Reviews (page 5 of 8)
I feel like this was a 2 teetering on a 3 but I ultimately decided on a 3. Some of the mic effects and production / mixing techniques were very cool- other elements of this album just went a little too long for me.
Ok? Meglio dell'altro immagino
I really did not enjoy this bathroom at all.
Усім любителям психоделічної музики минулого та сьогодення імʼя Капітана Біфгарта давно знайоме. Але для тих хто тільки відкриває для себе цей «досі невідомий світ» - цей дебютний альбом стане унікальний містком між доступною мелодійністю та сміливими експериментами, які згодом стануть візитівкою гурту. На відміну від радикального хаосу їхнього культового Trout Mask Replica (1969), цей альбом зберігає відносну стриманість, балансуючи на межі між традиційною структурою та психоделічними пошуками. Саме в цій напрузі між контролем і свободою криється його магія. Фундамент Safe As Milk - це блюз та R&B, щедро приправлені психоделією та фолковими мотивами, а хрипкий вокал Капітана Біфгарта що коливається між блюзовою глибиною та «сюрреалістичною дивакуватістю» надає пісням особливого шарму, коли не до кінця розумієш «якого біса тут взагалі відбувається». Значну роль в цьому поєднанні відіграє й слайд-гітара, що створює міцний зв’язок з блюзовим корінням, але водночас натякає на щось нове й незвичайне. Загалом альбом є дуже різноманітним : від дитячої простоти Yellow Brick Road до саркастичного Dropout Boogie, від соулової ніжності I’m Glad до психоделічної симфонії Autumn’s Child. Особливо виділяється Electricity- трек, з химерними ритмами, що вже говорить нам чого варто очікувати від майбутньої творчості гурту. Safe As Milk звучить сиро, але водночас продумано. Це альбом, який намагається бути частиною музичної сцени 60-х, але вже несе в собі зерна «бунтарства», які проростуть у наступних роботах Біфгарта. Як я вже казав, він доступний, але при цьому не поступається унікальністю, пропонуючи слухачеві зануритися в світ, де блюз та сюрреалізм зливаються в єдине ціле.
Really good blues rock. The album starts off stronger than it ends. Far more accessible than other Captain Beefheart projects. 7/10
Strikes a really good balance between weird and accessible. Didn’t exactly “enjoy” listening to it per se, but can see it being a grower.
Starts strong, goes even stronger, but then fizzles slightly near the end of side 2. I actually preferred some of the demo tracks to the last few tracks of the album. An extremely strong four stars.
This is all new to me. Some parts were incredible and genius. Blues and rock and roll and psychedelic and just plain weird, but some parts were a little too weird for me. To be expected on an album from the late 60's over an hour long.
Hoy toca en este reto el debut de Captain Beefheart, artista que ubico de nombre y por algún que otro trabajo con Frank Zappa, además de que sus músicas tienen un cierto parecido. Sesentoso a morir, me recuerda a bandas como Jefferson Airplane o Cream, pero con otras búsquedas, otras experimentaciones. Hay toques sutiles a lo circense entremezclados con psicodelia y el country, además de otros géneros. Tremendísimo debut, de un tipo de artista o banda que no sé si actualmente existe. Quizás sólo es cuestión de bucear más. Hasta mañana.
Well, it's better than Trout Mask Replica!!
Some parts are ok, some parts not so much. 3 stars or C-.
At three tracks in, everything I have heard so far sounds pretty deeply nested within the country/rock/hippie genre that was in fashion at the time. Dropout Boogie is pretty bad, and apparently starts a shift in the album to "weird and not really good" Electricity has a lot of really annoying shit in it Abba Zaba: ridiculous. Couldn't finish Grown So Ugly: bluesy and not bad at all Safe as Milk Take 5: needed at least a 6th take Big Black Baby Shoes: disclaimer: I am not a guitarist. These guitars are out of tune and terrible sounding Flower Pot: WILL IT EVER BE OVER? Trust Us: I almost didn't make through the intro. The song actually wound up to be maybe my favorite on the album so far. Pretty low bar there though. Oops, wrote that before the 3 hour outro. No thanks Korn Ring Finger: Absolutely fucking not. Terrible Final thoughts: Not great, overall. Weird, atonal, and uninspiring. Also, perhaps the squeakiest drum pedal in all of recorded music history
Now this is much more what I expected from the captain. A bit left field and experimental, but not too cacophonous. It's a good collection across several genres and musical, it carries a tune. Again hot to be worth a 3.
So much better than I thought it would be
Wow! What a great album. I really should have listened to more of Captain Beefheart when I was younger. It's certainly more accessible than TMR, but still off enough to make it stand out from most 1960's artists. This will certainly be getting a few more listens in future.
So at least this is music, compared to the Trout album this is a 10 star album. I really like the music and about half the time I really enjoy the lyrics. But, every time he goes into froggy voice it just feels like a joke and that he is making a mockery of the music or the genre. Sorry if that is his real voice and not the intent but it just feels that way to me.
This album is FAR better than Trout Mask Replica. I understand this was his first album and he hadn’t “found his sound” yet. If critics want to lie to themselves and dress up the turd that is Trout Mask, go for it I guess. There are actual songs throughout this album…many of them are good. Is it perfect? No, but at least I can enjoy it. This record reminds me Gris-Gris by Dr. John…another cool discovery on this project. They both have a swampy New Orleans psychedelic vibe that I’m finding I truly love.
This has such a vintage feel to it. I want to listen to it in a big old convertible driving down Route 66. Certainly an improvement from the travesty that was Trout Mask Replica!
Safe As Milk is a strange beast. It’s not an album that gets under your skin right away, but it has a glint in its eye and a crooked kind of energy that keeps pulling you back. Not because everything works – but because something feels different. It’s blues, it’s psychedelic rock, and it’s pure nonsense. But somehow it all holds together. My favorite tracks are “Zig Zag Wanderer,” “Dropout Boogie,” “Yellow Brick Road,” and the bizarre “Abba Zaba” – songs that balance the catchy with the completely chaotic in a wonderfully reckless way. Captain Beefheart’s voice is an experience in itself – rough, theatrical, and never boring. When he steps back, as in the more instrumental sections, the album loses some of its soul and starts to feel a bit monotonous. But that just makes the vocal-driven songs come alive even more. This isn’t a top 100 album for me, but it’s one I’m genuinely glad to know. It stands out – bold enough to be silly and artistic at the same time. Not everything hits the mark, but when it does, it’s like getting a crooked smile from a man with a guitar and a wild idea. 4/5
It twangs like '67, but nothing really draws me in to want to listen more. And there's too much to listen to on this already.
This record is okay, until it's not. How much fuck around time does one album need? Here it's half.
