Reviews (page 8 of 12)
This feels like some good Fallout-core, and I'm always down for that. Just good jazz.
po cara dá não
Lots of jazz. I am sure it's probably good. Very long but I did listen to both albumns.
I wish I could see bands like this today. (6 know/13 new)
Enjoyable - great skill on display and has an energy and vibe but not my cup of tea .
At Newport ‘56 My main thoughts of Duke Ellington are of his spirit living in the attic in Big Mouth writing songs full of sexual innuendo and trying to bang the ghost of Whitney Houston. Nothing like that is happening here though. This is a perfectly fine live big band/swing/jazz album with two stand outs. The smoky, piano-led Blues to Be There is great, the horns are used to augment it brilliantly and it genuinely feels like it tells a musical story. And the frenzied energy of Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue is undeniable, you can really feel the feedback loop of the players and the crowd and the resulting manic excitement. Generally I’m not a fan of this sort of uptempo Jazz, but this performance feels genuinely electric and you can’t help but be carried along on a wave of jazzy commotion. Jeep’s Blues is probably the best of the rest, with Festival Junction and Newport Up being fine but forgettable. Outside Blues to Be There and Diminuendo there probably isn’t a great deal to return to, but those two and Diminuendo in particular are so good they carry it to a medium-high 3. 🔵🔵🔵 Playlist submission: Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue
I found this to be a reasonably enjoyable jazz album, and eminently more enjoyable than the other big band albums we've had hitherto, such as Count Basie. I also like that the audience gets more vocal as it goes along, responding to the band's sporadic ejaculations. It's a very good live performance. I don't know what, if any, boundaries are being pushed, except for that clarinet player's temporal veins at the end of Diminuendo when it sounds like he's gonna pop a lobe. It suffers from the fact I've discovered Kind of Blue which, I think I'm beginning to understand, is a very different jazz to this - but nevertheless that is so good, that this pales a bit in comparison. In saying that, Duke was a massive inspiration to Miles Davis, and there are nuances in this performance which provide a hell of a lot more than vanilla big band swing. So overall I think it is in the three range and maybe pushing a high three.
норм
Buen disco, pero tan antiguo que es casi música clásica.
Pretty nice. Feels like a 3.5.
This was lots of fun for sure.
Video games introduced me to jazz and swing music, which led to me learning about the history of jazz and even though i hadn't heard the album i was well aware of the festival. It is part of music history and jazz history. in a time where jazz were shifting allot. A well earned spot on the list It is a bit long but it's enjoyable and pretty easy listened.
This is the second jazz album I've gotten in 5 rolls and I have a feeling my thoughts on all of them are going to be the same -- it's good jazz, sounds like good jazz, musicians are talented, and I would probably appreciate it more if I were more familiar with the ouvre of the jazz canon. I will say the length of this one is egregious and I'm choosing to only listen to Disc 1. I get that this is a famous performance but in general, I'm not fond of live albums because they never sound or feel as essential as being there in the moment, watching what's going on.
I don’t know what I’m listening to but I like it.
Patrolling the Mojave almost makes you wish for a nuclear winter.
It's good, it's interesting, but I feel like I'm forcing myself to listen to it, and the format makes it inherently hard to review. I'm not sure if it's me, but I feel like listening to jazz is harder than expected, even though I've thought I kinda like the genre - or maybe it's just this format.
Overall enjoyable. Some of the horns got quite shrill on one song and I can't say I understand it.
I was actually not in the mood for some jazz but this record changed my mind. So cool!
Not a fan of live albums
Some I liked, some I didn't like. Overall I've decided to learn jazz. :D
Some serious finger waggin', toe tappin' stuff. I loved his cameo in Big Mouth.
This album is so cool it doesn't need air conditioning in the summer. 5/5
Live jazz at its finest. I can picture it’s 1956 and a bunch of rich folk in suits/fancy dresses dancing around a dimly lit ballroom or amphitheater. I’d be doing the same if I was there. Smooth on the ears, like butter.
Super cool. One of the best jazz albums I've listened to. 5/5
Dear lord this was long. The tracks are great, it's awesome jazz, but there's so much of it. This is proof that you really need to be in the right mood for some of these because it's GOOD music, but I got sick of it very quickly.
Never listened to Duke before this album is long. It’s also live and I like all the little noises Duke uses to cheer on his band. Especially during the ripping sax solo in Dimineuendo And Crescendo In Blue, 27 bars apparently; it’s a long solo but fitting. It’s considered a huge album in jazz history. I enjoyed it more than I expected. Big band swing isn’t my go to but the significance of this recording wasn’t lost on me. 3/5
Good album but outrageously long and tough to get through... highs were HIGH and the live aspect actually added to the experience, but 2 hours? No chance lol
Duke's a persuasive composer; there's a preternatural uplift that all of his compositions share, a surety, a swagger, a candid sense of self and others. Nothing breaks down b/c everything's a great run into the center of life and its particularities. This live recording famously attains that sensibility with genius. Quite literally, Duke and Louis (who's unforgivably absent from this list) invented our music. And a special shout-out to Cat Anderson, the best of all muted trumpeters I've heard. Sam Woodyard too on ‘Skin Deep.’
Boring. I don't like jazz
Day 0019/1001 of One Album a Day / Listened to whilst: working from home Very jazzy. Found myself clicking my fingers a long to a lot of this.
This is #day158 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and... here we go with the second jazz album in a row. Ellington at Newport, an album that's almost 70 years old—crazy, right? The big band jazz takes me back to around 2011 when I was first getting into jazz on my own, so I’m at least familiar with classics like Take the 'A' Train and Tea For Two... This concert also brings to mind the Dzyga Art Center and the Jazz Bez festival in my hometown of Lviv, held at the beginning of December. But, 38 tracks on Spotify? That's too much jazz to get through, and I couldn't. I’m giving it a 2 out of 5. Looking forward to #day159.
very very great sound, would definitely listen again. study music or dinner background music!
It was good, more like background Jazz, didn't dislike it but didn't really sound special or light a spark
So my dad gave me Uptown when I was young because he thought I'd enjoy Louis Belson's drum solo on Skin Deep and boy did I. The rest of the music it took a bit of maturing to understand but I really enjoy this now. The soloist are amazing. Almost otherworldly sounds coming from the instruments. I actually said to myself "This band is cookin!" In 2025. They indeed cooked. It may be archaic now but I see why the term was used. It's great. And dare I say a lost art? At least on the young population of today. And thats a big ole shame.
loveeeee. perfect for a snowy day
Fun! I’m glad this came up because I was getting suicidal listening to so many British bands lately. Occasionally the sound was a little squeaky and kinda hurt my hear, but I’m guessing that’s either bc of when this was recorded or the instruments fault?? Idk but it was slightly bothersome at times.
This was a really long one so I hate to say it, but I’m eating it part way thru bc I know I will come back and listen later and I know my rating will remain the same. A little sharp on the ears at times but this was mixed in 1956 so I can’t be too picky there. Good Jazz. I like how they included the intros.
