Reviews (page 7 of 12)
Jazz is not my jam. This is very big band-y jazz, so it sounds very dated (it is!). I like some of the aspects of the big band influence, but ultimately, this didn't win me over. I am still not a jazz fan. The songs go on too long and are too repetitive. I think it might be less annoying to experience it live, but the repetition can be maddening. The high squeaky notes are infuriating. Music is supposed to make you feel something--I don't think frustration is the feeling they're going for, but that's what I feel listening to this. The live aspects of this album (the intros, the cheering, etc.) don't bother me like they do others. It's kinda neat to hear the old school way of talking that was once common in the USA.
Not really my kind of music, but he is a fantastic musician - a milestone
I've been a bit up and down on jazz but I am a bit attracted to big band and this is the sort of thing I'd be happy to be jangling away in the background.
Verryyyyyy good Every instrument blesses my ears
I felt like I needed to be in a jazz club sipping a cocktail to fully enjoy, but it’s a classic.
Before starting this I would’ve never listened to a Jazz album and, despite it being listed as one of my worst genres on the site, I have found a few that I have really liked and given 5 stars to. This however is not one of them. I got bored of this pretty quickly which is not good for a 2+ hour album. I never got to the point where I would say I hated it but by the end I was barely paying attention to it. I don’t doubt that if you are into Jazz this is probably brilliant but it just wasn’t one for me.
Very nice, long.
Cozy jazz - I like it! Too many in-between talks and noise for my liking (doesn't feel like a concert) The very high-pitched sax/trumpet is a horrible trademark
Smooth and live. I likes it. It won’t go in permanent rotation, but I would recommend it to those that are curious. Great sound for being recorded in a public setting.
Liveplatta. Gammal som gatan. Jazz. Inte riktigt min kopp. Många många många låtar.
This is a REAL challenge if you are like me and don’t really love jazz. I’ve found I only like jazz if it’s mixed with other things. Funk, singers, psychedelics, etc. But entry level, basic jazz, like Coltrane and Ellington, I really struggle with. Sometimes I can appreciate it cause it might sound pleasant or atmospheric to the point where I can enjoy it. But as a whole I’d have to say jazz is the genre I chemically don’t mix with. But that being said I can appreciate the immense amount of talent on this album. Duke is literally constantly introducing amazing musicians who have amazing timing and technical skill. But after over TWO HOURS I didn’t have any songs saved. So this album basically did nothing for me but I respect it for what it is.
Not sure whether the listing is for the original issue with only some songs, or the later full reissue (not being a fan of live recordings, I preferred the former).
Obviously an incredibly skilled musician, but not the music I would listen to.
Yes!
i'm a jazz lover.... but i hated hearing the emcee throughout this and also it was long and i really just wanted to listen to B-Day so i feel like i didn't give this the shot it deserved!!!
I can't believe there are so many live jazz albums on this list. It's starting to get a little repetitive. The middle section of the first song piqued my interest. "Blues to Be There" was ok, a bit boring. I'm feeling better than I was yesterday. 3 stars for "Ellington at Newport".
Adding a star for historical significance. Damn, people went nuts for the Duke! They broke a curfew for him!
2,4/5
5/5. I listened to the complete sessions of this album and it was definitely the correct choice. Up to the last main concert track, not the repeated songs later. The crowd gets more riled up as the songs go on and it culminates in an almost riot. This must have been a wild atmosphere because the jazz is good but there might have been something else going on in the audience. Either way, this was fantastic and a testament to the jazz genre. Excellent musicianship and energy from the band, these arrangements are complex yet accessible. Duke is a genius and this is a must listen for anyone who has the time. Best Song: Diminuendo and Crescendo In Blue, Black And Tan Fantasy, Blues To Be There
Enjoyable. 4/5
This makes me wish we had better recording technology years ago. This album is fun but I wish there was a cleaner recording. That said It's a very good album. I enjoy jazz but wouldn't say I'm a huge fan, that said this album is great to sit down and listen to. I started listening to it at home, drove to work and finished it at work. I then listened again at work. It's nice in all of those circumstances, I would of loved to see this live. I think it would have been amazing.
There was some serious squeak on this one
such a long album, but such an awesome concert. again, i’m so weak for live recordings, but the music and the air just feels soooo alive and i absolutely love duke!!
As a Canadian in the current socio-political climate, hearing an album start with the Star Spangled Banner, despite how well played, is not a way to win my heart. THAT and my generally not being much of a jazz guy aside, this recording really transported me back to an era before my time and made me feel fully immersed in its atmosphere. Not sure it's something I'll come back to, but I'm glad I visited. 3
Great Jazz album! Also love the introductions, they add a lot of history
Not my favourite style of jazz but Duke is the Duke
Too long!!!!
First Jazz album. Was alright for some background music during work but not much else. Made me long for an opium den.
uh i'm out of my depth but this is a nice listen and one i was happy to revisit for this project. deserves to be one of the 1001? yes
the fucking squealing
Switched to the abridged version without the M.C. and glad I did. Jazz is not my favourite genre, but even I could appreciate elements of this.
Huge and timeless
The Newport Jazz Festival (like its Folk cousin) had a reputation for being cerebral and (small c) conservative, which was why it was such a revelation when Duke Ellington pulled off this barnstorming performance that had the normally staid crowd dancing in the aisles. Due to problems with the recording the original release of this album was mostly a studio performance recorded the next day, but in 1999 another tape of a radio broadcast surfaced enabling us to hear the full show for the first time. This is really live jazz at its best! Nice!
The music is amazing, but the recording is pretty bad. Some instruments can hardly be heard (even with headphones) and the background noise of the crowd is too high. I felt like listening to a bootleg whereas it is supposed to be a "real" live album. So yes, jazz is a music that might be better live, but if it recorded in the right conditions, it's even better... 5 for the music, 2 for the recording.
Much respect for the Duke. Great musicianship. Good listen. Probably not going to actively register so should be a 3 but for the legend, a 4
I liked this better than other traditional jazz albums I’ve had, though that is a broad category. It felt big bandy at times which was fun. I didn’t know we were going to get Louis Armstrong, that was a nice surprise.