Truly safer than Beefheart's 1969 masterpiece, Safe as Milk is still unlike anything you've heard before: 'High voltage man kisses night to bring the light to those who need to hide their shadow deed'; 'Song before song before song blues / Babbette baboon abba zaba zoom.' Weirdness ever rules the day here, but listenability is hardly an obstacle you'll need to overcome. The same can't be said about Trout Mask Replica. My favorite tracks, the R&B-inspired 'I'm Glad' and the somehow catchy 'Electricity,' are permanent achievements. Finally, however, the debut is a mere tuneup for his far more virtuosic, erudite, and satisfying masterwork. A first step in the evolution of our foremost musicologist. 'Harvest moon be nimble.'
Day509 - i wasn’t expecting straight up blues then r&b from the captain. all in all i really enjoyed it
This wasn't for me
Much more palatable than the previous Captain Beefheart album, but for that same reason, not quite as interesting or unique.
i didn’t love this. i do really like psychedelic rock and a lot of the stuff seemingly in the same realm as these guys but this didn’t really do anything for me. i think it might be because of the heavier blues base that they had going on
Love their swampy psychedelic bluesy sound
About halfway through, my sole thought was, gee, this is a lotta beefheart.
One of my biggest fears came true… I enjoyed a Captain Beefheart album.
Пощадите мои уши, мне Боба хватает. (Порой прикольно, но не совсем мой стиль)
A classic, and a personal favourite - but on reevaluation I did find it more pleasant to listen to a mono version, oddly. The vocals especially have a weird channel distribution at times that I wasn't really digging
Meh
4/10 - another strange album but this one was more fun to listen to. The guitar was sometimes interesting
It was pretty good
Too weird. Maybe I could do it another day, but I've had enough oddball crap for this to land.
I had relatively high hopes for this one - I remember the track Ice Cream for Crow from my youth and thought that was pretty rad. This feels pretty classic rock n roll for the most part, just a bit more mental. Not much stood out to me, but I can recognise its place in this list for sure.
I will not include the CD bonus tracks in this review. Captain Beefheart & his Magic Band are a group that I started listening to within the past year. In fact, I already heard two tracks from their debut right here, "Zig Zag Wanderer" and "Electricity". Don Van Vilet, the man who would assume the on-stage persona of Captain Beefheart, started as a young sculpting apprentice. However, his parents never financially supported his pursuit of such a career due to pre-conceived notions of artists as being "queer". Don would become so bitter that he abandoned art until he turned 23. He and his family moved during his teenage years to the Mojave Desert area, where he developed his taste in music from the blues and jazz musicians who were popular around this time. Don made friends with the members of local bands, one of whom was Frank Zappa. Through frequent collaborations with Zappa, Don started getting comfortable performing at small clubs and venues. He was invited to front the first iteration of the Magic Band by guitarist Alex St. Clair and assumed the role of Captain Beefheart. After a few other lineup changes and going through a few labels with their demos, the band was able to record and release their debut, Safe as Milk. Right from the get-go, the Magic Band wore their influences on their sleeve with this record, particularly the Delta blues that Don and the rest grew into, while taking the style into a more garage rock direction. It does get abrasive and esoteric in places, with the grainy production quality, John French's well-accented percussion, the twin guitar complement of Alex and Ry Cooder, and the occasional use of theremin by Sam Hoffman on "Electricity" and "Autumn's Child". Of course, the standout player would be Don as Captain Beefheart, able to croon and howl like the big-name blues musicians while stretching his voice to higher registers that weren't thought of back in 1967. There were even moments where he sang gravelly on tracks like "Dropout Boogie" and "Electricity", which were probably alien for the time but pretty cool to find all these years later. If anything, the band played it "safe" on Safe as Milk and could've gone a little weirder. Yeah, this is the group's debut album, where they were getting their foot in the door by keeping themselves rooted in the Delta blues with little variations. There's potential for growth here in distinguishing themselves from their influences, which I'm sure has been explored in the rest of their catalog. All in all, this was a solid debut from Captain Beefheart & his Magic Band. I'd be interested to hear how they turned out a little later down the line.
Second album proposé par le générateur après 'Trout Mask Replica' que j'avais noté 1/5. Ce second album est plus abordable. Je n'apprécie toujours pas la voix du chanteur, mais là les morceaux sont plus construits tout en restant originaux (+1). Il évite donc la note minimale, mais le chant me rebute tellement que je ne souhaite pas l'écouter une seconde fois. =>2/5
Fun fun fun
I really don’t understand this album looking through the reviews I saw this is a more accessible album by the band if that’s the case I’m not looking forward to the other album because I really don’t understand the appeal
3 decent
Wow, what a fun ride this one was! I love how eccentric and whimsical the songs are without being too far-out. Electricity and Abba Zaba were especially surreal. I also really liked Zig Zag Wanderer and Autumn's Child.
I saw the name of this band and I immediately thought be at the hell is this? Lol but it was actually better than I thought it was going to be lol decent album though
3.5/5.0: Very Good
a little weird but a lot of fun. i went in knowing very little about captain beefheart but it was really enjoyable. it’s my understanding his other album on the list is a lot weirder and not as fun, im looking forward to it
TMR >> but a slightly more conventional Beefheart is most certainly welcome
What a wild album
It was weird. I think getting so many experimental ground breaking albums in such a short time is taking it's toll on me. 4/10
Didn't grab me at all.
Milk is starting to go bad
Nichts ist hängegeblieben. Es war einfach da und es ging vorbei.
This album was quite the experience. There were a number of super weird songs that felt surprising for ‘67. It definitely had an experimental sound to it and I liked it. The lead vocalist had a very gruffy sound. The bands bio said the vocalist had an impressive octave range and I am a little disappointed that I didn’t hear that too much in this. I listened to this on a nice walk through an unmapped part of my neighborhood.
What a mess of an album
You can hear the early beginnings of punk rock mixed in with blues/jazz. It's such a cool and unique sound, I think this opened the door for a lot of experimental stuff coming in the years after.
This is almost the ultimate border of creativity.
I don't consider myself an *out and out* Beefhead but I think his more accessible albums - particularly this one and Clear Spot -are genius slices of avant-garde Delta blues psychedelia. Abba Zaba is one of the songs of the 60s for me and as a whole album I don't think this is far behind.
The final track on this album “autumn‘s child” encapsulates my entire experience with this release. At times I was left thinking WTF is this? At other times I’m thinking OMG this is amazing! The album itself often wanders too deeply into psychedelia for my tastes, but is rescued by some fantastic rhythm and blues based tracks, and the 60’s beauty of “I’m glad”. I much prefer this release to the only other album of his that I’ve heard which was trout mask replica.
Fine, weird 60's freakout. I'll be honest, the name Captain Beefheart has always steered me away. That's probably the point.
Very strange band, and music. Figure you can only enjoy it ,unless your high.
