Reviews (page 7 of 15)
Je n'ai jamais été un super fan du concept d'opéra rock. Ce premier album de Meat Loaf ne m'émoustille pas tant que ça mais je dois avouer que j'ai depuis pratiquement sa sortie l'album Bat out of Hell II: Back into Hell de 1993 que je trouve très bon.
Vraiment une drôle de gugusse, Grease meets AC/DC. Avec un cover art à la Iron Maiden. Alternance ballade/toune plus hypée. Avec des tounes de 10 minutes. Je trouve l'amalgame plutôt de mauvais goût, même si j'aime bien la voix du chanteur et certains riffs.
Le cover dit heavy metal, la voix dit rock doucereux, le nom de l'artiste donne faim. C'est pas mauvais mais une écoute suffit. Son plus grand succès n'y est même pas en plus.
It was kind of stupid fun-silly and over the top. This isn't great music that I formed an emotional connection with, but I have to admit it was fun. It almost felt like a comedy record. I'm embarrassed (and guilty) at how much it did put a smile on my face.
I wish I was more in the mood to listen to Opera Rock when I got this album but I’m not all the way mad at it. I’d be interested in revisiting this in the future.
The album is over the top bombastic and operatic. I love it. 16 year old me loved Paradise By the Dashboard Light. 56 year old me still does. The album is a lot but it is great fun
So much fun. The title track and paradise by the dashboard light are musical theatre rock epics with so much character. Took the words and two out of three are just fun rock songs. Heaven can wait and for crying out loud are seriously beautiful ballads. I should listen to this at least once a month.
Overall: 9/10 And the award for Most Misleading Album Cover goes to.... This is a crazy album. It's so over the top that its boiling over. Extravagant and wild. I always knew Meat Loaf from movies like Rocky Horror Picture Show and Tenacious D but for some reason never had any interest in listening to his music. I regret that now. So glad to have this in my life now. Fav Song: Paradise by the Dashboard Light
Now this is more my speed!! The grandiose theatrical piano with the addition of rocking guitar supplemented by Meat Loaf’s heavy, sonorous voice is beautiful. I thought meat loaf was a hard rock album but I was so gratefully surprised with this emotional epic that somehow balances the excitement of banging your head to the beat and making your heart heavy. Loved it, wish I had discovered it before but so glad I know of it now.
Very theatrical, reckon would be fun to listen to live - not quite my thing
Good Americana fun!!!
Meatloaf is rock and roll for theatre kids. Not my thing, but I know a lot of theatre kids, and Meatloaf is right in their wheelhouse. I think this first record is always going to be the best, at least as a cohesive album.
Let me get this off my chest; I don’t care for Paradise by the Dashboard Light. I don’t hate it, but it’s like the ultimate boomer bait song. It’s finds its way into almost any social event (party or whatnot) and has the audacity to be over eight minutes for what can be described as “Somebody please take my wife”. The ultimate punchline to any boomer music. I really thought this whole album would fall under this category and expected to hate it. So naturally, I’m little bummed to say that I didn’t. Yea, the albums corny as shit and Meat Loaf is not the most classy of acts, but his ballads are actually pretty good and the dude had some talent. Most of the songs sound like the biggest shit ever, both production wise and vocally. It’s not that bad of an album. I just can go without hearing Paradise really much again. Favorite track: Heaven Can Wait Other hits: Bat Out of Hell, Two Out of Three Ain’t Bad, For Crying Out Loud, You Took the Words Right Out of my Mouth
Hell yeah!! This is one of those rare records where even if you've never heard it before, you somehow find yourself singing along—loudly, wildly, and without shame. The choruses are built to be shouted at full volume, preferably in a car, with the windows down.
Such a fun album
Meat Loaf is objectively a good song writer. Some of these songs don't need to be 8+ minutes long, but I think he has definitely crafted his place into music history. This was a really easy listen.
Sempre pensato che Meat Loaf facesse metal ignorante, mi ha sorpreso in positivo. Promosso
Caroline exposed herself as a mad Meatloaf fan - worth it just for that. Classic rock - overblown but enjoyable
Hated it then, hate it now.
loved it since kindergarten - still do !
This shit sucks
Pretty good
another debut album after the last one i listened to, this one by meat loaf. this album is quite a doozy, the same kind of energetic theatrical pop music that the likes of elton john and queen. i feel like meat loaf has been parodied and joked when it comes to how dramatic he can be with his music, and while a lot of those jabs are kinda right, i think it really drags us away from the fact that he IS a talented singer and songwriter. the music is consistently good, you don't really see too many albums especially today where every track has a consistent sound and it doesn't get old throughout the runtime.
It was never going to be GOOD...but I did at least hope for it to be more fun. Title track aside, it seems like glam rock by numbers to me.
Against all my better judgement about how this album seems to me, I really fucking like it. I find something incredibly endearing about the overblown romantic declarations in the title track. Also paradise by the dashboard light slaps, containing both an earworm of a chorus and the stupidest fucking bridge I’ve ever heard in a song. Love it.
Ridiculous, preposterous, brilliant - just enjoy it!
"Theatre Nerds Are Horny, Too: The Album." I had a soft spot for this album when I was a teenager, but that seems to have lessened as I've gotten older. The instrumentation on this album is terrific, the dynamics and song structure are on-point. But there's a schlocky desperation that permeates every note, and that is just too much to make this one I'll return to. 6/10
Ah, so that's where Jack Black gets it. 3/5
I mean, this is Meatloaf, what did I expect it to sound like? It’s the same piano-driven rock song after song. He’s talented, but this isn’t my jam. The fact that every song has to be funny gets old.
This is obviously not one of the 1001 Best Albums. But I'm giving it a 2 based on my love for it when I was a dumb kid in the 70s.
I already had this album and listen to it often. Excellent start to finish with some of his best hits.
It’s like the Rocky Horror Picture Show, and Out of the Blue, and the Declaration of Independence, and Susan's speech to Ricky Bobby all wrapped into one mad explosion of musical excess. I laughed. I cried. I recognized the absurdity and I didn't care. I DIDN'T CARE. I luxuriated in the audacity. And, when it ended, so tenderly, I - with a renewed faith in humanity's capacity for genuine self-expression in the face of artifice and pretension, greed and cynicism - I steeled myself for re-entry into the 21st century.
Over-the-top and theatric.
Someone else described meat loaf as heterosexual elton john, and that completely blew my mind. Meat loaf is sappy af, not what I expected.
It has an artificial feel to it.
I came into this album with absolutely no expectations, other than the fact that the album art looks cheesy as hell. Kinda cool in the edgy kind of way, but cheesy nonetheless. In the end, I found an album I didn't think I could relate to so personally, while also being so damn over the top about everything. This is the epitome of dad rock, but at the same time, it's so unabashedly itself, a rock opera that feels so whimsical you practically get sucked right into it. The only part that realistically took me out of the whole experience was the intro of "You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth", which while it sets the tone of how intimate the song can be, drags on for a bit too long, taking up like a fifth of the run time. Out of any album I've rated so far, this is the album that's most likely to go down in my rating scale. It's not at all flawless, you need to be in the right headspace to listen to it, and songs may go on for too long sometimes, but passion practically oozes through this project you can't help but appreciate it.
