Reviews (page 13 of 15)
Jazzy and enjoyable
4.5/5
De standaard-toeter- en pingeljazz. Vast heel goed, maar voor mij niet zo onderscheidend ten opzichte van wat we eerder al aan jazz hebben aangehoord.
Een standaard kelder-jazz plaat. Het hoort natuurlijk bij het genre. Maar voor mij soms net te vrij. Dan staat de toeter of piano me net teveel buitenspel.
Ik snap ergens wel de virtuositeit van dit soort jazz. Waarom het allemaal zo snel en zo nerveus moet, dat begrijp ik alleen niet. Er mist voor mij een warm bad, waarin ik me kan laten meevoeren. Het is allemaal door elkaar heen getoeter en gedrum, zo snel mogelijk. Ik word er heel onrustig van. Blij dat dit maar een half uurtje duurt.
Mind-blowing.
good
Joyous. You need to be in the right frame of mind I think though, otherwise it could come across as a bit protracted and laboured maybe? What an instrumental album though (pun intended) and has so clearly influenced other artists across the board.
What can I say, just an absolute masterpiece.
It is obvious from listening to this that it is a spiritual experience for Coltrane. I love that all four members of the quartet get their chance to show off their musicianship on this album.
One of the greatest examples of how music can be used to express raw emotions.
I didn't share the opinion of the YouTube comments.
John Coltrane is a huge influence on the jazz scene, especially the more erratic jazz
Waren er maar meer sterren! Best of the best van de jazz.
6 stars if they would let me
Every time Coltrane's sax pops into a song it feels like the heavens are opening. So glad that I can appreciate jazz a lot more than I could years ago, makes you realise just how unique this album is in the genre, there's really nothing else like it. It's amazing how much it manages to do in barely half an hour, and with just those 3 words repeated. Somehow feels deeply spiritual just through the sound alone. It's a masterpiece.
Not for me
1/4, 25%
No.
Some jazz huh? Okay. Coltrane is one of the greats so I hear. I'm going to be thinking of Whiplash. The cymbals on this first track is cool! Cool bass line. Meh it was okay. 2 stars
I need to be in the right mood to listen to an album like this but it's undoubtedly a masterpiece and was hugely influential.
my favourite jazz album of all time
I've been trying to listen to more jazz, this album is a treat. Another one for the regular playlist.
One of the best albums I’ve ever heard. The album that makes you fall in love with drums
Never listened to John Coltrane and jazz can get a bit monotonous to me. I appreciate the talent even if I don't think I would listen to the album again.
Ik heb echt de ballen verstand van jazz, dus eigenlijk ook geen idee wanneer ik iets wel of niet goed vind. Alles dat ik weet is dat dit gewoon een super chille en fijne luisterervaring was. Niet te wild, niet te gek. Komt ook wel door de focus op de sax denk ik, dat is altijd fijn. Een trompet of ander blaasinstrument is vaak al snel te aanwezig, maar een goeie sax is echt fantastisch.
It grows on me every listen. Coltrane was def cooking something up on this one, still don't know exactly what it is though
Thought i was gonna hate re-listening to this album, but tbh it’s not bad. very nice to toss on whilst working
Day 1: Some nice bits on this album but just far too much going on for me to settle in to it and properly engage. Am more a fan of slower jazz, but think for the moment my musical palate is not quite ready to properly appreciate this, I definitely didn't 'get it'. Worth revisiting at a later date if I think I'd get more out of it
While it's not something I'd choose to listen to again, it was a fun listen. And the instrumental/performance skill here is insane.
Beautiful album for jazz, but not something i really love to listen to on repeat. I would respect to watch live but not really more, and thats hard to say
Can’t say no to little Coltrane.
yeah this is just perfect. can’t ask for more
8/10
Way better than I thought it would be. Do I like jazz???
Good jazz 3.5
Eh
I tried this in stereo and mono, and it just isn't for me. It's very intense, almost violent jazz, and that's fine but I just didn't vibe with it. Too noisy.
There are jazz albums I listen to more often and prefer to this one, but every time I return its greatness is immediately evident.
The standard. I don’t know jazz. But I know that when I listen to A Love Supreme, I think, “oh, I want to hear that again.” And then I understand what I like about jazz, and why it’s the standard.
This was good but I suspect my aural palate needs a bit of training on jazz...
Dos escuchadas para entenderlo y sentir lo uqe realmente es una historia 10/10 no erra en absolutamente nada, es impresinante que transmita tanto. Las dudas, el extasis, la trsiteza, la agonía, la nostalgia, la rabia pero no tan rabia, etc.
Classic album from a jazz giant near the peak of his career. First time I ever heard A Love Supreme was actually covered by Umphrey's during a jam. I love this era of jazz: John Coltrane, Miles Davis, Herbie Hancock, John McLaughlin... Reading the wiki page, it says this was recorded in a single session. Probably not atypical for the genre, but damn that is cool. Pt I opens the album with some saxophone foreplay that gives way to the first introduction of the Love Supreme melody as introduced by the bass. This bleeds into a jazzy saxophone exploration over some dusty drums and piano. The atmosphere feels so lived in and lively. Obviously the sax work takes the central focus, but all of the backing is doing admirable service to the progression. The 5 minute mark brings us back to the Love Supreme melody. After some chanting of the album title to close out Pt I, Pt II comes in hot with some silky sax work over bounding drums. Side-note, jazz drummers are fucking amazing. They play ridiculous rhythms and counterpoint the rest of the band so well. Sax gives way to a splashy piano solo that fits like a glove. I was working for a bit through the intro of Pt III but by minute 4 it is straight fire. Pure energy coming through the sax; hard to understand how the drummer is keeping up. Drummer finally gets a solo around the 7 minute mark where he gets a chance to decompress a bit and make way for some calmer air that follows. Pt IV rumbles into form sort of like waves crashing on a beach. The sax floats above the rest telling an exalted and yet distressed tale through its closure. The album rounds out with rolling drums and cymbal that evoke a cascading storm. Beautiful album that is one of the great tenets of jazz music. 5 / 5.