I saw the band name and was instantly like, "oh god, another 60s band" Kinda funky. kinda weird, kinda aimless? 2*
bof
Best een prima album, een aantal highlights voor mij zoals im glad en call on me. Tegelijkertijd is veel van het album best verouderd zoals de zang op bepaalde nummers. Ook is de productie niet geweldig en kon ik zelfs met mijn koptelefoon niet altijd alles goed verstaan. Begrijpelijk voor de tijd, maar alsnog genoeg voor een minpunt
Not unpleasant, with an eclectic mix of songs. Some more enjoyable than others. Interesting listen. 2.5
Easily forgettable
Pretty decent. I fw beefheart.
Started off strong, tapered off
Honestly I love this. Beefheart had been challenging for me in the past but for whatever reason this hits the spot right now. Puts a lot of the Nuggets material to shame.
Good
Very good album. I'm Glad and Where There's Women are standout tracks. Can hear the Ry Cooder influence on this one.
fast and bulbous!
Okay, I guess. Not a fan of those older rock'n roll bands, they sound to samey for me.
Enjoyable but went kind of long.
I /just/ listened to Trout Mask Replica, so the timing of this is excellent. I like this much more - this isn't a review of TMR, but this is unquestionably the better album if we were comparing. It's almost incomparable, and I only am as both are Beefheart albums, but where Trout... is lauded as maybe the better 'art' I think this is where the Captain's talents are maybe better placed. This is very accessible, varied and interesting - big fan!
An unenjoyable listen
Now I knew what to expect with Captain Beefheart, and still reminds me of something I would hear on Dr. Demento. I like this one a bit better than Trout Mask Replica.
And interesting album for sure, a bit on the longer side. I like the more experimental take but not really for me
A bit weird rock music. Didn't like it much. Stand-out: Yellow Brick Road
Yeah I just listened to it twice in a row. While it’s not a perfect album, it probably my favourite one so far. The stand out track for me was “Zig Zag Wanderer.”
I've been down all the roads that run parallel and cross over this one so I am very familiar with the territory and don't feel like I've discovered much by listening to this all the way through. I'm sure in its original context this probably is more noteworthy and I feel like I'm coming into it wrong footed.
started from thats quited good ended with ok it's boring make it stop
His best
I really enjoyed this. The songs were different and unique.
This was some weird shit, in a good way
Good in parts
I never really had much interest in checking out Captain Beefheart, mostly because of the Zappa association, but I think maybe I shouldn’t have been so reticent. Make no mistake, this is still weirdo rock, but it’s for grimey weirdos, not uptight, self-important weirdos like Frank Zappa is.
Way more accessible than Trout Mask Replica
listened to again the blues content is solid (the bonus tracks on the version i listened to were much more experimental and less enjoyable)
Adding this to the list of ‘great bands fronted by a total wanker’. What if, and hear me out here, what if Captain Beefheart fronted by David Byrne? This struck me particularly when Yellow Brick Road came on, which sounds just like a lost track from Uh-Oh. I actually liked this a lot more than I thought I would. A lot of that is probably down to the Ry Cooder guitar.
I never thought that Blues rock needed versions that included "avant-garde" or "experimental", but here we are. And I gotta say, it's not bad at all - from what I know, Captain Beefheart was a bit of a dick, but the music here is definitely worth a relisten. I don't know how this plays into the larger CBahMB oeuvre, but I'm interested in picking up some more of their stuff.
6/10 Interesting, but not always pleasant. Highlights: Electricity
As we listened to some DJ rave about an "oldie but a goody" and it began to play, my dad said "this song sucked when it came out and it still sucks." Just because something is old, or "classic" does not immediately give it some free pass on excellence. Now Captain Beefheart is NOT that bad! My example was simply to illustrate that "just because" this album is from a beloved era of music and it is not bad, does not make it especially good or especially interesting is what I mean to say. I think my dad would say "I don't know too many people who got into this band." Which is neither an endorsement nor an outright dismissal. And that is how I feel. For me it feels like sort of a MEH band and there are others who simply "do it better."
A little better than "Trout Mask Replica" but still not good enough to connect me to the band's sound. I'm not saying it's a bad album, it just didn't win me over. And that's okay.
Electricity is the only song from this album I really knew properly though I think I have listened to Safe as Milk before. It's a great blues rock sound and a much better entry point to the strange world of Beefheart than Trout Mask Replica.
That was quite normal for the most part.
Enjoyable enough if a bit forgettable
Here’s the beef!
Nothing to significant for me here. Sounds like some other bands from the era, The Doors for example.
This is the most accessible Captain Beefheart album, with some quite remarkable moments. It dips a little here and there, especially with the maybe comical (?) “I’m Glad.” But the first two tracks should be enough to draw you in and keep you on the lookout for more weird greatness.
Listening to this album put me on edge. It is great music, but I almost am side-eyed the entire time. It's like someone told Captain Beefheart in advanced music composition class that he didn't understand Rock and Roll, and he made an album as a counter argument. While it isn't great rock and roll, it is a fabulous approximation by someone who clearly knows his craft well. Kind of like Mozart being asked to play something for the king, and Mozart playing down to him. It isn't arrogant or patronizing. Quite the opposite. It's like you're listening to a musical craftsman who you get the feeling could do so much more, if the occasion called for it. In so many ways it is refreshing and inspiring. Even if it feels a bit self aware, Captain delivers a tight, fun, provocative album of sex, drugs, and rock and roll. Not mired in excess but with the discipline of someone very much in control and in touch with their craft!
Weird and kind of funny-annoying, I'd not visit this again lol
Electricity was an interesting song. And the rest of the album was the same. Without looking it up, I'm hoping the start contrast of singing voices is the same guy lol. Overall not bad
Cpt Beefheart is always interesting to me because his music is so obviously steeped in irony. Dude is weird for the sake of being weird. Trout Mask Replica is his magnum opus in that regard, but this is also a really interesting take on 60s pop and blues.
I feel like this needs some time to process. I had no idea what to expect. I like all the different elements, they somehow work together to make a cohesive album. Interesting. I’ll be coming back to this one
Reminds me a bit of the rolling stones or similar bands, is nothing exceptional but has the same kind of sound. Interesting enough as a listen.
you know, some people just music isn’t their thing and that’s okay
Pre-listening thoughts: uh oh these are the guys who made trout mask replica (which we still haven’t gotten but is notorious for being disliked here). Scared! Post/during listening thoughts: okay so weirdly I kind of like this. My biggest complaint is it sounds like shit compared to other albums made at the time. Like the production or mixing or something is bunk. But whatever. I feel safe as milk rn. 6/10 DID I NEED TO HEAR THIS BEFORE I DIE: nah Fav tracks: Zig Zag Wanderer, Call on Me, Yellow Brick Road, Where There’s Women Least fav tracks: sometimes the vocals grated on me a little like on Dropout Boogie and Electricity but idk
This was much better than i anticipated based on the only other Beefheart record ive heard (trout mask - ick) Slightly twisted blues based stuff. Ry Cooder brings some magic.