Man I wish I could have been there! This rules!
The good kind of jazz
Duke Ellington is great, Caravan is one of my favorite tunes, especially the Thelonius Monk recording. That being said the big band genre is perhaps not my favorite. However the sheer amazing talent of the musicians is fully on display here, and I appreciate the compositional style of Ellington. This kind of live recording has a nostalgia for me, it takes me back to Tulsa as a teenager. The city has a great live festival every year that I would go to, with lots of raucous crowd participation and dancing. As an album this is overly long with too much emcee banter, but as an experience it is so cool that we have this kind of recording. I think I would listen to certain tracks again, Take the A Train, Festival Junction and Diminuendo in Blue are highlights for me, but not the whole album.
So cool. The intimate feeling of the album really puts you there, like you took a time machine back almost 70 years. Really amazing stuff.
This album didn’t resonate with me, as I’ve always found jazz a challenging genre to connect with. Ellington at Newport is clearly a landmark recording for jazz fans, but personally, I found it difficult to engage with the style and energy of the performance. Favourite Track: I couldn’t identify a standout track, as the overall sound didn’t quite click with me. Least Favourite: The whole album blended into what felt like an overwhelming wall of jazzy improvisation — not something I found easy to follow or enjoy. Album Artwork: The cover is fine — nothing remarkable, but it suits the era and genre
You can tell that this recording is old. There is too much talking.. I think that big band jazz is often more listenable. There is too much clarinet playing (my taste).
I actually did really like this. But it is 2hrs and 7 mins
A big band classic. Not my particular style of music, but world class players all, and a historically significant work.
Don't often find myself listening to big band/orchestral jazz albums, but here we are. Toe-tappers for sure, and talented musicians throughout, albeit not the type of music I look for often.
Grounded in the Big Band sound but with decidedly modern solo performances.
What a show.
It’s a strange thing listening to this album on streamers in 2025 because you’re conscious that you’re not hearing the original 1956 LP. The original album is a swift 46 minutes with studio overdubs liberally applied (60% of the “live album”. On the “complete” version, you’re firstly delivered the full 75 minute show, which is captivating, then studio excerpts from those curious overdubs. You are then presented with what is sort of the original album, with one track subbed in and one track subbed out. The two albums sound nothing like each other! Nothing at all! I wonder if anyone at the original performance who picked up the LP months later could tell that fake audience clapping was being faded in and out! The original unaltered recordings are sensational, really showing what Duke Ellington can do with a piano. Despite being recorded in an open air environment it’s full of warmth. I’m not hearing the original record through a gramophone set up, but listening side by side with the truly live recording it quite obviously lacks that same level of warmt. But then it sold an absolute tonne in the 50s - so what do I know about anything? Both records are great and give you a proper rush. But the original is a stealth studio album.
7/10 Duke Ellington really was one of the best jazz artists. An immersive project as a live recreation. My favorite has to be Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue. My only complaint is that it was a tad too long for me. If I’m looking for jazz, this will be where I go.
Wayyyyy too much patter in this live album but you cannot argue with that jazz
3.5
I can’t deny the high craftsmanship of the various musicians. Duke was a masterful bandleader and ran a great showcase for the style in Newport. I just don’t care at all for jazz, especially the older, band-style of the genre. I would avoid any elevator that played this music and just walk up the stairs. But 4 stars for their talent and artistry.
A 3+ hour Ella Fitzgerald freakin' box set yesterday and a 2+ hour Duke Ellington album today. Nothing bad about them, but damn! Would it kill you to give me a 40 minute Black Sabbath album this week? 3/5 Album 62/1001
Quality live big band
I typically don't like jazz and this is cozy but still does not make me want to listen to it. I get the vibes but the vibes are not for me. 3,5/10
Ele sabia o que tava fazendo
Dope
Decided to listen to the original album - which is 38 mins - and found this on Spotify. Really impressive performance and captures the raw energy of the big band.
Talented live big band jazz performances, might've enjoyed more with better audio/without all the stage introductions. Standouts: Take the A Train, Diminuendo In Blue
Hella long. Wow. Not my style, but I recognize the talent.
I love this. It’s a bit long for me but I appreciate having the complete show here.
Ellington and Company are simply spectacularly jazzy in this record, the performances and compositions here are excellent. Ellington is obviously great, but many others shine as well in different songs. My favourite was "Festival Junction" and "I Got It Bad" was also excellent, loved the slower vibe and the sax playing by Hodges is perfect, same with "Jeep's Blues". Gonsalves is also excellent in "Diminuendo in Blue". My least favourite moments where when the record gets more "swing-y", like in "Newport Up". It's not bad, just not my favourite. As an album, it's a bit different than most other records, it's more than 2 hours long, and being a live record, it has a lot of interludes in the form of talking, presentations and crowd interaction. The complete edition also has a fair amount of repetition in the second disc. Having this in mind, I think you have to have at least some taste for jazz and a bit of patience to enjoy the record cover to cover. I also found opening with "The Star Spangled Banner" was a bit too much. Overall, this is a historic piece of jazz, and justifiably so. But as an album, it still has a bit of room for improvement in terms of flow and removing some of the repetition.
Solid jazz/swing album. The first live album I've gotten in this project, and part of my rating considers the background noise and announcements included in the album
Wonderful. Seems like a product of time gone by (which it is). I loved the transition from Skin Deep into the crowd almost rioting - talk about something that would never happen in 2025. Blues to Be There is my favorite track.
Favorites: Festival Junction, Newport Up, Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue It's possible I made a mistake listening to the original pressing off of a YouTube rip instead of the complete edition... This was good, but I'm not 100% a fan of the big band sound.
Album #1 Not a jazz or big band fan. Still, some of this was great. The rest was technically good, and I see why this is a highly regarded album, but I lost interest multiple times. Until the squealing trumpet brought me back. Highlights: Black and Tan Fantasy Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue
Intense listening. Skin Deep is maybe the best track. Drums drums drums.
One of the best big bands at one of the best jazz festivals. I'm grateful that this was recorded and that we can hear it.
I guess you would call this Big Band Jazz, at least I would. Not something I would listen to again. Definitely appreciate the talent, just not for me
Not for me
This song reminds me of something you would hear in like a nice Italian resturant. I rate this song a 10/10.