When I saw this, I actually said ‘ooof’. I’ve never been into theatrical rock stuff, and this is no exception. The album imagery is cool and seems like something I’d be into based on appearances and the fact that I listen to a lot of metal, but alas. Right off the bat, the title track starts off with some crazy piano pounding bullshit and I knew I was in trouble. Then the vocals kick in and I officially tap out. I somehow made it 3 minutes but it felt like an eternity. ‘Ooof’ indeed.
A couple of good ones, notably the extended version of Bat Out Of Hell, but otherwise this was pretty forgettable.
Exactly what I thought a Meatloaf album was.
This is more than an album it's an experience! This album was one of my mom's favorites growing up so it is near and dear to me. Its so perfect in so many ways, the piano, the guitar, the lyrics and the vocals (shoutout to the females on this record, they are the unsung heros!). Its completely over the top, in a way that is borderline campy making it so much more believable. The lyrics are sung with such passion you miss how ridiculous they are (two out of three ain't bad). I mean how many of us have danced to Paradise by the Dashboard Light at a wedding and forgotten how ironic and ridiculous that is! Everything is dramatic, everything is rock, everything makes you buy in, dance around and sing at the top of your lungs.
Nothing sounds quite like Meat Loaf. Dramatic and passionate but with just enough quirky humor to make you go .. wut? Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth, All Revved Up, Two Out of Three, and Paradise by the Dashboard are all great songs. Phenomenal song writing with great energy. Bat Out of Hell and Crying Out Loud are not my favorites but they work well as an intro song and a finale song even if they are kind of long and not as good as the others. They work in the context of the album. Heaven Can Wait is a skip for me. But other than that, it's pretty much a masterpiece of rock n roll.
Bat is an all time classic album for me. It gave me some cool core memories from the days of driving around in my old school Toyota Prius with the tape deck chugging out the perfection of You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth, Two Out of Three Ain’t Bad, and Paradise by the Dashboard Light.
This album is perfection.
Had always heard of Meatloaf - did not realize this is his origin. Wow, is this very much of it's time. Considering it is a bat out of Hell, I thought it would be more intense/metal - instead the sax and vocals feel like a cheesy 80's sitcom or musical (which tracks, given the info in the wiki link). Def not my jam - not into over the top, over-dramatic rock operas! Will never ever listen to this again!
When you want Rock Opera done right, Jim Steinman was the go to guy. Bonkers, over the top nonsense and gloriously addictive. I don’t remember when I first heard this, but I’ve listened to it enough times to know every word. It’s a great album. Mars, but Steinman could write great albums and at this point Meatloaf could still perform them. That Old Grey Whistle Test performance of Paradise is enough for me.
Contender for greatest rock album.
Good at times and at times just too theatrical for me.
Rock has it should be. Bat Out of Hell, classic. Overall, a good album.
I enjoy that the album art for Bat Out of Hell looks like the album sounds. Unnecessarily huge, theatrical, explosive, way over produced, awesomeness. May a giant bat on a steeple watch over you as you launch your motorcycle out of the grave.
Never listened to before other than hearing to hits on the radio. Was expecting to like more than I actually did.
Not really to my taste. Rock opera at it's best.
Don't know, couldn't listen to it to the very end. Just not my cup of tea, it seems. Feels like I've listed to it so many times that it just feels bland. Perhaps, there's some historical context I'm missing.
The title track is enormous fun, an unbelievably over the top 9 minute epic with motorbike guitars and more cheese than Cathedral City, but it works, extremely well. Paradise By The Dashboard light is similar, OTT fun. The rest is very meh, schmaltzy ballads which bring the rest of the album down.
It’s cheesy but fun
This is the epitome of a rock opera. The songs are theatrical without being forced, and long without overstaying their welcome. Great stuff. Best Track: For Crying Out Loud
No my cup of tea. Not sure if meatloaf is parody or earnest and that's not great.
Ostigt och kul
Ostigt men mättande
Riktigt härlig musik! Tuff men sa samtidigt ganska lugn, gillar combon.
yay, musical theatre adjacent 4/5
Listens: 2 Standout Tracks: Paradise By The Dashboard Light Teenage Angst? One-Night Stands? Being horny? All in the form of a cinematic rock opera? This feels like one of those "it's so bad it's good" kind of situations. It's not amazingly bad, but like, who was the target audience for this when it came out? This album spent NINE years "in the charts" apparently. The album cover is excellent. Also, and totally unrelated, I can't wait to read the reviews for Fight Club references.
Felt like a musical and like if David Bowie had a child with Freddie Mercury and put out a musical about Ozzy Osbourne.
This man was part of the reason I wanted so badly to learn guitar lessons in school because I thought I maybe one day too could make a sick ass album. He's genuinely impressive and inventive with music and his ability to just keep going until literally the end was also impressive.
it takes one hell of an artist to make a 10 minute long banger that doesn't get bogged down or lost on the way. also hot summer night is one of the songs ever. good shit mr. loaf
There are some albums out there that are so iconic that they define an artist’s entire career—Bat Out of Hell is perhaps the pinnacle of that rule. This is an album that KNOWS it’s a silly romp (Meat Loaf being a member of National Lampoon tipped me off immediately), and delivers an absolutely fun and thrilling romp. The title track kicks the door into a theatrical journey, with the crowning jewel of Paradise by the Dashboard Light delivering us the most high-stakes petting the world has ever seen. The perfect album to drive to, and one of the funniest rock albums to ever exist.
You know Meatloaf. Operatic hard rock, with blues influences. Like Springsteen/Elton John meets glam rock. Some gospel/choir in there too. It's less hard rock overall than Meatloaf is stereotyped as. Really sounds like Springsteen with a whammy bar in places. Even some funky bit in Paradise By The Dashboard Light Each track is a mini album in it's own right, which makes it hard to love any of them.. Great Boleros of Fire is a nice instrumental interlude. Overall it feels a bit too manufactured, not much authenticity. But it's clear showmanship and basically set the standard for a genre so it deserves respect for that. Best track - All Revved Up, Paradise 3 stars
The highs are high, the lows much less so
There was a time when I would have said this album is OTT cheesy theatrical nonsense and rubbish. All true except the rubbish part.
Probably closer to 4.5, but not quite a 5.
Don’t judge an album by its cover. Not much to say except I enjoyed it. The intro to track two really creeped me out when I was by myself though.
Wasn’t the worst but I didn’t love it. For Crying Out Loud was probably the best out of the whole album, and the album wasn’t awful but again just felt a little weird listening to it
Garage band?? Idk man this seems like custom mode in guitar hero after doing some type of illegal stimulant.
This album was meh. I felt like I was listening to a musical all the way through, which I’m not sure a band named Meatloaf intended to happen
Felt like i was back in 7th period advanced drama class. I do not wish to go back to that.
Sounds kinda like Elton John. 🤷♀️ Power Ballads aren’t really for me.