Another one I didn't finish. Found what I did hear boring and forgettable.
Accidentally started listening to the extended version (don't recommend..). Though the original issue isn't too bad, much much more accessible than Trout Mask Replica. Though this is more of a standard blues/country blues style album.
The weirdness and experimentation which this album present makes this a very interesting experience. Loved how you can both enjoy the songs for both being rocks jams or beceause how weird they are. My main complain about this album would be the production. I'm aware that this album is from 1967, but sometimes it feels messy, to the point where makes things hard to understand.
I can understand why my younger self at the age of 14 would not like this record. I was much too immature to appreciate blues music when my head was being turned by the sounds of The Beatles. A few years later thanks to the likes of Clapton the Blues did awaken in me. My record collection therefore has a sizeable amount of Blues associated music but alas no Captain Beefheart (even Trout Mask Replica). So today I listened to this album with the intention of probably righting this wrong. It turns out that in fact there is no wrong to be righted. Not certain if you can pigeon hole this pure Blues and after listening confirmed my suspicions all along that Captain Beefheart was more a product of Southern States drawl if you get my meaning. Turns out my younger self was right all along (as he normally is - the little bastard) 2/5 20/5/25
My only experience of Captain Beefheart is from Trout Mask Replica which I gave a 1. So I wasn't thrilled to see yet another of their albums pop up I was so shocked though because I weirdly quite liked this one! Totally different sounds but still kinda odd. I liked it 4 ⭐️
Listened Before? N These goofy mofos. Musically this album is pretty good. It just feels like a giant joke - much like their other stuff I've heard. Sometimes it borders on serious before going back to it's tongue in cheek humor. I don't really like it overall. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: I'm Glad
This is my first time experiencing Beefheart, so my opinion may change the more I listen to them. This sounds like music for people that don’t enjoy listening to music
First half was decent enough then turned into the musical self indulgence of its time.
Весело. Лучшая песня - Zig Zag Wanderer.
3 as it's a solid listen but not inclined to go back, Electricity is a banger
Not bad, don't think I'm likely to go back to this one necessarily
Neither of these beefheart albums are ones i would pick but this is definitely the better.
The Good: We drink as much milk as we want to! The Bad: That it isn’t Doctor Beefheart who’s telling us that… The Ugly: Realizing that we’ve been tricked by magic… Ry Cooder… He’s alright. To an extent. Then, he ain’t… I’d say that the first couple of tracks were straight forward, no nonsense, blues. After that, we don’t know what to call it. The fun part about participating in this little experiment of 1001 albums, is that we start becoming more critical while we are listening to anything. The bad part about participating in this little experiment of 1001 albums, is that we start fearing the unknown on the list, as there is too much forced weirdness, and not enough “this is awesome”… 2 1/2*
jävligt skumt men också lite kul emellanåt. tydligt 60-tals sound. men man slipper iaf en massa sitarr.
Another one where I'm not entirely sure why it made the cut. This being an album I "Have to hear" is insane because my life hasn't changed after this, in fact it's pretty much the same. "I'm Glad" is cool, but it would probably sound better from an actual black person, much like every single song on here.
Gekkigheid met een randje bluesfolk. De vorige bijdrage van deze zeebonk was afschuwelijk, dus ik had me schrap gezet voor het ergste. Het valt mee. Wat rare stemmetjes, maar er wordt zowaar muziek gemaakt en mijn oren tuiten niet. Maar één keer draaien is ook wel weer genoeg.
Nee joh, een verzameling manieren om kinderachtig te zingen. Volgens het boek is het een 'doorleefde bluesstem'. Kom op... Er is in elk geval voldoende variatie. Saai kan ik het niet noemen. Daarmee kan ik er nog wel 1,5 ster voor over hebben.
Ik ben Kapitein Vleeshart en ik doe met een gek stemmetje Muddy Waters na. Ik ben Kapitein Vleeshart en ik doe met een gek stemmetje Jefferson Airplane na. Ik ben Kapitein Vleeshart en ik doe met een gek stemmetje Ray Charles na. Het lijkt een grote parodie op muziekstijlen als delta blues, folkrock en rhythm n blues. Moet ik deze man serieus nemen? Neemt hij de muziek wel serieus? Neemt hij zijn collega's serieus? Wat wil hij met deze muziek zeggen? Is hij oprecht bezig om mooie of goede muziek te maken of loopt hij expres de boel te verstieren met gekke stemmetjes en rare geluidjes. Het stomme is dat de achtergrondmuziek best prima is. Alleen lijkt het meer een verzameling diss-tracks. Voor de muziek zou ik een 4 kunnen geven, maar ik kan er niet om heen dat ik er ook boos door word. Dit zijn van die gasten die je een klap op hun muil wil geven en tegen ze zeggen dat ze gewoon normaal moeten doen. Ga muziek maken. Het is dat ik bij dit album geen Muldertje hoef te pullen, zoals bij het vorige album wat we van hem kregen. Deze heb ik redelijk eenvoudig af kunnen luisteren. Maar ik twijfel of ik dat album laat meewegen. Dat had zoveel strafpunten, dat ik er nog wel een paar over heb om dit ook mee omlaag te halen.
Albumi #178, 17.03.2025 Safe As Milk on Captain Beefheart & His Magic Bandin debyyttialbumi vuodelta 1967. Ihan kiinnostavaa musisointia, mutta silti aika perusmeininkiä.
When I first started thinking about putting a number rating on this I thought: “Well, a lot of it isn’t that weird and unpleasant so I can give it a three (obviously some of it is a bit weird and unpleasant)” But then what if the bits that are “normal” and “pleasant”? They’re not actually all that good, they’re just surprising like standard music. So if the lows are low and the highs are only OK, I think we have to go with a two.
I had high hopes....there were moments...not enough of 'em tho.
Some of this is pretty weird. A few good ones.
I liked the spookiness on the song electricity but I think this album can't get a fairshake until it is remastered or in a different format. The audio was a muddy as the bayou waters
Zig zag wanderer is one of my new favorite songs
I’m lactose intolerant
it may have been clever to take the piss out of pop music at the time, but this aged like milk
3/5
Always appreciate the weirdness of Captain Beefheart.
An experimental album that just falls on its face with more missteps than success.
I stopped at track #12 since the wiki page said tracks 13-19 were bonus ones. Just for the record. This is pretty harmless blues music that is fairly easy to listen to. The opening song had some juice to it. Also enjoyed Yellow Brick Road. Nothing earth-shattering or anything. Fine = 3 stars.