I rate Jeeps Blues a 5 star because its like jazz and I really like jazz and the saxophone is good all the instruments are good ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐. I rate Take The "A" Train a 5 star because its like jazz and I really like jazz and the saxophone is good all the instruments are good⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐. I rate Saffiicated Ladie a 5 star because its like jazz and I really like jazz and the saxophone is good all the instruments are good⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐.
Song: jeeps blues this song has no lyrics so that is fine i guess never heard this song because i do not listen to jazz Song: take the a train this song is good again i do not really listen to jazz and there are no lyrics too Song: Sophisticated lady this song is good i honestly like this one a little bit but it is a little goofy and no lyrics again this is the song that older movies will play
This album sounds like hotel lobby music which makes me feel nostalgic. It sounds really good to be honest I will probably listen again.
Do you want to listen to some music that has some nice saxophone? Well in Jeep's Blues you can! I rate this song a ⭐⭐⭐⭐. I recommend this song. Do you want to listen to some music that has some really nice piano? Well Inn Take The "A" Train you can! I rate this song a ⭐⭐⭐⭐. I recommend this song. Do you want to listen to some music that has a lot of saxophone? Well in sophisticated lady you can! I rate this song a ⭐⭐⭐. I kind of recommend this song.
i dont like this song because there is no singing but the beat is kind of good . i dont like the second song i dont like the beat i dont recomend this album
I dont like this at all because I don't like jazz and I don't like how there are no lyrics. I would not recommend this to someone else because I think that they would not like them. I give this 1 star.
I don't like it because it has no words and its just the piano and I wouldn't listen to it cause I would get bored the second song I also don't like cause it has no words the third song I also don't like cause its not a song I would listen too
the first song is lowk bad idk why I don't like it its js that the background music was alr n yea the second song was alr bc the music was ok n the trumpet I think I was idk how to spell it but that part was good.
"Jeep's Blues" wasn't terrible. I'm not a fan of jazz but this is good. I like the saxophone and piano. "Take The A-Train" was not as good. The piano sounded off-pitch. But I did like the horns. "Sophisticated Lady" is okay. It actually sounded like in a movie a sophisticated woman is entering the room and seducing men. I don't know if I would recommend this album.
the first song is okay i like how the instruments sound i just dont like how silent it gets and i also dont like how quiet the song is in general. the next song is also okay there is not much of a difference between the two songs they are both pretty quiet. the last song is still the same. overall i dont really like this album i would not recommend it.
The first song is okay but I think I like the second song better. The album cover is kinda odd but I don't think its weird like some of the other album covers I've seen. It just kinda sounds like elevator music. Jazz isn't really my thing so I don't know about this album. The third song is for sure not my favorite one out of this album. I'm not sure if I would recommend this album to someone because people aren't very fond of jazz music.
Big band jazz - not my favourite type but you can't help but toe tap to it. Probably more famous for the reception Ellington got that makes this a historic piece of art, listen to the whole set to get a real feel of the electricity in the crowd. Spread out a picnic blanket, have some nice food, smoke a joint and just enjoy it. Best Tracks: Blues To Be There; Jeep's Blues; Diminuendo in Blue
Smooth
It's Duke Ellington. Ya gotta respect it.
It goes!!!!
This album almost makes up for the stunning lack of important Jazz on this list. 5/5
An interesting piece of musical history — the solo in Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue truly lives up to its reputation.
Wow, this was fun! I only winced a little bit at those squeaky high notes that felt more show-offy and novelty than musical.
This wasn't bad. The band really started to cook on the last track.
This one is hurt by the recording itself. The band is great, the solo is amazing. I’m not normally a jazz guy, but I can get behind this one, but I think that’s because I do enjoy Big Band type jazz. But the recording is so subpar. The crowd noise is too high (but man is the crowd enjoying themselves!) and overall the mix is just bad. Would’ve loved to hear this with modern recording tech.
Album very Jazz. Contains much sound. It is rated
I'm generally much more a fan of more stripped down jazz than big band stuff, but this album is just undeniably phenomenal. This is one I absolutely need to get.
Si alguien hiciera la lista super oficial con todos los discos de la historia y éste quedara en primer lugar, no tendría peros. Así de bueno es.
Very talented but not my jam
Good background
Good happy background music that is calming
He is talented but jazz stresses me out. I preferred the more structured songs with vocals like ""Day in And Day Out".
I could enjoy this in 5 minute intervals, but a whole record was too much. Not for me.
If I wanna listen to a jazz concert, I'll go to a jazz concert. Obviously amazing musicianship etc but not enough to grab me when I listened to it.
Increeeedible solos on this one. Shoutout to sax on Diminuendo in Blue for the 27-chorus long solo. Also really impressed at the production quality for it being a 50s album, that trumpet felt like it was in my brain.
"Diminuendo in Blue" is amazing. The solo is unbelievable.
It's a pretty good jazz album. Despite being a big band the songs give plenty of time to some of the individual members and let them shine. I wish there was a more concise edition than the one on Spotify though, which included the recordings from between songs and two versions of some tracks.
Not quite my tempo… unfortunately an all around snooze fest. I can appreciate what he may have done for the genre but me listening to it today was tough to get through. INCREDIBLE background music tho. 3/10 My Top Track: Take the “A” Train
I’m sure Duke Ellington paved the way for jazz music. However, this “album” is half of them speaking and the other half is live performances where I can’t hear any other instruments other than this🎺 If it was 1950 and I had some ❄️ with a broad on my shoulder drinking an old fashioned, this would be a 10/10. Instead it’s a 2/10 especially for it staring with the star spangled banner.
Obviously excluding all of the introductions and the national anthem, the album isn't the worst. Jazz instrumentals always make for good background music. If that trumpet wasn't so overbearing at times, I would have enjoyed it more. 3.5/10
If you really like Jazz this album is probably pretty awesome and I can see how it is musically technically impressive.
"Shocker: I didn't hate it! But the live recording made me feel like I was stuck in a stuffy auditorium. 2/5 – close enough to decent, I guess."