They kinda get lost in the sauce during pursuance, but the rest is 10/10.
Hot take: John Coltrane is better than Miles Davis. Maybe it's not so hot a take, or maybe I'm more of a Coltrane guy than a Miles man. Acknowledgment, Resolution, Pursuance, Psalm. That's all any of us need.
I don’t know this music at all, but really enjoyed it. The finish on the last song with the drums rolling behind the trumpet was really cool.
Ja... wat moet je hier mee. Ik denk dat je meer van Jazz moeten weten om het te kunnen begrijpen.
Ik denk dat ik gewoon echt heel erg weinig van jazz snap?? Veel dingen overgeslagen omdat het me op de zenuwen werkte maar sommige dingen ook ontzettend mooi. Wellicht is deze week niet de week voor mij om te luisten, alhoewel ik de radio dus weer een stuk fijner en makkelijker vind!
Een paar jaar geleden besloot ik om eens in jazz te duiken, en dit was een van de eerste albums die ik toen luisterde. Ondanks dat het niet gelijk in de smaak viel, bleef het me aantrekken. Het is denk ik de combinatie van zijn blik op de cover en het feit dat het een concept-achtig vierdelig album is wat mij toch aantrok en het opnieuw bleef luisteren. Het duurde bij mij een paar keer voor het klikte, maar om dit album in alle rust in één zit te luisteren is echt een mooie ervaring. Ik ben verre van een jazz-expert, maar een Coltrane nummer hoor je van mijlenver.
In this project I have had to reevaluate my appreciation for jazz as I have heard so many incredible albums that I have truly enjoyed. Sadly, this wasn’t one of them. Perhaps I missed something. I read all the praise for this album but I didn’t hear what they did. I will say that I thought Part 4 was quite beautiful, but it took a while to get there.
I have listened to Coltrane, but not this album. Most of the album I came to really like…being a short album, I had the chance to get a few listens in. The first track, in particular, captured my attention. There are some noodly jazz solos that I don’t jive with, but otherwise, I dig it.
I feel so hip!
This project has opened the door to jazz for me. I loved this the first time through and enjoyed repeated listens. Wonderful!
Discazo aunque se le noten los años
I was looking forward to this one as I know it's widely regarded as Coltrane's masterpiece. I can appreciate the musicianship on display for sure. Every member clearly a master of their instrument. I think it's just my relationship with jazz in general but when the pieces drift apart or delve into atonal sound, I enjoy it less overall. Maybe after subsequent listens I will warm to it more.
I think I like the story behind this album more than the listening experience. I've read Ashley Kahn's book on this and I am confronted with an album I want to like more than I do - and I know I only like it as much as I do because of all the context I have for it - good luck to those of you without it.
I'm going to use my ignorance here as a crutch as to why I dislike this. I'd like to think I'm at least somewhat musically adept, as I've played both bass and piano for years now, but this sort of stuff can really come off as a wall of noise and not much more to me, where I know I'm hearing something musically impressive, but gaining nothing from it. It certainly isn't as hard for me to like as Bitches Brew in this case, but this album still suffers (for me) with this stuff. There was things I liked (like, shocker, the bass and piano), but there were also plenty of moments I was growing quickly sick of what I was listening to. This manages to claw itself out of the one star depths, but mostly because I feel it is more my fault than anything that I think, at best, nothing of this.
pretty good
This really stressed me out for some reason.
Music as meditation. The sort of thing that can keep playing all day and is only ever going to lift the mood. It's pot purri of scales, rythyms and free flowing jazz. Timeles.
Honestly just sounds like a 3 year old let loose on a trumpet.
first time listening
what it says on the tin: supreme. like a summer storm of brilliance! best tracks: all
I think this one will take more listens to fully appreciate. Wonderfully crafted solos but Coltrane’s tone has never been my favorite. Some pretty incredible playing on this record though.
Classic Jazz. If you THINK you don't like jazz, you should listen to this album. Jazz isn't for everyone all the time, but this album is a classic for a reason. Good background music if nothing else.
All time great jazz album
This type of jazz is not my jam, I need more structure.
I don’t enjoy jazz. It was very honky in the beginning, but got tolerable.
Nice cool sax
Jazz is hard for me to rate. There are to many doodledtdoos on this for me to really enjoy it. But that doesn't mean it's bad.
👎
Jazz not for me, I’m afraid
Easily one of my favorite Jazz albums of all time. John Coltrane is at the heights of his powers in my opinion on this album and in this era. I am a huge Coltrane fan and love a majority of his albums but if I were forced to say my favorite of his works I think I would pick A Love Supreme which may be a basic pick but this is one of those cases where public opinion is right. I know some people prefer Blue Train, Giant Steps, or even Ascension but this album is perfect for me. It is one of the few Jazz albums I always have in my rotation as someone who doesn't listen to Jazz on a consistent basis. Every part is great but I think my favorites are between 2 and 4. One of the easiest 10/10s and one of the few albums I think is perfect.
Jazz 🕴️
Great jazz album!
not familiar enough with jazz as a genre to like, dissect the album and highlight specific things that are good about it, but i found the whole thing atmospheric and lively, just generally enjoyed it
If you like jazz, you like this. I like jazz and I like this.
A cruisy listen on a relaxed Saturday afternoon. Some nice jazzy sax.
Very good
I'd like to like this music more than I do, but the wild note choices Coltrane goes for in a lot of his music sounds more miss than hit to me.
I know this is a classic but I prefer Coltrane's quieter music.