No thanks. Cheesy and overproduced. The charm is lost on me. Musical theater melodies, which I don’t hate, but everything else just misses. Is it a satire? I can’t tell. Everything is so campy, and I can’t tell if it’s supposed to be intentionally sarcastic. So theatrical and melodramatic, with textures as thick as cold oatmeal. The tracks drag on and overstay—the longer it went on the more I hated it. For 70s rock, it feels very shallow. 2.5-3/10 Could have done without the ASMR intro too.
I feel like this is a perfect addition to this list. Not because it's really a "great" album, but because it truly fits the idea of something you need to listen to at least once in your life. It's theatrical, it's whimsical, it's dumb, it's absurd, it's fun. At no point is it boring. That's probably what you should expect from an artist named Meatloaf, especially considering this started as a musical/play concept on Peter Pan. I think over-the-top is an apt descriptor, for better or for worse. Everything about it is in that mould. Just starting with the title and artwork, you'd think this was something hard and heavy (as I did for a long time before hearing any of it). It'd be like, I don't know, calling a movie "There Will Be Blood" and creating a imposing poster with gothic font for it, when the movie is just 3 hours of people disagreeing about land (I kid, I kid. Well, sort of). I feel like that setup matches the tone perfectly for what they were trying to accomplish, though. And the presentation of the music and vocals is complete theater. Kind of like getting the porn parody of a medieval epic instead of the real thing. That said, it's not all fun and games. The style and performative nature makes it a bit polarizing, I'm sure. Opera and theater aren't for everyone (including me, even with the rock context). Also, the novelty would almost certainly wear off quickly with any attempt at a re-listen. Even so, that first listen is quite the experience. Regardless of whether you like it, it's not something you'll quickly forget. On my part, I can't say I loved it. But I can say that I couldn't avert my ears from the experience. It was an interesting ride, and gets credit for its gusto and being mostly enjoyable. I didn't think it was all that "good" as a whole, though. Overall: 2.8/5
Great album
Git
I've never listened to this album, but I knew one or two songs (3). Some good parts (Dashboard Light) but overall really cheesy, even cheesier than I thought.
Uptempo songs: yay👍 - ballads: nay 👎 I don’t need to listen to this again but I can respect the musicianship that went into writing and performing these songs
I really feel like I'm being pranked that this is the highest selling album of all time in Australia. It is definitely my aversion to musical theater that's hurting this for me. This is another case of musically, I get how this is impressive and dare I say a maximalist feat but I just don't get it. I had to reframe my approach to listening to this and go again in a mindset of this is silly musical theater that I shouldn't be looking at through the same lens as like To Pimp a Butterfly. Made way more sense that way. I think I'm going to rock a 4 on this but I can appreciate a fully orchestrated rock opera that isn't the worst thing you've ever heard.
I love this over the top rock opera. So clearly a musical in rock album format, I love this thing. So silly but the playing and singing is just so good it adds to it. 5/5
Epic
This is a top teir album, Meatloaf is one of one.
I tried really hard. Every song felt like 10 minutes of torture. Bat out of hell was 8+ minutes of me waiting for it to be over. I love all music but I honestly cannot see the appeal of Meat Loaf. Clearly not my cup of tea.
I wish this album was mastered better. Fun electric guitar and the beat was fun. Bat Out of Hell, Paradise By the Dashboard Light, and Fpr Crying Out Loud were a bit longer than what I like though, after 4-5 minutes it was just too much. Also why the moaning in PBDL? Was that really necessary?
Deserves 10 stars!
Sounds like that one scene in Happy Gilmore where he tries to go to his happy place and his gran is necking on with Gene Simmons, or like a rock opera version of Thunder Road by Springsteen
Not my thing but a fun listen.
Lemmesleeponiiiiiit
I grew up listening to Meat Loaf. Maybe not the best decision on Mom's part, but I still love him. Even if you think he's over the top or too dramatic, you have to admit that this album has some phenomenal written lines!!!!
Guys, you're causing me to have a Meatloaf Flareup. That's when someone mentions Meatloaf then I've got to listen to Meatloaf non-stop for the next several days. I'm not mad, I just wanted you to know the power you have over me.
MEATLOAF!!!!!
I played this too much in my youth and find to be somewhat histrionic… but it is still a brilliant album.
I've never listened to Meatloaf before, I was definitely expecting more of a Metal album based off the cover art, not what sounded like a 1970s rock opera. It was a fun listen but definitely not what I was expecting. As I listened to the album more I got more into the groove of it, but it just wasn't what I was expecting.
Show tunes for dads. Horny and not in a cute way. Never need to hear this again.
I like him as a performer (his sweat drenched performances on OGWT are amazing) and I like some of these songs in isolation but as an album it is a bit much.
Saw a review that said this was a heterosexual’s Elton John which seems pretty on the nose. Seems to employ similar tropes in a lot of songs, lyrical or melodic hook, followed by quieter piano part, build up to uptempo rock part, changing tempo occasionally and repeat ad infinitum. It’s just a bit…much isn’t it? Very little finesse on a lot of it.
I hated this album. I hated it a lot more than I thought I would. Its theatrical in the most amateur way. His voice is bad; the songs are bad. It's just a weird novelty act. I want my 47 minutes back!
So many classic songs. Rock on an epic scale.
I really really want to give this 5 stars. I do but if 5 stars is perfect and “All Revved up” is not a good song, what do I do? Fuck it. I’ll buck my trend. It’s perfect enough. I mean, the storytelling, the anthemic songs. It’s a rollercoaster.
Heard of Meatloaf but had never really listened to him. Fun album with energy. He’s got a great voice and the music felt big. Got a rock-opera thing going on.
Middle school classic! This brought back so many golden memories, love it
It's a lot. Big drama. Really good production. I can't take it seriously, so I won't be returning to it.
Nope. Not my cup of tea. Interesting, though.
Classic album from a young Meatlosf. I have this album in my collection since 1977 snd always liked it. I think all of the songs are good. I also enjoyed watching the videos
Album Art Review - another iconic cover for an iconic album. Literally a demonic motorcycle launching out of a graveyard hellscape with a giant demonic bat cackling over the whole scene. Great cover that both teases the music on the album, without really preparing the listener for what they are about to experience.
Ok
Cool album. But I do find the songs too long.
What a fun ride, like a bat out of hell. Honestly, the album cover goes so hard it deserves an extra star for just bringing so much emotion to the album, and on top of the unique and sick guitar that exists plus the "musical" style that I think it does really, really well. A solid 4.5/5 album for me, leaning 4 because I can't put some of the 9 minute songs into any of my playlists.
3 1/2 stars I used to love this album when I was a kid. It was so dramatic. I thought I was going to dislike it this time around but it didn’t. It’s fun and a great rock opera. I as pleasantly surprised.
Too pompous.
