Reviews (page 12 of 16)
משעמם
Somehow angstier than I had already thought from Bullet with Butterfly Wings. I do really like 1979, but didn't much enjoy the rest of the album.
I do not like this band in any way. Whiny voice
Mellin collie de smashing - uno de los mejores albums de los 90 y de el alternative en general. Completamente diferente y el productor se la comio. Ningun album despues se compara a este y sus mejores hits y non hits estan aqui. Este posiblemente sea el pinnacle de la era. Odio a Billy pero este album esta cabron lo unico malo es que es muy largo. Pero 5⭐️
Break down, 1979
Love it! So many great songs. Fave songs "1979", "Tonight, Tonight", "Zero", "Bullet with Butterfly Wings" and "XYU" 5/5
Another album that I've listened to previously but didn't really stick in my mind, thought I wouldn't care for it and it's too damn long. Actually listening I don't recall a song I didn't like, which is quite impressive for a double album.
Really enjoyed this, didn't expect to! Some good riffs, Jellybelly being a track that stood out to me! As well as Zero (I think it was called?)
I would have given this a five if it weren't so damn long!
Lots of stuff I like and lots of others.
It's been a good album, lasted too long for my liking but some of the songs were good, others not much, maybe I will listen to sum of it in the future but no all the album.
Better, but soooo long
Booooooo
A lot of great stuff here (first six tracks might have you hovering over the 5 stars - and that doesn't even include the best track of the bunch, "1979"), but there's just SO. MUCH. FILLER! One of the most "double album-y" double albums of all time.
The intro instrumental track, also the title track, is peaceful and sets the tone light. Stretched, almost anguished vocals join heavy riffs as the production is powered by guitar with accompanying drums. Tracks tie “teen angst” to “teen hope” as the Pumpkins paint a picture of what is now and what is to come. 28 tracks spanning over 2 hours in length portray the passion of the craft that embellish the Pumpkins critically acclaimed rapport.
I bought this CD when it came out and I’m not sure i ever listened to every song. There are so many classic but in listening to it through all these years later i really enjoyed the creative variety. Even the songs i didn’t love, i appreciate. A gem.
I'm not sure this needed to be a double album.
- Alt for langt - For generic - Få gode sanger + Et par bangers
Not as cohesive of an album as I would have liked. Many songs felt underwhelming and out of place at times. Siamese Dream feels like more of a complete listening experience.
A high point in 90's rock (and Smashing Pumpkin's career).
rly loving the spotify background graphic with them jumping and falling. relate. they should play this in more dentists office waiting rooms. already had some songs liked from this album but hearing it all the way through is not the way to hear these songs for me.
duhhhhhhh
i mean it's the smashing pumpkins alright... billy corgi... its real long... its got some ballads and bangers... Galapogos...
Um yeah so do you all know this band, The Smashing Pumpkins? They are really underground... yeah... I'm sure you've never heard of them. If I lived in the 90's, absorbed in the thralls of Grunge this would make me go absolute feral. I think I prefer Siamese Dream but they're just about at the same level - middle of the road and not something I would necessarily listen to on a day off. Fortunately for Virgin Record Sales, the grind never stops. This album is so long, a lot of the songs start to meld together when listening. A few standouts other than the obvious are Here Is No Why, Cupid De Locke, In The Arms Of Sleep, Lily (My One And Only) - I am a sucker for love songs, and Farewell and Goodnight. The last one has female vocals on it and I love to hear more than Corgan being sad. I enjoy Billy Corgan's voice, I think he writes emo ass lyrics (seen in every song... my dreams are dead yada yada ok chat gpt... I am kidding some lyrics are good). I was tired of the music by the second disc. It's super long and obviously Corgan is working through stuff. Fun facts: - The Smashing Pumpkins headlined LalaPalooza in 1994. - Prior to Madison Square Garden Shows, keyboardist Melvoin died from a heroin OD and the drummer Chamberlin survived his OD but was FIRED. - Female bassists :) D'Arcy Wretsky played for majority of bands big career and was replaced by Hole Bassist Auf der Maur
#137. Most people: the world is round Weirdos: the world is flat Billy Corgan: the world is a vampire 4/5: excellent *this is the twelfth album I purchased from this list Song added to playlist: 1979 I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link
This is an awful lot of music. Which isn’t to say it’s awful. Lots of it is really cool, and genre-bending. But it’s just like… a lot.
Two... hours? There are a number of good tracks on this, and it has the iconic "Bullet With Butterfly Wings," "1979" "Zero" (my son's favorite track of theirs). But... two hours of listening to Billy Corgan whine is asking a LOT. At least this isn't really a concept album; sure there's a thematic concept, but that's it. "Despite all my rage I am still just a rat in a cage..." It's such a great line, it's undeniable. Still... two hours? That's asking too much of me.
I've listened to Siamese Dream about a thousand times but I don't know if I've ever listened to this album, both sides, all the way through. Side one starts off nicely with the title track, a lovely instrumental, mostly piano piece that flows perfectly into Tonight, Tonight - perhaps their most artful and skillful song with its orchestral backing. And while it abruptly turns into heavy grunge at song three, I don't mind at all because the next few songs - from Jellybelly to Zero to Here Is No Why to Bullet with Butterfly Wings - is just incredible. Hard, gritty guitars, pounding drums, angsty lyrics. Grunge perfection. And there's still 8 songs to go on side one and it just keeps humming along - favorites are An Ode to No One (pulsing), Galapogos (sweeping like Tonight, Tonight), Muzzle (crunchy, a well known single), and Porcelina... (another sweeping tune). But this is a double album, which is ambitious but also dangerous if both sides don't hold up - might've nailed it with the best in just one album. And this album is a bit of that, as the back half of side two lags a bit. But the opening 6 song sequence is almost as good as the opening 6 song sequence on side one, with 1979 and Thirty-Three (softer) alternative classics and Where Boys Fear to Tread, Bodies, and Tales of a Scorched Earth more grungy goodness. Side one is without a doubt a 5. Side two is about a 4, but definitely better than a 3. And I'm rewarding the ambition of a double album with a 5. This is a classic from the brief grunge era.
A masterpiece of 90's sound. Captures the anger, angst and complications of a twenty-something in that decade with walls of lush instrumentation produced by singer Corgan himself. It is a long and ambitious double LP, but unlike some projects, it flows from mood to mood, emotion to emotion, without ever feeling like it overstays its welcome. Furious angry guitars and vocals give way to delicate acoustics and soft melodies by Corgan, Iha & co. Deserves every bit of critical acclaim it has received, and sounds every bit as fresh today as it did nearly 30 years ago.
Why is this such a long fucking album :c Intro track was really good actually love the instrumental Okay the fucking singer sounds like he has half a pussy and a full dick in his mouth I came in here expecting to hate this but I really didn’t mind it, atleast so far I haven’t hated it, the lyrics are kinda stupid but I like the rock grunge feel to it. They tried way to hard to make a rock album that it’s embarrassingly obvious that they had no clue what they were doing None the less… Who ever is singing this shit should kill himself 3.1/5
Best Songs: Tonight Tonight, Zero Listen Again: Probably not
There are a handful of quite good songs on this album, but mixed in with some other stuff that I'm not terribly fond of. This would definitely be an album that, if I were to buy it, would prefer to buy only the songs that I'm actually interested in and skip the rest.
Definite melancholia inducing album. Gave me serious flashbacks to the O.C. but I've no idea if they even used this for any part of the soundtrack.... Some parts had too much screaming for my liking but that's a personal preference. Favs: "Tonight, Tonight", "Thru the Eyes of Ruby", "Stumbleine", "Beautiful", "Lily (My One and Only)",
Despite all my rage I am still just a rat in a cage.