There were times when, while packing up books for a move, I almost felt like I got it. If the only way I can get down with some music is if I'm super distracted, what does that say? Idk man, it's gonna be super embarrassing when jazz is my least-liked genre at the end of this, but I guess I'm just not a hep cat. At least not when it's ponderous pretzel jazz.
pretty good for jazz definitely something that I could imagine myself zoning out to 3.5
Mi único tema es el paneo carajo Lo demás espectacular, en especial John y el Baterista.
Jazz is a fucking mess isn’t it!? I don’t have a clue how to go about this. I’m sure it’s all very good to those who ‘get it’ but I’m not about about to gush about something just because I feel like I ought to… at times this borders on unlistenable. I don’t understand it and I don’t like it.
Yea nice enough
Added to my Spotify
Quite special this one. Not easy listening, but with interesting great elements
9,75/10
Classic, essential jazz.
It's a nice album to have on in the background, something that you'd be cooking to. Final song on the album is great.
Got dizzy from all the gayness
Jazzzzzy
Not bad but got a bit jarring towards the end
Hell yes. Classic.
So much better than some of his later work
enjoyable enough
Appreciate it but my god it went on.
Was okay. Don't remember much of the melodies. Heard before. A love supreme A love supreme A love supreme A love supreme
Very nice, just as I expected.
Not my fav Coltrane.
I don't need any notes for this. And you, dear reader, don't need my notes for this. An Album Supreme.
One of the greatest jazz records. The opening as absolutely epic.
An absolute jazz classic and one of Coltrane's best. A perfect example of mid 60s modal/hard/post bop. Coltrane is great, but the rest of the quartet are top musicians too. Elvin Jones is a motherfucker on drums, McCoy Tyner kills it on keys, and Jimmy Garrison keeps it on the groove. Part 3 is the highlight where they're fully cooking, but the whole album is sequenced perfectly. You can see why Santana and so many other major musicians are huge fans of this.
I'm surprised my headphones didn't catch on fire with how hard Mr. Coltrane was going during Pt. III. It was nice to get some jazz as a change of pace from the rest of this album list.
Interesting this was recorded in one session. Impressive to say the least. Don’t really understand exactly how this is described as “spiritual” but maybe by some who knows more about jazz than I do. The thing I love about jazz the most is that it seems to take you to another place, and this album certainly did that for me.
Perfect album to listen to on an Easter Sunday morning when it is approximately 38 degrees out Captain Sassy told me to keep an ear on the drummer. He is smacking those skin cans hard for sure I
Well this was a perfect Saturday morning listen. Part 1 was solid but part 3 really put things into perspective. Part 4 ended things on a note. Loved it I’m a sucker for some yazz.
This is unintelligible to me, like all modern freeform jazz - I'm sure it's superb musicianship, but it just isn't what I want to listen to.
This is perhaps an enjoyable album but as much love as this one gets, I’ve always preferred an album like Blue Train and Ascension. This one just feels like ordinary free fusion jazz. It’s really good no doubt about it and the playing is incredible for the duration of the 32 minutes. But, it’s not the essential jazz album for me.
A Love Supreme is a pleasant jazz album to listen to. I understand why this is considered a classic.
This kind of music makes me nervous. I understand the poetry and fascination but I really need to skip this one. One track is enough.
Beautiful. Smooth. Wandering, but never aimless. Every musician seems to be playing in their own little world, and yet those worlds somehow manage to live together in chaotic harmony. You can listen to the band as a whole and it'll be an overall soothing experience. Or you can just as easily tune into what each musician is doing, and just follow them on their own little journey, distinct from the others, and yet still informed by them.
The list has really opened me up a bit more to jazz than I was willing to tolerate before. This is still a little much for me, modal anything is just hard to get into unless you are a different level of music nerd. I can appreciate what it is, but it's just not for me.
Sometimes lilting, sometimes chaotic. Some fine musicianship going on here. I enjoyed it
I have listened to this recording dozens of times. It always has an impact on me, musically and spiritually. Even if I think of this record, I cannot get the melody at the start of the Resolution section out of my head for days.
I’m sure if you’re in to jazz this is great. Brb just making stuff up for half an hour.
Awesome album, one of the jazz greats. I probably prefer Blue Train and Giant Steps to this, but it’s still classic Coltrane.
On the borderlands of out of control and smooth jazz, maybe a bit over the edge into chaos than I like but the rest the band were excellent and well worth the listen. To me nowhere near Miles Davies, my favourite jazz artist so far but I did enjoy the album how ever short it was. I loved the timpani on track 4.
John Coltrane's A Love Supreme is like the Energizer bunny of jazz albums - this dude just keeps on going and going! I mean, seriously, the way Coltrane's saxophone just spirals and spirals, you can practically feel the energy coming off the record. It's like he found the musical equivalent of the Fountain of Youth and just never looked back. And what's even more impressive is that this album was recorded in a single session. Can you believe it? One moment, Coltrane's just noodling around on his horn, and the next he's blowing minds with one of the most iconic jazz albums of all time. So if you're looking for a musical pick-me-up that'll keep you going all day (or night), look no further than A Love Supreme. John Coltrane's got the magic touch, and he's not afraid to use it!
Played it over the weekend + don't really have much to say other than it was highly enjoyable jazz. No complaints from me so max points from yours truly.
Supreme
Nice!
A lovely slice of jazz.
Jazzzzzzzz...
If you do an album in one take and it works, that's a cool story. If you miss a bunch of notes and play out of breath for half a song, maybe you should have just done another take. Best track: N/A
Such an incredible energized recording. It’s a whole world of its own.
Such a masterpiece. Hard to know what to say about this one. All the quartal harmony on this makes it feel enormous. This would be so much better in mono or on speakers, the stereo hard-panning in headphones is really annoying.