2 out of 5 ain’t bad. Had some Italian restaurant vibes but not as good
pa okej je ovo ispalo, zbog omota sam mislio da će bit žešće sranje. podsjeća me na todda rundgrena, ali nije toliko dobar
Rock opera has never really been something I seek out, so this is an interesting first album to get! Part way in, this is very cheesy and over-the-top. It reminds me a lot of Christmas in a sense despite no direct connection. I don't dislike it so far, both "Bat Out of Hell" and "You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth (Hot Summer Night)" delivered about what I expected with the intense guitar riffs, general instrumental weight, and booming screams of a vocal delivery. "Heaven Can Wait" is a pretty minimalist ballad, a nice change of pace from the prior two tracks. "All Revved Up With No Place To Go" follows up with more of the prior funk, feeling very 50s in its soundscape. This one ends up being a bit too tacky for my tastes especially with the very sped-up ending. "Two Out of Three Ain't Bad" didn't particularly stand out from prior tracks in any way to me. It's yet more decent rock opera. "Paradise by the Dashboard Light" definitely has the most variation, being a song in three acts, with increasing dramatics between the two characters portrayed in the lyrics. It builds to a satisfying climax, definitely standing out amidst its contemporaries. "For Crying Out Loud" goes for a more ballad-y approach to finish off the album, while still getting quite operatic. The piano work here is pleasant. Overall, a pretty cheesy product that is very of its time, even with all the 50s influence strewn throughout the construction of the music. Nice to explore, but not something I'd soon revisit.
J’ai surtout apprécié le 1er titre aussi non le reste se laisse écouter mais sans plus
Before hearing this, the only Meat Loaf song I knew was his track from The Rocky Horror Picture Show (one of the best in the film btw). I was aware of this album and its huge success, but I never understood why it was so big. After finally giving it a listen, I get it a little more now, though it still feels like a bit of an anomaly to me. Doesn't matter though. This album kicks ass. It really does feel like the soundtrack to a theater musical production (I mean it literally was adapted into a musical at one point). Its so over the top in all the right ways! A hell of a good time. Favorite track: Bat Out Of Hell 3.5/5
Better than I expected, just not my thing
What a magnificent album! Plenty of epic and melodic moments. Forget the cheesy name and give a bite to this monstruous piece of Meat!
Great vocal layering. Elite harmonizing and the use of spoken word samples is perfectly executed. Very very reminiscent of Queen??? Wasn’t expecting that. A beautiful mix of ballads and absolute guitar rippers. Listened to: walking through prospect park. Favorite tracks: Bat Out of Hell, Heaven Can Wait, Two Out of Three Ain’t Bad
If 'The Room' were an album, this would be it. It's fucking terrible, but I don't hate it.
A classic, loved it since I was in highschool. Slower songs overall but Meatloaf always kicks it into gear
One of the best first songs of a album
This album is making me reconsider how I rate these. Part of me says that I should consider this a guilty pleasure, but I unreservedly love this album and I will rate it as such.
I was haunted by the popularity of this Album when I was a teenager and resisted it for a long time. This album seems to have everything dialed up to 11, including the concept, drama and album art. It's definitely a moment in time!
Pretty wild! I felt like I was in a rock musical! Not really my thing, but a nice little escape for the afternoon
picks: bat out of hell, paradise by the dashboard light
3 estrelas - só pelo Todd Rundgren
Macht Laune (gute)
Meat Loaf is Springsteen for theater kids. It's a damned good album.
Testosterone-driven opera about love and sex — the adolescent experience. Operatic, dramatic, and a little shallow, it was quite a ride in my youth. Best experienced now with limited attention to the lyrics, which feel like an uncomfortable reminder of the world before the prefrontal cortex develops. Fun, but also a bit embarrassing. *A punchy ChatGPT summary of my statement above: A bombastic adolescent opera about sex and longing — thrilling in youth, cringey in hindsight.”
Oh yea classic 70’s rock!
Epic
I always think Bat Out of Hell is poking fun at the inherent ridiculousness of rock & roll, but it's like Mel Brooks' Young Frankenstein - a spoof made with such skill and care by people who genuinely love the thing they're parodying that it becomes a classic in its own right.
This album is over the top, over produced, cheesy and everything you’d expect from Meat Loaf. The opening to You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth is absolutely ridiculous. Bat Out of Hell saves it from 1 star treatment.
Okisg
This album is too much and ridiculous (complimentary)
strange - i usually like strange but…meh. Sad cuz i do like rocky horror
I would have thought this was glam rock, but the delivery is just a bit too earnest to have any level of self-awareness about the cheesiness. The titular track is alright but the rest is a big bag of meh.
Wayyy more theatrical than I expected which was interesting. But it wasnt bad!! I appreciated the artistry of it all. Opened strong and closed strong, which makes it a solid album imo.
title track was great and album felt like classic older ish but still harder rock! songs were really long lol. been meaning to dabble in meatloaf so this was good but wanna let this marinate and listen again sometime.
In high school, you could occasionally bring LPs to music class. Very often, this LP was brought by a classmate.
A gem of an album from the golden age of rock. Killer guitar solos, and that most glorious rarity, the rock piano. There's only seven songs but he draws everything out of them. I didn't begrudge giving 10+ minutes to a song to allow him space to explore different ideas. These songs were epic before it was overdone, and so passionate. I love the storytelling - it's theatrical without tipping over into cheese. Really top stuff. Absolutely no issue or dispute in giving this a 5.
Thought this would be a fun listen but I didn't care for it at all.
First time I have actually listened to this album all the way through. Outside of Bat Out of Hell, nothing too exciting from my perspective. It was fine and enjoyable at times, I probably wouldn't go through the whole album again.
What a belter of an album. Familiarity: 5 – Deep Familiarity Songs I would actively choose to listen to: 3 - Half What can I remember the next day?: 4 - Most Best song: Paradise by the Dashboard Light
Wedding season
Ok
This is such an easy 5. This is probably mum's favourite album so including bias points here. Bat Out of Hell speaks for itself, it really does carry this album. Don't get me wrong, the rest of the songs on here are good - but Bat Out of Hell is Meatloaf's magnum opus - a near perfect song. You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth is included as my other favourite song on here. It's perfect addition cooldown song to Bat Out Of Hell, and sets you up for the more sombre tone for the rest of the album. Honestly, everything else on here is rather forgettable. A good listen, but nobody listens to Bat Out Of Hell for anything except the first two songs, and maybe Paradise.
More like Fat and out of Health
They call him 007 0 songs written 0 sex appeal 7 double cheeseburgers
I did not expect ti enjoy this at all, I have a particular disdain for hair metal (to no-ones surprise). But this album is well produced, funny, camp and proportionally cool. Nah gammon, the above is partially true but it's mid 5/10
Theatre kid album. This was pretty good at first, very bombastic and full-throttle. As the album continued, I found myself getting tired of it. The first two songs are great, especially the second track. By the time it gets to Paradise by the Dashboard Light, I am ready to stop listening. The original song was supposed to be 27 minutes? Yeah I bet it was just an additional 20 minutes of baseball commentary. Jesus fucking Christ. 'kitchen sink rockabilly' is the best way to describe this song. I need to be in the right mood for this, I can't just throw this on at anytime. This would be great for a roadtrip with likeminded (drunk) people or in a an environment with enough stimuli to distract me from focusing on the finer details of the album (being drunk). One good half, one admittedly shit half. I'm feeling generous so it gets a 3. Furthermore, I am finding it difficult to not make a link between how indulgent this album is and the artist's physique. I'm choosing to be the bigger man. Highlights: You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth (Hot Summer Night)
I must preface these comments with the fact that I LOVE Meatloaf. I love the songs, I love the swagger, I love the earnest devotion to rock. I'm also amazed that something like this got made in the first place. It's outlandish and odd and epicly vague. Who would green light this project? It must have taken such a force of will to make it happen and I respect that so much. There's no shame or guilt in this music, it feels uninhibited and unleashed. They are playing to their tribe so there's no judgement and each song lets loose with honesty and rage and disappointment and hurt and lust. It's OK to feel these things about all the other things. This is rock and roll and only you can define what that actually means.