Better listened to in segments as it's LONG. Billy's voice is annoying but there's a lot of great songs on this album and they're spaced nicely throughout the tracklist so if you do listen to all in one go, it's never boring.
This album have been describe has "The Wall for generation X", it got a pretty good artwork and the CD have cool design and a booklet with the lyrics of the songs that reminds us of a old story book. The album is goddman long too, i'm never sure about double album to be honnest, any of them, sometimes they are just too long with very random and "useless" songs, even if the album have a concept like this one, or the wall. The album goes from instrumental, to art rock with an orchestra to classic grunge and alt rock, its pretty intersting. Some songs that stand out, among 28 we have Tonight Tonight (with the orhestra is very beautiful) JellyBelly one of the hardest song on the reccord. Zero is also pretty hard and its one of their best known I like the riff in Here Is No Why The others song are not bad, simply not so much impactfull i think, they range from calm and melodic song, to heavy in your face alt rock.
An album ruined with hubris. It's too god damn long
It’s impressive how, for as long as this album is, that it can maintain such a high level of quality across the range of rock from hard (Jellybelly, Bullet With Butterfly Wing), through pop (1979) to the softer side (Stumbleine). I was already listening to the hits off it all the time, but I’m very happy to have been introduced to the rest of it
Mellon Collie and The Infinite Sadness holds up incredibly well nearly 30(!) years later. It has a massive sound when it wants to be massive, it has a softer and more considered ballad side, it has a momentum about it in the first half, the drumming is excellent, it's very listenable and memorable overall. Negatives are that it's far far too long and that momentum from the first half is clearly lacking in the back half, and I've never really liked Corgan's vocals much, they grate quite considerably as we go along given the length of the album. I'll probably forgive that a bit, it's a high 3 or a low 4. Tonight, Tonight is such a fucking good track though I might just let it sit at a 4 because of that.
An absolute mess of an album, incoherent, way too long, jumps between styles way too quickly, and the guy really struggles to sing (which isn't an issue when he stays in his lane, but he really doesn't). But, it's punctuated by some absolutely great singles - Bullet With Butterfly Wings, 1979, and Tonight, Tonight are really good songs that don't overstay their welcome, unlike the album as a whole. Makes it quite hard to rate, so I'll go (unsurprisingly) down the middle with a 3, the incoherence and the filler balancing out the patchy greatness.
Thought it was alright. Good music, didn’t love the singing, because I’m not a hard rock fan
I can't be objective about this. This is one of those albums from my early teens that burrowed its way inside me and became part of my DNA. I could no sooner give it a fair rating than I could rate myself, or my adolescence, or what it means to grow up. Not every song on this album is a 5/5 -- honestly, not every song on this album is even good. Some of them seem to delight in their own ugliness. But the *variety* of music here; the ridiculous, laughable, incredible scope of it; the giddy soaring highs and the miserable vacant lows - none of the songs sounds remotely the same. I can't not give it a 5! This is less a collection of songs and more of an album of important moments to me. And there are so many of them. The defiant battle cry of "We'll crucify the insincere tonight" from Tonight, Tonight that wouldn't be out of place in an MCR song; the escalating bridge in Here is No Why that begs you to scream along; "Destroy the mind / destroy the body / but you cannot destroy the heart," which should be melodramatic dreck but feels as essential as marching orders; "Rescue me from me," perhaps the most self-aware Billy Corgan has ever been in his life; the snarling, vicious "Love is suicide" refrain in Bodies and the jacknife whiplash of Thirty-Three's sugar-spun "I know I'll make it / Love can last forever," right after it; the, again, very self aware "Suffer my desire" from In the Arms of Sleep; 1979, kicking off the slow march to the end of the album with the kind of sun-soaked, melancholy (ha!) nostalgia for things you may not even have experienced yourself; the almost silly Beautiful and Lily (My One and Only) and what I can only call a group lullaby on the last track. God, it's crazy. I love it so much. Unfortunately, it was also written by Billy Corgan, who by all accounts seems to be one of the most personally unpleasant people on the planet and has the political opinions to match. Maybe that's part of this album's appeal to me - I keep trying to crack the nut of how such a miserable, hateful prick could've made something so perfect. Maybe he poured out his heart and soul into this album and just... left them there. How do shitty people make good art? I don't know. It still doesn't make it less sincere to me. Whoever he is now or before, I believe every word he's saying here. It's part of the infinite fascination with the Infinite Sadness, I guess. Anyway. It's a mess, it's pretentious, it's painfully earnest, it's so fucking good. I totally understand the 1 star reviews. I think you either get it or you don't but I really, really do.
what a weird and cool album! it's perhaps the greatest thing William P. Corgan has ever made, though there's absolutely an air of art-house pretension to the whole thing. i mean it is a 2+ hour-long double album, but i dunno... it just kinda works. it's hard to explain how billy's weird voice, lyrics that could've come from an eighth grader's spiral notebook, and a very rough "concept" album throughline combine to make something far greater than the sum of their parts, but this album is great. the musicianship is rock solid and the songs all feel unique while still contributing toward a cohesive whole. bullet with butterfly wings was definitely the first one i heard (probably in middle school) and i slowly discovered the other singles in the years following. basically the entire first disc is good to great, starting off super strong and punctuated by highlights throughout. the second disc gets a bit lackluster in the middle/towards the end but finishes on a sweet note. it's a great listen overall, and I'll be returning to this one in the future. oh and obligatory mention that billy corgan is like, the worst. not sure how he knocked it out of the park with this one but yeah favorites: mellon collie and the infinite sadness, tonight tonight, jellybelly, zero, bullet with butterfly wings, galapogos, muzzle, thirty-three, 1979, farewell and goodnight
Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, well it certainly feels like it'll last forever. Double albums are usually a big ask, a couple of hours is hard to give to something you weren't planning on listening to and the link through on this went to the 92 song dep deluxe edition that runs for nearly 6 hours. FUCK. THAT. I hadn't really heard much outside of the monster singles this thing produced and I was somewhat pleasantly surprised at times, but it was mostly that nostalgic trip back to the mid-90s of my youth, and all I really came away with was that Billy Corgan is a madman when he's inspired, but that mad Billy Corgan could really use an editor.
Moderately interesting, some good tunes.
6.5/10 Really liked a lot of this, Corgan’s voice in particular was amazing, hypnotic, lovely. More variety in genres than expected Some really great tunes But a few major caveats No studio album should be over 2 hours long, a bit of editing could have improved this greatly Case in point: it stayed on concept, but the lullaby final quarter was weird and unsuccessful for me Wasn’t in love with the harder/metal stuff Best: 1979
Fantastic album, lots of different yet consistently good genre crossing music.
Standouts- "Zero," "Tonight, Tonight," "Bullet with Butterfly Wings," "An Ode to No One," "Love," "Bodies," "In The Arms of Sleep," "1979," "Thru the Eyes of Ruby," "X.Y.U.," "We Only Come Out At Night," "Beautiful," "Farewell and Goodnight" Vocals/Lyrics- 5/5 Instrumentals- 5/5 Vibes- 4/5 Overall- 4/5 This album is a weird one to rate. The slower songs are the ones that appeal to me the most, but on the other hand the harder songs are so full of rage and anger that I feel like it's really jarring, going from the soft "1979" to the angsty, rage-filled "Tales of a Scorched Earth" for example really messes with the flow. However, despite that I would consider this album to be a masterpiece. It's a long album, at 2hrs and 5 minutes. It's a great listen all in all. Definitely one of those albums where it may not be for everyone though, but if you're really into that grungey sound or that just rage-filled piss and vinegar type sound then this is for you.
