/5 Now You Know 4/5 I Keep Coming Back 3/5 Brother Woodrow 3/5 Average: 3,36 Musically I liked this, the singers voice really showed some weaknesses on some songs.
Debonair is a high point. Otherwise this is the epitome of an early 90s, grunge-adjacent, rock album. And I say that, as a fan of early 90s rock music, in the least nostalgic/complementary way possible. It's just kind of boring. The singer isn't great. It kind of reminds me of The Lemonheads or Paul Westerberg. Not really heavy enough to be grunge, but with some of the same affectations. A grunge-ish paint-by-numbers album, if you will. Not terrible, I guess. Would give a 2.5 if I could.
Great album cover. Songs are decent.
More than 4, great!
Ehhh... didn't really like it. Not a fan of that 90s sound on this album. Plus the lyrics are ughhh which brings it down 2.5/5
Laulajalla häiritsevä ääni. Itse biisien sanoitukset on kyllä jotenkin korneja... Kaippa ne liittyy tähän ironiseen levyn nimeen? Ei tämäkään ole mun juttu. Musa itsessään ois ehkä kolmosen arvoinen, laulu tiputtaa kakkoseen.
2.5 Ok. Couple of decent tracks. Sounds like a Trent Reznor impersonator backed by the Ataris playing 90s rock covers
Didn't do anything for me, not bad necessarily
Varsin viihdyttävä. Viikonlopun aikana pyörähti useamman kerran läpi.
Uusi tuttavuus. Ihan hauska ja solidi levy.
way better than i expected, i enjoyed a decent amount of this. 3.7-3.8
Typical whiny '90s shite
Run of the mill, unspectacular American rock zzzzzzzzzzzzz
Eerste indruk is goed, album begint spannend Gentlemen echt meega lekker nummer damn Debonair ook top Erg goed album, kende deze band ook nog niet dus leuk om te leren kennen! Sommige nummers zijn wel een beetje vals ofzo haha en ergens heeft vet wel wat puurs maar ook beetje vreemd Zou sommige nummers zeker vaker luisteren, dus would buy maar komt niet op m'n wishlist.
Some tunes ok, not keen on the vocals.
Al lijken een paar nummers goed op elkaar, toch heb ik van dit album genoten
2.9/5 - Nothing fancy, and ona first listen i assumed they were like every other late 80s - mid 90's grunge band. i felt i was missing something. A second listen and their uniqueness came to me. It sjus tnot always prevalent, or front and center. But it's got some enjoyable songs on it.
This is not for me. Songs I’ve listened to were samey and kind of boring. Not memorable at all.
the music is okay but the lyrics and whiney singing is representative of a man in a hard place. we've all been there, some of us crywank whilst binge watching peep show, others release this album
If this is considered their best album I'd hate to hear their worst
Started strong, liked the first couple of songs, then took a turn for the worse
Not my style.
Melody and pitch are optional, but a lot of mid-90s aggro. 3.5
Felt weirdly uncomfortable listening to this for some reason? I’m not entirely sure how I feel about it, would need to listen to it again
I really enjoyed this but I'm not sure why. I didn't like any of the songs but I really enjoyed this. Really enjoyed this, for some reason 🤷♀️
Dripping with drama, angst, and a fucking unrelenting rhythm section, this album really doesn’t let up. Dulli’s distinct vocal style really resonates here in a way that virtually no other artists in the 80s-90s were capturing. There are a lot of great tracks on their own, but I think the record works better as a whole, slow burn piece. The miserable cycle of a break up digs a bit deeper as you get more into the album. The more you sit it in, the more it sits in you.
Take a dive down into the dark, debaucherous depths of Dulli and The Whigs’s most well-known—and most malignant—masterpiece; fucked up as it might seem, it’s one of my favorite places to be.