This is rock opera. I don't like rock opera. Earlier in this project I hypothesized that part of the reason for The Beatles' success was that their tracks are short and to the point--every track on Hard Day's Night is under 3 minutes. This is anything but that. 4:19 is the shortest track. Three tracks are 8 minutes or longer. Also clapping? Please don't. Heavy sax? Also a no for me. 2/5
Loved this album growing up but mostly because my mum sold it to me pretty hard. Incredible moments on it but it isn’t one I would listen to again out of the blue
Enjoyable but likely never again.
No. Just no.
Loved the rock opera sound.
Maximalist songs. Very long. Sounds like a show choir
REALLY fun!!! super upbeat and intense while being beautiful throughout its runtime
Quite a voice, but also sappy orchestration and lyrics that put me to sleep. Zzz
Judging by the cover, I think this album might be just too subtle to be any good! This has to be the most overblown, overproduced, over the top album than has ever been created. Operatic extravagance with motorbike engines and musical theatre earnestness. It’s all very safe, and very high camp drama. Meat Loaf seems permanently on the cusp of a breakdown, but never more so than on For Cryin’ Out Loud, which camp drama in the extreme. I never know whether to take Bat Out of Hell seriously or not because it works best as a great party album. I don’t think it stands up to intense critique of the artistry. I love it.
Another album that requires separation of the art and the artist. Album: ridiculous, over the top, bombastic silly fun. The artist? Well, let's just say I wasn't sad when he died. This is a review of the album, so... yes, excellent nonsense, five stars.
Meaty Horror Picture Show. If you ever want an alternate Grease universe with a theater nerd's version of rock and roll, and some cutesy (slash rather die than have a relationship) lover-boy ballads, Meatloaf's got you covered. Really catchy and fun tunes, and would really love to see Bat out of Hell: The Musical, baseball-sex scene and all.
Bloated, pretentious and overproduced. Everything punk rock saved us from
It's big, brash, bombastic, bold and I hated every second of it. Never liked Meat Loaf. This is so over the top that it hurts. Painful listen.
Ballad after ballad. Really great listen all the way through.
Bra variation och allt var typ bra
That was very theatrical. If nothing else Meat Loaf sure has a knack for theatrical, epic duets with powerful female singers. I was quite surprised to find out that Paradise and I Would do Anything for Love have different female lead vocalists. Also the one on I Would Do Anything for Love didn't get any royalties. That isn't cool. Anyway, I'll never listen to this again and won't mind. That said, I enjoyed this far more than I'll ever admit.
In terms of dramatic rock piano ballads - Meat Loaf is at the top of his game… perhaps even the creator of the genre. With lines like “you’ve been so cold Im crying icicles instead of tears” - what more could you want. Did he inspire the series Twilight - given some of the werewolf themes perhaps. I could have done without “paradise by the light of the dashboard”… awkward first time in a car but as a rock duet ballad… huh. For the record - I will forever associate Meatloaf with Noel forcing us to listen to the extended 12 minutes version of “I would do anything for love”. Perhaps the longest 12 minutes of my life. Also who knew it was a duet.
goofy
bat out of hell - pocinjemo s pjesmom po kojoj je album dobio ime, odlican intro, fora klavir, onaj tip rocka koji mi inace nije bas drag - onak parent rock, slatki stihovi, spoj brzog i sporog instrumentala, oooodlicni gitara riffovi, lajkam world building i metafore you took the words right out of my mouth - opet kuuul intro, svida mi se tematika, slaaatko, dosta ponavljanja istih stihova na kraju heaven can wait - laganija od prethodne dvije, kinda mid zapravo all reved up with no place to go - najs, djelomicno relatable, smijesan background voice, dobar ritam, prva koju sam sejvala u playlistu two out of three aint bad - zanimljiv naslov, dosta specificni stihovi (ali ipak sigurno relatable nekima), ne kuzim ovo 2/3 i OUCH sa ovim "im never gonna love you", personal story, projectionnn, dosta harsh al tak to nekad ide ig paradise by the dashboard light - tone change od prosle pjesme lol, uuu zenski vokal, UGH throwback na 17, omg dvije pjesme u jednoj, haha baseball inuendo, ajme frajer ispada kao takav douche wow, svida mi se ovo kad ga tjera da odgovori, 100% sam na njenoj strani, AJME WOW KAKAV KRETEEEEEEN, obozavam ovu pricu, jeeeeez for crying out loud - boring, ipak moze voljet hmmm, skoro sam zaspala neironicno, cijeli orkerstar u pozadini damn great boleros of fire - jao puno tog zvuci bolje uzivo, ovo se cini ko bas odlican vajb, pol pjesme je intro, jesu to orgulje u pozadini, aha okej ovo je instrumental, onda mi je ta za sad najdraza bat out of hell live - omggg 11:11, ovo je izvedeno u kratkom periodu gdje se moj tata vec bio rodio, a mama jos nije, duugacak intro, a mislim isto ko i og samo live lmao, gitara solo ODLICAN, ponio bi me vajb da sam bila tamo overall - ja cijelo vrijeme mislim da je meat loaf neki reper ali okej. fora rock album al nisam se bas povezala s njim, malo pjesama i dosta razlicite sta je fora al stihovi su dosta osobni i specificni pa nije bas za sve (sta je cesto pozitivna stvar ali ovdje mi je bila meh), fora cover art tho, da mogu dala bih 2.5, al 2 mi se cini premalo pa bude 3
Not my thing at all
Some catchy tunes but a bit too stage musical for my liking.
Some really good songs on an enjoyable album. -3.5/5
The rock opera that sets the stage for the rest.
4 Wow what a banger. So theatrical.
While there's a LOT to like about this - extremely well crafted songs, great song titles, and a very strong energy - it doesn't really connect with me. Glad I heard it, but not so sure it'll find its way back into my ears.
Surprised I knew probably most songs would
Iconic operatic glimpse of love, lust, coming of age.
For the longest time in my life I imagined Meatloaf’s music was something completely different
Drôle, on dirait la soundtrack d’un film de Ken Russell
Amusant mais un peu cheesy. Plusieurs Queen vibes!