4/5 double album, no bad songs Has some great iconic grunge songs, but gets a little boring at times. Bullet with butterfly wings, 1979, and X.Y.U are maybe some of the best grunge songs i've heard great album
I remember this group being an American ‘institution’ back in the 90s, however they never really had the same effect here in the UK, I guess we were all distracted with Britpop! This is one of my least favourite music genres but I wanted to give it a chance in the spirit of this project. A few of the tracks are pretty good, objectively speaking, but frankly any goodwill I had tracks wise was wiped out by the vocals. Absolutely terrible. I understand his voice is considered an ‘acquired taste’ but I’m afraid for me it’s just bad. An assault to the ears. Also no album has any business being 2 hours long. In order for an album to be 2 stars I have to be willing to at least listen again, but for this I just can’t. So it has to be one star sorry
Better than I remember. I have more appreciation for the band past the hits.
A lot more varied in its sound than I imagined it be. A decent representation of a lot of different styles from the 90s. Great album to showcase this era.
Horrible
Boy starting off with a challenge. Never been a big Pumpkins fan, only song I really knew was 1979. To kick off with a double album from a band I don't care for much was real difficult to stay focused on, but I persevered. Liked it more than I expected to. Where Boys Fear to Tread was good, I also enjoyed the thrashy Tales Of a Scorched Earth, and Thru the Eyes of Ruby. Still not sure if I like Billy's voice at all but his lyrics are good
Super long. But worth it.
2hrs. Tons of bangers, like the other stuff too. Textbook 4
High school flashback album
I remember this album was a big deal back when music was a big deal to me. I didn't buy it because it was expensive and I didn't think I'd like many of the songs other than 1979 and Bullet with Butterfly Wings. Tonight, Tonight was on MTV in heavy rotation and it's fine but I knew most of the album was post-grunge, reverb, wall of sound that is grating to listen to. Then you add in Corgan's singing which at times I really enjoy and other times I really don't enjoy. I certainly don't want to hear the song where he is straight up screaming. I think I'll only come back for 2 songs, but those two songs are good enough to save this from getting 1 star only
Classic. A little long!
Awesome!!!!
I really missed out on a great album
Wow, I liked it, before Ive only heard Siamese Dream. Double album, lots of things, I will listen again.
Whiny McWhinerson
Nr. 120/1001 Mellon Collie 4/5 Tonight, Tonight 4/5 Jellybelly 3/5 Zero 3/5 Here Is No Why 5/5 Bullet With Butterfly Wings 3/5 To Forgive 4/5 An Ode To No One 3/5 Love 3/5 Cupid de Locke 4/5 Galapagos 4/5 Muzzle 4/5 Porcelina Of The Vast Ocean 3/5 Take Me Down 3/5 Where Boys Fear To Tread 2/5 Bodies 3/5 Thirty-Three 4/5 In The Arms Of Sleep 3/5 1979 5/5 Tales Of A Scorched Earth 1/5 Through The Eyes Of Ruby 4/5 Stumbleine 4/5 X.Y.U. 1/5 We Only Come Out At Night 4/5 Beautiful 3/5 Lily 4/5 By Starlight 4/5 Farewell And Goodnight 4/5 Average: 3,43 Had some really big hits and flops for me.
It had a very epic scale to it and I quite enjoyed it. Quite long though.
4?
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!! 6/5 stars!
I really enjoy the smashing pumpkins, This album showed their ability to mix art with pure rock
High - low - high energy Sick guitar Sounds fun to perform
Meh
I liked the album. It was rather long not going to lie
It blows my mind how a band can produce a 2 hour long album, and it be so versatile and dynamic throughout. A brilliant listen.
My first time listening to the Smashing Pumpkins. I like some of it especially the heavier stuff which is more accommodating to the lousy vocals. I’m surprised I made it through the whole two hours which I guess says something good about it. Cool cover.
Overblown. Pretentious. Sprawling. I wore out my two CDs when this came out. 5/5!
I may be a little blinded by nostalgia on this album but it seriously holds up. Somehow this album can be simultaneously beautiful, angry, sad and joyous from track to track and still be coherent as one of my favorite double albums of all time. 1979 is one of my favorite music videos ever and is like a time capsule of being a teenager in the 90s.
Irre wie unterschiedlich mal extremer Hardrock und dann wie ganz soft
Oh boy. The Smashing Pumpkins are one of the most important bands in my life. I was gifted the album Siamese Dream when I was 15 and it was transformative. My notebooks throughout high school were littered with Billy Corgan lyrics as well as SP hearts. I even rocked my own Zero t-shirt. This was all in the late 2000s, way past the Pumpkins peak; so like the subject matter of many Billy Corgan lyrics, I felt alone in my fandom for this band. To this day, listening to SD or MCIS brings back the feelings of being a teenager. While I prefer SD over MCIS, that is not to say that MCIS is not a classic and a near perfect body of work. The album has incredible range, with songs as dynamic and heavy as Jellybelly, Porceleina, Here is No Why, etc., contrasted with tracks so incredibly gentle and beautiful as the title track, In the Arms of Sleep, and By Starlight. Thus dichotomy of the album, and the band throughout their discography, is what I perhaps most adore about the Pumpkins. Notes: -the title track is apparently a song Corgan wrote to learn piano. Similarly, it’s one of the first songs I learned, and one of my go-tos -the strings to Tonight, Tonight are fucking incredible. I love this song more and more with each listen, even 15 years in. -hot take: the heavy singles (Bullet with Butterfly Wings, Zero) I find to be much weaker than other heavy tracks (Jellybelly and Muzzle should definitely have been singles) -1979 is so iconic. Who doesn’t think of that music video? Quintessential 90s. -the grandnesses of the album is what makes it alluring, but also where it suffers. Cut some songs here and there and I would consider it perfect. Overall: 5/5 Favorite tracks: title track, Tonight, Tonight, Porceleina, Thru the Eyes of Ruby, Here is No Why, Muzzle, 1979
Some really good, like “tonight tonight” but not exactly my genre.
A mix of ambient chill and charged bangers!
Ik zit te twijfelen of ik een 5 ga uitdelen. Ik heb twee redenen om het niet te doen: - Siamese Dream vind ik beter - Dit album duurt 2 uur Dat eerste punt laat ik even voor wat het is. Ik kan er best mee leven als ik ze beide een 5 geef. Dan zet ik gewoon in de comment die niemand leest iets over afronding. Het tweede punt ga ik even rustig uitzoeken. Er staan heerlijke tracks op dit album. Sommige tracks zijn snoeihard, wat je niet zou verwachten als je alleen Tonight, Tonight kent. De bekende nummers zijn goed, maar ook 'Here Is No Why' en 'An Ode To No One' van disk 1 vind ik heerlijk. De Verpletterende Pompoenen hebben op hun gitaren vaak een perfecte combinatie van fuzz, distortion en noise waar ik graag naar luister. En dan nog al die bijna verborgen laagjes op de achtergrond die je amper doorhebt, maar die het geluid compleet maken. Ik denk dat dat de reden is dat ik de zang van ome Billy kan verdragen: De eigenlijk onprettige stem is een van de vele texturen en is slechts een instrument in een groter geheel. De eerste track van disk 2 zorgt ervoor dat bij mij de goesting nog niet is weggezakt. Maar ook Bodies (track 2) is heerlijk. Overduidelijk een vijf-sterren-ervaring, ook al vind ik Siamese Dreams dus nog iets vetter. Godverdomme wat een goed album zeg. Kakt richting het einde een beetje in, maargoed. Tegen die tijd heb je al anderhalf uur genot gehad.