I was so bored listening to this I’m sorry I know that probably hurts your soul.
Every time I've gotten an album I've told one of my friends and they'll give me a little fact if they like the album and apparently John Coltrane was such a good saxophonist that they made him a saint in a religion. I thought this album was really good to just sit and do a puzzle to, so that's what I did.
Great jazz
Accomplished but not for me
Well, I mean it was lovely. Bit of Jazz. Perfectly listenable. Not sure I'd ever be able to tell it apart from other jazz albums, but it's nice.
Álbum de jazz, com o pouco conhecimento que tenho do gênero acredito que John Coltrane seja um artista fora da curva
ok. but overrated??
John Coltranen puolituntinen "A Love Supreme" albumi on yksi kunnioitetuimmista jazz-albumeista koskaan. Albumissa esiintyy saksofonisti Coltrane itse, pianisti McCoy Tyner, basisti Jimmy Garrison sekä rumpali Elvin Jones. Kvartetin jäsenet saavat jokainen oman mahdollisuutensa loistaa, vaikka albumin suola on toki instrumenttien dynamiikka keskenään. Albumi alkaa improvisoidulla sektiolla, aikakautenaan kovin avantgarde, spirituaalinen ilmaisu. Omasta mielestä ensimmäinen osa jää ehkä hieman latteaksi, vaikka soittajien musikaalinen kyky on välittömästi ilmeistä. Toinen sävellys alkaa olla sitä lihaa luun ympärillä niin sanotusti. Saksofööni alkaa tahdittaa sellasta valssia että oksat pois...heh...puupää konsanaan... kolmas biisi alkaa kunnon rumpali ritaroinnilla... lopussa basso lurauttelee kuin turkmen brother... from the steppes we come, turkiye tge strongest nation.... ILMEISESTI JOSSAIN VERSIOISSA JÄTETTY POIS... ei lopu kaikki seitsemän minuutin kohtaan ei...heh... vapaamuotoinen genre vaijaha, pitää seitsemän veljeksen mukaan mennä heh... lopussa resoluutio..vaikka on tokan bioisin nimi heh.. se tulee vasta lopussa heh... draaman kaaari..opeteleppa siitä...saxofone anf piano talking together,..duality of instrumentation....and deep beneath the rolling waves in labtrinths of coral cavesesque...referenssi...
Yes, please, thank you
I haven’t heard John Coltrane before. Prior to this review project I was pretty much a blank slate with jazz in general, but Miles Davis easily won me over. So let’s see if I enjoy this as much! Songs I already knew: none Favourites: A Love Supreme Patient 4: Psalm This album gave me a headache. There is an old saying in jazz in that it’s all about the notes they AREN’T playing. Well I’m pretty sure than John Coltrane plays all the notes regardless of what the rest of the band is doing which ends up making a big mess of sound. There are parts where you can hear the brass instruments squeaking (I think it’s saxophone) and it’s just an all round unpleasant sound. The one positive is that track 4 was a little easier to listen to, but it’s still not good by any means.
I know everyone thinks John Coltrane is like the coolest thing ever (or at least used to). But man, jazz is just not my thing.
JAZZ
Alright
I don't think I've ever listened to a jazz album before, so I really have no frame of reference for what's considered a good jazz album. I did enjoy listening to this though, and it seemed like everyone involved with making it was a master of their instrument.
100
- had Pt. 1 as a morning alarm for a short time, so I already feel alert listening to this -Think I ended up being more focused on the talent of the musicians than the overall movement & composition. This might be a masterpiece, but having just listened to Coleman’s “The Shape of Jazz To Come” (not on this list) a few days ago, I find I still get lost sometimes in the tempo changes and frenetic improvisation of free jazz. Make no mistake, this is still a gripping listen, with one of the coolest bass solos I have heard. Was going to put it as a 3, but after listening to certain passages another time think I may have to bump it up to a 4
Made it halfway through. I enjoyed it for the most part but it felt disjointed sometimes
At the very beginning, “A Love Supreme”, feels like a train wreck. In its first track “acknowledgement”, sounds of cymbals, horns, upright bass, and of course Coltranes’ signature sax hit your eardrums from all sides. Wreckage is being strewn violently all around you and you’re just holding on for dear life, hoping to come out the other side unscathed. But In the thick of it all, comes light and salvation. Coltrane, like a true master at work, helps to guide and show you that it isn’t a wreck at all, but instead is actually an intricate, precisely-timed ballet of beautiful sound, creativity, and primal expression. By the time the third track, “Pursuance”, comes on you may think you have it all figured out. But the second Elvin Jones’ sticks hit the drum kit, you immediately know you’ve entered uncharted waters, a space that has and never will again be touched or tread upon. Arguably the best track, “Pursuance” holds you, shakes you, throws you around, and then leaves you hoping, praying, and pleading for just another second, truly pushing its limits to the breaking point, and then cruelly leaving you wanting more. And then, just as quickly as it had come, like a wave washing over you, it’s over. And in it’s place, gently leading you back to shore to all you know and love, is “Psalm”, the final track of the album. It feels less like a conclusion or finale, and more like the loving caress of a mothers touch on the back your neck. Showing you all the beauty and simplicity of the world around you. Reassuring, kind, soft, it brings you back to reality with the soft cooing of Coltrane sax. Almost like a poet, he helps to guide you through this tale, and help you to see and understand what you were just a witness too. But there are no words, no sweeping speeches, no long winded verses or hooks. Just pure sound. And by the end of the final note, we’ll, it’s like finishing that last page of a good book. You’re sad to see it end, wishful in thinking that there could be more, but feel all the better, stronger, and more alive for having sought it to its end. Like your first breath of air as a new-born baby, you never knew you needed it, but once you’ve tasted it, filled your lungs with it, you can never go back to what was before. It personally brought me back to childhood memories, when I would spend long summer days at my grandparents house and would give me the most wonderful flashbacks of car rides with my grandfather. No matter where we went, he would always have jazz on in the car. You wouldn’t notice it if you were paying attention, but under his breath, you could hear the unmistakable sound of him humming snd scatting along. It lives on only in my memories now, but if it weren’t for him I don’t know if I’d have the same appreciation and love for jazz that I do today. Love you and miss you grandpa, keep looking out for us and we’ll never forget you. 4.5/5⭐️- probably one of my new favorite jazz albums and an instant classic to go on the shelves; Realistically, not for everyone tho. If you aren’t someone who already likes/appreciates jazz, it might be a tough listen. Just being honest.