Middling
Never really dove into the Afghan Whigs discography, so this is my first foray into really listening to their music. This album started off very strong and then the last 3-4 songs became a bit of a drone and were too lengthy for me. Overall, I enjoyed this album and would listen to it again. It deserves a place on this list, if only because it's an album that serves as a midpoint between grunge and post-alternative music. It does have a timeless sound.
Musicality: 4 - decent melodies, solid layering Production & Sound: 5 - sounds very good Artistic Expression: 4 - emotional, angry Performance: 4 - all very good, vocalist does well Engagement & Enjoyment: 4 - some songs I enjoyed a lot, kept me listening Decent album overall
Interesting Indy
I love the Afghan Whigs and I really liked re-listening to this album. This album kind of shows the group figuring out the right mix of ingredients for their sound, which I think gets better and better with each release. If you listen to this and "1965"--which is chock full of hits--you will be very confused why they didn't have a bunch of number 1 hit singles and make it into the big time.
I really wanted to like this but I just couldn't form any sort of emotional connection to the music. I feel like its more my own fault that I couldn't appreciate it though, I don't have an objective issue with it. Just so at odds with the styles and general chord movements that I grew up on that the listening experience felt like a chore, so maybe its an exposure thing.
I’ve never heard of this group and was skeptical at first but this won me over by the end. Good lyrics and not too soft. When We Two Parted was the first track to make me perk up. Dug the strings in Fountain and Fairfax. My Curse was my favorite - excellent song. There is something almost post-emo about this even though it came out in the 90s and that makes no sense.
The music on this was just okay. But there was more raw emotion on here than we usually hear on a record. Almost confessional. A touch cringe but still powerful
I know they aren't a Seattle band, but this album definitely had some of the grungy feel of the time. Rocks hard with biting lyrics. Kind of surprising this band never really broke into the big time.
A great find for me! The vocals were much weaker than the instrumentation on this albums though the lyrics were decent and the vocals did grow on me as I listened. Since I didn’t know anything about this band the second vocalist was a fun surprise (and she was great on My Curse). The guitars reminded me a lot of Ash from a few days ago. “Debonair” had a funky intro and the solo on “My Curse” was my playing style so that was fun. The album sounds like a hybrid between Pearl Jam and Drive By Truckers. Would do a 4.5 if possible but I think this would keep growing on me if I listened more so I’ll give it a 5.
Not a fan. Couldn’t even finish this album.
Echt een bagger stem na twee nummers kon ik het niet meer aan
Nice
I mean it’s not something I’d throw on everyday but it’s not awful background noise.
I remember being disappointed in this record initially because it wasn't as tough as Congregation which itself wasn't as gritty as Up in It. I had so desperately wanted a "return to form" and did not get it. All the biases of youth and wanting a band or recording artist to regularly deliver the thing I first picked them up for. I didn't want growth back then, I didn't want experimentation. Just give me the loud and the fast and never take our foot of the gas. It didn't take too long for this album to grow on me just like Congregation had. It's not my favorite AW but it turns out this is a pretty good record.
holy hell this guy down baaaddddd. Lyrics are too sobby which drags it down, but musically it's not too bad it has a garage rock feel to it. Last track the guitar + cello sound great together to get an ominous but big sound.
3/5 interesting but no.
Rock alternativo. Ni fu ni fa.
It started too sad for me but hen developed into Aspen very cool alternative rock. Nice to listen to once in a while
Big like, wild shortly listen again.
I enjoyed it quite a lot, especially the instrumentals.
Not a ton to say about this one... very 90s guitar sounds that I fojnd pretty enjoyable on a few tracks, but all around the lyrics made this a pretty tough listen..
Woah woah! Honestly not much to say about this album. I loved the guitar parts! But I did not particularly enjoy this approach to the vocal production. I feel like it left me wanting more. The songs, the tones, even the lyrical content was all pretty enjoyable though.
Angsty, muddy and kind of dull
Another entry for vocalists ho can't carry a tune. The reviews are bad on this and I'm shocked to see the artist on this list...but you know what? I loved it.
What a find! Only heard of them before but never listened. It's not perfect but good album.