Onbekend met de smashing pumpkins, ik ga ze wat vaker opzetten
Classic brilliant
There's a place for everything. The Smashing Pumpkins have earned their place in every 90's kegger between better songs by better bands. Going outside for a smoke or a quieter chat? Their music provided the perfect excuse. Some songs, like Bullet with Butterfly Wings, are cultural touchstones. But not in the way that the Mona Lisa or even Die Hard is. The best of this band will be remembered with the same reverence as the devil's air raid siren that announced you were seconds away from your dial up connection to the internet: it may bring to mind fond memories by association, but you're glad there are much better options and relieved that you'll never have to hear it again. Had this been a single album, I may have considered 2 stars for nostalgia. 2 hours? I listened, but it just made me sad... and not in a way that good music can.
some solid moments, but ultimately not for me
Eyeshadow
I enjoyed the album. Wasn't blown away, but very good.
Ahhhh damn me, It did not registered the review I wrote so now I have lost it all. To make the tale short: Thought it was another band, but no, first time listening. And it simply is. I got bored by the middle of the second disk. Some people might like it but it is not for me. 2/5
this is my first time listening to the Smashing Pumpkins – there are some nice songs and the music is definitely pleasant enough to have on in the background but I'm not drawn in enough to deliberately listen to their music after this. the album title might be my favourite thing about it
Another classic! Hard not to have some filler on a double album but even the filler here is decent and the storage songs are really strong.
1,001 albums is turning into "do I think The Smashing Pumpkins are a real band?". They clearly have some interesting things to do and their instrumental stuff is a bit wild. I kind of dig it but man do they need a new audio engineer at least on the Spotify version. The drums are muted to a fault and it doesn't sound crisp. This album is wildly too long and all over the place but I liked chunks of it for sure and they sound unique. Toss this into the bucket of "is this good singing or not". I'm not sure but I do think at least on some songs it fits really well. Despite feeling like this is too long I did like the audacity of what it is and how broad it goes in style. I don't think it all lands but one of these stars is purely on the artistic push of what this is and how bold a move it was for them at the time.
Oof this is a very long one. Great musically, great composition. Big bucks production here. A really good double album. I don't care much for Billy as a person. As a vocalist sometimes what he does works but often I'm tired of his choices.
I am fan of anything with melancholy vibes. I liked the album cover and the album name. The album has range. I see how smashing pumpkins is a band that has a cult following
Nah
Sorry! Not for me, I'm afraid! I found it overlong, overblown and I really couldn't get on with Corgan's voice. The 'grungey' bits sounded like they were just trying too hard!
It’s a difficult album to review as it was one of those albums that entered my life as an “instant classic” lauded as genius. It’s a good grind, serious rock feel. At this stage, I’m weary of Billy’s voice and kind of wish I had an instrumental version. Bullet with Butterfly Wings is my standard fave. Muzzle hit me as a solid track on this listen, it might be a new top SP song. The double album gets a bit long and repetitive on a full listen.
The usual and beautiful
Great
Favorite of mine
Just not my thing tbh. Lead singer's voice is meh
Thought they were just another grunge band…didn’t realize the scope of their stylistic competence…reminds me of one of my favorite breweries; if you don’t like the beer you’re drinking it’s because you don’t like that style, it’s not because they made a bad version of it..
Speaks to just how great this album is that I give it 5* despite Billy Corgan's godawful voice. I am frequently haunted by the idea of how incredible the Pumpkins could have been with a decent singer
This was a defining album growing up for me. Over the years, I feel like I’ve looked back on it with rose colored glasses. A lot of it still holds up, but listening to it with fresh critical ears, there’s some bloat to it. The first part (disc 1 from the original CD release) sets the bar high, but the second part (disc 2) doesn’t quite stick the landing as well as it could. Still, a great album, and still hold it very near and dear to my heart, but not quite perfection.
At first I thought I didn’t like it at all but it has some really great songs. But the voice is not really my kind of voice.
Respect to Billy Corgan because if I heard myself singing for the first time and it sounded like this I'd try my hand at cartoon voiceovers instead. He deserves credit for his perseverance despite the obvious problems he suffers with his sinuses. I thought I knew enough about smashing pumpkins to guess what this album was going to sound like and that I wouldn't like it. Never going to be easy when the singers voice just sounds so affected. I didn't like it.
Despite seeing the Pumpkins in concert a few times, I'd never listened to this album all the way through. As a kid, "Tonight, Tonight" was one of my favourite songs. If this album was cut down to just the hits and a couple others, it would be basically perfect. As it is, it's overly long with too much filler.
just 2 or 3 good tunes
this album surprised me! i was expecting a pure grunge and alternative album, but the smashing pumpkins didn't allow themselves to be defined. there was some beautiful piano work that took my breath away! they allowed themselves to explore metal and the more artsy side of rock. as a result, songs within mellon collie and the infinite sadness were interesting and different. to be fair, while i enjoyed this album and there was no wasted space, i do not know why it had to be a double album at two full hours. the music was great, creative, and intriguing, yet i feel like they could've gotten their point across in under an hour.
This album is chock full of such great Smashing Pumpkins songs, some of which are hits, others not. There's still plenty of grunge here to love, but this album has given way a lot more to the art rock side of the band. The two genres seem as if they would clash in almost every situation, but it somehow works here. It's not incredibly surprising that they make it work here; from their inception, they had a knack for blending grunge with more "melodic" music. That said, this was probably their last grunge album, before they transitioned away from that sound for more electronic rock sounds. I know a lot of people complain that Billy Corgan can't sing. I don't argue that, but I just feel like it doesn't end up mattering. Again, it is something else that simply works for these guys. I absolutely dug this album, don't get me wrong. But it was too long, felt a bit self-indulgent, and some of the art rock tracks just dragged a little too much. And sure, it's a double album so the length is "justified", but I rarely have the listening patience for a double album of any kind. I was definitely ready to be done by the time it was finished.
This album takes me back. I had this on double disc CD and wore it out! Definitely like some tracks better than others, but this one had some of my favorite SP songs on it.
This album is a Rollercoaster but not in a good way. Some bangers but the slower songs kill the vibe. Though I'm intrigued to check out more.
No no no no no horrible voice and music couldn’t stand it
good more rock than I would think
Little long for my liking but still a great album. The harder faster paced songs were more up my alley but the ballads and slower songs still make the album worth listening to.
love these guys
I was quite surprised by how much I enjoyed this album. I already knew a few Smashing Pumpkins songs that I had assumed were singles from across their discography - Turns out they were all from this album (Tonight, Zero, Bullet with Butterfly Wings, 1979). My heart sank when I opened the album and saw it was 28 songs and over 2 hours long. As far as I’m concerned the perfect album length is 45 minutes. Any longer and you’re almost guaranteed a lot of filler. I was surprised to not find any on this album, although I did enjoy the first half more than the second, probably due to musical fatigue. There were a few moments that even made me “Oh, hell yeah!” out loud (e.g. when the drums kick in on An Ode to No One). Highlights: Bullet with Butterfly Wings, An Ode to No One, 1979.
Musically nice enough. Vocally, generally annoyingly vocal. Lyrically, hard to make out. Kind of fun in their over-the-top-ness. "Stumbleine" is a nice track, though.
One of my favorite albums of all time!
Soooo mannnny memories! And sooo much good music!! Loved.
4.5 stars! It's not close to Siamese dream but I still listen to that album.
Not for me
Love this album! I remember buying it in high school and the moon faces on each cd. CD’s! Wow I’m old
I used to be obsessed with this album. Still great, not elite. Tonight, Zero, Bullet, and Muzzle still pump me up
A moment in time and such a unique style.
I've always been neutral on the Smashing Pumpkins, but was definitely a fan of Mellon Collie. Every time I hear this band and this album in particular, I'm taken back to the late 90s and a good friend of mine that was an über Smashing Pumpkins fan. We jabbed each other over music and SP were always an easy target for me. My buddy is no longer with us but it's times like this that I fondly remember our friendship and great conversations. So, for any future reviewers of this album, regardless of where you stand on it, please know that Dave loved it and loved people. Cheers Dave! 5/5 for Dave.