As someone not very experienced with jazz, this is a bit unapproachable for me. Though there were moments where I could definitely feel the music.
I've written how on here how much I love swing era jazz but when jazz evolved into other forms, I don't enjoy them as much. This album fucking rocks. The musicality. The skill. Everything about this album is perfect.
Technically very good, I unfortunately don’t have the attention span for jazz 😞
Incredible album, you can just feel the powerful force of this album through your whole body. Coltrane is a master at what he does and only proves it in this album, beautiful keys and drums really lays the backing perfectly. You can really hear he lets his soul play for him. 9/10 Album.
Fantastic and digestible Jazz album. Every part comes across incredibly strongly. Excellent arrangements. Definitely a worthwhile listen.
Like it's jazz I get it, but just sounded like an unorganised orgy of instrumentals
Goat
Too much jazz for me
Fuck jazz
Too jazzy
мало слушала, но кажется слышала раньше. сопроводила книгой про бейсбол, было полное американское погружение) духовые всегда хорошо!
Very nice to listen to. I’m sure I’d give it a 5 if I knew more about jazz.
Definitely enjoyed this while working but I’m not the kind of jazz appreciator where I need to close my eyes and do nothing but focus on this album each time I listen to it. It’s good for sure but I tend to like slightly more accessible jazz
What is there to say that has not been said. Recorded in one session, this moved me in a way few records have. I have revisited it numerous times over the years and my admiration and love for this has only grown over the years. Truly spiritual and obviously a classic.
I'm not a jazz person so a little hard to comment on this for me. I liked that it was not completely freeform and of course the horns are great, but overall this is background music to me.
Magnificent. One large flowing and vibrant piece of music over 4 Parts. Really excellent stuff. Feels superhuman and like it may have influence psychedelic rock given its year of release?
Amazing. Not so much for the album part, which is incidental, but amazing music performed amazingly by an amazing artist. 5/5
Jazz is only good when I feel like I'm being assaulted with a crowbar in musical form, and this fits the bill. Reading this guy's Wikipedia article was a trip. One day I aspire to also do so much heroin that people in San Francisco begin worshiping me as God incarnate. John Coltrane has officially joined my expansive list of a whopping four good jazz artists along with Charles Mingus, Frank Zappa and Fela Kuti.
Baller
Jazz, I feel nothing special about jazz
Just don't like jazz that much.
En av de første platen jeg hørte med heftig jazz. Helt koko med trommekombo
Coltrane was a master of his craft, but this just doesn't appeal to me.
A monumental album, the finest in the world of jazz. I'm more into rock and other styles of music but this is unbelieveable. It draws you in like nothing else.
Jazz meh
Hard core jazz, the type of jazz music that made jazz fall out of fashion
First jazz album, very chill and easy to revise to
I'm sure it's good, just not for me right now. Maybe one day
This is one of those special albums that defines jazz. Like, you could play it for an alien, tell them "this is jazz" and they would get it, and they would be hooked. It's challenging, but it's also warm and infectious.
Spellbinding. A real sweet spot in his discography where he tempered soul searching experimentation with hypnotic grooves, all before he went completely out the window with free jazz.
Furious and complex. I can't even begin to understand what's going on musically here, I'm not that well-informed in that regard. I'm pretty sure I could listen to this 100x and find something new about it. I can't say I understand it, but I can appreciate it.
An all timer. A consensus top10 jazz record by most, for good reason. Not merely just an accessible jazz record, but one that those with more wild preferences in jazz can also appreciate. Transcendent, generational, divine, all that.
Good but definitely an active listen
Too much for moi.
This is my first step into jazz and while I enjoyed my time with this album it doesn't make me want to get further into jazz. That being said I appreciate this for what it is, an influential album in history. Just not my kind of thing
Didn't expect it to be quite so frantic.
I’m not a big jazz fan, but this is something I could listen to again.
Hyvää taustajazzia. En pysty jazzia oikeen kauheesti arvostelemaan muuten kuin että soittaminen on kyllä ihan hullulla tasolla
I'm not a jazz guy. I lack the context of the times when this was released, and I suppose don't appreciate It for what it was at the time. Part IV was pretty good though.
A stone cold classic, maybe even the greatest jazz album ever recorded. I struggle to put into words how to describe it - just listen to it. Then listen to it again and again.
As a smooth-brained popular music enthusiast, I don't know how to listen to this. I've watched a lot of Adam Neely videos, too, and I still can't crack the code.
It was pretty good.
This is a very good jazz album. But it lacked something. I cannot tell what it is, but it did just not feel outstanding. 9/10
Love it. Not a dull moment.
This is such a joy to listen to. I wish to be this man someday! What's to say? Just 30 minutes of great jazz. Will definitely listen to it again, amazing to study to. Pt 2 is my favourite by far - the sax just goes wild! High 4, low 5 depending on mood.
I really liked it. Is a 5 be too high? I don't know. But I know that I like this album.
Sikkert nice til sitt bruk, huske kje
Recommended to everyone: absolutely sensational. Simply one of the best pieces of music ever recorded.