97/1089 - Amazing soloists. Cool harmonies. Crowd was loving it. A fun live album to listen to.
I heard if you wanted this at Gordon Ramsay’s restaurant you have to call ahead…no wait, that’s Beef Wellington… The music was great, but I could do without all the emcee banter. 3⭐️
pretty jazzy pretty good
Good, but long -- it was a double-album, and that's a lot of jazz. I can only take jazz in small doses, but it was a classic.
Fantastic. I am typically not a fan of big band jazz, but this is just right.
I have to apply my live album tax to this rating as per previous reviews, undoubtably excellent but live albums do not belong on this list
Good album
Fantastic, lively live jazz album. Very enjoyable.
Swinging stuff!
Swingin as gideon said
Some great jazz!
This is a tough one to rate. Duke Ellington is an electric musician and is a once in a millennium talent. He makes the instruments sing and come alive and I wish I could have been there at this performance taking it all in. Listening to this album reminded me of why I don’t like live albums. I don’t like the audience cheering or interruptions and the banter from the emcee made an already long album a bit of a slog. Also there were times at the end of the songs that he’d make the trumpet squeal in a really unpleasant and loud and repetitive way that almost made me want to turn this off. I wouldn’t listen to this again but I’d listen to the studio versions of any of these songs.
So fucking beeindruckend 🥹
I'm sure that's music that requires incredible skill and talent to make, but it's just not my thing. Also I personally didn't like this particular live recording.
This is so my speed
Duke Ellington! Hell yeah.
What an igniting performance! If you don't like this, you don't like jazz.
Stunning “live” performance from Duke Ellington and his band. Textbook definition of what a jazz recording should be.
So familiar. i know and can hear Ellington's brilliance but I have a hard time connecting with the music
Too much talk
Okay, it's long - but Jazz is easy listening, right? Yes, it is, this is great. I did skip the announcements; I understand it's a live album, but I don't feel like I missed anything by skipping them. First time listening to a full jazz record and I can really get behind this.
First listen. Solid album with great solos but what do I know about Jazz? Liked the part where Duke had to calm down the audience to stop a riot.
Before I die, am I supposed to listen to the 1956 album or the complete version released in 1999?
Fantastic album, absolutely love jazz if I don’t listen to it all the time. Duke Ellington is really really good, his group is so tight. It’s a bit long at two hours and 11 minutes, with a lot of those filler talking in between, but I think it was important for me to listen to this.
Wish i liked jazz, but I don't.
not for me
Plenty of respect for this musician and this album, but I don't think I'm going to be listening to this a lot in the future. It's just not my jam
This album leaves a similar impression as the Muddy Waters At Newport one, it's a good album, but it's a shame it's a live one. It starts off rather slowly, but picks up the pace after a couple of tunes. The winded instruments shine the most in my opinion, the sax, trumpet and the clarinet. The rhythm section is not that well mic'd up, so it doesn't come of as loud as it should and is kind of underwhelming. While on the other hand, brass instruments come of as too strong at times. The piano provides a nice background to the wind soloists. The album is a nice, relaxing listen, especially because of the aspect of it being live. It sounds more laid back, natural and "next to you", even though the quality suffers because of this. Still, this is a great example of a big band jazz orchestra doing everything from big monumental intros to intricate solo pieces and improvisations. Solid album, but it's not amongst the best I heard in the genre, mostly because of it's lack of fidelity. Wasn't sure whether I should give it 3 or 4. Giving it a 4 just because of the musicianship and talent on display.
It's jazz. Live jazz.
Absolutely fine. The band and audience are having a great time. It's too old-fashioned for my taste though.
I skipped over some of the extra long emceeing and did find it all a bit long for me. But wow what a band. It’s insane how crisp and flawless they sound on a live album. The musicianship is off the charts. Truly quintessential. And I enjoyed hearing the crowd reactions; they were going wild at some parts!
Pretty good big band jazz album, great playing overall. But let me just say, it is so annoying when Spotify only has the extended (or in this case "complete") versions of albums. The way I like to listen to music is by adding them to the queue, so when it's the extended version it adds a whole bunch of demo/live versions/b-sides that I don't really care about. However, this extended version doesn't even start with the original 1956 release, it ENDS with it, with some other stuff shoved in between. Here is the original track list: Festival Junction Blues to Be There Newport Up Jeep's Blues Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue Anyways it was a good album. High 4.
Duke is the king of big band, but even the best swingy jams couldn't save this 2+ hour monster from feeling like a chore
I knew that Duke Ellignton was someone that I had to deep dive. He is a god and walked this earth so that Coltrane, Davis, and Mingus could run. What a fun fun jazz album and a new must have on Vinyl
I liked the music, but the album was too long. At disc 2, I was starting to zone out. I prefer albums around 45 minutes to 1 hr running time. I can make an exception for specific artists and genres, but I like them short overall. Still, that won't affect the rating that I am giving, which is 4 stars.
Listen, I'm sure this was insane to hear in the 50s. There wasn't anything else to do back then so I'm sure listening to a 2 and a half hour album was amazing, but now? Now, all I can think is, "Wow, the songs are really good, why do I have to hear him introduce the songs and talk about the weather? I really don't care."
****a great album
If you like jazz, you'll love this album.
I found this to be insanely good. The craft and musicianship at display here is incredible and the energy that seeps out of this thing is insane. This is the kind of surprise that I do this challenge for.
Very good jazz music to study to, just not that big of a fan of jazz
good
This is an amazing album!
Enjoyed this.
Great, fun background music
I like jazz, and this was certainly that
Great jazz
40 songs !?!?! Thank god there was some songs of few seconds or minutes which was perfect. Actually I hate albums which have way too long songs but this time that was perfect and Duke is clearly one of the best musician ever so that's awesome to listen to his work, I particularly looooove the first album for sure. So thank you for your work Duke we <3 U
Long album! Black and tan fantasy - great opener Super high pitched trumpet parts are so goofy 3.5
I hate jazz
Classic Jazz, also gave me big band vibes. Easier to listen to than more complex jazz
Yall I found a shortcut just listen to the 40 minute version 😜
4/5 Mostly instrumental jazz, some blues.