Too much racket
Straight banger. Drums drive everything. Will repeat.
The world is indeed a vampire. Before I begin, I want to quickly reflect on this video game that my roommates and I played prior to the start of the 2nd semester of my freshman year. One of my roommates had a Sega and this game had to do with Jack the Ripper and vampires. We played it for 4 days straight to solve it. Our RA lived next door and played the whole time with us. And he was really in to SP. Played them all the time. So that was my first introduction to the band, in the context of vampires. Leading to their creation of this album 2 years later. Great times... Also, I've listened to this one many times, so I don't know what kind of review I'll give here. Its a looong album. I always loved how disc 1 opened. My roommate had a gigantic stereo, with a 100 disc changer. It was insane. And this album/song would get pumped. Nice growing sound getting into the album. And Tonight, Tonight was one of my favorites. Lots of pumpkins songs played. I just listened. Some I like, and some are just ok. In general across Gish, Siamese Dream, and MCIS, I always liked the lighter songs (other than BWBW). My fav on this one was always 1979, which for disc listening wasn't ideal, since I liked disc 2 overall much less than disc 1. I went ahead and called time of death on the song after 1979 because I didn't want Billy yelling at me any more. I feel this is exactly the same behavior I had back in 1995. And this was the last of the great SP albums I think. They had a pretty good run.
holy shit, this album is LONG. and it suffers from it, in my opinion. it has some truly great songs, iconic bangers and songs that i can’t even remember. also the songwriting is kinda all over the place. this album has some hard hitting lines, but also some unbearably cringy ones. and wtf was “tales of a scorched earth”? overall though i can say i enjoyed it.
I enjoyed this album but it’s far too long
Ambitious in scope yet lacking focus, this feels like the output of a band suffering through a profound identity crisis. It simply doesn’t come together as a cohesive piece of art. They are truly at their best in post-grunge goth mode of “JellyBelly”, “Zero”, “Bullet with Butterfly Wings”, etc. The ballads seem out of place, mostly because the harder edged tracked are so perfectly executed in comparison. While every song on the album is done well, some of the softer ones seem included solely for the sake of making a double album - they feel like outtakes rather than thoughtfully curated elements. While some of their best known work is here (“1979”, “Tonight Tonight”) it feels like they would be better suited for another album. It’s just too much thrown together. Again, any 10 songs on here put together would be a 4+ star record. This suffered from being too packed. 3.5
I liked it!
Great album that is let down by how self indulgently long it is. With a good prune it is an easy 5, but the padding let's it down.
Didn't listen in full, but I want to! It goes all over the place from loud and heavy rock to ballads which was a little surprising, and has a crazy amount of tracks. But good stuff.
Dont need an app to know this is incredible
Amazing album. I've liked it ever since it was released.
Didn’t finish this album but was a solid listen !!
great songs, lots of filler
I have always LOVED Siamese Dream. So I bought Mellon Collie the week it was released; but I've never liked it. There is WAY too much mediocrity here to truly appreciate the two or three amazing moments. And those amazing moments were played SO much on the radio in 1995, that listening to the album was just about exploring the mediocrity. It also comes across as a bit artsy (c'mon...Mellon Collie?) - too much of it sounds affected, gimmicky and/or half-baked. Corgan's clearly trying to expand his sound; which is laudable. But the less grungy the backing tracks get, the more they're ruined by their exposure of his voice - revealing his jarring and incongruously-timed transitions between whisper, vocalfry, failed attempts at real singing, and mediocre James Hetfield impressions. Ultimately, I'm frustrated by all of it. If he'd focused on making the best one-third of the songs here great (instead of making the Wall for Gen X - give me a break) he could have made a great album. Bullet With the Butterfly Wings is so great, though, that it earns the album two stars all on its own.
I've always been daunted by the 2 hour runtime so I've never listened to this album all the way through despite loving the singles and Siamese Dream. I'm glad that this project finally motivated me to do so. Even though it's 2 hours long, I enjoyed every minute of it. There isn't as much bloat on here as I expected, although the second half is just good while the first half is mind-blowing. If this was the first half only--with 1979 promoted to the first half--it would be a 5 but I have to acknowledge the inconsistency and give it a 4.5. Highlights: Jellybelly, Here Is No Why, Galapogos, Muzzle
Started with Siamese Dreams and though the SP were phenomenal. This sounds more of a Mish mash. Some great songs but still something missing for me.
There's songs that I don't mind, or even like, but this is way too long. 3/5
4.1/5 so many bangers on this album but Love, Tales of a scorched Earth and X.Y.U. exist and it's 2 hours long
what can i say - classic to me
Such enormous scope and presence.
drags a bit too long but very enjoyable listen (if you don't mind his voice). Mix of heavier and softer songs
A really great album that goes on for a bit too long. There are some great tracks like "Bullet with Butterfly Wings" and "Tonight, Tonight". 4/5.
I don’t like sad
It was ok!
not a fan of Corgan's voice. but the music is nice. More of a prog feel than I was expecting. 4/5
I think the reason the Pumpkins haven't ever clicked with me is Billy Corgan's voice. And if there ever was an album to test this theory, this would be the one. At just over two hours this is a trial by fire. My theory may be correct? It's hard to say, because at times I'm annoyed with the vocals, other times I feel they fit perfectly, and then there's times where both are true. Either way this is a mondo album filled with an intense variety of sounds and genres. It's hard not to admire the sheer scope, and I came out on the other end rather liking it in spite of my mixed feelings on Billy's vocals.
Felt a bit too long, and some songs blended together, but overa;; a very good album.
Sounded like skater but but long
Stupid long with generally solid songs with some really good ones like tonight, tonight and 1979, there were some stinkers but otherwise solid.
Every song on this double album is great, but it's so long that I end up forgetting what happened an hour ago. Even though all of the songs are good, because of the sheer number of them, a lot of the tracks blend together and few actually stand out on their own. The ending is peak though
MC&TIS The well known songs (Tonight, Bullet, 1979 etc) and then To Forgive, Cupid de Locke, Galapagos, Porcelina of the Dark Oceans, Thru the Eyes of Ruby, By Starlight, Farewell and Goodnight stood out Jellybelly, Zero (terrible lyrics), An Ode to No One, Tale of a Scorched Earth - not a fan of those at all Take me Down sounds a lot like a song from a musical, particularly the rising chorus, which kind of chimes with Dan’s Queen observation, they do have those slightly showtune/musical theatre aspects some of the melodies. We only come out a night has a similar Queen vibe too. That’s not a criticism btw. Generally, like on SD, not a fan of the harder songs, the slower tempo ones are more interesting melodically and atmospherically, and I think his voices suits those songs better. Lots of great musical hooks and instrumentation, I didn’t really realise what a great gift for melody he has. I admire the ambition and genuinely earnest pretension of it, but it is A LOT of music and whether it’s me or the music that falters, his voice does start to grate on mover the course of 2 hrs. I think I’d be likely to go back to SD more frequently than this but a very enjoyable listen none the less. ⭐️⭐️⭐️/⭐️ Prob closer to 4 but the length is why I’m prevaricating
One of my first albums ever. Bought by Mom’s BF Marc. Jamie G gave me the shirt. Incredible album start to finish
Very fucking long
This album needs to be blasted on a cross country drive. Moments I was in tune, others I was waiting to get thru more hard core rock moments…undeniably good, though
2 Stunden Grunge Melancholie. Anstrengend.
Good album enjoyed more than anticipated
War sehr gut, vielseitig. Manches etwas schräg.