Top stuff.
Apparently my answer to "you like jazz?" is no. I can appreciate the talent, it's just not for me.
Een van de weinige jazz platen die ik vroeger luisterde
Normaliter ben ik niet vies van een toetertje, maar dit ging me echt te ver.
Dit trek ik écht niet op de vroege morgen. Sterker nog, ik trek dit ook niet in de late morgen. Of rond de middag. Begin van de middag trek ik dit ook niet. En zo rond etenstijd moet ik er helemaal niet aan denken. En in de avond heb ik sowieso wel iets beters te doen dan naar dit zenuachtige gemiep op een saxofoon te gaan zitten luisteren.
Ik kan dit gewoon niet zo goed aan.
Stutt en mjög intensív og afar flott. Hlustaði tvisvar og myndi gera aftur. Gerið það endilega líka.
An absolute genius! I loved this.
Rips all the way through, real smooth
5. Perfect work music.
Psalm
Exquisite. It’s like a prayer or a whisper or a thought. Full of life and fascination, pulling you in. Extraordinary artistry. Unmatched.
Sublime
3.5 Know it well
Listening to this one slightly out of order as I didn't have time the day this one came up for me. Listening to it the day after 'Bitches Brew' gave me a different perspective on it. As I mentioned, I don't have a deep knowledge or understanding of jazz music but this album is definitely more accessible for me and a completely different type of jazz music. This is a really beautiful set of songs with raw recording choices and a live feel. I had a much easier time sitting back and enjoying this album. It flows super well and allows you to just appreciate the incredible musicianship. Standout Tracks: Acknowledgement, Resolution, Pursuance
Don't make this brilliant album your introduction into Jazz, save that for Kind of Blue or Time Out. Don't even make it your introduction to Coltrane; Giant Steps or My Favourite Things would be better places to start. Once you think you're ready it will still probably take a 5 or 6 listens before the magic of this gorgeous, spiritual album hits the mark. It took at least that many listens did for me, but how....5 stars
What is there to say? An all time classic, a game-changer for the genre of jazz, and a huge leap into the unknown by Trane. 5/5
Is this jazz?
Offen gestanden mehr eine dem musikhistorischen Interesse geschuldete Pflichtübung denn ein Genuss. Mich hat es eher gelangweilt.
It’s not my kinda thing but was enjoyable and I can’t deny the talent 3/5.
clearly a classic album but Jazz isn't on my top genres to listen to.
Finally, an album I hadn't listened to and sounds like a must hear! Part I was sublime. Great jazz album.
More recently, I've been exploring and purchasing classic jazz albums. My first vinyl buy was a re-issue of A Love Supreme from John Coltrane without hearing any of it first. Of course, it blew me away and confirmed my new passion for jazz, which is beginning to snowball into an obsession. Great record, amazing lineup of super talent musicians and a recording that is seemingly timeless. A must-hear!
I just don't love this style of Jazz. Listened to some Miles Davis recently and loved it, but Coltrane isn't my favorite. That said, I can see why this is important to listen to.
John Coltrane was a jazz saxophonist from the 60's. He got his start as a sideman for Miles Davis before heading out on his own in 1957. Coltrane pioneered a playing technique called "Sheets of Sound", which consisted of a saxophonist playing a flurry of notes on his tenor within the confines of a few chords. A Love Supreme is a dedication by Coltrane to God, as a thank you for blessing him with his gift of music. That being said, there was a very personal, intimate touch to this album. On this record, Coltrane had paired up with bassist Jimmy Garrison, pianist McCoy Tyner, and drummer Elvin Jones. What I enjoy about this record is that each artist is given a solo with which to showcase their skills. The drummer in particular was insanely skilled! Overall, this record wasn't bad. Jazz isn't my favourite type of music, and sometimes it just felt like each artist was playing whatever they wanted, instead of keeping things cohesive like a band should, but even still it wasn't bad. The artistic talent on this album is crazy! Favourite song: A Love Supreme Part 1: Acknowledgement Least favourite song: A Love Supreme Part 3: Pursuance 3/5
Perfect album, each song on this album takes you through a journey of some of the best jazz ever made. 10/10
Smooth
Only listened to this maybe once before - it's great stuff! I was kinda expecting some listener-hostile avant-garde what-time-does-the-tune-start biz, (which I can handle and even enjoy, in small doses, when I'm in the right mood) but this was a pleasant experience! Will definitely be revisiting. It's just shy of a five, for me, but maybe with more repeats it'll grow on me.... Fave track - "Part 1 - Acknowledgement"
Really a masterpiece in jazz and it was a nice short album to listen to. 8/10.
Nice jazzy album
One of the most beautiful albums I’ve ever heard.
Good jazz — but not sure I like jazz that much
Wat een manier om te starten
It was cool
Could have this music in the background and wouldn’t bat an eye. Not for me in long sessions though
nice jazz
I didnt connect with it, but i generally like jazz so i think i should try it again another time
I know he's a legend but not my thing...
Relaxing jazz classic.
4.0
Everyone talks about Giant Steps as the definitive Coltrane. For me, it's this one. Head and shoulders. Powerful playing, and next level improvisation. I remember the story of Miles telling John his solos were too long. Coltrane said, "I just can't stop playing! I don't know how to stop." "It's easy," replied Miles. "Just take the damned horn out of your mouth." Coltrane kept it in his mouth for this record and I'm glad he did.
I hate to say this but not smart enough musically I feel to "get" this one. It works for me as great non-distracting sound in the background, but to sit and listen to it, makes me feel kind of dumb...not getting what is happening here and it is obviously influential. So going very safe and middle of the road scoring on this.