Music was fantastic and a live album showcases the peak talents of everyone but the emcee yapping and length bring it down to 4 stars
8.9
The fact that Ellington thought the original recording wasn't good enough so he had to fake it in the studio is absolutely absurd. Some incredible recordings here. So much energy, so much creativity. Loved this a lot. The vocal tracks are by far the worst here, as vocal jazz is typically not very good!!
If I was actually in the audience for this performance, I'm sure this would be a 5. I wasn't. I can't fault any of the playing, but this shouldn't have been experienced as an album. 2 Stars.
Great historical document if you will. Probably my attention span doesn't hold up for this 2 hour experience
Infectiously energetic. Masterful performance from the Duke and the whole band. And Sam Woodyard rocking a double bass setup behind the drum kit - in the 50s! Wild stuff.
So I didn't realize the original version was only FIVE tracks and listened to almost the entire complete version. I don't regret hearing the entire Newport set, and so that's where I ended my listen and that's the version I will be rating. The MC sections are not necessary and ruined my enjoyment. I get it's meant to make you feel like you're there, but it's not for me.
Not my fav jazz style. Big band with lots of tongue in cheek playing and a showy feel. Has a great version of take the a train. A great introduction to the sounds of big bands in the mid 50s Ellington is a master of his sound sadly I Don't think this recording showcases the best of his writing style. I much prefer the tape with coltrane. Was a long concert back then! Didn't really appreciate the intros between tracks but still gives it an authenticity.
Oh god it was so long. 2+ hrs of Duke Ellington is too much. Maybe it would be fine as background noise but does it deserve to be in 1001 albums if it's only good for background noise...
Although I’m not a massive fan of this genre, I felt rather swooned and intrigued by this one. I found myself listening to each note, seeing its meaning and all things like such.
Listening to Sir Duke immediately after having to sit through a SZA album is akin to slowly sipping a neat 15-year Talisker single-malt in front of a roaring fire after having been force-fed a bowl of moldy Weetabix soaking in your dog's water dish for a month. 9/10 4 stars.
Great
A wordless story Instrumental class and skill Beyond just grandeur
The Big Band Great.
Live album. Jazz. 10/10
two
Classical night jazz set. Not the best one, but it’s Duke Ellington, its legend
If you want to havea albums on this list, they need to be a step above board tapes. This sounds like it was recorded from a TV broadcast. I'm not buying the time period as an excuse. That being said....its some ok jazz. Thats about it.
More Big Band than Jazz.
I chose to patch together the original 1956 L.P. track listing using the 2017 Columbia - Legacy "Newport 60th Anniversary Edition" 96kHz/24 bit mono release. That gave me something a more manageable 43 minutes long to listen to. The various "complete" and "expanded" editions are, I am sure, "important" but this list is taken from "1001 albums..." so I'm going to listen to the original album where possible. Just to see what all the fuss was about. The sound quality on this album is very much of its time; mono and a bit "distant". Curiously, I prefer that to the snippet I head of the re-mastered, massaged into "stereo" recordings. YMMV. It's the sort of album that I expect to sound great on my valve amplifier. I'll get around to that a bit later, solid-state will have to do for the moment. The playing is exceptional. Real top quality swing/jazz. 4/5.
Hit a pr while listening. Goated jazz.
He's a talented man, but it's not something I can easily listen to for a full album!
Interesting concert, listened to the original version.
Festival Junction- fun, high-spirited introduction Blues to Be There- the trumpet player with the mute is the hero- don't love the end, which sounds like something from a 50s sitcom Newport Up- clarinet and trumpet solos to open Jeep's Blues Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue- feels like a goshdarned juke joint, which is strange, because that wasn't Ellington's thing- he led the classics, most talented Orchestra in the world
Twooooo hourssssssssss!!
Duke Ellington always delivers and is pleasant to listen to. There's some great playing on here and the band seems to be really energetic. Listening to this one really made me want to listen to the complete 2 hour concert. I can see why he was so popular back in the day, its very easy yet pleasant Jazz to listen to. It really feels like a celebration of Jazz and Ellingtons own career.
This is such an odyssey and I loved the elongated introductions (including the Quincy Jones shout-out!), but it loses a star because I think the solo on "Festival Junction" burst my eardrums.
I was a little skeptical about this one at first, but I think the fact that it was live saved it for me. It was a great album, and upon reading more about it, it was cool how this album re-ignited Duke's career, and also got such a huge crowd response toward the end. Pretty cool to hear that live.
Big band style jazz is not my cup of tea and this live format didn't do anything to change that. Furthermore it was way too long. It must have been a double or triple on vinyl.
Cool.
Genuinely, this album has to be one reason headphones, an easy chair, and gin was created. Never listened to his particular album before but it will be staying on regular rotation now. Stunningly talented musicianship with the leadership of Duke.
As tough to listen to as expected.
Marginally better than the average jazz album, of which there are too many on this list.
A fun album that. To my mega naive ear in this genre that seemed to owe as much to big band style as to jazz. Quite a pleasant mix really. My favourite parts are the nifty funky bass lines which I’d love to hear more prominently, but for obvs reasons that isn’t possible in a live album. Would happily listen again.
Boring
Love this rendition of 'Take the A-Train.' Also the drum solo at the end of the album is absolutely killer. High energy, songs that sound like they were extremely fun to play!
Instrumentals were cool but never found myself getting into straight Jazz instrumentals, not for me. Talent is amazing tho.
# Album Name: Ellington at Newport # Artist: Duke Ellington # Rating: 4/5 # Comments: Im not a jazz fan but i enjoyed the album in its entirety. # Top Tunes: Not sure - it blended into one tbh. Good album all round. # Would I listen to it again? Yes
Typical post-war jazz. Like the stuff you would hear at one of those expensive restaurants that are trying too hard to sell you an experience over actual ambiance and good food. I don't know enough about jazz to really comment on it, but the production value and quality of the players is definitely really good. I think if I was more into jazz this would be at the top of my list. I can also appreciate that Ellington was super influential in the jazz arena.
I usually like jazz but this one just didn't hit for me.