Super fun. Super massive. Has a sense of humor and rips. Even one of the ballads caught my attention. Also...43 million copies sold world wide? holy shit
Albumcover ist ja schonmal sehr gelungen. Pop-Oper Version einer judas priest Platte? Bissi wierd, aber irgendwie feier ich das
Really nice sorta prog style stuff with the progressions throughout the songs, great sound to go along with it. 4 stars
One of the GOATs. It's such a ridiculously over the top album and they use a motorbike as an instrument.
not bad, quite a short album though
Rollicking. Not my thing but I like him and I like that this album was made and was so successful.
Did not expect meatloaf to produce so many droll love songs on one record
Fun and energetic but man I really wish this album had more to give than love songs. Nothing wrong with love songs but when you have some of the most metal album art of all time I kind if expect more... metal. It was good though I just wish it had more to offer
The album artwork doesn't match the music. This is my first experience with Meat Loaf; he kind of reminds me of Elton John. Overall, it wasn't a bad album, but it's not a sound I would normally listen to. It had a nice variety of instruments, and it had plenty of energy. But it won't be played again. 5/10
Fun. Feels like a cheesy movie musical from the 80s, which I guess makes sense given what I know about Meat Loaf.
Maximalism, sometimes for the better and sometimes for the worse. For a fortyish minute album this should not feel this long. Songwriting by Steinman is basically gibberish, but is operatic enough to work (similar to The Killers). Total nonsense album, pure dad music but I think it’s a good enough execution of that.
I could see myself listening to this again Favorite tracks: You took the words right out of my mouth, All revved up with no place to go, Pardise by the dashboard light
Despite the album cover art, this was WAY more Broadway Cast Recording than it was heavy metal record. Some of the songs were pretty catchy. It wasn't bad.
listened on the way to the folkestone eurotunnel entry. it was more musical and less heavy than expected but i think i will enjoy it much more when i know the songs.
SO much fun
I’d Do Anything for Love (But I Won’t Do Bat). 4.5.
This was decadent in all of the right ways. I'm still a firm believer that Meatloaf's best work was the acting he did in Spice World. Personal enjoyment: 4/5 Relevance to this list: 5/5
Meatloaf is a whole thing all himself.
It was good. Didn't realise how similar Meat Loaf and Bruce Springsteen music sounds. But Meat Loaf more operatic. The hits are there. Between a 3 or 4. Stand out song - 2 out of 3 ain't bad
Works great as straight up hard rock, or as hard rock parody. 7 songs, 4 bangers. A fun album for sure. 4/5 Heard before? Just the singles Owned: No. 1/1001, 1/5 (20%) Will I get? Maybe Recommend: Yes
Pomp rock, well produced strong songs overblown for my tastes.
Much better than I thought it was going to be. Bat Out Of Hell is a banger and All Revved Up is a find. Some absolute overblown claptrap in there as well.
8/10 Rock opera at its best - the title track is awesome. The rest has its moments too, obviously, although it often feels like the sum of its parts. My wife hates Meatloaf, so let's keep my admiration for this between ourselves, shall we?
Es grandilocuente, recargado, dramático. Pero suena bien, hay música aquí.
Listened to this while playing Through Ice and Snow. I lost...again. This album was so much more enjoyable than I was expecting it to be. It felt like I was listening to a more enjoyable act 2 of Rocky Horror Picture Show. I loved the grandiosity of the arrangements...it felt appropriately epic. Almost a 5...but just shy.
At first glance, 𝘉𝘢𝘵 𝘖𝘶𝘵 𝘰𝘧 𝘏𝘦𝘭𝘭 looks like a heavy metal album — the cover screams fire, fury, and motorcycles bursting from graves. What you get instead is a theatrical rock opera full of melodrama, heartbreak, and teenage dreams. Without Meat Loaf’s over-the-top vocals and Jim Steinman’s operatic lyrics, much of the album could easily pass for a Todd Rundgren project — which makes sense, since he produced it, and the instrumentation carries his fingerprints (especially if you’ve heard 𝘚𝘰𝘮𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘯𝘨/𝘈𝘯𝘺𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘯𝘨?). Still, the album lives and dies on Meat Loaf’s performance. His voice turns camp into conviction and absurdity into art. Whether it’s genius or glorious excess depends on your tolerance for theatrical rock — but there’s no denying it’s one of a kind.
Springsteen for theatre kids, it's brilliant
Suena a demasiadas bandas buenas mezcladas, es teatral y exagerado y aún así no logra evocar nada en mi. Las letras son demasiado fomes. Musicalmente no tengo quejas supongo pero simplemente no es para mí.
Muy teatral y disperso. No soy una persona que se banque eso. Canciones que guardé: 2, 4 y 5 Nota: 5.5/10
7/10, teatral, rockero pero los lentos son lentos de verdad y cansan un poco
I absolutely love this album. I'm a big fan of huge production and this album has it in spades. An absolute allstar cast helped record and produce this album and it shows. While the mix is perhaps not the cleanest in the world, the instrumentation and songwriting is top notch. Reminds me a lot of Elton in places, if Elton john had a little bit more of a rock edge. Solid 4 for me
Fun album that continues beating throughout.
Liked how the album begins with a heavy song and then switches to more delicate tracks. Generally a high-quality one.
Surprisingly epic! You really don't know what to expect when you see an album with a cover this metal and an artist named Meatloaf. "Bat Out of Hell" is a certified banger, "Two Out of Three Ain't bad" walks the line gracefully between drama and humor, and "Paradise By the Dashboard Light" has the greatest switch-up I have heard in a song recently. I'm probably not going to revisit it soon, but you can't deny how great and unique this album is. 4/5 ain't bad
Ended up enjoying this so much more than expected.
A classic Meat Loaf album. Almost a five, but I cannot call it flawless
Eh this one was alright. Not awesome, not horrible. Great band name tho. Best song: Bat Out Of Hell Notable(s): You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth, Paradise By The Dashboard Light
Broadway musical with distortion no thanks
I don’t remember what song by Meat Loaf I knew already that made me dread this one but I was not excited going into this one. But that opening roaring and wholly epic opener changed that immediately holy ravioli was it good. It immediately throws us into another excellent track in “You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth”. I disliked “Heaven Can Wait” but again it shot back up with the good “All Revved Up With No Place To Go”. I also liked “Two Out Of Three Ain’t Bad”. However the most popular song on the record is “Paradise By The Dashboard Light” which started great but was ultimately ok I guess by the time it ended. Then the closer “For Crying Out Loud” which was boring for the first couple minutes but exploded into coolness before immediately dying down to meh again. This album was a mixed bag, some truly excellent stuff and some really lame stuff too.
Some great moments carry this album, but it feels like the kind of cultural moment where you just had to be there.
I genuinely dislike Bat Out of Hell. The heart loathes what it loathes.
takie pecie kwak
Good guitar riffs, but I’m not a fan. Made for a musical.
Kind of sucked--
A couple of tracks are complete dross
Objectivity is not possible here. I've listened to this literally hundreds of times in my life. And it looks like I'll be adding another time (or two) to that total today.
Speaking objectively, removing all personal biases. Meatloaf can be long winded, and a little cheesy at times. But i don’t really care. I’ve listened to this album since I was a child, and it still slaps to this day. A personal favorite of mine.