Had this on in the background while working and honestly enjoyed it a lot more than I expected. Its delightfully crusty and, in a sense, warm in tone. I could see the vocals being a bit polarizing, but I didn't mind them at all. They had a certain husk that matched the production. Not a lot in the way of standouts for me, but this was a greater than the sum of its parts sort of adventure for me. I'd say this falls high 3 low 4 for me. Giving the nudge because I dipped into the bonus material and still was enjoying myself. --- Bass tone on Zig Zag Wanderer reminds me a bit of Herbie Hancock's Watermelon Man. Song itself is fine enough for what it is. Yellow Brick Road is a wild and wonderful one. Sort of like Americana meets acid with the shouting.
Wow this album is significantly better than the previous Captain Beefheart album. The beginning was mixed weird or something cause the vocals felt very off to me. The whole album settled in quite nicely as the instrumentals started hitting. Very very solid 3 here. I feel like I am very biased because I expected this to suck eggs. Had some moments I thought it was a 4 and some moments that I thought it would be a 2 so those kinda cancel out.
Definitely weird, but not even on the same planet of weird that Trout Mask Replica was. This one was actually some semi decent music that just sounded like it was made from some guy in the 60s who loved doing drugs. Low 3
Oh god I hated the last Trout one so much. Right off the bat this is so much better. Digging the bluesy vibe instead of the just blatant weirdness. As I'm going on there is some weirdness to this but its much more nuanced. Electricity is a standout for me.
A voice made scaly, Bluesy bass, and good time riffs, Makes oddball classic
I LOVED seeing so many five star reviews for this album. About thirty in a row. Beautiful. I gave this a lot of listens a few years ago as part of a campaign to appreciate Beefheart, and quickly became obsessed with it (also TMR, LMDOB). A terrific album.
Not into prog
No los conocía. Suenan muy bien, pero no es lo que me apetece últimamente. La primera canción es bastante buena: "Sure 'Nuff 'n Yes I Do".
Enjoyable rock that was abrasive and edgy, but ultimately hasn’t stuck with me! Will have to dig deeper into Captain Beefheart’s bag of goodies and revisit this.
🙂
So weird it's good
This was great. Loved that final freak out.
I love records like this. Weird, goofy, experimental and explorative. The sounds are unique and trippy, making me think differently about the process of creating music. This isn't a record I'll revisit regularly, but I absolutely appreciate this type of production. Weirdos unite.
A precursor to their infamous Trout Mask Replica album, though not nearly as experimental. Safe As Milk still displays some of Captain Beefheart's oddball delivery with his interesting vocals and playful lyrics. Is it alright? Sure, but it also comes across as incredibly unpolished an amateurish. This is a rough draft of some pretty middle-of-the-road songs. It's fine.
Nice chunky blues-rock, the type I adore (way more than anything Eric Clapton put out around this time). Everything just sounds so full, from the drums to the bass, and to the vocals - no millimeter of the sonic space here is wasted. And while this wasn't as interesting as Captain Beefheart's 'Trout Mask Replica', it was certainly more digestible. Certain songs, like the proto Tom Waits 'Dropout Boogie' and 'Electricity', have hints of that experimental and downright intangible sound that'd get fully fleshed-out on the band's 1969 album. And I can't help but notice many similarities to PJ Harvey's 'To Bring You My Love', one of my favorite albums ever, from their sharing similar first lines on the album to that melody on 'Dropout Boogie'. The more straightforward moments here like 'I'm Glad' and 'Yellow Brick Road' come off almost as gags and very sarcastic in the mix here. With that said, they still act as these very nice breathers. I really enjoyed 'Zig Zag Wanderer' because it blends both this album's distinct sounds and it's also the chunkiest-sounding thing here. I also love Beefheart's vocals all across this album, they're eccentric but never get to be too much. They're more satisfying than anything - I really liked him on the playful 'Abba Zaba' and his more emotive side coming out on 'Autumn's Child' was a great way to send off the record. Super fun and an album that I'm sure will only continue to grow on me. There is just so much personality, heart, and innovation behind Beefheart's take on Garage and Blues Rock here that I couldn't help but smile when it all finished.
Not bad. I’ve only know Trout Mask Replica and honestly this hits better for me.
Gimme the BEEF
I've only listened to their (in)famous record, Trout Mask Replica. I found this way more digestible.
Sounded a lot like any other sixties American rock band, but with better drums
Pretty fun, nothing super special
It’s fine, and pretty unique compared to similar albums, but I still don’t love it.
I’m happy I got this before I eventually stomach trout mask replica 3/5
Whew. This was not easy. Had peaks and valleys. more valleys... Capt Beefheart was ahead of their time, but when their time caught uo with them, that still did not help.
Far from the worst thing I've ever heard (especially considering I know what's coming with another Captain Beefheart album on this list), but overall still a really sloppy and boring album.
Sorry Ben, not for me. I had to give up after three or four tracks.
I don't know why it shows me the previous album's comments after I've saved comments for this album. So annoying.
wow this is amazing... was expecting "Frownland" but this is much more pleasant but still experimenetal. All the songs are great, even the extra disc of instrumentals at the end.
Too much going on to enjoy for me. Some cool concepts but not enough space to flesh any of them out. I might come back to explore but this is not a great introduction.
Wtf is this? Parody? Experimental?
Yeah, no. Sixties fayre that, i think, tried to be at the slightly edgier/alternative end of the spectrum. I just found it lacked the purity of others of this time and none of the hooks.
longggg but i liked it more than Trout Mask Replica
Wasn’t quite as wacky as I expected, and there’s some decent tracks on here. Beefhearts performances are amazing. The instrumental back half dragged a bit for me. Rating: 3.75
Its Ok pretty interesting and innovative for the time.
I read that this is their most "accessible" album. Eek. Just being weird is not enough. And bad vocals. Oh, and the name makes me fill ill.
Not a huge fan. Electricity was a stand out track for me, but overall kind of boring blues with not great instrumentation.
This album is extraordinarily creative music, laid over a blues-rock chassis. I feel like every rock/modern pop song i’ve heard since this album is somehow contained in these songs. Not all the songs are easy to listen to, and Vleit’s voice is not super pleasant. But this is good — really good!