Well I fucked up on this one. The album refered to is relatively short and good jazz. I unknowingly listened to the complete version, which clocked in over 2 hours and had multiple introductions and "that's it folks." The spoken parts were rather annoying to have constantly throughout a live album (pick one introduction, limit endings). I don't feel like going back and listing to the shorter, original album, but I don't think being more condensed will up my rating anyway. Jazz doesn't blow me away or beg me to listen to that particular album again right away (my criteria for higher vote)
Great jazz
Don’t really like jazz
I think it may be that I’d rather hear a small combo than a whole jazz band, but two hours of this album was a bit long. That said, you can’t deny the musicianship and importance of the thumbprint left on jazz music by Duke. As the album goes on (and on, and on), you do really start to get a sense of the evolution of the form.
I was super productive while listening to this album. I appreciated the speaking in between the songs, made me feel like I was there!
The announcements are annoying, interrupting the flow of the album. Buy maybe necessary to paint the picture of the excitement of the crowd and the atmosphere. Then I read where a lot of it was recreated in the studio. Still a cool album though. 1001 album worthy: Yes - 54/102
Annoying intros. Jazz album.
58’ classical jazz
Coole Zeitreise und schöne Musik. Hätte ich lieber als Video und als Album dann doch ein bisschen lang 😅
Explosive live big band jazz. The solo on Diminuendo In Blue is nuts. Really fun to listen to. Favorites were Festival Junction and Diminuendo In Blue.
It was a fun album to listen to mostly because of the look back to 1956, but I will not be seeking it out again.
I can appreciate the history but this album did not do it for me. Waaayyy too much talky talky and not enough music
Sheer musicality and excellence.
Pretty jamming, do not know much about jazz but can say this is definitely talented. Sampled the tracks.
Glad to listen to this. Felt like a naked gun soundtrack. Nice to actually hear some sort of structure but again not a heck of a lot of melodies. At least it didn’t sound like practice. Appreciation for this music came from watching whiplash. This is classic essential music.
A little too lengthy for my taste.
Deduction points for the length and the extra banter.
Way way way too long. so much talking
Nice sound. Surprised to learn they overdubbed as far back as the 50's. Ellingtons classic sound
A vibe but a way too long vibe.
Not for me, was really way too long. I respect it, but won't relisten. DNF
Не очень
Duke Ellington, well, that's Duke. One of the great ones of American and world music history. One of the biggest or event the bigges composer of non-classical music. This double disc album is from a concert in Newport and gives a good summary of his music. For me it is not one of the greatest albums of all times, I like more the more modern versions of his music. But that does not change anything about his importance.
Raw as fuck
Love the MC, and the solos were brilliant.
Not super into jazz, but this had my ass locked in the whole commute home. And loved that little easter egg of young Quincy Jones being mentioned
Don't get it...
The playing is rock solid but I wish this was done in a studio instead of a live setting. The introductions and crowd noise hurt this. The music is fine which gives it a passing grade.
Always great to hear old school jazz when it was the best music. Instrumental which Ibusually dont lime but thos genere is absolutely beautiful. This album has no bad songs all are great
Wow! The jazz/big band/swing music of the Greatest Generation and it is amazing. This is music WAY before my time, but it's almost timeless and very engaging. Take the "A" Train is one that is instantly recognizable and a great song. Even though I did not recognize a lot of other songs specifically, all of them sound so familiar.
Vert good
Festival Junction 4 Blues to Be There 3.6 Newport Up 3.8 Jeep's Blues 4 Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue 4.1 Score: 3.9
Not bad. Jazz isn’t always in my listening rotation, but I do enjoy it when it comes around. Love me some big bands, but not all the time. 3.5 ⭐️
Is it blasphemy to say a Duke Ellington release is middle of the road? Nothing special to me....but at least it's melodic and has a little pep. 2.5, rounding up.
swinggggg spang a lang there were some beautiful moments that i wish stretched out for longer some excessive soloing for me “pt 1 - festival junction” easy favourite
Brilliant
sophisticated
Чарівно, вартий уваги альбом
Its listed as Jazz, but it feels to me like Jazz emerging from Big Band in a very positive way. All the corny intros throw you back into an entriley different era. Really good stuff IMO, but not my everyday listen.
Look - Duke’s band is tight as hell but this didn’t do it for me. The “live” parts of the record were annoying to sit through and it was a bit too swing-y for me.
Probably the longest and hardest album to get through since Houmous & Chutneys experimental ‘Chinese Water Torture’ album back in ‘61. 2.5
Too long, too live, too much chit chat
Great jazz.
Excellent - when I think Jazz, this is what I think of.
Album was really good, I'm assuming it would have been one of the best albums at that point in time, but in modern day, it holds up well, but not as well. Favorite song Pt 2: blues to be there
Musikerene som spiller her er alle fantastisk flinke og ganske underholdende. Og en så behagelig atmosfære man får av å høre gjennom albumet. Jeg forstår også det at denne konserten var av historisk betydning. Med det sagt, så syns jeg også at dette blir altfor langdrygt. Alle introduksjonene og all klappingen gjør ikke stort for musikken. Jeg har også hatt lite eksponering til slik storbandjazz gjennom livet. Derfor gir selve tonen av alle disse blåseinstrumentene meg hverken fryd eller gammen. Jazz er kult, men dette blir litt fjernt for mine ører.
🎧Terrific big band jazz from Duke
Итс окэй. Лучшая песня - Diminuendo in Blue.
'Eff me. More 'effing jazz? I mean, it starts with a faithful rendition of The Star Spangled Banner. Please. I know for certain this is an historically important work in the annals of jazz, but it's still jazz - and there are 2 disks and even vocals. YAWN! I am really old and this museum piece predates me.