There is jazz that I can genuinely enjoy & appreciate, and jazz that I just do not understand. I regret to say that this falls into the latter. There are some interesting melodies every so often, but most times I feel like I'm listening to someone tuning a guitar or randomly pressing keys on a piano.
It's not for me
Relaxing Jazz, still like Davis more though
A Love Supreme is a 1965 album by American jazz saxophonist John Coltrane - widely considered his masterpiece. This critically acclaimed jazz album is one of the most important albums of post-war jazz and was selected for preservation in the National Recording Registry due to its significance. This spiritually pleasing album was fun to listen to, but jazz is not one of the genres I usually enjoy, so that affects my rating. I can tell this is an important album, but personally I categorize it as background music aka elevator music.
Nice jazz album. Did make my day!
Legendary. Best served with fine herbs.
Damn, this is good jazz. I liked all the tracks on this surprisingly short album. Just four parts of one musical idea. Uhm, 5/5 with the caveat being that I'm not experienced in Jazz.
Beautiful record. Love Coltrane.
One of the best jazz albums of all time
Typically more into gypsy jazz but really enjoyed this, lots of nice motifs
My only complaint is that is stops after only half an hour
Enjoy the overall vibe, the improvisation and the mad drums. I typically prefer a bit more of an underlying structure.
Alright, I don't know if it's because I'm getting older or what but it might be time to admit that I like jazz. Listened to it twice and found new things the second time around -- and, yes, I know what that makes me sound like.
4 songs that all sound the same, just jazz, not much else to say
A Love Supreme (1965) is recorded in one session on December 9, 1964. Often mentioned in manu lists of top jazz albums. A Love Supreme is a through-composed suite in four parts: "Acknowledgement" (which includes the oral chant that gives the album its name), "Resolution", "Pursuance", and "Psalm". Coltrane plays tenor saxophone on all parts. One critic has written that the album was intended to represent a struggle for purity, an expression of gratitude, and an acknowledgement that the musician's talent comes from a higher power. Great album!
Supremely lovable (and best heard on headphones in mono).
Listens: 2 Enjoyed: yes Nice and chilled. Not a lot more to say. Arguably a perfect album
Finnish reviewwer.. see translatio belouw..google..kääntäjä.. Musta poika musiikkia.. Jahas.. ALKAA KYLLÄ NIIN HURJAN VAHVASTI! Alkaa pelottaa.. ne mustat pojat.. täytyykö kaikille antaa... täydet pisteet.. tämmöstäkö tämä MUSTA POIKA MUSIIKKI ON!! ainakin nykymaailmassa näyttää olevan näin.. Sitten onneksi.. alkaa olla niin toistokasta.. Kuivaa taitelua.. albumi joka viestii jotain... ei kuuntelualbumia... lauleskellaan saksofonilla jumala (ei kristillinen jumala vaan maailman eri uskontojen jumala -🤓) teemainen runo... Lyriikat albumin takakannessa.. jaha.. No spotifyssä ne näkyy videolla... TEKNOLOGIA! huudahdan.. huusin... "Lyhyen intron jälkeen basso alkaa soittaa kuuluisaa Love Supreme -kuviota, jonka päälle Coltrane soittaa julistavia melodioita jotka etäisesti muistuttavat etelän mustien kirkkojen saarnaajien saarnatyyliä" "Resolution”-jakso alkaa Coltranen esittelemällä teemalla, jotka seuraavat teeman kehittelyjä intialaisen raga-musiikin tyyppisesti." "Coltrane begins a solo. He plays variations on the motif until he repeats the four notes thirty-six times. The motif becomes the vocal chant 'a love supreme' " Paskalla kielellä sanottu.. minä selitän... mollissa.. muista se poika.. du pää dä pää du pää dä pää du pää dä pää du pää dä pää du pää dä pää du pää dä pää a love supreme a love supreme a love supreme NOIN SE MENEE! Black boy music.. Jahas.. IT STARTS SO FREAKING STRONG! It's starting to scare me.. those black boys.. do I have to give everyone... full marks.. is this what this BLACK BOY MUSIC IS!! at least in today's world it seems to be like this.. Then luckily.. it starts to be so repetitive.. Dry art.. an album that communicates something... not an album to listen to... let's sing on the saxophone god (not the Christian god but the god of different religions of the world -🤓) themed poem ... The lyrics on the back cover of the album.. jaha.. Well, on spotify they can be seen in the video... TECHNOLOGY! I scream.. I screamed... "After a short intro, the bass begins to play the famous Love Supreme pattern, over which Coltrane plays evangelistic melodies that remotely resemble the preaching style of preachers in black churches in the South" "The 'Resolution' section begins with a theme introduced by Coltrane, which follows the theme's developments in the Indian raga music type." "Coltrane begins a solo. He plays variations on the motif until he repeats the four notes thirty-six times. The motif becomes the vocal chant 'a love supreme' " Said in crappy language.. I'll explain... du head dä head du head dä head du head dä head du head dä head du head dä head du head dä head a love Supreme a love Supreme a love Supreme THAT'S HOW IT GOES!
Fucking fantastic, a great listen all the way through
Cant describe in Words. Epic album. Legend
Banger
A banger. Sure to trigger Alex's fight or flight response
Certainly a masterpiece, but Coltrane's sound can also become a little exhausting.
I still don't know if I can say I like jazz. I'll start to like a song, then they play the same 4 notes 18 times in a row. Oh well.