I always thought my contempt for this was just some residual teenaged snobbery but now that I've listened to the whole album, no, this just absolutely sucks. Musical/opera sounding bullshit with strings and nonsense. Get it to fuck.
Anyone who listens to classic rock hears some of these songs on the radio regularly. And some of you are undoubtedly like me: while I don’t go seeking them out, I find myself singing right along when they come on. What was interesting is listening this album front to back, as it’s actually quite good. Paradise By The Dashboard Lights is always so much fun. That they including the Phil Rizzuto part always kills me (even if he didn’t know what it was for, which actually might make it better). But the way this track moves through different parts and phases is the true genius that drives this song. Truly great. There’s so much to like on this beyond that tune though. Right from the jump, the title track is an epic tune that’s just in your face, over the top, and really lets you know what you are in store for across the rest of the album. A great way to open. Two Out Of Three Ain’t Bad is another fun song, as is You Took The Words Right Out of My Mouth (even if the opening is super strange). The low point for me was For Crying Out Loud, which I thought was a bit boring at times. Even then, Meat Loaf’s voice is great and the orchestral backing soars at numerous points. The roll up is that this was way better than I anticipated. Meat Loaf’s voice is great and there are a lot of intricacies to these songs which make them interesting. Is it bombastic and exaggerated? No doubt, but that shouldn’t diminish how well constructed this album is.
Three great songs and some filler. The vocals are superb
Well it hasn't got any less overdone or bombastic over the years, has it? This was never one's thing, even if one can vaguely admire the over-the-top-ness of it (an admiration tempered by something like embarrassment for this cat). "Two Out of Three" is a bit better than one remembers, but could never (and still can't) abide "Paradise by the Dashboard Light," however close it hit home, this Spectrian opera for teens, however accurately it represented one's lived experience (speaking of embarrassment).So bonus points for verisimilitude, one would say, plus ML had a voice rather well suited to his physique. The Rizzuto sample is a multimedia innovation but also strains the metaphor far past the breaking point. One’s not saying the song is unoriginal or lacks authentic drama (or even truth). But, for context, compare it to two other songs of roughly the same vintage covering the same volatile material (i.e., teenage sex) in similarly direct but more thoughtful and less obvious (and thus more powerful) ways: Carole King’s “Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow?” and Billy Joel’s “Only the Good Die Young.” But generally one's feeling is that this sort of extravagance (maybe exhibitionism) should not be encouraged, and especially not in rock and roll.
It didn't really get me. I think it would have been different, had i seen the musical
Over-the-top in the best way, such a fun album
Great album, easily his masterpiece
Este álbum es como escuchar una película de terror comercial de los 80s (así bien se publicó a finales de los 70s, creo que representa muy bien las estética que predominó en los 80s). En lo personal no me gustan ni los musicales ni la ópera, así que no es un álbum que me haya gustado. Me pareció grasa, excesivo y graciosamente estúpido. Sin embargo entiendo que un poco de ello es adrede, y la ejecución y grabación suenan bien. Podría apreciarlo como contenido irónico, pero ni siquiera me resulta memorable, como por ejemplo Vitas. Me llama la atención no reconocer ninguno de los temas. Se ve que el álbum como obra y acto integral fue el gran evento en sí durante la época, pero no los temas en particular. No termino de entender cómo es que este es uno de los álbumes más vendidos de la historia.
До этого я не знал ни про Мита Лофа, ни про Джима Стайнмана, ни уж тем более про альбом Beat Out Of Hell. Обложка меня заинтересовала. Очень красивая! Ну а сам альбом хорош, ни больше, ни меньше. Вокал Мита Лоуфа хороооош! Мелодии Джима Стайнмана тоже хороши! Мне понравились песни: All Revved Up with No Place to Go Paradise by the Dashboard Light Это на любителя, я поставлю оценку 4, но если можно было, то я поставил бы 3,5
smece
This crew understood the importance of extremes in rock and roll. For this album, they cranked everything- song lengths, instrumentation, emotion, and lyrics up to 11. And never let up for a second.
I can only respect this album for the vision and theatrics, but I also think it is extremely cheesy in many parts and doesn't resonate in 2025 even in the way it did closer to release or in the 90's when I heard a couple songs repeatedly. I think there are better ways to do a rock opera, but I approach this album like the soundtrack of a musical, and I can understand why it has fans. I'd give it a 3.5, but I'm rounding up to 4 for this scale.
Felt like a rock opera, I loved it
OK, this album is pretty much porn for the drama club kids. It's a soundtrack to a musical, which makes sense since Jim Steinman did everything for it. Meatloaf was great in Rocky Horror and his singing style will always be that dramatic rock opera sounding voice. Not a bad thing. Is this an album everyone should hear before they die? I think so. Will I listen to it often? No. I'm sure Paradise by the Dashboard Light will pop up on my shuffle every now and then, but it's just... I dunno, meh. Maybe I'd prefer something more hard rock. This one isn't there. 2.64/5 stars = 3 stars. Paradise by the Dashboard Light is the star of this album, listen to that. The rest is just OK.
mostly painful
very entertaining. made me feel like a conservative 50 year old dad who is lowkey an alcoholic. not totally sure if that’s a good or bad thing but i did thoroughly enjoy myself.
great sound, especially love the use of strings and brass instrumentals! cohesive and not repetitive, but the songs are really long making them difficult for casual listening. highlights: All Revved Up with No Place to Go, Bat Out of Hell
interesting album, idk why there was a whole conversation before one of the songs. very odd and quirky but fun.
I remember liking this as a teenager and being fascinated with the videos, but I rediscovered it again as a young sailor in the 90s, a year or so before Bat Out of Hell II came out. It's nice re-rediscovering it again and falling into the uber-dramatic lyrics.
I have a hard time separating Meat Loaf from his role in Rocky Horror. Like this just sounded like him doing bonus tracks for the movie. Which would be great. I like his expressiveness. It's like a soundtrack to a musical rather than just pop or rock music. Solid
I feel like I remember liking this album? Honestly, it was a little much. Dashboard Lights is a fun track, but everything is over the top.
Strong 3.5
In a nutshell: full throttle rock. Theatrical. Excessive. Iconic in the eyes of many. Always played loud. Props to the backing band. I still feel icky after listening to I Can See Paradise By The Dashboard Light for some reason. Overall: 6/10
It would get 5 stars if it weren't so subtle.
On paper I shouldn’t like this: It’s theatrical, proggy, overly fussy at times, odd and completely over the top. But it’s actually pretty great. Jim Steinman’s songs and compositions are strong, and Meat Loaf seals the deal, singing like a man trying to break free of possession by his own impulses. A couple slow clunkers, but “Paradise by the Dashboard Light” is maybe the best song ever written about teenage lust. It sounds like something that could have only come out of 1970s America.
What a strange record. Bombastic Broadway style songs with a fake Frank Frazzetta style cover that doesn't belong on a record full of power ballads. Apparently this is the best selling lp ever in...Australia?!?! But you definitely should listen to this because it is unlike anything else that has ever been a multiplatinum record.