My dad, a fan of this performance, says “Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue” is the one he returns to, the climax to Ellington’s popular story rather than his life, the gig where a chunk of the band don’t turn up to the first set, and the track written for the festival fails to rouse, only for the tenor saxophonist, blows a marathon into the wrong microphone, nearly incites a riot according to the papers, though this recordings indicates little more than a few encore demands and likely dancing. Reading the hype first, the solo almost disappoints, probably because I was expecting some sort of Coltrane-es que explosion rather than the fleet, chatty and upbeat hopping between notes that Gonsalves holds for six minutes, but once I accepted this is more an ocean liner than a power boat I had a good time, though maybe not as much as the blonde woman in a black dress that the accounts place unusual emphasis on. The squeals at the end of “Festival Junction” sound like a tantrum, either at the band’s structure or the perception of its obsolescence, its dead economic model: we can blast too. There’s defiance as well as melancholy in celebrating a near-extinct form, a collective in their late middle-age demonstrating their mastery of banging out tunes as one; the songs were old by then, and you can hear the sweat flicking off the drums. I’ll take my dad’s approach to this one.
There's a lot of jazz on this, and a *lot* of introducing the performers. You could probably skip anything without a song title and save yourself some time, if sacrificing the atmosphere a bit. Nothing much stuck, even the highlight "Diminuendo in Blue" which is pretty great if you're paying attention. Unfortunately, the story of the album is more exciting to me than the actual recording.
Solid example of the genre. I don’t think it gains anything from being a live performance, other than capturing that moment in time, and it limits the appeal of a relisten.
Soul
Big Band at it's best.
I like it
These 2-hour albums make it hard to keep up. I'm not the biggest jazz fan, but this was good music to have on the background while I worked.
Extremely fun listen.
swinging and composition
Skipped the Star Spangled Banner cuz it sounded goofy. Enjoyed all of the other tracks, with my faves being Tulip or Turnip, Diminuendo in Blue, I Got it Bad and That Ain't Good, Skin Deep, Jeep Blues and Blues to Be There. The band was amazing and the crowd work was good. It was nice to hear how much the audience loves the music. Easy to listen to and could definitely picture myself listening to this in a cozy cocktail bar after a long day.
Ellington At Newport Fave Tracks: DISC ONE - Tea For Two - Pt.1 Festival Junction (the best one) - Pt. 2 Blues to Be There (amazing) - Pt. 3 Newport Up - Diminuendo In Blue (meaty boy) DISC TWO - Jeep's Blues - Tulip or Turnip - Skin Deep (magnum opus max) Honourable Mentions: - Day In, Day Out (omg vocals?) So I knew it would end eventually... The amazing intros run ruined by the good old 🦅🦅. It's terrible. I hate it. Greasy ass anthem. So I had to skip it. Ofc I'm not gonna include the Duke announces, I know it's a live album, but it just takes forever I just wanna slurp the meat. Black and Tan fantasy sounded like a horse... However, as the album progressed I fell deeper in love... just wow. I rarely listen to jazz despite me enjoying the genre, but this makes me want to LIVE BREATHE EAT RAVE Jazz ya feel?! It's just... ugh such a quintessential shower, morning routine, driving in the dark listening. At any point of the day, if ones of these comes on I'm just happier. However, the stand out tracks are imo the masterpieces but the rest sound very much like random vibes? Idk. To me its a 3.5 tho i cant rate it that... So it's a low 4. For the standout tracks simply because they are I.M.M.A.C.U.L.A.T.E
Not really a fan of live albums. The trumpets were annoying too. But I liked most of it. Would listen to non trumpet songs again as background music.
That album is a masterpiece!
Not my ideal album, very slow, the live breaks/introductions really killed it for me.
It's Jazz. Good jazz but just jazz. Not my flavor
Really torn between 4 and 5
- Sensational. Vibrant. Enduring. Possibly the best swing jazz I have ever heard. I had to turn this off while I was working because I found myself wanting to dance too much. - Some of the out-of-control solos at the end of "Festival Junction" and "Diminuendo In Blue" light you on fire. - First album on the list where I listened to the original LP and found myself actually wanting to listen to the extended album.
skipped through the song and artist introductions/vamping i’m soz. live jazz is incredible . does anyone else remember how duke ellingtons ghost is a character in hit netflix show big mouth .
Hell yeah, this is a triumph. Though I could do without Father Snorman and his damn announcements. A very impressive display of technical talent in that classic big band jazz style. A very nice thing. Diminuendo In Blue kicks ass. Solid drum solo on Skin Deep and the crowd goes nuts. What a killer album and story.
8/10. This one definitely gave me massive fomo for never being able to go to a show like that (until I realised that means living in America in the 50s). Genuinely when the crowd get so hyped it's hard to not do the same yourself. Musicianship is obviously outstanding on the record and while some features such as some of the high pitched 'wailing', it was a fun listen. Definitely giving 'you had to be there' though, probably a 10/10 live.
Hermoso
Not sure
Such a classic album with Duke Ellington being one of the great jazz composers. I grew up playing "Take the A Train", really enjoyed "Tea for Two" and "Mood Indigo" was always a track I loved too. Logistically, listening to the live album was a bit more distracting.
I've slowly become appreciative to jazz thanks to this list but this one just wasn't hitting the spot for me. Maybe it was the live elements, or maybe it was the sheer length of some it (I mean 15 minutes for one song, do me a favour). Much better jazz albums on this list so I could've done without this one
Cool, Daddyo. Virtuoso musicianship. Spoiled a bit by all the chatter. I don't need to hear the long intros, and I'm definitely not interested in some priest talking about the rain, and where every member of the band lives. I can understand that this is a historical record of the complete concert that day, and that's great if you were actually there - but for the casual listener there's too much padding and not enough music. I didn't really like the sung songs either. So, in summary:- Instruments outstanding. Voices no thanks.
Words can’t express the joy of listening to this historical recording. The “Duke” is simply incredible and had assembled an amazing group of musicians.
Didn't make it through the whole thing, but definitely an enjoyable listen.
Som å høre på en Duke Ellington konsert live, for det er akkurat det det er. Og det er jævlig fett.
Während ich das erste Lied gehört hab (the Star spangled banner), hab ich gelesen, dass sei Vater butler im weissen Haus war 🤯. Der Name duke kommt auch nicht von ungefähr, sondern weil er schon als Teenie eine royale Ausstrahlung und geschliffene Manieren hatte und deswegen von Schulkolleg:innen als duke bezeichnet wurde. Ellington at Newport ist wohl sein heiss ersehntes comeback als Jazz Musiker, nachdem er auch viel mit klassischer Musik gearbeitet hatte. Schon chillige Musik, hat den Jazz wohl auch populärer gemacht, aber meins ist es leider heute trotzdem nicht :/. Sorry Duke!