Boy another tough album to rate. I thought the range from blues to rock to weird and even some R&B sounding song (I'm Glad) was pretty interesting. But in the end seem to drag on a bit too long for me. Though the first half the album was the strongest and there were a few songs that stood out for me. The opening 2 songs were solid in Sure Nuff and Zig Zag. I'm Glad sounded remined me of and old R&B song, but I can't quite put my finger on it. Some of the stranger songs I enjoyed include Dropout Boogie and Electricity. This album was good enough to keep my interest for most of the way and there were several parts of the album I thought were pretty good. Not sure if I would ever seek these guys out, but overall it kept me listening. For the older crowd, the one singer sounds like Wolfman Jack. Ha. Another album right down the middle for me. 2.5
In Lieu of a review here are excerpts from Marc Maron's Thinky Pain: "Captain Beefheart has been hanging over me, like this weird, you know, cryptic– you know, I can’t even– I’m not even– I will never be smart enough or large enough of mind to assess and understand Captain Beefheart. Like, it’s just been hanging there, but as soon as I start getting into records, I was like, “I got to fucking understand Beefheart" ... "I just walk into this record store, and it was only open for, like, ten more minutes. I just barge in. I’m like, “Beefheart! Where’s the Beefheart?” And the the guy in there, it was almost as if he was expecting me. He’s like, “Yep.” And he walks me over to this bin, and I’m like, “WHICH one? WHICH one?” “Safe as Milk?” “All right, this is the one? All right, good.” And as I’m walking out, I see there’s a sealed Kraftwerk album, and I’m like, “Well, I’m still kind of gay.” So, like, I get that" ... "then I’m waiting in the line. I got my records, and there’s some big old weird-looking dude behind me, and I approached the cashier kid, and he says, “What’d you get?” I’m like, “You wouldn’t understand.” That’s what I’m doing in my mind. So I go, “I got Captain Beefheart.” He’s like, “Oh, really? Which one?” I’m like, “Safe as Milk.” He’s like, “That’s a good start.” I’m like, “Who the fuck are you?”
2 I don’t really know a ton about Captain Beefheart, though I do know he’s allegedly an avant-garde sort of musician courtesy of Frank Zappa’s circle of cronies and that him and his so-called Magic Band are responsible for Trout Mask Replica - an album I’m admittedly not super well-versed in but that gives off the impression it’s the kind of thing music nerds would refer to as “challenging” when what they really mean is “unlistenable”. I’ll reserve my judgment until I give it a proper listen (and I’m sure I will before this list is through), but I say that all to say I was very, very surprised with how accessible this album ended up being. Though, it’s still not particularly good. While there have been quite a few albums on this list thus far that have grown on me with repeat listenings, this ended up being one I found myself hating more and more each subsequent time through. You definitely hear traces of what’s to come with Beefheart’s later, more experimental work, but it doesn’t result in anything overly remarkable or enjoyable here, and compounded with the lo-fi recording style of the era, some of this stuff is flat-out grating. Like, holy shit, Electricity was borderline painful. If that’s a sign of things to come with Trout Mask Replica, God help us all. Thankfully, most of the stuff here isn’t THAT bad, with the vast majority of it sounding like pretty standard 60s rock fare, though there are two bright spots that elevate this above a 1 for me - one of those being Yellow Brick Road, which is probably the catchiest track to be found (I also admittedly have a bit of a soft spot for the Wizard of Oz), and the other being Plastic Factory, which is just a fun blues number, like the kind you would expect to hear walking into a saloon. I wouldn’t go as far as to say they’re two songs I’m itching to listen to again per se, but they at least stuck out to me. Overall, not great, and it doesn’t make me particularly excited to listen to TMR. Still, considering I am one of said music nerds with more pretentious takes than I’d care to admit, there’s probably a scarily decent chance I end up referring to it as challenging as well ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Definitely out there for 1967, interesting
Now THIS is why I’m doing this challenge, to find music that’s new to me and hopefully discover some gems. Today I hit the motherlode; I’m a new fan. I don’t know what I expected but the mix of Louisiana gutbucket blues, 50s soul & R&B, 60s rock and just about everything else they could throw in works. There’s even a track that sounds like the roots of what will become Punk. Every track is so different than the next that I find myself sucked in, waiting to be surprised. And how can you go wrong when the lead singer sounds like a buzzed Wolfman Jack?I know their next release has the famous “fish face” on the cover; if it’s anything like this I’ll be smiling.
Blues music on acid
Who knew Blues Rock could be this catchy?
Can we call this psychedelic experimental blues? A completely outcast album, as the whole career of Captain Beefheart. Really in love with that one!
Liked it a lot more than I thought I would
I’ve attempted to listen to Captain Beefheart’s much more experimental work in the past and it’s never really clicked with me. This album is more traditional blues rock, but also has not clicked for me as of yet. Safe As Milk sounds like a combination between The Who and Canned Heat with a dash of very early Floyd psychedelia. There’s something very pastiche about Captain Beefheart that rings untrue to me, and I can’t place my finger on it. But objectively speaking, this is a really solid psychdelic blues album. 3.6 / 5
Has this underlying feeling that it could go full Trout Mask at any moment where the songs threaten to fall apart, but they never do.
Although a bit trippy in places, this was a really interesting album.
Better then the other Beefy album on this list.
Only being familiar with trout mask replica this is not as zany as I expected but it’s still got plenty of beef in it’s heart
Odd and bluesy. Worth another listen sometime, but I'm not rushing back to it.
not bad for Capt Beefheart!
I'm genuinely surprised about how much I like this, one of the best blues rock albums I've heard. Nothing sums up this album more than the switch from the soulful and dreamy vocals of I'm Glad, to whatever the hell those vocals are on the verses of Electricity, and yet it still slaps. Very happy giving this a 4. Actually like the album cover as well.
Pretty sick, some cool sounds and unique moments
I mean, the intro of Tubular Bells is the music for the closing scene of "The Exorcist," and that's one of the greatest uses of music in any soundtrack. But the rest of this album is bizarre.
absolutely not
1. Captain Beefheart and His Magic Band is such a stereotypical 60's band name that it would be rejected if a screenplay was being written. 2. I have been dreading Trout Mask Replica and so I completely overlooked there was another Captain Beefheart album in this book. Again, there is a lot of 60's rock that I don't really believe belongs but the sound brings back good memories so we are stuck with it. I'm a sucker for Chicago blues, so Captain Beefheart should be in my wheelhouse. The first song, "Sho' Nuff..." didn't really start the album off very strong in my opinion and I didn't love Electricity either. Both were a few of my least favorite songs. Zig Zag Wanderer was a great song though and you can tell the band really liked having Ry Cooder around. Yellow Brick Road is another great song. A lot of "Safe as Milk" is the typical 60's hippie rock I have railed against on other albums. This is pretty non-offensive rock and it's fine to listen to but I have no idea why I would revisit it. Probably didn't need two Captain Beefheart albums in this book, but average 60's bands getting overrepresented has been par for the course thus far.
This guys music is out there. I love it.
I wasn’t expecting to like this album as much as I did. The weirdest songs were the ones I liked most (“Dropout Boogie”, “Electricity”, “Abba Zaba”) but the more normal tracks were still very solid blues rock songs. That genre isn’t really up my alley but ultimately as a fan of similarly weird bands such as Primus (who seem like they could have had a heavy Beefheart influence, judging by the similarities in sound I noticed) I think I’ll be checking out more from these guys.
Not sure how a selection like this makes it too the list?
I sounded like something I would like in time, but I'm not going to go back to it any time soon.