This album would stink while driving but is a vibe while working on my computer
Good Jazz music and nice to listen to while working
Tea for Two is a banger so is Take the A Train
..
watch video of the band. hep af.
the live vibes are good but 2 hours of jazz is about an hour too much
<3 star spangled banner- 6 black and tan fantasy- 8 or 9 tea for two- 8 or 9 take the a train- 8 or 9 festival junction- 8 or 9 blues to be there- 8 newport up- 9 sophisticated lady- 7 day in day out- 7 diminuendo in blue- 8 or 9 i cant finish this because my attention span is rotted but jazz is one of the best things mankind ever came up with
Eso es musica, además virtuosismo de gran nivel. La pena es que es en vivo y se pierde gran rango de calidad que la grabación en estudio. Pese a esta perdida, Ellington y sus eximios instrumentistas brillan y enceguecen.
Very cool
great, kind of long though, i could handle about 40 minutes not 2 hours
I struggled with this album. Really just not my listening preference
The musicians are great, but the bantering and audience threw me off. It's a good jazz record, but I can't see anything really impressive over other works.
Very fun to do chores to, makes everything feel fun and cheeky - not a genre I resonate with however, so it can never be higher than a 3
An excellent first foray into jazz. A tad bit excessive for my admittedly under experienced taste. However, very much enjoyable.
Duke Ellington - Ellington at Newport Nice chill jazz live album coming from one of the greats to do it. Albums like these are the reason why I enjoy listening to music so much. How vibrant and colorful the music sounds, it feels as if you were back in time during that concert. It's great to be honest, this is great! 1.- Festival Junction = 8/10 2.- Blues to Be There = 7/10 3.- Newport Up = 7/10 4.- Jeep's Blues = 9/10 5.- Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue = 10/10 FINAL SCORE: 8.2/10
Allez, on ouvre le carnet de bord. Le grand livre, dans sa sagesse infinie et parfois discutable, m'a ordonné de me pencher sur un monument. Un truc en noir et blanc, qui sent le formol et les soirées où tes grands-parents s'encanaillaient. Duke Ellington. Pas n'importe quoi, attention : Ellington at Newport, 1956. Le disque qui, paraît-il, a ressuscité une carrière et foutu le feu à un festival de jazz un peu trop coincé du derche. Je vais être honnête avec vous, quand on a passé sa jeunesse à user des vinyles de punk, de post-punk, de rock indé crasseux et qu'on a vu défiler la britpop et le grunge, se fader un big band de 1956, c'est un peu comme passer d'une dose d'adrénaline pure à une tisane verveine-tilleul. Mais le projet est le projet. On doit tout écouter. Alors, j'ai appuyé sur "Play", non sans un soupir qui aurait pu éteindre les bougies d'un gâteau d'anniversaire. Pour comprendre ce disque, il faut comprendre le contexte. En 1956, le Duke, la classe incarnée, le génie de la composition, commençait sérieusement à sentir la naphtaline. Le jazz avait bougé. Les jeunes loups du bebop l'avaient ringardisé. Le rock'n'roll commençait à pointer le bout de son nez et de sa banane. Duke Ellington et son grand orchestre, c'était devenu une musique de papa, une institution respectable mais plus vraiment excitante. Sa carrière était sur le déclin, le genre de pente douce qui mène tranquillement au cimetière des éléphants musicaux. Et puis il y a ce fameux 7 juillet 1956, au Newport Jazz Festival. La haute société blanche et endimanchée, venue s'offrir un frisson culturel. Le concert d'Ellington commence, et, de l'avis de tous, ça commence mollement. Le public est poli, applaudit sagement, mais pense déjà au prochain cocktail. On sent l'ennui poindre, le genre de moment où tu te dis que t'aurais mieux fait de rester à la maison pour repeindre les volets. Ellington, vexé comme un pou, sent que son orchestre est en train de perdre la bataille. Il décide de jouer une vieille composition en deux parties, "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue". Un truc qu'il jouait déjà dans les années 30. Entre les deux, il lâche la bride à son saxophoniste ténor, Paul Gonsalves. Il lui dit, en substance : "Vas-y, mon grand, et joue jusqu'à ce que tes poumons explosent." Et là, le miracle. Le moment de bascule. Gonsalves, un type qui a l'air de sortir d'une sieste de trois jours, se lance dans un solo. Pas juste un bon solo. Un putain de solo. Au début, les gens n'en ont rien à foutre. Et puis, une blonde platine, un peu éméchée, se lève au milieu de la foule de culs-serrés en pantalon de golf, et se met à danser comme si sa vie en dépendait. Un type la rejoint. Puis deux. Puis dix. En quelques minutes, c'est l'hystérie collective. Les gens grimpent sur les chaises, hurlent, la sécurité est dépassée. Le big band le plus classe du monde vient de provoquer une émeute dans le festival le plus chic de la planète. Duke Ellington, ce soir-là, a rappelé à tout le monde qui était le patron. Sa carrière était relancée. Le disque, qui immortalise ce moment, est devenu un best-seller. Voilà pour la légende. C'est une histoire magnifique. Une histoire de résilience, de génie, un "fuck" monumental envoyé à tous ceux qui l'enterraient un peu vite. Maintenant, la réalité, cul posé sur mon canapé en 2025, avec mes écouteurs sur les oreilles. Et la réalité, c'est que ce disque, pour être tout à fait franc, je me suis fait chier. Oui, je sais, c'est un sacrilège. Mais que voulez-vous ? Passé l'intérêt historique, qu'est-ce qu'il reste ? Une musique qui a pris un sacré coup de vieux. Les arrangements sont brillants, certes, mais ça sonne daté, terriblement daté. Le son est ce qu'il est pour l'époque. Et puis, il y a la grande supercherie : une bonne partie de l'album, soi-disant "live", a été réenregistrée en studio quelques jours plus tard parce que la prise de son originale était pourrie. On a même rajouté des applaudissements en boîte. Pour un mec comme moi qui a grandi avec l'éthique du "vrai", du "brut", ça la fout mal. Alors, comment noter ce machin ? C'est tout le paradoxe de ce projet "1001 Albums". Doit-on juger l'objet pour ce qu'il est, ou pour ce qu'il représente ? Pour son impact historique ou pour le plaisir qu'il procure aujourd'hui ? Ce n'est pas un album, c'est un putain de documentaire audio. C'est le témoignage d'un moment charnière, d'une performance qui a changé le cours d'une carrière. Le solo de Gonsalves, même sur disque, reste un truc assez dingue, une montée en puissance qui force le respect. On entend presque la foule se réveiller. Mais est-ce que je vais le réécouter pour le plaisir ? Jamais de la vie. Ça ira rejoindre la pile des disques "importants mais chiants". C'est une pièce de musée. On la regarde avec respect, on lit le petit panneau explicatif, on hoche la tête d'un air entendu, et on passe à la salle suivante. L'événement : 5/5, sans hésiter. Un moment de grâce, de fureur et de génie. Le disque en tant que tel, pour mes oreilles de vieux rocker qui a besoin de sentir la sueur et l'électricité : 1/5. Et je suis généreux. C'est donc un 1 sur 5, mais un 1 sur 5 historique, un 1/5 "à découvrir". Un disque qu'il faut entendre une fois dans sa vie pour comprendre une histoire, pas forcément pour aimer une musique.
Don’t know anything about jazz but it makes me feel like Christmas and New York City and old films so for that I like it, but definitely not my genre of choice.