Not sure where to go with this one. Is it good? Yes? Is it corny/kitsch? Very much yes. Does it hold up? I don't think so. But not sure it ever was meant to. It does feel very much of its time on purpose. And for that, maybe it deserves some credit. This album DGAF and just went all-in on being a rock opera. And rock operas being one of the goofiest things humans have invented as entertainment. Then again, regular operas are pretty goofy too. I also feel this album is so popular due to late 70s DJs needed an 8-minute track to toss on for a smoke break.
This album is like Bruce Springsteen and Queen called up Elton John and were like “we are going to channel the most excessive and indulgent qualities that we have as songwriters and composers and ignore all the subtleties that make our most ridiculous songs still work.” Elton asks what the concept will be for this album and they respond, in unison, “it’s like Peter Pan, but the dude drives a motorcycle and there are werewolves.” In other words, it’s an absurd album that is a lot of fun
Yeah this kinda sucks. Albumcover blijft leip, maar de bijkomstige muziek klinkt alsof ik naar een Grease companion album luister.
Was heel anders dan de verwachting, had een meer metal sound verwacht. Wel een prettige verrassing tho, en zal er op een later tijdstip nog beter naar luisteren
Wel leuk als musical, maar daarvoor mis ik de dans en het verhaal. Het stoort me ook dat 90% van het album wordt gepresenteerd als het belangrijkste moment in het album
Niet mijn muziek.
Hier en daar wat toffe muzikale momenten, maar over het algemeen voelt het toch alsof ik naar een musical soundtrack aan het luisteren ben en ik ben absoluut geen fan van musicals over het algemeen.
Vermakelijk om door te luisteren. Niet echt fan
This album was a lot but truthfully such a fun listen. I enjoyed the more upbeat bluesy stuff compared to the ballads but it was mostly enjoyable
First of all... His name was Robert Paulson. Alright, now that we have a Fight Club reference behind us, I would like to actually talk about the album. So, wow, just wow. This is not what I expected. I haven't heard Meat Loaf's music before and mainly knew the guy from, well, Fight Club movie, but I did stumble upon his albums many times in record stores. The covers were really fun, including Bar Out Of Hell's cover, but I was expecting something that would sound more like ZZ Top or maybe Motorhead, but I was pleasantly surprised it was something more. The whole album sounded like combination of Elvis Presley, Queen, Frank Zappa, Kiss, 70's and 80's progressive rock, symphonic sound and also american vibes. The first track made me feel like this album might be perfect, this opening was so spectacular I couldn't let myself not smile, just pure happiness. Next songs weren't as perfect but Meat Loaf showed that he can make great music and I enjoyed the rest of the album almost on the same level. So, considering all the circumstances, I think that there is only one possible rating for this album. Pleasant surprise you were, Robert Paulson, pleasant surprise.
© Gloriously OTT Anthemic El Classico Productions 💪
Generally rip-roaring. Favourite New Song: All Revved Up with No Place to Go.
Cinema for the ears. Great
Some albums are just so huge and over the top that it's impossible to dislike them. The elements that make this one probably shouldn't have worked together but they absolutely did. Meat Loaf certainly doesn't look anything like a charismatic lead singer, and even decades later, it's shocking to see him channeling Freddie Mercury. Combine this with Steinman's music, originally intended to be a modern retelling of Peter Pan, it's seeped in sex and Americana (added by members of the E Street Band). If record sales were initially slow, it may have been that people had no idea what to make of it. But the ongoing sales decades later confirm that eventually people caught on. It's a ridiculous but feel good album. If it's not working for you, consider taking music less seriously.
70s rock pomposity at it's finest. Jim Steinman can suck a dick. Not a fan of this album.
Liked it, enjoyed more than expected. Great 80-ish sound.
Classic album, always a good listen to find again
Rolling raucous but not really up my alley. Good but not great.
Why is this one of the best selling albums of all time?
probably the funniest album so far
Loved the title track, Im not one to vibe with style of rock. But I loved the piano, and the album certainly grew on me. Solid 3 stars
Okay but for why was this actually good though. Shocked to enjoy an album this much of the genre it is, from the period it’s from, with the album art it has.
Over the top.
It's kitsch, it's over the top, it's cliché, it's cheap-operatic... but if not taken seriously it's a fun album. Very good at what it does and definitely influential so must be on the list. I will never listen to this by choice (any more) but have to give it at least a 3. Oh go on, a 4 then, after all, if you like kitsch etc. this is about perfect.
Operatic teenage angst songs sung with absolute passion. This shouldn’t work at all. But Bat Out of Hell is so full of life and urgency it’s impossible to not get swept up in its craziness. “Paradise” is one of the most ridiculous songs I’ve ever heard. It’s campy, and funny, and exciting, and has the best lyrical left turn in all of rock music. It’s amazing. Good times, great oldies, it’s got a beat and you can dance to it. FIVE STARS.
Solid 5 stars all the way. This album was a birthday present when I was 18, it was released in October the previous year. I was into motorbikes and I copied part of the lyrics from the title track and had that above my bed. Some of the lyrics wouldn't stand the test of time, but this was the 70s, a time unique in history. My era. As for the album cover, just awesome. Legend.
I don't appreciate Meat Loaf having an orgasm in my ear
I enjoyed the listening of this album, quite a nice transition from a song to another 2/5
Meatloaf rocks, no question about it.
I'd give this a 2 but I can respect the level of craft on display.
Pretty decent kind of butt rock
It’s been said but I have to say it again: the cover and title of this album vs the actual content is insane. This is a cross between a bad Queen album and a broadway musical. It’s so over the top and so dramatic, and not in a really good way. The songwriting is good in the sense that it’s complex and has some bizarre ass theme running through it, both musically and thematically. Meat Loaf himself has a good voice and a wide range, but it’s kind of lost in this total cheese fest that’s going on. This is a theater kids idea of a concept album I guess, and while technically it’s sound, the rest is too much for me. This is music for a person nearly diametrically opposed to me musically.
Sick album cover. It's fun and a little weird but doesn't live up to it. What 43 million people bought this?
liked Bat Out of hell track
Bloody brilliant. So good to hear this again after a very long time. And still remember most of the words. A rite of passage for any rock fan now between 60 and 70. Awesome record. Easy 5 from the moment it appeared on the screen (though of course I listened to confirm).
thank you to the meat loaf episode of glee i had no idea how much of this album i actually knew. actually thought this was quite good, big fan of meat loaf's work in rocky horror. don't know if this is one i'd listen to in my free time but it's objectively very brilliant for what it is.
Fav: bat out of hell The anthem of drunk driving down the interstate in the western US and fucking the cheapest hooker at the cheapest motel that money can buy
It's fun, but definitely not something I would go back and listen to.
Yeah this was very solid. Had a couple of songs I was familiar with but it did feel like it dragged a little. Beautifully put together though!
Another classic. 5 stars not enough
The energy Meatloaf brings to this music is incredible. A lovely album I used to listen to a lot when I was younger.
I don't understand why this was ever popular.