Forgot to rate it yesterday. Anyway, yeah, it was more accessible than I thought it would be, considering who Beefheart is, but that wasn't a flaw of it, far from it!
Funky and weird!
Doesn't come close to what he would do just a couple years later, where he really goes off the rails, but this is still decently fun blues rock. It's just a bit plain when you know where his music is about to go.
This has a more roots oriented feel to it than I was expecting. Good stuff. Needs more listening.
A delightfully weird album. Pure unadulterated 60s psychedelia that leans quite a bit into blues rock, among other things. There's actually quite a bit of range on display here. We go from the sweet harmonies on "I'm Glad" to the vocal performance on "Electricity", which is certifably insane. At one point it sounds like he's actually getting electrocuted. It's absolutely captivating. Very creative, kinda fun, though also very of its time. Fav tracks: Call On Me, I'm Glad, Electricity, Plastic Factory
Dropout Boogie is like 1 or two notes from being "California, here we come". Honestly, this is the most approachable Beefheart record I have come across. Abba Zaba is a great song. Very recognizable blues groove rock sound with some of that freak scene influence.
More digestable than Trout Mask Replica for sure. Sweet that Ry Cooder plays on it. Again, I know I should like Captain Beefheart more given what I'm into, but I still sort of think he's overrated.
Based on clips I had heard on music podcasts, I was expecting way weirder and more experimental, but it's his first album, in 1967, so it's pretty much psyedelic meets honky tonk rock and pretty digestible to the modern ear... except that it's over an hour long!
However this album was produced its a primary example of 60s music.
I've heard Trout Mask Replica before so I'm surprised by how relatively normal this album is. Enjoyable but I'm not sure I'd go back to it.
It’s super dooper cool on a lot of counts, but kind of tedious and a little too self consciously cool at too many points for top marks though.
Abba Zaba will stay in my head for a while.
eh
Previously rated: Trout Mask Replica (2/5) ***************************** I'm listening to this the day after Trout Mask since they are both streaming now. How does this earlier album compare? Well, it's not as unique or interesting as Trout Mask, but on the other hand it's more listenable. It's still quirky twangy rock that is alright, just not super memorable.
Better than the first one - can see the influence. A weird album. Nods to past and future
I started this album and thought it was dumb, but once I got into the groove, read up on him a little bit, I started to get it pretty quickly. Still, it's not resonating with me in a profound way. There are moments that have stellar singing and I like the avant garde feeling of a lot of it, probably setting up a lot for future artists. So based on the influence it must have had I need to give it some props. But the actual songs and music are rarely stand out to me, unfortunately. A couple bangers for sure, but it's more the willingness to go absurd or creative that stands out than the songwriting.
How did this make the list? it sucked and is not innovative or influential.
I discovered Captain Beefheart 2 summers ago. I read some of the reviews about Trout Mask Replica. I listened to some of Trout Mask Replica. I understood the reviews. Then I got this album with songs I recognized and a few new ones. Thoroughly enjoyed every second of it. *zig zag*
I've never been a fan of Beefheart, even though lots of friends are. Consequently I've never listened to this. While it's occasionally odd, it's mostly recognizably bluesy. I rather enjoyed it.
If a bunch of stoned white kids are going to play Chicago Blues, thank the Lard that it's this group. This is what the Yardbirds, Cream, and the rest of those Brits aspired to but were too insecure and pretentious about their skills to do right. Lean into the Howlin' Wolf and Willie Dixon, but get WEIRD about it. Roll a fat joint in the crease of the album jacket and puff-puff-pass, as the Good Lard intended.
Fine. I enjoyed the guitar playing (hooray for Ry Cooder) but otherwise the album did not grab me.
Solid bluesy garage rock from Mr. Beefheart. Not as iconoclastic or essential as Trout Mask Replica, but definitely in the same vein.
I really liked most of it! Ry Cooder can play guitar! Some of it was meh.
- Sure, I see that it was a good album, and yeah, I technically like this style of music - I just got a bit bored listening to it
Listen to this as if it were a Bebop album from the early 50s and you'll get it. 4/5
Could not get through the whole thing. What absolute toss. I would rather drink gone-off-milk than listen to this again.
Sounding like the bastard offspring of delta blues, this beautifully strange album combines RnB, doo-wop, country and psychedelic rock to mesmerising effect. What sticks out is how tight and disciplined the band play and how little improvisation there is. Basically it's quite a radio friendly record (the songs mostly just over 2 minutes) although I doubt Don Van Vliet's gruff voice had too many DJs spinning these tracks on AM radio back in 1967. The Captain's voice is, of course, terrific. The mood is generally playful and there's plenty of highlights. My personal faves are 'Abba Zabba', 'Yellow Brick Road', 'Zig Zag Wanderer' and 'Autumn's Child's. But there's no duff tracks and for my money, this is one of the best, most consistent records of the decade.
A band ive always meant to listen to, very good not as bonkers as i was expecting.
So is milk safe or unsafe? Both, right? The best kind of experimental sounds, I could get lost in this sort of stuff
I really want to like Captain Beefheart, but it's such a challenging listen.
🎧Interesting/weird bluesy record. Dropout Boogie is annoying, the rest I didn’t mind.
Better than the last one I listened to by captain beefheart but holy hell that is not hard
Vreemd en psychedelisch, maar niet op een goede manier
When it comes to Captain Beefheart, I find myself most drawn to the music and instrumentation. I don’t think I’ll ever fully warm up to Don Van Vliet’s guttural, gritty, and gravelly vocals. This album is deeply rooted in blues rock, but you can definitely hear the psychedelic influences of its time. While it’s probably one of their most accessible albums, it still has that avant-garde, experimental edge. The quirky instrumentation, unusual song structures, odd time signatures, off-kilter rhythms, dissonant chords, and “wrong” notes all add to the playful vibe. If you’re into Frank Zappa, this is the closest you’ll get without it feeling like a direct copy of his sound.
Too much „Shang-A-Lang“. „I‘m glad“ saved it.
Interesting record.
Late 60's jazzy/blues idiosyncrasy music. Influential for later punk/rock. Kinda whacky but ok to listen to
3.5/5
This was way more "normal" than the trout album, I will give it that. But then...doesn't that defeat the purpose of it being on the list?
It‘s a solid old timey rock record from Blues to Prog and experimental. Pretty nice
I have never heard of this band before, but I think this was a solid 3. Very 60s sounding and an enjoyable listen.
I'm not familiar with Captain Beefheart, but hoping to not hear from him again. Maybe General Porkbrain would've done better.
Am I not young enough anymore? There is a time I think I would have embraced this crazy. I can feel that me somewhere deep within. But when sitting down for a good listen, this is not what I'm reaching for. A low 3 because I know the hidden me will be sad if I gave this a 2.