Solid fun Jazz. I should figure out if this is Bop? Post bop? Hard bop? Bebop? Whatever it's jazz I can wrap my head around melodically, and I like it.
Band leaders are always hard to judge because you are judging their talent as a writer, but also the talent of so many unknown artists playing with them. Duke Ellington is an American icon, and this album is really good. It recalls days of sitting in Jazz Band class playing Take the A-Train. This album was well done and very listenable repeatedly.
Random thoughts review: * The talking interludes are a bit long/distracting. Did Duke Ellington leave and not come back? That's kind of what I heard around track 6. Just kinda weird. * The sound of this recording is immaculate. Listening to this on headphones sounds like I'm almost on the stage near the musicians. * Holy shit, the trumpet screaming at the end of "Pt. 1-Festival Junction"!!! * Wow, on disc 2 the crowd gets rowdy. I swear I heard boos in there too. Sounds like it was wild! * Ok, shit got insane with the crowd! Duke had to come in for "Riot Prevention". * They should have ended this album with the end of the live tracks. It was a bit disappointing to add those extra studio tracks. * Overall, this is a gem and part of why I like this exercise. Sometime you discover something new!
Pleasant enough. I enjoyed the bit where they all seemed to kick off a bit, but that was a way in, so not sure exactly which bit. Also a lot of chatting inbetween, which all felt a bit like I was at a lecture rather than a concert. It did transport me to another time, but not sure if that is a good or a bad thing.
This was a pleasant working soundtrack for the afternoon. It drifted, which is never a bad thing whilst I'm tapping away. I could have done without all the talking in-between tracks
Ok
Sans être fan de jazz, ça trompette bien tout ça
Skvělej jazz
Big band perfection. Swings hard and everything is in its right place. Grabbing the spotlight when needed and sitting in the pocket when not. Puts you right in the heat of it
classic
Not something I would normally listen to, but, you have to tip your hat to the impeccable musicianship and skilled arrangements here.
Fine
Finally an album for me - a lover of cigarettes
To preface this review, I do not like live albums. I think they tend to have poor recording quality, and often far too much filler. The original, 1956 version of this album, however, is very much an exception. It's a fantastic showcase of some of the best big band jazz music. The update 1999 version that the generator links to, however, is a different story. Many of the tracks sound only okay, and all of the talking really breaks up the album to me.
The album was longer but the individual songs didn't seem too bad. Jazz is not my fav but this felt more like Big Band Music that had Jazz influences. Duke Ellington is someone that is acclaimed for his music, and I will say it is really good in terms of Jazz music. The fact that the band had been together so long makes some of the improvising so much more polished and cohesive. Hearing how much the crowd wanted them to continue was inspiring. Skin Deep had great drums and I liked Newport Up and Dimineendo in Blue. The Studeio Concert Excerpts were also nice to just hear Duke play for a bit.
Sensational that this is a live album! It's a record of 1950's jazz as it's performed by talented, seasoned, passionate musicians and enjoyed by an enthusiastic audience. Seems like a fun mix of different jazz styles and moods from bright bursting big band, lots of stellar solos, sweeping blues, and much much more. This is too much great jazz to sink my ears into for the scope of this project. I'm going to bookmark this album and come back to it. If I were making a jazz collection, this would definitely go in it. The Star Spangled Banner is an interesting way to start a show. Turns out that the first couple numbers were just to kill time because the rest of the band wasn't even there yet. Funny because a couple of my favorites are the first ones: Black & Tan Fantasy and Tea for Two. But the audience really loses their shit after Diminuendo in Blue which is a pretty awesome 50's sax jazz song. After that it seems like Duke tried to calm the audience down with some slower blues numbers (not my favorites). Ending the show with a drum solo encore, Skin Deep, is a great finish to the show.
Newport is a lovely, old money town sitting on the Atlantic Ocean in Rhode Island with huge gilded age mansions, so the subdued politeness heard from the 1956 audience in the beginning feels authentic, then a damn riot breaks out later in the show because that’s just the power of Duke. The recording is so clean and crisp, and full of life. It’s a generous historic document on the vitality of live jazz. Again, live albums are A LOT. I love jazz though, so I approached this one as if I was a spectator sitting on the lawn of the well manicured park on a warm summer afternoon under a big oak tree with a picnic basket, some booze, and a few cultured friends. It was a lovely day, then shit got wild and we partied. It was a day I won’t soon forget!
I like the vibe, but it’s a LOT of jazz. Hard to get super into it because there’s a lot of jamming and not a lot of catchy beats. Totally appreciate the talent though. If I was a big jazz fan, I’m sure this would be really great.
Too long to be listened straight away but really nice ! Everybody love jazz
Duke Ellington. Jazz. Excellence. Some reservation on my part for the style of jazz.
Fantástico álbum, tanto musicalmente como por la historia que hay detrás. En primer lugar, encuentra el punto exacto entre swing y jazz (aka big band jazz), lo que me transporta varios años atrás, cuando escuchaba a Louis Prima, pero con un toque adicional de sofisticación. Por otro lado, me encanta poder escuchar la reacción del público de la época, una auténtica locura. Por este motivo, la versión en CD de 1999, que es más fiel al concierto, me gusta mucho más que la versión de semi-estudio original. Cinco estrellas que confirman que me estoy haciendo mayor.
Can‘t judge it.
This list is exposing me to music I haven't listened to much in the past, including jazz. I have never listened to much jazz until the last few years but I am acquiring a taste for it. This is a solid live recording and a lot of fun to listen to. I will listen to this record again.
Listened to this on a sunny, freezing cold day in my warm office while drinking coffee. Excellent time.
Diminuendo in Blue was pretty swinging throughout for 1956. The rest was just OK.
I made it about 45 minutes
I don’t know anything about jazz. I really like the oboe and muted trumpet.
Starting with jazz is interesting. I used to listen to jazz while studying in high school often, there was a station on the radio I would tune to and especially at night to wind down. Might bring that back. Some of those licks were insane, ngl, I just don’t listen to a lot of jazz so I don’t have much to compare it to!
Idk
This is not my kinda jazz, but I appreciate the musicians clearly having fun
The Good: The Duke! The Bad: This isn’t a Western… The Ugly: which means nobody can get shot… Wikipedia is a great tool to learn a little more about that which you’re listening to, and today that was really needed. Not because I wasn’t aware of Duke Ellington, or his music for that matter, more so because I needed to understand why this album specifically showed up on the list… So, Duke’s out on his luck as music has evolved from big band swing, to more laidback versions of jazz performed by smaller groups. And yet here we are, decades later, listening to music that was, at the time, decades old, to what is considered his opus maestro. Well, good for you Duke. Did we need to listen to the chatter in-between the tunes? The album could have been a cool 55 minutes feast of tonal eargasm… which is why I am giving this album a solid 4*
3.7 1x extended 2 disc 2h 7m
It feels kinda wrong to be rating this album a 3, but I'm doing these ratings based on personal taste and I've never gotten into instrumental jazz. It is a beautiful sound though! Favorite song: "I Got It Bad (And That Ain't Good)"
When you need to hear it how it all started....