Great
A stunning achievement
"A Love Supreme" is an album by jazz saxophonist John Coltrane recorded at Van Gelden Studio in New Jersey. It was also recorded in one session by the quartet of Coltrane (tenor sax), McCoy Tyner (piano), Jimmy Garrison (bassist) and Elvin Jones (drummer). The album is a through-composed suite which is a continuous, non-repetitive ordered set of musical pieces/parts. In this this case, four parts. This is obviously spectacular and considered Coltranes' masterpiece. The jazz is classified as modal jazz, avant-garde jazz, free jazz, hard bop and post-bop. It was also included in the National Recording Registry for its "cultural, historic or artistic" significance. Part 1: "Acknowledgement" begins with a gong and cymbals sounding almost like the ocean. There's a bass motif which turns into a "Love Supreme" chant. Both sax and piano solos. Part 2: "Resolution" enters with a sax solo which goes to a piano solo. Excellent and explosive drumming. Exceptionally explosive sax too. Speaking of explosive drumming, Part 3: "Persuance" begins with 1:40 extended drum solo. It then just bounces back and forth between sax and piano solos before going to another drum solo. And finally we get the bass solo. I'm a happy man now. In Part 4: ""Psalm," the band comes together with a smooth and sultry tone led by Coltrane's sax. The pace picks up slightly and becomes more dramatic ending with the drums. I am by no means a jazz expert but this is one of the best jazz albums I've heard. I like the way each song started differently. The band was both tight and loose giving each musician space in their solos and then finally coming together in the final part.
Whilst there was some rather interesting musicianship, I find it hard to stay engaged. Once again, not really my thing. 2 Stars.
Great jazz, no complaints, but not blown away 8/10
it was okay, very jazzy. not my type of music but it was still good.
Not for me
Très bon
Nice background music. I'm too much of a plebe to appreciate much jazz.
Coltrane is the bar for jazz performance from that era. No exception for this album...
One of my favorite albums of all time.
10/11/2022 Retrospective listen, Coltrane is god
who are we to judge john coltrane
Not bad. What you would expect from John Coltrane.
Yes!
Heretical I know. Not five stars. Not my favourite Coltrane album (Blue Train all the way). It's about this point that the idea of John Coltrane becomes so powerful that it's impossible to judge the music objectively.
I was moved just reading all those 5-star reviews about this masterpiece, transcendent in so many ways. It transcends the genre it's in, it transcends the ears, and it transcends the soul. I don't think I can do any better than this other reviewer who jested about God having this album on rotation on his personal I-pod. God, or whatever higher power there might be out there... So I'll just stop there and let the music speak for itself. Number of albums left to review: 782 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory: 113 (including this one) Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: 54 Albums from the list I will certainly *not* include in mine (many others are more important): 51
Muy bien, disfrutón
muy bonito 8 / 10
Jazz correcto. Me ha gustado. Un 4.
A religious experience for jazz fans, but for others probably not so much. It's elevating and otherwordly, but other more accessible Coltrane albums (My Favorite Things, Giant Steps [not Boo Radleys for Chrssakes!], Blue Trane, Soultrane, Ballads) are just as worthy of inclusion, through for different reasons.
Not only a spectacular jazz album, A Love Supreme is a beautiful expression of the relationship between man and God. Coltrane’s saxophone wails and sobs like a sinner yearning to be cleansed.
I have a vinyl copy of this masterpiece, so cracked a beer and put it on. It's not one that I can just have on in the background, it demands your attention. I'm by no means a jazz connoisseur, but I think I've listened to a decent portion of the all time greats. This is by far one of the finest I've listened to. It's quite experimental and has some passages that border on "free jazz", so it's not one I'd recommend for someone new to the genre. I don't have the knowledge to fully understand the music theory, but to my ear there's nothing missing here and no fat to be trimmed at all. Other than that, I'm not sure what else I can say that hasn't already been said. 10/10.
Jazz isn’t something I listen at all really, and while I think I like this, I just don’t have the ear to hear what sets this apart from the rest.
My first and still my favorite Coltrane album. Nobody will ever cover A Love Supreme, nor should they; it stands into the future as a testament to the greatest jazz can offer.
This is one of my favorite compositions. It is inspiring to hear Trane bear his soul through his playing.
Classed as one of THE most important Jazz albums ever - this is what it sounds like when a smack head is in cold turkey and finding the love of religion. If you're into atonal / modal jazz then this is for you, if you're more of a dip the toe in the jazz ocean then this probably isn't the best album to try. Yes, it is important, but be prepared for some hard work. Best Tracks: Acknowledgement; Resolution
Coltrane, you smooth cat.
I feel cooler for having listened to this album
I enjoy jazz when accompanied by great food, or good conversations with wonderful friends. I also use it sometimes at work but not typically as my focal point of attention. I enjoyed this album, my least favorite being in part I when they keep vocalizing “a love supreme” and I was hoping this wasn’t a trend to continue. Luckily it wasn’t, I loved part II but I think part III was my favorite with how it started with the drums and had all these sections building.
I enjoy jazz overall, but only as background music in most scenarios. This was good background music.
Not really my bag, but that's okay.
Fuck, finally. I've been waiting for far too long for a John Coltrane album on this list, and this is my favorite John Coltrane album (at among his albums as a band leader). It's a masterpiece from beginning to end; the product of a truly beautiful soul. Coltrane's virtuosity is on display often on the album, but he's also restrained in service of making a more cohesive piece of music Frankly, I don't know what else to say about this album. It gives me goosebumps when I hear it. Go experience it for yourself 5/5
One of the greatest jazz albums of all time. This album, track for track, is worth listening to.
Phenomenal start to finish what a man 10/10
I am comfortable with not being a jazz person 1
What a great album. Not for people who just want their jazz in the background, though.
Listened to one song, realized what it was trying to accomplish.
Didn’t get to listen.
Mix is interesting, all harmony in the middle, melody on the left, percussion on the right. 1965 so that stuff probably wasn't totally figured out yet. Insane musicianship though. Fucking crazy how they all play off of each other, somehow out of time and in time all at once. Oh shit there's vocals now, a creepy chant, "A love supreme". Really incredible album. I love this.