Eh this was too eccentric and experimental. There were some highlights ("Zig Zag Wanderer") but that difficult tracks ("Dropout Boogie") were too much to get through.
It's Capt Beefy - has to be 5 stars.
Really groovy, funky blues to start with and then the album just tailed off...
This would've been 4 stars but it had that early stereo technology trait of vocals in one ear instruments in the other that just doesn't work.
enjoyable though at times feels like a parody of the worst trends of the 60s. also, these are the fuckin guys who did trout mask? LMAOOOO
Nasteeee as shit! But on a good way and I loved it!
1967. Blues. Folk Rock. Acid Rock. 9/10 Sure 'Nuff 'n Yes I Do/Zig Zag Wanderer/ Call On Me/. Dropout Boogie/I'm Glad/Electricity/Yellow Brick Road/Abba Zaba/Plastic Factory/Where There's Woman/Grown So Ugly/Autumn's Child
cool blend of genres but it just didn’t click for me (outside of I’m Glad)
Weird and enjoyable,
Rock n roll once again
Wow it's so cool to listen to bands who have influenced your favorite bands I can definitely hear how early Grateful Dead was influenced by Caption Beefheart & His Magic Band. What a joy listening to Chicago blues and psychedelic rock fusion.
The panning messed me up. I am not judging it because it's from 1967 and they didn't know yet very much about mixing. The album itself is ok, it is pretty much like The Rolling Stones.
It’s a pretty straight forward listen in comparison, but strangely enough I don’t find ‘Safe As Milk’ anywhere near as compelling as ‘Trout Mask Replica’.
Weird and interesting. Not overly enjoyable though Standout songs: Zig Zag Wanderer Electricity
I kinda put this one off, because I wasn’t getting a great vibe. But it’s groovy and bluesy. Consistently pretty solid. Feel like I recognize it as a record utilized in turntablism a fair bit
Wouldn't necessarily listen to this again but it was a decent album. Vocals aren't great but the band puts out a gritty sound that has an authenticity to it. Overall, not bad.
I like quirky but this wasn’t fun.
This was not good. I like the blues - this isn’t it
Ok
Sure 'Nuff 'n Yes I Do Zig Zag Wanderer Electricity
Not as weird as I was expecting, but I liked it.
I. Hate. This.
Ehh
Eh
So the Captain can make normal music.
Strange cosmic blues. This must've been before the LSD got out of control
Bluesy roots rock? Pretty fun, but did get rambly
Bluesy and fun as hell
So fun!
Nah
Hard one to rate. It almost goes like an “every other song” situation, where one song is good, but the next song is just art for art’s sake. I did enjoy some of it, but I wouldn’t say I liked the album. Reminds me of Zappa, but without the musical talent to back it up.
goofy. dinky. fun music. thank you beefheart
A lot going on in this album. It was like a medley of a bunch of different genres that Captain Beefheart decided to throw together. Each song wasn't necessarily bad, but I felt it could have been done better by an artist who specializes in that correlating genre. Some of the vocals are wild.
I like the variety and that I couldn't predict what would come next. The vocals are pretty annoying and ruin a lot of the tracks. Interesting mix of 60s rock and elements of blues. Definitely unique. I really like the song I'm Glad. The whole record is in need of a remaster.
Blues rock that isn’t afraid to let its freak flag fly. The production is pretty rough and the band sounds like they haven’t overthought or over-produced anything here. They captured a great energy — crunchy blues riffs with stranger sounds and psychedelia mixed in. I really enjoyed the last Captain Beefheart album on this list, “Trout Mask Replica,” and I remember noting that some of the songs were essentially blues songs buried underneath noise and experimentation. Hearing their debut album and realizing they were more or less a blues rock outfit at the start makes a lot of sense.
Cool sound! I've been hearing of this band for decades but never really listened to them as I thought they were some jokey act but this music is intriguing and different. I appreciate the use of fuzzes', distortions, and production experimentation (even though I generally dislike the extreme panning choices), and I was surprised when "I'm Glad" came because it's so different from the rest up to that point. The singer has such an attractive timbre too; this album flew by and his crooning really stuck in my head. Cool record, I'll listen more!
Aimless, pointless musical meanderings - I hate the avant garde. There's some musicality there somewhere, but it never sticks around long enough.
this was a good album, i liked a lot of the songs they were relaxing, i liked the psychedelic vibe, good album
This was weird, eclectic, goofy, and really fun to listen to.
Did not enjoy. Captain Beefheart sounds like the worst porno name I've ever heard.
It's a bit rough but super fun and weird. Very 60's. Definitely I would put it on again. If I had one big knock I would criticize the recording/production. Maybe another complaint would be it's a bit on the silly side (druggy side?).
This was a lot more blue based then I was expecting.
Gregarious, complicated garagey bluesy pop rock. Relishing in its unexpectedness. Quite casually complicated, starting with the vocals and continuing through song structure. I have to say Electricity is brilliant. I have to say I was continually delighted.
I really didn’t know what to put for this. Firstly, I had severe misconceptions about this album. For years I thought they were prog rock but I obviously got that wrong. I gave this a second spin because I was decidedly undecided. It’s probably a 3.5 - I loved the weirdy vibes.
While I can appreciate and even enjoy some of Beefheart's otherworldliness, this was too disjointed and strange for me in too many places.
I wasn't sure about this at first—it seemed like the quaint first offering of a band that had yet to find its voice—but it grew on me. I liked how varied it was, and they're having a good time. I don't know that it's a masterpiece, but it's better than I expected. I prefer my Beefheart weirder, but this is still pretty badass.
I dug this! A couple songs sounded vaguely familiar and I only heard of Captain Beefheart bc if his Zappa connection. 1967…what a year!
Fine I guess
Weird and whacky blues album. Love it
Started out liking the album, but it seemed to trail off in the last few tracks of the album and I was less a fan of that part. I like the inclusion of the theremin in a few of the tracks too. I'm a sucker for any band that uses one.
Favourite track: Abba Zaba.
While I was expecting some "avant-gardistic" shit like "Trout mask replica", this wasn't that bad at all. Some fun bluesy parts, and quite interesting. Some songs were a little too experimental for my taste though.
A bit safe compared to his previous entry, which makes it a lot more listenable
Halfway through I wondered what I was listening to as I thought i'd put on Captain Beefheart and I was getting normal music. Nothing like Trout Mask Replica
What a mood, what an interesting mood. Blues but wonky.
Got over my hatred of the last Captain Beefheart album and gave this one a chance. Actually pretty good. Very 60's - but none of the Avant Garde bullshit from the last one we listened to. A bit weird, lyrics were interesting. But the background music was really good. They should have stuck with this sound. Solid debut album before they decided to get terrible.
Not for me
A much much better Captain Beefheart album. Very much 1960s bluesy rock n roll. I enjoyed this quite a bit.
They're just not very good. At least it was better than the Trout one