If I must. I think that if I liked this kind of thing I would have been up in it by now. Wharp-whoooaaaaaaarp! Tssss tssss. Doodly doodly DOOOOOOO! Might put this on at Christmas to keep my father-in-law entertained after lunch. Generous three stars.
laitappa päiväkirjaan vähän muistelmaa nyt tähän kohtaan: tänään oli TYÖ_ PÄIVÄ!! saatana.. päivä ennen suurjunailua taas kerran. kolmen viikon lomille... paitsi ei ole loma... pitää saatana vempuilla niin sanotulla vapaa-ajallakin.. sipilä OTTAA JA OTTAA JA OTTAA.. eikä anna perkele takaisin mitään!! btw ovela albumi. varsin juonikas. metkut päällä mennään herttuan kanssa ilmeisesti. tänään oli ihan kiva kuunnella älämölöä, turhaa pälätystä ja lätinää vanhanajan livesoittoa konsanaan. oikein mielekästä pikkuhyppyjä tehdään istuimella pikkuhyppyjä ylösalas.. annetaan kuomalle propseja tästä... props props props ja shillinki kainaloon.. siitä saat päivän eväät. blues to be there
I only listened to the songs on the original record. No way I would listen to the extended version. This was live jazz. It didn't make me mad but by no means did I like it.
Amazing live album, one of the best on the list so far!
Nice
Well done for that swing.
One of the most essential live Jazz recordings of all time. Astounding musicianship.
I hate to sound like I'm uncultured, or I don't have ears, but I found this a bit hard to get really into. I am generally unfamiliar with jazz. In fact, like a lot of people, it's probably one of my biggest musical blind spots. If I close my eyes and focus, I can sort of vibe with it, but it gets rather exhausting for me after a while. Maybe it takes a while longer to really "get" it. Maybe repeated listenings will uncover more. But for now, based on my enjoyment, I can't give it more than a 3. Fav tracks: Diminuendo in Blue
Loved the last song. I generally prefer some New Orleans style jazz over the more bluesy stuff but this wasn’t bad. Hard for me to catch the real rhythm or groove of some of the songs but that’s very typical for me with this genre. Long enough for them to get into it, short enough that I’m not going crazy waiting for a song to end. Diminnuendo in Blue is definitely my favorite here. High 2 low 3.
This album is pretty darn awesome. I actually listened to the 'Complete' version, all 2+ hours, and it was very much worth it. This is a fantastic performance, and it's honestly a relic of time. The big sounds, the crowd's reaction, everything about this makes me just want to get up and dance. I pictured myself in a jazz club, just being swept away by all these fantastic musicians. It feels wrong to give this a three, even if a four feels a bit high... but I think the uniqueness of this performance and album pushes it over the edge. It's pretty awesome.
I’m not a big jazz guy, but this was pleasant. It isn’t something I would intentionally put on, but it’s fine to have in the background.
Of the jazz albums we’ve had so far, I definitely enjoyed this one the most. It felt very upbeat and more fun to listen to. Thanks to American Hustle for introducing me to jeeps blues. That song is a banger and just the epitome of that old school jazz sound that u need sometimes. Also this gets an extra star just for that trumpet player at the end of festival junction. That last note that he plays at the end is a Db(7) as in 3 octaves higher than middle c, and only 11 notes higher than this on the entire musical spectrum. If you’ve ever played a trumpet before or any wind instrument, that’s just insane. God tier lip, cheek, lung, and breath control.
I really don’t know how to rate this. It was enjoyable, but it doesn’t have the depth or structure of a normal album. Low 3, but I don’t really think of it like other albums on the list.
Some wonderful jazz to have on in the background while working and driving. I’ve never heard a trumpet wail like that, really impressive. Already two live albums from the Newport Jazz Festival and it’s really cementing how important this series of shows was for music history. My biggest complaint is that the original release isn’t on Spotify and jumping around the complete version was a pain, but that’s not the album’s fault.
I've had a chance to listen to a bunch of Jazz on this list. I've learned over that time that I prefer a smaller group focusing on piano rather that a full band. I've also learned that I prefer a crisp clear recording rather than a live show for Jazz. Obviously Duke Ellington is one of the greatest of all time, but I was mostly bored with this album. A lot of the focus felt like it was on the horns, and some of the other instruments were washed out in the recording. I guess it's cool that I can now pick different Jazz styles that I like, but Mr. Ellington's is not for me.
I listened to the complete 2 hour edition, was a lovely Sunday morning soundtrack
Great album, when I think of listening to jazz this is what I want to hear.
Fun album! Not an experienced jazz listener but every time I would almost get tired of listening they’d switch the structure and hook me back in.
Nice for listening to while doing schoolwork but definitely not a go-to album.
Beautiful jazz, didn’t listen to the extended version but worth a listen. Energetic and groovy, keeps you entertained throughout.
Wow. So good from start to finish
Muy bueno pero muy largo
Domó el duque
Fun energy.
Outstanding.
Really long but a great live album. The Duke sure knew how to play. 4.5
Could probably cut and paste my other jazz reviews here. I enjoy it and tap my foot along without loving it hugely. Appreciate the artistry even if it's not my favourite genre It helped that I listened to a playlist of just the original LP (search Spotify if you don't want to listen to the expanded version with all the talking) so the length was manageable This is pretty much what I imagine when I think of the genre, the brass bits are good and the last song in particular is cool
Very cool and authentic old school jazz 👍
This is just beautiful. Big band jazz at its finest. Such amazing players! Unless you just need riffage or you don't have a soul -- you'll enjoy this.
Très sympa. Je connaissais pas du tout. Faut que j'écoute plus de jazz.
Un album excellent dans l'ensemble qui, si l'on omet la qualité de l'enregistrement, est un délice pour les oreilles. Mention spéciale pour : "Black and Tan Fantasy" qui sort vraiment du lot.
Duken er alt for jazz til mere af min opmærksomhed. Jeg kunne ikke drømme om at høre extendet udgaven!
Det swinger alt for meget
This was cool!! I'm trying to listen to the original length of all these older records because I don't think I would like it as much if I would've listen to the whole bloated complete version that is on Spotify right now. I just listened to the original five songs that were on the LP. Because I don't care about a jazz rendition of the Star Spangled Banner or four minute long banter introducing the band. But yeah this was really nice, good house cleaning music.
The music part was great, the live album part was excruciating, and 2+ hours is obnoxious. Album minus the "introductions" = 5 stars Album as is = 4 stars
neat big band album, not enough shredding
I mean, I'm just not that into jazz, except, sometimes, when it's live and you can see the interactions among band members. This is fine as far as it goes, but it's no more than background music for a few seconds in a bar or nightclub in a period movie. Sorry, jazz aficionados.
-I dislike live albums -Jazz is not my favorite -Entirely instrumental albums bore me -This album is too too too long
Never heard this album before. Kind of an odd album, especially with the announcements being included throughout. The mention of a "young Quincy Jones" was pretty funny to hear. Overall the sound of this live album is pretty clean. I didn't find this to be mind-blowing. But it's a very famous album. and increased the popularity of jazz festivals. The story of how the original album and CD release were "faked" but that they were fixed in a later release is also interesting. Overall I get why it's on the list, but can't rate it higher than 3 stars.