First time listening all the way through in over 10 years. It’s rawer than I remember, maybe not as intentional as I remember, full of grunge.
Some of the songs are great...but some of them I can't really relate to? The radio airplay songs seemed to have been standouts
The album is almost transcendental techno disguised as teen angst fueled rock. The music is beautifully composed but the immature lyrics and Billy Corgan’s voice are dealbreakers. Props to the Instrumental trax but his vocal ruins the album for me.
Enjoyed. Some of the longer pieces I wasn’t crazy about but always enjoyed his singing style and the sound of the strings, which I like about all these grungy bands.
Nice. Emo
To long, ok to listen some songs in a playlist but couldn't finish the record
Just not my usual vibe. Enjoyed Zero and Love.
Lyrics and majestic power chords are fine but I'm just not a fan because of Corigans grating vocals. Also found the mastering to be very lifeless and "made for car radio"
7/10
Loved it!!! Every song had a different vibe but still cohesive within the album and goes so hard
This is incredible. I had heard a few songs from this which i liked but the entire thing is nonstop quality. An amazing feat for such a long album.
Meh
College
Beautiful albulm. Less heavy than I'd anticipated, great melodies.
Ziemlich metalllastig. Nicht so mein Ding.
Familiar with quite a bit of this
Curious album. It's got positives - but negatives too. Definitely genre bending, or rather genre extending. The grunge vibe and whining lyrics are putting me off.... but there's something to this album & band that I'll listen to again to see if I see more. For now, it's a 3
Wow this took long to finish. Some great tracks, I feel like I need to relisten to this album to fully grasp the intricacies of each song, especially with how good the production on nearly every song is, but I might not be able to revisit this album for a long time considering how long it is. 2.5/5
The music was good but the vocals are so annoying
Listened to this while driving from Escondido to Palm Springs. This is another one of those albums where my partner knew every single word to both albums. I of course recognized the singles. I was never a fan of Billy Corgan's voice...and it still is a grating sound to me. The double album is a dangerous thing. It is so easy to get self indulgent and bloated. I think there is a 5 star single album buried in here...but there is just so much other stuff padding that experience. I wanted to rate it higher...but this gets a 3.
Smaching pumpkins 2nd best album
Smashing Pumpkins’s best album. People who only heard their radio songs probably didn’t realize how heavy they could play as heard on this one. It’s really quite a feat to put out a double album with as many songs that kick the way that these do. I was happy to go back to this one and listen with fresh ears. I think I’ll be listening more in the next few days.
Ughhh not my fav, struggling to finish this. Maybe I'll revisit
i have this cd
Nostalgic, good album. Can be a bit overly noisy in moments and corgans vocals are hard to listen to sometimes.
Sprawling, epic monster of an album that comes damn close to justifying its massive runtime. I was never exactly sure what to expect from the next track and I was rarely disappointed, it was a lot of fun to just put this on and enjoy the ride.
Wanna go for a ride? One of the best double-albums ever. The variety and mastery of different musical styles on here is incredible. I love the slow songs and the wild headbangers and everything in between.
Long. Some great tunes. Plus, who puts out a double album in 1995?
Solid nostalgia. Very long, towards the end I had enough.
What a sprawling album. You have to give it 5/5 for the effort that went into it, the impact and how diverse the music is and genres played.
4.5
a masterpiece theough and through… it is a bit long but I dont think there are skips on it. It’s all structured nicely and all the songs are beautifully recorded and mixed so theres that too. It has one of my favorite songs Cupid de locke also
Meh
Interesting vocal vibe, should dig further.
Great
Loved the overall tone of the offering.
This was good to start off with but just would not end any he last 1/4 just sucked. I wanted to rate this highly but just can’t.
I really wanted to like this album more than I did. There's some great songs on here--maybe some of The Smashing Pumpkins best--but two hours of his voice gets to be a bit rough. I'd rather cherry pick the songs on here than listen to the whole thing. 3.5/5
Could rate this entire album a 5 based solely on how I feel about Tonight, Tonight but luckily I don’t have to because the whole album slaps and deserves the 5.
Ótimo álbum! Sonoridade de primeira mesmo.
I am goof and I loved this album it's my favourite and I decided this rating on my own. 4/4 extreme gooDness. Tonight tonight is my favourite as well.
Stunning from start to finish
Don't love it all but the parts I do love are fantastic
Magnum Opus
2 hours? Triple LP? Come on.
This is a fantastic album. Most songs are ones that I am not tempted to hit the next button on. That means I like what I'm listening to. This is something certainly worth owning and listening to so it deserves it's place on this list as "an album to hear before you die". This is an easy 4 out of 5 compared to the crap I have heard before it.
A- super long B- killer album
Awesome. One of my favourites
Always in my top 10!!
I hate Billy’s voice so much.
Very good album. Only complaint is it is too long. Hardly gives a chance for any songs to stand out in any meaningful way.
Great album. Loved it as a kid and still love it now. Melodic and heavy at the same time
There's no getting around it - this is a long album. But, it's also amazing. A good variety of songs, with some heavier songs following ballads. It's great.
Some great songs but insanely too long of length. Some filler. Would have been an ez 4 if they picked the best songs and made it not a double album. Ez 3.5
The world is a vampire
This could have been a 4.5 to 5 for me had they made this just one hour of the best parts. Way too long and some songs clearly could have been scraped. Still the best parts are really good. Soft 4
good stuff
My wife hates this album. She says its the big sell out album for Corgan, but I cant help but really like it. The theme, the tracks, its just got some great production and ends up being a pretty good (if way too long) album. 4/5
So good
Quite a long album but some decent tracks here and there
Ambitious, trendsetting. It's always great to hear an artist or group fire on all cylinders and that's what The Smashing Pumpkins did here. Just raw output of emotion, musicality, and cohesion. Only four stars because I don't think I will come back to this very often, but a very good project.
Siamese Dream is tighter, but there's enough material this time to fill two CDs and then some. The companion album, The Aeroplane Flies High, is also pretty good. I like the followup, Adore, also this was the Pumpkins' peak. No tracks make me want to skip them.
Somewhere in a parallel reality is a 5/5 album that sounds exactly like Mellon Collie but sung by someone not Billy Corgan.
The closest I’ve been to giving an album a 5, but the run time is holding me back. A two disc, two hour album is just a bit much, even if I really like the songs. Favorite song: Bullet with Butterfly Wings Least favorite: Don’t really have one
Liked disc 2 more than disc 1 (with the major exception of Tales of a Scorched Earth), though the sound felt very similar the whole way through. Really what that means is that I preferred the last run of songs that chilled all the way out and became significantly less ~rock. Overall good though? Just not really my style.
This was decent. Definitely plenty of bangers on this album. But a good amount meh songs. Good album overall. But his voice is kinda annoying. Like some of the lyrics were good but I couldn’t enjoy hearing them lol. 3.5
Pompus but with some knockout moments
Holy shit this is good. I've only seen a few albums that go for 2 hours hold up and that's Songs In The Key Of Life - Stevie Wonder
Brilliant. A masterpiece of rock music.
aaaaaaaaaaa i like some of the songs on here but overall it feels a little……… like i’m just saying did it have to be 2 hours long
Not my type of thing. I liked some of the songs but most of it blended together.
A nice album, I liked the style of music. I recalled liked the song 1979.
Pretty good.
Good
The Smashing Pumpkins have this signature musical gesture - a 16 beat crescendo of repeated accented guitar/bass/drum notes followed by a drum outro. I noticed it used on at least 5 tracks on this album to heighten the drama. It works. This is arguably the last mythic grunge album. There’s so much to love on here - not only because it’s a double album. It’s ridiculous how good all of these far-ranging tracks are.