Oi Dude Ellington in Newport, leider isch mer hüt ned so jazzhändig zumute. Uf es 2 stündigs Live/Complete-Album scho gar ned, darum nonchalant selber eis ufs parkett g researched und mer siis 30 min Album geh, das het mer glanget. Tschüss my dukeness, gsehnd eus glaubs nüm so bald. Zwei Beef Wellington uf dich.
huere gopferdellisiech namal, isch das e fucking guggemusik vo de zentralschwiiz wo im album creator promoted wird?. pfui tüffel, ganz e grussige Track gsi, de ersti. Und au witer ischs gange mit dere Katzemusik, hed de ohre weh dah. nach 15min, aua weg damit. das gid zur abwechslig wiedermal 1 hoseknopf für das album. tschüsstschau - danke für nüd
Elli Welli don't want to be on tellie Stimmi am Don Neduzen zue dasi teilwis chli gugge flair mitbecho han Da würdi ezt au gern eh these ufstelle – guggemusig isch es geheims projekt vo de texaner gstartet um jazzmusig schlecht in europa darzstelle denked mal drüber nah de dead giveway isch halt das die nette texisste eifach nume wacki hillbilly's vo tobel affeltrange oder fischinge kennt hend zum ihren plan umsetzte, drum isches ih de meiste städt (ussert halt basel und loooozern) nöd so ihgschlage aber defür umso meh hinde ih de boonies da gebemer doch zwei ZAPFE DRUFF! ZAPFE!!! ZAPFE!!! (ja das isch vo de sirnacher fasnacht – wege tannzapfeland, digge)
Good musically but cannot do over 2 hours long of jazz.
3.83
Cool tunes but I skipped the talking bits, does that make me a bad person?
Big band jazz. Pretty good.
Dobrze siedzi ten album, bardzo lubię big bandową muzykę. Jazz z czasów, kiedy dało się go tak po prostu słuchać, bez nadęcia. Czytałem trochę o historii tego albumu i to też bardzo ciekawa sprawa, na pewno dodaje do jego ważności (choć nie ma wpływu na jego "słuchalność"). Nie będę udawał, że znam się na jazzie na tyle, żeby powiedzieć coś wybitnie mądrego na jego temat, ale na czysty feeling jest to solidne 4.
I think it would be completly unfair to give extra points just because I've read the whole story behind the album. For a jazz album it's 4/5 but there is this historical importance and you feel the story unfold while you are listening to the album. Jazz is indeed a devil music and it pushed me to give immoral 5/5.
Nieczęsto trafiam na jazz, który naprawdę mnie wciąga, ale "Ellington at Newport" to zupełnie inna historia. To album, który nie tylko dokumentuje legendarny koncert, ale wręcz oddaje jego energię – od pierwszych dźwięków czuć, że coś wyjątkowego dzieje się na scenie. Kulminacją jest "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue", gdzie saksofonowy szał Paula Gonzalesa rozpala publiczność i zmienia występ w prawdziwą eksplozję emocji. Słucha się tego jak perfekcyjnie uchwyconego momentu w historii – surowego, pełnego napięcia i czystej radości grania. Mocne 4
Top notch. The concert showcases all the members of the band. Big boisterous arrangements, classy piano playing, tons of horns and solos. Superb.
3.5
Well sir. This album is hard to find the original version of. The version that this thing takes you to is 2 hours long and includes all the stage banter and the bloody Star Spangled Banner. To be fair, listening to American patriotism might be even harder than listening to U2. I’ve found the “OG” version on YouTube. Oh fortune doth smile upon your humble narrator. Of course, due to my unwillingness to add yet another 10-15 loons to my monthly expenditure for yet another, I will be an absentee reviewer. I cannot close the app to provide my blow by blow (as in, my review will blow). Anyway, take it way Duke. Well that was cool. The opening with the clarinet gives way to excellent jazz featuring a multitude of deftly played instruments and an excellent atmosphere. I expected far more big band and swing due to the fact that those were the only genres listed online. And when an album on RYM says the genre is Hypnotica and CheeseCore, I expect to be hearing some fucking Hypnotica and CheeseCore before the day is out. The only real “big band” experience was the last song which, despite the revelry and clear enjoyment from the live crowd, sort of bored me. This was a cool album and one I could see myself enjoying once again. Not perfect but a sweet ride through the tracks of my mind propelled by the horns of the Ellington squad. Newport up. 3.5 HIGHLIGHTS: Festival Junction, Jeep’s Blues
Nice and mostly smooth. Very classic jazzy stuff. Will be throwing this on for a Friday night!
Big band jazz når den är som bäst. Kanske ska börja titulera mig jazz man 🤭
This is a first Duke Ellington listen for me- It's crazy how many feature musicians were on this album! It must have been a really fun evening for everyone involved. The music itself was nice- I enjoyed how they switched up who was being featured in the songs, and the instruments as a result. It did start to feel long though in the second half. I also feel like I didnt get enough Duke Ellington himself. Overall- good album. Jazz isnt really my thing but I can see how Jazz people would enjoy this. 3.5/5
Favorite Track: Diminuendo In Blue
jazz idk
I really cant review this album with objective mind. First time during this project personal feelings are so crappy that it affects this a lot. This album would have needed a better mood to concentrate into it. I recognize the talent on this but cant help.
If I understand correctly, this album holds a remarkable place in recording history, which likely explains why it’s included on this list. It’s also incredibly easy to listen to, and when someone mentions jazz, this style is exactly what comes to mind for me. That said, I nowadays lean more toward modern jazz in my personal jazz listening. Still, this album is undeniably entertaining and expertly performed—I really have no criticisms to offer.
Old timey swinging jazz is not something I enjoy. Had to cut this one short after four of five songs. I understand the playing, I get the skill, I know these are highly appreciated musicians, but I just cannot stomach the high pitch happiness rampage that these tracks seem to convey.
Man what would it have been like to be there for this live. Love the sax vibrato, almost sounds like a different instrument