Am I supposed to listen to the 38-song, 2h8m version that Apple Music proposes? Or the original 5-song, 43m version as released? A pity that Apple doesn't offer me the original format/length.
All the horns, piano, bass, drums had amazing sounds. I don't typically relate to jazz but this had big dance energy and reminded me of New Orleans (although it isn't from that region). Surprised how much I enjoyed this.
Wouldn't normally listen to this, but very pleasant.
I'd give this 5 stars if it was just Diminuendo in Blue.
I always love some Duke Ellington
America’s Mozart. But better. Why can’t we have beautiful music anymore?
I’ll take Duke over Miles any day. Miles Davis’s “classic” albums bore the hell out of me, but there is something about Duke’s band, combining technical perfection with tunes that actually swing. This is the sort of jazz that sets fire to my neurons, instead of stymieing them with the ice of cool bop. I wish there were video to illustrate just how crazy the crowd was actually reacting. I can’t imagine there was a single butt in a seat not at least bopping from side to side.
This was definitely an upgrade from that Justin Timberlake album the generator gave me yesterday! I don’t know much about Duke Ellington, but this live album was fun and enjoyable, especially for big band jazz and swing fans. The original 1956 LP only had five songs, but this version includes the full show with 40 tracks. Personally, I think they could’ve shortened it a bit since half the tracks are just talking or announcements. Even so, the music was great and gave me a new appreciation for Ellington.
Not for me
Some of the sounds those instruments made! Was a pleasure to listen to. Wish I was there screaming as well.
Make those instruments sing DUKE
Not really into solos. Rhythm section is good. Clarinet solo on black and tan fantasy is nice. Can't stand the trumpeter. Tea for Two is a nice song. Maybe I judge big band jazz too harshly. Hard to dislike Take the "A" Train. A classic and really well done.
Jazz. About as jazz as it gets. Most of this album had a very laid back sound to it, very understated. Good background music. I enjoyed it.
2 - I don't think it's bad, it's just something I don't really care about. Maybe it could get a higher rating if I was in the right mood, but all this is for me is nice enough background music at best, or just boring at worst.
Not the most interesting or wild jazz album I have ever heard, but this definitely made getting up super early in the morning a lot more bearable.
Jazz, not really my thing but good.
This would be fun at a jazz and wine festival with a lot of wine. Unfortunately I'm at work with no wine
Tooooooooooooo long! Buuuuuut this is my favourite era of jazz and I would happily put this on in the background while I’m preparing fondu.
Another day, another brilliant jazz album. The only thing I knew Duke for before this was Big Mouth. Skin deep could have been the whiplash finale
Finger waggin music! Fun to listen to, and I can understand the cultural significance of this performance and moment in history, but it’s not something I see myself listening to again. I’m not super well versed in jazz, but Swing/Big Band is not really my thing.
Good music to sleep through. 2 stars or D+.
this helped me place first at tft good songs and it was performed live the American national anthem as the opener caught me off guard so hard lol
Not my thing but respect those for whom it’s their thing
Some good songs, when in a jazz mood
Favorite Track: Diminuendo In Blue
3/5
He’s the best for a reason. This album totally holds up. Production is still on point.
Ellington and his crew killed it.
Wow. What an experience! I wasn't familiar with the Duke, but this album really showcased why he was such a legend. His group has such raw, potent energy. It's amazing to hear the crowd go wild. 'Black and Tan Fantasy' was my fave here.
It’s pretty good but starts to get boring after a while (2+ hrs long). Low 4
A bit long with some repeats, but this was great to listen to as I cleaned the house after having some difficult guests.
Too long 2/5
I tried, but jazz is definitely not my thing. I'm sure he's good at it, I've known his name my entire life, but it has ZERO appeal to me. "Everybody do your thing, we'll meet in the middle for a minute, then we'll wrap it up", jazz and it's freeform ways drive me bonkers since I'm not a musician. It all sounded the same, too many horns, too much orchestration. Probably impressive to see live, I love watching people jam out who are masters of their instruments, but not my kind of music. Not Top 1001, not on my list at least. 2 stars cause I'm sure someone appreciates this waaay more than I do.
A bit on the long side, don't know if the crowd interaction is necessary and could have a bit tighter. But still great example to know what it was like to be there live 4*
Great live album. I've never really sat down and listened to a Duke Ellington album, but this was a smooth play. Lots of shouts out on the mic. I give it a 3.
The musicianship on display throughout this album is outstanding, and I'm happy to hear an enthusiastic crowd roaring with applause after the songs, while quiet and attentive during them. Jazz is meant to be experienced live, to feed off each other's energy. This gets a little too big band-ish for me at times, but overall it's a skillful record of the immediate moment.
I enjoy the big band sound, impressive and cool to hear live. The live format with the emcee and Ellington speaking between numbers made the listening experience a little disjointed, but the talking was somewhat interesting from an historical perspective. It was cool to hear Ellington speak, as all I knew of his voice before this came from Jordan Peele's impersonation on Big Mouth lol
Hot damn, this was fun! Duke is a legend for a reason ❤️❤️❤️
Bardzo dobre, ale za dużo gadania
Enjoyed this very much, and the quality of the recording was fantastic. However, live albums aren’t a favourite of mine, and the various interlude felt like it slowed things up a little. Great listen though!
I struggle with jazz, but this was a great performance
Jazz.... it's the notes you don't play. This was over 2 hours long, I dont think I lasted an hour.
An interesting listen, not convinced by the fake crowd noises, but pretty good overall.
idk
4.5
I thought the music was very nice and I could easily listen to it again, I enjoyed the introductions to each artist and sing, however I did feel that made it overly long
Good jams, long album, but from what I did listen to it seemed incredibly easy to get on the A train
Sorry Seb, but I listened to this passively, as elevator music that was free to catch my attention here and there whenever it felt like it. And it did, here and there. Three stars is probably generous, but whatever. I hate live albums and those aspects here don't exactly entice, but I've also loved what little Duke Ellington that I've heard (mainly his soundtrack for Anatomy of a Murder) and the livelier aspects of this set reminded me of that.
Not for me, Jazz at its best but not my thing
Not typically a fan of live albums, but this was a treat. I wasn't a fan of the talking in between songs being included, but I really liked the high energy of the songs and the instruments were played so smoothly as well. Highlights: Tea for Two III Newport Up Sophisticated Lady
Can appreciate the sound of jazz but doesn’t do anything for me.
I’m sure it’s a classic if you like that kind of thing. To me it’s Tom & Jerry music.
Big band isn't my favorite flavor of jazz but this had some tasty moments on it and the musicians were impeccable. Paul Gonsalves was an obvious standout for his lengthy solo on the final song. It's too bad that the recording quality was so rough, it took me out of the performances. I guess for a live outdoor recording 68 years ago it's understandable. 3.5/5
Rating: 7.5/10
Inoffensive big band that never really struck a chord with me throughout our time together. Maybe I find the faux-live style disingenuous? I don't know, Duke Ellington is certainly someone to be respected, but this was just stereotypical "50s music" to my ears.
Real quality jazz. Miles Davis didn't get a 5 becuase I heard this before I rated the Davis album. The live aspect was also fun. I like the calming if the riot song. Audiences used to go hard!