Not sure that I've listened to this start to finish in more than 20 years. Lots of high marks.
If ‘MCATIS’ this was trimmed down to an hour, or even the length of one CD, 75 mins or so, it would have dibs on being the greatest rock album of the 90s. As it is, a lot of it is still good and there aren’t too many low points, but clocking in at 2 hours, it’s a lot to consume in one go, and that 2nd hour isn’t quite as strong as the first. And so, for that It loses points. Sometimes less is more.
Pretty sure they could have pared this down to one disc, but any album with "Tonight, Tonight," "Zero," "Bullet with Butterfly Wings," and "1979" gets no fewer than four stars.
Such a classic 90s album. Lots of gems on here. 4.5 stars
Siamese Dream is one of my favorite albums and when this album was released I remember being done with the Smashing Pumpkins. I thought this was such a bloated project, I didn't care for the overly commercial production, it just felt soulless. I do love this part "All songs written by Billy Corgan" - I love how uniquely original the music sounds, and while his lyrics aren't deep, they are his. Not my favorite from the band, still really good.
Pulling up this this album kind of blew my mind a little bit. I've seen the album art loads of times. I've heard the singles for years, but I never realized they were part of a 2-hour long behemoth album. What a crazy thing to create. As a whole, the album felt kind of like an entire night's sleep, with each song being a different dream. Some songs a quiet and peaceful, while others were chaotic and angry, just to dissolve into another whiny dream in another song. Waking up at the end of the album, it all felt a little shallow and meaningless, but the experience was kind of cool.
I loved this a lot. Maybe it’s nostalgia, but it was just fantastic. I remember buying this 2disk set when it came out and running up to my dorm room to listen on my stereo. The artwork was incredible, the videos were incredible. And the band had taken a turn from Siamese Dream. It was a great time. Love is my favorite track.
Good songs but this is SO L O N G !
1. gorgeous album cover! not to be annoying but so far (nearing the end of side 1) this is SUCH a great album. i shall continue to listen. 2. i'm getting a bit drained, this is a long fucking album. 1979 just came on though (yey!!!!) 3. on the whole i think the first half is better than the second half, i am still enjoying it but it's more same-y than the first half. or maybe i'm just smashing pumpkins-ed out 4. the last song is lovely 5. on the whole i really enjoyed this album i like the variations on the genre and the different things it tries out. i'd like to know its influences. and what it influenced. a nice thing to listen to from start to finish i wouldn't do it again but now i know what songs i like from it !!! yey!
Kept my attention for 2hrs, good variability, enjoyed the calmness of the final track after the album
Waves of Nostalgia are hard to ignore. I was expecting a lot of filler revisiting this double album, but it’s that’s not the case. Really enjoyed getting back to this after a long break
Damn good one
On All Saints Day, whilst meandering through suburbia, I saw a kid going door-to-door disfiguring Halloween decorations. What are you doing, I asked. Smashing pumpkins, the kid replied. Care to join? I stood at the entrance of the cul-de-sac and watched. The kid continued with methodological precision and aesthetic flair. Some squashes had their innards strewn out, others their tops knocked off, yet others merely bruised, or knocked to one side. A gaggle of fellow observers had joined me by the time the kid had completed the tour around the cul-de-sac. The kid headed out grinning, and proceeded down the next cul-de-sac. Shocked onlookers whispered aghast, surely not another cul-de-sac? Such ambition!
so the first song was so so so lovely and i was excited to listen to this, thinking i would love it so much. but sadly, i just didn’t, i hated most of it. there were like two songs i liked, the first i love, and then that one about being 33 or something which just sounds like journey to the past from anastasia so i will have to look into it. the beginning of the second song is so epic, i love that too, i actually like that song a lot. unfortunately i have to be fair and can’t rate it high for one or two songs… sorry.
A really underrated band in general on account of Billy Corgan’s personal life. Making a 2 hour album you don’t get tired of is insanely impressive.
lets go
A bit long.
An epic double CD when it came out. Kind of a mix between grunge and hard rock. Just great to listen to.
Wow. 2 hours. I would wager if i discovered this back in the day, i would have been able to give each track significant time to get under my skin. So both the easy to approach and more challenging/noisy tracks would have the same positive reaction. I do respect the energy and angst that drives many of the tracks and come away with a positive experience. Outside of the obvious bangers, it seems a repeating set of flavors but all good alternative.
In a nutshell: one of the last great concept albums of the century. If you’re already familiar with the album, try listening in “original vinyl version” track list order (see the Wikipedia page for details) so you can get a different listening experience. Overall: 8/10
Inoffensive.
Eerste twee nummers verrassend muzikaal en prettig, daarna neemt de harde gitaar, drum en het geschreeuw over. Hier en daar wel nummers waar nog muziek in zit.
This album was long. Its length made me want to dislike it. I listened to it a few times seeking any substantial flaw that I could use to give it a 4 instead of a 5. Unfortunately, despite its length, it is a perfect album. Even the songs that weren’t to my personal taste were essential to the album itself as a work of art. I have no choice but to give it a 5. Also, is it just me or does the song Thirty-Three sound just like Journey To The Past from the movie ‘Anastasia’?????
I’ve never made it all the way through this double album, despite professing a love for the band on and off through my junior high years. I tried again recently and same. I get turned off quickly by the heavier songs and guttural screeching into the mic. There’s no denying Corgan’s beautiful guitar playing, so I’m not not a fan, but it’s just never fully clicked. Let’s give it another go. First off, the hits still hit. They’re great. When their songs have dynamic range, I’m in. When it’s all raspy vocals and loud distortion the whole way through, I need a break. When it’s all slow and mopey (not that there’s anything wrong with that), I need a break. Thankfully, the track listing mixes it up every song or two. Had I previously stuck it out through those songs I wasn’t feeling, I’d have gotten much farther. I’m certainly happy that I’m forcing myself to listen regardless. If for no other reason than to know which songs to skip in the future, and to know that there are more gems in here than just the radio hits. But yeah it’s still way too long for me to give it more than 3/5 I can’t finish this review without mentioning that that is not how you spell Galapagos, but it’s still one of the aforementioned hidden gems.
To my ears, this is the correct way to sing badly. I think I'd be scoring this album lower if I'd already had Siamese Dream which is really the only Smashing Pumpkins album I come back to. This one has some good tracks, but its way too long and samey accross the span of it to leave a lasting impact.
I remember buying this album on double CD when it came out. Haven't listened to the whole thing in quite a while but was pleasantly surprised that my old favorites still resonate.
there’s one and a half GREAT albums here. “adore” forever
Interesting, very various.
Not bad
hell yeah man
It was pretty long. Too long imho.
Love this album
One of my all time favorites. Great mood music, lots of hits.
Fav song: fuck you
This alvum would easily be a 5 if there were less songs on it. I think Siamese dream is the better album
I always thought they were overrated in the 90s, and this certainly didn't change my mind.
Didn't like Smashing Pumpkins in the 90s. Still don't like them. Corgan's voice is so annoying
This album did not need to as long as it is. Over half of the songs could have been cut and this would have basically been a greatest hits. I put off listening to this album because I rarely have 2 hours together to dedicate to one album. I chose the day I drove two hours to the airport. It was early morning, dark, and very foggy. Most of the songs made my drive worse. Usually I like driving music that keeps me on the road, not songs that make me want to drive off of it. I'm conflicted about what my rating should be. I'm going to round up from a 3.5. It's mostly good. I did get sick of a few tracks before they were over, and a lot of them sound very similar. And Billy Corgan's voice... But the hits are the hits. They're good.
I was expecting to hate this but I was pleasantly surprised and only disliked it. They're imitators of grunge but they add a spoonful of sugar to make it easier for the general public's ears. The album has its well known hits and is painfully long.