Ok there are two versions of this album available, one has 5 tracks and one has 38. I guess I'll start with the former. Kicking off with the clarinet.. oh yeah. Didn't know the first few tracks but they were fun. Noticeably much fuller sound on track 4, Jeep's Blues, which I know well. Awesome to hear the crowd going absolutely nuts after each track. Halfway through the last track and this sounds like the craziest party of 1956, crowd is goin nuts. 1956?? god damn. This probably changed these people's lives. Super exciting ending. Awesome snapshot in time, great musicians. 3/5
I listened to the first 20 tracks (there were two CDs I think, so I did not listen to the second one). Overall, great jazz album, especially since it was live but I don't like all jazz, and I did not like this one too much.
I don't care to listen to jazz, even when it's good.
Jeeps Blues makes it
This was hard to get through. The audio quality on Youtube Music is quite bad -- it might just be that that's the best quality available, but either way, it was not as enjoyable as it could have been with a good, modern quality audio track. It sounded very thin and tinny and even though the music was pretty decent, I just couldn't really hear it well. Two stars.
9/10
Swanky!
Hearing the introductions and small speeches was really like looking into a Time Capsule! But I’m not well versed enough in jazz for any of the tracks to stand out to me :-(
There are so many versions of this album, some (including the original 50s release)are mostly studio recorded. After listening to that I found a complete cd release with the studio and live recordings separated. I liked it so much I will probably listen to it all.
How exciting, a jazz album! ‘Cat’ Anderson solo goes crazy, need to listen to the full two hour versions, but the original record is incredible!
urge un'enciclopedia del jazz per capire veramente perchè ciascuno di questi album è finito su questa lista. sempre molto piacevole, ma anche molto lungo.
It was exceptional! What a show and Music!
I'm not the biggest jazz fan, but this is good. It does sound a little bit like the background to a cartoon from the 50s though. Blues to Be There sounds like George Gershwin. Before the rise of pop music, every thing sounded like a score to a movie. This is a good listen. The longer this goes the more I like it. This is a great album. I only listened to the original release version but I will definitely check out the 2 hour complete recording now.
Assuming that this recommendation is for the original and not the 1999 "complete" edition, I'm going to base my review accordingly on D1 8-18 followed by D2 3 and D1 19. Kind of obnoxious, but I also don't really want to go in for a full 2 hour set just yet. Blues to Be There has a great sway to it. Love how patient the song is with the Trumpet vocals in the back section. Had this on in the background for the most part and it rips. For 1956 in a time where conformity was king, jazz stands apart for its looseness and ability for elastic expression. I went a little off of the original recording and found Skin Deep (a request) to be a hell of an enjoyable ride complete with open-ended drum solo. This had to have been the bees knees back in '56 because it still bangs today. 4 / 5
Perfectly fitting that I am in New Orleans while listening to this album. Nothing but great jazz, not sure what else to say about the good things in this album. It's pretty much exactly what I expected. A little long as for most albums, but the fact that this is a live album it's perfectly fine with me. I am a bit confused on Spotify's Disc 1 and Disc 2 since it has some of the same songs on each. I listened through Mood Indigo on Disc 2 because that's when they say good night to everyone.
We have been on an absolute jazz roll here for the past couple of weeks. This one was more of a \"standard\" type jazz and the horns are incredibly powerful. I would say this is not my favorite type but still good. This is in the high 3 range.
Love a good live album, but this is one where the crowd noise kinda takes me out of the music. Sucks because the music is great.
Teveel geklets
Not into jazz. Awful, listened to first song, not music for me.
01) Festival Junction - 4,0 02) Blues to Be There - 4,5 03) Newport Up - 4,5 04) Jeep's Blues - 5,0 05) Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue - 5,0 TOTAL: 4,60 (46/100) Current ranking: 343/359 I definitely have no intention of listening to the double CD release, instead I found a playlist of the original LP with only 5 tracks lasting an acceptable 40 minutes. Although, what is acceptable when it comes to Jazz... I just can't stand all that Jazz.
Very exciting
Didn't seem like this was much different than the other jazz albums we've had. Great performers, but just not my jam.
I hated this album. Is it incredible jazz? Yes. Are the horns screachy af? Also yes. This one was anxiety inducing. I’m rating it middle of the road because I respect other people’s appreciation, but cannot go higher than a 3.
Not my thing. Not a great mix but that’s also bc of how old it is. Maybe good party music in the background.
Respect for the legend.
Welcome to jazz club…
I love the sound, but the announcements in between take me out.
OK, so, to begin with — so we're clear — I only listened to the songs that were included on the original 1956 LP, in the order they were presented in. It's not that I didn't have time or want to hear the complete concert. Much like The Who and LIVE AT LEEDS, I wanted to hear the album as it was originally released (as much as I could, anyway),so... Here we are. And for my second "to begin with," let it be known that all of the material here is amazing. This band is just superb and tight as hell. Hearing these concert recordings specifically instead of the studio versions makes it all the better; knowing that they were doing this stuff live in one go in front of a crowd. I mean, hey, that's part of the magic of live albums, innit? And in terms of jazz live albums, goodness, this big band stuff is so much more my shit to listen to than that "Sunday at the Village Vanguard" album by some trio I can't remember the name of. Seriously, them horns and that drummer. It'd make me wanna watch WHIPLASH again if that movie wasn't so much... A **lot**, y'know? But that's off-point; simply put, none of the material here is worth missing. Now, of course, I say all that because... Goodness, "Diminuendo And Crescendo In Blue". I can't imagine anything else being the climax of the album. It's— wow, what a showstopper. Especially knowing that the solo Gonsalves played was apparently so exciting that the entire audience couldn't help but get up and cause a big ruckus dancing to it. That, and that one Gonsalves finished his solo he **collapsed**. On its own, without this extra context, it still would've been an awe-inspiring solo. With that extra info, though... Yeah, goodness, I can hear why this performance is so legendary, even without hearing all of it. Needless to say, I'm a big 5 on this album. Goodness me. I really gotta return and hear this thing in full sooner than later, I swear. A masterwork, pure and simple.
Some pretty solid jazz numbers, but not much else to point about this album. 3.5 bumped down to 3.
It’s a 5. I don’t need to use any more than 2 paragraphs to explain why. It’s a live jazz album, what did you think it was gonna get? The only way it could’ve been any lower than a 4 would be if someone had just been yelling into a microphone the whole time. I’m not super deep into music theory to tell someone why these are good, or to explain the deep complexities in the performance. I have an ear, and that’s about all I need, I think. My ear is telling me this was really fucking good. This is my first time listening to anything by Duke Ellington. I now want to listen to even more of Duke Ellington – I know the name, I know his place in history, and I know his deep, deep importance to this specific era of big band jazz. There’s a reason Stevie Wonder made Sir Duke. He lived up to the hype and more – this is a spectacular 44 minutes; there's neither a wasted note nor a moment where the energy dies down. Mix that with a red-hot crowd hanging onto every single flourish & some stellar compositions, and you end up at an easy 5.
Really actually pretty pleasant.
delightful
Of course this is masterful. Of course it is at the highest level. Nevertheless, there was something in THIS performance that I felt was too mechanical or maybe like "professional" and less personal and impassioned. I don't know why exactly, it may be to do wth chemistry, as iif you put together the worlds greatest sports team by hiring all the best players and sure, they win everything but where is the heart? Not going this far with this album (!) but it does feel like a performance. Perhaps because they ARE masters at their craft they need to put something more into their performances to personalize it more? Interesting...
Feels heavy, gritty and yearning but broken up by feathery piano. All in all really good. Of course even I recognize some of the more known songs. Can’t say more since I’m not the biggest jazz listener. Favorite Songs: Black and Tan Fantasy, Take the "A" Train, Newport Up
Had muddy waters at Newport yesterday, so good to get a direct Comparison to another live album, This is good, but has the pitfalls of what I don’t like about love albums. The CD version is also far too long. But more than worthy of this list
I have previously stated that I have a fairly mid level ceiling when it comes to live albums; as I never consider them a necessary stop when diving into an artist's discography. But like the English language - there are exceptions; and we have arrived at an exception to my general rule. In fact, I would generally consider this form of jazz to thrive on live performances and Duke Ellington's 'Ellington At Newport' does not disappoint whatsoever. I listened to the original 5 track release, seeing as Apple Music only had editions with a plethora of added tracks, since I want to get the authentic experience of each album that the generator gives me. After the brief introduction, the first track, ‘Festival Junction’, hits you. A 10 minute masterclass in what I like to call a “build up” song. What starts with simple wind instruments and ends with an explosion of bouncy brass, brilliant piano, and excellent drums with brilliant melodic work in between. It is followed up by the relaxing 'Blues To Be There' - almost tedious in its construction, but the conservative nature of it is a great counter-piece to the eclectic and exciting opener. 'Newport Up' is where I feel the primitive nature of the recording technology lets the album down just a little bit. It's one of the shorter tracks on offer and it's an uptempo attack of quick notes and fast melodies; and I feel this is where the drums were really supposed to shine, but they sound extremely muffled here. In fact they sound pretty muffled throughout the entire album, it just really stands out on this particular piece. Once again, the follow up to this track 'Jeep's Blues' is a more sombre affair - allowing the brass section to shine, with very light piano used as a backdrop as a means to apply decoration to the main course. Then we have the excellent finisher 'Diminuendo And Crescendo In Blue'; in which you can sense the band on stage having an absolute blast for 14+ minutes. Bouncy drums, the groovy brass section, with the piano backdrop adding fun loving personality to it all. It almost feels like the end credits to an excellent movie; while you sit there thinking this song is an absolute banger. And you're not turning it off until it's over. It is by far the most dance-able offering, and a perfect ending to the LP. 'Ellington At Newport' is a brilliant live album featuring some of the most efficient, technically great, musicianship you're ever likely to hear in the realm of jazz music; with a gold standard in how to construct a near perfect setlist that flows so damn seamlessly. Ellington knows when to bring the power and excitement with the more uptempo tracks; and more importantly he knows when to bring you down for a little breather in the slower, more restrained tracks. This honestly would be a perfect 5/5 if it wasn't for the actual recording hurting the sound quality a bit, which I don't hold against the album to a huge degree. But it's still worth pointing out. With that said, though, this is the kind of jazz album you could use to convince others to give the genre a chance if they think it wouldn't interest them. It's an excellent showcase of jazz, and Duke Ellington himself + his band; and it is rightfully held in high regard. 4/5
Still not old enough for jazz. I agree that Sir Duke has to be included in the 1001 list once (maybe more) but this one was a bit squeaky (and long) for me. Diminuendo In Blue is the best song despite being 14 minutes long. Broke this album into three separate fitness sessions and that seemed to work. But it’s still dated jazz (2.4*s)
This album was much too long and there were wayyy too many musician introductions at the end of each session. I doubt anyone in the crowd even knew the name of the third quartet flutist in seat 6 (or cared). I thought jazz was for old people but there were so many shrill, squeaky moments I started wondering if everyone's hearing aides were turned off. The live format of this album doesn't work at all, I know there are talented people on this stage but I think you had to be there. Jazz may be a living, breathing genre but I'm good on this one until I'm neither of those. Sufferable 1.35.
Can't say I enjoyed the album that much but 'Ol Dookie and his band play pretty well together and have a blast doing it. You can hear it on "Diminuendo in Blues" or is that the crowd? Really didn't like that at the end of songs the horn players were trying to hit the highest note and make their instruments sound like a shrieking fan-girl. Tell her to shut the f up please. And why are do many songs have Blues in the title...isn't this jazz? Had to be there live for this one I guess...1.25.
I'm sure this was a hell of a show back in 1956, but not much translates through when listening to the album version. It's 40 minutes of big band jazz that does very little to differentiate itself to the untrained ear for me. Duke is a legend from way back so I'm sure he deserves this entry on the list for historical reasons but I'm sure I could never hear any more of his work without issue. 1.39 stars
grande duketq
Pretty good. Good to work along to. Not as good as other jazz albums I’ve heard I think this was a bit too much at times but some of the tunes were a good vibe.
Good instrumental
Excellent....
Obviously a classic, signature performance. It's high twos for me as it's 'not the jazz I like'.
Very long, leading to a segmented listen.
I only listened to a couple, but it’s not my kind of music
Really really long like way too long and there's loads of chatter that we don't care about. But the music itself is cool
Don't have a lot to say about this because it's from an earlier era of jazz than I normally listen to, so it's harder for me to contextualize, but goddamn this cat could swing on the piano. Great music to put on and just go about your day 4/5
Its weird to parse through the complete version for the three songs included originally in the re-recording, and I think one day I want to sit down with the entire 2 Cd album but at least for the "Newport Suite", "Jeep's Blues" and "Diminuendo ans Crescendo in Blue" its all just the kind of energetic and fun jazz that just so clicks with me the most (mainly with Bebop), especially the Newport Suite which packs so many sonic emotional moments that transmit this sense of joy from all the players in the band, its always weird to describe that but those moments always make a jazz recording to me and even more with how the audience responds in turn. Wonderful stuff and totally get how this gave Duke's career a second wind
I don't really understand jazz (how does the song translate to the title-idk) but I like the way it makes my brain feel. I skipped all the intro talking parts, a downside to live albums. But I found the musical skill to be impressive. I would give it 4.5 but rounded it up instead
Great album by a master of the craft! The length hurts this one, as well as the fact it’s live (doesn’t bother me much but it will to some). Hard to pick a favorite for my 1001 playlist
Niiiice
Great background music for working. 4/5
DNF I'm not listening to two and a half hours of Jazz
Great jazz album. This was 1956. The performance was amazing and live recording and production was perfect.
This album is phenomenal. I don’t know much about jazz but I like this.
A great listen.
This is exactly what I think of when I hear Big Band Jazz. This concert had to be WILD. Reading up in the Wiki page, I had already known that Duke supported his band through some time but I had no idea this was the point it really turned around again getting them back on a record contract. And that sax solo in Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue....Holy shit, Gonsalves played his heart out to collapse. This had to be an epic experience and we are so lucky it was captured here.
I liked it, but I’m unlikely to revisit it.
Jazz is pretty cool.