Whew! I didn't listen to all 5 hours & 52 minutes in in Spotify. Fortunately the original release was much shorter - only a triple LP. Some good hard rock and interesting variations. The hits are okay.
It’s hard to believe that this album is 28 yrs old. I would say it’s one of the defining albums of the early Indie-Emo rock genre, as it was listened to obsessively by many angsty teens. The 2 hr length is weighty, and this album is almost schizophrenic melding gentle ballads with some very aggressive hard rock songs. However it’s hard to dispute that this album spawned a ton of great singles that have aged very nicely over the decades, and that itself defines an iconic album for me.
Excellent album
I THOUGHT I MISSED THE REVIEW DEADLINE I really enjoyed listening to this album. I would have to agree with Mike that the first half was better than the second. It was a long album but I never felt bored or ready to listen to something else. 4/5
"Time is never time at all / You can never ever leave / Without leaving a piece of youth" The smashing pumpkins is my #2 artist of all time on spotify, so this review is heavily biased. I have listened to this record before, but I don't remember it being 2 hours long, so I may have only listened to the first side in the past. I find it kind-of cringy that Corgan wanted this album to be "the wall" for gen. X, but damn if it doesn't come close. I really, really enjoy the musical ideas behind the smashing pumpkins and their music. And I think this album rivals that of the pumpkin's more accessible album for casual listeners- "Siamese Dreams" T2- "Tonight, Tonight" is an epic ballad about the inevitable passing of time, with a focus on making the most of the moment. Anything is possible tonight. T3- "Jellybelly" provides a heavy wall of sound complimented by Alt-rock vocals. T4- "Zero" has perhaps one of the most hard 'metal'-sounding riffs in the back, alongside emo lyrics that creates a contrarian's anthem. T5- "Here is no why" has a genius guitar riff that blends heavy fuzz with the best parts of mathrock and heavier rock, to preach it's cynical song T6- "Bullet with butterfly wings" complete's the album's run of 5 amazing songs to kick off the album and builds up to a chorus that preaches something that is all-too-familiar for those working the 9-5 rat race. T11 - "Galapogos" is a soft-spoken song of admitting one's struggles, and fears of solitude. Disc 2 offers a lot less in the form of obvious hits, but begins with T2 - "Bodies" and continues a cynical vibe of hopeless romanticism, with the haunting chorus "Love is suicide," which may be a reference to Courtney Love, Corgan's ex-girlfriend, and the woman rumored to have played a part in Cobain's suicide. T3- "Thirty-Three" offers a change of outlook, providing a hopeful wish that "Love can last forever." T5- "1979" is perhaps one of the pumpkin's greatest singles, and is the track that introduced me to the band. It offers an unfaltering wave of nostalgia with the hypnotic guitar backing, and wistful lyrics talking about the "cool kids" sung in the past tense, and ideas that there is little to worry about for these kids beyond something as frivolous as social clicks and their respective rules. 1979, to me, offers a direct response to the other hit track, "Tonight, Tonight" which calls one to make the most of the moment, and damn if that's not exactly what happens in 1979. T8- "Stumbeline" is a depressing track of misspent time, and past wishes, and connects to the album's theme of falling asleep with the last line "come around ruby, I could never sleep alone," and the name reminds me personally of "Thumbelina," a bedtime fairy-tale that recounts a girl, borne of a seed, that escapes an abusive marriage with a mole T9- "X.Y.U" is a very heavy song, with references to "Mary had a little lamb," continuing the theme of sleeping, and bed-time stories with dark background stories. This track offers a reflection back onto a very toxic relationship. The second disk ends the album with a fitting track given the theme of sleeping, saying "Farewell and goodnight" This album encapsulates a reflection of one's youth, and lessons learnt too late, relationships symbolized by fairy-tales, and the depressing realization that time can never move backwards. The entire album seems to suggest the universality behind the human emotion of sorrow, and spans multiple genres from rock, alt rock, grunge, heavy metal, alt pop, and art rock. The two sides (discs) of the album seem to suggest a theme of 'day' for the first, and night for the latter. Upon research from the wikipedia, the vinyl was split into 6 sides, including names like "Dawn," "Tea time," and "Dusk" to describe the first side, and names like "Twilight," "Midnight," and "Starlight," to describe the latter, although the songs are in a slightly-different order. This idea also goes along with the ideas expressed in the album, with more positive (yet sorrowful) memories of youth and nostalgia taking place in disc 1, for day, and more pessimistic ideas, fairy-tales, and other references to sleep happening mostly in disc. 2, night. Although a difficult choice, I'll put 1979 on the playlist due to my personal connection with the track. I love this record, and despite it's length, I never once found myself bored. I would recommend this to any enjoyer of music that has similar tastes to mine, that wants a thorough experience and reflection of music. An easy 5/5
There's a couple absolute classic on here. But it's definitely too long, not enough variety or substance for a 2 hour album. Best songs are 1979 and Bullet with butterfly wings (this song wil randomly jump in my head ever since I first heard it)
This was alright! Again the vocals didnt do it for me! I dont know. There were some interesting songs but for a lack of ability to express myself - the vibes were off. I hate to give something a 2 but aside from a few songs where there was max indie rock nostalgia I wasn't really feeling it. And to be honest, I couldn't finish it. I still have the tail end of the second side left. Will I finish it? We'll find out!
Long but quite good
Hard. Niet per se verwacht.
Thru eyes of Ruby, banger Tonight, tonight, nice Overall prima
Dik dik dik dik, tonight tonight, bullet sws en to forgive, smashing pumpkins underrated
While I never owned any Smashing Pumpkins albums, this band was a major part of the ambient sound backdrop of my college years. It’s familiar, but I don’t think I’ve ever sat down with this album before. For one thing, it’s too long. But also the grunge scene wasn’t really my thing then and it still isn’t. I can appreciate the album but once is more than enough and I really had to stop myself from giving up on it as it dragged on. Galapogos was a bright spot, 1979 lived up to my memory of it, Stumbleine was a surprise winner, and I’ve always loved the cover art. But a lot of the other songs aren’t memorable and a couple, like Tales of a Scorched Earth and X.Y.U., are ear-splittingly bad. After listening to the first several songs I had settled on a 3, but now that I’m blissfully at the end of the whole album I’m dropping it to a 2 for unnecessary length and whininess. I see that Amazon is offering to play me an EXTENDED version of this album that is almost SIX HOURS LONG and no thank you.
musicalmente falando um album bem alternativo, aonde todas as musicas se ligam e tem vibes bem legais, nao é enjoativo, so que tambem nao escutaria 6 horas do album deluxe. No geral um album otimo
Meh, didn’t finish
A couple bangers on this album but this is simply too much music. Maybe if you're a Smashing Pumpkins stan you would rage for this album but like at least 20 of these songs could be removed and it would be a good album. And I really don't mean to be judgmental because I really do like some of these songs but 2 hours is a long time to listen to Billy Corgan's voice. It's the first and hopefully only DNF for me.
8.5/10
An enjoyable way to spend 2 hours.
Kende alleen bullet, rest blijkt ook dik te zijn
Made me ill
Not what I usually listen to but I appreciate The art
Meh, too long
I liked this a lot, I wasn’t aware of the quality of the Smashing pumpkins. Would definitely listen to a few songs again, like “Zero”.
Not for me, music nice but didn't like his voice at all, didn't listen to it all
I’m ashamed I never listened to this all the way through. Great album!
Incredible triple album so rare to make a good one. It’s amazing how often it can slip from a heavy high energy song to a soft sweet song. Really tough to rate because there’s a ton of great tracks and decent bit of filler but don’t even think the filler is that bad. Rating: 4.6