Good
listened to the original LP. this album truly went in one ear and out the other. i was surprised at the extent this *doesn't* feel like a live album (i am told the remaster differs on this); it's all technical showmanship and feels very tight and regular
Sheer perfection.
4 1/2!
All for live albums but not a fan of how much song time the announcer gets here lol broke the flow way too often. Nice jazz besides that though. 6.5 / 10
Although I'm usually a sucker for Jazz, visiting a chunk of the jazz clubs in Manhattan almost every third weekend during my time there, this album did not resonate with me as much as I would've hoped. The jazz sounds so basic which has never been the case with most other jazz albums I've heard, this truly felt more like a band you'd find playing on a Saturday night at a reasonably fancy restaurant to appease your mood after seeing that abysmally small portion size. A 3 is justifiable for this album in particular.
Eh
Took some time for me to get in a groove with it but ends with a bang. Really cool
Some of these songs are going incredibly hard and that proto-double bassdrum solo is insane.
I usually enjoy the Duke a lot, but if I was at that show, I'm pretty sure I would've slept through it.
A very good, dynamic and fun big band album, but it still sounds very standard to me.
Not my bag
Acknowledging that duke is an icon for a reason but I’m just not a jazzy girl.
Thoughts before listening: One of the jazz greats and another huge music figure I have never really listened to. I believe Duke Ellington is big band swing style jazz, but I may be wrong on that. I'm glad this is a live album. Review: Very enjoyable album of live swing music. From reviews I've read it seems that this was a transitional album with soloists that typically didn't play with Duke Ellington and brought a newer, fresher take to their parts. So from an historical perspective this is an important album and from a quality perspective its a great representative overview of its genre from one of the heavyweights. 4-stars
With over 2 hours of material there are too many stand out tracks to list. This is jazz you have have on and not feel pretentious, its fun has that big band swing to it.
Not really my type of music…
Ik vind bij jazz de saxofoon erg mooi maar zodra die er niet is vind ik het vervelend gepingel wat erg op mn zenuwen werkt.
Just in awe of Duke's skill and the whole band. Love the whoops and hollers from the band as Duke plays that are caught on this live recording. You can feel how much fun Duke, the band, and the audience are having during this show. And the fuckin talent! Goddamn, Duke is a legend.
Star spangled banner! Bee in a dustbin.
Quite satisfying, if not my thing, it certainly was my father's thing. He loved big bands and the swaying and dancing that took place with fancy small town dance halls that thronged to this music. 2 stars. Not likely to listen to again.
Love this to work or chill to
One of the reasons I'm doing this project is to be introduced to all the great albums of jazz. It's not my go-to genre, but when it hits, it hits. I really enjoyed this. I learned a lot reading some of the most liked reviews on here, for instance, Diminuendo In Blue features the infamous 27 chorus saxophone solo by Paul Gonsalves. And also the fact that parts of this were recreated in the studio. I know there are mixed reactions to this, but to me, they created a final project that really showcases the energy and joy felt by the performers and audience both. However they got there is fine by me. I listened to and am rating the original ~44 minutes, but I want to listen to the complete version sometime as well.
Fun! Don’t really listen to jazz, but enjoyed this. Listened to original LP version.
Damn that's a long album, no thanks
Love this album. Ellington really knew how to make use of his musicians' incredible talents. Diminuendo in Blue is just thrilling.
Mind-numbingly boring most of the time, excruciatingly painful to the ears at others (I had to turn the volume waaaay down during some literal screeching from a trumpet at one point).
Jazz agradável, mas o show para ser só para iniciados.
7.5/10. It was performed really well. However, the album feels far too long.
Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue
the small little intros/conversations aside, this is some fun big band jazz. it doesnt really stand out to me (except the horns here and there) but it was definitely enjoyable.
That’s definitely a jazz album!
Very talented musicians. Artists. Not my cup of tea.
Duke Ellington's piano playing provides an incredible foundation for these insanely talented musicians to solo over. The rhythm section is killing it and everyone sounds so tight. Fantastic album. Man, it would be so fun to be a part of a big band like this. I played in jazz band in high school and this music is just a blast to play.
Bisher längstes Album. Aber nett mal für einen Nachmittag.
Too many interludes, and why the star spangled banner lol
The commentary was probably a really cool concept back in the 50s, but it detracts from the music more than it adds any sort of interesting content. The rest is great but a little more big-bandy than I like in jazz.
Only the second album out 200+ to come along and blow me away. I’ve wanted to find a classic jazz album that I chimed with for years … I was not expecting a live Duke Ellington recording to be the one. In parts it like trad jazz you hear in war films. But that is just luring you in. Every so often it just explodes and the crowd go with it and everybody. Loses. Their. SHIT! Like you can tell this is the 50s equivalent of a club absolutely going off. It’s an incredible journey of a listen and I’m very glad to have found it.
I just don’t like songs without lyrics. Feels too elevators to me. I think the tunes are great and would love it if it had some words to it
50s Tom and Jerry music again. Didn't like
what a drag
Don't normally like jazz but this was enjoyable. Didn't really notice any of the discordance stuff I usually hear in jazz
Canonical brilliance. Start here, abandon all hope of ongoing financial liquidity.
Nice, easy listening jazz album. I enjoyed the fact it was live, and the talking in between songs.
Fucking jazz.
I like it. The audio quality isn't the best, but it has a good rhythm. Jeep's Blues is probably the best track. There's also a nice history there. I can picture myself in the scene, so in a sense its a transformative album, it transforms you to a different time and place. And if that doesn't make it worthy of the top 1,000 & 1, then what does? One hell of a finale too
Grande
3☆/5 09.25.2024
I just don't like jazz.
I thought this would be a slog but I think I also would riot if I was there for Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue till the end. Also liked Blues to Be There and Skin Deep. Can't rate it 5 stars though because sometimes the brass is just PIERCING
This was an unexpected treat. Not a huge fan of live albums, but this one works.
Nice album
Fabulous
A lil too jazzy for me
OK, good jazz.
i am skipping all these introductions this album is long enough i do not care if it is not the 'full experience'. i am not a jazz guy so lets see how this goes. my first impression is that I will genuinely have no clue how to rate this because obviously the instruments are very impressive but I can't remove my prejudices and biases away from it - the music is very good and if I was somewhere and this was playing in the background I would not be upset and would enjoy it but I am never going to go out of my way to try and listen to this or recommend it to anyone cause it simply is not my kind of music I would say that after a while it simply just becomes more of a background music, not that it is necessarily a bad thing I apologise Mr Ellington, in another life this could easy be a 5 star album but alas it cannot be for me personally
Duke Ellington is one of most accomplished composers and bandleaders in jazz, who had an incredible career. Ellington at Newport was a "live" album - or, at least partially live. Ellington and his band played at the Newport Jazz Festival in 1956, and it was a historic performance. The show, and the very successful album, revitalized Ellington's career. Time has revealed that some of the tracks were re-recorded after the show, but that doesn't undermine this incredible recording. Ellington composed pieces to allow the talented members of his band to shine - structures designed to create space for soloists. The soloists in his band were all of the very highest caliber, and all of the members of the very large group are capable of incredible work. On a potentially negative note, this record contains a late-concert drum solo, and this may be the first such recording, so it is potentially responsible, at least in part...